Satpal v. The State of Hp and Others
- Court
- High Court of Himachal Pradesh
- Date of judgment
- 31 October 2026
- Bench
- Justice Vivek Singh Thakur, Justice Ranjan Sharma
- Case number
- CWP No. 11690 of 2025
- Result
- Disposed Off
- Acts & sections
- Article 309 Constitution, Article 187 Constitution, Article 14 Constitution
- Subject
- Service
Full judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA CWP No: 8504 of 2025 alongwith CWP Nos. 1323 of 2023, 2313 of 2023, 2421 of 2023, 3224 of 2023, 5453 of 2023, 5532 of 2023, 5544 of 2023, 5651 of 2023, 5788 of 2023, 5844 of 2023, 5847 of 2023, 5848 of 2023, 5849 of 2023, 5990 of 2023, 6023 of 2023, 6282 of 2023, 6283 of 2023, 6284 of 2023, 6345 of 2023, 6611 of 2023, 6952 of 2023, 7089 of 2023, 7152 of 2023, 7153 of 2023, 7158 of 2023, 7159 of 2023, 7160 of 2023, 7223 of 2023, 7244 of 2023, 7245 of 2023, 7246 of 2023, 7247 of 2023, 7248 of 2023, 7249 of 2023, 7250 of 2023, 7251 of 2023, 7252 of 2023, 7253 of 2023, 7254 of 2023, 7255 of 2023, 7335 of 2023, 7341 of 2023, 7376 of 2023, 7392 of 2023, 7394 of 2023, 7481 of 2023, 7644 of 2023, 7645 of 2023, 7646 of 2023, 7650 of 2023, 7699 of 2023, CWP No. 7857 of 2023, 7897 of 2023, 7957 of 2023, 7959 of 2023, 8039 of 2023, 8040 of 2023, 8043 of 2023, 8050 of 2023, 8059 of 2023, 8090 of 2023, 8097 of 2023, 8101 of 2023, 8104 of 2023, 8106 of 2023, 8177 of 2023, 8180 of 2023, 8192 of 2023, 8193 of 2023, 8233 of 2023, 8241 of 2023, 8242 of 2023, 8246 of 2023, 8256 of 2023, 8312 of 2023, 8501 of 2023, 8508 of 2023, 8559 of 2023, 8560 of 2023, 8561 of 2023, 8562 of 2023, 8563 of 2023, 8579 of 2023, 8581 of 2023, 8585 of 2023, 8587 of 2023, 8734 of 2023, 8742 of 2023, 8748 of 2023, 8749 of 2023, 8750 of 2023, 8751 of 2023, 8752 of 2023, 8754 of 2023, 8776 of 2023, 8940 of 2023, 9000 of 2023, 9001 of 2023, 9002 of 2023, 9176 of 2023, 9177 of 2023, 9179 of 2023, 9180 of 2023, 9217 of 2023, 9254 of 2023, 9255 of 2023, 9256 of 2023, 9257 of 2023, 9274 of 2023, 9312 of 2023, 9363 of 2023, 9387 of 2023, 9389 of 2023,
9471 of 2023, 9534 of 2023, 9546 of 2023, 9547 of 2023, 9581 of 2023, 9675 of 2023, 9703 of 2023, 9767 of 2023, 9768 of 2023, 9769 of 2023, 9770 of 2023, 9849 of 2023, 9851 of 2023, 9853 of 2023, 9885 of 2023, 9887 of 2023, 9889 of 2023, 9898 of 2023, 9907 of 2023, 9909 of 2023, 9948 of 2023, 9964 of 2023, 10023 of 2023, 10054 of 2023, 10091 of 2023, 10101 of 2023, 10102 of 2023, 10103 of 2023, 10121 of 2023, 10122 of 2023, 10123 of 2023, 10124 of 2023, 10125 of 2023, 10126 of 2023, 10127 of 2023, 10128 of 2023, 10129 of 2023, 10130 of 2023, 10274 of 2023, 10280 of 2023, 10356 of 2023, 10450 of 2023, 10490 of 2023, 10551 of 2023, 10552 of 2023, 10553 of 2023, 10554 of 2023, 10581 of 2023, 10585 of 2023, 10660 of 2023, 10661 of 2023, 10663 of 2023, 10680 of 2023, 10687 of 2023, 10734 of 2023, 10760 of 2023, 10761 of 2023, 10764 of 2023, 10830 of 2023, 10832 of 2023, 10841 of 2023, 10843 of 2023, 10845 of 2023, 10862 of 2023, 10863 of 2023, 10945 of 2023, 10958 of 2023, 10959 of 2023, CWP No. 54 of 2024, 56 of 2024, 71 of 2024, 176 of 2024, 255 of 2024, 303 of 2024, 379 of 2024, 407 of 2024, 408 of 2024, 749 of 2024, 777 of 2024, 988 of 2024, 1101 of 2024, 1561 of 2024, 1659 of 2024, 1978 of 2024, 2505 of 2024, 2676 of 2024, 2820 of 2024, 3001 of 2024, 3049 of 2024, 3263 of 2024, 3351 of 2024, 3560 of 2024, 3761 of 2024, 3762 of 2024, 3810 of 2024, 3837 of 2024, 3947 of 2024, 4345 of 2024, 4382 of 2024, 5070 of 2024, 5085 of 2024, 5307 of 2024, 5478 of 2024, 5557 of 2024, 5635 of 2024, 5636 of 2024, 5637 of 2024, 5638 of 2024, 5639 of 2024, 5640 of 2024, 5641 of 2024, 5668 of 2024, 5753 of 2024, 5755 of 2024, 5860 of 2024, 5870 of 2024, 5889 of 2024, 5948 of 2024, 5949 of 2024, 5975 of 2024, 5977 of 2024, 6041 of 2024, 6043 of 2024, 6045 of
2024, 6047 of 2024, 6055 of 2024, 6101 of 2024, 6131 of 2024, 6185 of 2024, 6187 of 2024, 6215 of 2024, 6221 of 2024, 6249 of 2024, 6405 of 2024, 6407 of 2024, 6409 of 2024, 6564 of 2024, 6566 of 2024, 6615 of 2024, 6665 of 2024, 6667 of 2024, 6668 of 2024, 6669 of 2024, 6670 of 2024, 6721 of 2024, 6723 of 2024, 6724 of 2024, 6725 of 2024, 6726 of 2024, 6727 of 2024, 6779 of 2024, 6780 of 2024, 6781 of 2024, 6782 of 2024, 6802 of 2024, 6815 of 2024, 6816 of 2024, 6868 of 2024, 6869 of 2024, 6871 of 2024, 6873 of 2024, 6931 of 2024, 6947 of 2024, 6979 of 2024, 6983 of 2024, 7020 of 2024, 7249 of 2024, 7305 of 2024, 7306 of 2024, 7341 of 2024, 7371 of 2024, 7598 of 2024, 7605 of 2024, 7621 of 2024, 7715 of 2024, 7725 of 2024, 7771 of 2024, 7772 of 2024, 7803 of 2024, 7910 of 2024, 7911 of 2024, 7973 of 2024, 7977 of 2024, 8016 of 2024, 8094 of 2024, 8121 of 2024, 8166 of 2024, 8167 of 2024, 8185 of 2024, 8257 of 2024, 8261 of 2024, 8263 of 2024, 8266 of 2024, 8272 of 2024, 8477 of 2024, 8478 of 2024, 8497 of 2024, 8512 of 2024, 8531 of 2024, 8593 of 2024, 8600 of 2024, 8609 of 2024, 8654 of 2024, 8655 of 2024, 8664 of 2024, 8665 of 2024, 8667 of 2024, 8725 of 2024, 8731 of 2024, 8837 of 2024, 8840 of 2024, 8843 of 2024, 8844 of 2024, 8845 of 2024, 8897 of 2024, 8898 of 2024, 8899 of 2024, 8900 of 2024, 8901 of 2024, 8902 of 2024, 8905 of 2024, 8907 of 2024, 8945 of 2024, 8948 of 2024, 8977 of 2024, 8989 of 2024, 9050 of 2024, 9051 of 2024, 9078 of 2024, 9079 of 2024, 9080 of 2024, 9081 of 2024, 9082 of 2024, 9083 of 2024, 9096 of 2024, 9101 of 2024, 9151 of 2024, 9186 of 2024, 9189 of 2024, 9199 of 2024, 9200 of 2024, 9202 of 2024, 9221 of 2024, 9223 of 2024, 9224 of 2024, 9231 of 2024,
9253 of 2024, 9254 of 2024, 9255 of 2024, 9256 of 2024, 9257 of 2024, 9258 of 2024, 9259 of 2024, 9260 of 2024, 9268 of 2024, 9311 of 2024, 9312 of 2024, 9343 of 2024, 9344 of 2024, 9353 of 2024, 9363 of 2024, 9365 of 2024, 9376 of 2024, 9427 of 2024, 9445 of 2024, 9453 of 2024, 9469 of 2024, 9470 of 2024, 9471 of 2024, 9472 of 2024, 9473 of 2024, 9489 of 2024, 9507 of 2024, 9508 of 2024, 9551 of 2024, 9681 of 2024, 9845 of 2024, 9848 of 2024, 9850 of 2024, 9852 of 2024, 9859 of 2024, 9860 of 2024, 9888 of 2024, 9893 of 2024, 9894 of 2024, 9902 of 2024, 9903 of 2024, 9905 of 2024, 10009 of 2024, 10043 of 2024, 10050 of 2024, 10054 of 2024, 10062 of 2024, 10063 of 2024, 10182 of 2024, 10184 of 2024, 10202 of 2024, 10205 of 2024, 10225 of 2024, 10257 of 2024, 10259 of 2024, 10261 of 2024, 10262 of 2024, 10314 of 2024, 10315 of 2024, 10321 of 2024, 10322 of 2024, 10323 of 2024, 10334 of 2024, 10337 of 2024, 10385 of 2024, 10405 of 2024, 10427 of 2024, 10437 of 2024, 10442 of 2024, 10507 of 2024, 10514 of 2024, 10515 of 2024, 10573 of 2024, 10617 of 2024, 10623 of 2024, 10626 of 2024, 10627 of 2024, 10633 of 2024, 10805 of 2024, 10901 of 2024, 10902 of 2024, 10903 of 2024, 10904 of 2024, 10905 of 2024, 10906 of 2024, 10908 of 2024, 10925 of 2024, 10956 of 2024, 11046 of 2024, 11056 of 2024, 11082 of 2024, 11083 of 2024, 11085 of 2024, 11086 of 2024, 11183 of 2024, 11210 of 2024, 11211 of 2024, 11261 of 2024, 11297 of 2024, 11315 of 2024, 11318 of 2024, 11361 of 2024, 11405 of 2024, 11406 of 2024, 11419 of 2024, 11420 of 2024, 11421 of 2024, 11422 of 2024, 11461 of 2024, 11537 of 2024, 11553 of 2024, 11557 of 2024, 11709 of 2024, 11713 of 2024, 11715 of 2024, 11716 of 2024, 11753 of 2024, 11957 of 2024, 12057 of 2024, 12067 of 2024, 12096 of 2024,
12223 of 2024, 12323 of 2024, 12341 of 2024, 12373 of 2024, 12571 of 2024, 12572 of 2024, 12578 of 2024, 12616 of 2024, 12617 of 2024, 12618 of 2024, 12641 of 2024, 12760 of 2024, 12962 of 2024, 13131 of 2024, 13132 of 2024, 13133 of 2024, 13134 of 2024, 13136 of 2024, 13229 of 2024, 13265 of 2024, 13281 of 2024, 13632 of 2024, 13633 of 2024, 13634 of 2024, 13645 of 2024, 13646 of 2024, 13647 of 2024, 13648 of 2024, 13649 of 2024, 13651 of 2024, 14210 of 2024, 14631 of 2024, 14821 of 2024, 15050 of 2024, 15338 of 2024, 15559 of 2024, 15631 of 2024, 15635 of 2024, 15926 of 2024, 16195 of 2024, 16399 of 2024, 16667 of 2024, CMP (M) No. 2123 of 2024 in CWP No. 7890 of 2023, CWP No. 1755 of 2025, 1789 of 2025, 1841 of 2025, 1843 of 2025, 1847 of 2025, 1861 of 2025, 2075 of 2025, 2077 of 2025, 2487 of 2025, 3265 of 2025, 3554 of 2025, 3755 of 2025, 4477 of 2025, 4771 of 2025, 4773 of 2025, 4775 of 2025, 4846 of 2025, 4883 of 2025, 6867 of 2025, 6881 of 2025, 6920 of 2025, 6922 of 2025, 7684 of 2025, 7868 of 2025, 8037 of 2025, 8950 of 2025, 8978 of 2025, 9180 of 2025, 9910 of 2025, 9940 of 2025, 10100 of 2025, 10281 of 2025, 10283 of 2025, 10502 of 2025, 10622 of 2025, 10624 of 2025, 10627 of 2025, 10685 of 2025, 10853 of 2025, 10855 of 2025, 10856 of 2025, 10858 of 2025, 11647 of 2025, 11650 of 2025, 11654 of 2025, 11655 of 2025, 11657 of 2025, 11683 of 2025, 11684 of 2025, 11685 of 2025, 11686 of 2025, 11687 of 2025, 11688 of 2025, 11689 of 2025, 11690 of 2025, 12144 of 2025, 12145 of 2025, 12147 of 2025, 12293 of 2025 12487 of 2025, 13238 of 2025, 13325 of 2025, 13736 of 2025, 14018 of 2025, 14129 of 2025, 14782 of 2025, 14798 of 2025, 15276 of 2025, 15565 of 2025, 15683 of 2025, 16072 of 2025, 16302 of 2025, 16537 of 2025, 16549 of 2025, 16553 of 2025, 16555 of 2025, 16557
of 2025, 16569 of 2025, 17356 of 2025, 18709 of 2025, 18875 of 2025, 19799 of 2025, 19801 of 2025, 20439 of 2025, LPA No. 557 of 2025, CMP (M) No. 147 of 2025 in CWP No. 7843 of 2023, CWP No.1477 of 2026, 4318 of 2026, 5615 of 2026, 6111 of 2026, 6816 of 2026, 7655 of 2026, 7657 of 2026 ; and Ex. Petition 53 of 2024 in CWP No. 7731 of 2023, Ex. Petition 70 of 2024 in CWP No. 7825 of 2023, Ex. Petition 71 of 2024 in CWP No.7927 of 2023 Ex. Petition 595 of 2024 in CWP No. 3336 of 2024, Ex. Petition 594 of 2024 in CWP No.3424 of 2024 & Ex. Petition 292 of 2024 in CWP No.2473 of 2023.
Reserved on: 01.07.2026 Pronounced on:31.10.2026
_______________________________________________________________
1.
CWP No: 8504 of 2025
MADHU DESHTA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others 2.
...Respondents
CWP No: 1323 of 2023 DURGA SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others 3.
...Respondents
CWP No: 2313 of 2023 SHER SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Another 4.
...Respondents
CWP No: 2421 of 2023 AMAR CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
5.
CWP No: 3224 of 2023 DUNI CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others 6.
...Respondents
CWP No: 5453 of 2023 RAVI KANT KAUSHAL
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others 7.
...Respondents
CWP No: 5532 of 2023 HIGH COURT STAFF PENSIONERS WELFARE ASSOCIATION ...Petitioner Versus STATE OF HP & Others
8.
...Respondents
CWP No: 5544 of 2023 ASHOK KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others 9.
...Respondents
CWP No: 5651 of 2023 SUNIL KUMAR CHANDEL & Others
...Petitioners
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
10. CWP No: 5788 of 2023 KULBHUSHAN LAL
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Another
...Respondents
11. CWP No: 5844 of 2023 JAGDISH CHAND HRTC & Another
...Petitioner Versus
...Respondents
12. CWP No: 5847 of 2023 TAMESHWAR RAM
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Another
...Respondents
13. CWP No: 5848 of 2023 ASHWANI KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Another
...Respondents
14. CWP No: 5849 of 2023 ROSHAN LAL
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Another
...Respondents
15. CWP No: 5990 of 2023 BEENA SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
16. CWP No: 6023 of 2023 MANORMA DEVI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
17. CWP No: 6282 of 2023 RAMESHWARI DEVI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
18. CWP No: 6283 of 2023 SUBHASH CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
19. CWP No: 6284 of 2023 [
GAITRI DEVI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
20. CWP No: 6345 of 2023 SANTOSH KUMAR & Others
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
21. CWP No: 6611 of 2023 SURINDER SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
22. CWP No: 6952 of 2023 ROSHAN LAL KHAJURIA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
23. CWP No: 7089 of 2023 SUNDER LAL NEGI & Others
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
24. CWP No: 7152 of 2023 SARSWATI NANDAN
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
25. CWP No: 7153 of 2023 ROOP RAM SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
26. CWP No: 7158 of 2023 ONKAR SINGH SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others 27. CWP No: 7159 of 2023
...Respondents
MANORMA SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
28. CWP No: 7160 of 2023 DESH RAJ
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
29. CWP No: 7223 of 2023 DAULAT RAM
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
30. CWP No: 7244 of 2023 BALBIR SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
31. CWP No: 7245 of 2023 RAMESH CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
32. CWP No: 7246 of 2023 DEVINDER PAL
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
..Respondents
33. CWP No: 7247 of 2023 SUBHASH CHANDER
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
34. CWP No: 7248 of 2023 MANJEET SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
35. CWP No: 7249 of 2023 OM PRAKASH LAKHARWAL
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
36. CWP No: 7250 of 2023 SUBHASH RANA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
37. CWP No: 7251 of 2023 KASHMIR SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
38. CWP No: 7252 of 2023 KARAM CHAND VERMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
39. CWP No: 7253 of 2023 BIR SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
40. CWP No: 7254 of 2023 SURESH SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others 41. CWP No: 7255 of 2023
...Respondents
BOMDHIR SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
42. CWP No: 7335 of 2023 NANDA RAM
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
43. CWP No: 7341 of 2023 SURJEET SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
44. CWP No: 7376 of 2023 HP SECRETARIATE AND OTHER AFFILIATED PENSIONERS WELFARE ASSOCIATION ...Petitioner Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
45. CWP No: 7392 of 2023 LOTUS KUMARI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
46. CWP No: 7394 of 2023 NEELAM SAINI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
47. CWP No: 7481 of 2023 HEAMENDER KUMAR SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another 48. CWP No: 7644 of 2023
...Respondents
SATYA VRATA SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
49. CWP No: 7645 of 2023 BALBIR SINGH BARWAL
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
50. CWP No: 7646 of 2023 SATISH KAUL
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
51. CWP No: 7650 of 2023 RAJ KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
52. CWP No: 7699 of 2023 JAI RAM
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
53. CWP No: 7857 of 2023 C.K. CHATURVEDI
...Petitioner Versus
HPSEBL
...Respondents
54. CWP No: 7897 of 2023 GIAN CHAND BHATT
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL
...Respondents
55. CWP No: 7957 of 2023 ARUN KUMAR GUPTA
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL
...Respondents
56. CWP No: 7959 of 2023 HARISH KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HPSEBL
...Respondents
57. CWP No: 8039 of 2023 JIWAN SINGH THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL
...Respondents
58. CWP No: 8040 of 2023 PUSHAPHAS KUMAR SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL
...Respondents
59. CWP No: 8043 of 2023 BALJEET SINGH THAKUR & Others Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Petitioner ...Respondents
60. CWP No: 8050 of 2023 OM PRAKASH SHAMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
61. CWP No: 8059 of 2023 CHAMAN LAL
...Petitioner Versus
HPSEBL
...Respondents
62. CWP No: 8090 of 2023 KUSUM AGGARWAL
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
63. CWP No: 8097 of 2023 RAMESH CHAND THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
64. CWP No: 8101 of 2023 RAJ KUMAR SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL
...Respondents
65. CWP No. 8104 of 2023 SANTOSH MONGRA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
66. CWP No: 8106 of 2023 ANITA GUPTA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
67. CWP No: 8177 of 2023 VIJAY KUMARI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
68. CWP No: 8180 of 2023 UMESH KUMAR GUPTA
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL
...Respondents
69. CWP No: 8192 of 2023 RAMESH CHAUHAN
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL
...Respondents
70. CWP No: 8193 of 2023 NEEL KANTH DUTTA
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL
...Respondents
71. CWP No: 8233 of 2023 CHUNI LAL
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
72. CWP No: 8241 of 2023 DILBAG SINGH RANA HPSEBL
Versus
...Petitioner ...Respondents
73. CWP No: 8242 of 2023 SANJEEV KUMAR GUPTA
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL
...Respondents
74. CWP No: 8246 of 2023 SURINDER KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
75. CWP No: 8256 of 2023 SHER SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HPSEBL
...Respondents
76. CWP No: 8312 of 2023 RAM KRISHAN KAUNDAL
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
77. CWP No: 8501 of 2023 NEELAM SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
78. CWP No: 8508 of 2023 SURESH KUMAR GUPTA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
79. CWP No: 8559 of 2023 SOHAN LAL THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
80. CWP No: 8560 of 2023 PREM LAL VERMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
81. CWP No: 8561 of 2023 HET RAM KAUNDAL
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
82. CWP No: 8562 of 2023 REKHA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others 83. CWP No: 8563 of 2023 SUBHASH CHAND
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
84. CWP No: 8579 of 2023 LEKH RAM
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
85. CWP No: 8581 of 2023 MURARI LAL
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
86. CWP No: 8585 of 2023 KARTAR SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
87. CWP No: 8587 of 2023 KARTAR SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
88. CWP No: 8734 of 2023 MOHINDER SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
89. CWP No: 8742 of 2023 SOHAN SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
90. CWP No: 8748 of 2023 SATISH KUMAR SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
91. CWP No: 8749 of 2023 DHANI RAM
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
92. CWP No: 8750 of 2023 TRIPTA GUPTA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
93. CWP No: 8751 of 2023 RAMESH CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
94. CWP No: 8752 of 2023 YADVENDER KUMAR SHARMA Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Petitioner ...Respondents
