Shiv Kirpal Singh v. Shri V. V. Giri
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Date of judgment
- 14 September 1970
- Judge
- Justice S.M. Sikri
- Neutral citation
- 1970 INSC 190
- Reported in
- [1971] 2 S.C.R. 197
- Result
- Dismissed
Full judgment
SIUV KlRPAL SINGH
v. SHRI V. V. Gnu
'n
.c
September 14, 1970 WITH CONNECTED PETITIONS [S. M. SIKRI, J. M. SHELAT, V. BHARGAVA, G. K. MrrTER :AND c. A. v AIDI.ALINGAM, JJ.J Presidential and V~ce-Presidential Election Act 31 of 1952-Part 111 of A:t whether ~Itra V.ll'es Art. 71(1) of Constitution of India 1950-£/ectton o~ Pres1~ent whether. c~n be challenged 011 grounds other thun those mentwned ~~ s. 18-Validtty of s. 5(2)-Section whether ultra \ires Art. 58 oj ConstJtutlon-Ca_ndi4ate signing his non_rination paper before prof!o_ser or seconder-Nommatt~n paper whether /table to be rejectedll_altdtty of s. 21-Whether sectiOn suffers from vice of excessive delecatron of legislative power-'Undue influence' itJ s. 18 meaning of--5tatements within purview of s. 171 G cflndian Penal Code whether can also /all under s. 111C-Comrivance by candidate of exercise of undue influ· enu by others, proof-Material t!ffect on election, proof-Bribery, evidei'ICe of. Costs-Election Petition-When cosl! may be refused,
Presidential and Vice-Presidemial Election Rules, 1952-Validity of Rule:J 4( 1 )and 4(2)-Requiremellf that nominatio11 paper must be accompanied by certified copy of entry in electoral roll relating to candidate, whether arbitrary and rmreasotwble and ultra vires 11, 21 of Act 3 1 of 1952 -Validity of rr. 4(3) and 6(3)-Requirement that elector shall nor subscribe whether as proposer or seconder more than one nomination paper a/ any election, whether contravene3 s. 5(2) of Act 31 of 19?2Certi/ied copy of electoral roll entry relating to candidate--Who can u.rue. Corutitmion of India, 1950, Art. 58-Age of candidate for office of Prtsidel'll of Jndia,-Minimum age prescribed as 35 year~-Entry In electoral roll sho wing candidate's age as above 35 years-Candt1at~s own statement as to date of birth showing he /11 below 35 years-ReJI!Ctton of nomination papu wht'fher justified. Constitution of India, 1950, Arts. 54, 367, 372 and 3~1-A--Gmerol Clause:J Act, s. 3(58)-Unlon Terrilory wltetlter 'State' wl/l11n meanf'g,:! Art, 54--Elected member:J of LtJtl~·/atures of Union Terrllorles 'S'fde~~ of num be Included In Electoral College for election to office o/ Pre India, . . h ld • A t 1969 The election to the office of President o[ I_ndia . c 10 u~~ main 0 1 Was challenged In five election petition! fil.:d thJs f ~t ·t"on of an QU<.'Siion that 'fc iJ (or COmidcration whether th~ dat;U~I ~ne of "tbo anonymous pamphlet making defamatory statcmenh ctitione,-, amount. candida!~ at the election, In the manner alleged by, 1 e J'r s 18 ' of the e(J to exercise of undue influence within the meamng f 95.; read witb a. Pr~idential and Vice-Presidential Elec.tion Act ti~~ ~he 1Co;;rt bud furt~er
WllS
171 C of the Jndlan Penal Code. Jn thrblf~n~c~nd distributed bv the ~ to decide whether the pamphlet wos pu s c 811 orters and whethe~ .e ning candidate or with his conn!vnncoir b~ ~lsby [);'0 publication aod d1s~; t~ult of the election was maten~lly 8 ec e her uestions o! low I bution "' the pamphlet in question. Thep~ Jllqof Act 31 o! 1952 h~d ft:ll ror eon~lderation were (i) whether
1~8,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1~71) 2 S.C.R.
the effect of curtailing the jurisdiction of this Court under Art. 71(1) of the Constitution and was therefore ultra vires; (ii) whether an election under the Act could be challenged on grounds other than those mentioned in s. 18 of Act 31 of 1952 which fell in Part III thereof; (iii)' whether :->. 21 fJf the Act was void because of excessiv.!! delegation of legislative power; (iv) whether r. 4(1) was ultra vires s. 21 and also void because it was arbitrary and unreasonable; consequently whether :r. 4(2) was void; (v) whether the prohibition in· r. 4{3) on an elector proposing or seconding more than one candidate was ultra vires s. 5(2) of Act 31· of 1952; consequently whether s. 6(3) was yoid; (vi) whether nomination paper of one of the candidates was rightly rejected when the electoral roll showed the candidate's age as above. 35 years·but the candidate's own statement us to his date of birth showed that he was below 35 years; (vii) whether certified copy of entry in electoral roll relating to candidate must under the Rules be issued either by the Electoral Registration Officer. or the -~ssistant Electoral' Regi~tration Officer; (viii) wh~ther a nomination paper stgncd first by the candidate and thereafter by hts proposer and seconder could be treated as valid; (ix) whether the elected representatives J~f the Legislatures of Union Territories arc entitled to be included irt ·· the Electoral College for the election of President of India O'l the footing that the word 'State' includes 'Union Territories'; (x) whether s. 5 (2) of Act 31 of ·1952 is ultra vires Art. 58 of the Constitution; (xi) whether .the \)ffcncc of 'bribery' as alleged by the petitioners was shown to have been committed and (xii) :whether in the circumstances of the case costs shduld he awardeo to the winning party. Dismissing the petitions,
HELD : (A) Per Sikri, Shelat and Vaidialingam, JJ. (Bhargava and Mittce, JJ. dissenting) : (a) Though undue influence for purpose of s. 123 the Representation of the People Act. 1951 .has the same meaning as in 1hc present Act that section does not go as far as. s. 18 of the present Act so as to provide that even if it is committed by a third party that is to say not an election agent nor a person with the consent ~f tne returned cant.lidate, the election ·.would still be declared to be void provideo it has been materially affected by such undue influence. Fron\ . tpe fact that hoth these Acts were enacted by the sarrie legislature and Act·3I of 1952 was passed after the Representation of the People Act was passed, it is dear that Parliament deliberately made s. 18 stricter than the Representution of the People Act. firstly, by using the word ''his consent" and secondly. by including undue influence committed even by a stranger having nothing to do with returned candidate as a ground for declaring the election to be void, the only condition in respect of such an Act being that it should have materially affected the election. The object of doing so is obvious. namely. that Parliament wanted to ensure that in respect of an election for the highest. Q.ffice in the realm the election should be completely free ~·rom any improper .liTfh~ ~manating even from a third party with whom the returned canJidate had no eon~tion and without any connivance on his part. The only limitation placed in s. 18 is that in such a case It has to be established that the election was materially affected. The que,;tions therefore which would arise under s. 18 would be : (1) Has the nffen~c of und~e influence been committed ? ( 2) If so .. was it committed by the returned cand·idate or by a person with his connivance? and (3·) Even if the offence was committed by a stranger and without .the conninnce of the returned candidate. bas the committal of that offence by Guc:h · "any person'' materially affected the election~· [222 E-22381 The argument that s. 17l C of the Indian Penal Code does not apply the mental process of weighing merits and Jemcnts of the candtdates but _only to. the second stage when having maJc his choice be goes to cast hts vote tn favour of tll the first st~ge when the e_lcctor goes thro!t!!h
S. K. SINGH V. SHRI V. V. GIRl
the candidate of his choice, cannot be accept~. The argument completely disregards the structure and provisions of s. 171 C. The section "is en~ted in three parts. The first stage contains the definition of undue influence. This is in wide terms and renders a person voluntarily interfering or .1ttempting to interfere with 'the free exercise of any electoral right guilty of committing undue influence.. That this is very wide is indicated by the opening sentence of sub-s. (2) that is, "without prejudice to the generality of the provisions of sub-s. (1) ". It is well settled that when ~r .• ~ e"oression is used anything contained in the proivsions 'following this expression is not intended to cut down the generality of the meaning of the preceding provision. [224 G-225 B]
King Emperor v~ Sibnath Banerii {1945] F.C.R. 195, referred to.
It follows that sub-s. ( 1) has to be looked at as it is without Testricting its provisions by what is contained in su~s. (2). Sub-s. (3) throv.'S a great deal of light on this question. It proceeds on the assumption that a declaration of public policy or a promiSe of public action or the mere exercise of a legal right can interfere with an electoral right, and therefore it provilles that if there is no intention to interfere with the electoral right it ahall not be deelhed to be interference within the meaning of this section. Such a declaration of public policy or the promise. of public action can only act and tend to interfere at the stage•when a vottr is trying to make up his mind as to which candidate he would support. [225 B-Dl Sub-s. ( 3) further proceeds on the basis that t~e expression "free exer~ cise of the electoral right" does not mean that a voter is not to be iriftuenccd. This expression has to be read in the context of an election in a demoerath: society and the candidates and their supporters must naturally be allowed to canvass support by all legal and legitimate means. This exercise of the right by a candidate or his supporters to canvass support does not interfere or attempt to interfere with the free exercise of the electoral right. What dot\s however attempt to interfere with the exercise of an electOral right is "tyranny over the mind". If the contention of the respondent was to be accepted it would be quite legitimate on the p\U't of the candidate or his supporters to hypnotise a voter an~ then· send him to vote. At th~ stage of casting his ballot paper there would be no pressure cast on him because his mind has. already been made up for him by the hypnotiaer.
l225 B-Gl
From a reading of s. 171 G it is clear that in pursuit of purity of elections the legislature frowned upon attempts to assail such purity by means of false statements relevant to the p'ersonal character and conduct of the candidate and made such acts punishable thereunder. But the fact that making'of such a false statement is a distinct offence under s. 171 G does not and cannot mean that it cannot take the graver form of undue influence .punishable under s. 171F. The false statement may be of such virulent. vulgar or scurrilous character that it would either deter or tend to deter voters from supporting that candidate whom they would have supported in the free exercise of their electoral right but for their bei-ng affected or attempted to be affected by the maker the publisher of such a statement. Therefore, it is the degree of gravity of the allegation which will be the determining factor in deciding whether it falls under s~ 171C or s. 171G. If the alleption, though false and relating to a candidate's personal charncter or conduct: ma~e ':Vith the intent to affect the result of an election, does not amount to. mterference or attempt at such interference, the offence would be the Jesse~ one. .If! on the other hand, it amount~ to interferenc~ or an 1!-ttempt to mterfere 1t would be the graver offence under s 171F read With s. 171C. [225 D-{J] _ '
or
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] 2 S.C.R.
The. above view is supported by the statement of objects :md reasons attached to the bill which ultimately resulted in the enactment of Ch. IXA of the Indian Penal Code, and by a number of decisions given on similar staluto·ry provisions. [226 B-Hl Amritsar City '(Mohammadan) Constituency Case No. 2-The Indian Election Cases ( 1935-50) Dobia Vol. II, 150-157; .Tujhar Singh v. Bhairon Lal 7 E.L.R. 457, 461; Radhakanta Mishra v. Nityanand Mahapatra, 19 E.L..R. 203, ·and Baburao Patel v. Dr. Zakir Husc.'in, [1968} 2 S.C.R. 133, 145. referred to. (b~ On the evidence in the case it must be held that the pamphlet in question was distributed by post and in the Central Hall of Parliament by some members of Parliament and there was wide rtiscussion about it in the Central Hall. The allegations in the pamphlet, made against one of the losing candid~tes were covered under s. 171C I.P.C. even if they may be covered under s, 1710. [231 F; 257 B)
The argument that the pamphlet cotttd not come under s. 171 C because it. was anonymously distributed was fallacious. A series of anonymous attempts in a country like ours wo11ld have as much if not more, effect as one open power'ful attempt. It would be dangerous to provide a sanctuary for anonymous attempts. Moreover, when members of Parliament distri·bute a pamphlet in the Central Hall it has the same effect as if they had endorsed the pamphlet in writing. {231 H]
Accordingly it must be held that the distribution of the pamphlet by
post as also distribution in the Central Hall constituted an attempt to in· terfere with the free exercise of the tight of vote within s. 18 of the Act. [232 C) (c) There was however no evidence to show that the respondent bad any connection with the pamphlet or with its distribution. Nor was <'here any evidence to show that anyone connected. with the distribution either through the po:,t or in the Central Hall had any contact with the respondent. er that he distributed it with his knowledge o~ c;:onnivanee. [257 J:>r-:EJ
(d) It is well settled that the burden of proving that the result of the election has been materially affected is O[l the petitioners. As held by tbi!l Court in Samant N. Balkrishna v. George Fernandes, the matter cannot be decided on possibility or reasonable judicial guess. There was no justification for over~ruliog that decision. [265 D-266 Cl Vashl'st Narain v. Dev Chandra, [1955] 1 S.C.R, 509, Mahadeo v. Babu UdtJi Prat(ip Singh; A.J.R. 1966 S.C. 824, Paokai Haikip v. Rishang C.A. :~''· .683/1958 dt. 12-8-1968, G.K. Samal v. R. V. Rao, C.A. No. 1540/69 dt. ,20"1•197(}, S1mndra Nath Khosla v. Dalip Singh, [1957] S.C.R. 179•, r~tie!-ti>n.:
-r•·
...
.. .
.
SamatJt N. Balkrishna v. George Fernandes, A.I.R. 1969 S.C. 1201, n:-
~;_(·..i.. ·•lftnn~•.. :.
. ...·.
.
12ri\/;':'{f-~bii·ti~:e\.1de~ce in tlie present case it was difficult to hold that the peti~
:.:: · ·. · · :tloners had proved· that the publicatiof!. and di!(ribution of the pamp~l·et :: :. : · . materially aflected.the result of the election. Jt only le~ds. tQ the conclusion Y~~c· that~it.:probably _d1d have some effect but the vast maJonty of t_he electo~s "?'~.· •· w~ able to throw o1t the effect of the pamphlet and VC?te accordmg to tbeu. ' . . ~'Wit personal wiSh or according to the mandate of the1r party, [269 B........C]
·' .;
; - I- ~
'- .·.
S. K. SINGH v. SHRI V. V. GIRl
II
Per Bhargava, J. : Sub-llection ( 1) of s. 171C in general terms make& any act an 'undue intluence' ·i!f it interferes or attempts to interfere with the free exercise of any electoral right and if it is committed voluntarily. The electchtl right according to the definition in s. 171A (b) is the right of a voter to vote or refrain from voting. Undue influence can be held to be committed if the person charged with the offence interferes or attempts to interfere wit~ the fri:e exercise of this right of voting or refraining from voting. When an elector exercises the right of voting it can be envisaged that he goes throug.'t the mental process of first taking a decision that he will vote in favour of a particular candidate and thereaftelr, having made up his mind, he has to go and exercise that electoral right by casting the vote in favour of the candidate chosen by him. The language used in s. 171C indicates that the offence of undue inftuence comes in at the second stage when the offender interferes or attempts to interfere with the free exercise of that choice of voting in accordance with the decision already taken bf the voter. It, therefore, follows that if any acts are done which merely inftuence tho voter in making his choice between one candidate or another, they will not amount to interference with the free exercise of the electoral right. In fact all canvassing that is caiTied on and which is considered legitimate is intended to influence the choice of a voter at the first stage and that i11 quite permissible. Once the choice ha·s been made by the voter, there should be no interference with the free exercise by him of that choice by actually casting the vote, or in the alternative the're may be cases where a voter may decide that he will not vote. for any candidate at all but some acts are done which compel him to cast his vote. It is in such easel! that the offence of undue influence will be held to have been committed. r32o B-GI The language used in the definition of undue intluence implies that an offence of undue influence will be held to have been committed if the elec· tor having made up his_ mind to cast a vote for a particular candidate does not do so because of the act of the offender, and this can only be if he is under the threat or fear of some advelrse consequence. Whenever any threat of adverse consequences is given it will tend to divert the elector from freely exercising his electoral right by voting for the candidate chosen by him for the purpose. In a case where the voter is threatened with an injury as defined in the Indian Penal Code, it has to be deemed under s. l71C (2) (a) that it interferes with the free exercise of the electoral right of the voter and the same applies if the elector is induced or attempt is made to induce him to believe that he or any person in whom he is interested will become olr will be rendered an object of divine displeasure or of spiritual censure. There can, however, be cases where the threat may not he of an injury as defined in s. 44 I.P.C., where the harm caused must be illegal. [320 H-321 CJ Mere propaganda against a candidate cannot be held to be exercise of undue influence. The word free is used in "S. 171C I.P.C. as qualifying exercise' and not as 'qualifying' the wdrd 'vote'. If undue influence had been interference with the exercise of free vote, possibly the definition could have been construed a3 indicating that influence brought on the mind of a yoter so a~ to cha~ge the rnan~er of his voting by. affecting his choice and JUdgment 10 selectmg the cand1date for whom he ts going to cast his vote would be comprised within undue influence. The word free having been used as qualifying the wor~ 'exercise' gives the indication that the freedom envisaged is to cast the vote in accordance with the choice alreadv arrived :tt and. if such freedom of cnsting the vote in that manner is interfered with the offence of undue influence will be held to have been committed. [322 A-CJ The subject of influence at the stage of making a choice was dealt with
... .202
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[197) ]2 S.C.R. .
