Shashi Pal Thakur v. State of Hp
- Court
- High Court of Himachal Pradesh
- Date of judgment
- 8 October 2026
- Bench
- Justice Vivek Singh Thakur, Justice Ranjan Sharma
- Case number
- CWPOA No. 8076 of 2019
- Result
- Disposed Off
- Acts & sections
- Article 309 Constitution, Article 14 Constitution
- Subject
- Service, Labour
Full judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA CWPOA No.8076 of 2019 Reserved on: 16.06.2026 Announced on: 08.10.2026. ____________________________________________________________
Shashi Pal Thakur and others ...Petitioners Versus State of Himachal Pradesh and others ...Respondents Coram: Hon’ble Mr. Justice Vivek Singh Thakur, Judge Hon’ble Mr. Justice Ranjan Sharma, Judge 1Whether approved for reporting?
Yes.
For the petitioners:
Mr. K. S. Banyal, Senior Advocate with Mr. Uday Singh Banyal, Advocate.
For the respondents:
Mr. Ramakant Sharma, Additional Advocate General for RespondentsState.
Ranjan Sharma, Judge Petitioner,
Shashi
Pal
Thakur
others, being Health Educators in Health Department of the Respondent-State, initially filed an Original Application No 4590 of 2016, before Learned State Administrative Tribunal and after abolition of Tribunal, the matter stood transferred to this Court as CWPOA No 8076 of 2019, seeking the following reliefs: “(i)
That the impugned Notification dated
Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?
30.01.2016
Annexure
A-1
may
very
kindly be set-aside and further direct
respondents to
Pay
revise
applicants to
Grade
Rs 5000/-
w.e.f. 01.01.2006 with all consequential benefits. (ii).
That the entire record of this case including
other
categories
Health Department may kindly be ordered to be summoned for the kind perusal of this Hon’ble Tribunal for an appropriate adjudication of the matter. (iii).
That
respondents
be
directed
to bear the cost of this Original Application as this litigation is a result
their
omission
commission. They have failed to give justice to its employees. Respondents No.
were
aware
about
the scale, qualification and inter-se hierarchy of different categories and their
duties
responsibilities.
Para 6(a) to (g) supra clearly depicts the injustice done to the category
applicants who
have
been
given lowest Grade Pay inspite of the fact that they were more qualified, experienced
having
more
job
responsibility than other categories, which
ultimately
present litigation.
resulted
in
FACTUAL MATRIX:
2. is
Case as set up by Learned Senior Counsel that
petitioners
possess
qualifications
of Graduate and Diploma in Health Education from a recognized University or Institute and by virtue of these qualifications, petitioners being eligible had a right to be considered for appointment/promotion to posts of Health Educators in health department of the Respondent State in terms of the Recruitment and Promotion Rules of Health Educators notified on 29.10.1999, Annexure A-2, {referred to as the Rules for the posts of Health Educators}, in the pay-scale of Rs 5800-9200. It is averred that after due selection, in terms of the R & P Rules of 1999, the petitioners were appointed/promoted as Health Educators in pay scale of Rs 5800-9200 and after the revision of pay scales in terms of the Himachal Pradesh Civil Services [Revised Pay] Rules notified on 26.08.2009, Annexure A-3, applicable w.e.f. 01.01.2006 {referred to as the Revised Pay Rules of 2009}, and Conversion Table in the Schedule to these Rules,
the pay-scale of Health Educators was revised from Rs 5800-9200 to Rs 10300-34800 + 3800 Grade
Pay
w.e.f. 1.1.2006; and thereafter on issuance of the Himachal Pradesh Civil Services (Category/Post-wise Revised Pay) Rules on 24.09.2012 {referred as the Re-revised
Pay Rules of 2012}, Annexure
A-12,
the pay scale of other categories of employees of the Respondent-Health Department, Senior Laboratory Technicians
Ward
Sisters
{who
were
in
lower revised pay scale of Rs 10300-34800 + 3800 GP w.e.f. 1.01.2006} were given the re-revised pay scale of Rs 10300-34800 + 4800 GP w.e.f. 1.9.2014, Annexure A-7, whereas, the benefit of the re-revised pay scale under the Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 was
initially not granted
to the petitioners-Health
Educators at the relevant time. 2(i).
It
is
averred
that
in
addition
to
categories spelt out in Para 2 supra, there existed category
re-designated
Female/Male as
Health
Male/Female
Supervisors
Multipurpose
[later Health
Supervisors] [referred to as the feeder category]
and the State Authorities notified the Recruitment and Promotion Rules for this category on 12.10.1999, Annexure A-6, giving them the pay scale of Rs 5480 -8925 w.e.f. 01.01.1996, which was revised to Rs 10300-34800+3600 GP w.e.f. 1.1.2006 in terms of the HPCS Revised Pay Rules notified on 26.08.2009, Annexure A-3, and this pay scale was Re-revised under Re-revised Pay Rules dated 24.09.2012, by issuing notification on 28.09.2012, Annexure A-12, to Rs 10300-34800+4200 GP w.e.f. 1.10.2012. It is averred that the category of Male Health Supervisors [redesignated
as
Male/Female
Multipurpose
Health
Supervisors] were included in the feeder category in promotional cadre of Health Educators to extent of 75% posts as per the Recruitment and Promotion Rules notified by the State Government on 29.10.1999, Annexure A-2. 2(ii).
It is further averred that on 01.10.2012,
an anomaly in pay arose between the pay of the feeder post holders and the promotional post holders whereby,
feeder
category
incumbents
i.e.
Female/
Male
Health
Supervisors,
[redesignated
as
Male/
Female Multipurpose Health Supervisors] who were in revised pay scale of Rs 10300-34800+3600 GP w.e.f. 1.1.2006. were later given the Re-revised pay scale of
Rs 10300-34800 + 4200 GP w.e.f. 1.10.2012
under the HPCS Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 by issuing Notification on 28.09.2012, Annexure A-12, whereas, on the other hand, the petitioners, who were holders of higher-promotional post of Health Educators, who were given the revised pay scale of Rs 10300-34800 + 3800 GP w.e.f. 1.1.2006 were neither considered nor granted the benefit of the re-revised pay scale/structure under the Re-revised Rules w.e.f. 01.10.2012 resulting in giving less pay to the petitioners, who were holders of promotional posts while giving higher pay to incumbents holding feeder posts. 2(iii).
Feeling
aggrieved
against
inaction
neither considering nor granting proportional higher grade pay w.e.f. 01.10.2012, the petitioners submitted representation to the State Authorities on 23.01.2014
Annexure A-9, on which the matter was processed and even Respondent No 3-Director Health Services after convening a meeting with the Association of Health Educators on 17.07.2015, referred the matter to the Respondent No 2-Additional Chief Secretary (Health) on 14.08.2015, Annexure P-13, to examine the claim of petitioners for removing the anomaly. For this purpose, an Expert Committee was constituted and respondents forwarded a Proposal-Memorandum No. Fin-(PR)-B(7)-64/2010-II-Loose undated Annexure A-10,
admitting
that
an
anomaly
in
pay
existed
between the pay of the petitioners-Health Educators vis-à-vis the holders of lower-feeder post and post of Health Educator did not exist in State of Punjab and once the lower-feeder post holders i.e. Male/ Female
Health
Multipurpose
Supervisors
Health
[later
Supervisors]
redesignated
as
were
given
re-revised pay of Rs 10300-34800 + 4200 GP w.e.f. 1.10.2012 therefore, the petitioners-Health Educators may be given the benefit of the re-revised pay of Rs 10300-34800+ 4200 GP with prospective effect. It
is averred that the proposal [as contained in the memorandum
Annexure
A-10],
was
placed
before
an Expert Committee consisting of Additional Chief Secretary [Finance], Special Secretary [Finance] and Controller [F & A] and Expert Committee submitted report on 20.10.2015 [at page 81 of paper book, part of Annexure A-10], admitting anomaly, as the feeder post holders of Male/Female Health Supervisors [redesignated as Multipurpose Health Supervisors] were given the higher rerevised pay structure of 1030034800+4200 GP w.e.f. 1.10.2012 whereas petitionersHealth Educators-holders of higher-promotional posts were
granted
lower
pay structure of
10300-34800
+ 3800 GP w.e.f 01.01.2006. The Expert Committee recommended to grant the re-revised pay structure prospectively with further recommended that in the event
granting
an
equivalent
pay
structure
to
petitioners-Health Educators as granted to the feeder post then, it was advised to amend the Recruitment and Promotion Rules for post of Health Educators, by
changing
nomenclature from
promotion
to
placement,
by
placing
these
recommendations
for
consideration and approval of the State Cabinet and State Cabinet in its meeting held on 14.01.2016 approved the Report-recommendations made by the Expert Committee on 15.01.2016 [at page 75 of the paper
book].
1-Additional
Sequel Chief
to
this,
Secretary
Respondent
[Finance]
issued
No
Notification on 30.01.2016, Annexure A-1, granting re-revised pay scale of Rs 10300-34800 + 4200 GP to the petitioners-Health Educators w.e.f. 01.02.2016. The petitioners have prayed for quashing and setting aside the Notification dated 30.01.2016 [Annexure A-1] granting the Grade Pay of Rs 4200 in the re-revised pay structure of Rs 10300-34800+ 4200 GP w.e.f. 01.02.2016 to the petitioners-Health Educators
i.e.
holders
higher-promotional
posts
under HPCS Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012, whereas, same very Grade Pay of Rs 4200 in the re-revised pay structure of Rs 10300-34800+ 4200 GP was given
to
holders
Male
/Female
lower-feeder
Health
Supervisors
post
holders
i.e.
[redesignated
as
Multipurpose date
Health
Supervisors]
w.e.f. 1.10.2012
under
from
an
earlier
HPCS Re-revised
Pay
Rules 2012 as per Notification issued on 28.09.2012, Annexure A-12; with the prayer to give proportional higher re-revised grade pay to the petitioners-Health Educators, over and above the Grade Pay of Rs 4200 to petitioners w.e.f. 1.10.2012 as was granted to feeder post holders and to various other categories in Respondent Department and in other government departments under the HPCS Re-revised Pay Rules 2012 ; with prayer to allow the writ petition with all consequential benefits. STAND OF AFFIDAVIT:
3.
STATE
Pursuant to
AUTHORITIES
IN
REPLY-
issuance of notice, the
State Authorities-Respondents 1 to 3 filed the Reply -Affidavit dated 11.01.2017 of Director Health Services, Himachal Pradesh. 3(i).
In Reply-Affidavit the claim of petitioners-
Health Educators has been opposed on the ground that Respondent-State Authorities is under no legal obligation to follow the pattern of pay scales existing
in other States. It is averred that in terms of the judgements passed by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in cases of P.U. Joshi and others vs Accountant General, Ahmadabad and others (2003) 2 SCC 632 and Union of India and others vs Basudeba and others (2003) 2 SCC 632, prescription of pay scales and determination of service conditions lie exclusively within the realm of the Government. It is further averred that Courts should not interfere in the grant of pay scale or pay fixation or parity in terms of the judgements passed by this Court in Chamera Hydroelectric Project vs Labour Court and another Latest HLJ 2004 (HP) 212
and judgement passed
by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Shiba Kumar Dutta and others vs Union of India and others (1997) 3 SCC 545 and the judgement passed in LPA 146/ 2013
State
Himachal
Navneet Gupta and the
Pradesh
others
vs
judgement of this Court in
LPA No 11 of 2012 titled as State of Himachal Pradesh vs Pratap Thakur decided on 22.09.2014 with the plea that equation of posts with similar nomenclature
-designation
or
similar
duties
is
not
subject
to
judicial review. 3(ii).
Reply-Affidavit states in Para 5 that there
is no parity between the category of the petitioners who are Health Educators vis-à-vis other categories of Senior Laboratory Technicians/Ward Sisters and Male Health Supervisors and merely because these posts carried the same pay scale at one point of time therefore, the claim for parity is not tenable in terms of the judgements in the cases of Steel Authority
India
Ltd.
others
vs
Dibyunda
Bhattacharya, AIR 2011 SC 897, State of Madhya Pradesh
others
vs
Ramesh
Chandra
Bajpai,
(2009) 13 SCC 635, State of West Bengal vs West Bengal Minimus Wages Inspector Association, (2010) 5 SCC 225. 3(iii).
Reply-Affidavit states in Para 6 to 8 that
State Government constituted an Expert Committee on 13.07.2012 to consider the case relating to the revision of pay scales recommending to grant the re-revision to the State Government employees and
resultantly Himachal Pradesh Civil Services (Category /Post-wise
Revised
Pay)
Rules
2012
were
notified
on 24.09.2012. It is averred that State Government decided in principle that the benefit of re-revised pay scale/ pay-structure /any financial benefit shall be given prospectively. It is averred that the State Government has extended the benefit of re-revised pay scale/structure to 41 different departments from 01.10.2012 and therefore prescription of cut-off date for giving this benefit lies within the realm of State Government and it cannot be claimed retrospectively. 3(iv).
Reply Affidavit states that State Government
gave the re-revised pay scale-structure of Rs 10300 -34800 + 4200 Grade Pay to the petitioners-Health Educators w.e.f. 01.02.2016 from prospective effect at par with the re-revised pay structure and grade pay as was given to the feeder post holders i.e. Male/Female
Health
Supervisors
[later
redesignated
as Multipurpose Health Supervisors] after approval of State Cabinet. 3(v).
Reply states in Para 9 of the Preliminary
Submission and Para 6(1) of the reply on merits that
as
per
Rule
HPCS
(Category/Post
-wise Revised Pay) Rules 2012, the pay rules have overriding effect over Recruitment and Promotional Rules [Annexure A-2] and in view of the overriding effect of the re-revised rules, the petitioners have no right with respect to the claims raised in the instant petition to seek higher grade pay benefits vis-à-vis
feeder
category.
Reply-Affidavit
states
in
Para 6 that equation of posts or the prescription
pay
scales
has
to
be
considered
on
several
factors, such as, source of appointment, recruitment, qualifications,
nature
work,
value
thereof,
responsibilities, reliabilities, experience, confidentiality, functional need of feeder and promotional category, etc. and based on these factors the petitioners-Health Educators have been given the re-revised pay band and grade pay on 30.01.2016 [Annexure A-1] w.e.f. 01.02.2016. In this backdrop, prayer is made for dismissing the writ petition. REBUTTAL BY PETITIONERS:
4.