95. CWP No: 8754 of 2023 DHARAM SINGH THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
96. CWP No: 8776 of 2023 SURYA PRAKASH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
97. CWP No: 8940 of 2023 SHIV RAM TANWAR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
..Respondents
98. CWP No: 9000 of 2023 BHAGAT RAM TANWAR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
99. CWP No: 9001 of 2023 ANIL KUMAR SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
100. CWP No: 9002 of 2023 ANANT RAM SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
101. CWP No: 9176 of 2023 LACHHI RAM
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
102. CWP No: 9177 of 2023 VEENA SEN
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
103. CWP No: 9179 of 2023 PURAN CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
104. CWP No: 9180 of 2023 DEVI SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
105. CWP No: 9217 of 2023 ANU KAISTHA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
106. CWP No: 9254 of 2023 TILAK RAJ
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
107. CWP No: 9255 of 2023 SURESH KUMAR THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
108. CWP No: 9256 of 2023 SUSHIL KUMAR RANA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
109. CWP No: 9257 of 2023 RAJESH KAPATIA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
110. CWP No: 9274 of 2023 SUMAN LATA
...Petitioner Versus
HPSEBL
...Respondents
111. CWP No: 9312 of 2023 BRIJ LAL SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
112. CWP No: 9363 of 2023 PREM CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
113. CWP No: 9387 of 2023 SUSHIL KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
..Respondents
114. CWP No: 9389 of 2023 GOPAL SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
115. CWP No: 9471 of 2023 NARESH KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
116. CWP No: 9534 of 2023 RAJINDER SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
117. CWP No: 9546 of 2023 PREM LAL
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
118. CWP No: 9547 of 2023 SOLU RAM
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
119. CWP No: 9581 of 2023 MADAN LAL JOSHI AND ANR.
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
120. CWP No: 9675 of 2023 HIRA SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
121. CWP No: 9703 of 2023 BAHADUR SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
122. CWP No: 9767 of 2023 MEHAR CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
123. CWP No. 9768 of 2023 BHIMI RAM
Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Petitioner ...Respondents
124. CWP No: 9769 of 2023 DURGA RAM
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
125. CWP No: 9770 of 2023 DILJAS RAI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
126. CWP No: 9849 of 2023 HET RAM
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
127. CWP No: 9851 of 2023 HAMENDER SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus HRTC & Others
...Respondents
128. CWP No: 9853 of 2023 SHER SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
129. CWP No: 9885 of 2023 RAM GOPAL
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
130. CWP No: 9887 of 2023 SADIK MOHAMMAD
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
131. CWP No: 9889 of 2023 DAVINDER KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
132. CWP No: 9898 of 2023 ROSHAN LAL
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
133. CWP No: 9907 of 2023 PURSHOTAM RAM
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
134. CWP No: 9909 of 2023 KANSHI RAM
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
135. CWP No: 9948 of 2023 SURESH KUMAR PATHAK
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
136. CWP No: 9964 of 2023 PUSHPA DEVI
...Petitioner Versus
HPU & Another
...Respondents
137. CWP No: 10023 of 2023 RAMESH KUMAR KAUNDAL
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
138. CWP No: 10054 of 2023 RANJANA MALHOTRA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
139. CWP No: 10091 of 2023 RAJ KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
140. CWP No. 10101 of 2023 NEELAM SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
141. CWP No: 10102 of 2023 PARESH PRABHAKAR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
142. CWP No: 10103 of 2023 AJAY KUMAR KAHOL
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
143. CWP No: 10121 of 2023 VANDANA BADHWAR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
144. CWP No: 10122 of 2023 RAM PAUL BHARDWAJ
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
145. CWP No: 10123 of 2023 SANJEEV SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
146. CWP No: 10124 of 2023 ANIL RATTAN VERMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
147. CWP No: 10125 of 2023 ANIL THAKUR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
148. CWP No: 10126 of 2023 INDER DEV SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
149. CWP No: 10127 of 2023 YASH PAUL SAINI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
150. CWP No: 10128 of 2023 VIJAY KUMAR DUTTA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
151. CWP No: 10129 of 2023 TRILOK CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
152. CWP No: 10130 of 2023 SUBHASH CHANDER CHAUDHARY
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
153. CWP No: 10274 of 2023 SURESH KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
154. CWP No: 10280 of 2023 DEVINDER SINGH KUTAAL
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
155. CWP No: 10356 of 2023 BHIM SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
156. CWP No: 10450 of 2023 CHANDER PRAKASH
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
157. CWP No: 10490 of 2023 SARWAN KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
158. CWP No: 10551 of 2023 HET RAM
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
159. CWP No. 10552 of 2023 PRAKASH CHAND THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
160. CWP No: 10553 of 2023 MADAN LAL THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
161. CWP No: 10554 of 2023 RAJENDER SEN
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
162. CWP No: 10581 of 2023 JAGAT SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
163. CWP No: 10585 of 2023 PRATAP SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
164. CWP No: 10660 of 2023 SUDHAKAR PRASAD
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
....Respondents
165. CWP No: 10661 of 2023 HARI RAM
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
166. CWP No: 10663 of 2023 PREM LAL
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
167. CWP No: 10680 of 2023 RAJ KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
168. CWP No: 10687 of 2023 KARAM CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
169. CWP No: 10734 of 2023 NAVEEN PURI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
170. CWP No: 10760 of 2023 GIAN CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
171. CWP No: 10761 of 2023 BHIM SINGH HRTC & Others
Versus
...Petitioner ...Respondents
172. CWP No: 10764 of 2023 VIDYA SAGAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
173. CWP No: 10830 of 2023 NARINDER CHAUHAN
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
174. CWP No: 10832 of 2023 TULSI RAM
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
175. CWP No: 10841 of 2023 PAL SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
176. CWP No: 10843 of 2023 SUBHASH CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
177. CWP No: 10845 of 2023 USHA DEVI
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
178. CWP No: 10862 of 2023 SANJAY SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
179. CWP No: 10863 of 2023 NARESH KUMAR VASHIST
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
180. CWP No: 10945 of 2023 PADAM DEV
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
181. CWP No: 10958 of 2023 AHILYA KAPOOR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
182. CWP No: 10959 of 2023 ASHOK KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
183. CWP No: 54 of 2024 MAHESH KUMAR SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
184. CWP No: 56 of 2024 MAHINDER SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
185. CWP No: 71 of 2024 SUBHASH CHAND HRTC & Others
...Petitioner Versus
...Respondents
186. CWP No: 176 of 2024 PREM LAL SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
187. CWP No: 255 of 2024 PARAM DEV
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
188. CWP No: 303 of 2024 DURGA DASS
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
189. CWP No: 379 of 2024 NARENDER KUMAR GUPTA & Others
...Petitioners
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
190. CWP No: 407 of 2024 NARINDER MOHAN SAINI
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
191. CWP No: 408 of 2024 KAMLA SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
192. CWP No: 749 of 2024 RAJINDER PAL
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
193. CWP No: 777 of 2024 TARA CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
194. CWP No: 988 of 2024 ASHWANI KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HPSEBL
...Respondents
195. CWP No: 1101 of 2024 SUSHIL KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
196. CWP No: 1561 of 2024 ANJANA KUMARI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
197. CWP No: 1659 of 2024 SURINDER SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
198. CWP No: 1978 of 2024 MANOHAR LAL SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus HONOURABLE HIGH COURT OF HP & Another ...Respondents 199. CWP No: 505 of 2024 GANGA RAM HRTC & Others
...Petitioner Versus
...Respondents
200. CWP No: 2676 of 2024 KANWARJEET SINGH MALHOTRA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
201. CWP No. 2820 of 2024 RAMESH CHAND PARIHAR HPSEBL
Versus
...Petitioner ...Respondents
202. CWP No: 3001 of 2024 SUMAN RAWAT
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP &Others 203. CWP No: 3049 of 2024 PREM LAL SHARMA
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
204. CWP No: 3263 of 2024 RAMPAL
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
205. CWP No: 3351 of 2024 RAVI SHANKAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
206. CWP No: 3560 of 2024 PUNEET VATSAL
...Petitioner Versus
HPSEBL
...Respondents
207. CWP No: 3761 of 2024 SATISH KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Another
...Respondents
208. CWP No: 3762 of 2024 RATTAN LAL
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Another
...Respondents
209. CWP No: 3810 of 2024 YOGINDER KUMAR THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL
...Respondents
210. CWP No: 3837 of 2024 DEEPINDER SINGH BATTO
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL
...Respondents
211. CWP No: 3947 of 2024 RAMESH CHAND SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
212. CWP No: 4345 of 2024 CHANCHAL DASS
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
213. CWP No: 4382 of 2024 JEET RAM
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
214. CWP No: 5070 of 2024 BAL KRISHAN VERMA & Others
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
215. CWP No: 5085 of 2024 RAJINDER PAL RANA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
216. CWP No: 5307 of 2024 KAILASH CHAND THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others 217. CWP No: 5478 of 2024 VIPAN KUMAR
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
218. CWP No: 5557 of 2024 UDHAM LAL CHAUHAN & Others
...Petitioner
Versus State of H.P. and others
...Respondents
219. CWP No: 5635 of 2024 ANJU SOOD
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
220. CWP No: 5636 of 2024 RAM KARAN
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
221. CWP No: 5637 of 2024 JAI CHAND VERMA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
222. CWP No: 5638 of 2024 USHA RANI
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
223. CWP No: 5639 of 2024 KRISHAN DUTT SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others 224. CWP No: 5640 of 2024 SHASHI KANTA
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
225. CWP No: 5641 of 2024 VIDYA KAPTA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
226. CWP No: 5668 of 2024 JIT SINGH & Others
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
227. CWP No: 5753 of 2024 ASHWANI KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
228. CWP No: 5755 of 2024 KHUSHI RAM
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
229. CWP No: 5860 of 2024 RAJESHWAR SINGH DUTTA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
230. CWP No: 5870 of 2024 KAMLA SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
231. CWP No: 5889 of 2024 ANIL KUMAR & Others
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
232. CWP No: 5948 of 2024 NISHA GUPTA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
233. CWP No: 5949 of 2024 THAKUR SAIN KAPTA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
234. CWP No: 5975 of 2024 VIJAY KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
235. CWP No: 5977 of 2024 RAJ KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
236. CWP No: 6041 of 2024 KRISHAN KUMAR SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP
...Respondents
237. CWP No: 6043 of 2024 GURVINDER PAL SINGH
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP
...Respondents
238. CWP No: 6045 of 2024 RAJ KUMAR KANWAR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
239. CWP No: 6047 of 2024 ASHOK KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
240. CWP No: 6055 of 2024 RAJINDER SINGH PAL
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL & Another
...Respondents
241. CWP No: 6101 of 2024 BISHAN DASS
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
242. CWP No: 6131 of 2024 HAR PARKASH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
243.CWP No: 6185 of 2024 MURARI LAL
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
244. CWP No: 6187 of 2024 DEVKU RAM
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others 245. CWP No: 6215 of 2024
...Respondents
SUSHIL KUMAR SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL
...Respondents
246. CWP No: 6221 of 2024 HARI DASS BANOLTA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
247. CWP No: 6249 of 2024 PARAS RAM VERMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
248. CWP No: 6405 of 2024 NANAK CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
249. CWP No: 6407 of 2024 ATMA RAM
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
250. CWP No: 6409 of 2024 HARBHAJAN SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
251. CWP No: 6564 of 2024 RAMESH THAKUR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
252. CWP No: 6566 of 2024 PARWATI DEVI VERMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
253. CWP No: 6615 of 2024 DEVENDER PAL SINGH
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL
...Respondents
254. CWP No: 6665 of 2024 CHAIN SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
255. CWP No: 6667 of 2024 KRISHAN DATT SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
256. CWP No: 6668 of 2024 JEET RAM SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
257. CWP No: 6669 of 2024 VIRENDER SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
258. CWP No: 6670 of 2024 SUNDER SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
259. CWP No: 6721 of 2024 RADHA RANI SOOD
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
260. CWP No: 6723 of 2024 SHAKUNTLA DEVI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
261. CWP No: 6724 of 2024 GANGA RAM SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
262. CWP No: 6725 of 2024 AMAR SINGH VERMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
263. CWP No: 6726 of 2024 RAJ SOOD
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
264. CWP No: 6727 of 2024 KALA DEVI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
265. CWP No: 6779 of 2024 SITA RAM SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
266. CWP No: 6780 of 2024 SUBHASH CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
267. CWP No: 6781 of 2024 SATISH KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
268. CWP No: 6782 of 2024 KUSHAL SINGH REHALIA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
269. CWP No: 6802 of 2024 KHIMA RAM VERMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
270. CWP No: 6815 of 2024 JOGINDER SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
271. CWP No: 6816 of 2024 BRAHAM DASS
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
272. CWP No: 6868 of 2024 VIRENDER THAKUR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
273. CWP No: 6869 of 2024 MOHAN LAL
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
274. CWP No: 6871 of 2024 MADHU SANGHAIK
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
275. CWP No: 6873 of 2024 SUNITA RAONGTA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
276. CWP No: 6931 of 2024 JOGINDER KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Another
...Respondents
277. CWP No: 6947 of 2024 SOHAN LAL & Others
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
278. CWP No: 6979 of 2024 OM SWAROOP SHARMA & Others
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL & Others
...Respondents
279. CWP No: 6983 of 2024 JEET SINGH DHARMANI
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others 280. CWP No: 7020 of 2024 RAJINDER KUMAR SHARMA
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
281. CWP No: 7249 of 2024 NAND LAL SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
282. CWP No: 7305 of 2024 NRIPENDRA KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
State of H.P. and others
...Respondents
283. CWP No: 7306 of 2024 ANOOP ANAND BHATNAGAR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
284. CWP No: 7341 of 2024 DHANI RAM CHANDEL
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
..Respondents
285. CWP No: 7371 of 2024 NIRAJ PALIWAL
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF H P & Others
...Respondents
286. CWP No: 7598 of 2024 NASIR ALI KADRI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
287. CWP No: 7605 of 2024 JAGDISH SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
288. CWP No: 7621 of 2024 OM PRAKASH SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others 289. CWP No: 7715 of 2024 MANOJ KUMAR SHARMA
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
290. CWP No: 7725 of 2024 RAKESH SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
291. CWP No: 7771 of 2024 SHAMBU SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
292. CWP No: 7772 of 2024 UMESH SHARMA & Another
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
293. CWP No: 7803 of 2024 NAND LAL SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
294. CWP No: 7910 of 2024 MEENA BAM
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
295. CWP No: 7911 of 2024 PUSHPINDER MALIK
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
296. CWP No: 7973 of 2024 MEENA GOYAL
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
297. CWP No: 7977 of 2024 DHARAM CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Another
...Respondents
298. CWP No: 8016 of 2024 GULZAR HASSAN
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
299. CWP No: 8094 of 2024 BHAWANI SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
300. CWP No: 8121 of 2024 SITA DEVI & Another
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
301. CWP No: 8166 of 2024 RAMESHWAR KUMAR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
302. CWP No: 8167 of 2024 SHANTI THAKUR & Another
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
303. CWP No: 8185 of 2024 PREM SUKH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
304. CWP No: 8257 of 2024 KAMAL KISHORE
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
305. CWP No: 8261 of 2024 YASHWANT SINGH PATHANIA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
306. CWP No: 8263 of 2024 HEMRAJ
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
307. CWP No: 8266 of 2024 VIDYA SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
308. CWP No: 8272 of 2024 BRINDER CHAUHAN
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
309. CWP No: 8477 of 2024 KEWAL KRISHAN KAPOOR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
310. CWP No: 8478 of 2024 ANIL MANUJA
Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Petitioner ...Respondents
311. CWP No: 8497 of 2024 JAGDISH THAKUR & Others
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
312. CWP No: 8512 of 2024 MOHINDER PAUL
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others 313. CWP No: 8531 of 2024 VIKRAM JEET SINGH
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus HRTC & Others
...Respondents
314. CWP No: 8593 of 2024 RAJESHWAR SINGH JASWAL
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
315. CWP No: 8600 of 2024 BHAGWATI PRASAD KOTHARI
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
316. CWP No: 8609 of 2024 DALIP SINGH CHAUHAN
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others 317. CWP No: 8654 of 2024
...Respondents
SANJEEV SOOD
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
318. CWP No: 8655 of 2024 VED PRAKASH SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
319. CWP No: 8664 of 2024 RAM RATTAN
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
320. CWP No: 8665 of 2024 PREM THAKUR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
321. CWP No: 8667 of 2024 SHIV KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
322. CWP No: 8725 of 2024 VANA JYOTSANA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
323. CWP No: 8731 of 2024 RAJ KUMAR DOGRA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
324. CWP No: 8837 of 2024 JEEVAN LAL
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
325. CWP No: 8840 of 2024 BRIJ LAL THAKUR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
326. CWP No: 8843 of 2024 DALIP SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
327. CWP No: 8844 of 2024 GULAB SINGH KANWAR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
328. CWP No: 8845 of 2024 ROSHAN LAL LACKTOO
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
329. CWP No: 8897 of 2024 BALBIR BAHADUR SINGH SUNTA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
330. CWP No: 8898 of 2024 RAMAN RANI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
331. CWP No: 8899 of 2024 MOTI LAL NEGI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
332. CWP No: 8900 of 2024 DALEEP SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
333. CWP No: 8901 of 2024 HEM PRABHA CHAUHAN
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
334. CWP No: 8902 of 2024 PAWAN KUMAR BHARDWAJ
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
335. CWP No: 8905 of 2024 RAJ KUMAR & Another
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
336. CWP No: 8907 of 2024 HARI DASS CHAUHAN
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
337. CWP No: 8945 of 2024 MADAN LAL SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
338. CWP No: 8948 of 2024 HARDYAL SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
339. CWP No: 8977 of 2024 VINOD KUMAR THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
340. CWP No: 8989 of 2024 SUJATA SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
341. CWP No: 9050 of 2024 MANOHAR LAL
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
342. CWP No: 9051 of 2024 MAHIMA VERMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
343. CWP No: 9078 of 2024 LALIT SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others 344. CWP No: 9079 of 2024 PUSHPA DEVI
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
345. CWP No: 9080 of 2024 HARI SINGH CHAUHAN
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
346. CWP No. 9081 of 2024 JEET SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
347. CWP No. 9082 of 2024 MADAN LAL RANOTE
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
348. CWP No: 9083 of 2024 SHANKAR SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
349. CWP No: 9096 of 2024 GAURI DUTT SHARMA & Others
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
350. CWP No: 9101 of 2024 CHANDERJOT SINGH
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
351. CWP No: 9151 of 2024 PREM SINGH & Others
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
352. CWP No: 9186 of 2024 RAM DASS PARWANA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
353. CWP No: 9189 of 2024 NARESH CHAND SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
354. CWP No: 9199 of 2024 LAL CHAND SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others 355. CWP No: 9200 of 2024
...Respondents
RAJINDER SINGH THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
356. CWP No: 9202 of 2024 MADAN LAL SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
357. CWP No: 9221 of 2024 NAVNEET HANDA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
358. CWP No: 9223 of 2024 AJAY PATHANIA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others 359. CWP No: 9224 of 2024 NARESH SHARMA
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
360. CWP No: 9231 of 2024 ASHOK HANDA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
361. CWP No: 9253 of 2024 SURENDER PAUL KASHYAP
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
362. CWP No: 9254 of 2024 MANGAT RAM
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others 363. CWP No: 9255 of 2024 MAN SINGH
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
364. CWP No: 9256 of 2024 GULABA RAM
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
365. CWP No: 9257 of 2024 ACHHAR SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
366. CWP No: 9258 of 2024 KRISHAN CHAND THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
367. CWP No: 9259 of 2024 BAHADUR SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
368. CWP No: 9260 of 2024 PURAN CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others 369. CWP No: 9268 of 2024 MADHU BALA
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
370. CWP No: 9311 of 2024 KULDIP SINGH JASWAL
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
371. CWP No: 9312 of 2024 NARINDER KUMAR GUPTA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
372. CWP No: 9343 of 2024 PUNAM JAIN
Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Petitioner ...Respondents
373. CWP No: 9344 of 2024 RAVINDER SINGH RANA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
374. CWP No: 9353 of 2024 RAJESH KUMAR VERMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
375. CWP No: 9363 of 2024 BALBIR KUMAR THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others 376. CWP No: 9365 of 2024 SANT RAM RANA
..Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
377. CWP No: 9376 of 2024 DALIP SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
378. CWP No: 9427 of 2024 BIJENDER SINGH RANA & Another
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
379. CWP No: 9445 of 2024 DEVESHWAR PANDEY
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
380. CWP No: 9453 of 2024 DEEP RAM SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
381. CWP No: 9469 of 2024 SURESH KUMAR VERMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
382. CWP No: 9470 of 2024 RAJESH KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
383. CWP No: 9471 of 2024 YASH PAL SINGH VERMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
384. CWP No: 9472 of 2024 MAHESH GUPTA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
385. CWP No: 9473 of 2024 RAKESH SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others 386. CWP No: 9489 of 2024 KAMLESH KHANNA
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
387. CWP No: 9507 of 2024 SARWAN SINGH GULERIA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
388. CWP No: 9508 of 2024 GHANSHYAM THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
389. CWP No: 9551 of 2024 BHAGAT RAM
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
390. CWP No: 9681 of 2024 BHAG SINGH & Another
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
391. CWP No: 9845 of 2024 DHARAM SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
392. CWP No: 9848 of 2024 NIKKA RAM
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others 393. CWP No: 9850 of 2024 KHEM CHAND
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
394. CWP No: 9852 of 2024 VIJAY KUMAR & Others
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
395. CWP No: 9859 of 2024 KRISHAN LAL
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
396. CWP No: 9860 of 2024 YASHWANT SINGH PALSRA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
..Respondents
397. CWP No: 9888 of 2024 SHAKTI AWASTHI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
398. CWP No: 9893 of 2024 JAWAHAR SARUP
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
399. CWP No: 9894 of 2024 ARVIND KUMAR SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others 400. CWP No: 9902 of 2024 LAIQ RAM CHAUHAN
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
401. CWP No: 9903 of 2024 KAMAL KRISHAN GUPTA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
402. CWP No: 9905 of 2024 LAIQ RAM
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
403. CWP No: 10009 of 2024 MOHAN LAL BHARDWAJ
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others 404. CWP No: 10043 of 2024 JEET RAM
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
405. CWP No: 10050 of 2024 MANOHAR LAL
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
406. CWP No: 10054 of 2024 SANDHYA DEVI
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others 407. CWP No: 10062 of 2024 GANGA KUMAR
,..Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
408. CWP No: 10063 of 2024 KESHAV SINGH NEGI
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
409. CWP No: 10182 of 2024 PRAKASH CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
410. CWP No: 10184 of 2024 RAM SWAROOP
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
411. CWP No: 10202 of 2024 BAM DEV SHARMA & Others
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
412. CWP No: 10205 of 2024 SANTOSH KUMAR BHARDWAJ
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
413. CWP No: 10225 of 2024 RAVINDER SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others 414. CWP No: 10257 of 2024 NIMA CHHERING
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
..Respondents
415. CWP No: 10259 of 2024 DESH RAJ
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
416. CWP No: 10261 of 2024 NARENDER SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
417. CWP No: 10262 of 2024 ONKAR CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
418. CWP No: 10314 of 2024 LAHOR SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
419. CWP No: 10315 of 2024 BIRBAL SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
420. CWP No: 10321 of 2024 MADAN LAL SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others 421. CWP No: 10322 of 2024 KIRTI SINGH THAKUR
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
422. CWP No: 10323 of 2024 AJAY KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
423. CWP No: 10334 of 2024 SANJEEV KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
424. CWP No: 10337 of 2024 PRAKASH SINGH CHAUHAN
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others 425. CWP No: 10385 of 2024 HARI RAM SHARMA
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
..Respondents
426. CWP No: 10405 of 2024 JOGINDER SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
427. CWP No: 10427 of 2024 BHAGAT CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others 428. CWP No: 10437 of 2024 RANBIR SINGH
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
429. CWP No: 10442 of 2024 INDER CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
430. CWP No: 10507 of 2024 KULDEEP
Versus
HRTC & Others 431. CWP No: 10514 of 2024
...Petitioner ...Respondents
KANSHI RAM KAUNDAL
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
432. CWP No: 10515 of 2024 YASH PAL GARNERIA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
433. CWP No: 10573 of 2024 SURJEET SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
434. CWP No: 10617 of 2024 VIRENDER SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
THE HPSEBL & Another
...Respondents
435. CWP No: 10623 of 2024 VINEET KAUSHAL
...Petitioner Versus
THE HPSEBL & Another
...Respondents
436. CWP No: 10626 of 2024 PUSHPA CHANDEL
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
437. CWP No: 10627 of 2024 RANBIR SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
438. CWP No: 10633 of 2024 RAJESH MAHAJAN
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Another 439. CWP No: 10805 of 2024 SARWAN LAL SHARMA
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
440. CWP No: 10901 of 2024 SHYAM BIHARI LAL CHAUHAN
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
..Respondents
441. CWP No: 10902 of 2024 KESHAV RAM
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others 442. CWP No: 10903 of 2024 GOPAL DASS
Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents ...Petitioner ..Respondents
443. CWP No: 10904 of 2024 VINOD SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
444. CWP No: 10905 of 2024 PARMOD KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
445. CWP No: 10906 of 2024 RAMESH CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
446. CWP No: 10908 of 2024 VIJAY SINGH CHAUHAN
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
447. CWP No: 10925 of 2024 PARMOD KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
448. CWP No: 10956 of 2024 RAJINDER SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others 449. CWP No: 11046 of 2024 ALBEL SINGH THAKUR & Others
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
450. CWP No: 11056 of 2024 RAKESH KUMAR DHIMAN & Others
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
..Respondents
451. CWP No: 11082 of 2024 KARAM CHAND SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
452. CWP No: 11083 of 2024 LEKH RAM SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others 453. CWP No: 11085 of 2024 PARMA NAND THAKUR
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
454. CWP No: 11086 of 2024 HEM RAJ
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
455. CWP No: 11183 of 2024 SURESH KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others 456. CWP No: 11210 of 2024 SANT RAM
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
457. CWP No: 11211 of 2024 KRISHAN KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
458. CWP No: 11261 of 2024 RANDHIR SINGH KATOCH
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
459. CWP No: 11297 of 2024 REWAL SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
460. CWP No: 11315 of 2024 BIDHI CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
461. CWP No: 11318 of 2024 DHANI RAM SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
462. CWP No: 11361 of 2024 ANIL SOOD
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others 463. CWP No: 11405 of 2024 ANJNA KUMARI
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
464. CWP No: 11406 of 2024 RAVI KANT
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
465. CWP No: 11419 of 2024 SAROJ KAPUR SANGRAI
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
466. CWP No: 11420 of 2024 SUSHIL KUMAR SANGRAI
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
467. CWP No: 11421 of 2024 SUBHASH CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
468. CWP No: 11422 of 2024 KAMLESH KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
469. CWP No: 11461 of 2024 KAMLA DEVI
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others 470. CWP No: 11537 of 2024 SONA DEVI
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
471. CWP No: 11553 of 2024 CHANDER PRABHA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
472. CWP No: 11557 of 2024 DILE RAM THAKUR
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
473. CWP No: 11709 of 2024 ANIL BHAI PURI & Others
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
474. CWP No: 11713 of 2024 JAYANT SHARMA & Others
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
475. CWP No: 11715 of 2024 VIJENDER THAKUR & Another
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
476. CWP No: 11716 of 2024 JAGDEV & Others
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
477. CWP No: 11753 of 2024 SUNIL KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
THE HPSEBL & Others
...Respondents
478. CWP No: 11957 of 2024 SUMESH KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
479. CWP No: 12057 of 2024 VARESH KUMAR GUPTA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Another
..Respondents
480. CWP No: 12067 of 2024 JAGDISH SINGH JASWAL & Others
...Petitioners
Versus THE HP SCHEDULED CASTES AND SCHEDULED TRIBES DEVELOPMENT CORPORATION ...Respondents 481. CWP No: 12096 of 2024 LAYAK RAM SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
482. CWP No: 12223 of 2024 PAINE RAM & Others
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
483. CWP No: 12323 of 2024 RAJESH BAKSHI
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
484. CWP No: 12341 of 2024 OM PARKASH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
485. CWP No: 12373 of 2024 MOHAN SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
486. CWP No: 12571 of 2024 SHYAM SINGH THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
487. CWP No: 12572 of 2024 PREM KUMARI SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
488. CWP No: 12578 of 2024 KUSUM LATA KALIA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
489. CWP No: 12616 of 2024 KUSAM CHAND MAHANT
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
490. CWP No: 12617 of 2024 SHAMSHER SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
491. CWP No: 12618 of 2024 BALBIR SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
492. CWP No: 12641 of 2024 SATISH KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
493. CWP No: 12760 of 2024 MANMOHAN CHAND SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
..Respondents
494. CWP No: 12962 of 2024 LALTI CHANDER KATOCH
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others 495. CWP No: 13131 of 2024
...Respondents
NARENDER PAL SEHGAL
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
496. CWP No: 13132 of 2024 BRAHAM DASS
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
497. CWP No: 13133 of 2024 RAJ KUMAR RANA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
498. CWP No: 13134 of 2024 RAJ KUMAR SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
499. CWP No: 13136 of 2024 DESH RAJ
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
500. CWP No: 13229 of 2024 HANS RAJ
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
501. CWP No: 13265 of 2024 LEELA DHAR SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
502. CWP No: 13281 of 2024 SURAT RAM THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
503. CWP No: 13632 of 2024 JAI GOPAL
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
504. CWP No: 13633 of 2024 BALDEV KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
505. CWP No: 13634 of 2024 BHARAT BHUSHAN
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
506. CWP No: 13645 of 2024 SURAJ PRAKASH
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
507. CWP No: 13646 of 2024 TIKAM CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
508. CWP No: 13647 of 2024 NAHAK RAM
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
509. CWP No: 13648 of 2024 MOHAN SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others 510. CWP No: 13649 of 2024 PRITAMA SHARMA