"in Ch. IXA of the Indian P.:nal Code under a separate anu distinct provi~ion which is contained in s. 171 G. This section clearly recognises, that, at elections, the're is bound to be propaganda ,in which candidates or their ·supporters may be issuing statements so as to influence the voters against their rival candidates, and it limits the' prohibition by law to only those statements of fact which are false, or believed to be false, or believed not to be true, in relation to the personal character or conduct of any candidate, Thesi! false statements about the personal character and conduct of the candidate may .of course be scurrilous and foul, but even theri.. the oft'enc&: comn1itted· would faH under s. 171G I.P.C. which makes the offence punishable with the firie only. On the other ha'nd, an offen~o:e··of undue influence as defined in s. 171C I.P.C. has been made punishable under s. 171F I.P.C. with imprisonment of· either de-scription for a term which may extend to one year or with fine, or with both_ If it is held that false propaganda · ugainst pe'rsonal C'haracter or conduct oCa ~didatc can amount to undue influence the person indulging in that propaganda would -become liable to punishment under s. 171F I.P.C. which has been considered a more serious offence by being made punishable with imprisonment in addition to, or, in the alternative with fine. This interpretation would thus make s. 171 G l.P.C., totally ineffective and otiose.' 1f the false statements as to personal character or conduct a're held to be punishable under s. 171F as constituting the offence of~undue influence, there would b~ no point in prosecuting the ~"me person for the less serious o~~nce under s. J}JG. [323 C-324 Al In the Representation of the People Act. 195 t also. undue influence is .defined in almost the samc ·languagc as that contained·in s. 171C l.P.C. Jn that Act an eleCtion can be dedared void not only on the ground of commission of the corrupt practice of undue inlluencc. but also on the g:rc;i.md of publication of false propaganda as to the personal character or conduct of a candid,ate. Parliament, however, cho-se not to include any such provision in Act 31 of 1952 which was passed when the Representation of the People Act, 1951 had already. been enacted and enforced. The omission may be deliberate or accidental but. in either case, it is not for th; court tn attempt to fill up this gap by enlarging the meaning to be given to the· expre~sion ·undue influence' which is the corrupt practice included in the Act as a ground for setting aside tht: election. It is clear from the scheme of Ch. IXA of the Indian Penal Code that false propaganda as to the per~ sonal character and conduct of a candidate was created as a sepaJrate ·offence -and the definition given in s. 171C of undue influence was not in·tended to lay down that such propaganda will amount to interference with the free exercise of electoral right so as to constitute undue influence. [324 F-325 A] Case-law referred to. (b.) In the present case the contents of the pamphlet in question did not contain any threat of a nature which would constitute undue influence as explained above. But even on the assumption that the publication of this pamphlet could constitute undue influence the election of the respondent was . not liable to be set aside because it had not been proved that the distribution by post or in the Central Hall of Parliament was with connivance of the respondent dr had materially affected the result of the election. [337 ·B-FJ . '. Per Mitter, J.-The only difference between the Act of 19~1 aDd tbe Act of 1952 lies iri .the fact that under the latter Act corru!)t practice of ·. bribery and undue influence by one who was not a party to the electi~n 1)r his agent are also brought. in. But the nature and c~aracter of undue mfluence under both· the Acts remains the saJlle. There ts no reason for tak· ing the view that what would not be undue influence under the Act of 1951 can become one un4er the Act of 1952. [354 F-GJ
'
I
S. K. SINGH V. SHRI V. V. GIRl
If publication of any defamatory matter relating to a candidate was tobe treated as a direct or indirect interference or an- attempt to interference
with the exercise of any electoral right under the wide words of s. 171C(l) there would have been no occasion for the legislature to provide for it separately under s. 123 ( 4) of the Act of 1951. The same position would obtain under the Act of 1952, and before any publication of defamatory matter relating to a candi<tate can be treated as commission of the offence of undue influence there must be some overt act in addition to the mere publication, S('lme attempt or persuasion of a voter to restrain the free choice of a candidate before the law of undue influence is excited. [354H-35SBJ The decided cases are sufficient to reject the respoqdent's contention that in otd~r. to establish undue influence it must be shown that there was some threat to a voter or at least an element of complusion in the appeal to him. The case~ also show that it would be futile to attempt to lay down a simple test applicable to all sets of facts and circum:stances where undue influence is alleged to have been exercised. It can however be said that an attempt on the part of anybody to deftect a voter's will away from a particular candidate by creating prejudice against or hatred for him, as for in- · s~ance by casting false aspersions on his personal conduct and character whether by spoken words or in writing may be sufficient for the purpose of establishing the commission of undue influence.. Much would however de· pend on the nature of the attempt, the. position of the person making it, and · the manner in which it is made. The mere publication by postal despatch D of an· anonymous but scurrilous pamphlet relating t<1 the personal character of .a candidate to voters all and sundry might attract the operation of s. 1710 of the Indian Penal Code but would fall short of s. 171C. But if such a pamphlet is pressed upon voters and methods of induj:ement applied to- them, specially by others who are equally interested in the election. different considerations may well arise. ln such a case a court of law may legitimately hold that the dis~eminators of the pamphlet were attempting to canalise or force the will of others away from the person whose. character . was assailed. [263 B-F] Case-law referred to. (b) There can be no doubt that a charge of undue inftuence is in the nature of a criminal charge and must ·be proved by cogent and reliable evidence not on the mere ground of balance of probability but on reason. able certainty that the person'S charged therewith have committed the offence, on the strength of evidence which 1e~tves no scope for doubt as F to whether they had done so. Although there are inherent difference~ betweeft tnc trial of an election petition and that of a criminal charge in the matter of investigation. the vital point of identity for the two trials i:o that the court must be able to come to the condusion beyond any reasonable doubt as t& the commission of tht corrupt practice, However onerous, the task of the court may be because of the partisan nature of the witnesses it cannot reject the oral evidence adduced merely on that ground, but it has to examine tl\e SMme carefully and come to a concbl· sion whether the evidence establillhes the corrupt practice beyond reasonable doubt. Even .in a criminal trial t~ coun can hold a person guilty of a c,rime on the stn:ngth of evidence of partisan witnesses if they are found to be reliable although there may be no independent corrobontion therepf and there is no reason to depart from that prim:iple in the ·trial of an eJection petition where charges of o«enees culpable under the Indian Penal Code are levelled. [366 F-367 G) Case-law refdrred to. (-.b) ll\ the present case· althouah the pamphlet in question was defamatory, tile evidence fell short of any per!Onal appeal through the means of .the pamphlet and it could not be held that the offence of undue influence
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] 2 S.C.R.
was committed by some people by merely distributing the same. Such distribution may attract culpability under s. 171G of the Indian Penal Code but would not per se attract s. 17IC. [380 D]
(b) Per Bhargava, J (Sikri, Shelat, Mitter and Vaidialingam, JJ. concurring) : The contention that Part Ill of the Act is ultra vires Art. 71 (1 ) of the Constitution on the ground that it purports to curtail the, jurisdiction conferred on the Supreme Court to enquire into and decide all doubts and disputes arising out of or in connection with the election ot. a President or Vice-President by laying down certain limitations such as the grounds on which only the election of a President may be cha~enged in an election petition, cannot be accepted. A similar contention was rejected by this Court in Dr. N. B. Khare's case. Even if it is accepted that Art. 71 (1) lays down the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court, the manner in which that jurisdiction is to be exer~ised can only be regulated by an Act of Parliament passed in exercise of its power under Art. 71 ( 3). Jn exercise of the power to regulate all matters relating to or connected with · the election of a President or Vice-President, Parliament clearly had the power of laying down the grounds on which the election can be challenged and set aside, in addition to other matters rel:\tirlg to the election.
{295 B-297 BJ Dr. N. B. Kh.are v. Election Commission of India, [1958} S.C.R. 648, .applied. The fact that Art. 71 ( 1) does not contain a provision corresponding to that in Art. 329(b) which specifically mentions a law made for calling 1n question an election by an_ election petition, could not lead to an inference in support of the petitionelr's argument. Article 329(b) is a provision which lays down a limitation on the manner in which an election can be called in question, while the procedure for calling in question the election, as well as the grounds on which the election can be called ·in question, can only be hiid down by Parliament by a law passed under Art. 327. In the case of Art. 71, it appears that no need was felt of makin~(a provision similar to Art. 329(b) when A'rt. 71(1) itself laid ·down the limitation that all doubts and disputes arising out of or in connection with the election of a President or Vice-President are to be inquired into and decided by the Supreme Court whose decision shall be final. [297 C-G] (ii) On the above .finding that Part III is not ultra vires, the .-:onten· tion that the petitioners were entitled to challenge the election on ground~ other than those mentioned in s. 18 of the Act, must also fail. ~315 HJ {iii) The power of making rules conferred on the Central Govern-· ment by s. 21 of the Act is subject to two principles of guidance. One i~ that the .rules are to be made after consulting the Election Commission, arid the second is that the Rules must be such as are needed for carrying out the purposes of the Act. Such power being already limited by tbe purposes of the Act cannot be held to be unguided or even arbitra11·, ~ven though Parliament did not choose to lay down the requirement that the Rules framed must be laid on the table of the two Houses of Parliament and should be subject to modification or annulment within a specifie period. In fact, Parliament all the time has power of altering the Rules by amending the Act itself in case it disapproves any of the Rules made by the Govet:nment, while a~~ Rule, which is shown to have been !llade in contraventiOn of the prov1s1ons of the Act, would be declared vo1d by the Court not on the ground that there was excessive delegation of !egi~lative power, but that it goes beyond the scope of the power conferred
C
S. K. SINGH V. SHRI V. V. GIRl
on the Government under s. 21 of the Act. Section 21 of the Act cannot therefore be held to be void on any ground. [298 B-GJ
(iv) The contention that r. 4(1) of the Presidential & VicePresidential Rules 1952 is beyond the rule making power of tlte G<Wemment under s. 21 of the Act 31 of 1952 has no force. Clause (d) of subs. (2) of s. 21 lays down that the Rules made under that section may, in particular, and without prejudice to the generality of the power granted under sub-s. ( 1), provicte for the form and manner in which nominations may be madt and the procedure to be followed in respect of the presentation of nomination papers; and the requirement that a certified copy of the entry showing that the candidate being nominated is an elector for a Parliame;::.~ary constituency which alone makes him eligible to stand aa a candidate for the office of President or Vice-President must accompany the nomination paper falls squarely within this clause. This requirement relates to the man.ner of proving that the candidate is an elector in a Parliamentary constituency. In any case, this provision in r. 4(1) would be fully covered by s. 21 (1) of the Act inasmuch as the requirement ia fdr no other purpose except of ensuring a smooth and proper election to the office of President .or Vice-President which object can be achieved by enabling the Returning Officer to ensure that candidates, whose nomi· nations are accepted by him, are eligible for election. [299 0-F] Ranjit Singh v. Pritam Singh & Or:r. [1966] 3 S.C.R. 543 applied..
The election to the office of a President or Vice-President mav not coincide with or be very do'le to the time when there is general revision of the electoral rolls, so that the electoral roll printed or published nearabout the time of. general elections may be out of date by the time the election tor the office of a President or Vice-President is held. The published electoral roll may therefore be misleading if it is allowed to be filed before the Returning Officer to show eligibility in the case of a Presidential or Vice-Presidential election. That, seems to be the reason why r. 4 (1 ) lays down that a certified copy of the entry alone will be the proper mannct of satisfying the Returning Officer of the eligibility of the candidate. The rule is therefore neither arbitrary nor unreasonable.
[301 B-E]
.
Acccudingly r. 4(1) must be held to be valid. Rule 4(2) which prea-
cribes the consequence for non-compliance with the requirement of r. 4( 1) must also be held to be valid as it is intended merely to make the valid r. 4( 1) ~ective. [301 Fl (v) The s'Obmission that s. 5(2) should be read as conferring any rlabt
either on the candidate or on the electon in respect of signing of nomi· n11tion pape.;s cannot be accepted. Had there. been an intention to eonfer a right on any of them the language would have been different aivina such indication by layin& down what thP, candidate and the electors are enritled to do in respect of a nomination paper. Obvioualy, s. 5 onlY lays down the essential ingredients of the process of nomination1 leavin& the details .of the manner of nomination to be filled up by llwes made by the Oovmunent under s. 21 of the Act. Rule 4(3) which requires that no elector shall sub5cribe whether as plroposer or seconder, more than one nomination paper at any election, is thus, supplementary to s. 5(2) as containing a more detailed direction in respect of filing of nomination papers. [302 D-303A] The fact that there is no ban in s. 5(2) of the Act on an elector signing more than one nomination paper as a proposer or a seconder does not, therefore, mean that r. 4(3) of the Rules could not have been
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971) 2 S.C.R.
com~tently made by the Government Rule 4(3). on the face of it . co~tams a very. reasonable direction. If there is only one vacancy for wb1c~ election IS to be ~eld, an elector can reasonably be expected to nommate only one candtdate as proposer and put him forward before the other electors as a suitable person to be chosen. Similarly, when seconding a nomination paper, an elector indicates his preference for that candidate to the general electorate which is to cast votes at the election. H the indication of such choice is restricted to as many candidates a~ there are vacancies, the provision is, on the face of it .s alutary and conducive to proPE:r election. [303 H-304 BJ The historical background of the Rules. relating to elections in lnc:tia also bears out that such a prevision has always been considered desirable. A similar provision exists in the Rules governing elections in England.
.[304 C-305 DJ
. ~. ..
.
.
·.
: In the circumstances it must be held that r. 4(3) of the Rules was validly made by the Government in exercise of its rule making powe1: under s. 21 of the Act~ that Rule being valid r. 6(3)(c) of the Rules which is consequential, must also be held to be valid. [305 Hl Amolok Chand v. Raghuvir Singh, [19'68] 3 S.C.R. 246, referred to. · (vi) The entry in the electoral roll showing a candid~.te as being above 35 years of age has little value when the candidate's own statement to the Returning Officer as to his date of birth shows that he is below 35 years of age. [306 E-FJ (yii) There is nothing in the Rules framed under the Act or under the Representation of the People Act, 1950 and Rules framed t~ereunder, requiring that a certified copy of the eltctoral roll must necessarily be issued by either an Electoral Registration Officer or ~-n~tant Electoral Registration Officer. Every government servant, who · has custosly ·of a document, is competent to issue certified copies of that document. {;308 B] · (viii) When the Act was enacted in 1952, the law in India, as administci·ed bv various Election Tribunals, was clear that the order in which signatures are made on a nomination paper by the candidate the proposer and the seconder is immateri~l and no nomination paper would he invalid if the signaturi!S are ni1lde· by .the_candidate before the propuser and the seconder signed it. The Legislatute, when enacting the Act must be presumed to know that this w.as the law as intet'preted in lradia and consequently, whcu the language incorporated in s. 5(2) of lhe Act was used, it mu3t have been intended that nomination papers would not be invalid by reason of the candidate making his signature before the proposer and the seconder. r3I2 C-El Therefore. in the present C!ISe. the nomination papers Of the candidate who signed 'his nomination paper before the proposer and tbe seconder a!'; well as those of the candidate who signeo his. nomination paper 'before his seconder. were rightly accepted. [.312 F) Case-law referred to. (ix) The. argument thut the definition of ·state' in s. 3 (5!0 of the General Chlllscs Act inclu<.lcs Union Territories and therefore the elected members of the Legislative Assemblies of the Union Territories arc nls(' to be inciUlkll in the Electoral College. mu<.t he rejected. £3D D-El It is ~rue that unJer Art. 36 7. the Gene'ral Clauses Act ap~Jlics for interpretation of the ·con~litlltion as it . applies for ~he interpretation of .m Act of the Lcgi~lature ot the Dom11110n of [n<.ha but that A~t ~a-: been applied a<; it stood on ~nth January. 19:'0 when the Consti!UIIO~<
S. K. SINGH v. SHRI V. V. GIRl (Sikri, J.)
came into force subject only to any adapta1ons and modifications that may bt' made therein under Art. 372. The General a auses Act as it was defined State so as to include a Union Territory. This was done by Art. 372 A which was introduced by the Constitution 7th Amendment Act, 1956. The new definition of State in s. 3(5) of the General Clauses Act as a result of the modifications and adaptations under Art. 37l(A) wquld, no doubt, apply to the interpretation of all laws of Parliament but it cannot apply to the intel'ijretation of the Constitution because Art. 367 wus not amended and it was not laid down that the General Clauses Act as adapted and modified under any Article oth« than Art. 372 'M1l also apply to Ole interpretation of the Constitution since its amendment in 1956. Since, until its amendment in 1956, Section 3(58) ol- the General Clauses Act did not define 'State' as including Union Territories for purposes of interpretation of Art. 54, the Union Territories cannot be treated as included in the word 'State'. [313 E-314 BJ Further the members of Houses known as Legislative Assemblies under
Art.. 168 can be members ot the Electoral College under Art. 54. In the case of Union Territories the provision for legislatures is contained il1 Art. 239A but that Article does not mention that any house of the
legislature created for any Union Territories will be known a!' Legislative Assembly. All that that ,Article lays down is that Parliament may by law create a body whether elected or partly nominated or partly elected to function as a Legislature in the Union Territory. Such a Legislature created by Parliament is not a legislative Assembly as contemplated under Art. 168 or Art. 54. Members of Legislatures created for Union Terri- . tories under Art. 239A cannot, therefore, be held to be members of Legis-. lative A&<iemblies of States. They were, therefore, rightly excluded from the EJ,~toral College. [314 C-El (x) On the .face of it the argument that s. 5(2) of the Act contravenes Art, 58 or any other Article of the Constitution has no force at all. The !'equirement laid down by Parliament that every person. must be nominated by two electors as proposer and seconder is a reasonable requirement relating to regulation of election to the office of President and cannot be held to be a curtailment of the right of a candidate to stand as candidate under Art. 58. [315 E) (xl) If in fact a licence had been granted to a private limited company with the specific purpose of obtaining the vote of an elector, for the respondent, that could constitut~ bribery. However from the evidence led on this issue on behalf of the. petitioners themselves no case at aU of commission of the offence of bribery during the election period could possibly be established. [316 G-Hl (C) Per Sikri, Shelat and Vaidialing~:iffi, JJ. (Bbargava and Mitter, JJ. Concurring)-The pat-ties must bear t~eir own costs.. The .,amphlet had been sent by post and distributed in the Centtal Hall and this justified the petitioners in bringing the two main petitions. Most of the evidence which was led in court dealt with the question of the distribution of the pamphlet. Further, a number of witnesses bad not told the whole truth. It was distressing to see truths being sacrificed at the altar of political advantage by these witnesses. [288 B--C]
OJUGINAL JURISDICTION : Election Petitions Nos. 1 and 3 to
5 of 1969. Petitions under Part ID of the Presidential and Vice-Presiden~
tial Elections Act, 1952. f-L308Sup.Cif71
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
t rLJ7 11 ~ s.c.~<.
/
A1. S. Gupta. K. C. Sharma, K. !.., Rathi and C. L. l.akhml(l({{.
for lhc petitioner (in E. P. No. 1 of 1969). Petitioner in person (in E. P. No. 3 of 1969).
K. C. Sharma, K. L. Rathi, C. L. Lakhanpal, S. K. Dhingra and M. S. Gupta, for the petitioners (in E.P. No. 4 of 1969).
S, C. Malik, M. S. Gupta and K. L. Rathi, for the petitioners (in E.P. No. 5 of 1969). · " C. K. Daphtary, D. Narsaraju, Mohan Kumaramangalam, S. T. De;o,ai, S. K. Dholakia and A. S. Nambiar, for the respondent (in E.P. No. 1 of 1969).
Jagadish Swarup, So!icito~General, L. M. Singhri, R. H. Dhebar and S.- P. Nayar, for respondent No. 1 (in E.P. No. 3 of 1969) and the Attorney-General for India, Election Commission of India and Returning Officer, Presidential Election (in E.Ps. Nos. 3 to 5 of 1969). C. K. Daphtary, D. Narsaraju, Mohan Kumaramanga/am, A. S. Nambiar and S. K. Dholakia. for respondent No. 2 (in E.P. No.3 of 1969).
