Shaik Taher v. The State of Telangana,
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 26 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice J Sreenivas Rao
- Case number
- CRLP No. 10687 of 2026
- Result
- ALLOWED NO COSTS
- Acts & sections
- Section 528 BNSS
- Subject
- Criminal
Full judgment
[ 33031 IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD MONDAY, THE TWENTY SIXTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENry SIX PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J.SREENIVAS RAO
CRIMINAL PETIT ION NO: 10687 0F 2026 Between: 1. Shaik Taher, S/o. Shaik Fayaz, Age: 37 years, Occ: Business, Fi/o ' Sofinagar Colony, Nirmal Town and Mandal, Nirmal District, Telangana State'
2.ShaikAslam,S/o.Shabbir,Age.28years,OccDriver,R/o'AshmiColony'
Nizamabad Town and Mandal, Nizamabad District, Telangana State' 3. Snaif< Rafeeq, S/o. Shaik Anwar, Age.29 years, Occ Driver, Fl/o' Asad baba
Nagar,NizamabadTownandMandal,NizamabadDistrict,TelanganaState. ...Petitioners/Accused No'1 to 3 AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep. by the Public Prosecutor, High Court at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana
Z. Siate potice, through D.Jyothimini, Wp Sub lnspector of Police, P.S.Soan Nirmal District, Telangana State.
...Respondents
in Petition under section 528 of BNSS praying that in the circumstances stated pleased to the Memorandum of Grounds of criminal Petition, the High court may be Judicial Principal qri.n tn" proceedings in CC No. 598 ol 2021 on the file of the Magistrate of First Class at Nirmal in so far as petitioner'
I.A. N O:2 OF 2026 in Petition under section 528 of BNSS praying that in the circumstances stated pleased^to the Memorandum of Grounds of criminal Petition, the High court may be to 3 in CC No. petitioners /Accused trant stay of all further proceedings against the ilo. s98 or z1zl onthe fite of the Frincipal Judicial Magistrate of First Class at Nirmal pending disposal of the main criminal petition.
ThisPetitioncomingonforhearing,uponperusingtheMemorandumof Divakar Grounds of Criminal Petition and upon hearing the arguments of Mr' A n"aJy, nOro"rte for the Petitioners and Mr. Jithender Rao Veeramalla, Additional Public Prosecutor on behalf of the Respondents'
The Court made the following: ORDER
IN-I-IIE HIGH COURl'F oR' I-II}- STATT] OF 1'ELANGANA A1'IIYDERAI}AD
I'IIE HoNOT:RAI}LT] SRI JTISTICT, J.SRET,NIVAS RAO CRIMINAL PETII'ION N o.10687 of2026 (lNR No. Hllllco 10446772026 Date:26.10.2026 []ctrr cerr Shaik
-[-ahr-r'
and rri o oLhcrs I)ctiLioners/Accused Nos. I to 3
ANI) I'he State ol''['clangana and anothcrRespondcnts
ORDER
Ihis ( r'irninal Petitjon has bccn lllccl b; pe t it ioners/acc tiscd \os.
rhc
I to 3 scci<ing [o quash the proceedings in
('.( .\o. jt)[i ,.rl' ]01 I on rhe fllc ol the principal Judicial Magistratc oi I:i'sL Clas. at \ir-rral. l.r thc .fli,,ccs punishablc ,ndcr Scction 420 r/vr'3,1 of thc Indian pcnal Coclt-. lg60 (tbr short. ,thc IpC.) and Scction 7 ol tlrc Esscntial (_'ornnrodities Act, 1955 (1br shon 't hc Il.('. .\cr')
l.
Ileard \1r. \.1)irrrkar. I{crlcir. Icarncd counscl fbr thc
pctirionls. rrnd \lr...lithcndcr Rao \ ecrarnalla. learncd Additional PLrblic Prosec-rtor firr thc rcspondcnts.
3.
The specific allegation against the petitioners/accused Nos.l
to 3 is that they had procured PDS rice lrom the beneficiaries at cheapcr rate to sell the satre 1br prolit and on 26.08.202 I at about
I9-30 hours, the petitioners were lound in possession of' 75.00 quintals of PDS rice.
1.