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
511. CWP No: 13651 of 2024 RAJENDER SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
512. CWP No: 14210 of 2024 RAM LAL VERMA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
513. CWP No: 14631 of 2024 DEEPIKA WALIA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
514. CWP No: 14821 of 2024 KUNDAN LAL
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
515. CWP No: 15050 of 2024 NISHU SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others.
...Respondents
516. CWP No: 15338 of 2024 VIDYA NAND
Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Petitioner ...Respondents
517. CWP No: 15559 of 2024 SEWA NAND
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
518. CWP No: 15631 of 2024 HIRANAND ATTRI
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
519. CWP No: 15635 of 2024 NARAYAN SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
520. CWP No: 15926 of 2024 PROMILA DEVI
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
521. CWP No: 16195 of 2024 PYARE LAL VERMA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
522. CWP No: 16399 of 2024 LEKH RAJ & Others
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
523. CWP No: 16667 of 2024 VIRENDER SINGH & Others
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP AND OTHERS 524. CMP(M): 2123 of 2024 in CWP No: 7890 of 2023 THE STATE OF HP AND OTHERS
...Petitioner
Versus RAVINDER CHAND AND ANOTHER
...Respondents
525. CWP No: 1755 of 2025 KRISHAN CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
526. CWP No: 1789 of 2025 RAJINDER SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
527. CWP No: 1841 of 2025 BHUPINDER SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
528. CWP No: 1843 of 2025 CHAMAN LAL
...Petitioner
Versus HRTC & Others
...Respondents
529. CWP No: 1847 of 2025 PREM KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
530. CWP No: 1861 of 2025 BAL KRISHAN VERMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
531. CWP No: 2075 of 2025 BAHADUR SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
532. CWP No: 2077 of 2025 KAMALJEET SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
533. CWP No: 2487 of 2025 ROSHAN LAL & Others
...Petitioner
Versus HRTC & Another
...Respondents
534. CWP No: 3265 of 2025 NAND LAL
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
535. CWP No: 3554 of 2025 RAKESH GUPTA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
536. CWP No: 3755 of 2025 RAM DEV SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
537. CWP No: 4477 of 2025 RAJINDER KUMAR & Others
...Petitioner
Versus HRTC & Another
...Respondents
538. CWP No: 4771 of 2025 KULDEEP SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
539. CWP No: 4773 of 2025 KANTA DEVI
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
540. CWP No: 4775 of 2025 YASHODA
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
541. CWP No: 4846 of 2025 ANIL KUMAR KAKKAR
...Petitioner
Versus State of HP & Others
...Respondents
542. CWP No: 4883 of 2025 CHANCHAL JOSHI
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Another
...Respondents
543. CWP No: 6867 of 2025 ARUNA KUMARI
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
544. CWP No: 6881 of 2025 RAJ MAL MUKUL
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
545. CWP No: 6920 of 2025 BALWANT SINGH BHATIA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
546. CWP No: 6922 of 2025 SURINDER KUMAR DHIMAN
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
547. CWP No: 7684 of 2025 SURINDER VASHISTHA & Others
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
548. CWP No: 7868 of 2025 SARLA SHARMA & Others
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
549. CWP No: 8037 of 2025 JULMI SHARMA & Others
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
550. CWP No: 8950 of 2025 VICTOR DEAN
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
551. CWP No: 8978 of 2025 SHYAM LAL SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
552. CWP No: 9180 of 2025 KARAM CHAND THAKUR & Others
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
553. CWP No: 9910 of 2025 DIKKA SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
554. CWP No: 9940 of 2025 VINAY KUMAR SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
555. CWP No: 10100 of 2025 MADHUKAR SOOD
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
556. CWP No: 10281 of 2025 DINESH CHAND SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
557. CWP No: 10283 of 2025 UMESH PRATAP SINGH
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
558. CWP No: 10502 of 2025 JASWANT SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & others
...Respondents
559. CWP No: 10622 of 2025 DEV DUTT SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
560. CWP No: 10624 of 2025 JAGDISH RAM BHARDWAJ
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
561. CWP No: 10627 of 2025 SEWAK RAM SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
562. CWP No: 10685 of 2025 SHIV DAYAL SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
563. CWP No: 10853 of 2025 KAPURA RAM & Others
...Petitioner
Versus HRTC & Others
...Respondents
564. CWP No: 10855 of 2025 KIRAN BALA SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
565. CWP No: 10856 of 2025 RAM GOPAL SHARMA & Others
...Petitioner
Versus HRTC & Others
...Respondents
566. CWP No: 10858 of 2025 MANJEET SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others 567. CWP No: 11647 of 2025 HEM RAJ SHARMA
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
568. CWP No: 11650 of 2025 SUSHIL KUMAR SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
569. CWP No: 11654 of 2025 VIJAY KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
570. CWP No: 11655 of 2025 KISHORI LAL
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
571. CWP No: 11657 of 2025 PADAM DEV THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
572. CWP No: 11683 of 2025 KAPIL DEVI
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
573. CWP No: 11684 of 2025 SUBHASH CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
574. CWP No: 11685 of 2025 ANIL KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others 575. CWP No: 11686 of 2025 SUMITRA DEVI
...Respondents ...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
576. CWP No: 11687 of 2025 PIAR CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
577. CWP No: 11688 of 2025 RAJINDRA KUMARI
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
578. CWP No: 11689 of 2025 RAGHUBIR SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
..Respondents
579. CWP No: 11690 of 2025 SATPAL
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
580. CWP No: 12144 of 2025 HEM CHAND THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
581. CWP No: 12145 of 2025 ASHOK KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
582. CWP No: 12147 of 2025 GITA RAM
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
583. CWP No: 12293 of 2025 SATISH KUMAR & Others
...Petitioner
Versus HRTC & Others
...Respondents
584. CWP No: 12487 of 2025 RAJ KUMAR THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Another
...Respondents
585. CWP No: 13238 of 2025 RAGHU NATH SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
..Respondents
586. CWP No: 13325 of 2025 RAMESH CHAND
...Petitioner Versus
H.R.T.C. & Others
...Respondents
587. CWP No: 13736 of 2025 KAM RAJ JHINGTA & Others
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
588. CWP No: 14018 of 2025 KALYAN CHAND & Others
...Petitioner
Versus HRTC & Others
...Respondents
589. CWP No: 14129 of 2025 KULDEEP KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
590. CWP No: 14782 of 2025 BODH KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
591. CWP No: 14798 of 2025 ROSHAN LAL JASWAL
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
592. CWP No: 15276 of 2025 UPENDER SOOD
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
593. CWP No: 15565 of 2025 PIAR CHAND & Others
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
594. CWP No: 15683 of 2025 VIJAY KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Another
...Respondents
595. CWP No: 16072 of 2025 SANTOSH KUMARI
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
..Respondents
596. CWP No: 16302 of 2025 SANTOSH RANA
Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Petitioner ...Respondents
597. CWP No: 16537 of 2025 RAM SWAROOP
Versus
HRTC & Others
...Petitioner ...Respondents
598. CWP No: 16549 of 2025 BANKA RAM
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
599. CWP No: 16553 of 2025 CHHOTA LAL
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
600. CWP No: 16555 of 2025 SUCHA RAM
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
601. CWP No: 16557 of 2025 TILAK RAJ
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
602. CWP No: 16569 of 2025 SADIK MOHAMMAD
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
603. CWP No: 17356 of 2025 NARESH KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
604. CWP No: 18709 of 2025 SANT RAM SHARMA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
605. CWP No: 18875 of 2025 KHEM RAJ SHUKLA
...Petitioner Versus
THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
606. CWP No: 19799 of 2025 DEEP RAM
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
607. CWP No: 19801 of 2025 HAR GOPAL
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
608. CWP No: 20439 of 2025 BALDEV SINGH & Another
...Petitioner
Versus HRTC & Another
...Respondents
609. LPA No: 557 of 2025 STATE OF HP & Others
...Appellants
Versus MINI SHARMA
...Respondents
610. CMP(M) No: 147 of 2025 in CWP No: 7843 of 2023 State of H.P. & Others
...Petitioners
Versus Balbir Singh and another
...Respondents
611. CWP No: 1477 of 2026 VEENA DEVI
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
612. CWP No: 4318 of 2026 ANITA DEVI
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
613. CWP No: 5615 of 2026 AMAR NATH SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
614. CWP No: 6111 of 2026 RAJ KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
HRTC & Others
...Respondents
615. CWP No: 6816 of 2026 KIRPA RAM SHARMA & Others
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
616. CWP No: 7655 of 2026 ROSHAN LAL & Others
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
617. CWP No: 7657 of 2026 DURGA CHAND BHARDWAJ
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
618. Ex. Petition 53 of 2024 in CWP No: 7731 of 2023. HARI SINGH THAKUR
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
619. Ex. Petition 70 of 2024 in CWP No: 7825 of 2023. SHAKUNTLA SHARMA
...Petitioner
Versus THE STATE OF HP & Others
...Respondents
620. Ex. Petition 71 of 2024 in CWP No: 7927 of 2023. SATISH KUMAR DHIMAN
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL
...Respondents
621. Ex. Petition 595 of 2024 in CWP No: 3336 of 2024 RAJENDER KUMAR UPADHYAY
...Petitioner
Versus HPSEBL
...Respondents
622. Ex. Petition 594 of 2024 in CWP No: 3424 of 2024 BALWAN SINGH
...Petitioner Versus
HPSEBL
...Respondents
623. Ex. Petition 292 of 2024 in CWP No: 2473 of 2023 VIJENDER KUMAR
...Petitioner Versus
STATE OF H.P. AND OTHERS ...Respondents __________________________________________________________ Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Vivek Singh Thakur, Judge Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Sharma, Judge 1Whether approved for reporting?
For the petitioner(s):
Yes.
Mr. Prem P. Chauhan, in Lead Case and Mr. Onkar Jairath Senior Counsel with Mr Anshul Jairath and
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
Mr. Sanjeev Bhushan, Senior Advocate with Mr. Sparsh Bhushan, Advocate, Mr. K.C. Chauhan, Mr. Manohar Lal Sharma, Mr. Rakesh Kumar Dogra, Mr. Bhupinder Kumar, Mr. Shiv Pal Manhans, Mr. Prashant Manhans, Mr. Rajesh Kumar, Mr. Sunny Dhatwalia, Mr. Ashok Chaudhary, Mr. Vikas Rathore, Mr. Yogesh Kumar Chandel, Mr. Mandeep Chandel, Mr. Kul Bhushan Khajuria, Mr. Parkash Sharma, Mr. Mohan Singh, Advocate vice Mr. Sanjay Kumar Sharma, Mr. Shubham Sood, Mr. Mohit Thakur, Mr. Ashish Verma, Mr. Raj Kumar, Mr. Ashwani K. Sharma, Ms Dhanvanti, Mr. Atharv Sharma, Mr. Ashwani Chawla, Mr. Ramesh Kumar Kaundal, Mr. Pranav Kaushal and Mr. Sameer Miyan, Advocate, vice Mr. M.A. Safee, Mr. Sumit Sharma, Mr. Gopal Singh, Mr. Ashok Kumar, Mr. K.C. Sankhyan, Mr. S.P. Chatterjee, Mr. Shourya Sharma, Ms. Minakshi Sharma, Ms. Monika Sharma, Advocate vice Mr. Adarsh K. Vashista, Mr. Topender Kumar Verma, Mr. Aditya Kaushal, Mr. Sarthak Mehta, Mr. Narender Sharma, Ms. Shikha Chauhan, Mr. Vivek Thakur & Mr. Vijay Mokta Advocates vice Mr. Vijay Chaudhary, Mr. C.N. Singh, Mr. Anshul Gandhi & Dr. Nidhi Singh, Advocates, Mr. Sandeep K. Pandey, Ms. Babita Chauhan, Advocate vice Mr. A.K. Gupta, Mr. H.S. Rangra, Mr. Bhim Raj Sharma, Mr. H.R. Bhardwaj, Mr. Tarun Sharma, Ms. Sakshi Bhardwaj, Advocate vice Mr. Ajay Kumar Dhiman, Ms. Neha Negi and Ms. Sakshi Bhandari, Advocates, Mr. Tek Chand Sharma, Mr. Vishwa
Bhushan, Mr. Chitranjan Kumar Sharma, Mr. B. Nandan Vasishta & Mr. S.S. Sood, Mr. Karan Singh Parmar, Ms. Rashmi Parmar, Mr. Piyush Dhanotia, Mr. Vaibhav Tanwar, Mr. Ajay Thakur, Mr. Devender K. Sharma, Mr. S.D. Gill, Mr. Adarsh K. Sharma, Mr. Vinod Chauhan, Mr. Aanchal Singh Mr. Ajeet Singh Saklani, Mr. Ajay Chauhan, Mr. Praveen Thakur, Mr. Kuldeep Chand, Mr. Amrick Singh, Mr. Gaurav Sharma, Mr. Surinder Saklani, Ms. Archna Dutt, Mr. Nishant Khidtta, Advocate vice Mr. V.D. Khidtta, Mr. Hemant Kumar Thakur, Mr. Aditya Chauhan, Mr. Mohit Dogra, Mr. Vinod Thakur, Mr. Chaman Lal, Mr. Rajat Thakur, Ms. Kamlesh Shandil, Advocate, Ms. Samridhi Rathour, Advocate vice Mr. Naresh K. Verma, Advocate, Mr. Bharat Bhushan, Mr. Gaurav Singh Damseth, Mr. Jagat Pal, Ms. Anita Devi, Advocates, for petitioner(s)/applicant(s), in respective matters. For the respondent(s):
Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate General with Mr. Ramakant Sharma, Additional Advocate General, Ms. Swati Draik, Deputy Advocate General and Mr. Shalabh Thakur, Assistant Advocate General, for the respondents-State in respective petitions. Mr. Kunal Mehta, Advocate, for respondents No.2 and 3 in CWPs No.11085 & 11086/2024. Mr. Ashok Kumar Tyagi, Advocate, for the respondent, in CWP No.1978 of 2024.
Mr. Abhishek Nagta, Advocate, for respondents No.2 and 3 in CWP Nos.11085 & 11086 of 2025. Dr. Lalit K. Sharma, Advocate, for the respondent in CWP No.12067 of 2024. Mr. Abhishek Dulta, Advocate, for respondent No.3 in CWP No.14210 of 2024. Mr. Himender Singh Chandel, Advocate for respondent-HPPCL. Ms. Shivani Gangotra, Advocate, vice Mr. Vikrant Thakur, Advocate, for respondent No.5-HPPSC in CWP Nos.176 of 2024 and 7376 of 2023. Ms. Shrutika Chauhan, Mr. Raman Jamalta, Mr. Vinod Kumar Gupta, Mr. Virender Singh Kanwar, Advocate, Mr. Deepak Sharma and Ms. Shubh Mahajan, Advocates, for respondent-HRTC in respective petitions. Mr. Ravinder Thakur, Advocate, for the respondent-HPSEBL, in respective petitions. Mr. Uday Singh Banyal, Advocate for the respondent-Vidhan Sabha. Mr. Devender K. Sharma, Advocate, for the respondent-University. Mr. Shivank Singh Panta and Ms. Maheshwari Sharma, Advocates, for HPTDC, in respective petitions. Mr. Devender Sharma, Advocate, for respondents No.2 and 3 in CWP No.8501 of 2023. Mr.
Virender
Singh
Rathore,
Advocate, for the respondent in CWP No.6249 of 2024. Mr. Shashi Bhushan Singh, Advocate, for respondent in LPA No. 557 of 2025. Mr. Mr.
Tara Dikken
Chand Chauhan, Kumar Thakur and
Mr. Rangil Singh, Mr. Abhishek Sharma, Mr. Rajesh Kosh, Ms. Komal Chaudhary & Ms. Rekha Thakur, Mr. Ramesh Kumar Advocates, for the Accountant General, in the respective petitions. Ranjan Sharma, Judge Petitioner-Madhu
Deshta
[having
retired
as
a Lecturer, School Cadre from the service of the State Government] has come up before this Court, seeking the following reliefs: “15 (a)
to
issue
a
writ
of
certiorari,
or
any other appropriate writ, order, or direction in nature thereof, quashing Rule 13 of the H.P. Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2022 (Annexure P3),
Paragraph
Memorandum
of
dated
Office
25.02.2022
(Annexure P-4), the impugned Office Memorandum
dated
(Annexure
and
P-2),
19.10.2024 other
similar
Office Memoranda including Annexure P-5,
Annexure
P-6,
and
Annexure
P-7, to the extent that they authorize or
implement
a
acknowledged
policy
of
arrears
paying of
pay
and pension
revision
benefits
in
installments or in a deferred manner, holding
such
provisions/stipulations
to be illegal, arbitrary, discriminatory, and unconstitutional; and 15(b)
to issue a writ of mandamus, or any
other
appropriate
or
direction
in
writ,
nature
order, thereof,
directing the Respondents to forthwith release
and
entire
pay
to
outstanding
Petitioner
benefits
of
pay revision effective from 01.01.2016, including revised
all
arrears
pensionary
of
pay,
benefits,
Death-
cum-Retirement
Gratuity
commuted
of
value
(DCRG),
pension,
and
leave encashment, in a lump sum, along with interest thereon @ 9% per
annum
from
date
such
amounts became due till the date of
actual
payment,
with
all
consequential benefits for all purposes and intents.” LEAD CASE AND CONNECTED CASES ADJUDICATED BY A COMMON JUDGMENT:
2.
Sequel to the orders passed by this Court
on 03.07.2025, Learned Counsel(s) for the respective parties jointly represent that since the issue involved in all these connected cases is pari-materia therefore, CWP No 8504 of 2025, Madhu Deshta versus State of
Himachal
Pradesh
and
others,
may
be
treated
as the ‘Lead Case’. As agreed, this Court proceeds to adjudicate the ‘Lead Case’ and other connected CWP’s/CWPOA’s/ LPA’s and CMP(M)’s in LPA’s by a common judgment. FACTUAL MATRIX IN ‘LEAD CASE’ [CWP 8504 OF 2025- MADHU DESHTA’s CASE :
3.
Case,
as
set
up,
by
Learned
Counsel
NO:
is
that petitioner joined as Lecturer in Political Science in the School Cadre, in Directorate of School Education, under the Respondent/State on regular basis and she superannuated from service on attaining the age of 58 years on 31.01.2021. On her superannuation, she was granted retiral benefits i.e. Pension and Gratuity etc., at the unrevised rates in accordance with the Central Civil Services [Pension] Rules 1972 and Leave Encashment under the Central Civil Services [Leave] Rules 1972 and Commuted Pension under the Central Civil Services [Commutation of Pension] Rules, 1981, as applicable to the petitioner and other employees of the State Government, including the employees of various Boards, Corporations and Public Sector Undertakings owned and controlled by the State Government. 3(i).
It
is
averred
that
State
Government
notified the Himachal Pradesh Civil Services [Revised] Pay Rules 2022 [hereinafter referred to as ‘Revised Pay
Rules
2022’]
on
03.01.2022
[Annexure
P-3]
deciding to give the benefit of the Revised Pay Scale/ Pay Structure to its employees w.e.f. 01.01.2016. It is averred that on the basis of the Revised Pay Rules 2022, the petitioner, who stood retired from service on 31.01.2021 was deemed to have been covered under Revised Pay Rules 2022 [Annexure P-3] was entitled to be re-fixed in applicable revised Pay Structure and was to be given the arrears of Pay and Allowances for
period
from
01.01.2016
till
superannuation
on 31.01.2021 but, State Authorities invoked provision of
Rule
of
said
Rules,
by
deciding
to
give the Revised Pay Arrears in such manner and at such time as may be approved by the Government and based on Rule 13, the State Government issued an Office Memorandum on 17.09.2022 [Annexure P-5], releasing
revised
pay
arrears
in
a
staggered
form,
by ordering the release of a meagre amount of Rs 50,000-60,000/- whereas, the petitioner was entitled to much higher amount of arrears under the Revised
Rules
during
this
period
from
01.01.2016
till
her
superannuation on 31.01.2021. 3(ii).
It is averred that after the issuance of the
Revised Pay Rules on 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3], the State Government issued another Office Memorandum dated
25.02.2022
[Annexure
P-4],
deciding
to
give
the Revised Retiral benefits i.e. Revised Pension, Revised Gratuity,
Revised
Commuted
Pension
and
Revised
Family Pension [in case of death of employee] to its employees but while issuing this Office Memorandum on
25.02.2022
inserted
Para
[Annexure
in
P-4]
State
said
Office
Authorities
Memorandum,
that the arrears of revised retiral benefits i.e. Revised Pension/Gratuity/Commuted
Pension/Family
Pension
for the period from 01.01.2016 to 31.12.2021 shall be
paid
in
by
State
such
that after the
a
manner
Government issuance
in
as
may
future.
of the
Office
be
decided
is
averred
It
Memorandum
dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4], the State Authorities issued a communication on 17.09.2022 [Annexure P-6], releasing
20%
of
arrear
of
Revised
Pension/
Family Pension and Revised Gratuity to the retirees
alike the petitioner. It is averred that on 13.03.2024 [Annexure P-7], the State Authorities issued another Office Memorandum, releasing part arrears of Revised Pension/Family Pension between 15% to 35% based on age criteria of the retirees. It is further averred that on 19.10.2024 [Annexure P-2], the State Authorities have
issued
another
Office
Memorandum,
whereby,
the retirees who had crossed the age of 75 years and
above
were
released
100%
arrears
of
Revised
Pension /Family Pension, whereas, the petitioner was singled out, ignoring that all employees who retired from service on or after 01.01.2016 constituted one Homogeneous Class and the State Authorities cannot adopt a pick and choose method while releasing the revised retiral benefits whims, amongst
by
carving
one
in a
out
an
homogenous
staggered
form, at its
artificial
discrimination
class
retirees
of
was
discriminatory, illegal, arbitrary and unconstitutional. 3(iii).
In above backdrop, it was averred that the
action of the State Authorities in not releasing the revised pay arrears in lump sum but in withholding this benefit at the mercy of the State Authorities and
in releasing the same in a staggered or deferred or in a piece meal manner by invoking Rule 13 of the Revised
Pay
Rules
dated
03.01.2022
[Annexure
P-3]
and likewise, the action of the State Authorities in not releasing the benefits of revised retiral benefits in
lump
sum
but
in
withholding
Revised
in
Pension,
terms
of
revised
Revised
Statutory
retiral
Gratuity,
Rules
benefits
Revised
i.e.
Leave
Encashment and the Revised Family Pension [wherever applicable] but in releasing the same in a staggered or deferred or in a piece meal manner by invoking Para 10 of the Office Memorandum dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4] at the mercy of the State Authorities was
illegal.
It
was
averred
that
denial
of
rightful
dues by way of an executive order by issuing an Office Memorandum on 17.09.2022 [Annexure P-6] and similar communications on 13.03.2024 and 19.10.2024 [Annexure P-7 and Annexure P-2 [releasing arrears of revised retiral benefits in a piecemeal manner or in a staggered-deferred form] was alleged to be violative of Article 300-A of the Constitution of India and the State action was unfair, unjust, illegal, arbitrary and
unconstitutional. In this backdrop, it was prayed that the offending
Rule/Office
HPCS
Revised
Memorandum Pay
Rules
of
i.e.
Rule
of
2022
notified
on
03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] and Para 10 of the Office Memorandum
dated
25.02.2022
[Annexure
P-4]
may
be quashed and set-aside with the prayer to quash and set-aside the resultant OM’s or Communications releasing the benefits in a piece-meal manner with the prayer to release the arrears of revised pay from 01.01.2016
till
her
superannuation
on
31.01.2021
and thereafter to release the arrears of revised retiral benefits from the date of her superannuation from 01.02.2021,
which
became
due
and
payable
after
the issuance of the Revised Pay Rules on 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] and issuance of the Office Memorandum on 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4], and to release all these benefits in lump-sum, alongwith interest @ 9% per annum till the date of actual release of benefits; and the action of the State Authorities in releasing these benefits piecemeal
in
staggered
manner
or
deferred
being
contrary
form to
or
in
a
Statutory
Rules may be declared unreasonable, illegal, arbitrary, discriminatory and unconstitutional. STAND OF AFFIDAVIT:
4.
STATE
AUTHORITIES
IN
REPLY-
Pursuant to the issuance of notice by this
Court on 22.05.2025, the State Authorities have filed Reply-Affidavit dated 17.06.2025 of Special Secretary [Finance], Government of Himachal Pradesh. 4(i).
Reply-Affidavit indicates that the employees
who
retired
from
service
between
01.01.2016
to
31.01.2022 were released the pay and retiral benefits like Pension, Gratuity, Commuted Pension and Family Pension [wherever applicable] in accordance with the Revised
Pay
Rules
2009
as
applicable
in
case
of
the petitioner. 4(ii).
Reply-Affidavit indicates that on 03.01.2022
[Annexure
P-3]
State
Authorities
notified
Himachal Pradesh Civil Services [Revised] Pay Rules under the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of
India
and
these
Rules
deemed
to
have
come
into effect w.e.f. 01.01.2016. Reply-Affidavit indicates that after the issuance of Revised Pay Rules dated 03.01.2022,
State
Authorities
issued
an
Office
Memorandum on 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4], notifying amendments
to
Central
Civil
Services
[Pension]
Rules, 1972. Reply-Affidavit indicates that despite the adverse
financial to
constraint,
has
decided
revise
from
retrospective
effect
Pay
w.e.f.
State
Government
Scales/Pension
etc.
01.01.2016
in
interests of Government Employees/ Pensioners. 4(iii).
Para 7 of Reply-Affidavit indicates that as
per Rule 13 of Revised Pay Rules dated 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3], it was decided retired
employees
for
that arrears to the
period
from
01.01.2016
to 31.01.2022 shall be paid in such a manner and in
such
a
time
as
may
be
approved
by
State Government. Reply-Affidavit further indicates that so
far as
Pension,
the revised retiral benefits, like
Gratuity,
Commuted
Pension
and
Revised Family
Pension [wherever applicable] are concerned, the State Authorities issued an Office Memorandum on 25.02.2022 [Annexure
P-4]
and
Para
of
said
Memorandum
provided that arrears, on account of revised retiral benefits for the period from 01.01.2016 to 31.12.2021 shall be paid in such a manner as may be decided
by the Government in future. Based on this, ReplyAffidavit
indicates
that
in
terms
of
Office
Memorandums, the arrears of revised pay and the arrears
of
instalments
revised as
per
retiral
benefits
were
released
in
Communications
issued
on
17.09.2022; 28.08.2024 and 19.10.2024. 4(iv).
In Para 12 to 14 of Reply-Affidavit, State
Authorities
have
placed
reliance
on
judgments
passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Civil Appeal No.7427 of 2011, titled as Punjab State Co-operative Milk Producers Federation Ltd. and another versus Balbir Kumar Walia and others; Civil Appeal No. 5114 of 2022, titled as The State of Tripura and others versus Smt. Anjana; State of Punjab and others versus Amar Nath Goyal and others, (2005)
SCC
754;
State
of
Bihar
and
others
versus
Bihar Pensioners Samaj, (2006) 5 SCC 65; to assert that financial stringency is a valid ground for denying arrears and grant of higher pay and based on financial liability, the State has right to prescribe or fix the cut-off date for the purposes of releasing the Revised Pension to its employees. Based on aforesaid judgments
it was averred that the
financial crunch/ financial
constrains is a valid factor and therefore, Rule 13 in the Revised Pay Rules dated 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] and Para 10 in Office Memorandum dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4] was included by the State Authorities. Reply-Affidavit indicates that the employees who have retired between from 01.01.2016 to 31.12.2021 form Homogeneous
Class
and
entire
arrears
cannot
be
released to the petitioners, ignoring other employees. 4(v). (A)
Reply-Affidavit further indicates in Para 12 and
(A)
to
(D)
that
there
is
no
specific
provision under the Himachal Pradesh Civil Services [Revised] Pay Rules dated 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] or the Central Civil Services [Pension] Rules, 1972; the Central Civil Services [Leave] Rules, 1972; and
Central
Rules
1981
Civil to
Services
allow
Commutation
interest
on
of
Pension
Gratuity,
Arrears
of Pay, Pension, Leave Encashment and Commutation and in absence of any specific provision for interest in the Rules, the claim of the petitioners for interest on delayed payments was denied by the Respondents. 4(vi).
Reply-Affidavit
further
indicates
that
State Government was committed to release arrears of Revised Pay and Arrears of Revised Retiral Benefits to the retirees, including the petitioners, who had retired between 01.01.2016 to 31.12.2021 and therefore, it was
prayed
that
writ
petition
may
kindly
be
dismissed. REJOINDER BY PETITIONER:
5.
In Rejoinder, petitioner stated that Rule 13
of Revised Pay Rules dated 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] giving unbridled, unfettered and unrestricted discretion to the State to release the arrears of Revised Pay “in such a manner and at such a time”, as may be approved by the Government, was highly arbitrary, illegal
and
unconstitutional
as
salary
earned
becomes the lawful entitlements and such an accrued benefit
being
Constitution
property of
India
under
Article
300-A
could
not
withheld,
be
of
staggered, deferred or released in piecemeal manner at the whims and discretion of the State Authorities indefinitely
and
that
too
without
there
being
any
law; merely on the basis of the Revised Pay Rules dated 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3], cannot sustain. 5(i).
Rejoinder further mentioned that the action
of the State Authorities in incorporating Para 10 in Office Memorandum dated 25.05.2022 [Annexure P-4] decided to release the revised retiral benefits “in such manner as may be decided by the Government in future” amounted to carving out inter-se discrimination within
retirees
who
have
attained
age
of
70 years and above have been released the entire Revised Pension/Gratuity by the Respondents. It was further averred that the OM being a mere executive order
cannot be
made
basis
for deferring
retiral benefits which had accrued under the Central Civil
Services
[Pension]
Rules
[in
case
of
Pension
and Gratuity] and Revised Leave Encashment under the Central Civil Services [Leave] Rules and Commuted Pension under the Central Civil Services [Commutation of Pension] Rules, upon the issuance of the Revised Pay Rules on 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] and Office Memorandum dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4] to the petitioner and other like employees. 5(ii).
The judgments mentioned in Para 12 and
14 of Reply-Affidavit were held to be not applicable, in fact-situation of instant case.
In this backdrop, averments and the claim spelt out in the writ petition was reiterated with the prayer for quashing the Impugned Rules/Orders and to
direct
release
retiral
benefits
in
lump-sum
alongwith interest. AFFIDAVIT BY PRINCIPAL SECRETARY [FINANCE] DATED 14.10.2025:
6.
State
Authorities
filed
an
Affidavit
dated
14.10.2025, indicating that after the issuance of the Revised Pay Rules on 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] giving
revised pay
scales
w.e.f.