C. K. Daphtary, D. Narsa1·aju, S. T. Desai, Mohall Kwnara• mangalam, H. K. L. Bhagat, s. K. Dholakia, J. B. Dadacllanji, Ra~·inder Narain and 0, C. Mathur, for the respondent (in E.Ps. Nos. 4 and S of 1969).
·o
Jagadish Swarup, Solicitor-General, L. M. Sing~vl, S. P. Nayar,. R. H. Dhebar and Lily Thomas, for the Attorney-General for India, Election Commission of India and Returning Otllcer, Presi~ dential Election (in E. P. No. 1 of 1969).
The Judgment of S.M. Sikri, J. M. Shelat and C. A. Vaidia· lingam JJ., was delivered by Sikri, J. Bhargava, J. add Mitter, J. gav~ separate opinions. These four election petitions filed under s. 14 of the Presiden· tial.and Vice-Presidential Election Act (XXXI of 1952) (herein·atter referred to as the Act), and Art. 71 of the Constitution of India cha1lenge the election of the respondent Shri V. V. Giri, to the office of the President of India. The petitioner in Election Petition No. 1 of 1969, Shri Shiv Kirpal Singh, was a candidate in the election, and so was the petitioner in Election Petition No. 3, Shri Phul Singh. The nominations of both these petitioners were rejected by the Returning Officer.· Election Petition No. 4 was filed by Shri N. Sri Rama Reddy, M.P., and twelve other electors, all members of Parliament. Eleetion Petition No. 5 was .filed by Shri Abdul Ghani Dar, M.P., and nine other members of
S. K. SlNGH V, SHRl V. V, GIRl (Sikri, J.)
20~
Parliament and eight members of Legislative Assemblies llt Haryana, Madhya. Pradesh and Bihar. Shri V. V. Giri is the sole respondent in Election Petitions Nos. 1, 4 and 5 while in Election Petition No. 3 he was impleaded as respondent No. 2 and Union of India, through the Election Commission, was impleaded as respondent No. l.
I
After the sad demise of the then President of India, Dr. Zakir Hussain, on May 3, 1969, the Election Commission issued a notification under s. 4 of the Act appointing July 24,_ 1969, as the· last date for filing the nomination papers> July 26, 1969, as _the date for scrutiny of the nomination papers, and July 29, 1969, as the last date for withdrawal of nomination papers. Polling was fixed for August 16, 1969. 24 nomination papers were filed before the Returning Officer. On scrutiny which took place on July 26, 1969, the ~eturning Officer rejected 9 nomination papers, including the nomination papers of Shri Shiv Kirpal Singh, petitioner in Election Petition No. 1, and Shri Phul Singh, petitioner in Election Petition No. 3. He accepted the nomination papers of 15 candidates. No candidate withdrew his nomination by the· due date. Counting of votes took place on August 20, 1969, when the result was announced and the respondent, Shri V. V. Giri,.
was declared elected.
The election was sought to be challenged on various grou11ds in these election petitions. Some of these grounds were common. The ·grounds may be broadly fonnulated as follows :
(1) That the nomination papers of Shri Shiv Kirpal
Sing~, .Shri Charan Lal Sahu ~d Shri Yogi Raj were w~ngly accepted by the RetlimiDg Officer;
(2) That the nomination papers of Shri V. V. Giri,
~he respondent, were wrongly accepted by the Returnmg Officer;
(~) That the nomination papers of Shri Ra'bho' Pan_durang Nathuji, Shri Santqsh Singh K:achh~aJ Shn ·Babu Lal Mag and Shri Ram Dulate Tripathi wer~ wrongly accepted by the Returning Officer;
(4) That Part III and section 21 of the Act a ultra-vires, the Constitution; re
. (5) T~at ~ules 4 and 6(3)(a) of the Presidential and
VIce~Pre&dentlal Election Rules, 1952 (hereinafter referred to as the Rules), promulgated under section 21 of the Act, are ultra vires the Constitution and. th
A~
e
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] 2 S.C.R.
(6) That the elected members of the Legislat:i_ve Assemblies of the Union Territories· were entitled to be included in the El~toral college for the election of the President and their wrongfulnon·in~lusion had not only ll}~Jerially affected the result of. the election but also Vlolated Art. 14 of the Constitution;
(7) That the petitioners were entitled to dispute the election even OJ:l grounds other than those mentioned in s. 18 of the Act; (8) That the offence of bribery at the election had been committed by the respondent and his supporters wtih his connivance; and
(9) That the result of the election had been ma!e· riallv affected by the commission of the offence of bri· becy by persons other than the respondent. In addition to these allegation:) it was alleged that the offence of undue influence had been committed at the eleetion with the connivance of the respondent. In any event the result of the election had been materially affected by the commission of this offence. We will elaborate the pleadings on this point when we come to deal with the issues arising out of that allega1·ion. ·
We have read the judgment prepared by Bhargava, J. He has deal~ fully with the issues arising out of the allegatiop.s other than
the allegation of undue influence and, as we agree with him, it is not necessary to add anything to his reasoning. We may, however, reproduce the issues and the conclusions thereon.
Issue No. 5 of Electio~ Petitions Nos. 1, 4 and 5I 1969
E. P. No. .1 : Whether section 21 of the Act. is ultlt!
vires the Constitution of India ?
E. P. Nos: Whether Part ID and section 21 of the Act are ultra vires the Constitution of India ? We hold that Part ill and section 21 of the Act are not l!ltra vlres the Constitution of India.
.
Issue No. 6 of EleCtion Petitions Nos. 1, 4 and 5/69 E. P. Nos. 1, 4 & 5 : Whether Rules 4 and 6(3) (e) of the Rules are ultra vires the Constitution and the ru1e-making power of the Central Government ?
.H
S. K. SINGH v. SHRI V. V. GIRl (Sikri, /,)-
We hold that r. 4(3) of the Rules was validly made by the Government in exercise of its rule-making power under s. 21 of tlul Act. That rule being valid, rule 6(3)(e) of the Ru1es, which is consequential, must also be held to be valid.
Issue No. i in Election Petitions Nos. 1, 4 & 5/ .i969 E.P. No. 1: Whether the nomination papers -of tM petitioner, Charan Lal Sahu and Yogi Raj were wroogly rejected as alleged in pargraphs 5(a) and (b), 6 and 7 of the petition ? E.P. No. 4 : Whether the nomination papers of Shiv Kirpa1 Singh, Charan Lal Sahu and Yogi Raj were wrongly rejected, as alleged in paragraphs 8(a) and 9(a), (b) and (c) of the petition? E.P. No. 5: Whether the nomination papers of Shiv Kirpal Singh, Charan Lal Sahu and Yogi Raj were wrongly rejected as alleged in paragraphs 8(a) and 9 of the petition ? We hold that the nomination paper of Shri Shiv Kirpal Singh was rightly rejected on the ground that it was not accompanied by a certified copy of the entry relating to him in the electoral roll of the Parliamentary constituency in which he was registered as a voter. We further hold that the nomination paper of Shri Charan Lal Sahu was rightly rejected on the ground that he was not 35 years of age on the date of nomination. We also hold that the nomination paper of Shri Yogi Raj was rightly rejected on the ground that he had been proposed and seconded by the same electors who had proposed and seconded another candidate, Shri Rajbhoj Pandurang Nathuji, the nomination paper of the latter having been received earlier by the Returning Officer. Issue No. 2 in Election Petition Nos. 1 and 5 and Issue No. 3 in Election Petition No. 4 of 1969 E.P. No. 1 : Whether the nomination paper of the respondent were wrongly accepted as alleged in paragraphs 5(c) and 8 of the petition? E.P. No. 4 : Whether the nomination papers of the respondent were wrongly accepted as alleged in paragraphs 8(c) and 11 of the petition? E.P. No. 5_ : Whether the nomination papers of the respondent were wrongly accepted as alleged in paragraphs 8(b) and 10 of the petition ? We hold that the nomination papers ·of the respondent were validly a~: The certified ~ies of the electoral roll filed with the nommation papers were ISsued by the appropriate authority.
·j
~
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1971 ]2 S.C.R.
lssue No. 3 in E. Ps. Nos. 1 & 5 and issue No. 2 in E.P. No. 4/1969 E.P. No. 1 : Whether the nomination papers of Rajbhcj Pandurang Nathuji and Babu Lal Mag were wrongly accepted as alleged in paras 5(d) and 9 of the petition '? E.P. No. 4 : Whether . the nomination papers. of Rajbhoj Pandurang Nathuji, Babu Lal Mag and Ram Dulare Tripathi v.·ere wrongly accepted as alleged in ~aragraphs 8(b) and 1O(a), (b) and (c) of the petition? E.P. No. 5 : Whether the nomination . papers of Rajbhoj Pandurang Nathuji, Santosh Singh Kachhwaha, Babu Lal Mag and Ram Dulare Tripathi were wrongly accepted as alleged in paragraphs 8(c) and 11 of the petition'? We hold that the nomination paper of Shri RajbhoLEandurang . Nathuji was validly accepted, the certified copy of the ele:ctor~l.· I) . . . roll filed by him was a valid and a good COPY..· . We further hold .· .that the nomination paper of Shri Santosh Singh Kachhwaha was not invalid even though he signed his nomination paper before . his seconder had signed it. His nomination paper, therefore, was . rightly accepted. We further hold. that the nomination paper of. · .Shri Babu Lal Mag was not invalid even though he had signed his nomination paper before it was signed by the proposer and the · E seconder. His nomination paper was, therefore, rightly accepted. We further hold that the nomi11ation paper of Shri Ram Dulare Tripathi was not invalid. The disputed signatures have not been shown to be not genuine. · Issue No. 4 in E.P. No. 1 and issue No. 7 in E.P. Nos. 4 and 5
d 1969
(a) Whether the elected members of the Legislative Assemblies of the Union Territories were entitled to be included in the electoral college for the election of the President? (b) If so, whether the non-inclusion of the inen1bers of the Legislative Assemblies of the Union Territories in the electoral college amounts to non-compliance with the provisions of the Constitution ? If so, whether the result of the election has been materially affected by such non~compliance ?
. {c) Whether the alleged non-compliance with the provisions of the Constitution has violated Article 14 ()f the Constitution '! ··. ·
..H
S. K. SINGH v. SHRI V. V. GIRl (Sikri, J.)
We hold that members of Legislatures created for Union Territories under Art.· 239A cannot be held to be members of Legislative Assemblies of States. They were, therefore, rightly excluded from the ·electoral college. Issue No. 4(a) in Election Petition No. 1 and Issues Nos. 7(a) in Election Petitions Nos. 4 and 5 are accordingly decided against the petitioners.. In view of this conclusion Issue No. 4(b) and Issue No. 4(c) of Election Petition No. 1 t~nd hsues Nos. 7(b) and (c) of Election Petitions Nos. 4 and 5 do not arise. Issues Nos. J and 2 in Election Petition No. 3 of 1969
I. Whether the nomination paper of Phul Singh, the petitioner, was wrongly rejected ?
2. What relief, if any, is the petitioner entitled to?
We hold tqat the nomination paper of Shri Phul Singh was rightly rejected on the ground that his nomination paper was not signed either by a proposer or a seconder. Election Petition No. 3 of 1969 accordingly fails and is liable to be dismissed. Issue No. 8 in Election Petitions Nos. 4 and 5I 1969 E.P. No. 4: (a). Whether the petitioners are entitled to dispute the election of the respondent on grounds othc;r than those mentioned in section 18 of the Act ?
(b) If issue No. 8(a) is decided in favour of the petitioners, (i) whether the respondent or any person with his connivance printed, published .and distributed the pamphlet, at Annexure A-3, to the petition?
\ii) Whether the pamphlet, at Annexure A-3, contained any false statement of facts relating to the personal character and conduct of N. Sanjiva Reddy, ~ candidate at the election and other persons named in the pamphlet?
(iii) Whether the persons found responsible for publishing the pamphlet believed the statements made therein as true or had reason to believe them to be true?
(iv} Whetber the pamphlet was published with the object of prejudlcitac 6e, ~.of the election of Sanjiva Reddy and furtliering the prospects of the election of the respondent' , (v) Whether the election of the respondent is liable :to be declared void On tbis ground ?
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] 2 s.c.R.
E.P. No. 5 : Issue 1No. 8 in Election Petition No. 5 is ~bstantialJv the same except that the annexure in Petition No. 5. is Annexure A-38 anci not Annexure . . A-3. On the first part of Issue No. 8 we hold that the petitioners are not entitled to dispute the election of the respondent on grounds other than those mentioned in s. 8 of the Act. The other part of the issues, as a consequence, do not arise at all.
Issues Nos. 9, 9A and 10 in E.P. No. 5/1969 9. Whether the respondent or any other person with his connivance committed the offence of bribery as alleged in paragraph 15 of the petition?
9A. Whether the allegations in para 15 constitute bribery within the meaning of the Act ? 10. Whether the offence of bribery was committed at .the election by any other person without the connivance of the respondent as alleged in paragraph 15 of the petition, and if so, whether it materially affected the result of the election ? We hold that no offence of bribery was committed in the matter of grant of licence for the Polyester factory to Swadeshi Cotton
Mills.
This leaves Issues Nos. 4 in Election Petition No. 4 and Election Petition No. 5. These read as follows: E.P. No.4
(a) Whether all or any of the allegations made in paragraphs 8(e) and 13(a) to (m) of the petition. constitute in law an offence of undue influence undt!r section 18(1)(a) of the Act? (b) Whether the said allegations made in paragraphs 8(e) and 13(a) to (m) are trilf~ and proved?
(c) In the event of these allegations being proved and constituting undue influence, (i) whether the returned candidate has committed the offence of undue influence ? (ii) whether the offence of undue 1nfluence was committed by his workers, and if so, with his connivance ?
"
S. K. SINGH v. SHRI V. V, GIRl (Sikri, J.)
(iii) whether the offence of undue intluence was committed by others without his connivance, and if so, whether that has materially affected the result of the election?
-
E.P. No.5 (a) Whether all or any of the allegations made in paragraphs 8(e) and 13 of the petition constitute in law an offence of undue influcmce Jlnder section 18 (l)(a) of the Act? (b) Whether the said allegations in paragraphs 8(e) and 13 are true and proved ? . (c) In the event of these allegations being proved ~md constituting undue infiuenoo(i) whether the returned candidate has committed the offence of undue influence ?
(ii) whether the offence of undue influence was committed by his workers, and if so, with his connivance? (iii) whether the offence of undue irifluence was committed by others without his connivance, and if so, whether that has materially affected the result of the election? We may now refer to the pleadings relevant to Issue No. 5 in Election Petition No. 5.
In para 8(e) of the petition it is stated that the offences of undue influence at the election have been committed by the retw:ped candidate. and by his supporters with the connivance of the returned candidate. It is further stated that the. material facts in support of this ground are in para 13 of the petition. In para 13(a) are set out the facts which according to the petitioners led to the sharp cleavage between the electors of the Congress Party and all electors in general. In brief, the history of the dispute between the two sections of the party, which we will refer to as Congress (R) led by Shri Jagjivan Ram and Congress (0) led by Shri Nijalingappa, was set out. We need not extract the pleadings on this part of the case in detail because we will briefly refer to the background of the dispute and the facts as proved before us. But we may mention that this Court is not concerned with the merits of the dispute between the two sections of the Congress Party and we will consider this matter only insofar as it throws any light on the question of the offence of undue influence.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[ J 971
F S.C.R.
In paragraph 13(b)(ii) it was alleged that "Shri Nijalingappa, A. Shri S. K. Patil, Shri K. Kamaraj, Shri Morarji Desai and Shri Y. B. Chavan, electors at the election, were threatened by Smt. Indira Gandhi on July 12, 1969, at Bangalore with serious consequences with the object of unduly influencing these people for . changing their decision to nominate Shri N. Sanjiva Reddy as their candidate. The threat given was repeated subsequently between B 12th and 16th July, 1969 a 'number of time~." By order dated January 23, 1970, we directed that the petitioners w~re not entitled to lead evjdence on this sub-para because we were of the.· opinion that these allegations, even if accepted, did not constitute any inter·f7rence with the electoral right as defined in s. 171-A of the lndran Penal Code, i:e. the right to vote or refrain from voting · c at an election. As far as Shri. Sanjiva Reddy was concerned there is no allegation that the Prime Minister had interfered or attempted to interfere with . his right to stand as a candidate. , In para 13(b)(iii) it was alleged that a nun1ber of supporters of the returned candidate, and in particular Shri Jagjivan Ram, Shri Yunus Saleem, Shri Shashi Bhushan, Shri Krishan Kant and Shri Chandra Shekhar, Shri Jagat Narain, Shri Mohan Dharia and Shri S. M. Banerji, with the consent or the connivance of the returned candidate, published by free distribution a pamphlet, Annexure A-38, in Hindi and English, in cyclostyled form as well as in printed form. in which very serious allegations were made which amounted to undue in~uence within the meaning of s. 171C cf the Indian Penal Code. ·
In para 13(b)(iv) it was alleged that "this pamphlet was <.listributed frorn 9th to 16th August, 1969, among all the electors of the electoral college for the Presidential election. During these . .days it was also distributed in the Central Hall of the Parliament by the persons mentioned nbove. A large number of elector.~ were asked to read the cllntents of this pamphlet and they were asked "Will you vote for such a debauch <md corr,Upt man ?" The mindsof the voters were so unduly influenced and an impression was purposely sought to be created that if Mr. Reddy was elected to the office of the President of India, the Rashtrapati Bhavan will G become a centre of vice and immorality and that Shri Reddy wilt assume dictatorial powers and will bring an end to democracy iu India. This scare was created in the minds of. the electors with the direct object of interfering with their free exercise of their electoral right to vote for the candidate of their choice. As a ·single instance Shri Yunus Saleem approached Shri Abdul Ghani Dar, Member of Parliament, one of the petitioners herein, a11d talked to ·him in this beh<tlf as stated earlier. This was said in the presence ·of a number of Members of Parliament."
'
..·
S~ K. SINGH v~ SHRI V. V. GIRl (Sikri, J.)
.··.
In sub-para 13(b)(v) it was alleged that the petitioner, Shri Abdul ~bani Dar, "wro~ a letter to Shri V. V. Girl, copy of which was ·~ndorsed. to the Pnme Minister and Shri Humayun Kabir." In thJs 1ett~r .the petitioner requested Shri V. V. Giri, to condemn those ":ho ~a~ pub~shed this pamphlet and make a public state18 ment dJssoctatmg htmself from and denouncing the publishers of the pamphlet but Shri V. V. GirLfailed to do so. In sub-para: 12(b) (vi) it was alleged that 'this low level pamphlet had evoked .great public and press criticism and it came out openly in the press that such low level pamphlets were being distributed in the ·election campaign.'·' It was further alleged that .C' ' 1even news items regarding this pamphlet appeared in almost all .. ~ Jeading newsp~pers o.f the country. In spite of this, the returned . candidate, who was repeatedly harping upon and asking for votes in the name of character, integrity, etc., failed to dissociate him.· .self. from the pamphlet or even to condemn the same." D .