Petitioners
filed
a
rejoinder
denying
averments made in Reply-Affidavit. It was averred that even after granting the re-revised scale of Rs 10300-34800+4200
GP
w.e.f.
01.02.2016,
anomaly
in pay still existed in pay of the petitioners-Health Educators
(holding
higher-promotional
posts
vis-à-
vis the holders of feeder-lower posts of Male/Female Health
Supervisors
[redesignated
as
Multipurpose
Health Supervisors] by giving same re-revised pay structure to unequal and dissimilar. It was averred that
petitioners
were
not
seeking
parity
in
pay with other categories of employees i.e. Senior Laboratory
Technician,
or
Ward
Sisters,
or
Male/
Female Multipurpose Health Supervisors, TGTs etc. 4(i). questioned
It was averred that the petitioners have decision making
process
in
prescribing
different cut-off dates for giving re-revised pay scales and this action defeats the object/intent of granting Re-revised scales. It is contended that the operation, scope, applicability and the rights accruing under the Recruitment and Promotion Rules notified under
the provisio to Article 309 can neither be curtailed, restricted, whittled down in any manner nor can Statutory Rules be supplanted by a mere executive decision taken by State Cabinet and then notified on 30.01.2016 [Annexure A-1]. It was contented that nomenclature of the post of the petitioners-Health Educators, being a promotional post, in Recruitment
Promotion
Rules
notified
under
provisio
to Article 309 on 18.11.1999, Annexure A-2, cannot be changed from “promotion to placement” without amending the Statutory Rules of 1999 and when, no
amendment
in
Rules
has
out till July 2021, in view of the
been
carried
fact that as
per the office order dated 02.07.2021, Annexure P-15, feeder category incumbents i.e. Male/Female Health Supervisors [later redesignated as Multipurpose Health Supervisors]
were
promoted
as
Health
Educators
and such feeder category incumbents were allowed to avail promotional increments under Fundamental Rule 22 (1) (a) (i) also. 4(ii).
It was contented that Rule 8 of the HPCS
Re-revised
Pay
Rules
has
been
misconstrued
by
State Authorities. It was contented that Rule 1(ii) and Rule 9 of the HPCS Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012, enabling the State Authorities to notify the Schedule which the
to
prescribe
cut-off
date
from
re-revised pay scale/pay structure was
to be granted to its employees, yet, State Authorities cannot pick and choose the prescription of cut-off dates for giving the re-revised pay structure when, the object of granting the Re-revised Pay Structure and enhanced Grade Pay] is common to all the categories/posts irrespective of departments, so as to ensure better service conditions and also to bring efficiency in service, in lieu of stagnation on the same post-scale-grade pay to employees, who have rendered two years regular service, which is clearly borne out from the Notification issued on 27.09.2012 whereby, the re-revised pay scale was given to 26 categories {Taken on record} and as per Notification issued on 28.09.2012, Annexure A-12, was given to 14 categories {including feeder category incumbents}
in respondent-Health department w.e.f. 01.10.2012, whereas, the petitioners were given the re-revised pay scale by issuing a Notification on 30.01.2016 [Annexure A-1] w.e.f. 01.02.2016; and the action of the State Authorities in carving out different dates for releasing the Re-revised Pay benefit under the Common
Re-revised
Pay
Rules
2012
differential treatment meted out to the petitioners by giving the re-revised pay scale to
them from
01.02.2016 while giving the re-revised pay benefit to others categories, including feeder category and other lower categories from 01.10.2012, is not based on any classification and the differential treatment meted to petitioners by granting the benefits belatedly has
no
object
which
is
sought
to
be
achieved.
It is contented that the belated release of re-revised pay benefit to the petitioners, by resorting to pick and choose criteria is alleged to be discriminatory, unreasonable,
defeating
intent and
object
behind the grant of the re-revised pay was bad in law. In this backdrop, it contented that the decision
making process, which has led to gross anomaly in pay of the petitioners, despite being holders of higher-promotional post was alleged to be arbitrary, illegal and unconstitutional and the claims made in writ petition were reiterated. COMPLIANCE AFFIDAVIT FILED BY STATE AUTHORITIES IN TERMS OF ORDERS DATED 29.12.2025 AND REBUTTAL-COUNTER THERETO:
5.
Upon listing of the matter on 29.12.2025
this Court directed the State Authorities to file an affidavit detailing the job profile of the feeder-lower post of Male/Female Multipurpose
Health Workers
and the job profile for the posts of Male/Female Health Supervisor [later redesignated as Multipurpose Health Supervisors] and the job profile of higherpromotional posts of Health Educators, being held by the petitioners- Health Educators within a week. 5(i).
In compliance to orders dated 29.12.2025,
the State Authorities filed a Supplementary Affidavit dated
05.01.2026,
detailing
job
profile
all
three categories i.e. the foundational category of Male /Female
Health
Workers;
and the
feeder
category
of Male/Female Health Supervisors, who were later re-designated
as
Multipurpose
Health
Supervisors
and promotional-higher category of petitioners-Health Educators, is placed on record as Annexure R-3/A (colly). 5(ii).
Petitioners filed a counter affidavit thereto
by reiterating their claim. 6.
Heard,
Mr.
K.S.
Banyal,
Learned
Senior
Advocate assisted by Mr. Uday Singh Banyal, Advocate for the petitioners and Mr. Ramakant Sharma Learned Additional Advocate General, for the Respondents. CONTENTIONS OF LEARNED SENIOR COUNSEL FOR PETITIONERS:
7.
Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners
contends
that
decision
making
process
the resultant decision borne out from the Impugned Notification issued on 30.01.2016 [Annexure A-1], in granting benefit of the re-revised pay scale-structure, under the HPCS Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 to the category of the petitioners-Health Educators of Rs 10300-34800+4200 GP w.e.f. 01.02.2016 is be unsustainable, for the reason, firstly, the Impugned
Notification giving the same re-revised pay structure to
feeder
post
holders
promotional
post holders-petitioners is illegal; and secondly, the decision making process in equating the promotional post holders-petitioners-Health Educators with lower -feeder post holders-Male/Female Health Supervisors [later redesignated as Multipurpose Health Supervisors] despite the two posts having wholesale dissimilarity and unequal in all respects is illegal; and thirdly, the decision making process undertaken by alleged Expert Committee in changing the nomenclature of the post held by the petitioners-Health Educators from “promotion to placement” and Recommendation made by the Committee on 20.10.2015 [at page 81 -82 of paper book] ignoring wholesale dissimilarity in both the posts, and yet, in placing the
said
recommendations before State Cabinet on 14.01.2016 leading to approval on 15.01.2016 and the action of ipso-facto implementing the said report/decision, by issuing the Impugned Notification on 30.01.2016, Annexure A-1, and even the decision making process
in implementing the said recommendations/approval but without satisfying the pre-conditions expressly mandated in said recommendations/ report and that too without amending the Statutory Rules notified on 18.11.1999, Annexure A-2 is illegal; and fourthly, action of the State Authorities in adopting a pick and choose criteria, for giving the
re-revised pay
scales defeats the very object of HPCS Re-revised Pay
Rules
categories/posts
2012,
which
irrespective
is
common
to
departments
all
with this object, once the re-revised pay scale was given to 26 other categories w.e.f. 01.10.2012 by issuing a Notification on 27.09.2012 and then to
other
categories
in
Respondent-Health
on
28.09.2012, Annexure A-12, and therefore, the grant of benefit to the petitioners belatedly on 30.01.2016 [Annexure A-1] w.e.f. 01.02.2016 is unconstitutional; and fifthly, the provision of Rule 1 (ii) and Rule 9 of HPCS Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 conferring unfettered, uncanalised, unbridled and unrestricted discretion to prescribe cut-off dates, by notifying the
Schedule, for giving re-revised pay scales to employees is arbitrary, discriminatory illegal; and sixthly, Rule 8 of the HPCS Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 has been
misconstrued
contentions raised
by
State
Authorities;
in reply-affidavit are
ill-founded
as discussed hereinafter; and therefore, the Impugned Notification issued on 30.01.2016 [Annexure A-1] may be directed to be modified by giving an appropriate proportional
higher
re-revised
pay
structure
Grade Pay to the petitioners-Health Educators, over and above the re-revised pay structure and grade pay of Rs 4200 w.e.f. 1.10.2012 as was granted to feeder post holders and to other categories in the Respondent Department and also to various other categories
in other
government departments under
Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 from 01.10.2012, with prayer that the decision making process undertaken by ignoring relevant considerations and in issuing resultant Notification on 30.01.2016, Annexure A-1, by changing the nomenclature of post of petitionersHealth Educators from promotion to placement dehors
the extant Statutory Rules is arbitrary and illegal with prayer to grant a proportional higher re-revised pay scale and grade pay, over and above the pay scale and grade pay of feeder category from the date it was given to feeder post incumbents and others w.e.f. 01.10.2012 instead of giving it to promotional post
holders-petitioners
belatedly
w.e.f.
01.02.2016,
with all consequential benefits. STATUTORY RULES AND NOTIFICATIONS
8.
For
appreciating
controversy,
it
is
necessary to have a recap of Statutory Recruitment and Promotion Rules for posts of Health Educators [i.e. Promotional Post] dated 29.10.1999/18.11.1999, Annexure A-2 ; and the Recruitment and Promotion Rules for posts of Male/Female Health Supervisors, later redesignated as Multipurpose Health Supervisors [Feeder-Lower Posts] dated 12.10.1999, Annexure A-6; and the Himachal Pradesh Civil Services (Category /Post-wise Revised Pay) Rules notified on 24.09.2012 [referred to as the Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012] giving the re-revised pay to its employees ; and
Notification dated 30.01.2016, Annexure A-1, giving re-revised pay scale of Rs 10300-34800+4200 GP w.e.f 01.02.2016 to the category of the petitionersHealth Educators [promotional post holders]; and the Notification dated 28.09.2012, Annexure A-12, giving the re-revised pay scale of Rs 10300-34800+4200 GP w.e.f 01.10.2012 to Male/Female Health Supervisors, who were later redesignated as Multipurpose Health Supervisors [feeder post holders] and to 13 other categories of the Respondent-Health department by same notification; and Notification dated 27.09.2012, giving the revised pay scales under Re-revised Pay Rules w.e.f. 01.10.2012 to 26 other categories reads as under:STATUTORY RULES FOR POSTS OF HEALTH EDUCATORS-PROMOTIONAL POST-PETITIONERS:
8(i).
Respondents-State notified the Recruitment
and Promotion Rules for post of Health Educators on 29.10.1999/18.11.1999 [Annexure A-2], being a “promotional post” consisted of 77 posts and the strength was increased to 85 posts. Rule 4 stated that pay scale of post of Health Educator was Rs
5800-9200. As per Rule 7, in the case of direct recruitment, these posts were to be filled up from persons possessing Bachelor’s Degree and Diploma in Health Education or equivalent from recognized University or Institute. Rule 10 provides that posts of Health Educator were to be filled up 75% by promotion and 25% by direct recruitment and Rule 11 states that in case of promotion, posts were to be filled from Male Health Supervisors /Female Health Supervisors who possess Diploma in Health Education with five years regular service or regular combined with
continuous
adhoc
service,
failing
which
by
promotion from Male/Female Health Workers/ Cinema Technicians who possess Diploma in Health Education with 10 years regular service or regular combined with continuous adhoc service. Relevant extract of Rules for post of Health Educators, read as under:ANNEXURE A-2 29.10.1999/18.11.1999
Recruitment and Promotion Rules for the post Health Educator [Non-Gazetted], Class-III in the Department of Health and Family Welfare, Himachal Pradesh.
1.
Name of the post
Health Educator
2.
Number of posts
77 (Seventy Seven)
3.
Classification
Class-III (Non-Gazetted)
4.
Scale of Pay
Rs 5800-200-7000220-8100-275-9200
5 to …not relevant..
7.
Minimum
educational Essential Qualification:
and other qualification (i). Bachelor’s Degree or its required for direct equivalent from a recognized recruits.
university. (ii).
Diploma
in
Health
Education or its equivalent from a recognized University or institute duly recognized by
Central
/State
Government. 10.
Method of recruitment (i)
75% by promotion.
whether
25% by direct recruitment.
by
recruitment
direct (ii). or by
promotion, deputation, transfer
percentage of vacancies to be filled in by various methods 11.
In case of recruitment By promotion from amongst promotion, the Male Health Supervisor/
by deputation, grade
from
transfer, Female Health Supervisors which who
possess
Diploma
in
promotion/deputation/
Health Education with five
transfer is to be made.
years regular
regular
service
combined
or with
continuous adhoc (rendered upto 31.3. 1998) service, if any,
in
which
grade
failing
promotion
from
by
amongst
Workers/
Male
Health
Female
Health
Workers/Cinema Technicians who
possess
Diploma
Health
Education
years
regular
regular
in
with
service
or
combined
with
continuous adhoc (rendered upto
31.3.1998)
service,
any in the grade; STATUTORY RULES FOR POSTS OF MALE/ FEMALE HEALTH SUPERVISORS [RE-DESIGNATED AS MULTIPURPOSE HEALTH WORKERS]-FEEDER -LOWER POST:
8(ii).
State Authorities notified the Recruitment
and Promotion Rules for the post of Male Health Supervisors notified on 12.10.1999 [Annexure A-6], being a “feeder-post” for post of Health Educator. Rule
prescribes
that
post
is
in
pay
scale
Rs 5480-8925. As Rule 10, this post was to be filled 100% by promotion from Male Multipurpose Health Workers, who have undergone six months training of Male Health Supervisor from a recognized training
if
Institute and possess five years of regular service or regular combined with continuous adhoc service in the grade. Relevant extract of the Rules for post of Male Health Supervisor, read as under:ANNEXURE A-6 Dated: 12.10.1999
Recruitment and Promotion Rules for the post of Male Health Supervisor [Non-Gazetted], ClassIII in the Department of Health and Family Welfare, Himachal Pradesh. 1.
Name of the post
Male Health Supervisor
2.
Number of posts
[Three
hundred
Twenty-five] 3.