01.01.2016
and
after
the issuance of an Office Memorandum on 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4] giving the revised retiral benefits w.e.f. 01.01.2016, an estimated arrears of Rs 16600/- Crores shall
accrue,
out
of
which,
State
Government
had already released/adjusted the arrears of Rs 8045/Crores
by
disbursing
alike
petitioner,
though
Affidavit
further
indicates
benefits
that
in
a
to
retirees
deferred
form.
balance
arrears
of Rs 8555/- Crores are required for meeting out
liability
towards
arrears
of
revised
pay
and arrears of revised retiral benefits. Para 7 and 10 of the affidavit indicates that as per 15th Finance
Commission during the award period from 2021-22 to 2025-26, the State had received a total Revenue Deficit Grant [RDG] of Rs 37,199/- Crores and the State Government awaits the release of similar Revenue Deficit Grant from the 16th Finance Commission w.e.f. 01.04.2026 onwards. AFFIDAVIT DATED 28.02.2026 SECRETARY [FINANCE]:
BY
PRINCIPAL
6(i).
State Authorities through Principal Secretary
Finance
filed
another
Affidavit
dated
28.02.2026,
with the averments in Para 6 and 7 that 16th Finance Commission
has
not
recommended
Revenue
Deficit
Grant [RDG] to the States, so that the States increase their revenue and rationalize their expenditure. It is averred that due to the non-recommendation of the Revenue has
Deficit
been
Grant
caused
states
that
Deficit
Grant,
to
despite
an
adverse
financial
impact
Respondent-State.
Affidavit
non-recommendation State
Authorities
of
Revenue
have
released
arrears of Revised Pension to the retirees who are above 70 years of age on 27.01.2026 [Annexure R-1/I] and Class-IV who had retired/died during 01.01.2016 to
31.01.2022
have
been
released
additional
50%
Gratuity and 70% Leave Encashment Arrears besides releasing the Medical Reimbursement Claims of the employees-retirees. AFFIDAVIT IN TERMS OF ORDER DATED 27.04.2026 FILED BY PRINCIPAL SECRETARY [FINANCE]:
6(ii).
Principal
Secretary
[Finance]
filed
another
Affidavit dated 15.05.2026, with the stand that 16th Finance
Commission
has
neither
recommended
any
Revenue Deficit Grant for State of Himachal Pradesh for the period from 2026-2031 nor any Special Grant has
been
released
to
State
in
lieu
thereof.
Affidavit further indicates in Para 6 that the Salaries, Pension
and
Gratuity
Budget
besides
other
attribute
to
expenditures
about and
78%
on
of
interest
payments, repayment of loan, grant-in-aid etc., and 20% of budget is available for other developmental works for the year 2026-27. Para 7 of this Affidavit indicates that deferral of arrears is not selective or wilful but is a consequence of uniform fiscal austerity due
to
discontinuation
of
Revenue
Deficit
Grant. Para-9 of this Affidavit indicates that as per Office Memorandum dated 25.04.2026 [Annexure R-I/III Colly], entire benefits have been released to Class-IV
employees who retired from service between 01.01.2016 and 31.01.2022. Affidavit indicates that State Government had been releasing arrears in a phased and prioritized manner
giving
precedence
to
age
and
vulnerability.
Affidavit further indicates that constraints is entirely one of resources and therefore, the State Government has taken several measures for generating and improving its resources as detailed in Para 13 of this Affidavit. INSTRUCTIONS FURNISHED BOARDS/CORPORATIONS:
6(iii).
Besides
State,
BY
there
COUNSELS
are
FOR
numerous
Boards, PSUs or Corporations which are owned and controlled by the State. After issuance of Revised Pay Rules dated 03.01.2026 [Annexure P-3] and the Office Memorandum dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4], almost majority of the Boards/Corporations and PSUs have by
and
large,
in
principle
have
adopted,
followed
and decided to give arrears of the Revised Pay to its employees between the period from 01.01.2016 to 31.12.2021 and based on revised emoluments, these Boards/Corporations have decided to give the Revised Retiral Benefits to employees who had retired from service on or after 01.01.2016 till 31.01.2022. Learned
Counsel
for
Respondent
Boards/Corporations
in
present batch of cases, do not dispute these facts. Even Learned Counsel(s) for Respondent Board {HPSEBL} have furnished Instructions to this effect, which form part of the orders passed by this Court from time to time. 7. in
Heard, Mr. Prem P. Chauhan Learned Counsel Lead
Case
and
Mr.
Sanjeev
Advocate
with
Mr.
Rajesh
Bhushan,
Kumar
Senior
Advocate,
Mr.
Onkar Jairath Senior Counsel with Mr. Anshul Jairath Mr.
K.C.
Rakesh
Chauhan,
Kumar
Mr.
Dogra,
Manohar Mr.
Lal
Sharma,
Mr.
Bhupinder
Kumar,
Mr.
Shiv Pal Manhans, Mr. Prashant Manhans, Mr. Rajesh Kumar, Mr. Sunny Dhatwalia, Mr. Ashok Chaudhary, Mr. Vikas Rathore, Mr. Yogesh Kumar Chandel, Mr. Mandeep
Chandel,
Parkash
Sharma,
Mr. Mr.
Kulbhushan Mohan
Singh,
Khajuria,
Mr.
Advocate
vice
Mr. Sanjay Kumar Sharma, Mr. Shubham Sood, Mr. Mohit
Thakur,
Mr.
Ashish
Verma,
Mr.
Raj
Kumar, Mr. Ashwani K. Sharma, Mr. Sanjay Bhardwaj, Mr. Atharv Sharma, Mr. Ashwani Chawla, Mr. Ramesh Kumar Kaundal, Mr. Pranav Kaushal and Mr. Sameer
Miyan,
Advocate,
Sharma, K.C.
Mr.
vice
Gopal
Sankhyan,
Mr.
M.A.
Safee,
Mr.
Singh,
Mr.
Ashok
Kumar,
Mr.
S.P.
Chatterjee,
Mr.
Sumit Mr.
Shourya
Sharma, Ms. Minakshi Sharma, Ms. Monika Sharma, Advocate vice Mr. Adarsh K. Vashista, Mr. Topender Kumar Verma, Mr. Aditya Kaushal, Mr. Sarthak Mehta, Mr.
Narender
Sharma,
Ms.
Shikha
Chauhan,
Mr.
Vivek Thakur & Mr. Vijay Mokta Advocates vice Mr. Vijay Chaudhary, Mr. C.N. Singh, Mr. Anshul Gandhi &
Dr.
Nidhi
Singh,
Advocates,
Mr.
Sandeep
K.
Pandey, Ms. Babita Chauhan, Advocate vice Mr. A.K. Gupta, Mr. H.S. Rangra, Mr. Bhim Raj Sharma, Mr. H.R.
Bhardwaj,
Mr.
Tarun
Sharma,
Ms.
Sakshi
Bhardwaj, Advocate vice Mr. Ajay Kumar Dhiman, Ms. Neha Negi and Ms. Sakshi Bhandari, Advocates, Mr. Tek Chand Sharma, Mr. Vishwa Bhushan, Mr. Chitranjan Kumar Sharma, Mr. B. Nandan Vasishta & Mr. S.S. Sood, Mr. Karan Singh Parmar, Ms. Rashmi Parmar, Mr. Piyush Dhanotia, Mr. Vaibhav Tanwar, Mr. Ajay Thakur, Mr. Devender K. Sharma, Mr. S.D. Gill, Mr. Adarsh K. Sharma, Mr. Vinod Chauhan, Mr. Aanchal Singh Mr. Ajeet Singh Saklani, Mr. Ajay Chauhan,
Mr. Praveen Thakur, Mr. Kuldeep Chand, Mr. Amrick Singh,
Mr.
Gaurav
Sharma,
Mr.
Surinder
Saklani,
Ms. Archna Dutt, Mr. Nishant Khidtta, Advocate vice Mr. V.D. Khidtta, Mr. Hemant Kumar Thakur, Mr. Aditya Chauhan, Mr. Mohit Dogra, Mr. Vinod Thakur, Mr.
Chaman
Shandil,
Lal,
Mr.
Rajat
Thakur,
Advocate,
Ms.
Samridhi
Ms.
Kamlesh
Rathour,
Advocate
vice Mr. Naresh K. Verma, Advocate, Mr. Bharat Bhushan, Mr.
Gaurav
Singh
Damseth,
Mr.
Jagat
Pal,
Ms.
Anita Devi, Advocates, for the petitioner(s)/applicant(s), in respective matters and Mr. Anup Rattan, Learned Advocate General with Mr. Ramakant Sharma, Additional Advocate General, Ms. Swati Draik, Deputy Advocate General and Mr. Shalabh Thakur, Assistant Advocate General, for respondents-State in respective petitions; and Mr. Kunal Mehta, Advocate, for respondents No.2 and
in
CWPs
No.11085
&
11086/2024;
Mr.
Ashok Kumar Tyagi, Advocate, for the respondent, in CWP No.1978 of 2024; Mr. Abhishek Nagta, Advocate, for respondents No.2 and 3 in CWP Nos. 11085 & 11086 of 2025; Dr. Lalit K. Sharma, Advocate, for respondent in CWP No.12067 of 2024; Mr. Abhishek
Dulta,
Advocate,
for
respondent
No.3
in
CWP
No.
14210 of 2024; Mr. Himender Singh Chandel, Advocate for respondent-HPPCL; Ms. Shivani Gangotra, Advocate, vice
Mr.
Vikrant
Thakur,
Advocate,
for
respondent
No.5-HPPSC in CWP Nos.176 of 2024 and 7376 of 2023;
Ms. Shrutika
Chauhan; Mr. Raman
Jamalta;
Mr. Vinod Kumar Gupta; Mr. Virender Singh Kanwar, Advocate; Mr. Deepak Sharma; and Ms. Shubh Mahajan, Advocates, for respondent-HRTC in respective petitions; Mr. Ravinder Thakur, Advocate, for the respondentHPSEBL, in respective petitions; Mr. Uday Singh Banyal, Advocate for the respondent-Vidhan Sabha; Mr. Devender K.
Sharma,
Advocate,
for
respondent-University;
Mr. Shivank Singh Panta and Ms. Maheshwari Sharma, Advocates, for the HPTDC, in respective petitions; Mr. Devender
Sharma,
Advocate,
for
respondents
No.2
and 3 in CWP No.8501 of 2023; Mr. Virender Singh Rathore,
Advocate;
6249 of 2024; Mr.
for
Shashi
respondent in Bhushan
Singh,
CWP
No.
Advocate,
for respondent in LPA No. 557 of 2025; Mr. Tara Chand Chauhan, Mr. Dikken Kumar Thakur; Mr.
Rangil
Singh; Mr. Abhishek Sharma; Mr. Rajesh Kosh; Ms.
Komal Chaudhary & Ms. Rekha Thakur; Mr. Ramesh Kumar Advocates; for the Accountant General, in the respective petitions. HPCS REVISED [ANNEXURE P-3]
8. and
PAY
RULES
DATED
03.01.2022
Before proceeding to analyze the rival claims contentions,
it
is
necessary
to
have
a
recap
of the Himachal Pradesh Civil Services [Revised Pay] Rules dated 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] giving revised pay scales/structure to its employees w.e.f. 01.01.2016 as under: ANNEXURE P-3 Dated: 03.01.2022 Govt. of Himachal Pradesh Finance (Pay Revision) Department. Notification No. Fin-(PR)B(7)-1/2021 Dated: 03.01.2022 In
exercise
of
powers
conferred
by
proviso
to Article 309 and clause (3) of article 187 of the Constitution of India read with proviso to sub-rule (1) of rule 10 of
Himachal
Pradesh
Vidhan
Sabha
Secretariat
(Recruitment and Conditions of Service) Rules, 1974, the Governor,
Himachal
Pradesh,
is
pleased
to
make
be called
following rules, namely:1.
Short
title
Commencement.
and (1)
These rules
Himachal
may
Pradesh
Civil
Services
(Revised Pay Rules, 2022. (2)
They shall be deemed to have
come into force on and with effect from the first day of January, 2016.
2.
Application.
(1) Save as otherwise expressly provided by or under these rules, they shall apply to all the persons appointed on regular basis to the services and posts in connection with the affairs of the State of Himachal Pradesh and whose pay is debited to the Consolidated Fund of State of Himachal Pradesh. Not Relevant
3-4. 5.
Drawl
of
pay
in
the Save as otherwise provided in these
revised pay structure.
rules, a Government employee shall draw pay in the Level of Pay Matrix in the revised pay structure applicable to
post
to
which
he
is
appointed. 6.
Exercise of option.
(1)
The Government employee shall exercise
option
in
Form
appended to these rules so as to reach the authority specified in sub-rule (2), within a period of
one
month
from
date
of notification of these rules: Provided that: (i)
in the case of a
Government
employee, who on the date of notification
of
these
rules,
is
out of India or on leave or on deputation or on foreign service or on active service, the option shall
be exercised in the said
Form so as to reach the said authority
within
a
one
month
from
his
taking
post
period
of
date
of
charge
of
his
under
State
Government, if that date is later
than the date specified in this sub-rule; and (ii)
where is
a
Government
under
suspension
employee on
date of notification of these rules,
option
shall
be
exercised
within a period of one month from the date of his return to his duty, if that date is later than the date specified in this sub-rule. (2)
The
option
shall
be
in
submitted
Form by
Government employee to the Head of the Office. (3)
If
option
within
is
not
time
received
specified
sub-rule
(I),
employee
shall
be
in
Government deemed
to
have opted/elected to be governed by
with
revised
effect
pay
from
structure
first
day
of
January, 2016. The Head of the Office shall determine his pay in
revised
pay
structure
with reference to provisions of rule 7 of these rules. (4)
The option once exercised shall be final.
7.
Fixation of pay in the The revised pay structure.
basic
pay
of
a
Government
employee shall, unless in any case,
Government
otherwise
directs,
by
special
be
fixed
order in
revised pay structure in the following manner: 7 (I) to 11
Not relevant
12.
Drawl of revised pay.
(1)
The
revised
rules shall
pay
under
these
be drawn from
month of January, 2022 (payable in month of February, 2022). (2)
The
Government
employee
who
was on extension in service as on 01.01.2016
or
thereafter,
shall
not be paid any arrears, if any, for the extended period of service due to
revision of pay as
per
provisions of these rules. 13.
Arrear of revised pay.
Notwithstanding in
these
rules,
anything
contained
arrears
with
effect from the 1st January 2016 to 31st December, 2021, shall be paid in such manner and at such time as may be approved by the Government. 14 to 16
Not relevant
OFFICE MEMORANDUM DATED 25.02.2022 [ANNEXURE P-4] GIVING THE REVISED RETIRAL BENEFITS:
8(i).
After the issuance of Revised Pay Rules on
03.01.2022 Annexure P-3], the State Government issued an Office Memorandum on 25.2.2022 [Annexure P-4] giving the Revised retiral benefits i.e. Revised Pension, Revised Gratuity, Revised Commutation of Pension and Revised Family Pension to Government Servants who retire or die in service in harness on or after age 01.01.2016. In terms of this OM, the claim of these retirees
for
Revised
Pension
is
to
be
regulated
in
terms of Para 5 and claim for Revised Retirement / Death Gratuity/Death Gratuity is to be regulated in terms of Para 6 and the claim for Revised Family Pension is to be regulated in terms of Para 7 and
claim
for
Revised
Commutation
of
Pension
is
to be governed by Para 8 of this OM. The operative part
of
Office
Memorandum
dated
25.02.2022
[Annexure P-4] reads as under: ANNEXURE P-4 Dated: 25.02.2022 “No. Fin(Pen)A(3)-l/202l-Part-l Government of Himachal Pradesh Finance (Pension) Department *********** Dated: Shimla-17002, 25th February, 2022 OFFICE MEMORANDUM Subject:
Revision of provision regulating Pension/Gratuity/Commutation of Pension and Family Pension. The
undersigned
is
directed
to
state that the Governor, Himachal Pradesh is pleased to introduce the following modifications in
Rules
/Death/Service under
regulating Gratuity
C.C.S.
Pension, and
(Pension)
Retirement
Family Rules,
Pension 1972
(hereinafter referred to as Pension Rules) and the Commutation of Pension under the CCS (Commutation of Pension) Rules, 1981.
These orders shall apply to the Himachal
2.
Pradesh
Government
employees
governed
by
the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. DATE OF EFFECT 3.1
revised
The
provisions
orders shall apply to who
retire/die
in
as
per
Government
harness
on
these
servants or
after
01.01.2016. Separate orders are being issued in respect of the employees who retired/died before 01.01.2016. 3.2
Where pension/gratuity/commutation and
family
pension
has
already
been
sanctioned
in the cases occurring on or after 01.01.2016
shall
same
be
revised
these
order.
In
been
finally
sanctioned
cases,
in
where on
terms
of
pension
has
pre-revised
orders and if it happens to be more beneficial than the pension becoming due under these orders,
not
revised
be
pension to
already
sanctioned
disadvantage
shall
of
pensioners in view of the provisions contained under Rule 70 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. EMOLUMENTS The term 'Emoluments' for the purposes
4.1 of
calculating
other
than
have
Central
various
various
same
kinds
meaning
Civil
pensionary of
as
Services
benefits
gratuity in
Rule
(Pension)
shall
of
Rules,
1972 read with instructions contained in the Government OM No. Fin (Pen) A (3)-12/2010 dated 12th March, 2013.
The 'Basic Pay' in the revised pay structure
4.2 means
'Levels
of
01.01.2016,
pay
drawn
Pay
but
does
in
prescribed
Matrix
with
effect
from
not
include
any
other
type of pay like special pay etc. In the case of all kinds of gratuity,
4.3
dearness allowance admissible on the date of retirement / death shall continue to be treated as
emoluments
along
with
emoluments
as defined in Paragraph 4.1 above. PENSION 5.1
Subject to Parn 5.2 below, there shall
be no change in the provisions regulating the amount of pension as contained in Rule 49 of the CCS (Pension) Rules 1972. 5.2 to
The amount of pension shall be subject a
minimum
maximum
of
Rs.
9,000/-PM
pension
will
be
Rs.
and
112050/-PM
(i.e. 50% of the Rs.2,24,100/-). The provisions of the sub-rule (2) of Rule 49 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 shall stand modified to this extent. 5.3
The quantum of the additional pension/
family pension available to the old pensioners /family years
pensioners and
above
attaining shall
age
of
continue
to
be
as
follows: Age of pensioner
Additional quantum of pension/ family pension
From 80 years to less 20% of basic than 85 years family pension
pension/
From 85 years to less 30% of basic than 90 years family pension
pension/
From 90 years to less 40% of basic than 95 years family pension
pension/
From 95 years to less 50% of basic than 100 years family pension
pension/
100 years or more
100% of basic pension/ family pension
The Pension Sanctioning Authorities shall ensure that the date of birth and the age of pensioner is invariably indicated in the Pension Payment Order (PPO) to facilitate payment of additional pension by the Pension Disbursing Authority, as soon as it becomes due. The amount of additional pension will be shown distinctly in the pension payment order. For example: in case where a pensioner is more than 80 years of age and his pension is Rs. 20,000/- PM, the pension will be shown as (i) basic pensionRs.
20,000/- PM
and
(ii)
Additional
pension
Rs. 4,000/- PM. The pension, on attaining the age of 85 years, will be shown as (i) basic pension Rs. 20,000/-PM and (ii) additional pension Rs. 6,000/- PM. Retirement/Death Gratuity 6.1
The rates for payment of death gratuity
shall be revised as under:Length of qualifying Rate of Death Gratuity service Less than one year
times of emoluments
monthly
One year or more but 6 times of emoluments less than 5 years
monthly
5 years or more but 12 times of less than 11 years emoluments
monthly
11 years or more but 20 times of monthly emoluments less than 20 years 20 years or more
Accordingly,
Half month’s emoluments for every completed sixmonthly period of qualifying service subject to a maximum of 33 times of emoluments.
Rule
50(1)(b)
of
CCS
(Pension) Rules, 1972 shall stand modified to this extent. 6.2
The maximum limit of retirement gratuity
and
death
gratuity
is
enhanced
from
Rs
10 Lakhs to Rs.20 Lakh. The revised rates of retirement gratuity and death gratuity shall be
admissible
w.e.f.
01.01.2016.
The
first
proviso under Rule 50 (1)(b) of CCS (Pension) Rules.
1972
shall
stand
modified
to
this
extent. FAMILY PENSION, 1964 7.1
Family
pension
shall
be
calculated
at
a uniform rate of 30% of basic pay in the revised pay structure and shall be subject to a minimum of Rs.9,000/-PM and the maximum family pension will be Rs.67,230/-PM i.e. 30% of the Rs. 2,24,100/-. Rule 54(2) relating to Family
Pension,
Rules,
1972
1964
shall
under
stand
CCS
modified
(Pension) to
this
extent. 7.2
The amount of enhanced family pension
shall
be
pay
structure
50%
of and
basic
pay
shall
be
in
revised
subject
to
a
minimum of Rs.9000/-PM and the maximum family
pension
50%
of
will
be
Rs.1,12,050/-PM
(i.e.
the Rs.2,24,100/-). There will be no
other change in the provisions regulating family pension, enhanced family pension and additional family pension to old family pensioners. COMMUTATION OF PENSION 8.1
There shall be no change in the existing
provisions
with
regard
to
commutation
values, the limit upto which the pension can be commuted or the period after which the commuted pension is to be restored. 8.2
The
Government
employees
retired
between the period 01.01.2016 to 31.12.2021 shall 40% of the differential part of be paid lump-sum commutation arrears of an amount upto 40 revised pension in a phased manner as to be notified by the Finance Department. Till such time, these pensioners will get higher revised pension. 8.3. period
These
pensioners
01.01.2016
to
retired
between
31.12.2021
shall
also
have an option not to commute their differential part of revised pension. An option on 'Form-1" shall be exercised by such pensioners within three
months
from
date
of
issuance
of
these Orders. Payments of arrears 10.
The arrears on account of revision of
pension/ gratuity/ commutation/family pension for the period w.e.f. 01-01-2016 to 31-01-2022 shall be paid in such manner as may be decided by the Government in future. 11.
The
Heads
of
Departments/Heads
of
Offices and the Principal Accountant General A&E),
Himachal
Pradesh
will
take
immediate
action for revision of pension etc. in terms of these orders. By order Sd/Prabodh Saxena, IAS Additional Chief Secretary (Finance) to the Government of Himachal Pradesh.”
9.
Now
this
Court
proceeds
to
analyze
contentions of the Learned Counsels for the respective parties hereinbelow. CONTENTIONS OF LEARNED PETITIONERS-RETIREES:
COUNSEL(S)
FOR
First contention of Learned Counsel for the
10.
petitioner is that Rule 13 of the Himachal Pradesh Civil Services [Revised] Pay Rules dated
03.01.2022
[Annexure P-3], which confers unguided and unfettered discretion on the State Authorities to release arrears of
salary
which
had
accrued
on
account
of
Revised Pay from 01.01.2016 till her superannuation on 31.01.2021 [in Lead case and in other cases till 31.12.2021] but the action of the State Authorities in
withholding
and
deferring
release
for
about
four and a half years (4½ years) now and in releasing the arrears of salary in a piecemeal and staggered manner is illegal and unconstitutional. The
above
contention
has
force,
for
reason, that once the State Authorities has taken a
conscious decision and notified the Himachal Pradesh Civil
Services
[Revised
Pay]
Rules
on
03.01.2022
[Annexure P-3], giving the arrears of salary accruing on account of revised pay scales to all the persons appointed on regular basis to posts and services w.e.f. 01.01.2016 then, the State Authorities cannot escape its liability for releasing the arrears of salary which had accrued in favour of the petitioners and others similar employees by virtue of the aforesaid Rules; and the action of the State Authorities in incorporating Rule
in
Rules
that
arrears
of
revised
salary from 01.01.2016 to 31.12.2021 shall be paid in “such manner” and “at such time” as may be “approved by the Government”, cannot stand the test of judicial scrutiny for the reason, firstly, the expressions “in such manner” and “at such time” as “as may be approved by the Government” contained in Rule 13 of the Rules confer unbridled, unrestricted, unfettered, uncanalised
and
unguided
discretion
on
State
Authorities to release the arrears of revised salary is unreasonable and arbitrary; and secondly, the provision of Rule 13 which makes the actual release of arrears
of and
revised
salary
unfettered
wholly
at
discretion
of
whims
and
State
mercy
Authorities
but without there being any guidelines for exercise of such discretion by State Authorities is unreasonable and arbitrary; and thirdly, the provision of Rule 13 enabling the State to release the arrears of revised salary at the discretion of the State Authorities but by
giving
a
complete
go-bye
to
principles
of
fairness, non-arbitrariness and credibility and action of
State
in
releasing
at
its
Authorities
in
earned/accrued
whims
and
embedding salary
discretion,
but
at
uncertainty
revised
without
rates
spelling
out the circumstances or eventualities or situations in clear and precise guidelines, where the aforesaid Rule was to be invoked; and in the absence of any guidelines, to
life,
liberty
fundamental and
and
property
constitutional
cannot
be
right
permitted
to be consigned to the limo of undefined premises and uncertain applications; and fourthly, the unfettered discretion vested in the State Authorities by virtue of Rule 13 cannot operate against the Rule of law embedded in Article 14 of the Constitution of India
so
as
to
of
salary,
divest
petitioner
indefinitely
for
of
almost
legal four
entitlement and
a
half
years {4½ years now} when, the earned/accrued salary is a property, within the meaning of Article 300-A of
State
Constitution Authorities
of
and
India;
fifthly,
have not enacted any
once
law, which
permits the State Authorities to divest an employee of the earned and accrued salary, (property) in case of
financial
constraints,
and
therefore,
in
absence
of any law, the action of State Authorities in depriving
petitioner
of
earned/accrued
salary
by
invoking
Rule 13 cannot sustain; and sixthly, even Rule 13 is
not
situation
a
substitute
for
contemplated
an
enacted
law,
qua
under
Article
300-A
of
Constitution of India; and seventhly, even otherwise,
provision
of
Rule
is
an
exploitative
and
unconscionable provision inserted by State Authorities due
to
inequality
of
bargaining
power
of
petitioner and other similar incumbents; and eighthly, aforesaid
Rule
defeats
foundational
concept
of
fair play in State Action by depriving the petitioner of the means of livelihood, violating the core object
of social and economic justice embedded in Article
of
Constitution
of
India;
and
ninthly,
plea of the State Authorities, that the State has a discretion to release arrears of revised pay by fixing cut-off
date
for
releasing
arrears,
cannot
sustain,
when, the State Authorities, by a conscious decision notified the HPCS Revised Pay Rules on 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] deciding to prescribe the cut-off date as 01.01.2016 for giving salary at revised rates then,
action
of
State
Authorities
in
carving
out
an artificial distinction at its whims and fancies for releasing the arrears of earned salary by treating it as a bounty, payable at the sweet will of the State Authorities
is
unreasonable,
arbitrary
and
contrary
to the State being a model employer; and tenthly, after
issuance
03.01.2022
of
[Annexure
Revised
P-3] the
Pay
Rules
on
petitioner and other
similar incumbents were bound to exercise an option for
fixation
of
pay
in
revised
pay
scale
within
one month from the date of issuance of these Rules i.e. before 28.02.2022 under Rule 6 and after taking into account processing time of three months upto
31.05.2022 “hereinafter referred to as the gestation period”, which may normally be required by respective Head of Institution /Drawing and Disbursing Officer and Treasury etc., and therefore, the arrears of revised salary became due and payable to the petitioner and other similarly placed incumbents w.e.f. 01.06.2022. Based on this, once the arrears of revised salary became due and payable w.e.f. 01.06.2022 but
action
or
in
of
prolonging
State or
Authorities
deferring
or
in
in
withholding
staggering
or
in releasing the revised pay arrears in a piece-meal manner by invoking its unfettered, unbridled, uncanalised, unrestricted and unguided discretion under Rule 13 has resulted in grave and undesirable consequences. Absence of an defined and certain application of this
Rule
and
even
absence
of
clear
and
precise guidelines, spelling out the eventualities or situations or circumstances or occasion as to when and at what time the arrears of revised pay could be withheld or delayed or could be released in a staggered, deferred or in a piece meal manner and therefore, the action of the State Authorities amounts
to withholding or delaying the “actual release of the earned
and
accrued
right to salary at the
revised
rates” by virtue of Revised Pay Rules dated 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] and when, the “payability of entire arrears of revised pay became due w.e.f 01.06.2022” to petitioner and other similar incumbents. Moreover, nothing has been placed on record to establish that the State Authorities had any enacted law spelling out the eventualities or situations or circumstances or occasion for either withholding or delaying or in releasing the entire accrued arrears
in a staggered
or in a piece-meal manner and in the absence of any enacted law, the petitioner and other similar incumbents could not be deprived of her property i.e. earned
salary
including
unbridled
unfettered
to
render
and
rights
arrears
by
invoking
unguided discretion so as
and
benefits
accruing
under
the Rules as redundant, otiose and nugatory. Further Rule
of
Rules
cannot
be
made
basis
for not releasing the entire arrears of earned/accrued salary
at
payability
w.e.f.