II
It was alleged in sub-para (viii) that "the language of the pamphlet and the laudatory references to Smt. Indira Gandhi and her followers themselves point to the origin of the pamphlet." In sub-para (ix) of para 13!b) reference was made to a letter issued by Shri Madhu Limaye, M.P., which he wrote to the Election Commission of Inoia, protesting against the alleged pamphlet and requesting 'him to take appropriate action. In sub-para (x) reference is made to the reply of the Chief Election Commissioner. It was alleged in sub-para (xi) that a similar letter was written by Shri Kanwar Lal Gupta, M.P., to the Election Commission, and in sub-para (xii) reference was made to the reply of the Chief Election Commissioner dated August 14, 1969. 1n sub-para (xiii) it was alleged that the returned candidate. Shri V. V. Giri, made various statements at various places condemning the decision of the Congress Parliamentary Board in selecting Shri Reddy as its candidate and described it as irnnHl· ture. It is further alleged that Shri V. V. Giri. "repeatedly stated that a man of chaxacter and integrity should huve been selected.'' "The· returned candidate in well guarded language was stating that Mr. Reddy was not a man of character. He also exhorted Congressmen to demand a right of vote and made capital of the Congress President's appeal to Jan Sangh and. Swatantara Party.'' In sub-para (c)(i) of para 13 it was alleged that "the supporters of the returned candidate, Smt. Indira Gandhi, Shri Jagjivan Ram, Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahn)ed, Shri Yunus Saleem, Dr~ ~ran Singh. Shri Dil).esh Singh, Shri Swaran Singh, Shri I. K. Gujral. Shri Satya Narain Sinha, Shri K. K. Shah and Shri Triguna Sen \\We a11 occupying high ministeriat positions in the Central Gov-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971 ]2 S.C.R.
ernment and they misused these positions for furthering the prospects of the returned candidate by telephoning a large number of electors from their ministeriJl telephones of the Government, openly telling them that it was a matter of prestige and existence for them and that if the electors did not vote according to their wishes for Shri V. V. Giri, they would lose all their patronage and that if the electors voted as desired by them, they would receive aovernmental patronage at every step. So many electors were calkd by the above named Ministers at their official residences and offices in Delhi and undue influence was brought upon them by ordering them to vote for the returned candidate." It was further stated that the returned candidate, Shri V. V. Giri, sounded one of the Ministers mentioned above to influence the particular elec tors who were not found amenable to his own influence or persuasion.
In para 13(c)(ii) reference was made to Shri Yunus Saleem, De,l)uty Law MinistJer, obtaining signatures of the members of Rajya Sabha on some paper which in effect amounted to pledging their support for Shri V. V. Giri, the returned candidate, and what happened in he Rajya Sabha in connection with that incident. In sub-para 13(c)(iii) it is alleged that Shri Fakhruddin J.Ji Ahmed and Shri Yunus Saleem threatened the Muslim voters that Shri Sanjiva Reddy was in fact a candidate of the Jan Sangh party and if he was f-leeted the fate of the Muslim community in India will be in danger and in constant threat of extinction. A!:.. instance was given when Shri Yunus Saleem met Shri Abdul Ghani DarJ petitioner, and talked to him in the same terms. Further, reference was made to a letter issued by Shri Abdul Ghani Dar to all Muslim electors describing such a threat as baseless and mischievous. In sub-para (iv) reference was made to a letter written by Shri Abdul Ghani Dar to the press in this connection. In paras 13(c)(v) and (vi) reference was made to a threat issued to the ·members of the Legislative Assembly of Bengal that if Shri Sanjiva Reddy was elected he would enforce President's rule in Bengal, thus wiping off the United Front Government and the Legislative Assembly. Reference was made to a news item appearing in the papers on August 12, 1969, in this connection. We need not say anything more about this allegation because we refused to al!Qw evidence to be led on this jssue, as the allegations do not, even if accepted, amount to "undue influence." In sub-para (vii) it was alleged that a threat was issued to the Members of the Legislative Assembly of Andhra Pradesh that the Assembly would be dissolved if Shri Reddy was elected. By
{.C
S. K. SINGH v. SHRI V. V. GIRl (Sikri, J.)
order dated January 23, 1970, we refused to allow evi?ence to be taken on this point as the allegations do not, even if accepted, amount to "undue influence". Some other allegations of undue influence. yrere made in th.e subsequent paras but we did not allow the petltiOn~rs to lead evidence on those paras and they need not be mentioned.
I
r
The respondent, Shri V. V. Giri, in his reply first stated that "I propose to traverse the allegations directly m.ade against me and also the ininuations or innuendoes that anythmg was d~me at my instance or with my knowledge and consent or conmvance. I submit that I cannot traverse the allegations made against the Prime Minister or any other persorl as I do not have personal knowledge thereof." The respondent did not, however, admit any of the allegations or insinuations against such persons and it was submitted that the petitioners were put to strict proof of every one of them. The respondent denied the allegation in sub-para (i) of para 13(b) of the petition and said that "I was always appealing to the voters to exercise their vote according to their conscience and free will. I was, in fact, conducting my campaign single-handed." In roply to sub-para (iii) the respondent characterised the allegations as most reckless, wild and false and emphatically denied them. He stated that "nowhere or at no time was it ever aJleged within my knowledge that I or my supporters had anything to do with the publication or circulation of the alleged pamphlets." In reply to sub-para (iv) of para 13(b) the respondent stated that he had nc- knowledge and did not admit any of the allegations made in that para and the petitioners were put to strict proof. He also did not admit that Shri Yunus Saleem approached Shri Abdul Gnani Dar, as alleged.
In reply to sub-paras (v) and (vi) of para 13(b) the respondent denied that he had received any letter from Shri Abdul Ghani Dar. He stated that the only letter he received from Shri Abdul Ghani Dar was a letter dated July 24, 1969, in reply to respondent's circular letter to the electors seeking their support. He further denied that he ever received a copy of the alleged pamphlet. He further stated : "I say that in fact I saw the letter of August 11 1969 of Shri Dar and the pamphlet attached as annexure to ~ Petition only after I received the copy of the Election Petition and the annexures. I ent!rely repud!ate that I had anything to do with the pamphlet before Its publication or after its publication. I also d~ny .that. any of my workers or supporters bad anything to do With It, With my knowledge or connivance."
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1971] 2 S.C.R.
" A.
In reply to sub-para (Viii) of para l3 (b) the respondent ~eni~d that pers?ns alleged to be his wor~ers and supporters were ·dts: tributing the· pamphlet and were telling V'!ters not to vote for Shn · Reddy, as alleged. He characterised both these allegations as baseless and false. In reply' to sub-para (ix) he said that he was · not aware of the letter, Annexure A-39. In reply to sub-para · (x)· he said that this. matter was not relevant. In reply to sub-para B (xi) it .was asserted that Shri Gupta's allegations were wild and baseless and the matter was irrelevant. In reply to sub-para (xii) . he had no submission to make except that the matter was irre· levant.
With reference to sub-para (xlii) of para 13(b) the respondent · c
·
.. denied that during his tour of various places mentioned in the said' · · -paragraph he stated in any well-guarded language or otherwiSe · ·
that Shri Reddy was not a man of char~cte.r. He stated that .throughout his · statements he adhered to the stand he had taken · his first statement of July 13, '1969, announcing his decisjon · · to stand as a candidate for the office of the President. He also D annexed copy of a Press Statement issued on August 10, 1969, in which he reiterated the aforesaid stand.
in
With reference to s~b-para. (i) of para 13(c) the respondent characterised the allegations as reckless, and irresponsible. The petitioner also denied that he sounded any Minister as alleged in . the sub-para.
With reference to sub-paras (ii), (iii), (iv) and (v) of para 13(c) the respondent said that he had no personal knowledge but ..put the petitioners· to strict proof. · The respondent further replied to other paragraphs but noth~ . ·. · ing much turns on th~m. We may mention that at various places the respondent alleged that the paras -were vague and no particulars had been. given. · .., . I
·F
·.· .. The resp~:md~nt ask~ for particulars on various points and . ~his Court directed particulars to be supplied. Particulars were
· ~upplied regarding para 13(b)(xiii) and para 13(c)(i). We \\!ill , refer to the particulars whenever it is deemed necessary while· ap. predating the evidence of the petitioners .
.. .· We need not refer in detail to the allegations in Election Petition No. ·4 which are substantially similar to those in Petition No. · 5. The Advocate-on-Record for Election Petition No. 4 and · Election Petition No. S was the same and common evidence was ·· 100. in both the petitions and common arguments were addressed · : thereon.
S. K. SINGH V. SHRI V. V. GIRl (Sikri, 1.)
22 I
From the pleadings ~nd the evidence led the main points which arise for our determination are : (1) What is the true interpretation of s. 18 of the Act ?
(2) Was the pamphlet distributed by post to the electors?
(3) Was the pamphlet distributed in the Central Hall of Parliament '? (4) Does the distribution of the pamphlet by post and or in the Central Hall constitute undue influence under s. 18 of the .Act? (5) Was this pamphlet distributed with the connivance of the returned candidate? (6) Whether the offence of undue infiuence was committed by others without his connivance, and if so, whether it had mate· rial effect on the result of the election ?
Let us first address ourselves to the question of interpretation of s. J 8. We have read the Yiews .expressed by Bhargava, J., and Mitter J., but with respect we differ from them. Bhargava, J., has held that the distribution of the pamphlet amount¢ to an oftcnce under s. 171G, I.P.C., and not under s. 171C, I.P.C. According to Mitter, J., distribution of the pamphlet by post and in the Central Hall does n\)t by itself fall within s. 18 of the E Presidential and Vice-Presidential Election Act, 1952. According to him, before any publication of a defamatory matter relating to a candidate can be treated as commission of the offence of undue influence there must be some overt act in addition to the mere publication-some attempt or persuasion of a voter to res~~-train the free choice of a candidate before the law of undue in· F .ftuence is attracted. In our opinion,. if distribution of the pamph· let by post to electors or in the Central Hall is proved it would constitute 'undue inftuence• within s. 18 and it is not necasary fo.r the petitioners to go further and prove that statements contained in the pamphlet wete made the subject of a verbal appeal or persuasion_.by one member of the electoral college to anotl1er and particularly to those in the Congress fold.
The Presidential arid Vice-Presidential Elections Act, 1952, was passed to regulate certain matters relating t<> or connected with electrons to the office~ lnt~r alia, of the President of India. Part Ill o~ the A~t deals with disputes regarding elections and s. 18 therer~ contame.d la~s down the g~unds for declaring the election of a H'turned candrdate to he vord. Th~ relevant part of the: section pwvidcs : ''If the Supreme Court is of opinion :
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[I971J 2 s.C.R.·
(a) that the offence of bribery or undue influence,at the election has been committed by the returned candidate or by an~person with the cvnnivance of thereturned candidate; or (b) that the result of the election has been materially affected (i) by reason that the offence of bri_bery or undue influence at the election has been committed by any person who is neither the returned candidate nor a person acting with his. connivance. . . . . the Supreme Court shall decl~re the election of the returned candidate to be void/' Under s. 18, therefore, the election has to be declared to be void .jf, amongst other things, undue influence has been committed (i) by the returned candidate himself, (ii) by a person with his con· nivance,or (iii) by any wrson who is neither the returned candi· date nor one having actt;<t wtih his connivance, if the result of the election has been materially affected. S.ection 18(2) declares that for the purposes of this section the offences of bribery and undue inBuence at an election have the same meaning as in Chapter IX-A of the Indian Penal Code. We may here com~are the provisions of s. 18(1)(a) and s. 18(1)(b)(i) read with s. 18(2) with s. 123 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. 'This section lays down corrupt practiCes for the purposes of that Act which include undue in.ftuence upon· proof of which an election ·has to be. set aside. Though undUe influence for purposes of that Act has ·the '\Same meaning as in the . present Act, that section does not go as far as s. 18 of the present Act so as to provide that even if it is committed by a third party, that is to say, not an election agent nor a person with the consent of the returned candidate, the election would still be declared to ·be void provided of course that it has been materially affected .bY such undue influence. From the fact that both these .ACU, were enacted by the same Legislature and Act 31 of 1952 wa-s passed after the Representation of the People Act was passed~ it is .clear that Parliament deliberately made s. 18 stricter than the Representation of the People Act, firstly, by using the words "connivance of the returned <;andidate" instead of the words "his· con~erit'~. and secondly, by i~cluding undue influence committed even by a stranger, having nothing to do with the returned candidate, as a ground for declaring the election to be void, the only condition in respe~t of such an act being that it should have materially affected t~e election. The object .of do~1g so is obvious, namely,. that Parl1ament wanfed to ensure that 1n respect of an election for the highest office in the realm the election should be comple· tely free from any improper . influence emanating even from a
'.
S. K. SINGH v. SHRI V. V. GIRl (Sikri, /.)
third party with whom the returned candidate had no connection and without any connivance on his part. The only limitation, as aforesaid, placed in s. 18 is that in such a case it has to be established that the election was materially affected. The ques~ tions, therefore. which would arise under s. 18 would be : (1) Has the offence of undue influence been committed? (2) If so, was jt committed by the returned candidate or by a person with his connivance '? and ( 3) even if the offence committed was by a stranger and without the connivance of the returned candidate, ha• the committal of that offence by such "any person" materially affected the election ? Chapter IXA of the P~nal Code which deals with offences relating to elections was introduced in the Code by the Indian Eleciion Offences and Inquiries Act (XXXIX of 1920). Section 171A defines 'candidate' and 'electoral right'. An electoral right means the right of a person to stand or not to stand as, or to withdraw from being •. a candidate or to vote or refrain from voting at an election. Section 171 C, which deals with the offence of undue influence reads as under : "(1) Whoever voluntarily interferes or attempts to interfere with the free exercise of any electoral. right commits the offence of undue influence at an election. ( 2) Without prejudice to the generality of the provisions of sub-section (1), whoever(a) threatens any candidate or voter, or any person in whom a candidate or voter is interested, with injury of any k~nd, or , (b) induces or attempts to induce a candidate or voter to believe that -he or any person in whom he is in~ terested will become or will be rendered. an object of Divine displeasure or of spiritual censure, shaH be deemed to interfere with the free exercise of the electoral right of such candidate or voter within · ' the ~]leaning of sub-section (1)." Su~section (3) lays down that:
. "A_ declaration of public policy or a promise of pub!lc actiOn,_ or the me!e exercise of a legal right without mtent to mterfere With an electoral right, shaH not be deemed to be interference within the meaning of this section."
section 171F provides for the penalty for the offence of undue influence which is either imprisonment upto one year or with fine or both. Section 171 G provides : l-L30S Sup CJ/71
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971]2 S.C.L
"Whoever with intent to affect the result of an election makes or publishes any statement purporting to be a statement of fact which is false and which he either · knows or believes to be false or does not believe· to be true in relation to the personal character or conduct of any 'candidate shall be· punished with fine," The electoral right of an electQr, as defined in s. 171A(b) of the Indian Penal Code, means "the right of a person to stand. or not to stand as, or to withdraw from· being, a candidate or to vote or refrain from voting at an election." It was said that the right to vote envisages two stages; the first s(age is when the elector goes through the mental process of weighing the merits and demerits of the candidates and then making- his choice and the second stage is when having made his choice he goes ~o cast his vute in favour of the candidate of his choice. The argument was that the language of s. 171 C suggests that undue influence comes the second and not at the first stage. and therefore, it can in only be by way of some act which impedes or obst1 ucts the elector in his freely casting the vote, and not in any act which precedes the second stage, i.e., during the stage w1;ten he is making .his choice of the candidate whom he would support. Tbis argument was sought to be buttressed by the fact that canvassing is ~rmissible during the first stage, and therefore, the interference or attempted interference contemplated by s. 171 C can only be that which is .commit~ed at the stage when the elector exercises his ·right, i.e., after he has made up his mind to Vote for his'chosen candidate or to refrain from voting. It was further argued that the words Used in s. 171 C were "the free exercise of vote" and not "exercise of free vote." The use of those words shows that canvassing or propaganda, however, virulent, for or against "'a candidate would not amount to undue influence, and that undue influence can only mean some act by way of threat or fear of some. adverse consequence administered at the tim~ of casting the vote.
at
We do not think that the Legislature,- while framing Ch. IXA of the Code ever contemplated such a dichotomy or intended to give such a narrow meaning to the freedom· of franchise essential in a representa~ive system of government. In our opinion the argume~t mentioned ~bove is fallacious. It completely disregards the struclure and the' provi~ons of s. 171 C. Section 171 C is enacted in three oarts. The:jirst sub-section contains the definition of "undue 'influence~·~ This is in wide terms and renders a person voluntarily interfering or attempting to interfere with the free exercise of any eleetqr~l right guilty of committing undue influence. That this. is very~~~ !nd!cated by the ope_!ling sentence of sub-s. (2), r.e. "wtt~•r.-Jwhce to the generaltty of the '·~ ·,
•"
.
'
S. K. SlN5H v. SHRI '. V, GIRl (Sikri, J.)
provisions of sub-sectio~ (1)." I~ is ~ell-settlled .~at whoa tilis expression is used anythmg contamed m the proviS'J.ODS .foUowtag this expression is not intended to cut down the gqperabty of tile meaning of the precedi~g provision. This w~. so held by the Privy Council in King-Emperor v. Sibnath Baner}r( 1 ). It follows from this that we have to look at sub-s. (1) as it is without restriCting its provisions by what is contained in sub-s.(2). Sub-s.(3) throws a great deal of light on this question. It proceeds on the assumption t:bat a declara~ion of public policy or a promise of public action or ~e mere exercise ~ a lega! right ~ interfere with an electoral nght, and therefore 1t provides that If there is no intention to interfere with the electoral right it shaH. c not be deemed to be interference within the meaning of this section. At what stage would a declaration of public policy or a promise of public action act and tend to in·4erfere ? Surely only at the stage when a voter is trying to make up his min~ as to which candidate he would support. If a declaration of public policy or a promise of public action appeals to him, his mind would decide. in favour of the r.andidate who is propounding the public policy or promising a public action. Having made up his mind he would then go and vote and the declaration of public policy having had its effect it would no longer have any effect on the physical final ,
act of casting his vote.