Classification
Class-III [Non-Gazetted]
4.
Scale of pay
Rs.
5480-160-5800-200-
7000-220-8100-8925 8.
Whether
age
and Age: Not applicable.
educational
Education Qualification:
qualifications
Not applicable.
prescribed
for
direct
recruitments will apply in case of promotes 10.
Method of recruitment 100% by promotion. whether
by
recruitment
direct or
by
promotion, deputation, transfer
percentage of vacancies to
be
filled
various method.
in
by
- 30 11.
In case of recruitment By promotion from amongst by
promotion, the Male Multipurpose Health
deputation, grades
transfer, Workers who have undergone
from
which six months training in Male
promotion / deputation Health /transfer is to be made
Supervisor
recognized
from
training
a
school
/institute and possess five years
regular
regular
service
combined
or with
continuous adhoc [rendered upto
31.3.1998]
service,
any, in the grade. …not relevant…
to
HPCS (CATEGORY/POST WISE REVISED PAY) RULES - REREVISED PAY RULES OF 2012:
8(iii).
While working as such, State Authorities
notified Himachal Pradesh Civil Services (Category/ Post-wise Revised Pay) Rules on 24.09.2012 [referred to as the Re-revised Pay Rules 2012] giving the re-revised pay scales to its employees from the date mentioned
in
Column
No
Schedule
to
be notified by State Authorities; and relevant extract of Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 read as under: GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH FINANCE (PAY REVISION) DEPARTMENT NOTIFICATION No. Fin(PR)-B(7)-64/2010-loose Dated:
24.9 2012.
if
- 31 In
exercise
powers
conferred
by
proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution of India,
Governor,
Himachal
Pradesh,
is
pleased
to
make the following rules, namely:1.
Short title and commencement:
(i)
These
rules
may
be
called
Himachal
Pradesh Civil Services (Category /Post-wise Revised Pay) Rules, 2012. (ii)
They
shall
come
into
force
with
effect
from the date as mentioned in Column
"Schedule"
appended
to
these
rules. 2.
Application: Save
as
otherwise
expressly
provided
by
or under these rules; they shall apply to only
such
categories
Himachal
Pradesh
Government employees as mentioned in the aforesaid Schedule; Provided
that
Himachal
Pradesh
Civil
Services (Revised Pay)Rules, 2009 notified vide No. Fin-(PR)B(7)-1/2009 dated: 26th August, 2009
subsequent
shall
not
apply
employees
as
to
amendments
mentioned
category/ in
thereto post
'Schedule'
with effect from the date mentioned in Column No. 6 of the said Schedule. 4.
Drawl of pay in the different Pay Structure: Save as otherwise provided in these rules, a government employee shall draw pay in
respective
pay
structure
applicable
to
the post to which he is an appointee as on the date of commencement of these rules or thereafter. 5. to 7. …not relevant… 8.
Overriding effect: The provisions of Fundamental Rules and various orders issued thereunder, from time to time, and the Himachal Pradesh Civil Services (Revised Pay) Rules, 2009, as well as various orders issued thereunder by the Himachal
Pradesh
Government
with
regard
to pay revision & fixation of pay shall not save as otherwise provided in these rules, apply
to
cases
where
pay
is
regulated
under these rules, to the extent they are inconsistent with these rules. 9.
Power to amend the Schedule: The
Government,
may
by
notification,
add to or delete from the Schedule any entry or otherwise amend the Schedule, and thereupon the Schedule shall be deemed to have been amended accordingly. 10.
Power to relax: Where the Government is satisfied that the operation
these
rules
causes
undue
hardship to any individual existing Government employee, it may, by an order in writing, relax or dispense with any of the provisions of these rules to such extent and subject to
such
conditions,
as
it
may
consider
necessary. 11.
Interpretation: If any question arises relating to the interpretation of any of the provisions of these rules, the Government shall decide the same. BY ORDER Sd/PRINCIPAL SECRETARY (FINANCE) TO GOVT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH
NOTICATION DATED 30.01.2016 [ANNEXURE A-1] GIVING BENEFIT OF RE-REVISED PAY SCALE TO PETITIONERS-HEALTH EDUCATORS W.E.F. 01.02.2016
8(iv).
Pertinently,
in
terms
Recruitment
and Promotion Rules for Health Educators of 1999 vide Annexure A-2, Health Educators [i.e. promotional post holders] were given the pay scale of Rs 5800 -9200 w.e.f. 1.1.1996. After the revision of pay scale as per the HPCS (Revised Pay) Rules notified on 26.08.2009 [Annexure A-3], they were given revised pay scale of Rs 10300-34800+3800 GP w.e.f 01.01. 2006 but after issuance of the Himachal Pradesh Civil Services (Category/Post-wise Revised Pay) Rules on 24.09.2012 [referred to as the Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012], petitioners, who were initially not granted
re-revised
pay
benefits,
were
granted
re-revised pay scale of Rs 10300-34800+4200 GP w.e.f.
01.02.2016,
by
issuing
a
Notification
on
30.01.2016, Annexure A-1, reads as under:ANNEXURE A-1 Dated: 30.01.2016 GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH FINANCE (PAY REVISION) DEPARTMENT NOTIFICATION NoFin(PR)-B(7)-64/2010-II-Loose Dated: 30.01.2016
In exercise of the powers conferred by Rule
Himachal
Pradesh
Civil
Services
(Category/Post wise Revised Pay) Rules 2012, read
with
Rule
rules
ibid,
Governor
Himachal Pradesh, is pleased to add the following words and figures after Sr No 15 under Heading “12. HEALTH & FAMILY WELFARE DEPARTMENT”
Schedule
appended
vide
this
Department’s
number
dated
notified even
28th
to
rules
notifications
September,
2012
ibid
30th August, 2014, categories/posts in the Schedule to the rules ibid, as under: 12. HEALTH & FAMILY WELFARE DEPARTMENT Sr. No.
Name category/post.
Pay Band
Grade Pay
Remarks, any
(2)
(3)
(4)
(5)
Health Educator
1030034800
4200
(1) 16.
B
if
To be given by placement
Date from which applicable (6) 01.02.2016
By Order Sd/Addl. Chief Secretary (Finance) to the Government of Himachal Pradesh
NOTICATION DATED 28.09.2012 [ANNEXURE A-12] GIVING RE-REVISED PAY SCALE TO 13 OTHER CATEGORIES INCLUDING FEEDER POSTS IN HEALTH DEPARTMENT W.E.F. 01.10.2012:
8(v). were
Notably, working
on
some
posts
incumbents
Male/Female
who Health
Supervisors [redesignated as Male/Female Multipurpose Health
Supervisors]
[i.e.
feeder
post
holders]
in
lower pay scale of Rs 5480-8925 w.e.f. 1.1.1996. After revision of pay scales as per the HPCS (Revised Pay) Rules notified on 26.08.2009 [Annexure A-3], were given
revised
pay
scale
Rs
10300-34800+3600
GP w.e.f 01.01.2006 but on issuance of Himachal Pradesh
Civil
Services
(Category/Post-wise
Revised
Pay) Rules on 24.09.2012 [referred to as Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012], these feeder post holders were given the re-revised pay scales of Rs 10300-34800 + 4200 GP w.e.f. 01.10.2012 and besides the feeder category, as referred to above, 13 other categories of employees of Health Department were given the re-revised pay scales w.e.f 01.10.2012 on 28.09.2012 [Annexure A-12], in following terms:-
Annexure A-12 Dated: 28.09.2012
GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH FINANCE (PAY REVISION) DEPARTMENT NOTIFICATION No. Fin (PR) – B (7) – 64 / 2010-Dated: Shimla 28.09.2012 In exercise of the powers conferred by Rule
Himachal
Pradesh
Civil
Services
(Category /Post wise Revised Pay) Rules 2012, read with Rule
of rules ibid, the Governor,
Himachal Pradesh, is pleased to add the following categories /posts in the Schedule to the rules ibid, as under: Sr No
Name category/ post (2)
(1) 1.
Pay Band
Grade Pay
Remarks, any
(4)
(5)
if
Date from which applicable (6)
(3) Staff Nurse
(i) 1030034800 (ii) 1030034800
3200
13500 Initial Start
Already existing
4600
This PB & GP will be given after 2 years regular service -----
01.10.2012
2.
Sister Tutor/Public Health Nurse [Teaching]
1030034800
4800
3.
Matron
1560039100
5400
-----
01.10.2012
4.
Nursing Superintendent/ Principal Nursing Officer Multipurpose Health Supervisor (Male & Female) Senior Laboratory Technician
1560039100
6600
----
01.10.2012
1030034800
4200
-----
01.10.2012
(i) 1030034800
3200
13500 Initial Start
5.
6.
01.10.2012
Already existing
- 37 (ii) 1030034800
3600
01.10.2012
01.10.2012
7.
Chief Pharmacist
1030034800
8.
Pharmacist
(i) 591020200
3000
11470 Initial Start
Already existing
(ii) 1030034800
4200
This PB &GP will be given after 2 years regular service
01.10.2012
(i) 591020200
2800
11170 Initial Start
Already existing
(ii) 1030034800
3200
This PB & GP will be given after 2 years regular service
01.10.2012
i) 591020200
3000
11470 Initial Start
Already existing
(ii) 1030034800
3600
This PB & GP will be given after 2 years regular service -----
01.10.2012
01.10.2012
2000
8240 Initial Start
Already existing
2400
This PB & GP will be given after 2 years regular service 11470 Initial Start
01.10.2012
This PB & GP will be given after 2
01.10.2012
9.
10.
Multipurpose Health Worker [Male & Female]
Radiographer
11.
Senior Radiographer
1030034800
12.
Operation Theatre Assistant
i) 591020200 (ii) 591020200
13.
Food Inspector (H & FW)
i) 591020200 (ii) 1030034800
4600
This PB &GP will be given after 2 years regular service -----
4200
3000
4200
Already existing
years regular service.
14.
Trained Dais
B y O r d
i) 490010680
1400
6700 Initial Start
Already existing
(ii) 490010680
1800
This PB & GP will be given after 2 years regular service
01.10.2012
BY ORDER Sd/Principal Secretary (Finance) Government of Himachal Pradesh
NOTICATION DATED 27.09.2012 GIVING THE BENEFIT OF RE-REVISED PAY SCALE TO 26 OTHER CATEGORIES IN OTHER DEPARTMENT W.E.F. 01.10.2012:
8(vi).
Besides the above, Learned Senior Counsel
asserts that there were many other categories of employees of other departments, who were given the revised pay scales w.e.f. 1.1.1996 and on revision of pay scales as per the HPCS (Revised Pay) Rules notified on 26.08.2009 [Annexure A-3], their pay scales were revised w.e.f 01.01.2006 but on issuance of Himachal Pradesh Civil Services (Category/Post-wise Revised Pay) Rules on 24.09.2012 [referred to as the Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012], these categories were given the re-revised pay scales w.e.f. 01.10.2012 as per Notification issued by the State Authorities
on 27.09.2012 [Taken on record], read as under: GOVERNMENT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH FINANCE (PAY REVISION) DEPARTMENT NOTIFICATION No.Fin(PR)-B(7)-64/2010-Dated: Shimla 7.09.2012
In exercise of the powers conferred by Rule
Himachal
Pradesh
Civil
Services
(Category /Post wise Revised Pay) Rules, 2012, read with Rule 3 of rules ibid, the Governor, Himachal Pradesh, is pleased to add the following categories /posts
in
Schedule
to
rules
ibid,
as
under: Sr No (1) 1.
Name category/ post (2) Junior Technician
Grade Pay
Remarks, any
(3) (i) 5910 20200
(4) 1900
(5) 7810 Initial Start
2400
01.10.2012
(ii) 591020200
if
Date from which applicable (6) Already existing
Pay Band
2.
Technician GradeII
5910 20200
2800
This PB & GP will be given after 2 years regular service ----
3.
Technician Grade-I
1030034800
3200
-----
01.10.2012
4.
Chargeman Grade-II/Assistant Foreman
(i) 591020200
3000
11470 Initial Start
Already existing
(ii) 1030034800
3200
This PB & GP will be given after 2 years regular service ----
01.10.2012
01.10.2012
13500
Already
5.
Chargeman Grade-I
1030034800
6.
Foreman Grade-II
i)
3600
01.10.2012
7. 8.
9.
Foreman Grade-I Junior Draftsman
Draftsman
1030034800 ii) 1030034800
3200
Initial Start
existing
3600
01.10.2012
1030034800 (i) 591020200
3800
This PB & GP will be given after 2 years regular service -----
01.10.2012
3000
11470 Initial Start
Already existing
(ii) 1030034800
3200
This PB & GP will be given after 2 years regular service
01.10.2012
(i) 1030034800
3800
11590 Initial Start
(ii) 1030034800
4200
01.10.2012
2400
This PB &GP will be given after 2 years regular service ------
2800
------
01.10.2012
10.
Restorer
11.
Record Supervisor
12.
Driver [Heavy, Light, Commercial vehicles & staff cars of various departments)
i) 591020200
2000
8240 Initial Start
Already existing
(ii) 5910 20200
2400
01.10.2012
Peon, Chowkidar, Sweeper, Mali, Bhishti, Frash & all other Class-IV
(i) 4900 10680
This PB & GP will be given after 2 years regular service 6200 Initial Start
01.10.2012
Head Mali, Jamadar & Record
490010680
This PB & GP will be given after 2 years regular service ----
13.
14.
(i) 591020200 591020200
Already existing
(ii) 490010680
1300
1650
1800
01.10.2012
Already existing
01.10.2012
15.
Lifter Clerk
i) 591020200 (ii) 1030034800
1900
7810 Initial Start
Already existing
3200
01.10.2012
16.
Junior Assistant
1030034800
3600
This PB & GP will be given after 2 years regular service. ----
17.
Senior Assistant
1030034800
4400
----
01.10.2012
18.
Superintendent Grade-II
1030034800
4800
----
01.10.2012
19.
Superintendent Grade-I
1560039100
5400
----
01.10.2012
20.
Steno Typist
i) 2000
8240 Initial Start
Already existing
(ii) 1030034800
3200
This PB & GP will be given after 2 years regular service.
01.10.2012
i) 1030034800
3200
13500 Initial Start
Already existing
(ii) 1030034800
3600
01.10.2012
591020200
21.