revised
rates,
01.06.2022
from for
date
almost
4½
of
its
years
till day is highly oppressive, unreasonable, capricious, arbitrary. Even, the mischief contained in aforesaid Rule,
leaving
petitioner
and
other
incumbents
at the mercy of the State Authorities for receiving their legal entitlements needs to be eliminated so that
petitioner
and
other
similar
incumbents
are not deprived of their earned and accrued benefits of
revised
for
their
pay
arrears
earned
and
not
are
benefits
kept
indefinitely,
waiting
and
that
too at the whims and fancies of State Authorities, due
to
unfettered,
unbridled,
uncanalised
and
unguided discretion conferred on the State Authorities/ Government. Petitioners having rendered service and having
earned
revised
pay
cannot
left
at
mercy of the Authorities for seeking release of their legal entitlements. The salary earned by the petitioner and
other
incumbents
under
Revised
Rules
of
2022 w.e.f. 01.01.2016 is “neither a bounty nor a charity but salary earned is a legal entitlement” and its payability and release cannot contingent upon the absolute and unfettered discretion of the State Authorities. The fundamental and constitutional right
to
life,
arrears be
liberty of
and
salary
consigned
to
property
earned]
limo
[including
cannot of
be
entire
permitted
undefined
to
premises
and uncertain applications. Petitioner and other similar incumbents cannot be made to go with a begging bowl or to await the issuance of orders for release of
earned/accrued
benefits
at
mercy
and
discretion of the State Authorities [which in instant case has been delayed for 4 ½ years now] and that too by releasing the meagre amount in a staggered or in a piece-meal manner. In
these
circumstances,
in
order
to
give
effect to the Object and Scheme of the of the HPCS Revised Pay Rules dated 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-1], mischievous provision i.e. Rule 13 of the aforesaid Rules, is read down and is declared inoperative, so as to remedy the injustice caused to the petitioner and other similar incumbents. Resultantly, the petitioner and other similar incumbents are held
entitled
for
release of “entire arrears of salary of revised pay” for
period
from 01.01.2016
till
her
superannuation
on 31.01.2021 [in Lead Case of Madhu Deshta and
likewise in other cases], despite the fact that “payability of entire arrears-benefits became due w.e.f. 01.06.2022”. Even, the action of the State Authorities in releasing a meagre amount(s) in a staggered or in a piecemeal manner but in still not releasing entire amount of arrears of earned salary for more than 4 ½ years and therefore, the State Authorities cannot be permitted to perpetuate the injustice to the petitioner and to other similar incumbents anymore hereinafter. Ordered accordingly. INTEREST ON DELAYED RELEASE OF ARREARS OF REVISED PAY:
Second contention of Learned Counsel for
11.
the petitioner is that after the issuance of Revised Pay Rules on 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] once salaryrevised State
pay arrears became due and payable but since Authorities
did
not
release
entire
arrears
for
more than 4½ years now, and therefore, the petitioner may be held entitled for interest on such deferred release. The above plea has force, for the reason, that once monetary entitlement of revised salary and its entire arrears has accrued in favour of petitioner
on
issuance
of
03.01.2022
its payability had crystallized
[Annexure
w.e.f.
P-3]
but
01.06.2022
but
payment of such monetary entitlement was withheld beyond the time and an employee was deprived of the right to use the said amount-lawful entitlement, then, deprivation of use of monetary lawful entitlement, entitles the petitioner to seek compensation or interest for loss occasioned by delay, in view of the mandate of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Bihar State
Ardh
Sarkari
Sangh
and
others
Arajpati versus
Karamchari
State
of
Bihar
Maha and
others [Writ Petition (Civil) No.932 of 2022] decided on 28.09.2026, underscoring the award of interest by compensating an employee who was deprived of the use
of
money,
which
had
crystallized
for
payment
but was withheld, delayed and was unduly prolonged by the State, entitling such employees for interest, in the following terms:“52.
The aforesaid exposition underscores that the rationale underlying the award of interest lies in compensating for the deprivation
of
use
of
money
lawfully due to a person. Where a monetary entitlement has crystallized and payment thereof is delayed beyond the time when
it became due and payable, the person entitled
thereto
is,
for
intervening
period, deprived of the use and benefit of the amount to which he is lawfully entitled. Interest, in such circumstances, serves as recompense for such deprivation
and seeks to compensate, to the extent capable of monetary assessment, for the loss occasioned by the delay. 54.
Having said that, the award of interest in exercise of the Court’s equitable or constitutional
jurisdiction
cannot
be
permitted to assume the character of a punitive levy upon the public exchequer. Interest in such circumstances is intended to compensate, in a reasonable measure, for
prolonged
use
of
money
deprivation
lawfully
due
of
and
not
to penalize the State. The rate of interest must,
therefore,
bear
a
reasonable
relationship to the nature of the deprivation, the period for which the dues remained unpaid
and
prevailing
economic
conditions. 55.
Applying the aforesaid principles to the facts of the present case, we find that the employees/workmen have been deprived of
their
lawful
salary
monetary
arrears
and
entitlements
other for
an
exceptionally prolonged period, extending, in several cases, over decades. Such delay cannot be attributed by any figment of imagination to any act or omission on the part of the individual employees /
workmen. They
have,
for
no
fault
their
own,
been
kept
out
of
amounts
which
were
lawfully due to
which,
in
have been benefit.
ordinary
them
course,
and
would
available for their use
The
prolonged
of
and
withholding
of
such dues, therefore, constitutes precisely the kind of monetary deprivation for which
reasonable
interest
serves
as
recompense. E. 59.
CONCLUSION AND DIRECTIONS
In light of the aforesaid discussion, we deem
it
appropriate
to
summarise
directions issued hereinabove as follows:e.
The States of Bihar and Jharkhand shall
ensure
payment
of
simple
interest at the rate of 12% per annum on the delayed EPF dues, and at the rate of 6% per annum on the delayed
salary,
monetary period on
wages
and
entitlements,
commencing
which
from
respective
other
for
date
amounts
became due and payable until the date of their actual payment.”
Considering the fact-situation of instant case, once the HPCS Revised Pay Rules were notified on 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] deciding to give the revised pay w.e.f.
arrears
to
01.01.2016,
petitioner
subject
to
and
other
exercise
of
employees an option
within one month and even to those, who do not exercise under these Rules. After considering the period of option of one month and the time required for processing such option and thereafter in submitting Revised Pay Arrear Claim by Head of Office or by Drawing and Disbursing Officer to concerned Treasury and other Offices, if any, and after considering the gestation period
of
three
months,
payability
of
arrears of salary at revised rates crystallized w.e.f. 01.06.2022. w.e.f.
Despite
01.06.2022,
crystallization
State
of
payability
Authorities
did
not
release entire arrears of salary at revised rates, without any
fault
have
prolonged,
release
of
attributable
entire
to
them
but
withheld,
denied
arrears
for
and
more
Authorities delayed
than
4½
years
till day which has certainly prejudiced the petitioner. For such deprivation of use of the lawful monetary entitlement-salary,
petitioner
and
other
similar
incumbents are entitled to seek recompense for such deprivation
of
their
rightful
use.
Consequently,
as
per the principles outlined by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Bihar State Ardh Sarkari Arajpati
Karamchari Maha Sangh [supra], this Court holds the petitioner entitled for release of entire arrears of Revised Pay in lump-sum with the further mandate to recompense the petitioner by giving simple interest @ 6% per annum from the date its payability had crystallized
w.e.f 01.06.2022
till
date
of actual
release of the earned/accrued right in terms of this judgement.
12.
ACTION OF STATE IN PENSION UNSUSTAINABLE:
DEFERRING
Third
Learned
contention
of
REVISED
Counsel
is
that once the State Authorities have issued an Office Memorandum dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4], giving Revised
Pension,
Revised
Gratuity
and
Revised
Commuted Pension to Government servants who retired from service on or after 01.01.2016 but Para 10 of
Office
Memorandum
provided
that
arrears
of Revised Retiral Benefits accruing from 01.01.2016 to 31.01.2022 leaving the release of arrears of retiral benefits at the mercy of State Authorities Government is illegal. MANDATE OF LAW ON RIGHT TO PENSION:
12(i).
Before proceeding to analyze this contention,
it is necessary to have a recap of the mandate of law regarding the legal recognition accorded to “concept of pension” is detailed hereinunder: 12(ii).
While dealing with the right of an employee
for pension, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has outlined that pension is not a bounty and right to pension is a valuable right in a Government Servant. Pension cannot be given by a State out of generosity. Pension is
an
earned
benefit
and
continuous
available and
to
pension
receive
is
right
by
virtue
of
long
unblemished service. Right
covered
under
right
to
property. Deprivation, delay or denying the right to receive pension fortifies the fundamental right of an employee. Antiquated notion of the State Authorities that since the pension is a bounty or a gratuitous payment depending upon the sweet will or the grace to the discretion of an employer and the same cannot be enforced by the Court has been held to be oppressive and has been deprecated. Right to pension and its payment does not depend upon the discretion of the Government being a social welfare means, so as to
achieve and provide socio-economic justice to a retiree, in the case of Deokinandan Prasad vs The State of Bihar and others, 1971 (2) SCC 330, in following terms:“30.
The question whether the pension granted to a public servant is property attracting Art. 31(1) came up for consideration before the Punjab High Court in Bhagwant Singh v.
Union
of
India.
It
was
held
that
such a right constitutes "property" and any interference will be a breach of
Art
31 (1) of the Constitution. It was further held that the State cannot by an executive order curtail or abolish altogether the right of the public servant to receive pension. This decision was given by a learned Single Judge. This decision was taken up in Letters Patent Appeal by the Union of India. The Letters Patent Bench in its decision in Union of India v. Bhagwant Singh
approved
decision
of
learned Single Judge. The Letters Patent Bench
held
that
pension
granted
to a public servant on his retirement is "property" within the meaning of Art 31(1) of the Constitution and he could be deprived of the same only by an authority of law and that pension does not cease to be property on the mere denial
or
cancellation
of
it.
It
was
further held that the character of pension as
"property"
cannot
possibly
undergo
such mutation at the whim of a particular person or authority. 31.
The
matter
again
came
up
before
a
Full Bench of the Punjab and Haryana High Court in K.R. Erry v. The State of Punjab. The High Court had to consider the nature of the right of an officer to get
pension.
The
majority
quoted
with
approval the principles laid down
in the
two earlier decisions of the same High Court, referred to above, and held that the pension is not to be treated as a bounty payable on the sweet will and pleasure of the Government and that
right
to
superannuation
pension
including its amount is a valuable right vesting
in
But
agree
we
a
Government with
servant….
view
of
majority when it has approved its earlier decision that pension is not a bounty payable on the sweet will and pleasure of
Government
and
that,
on
other hand, the right to pension is a valuable right vesting in
a
government
servant. 33.
Having due regard to the above decisions, we are of the opinion that the right of the petitioner to receive pension is property under Art 31 (1) and by a mere executive order
State
had
no
power
to
withhold the same. Similarly, the said claim is also property under Art. 19(1)(f) and it is not saved by sub-article (5) of Art. 9. Therefore, it follows that the
order dated June 12, 1968 denying the petitioner fight to receive pension affects the fundamental right of the petitioner under Arts. 19(1) (f) and 31(1) of the Constitution,
and
as
such
writ
petition under Art. 32 is maintainable. It may be that under the Pension Act (Act 23 of 1871) there is a bar against a civil court entertaining any suit relating to the matters mentioned therein. That does not
stand
in
way
of
a
Writ
of
Mandamus being issued to the State to properly consider the claim of the petitioner for
payment
of
pension
according
to
law.”
12(iii).
While dealing with a right of a retiree for
pension, it has only
been
compensation
outlined that pension is
for
loyal
service
rendered
not
in
a
post but pension has broader significance, to ensure socio-economic justice. Pension payable to Government Servant is earned by long efficient service and is a deferred portion of a compensation for service rendered. The object of pension is to ensure that a pensioner lives
with
standard
decency,
equivalent
independency, at
self-respect
pre-retirement
level,
in
and view
of the broader principles outlined by the Constitutional Bench of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in D.S. Nakara
versus Union of India, (1983) 2 SCC 305, in following terms: “22.
In the course of transformation of society from feudal to welfare and as socialistic thinking
acquired
respectability,
State
obligation to provide security in old age, an
escape
from
undeserved
want
was
recognised and as a first step pension was treated not only as a reward for past service but with a view to helping the employee to avoid destitution in old age. The quid pro quo, was that when the employee was physically and mentally alert
he
rendered
unto
master
best, expecting him to look after him in the fall of life. A retirement system therefore exists solely for the purpose of providing benefits. In most of the plans of retirement benefits, everyone who qualifies
for
normal
retirement
receives
the same amount. 24.
A
political
society
which
has
a
goal
of setting up of a welfare State, would introduce
and
has
in
fact
introduced
as a welfare measure wherein the retiral benefit
is
grounded
on
'considerations
of State obligation to its citizens who having
rendered
service
during
useful span of life must not be left to penury in their old age, but the evolving concept of social security is a later day development'.
And
over a rough terrain….
this
journey
was
26.
Let us therefore examine what are the goals
that
pension
scheme
seeks
to
subserve? A pension scheme consistent with available resources must provide that the pensioner would be able to live: (i) free from want, with decency, independence
and
self-respect, and
(ii)
at a standard equivalent at the preretirement level…. Many
are
literally
surviving
now
than
in the past. We owe it to them and ourselves
that
exist.
The
given
society
development
they
live,
philosophy at
not
merely
prevailing
various
profoundly
in
a
of
its
influences
its
stages
social objectives. These objectives are in turn a determinant of a social policy. The law is one of the chief instruments whereby the social policies are implemented and
'pension is paid according to rules
which
can
be
said
to
provide
social
security law by which it is meant those legal mechanisms primarily concerned to ensure the provision of a cash income
for the individual
adequate, when taken
along with the benefits in kind provided by
other
social
services
(such
as
free
medical aid) to ensure for him a culturally acceptable minimum standard of living when the normal means of doing so failed'. 29.
Summing-up it can be said with confidence that pension is not only compensation for loyal service rendered in the past,
but pension also has a broader significance, in that it is a measure of socio-economic justice which inheres economic security in the fall of life when physical and mental prowess is ebbing corresponding to aging process and therefore, one is required to fall back on savings. One such saving in kind is when you gave your best in the hey-day of life to your employer, in days of invalidity, economic security by way
of
periodical
payment
is
assured.
The term has been judicially defined as a stated allowance or stipend made in consideration of past service or a surrender of rights or emoluments to one retired from service. Thus the pension payable to a Government employee is earned by rendering long and efficient service and
therefore
can
be
said
to
be
a
deferred portion of the compensation or for service rendered. In one sentence one can say that the most practical raison d'etre for pension is the inability to provide for oneself due to old age. One may live and avoid unemployment but not senility and penury if there is nothing to fall back upon. 31.
From the discussion three things emerge:
(i)
that a
pension matter
is
of
neither grace
a
bounty
depending
nor upon
the sweet will of the employer and that it creates a vested right subject to 1972 rules
which
because
they
are are
statutory
in
character
enacted
in
exercise
of powers conferred by the proviso to Art 309 and clause (5) of Art. 148 of the Constitution; (ii)
that
pension
is
not
an
ex-gratia
payment but it is a payment for the past service rendered; and (iii)
it is a social welfare measure rendering socio-economic
justice to those who
in
the hey-day of their life ceaselessly toiled for the employer on an assurance that in
their
old
age
they
would
not
be
left in lurch…..” RIGHT TO PENSION AND GRATUITY UNDER STATUTORY RULES-CCS (PENSION) RULES 1972:
12(iv).
For appreciating the claim of the petitioner,
it is necessary to have recap of Rule 3 (1) (j); Rule
(1)
(o)
&
(1)
(r),
Rule
33,
Rule
(2),
Rule
74, Rule 83; and Rule 85 (i) and (ii) of CCS Pension Rules, 1972, as applicable to the employees of the State Government, read as under:“Rule 3 (1) (j) of CCS [Pension] Rules:‘Gratuity includes: (i)
‘service gratuity’ payable under subrule (1) of Rule 49;
(ii)
retirement
gratuity/death
gratuity
payable under sub-rule (1) of Rule 50; and (iii)
‘residuary gratuity’ payable under subrule (2) of Rule 50.
Rule 3 (1) (o) of CCS [Pension] Rules: ‘pension’ when
includes
gratuity
term
except
pension
is
used in contradistinction to gratuity, but does not include dearness relief. Rule 3(1) (r) of CCS [Pension] Rules:‘retirement Benefits includes pension or service gratuity, and retirement gratuity, where admissible. Rule 33 of CCS [Pension] Rules: The expression emoluments’ means basic pay as defined in Rule 9 (21) (a) (i) of Fundamental Rules, which a government servant was receiving immediately before his retirement or on the date of his death and will
also
include
non-practising
allowance granted to medical officer in lieu of private practice. Rule 49 (2) of CCS [Pension] Rules:(2)
Subject
to
provision
of
Sub
Rule (2) of Rule 38, in the case of a
Government
accordance
servant
with
retiring
in
provisions
of
these rules after completing qualifying service of not less than ten years, the amount of pension shall be calculated
at
fifty
per
cent
of
emoluments or average emoluments, whichever
is
more
beneficial
to
him, subject to a minimum of nine thousand per mensem and maximum
of one lakh twenty five thousand rupees per mensem. Rule 74 of CCS [Pension] Rules:74.
Date of retirement to be notified: When a Government servant retires from service:
(a).
notification in the Official Gazette in the case of a Gazetted Government servant, and
(b).
an office order in the case of a nonGazetted Government servant shall be
issued
specifying
date
of
retirement within a week of such date and a copy of every such notification or office order, as the case may be, shall be forwarded immediately to the Accounts Officer: Provided that where a notification in the Official Gazette or an office order, as the case may be, regarding the grant
of
leave
preparatory
to
retirement to a Government servant is issued, a further notification or office order
that
Government
servant has actually retired on the expiry of such leave shall not be necessary unless the leave is curtailed and the retirement is for any reason ante-dated or postponed. Rule 83 of CCS [Pension] Rules: 83.
Date from which pension becomes payable
(1)
Except in the case of a Government servant to whom the provisions of Rule 37 apply and subject to the provisions of Rules 9 and 69, a person other than family pension shall become payable from the date on which a Government servant ceases
to
be
borne
on
establishment. (2)
Pension
including
family
pension
shall be payable for the day on which its recipient dies. Rule 85 of CCS [Pension] Rules:85.
Manner of payment of gratuity and pension
(1)
Except
as
these
rules,
otherwise a
provided
gratuity
shall
in be
paid in lumpsum. (2)
A pension fixed at monthly rates shall be payable monthly on or after the last working day of the month to which
pension
relates
except
for the month of March when it shall be payable on or after 1st working day of April.” MANDATE OF LAW- BENEFITS ACCRUING UNDER STATUTORY RULES-THE CCS (PENSION) RULES 1972 CANNOT BE NEGATED BY EXECUTIVE FIATORDER:
12(v).
The Hon’ble Supreme Court has mandated
in
case
of
U.P.
Raghavendra
Acharya
and
others versus State of Karnataka and others, 2006
(9) SCC 630, that the rights and benefits accruing under the Statutory Rules cannot be negated, defeated or taken away by a mere executive order or an OM in the following terms:“23.
The stand of the State of Karnataka that the pensionary benefits had been conferred on the appellants w.e.f. 1.4.1998 on the premise that the benefit of the revision of scales of pay to its own employees had
been
conferred
from
1.1.1998,
in
our opinion, is wholly misconceived. Firstly, because the employees of the State of Karnataka
and
appellants,
in
matter of grant of benefit of revised scales of pay, do not stand on the same footing as revised scales of pay had been made applicable to their cases from a different date. Secondly, the appellants had been given the benefit of the revised scales of pay w.e.f. 1.1.1996. It is now well settled that a notification can be issued by the State accepting the recommendations of
Pay
Revision
Committee
with
retrospective effect as it was beneficent to the employees. Once such a retrospective effect is given to the recommendations of
Pay
concerned
Revision
Committee,
employees
despite
their
reaching the age of superannuation in between
date
issuance
of
said
dates
and/or
of
notification
would be deemed to be getting the said scales of pay as on 1.1.1996.
By reason
of such notification as the appellants had
been
they
could
derived
of
not
have
a
vested been
right,
deprived
therefrom and that too by reason of executive instructions. 25.
Pension, as is well known, is not a bounty. It is treated to be a deferred salary. It is akin to right of property. It is co-related and has a nexus with the salary payable to the employees as on the date of retirement.
28.
The
impugned
orders
furthermore
is
opposed to the basic principles of law inasmuch
as
instructions
by
reason
an
employee
of
executive cannot
be
deprived of a vested or accrued right. Such
a
right to
draw
pension
to
extent of 50% of the emoluments, computed in terms of the rules, w.e.f. 1.1.1996, vested to the appellants in terms of Government notification read with Rule 296 of the Rules.”
12(v-a).
Similar reiteration of law has been outlined
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Jharkhand and others versus Jitendra Kumar Srivastava and another, (2013) 12 SCC 210,
mandating that the
Instructions cannot supplant the Statutory Rules, in following terms:“7.
The aforesaid arguments of the learned Senior Counsel based on the judgment
in
Sant Ram
any ice in so
Sharma
would
far
present case is
as
not
cut
concerned, because of the reason this case has no applicability in the given case. Sant of
Ram
judgment
administrative
governs law
field
wherein
Constitution Bench laid down the principle that the rules framed by the authority in exercise of powers contained in
an
enactment, would also have statutory force.
Though
administration
can
issue administrative instructions for the smooth
administrative
administrative
instructions
supplant
rules.
such
function,
cannot
However,
these
administrative instructions can supplement
statutory
rules
by
taking
care
of
those situations where the statutory rules are silent. This ratio of that judgment is
narrated
in
following
manner:
(AIR p. 1914, para 7) “7…….It is true that there is no specific provision in the Rules laying down the principle of promotion of junior
or
senior
grade
officers
selection
grade
posts.
But
to
that
does not mean that till statutory rules
are
framed
Government
in
this
behalf
cannot
issue
administrative instructions regarding
principle
to
be
followed
in
promotions of the officers concerned to selection grade posts. It is true that
Government
cannot
amend
or supersede
statutory
rules
by
administrative instructions, but if the rules are silent on any particular point Government can fill up the gaps and supplement the rules and issue instructions and inconsistent with the rules already framed”. There cannot be any quarrel on this exposition
of
law
which
is
well
grounded in a series of judgments pronounced post Sant Ram Sharma case as well. However, the question which is posed in the present case is altogether different. 14.
The
right
to
receive
pension
was
recognized as right to property by the Constitution Bench Judgment of this Court in Deokinandan Prasad v. State of Bihar; as is apparent from the following discussion: (SCC pp. 342-43, paras 27-33) “27.
The last question to be considered, is,
whether
right
to
receive
pension by a Government servant is property,
so
as
to
attract Articles
19(1) (f) and 31(1) of the Constitution. This question in writ
falls to
order to consider petition
is
be decided whether
maintainable
under Article 32. To this aspect, we have already adverted to earlier and we now proceed to consider the same. 30.
The question whether the pension granted to a public servant is property
attracting Article 31(1) came up for consideration
before
Punjab
High Court in Bhagwant Singh v. Union of India. It
was held
that
such a right constitutes "property" and
any
interference
will
be
breach of Article 31 (1) Constitution. that
It
State
was
of the
further
cannot
a
by
held an
executive order curtail or abolish altogether the right of the public servant to receive pension….” EVENTUALITIES IN WHICH PENSION AND/OR GRATUITY COULD BE WITHHELD OR WITHDRAWN OR RECOVERY CAN BE MADE THEREFROM:
12(vi).
Government of India issued the Central Civil
Service (Pension) Rules 1972, and these Rules were adopted and made applicable by State of Himachal Pradesh for regulating the claim for Pension (including Family Pension) and Gratuity (including Death Gratuity) to retired government servants. By and large various Boards/Corporations which are owned and controlled by State of Himachal Pradesh have adopted and applied these Rules and some of them have issued their own Rules /Regulations, which are pari-materia to these Rules. Rule 9 of the CCS (Pension) Rules spells out the eventualities, when, the State Government has been empowered to either “withhold or withdraw or to
recover” either the pension or gratuity or both, which is payable to a retired government servant alike the petitioner. Rule 9 of the CCS [Pension] Rules read as under:Rule 9 of CCS [Pension] Rules:9.
Right of President to withhold or withdraw pension
(1)
The President reserves to himself the right of withholding a pension or gratuity, or both, either in full or
in
part,
withdrawing
or
a
pension in full or in part, whether permanently
or
for
a
specified
period, and of ordering recovery from a pension or gratuity of the whole
or
part
of
any
pecuniary
loss caused to the Government, if, in any departmental or judicial proceedings, the pensioner is found guilty
of
grave
misconduct
or
negligence
during
of
period
service, including service rendered upon re-employment after retirement: Provided
that
Service
Commission
Union shall
Public be
consulted before any final orders are passed: Provided further that where a part of pension is withheld or withdrawn the amount of such pensions shall not be reduced below the amount
of rupees
three
thousand
five
hundred per mensem. (2) (a) The
departmental
proceedings
referred to in sub-rule (1), if instituted while the Government servant was in
service
whether
retirement
or
before
his
his
re-
during
employment, shall, after the final retirement
of
Government
servant, be deemed to be proceedings under
this
rule
and
shall
be
by
continued
and
concluded
authority
by
which
commenced
in
they
same
were
manner
as if the Government servant had continued in service: Provided that where the departmental proceedings
are
instituted
authority
subordinate
by to
an
President, that authority shall submit a report recording its findings to the President. (b)
The
departmental
proceedings,
if
not instituted while the Government servant
was
in
service,
whether
before his retirement, or during his reemployment(i)
shall not be instituted save with the sanction of the President,
(ii)
shall not be in respect of any event which took place more than four years and
before
such
institution,
(iii)
shall be conducted by such authority and in such place as the President may direct and in accordance with
procedure
applicable
to
departmental proceedings in which an order of dismissal from service could be made in relation to the Government
servant
during
his
service. (3)
Deleted.