[.carncd cor"ttrscl tbr thc pctitioners w'ould submit that
without there being any complaint from any beneficiary, alleging that the rice was procured deceptively or with a criminal intent and charging the petitioners lbr prosccution is untenable and improper' The allegations, even taken at their 1'ace value cannot be sustained against the petitioners. Further, this Court, in Crl'P No'5709 of 2019.
"rhilc
considering the satrre sitrration. categorically observed
tliat the offences alleged against the petitioners thcrein could not be
continued and accordingly quashed the proceedings' The petitioncrs are also entitled to the satnc reliel-and hence prayed to cluash the proceedings against the pctitioners.
5.
The leamed Additional Public Prosecutor submits that as per
prosecution. the of'f'encc saicl to havc bcen committcd b;- the petitioners is cheating and violation of Section 7 ol the E C Act and requested to pass appropriate orders.
6.
Section 7 o1' the F..C. Act contemplates that any person
contravcnes r' ith Lhe prodr-rction. sr_rppll. disLribLrtion arrd trade ofesscntial con r rrod rtics, IS punrshablr.. .\s pcr tlrc prosccution, the pctit.ionels havc procured pDS rice fiom the beneficiaries after sLrpplr lionr thc dcalcr
,A Coolelinarc l]ench ol'rhis Coun in Crl.l).No.7217 ol-1025
has considereri the identical facts and observed that
Thtra is tl) .lct-ulan/ ittrltctrtrtt.q tlt(l tl1( l)t,ltiott!r. itt ,tnr trtl. LiL,.(l)lt\\ l\ .tttitt,-L't/ tlt.' ht, (/4 t t tt,\ tt) /)tt1.l \t ttlt tltt strltltlit,Ll ['l).\ t-ttt, or tltL' 6t,ttalic.ittrt atttrtt.stt,t/ tha I'l).\ rrtL /tLttt/t,r:ctl hr t/rcnt t ttlt /ltt, l)!tttit)t,t 0ttrl t/ut Lli:hottr:;ti.t utt\(11)pr()l)t tLtttLl t)r Lotlt.L,rtr(l tt) tht!r o,t tl Lt\c )t' u.\ed tt itt t iolutton of .t ltnt litl tlirection or a.ont(rct l llt( tr/t.scutc rt/ t,.tcrtttol lcrctors on lht, ltrc ()l (ottt thl, lt.o\((.ulion lincls it to fu t /it( r/\(, /r.r L2\.c/.c /\( th( furi\tliLtt{)t1 unLltt.\fL.lit)u -;l,f i,,/ /J\.!l\ )l)lJ. ,'lttn (ontinutlLf of pnttctL/trtgr tt.uttintt the pelittoncr i.s rrhLr.se o/ l)1'()[L'\ ' t)t lu','
8.
'l he iz,.cts
a,cl circLrrnstances o1'the present case also silnilal
to those in lhe rrbor c casc and hcnce. rhis ('oun llnds it to be a tlt
casc to c\e|ci:iL- .jUrrsdiction rrncjer SccLion 5lg of IINSS br appl\ ins the sarne analog) and to qLrash thc proceedirrgs againsr thc petitioncrs hc-rcin
9.
Accordinrlll , the Crirnina j pctition is allowecl and the
proceed ings ln r- .(' \o.598 ol' l0l
I on rhe lllc ol- thc l)rincipal
.lud ic ia
I \{agistratc ol' l'it'st ('lass at Nirrral, against the
petitioners/accr-rsed Nos.l to 3, arc hereby qr-rashed
Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, shalI stand closcd SD/- L. VIJAYA LAXMI ASSISTANT REGISTRAR
G
//TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER To,
1. The Principal Judicial Magistrate of First Class at Nirmal 2. The Station House Officer, Soan Police Station, Nirmal District'
3. One CC to Mr. A. Divakar Reddy, Advocate [OPUC] 4. Two CCs to Public Prosecutor High Court for the State of Telangana' at Hyderabad [OUT]
5. Two CD CoPies KAMiGNK
€l (.
HIGH COURT
DATED: 261101202O
ORDER
CRLP.No.10687 of 2026 ( oB
o
1kl
,e
* o
I ztllol>t'
z
!
o
ALLOWING THE CRIMINAL PETITION
P
0 4 lt0v 202[
E5 PATca'. (1,