Jr. Scale Stenographer
01.10.2012
22.
Senior Scale Stenographer
1030034800
4400
This PB & GP will be given after 2 years regular service. ----
23.
Personal Assistant
1030034800
4800
----
01.10.2012
24.
Private Secretary
15600 39100
5400
----
01.10.2012
25.
Junior Auditor
i) 1030034800 ii) 10300-
3800
14590 Initial Start
01.10.2012
4400
This
PB
&
01.10.2012
34800
26.
Senior Auditor (Non-SAS)
1030034800
GP will be given after 2 years regular service. ----
4800
01.10.2012
By ORDER Sd/Principal Secretary (Finance) to Government of Himachal Pradesh
ANALYSIS OF CONTENTIONS OF PETITIONERS:
9.
Now, this Court proceeds to analyze the
contentions of Learned Senior Counsel for petitioners, hereinunder: GIVING SAME RE-REVISED PAY STRUCTURE FOR PROMOTIONAL POST AND FEEDER POST ILLEGAL:
10.
First contention of Learned Senior Counsel
is that the action of the State Authorities in giving same re-revised pay scale to the petitioners-Health Educators i.e. holders of promotional-higher posts as was granted to holders of feeder-lower post of Male /Female
Health
Supervisors
[later
redesignated
as
Multipurpose Health Supervisors] is illegal. 10(i).
Minimal
facts
required
for
analyzing
above contention are the State Authorities notified the Recruitment and Promotion Rules for the post
of Health Educators [i.e. promotional-higher post] under the provisio to Article 309 of the Constitution of India on 29.10.1999/18.11.1999 [Annexure A-2], carrying the pay scale of Rs 5800-9200; and Rule 7 provided that these posts were to be filled up from
persons
possessing
Bachelor’s
Degree
Diploma in Health Education or its equivalent from recognized University or Institute ; and further Rule 10 provided that posts of Health Educator were to be filled up 25% by direct recruitment and 75% by promotion, from feeder category of Male/Female Health Supervisors [later redesignated as Multipurpose Health Supervisors] possessing qualification of Diploma in Health Education. After the revision of pay scales by
virtue
HPCS
(Revised
Pay)
Rules
notified
on 26.08.2009, [Annexure A-3], the petitioners being Health Educators were given the revised pay scale of Rs 10300-34800
+ 3800 GP w.e.f
01.01.2006;
and thirdly, even after the issuance of the Himachal Pradesh
Civil
Services
(Category/Post-wise
Revised
Pay) Rules on 24.09.2012 [referred as the Re-revised
Pay Rules of 2012], the petitioners-Health Educators were given the re-revised pay scale of Rs 1030034800 + 4200 GP w.e.f. 01.02.2016, by issuing a Notification on 30.01.2016, Annexure A-1. On the other hand, there existed another category of Male /Female Health Supervisors [feeder-lower post] for which,
State
Government
notified
Recruitment
and Promotion Rules on 12.10.1999, [Annexure A-6], prescribing the pay scale of Rs 5480-8925 to them. After the revision of pay scales by virtue of the HPCS (Revised Pay) Rules notified on 26.08.2009, [Annexure A-3], the feeder-lower category was given the revised pay scale of Rs 10300-34800 + 3600 GP w.e.f 01.01.2006 ; and sixthly, even after issuance of the HPCS (Category/Post-wise Revised Pay) Rules on 24.09.2012 [referred as the Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012], they were placed in the re-revised pay scale of Rs 10300-34800 + 4200 GP w.e.f. 01.10.2012 by issuing a Notification on 28.09.2012, Annexure A-12. HIERARCHICAL STRUCTURE OF PROMOTIONAL POST OF HEALTH EDUCATORS ESTABLISHED
- 45 BY RECRUITMENT VIOLATED:
10(ii).
AND
PROMOTION
RULES
Above facts establish that once the posts
held by the petitioners of Health Educators was a
promotional
post
and though petitioners were
granted the pay scale of Rs 5800-9200 in terms
Recruitment
Promotion
Rules
notified
on 29.10.1999/18.11.1999 [Annexure A-2], and were given the Revised Pay Scale of Rs 10300-34800 + 3800 GP w.e.f. 01.01.2006 and were the Re-revised Pay Scale of
Rs
10300-34800
+
4200
GP
w.e.f.
01.02.2016 as per Notification issued on 30.01.2016, Annexure A-1, whereas, the category of Male/Female Health Supervisors, later redesigned as Multipurpose Health Supervisors
[i.e. feeder-lower post] in terms
of the Recruitment and Promotion Rules notified on 12.10.1999 [Annexure A-6], were placed in the pay scale of Rs 5480-8925 and were given the Revised Pay
Scale
01.01.2006
Rs
Pay Scale of
Rs
10300-34800 they
were
+
3600
GP
given
Re-revised
4200
GP
10300-34800
+
from
w.e.f.
01.10.2012 by issuing a Notification on 28.09.2012
Annexure A-12. 10(iii).
Material
petitioners
despite
on
record
being
establishes,
promotional
that
post
holders
were given lower pay structure of Rs 10300-34800 + 3800 GP w.e.f. 01.10.2012 till 01.02.2016 whereas feeder post holders were given higher pay structure
Rs
10300-34800
+4200
GP
w.e.f.
01.10.2012
till 01.02.2016. Action of the State Authorities in giving
lower
pay
structure
to
petitioners,
despite
being holders of promotional posts
while granting
higher
posts
pay
structure
to
feeder
holders
is unsustainable, for the reason, firstly, this action establishes
grave
absurdity
anomaly
petitioners-promotional post holders
between
vis-à-vis
feeder
post holders; and secondly, this action violates the established higher hierarchical status, rank, position and pay scale recognized by the Statutory Rules to
petitioners; and thirdly, the action of the
State Authorities in giving the lower pay structure [pay scale and grade pay] to the promotional post holders-petitioners-Health
Educators
vis-à-vis
feeder
post holders by granting them higher pay structure during the period from 01.10.2012 till 01.02.2016 was
ex-facie
violative
Articles
the Constitution of India; and fourthly, the action of granting lower pay structure to promotional post holders {petitioners} while giving higher pay
structure
to feeder post holders is violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution, and lastly, the action of giving lower pay to the promotional posts holders {petitioners} and in giving the higher re-revised pay to feeder post holders is violative of the broader principles outlined in the cases of Sunder Lal Jain vs State of Haryana, 1995 (1) SLR 215, [against which SLP © Diary No 9475 of 1995, titled as State of Haryana vs Sunder Lal Jain was dismissed by the Honble Supreme Court on 28.08.1995], and the reiteration of the similar principle in the case of Tarsem Singh vs State of Punjab, (1994) 5 SCC 392, which was followed in the case of Mehar Chand & another vs State of Punjab, 2013 SCC Online PH 20428 and reaffirmation of aforesaid principle
by the Honble Supreme Court in the case of State of Uttar Pradesh and another vs Virendera Bahadur Katheria and others (2024) 15 SCC 1, mandating that the State is obliged to ensure that the pay structure of a promotional/higher post is not lower than the pay structure of the feeder cadre, in the following terms: 53. It needs no emphasis that prescription of pay scale for a post entails Policy decision based upon the recommendations of an expert body like Pay Commission. All
that
State
is
obligated
to
ensure is that the pay structure of a promotional or higher post is not lower than the feeder cadre. Similarly, pay
parity
cannot
indefeasible except
be
enforceable
where
claimed right
Competent
as
an
save
Authority
has taken a conscious decision to equate two posts notwithstanding their different nomenclature
or
distinct
qualifications.
Incidental grant of same pay scale to two or more posts, without any express equation be
amongst
termed
as
an
such
posts,
anomaly
in
cannot a
pay
scale of a nature which can be said to have infringed the right to equality under Article 16 of our Constitution.
- 49 ANAMOULOUS REMEDIED:
10(iv).
SITUATION
NEEDS
TO
BE
Considering the mater in aforesaid terms,
action
State
Authorities
in
giving
a
lower pay structure [pay scale and grade pay] to promotional post holders-petitioners-Health Educators but in giving higher pay structure to the feeder post
holders
01.02.2016
for
period
from
01.10.2012
establishes
gross
anomaly
in
pay
till
promotional post of the petitioners-Health Educators vis-à-vis lower post of Male/Female Health Supervisors [redesignated
as
Multipurpose
Health
Supervisors]
being wholly absurd, arbitrary and is contrary to foundational principles of service jurisprudence and is violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. Resultantly, this anomalous situation cannot sustain and is interdicted by this Court, with the directions to the State Authorities to remedy the illegality,
with
mandate
to
grant
an
appropriate
proportional higher pay structure to petitioners, who are promotional post holders, over and above the
pay structure of the feeder post w.e.f. 01.02.2012 till 01.02.2016 and thereafter. ACTION OF EQUATING TWO UNEQUAL AND DISSIMILAR POSTS - PROMOTIONAL POST AND FEEDER POST ILLEGAL:
11.
Second contention of Learned Senior Counsel
is that the decision-making process in equating two unequal posts, having wholesale dissimilarity i.e. the promotional post of the petitioners-Health Educators with
the lower-feeder post of Male/Female Health
Supervisors [as Multipurpose Health Supervisors] is illegal. For appreciating the above contention, it is necessary to have a reap of broad legal principles governing invocability of “equal pay for equal work and equal value” and the exceptions thereto and “principles governing the pay fixation” and “equation and equivalence of posts” are detailed hereinunder. MANDATE OF LAW APPROVING EVENTUALITIES FOR CARVING OUT DIFFERENTIAL TREATMENT TO EMPLOYEES:
11(i).
In normal parlance, the determination and
prescription of pay scales to employees lies within domain of executive. However, in case, an employee
asserts a claim for parity in pay and/or pay scales then, such a claim can sustain, in case an employee establishes “Equal Pay for Equal Work and Equal Value”. Legal
precedents,
as
discussed
here
in
below, have carved out an exception, where principle of “Equal Pay for Equal Work and Equal Value” cannot be invoked, if educational qualifications are different; mode of selection is different, the quality of work
produced
the nature of work assigned
or performable make a difference; and the qualitative difference
as
regards
reliability
responsibility
make a difference. 11(ii).
The
foundational
principles of Article
of the Constitution of India, cannot be applied, for purposes
pay
scales,
where
an
employee
was
not similarly placed or such an employee was given higher
scale
qualifications,
in
view
which
is
his
valid
higher
educational
classification
having
a reasonable differentia; with the mandate that the grant of two different pay scales is suggestive of the
fact that the duties and functions of a post are different, as mandated by the Three Judges of the Honble Supreme Court in the case of Government of West Bengal vs Tarun Kumar Roy, (2004) 1 SCC 347, in the following terms:15.
In State of J & K vs Triloki Nath Khosla, this Court has held: Educational recognized criterion
qualifications by
for
this
have
been
Court
as
a
safe
determining
validity
of classification." 16.
The Post of Operator-cum-Mechanic and Sub-Assistant
Engineers
are
technical
posts. As noticed hereinbefore, whereas for the posts of Operator-cum-Mechanic
qualification
school
final
examination and a certificate obtained from
Industrial
Training
institute
would be sufficient; for the posts of Sub -Assistant
Engineer
person
must
have a diploma from a polytechnic apart from being a matriculate. 20.
Question of violation of Article 14 of the Constitution of India on the part of the State would arise only if the persons are similarly placed. Equality Clause
contained
in
Article
14,
in
other words, will have no application where the persons are not similarly
- 53 situated
or
when
there
is
a
valid
classification based on a reasonable differentia. Doctrine of 'equal pay for equal work', therefore is not attracted in the instant case. 22.
The very fact that from the very beginning two
different
pay
scales
were
being
maintained is itself suggestive of the fact that the duties and functions are also different. In fact it is not disputed that the two post of Sub-Assistant Engineer is a higher post.
11(iii).
Differentiation in pay scales on the basis
of degree of responsibility, reliability confidentiality was approved by Three Judges of the Honble Supreme Court in the case of SBI vs M R Ganesh Babu, (2002) 4 SCC 556, in following terms: 16. The principle of equal pay for equal work has been considered and applied in many reported decisions of this Court. The
principle
has
been
adequately
explained and crystalized and sufficiently reiterated in a catena of decisions of this Court. It is well settled that equal pay must depend upon the nature of work done. It cannot be judged by the mere volume of work, there may be qualitative difference as regards reliability and responsibility. Functions may be the
same but the responsibilities make a difference. One cannot deny that often the difference is a matter of degree and that there is an element of value judgment by
those
who
are
charged
with
administration in fixing the scales of pay and other conditions of service. So long as such value judgment is made bonafide, reasonably on an intelligible criterion which has a rational nexus with the object of differentiation, such differentiation
will
not
amount
discrimination. The principle is not always easy to apply as there are inherent difficulties in comparing and evaluating the work done by different persons in different organizations, or even in the same
Differentiation
organization.
in
pay scales of persons holding same posts on
degree
performing
basis
similar
difference
responsibility,
work
in
reliability
and confidentiality would be a valid differentiation…
11(iv).
Different
pay
scales
given
on
basis
of qualities or characteristics having a reasonable relation with the object sought to be achieved on the basis of merit or experience and educational qualifications
in
combination
with
former
or
in
isolation shall be justified, as mandated by Three Judges of the Honble Supreme Court in the case of State of Haryana vs Charanjit Singh, (2006) 9 SCC 321, in the following terms: 19.
Having considered the authorities and the submissions we are of the view that the authorities in the cases
Jasmer Singh, Tilak Raj, Orissa University
Agriculture
&
Technology
Tarun K. Roy lay down the correct law. Undoubtedly, the doctrine of "equal pay for
equal
work"
is
not
an
abstract
doctrine and is capable of being enforced in a Court of law. But equal pay must be for equal work of equal value. The principle of "equal pay for equal work" has no mechanical application in every case.
Article
permits
reasonable
classification
based
on
qualities
characteristics
persons
or
recruited
and grouped together, as against those who
were
left
out.
Of
course,
qualities or characteristics must have a reasonable relation to the object sought
to
be
achieved.
In
service
matters, merit or experience can be a
proper
basis
for
classification
for
the purposes of pay in order to promote efficiency
in
administration.