(4)
In the case of Government servant who has retired on attaining the age of superannuation or otherwise and against whom any departmental or judicial proceedings are instituted or where departmental proceedings are continued under sub-rule (2), a provisional pension as provided in Rule 69 shall be sanctioned.
(5)
Where the President decides not to withhold or withdraw pension but orders recovery of pecuniary loss from
pension,
recovery
shall
not ordinarily be made at a rate exceeding one-third of the pension admissible on the date of retirement of a Government servant. (6)
For the purpose of this rule:
(a)
departmental proceedings shall be deemed to be instituted on the date on which the statement of charges is issued to the Government servant or pensioner, or if the Government
servant
has
suspension
been
from
placed
under
earlier
date,
an
on such date; and (b)
judicial proceedings shall be deemed to be instituted –
(i)
in the case of criminal proceedings, on the date on which the complaint or
report
which
of
a
police
officer,
Magistrate
of
takes
cognizance, is made, and (ii)
12(vii).
in the case of civil proceedings, on the date the plaint is presented in the court.”
In the backdrop of the Statutory Rules i.e.
the CCS (Pension) Rules 1972 though right for pension accrues to a Government Servant and such pension becomes
payable
from
next
month
after
date
a government servant ceases to be on establishment after retirement. Rule 9 of the Rules, as extracted above spells out that State Authorities have been empowered to “withhold or withdraw or to make recovery” from payable Pension or Gratuity or both, if departmental or
judicial
proceedings
are
instituted
and
such
proceedings are pending on the date of retirement and such proceedings are continued, in which, a pensioner is found guilty of grave misconduct or negligence during the period of service.
In
lead
case
and
other
connected
cases,
State Authorities issued an Office Memorandum dated 25.02.2022
[Annexure
P-4]
entitling
petitioner
for and other retirees for Revised Pension from the date of her superannuation w.e.f. 01.02.2021 [in the Lead Case] and similar entitlement for Revised Pension had accrued to other Government Servants who retired from
government
service
or
service
of
Boards
/Corporations, who were governed by CCS (Pension) Rules on or after 01.01.2016. Despite the entitlement and
accrual
of
right
for
pension
under
CCS (Pension) Rules 1972, as referred to above, the State Authorities have incorporated Para 10 in the Office Memorandum dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4] providing that the arrears of revision of pension/gratuity /commuted
pension/family
pension
from
01.01.2016
to 31.01.2022 shall be paid in “such manner
as
may be “decided by the Government in future”. Para 10 of the OM cannot pass the test of judicial scrutiny, for the reason, firstly, that accrual of right of Pension by virtue of the Statutory Rules, i.e. the CCS
[Pension]
Rules,
cannot
be
defeated,
curtailed
or negated by mere insertion of Para 10 in the OM and secondly, even Para 10 as contained in Office Memorandum dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4] being an executive order, can neither take away or curtail or deny or delay the release of the arrears of Revised Pension to the petitioner and other retirees by giving a complete go-bye to the Statutory Rules establishes manifest unfairness, unreasonableness, arbitrariness in State
action
and
aforesaid
Executive
order-OM
cannot be permitted to form the basis for defeating the accrued-vested valuable right for revised pension and arrears of revised pension, which had crystallized under Statutory Rules; thirdly, the use of expression “in such manner as may be decided by Government in future” in Para 10 of the OM confers unbridled, unrestricted, unfettered, uncanalised and the unguided discretion on the State Authorities to release arrears of
pension
is
unreasonable
and
arbitrary,
actual release of arrears of revised pension
as
cannot
be made wholly dependent at the whims and mercy and
unfettered
discretion
of
State
Authorities
and that too without there being any guidelines for
invocation of such discretion by the State Authorities ; and fourthly, once by virtue of Statutory Rules, i.e. the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules 1972, petitioner had acquired a fundamental and constitutional right to receive pension, including revised pension and its arrears
therefore
such
an
acquired/vested
right
cannot be permitted to be consigned to the undefined and by
uncertain a
mere
premises
executive
and fiat
uncertain by
applications
invoking
Para
of the OM is unsustainable; and fifthly, the unfettered discretion
vested
in
Para
cannot
be
permitted
to operate so as to divest the petitioner of valuable legal
entitlement
four and a half
for
arrears
of
pension
for
almost
years {4½ years now}; and sixthly,
the action of the State Authorities in divesting the petitioner a
of
property,
earned/accrued
within
meaning
pension, of
which
Article
is
300-A,
without there being any law enacted by the State Authorities
providing
for
divesting
a
retiree
of
earned and accrued pension (property) even in case of financial constraints ; and seventhly, the provision of Para 10 is an exploitative and unconscionable provision
which due
has to
been
inserted
by
State
inequality
of
bargaining
Authorities power
of
the petitioner and all other similar incumbents; and eighthly,
State
Authorities
are
under
obligation
to provide security in old-age and Para 10 of Office Memorandum
cannot
be
permitted
to
be
used
as
an escape route for not releasing arrears of revised pension ; and ninthly, the provision of Rule 9 of CCS (Pension) Rules 1972, provides that State Government can “withhold or withdraw or recover” either Pension or Gratuity or both, of a pensioner if departmental or
judicial
proceedings
are
proceedings
are
on
and
proceedings
such
pensioner
is
pending
found
are
guilty
instituted
and
such
date
of
retirement
continued
in
which
of
misconduct
or
grave
negligence. In case, neither any disciplinary proceedings nor an judicial proceeding were pending nor was a pensioner held guilty of grave misconduct or negligence during service in the said proceedings; then, in the absence of any such proceedings and findings recorded therein, the non-release of entire arrears of revised pension amounts to “withholding or withdrawing” the
unreleased
arrears
of
revised
pension”
by
invoking
Para 10 of the OM, is contrary to Rule 9 of the CCS (Pension) Rules and non-release being without any authority of law is unsustainable; and lastly, non-release of entire arrears of earned/accrued revised pension results in forcing the retirees, alike petitioner and
others
indigency
to
and
destitution
in
old-age,
penury
of
depriving,
withholding,
action
and
denying or delaying the actual release of pension to a retiree by invoking Para 10 is opposed to public policy, and such action defeats the object and social justice being contrary to the bounden obligation of State being a model employer. Action of the State Authorities in not releasing entire arrears of revised pension to petitioner and other retirees by assuming and
treating
such
benefits
to
be
bounty
or
gratis, releasable at the mercy of State Authorities cannot be permitted to operate anymore hereinafter in violation of Statutory Rules, Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules 1972, so as to offend the fundamental ethos of the Constitution of India.
Resultantly, Para 10 of Office Memorandum dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4], is opposed to public policy and being contrary to Statutory Rules i.e. CCS (Pension) Rules 1972, and action of State Authorities which tends to defeat, take away, curtail, withhold or delay the actual release of entire arrears of revised pension,
without
any
right
revised
pension
to
authority and
of
law;
entire
when,
arrears
earned
had accrued and crystallized and had become payable from the next month [w.e.f. 01.02.2021 in Lead case} after the date of retirement on 31.01.2021 but the non-release of entire arrears of pension, cannot be permitted to operate hereinafter, anymore, so as to defeat the very foundational fabric of social justice, and
right
with
human
of
livelihood,
dignity,
and
post-retirement
right
also.
to
live
Action
of
negating or delaying the release of entire arrears of revised
pension,
being
property,
without
there
being any authority of law, indefinitely [for about 4½ years now]; but in releasing arrears of revised pension in a staggered or piecemeal manner; certainly impinges Article
and 300-A
of
the Constitution
of
India
and is violative of the Statutory Rules. Consequently the offending provision i.e. Para 10 in the OM enabling the State Authorities to release arrears of revised pension in a staggered or piecemeal manner at its unbridled, unrestricted, uncanalised, unfettered discretion, whims and fancies cannot sustain and is accordingly, quashed and set-aside ; and the petitioner and other
similar
incumbents in
connected matters
are held entitled for the release of entire arrears of revised pension, alongwith interest, in terms of the directions contained in this judgement. WITHHOLDING, DENYING OR DELAYING RELEASE OF REVISED GRATUITY:
Fourth
13.
contention
of
Learned
Counsel
is
that once as per Rule 50 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972,
Gratuity
under
these
Rules,
becomes
payable
then,
Para
in
lump-sum
of
Office
Memorandum dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4], providing to give the arrears of Revised Gratuity to Government servants at mercy of the State Authorities Government is illegal. STATUTORY RULES-CCS (PENSION) RULES 1972 GOVERNING RIGHT TO PENSION AND GRATUITY:
13(i).
For appreciating the claim of the petitioner
at the sake of repetition, it is necessary to have a recap of Rule 3 (1) (j); Rule 50 and Rule 85 (i) and (ii) of CCS Pension Rules, 1972, as applicable to the employees of the State Government, read as under:“Rule 3 (1) (j) of CCS [Pension] Rules: ‘Gratuity includes: (iv)
‘service gratuity’ payable under subrule (1) of Rule 49;
(v)
retirement
gratuity/death
gratuity
payable under sub-rule (1) of Rule 50; and (vi)
‘residuary gratuity’ payable under subrule (2) of Rule 50. Rule 50 of CCS [Pension] Rules:
50.
Retirement/Death Gratuity
(1) (a)
A
Government
servant,
who
has
completed five years' qualifying service and has become eligible for service gratuity or pension under Rule 49, shall, on his retirement, be granted retirement gratuity equal to onefourth of his emoluments for each completed
six
monthly
qualifying
service,
maximum
of
period
subject
16½
times
to
of a
emoluments. 1(b)
If a Government servant dies while in service, the death gratuity shall
be paid to his family in the manner indicated in sub-rule (1) of Rule 51 at the rates given in the Table below, namely:Length of qualifying service
Rate of death gratuity
(i)
Less than 1 year
2 times of emoluments
(ii)
One year or more but less than 5 years
6 times of emoluments
(iii) 5 years of more but less than 20 years
12 times of emoluments
(iv) 20 years more
Half of emoluments for every completed six-monthly period of qualifying service subject to maximum of times of emoluments
or
Provided
that
amount
of
retirement gratuity or death gratuity payable under this rule shall in no case exceed ten lakh rupees; Provided
further
that
where
amount of retirement or death gratuity as
finally
calculated
contains
a
fraction of a rupee, it shall be rounded off to the next higher rupee. (2)
If a Government servant, who has become eligible for a service gratuity or pension, dies within five years from the date of his retirement from service including
compulsory
retirement
as a penalty and the sums actually received by him at the time of his
death on account of such gratuity or pension including ad hoc increase, if any, together with the retirement gratuity admissible under sub-rule (1) and the commuted value of any portion of pension commuted by him are less than the amount equal to
times
residuary
of
his
emoluments,
gratuity
equal
to
a
deficiency may be granted to his family in the manner indicated in sub-rule (1) of Rule 51.
Deleted
Deleted.
(5)
The emoluments for the purpose of gratuity admissible under this rule, shall
be
reckoned
in
accordance
with Rule 33: Provided that if the emoluments of a
Government
servant
have
been
reduced during the last ten months of his service otherwise than as a penalty,
average
emoluments
as
referred to in Rule 34 shall be treated as emolument. Provided further that the dearness allowance admissible on the date of retirement
of
death,
as
case
may be, shall also be treated as emoluments for the purpose of this rule;] (6)
For the purposes of this rule and Rule
51,52
and
53,
`family',
in
relation to a Government servant, means – (i)
to (xi) … not relevant… Rule 85 of CCS [Pension] Rules:
85.
Manner of payment of gratuity and pension
(1)
Except as otherwise provided in these rules, a gratuity shall be paid in lumpsum.
(2)
A pension fixed at monthly rates shall be payable monthly on or after the last working day of the month to which the pension relates except for the month of March when it shall be payable on or after its working day of April.
13(ii).
Perusal of Rule 50 (1) (a) read with Rule
85 (1) of CCS (Pension) Rules establish that the right to
Gratuity
crystallizes
and
becomes
payable
to
a
Government Servant on his/her retirement in lumpsum. Moreover, in terms of the Statutory Rules, once
petitioner
and
other
retirees
had
acquired
a
right for revised gratuity and release of entire arrears of
Gratuity
in
lump-sum,
therefore,
provision
of Para 10 of Office Memorandum dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4], conferring unfettered, unbridled, unguided unrestricted,
and
uncanalised
discretion
on
State
Authorities to release the arrears of Revised Gratuity in
“such
manner
as
may
be
decided
by
Government in future”, cannot sustain, for the reason, firstly, Rule
Para
and
of
Rule
OM
being
(1) of CCS
contrary
to
[Pension] Rules
is illegal; and secondly, Para 10 of OM cannot be “a modus operandi” so as to negate the right under the Statutory Rules; and thirdly, the action of the State Authorities in not releasing the entire earned and accrued arrears of Revised Gratuity, despite its payability after the
issuance of OM on 25.02.2022
[Annexure P-4], and after taking into account the gestation
period
of 3
months
{under Rule 68 of
CCS (Pension) Rules and instructions issued thereunder] i.e. period required for processing the claim for revised gratuity at the Departmental Level and by Accountant General, in case of government servants} and based on this, Revised Gratuity and entire arrears became payable w.e.f. 01.06.2022 and neither any departmental nor criminal-judicial proceedings were pending against petitioner-a
retiree
on
such
date,
then,
non-release
of entire arrears of revised Gratutity to the petitioner
and other like retirees amounts to “withholding or withdrawing” the accrued right of entire arrears of gratuity in lump-sum, dehors the mandate of Rule 9 read with Rule 50 and Rule 85 (1) of the CCS Rules; and fourthly, the right to Gratuity
(Pension) being
a
retiral
benefit
akin
to
pension
constitutes
property of a pensioner under Article 300-A of the Constitution of India and in the absence of “any enacted law”, the provision of Para 10 of the Office Memorandum cannot be permitted to take away or curtail, defeat or negate the Constitutional right of the petitioner in a capricious and arbitrary manner; and fifthly, the right to receive revised gratuity and entire
arrears
withheld
or
of
such
delayed
revised
and
gratuity
denied
for
cannot
an
be
indefinite
period indefinitely [i.e. for about 4 ½ years now] ; and
lastly,
action
of
State
Authorities
in
making release of entire arrears of revised gratuity, which were payable in lump-sum, purely contingent on the capricious discretion and whims of the State Authorities.
Even,
manifest
perversity
in
decision
making process is apparent, for the reason, that
once
State
Authorities
have
taken
a
conscious
decision to enhance/revise the Gratuity from Rs 10 lakhs of
to
Rs
lakhs
Para
3.2
and
w.e.f.
6.2
of
01.01.2016, OM
dated
in
terms
25.02.2022
[Annexure P-4] subject to fulfilment of other conditions, from
date
of
retirement of
government servant
and based on such entitlement, petitioner and other retirees became entitled for the release of Revised Gratuity
in
lump-sum
under
Statutory
Rule
and
therefore, for reasons already detailed [in Para 12(vii) of this judgement], Para 10 of the OM enabling the State Authorities to release arrears of revised gratuity in staggered or piecemeal manner or at its unbridled, unrestricted, uncanalised, unfettered discretion, whims and fancies cannot sustain. Consequently, Para 10 is quashed and setaside; and the petitioner and other similar incumbents in
connected
matters
are
held
entitled
for
release
of the entire arrears of revised gratuity in lump-sum, alongwith interest, in terms of the directions contained in this judgement. WITHHOLDING AND DELAYED RELEASE OF REVISED DCRG- UNTENABLE:
Fifth
14.
contention
of
Learned
Counsel
is
that as per Rule 54 of the CCS (Pension) Rules 1972 Death Cum Retirement Gratuity is a part of Gratuity, which becomes payable in lump-sum. Para 10 of the Office Memorandum dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4], providing for giving arrears of Revised DCRG at the mercy of the Government and thus, the resultant action of State Authorities in withholding or delaying the release of entire arrears of DCRG in lump sum, [to eligible family members in connected cases, wherever applicable] on the same analogy, on which, the Retirement /Service Gratuity is payable is capricious, arbitrary and illegal. PROLONGING THE RELEASE OF REVISED FAMILY PENSION- UNTENABLE:
Sixth contention of the Learned Counsel is
15.
that Para 10 of Office Memorandum dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4], providing that the arrears of Revised Family Pension shall be released in “such manner as may
be
decided
by
Government
in
future”,
is contrary to Rule 54 read with Rule 83 (2) of CCS (Pension) Rules 1972 and in terms of Para 7.1 and Para
7.2
of
Office
Memorandum
dated
25.02.2022
[Annexure P-4], eligible family members are entitled for enhanced/revised Family Pension from the date, the Government Servant dies. Moreover, Para 10 confers unfettered
and
uncanalised
discretion
on
State
to release the Revised Family Pension Arrears amounts to forcing the family members to lead to indigency and penury and deprives the family members to live with dignity. In these circumstances, the eligible family members of deceased government servants {in any of the connected cases herein, and all other similar family members} shall be entitled for release of entire arrears of Family Pension along with interest in terms of this judgement. NON-RELEASE OF ARREARS OF COMMUTED PENSION: [CWP No 11716 OF 2024, Dr JAGDEV & ORS vs STATE]
16.
Seventh contention of Learned Counsel is
that Para 8.2, Para 8.3 and Para 10 of the Office Memorandum dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4], providing that the deferential amount or arrears of Commuted Pension
[wherever
applicable
in
connected
cases
or
in case of other retirees] is to be released in “a phased manner as may be notified by the Government”, is contrary to Statutory Rules, i.e. CCS [Commutation
of Pension] Rules 1981 and therefore, aforesaid Paras are illegal. STATUTORY RULES-ON COMMUTED VALUE OF PENSION UNDER CCS (COMMUTATION OF PENSION) RULES 1981:
16(i).
For
appreciating
contention,
a
recap
of Rule 4 and 5 of the CCS [Commutation of Pension] Rules 1981, as is applicable to the employees of State Government and Boards and Corporations owned and controlled by the State [whichever is applicable], read as under:Rule 4 of CCS [Commutation of Pension] Rules, 1981 4.
Restriction on commutation of pension No
Government
whom
servant
departmental
or
against judicial
proceedings, as referred to in Rule 9 of the Pension Rules, have been instituted
before
date
of
his
retirement, or the pensioner against whom such proceedings are instituted after
date
of
shall
be
eligible
his to
retirement, commute
a
percentage of his provisional pension authorized
under
Rule
of
Pension Rules or the pension, as the case may be, during the pendency of such proceedings. 5.
Limit on commutation of pension –
(1)
A Government
shall
servant
be
entitled to commute for a lump sum payment of an amount not exceeding forty percent of his pension. (2)
In an application for commutation in Form 1 or Form 1-A or Form 2, as the case may be, an applicant shall indicate the percentage of pension which he desires to commute and may either indicate the maximum limit of forty percent of pension or such lower limit as he may desire to commute.
(3)
If
percentage
of
pension
to
be
commuted results in fraction of a rupees,
such
fraction
of
a
rupee
shall be ignored for the purpose of commutation. 10.
Retrospective revision of final Pension:An
applicant
who
has
commuted
a fraction of his final pension and after has
commutation been
revised
retrospectively
his
pension
and
enhanced
as
a
result
of
Government's decision, the applicant shall be paid the difference between
commuted
value
determined
with reference to enhanced pension and the commuted value already authorized. difference
For
payment
of
shall
not
applicant
be required to apply afresh:
Provided that …..not relevant…”
16(ii).
Bare
reading
of
Rule
(1)
of
CCS
(Commutation of Pension) Rules 1981 mandates that an eligible government servant shall be entitled for commutation, for lump-sum payment, not exceeding 40% of his/her pension. Rule 10 provides that person who has commuted a fraction of his final pension and after commutation, his pension has been revised and
enhanced
retrospectively
as
a
result
of
Government's decision, then, such person shall be paid
difference between commuted value determined
with
reference
to
enhanced
pension
and
commuted value already authorized and for payment of difference, applicant shall
not
be required to
apply afresh. 16(iii). of
In terms of the Statutory Rules, the object
commutation
of
portion
of
pension
is
to
remit
a lump-sum payment, out of the total pension to a
Government
Servant
and
on
revision
of
pension
retrospectively, the commutation value is to be revised /enhanced, without calling for any fresh option for commutation.
16(iv).
Para 8.3 of the Office Memorandum dated
25.02.2022
[Annexure
P-4],
requiring
a
person-
retiree, who had already availed of commutation, to exercise a fresh option, in case, he does not intends to
seek
whittling
revised/enhanced down
or
commutation
restricting
rights
amounts
to
carved
out
under Rule 10 of the CCS (Commutation of Pension) Rules,
which
expressly
mandates
that
revised
commuted value of pension is to be released without there being any requirement for making a retiree to exercise fresh option for availing or not to avail the revised commuted value of pension. Consequently, Para 8.3 of the OM which defeats the mandate of the Statutory
Rule
i.e.
Rule
of
CCS
(Commutation
of Pension) cannot be permitted to operate in instant form. Ordered accordingly. 16(v).
Para 8.2 and Para 10 of Office Memorandum
dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4], providing that the deferential amount or arrears of Commuted Pension [wherever applicable in connected cases or in case of other retirees] is to be released in “a phased manner as
may
be
notified
by
Government” cannot sustain,
being contrary to Rule 5 of Statutory Rules, which entitles a retiree for lump sum commuted value of pension
and revised commuted value of pension
and these offending provisions cannot be permitted to operate dehors the Statutory Rules. Moreover, action of
State
Authorities
abusing
its
discretion
by
staggering or deferring the release of Revised Commuted Pension Benefits in a whimsical manner renders the rights accrued under the Statutory Rules ineffective, unworkable,
otiose
and
nugatory
and
thus
these
offending provisions, depriving a retiree of his legal entitlements, to the extent it provides for releasing benefits of revised commuted value at the unfettered, and unbridled mercy-discretion of the Authorities is unreasonable, illegal,
arbitrary
and
is
quashed
and
set-aside. DEPRIVATION OF REVISED LEAVE ENCASHMENT DEHORS STATUTORY RULES IMPERMISSIBLE:
17.
Eighth
contention
of
Learned
Counsel
is
that though the State Authorities have granted benefit of
revised
pay
to
petitioner
by
issuing
HPCS
Revised Pay Rules 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] w.e.f. 01.01.2016
and
on
revision
of
pay
retrospectively,
petitioner was entitled for the benefit of Revised Leave Encashment on superannuation on 31.01.2021 [in the Lead Case and likewise to others from date of their respective retirements}, then, action of the Authorities in withholding or delaying the release of the entire arrears of Leave Encashment is illegal. 17(i).
For the purpose of appreciating the claim
for Leave Encashment, it is necessary to have a recap of Rule 39 of the CCS (Leave) Rules 1972, as applicable to employees-retirees of State Government and from service of Boards and Corporations, reads as under: Rule 39 of CCS [Leave] Rules:39.
Leave/Cash payment in lieu of leave beyond the date of retirement compulsory retirement or quitting of service:
(1)
No leave shall be granted Government servant beyond-
(a)
the date of his retirement, or
(b)
the date of his final cessation of duties, or
(c)
the date on which he retires by giving notice to Government or he is retired by Government by giving him notice or pay and allowances in lieu of such notice, in accordance with the terms and conditions of his service, or
(d)
the date service.
(2)(a) Where
of a
his
resignation
Government
to
a
from
servant
retires on attaining the normal age
prescribed for retirement under the terms and conditions governing his service, the authority competent to grant leave shall, suo motu, issue an order granting cash equivalent of
leave
salary
for
both
earned
leave and half pay leave, if any, at
credit
of
Government
servant on the date of his retirement subject to a maximum of 300 days; (b)
The cash equivalent of leave salary under Clause (a) shall be calculated as
follows
in
one
shall
and
lumpsum
as
be
payable
a
one-time
settlement:(i)
Cash equivalent for earned leave
= (ii)
Cash payment in lieu of half pay leave component =
Pay admissible on the date of retirement plus Dearness Allowance admissible on that date Half pay leave salary admissible on date of retirement plus Dearness Allowance admissible on that date
Number of days of unutilized earned leave at credit subject to the total of earned leave and half pay leave not exceeding 300 days x Number of days of half pay leave at credit subject to the total of earned leave and half pay leave at credit not exceeding 300 days x
NOTE: The overall limit for encashment of leave including both earned leave and half
pay
leave
shall
not
exceed
days. (c)
To make up the shortfall in earned leave, no commutation of half pay leave shall be permissible.]
(3)
The authority
competent
to
grant
leave may withhold whole or part of cash equivalent of earned leave in the case of a Government servant who retires from service on attaining the age of retirement while under suspension or while disciplinary or criminal proceedings are pending against him, if in the view of such authority there is a possibility of some
money
from
him
becoming
on
recoverable
conclusion
of
proceedings against him on conclusion of the proceedings, he will become eligible to the amount so withheld after adjustment of Government dues, if any. (4)(a) …not relevant… (5-A)
deleted.
(6)(a)(i) ….not relevant… 39-A.
Cash equivalent of leave salary in case of death in service In case a Government servant dies while in service, the cash equivalent of leave salary for both earned leave and half pay leave, if any, at the credit of the deceased Government servant on the date of his death, not exceeding 300 days shall be paid to his family in the manner specified in Rule 39-C and the cash equivalent payable shall be the same as in sub-rule (2) of Rule 39.
NOTE:
In
addition
to
cash
equivalent of leave salary admissible under this rule, the family of the deceased Government servant shall also
be
entitled
to
payment
of
Dearness Allowance only as per orders issued in this behalf separately. 39-B.
Cash equivalent of leave salary in case of invalidation from service
(1)
….not relevant…
39-C. ….not relevant… 39-D.
Cash
equivalent
leave
of
salary
in
case of permanent absorption
in
Public
Sector
Undertaking
/
wholly
or
Body
Autonomous
substantially owned or controlled by the Central /State Government A Government servant who has been permitted to be absorbed in a service or post in or under a Corporation or Company wholly or substantially owned or controlled by the Central Government or State Government or in or under a body controlled or financed by one or more than one such Government shall be granted suo
motu
competent
by to
grant
authority leave
cash
equivalent of leave salary in respect of earned
leave
at his credit on
the date of absorption subject to a maximum
of
days.
This
will
be calculated in the same manner
as indicated in Clause (b) of subrule (2) of Rule 39. NOTE:
The
expression
'permanent
absorption' used in Rule 39-D shall mean
appointment
of
a
Government servant in a Public Sector Undertaking or an Autonomous Body, for which he had applied through proper
channel
and
resigns
from
the Government service to take up that appointment. MANDATE OF LAW RECOGNISING RIGHT FOR LEAVE ENCASHMENT AS PROPRTY AND LEGAL ENTITLEMENT:
17(ii).
While
dealing
with
claim
for
Leave
Encashment {though in case of reemployed employee} the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Sikkim and others vs Dr. Mool Raj Kotwal, (2025) 10 SCC 584, has accorded legal recognition to Leave Encashment, accruing on retirement, under the Service Rules to be a property and a legal entitlement in
following terms: “27.
In
said
sequel,
philosophy
and purpose of granting encashment of unutilized
earned
leave
also
warrants
attention. Leave encashment is a legal entitlement that exists within the framework of service law and in the welfare of the employee. It allows employees to receive a
monetary
benefit
in
exchange
for
leave they have earned
but not
taken
during regular employment. This right is based
on
principle
of
deferred
compensation to an employee who has not taken leaves and served, for which the employer must compensate not only for his/her work, but also for benefits of leave accumulated over time limited to 300 days maximum. This entitlement is often established in statutory provisions, service rules (such as Rule 36 of the Leave Rules) or employment contracts, ensuring that employees are fairly compensated for their unutilized leave. 28.