I
,
Sub-section (3) further proceeds on the basis that the expression ..free exercise of his electoral right" does not mean that a voter is not to be inftuenced. This expression has to be read in the context of an election in a democratic society and the candi· dates and their supporters must naturally be allowed to canvass support by all legal and legitimate means. They may propound their programmes, policies and views on various questions ·which . are exercising the minds of the electors. This exercise of the right by a candidate or his supporters to canvass support does not interfere or attempt to interfere with the free exercise of the electoral right. What does, however, attempt to interfere with the free exercise of an electoral right is, if we may use the expression, "tyranny over the mind". If the contention of the respondent is to be acceD'ted, it would be quite legitimate on the part of a candidate or his supporter to hypnotise a voter and then send him to vote. At the stage of casting his ba Hot paper there would be no pressure cast on him becaus~ his mind has already been made up for him by the hypnotiser.. It ·was put Jike this in a book on EJections : "The freedom of election is two-fold; (1) freedom in _the-exercise of judgment. Every voter should be free (1) [194.5] F.C.R. 195.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] 2 S.C:R,·
to_-exercise his OW!l judgmem, in selecting the cand~~ date he believes to be best fitte4 to represent the constl·tuency; (2) Freedom to go a_nd have the means of going· . to the poll to give his vote without fear or intimidation." & (2)
e)
We are supported in this view by the statement of Object!> and Reasons attached· to the bill which .ultimately resulted in the enactment of Chapter IXA. That ~tatement explains in clear language that undue influence was intended to mean voluntary interference or attempted interference with the right of any person to stand or not to stand as or -withdraw from being a candidate or to vot~ or refrain from voting,.·and that the definition covers aU threats of injury to person nr property and all illegal methods oj persuasion, and ;any interfeFence with the liberty of the candidates or the electors. · "The legislature has wisely refrained from defining the forms interference may take. The ingenuity of the human mjnd is unlimited and perforce the· nature of interference must also be unlimited".'' (1) & e). .From a reading of s. 171 G it is clear that in pursuit ot purity of elections the legislature frowned upon attempts to_ assail such purity by means of false statements relating to the personal character and conduct of a candidate and made such acts punishable thereunder. But the fact that making of such a false statement is a distinct offence under s. 171 G does not and cannot mean that it cannot take· the graver form of undue influence punishable under s. 1.71 F. The false statement may he of such vtrulent, vulgar or scurrilous character that it would either deter or tend to deter voters from supporting that candidate whom they would have supported in the free exercise of their electoral right but for their being affected. or attempted to be affected by the maker or the publisher of such a statement. Therefore, it is the degree of gravity of the allegation which will be the determining factor in deciding whether it falls under s. 17.1 C or s. 171 G. If the allegation, though false and relating to a candidate's personal charac'kr or conduct, made w_ith the intent to affect the result of an election. does not amount to interference or attempt at such int~rference. the offence would be the lesser one. If, on the other hand. it amounts to interference or an attempt to interfere it would be the graver offence under s. 171 F read with s. 171C.
,_
We are also supported in our vie\v by a number of decisions given on similar statutory provisions. The Government of India (Provincial Elections) Corrupt Practices and Election Petitions - 0)- Law· and Prac;ice of Elections & Election Petitions-Nanak ('hand-1937 Ed. p. 36_ . . (2) Law of Elections and Election Petitions-- Nanak Cfland-1958 Ed. p. 263.
S. K. SINGH v. SHRl V. V. GIRl (Sikri, J.)
Order, 19-36, contains the following relevant provisions. The expression "electoral right" was defined in the same manner as in s. 171 A(b) of the Indian Penal Code. "Corrupt practice" in relation to an election by the members of a Provincial Legislative Assembly to fill seats in Provincial Legi~lative Council, means one of the practices specified in Parts I and II of •.he First Schedule to this Order. ·~undue influence" was defined in clause 2 of the First Schedule to mean "any direct or indirect interference or attempt to interfere on the part of a candidate or his agent, or of any o'ther person with the connivance of the candidate or his agent with the free exercise of any electoral right, provided that(a) -without prejudice t9 the generality of the provisions of this paragraph, any such person as is referred to therein who : ·
(i) threa~ens any candidate or elector, or any person in whom a candidate or elector is interested, with any injury of any kind; or (ii) induces or attempts to induce a candidate or
elector to b~Jieve that he, or any person in whom he is interested, will become or will be rendered an object of divine displeasure or spiritual cen·
sure, I
shall be deemed to interfere with the free exercise of th~ electoral right of that candidate or elector within the maning of this paragraph: (b) a declaration of public policy, or a promise of P.ub!ic .action•. or the mere exercise cif a legal
nght w•thout mtent to interfere with an electoral right, shall not be deemed to be interference within the meaning of this paragraph.'' Paragraph 5 of the First Schedule is similar to s. l71 G and reads as follows:
"The publicatio~ by a candidate or his agent, or by any other person w1th the connivance of the candidate or his agent, of any statement ct fact which is false and which he either believes to be false or does not b~lieve to l:>e true, in relation to the personal character or conduct of any candidate, or in relation to the candidature or .withdrawal of any candidate, being a statement reasonab y ca'culated to prejudice the prospects of that candidate's election."
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
!"J Li7! J 2 S.C. k.
{.hese provi;io~s were .the su~ject-nnller of decision by the ElccJon Tnbunal m A mntsar Cay ( Mahammndc111) Comtituenc,· Case No. 2 ( 1 ). It was observed <ts foilows : ' . ''.It is true that the definition of undue intlucnce i~ w1dely worded and covers all kinds of fraudulent acts ?r ~~~!iss~on~ which in any w.ay, directly or iHdirectly, mte1 ~·· ~re w1th the free exerc1se of any electnr<ll rioht and 11 1~ als~ tr;.~e that the detlnition extends not l)nly to actual mtertcrence but even to an attempi to interference.''
·A
But on the facts the Tribunal observed : "There is no .proper e.. idence of actual interference before us, and as regards the attempt, we have to s~e if there wa.• the deliberate intent to mislead voters and thus make them exercise their electoral right under the wrong impression that the respondent had been set up as a candidate by the Muslim League."
It was argued before the Commission that threat or element of compJJlsion was clfl essential ingredient of the corrupt practice ci undue influence. The Commission observed : "We cannot, however. find any basis in the definition of "undue influence'' for the proposition that unless M. Zaffar Ali· Khan threatened, or compelled the voters to vote in a particular manner, the offence of "undue influence'' was not complete. The definition of "undue influence" is very wide- in its terms ·and ·includes four different forms of interference viz., direr.t interference, indirect interference, direct attempt to interfere and indirect attempt to interfere, and it is nowhere laid down that such interference or attempt to interfere should be by the method of compulsion .... although we are prepared to concede that the inducement must be of such a ·powerful type as would leave no free will to the voter in the exercise of his choice. There would, of course, be in such a case mental compulsion in a sense but it is not necessary that there should be physical compulsion or that a threat must be actually held out by the person who interferes or attempts to interfere." ( p. 160) In Jujhar Singh v. Bhairon Lall(2) the petitioner was a Ram Rajiya Parishad candidate, and the ~espondent, Bhairon Lall, fought on the Congress ticket. It .was alleged that a poster was (1) The Indi'!ln Election Cases (193~·1950)-Doabia-Vol. H, 150-157. (2) 7 E.L.R. 457, 461.
t.
'L.
n
. s. K. SINGH v. SHRI V~ V. GIR.I (Sikri, I.)
published against ~e Ram R~ji~a Parishad and Jagirdars and ~is constituted undue mfluence w1thm s. 123(2) of the Representation of People Act, 1951. It was held that the publication of the poster constituted undue influence. The Commission observed : "It may be observed that an attempt to interfere by the method of compulsion is not necessary and that even the method of inducement may be sufficient, provided it be of such a powerful type as would leave no tfree will to the voter in the exercise of his choice. In other words, actual physical compulsion is not necessary, but, positive mental compulsion may be enovgh to give rise to an undue influence. For the reasons which we shall presently give, we read this sort of mental compulsion in the poster, and, therefore, hold that it falls within the purview of undue influence." The slogan of the poster was described thus :
'
"Vote for Congress in order to put an end to the atrocities of the Jagirdars. On the .loft-hand side, a person-apparently a tenant-is' shown tied up to a tree with a rope. On the right, there is a well dressed Jagirdar asking his man, who is seen waving a whip, to flog the tenant. Evidently, the tenant's wife, who has apparently attempted to intervene, has been thrown down prostrate on the ground. To the right hand side of .the picture, there is symbol of 'two bullocks with yoke on•, and near about the slit there are the hands of so many voters, male and female; attempting to cast their votes in the ballot box.'' ·
v.
In Radhakanta Mishra NityaMnda Mahapatra(l) there was a difference of opinion whether the respondent and his agent had committed corrupt practice of undue influence by publishing a booklet entitled ''why should you vote for me" where the picture of a dead body with the objectionable caption appeared, and it was stated that the individual had died of police firing and that the eongress had killed him. Barman, J., held that it constituted undue influence while Rao, J., held that it did not. There being difference·of opinion, the case went to Das, J., who held that it did not amount to uridue influence. Das, J ., observed regarding s. 123(2) of the Representation of' People Act that "there may be some elemC?nt of mental compulsion, but not necessarily a physical one or a threat actually held out by the person who interferes or attempts to interfere." We are not concerned with the question whether the booklet in that case constituted undue influence or ~t but only with the interpretation of the section. Barman, J., (I) 19 E.L.R. 203.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1971] 2 S.C.R...,
observed : "A voter must be able to freely exercise his electoral tight. He must be a free agent. All ir.Jluences are not neces sarily undue or unlawful. Legitimate exercise of influence by a political ·party or association,. or even an individual should not be confused with undue influence. Persuasion may be quite legitimate and may be fairly pressed on the voters. On the other hand, pressure of whatever character, whether acting on the fears, threat, etc., if so exercised as .to overpower the volition withouf . convincing the judgment is a species of restraint which interferes · with the free exercise of electoral right .... It is pot necessary to establish that actual violence had been used or even threatened. Methods a.f inducement which are so powerful as to leave no free will to the voter in the exercise of his choice may amount to undue influence. Imagipary terror may have been {;reated sufficient to deprive him of free agency."
The scope of s. 171C, I.P.C.; was considered in a recent deci sion of. this Court in Baburao Patel v. Dr. Zakir Hussain,(l). Wanchoo, C.J., speaking for the Court observed:
"It wiH be seen from the above definition that the gist of undue inftuence at an election consists in voluntary interference or attempt at interfer~nce with the lree exercise of 21ny electoral right. Any voluntary action which interferes with or -attempts to interfere with such free exercise of electoral right would amount to undue influence. But even though the definition in sub-s. ( 1) of s. 171 C is wide in terms it cannot take in· mere canvassing in favour: of a candidate at an election. If that were so, it would be impossible to run democratic elections. Further sub-s. (2) of s. 171C shows what the nature of undue infiuence is though of course -it does not cut down the generality of the provisions contained in sub-section· (1). Where any threat is held out to any candidate or voter or any. person in whom a candidate or voter is interested alld the threat is of injury ct any kind, that would amollillt :.o voluntary interference or attempt at interference with the free exercise of electoral right and would be undue influence. Again where a person induces or attempts to induce a candidate, or voter to believe that he or any person in whom he is interested will become or be rendered a:n object of Divine displeasure or of spiritual censure, that would also amount to voluntary interference with the free exercise of the electoral right and would be undue influence
will
(l) [1968) 2 S.C.R. 133, 145.
S. K. SINGH v. SHRI V. V. GIRl (Sikri, J.)
23 I_
What is contained in sub-s. (2) o.f s. 171{: is merely illustrative. It is difficult to lay down in. general term~ where mere canvassing ends and interference or attempt at interference with the free exercise of any ·electoral right begin5'. -That is a matter to be determined in each case; but there can be no doubt that if what is done is merely canvassing it would not be undue influence. As sub-section ( 3) of s. 171 C shows, the mere exercise of a legal right without intent to interfere with an electoral right would not be undue influence."
It is not necessary to consider the provisions of the Indiun· Contract Act t1r the English Law on the subject because we have· a ~pecial definition given by Purliamont The question that then arises is : Whether the publication of this pamphlet can be said to co'nstitute undue influence 'J Wehave no doubt that it does ~a!l within that definition. It is not nece~sary to reproduce the pamphlet in detail as we shall only be· giving further publicity to this most objectionabie pamphlet. The pamphlet. after giving various fictitious incidents of ·sexuai immorality. describes Shri N. Sanjiva Reddy a debauch without any sense of shame or morality . Then the pamphlet asks ; "Should the name of the Congress be lowered to such depths that thi.,. r ,oral leper, this depraved man should be st:t up as the- Cvngress candidate for the highest post?" It further adds : "A senior Congress MP has expressed the fear : If Sanjiva Reddy becomes PrcsiL1cnt he will turn Rashtr::tpati Bhavan into a harem, a centre of vice a:11.d immorality." It seems to us that these allegations are covered under s. 171-C. even if they may be covered under s. 1.71G. But we are not concerned with s. 171G because that section has not been made a ~round for setting aside an election. We are only concerned with s. 171C. Be that as it may, we cannot add another subsection to s. 171C, as follows : "A false statement of fact in relation to the personal character or conduct of any candidate even if made with the intention of interfering with the electoral right sh-::~ll not be deemed to be interference within the meanin2: ~.f this section." ·
lt was said th~t this pamphlet cannot come under s. 171 C becau~e it was issued anonymously and. therefore, it was not likely
t.J interfere with · the choice of the electorate partichlarly ·as the electorate consi_sted only of members of Parliament and -Members of State Legislatures. But, in our opinion. this argument is fallacious. First. this has no relevance to the question whether any attempt to interfere with the electoral ri~ht has been made or not.
SuPREME COURT REPORTS
(1971] 2 S.C.ll.
. .Secondly, a series of ancnymous attempts in a country like ours would have as :much, ~f not more, effect as one open pov;erful .attempt. It would !Je dangerous to provide a sanctuary to ailonymous attempts. Thzrdly, on the facts of this case, can we sa,r that the distribution in the Central Hall is the same thing as anonymous publication? If a member of Parliament distributes a pamphlet, is he not identifying himself with it unless he expressly disasso:iates .himself from. the pamphlet? It seems to us that the distribution in the Cent,a! Hall by members of Parliament has the same effect .:as if they had endorsed the pamphlet in writing. We are accordingly of the opinion that distribution of the pamphlet by post as also distribution in the Central Hall con!:titut..e4 an attempt to interfere with the·free exercise of the right to vote within s. 18 of the Act. We must first mention that both the parties l~d extensiv~ evid·ence to prove the genesis of the dispute between the Con~ress ·party led by Shri Jagjivan Ram and the Con&ress party lc:d by Shri · Nijalingappa. We were told about the proceeding~ c,f the Faridabad session and the Bangalore Session, ·and the circumstances :attending Shri Morarji Desai's resignation. I:urther, ·the whole ,of the correspondence between the Prime Minister and Shri Nija1ingappa, and between Shri Jagjivan Ram. and Shri Fakh1'1Jddin Ali Ahmed and Shri Nijali:ngappa between August 9 and August 18 was exhibited 'in the case. But as it is not necessary for us to ·determine the exact genesis of the dispute we will only take note ·of the· .~act' that both the congress parties were opposed to each -other at the time of the election and had different views on tt!ttain economic issues, and the Preside~tial election became -a vital issue between them. In view of the above we will have to judie the ·evidence given by the witnesses with care, and wherever possible ·seek corroboration of the evidence from circumstances or other independent evidence. We mflv now deal with the question whether it is possible to find out who printed or published the pamphlet and whether it was distributed by post and/or in the Central Hall of Parliament. "Regardincz the authorship of the pamphlet no evidence has been led by the petitioners but it was contended on their behalf that if the pamphlet is closely scru~inised · there are indications in the pamphlet that it is the work of some congressmen belonging to that party o,f the Congress which is now led by Shri Jagjivan. Ram. Although this argument appears to be attractive. we cannot come 1o the conclusion that it was the work of the members of. any -particular party. The fact that certain witnesses have admitted 1hat the first part of the pamph~et represents their ideology lead5 us nowhere because .it would not be difficult for other persons to
S, K. SINGH v. SHRl V, V, GIRl (Sikri, J.)
I
J'
reproduce their ideology in words. Their ideology is welt-known and they are not averse to expoundi·ng it in great detail. a~ was done before us. But as we have already said, we cannot hold that it is the work of members belonging to any particular p~.)litical party.. Regardmg the distribution by post there is overwhelming evidence that the pamphlet was widely distributed by post. Part of it will be referred to when dealmg with the question of distrioution of the pamphlet in the Central Hall. Even the Prime Minister. Smt. Indira Gandhi, received a copy of it, as is cleat from her letter-Ext. P. 85-dated August 21, 1969, to Shri Madhu Limaye. M.P., in reply to his letter dated August 13. 196Q. In this letter she. inter alia, wrote :
·'The leaftet came to rne by post and I immediately asked the Home Ministry to institute an inquiry as to the source so that necessary action c0uld be considered. This was before I received your letter." No evidence was led by either side as to whether such an inquiry was made, and if so, 'whether the authorship of th'! pamphlet was {ound out.· We may mention that Mr. Daphtflry. the learned counsel for the respondent. did not argue the que·;tion about the distribution by post and admitted th&t distributbn of the pomphlet by post had taken place. The!" we come to the ques•ion ol distribution of the pumphll!t in the Central Hall. On this p~int the evidence i:; extremely Cllnfticting. Shri K'8nwarlul Gunta, M.P., P.W. 11. stated that he saw the pamphlet bein~ dis•ributed in the Central Hall of Parliament by some members; one was Shri Yunus Saleem and the other was Shri Shsshi Bhushan. He said that he was definite about these two members. He further stated that he did not recei'le it in Parliament but some other members did Jlnd it was being op~nly distributed. In cross-examination he stated that Shri Yunu~ Saleem gave it to two or three people; he came and gave one pamphlet to ea~h. Shri Gupta produced copy of a letter dated August 14; 1969. which he. had written to the Chief Election Commissioner ir. this connection. In this letter-Ext. P 37-·it is. inter alia, stated : "Moreover, vamphlets are belng distributed in which
vul~ar charges have been levelled against a:nother candidate for this hi~h office. Character assasination is going
on. I am 8endin£ a copy of the pamphlet in which vul~·ar and filthy -attacks have been made a~ainst Shri N. Saniiva Reddy. This amounts to cor.ruot practice under the EJection Law.• These pamphlets are being distdbuted
•
I
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[!971] 2 S.C.R.
by the supporters of the Prime·Minister. Shri M . .Yun,us Saleem, a Minister in her Cabinet and some others att! very active in it." (emphasis supplied) The Chief Election Commissioner acknowledged this letter by his d.o. letter-Ext. P 16-dated August 14, 1969. This letter certainly corroborates Shri Kanwar Lal Gupta's statement that Shri Yunus Saleem was distributingrthis pamphlet but it would be noted that in the letter to the Election Commissioner there is no mention of the Central Hall of Parliament. We· will discuss this letter in detail· a little later. Smt. Jayabehn Shah, M.P., P.W. 25, deposed that she saw this . pamphlet belng distributed in the Central Hall and she saw Shri Shashi Bhushan, M.P., distributing it, although she did not rl!ceive it personally ,from him. We may mention that she belongs to the Congress Party headed by Shri · Nijalingappa. Shri Nanubhai Nichhabhai Patel, M.P:, P .. W. 26, deposed that he saw the pamphlet in the~central Hall of Parliament about the 12th ·or 13th of August and Shri Yunus Saleem, Shri Shashi Bhushan and Shri Chandra Shekhar were distributing. the. pam-· ph let; they came to give him this pamphlet but he told them : "Yes, 1 have received it in my fiat." In answer to the question "what did. they tell you" he stateci : ''They asked me whether l had gone through this pamphlet thoroughly. I said, "Yes": Then they tol~ me "Be careful and before voting you consider all these facts." In answer to the question "who to!d you" he replied: ''Mr. Saleem.'' In c~oss-examination\ ~e said. that he had no~ told the petit.ioners or etther of them, Shri Rama Reddy or Shn Abdul Ghan1 Dar, that the pamphlet w,as distributed by Shri Jagat Narain, Shri Mohan Dharia or by Shri Yunus Saleem. This question_ was put in crossexamination in view of the particulars supp1ied by Shri Abdul Ghani Dar, petitioner, that Shri . Krishan Kant, Shri Chandra Shekhar, Shri Jagat Narain, S!1ri Shashi Bhushan and Shri Mohan Dharia had distributed the pamphlet. inter alia, to Shri N. N. Patel, M.P .. Shri Abdul Ghani Dar had verified that this was on the information received from the member of Parliament mention· ed as recipient of the pamphlet. The learned counsel for the respondent, Mr. Daphtary, had at various times asked questions in cross-examination from the petitioners' witnesses in order to elicit the information they gave to. Shri Abdul GhaniDar or Shri Sri Rama Reddy with a view to show that the particular" aml the evidence in most cases are in conflict. He says that we should draw an inference against the evidence of
c·
E.