A
higher
pay scale to avoid stagnation or resultant
- 56 frustration
for
lack
promotional
avenues is also an acceptable reason for
pay
differentiation.
The
very
fact
that the person has not gone through the process of recruitment may itself, in
certain
cases,
make
a
difference.
If the educational qualifications are different, then also the doctrine may have
no
application.
Even
though
persons may do the same work, their quality of work may differ. Where persons are selected by a Selection Committee on the basis of merit with due regard to seniority a higher pay scale granted to
such
persons
by
competent
who
are
authority
evaluated
cannot
be
challenged. A classification based on difference in educational qualifications justifies a difference in pay scales. ….”.
11(v).
The equality clause in Article 14 can be
invoked in the matter of pay scales, only when, there is wholesome/wholesale identity between the two posts, as has been mandated by Three Judges of the Honble Supreme Court in Steel Authority of India and others vs Dibyendu Bhattacharya, (2011) 11 SCC 122, in following terms: 31. ...Unless there is complete and wholesale
wholesome identity between the two posts they should not be treated as equivalent and the Court should avoid applying the principle of equal pay for equal work.
11(vi).
The claim for parity or equation of posts
Difference in pay scales shall entail on the basis of dominant and primary nature of duties of a post and once there is no comparison between two posts, then, in such an eventuality, unequal and dissimilar posts cannot be equated for purposes of pay, in terms
broad
principles
mandated
by
Honble
Supreme Court in the case of State of Punjab vs Jagjit Singh, (2017) 1 SCC 148. BROAD PARAMETRES FOR FIXING THE PAY SCALES AND FOR DETERMINING EQUIVALENCE VIOLATED:
11(vii).
The factors for fixing the pay scales and
for determining the equivalence of posts has been spelt out by the Honble Supreme Court in Punjab State Power Corporation vs Rajesh Kumar Jindal and Others (2019) 3 SCC 547, in following terms: Burden of proof on the person claiming parity of pay scale:
- 58 20.
Ordinarily, the scale of pay is fixed keeping
in
view
several
factors
i.e.
21.
(i)
method of recruitment;
(ii)
level at which recruitment is made;
(iii)
the hierarchy of service in a given cadre;
(iv)
minimum educational/technical qualifications required;
(v)
avenues of promotion;
(vi)
the nature of duties and responsibilities; and
(vii)
employer’s capacity to pay, etc.
It is well settled that for considering the equation of posts and the issue of equivalence
posts,
following
factors had been held to be determinative :
26.
(i)
The nature and duties of a post;
(ii)
The responsibilities and powers exercised by the officer holding a post, the extent of territorial or other charge held or responsibilities discharged;
(iii)
The minimum qualifications, if any, prescribed for recruitment to the post; and
(iv)
The salary of the post (vide Union of India and Another vs P.K. Roy and Others AIR 1968 SC 850).
Considering the differences in the nature of duties and responsibilities performed by the Head Clerks and Internal Auditors Pay
Anomaly
Committee
decided
to
- 59 allow
revised
scale
for
Internal
Auditor at Rs. 1800-3200 with benefit of promotional increments and Rs 2000 -3500 for Head Clerks. Merely because Internal Group
Auditors XII
are
categorized
with
Head
Clerks,
Auditors
cannot
claim
along
Internal
in
parity as the nature of duties and responsibilities
Internal
Auditors
are different from Head Clerks. FOUNDATIONAL TEST OF COMPETE PARITY FOR EQUATION/EQUIVALENCE:
11(viii). where,
Equation complete
in
pay
parity
in
scales
can
source
be
invoked
recruitment,
educational qualifications, and experience, mode of appointment through a Constitutional process, and the nature of responsibilities and accountability, is established and after taking note of the principles in State of Bihar vs Bihar Secondary Teachers Struggle Committee, (2019) 18 SCC 301, the Honble Supreme Court reaffirmed the scope of interference only in case of infraction of the principle of equal pay for equal work and equal value, in the case of G P Sangeetha and Ors vs State of Kerela and Ors, Civil Appeal No 7565-7567 of 2021, decided
on 08.09.2026 [2026 INSC 1004] in the following terms: 8.
In
last
decision
in
century,
Randhir
following
Singh
v.
Union
of India this Court treated equal pay for equal work as an expansive antiexploitation principle under Articles 14 and 39(d), where the mere sameness
designation-teacher
with
teacher,
accountant with accountant, clerk with clerk, driver with driver, etc. was sufficient to claim parity. In this century, however, beginning with the decision in State Bank of India vs. M.R. Ganesh Babu
ending
Bihar
with
State
Secondary
Bihar
Teachers
vs.
Struggle
Committee, the doctrine has been recast as a strict test based on service rules. Decisions
are
legion
that
equal
pay
cannot be claimed by merely showing identical
work;
claimant-employee
must establish complete parity in the source
recruitment,
educational
qualifications and experience, mode of appointment
through
a
constitutional
process, and nature of responsibilities
accountability.
Mere
functional
similarity of work has been held to be no longer enough. 13.
It is, therefore, clear on reading the relevant precedents that a mechanical
application
doctrine
equal
pay for equal work has to be eschewed. It
is
not
law
that
doctrine
can never be enforced; but, for such enforcement,
a
host
factors
need
consideration. If there is complete parity qua all such factors and should equal pay equal
be
claimed value,
for
equal writ
work
court
can
intervene and grant appropriate relief; otherwise not. EQUATION-EQUIVALENCE OF PAY STRUCTURE WHICH LEADS TO ANAMOLY UNSUSTAINABLE:
11(ix).
Parity or equation or equivalence of pay
scales cannot be invoked, where, rationalization of pay structure throws up anomalies. Such a carefully evolved
pay
structure
ought
not
to
be
ordinarily
disturbed as it may upset the balance and cause avoidable ripples in other cadres as well. Interference by the Courts is invokable in case a grave error had crept in, needs to be remedied, so as to undo justice, as mandated of the Honble Supreme Court in the case of Secretary Finance Department and Others vs West Bengal West Bengal Registration
Service Association, 1993 Supp (1) SCC 153, in the following terms: 12.
We do not consider it necessary to traverse the case law on which reliance has been placed by counsel for the appellants equation
as
it
is
posts
well-settled
that
determination
of pay-scales is the primary function of the executive and not the judiciary and,
therefore,
ordinarily
courts
will
not enter upon the task of job evaluation which is generally left to expert bodies like the Pay Commission, etc. But that is not to say that the Court has no
jurisdiction
aggrieved
employees have no remedy if they are unjustly treated by arbitrary state action
or
inaction.
Courts
must,
however, realize that job evaluation is both
a difficult
time
consuming
task which even expert bodies having the assistance of staff with requistite expertise have found difficult to undertake sometimes
on
account
want
relevant data and scales for evaluating performances
different
groups
employees. This would call for a constant study of the external comparisons and internal relativities on account of the changing The
nature
factors
job
requirements.
which
may
have
to
be
kept in view for job evaluation may include (i) the work programme of his department (ii) the nature of contribution expected of him (iii) the extent of his responsibility and accountability in the discharge
his
diverse
duties
functions (iv) the extent and nature of freedoms/limitations available or imposed on him in the discharges of his duties (v)
extent
powers
vested
in
him (vi) the extent of his dependence on superiors for
the exercise of his
powers
need
(vii)
to
co-ordinate
with other departments, etc. We have also
referred
to
history
service and the effort of various bodies to
reduce
total
number
pay-
scales to a reasonable number. Such reduction in the number of pay-scales has
to
broad
be
achieved
banding
by
posts
resorting by
to
placing
different posts having comparable job -charts in a common scale. Substantial reduction in the number of pay-scales must
inevitably
lead
to
clubbing
posts
and grades which were earlier
different and unequal. While doing so care must be taken to ensure that such rationalization of the pay structure does not throw up anomalies. Ordinarily a pay structure is evolved keeping in mind several factors, e.g., (i) method
- 64 of
recruitment,
(ii)
level
at
which
recruitment is made, (iii) the hierarchy of service in a given cadre, (iv) minimum educational/technical qualification required
(v) avenues of promotion, (vi) the nature of duties and responsibilities, (vii) the horizontal and vertical relativities with similar jobs, (viii) public dealings, (ix) satisfaction level, (x) employer's capacity to pay, etc. We have referred to these matters in some detail only to emphasize that several factors have to be kept in view while evolving a pay structure and the horizontal and vertical relativities have to be carefully balanced keeping in mind the hierarchical arrangements, avenues
for
promotion,
etc.
Such
a
carefully evolved pay structure ought not to be ordinarily disturbed as it may
upset
balance
cause
avoidable ripples in other cadres as well. It is presumably for this reason that
strongly
Judicial
Secretary
recommended
a
who had substantial
hike in the salary of the Sub- Registrars to the Second (State) Pay Commission found it difficult to concede the demand made by the registration service before him in his capacity as the Chairman of the Third (State) Pay Commission. There can, therefore, be no doubt that equation
posts
equation
salaries is a complex matter which is best left to an expert body unless there is cogent material on record to come to a firm conclusion that a grave error had
crept in
while
fixing the
pay
scale for a given post and Court's interference
is
absolutely
necessary
to undo the injustice.
Considering the factual matrix in the light of the mandate of law as discussed hereinabove, this Court is of the considered
view, that
claim
of Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioners has force and the stand of the State Authorities cannot stand the test of judicial scrutiny, for the reason, firstly, it is established on record that the aforesaid two posts have different nomenclature in terms of Statutory Rules notified under the provisio to Article 309 of the Constitution of India ; and secondly, the historical
genesis
establish
that
both
these
posts
were given different revised pay scales atleast w.e.f 01.01.1996 and difference in pay scales of two posts was duly recognized by the Statutory Rules i.e. the Recruitment and Promotion Rules of both respective
posts; and thirdly, even after revision of pay scales both these posts were given the different revised pay
scales
by
virtue
HPCS
(RP)
Rules
dated
26.08.2009 w.e.f. 01.01.2006; and fourthly, a perusal
posts
Recruitment
Promotion
petitioners-Health
Rules
Educators
for
notified
on 29.10.1999/18.11.1999, Annexure A-2, mandates that promotional posts of Health Educators were to be
filled
75%
by
promotion
from
amongst
feeder category of Male/Female Health Supervisors [redesignated
as
Male/Female
Multipurpose
Health
Supervisors]; and fifthly, a comparative reading of Statutory Rules i.e. the Recruitment and Promotion Rules of both the posts i.e. promotional posts and feeder
posts
establish
that
both
posts
have
wholesome dissimilarity in relation to the foundational parameters of two posts; and sixthly, two posts are governed by separate Statutory Rules framed under the provisio to Article 309 of the Constitution of India; and seventhly, in terms of the Statutory Rules the aforesaid two posts have conceptually altogether
different conditions of service and eighthly, a bare perusal of Statutory Rules establish that the essential qualifications
for
both
these
posts
at
variance, as essential qualifications for
entirely
at
promotional
posts of Health Educator (petitioners) is Bachelor’s Degree with Diploma in Health Education whereas essential qualifications for the feeder post of Male /Female
Health
Supervisors
[redesignated
renamed
as Multipurpose Health Supervisors] is Matric with Science or Higher Secondary or equivalent with and one and a half year training certificate as Female Health
Worker
from
a
recognized
institute
;
ninthly, even method of recruitment of two posts is at complete variance, as the promotional post of Health Educators has an element of direct recruitment and promotion and in both eventualities {direct or promotion} the requirement of essential qualifications
Bachelors and Diploma in Health
mandatory whereas
in case of feeder
Educator
is
post, same
is to be filled 100% by promotion from the next lower category of Male/Female Health Workers who
are matriculates with Science or Higher Secondary with training of Female Health Worker; and tenthly, material on record establishes wholesome functional dissimilarity between two posts, in relation to nature of work, job, duties, functions, responsibilities being at variance; and a perusal of Supplementary Affidavit dated 05.01.2026 filed by State Authorities, placing on
record
Health
job
Educators
profile
{petitioners}
promotional post
feeder
category
of Male/Female Health Supervisors [later redesignated as Multipurpose Health Supervisors] and the basic feeder category of Female Health Workers is annexed as Annexure R-3/A, and perusal of the job profile of post of Health Educators {at page 259} establishes that this post is superior post at the Block Level at Primary Health Centre level, who has to provide support to all National Health and Family Welfare Programmes, having multifarious and arduous duties and functions including conducting training of the Health Workers under various schemes to organize in cooperation with Local Voluntary Agency, School
Teachers and to complete set of educational aids for training purposes, and to coordinate inter-sectoral coordination
Health
Educators
at
Block
Level
Family Welfare Committee by acting as a resource person
to
liaison
with
media
units
for
organizing mass communication programme and to conduct educational, motivational and communication programme
in
PHC’s
to
support,
guide
supervise field workers and to ensure the utilization
information
whereas
on
other
hand,
job profile of feeder post holders {at Page 252} of Male/Female
Health
Supervisors
[redesignated
as
Multipurpose
Health
Supervisors]
establishes
that
feeder post holders are to foresee six sub-centers and to supervise and guide the health workers by strengthening their knowledge and skills by visiting their health centers once a week. Job profile of feeder post holders-Health Supervisors provides that it is a team work and such supervisors are under obligation to check the stores of sub-centers and to scrutinize records maintained by health workers
in sub-centers under their control and to ensure /supervise
malaria
symptoms
take
remedial
measures for its control and to ensure environmental sanitation,
female
nutrition
medical
care
in
primary health centers, inquire the health education, carry
out
educational
activities
communicable diseases, etc. is
for
control
to be ensured by
them and the foundational-basic health workers are Male/Female
Health
Workers
with
job
profile
{at
page 245 of the paper book and lastly, the material on record, including the Statutory Rules and the Job Profile of the two posts of Health Educators
Male/Female
Health
Supervisors
[redesignated
as Multipurpose Health Supervisors] establish that there
is
wholesale
nomenclature, educational
its
dissimilarity hierarchical
qualifications,
set-up,
method
variance pay
in
scales,
recruitment,
job profile, and nature of work, job, functions, duties
degree
responsibilities
accountability
both qualitatively and quantitively are different and conditions of service including promotional avenues
of two posts are different and the two posts are unequal in all respects, and such dissimilarity was recognized
by Statutory-Recruitment and Promotion
Rules of two posts. 12. is
Third contention of Learned Senior Counsel that
decision
making
process
undertaken
for changing the nomenclature of Health Educators {petitioners} from “promotion to placement” on the basis of the Recommendation made by Committee on 20.10.2015 [at page 81-82 of paper book] and acceptance of such recommendations by the State Cabinet on 14/15.01.2016 and issuance of Impugned Notification on 30.01.2016, Annexure A-1, but without satisfying the pre-conditions expressly mandated in aforementioned recommendations/report and too that without amending the extant Statutory Rules notified on 18.11.1999, Annexure A-2, is illegal. ANAMOLY IN PAY WRIT LARGE FROM 01.01.2006 TILL 30/31.01.2016:
12(i).