A three-judges Bench of this Court in ‘State of Rajasthan and Another v. Senior Higher
Secondary
School,
although in
context of Section 29 of Rajasthan NonGovernment Education Institutions Act 1989
interpreted Leave Encashment as “nothing but salary for the un-availed leave to the credit of the employee”. Nonetheless, something more is required to understand the full import behind grant of Leave Encashment, which is the benefit after retirement
to
Jurisprudentially,
a
devoted
leave
employee.
encashment
is
grounded in two key principles: equity and economic security. The principle of equity ensures that employees who forgo their right to take leave for the benefit of
organization
of
its monetary
value.
are The
not
deprived
principle
of
economic security treats leave encashment
as a form of deferred wages, similar to gratuity or pension benefits. This reinforces
employer’s
duty
to
maintain
fair
labour practices and protects employees’ financial rights. 29.
Interpreting leave encashment provisions goes beyond financial compensation and connects to broader legal principles of dignity
and
welfare
during
service.
However, such interpretations must carefully balance the interests of both employees and
organization,
financial
stability
especially
when
of
public
exchequer is involved. Courts must tread carefully to prevent employees from claiming leave encashment multiple times for the same accrual, which could lead to unjust enrichment and may go against the public interest of largesse.”
17(iii).
Considering the mandate of Rule 39 of the
CCS [Leave] Rules, 1972, an employee on retirement is entitled for encashment of unutilized earned leave and half pay leave upto a maximum of 300 days in her leave account. Leave encashment is a deferred compensation to an employee for who has not taken earned
leave
during
service
and
who
had
forgone
their right to take leave for the benefit of organization and
such
persons
are
not
to
be
deprived
of
its
monetary value. An employer is bound to compensate
such an employee, by granting salary or encashment for leaves in credit, subject to a maximum of 300 days of accumulated earned leaves in terms of the CCS (Leave) Rules, 1972 or similar Rules Service. Leave Encashment is based on the principle of equity and economic security. It is an economic security, in the form of deferred wages, similar to Gratuity or other pensionary benefits. Even if an employes stood retired from service and was granted the salary-encashment for
unutilized
earned/half
pay
leaves
in
credit but
after the revision of pay scales retrospectively, the pay
of
such
an
employee-retiree
is
enhanced
from
date of retirement and the revised pay turns out to be the pay admissible on the date of retirement; therefore, of
such
retirement
admissible
has
to
form
pay
due
on
date
basis
for
releasing
the salary-leave encashment to an employee, so as to and
enforce
mandate
of
Rule
of
Rules
to attain the object of equity, economic security
and to compensate an employee for having not taken /availed leave during regular service, and to attain objective of Statutory Rule and the legal recognition
accorded to such legal entitlement by Three Judges Bench of Honble Supreme Court in case of State of Rajasthan and Another vs Senior Higher Secondary School, (2005) 10 SCC 346 and reiterated in the case of Dr. Mool Raj Kotwal (supra). 17(iv).
In terms
of Rule 39 (2) (b) of the CCS
(Leave) Rules 1972, the salary for unutilized earned leave based on “admissible pay” [with reference to the unrevised pay or revised pay] of a government servant on retirement, in lump-sum as a one-time settlement then,
State
Authorities
have
no
authority
in
law, either to defer or stagger its release by abusing its discretion or releasing this benefit in a piece-meal manner dehors the mandate of the aforesaid Statutory Rule. Discretion cannot be permitted to be exercised by State Authorities, on an issue or subject already occupied by the Statutory Rule, so as to make the beneficiaries to await their rightful legal entitlement(s) of Leave Encashment, indefinitely for about 4½ years now. Uncertainty in action or in extending rightful entitlements benefits is grossly unreasonable and highly arbitrary and is oppressive. Any administrative order
or instruction, if any, issued by the State Authorities which negates or takes away or deprives or tends to deprive an employee-retiree of the legal entitlement of Salary-Leave Encashment “on admissible pay due on retirement” under Rule 39 of the Statutory Rules cannot be permitted to operate hereinafter. 17(v).
Even Rule 39 (3) of the CCS (Leave) Rules
as extracted above spells out that the State Authorities have
been
empowered
to
“withhold”
either
whole
or any part of cash equivalent of earned leave in case of Government servant who retires from service on attaining age of retirement while under suspension or while disciplinary or criminal proceedings are pending against him, if in the view of such authority there is a possibility of some money becoming recoverable from him on conclusion of the proceedings against him on conclusion of the proceedings, he will become eligible to the amount so withheld after adjustment of Government dues, if any. In the absence of any such permitted eventualities, as detailed in Rule 39 (3) above, the Authorities had no authority in law to “withhold or defer or delay or release this benefit
in a staggered or piece meal manner, by acting contrary to the Statutory Rules, which recognizes its lump-sum payability. Consequently, the action of State Authorities is oppressive and contrary to the Statutory Rules i.e. CCS (Leave) Rules 1972 and therefore, Authorities are mandated to release the entire lump-sum arrears of Leave Encashment [Unrevised and Revised] accruing on retirement [on 31.01.2021 w.e.f. 01.02.2021 in Lead case and from respective date of retirement of other employees-retirees], alongwith interest in terms of this judgement. DEPRIVATION OR DELAY OF RETIRAL BENEFITS VIOLATIVE OF ARTICLE 300-A OF CONSTITUTION OF INDIAN:
18.
Ninth contention of Learned Counsel is that
deprivation of retiral benefits, which constitutes the property and the legal entitlement of the petitioner and other similar incumbents has force. Action of Authorities in withholding, delaying, deferring or staggering the release of retiral benefits, including Revised Pension, Revised Gratuity, Revised Leave
Encashment,
Revised
Commuted
Pension
and
Revised Family Pension [wherever applicable], amounts
to
defeating
Government
Servants-Retirees
their
property under Article 300-A of the Constitution of India and such action of the Authorities is punitive and
unsustainable, in view of the mandate of the
Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Dr. Hira Lal vs State of Bihar and others, (2020) 4 SCC 346, in the following terms:“24. The
right
to
receive
pension
has
been held to be a right to property protected
under Article
300A
of
Constitution even after the repeal of Article 31(1) by the Constitution (FortyFourth
Amendment)
Act,
1978 w.e.f.
20.06.1979, as held in State of West Bengal v. Haresh C. Banerjee and Ors.” INTER-SE DISCRIMINATION IN EXTENDING REVISED RETIRAL BENEFITS UNSUSTAINABLE:
19.
Tenth
Contention
of
Learned
Counsel
is
that the State Authorities have adopted a pick and choose criteria in releasing the benefits of arrears of revised pay and also arrears of revised retiral benefits amongst one Homogeneous Class of employees-retirees is discriminatory and unconstitutional. 19(i).
For
appreciating
this
contention,
material
on record indicates that after the issuance of HPCS Revised
Pay
Rules
on
03.01.2022
w.e.f. 01.01.2016
[Annexure P-3], the State Authorities released part of arrears of revised pay on 17.09.2022 [Annexure P-5/R-1] in a staggered manner by releasing an instalment of Rs 50000 to Rs 60000/-. 19(ii).
Likewise, after issuance of Office Memorandum
dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4], the State Authorities issued
various
other
Office
Memorandum
Office on
Memorandums
17.09.2022
i.e.
[Annexure
an P-6],
then on 13.03.2024 [Annexure P-7]; then on 19.10.2024 [Annexure
P-2], then on 27.01.2026 [Annexure R-1/III,
at page 267 of the paper book]; then on 27.01.2026 [Annexure R-1/IV, at page 271 of the paper book] and on 25.04.2026 [Annexure R-1/II (colly), at page 276 of the paper book], releasing 100% of Revised Retiral Benefits to those retirees, who have crossed the age of 70 years and above, whereas, the petitioner in Lead Case and similar others who are below the age of 70 years were discriminated. 19(iii).
Even
in
case
of
Class-IV
Employees
who
stood retired between 01.01.2016 to 31.01.2022, the have been released majority of retiral benefits.
19(iv).
State Authorities have admitted in Para 8
of Reply-Affidavit dated 17.06.2025 [at Page 78 of the paper book} that all the petitioners, including other similarly situated employees, retired between the period 01.01.2016 form one homogenous class. MANDATE OF LAW-NEGATING PRACTICE OF PICK AND CHOOSE IN RELEASING BENEFITS AMONGST ONE HOMOGENOUS CLASS OF RETIREES:
19(v).
In above backdrop, the action of the State
Authorities in extending the Revised Retiral Benefits by adopting a pick and choose criteria amongst one Homogeneous Class of retirees, amounts to treating “equals as unequals” and this action is violative of Article 14
of the
Constitution of India
in view of
broader principles outlined by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of All Manipur Pensioners Association by its Secretary versus The State of Manipur and others, (2020) 10 SCC 625, in following terms:“8.
Even otherwise on merits also, we are of the firm opinion that there is no valid justification to create two classes, viz., one who retired pre 1996 and another who retired post 1996, for the purpose of grant of revised pension, In our view, such a classification has no nexus with the object and purpose of grant of benefit of revised pension. All the pensioners
a one
form
class
who
are
entitled
to pension as per the pension rules. Article
14 of
Constitution
of
India
ensures to all equality before law and equal protection of laws. At this juncture it is also necessary to examine the concept of valid classification. A valid classification is truly a valid discrimination. It is true that Article
16 of
Constitution
of
India permits a valid classification. However, a very classification must be based on a just objective. The result to be achieved by
just
objective
presupposes
choice of some for differential consideration /treatment over others. A classification to be
valid
must
necessarily
satisfy
two
tests. Firstly, the distinguishing rationale has to be based on a just objective and secondly, the choice of differentiating one set of persons from another, must have a reasonable nexus to the objective sought to
be
achieved.
The
test
for
a
valid
classification may be summarized as a distinction based on a classification founded on an intelligible differentia, which has a
rational
relationship
with
object
sought to be achieved. Therefore, whenever a
cut-off
date
(as
controversy)
is
fixed
one
pensioners
set
of
consideration test
for
over
valid
in
present
to
categorize
for
favorable
others,
twin
classification
or
valid
discrimination therefore
must
necessarily
be
present
case,
satisfied.
In
classification in question has no reasonable
to the
nexus
objective
sought
to
be
achieved while revising the pension. As observed
hereinabove,
object
and
purpose for revising the pension is due to the increase in the cost of living. All the pensioners form a single class and therefore such a classification for the purpose of grant of revised pension is unreasonable, arbitrary, discriminatory and
violative
of Article
of
Constitution of India. The State cannot arbitrarily pick and choose from amongst similarly situated persons, a cutoff date for
extension
of
benefits
especially
pensionary benefits. There has to be a classification
founded
on
some
rational
principle when similarly situated class is differentiated for grant of any benefit. 8.1
As
observed
hereinabove,
and
even
it
is not in dispute that as such a decision has been taken by the State Government to revise the pension keeping in mind the increase in the cost of living. Increase in
cost
of
pensioners
living
would
irrespective
of
affect
all
whether
they have retired pre 1996 or post 1996. As observed hereinabove, all the pensioners belong to one class. Therefore, by such a classification/cut-off date the equals are treated as unequals and therefore such a classification which has no nexus with the object and purpose of revision of pension is unreasonable, discriminatory and
arbitrary
and
therefore
said
classification was rightly set aside by the learned Single Judge of the High Court. At
this
stage,
it
is
required
to
be
observed that whenever a new benefit is granted and/or new scheme is introduced, it
might
provide
be
possible
a
cut-off
for
date
State
taking
to into
consideration its financial resources. But the same shall not be applicable with respect
to
one
and
single
class
of
persons, the benefit to be given to the one class of persons, who are already getting the benefits and the
otherwise
question is with respect to revision.”
Considering
factual
matrix
and
mandate of law in case of All Manipur Pensioners Association [supra], the action of the State Authorities in carving out an artificial distinction between one homogeneous
class
of
retirees
who
retired
between
the period from 01.01.2026 to 31.01.2022 for purposes of releasing retiral benefits of Revised Pension, Revised Gratuity,
Revised
Commuted
Pension,
Revised
Leave
Encashment and Revised Family Pension etc., [wherever applicable], does not satisfy the “twin tests” required for a valid classification. Action of the Authorities in
giving
preferential
treatment
to
some
categories
based on age or category {Group C or D or Class III
or
IV]
is
not
based
on
a
valid
classification
and
such differential has no nexus which is sought to be achieved, as the object of giving the “revised retiral benefits is common to all categories of retirees” ; and the criteria and practice adopted by the Authorities amounts to treating “equals and unequal”. In these circumstances, the disparity carved out by Authorities while releasing the retiral benefits by applying pick and choose criteria is violative of HPCS Revised Pay Rules dated 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] and the Office Memorandum dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4] giving revised
retiral
benefits
contrary
to
and
dehors
Statutory Rules occupying the field i.e. the Central Civil Services (Pension) Rules 1972 and Central Civil Services
(Commutation
of
Pension)
Rules
1981
and
the Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules 1972 [except for
offending
provision
of
Rule
of
Revised
Pay Rules dated 03.01.2022, Annexure P-3 and Paras 8.2 and Para 10 of OM dated 25.02.2022, Annexure P-4, which
have
been
interdicted
by
this
Court]
and
the action of the State Authorities is unreasonable
arbitrary and violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India. CLAIM FOR INTEREST ON DELAYED ENTITLEMENTS-MONETARY BENEFITS:
LEGAL
20.
Last Contention is that in terms of HPCS
Revised
Pay
Rules
03.01.2022
[Annexure
P-3]
and
the Statutory Rules i.e. the CCS (Pension) Rules 1972 and CCS (Commutation of Pension) Rules 1981 and CCS (Leave) Rules 1972 and Office Memorandum issued on 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4] giving revised retiral benefits, once the State Authorities have withheld or deferred and in not released entire arrears of revised pay and retiral benefits for about 4½ years now, therefore, the petitioner in Lead Case and others connected cases are entitled for interest on delayed payments. MANDATE OF LAW ON INTESET ON DELAYED RELEASE OF REVISED PAY AND REVISED RETIRAL BENEFITS:
20(i).
While interdicting the inaction of releasing
retiral dues promptly, the entitlement of interest on delayed release of benefits was approved by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Kerala and others vs M. Padmanabhan Nair, (1985) 1 SCC 429, in following terms:
“2.
Usually the delay occurs by reason of non-production
of
certificate)
and
L.P.C.
N.L.C.
(last
(no
pay
liability
certificate) from the concerned Departments but
both
these
documents
pertain
to
matters, records whereof would be with the concerned Government Departments. Since
date
of
retirement
of
every
Government servant is very much known in
advance
we
fail
to
appreciate
process
of
collecting
information
and
issuance
of
these
documents
should
be
completed
not
why
requisite two
atleast a week before the date of retirement so that the payment of gratuity amount could
be
made
to
Government
servant on the date he retires or on the following day and pension at the expiry
of
necessity
for
following
prompt
month.
payment
of
The
retirement dues to a Government servant immediately after his retirement cannot be
over-emphasised
and
it
would
not
be unreasonable to direct that the liability to pay penal interest on these dues at
current
market
rate
should
commence at the expiry of two months from the date of retirement.”
20(ii).
While
dealing
with
similar eventuality, the
admissibility of interest at the rate of 18% per annum on
retiral
benefits,
which
were
withheld
by
about
two years was approved by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in case of Vijay L. Mehrotra vs State of U.P. and others, (2001) 9 SCC 687, in following terms: “2.
The
appellant
31st
August,
retired 1997.
from
From
service
on
response
filed by the respondent, it is clear that most of the payments of the retiral benefits to her were made long after she retired on 31st August, 1997…. 4.
In
this
reason
case, or
there
is
justification
absolutely
for
not
no
making
the payments for months together. We, therefore, direct the respondent to pay to the appellant within 12 weeks from today simple interest at the rate of 18 per
cent with
effect
from
date
of
her retirement, i.e., 31st August, 1997 till the date of payments.”
20(iii). in
Upholding
settlement
and
right
to
disbursement
interest of
on
retiral
delay
benefits,
which were held not to be a “bounty”, Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of D.D. Tewari (Dead) Through Legal Representatives
vs
Uttar
Haryana
Bijli
Vitran
Nigam Limited and others, (2014) 8 SCC 894, has awarded interest at the rate of 9% on delayed Pension and Gratuity from the date of entitlement till payment, in following terms:“8.
For
reasons
stated
above,
we
award interest at the rate of 9% on
the delayed payment of pension and gratuity
amount
from
date
of
entitlement till the date of the actual payment.
If
this
amount
is
not
paid
within six weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this order, the same shall carry interest at the rate of 18% per annum from the date the amount falls due to the deceased employee…”
20(iv).
While dealing with the claim for interest on
entitlement to salaries and pensions. which are legal entitlement and was not a charity, the interest on delayed release of benefits was awarded by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of State of Andhra Pradesh and another vs Dinavahi Lakshmi Kameswari, (2021) 11 SCC 543, in following terms: “13.
The direction for the payment of the deferred portions of the salaries and pensions
is
unexceptionable.
Salaries
are due to the employees of the State for services rendered. Salaries in other words constitute the rightful entitlement of the employees and are payable in accordance with law. Likewise, it is well settled that the payment of pension is for years of
past
service
rendered
by
pensioners to the State. Pensions are hence a matter of a rightful entitlement recognised by the applicable rules and regulations which govern the service of
the employees of the State. The State Government
has
complied
with
directions of this Court for the payment of the outstanding dues in two tranches. Insofar as the interest is concerned, we are of the view that the rate of 12% per annum which has been fixed by the High
Court
down.
While
should
be
learned
suitably counsel
scaled for
respondents submits that the award of interest
was on
account of the action
of the Government which was contrary to
law,
we
are
of
view
that
payment of interest cannot be used as a means to penalize the State Government. There can be no gainsaying the fact that
Government
which
has
delayed
the payment of salaries and pensions should be directed to pay interest at an appropriate rate. 14.
We accordingly order and direct that in substitution of the interest rate of 12% per annum which has been awarded by
High
Court,
Government of
Andhra Pradesh shall pay simple interest computed at the rate of 6% per annum on account of deferred salaries and pensions within a period of thirty days from today….”
20(v).
Right
of
an
employee
and
a
retiree
for
interest on the delayed release of retiral benefits has been outlined by the Honble Supreme Court in case of
Dr. A. Selvaraj vs C.B.M. College and others, (2022) 4 SCC 627, in following terms:“10.
Having
heard
learned
counsel
for
respective parties, we are of the opinion that as there was a delay in making the payment of retirement benefits and settling the dues for which the appellant employee is not at all responsible, he is
entitled
delayed
to
payment.
interest Even
on
Division
Bench of the High Court has also observed in that
impugned
judgment
appellant
is
and
entitled
order to
interest on the delayed payment. However, there is an inter se dispute between the Secretary, Management and the Government as to who is responsible for the delay in making the payment to the appellant and therefore, he has been denied the interest
on
delayed
payment
though
entitled to. 12.
In that view of the matter, subject to
further
final
order
that
may
be
passed by the Government, the College /Management is first liable to pay the interest
on
retirement decision,
delayed
payment
dues
subject
to
which
may
be
taken
by
of
final
Government, after hearing the Management and
former
Secretary.
However,
because of the inter se dispute between
Management,
Government
on
Secretary
who
is
and
responsible
for
the delay in making the payment and /or settling the dues, the retired employee should not be made to suffer for no fault of his.”
20(vi).
Similar reiteration of law has been approved
for interest on delayed release of retiral benefits at the rate of 6% per annum, by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in case of Ashok Kumar Dabas (Dead through Legal
Heirs)
versus
Delhi
Transport
Corporation,
2025 SCC OnLine SC 2744, in following terms: “12.
For
reasons
mentioned
above,
present appeal is partly allowed to the extent that the legal heirs of deceased employee are held entitled to receive gratuity in terms of provisions of the 1972 Act. They are also held entitled to
receive
amount
towards
his
leave
encashment. As far as grant of family pension is concerned, the claim being not admissible as per 1972 Rules, no relief on that account can be granted to the legal
heirs
of
deceased
employee.
The
amount due to the deceased employee be paid within a period of six weeks along with interest @ 6% p.a. from the date of his resignation till payment.”
20(vii).
Reiterating the right for interest at the rate
of 6% per annum on the delayed release of retiral benefits, like Pension and Gratuity, which were held
back,
despite
having
earned
by
an
employee
for
unblemished service, the Hon’ble Supreme Court has outlined in case of Panchayat & Rural Development Department and ors vs Santosh Kumar Shrivastava, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 2042, in following terms: “5.
Having withdrawn his earlier Writ Petition in view of intervening developments, the writ
petition
which
gave
rise
to
present proceedings came to be filed. The learned
Single
Judge
allowed
writ
petition observing that the entire amount of pension and gratuity could not have been withheld on account of there being an order for recovery. It was held that since
amounts
him
forthwith
on
were his
not
paid
to
retirement,
appellants could not have charged him for illegal occupation of his government residential a
view
premises.
was
drawn
Support from
for
HK
such
Saxena
(Dr.) v. Dr. Harisingh Gour Vishwavidyalaya and
Anr.
The
recovery
of
the amount
was thus held illegal, and the appellants were also directed to pay 6% interest on the total amount to be refunded to the respondent as also 6% interest on the amount of pension and gratuity paid to him from the date of superannuation till payment. The same was directed to be done within a period of three months. 11.
In
essence,
what
Appellants
did
before the High Court was to blame the
Respondent for the delay in him receiving benefits rightly owed to him. We cannot accept this position. Pension and other retiral dues are benefits that have been earned
by
service
rendered
paying
benefits.
an
employee
to
institution
pension/other
retirement
The
to
due
grant
of
a
residence
corresponds to the position held at the time by such employee. The width of these two
aspects
Pension
and
is
separate
retirement
and
distinct.
benefits
accrue
from a much wider base as the culmination of all efforts, across employment whereas the latter is only for a limited time, till such a person is holding that position. The latter cannot obstruct or defeat the former. The Appellant cannot be allowed to withhold a duly accrued right on this count. 12.
Since the delay is entirely on part of the Appellant, and no reasonable explanation acceptable to law is forthcoming except for the attempt to hold back pensionary benefits as a sword on the Respondent’s head for not having vacated his government allotted accommodation, in the facts of this case we see no error in the order of
learned
single
Judge
awarding
interest to the Respondent.”
20(viii).
Recently, entire law on interest on delayed
payment
of
salary
and
monetary
legal
entitlements
has been recapitulated by the Hon’ble Supreme Court
in the case of Bihar State Ardh Sarkari Arajpati Karamchari Maha Sangh and others vs State of Bihar and others decided on 28.099.2026, (supra), in following terms:“49. Insofar as the salary arrears and other monetary dues, excluding provident fund dues, are concerned, the position stands on a somewhat different footing. Unlike the interest contemplated under Section 7-Q of the Act, there is no uniform statutory provision prescribing a particular rate of interest in respect of the salary and other
dues
involved
in
present
proceedings. The entitlement to interest in such cases is, therefore, required to be examined having regard to the nature of
dues,
period
for
which
they remained unpaid, the circumstances occasioning the delay and the extent of prejudice caused to the employees/ workmen by such withholding. 51.
Interest,
in
its
ordinary
legal
sense,
represents
compensation
for
deprivation
of
money
to
use
of
which a person is otherwise
lawfully
entitled. The concept of interest is not confined to a return upon money borrowed or advanced, but extends to compensation for the unjust deprivation occasioned by the withholding of money beyond
time
when
it
becomes
due
and
payable. It is, in substance, recompense
for the loss occasioned by being kept out of the use of money which ought to have been available to the person entitled
thereto. A Constitution Bench
of this Court, in Central Bank of India v.
Ravindra
&
Ors.,
while
examining
the concept and nature of interest, referred to the meaning attributed to the expression “interest” in various legal authorities and precedents, and observed as follows: Black’s Law Dictionary (7th Edn.)
“37.
defines
“interest”
compensation
inter
fixed
alia
by
as
agreement
or
allowed by law for the use or detention of money, or for the loss of money by
one
who
is
entitled
to
its
use;
especially, the amount owed to a lender in return for the use of the borrowed money.
According
to
Stroud’s
Judicial
Dictionary of Words And Phrases (5th Edn.) interest means, inter alia, compensation paid
by
borrower
to
lender
for deprivation of the use of his money, In Secy.,
Irrigation
Deptt.,
Govt.
of
Orissa v. G.C. Roy [(1992) 1 SCC 508] the Constitution Bench opined that a person deprived of the use of money to
which
he
is
legitimately
has
a
right
to
be
entitled
compensated
for
the deprivation, call it by any name. It may be called interest, compensation or
damages.
of Section
This
34 of
is
principle
Civil
Procedure
Code. In Sham Lal Narula (Dr) v. CIT
[AIR 1964 SC 1878: (1964) 7 SCR 668] this Court held that interest is paid for the deprivation of the use of the money. The essence of interest in the opinion
of
Lord
Wright,
in
Riches
v.
Westminster Bank Ltd. [(1947) 1 All ER 469: 1947 AC 390 (HL)] All ER at p. 472 is that it is a payment which becomes due because the creditor has not had his money at the due date. It may be regarded either as representing the profit he might have made if he had had the use
of
money,
or,
conversely,
loss he suffered because he had not that use. The general idea is that he is entitled to compensation for the deprivation; the money due to the creditor was not paid, or, in other words, was withheld from him by the debtor after the time when payment
should
have
been
made,
in
breach of his legal rights, and interest was
a
compensation
compensation
was
whether
liquidated
under
an
agreement or statute. A Division Bench of the High Court of Punjab speaking through Tek Chand, J. in CIT v. Dr Sham Lal Narula [AIR 1963
Punj 411: (1963)
50 ITR 513] thus articulated the concept of interest: (AIR p. 414, para 8)” (Emphasis supplied) 59.
In light of the aforesaid discussion, we deem
it
appropriate
to
summarise
directions issued hereinabove as follows:(a) to (d) ….xxx…
(b)
e.
The States of Bihar and Jharkhand shall ensure payment of simple interest at the rate of 12% per annum on the delayed EPF dues, and at the rate of 6% per annum on
delayed
salary, wages
and other monetary entitlements, for the period commencing from the date on
which
respective
amounts
became due and payable until the date of their actual payment.”
20(ix).
Besides the above, Authorities have regulated
the retiral benefits of Pension and Gratuity in case of State Government Employees, including employees of Boards and Corporations [subject to adoption] by CCS (Pension) Rules 1972. In terms of these Rules, expression “pension includes gratuity” and both are recognized as “Retirement benefits” of an employee. Rule
of
CCS
(Pension)
Rules
1972
provides
for
admissibility of interest on delayed release of retiral benefits,
inaccordance
with
instructions
issued
from
time to time, reads as under: Rule 68 of CCS [Pension] Rules:Interest on delayed payment of gratuity: (1).
If the payment of gratuity has been
authorized
later
than
date
when
its payment becomes due, and it is clearly established that the delay in payment
was attributable to administrative lapses, interest shall be paid at such rate as may
be
with the
prescribed
and
in
accordance
instructions issued from time
to time: Provided that the delay in payment was not caused on account of failure on the part
of
Government
servant
to
comply with the procedure laid down by the Government
for
processing
his
pension
papers.”
20(x).
Considering
mandate
of
Statutory
Rule i.e. Rule 68 of the CCS (Pension) Rules 1972, and the instructions issued by the State Authorities, prescribe the admissibility of interest on the delayed payment of Gratuity, as in payable on GPF, which is 7.1% per annum and in view of broad principles outlined by the Honble Supreme Court on admissibility of interest on delayed release of salary or retirement benefits, in the cases of M Padmanabhan Nair, Vijay L
Mehrotra,
Dinavahi
Lakshmi
Kameswari,
Dr.