S. K. SINGH v. SHRI V. V. GIRl (Sikri, J.)
these. w:tnesses wherever there is a conflict between what is stated in the particulars and what is ultimately stated in the evidence. In this particular case it appears that some particulars were given by gyess w.ork rather than by ascertaining from the witnesses: We cannot, however, disbelieve witnesses only because the particulars are at variance with their evidence. But we will bear the fact in mind while appreciating their ev_idence.
Shri Mohan Lal Gautam, M.P., P.W. 27, stated that he had received a copy of this pamphlet in the Central Hall of Parliament from Shri Shashi Shushan and he saw it being distributed to other members also. In cross.examination it was put to him that his impression .that Shri Shashi Bhu~han gave it to him was not correct c and he replied : "My recollection is quite correct because I came here on the 14th August and I had only one day here-15th was holiday and 16th was polling day, so there cannot be any confusion.'' We may mention that he was elected on the 13 of August. 1969, to the Rajya Sabha and took oath on August 14, 1969. Shri C. D. Pande, M.P., P.W. 29, is one of the petitioners in Election Petition No. 4. He deposed that when he was sitting in the Central Hall he saw the pamphlet being distributed by certain members; he could recollect two or three and he recollected Shri Shashi Bhushan, Shri Krishna Kant and Shri Yunus Saleem. although they did not give him a copy of the pamphlet. In crossexamination he stuck to the position and said that they did not give the pamphlet to him because "they were giving to such persons who-·they thought fit, because I was too patent not to ac,:cept it.'' In answer to the suggestion that "loyalty was too obvious" he said ''yes". He was cross-examined in regard to the particulars a~d he said that he never told Shri Sri Rama Reddy that the pamphlet was given to him in the Central Hall of Parliament by Shri Jagjivan Ram and 11 other M.Ps. He also denied that he told Shri Sri Rama Reddy that the pamphlet was given to him on the 11th of August in the Central Hall by Shri Mohan Dharia and Shri Chandra Shekhar. In the particulars supplied by Shri Sri Ram a Reddy it is stated that one of the persons who was given the said pamphlet in the Central Hall of Parliament was Shri C. D. Pande. Shri D. N. Deb, M.P., P.W. 30, belonging to the Swatantra Party, deposed that the pamphlet was being ·distributed in the Central Hall by Shri Shashi Bhushan and some others who were in general called 'Young Turks', and Shri Shashi Bhushan gave him a copy. He said tha! the pamphlet was distributed openly in the Central HalL He denied in cross-examination that he to(d· Shri Sri Rama Reddy that Shri J agiivan Ram and 11 others gave him a copy of the pamphlet. In the particulars supplied by Shri Abdu1 Ghani Dar it is stated that .he is one of the persons who was given a copy of the pamphlet in the Central Hall. This is rather
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] 2 s.c.R.
strange because he stated in cross-examination that although he met Shri Abdul Ghani Dar, it was not he but Shri Sri Rama Reddy who Hsk~:d him to give evidence. He does not say that he told Shfi Abdul Chani Dar nnything jn particu:ar. Shri HuY:an·. Chand Kachwai, M.P., P.W. 32, pclonging to the Jan Sangh p:..~ty, deposed that Shri Shashi Bhushan and Shri Jagjivan Rar11 g<wc (he p:imphlet to him in the Central Hall. He further said that "Mr. Shashi Shushan told me that Mr. Giri was the supportep of the labour rutd I should support him and the other thing 1JU:tl he told me was that Mr. ,Sanjiva Reddy was a characterJc.t;s person and the description of his character is in this pamphlet which I can see." He said that he received this pamphlet in the Central .Hall on the 12th of August. ln cross-examination he deposed that Shri Shashi Bhushan came alone and gave him the pa'mphlet and further that Shri Jagjivan Ram had also given him a similar pamphlet but that was on August 13, 1969. He further stated that he went with the. pamphlet to his leader, Shri Atal Behari Ba.ipai, although he did not ask Shri Bajpai w~ether what was stated in the pamphlet was true. He further satd in crossexamination that he did not meet Shri Abdu.l Ghani Dar or Shri Sri Rama Reddy. Sm1. Pushpabehn Mehta, M.P., P.W. 36, stated that some members including Shri Shashi Bhushan, were distributing the pamphlet in the Central Hall of the Parliament and they were discussing. She stated in cross-examination that she did not report to the Security Officer. In cross-examination she stuck to her position that Shri Shashi Bhushan and Shri Krishan Kant were distributin~ the pamphlet. She had not talked to Shri Sri Rama Reddy or Shri Abdul Ghani Dar or anv other person on their behalf before giving evidence. She stated that there were many persons in the Central Hall and they were sittin.l! in groups and distributing, but she did not l!Jention Shri Jagjivan Ram's name in particu1nr. In the particulars supplied by Shri~Abdul Ghani Dar it was stated that she received the pamphlet in the Central I:lall of Parliament and Shri Krishan Kant, Shri Chandra Shekhar, Shri Ja~at Narain. Shri Shashi Bhushan and Shri Mohan Dharia distributed the pamphlet among others to this witness. Shri Patil Puttappa, M.P., P.W. 50, said that Shri Yunus Saleem was distributing the pamphlet among the members in the Central Hall of Parliament and he gave him one copy. He says that he talked to Shri Saleem and told him that he was 1not doing the right thing. and Shri Saleem replied : ·"It is none of your business." Later on Shri Puttappa said that he saw Shri Krishan Kant.- .Shri Chandra Shekhar. Shri Shashi Bhushan and Shri Mohan Dharia also distributin~ the pamphlet in the Central Hall. He did not complain to_ the Watch and Ward Officer or to the Deputy Speaker,
.
S. K. SINGH V•. SHR.l V. V, GIRl (Sikri,. J.)
Shri Khadilkar, and the reason he gave was : "Since I had earlier come to know that Mr. Kanwarlal Gupta had earlier complained to the Election Commissioner and the Deputy Speaker of the House -Lok Sabha." He stuck to hls position in cross-examination. He further 3tated that neither Shri Abdul Ghani Dar nor anybody on his behalf asked him to come and give evidence and that if Shri Dar said on oath that he had given information relating to this, that ·w<JUid be false. He added that till he stepped into the witness box nobody had asked him as to what evidence he was going to give. In the particulars given by Shri Abdul Ghani Dar the only reference to this witness is in connection with the alleged distribution of the pamphlet on August 9, 1969, by Shri Shashi Bhushan, and Shri Krishan Kant, to him at 134, North Avenue~ New Delhi. We may mention that in his evidence he does state· that he received one pamphlet by post at his residence but he does. not say that Shri Shashi Bhushan and Shri Krishan Kant personally distributed it.
Shri Sher ~han, M.P., P.W. 51, stated that he r~ceived the pamphlet in the Central Hall and three or four persons, Shri Shashi Shushan, Shri Krishan Kant, Shri Jagat Narain and two or three other persons gave the pamphlet to him and they were· distributing it openly, In cross-exammation he stated that before coming to give evidence in Court he did not have conversation with Shri Abdul Ghani Dar or anyone about what he was going ·to depose in the Court. In the particulars it is stated that he received the pamphlet in the Central Hall Qf Parliament, a:tMl Shri Krishan Kant, Shri Cha·ndra Shekhar, Shri lagat Narain, Shri Sha-;hi Bhushan and Shri Mahan Dharia had distributed the pamphlet, among others, to this witness. Shri C. M. Kedaria, M.P., P.W. 53, deposed that Shri Shashi" Bhushan the pamphlet to him in the Central Hall of Parliar ment and gave the Young Turks were distributing the pamphlet. Among the Young Turks he named Shri Mohan ·nharia, Shri "Krishan Kant, Shri Arjun Arora, Shri Shashi Bhushan, Shri Chandra Shekhar and others. It was brought out in cross-examination that he was one of the signatories to a letter, appearing in th;! issue of National Herald dated August 14, 1969-Ext. R-7-written to the Congress President on August 13. 1969, demanding lppropriate action against those who did not respect the party mar..date in regard to the Presidential election. He S~ilted that there was no point in complaining about the distribution of the pamohlet in the Central Hall because responsible persons were distributing it. Hik name appears .in the particulars as one of the persons who had received the pamphlet in the Central Hall of Parliament and that Shri Krishan Kant, Shri Chandra Shekhar, Shri Jagat - Narain, Shri Shashi Bhushan and Shri Mohan Dharia distributed the pamphlet to him. among others..
..
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
p9n]2 s.c.R.
Shri N. Sri Rama Reddy, M.P., P.W. 54, one of tbe petitioners, .says that he received the pamphlet both in the Central Hall as well .as iQ his house and this pamphlet was being distributed in the Central Hall from 11th to 15th August. He received it in the ,central Hall either on the 12th or on the 15th and received it from Shri Yunus Saleem and Shri Shashi Bhushan who were together. He .further stated that from 11th to 15th August he saw Sltri Yunus Saleem, Shri Shashi Bhushan, Shri Krishan Kant, Shri S. M. Banerjee, Maulana lshaq, Shri Chandra Shekhar and Shri Mohan Dharia distributing the pamphlet. He did not complain to the Watch and Ward Officers because he could never imagine that "subordinate men should be my authortiy to complam to. It never struck me once." Then he said that he had complnined to the Deputy Chnirmnn, who was presiding, that Shl'i Yunus .Saleem was carrying on these nefarious activities in the house, and then Shri Yunus Saleem ran away. It seems to us that he is mistaken that his complaint to the' Deputy Chairman was about the pamphl~.t. From the prodedings of the House it appears th:.~t his .complaint was r~garding a signature campaign which is alleged to have been carried on by'Sh,ri Yunus Saleem. ln the cross-examination he said that Shri Chandra Shekhar and Shri Mohan Dharia distributed the pamphlet only on one day, may be on th~ 14th or 15th August. We have outlined the evidence of 12 members of Parliament .above. They all deposed that Shri Shashi Bhushan, among other=>. either gave them the pamphlet in the Central Hall or the;:y saw :him distributing the pamphlet in the Central Hlll to others. Shri Shashi Shushan. M.P .. R.W. 38, in his evidence strongly denied the allegations against him; however he admitted that he .received the pamphlet at his residence by post. He said that the evidence was totally false and the reason he gave why Shri Kanwar Lal Gupta made the statement was, in brief, that the Jan Sangh party of India was very much angry with the witness. He gave the history of the enmity \vhich we need not set out in detail here. He said that looking to the relationship of the Jan Sangh and the ·witness, if Shri Gupta said so he was not surprised. He said that ·"there is many times conflict with him even in the House. Over there several times he levelled personal charge agajnst me. 1 also spoke against .his brother in the House." Regarding Smt. Jayabeh:J. 'Shah's evidence he said that she deposed wrongly because of political motives. He gave the political reasons in his ·evidence, one reason being that Smt. Jayabehn was a member of the Bir!a ··robby which was very strong in Parliament and which opposed him strongly i11 connection with the hunger strike he un~ertook at the Birla Bhavan in 1968. Regarding ·Shri N. N. Patel, Shri Shashi 'Bhushan said that he did not know him and his evidence was :incorrect. He said : "When I don't know him how can he talk
F.
S. K. SIN(;H v. SHill V. V, GIRl (Sikri, J.)
.~.~~
to me.'' Regarding Shri Mohan Lal Gautam he said that ~s evidence was wrong and he was a member of the Congress Synd1.. cate and that was the reason why he deposed against the witness. Regarding the evidence of Shri Pande, the reason he gave was that at the tiine of the hunger strike at Birla House Shri C. D. Pande moved about in the Parliament House Central Hall with a 'flag' B on behalf of Birlas whose 'flag', symbolically speaking, was per: mitted in the Parliament. He characterised the statement of Shr1 N. N. Patel about the distribution of the pamphlet as being without any basis and the statement of Shri D. N. Deb as quite wrong. According to him, Shri D. N. Deb spoke falsely. against him because he (Shrj Deb) was a prince (Raja) and lhe witness had C said several times in Parliament that those who presented the freedom of India on golden dishes to the Britishers had no right to take the pension as well as engage in politics. The witness further said that Shri Hukam Chand Kachwai had wrongly deposed about the giving of the pamphlet and about the witness talking with him. According to the witness the reason why Shri K.achwai gave this false statement was that he (Shri Kachwai) "belongs to D Jan Sangh party. He has come from R.S.S. The R.S._S. believes in Evil Policy (Kootniti)." Regarding the evidence of Smt. Pushpa~hn Mehta, the witness said that she deposed falsely nnd the reuon he gave was : "I am sorry that such an old woman can tell a lie. She may not be able to recognize me. One has to do everythiag in po1it1cs." Then the witness added that she belongs E to the Syndicate Congress. Regarding Shri Patil P\lttappa the,· witness said that he even did not recognize him and .he could not give the reason why he gave the evidence falsely agaiqst· him. He characterised the evidence of both Shri Sber Khan and Shri C. M. Kedaria as false. He attributed Shri Kedaria's statement to the fact that Shri Kedaria ''is one of the principal disciples of · Mr. Morarji Desai. Everyone knows the relations Mr. Morarji F Desai and I have. It is the effect of it. He is a member of the Syndicate." The witness described his relations with· Shri Morarji Desai thus : "I have always taken Morarji Desai as an opponent of socialism., a supporter of the capitalists." The witness further said that the statement of Shri Sri Rama Reddy that he . and ~ Yunus Saleem were together at the time and Shri Ytm.~ G ~Ill gave this pamphlet to Shri Rama Reddy was wrong. He said that Shri Rama Reddy was unhappy with him over the hunger strike at Birla Bhavan, even more than the Birlas. . The witness further said that Shri Rama Reddys statement that he was one of · the persons distributing the pamphlet in the Central Hall from the 11th to the 15th August we quite wrong. He added: "He has H freedom of speech. What cari I do." He characterised the eVidence of Shri N. N. P.atel about the distribution of the pamphlet as false. He stated in cross-examination that "there was no need of t~lking about this pamphlet particularly. Several persons of .
· 4-308Sup.Cif71
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1971] 2 S.C.R.
course talked to me as happens in the lobby." He admitted in cross-examination that he had no personal enmity with Shri Pande, Smt. Jayabehn Shah, Shri Sri Rama Reddy, Shri Patil Puttappa, Shri N. N. Patel, Shri D. N. Deb, Shri Mohan Lal Gautam, Shri H. C. Kachwai and Smt. Pushpabehn Mehta, and also no personal enmity with Shri Kanwar Lal Gupta but he had only political enmity. To the question : "Do you consider that whoever opposed you politically will try to involve you in this kind of work, i.e., .distribution of pamphlet, etc. ? he replied : "They have involved me. Therefore I think so. The proof is there." In cross-examination he produced a copy oi the Lok Sabha debate. dr.ted December 5, 1967, to sbow the enmity between him and Shri Kanwar Lal Gupta. There was some discussion about Shri Gupta's alleged brother-we say ~alleged' because the petitioner's counsel tried to suggest that Shri V. M. Gupta was not Shri K. L. Gupta's brother. The witness admitted that he was against Shri Sanjiva Reddy's nomination from the very beginning. It was suggested to him that he wa~ responsible for printing and publishing this pamphlet and he replied : "I would have committed suicide if I had brought out this pamphlet." In answer to a Court question uis it your evidence that all this discussion about the pamphlet was goinp; on without a pamphlet being there" he replied : "Of course, so many discussions were going on." It will be seen from the evidence of these 12 witnesses that they all deposed to the distribution of the pamphlet by Shri' Shasbi Bhushan and four of them deposed to the actual receipt of the pamphlet .from Shri Shashi Bhushan. Shri Shash~ Bhushan hru; denied the alle_gations. There is no doubt that the evidence is con:fticting, and most of the witnesses are politically interested. It is true, as urged by Mr. Daphtary, that we cannot judge the evid· ence by mere number of members who deposed to the distri· bution though we cannot completely ignore that fact. We will have to see whether any circumstances which are proved on the record corroborate one side or the other. 11 witnesses· deposed that Shri.Yunus Saleem either distributed the pamphlet or gave it to them in the Central Hall of Parliament. WI! have already referred to the evidence of Shri Kanwar Lal G~pta. P.W. 11, Shri N. N. Patel, P.W. 26, Shri C. D. Pande, P.W. 29, Shri PatH Puttappa P.W. 50 and Shri Sri Rama Reddy P.W. 54. The other six witnesses are Shri N. P. C. Naidu, P.W. 17, .Shri Shiv Narain, P.W. 24, Shri Mahadevappa Rampure, P,W. 35, Shri D. S. Raju, P.W. 49j Shri Abdul Ghani Dar, P.W. 55, ·and Chaudhary A. Mohd., P.W; 52. Shri N. P. C. Naidu, P.W. 17, deposed thatShd Yunus Saleem gave him one pamphlet in the Central Hall on August 11 or 12. He stated that there was a t'alk between him and Shri Yunus Saleem.