Material
on
record
indicates
that
State
Authorities, notified the Statutory Rules on 18.11.1999 Annexure
A-2, for
post
Health Educators,
recognizing the “nomenclature of promotion” to post of Health Educators between from 01.01.1996 till 30/31.01.2016. Despite this the pay scale of the post
Health
Educators
was
Rs
GP
w.e.f
01.01.2006
after
Pay
Re-revised
Rules
10300-34800
2012
issuance
pay
+3800
scale
Health Educators (petitioners) was not revised for after issuance of the Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 from
01.10.2012
to
hand,
category
Supervisors
feeder
30/31.01.2016.
[Multipurpose
On the other
Male/Female
Health
Health
Supervisors],who
were in the lower pay scale of Rs 10300-34800 + 3600
GP
w.e.f
01.01.2006,
after
issuance
the Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 were given the higher pay scale of Rs 10300-34800 +4200 GP w.e.f. 01.10.2012 whereas the petitioners were given the Re-revised Pay Scale under the Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 on 30.01.2016, Annexure A-1. The above facts establish that though the petitioners
were
holders
promotional
posts
of Health Educators yet they were made to draw
pay
in
lower
pay
scale
from
01.10.2012
till
30/31.01.2016, whereas feeder category incumbents were granted higher pay in the higher pay structure during this period, without any rationale, is ex-facie anomalous, establishing brazen violation of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. PROCESS NEGATING STATUTORY RULES BY INFERRING EQUATION WITH FEEDER POST FROM 01.01.2006 TO 30/31.1.2016- UNTENABLE:
12(ii).
The
decision
by
State
Authorities,
making
process
which
tends
undertaken to
scuttle
Statutory Rules notified on 18.11.1999, Annexure A-2, for the post of Health Educators (petitioners) cannot stand the test of judicial scrutiny, for the reason, firstly, the “nomenclature of promotion” was attached to
post
Health
Educators
(petitioners)
by
Statutory Rules of 1999 Annexure A-2 could neither be
whittled
down
nor
curtailed
or
negated
by
inferring equation or equivalence between promotional post of Health Educators with feeder post of Male /Female
Health
Supervisors
[later
redesignated
as
Multipurpose Health Supervisors] w.e.f. 01.10.2012 till
30/31.01.2016 arbitrarily; and secondly, equation or equivalence in posts for the purpose of pay scales cannot be inferred; and thirdly, in the absence of any conscious express decision by State Authorities in
granting
equation
or
equivalence
between
two
posts, the same can neither be inferred or assumed, as has been done in instant case; and lastly, the action of State Authorities in inferring or assuming equation
or
equivalence
between
promotional
posts of Health Educators vis-à-vis the feeder posts
Health
Supervisors”
by
defeating
negating
the statutory right of higher hierarchical set-up and right of higher rank, higher status and higher pay scale recognized by the Statutory Rules for posts of Health Educators notified on 18.11.1999 Annexure A-2, for period from 01.10.2012 till 30/31.01.2016; vitiates
decision
making
process,
resulting
in
giving the lower pay in lower pay structure to the petitioners, despite being holders of promotional posts is highly arbitrary, unreasonable and is violative of Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India.
PROCESS OF CHANGING NOMENCLATURE FROM PROMOTION TO PLACEMENT VITIATED BY ARBITRARINESS:
12(iii).
Though the State Authorities notified the
Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 and initially though the State Authorities did not grant the benefit of the re-revised
pay structure under
the Re-revised
Pay Rules whereas 14 categories in the RespondentHealth Department, including the feeder category of Male/Female as
Health
Multipurpose
Supervisors
Health
[later
Supervisors]
redesignated were
granted
benefit of Re-revised Pay structure w.e.f. 01.10.2012 on 28.09.2012, Annexure A-12. Feeling aggrieved, the petitioner represented the matter and thereafter the State Authorities constituted
an Expert Committee
and the said committee after admitting anomaly, forwarded its Recommendation-Report on 20.10.2015 [at
page
81-82
paper
book]
for
changing
nomenclature of post of Health Educators (petitioners) from “promotion to placement” yet in recommending the pay scale of Rs 10300-34800 + 4200 GP to the petitioners with prospective effect, leading to issuance
the Notification on 30.01.2016,
Annexure
A-1,
giving revised pay scale of Rs 10300-34800 + 4200 GP to
petitioners-Health
Educators
w.e.f.
01.02.2016,
speaks volumes of unreasonableness and arbitrariness in State action by neither considering nor granting the revised pay scale to promotional post holders -petitioner
as
was
granted
to
others,
including
incumbents belonging to the feeder category w.e.f. 01.10.2012, is without any rationale, is whimsical and unsustainable and is accordingly, interdicted by this Court. NON-FULFILMENT OF THE PRE-CONDITIONS BEFORE CHANGING NOMENCLATURE VITIATES PROCESS AND IMPUNGED NOTIFICATION:
12(iv).
Process followed by the State Authorities
for changing the nomenclature of posts of Health Educators (petitioners) from promotion to placement cannot
sustain,
for
reason,
firstly,
State
Authorities had constituted an Expert Committee and though the said committee had admitting anomaly, in pay, yet the recommendations made by the said committee in giving same pay structure as given
to feeder category arbitrary; and secondly, the Expert Committee
Recommendations
made
on
20.10.2015
[at page 81-82 of paper book] indicates that the Committee made the “conditional recommendations” for
changing
nomenclature
post of Health
Educators (petitioners) from “promotion to placement” subject
to
condition
that
in
event
granting an equivalent pay structure to petitioners -Health
Educators
as
was
granted
to
feeder
post holders then, it was advised to amend the Recruitment and Promotion Rules for the post of Health Educators; and thirdly, the State Authorities have neither satisfied nor fulfilled the terms spelt out in the form of “conditional recommendations” by
Expert
amending
Committee
on
20.10.2015
by
not
the existing Recruitment and Promotion
Rules for the post of Health Educators (petitioners) and therefore, the process followed for changing nomenclature of the category and post of petitioners -Health Educators from “promotion to placement” is vitiated
by
non-application
mind;
fourthly,
even the action of the State Authorities in placing the matter before State Cabinet on 14.01.2016 and approval given thereto on 15.01.2016 [at page 75 of paper book], without amending the Recruitment and Promotion Rules prior to the grant of approval and thereafter till the issuance of the Notification on
Annexure
30.01.2016,
A-1,
establishes
gross
perversity in state action; and fifthly, the operation, scope,
applicability,
conditions
service
nomenclature of the petitioners expressly mandated in Statutory Rules of 1999, Annexure A-2, notified under the provisio to Article 309 for the post of the petitioners-Health Educators cannot be curtailed restricted, negated by issuing a Notifications under HPCS Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012, but without amending the Statutory Rules of 1999 aggravates illegality; and sixthly, even the conditions of service, including
{promotional
nomenclature
post
or
prescribed
placement
post
for
posts
etc.,}
under
Statutory Rules of 1999, Annexure A-2, cannot be altered
ipso-facto
by
Revised
or
Revised
Pay
Rules of 2012 “which have restrictive applicability only qua pay scales”; and seventhly, the Revised or Re-revised Pay Rules cannot be invoked to the prejudice of the petitioners, so as to deprive them of the right for higher status, and the right for higher rank (promotional rank) and the right for promotional
increment(s)
under
Fundamental
Rule
22(1)(a)(i) attached to the promotional post of Health Educators by virtue of Recruitment and Promotion Rules of 1999. In these circumstances, the decision making process
undertaken
by
State
Authorities,
has
resulted in diminishing the core foundational fabric attached
to
Statutory
Rules,
post which
Health
Educator
recognizes
this
under
post
as
a promotional post; in a casual manner and by ignoring “relevant considerations” and also without complying
with
or
satisfying
preconditions
“conditional recommendation and its approval” and “without
amending
Statutory
Rules
Health
Educators” and therefore, changing the nomenclature
of the petitioners-Health Educators [i.e. promotional posts] from promotion to placement”, by “equating their posts with category and post of Male/Female Health Supervisors [Multipurpose Health Supervisors] [i.e. feeder posts] despite the fact two posts were unequal and had wholesale dissimilarity in all respects therefore, process undertaken by State Authorities, and the resultant Impugned Notification issued on 30.01.2016, Annexure A-1, is arbitrary, unreasonable and offending Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India cannot sustain and accordingly, interdicted by this Court. PICK AND CHOOSE RELEASE OF RE-REVISED PAY UNDER REREVISED PAY RULES IS PER-SE DISCRIMINATORY AND UNTENABLE:
13. is
Fourth contention of Learned Senior Counsel that
State
Authorities
have
adopted
and choose criteria, for giving the
a
pick
re-revised pay
scales under HPCS Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012, by giving this benefit to 26 other categories and to 14 other categories in the Respondent-Health w.e.f. 01.10.2012 but in giving benefit to the petitioners
on 30.01.2016 [Annexure A-1] w.e.f. 01.02.2016 is illegal, arbitrary and unconstitutional; The above plea has force, for the reason, firstly, the State Authorities notified Statutory Rules for post of Health Educators, [i.e. promotional post] granting the pay scale of Rs 5800-9200 from date of issuance of these Rules in 1999 (Annexure A-2) and this pay scale was revised to Rs 10300-34800 + 3800
GP
w.e.f
01.01.2006
but
after
issuance
Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012, the category of the Health Educators (petitioners) were given Re-revised Pay Scale Rules of Rs 10300-34800 + 3600 GP as per the Notification dated 30.01.2016, Annexure A-1, w.e.f 01.01.2006. On
other
hand, the State
Authorities notified the Statutory Rules for the post of Male /Female Health Supervisors [redesignated as Multipurpose Health Supervisors] [i.e. feeder posts] granting the pay scale of Rs 5480-8925 from the date of issuance of Statutory Rules on 12.10.1999 (Annexure A-6) and this pay scale was revised to Rs 10300-34800 + 3600 GP w.e.f 01.01.2006 but
after the issuance of the Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012, this category was given the Re-revised Pay Scale of Rs 10300-34800 + 4200 GP w.e.f. 01.10.2012; and secondly, the action of the State Authorities in giving the Re-revised Pay Scale under the Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 by applying pick and choose criteria cannot sustain;
and thirdly, once after the
issuance of HPCS Rerevised Pay Rules on 24.09.2012, the action of State Authorities in issuing a Notification on 27.09.2012 giving the Re-revised Pay Structure w.e.f
01.10.2012
to
categories
further
in
issuing another Notification on 28.09.2012, Annexure A-12, giving Re-revised Pay Scale w.e.f. 01.10.2012 to 14 other categories, including the feeder category -post holders Male/Female Health Supervisors [later designated
as Multipurpose Health
Supervisors]
in
Respondent-Health Department whereas promotional post holders of the petitioners-Health Educators were given
this
benefit
belatedly
with
immediate
effect
on 30.01.2016, Annexure A-1, is highly arbitrary, discriminatory
illegal;
fourthly,
State
Authorities
had
notified
Re-revised
Pay
Rules
2012 with the object of removing stagnation of those employees who had rendered two years of regular service and to bring efficiency in administration by providing them better service conditions in the form of rerevised-enhanced pay structure {including Grade Pay} under these Rules to its employees ; and fifthly, with above objective, the State Authorities had issued notifications giving benefit of Re-revised Pay StructureScale
to
majority
categories/posts,
who
had
rendered two years of regular service w.e.f. 01.10.2012; and sixthly, even though petitioners-Health educators have rendered much more or several years of regular service as Health Educators {over and above 2 years regular of service} and the action of State Authorities in excluding the
category of the
petitioners from
being given the benefit of Re-revised Pay StructureScale w.e.f 01.10.2012 has no rationale and such exclusion
is
not
based
on
a
valid
classification
and exclusion or differential treatment meted to the petitioners
has
no
nexus
with
object
sought
to be achieved, by extending this benefit to category of the petitioners belatedly by issuing a notification on 30.01.2016 [annexure A-1] w.e.f. 01.02.2016 and therefore, the state action is wholly unreasonable, arbitrary, offending Article 14 of the Constitution of India; and seventhly, the object of giving Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 [of removing stagnation and bringing efficiency in administration of employees by providing better pay incentives, to employees who have rendered two
years
regular
service
as
on
date
promulgation of the Rules in 2012 on 24.09.2012 and/or as on 01.10.2012] and factum of stagnation and corresponding right for better service conditions was
common
to
all
posts
categories
in
State irrespective of departments, then, the action of State Authorities in releasing the Re-revised Pay Structure-Scale and Grade Pay belatedly to category of the petitioners-Health Educators w.e.f 01.02.2016 {on the basis of A-1} defeats the very object, rationale and intent behind the issuance of the Re-revised Pay Rules 2012 ; and eighthly, the action of the
State Authorities prescribing different dates for giving Re-revised
Pay
under
HPCS
Re-revised
Rules
2012 to its employees amounts to abuse of discretion, and prescription of different dates for granting this benefit is not based on any valid classification and grant of Re-revised Pay to the petitioner belatedly on 30.01.2016 w.e.f. 01.02.2016 whereas 14 other incumbents of the Respondent-Department and many others
categories
posts
in
other
department
were given this benefit from 01.10.2012 then, belated release of re-revised benefits to the petitioners without there being any cogent and valid reason, offends Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India and State action is interdicted. RULE CONFERRING UNFETTED DISCRETION LEADING TO HOSTILE DISCRIMINATION BY DEFEATING CORE OBJECT OF RE-REVISED PAY CANNOT SUSTAIN:
14.