A. Selvaraj, Ashok Kumar Dabas, Santosh Kumar Shrivastava and Bihar State Ardh Sarkari Arajpati Karamchari Maha Sangh (supra), this Court is of the considered view that, firstly, the delay in payment of Pension and Gratuity is attributable to the State
Authorities due to invocation of offending provisions i.e. Rule 13 in the Revised Pay Rules dated 03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] and Para 10 of the Office Memorandum dated
[Annexure
25.02.2022
P-4];
and
secondly,
delay is not at all attributable to employees-retirees; and thirdly, once the employees-retirees have been held entitled for the revised pay arrears and revised retiral benefits on
after
issuance
of
Revised
Pay
Rules
03.01.2022 and by issuing an OM on 25.02.2022
under the CCS (Pension) 1972 and CCS (Commutation of Pension) Rules 1981 holding the employees-retirees, alike the petitioner(s) for “revised pay benefits from 01.01.2016
and
revised
retiral
benefits
from
date
of respective retirements w.e.f 01.01.2016 or thereafter till 31.12.2021 and State Authorities have “conferred legal
entitlement
benefits
by
on
prescribing
employees-retirees
cut-off
date
for
w.e.f.
01.01.2016” then, accrued/crystallized valuable rights and benefits being “legal entitlements can neither be withheld
nor
restricted
or
delayed
indefinitely
or
be released in a piecemeal and stagged manner due to the
unbridled, unfettered, unguided discretion
of
the State Authorities and that too by adopting pick and
choose
criteria
amongst one
homogenous
class
of retirees”; and fourthly, once State Authorities have prescribed the cut-off date for admissibility of legal entitlement w.e.f.
i.e.
benefits
01.01.2016
and
of
arrears
benefit
of
of
revised
arrears
of
pay
revised
retiral benefits from the date of respective retirement between
01.01.2016
Authorities cut-off
date
artificial
cannot
till be
originally
cut-off
date
31.12.2021
then,
permitted to tinker prescribed, in
by
years
State
with
prescribing
an
2022
to
2026
on the plea of financial constraints, which was to taken
into
account
at
time
of
notifying
Rules and the OM and not subsequently; and lastly, once the “payability of these benefits had accrued /crystallized w.e.f. 01.06.2022” then, the petitioner in Lead
Case
and
others
connected
cases
and
also
those retirees, who had taken legal recourse, by filing petitions, which are pending or had been decided, as on the date of this judgement, are held entitled for interest on delayed payment(s) of entire revised pay arrears
and
entire
retiral benefits
w.e.f.
01.06.2022
[i.e. date of payability of said benefits, as carved out by this Court after taking into account the gestation period of three month i.e. one month’s of option period and the time required for completion of codal formalities after issuance of the Rules/Office Memorandum as referred to above]. Consequently, the incumbents, as spelt out above, are
held
entitled
for simple
interest at the
rate of 6% per annum on arrears of pay as well as arrears
of
Revised
Retiral Benefits
from
01.06.2022
till its actual release in lump-sum, in terms of this judgment. ANALYSIS OF CONTENTIONS ADVOCATE GENERAL:
21.
BY
LEARNED
First Contention of Learned Advocate General
is that due to financial constraints, and discontinuance of Revenue Deficit Grant by the Central Government, the State Authorities was forced to release the benefits by applying the provision of Rule 13 of the Revised Pay
Rules
and
Para
of
OM
granting
Revised Retiral benefits in terms of the Statutory Rules. The above contention cannot sustain, for the reasons detailed hereinabove.
FINANCIAL CONSTRAINTS AND BURDEN NOT A GROUND TO DENY THE LEGITIMATE DUESMONETARY ENTITLEMENTS:
21(i). State
Factual matrix, indisputably, establishes that Authorities
issued
Revised
Pay
Rules
on
03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] by giving effect to these Rules w.e.f. 01.01.2016. Likewise, the State Authorities also issued an Office Memorandum dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4] under the Statutory Rules giving revised retiral
benefits
for
persons
who
retire
between
01.01.2016 to 31.12.2021 under CCS (Pension) Rules 1972 and CCS (Commutation of Pension) Rules 1981. Reply-Affidavit filed by the State Authorities does not dispute the entitlements of Government Servants for Revised Pay Arrears and retirees for Revised Retiral Benefits.
Stand
in
Reply-Affidavit
that
due
to
financial burden or constraints, Rule 13 of Revised Pay
Rules
dated
03.01.2022
and
Para
8.2
and
Para 10 of the OM dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4] was incorporated and invoked by State Authorities. 21(ii).
Plea of financial burden cannot be invoked
so as to defeat the legitimate dues or monetary benefits to the petitioner in Lead Case and other petitioners in connected cases, in view of the mandate of the Hon’ble
Supreme Court in the case of State of Rajasthan and others vs Mahendra Nath Sharma, (2015) 9 SCC 540, in following terms: “30
It is urged before us that it will put a heavy financial burden on the State. The said submission has been seriously resisted by the learned counsel for the respondents by
urging
that
hardly
200-250
retired
lecturers in the selection scale are alive in praesenti and the State cannot take a plea of financial burden to deny the legitimate dues of the respondents.”
21(iii).
Similar plea of financial burden was negated
mandating that the
legitimate monetary entitlements
flowing from Statutory Rules, constitute the property under Article 300-A of the Constitution of India and such valuable right cannot be defeated or negate by raising the plea of financial burden, by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Bhikhani Devi and etc. vs Union of India and Others, 2026 SCC OnLine SC 1055, in the following terms:“74.
The
argument
founded
upon
financial
burden is equally untenable. Pension is not a matter of grace dependent upon the financial convenience of the employer, but
a
deferred
wage
earned
through
long years of service. As already noticed hereinabove,
this
Court
has
recognized
pension as a constitutional right in the nature of property protected under Article 300A of
Constitution
of
India
as
held in Jitendra Kumar Srivastava Case (supra) and it, therefore, cannot be denied on the plea of financial burden.”
21(iv).
Considering the fact-situation of instant cases
and the principles outlined by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Mahendra Nath Sharma and Bhikhani Devi [supra], the plea of financial stringency, cannot sustain, for the reason, that once the State Authorities have taken a conscious decision, leading to issuance of Revised Pay Rules on 03.01.2022 and Office Memorandum dated 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4] by giving retrospective effect to the Rules and Office Memorandum from 01.01.2016, and
once
the State
Authorities have prescribed cut-off date for admissibility of legal entitlement i.e. benefits of arrears of revised pay w.e.f. 01.01.2016 and benefit of arrears of revised retiral benefits from the date of respective retirement between
01.01.2016
Authorities cut-off an
cannot
date
artificial
till be
permitted
originally cut-off
31.12.2021 to
prescribed,
date
in
then,
State
tinker with by years
prescribing 2022
to
2026 on the plea of financial constraints, which was to taken into account at the time of notifying the Rules
and
OM
and
not
subsequently.
Plea
of
financial constraints or stringency is not a ground to defeat the rights under the Statutory Rules, as in instant batch of cases. State Authorities cannot issue norms
which
are
in
conflict
extant
Statutory
Rules and thus Rule 13 and Para 8.2 and Para 10 of the OM as referred to above, cannot be permitted to operate hereinafter. Even the legitimate expectation acquired under Statutory Rules for revised/enhanced benefits
can
neither
be
negated
or
whittled
down
or taken away or withheld nor can their release be prolonged
indefinitely,
merely
by
invoking
offensive
provisions of Rules 13 and Para 8.2 and Para 10 of the OM, defeats the very idea of welfare state. Moreover,
while
answering
Question
No
(though
in the context of Dearness Allowance, which was a right accruing under the Statutory Rules}, the Honble Supreme Court has outlined in the case of
State
of West Bengal and another vs Confederation of State
Government
Employees
West
Bengal
and
Others (2026) 6 SCC 641, that the payment of the “established
right
for
salary,
pension,
gratuity,
or
other statutory benefits” cannot be refused or denied or delayed on the plea of paucity of funds or financial constraints
and
commitments
and
State
is
bound
to
honor
its
obligations
under
Statutory
Rules for its employees. PLEA OF ABRUPT DISCONTINUANCE OF REVENUE DEFICIT GRANT IS AN AFTER THOUGHT AND ALSO FARCE:
22.
Second contention of the Learned Advocate
placing reliance on the Affidavit dated 15.05.2026 [at page 209 onwards of paper book] and Affidavit dated 28.02.2026 [at page 230 onwards of paper book], that 15th Finance Commission had recommended Revenue Deficit Grant [RDG] for the award period from 2021 -2022 and 2025-26 amounting to Rs 37,199/- Crores but 16th Finance Commission has not recommended any Revenue Deficit Grant for the Respondent-State for the award period 2026-2031 and even no other special
grant
has
been
released
to
State
and
due to discontinuance of Revenue Deficit Grant, the State
is facing financial hardships
arrears of pay and retiral benefits.
in releasing the
Above
plea
of
State
Authorities
does
not impress this Court, for the reason, firstly, the material on record indicates that Himachal Pradesh Civil
Services
[Revised
Pay]
Rules
were
notified
on
03.01.2022 [Annexure P-3] giving the revised pay to its
employees w.e.f. 01.01.2016
Memorandum
dated
25.02.2022
and likewise, [Annexure
Office
P-4]
was
notified giving Revised Retiral Benefits to Government Servants
who
retired
on
or
after
01.01.2016
till
31.12.2021 and from the date of issuance of Rules/ Office
Memorandum
in
January/February
2022
till
the discontinuance of such RDG in the year 2026, State
Government
had
received
Revenue
Deficit
Grant of Rs 26950/- Crores [at page 165 of the paper book] for the award period from 2022-26, then,
plea
of
non-releasee
of
benefits,
due
to
discontinuance of Revenue Deficit Grant cannot sustain; and
secondly,
plea
of
discontinuance
of
RDG
is an after-thought to cover up its inactions/ lethargy in depriving the petitioners and others retirees of their statutory legal entitlements; and thirdly, non-existent and farce plea of paucity of funds is untenable when,
Rs 26950/- Crores [at page 165 of the paper book] for
award
period
from
2022-26,
in
addition
to States own budgetary allocation yet, the paucity of funds cannot be permitted to be the basis for not released the accrued/earned and crystallized statutory benefits. ABSENCE OF PROVISION FOR INTEREST STILL ENTITLES AN EMPLOYEE-RETIREE FOR INTEREST ON DELAYED PAYMENTS:
23.
Third Contention of the Learned Advocate
General is based on the stand taken in Para 12 (g) and 15 (a to d) of Reply-Affidavit dated 17.06.2025 that once there is no provision for payment of interest on arrears of pay/pension, then, the claim for interest is untenable. Above stand of the State Authorities in the Reply-Affidavit
cannot
stand
test
of
judicial
scrutiny, for the reason, that the admissibility of interest on delayed payments, even if, there are no specific Rules or Orders for providing for interest, has been approved by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in view of the Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution of India as retiral benefits are not bounty in S.K. Dua
vs State of Haryana and another, (2008) 3 SCC 44, in the following terms:“14.
In
prima
circumstances,
facie,
we
are of the view that the grievance voiced by
appellant
appears
that
would
founded
he
to
be
be
well-
entitled
to
interest on such benefits. If there are Statutory
Rules
appellant
occupying
could
claim
field,
payment
of
interest relying on such Rules. If there are Administrative Instructions, Guidelines or
Norms
prescribed
appellant
interest
on
may
that
for
claim
basis.
But
purpose,
benefit
of
even
in
absence Statutory Rules, Administrative Instructions or Guidelines, an employee can claim interest under Part III
Constitution
14, 19
relying
of
on Articles
and 21 of the Constitution. The
submission of the learned counsel for the appellant, that retiral benefits are not in the nature of “bounty” is, in our opinion, well-founded
and
needs
no
authority
in support thereof. In that view of the matter,
in
our
considered
opinion,
High Court was not right in dismissing the petition in limine even without issuing notice to the respondents.”
24.
Fourth Contention of the Learned Advocate
General is based on the judgments passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Punjab and others
versus Boota Singh and another, (2000) 3 SCC 733; State of Punjab and others versus Amar Nath Goyal and others, (2005) 6 SCC 754; Himachal Road Transport Corporation
Retired
Employees
Union,
(2021)
SCC
502; and State of Tripura and others versus Anjana Bhattacharjee and others, (2022) 19 SCC 705,
to assert
and
a
establish
that
financial
constraints
is
valid
ground for prescribing the cut-off date which cannot be questioned by the Court. 24(i).
Above plea of Learned Advocate General and
reliance placed in the case of Boota Singh [supra] is misconceived, for the reason, that factual matrix was entirely different, wherein, the employees had retired from service in 1982 and they were seeking benefit of Notification dated 09.07.1985, which provided that Dearness Allowance and ad hoc Dearness Allowance was those
to
be
treated
persons
who
as
Dearness
retired
on
or
Pay after
in
terms
of
31.03.1985.
The employees in the case of Boota Singh [supra] who retired prior to the cut-off date on 31.03.1985 were held to be not covered for the said benefits.
Reliance in the case of Amar Nath Goyal
24(ii).
[supra] is also misplaced, for the reason, that issue in said case is entirely different and is distinguishable, for the reason, that State of Punjab had taken a decision
prescribing
cut-off
date
as
01.04.1995
for giving benefit of increased Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity [DCRG] after merging Dearness Allowance and the claim by pre-01.4.1995 retirees, including Amar Nath Goyal [supra], was negated. Reliance placed in the case Himachal Road
24(iii).
Transport
Corporation
Retired
Employees
Union
[supra] is misplaced when, the fact-situation in the case in
was
entirely
case
had
different.
Respondent-Corporation
introduced Pension
Scheme
dated
06.10.1995 w.e.f. 05.06.1995 and the retired employees of Association who retired prior to the cut-off date i.e. 05.06.1995 had come up challenging the cut-off date
and
extension
of
benefits
which
were
denied
on the ground that prescription cut-off date in view of
financial
stringency
was
valid.
in instant case is entirely different.
The
fact-situation
24(iv).
Reliance
Bhattacharjee
placed
[supra]
in
cannot
of
Anjana
aid
case
come
to
of
the State, for the reason, that in the said case, the State of Tripura had notified Tripura Revised Pension Rules in 2009 and the said Rules expressly mandated that benefits shall accrue “notionally from 01.01.2006 and financial benefits shall accrue from 01.01.2009 or
date
of
superannuation
which
is
later.”
In
aforesaid case, the State Tripura had taken a conscious decision
to
give
notional
benefits
from
retrospective
date and actual financial benefits from the issuance of said Rules, then, said judgment is distinguishable and not applicable on facts. Considering the aforesaid judgments,
same
are
not
applicable
and
are
distinguishable. PLEA REGARDING JUDICIAL REVIEW IN ECONOMIC POLICY MISCONCEIVED:
Last contention of Learned Advocate General
25.
is that in cases of economic legislation or formulation of economic policy, judicial Review is not permissible, as
policy
decision
of
Government,
cannot
be interfered by the Courts, by placing reliance on the judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the
case of R.K. Garg vs Union of India and others, (1981)
SCC
675;
Narmad
Bachao
Andolan
vs
Union of India and others, (2000) 10 SCC 664; and Vivek Narayan Sharma and others vs Union of India and others, (2023) 3 SCC 1. 25(i). does
Reliance placed by Learned Advocate General not
impress
this
Court
as
ratio
of
aforesaid judgments is not in dispute but the same are not applicable in the fact situation of the instant batch of cases. 25(ii).
Reliance on
judgment in
case
of
R.K. Garg [supra] was with respect to the economic legislation with the findings that mere possibility of abuse or inequity or immorality will not constitute a ground for unconstitutionality. The said judgment is distinguishable of
on
petitioners
facts, for
for
Revised
reason,
Arrears
of
that
right
pay
and
Revised Retiral Benefits flow from Statutory Rules. The legal entitlements for these benefits are not in dispute. It is the payability and mode of release of benefits by invocation of Rule 13 and Para 8.2 and Para 10 which is capricious, arbitrary, oppressive and defeats
constitutional right of Article 300-A of the Constitution of India and teats “equals to unequals”, leads to grave violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India and therefore, in the fact-situation of instant case, reliance on the judgment in the case of R.K. Garg [supra] is distinguishable. 25(iii).
Reliance placed in the case Narmad Bachao
Andolan
[supra]
cannot
come
to
aid
of
State Authorities, as the issue was with respect to
policy
decision
for
construction
of
a
dam
for
ecological protection. Even, principle of law mandated in the said judgment stands against the State, for
reason,
that
broader
principle
outlined
in
said
judgment is that once fundamental and constitutional rights are infringed or action is arbitrary or malafide, judicial review is permissible. 25(iv).
Reliance on
judgment in
case
of
Vivek Narayan Sharma [supra] was in a different context, India,
whereby, on
decision
demonetization
being
of
Reserve a
policy
Bank
of
decision
was upheld, being a policy decision. In facts of instant case, once the financial capability and its payability,
was to be examined, considered, decided and approved at the time of issuing the Revised Pay Rules dated 03.01.2022 and while notifying the Office Memorandum dated
25.02.2022
[Annexure
P-4]
and
while
giving
retrospective applicability to these Rules and/or the Office Memoranda from 01.01.2016. After having notified the Rules/Office Memoranda, entitling the Government Servants/ Retirees for benefits from 01.01.2016, the State Authorities cannot take U-turn, to the extent of
payability-release
of
to
State
aid
of
arrears,
which
Authorities
cannot
come
in
facts
of instant case. Consequently, the reliance on the judgment in case of Vivek Narayan Sharma [supra] cannot be accepted and is turned down. 25(v).
Learned Advocate General has placed reliance
on the judgment in case of State of Punjab and others vs Ramlubhaya Bagga and others, (1998) 4 SCC 117, to assert that the Government had right to change policy and no person has absolute right under the old policy. Above contention is misplaced, for the reason, that policy, in question, in the case of Ramlubhaya Bagga [supra] was with respect to
the medical reimbursement and the policy in question in
said
case
was
a
mere
administrative
which was not based on
any
Statutory
decision,
Rule,
as
in
instant case. 25(vi).
Learned Advocate General tried to impress this
Court by placing reliance on the CCS (Pension) Rules 2021, but on query by this Court, nothing could be brought to our notice that the State Authorities have adopted these Rules for the State Govt Rules. Even CCS (Revised Pay) Rules dated 03.01.2022 and the OM dated 25.02.2022 confer benefits by applying the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972. CONCLUSION:
26.
Facts
a valuable
of instant case, establish that once
right for arrears of revised salary, and
arrears of revised retiral benefits i.e. Revised Pension, Revised Gratuity, Revised Commuted Value of pension, Revised
Leave
Encashment
had
accrued/crystallized,
in accordance with Statutory Rules i.e. CCS [Pension] Rules 1972; and the CCS [Leave] Rules; and CCS [Computation of Pension] Rules, as applicable in the instant batch of cases, but despite accrual of rights under
Statutory
Rules,
State
Authorities
have
made an attempt to incorporate Rule 13 and Para 8.2 and Para 10 of the OM, as referred to above, usurping the unfettered, unbridled, uncanalised and unrestricted in
State
Authorities
to
exercise
its
discretion
at its whims, fancies, mercy, so as to negate, curtail, deny, or
withhold and thereafter and/or to release
Arrears of Revised Pay and/or Arrears of Revised Retiral Benefits,
in
instalments
a
staggered
and
that
too
or
piece-meal
when
manner,
release
spills
in
over
to more than 4½ years now and the revised balance arrears of pay and Balance Revised Retiral Benefits are yet to be released to the petitioners and other retirees. Carving any
valid
benefits
to
out artificial discrimination
without
inclusion
and
rationale
by
releasing
some
retirees
who
retired
after
of
01.01.2016 [may be who have attained 70 years of age and above or to Group D/Class-IV] amounts to carving inter-se discrimination cannot sustain. Treating members of homogeneous Class being retirees differently speaks of volumes and arbitrariness, unfairness and legal malafides. Moreover, constitutional right of Article 300-A
of
Constitution
of
India
have
been
patently
violative due to the inclusion of oppressive Clauses in Revised Pay Rules and Office Memoranda giving the Revised Retiral Benefits, are contrary to the Statutory Rules, coupled with the fact that inter-se discrimination in release of benefits and the plea of stoppage of Revenue Deficit Grant, being an afterthought, negates
plea
of
constitutional
State.
Once
violations,
fundamental
and
malafide
and
including
arbitrariness in State action is writ large, therefore, plea of the State Authorities and the contention of Learned
Advocate
General
cannot
pass
test
of
judicial scrutiny. Resultantly, the action of the State Authorities -Respondnets in withholding, or deferring, staggering or indefinitely delaying the release of the legal
entitlements
crystallized
and
monetary
and accrued
dues
and vested
in
which
have
Government
Servants/Retirees from 01.01.2016 onwards by virtue of
Statutory
Rules,
cannot
be
negated
by
invoking
offensive, capricious Rules/Office Memoranda conferring unfettered,
unbridled,
uncanalised
and
unrestricted
discretion to release the benefits at the mercy of the State Authorities.
In by
Learned
these
circumstances,
Counsel
for
contentions
respective
raised
petitioner(s)
are
accepted whereas the contentions of Learned Advocate General, which have been adopted by other Learned respondent Counsel {except in LPA} do not have any force
and
same
are
accordingly
Resultantly,
offending
part
of
of
quashed
and
set-aside
OM
are
turned
Rule in
down.
and
Paras
view
of
and
for
directions contained hereinbelow. 27.
No other points was argued/raised. DIRECTIONS:
28.
In
reasons
recorded
view
of
above
hereinabove,
discussion
instant
petition
[Lead
Case] and all connected petitions are allowed, in following terms:(i).
Instant petition, Madhu Deshta versus State of Himachal Pradesh and others [CWP No: 8504 of 2025], is allowed;
(ii).
Rule 13 of the Himachal Pradesh Civil Services on
[Revised
Pay]
Rules
[Annexure
03.01.2022
notified
P-3],
and
the expressions in “such manner” and “at such time” as may be “approved by the Government”; which makes other provisions and
otiose
of
and
Rules which
unworkable deprives
petitioner of the right to receive the entire earned/accrued arrears of revised pay, due to the unfettered, unbridled, uncanalised, dictates
unguided
and
discretion
fancies
of
or
State
Authorities, violates Constitutional right to property under Article 300-A and being oppressive and unreasonable and arbitrary, is read down and is declared inoperative,; (iii).
Para
of
Office
Memorandum
notified on 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4] and the expressions in “such manner as may be “decided by the Government in future” and makes actual release of arrears of Revised Pension/ Family Pension from
and
Revised
Gratuity/DCRG
due
date
of
retirement
{01.02.2021
in
Lead
Case}
and
aforesaid provision depriving petitioner and other retirees of earned/accrued right-legal entitlement to receive entire arrears of revised retiral benefits due to
unfettered,
unbridled,
uncanalised,
unguided discretion of State Authorities, being
violative
of
constitutional
right
to property under Article 300-A, and being offensive, and unreasonable and arbitrary, and the OM being contrary to the Statutory Rules i.e. the CCS [Pension] Rules 1972; is quashed and set-aside; (iv).
Para 8.2 of the Office Memorandum notified on 25.02.2022 [Annexure P-4]
and expression “in a phased manner as to be notified by Finance Department,” restricting the right of the retirees to receive the entire arrears of Revised Commuted Pension “which is payable in lump sum” in CWP 11716 of 2024, titled as Dr Jagdev & Ors vs State, being contrary to Rule 5 and 10 of the CCS (Computation of Pension) Rules 1981, is quashed and set-aside; (v).
Action of State Authorities in withholding or delaying the release of entire arrears of Revised Leave Encashment; despite its payability in lump-sum under the Statutory Rule i.e. CCS (Leave) Rules ; is quashed and set-aside;
(vi).
State Authorities shall release entire arrears of revised pay to petitioner in Lead Case in two equal instalments; by releasing first lump-sum instalment on
or
before
15th
December,
2026
and the second lump-sum instalment on or before 28th February, 2027 ; (vii). State Authorities shall release entire arrears of Revised Retiral Benefits i.e. the Revised Pension/Family Pension and Revised Gratuity/DCRG and Revised Leave
Encashment
and
Revised
Commuted Pension and Revised Leave Encashment to the petitioner in Lead Case in two equal instalments; as in Direction no (vi) (supra); (viii). Sequel to directions (vi) and (vii) above,
State Authorities
shall
give
interest
at the rate of 6% per annum w.e.f. 01.06.2022 [i.e. date of payability] till release of benefits during the pendency of instant petition; and also on the unpaid amount, which is liable to be released
in
terms
of
this judgement
before 15.12.2026 and 28.02.2027 as directed hereinabove; (ix).
Directions passed in Lead Case [CWP No. 8504 of 2025, titled as Madhu Deshta vs State of Himachal Pradesh and others] shall also mutatis mutandis apply in all connected writ petitions/ cases, with further directions to the State Authorities / Boards / Corporations to extend all admissible benefits as in Paras 28 (vi) to (viii) of this judgement; within the same time-frame mandated therein;
(x).
In the light of the findings recorded in CWP No: 8504 of 2025 [in Lead Case]; LPA No: 557 of 2025, titled as State of Himachal Pradesh and others vs Mini Sharma, and CMP (M) No. 147 of 2025, State of Himachal Pradesh and others vs Balbir and anr, and CMP (M) No. 2123 of 2024, State
of
Himachal
Pradesh
and
others vs Ravinder Chand & anr, shall accordingly stand dismissed; (xi).
Needless to say, that those employeesretirees, who had not filed any writ petition, on the date of this judgement,
[30.10.2026] such incumbents shall be entitled to claim substantive benefits only; (xii). Sequel to the direction no (xi) above, retirees, being fence-sitters, who have not taken legal recourse as on day, such incumbents shall be entitled to substantive benefits only; but without any interest, as has been awarded to petitioners in instant batch of cases; (xiii). Executions Petitions, 53 of 2024 in CWP No. 7731 of 2023, Ex. Petition 70 of 2024 in CWP No. 7825 of
2023, Ex.
Petition 71 of 2024 in CWP No.7927 of
2023 Ex. Petition 595 of 2024 in
CWP No. 3336 of 2024, Ex. Petition 594 of 2024 in CWP No.3424 of 2024 & Ex. Petition 292 of 2024 in CWP No.2473 of 2023 listed with the present batch
of
cases,
are
de-tagged,
with
directions to Learned Registrar (Judicial), to list the same hereinafter, as per norms; (xiv). Following cases i.e. CWP No. 7152 of 2023
alongwith
CWP
No.
7153
of
2023, 7158 of 2023, 7159 of 2023, 7160 of
2023,
7223
of
2023,
7244
of
2023, 7245 of 2023, 7246 of 2023, 7247 of 2023, 7248 of 2023, 7249 of 2023, 7251 of 2023, 7252 of 2023, 7253 of 2023, 7254 of 2023, 7255 of 2023, 8193 of 2023, 2820 of 2024 and
CWP
No.
9268
of
2024,
were
already disposed of, but were erroneously
shown as
connected
with
present
batch of cases and therefore, the same are de-tagged and may be treated as already disposed of ; (xv). Parties to bear respective costs;
In the aforesaid terms, the instant petitions and all pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall accordingly stand disposed of. (Vivek Singh Thakur) Judge
October 31, 2026 [Bhardwaj]
(Ranjan Sharma) Judge