S. K. SINGH v. SHRI V. V. GIRl (Sikri, J.)
H1
A He betongs to the Congress Party presid~d over by Shri Nijahn, gappa. No cross-examination seems to have been directed on ·the point of distribution and whether Shri Yunus Saleem distributed the pamphlet. It was urge~ that it was an oversight.
C
Shri Shiv Narain, M.P., deposed that apart from receiving the pamphlet in his house he saw the pamphlet being distributed in the Central Hall by some gentlemen including Deputy MirJster Yunus Saleem, Shri Chandra Shekhar, Shri Mohan Dharia, and Shri Krishan Kant. He admitted that no pamphlet was given to him by these persons. He stated that he did not tell Shri Abdul Ghani Dar or Shri Sri Rama Reddy the names of the persons he gave in the ::ourt as having distributed the pamphlet. It is remarkable that in the particulars supplied' by Shri Abdul Ghani Dar th~ witJiess is alleged to have received the pamphlet in the Central . Hall of Parliament on August 11, 1969, irom Shri Jagjivan Ram Shri Mahadevappa Rampure, P.W. 35, M.P., deposed that he received the pamphlet in .the Central Hall from Shri Yunus Saleem and saw him distributing it. He further says that Shri Yunus Saleeni said: "You can go through this pamphlet. You will gt91: enough information about the contesting candidates." He stated that he received information about the 12th February that he would have to give evidence and before that he did not have any conversation either with Shri Abdul Ghani Dar or Shri Sri Rama Reddy. He admitted that he did not complain to the Security Officer about the distribution. He could not say to whom else Shri Yunus Saleem distributed the pamphlet. His name does not figure in the particulars suwlied by Shri Abdul Ghani Dar or by Shri Sri Rama Reddy. Shri D. S. Raju, M.P., P.W. 49, stated that he received one
copy of the pamphlet in his house and another copy in the, Ce-ntral Hall· of tQe Parliament and if he could trust
his memory, it ·was Shri Yunus Saleem who passed it on tu him.
·G
He admitted th!U when Smt. Gandhi became the Prime Minister she did not continue him as one of the Ministers, and that he belonged to the party of which Shri Nijalingappa is the President. He said that it was incorrect that Shri Jagjivan Ram and some others delivered the pamphlet at his residence. His name does not figure in the particulars given by Shri Abdul Ghani Dar except that it is ~tated that persons mentioned in paragraph 13 (b)( iii) ,1f the Election Petition distributed the said pamphlet by leaving the ~rune at the residence of the witness. Chaudhary A. Mohamed, M.P., P.W. 52, deposed that he met Shri Yunus Saleem in the Central Hall and he talked ab\>ut the election and Shri Yunus Saleem said that it had been decided not to vote for Shri Sanjiv'a Reddy. While giving the reasons for this
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] 2 s.c.R.
decision Shri Yunus Saleem had said that there was some pamphlet which he had distributed and then gave a copy to the witness.· He stated that he had not told.Shri Abdul Ghani Dar that Shri Jagjivan Ram and others had given this pamphlet to him. In answer to the question : "I put it to you that Shri·Y.unus Saleem did not give the pamphlet to you or an)'One else in your presence?", he replied : "You can say so. As the pamphlet was given to me by him, how can I deny it." It is rather extraordinary that in the particulars supplied by Shri Abdul Ghani Dar, Shri Krishan Kant, Shri Chandra Shekhar, Shri Ja~t Narain, Shri Shashi Bhushan, and Shri Mohan Dharia are alleged to have given the pamphlet to this witness in the Central Hall of Parliament but net Shri Yunus Saleem. ..
Shri Abdul Ghani Dar, M.P., P.W. 55, one of the petitioners, ·deposed that Shri Yunus Saleem gave three pamphlets to him, two in Engliish, one cyclostyled and one printed, and one in Hindi. He further deposed.;hat Shri Yunus Saleem took him aside and on his a<;k.ing Shri Saleem told him about tbe contents of the pamph~ let. ·· The witness said that he has one eye and that is also defec. . 0 tive, s·o he could not read the pamphlet. In the Election Petition (No. 5) it was stated in sub-para 13(b)(iv)'that a scare was
created in the minds of the electors with the direct object of ]ntcrM .. ferin$ with the free cxerciS~ of their electoral right to Vote for the ciUldldute of their choice. It ·was also stated therein that 11 as' a single instance Shri Yunus Saleem approached Shri Abdul Ghani Dar, member of Parliament, ono of the petitioners herein, and E talked to him in this behaJt as stated earlier. This was said in the presence of a number of members of Parliament." Shri Abdul Ghani Dar was confronted with this statement and asked about the presence of a nu111:ber of memb~rs of Parliament. He replied : ''I have even now not denied that where I was taken no other members ·were present.'' In reply to another question he said both his statements, h,is statement in ~ub~para 13 (b) ( iv) and what he stated in Court, were correct. But. in the particulars it is stated that Shri Yunus Saleem, Shri Shashi Bhushan and Shri Krishan Kant distri· buted the said pamphlet to the witness. These particulars were given on February 7, 1970, and his evidence was taken on March 5. 1970. If his evidence in Court ~~ true, he clearly gave false particulars on February 7, 1970. It is further evident that both his statement in sub-para 13(b)(iv) and his statement in Court cannot· be true. It seems to us that Shri Abdul Ghani Dar gave .the particulars more by guess work than after having ascertained them from the witnesses or persons to whom the witnesses had spoken. We have no doubt that the verification of the affidavit giving the particulars was false in this .respect.
'
I
S. K. SlNGH V. SHRI V. V. GIRl (Sikri, J.)
·G
Sbri M. Yunus Saleem, M.P., R.W. 51, then Union Deputy Minister of Law stated that he had not seen anyone distributing the pamphlet in the Central Hall. In reply to the question: "Did yoJ.i- yourself distribute this pamphlet in the Central Hall or anywhere else as a matter of fact?'', he replied ~ "No. A penon having a little knowledge of law, how can he afford to indulge in such activities of distributing such pamphlets in tho Central Hall." The learned counsel then put the statements of these 11 witnesses, which we have extracted above, and he said that they were aJI baseless and incorrect. He further said that he vhad not seen this pamphlet before the date of his evidence and so the question of his giving this pamphlet to anyone _hardly arose. In connection With the evidence of Shri Sri Rama Reddy and the incident in the Rajya Sabha he admitted that he was obtaining signatures on a paper demanding freedom ·or vote in Rajya Sabha before the commence~ ment ot the proceedings in t:he House and the moment the Deputy Chairman appeared and occupied the seat he also occupied his seat and as he had to go to the other House he left his seat. He further stated that this incident had nothing to do with the distribution of the pamphlet. Regarding the evidence of Shri Abdul Ghani Dar he said that except that he had a talk with Shri Abdul Ghani Dar about the Presidential election every other part of it was iqcorrect. He gave his own version of the talk which took place between him and Shri Abdul Ghani Dar. He further deposed that Shri Kanwar Lal Gupta deposed falsely against him because "he belongs to a political ·organisation which is against the politi.::al party to which I belong and also because in my election l had defeated the Jan Sangh candidate {rom a constituency which was overwhelmingly non-Muslim constituency and where ~he security of th.e Jan Sangh candidate was forfeited." As far as Shri Abdul Ghani Dar was concerned be said that he had deposed against him because "perhaps he is in the habit of writing false lettets and fili'ng false affidavits and attacking persons who do not agree with him in his political ideas." In answer to the question : "Why Shri Mahadevappa Rampure deposed against you ?", he said : "Because ~e is from the Mysore Sta,te <:!nd is under the influence of Shri Nijalmgap~a, perhaps in order to please him and gain his favour." The Witness also referred to a report circulated by Shri Abdul Ghani Dar after his return from Haj in which Shri Abdul Ghani Dar had attacked Shri Yunus Saleem. The witness admitted that he was an active supporter of Shri V. V. Girl. He further stated that Shri Shashi Bhushan was also an active supporter. He further a~itt«:d ~at he was supporting tJie move for freedom of votwhich nnplted freedom to vote against the official candidate. He further admitted that he was one of those persons who was not very ~p~ from the very beginning at the way the official candidate ha4 been selected by the Parliamentary Boatd. He also deposed that he never saw Sbri Giri during the election oeriod.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971)2 S.C.R.
He characterised as absolutely wrong and incorrect that he was in A constant touch with Shri V. V. Giri. He further deposed that Sh(i Naidu and Shri Sanjiva Reddy were personal friends and Shri Naidu wes canvassing for Shri Sanjiva Reddy in the Central Hall. He denied the suggestion that he was carrying the pamphlets with him. In answer to the question : "You did not show those papers to Mr. Raj Narain because you were carrying pam~ B phlets with you and that would have exposed you further ?", he replied : ''It is incorrect and contrary to the proceedings of the Rajya Sabha." To the question: "Mr. Kimwar Lal Gupta moved a motion that the debate on the motion be adjourned and he wanted the House to discuss what was happening in the Central Hall ' about the signature and thereafter reference. was made to character assassination. Were you present there?", he answered : '"No c such motion was moved during my presence in the Lok Sabha." He was asked whether he came to know that a point of order ha,d been raised in the Lok Sabha on August 14, 1970, and he replied; "No body told me about it." We will presently refer to the proceedings in the Lok Sabha. We may. mention th~t he was cross-examined at great length and his cross-examination covers nearly 55 pages. Various questions were asked about his early career, his political association and views, etc., but we do not find it necessary to mention these because ' these do not assist us in weighing hiS evidence.
Shri Yunus Saleem has completely contradicted the evidence of the· 11 witnesses, all members of Parliament. It is, however, remarkable that in the particulars supplied by Shri Abdul-Ghani Dar the only person to whom he is supposed to have distributed the pamphlet is Shri Abdul Ghani Dar himself. From the particulars nobody could have .imagined that Shri Yunus Saleem played such a prominent part in the distribution of the pamphlet in the Central Hall, as . stated by the petitioners' witnesses. Seven_ witnesses deposed to receiving the pamphlet from him. In these circumstances we will have to see whether any circumstances have been proved on record which corroborate one side or the other.
We may next take the batch of witnesses who deposed to Shri Krishan Kant ·having distributed the pamphlet in the Central Hal!. These witnesses are Shri K. S. Chavda, P.W. 12, Shri Shiv Narain, P.W. 24, Shri C. D. Pande, P.W. 29, Shri Patil ,Puttappa, P.W. 50, Shri .Sher Khan, P.W. 51, Shri C. M. Kedaria, P.W. 53, and Shri ~Sri Rama Reddy, P.W. 54. We have already extracted the re]evap.t evidence of six witnesses and the only witness whose evidence we have not considered before is Shri K. S. Chavda, P.W. 12. Shri K. S. Chavda, M.P., said ·that he received the pamphlet in his·house and Shti Krisban Kanf, member of Rajya Sabha, gave
S. IC. SINGH v. SHRI V.
v.· GllU (Sikri~ J.)
it to .h!ni in the Central Hall.
He is one or lnt; pclsons wno entirely· changed his mind about voting for Shri Sanjiva Reddy after reading the pamphlet. No cross-examination WBB directed m particular to the question oi distribution by Shri Krishan Kant. In the particulars it is stated that Shri Krishan Kant, Shri Chandra Shekhar, Shri Jagat Narain, Shri Shashi Bhushan ar.d Sbri Mohari Dharia had distributed the pamphlet to members of Parliament, including this witness.
Shri Krishan Kant, M.P., R.W. 32, in answer to the question: "Will you please see thls pamphlet ? Have you ever seen this pamphlet before?'' stated; "I am seeing it for the first time". fu
view of this statement, when confronted with the evidence of these witnesses he naturally characterised their evidence as "atrocious lie," "absolutely wrong" etc. He, however, admitted that seme people had talked to him about the pamphlet and told him·that such a pamphlet using some filthy and derogatory language had. ~n written. His immediate reaction then was that some enemy D Of Shri Giri had done it. He further stated that Shri K. R. Gal1CSh, M.P., talked to him about the pamphlet though not in ·detail. This talk must have been either in the lobby or in the Central Hall. He further stated that at the time Shri Ganesh talked to him he was the suppo~r of Shri Giri, and that he never met Shri V. V. Giri during the whole oi the election. He described the suggestion that he alongwith his coUeagues were responsible for the drafting of E this pamphlet and getting it published as utterly scandalous. He said that there was no foundation in the allegation that he distributed the pamphlet in the Central Hall from the 9th to the 16th August. In re-e~amination he was asked the reasons wlty-- the persons, who had stated that he had distributed the pamphlet to them, had given false evidence. He replied that the only reason F ~sible could be political opposition, and by that he meant that they were the supporters of Shri Sanjiva Reddy. Here again there is direct conflict between the evidence of Shri Krishan Kant, M.P., and of the witnesses whom we have just discussed.
Coming to the evidence relating to the distribution by Shri Chandra Shekhar, it consists of the evidence of six witnesses; Shri Shiv Narain, P.W. 24, Shri N. N. Patel, P.W. 26, Shri H. C. Kachwai, P.W. 32, Shri Suraj Bhan, P.W. 33, Shri Patil Puttappa, P.W. 50, and Shri Shri Rama Reddy._ P.W~ . 54. We have already extracted the relevant evidence of the witnesses other than Shri Suraj Bhan, M.:P. He stated that 'lie saw the pamphlet being distributed in Puliament House · ~y Shrl Amrit Nahata, Shri Chandra Shekhar, Shri Chand.rajeet Yadav and so many others. The witness belongs to the: ·'Jan
S.UPREME COUllT REPORTS
[1971] 2 S.C.Il
SaDgh party. He said that he did not mention that Shri Jagjivan Ram and 11 other persons distributed the pamphlet. He further admitted that he did not tell Shri Sri Rama Reddy or Shri Abdul Ghani Dar that the pamphlet was given to him in the Central Hall between the 11th and the 15th of August by Shri Jagjivan Ram and others. In the particulars he is one of the membets of Parliament who is supposed to have been given this pamphlet in the Central Hall of Parliament by Shri I agjivan Ram and 11
.B
others. ·
S~
Chandra Shekhar himself appeared in the witness box
as R.W. 5. He stated that he did not actually see these pamphlets but a portion of .the pamphlet in English was read out to him by a friend. He denied having distributed copies of the paJtlphlet, either the English version or the Hindi version, to
other persons in the Central Hall of Parliament. He described the evidence of Shri Suraj Bhan as mere concoction and the evidence of Shri Kachwai as totally wrong. It may be mentioned that on the morning of Augt:st 9 he went to Calcutta by plane and was in Calcutta on the 9th and lOth August. On the 11th D morning he left Calcutta by plane for Patna and he was in Patna on the 11th, and on the 12th morning he was due to leave for Delhi but his plane was delayed and he reached Delhi sometime in the evening of the 12th. So, if he did distribute the pamphlet it must have been only on the 13th and 14th for he says that he did not go to Parliament on the 15th as it was a holiday. In cross-examination he said that he had no discussion about the pamphlet because no serious person would discuss such a thing. He on1y . h~ard whisperings ab~ut the pamphlet. But even after coming to know abcut the whisperings he did not know that the pamphlet was in circulation. He characterised the suggestion that the· pamphlet was prepared and F published with his knowledge and after consult~tions with him ~ unfounded, incorrect, mischievous and scandalous. He admitted that he had demanded the resignation of the Congresc; President on August 14, 1969, but said that he demanded it on certain conditions. The evidence of Shri Chandra Sbe)cllar and of the other six members of Parliament, which we h.ave ext:acted above, is conflicting and we will have to look for cortoborating circun1stances. Five witnesses deposed to Sbrl Mohan Dharia, M.P., as having distributed the pamphlet in the Central Hall. We have already extrac!ed the relevant evidence of Shri Shiv Narain, P.W. 24, Shri H. C. Kachwai, P.W. 32, Shri Patil Puttappa,. P.W. SO, Shri Kedaria, P.W. 53, and Shri N. Sri Rama Reddy, P.W.~.
S. IC. SINGH l'. SRRI V. V. GW (Sikri, J.)
·n
24 7
Sbri Mohan Dbaria, M.P., R.W. 17, admitted that the pampblet in English came to him by post and that he had glanced . through it He characterised it as baseless, filthy and said that \ as it was not signed ·by anybody he did not ta~ any serious notice of it and ignored it. , In answer to the question : "Did you distribute this pamphlet in the Central Hall to anybody on any day?", he said : "I have never distributed this prunplet. I have no relation with this pamphlet. On the contrary 1 would Jite to tell that I was not supporting Mr. Girl, but I was suppon· ing Mr. Reddy at that time." In this statement he is supported by other witnesses. He said that when he wa$. at Nagpur on August 9, 1969, he participated in as many as eight programmes and there was one Press Conference ·besides, wherein be had categorically said that Shri Reddy would win in the Presidential election. In an issue of Dail¥ T~run Bharat dated August 10. 1969,. the repon of his Press Conference was published, tran.~ta tion of which was marked Ext. R 12A. The report reads: "The decision of setting up Shri Sanjiva Reddy for the Presidential election .has been taken by the Congress Party and it is binding on aU from Prime Minister to ordinary Member. Besides, Shri Reddy has created respect in the minds of Members of Parlia· ment because of his impartial regime as Speaker. On this cackground Shri Mohan Dharia. M.P., leader of Young Turks,. in a Press Conference, confidently expressed the certainey of success of Shri Reddy in pre~ sidential election." He admitted that his attitude in relation to the Presidential election remained the same till the 16th August, the day ()f polling. He was not shaken in his cross~examination. He wa~ asked whether he made any similar statement like the stntcnient he made on August 9, 1969, and he replied that there was no occasion of meeting the press after the 11th. He 'vas confronted with a despatch in the Times of India, dated August 1:!. 1969, from Patna which appeared in the Times of India on August 13, 1969, which reads: "Three 'Young Turks' today condemned what they described as a move by the "Syndicate'' in the Congress to forge an alliance with the Swatantra Party and the Jan Sangh.
Mr. Chandra Shekhar, Mr. Mohan Dharia and Mr.. Sbanti Kothari, all MPs, expressed concern at the recent deve{Qpments in New Delhi and pointed out that the Con· RSS President's "overtures~· to Jan Sangh and Swatantra leaders had "deeper implications."