Fifth contention of Learned Senior Counsel
is that Rule 1 (ii) and Rule 9 of the Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012, in prescribing date for notifying the Schedule, so as to give the re-revised pay scales to
its
employees
is
arbitrary,
discriminatory
illegal; The contention has force, for the reason, firstly, though the provision of Rule 1 (ii) of the HPCS (Category /Post-wise Revised Pay) Rules notified on
24.09.2012
give/release
enabled
State
Authorities
to
the re-revised pay and
grade pay
to
its employees from the date mentioned in Column 6 of the Schedule to be notified by State Authorities yet,
this
provision
cannot
be
construed
to
give
any leverage to the State Authorities to resort to discrimination
invidious
employees
Respondents-Health
treatment,
amongst
department;
and secondly, the provision of Rule 1(ii) and Rule 9 cannot be permitted to be invoked, at the mercy of the State Authorities ; and thirdly, the provision of Rule 1(ii) and Rule 9 of the Revised Pay Rules 2012
or
a
like
provision,
which
gives
unbridled,
unfettered, and uncanalised discretion to the State Authorities
to
notify
Schedule
so
as
to give
/release the Re-revised Pay Structure and Grade Pay to its employees, {alike the petitioners} despite the
fact that the Re-revised pay Structure and higher Grade
Pay
was
to
be
granted/released
to
those
employees, who had rendered minimum two years of regular service on a post, on the date of the issuance of the Re-revised Pay Rules on 24.09.2012 or as on 01.10.2012 or any nearby date and based on
this,
once the
State
Authorities
have
granted
/released benefit of the re-revised pay structure to
categories
other
on
27.09.2012
to14
other categories of the Respondent-Health Department on 28.09.2012, Annexure A-12 including the feeder post holders w.e.f. 01.10.2012 whereas the petitioner was given this benefit w.e.f. 01.02.2016 in terms of Notification issued on 30.01.2016, Annexure A-1, then, the pick and choose method/criteria adopted by
State
Authorities
has
seriously
prejudiced
a section of its employees alike petitioners offends Article 14 of the Constitution of India; and fourthly,
belated
release
benefits
to
petitioners
also defeat the object of giving the Re-revised Pay Structure under the Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012
defeats the very object, rationale and intent behind issuance of the Re-revised Pay Rules 2012 ; and lastly, the abuse of discretion, resulting in gross discrimination and arbitrariness in State action cannot be permitted to operate hereinafter. 15.
Considering the fourth and fifth contention
collectively,
this
Court has
no
hesitation
to
that the pick and choose method-criteria
hold
adopted
by the State Authorities and exercise of unfettered, unrestricted,
uncanalised
under
garb
Rule
unbridled
1(ii)
discretion
Rule
the Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 has resulted in discrimination, and also by defeating the object of giving the Re-revised Pay Structure and Enhanced Grade Pay to its employees, after having rendered two
years
of regular
service
based on
this,
once the benefits have been granted to others w.e.f 01.10.2012 but the action of granting such benefits to
petitioners belatedly and that too prospectively
w.e.f.
01.02.2016
Annexure
A-1, is
discriminatory,
arbitrary and illegal. Even, Rule 1(ii) and Rule 9
down,
Re-revised for
provision
in
Pay
reason,
existing
Rules that
form,
2012
is
read
application
such
has
led
to
manifest
invidious and hostile discrimination and arbitrariness in
State
action, offending
Articles 14
and 16
the Constitution of India. On facts, the exclusion of petitioners
{in
not
giving
benefit
to
them
w.e.f.
01.12.2012} is not based on any valid classification and differential treatment meted to the petitioners has no object sought to be achieved. Rather, the differential treatment meted to the petitioners defeats the core object of issuance of the Re-revised Pay Rules, as discussed above, necessitating interference. Consequently, the Impugned Notification giving the benefit of the Re-revised Pay to petitioners belatedly w.e.f.
01.02.2016
{as
in
Annexure
A-1}
needs
to
be remedied, so as to mitigate the injustice meted out to the petitioners; and therefore, the petitioners are held entitled for the Re-revised Pay Structure w.e.f 01.10.2012 with all consequential benefits. RELIANCE BY STATE ON RULE 8 OF REVISED PAY RULES 2012-MISPLACED:
16.
Sixth contention of Learned Senior Counsel
is that Rule 8 of the HPCS Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 has overriding effect has been misconstrued by State Authorities. The above contention, has force, for the reason, that firstly, Rule 8 gives an overriding effect to the Re-revised Rules of 2012 over Fundamental Rules
orders
issued
thereunder
as
well
as
Himachal Pradesh Civil Services [Revised Pay] Rules notified on 26.08.2009 [Annexure A-3] and orders issued thereunder with respect to pay revision and fixation of pay ; and secondly, the provision of Rule
in
clear
unambiguous
terms,
expressly
giving an overriding effect to Re-revised Pay Rules
2012
“over
aforementioned
three
rules/orders
issued thereunder” as detailed therein and not qua any other Rule and orders issued by the Govt; and thirdly, the State Authorities can neither construe nor invoke “Rule 8 so as to invoke its overriding effect” contrary to the express mandate of the said
Rule; and fourthly, even the overriding effect of Rule 8 of the Re-revised Pay Rules 2012 was to be invoked /applicable
“in
case
any
inconsistency
existed
in
pay regulated under Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012” vis-à-vis the “pay fixed under Fundamental Rules and orders issued thereunder as well as Himachal Pradesh Civil Services [Revised Pay] Rules notified on 26.08.2009 [Annexure A-3] and the orders issued thereunder with
respect to pay revision and fixation
of pay”; and fifthly, Rule 8, cannot be invoked so as to given an overriding effect to Re-revised Pay Rules
2012
over
Statutory
Rules
i.e.
Recruitment and Promotion Rules for the post of petitioners-Health
Educators
notified
under
proviso
to Article 309 of the Constitution on 29.10.1999, Annexure A-2, by negating the legal and statutory right of petitioners for higher nomenclature, higher rank, higher status and higher pay scale attached to
post
petitioners-Health
Educators
is
vitiated
by non-application of mind ; and sixthly, moreover, “express mandate of Rule 8” also “nowhere gives
over-riding effect to Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 over
Statutory
Rules”
cannot
sustain;
seventhly, the Re-revised Pay Rules 2012 governs
regulate
a
situation-specific
for
giving
re-revised pay structure and grade pay then, the aforesaid Rule cannot in any manner be construed to override express conditions of service, including nomenclature,
higher
rank,
higher
status,
higher
hierarchical set-up and even the proportional higher scale to the petitioners-Health educations, who are holders
promotional
posts
vis-a-vis
feeder
post; and eighthly, the provision of Rule 8 cannot be
invoked,
so
as
to
render
Recruitment
and Promotion Rules for post of Health Educators as
nugatory
otiose;
besides
above,
ninthly, State Authorities have given the benefit of Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 and the Revised Pay Structure to
categories
of employees in other
departments
on
27.09.2012
to
categories
of employees in the Respondent-Health Department {including
feeder
post
holders}
on
28.09.2012
to
many
other
categories
w.e.f.
01.10.2012,
whose conditions of service were governed by their respective Recruitment and Promotion Rules notified under the provisio to Article 309, without invoking Rule 8, {which infact was not invocable/applicable}, as discussed hereinabove, then, the action of the State
Authorities
in
applying/invoking
Rule
in
only in case of petitioners is just to wriggle out of its legal obligation for removing stagnation and to
bring
efficiency
in
service
to
petitioners
by giving the Re-revised Pay Structure and Grade Pay
to
other
categories
in
Respondents-health
department
several
other
categories
in
other
government
departments
w.e.f
01.10.2012
whereas
petitioners have been singled out by giving re-revised pay benefit to them belatedly w.e.f. 01.02.2016. The denial of benefits to the petitioners by misapplying and misconstruing this rule, {which infact is not applicable}, reveals inherent unreasonableness, which smacks of legal malafides and thus the State action is quashed and set-aside.
17.
ANALYSIS OF CONTENTIONS OF LEARNED STATE COUNSEL:
Now this Court proceeds to examine the contention of the State Authorities. STAND OF STATE AUTHORITIES THAT RULES OF OTHER STATES ARE NOT TO BE FOLLOWED:
18.
First Contention of Learned State Counsel
is that in terms of Rule 1(ii) and Rule 9, the State Authorities had been vested with the authority to grant benefit of the HPCS Re-revised Pay Structure and Enhanced Grade Pay under the Re-revised Pay Rules 2012 to any post or category of employees from the date of issuing the Notification, by adding to Schedule to said rules. The above
contention cannot sustain, in
view of the detailed discussion made in Paras 14 to 16 of this judgement, and the discretion conferred on the State Authorities by virtue of the aforesaid Rule, cannot be abused, so as to result in hostile discrimination,
gross
arbitrariness
unfairness
to section of employees, alike the petitioners, ignoring material/germane factors, that the object of Re-revised
Pay rule of 2012 was common to all posts and categories,
irrespective
pick
choose
method
departments
then,
adopted
State
by
Authorities in granting the benefit of re-revised pay structure and enhanced grade pay to the petitioners w.e.f. 01.02.2016, after issuance of the Notification on 30.01.2016 [annexure A-2] whereas majority of other categories, including the feeder category were granted this benefit from 01.10.2012. 19.
Second Contention of Learned State Counsel
is that in terms of Rule 8 of the Re-revised Pay Rules 2012, these Rules shall have an overriding effect over all other Rules and therefore, the action of State Authorities in changing the nomenclature of the posts of the petitioners-Health Educators from “promotion to placement” was valid. The above contention is misconceived, in view of the discussion in Para 17 of the judgement, as
Rule
gives
an
overriding
Fundamental
Rules
orders
effect issued
over
thereunder
as well as Himachal Pradesh Civil Services [Revised
Pay] Rules notified
on 26.08.2009 [Annexure A-3]
and orders issued thereunder with respect to pay revision can
and fixation of pay. Provision of Rule 8,
neither
whittle
be
down,
construed
curtail,
nor
restrict
invoked
so
as
to
away
or
take
alter the “conditions of service” and the legal and statutory right of petitioners for higher nomenclature, higher
rank,
higher
status
higher
pay
scale
attached to post of the petitioners-Health Educators by
virtue
Statutory
Rules
notified
under
the proviso to Article 309 of the Constitution on 29.10.1999, Annexure A-2. Rule 8 cannot be invoked, so
as
to
render
Rules
for
post
Recruitment
Health
Educators
as
Promotion nugatory
and otiose. Rule 8 cannot be sought to be invoked so as to change the “nomenclature of petitionersHealth Educators from “promotion to placement but without amending the Statutory Rules” notified for the post in 1999 and even the Expert Committee made recommendations in its Report on 20.10.2015 making
“conditional
recommendations”
that
in
case, the petitioners-Health Educators [promotional post holders]
were
equivalent
to
to
be
that
granted
re-revised
feeder
pay
posts,
scale
then,
in
such an eventuality, without adhering to the advise of the Committee and that too without amending Statutory Rules-Recruitment and Promotion Rules of 1999 then, the process followed by State [including Cabinet] in giving an ipso facto approval, “without amending
Rules”
cannot
sustain;
unless
and until Statutory Rules were amended inaccordance with law and until such time, the recommendation made by Pay Commission or Expert Body cannot be
enforced
to
prejudice
or
dis
advantage
of employees, as has been done in instant case, in view of the mandate of the Honble Supreme Court in
case
Inder
Singh
Ors
vs
Vyas
Muni, 1987 (Supp) SCC 257 {Para 8 thereof}. Even a policy decision for merging or integrating cadres, which had different qualifications functions, duties and powers treating “unequals as equal” was violative of Article 14 of the Constitution of India and the
same can be enforced after issuing appropriate rules {by amending or substituting existing rules or by issuing
new
rules}
in
view
principle
reinforced by the Honble Supreme Court in case of P U Joshi and others vs Accountant General (2003) 2 SCC 632 [para 8 thereof]. Resultantly, Rule 8 being inapplicable, was misapplied by the State Authorities and therefore, the contention of Learned State Counsel is turned down, 20.
Third Contention of Learned State Counsel
is that the State of Himachal Pradesh is not bound to follow the pay pattern and pay structure of other States including the State of Punjab. The above contention is misconceived and for the reason, that the prayer of the petitioners being Health Educators have not claimed parity in pay
with
their
counterpart
categories
Health
Educators in the State of Punjab. Besides, claim is against State Authorities, in not granting them the benefit of Re-revised Pay Structure and Grade Pay to them w.e.f. 01.10.2012,
on
analogy
on
which
benefit
was
extended
to
26 categories in other departments on 27.09.2012 and 14 other categories in the Respondent-Health Department {including the feeder post holders} on 28.09.2012 whereas the petitioner was granted this benefit
belatedly
w.e.f.
01.02.2016
prospectively;
and another claim is for removing the anomaly by restoring his legal entitlement for proportional higher grade pay over and above the grade pay to Rs. 4200, which was given to feeder category, as grant of same grade pay to petitioners-Health Educators [promotional post holders] vis-à-vis the feeder post holders, despite there being wholesale dissimilarity in
all
respects
treating
unequals
as
equal,
but without amending the Statutory Rules of 1999 cannot sustain, as discussed above. RELIANCE ON THE JUDGEMENTS BY THE STATE IS MISCONCEIVED:
21. is
Last Contention of Learned State Counsel this
relating
Court to
pay
should
not
fixation,
interference as
per
in
matters
mandate
the Honble Supreme Court judgements in the case
P.U.Joshi
others
vs
Accountant
General,
Ahmadabad and others and the connected case of Union of India and others vs Basudeba and others and in Shiba Kumar Dutta and others vs Union of India and others (1997) 3 SCC 545 and judgement passed by this Court in State of Himachal Pradesh and others vs Navneet Gupta, LPA No 146/2013, and in State of Himachal Pradesh vs Pratap Thakur, LPA No 11 of 2012 decided on 22.09.2014. 21(i).
The above contention is misconceived, for
the reason, firstly, the judgements relied upon by Learned State Counsel are distinguishable on facts; and secondly, this Court is conscious of the limits
interference
in
matters
relating
to
fixation
pay or pay scales and/or equivalence but, at the same time, the Honble Supreme Court has permitted interference in following situations: SCOPE OF INTERFERENCE- IN CASE EXCEPTION MADE OUT:
21(ii).
Normal principle is that the Court should
exercise restraint in matters relating to prescription
pay
scale and
fixation of pay
but the Court
can show indulgence, by way of an exception, in case, sustainable reasons exist establishing hostile discrimination, in the case of Union of India vs P V Hariharan (1997) 3 SCC 568, in the following terms: 5.
……We have noticed that quite often the Tribunals are interfering with pay scales without
proper
reasons
without
being conscious of the fact that fixation of pay is not their function. It is the function
Government
which
normally acts on the recommendations of a pay Commission. Change of Pay scale
a
category
has
cascading
effect. Several other categories similarly situated, above
as
well
as
those
situated
below,
put
forward
their
claims on the basis of such change. ………….Unless a clear case of hostile discrimination
is
made
out,
there
would be no justification for interfering with the fixation of pay scales.…”
21(iii).
Courts can interfere if the decision of the
Government is unjust, irrational and prejudicial to a
section
taken
a
relevant
of employees decision
to
by
ignoring
the decision
Government has
factors,
making
which
process
are
and the
end result, and in such an eventuality, the Court can direct the Government to reconsider the matter, in the case of State of Haryana and Anr vs Haryana Civil Secretariat Personal Staff Association, (2002) 6 SCC 72, in the following terms: 9.
“There can therefore, be no doubt that equation of posts and equation of salaries is
a
complex
matter
which
is
best
left to an expert body unless there is cogent material on record to come to a firm conclusion that a grave error
had crept in while fixing the
pay scale for a given post and Court's interference
is
absolutely
necessary
to undo the injustice. 10.
….The
courts
should
approach
such
matters with restraint and interfere only when
they
are
satisfied
that
decision of the government is patently irrational a
unjust
section
prejudicial
employees
to
government while taking the decision has ignored factors which are material and relevant for a decision in the matter. Even in a case where the court holds the order passed by the government to be unsustainable then ordinarily a direction should be given to the State Government
or
authority
taking
the decision to reconsider the matter and pass a proper order……”
21(iv).
Normal
principle
that
judicial
review
in
matters relating to prescription of pay scales, on the recommendations of expert committee, having financial implication shall not ordinarily lie, but the Court can interfere if it is satisfied that the Governments decision is arbitrary, as mandated by Three Judges of the Honble Supreme Court in the case of Union of India vs M V Mohanan Nair, (2020) 5 SCC 421, in following terms:35.
The
prescription
Pay
Scales
incentives are matters where decision is taken by the Government based upon
recommendation
expert
bodies like Pay Commission and several relevant
factors
including
financial
implication and court cannot substitute its
views.
Secretariat
As
held
Personal
in
Haryana
Staff
Civil
Association
(2002) 6 SCC 72, the Court should approach such matters with restraint and interfere only when the court is satisfied
that
decision
Government is arbitrary. Even in a case where the court takes the view that
order/Scheme
passed
by
Government is not an equitable one, ordinarily only a direction could be given to the State Government or the authority for
consideration
matter
take a decision…..
21(v).
Courts
can
show
indulgence
in
matters
relating to economic policies, if the lawful authority is abused if the actions are wholly unreasonable or violate the Constitution or the Statute, as mandated by the Three Judges of the Honble Supreme Court in Small Scale Industrial Manufacturers Association vs Union of India, (2021) 8 SCC 511, in following terms: 69.
….Merely
because
some
class/sector
may not be agreeable and/or satisfied with
such
packages/policy
decisions,
the courts, in exercise of the power of judicial review, do not ordinarily interfere with the policy decisions, unless such policy could be faulted on the ground of mala fide, arbitrariness, unfairness etc.
21(vi).
Indulgence can be shown, where material
on record establishes that error had crept in while
fixing
unfairness
pay
such
needs
to
be
gross
arbitrariness
rectified/remedied,
as
per
the mandate of the Honble Supreme Court in the case of Union of India vs Indian Navy Civilian Design Officers Association and Another, (2023) 19 SCC 482, in following terms:20.
The powers of judicial review in the matters involving financial implications are also very limited. The wisdom and advisability of the Courts in the matters concerning the finance, are ordinarily not amenable to judicial review unless a
gross
case
unfairness
is
arbitrariness
established
by
or
aggrieved party.
21(vii).
Courts can interfere if the pay structure
the higher-promotional post is
lower than the
feeder post and the decision of government offends Articles 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India, in the case of State of Uttar Pradesh vs Virender Bahadur Katheria, (2024) 15 SCC 01, in following terms: 53.
It needs no emphasis that prescription
pay
Policy
scale decision
for
a
based
post upon
entails
recommendations of an expert body like Pay Commission. All that the State is obligated to ensure is pay
structure
a
that the
promotional
or
higher post is not lower than the feeder cadre… 54.
Equally well settled is that the creation, merger, de-merger or amalgamation of cadres within a service to bring efficacy or in the administrative exigencies, is the State’s prerogative. The Court in exercise of its power of judicial review would
sparingly
interfere
in
such
a
policy decision, unless it is found to have
brazenly
offended
Articles
and 16 of the Constitution.
21(viii).
Considering
factual
matrix
material on record, this Court is of the considered view that that decision making process and the resultant action of the State Authorities in releasing Grade Pay of Rs 4200 in re-revised pay structure of Rs 10300-34800+ 4200 GP to the petitionersHealth Educators as per the Notification issued on 30.01.2016 [Annexure A-1] w.e.f. 01.02.2016 whereas
feeder post-lower
post
of Male/Female Health
Supervisors [later redesignated as Multipurpose Health
Supervisors] were granted the same re-revised pay structure as per Notification issued on 28.09.2012, Annexure A-12 w.e.f 01.10.2012; and the decision making process giving equivalence to the promotional post
holders
lower-feeder
i.e.
petitioners-Health
post
holders
i.e.
Educators
Male/Female
with
Health
Supervisors [later redesignated as Multipurpose Health Supervisors] when, both these posts had wholesome dissimilarity
decision
were
unequal
making
process
in all is
respects;
vitiated
by
non-application of mind and perverse, as the Expert Committee made “conditional report-recommendations on 20.10.2015 [at page 81-82] but without satisfying -fulfilling
pre-conditions,
nomenclature
promotional post of the petitioners-Health Educators cannot be changed from “promotion to placement” by resorting to an artificial equivalence dehors the Statutory Rules and that too without amending the Statutory Recruitment and Promotion Rules for the post
Health
Educators
issued
on
18.11.1999,
Annexure A-2], establishes gross error, irrationality
and perversity in decision making process. The action of the State Authorities in applying
pick
and choose criteria for releasing/granting re-revised pay structure under the HPCS Re-revised Pay Rules 2012, ignoring that the core object of giving the Re-revised Pay Rules, was so as to ensure
better
service conditions and to bring efficiency in service, in lieu of stagnation, for employees having rendered two years of regular service and once this object was “common to all employees, irrespective of posts and categories and departments” then, it is highly unjust,
irrational
prejudicial
on
part
of the State Authorities to grant/release benefit to
petitioners
belatedly
by
issuing
a
Notification
on 30.01.2016 [Annexure A-1] w.e.f. 1.02.2016 and no
cogent,
convincing and sustainable
explanation
is forthcoming as to why petitioners were granted benefits belatedly and exclusion of the category of petitioners
from
01.10.2012
is
being not
differential
granted
based
benefits
from
on
valid
classification
treatment
meted
out
to
petitioners
has
no
nexus
with
object
sought
to be achieved therefore, in the absence of these foundational preconditions, the action of the State Authorities is arbitrary and unreasonable, warranting interference by this Court. Even, the plea of the State Authorities in granting Re-revised Pay Structure to
petitioners
from
date
Schedule
was notified under Rule 1(ii) and Rule 9 of the HPCS Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012 cannot sustain and once the State Authorities have abused its lawful authority, inferring unfettered, uncanalised, unbridled and unrestricted discretion to prescribe dates for extending benefit of re-revised pay structure and grade pay by applying a pick and choose method and that too by ignoring relevant considerations of removing stagnation and bringing efficiency in service by giving better pay incentives to those who have rendered
two
years
of regular service as on the
date of issuance of the Re-revised Pay Rules on 24.09.2012, applicable w.e.f. 01.12.2012, by ignoring relevant and germane twin objective for granting
the re-revised pay structure was common to all employees, throughout the State. The action of the State Authorities in denying and delaying the release of re-revised pay structure to the petitioners from 01.10.2012
till
31.01.2016
establishes
manifest
arbitrariness, offending constitutional ethos embedded in Article 14 and 16 of the Constitution of India. Rule
Revised
Pay
Rules
2012
cannot
be applied/invoked so as to render the Statutory Rules notified for the post of Health Educator of 1999 redundant, nugatory or otiose and Rules 8 cannot be invoked/applied in arbitrary, discriminatory and whimsical manner so as to negate and defeat the rights of the petitioners for higher nomenclature, higher
rank,
higher
status,
hierarchical
set-up vis-à-vis the feeder post and the conditions of service recognized by Recruitment and Promotion Rules-Statutory Rules of 1999; therefore, the Rule 1 (ii) and Rule 9 of the Re-revised Pay Rules of 2012
are
read
down;
Rules
cannot
be
invoked/applied so as to take away, whittle down
and defeat the rights, legal entitlements, conditions of service and benefits accruing under the Statutory Rules of 1999, when, these Statutory Rules occupied the field on the date of issuance of the Impugned Notification on 30.01.2016, Annexure A-1 and even thereafter,
when,
who
inducted/promoted
were
similarly
placed
as
incumbents,
Health
Educators
and were placed alike the petitioners were granted benefit of Fundamental Rules 22 (1) (a) (1) even till 2018. ADMISSIBILITY OF RELIEF:
22.
Consequently, the decision making process
as well as the Impugned Order dated 30.01.2016, Annexure
A-1,
existing
in present
form,
qua
grant of Grade Pay of Rs 4200 w.e.f. 01.02.2016 in the Revised Pay Structure of Rs 10300-34800+ 4200 GP, is quashed and set-aside and in view of the discussion made above, the State Authorities shall
re-visit
appropriate
issue
proportional
thereafter
Re-revised
Pay
grant
an
Structure
and Grade Pay to the petitioners-Health Educators,
over and above the Re-revised Pay Structure and Grade Pay as granted to the feeder category and for
removing
charge
hostile
discrimination,
arbitrariness, and to ensure parity in the light of
object
issuing
HPCS
Re-revised
Pay
Rules of 2012; State Authorities shall also grant these
benefits
to
petitioners-Health
Educators
[promotional post holders] 01.10.2012 i.e. the date from which this benefit was granted/released to the feeder post incumbents and to other categories of employees in the Respondent-Health Department and to many other employees w.e.f. 01.10.2012. 23.
In
order
carve
out
a
balance
between
the rights of the petitioners and the interests of State Authorities, though the Impugned Notification dated 30.01.2016 [Annexure A-1],
has been quashed,
but in order to safeguard the right of the petitioners
to
protect
them
reduction
in
pay
structure
and Grade Pay hereinafter, therefore, it is clarified that
till
date,
Revised/Modified
State
Notification,
Authorities in
view
issues
aforesaid
discussion, the petitioners-Health Educators, as an interim arrangement, shall continue to draw pay in Re-revised pay structure of Rs 10300-34800 + 4200 GP and accruals, till such time, the Modified / Revised /Amended Benefits are notified, hereinafter. 24.
No other point was raised/argued. DIRECTIONS:
25.
In view of the above discussion and for
reasons recorded hereinabove, the instant petition is allowed, in following terms: (i).
Impugned Notification dated 30.01.2016 [Annexure pay
A-1]
structure
giving
Rs
re-revised
10300-34800
+
4200 Grade Pay w.e.f. 01.02.2016 to petitioners
is
quashed
set-aside;
[to the extent it gives Grade Pay of Rs 4200]; (ii).
State Authorities shall re-visit the case of the petitioners and shall thereafter give an appropriate proportional higher Grade Pay, over and above the Grade Pay of Rs 4200, to petitioners-Health Educators, w.e.f 01.10.2012;
(iii).
Action of releasing the Re-revised Pay Structure and Grade Pay to petitioners prospectively
from
01.02.2016
as
in
Annexure A-1, is quashed and set-aside; (iv).
Rule 1 (ii) and Rule 9 of the Himachal Pradesh
Civil
Services
(Category/Post-
wise Revised Pay) Rules 2012 conferring unfettered,
unbridled
uncanalised
unbridled discretion; and its abuse by adopting
a
pick
choose
criteria,
while granting re-revised pay structure; resulting in hostile discrimination, and arbitrariness, offending Articles 14 and
Constitution
India,
is
read down; (v).
Rule 8 is held to be inapplicable in fact-situation of instant case;
(vi).
Action of giving the same Grade Pay of Rs 4200 Educators
to the petitioners-Health
[promotional
posts
holders]
and the feeder post holders, is quashed and set-aside; (vii). Decision making process in changing nomenclature of Health Educators from “promotion to placement” but without amending
Statutory
Rules
1999
[Annexure A-2], and that too by ignoring germane factors, or “preconditions as spelt out in Expert Committee Report dated 20.10.2015 [Pg 81-82 of paper -book] vitiates entire process and thus resultant
decision,
as
in
Notification
Annexure A-1, is declared inoperative for all purposes hereinafter;
(viii). Sequel to above directions, the State Authorities shall grant the appropriate proportional higher Grade Pay {as in direction no (ii) to the petitioners from 01.10.2012, with benefit of pay fixation in such modified/revisited Revised Pay Structure-Grade Pay from the due date [01.10.2012] notionally; but the actual monetary benefits shall accrue for three years preceding the filing of writ petition [on 15.09.2016] w.e.f. 15.09.2013 and thereafter with all consequential benefits; (ix)
State Authorities shall comply with the directions and release all benefits within four weeks from today;
(x).
Till revised benefits in terms of this judgement are released, the directions contained in Para 23 shall operate;
(xi).
Parties to bear their own costs.
In the aforesaid terms, the instant petition is allowed and pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall accordingly stand disposed of. (Vivek Singh Thakur) Judge (Ranjan Sharma) Judge October 08, 2026 [tm]