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
{19711 2 S.C.R.
In a joint statement, they supported the action of Mr. Jagjivan Ram and Mr. Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed, Union Mimsters, in seeking clarifications in this regard from Mr. Nijalingappa." He -replied that the despatch was correct but it was not his statement. He further said that on the 14th August there was a meeting of the MPs from Maharashtra and in that meeting he ag8in had occasion to declare publicly that ·he stood for .Shri _SMjiv~ Reddy in the Presidential election. He admitted that not onJy_llid he sign the requisition for calling the A.I.C.C. meeting fc)r.1he Delhi Session but he was also one of t)le cauipaigneJ;S· to have ·:that meeting called. He dtnied seeing anybody discussing the': pamphlet because he said that he was ha!'dly ·there for more , $.3D one. or two days; he was in Nagpur on the 9th, and the lSth was a holiday. He characterised the suggestion that h~ and the other so-c.allcd Young Turks were responsible for the publication .of this. pamphlet as absolutely false, frivolous, baseless and so far as he .was concerned it was absolutely defamatory because he had worked for .Mr. Reddy and would not issue such statements Besides, in his career he had never done so. He recognised Shri Y. B. Chavan as his leader and he said that Shri Y. V. Chavan support· ed Shri Sanjiva Reddy. In view of his statement and the statement of other witnesses that he was a supporter of Shri Reddy it would be difficu1t ~"hold that he would be a party to distributing the pamphlet, unless there ar~ some other circumstances which corroborate the evidence given by the witnesses implicating Shri Mohan Dharia. Two witnesses named Shri Amrit Nahata, M.P., as having distributed the pamphlet; Shri Venkatasubbiah, P.W. 11 and Shri Suraj Bhan. P.W. 33. Shri Venkatasubbiah said that he saw it being distributed in the Central Hall by some members of Parlia· ment. To the question; "Can you nname anyone ?", he answered; "I cannot because so many days have elapsed. I remember to some extent Mr. Amrit Nahata T have seen distributing." He further said that he did not receive it in the Central Hall. We have already referred; to the evidence of Shri Suraj Bhan, M.P., P.W. 33. H~ named Shri Amrit Nahata as one of the distributors. Shri Amrit Nahata, R.W. 3, admitted that he received the · pamphlet by post but said that he just threw it away. He further deposed that he did not he~r· any talk about the pamphlet in the Central Halt.· He described Shri Venkatasubbiah's evidence regarding distribution of the pamphlet as a blatant lie. He also characterised Shri. Suraj Bhan's evidence naming the witness as a distributor of the pamphlet as absolut~y incorrect.
$. K. SINGH V;SHIU V.;V.• Ollli ~$ikri, J.)
2.49·
Here we have two members of Parliament saying that· Shri Amrit Nahata was distributing the pamphlet in the Central Hall,. while Shri Amrit Nahata has flatly denied the allegation. Further Shri Venkatasubbiah was not very definite, though no quesJions were asked in cross..exam.ination to elicit why he remembered Shri Amrit Nahata's name to some extent. Nor was any· question asked to establish any personal or po~cal animosity between Shri Ainrit Nahata and the two witnesses. · His name does not appear in the· particulars given by Shri Abdul Ghani Dar, though his namedoes appear in the particulars given by Shri Sri Rama Reddy. On· this evidence it would be difficult to hold that· it has ~n. proyed that Shri Amrit Nahata had distributed the p~hlet uatess some corroboration is forthcoming.
This 'leaves us to deal with five other alleged distributors of They have one thing in commo.n.. Only ~-witness in each case saw them distributing the pamphlet.. S1)ri Japt Narain, M.P., RW. 25, was seen by Shri Sher Khan,. P.w.· Sl; ·distributing the pamphlet with Shri Shaslli Bhushan~ and Shri Krishan Karit. Shri Jagat Narain deposed that he did not receive any pamphlet and saw it for tho first time in Court. He· further says that his correspondent-tho witness has connection: with ·a. newspaper 'Hind Samachar'-Shri Suri, who representod. the paper from Delhi asked him in tile first. or· second week of· August whether he had received the pamphlet or not. He said that the evidence pf Shri. Sher Khan, M.P·~ was not true. It iJ. difficult to believe that he never Q8Jlle across the pamphlet and saw it for the first time in Court. He was a journalist -~d theque'ry of Shri Suri would at least have set him on the trail. parilphl¢~ in the Central Hall.
Shri N. Sri Rama Reddy, P..W. 54, said that Shri S. M~ Banerjee was one of the persons who was distributing the pamphlet in the Central Hall and he had named him in the petition.•Shri S. M. Banerjee, M.P., R.W. 31, who is politically with the Com-· munist Party of India, headed by Shri S. A. Dange, stated that "a pamphlet was sent to my address by post and when my wife told me that this pamphlet contained certain things which according to• G her were altogether rubbish and that it was anonymous I asked· her to tear it off.n He characterised Shri Sii Rama Reddy's evidence regarding him as absolutely false and malicious. He · admitted that ·some members of Parliament had talked to him and told him that there was a very nasty pamphlet issued against Slu'i SatJ.jiva Reddy but he did not think it necessary to make further H . enquiries. In answer to the question : "Who were the persons who talked to you about this pamphlet?'~, he replied : "Many peopte, it was the talk· .of the day."· The cross-examination further: proceeded thus : ·
:250
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1971] 2 S.C.R. .~
Q. Kindly give some names ?
A. My own group. Members of Parliament and some of them did talk to me about this pamphleJ. PC.
In the Central Hall? A. In the Central Hall, lobby and even outsid~ the Parliament. But I told them we were more interested in an idealogical fight than this character assassination.
His evidence clearly corroborates the evidence of P.Ws. to this extent that the pamphlet was the talk of the day. We will examine the implications of his statement a little later.
C
On this evidence it would be difficult to hold that Shri S. M. Banerjee was one of the dist1ibutors unless there is some independent corroboration. Shri Jagjivan Ram, M.P., R.W. 52, was named hy Shri H. C. Kachwai, M.P., P.W. 32, who said that .Shri Shashi Bhushan and Shri Jagjivan Ram gave the pamphlet to him in the Central Hall. Later he clarified that Shri Shashi Bhushan and Shri Jag]ivan Ram came separately and Shri Jagjivan Ram also gave him a. similar pamphlet. Shri Jagjivan Ram characterised. this part of the evidence of· Shri H. C. Kachwai as entirely and conipletely false. He further said that Shri Kachwai belonged to Jan ~angh, which party was, due to the Presidential election, more virulent about the Congress·: than usual. We may mention that he ~aid that he did . not receive the pamphl~t by post or in the Central Hall and he did not see any distribution in the Central H:all -()r hear any dis" cussion about this pall1phlet during' that period, although he used to go to the Central Hall practically every day after the Question hom• and usually sat there for half an hour.. Jn the particulars given by Shri Abdul Ghani Dar it is stated that Shri Jagjivan Ram distributed. the pamphlet to Shri Shiv Narain, M.P., and Shri Hukam Chand Kachwai, M.P. Shri Shiv Narain, P.W. 24, did not implicate him though he implicated others. Sliri J agjivan Ram was at ·the relevant time a Cabinet Minister and one of the important leaders of the Congress Party. If he was going to distribute the pamphlet it is difficult to be~ieve that he would distribute it to tme member of Parliament only and that too to a member belonging to the Jan Sangh. If he was gojog. to distribute we would expect him to approach many memben; -of Parliament and play a leading part. In the circumstances vie .cannot hold it proved that Shri Jagjivan Ram (fistributed the pamphlet in the Cent~al Hall unless there is independent corroboration.
f
S. K. SINGH V. SHRI V, V. GIRl (Sikri, J,)
25 I
Shri Chandrajeet Yadav, M.P., R.W. 56, was seen by Shrr Suraj Bhan, P.W. 33, distributing the pamphlet in the Central Shri Chandrajeet Hall. The latter belongs to the Jan Sangh. Yadav, in his evidence, said that Shri Suraj Bhan had made ~ completely false and baseless allegation. Actually he would deem it below his dignity to distribute a pamphlet of this nature. He guessed that Shri Suraj Bhan had named him because he had always attacked the policy of Jan Sangh. He said that althougb two friends talked to him about the pamphlet at a function he had not seen the pamphlet till he came to this Court. On this state of evidence was cannot hold it to be p1.>ved that Shri Chandrajit Yadav distributed the pamphlet unless there is some independent corroboration. Maulana Ishaq Sambhali, M.P., R.W. 57, is implicated by Shri Sri Rama Reddy, P.W. 54, wh0 said that he saw Maulana Ishaq and others distributing the patuphlet and he had named him in the particulars supplied by him. Maulana Ishaq Sambhali, when showed this evidence, deposed : "I am sorry if he has mentioned my name for distributing the pamphlet. It is totally false· and incorrect." He further said that he was elected on the Communist Party of India ticket and worked for Shri V. V. Giri, spoke to members of Parliament and approached M.L.As. of his state (Uttar Pradesh). He also said that he did not hear any talk about this pamphlet before the filing· of this petition. On this evidence we cannot hold it proved that Maulana lshaq Sambhali distributed the pamphlet in the Central Hall unless there is corroboration.
Apart from what we have already noticed, the petitioners led evidence to show that the pamphlet was not only widely distributed but also talked about for two to three days. Shri S. K. Patil, M.P., P.W. 16, said : "It' was the talk of the towu. In the Central Hall and wherever we went, there was nothing except this pamphlet." They considered what to do but could do nothing. He tried to trace the Press "but there was nothing." Shrimati Tarkeshwari Sinha. M.P .. P.W. 34, said that she did not see the pamphlet being distributed but found that the pamphlet had become the subject-matter of discussion in the Central Hall amongst all groups and in the Ladies lounge where they generally went and sat. We will refer to her alleged visit to Shri V. V. Girl
later.
SUPREME COURT -REPORTS
[1971] 2 S.C.R.
Shri Ram Krishan Gupta, M.P., P.W. 43, said that he received .the pamphlet in the house and he saw the pamphlet being distributed in the Central Hall but did not receive it there and could .not remember who was distributing: We will refer to his evi· dence regarding his alleged visit to Shri V. V. Girl later. Shri Morarji Desai, M.P.,. P.W. 39, said that be received the pamphlet by post. He gave the following reasons for not doing .anything: "I .could not do much about the pamphlet because one cannot merely deny it. One has to give facts. There are so many people mentioned anonymously in it. It would take a long time to enquire. Within two days. it was not possible to find out anything to contradict this effectively. It would also mean that mere d'i:nial would give more prominence to it and make its cir7 culation even more effective." He said that in his statement printed in the Hindustan Times of August 15, 1969-Ext R 6---he indirectly referred to the pamphlet in the following sentence : "All of us have at different times received our share of mud slinging, criticism or hostility, but the organisation has remained s.,upreme over individuals and bodies and we have served it loyally and faithfully/' (emphasis supplied) Shrl S. Nijalingappa, P.W. 47;· who was President of the Indian National Congres in August 1969, said that he received the pamphlet on 11th or 12th August but did not try to find out who were the persons who had published this pamphlet, because in the first· place it would be difficult and in the second place the more he looked into and made enquiries, it would possibly receive greater publicity which he wanted to avoid. He further said that quite a few Members of Parliament brought the pamphlet to his notice. Shri M. S. Gurupadaswami, M.P., P.W. 4~, then a Minister (He ·ceased to be a Minister on October 17 ~ 1967) said that he ·received the pamphlet by post. To the question : uDid you come across this ·pamphlet in Parliament?", he answered: "Yes. I saw the pamphlet being read by many people in the Central Hall of ·parliament." He added that he' did not see it being distributed but only read.
Before dealing with the evidence of the respondent's witnesses we may deal with certain contemporaneous documents and debates in Parliament on which the petitioners rely. Shri Madhu Limaye, M.P., P.W. 8, wrote to the Chief Elec·tion Commissioner on August 13, 1969-Ext. 7 P17- about the pamphlet. This letter does not say anything about distribution in the Central Hall of Parliament but it corroborates the case of distribution. He deposed that he Y...,ared that it might affect
S.'K, SINGH v. SHRI V. V. GIRl (Sikri, J.)
the chances of his Presidential candidate, meaning the respondent, and it would affect the validity of the election. We have already mentioned that he wrote to the Prime Minister whose reply we have already referred to. Shri Kanwar Lal Gupta, M.P., P.W. 11, wrote a letter, Ext. P37, on August 14, 1969, to the Chief Election Commiss1oner. B It is, urged that the first para of the letter clearly indicates distribution in the Central Hall. The first para reads : u The Prime Minister, along with some of her colleagues in the Ministry. are putting pressure on some Membm of Parliament to vote for Sbri V. V. Giri, who is a candidate for the post of President. A signature campaign is also going on in the Parliam~nt. Money is being offered to some members who vote for Shri V. V. Girl. MQreover, pamphlets are being distributed in which vulgar charges have been levelled against another candidate for this high office. Character assassination is going on. I am sending a copy of the pamD phlet in which vulgar and filthy attacks have been made against Shri N. Sanjiva Reddy. This amounts to corrupt practice under the Election Law.. These pamphlets are being distributed by the supporters of the Prime Minister. Shri M. Yunus Saleem, a Minister in her Cabinet and some others are very active in it."
It is· urged that the words "moreover pamphlets are being distributed" and "these pamphlets are being distributed by the sup· porters of the Prime Minister. Shri M. Yunus Saleem~ a Minister in her Cabinet and some others are very active in it" and read together and properly interpreted mean that the pamphlets were being distributed in ways other than by post; it is nobody's case F that S'..ui Yunus Saleem was active in distributing the pamphlet by post. On the respOndent's side it is urged that the words "are very active. in it" 'have reference not to distribution of the pamphlet but to the signature campaign. This is also a possible interpretation ·but we are of the opinion tbat, in the context,. the interpretation suggested by the petitioners is correct. If the respondent's G inter·pretation were correct, we would expect some other word to be used than ''distributed" ~nd further the word "being would not have been used. and instead the words "have been" would have beon employed. Further,· if reference is to distributoin by post it is nobody's case that the supporters of the Prime Minister were doipg it. No body ther. knew and no body even now knows who H actually posted them. It may have been done by supporters not belonging to the Congress Party. But having seen persons actually distributing the pamphlets the writer could very well use the expression "supporters of the Prime Minister". In our opinion, this
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] 2 s.c.R.
letter which is contemporaneous, strongly corroborates the story A told by the petitioners' witnesses that some persons alleged to be \ the supporters of the Prime Minister were distributing the pam· phlet in a way other than through post. Reading the letter as a whole we would interpret the words "active in it" as active in distribution because the sentence in which it occurs follows immediately the sentence "these pamphlets are being distributed by the B supporters of the Prime Minister.'' Shri Kanwar Lal Gupta has, in his evidence, implicated Shri Yunus Saleem and Shri Shashi Bhushan though he also stated that there w~re m"ny others. This letter corroborates his version. At the time he wrote there was no question of creating evidence for a possible election petition. His letter ·.Vas even mentioned in a news item. Reliance was also placed on a number of proceedings in Par· liament, but we find that the only proceeding that assists the peti· tioners is that in the Lok Sabha on August 13, 1969, when dis· (:ussion took place on a submission under Rule 340 made by Shri Kanwar Lal Gupta. Shri Om Prakash Tyagi said : "I am not going to surrender .... (interruptions). Just now, a minister was questioned about obtaining signatures and obiection was befor~ there. I want to inform you that even dirty pamphlets are being distri~ buted. On reading which one's head goes down with shame. Therefore I request you that the motion pre~ented by Shri Gupta Ji should be put to vote. False propaganda which is going on in the lobbies should be stopped." These stat~ments obviously allude to the distribution of the pamphlet the premises of Parliament.
in
Now let us look at the evidence of witnesses of the respondent other than those alleged t~ be distributors of the pamphlet in the Central Hall. Apart from the M.Ps. who are alleged to have distributed the .pamphlet in the Central Hall, 14 other M.Ps. who have been examined on behalf of the respondent depose on the point of distribution of the pamphlet and discussion about it. These are Sarvshri Munshir Ahmed Khan, R.W. 2, M. Anandam, R.W., 4, R. K. Sinha, R.W. 8, Smt. SaV'itri Shyam, R.W. 11 Sarvshri Syed Ahmad Agha, R.W. 10, P.M. Syed, R.W. 13, M. V. Krishnappa, R.W. 22, Gulabrao Raghunathrao Patil, R.W. 29, P. Viswambharan, R.W.39, I. K. Gujral, R.W. 40, Fathruddin Ali Ahmed, R.W. 44, T. D. Kamble, R.W. 46, Raghu Ramiah, R.W. 47. and Tulsi Das, R.W. 50. All of them (except Shri Kamble. R.W. 46, who was away from Delhi from 8th to 14th August and did not go to the Central Hall on 15th August) said that they saw
S. K. SINGH V. SHRI V. V, GIRl (Sikri, J.)
no distribution of tile pamphlet in the Central Hall. · Ten of them said that there was no discussion about the pamphlet in the Centfal Hall. One lady member said that there was .no discussion in ·the Ladies Lounge. Two (R.W. 4 and R.W. 8) have admitted.'that th~re was discussion. Five admitted having received the pamphlet by post (R.W. 2, R.W. 3, R.W. 8, R.W. 11 and R.W.l3).' It is not necessary to ref~r to their evidence in detail because it is. possible that these witnesses did not see distribution of the pamph.. let in the Central Hall. Some of th'e petitioners' witnesses also did not see distribution with their own eyes. The Central Hall was stated to be a big place, having as many as 396 fixed seats. A member sitting on one side may not be able to observe what is happening on the other side of the Hall. But it is hardly believable that when the pamphlet was the talk of the town, as admitted even by Shri S. M. Banerjee, these M.Ps. did not discuss, however casually, or hear or overhear discussion about the pamphlet. Some of the alleged distributors have also denied hearing talk or discussion about the pamphlet. We find it equally difficult to believe them in this respect. We may add that Shri Din.<;:sh Singh (who is not included in the M.P.s mentioned above) stated in cross-examination that he came across the pamphlet and glanced through it. Both sides refrained from asking him al:?out distribution of the pamphlet in the Central Hall. But the omission on the part of the counsel for the respondent to ask him about it has some significance,
We may here briefly refer to the evidence of Shri M. Anandam, R. W. 4, and Shri R. K. Sinha, R. W. 8. as their. evidence lends support to some extent to the case of the petitioners. Shri M. Anandam, M.P. deposed that he received the pamphlet (Ext. P 18/B) in English by post, just F glanced through it and it was in such filthy language that he just threw it away. He saw no one distributing it in the Central Hall. To the question : "Do you remember any discussion about thi's pamphlet in the Central Hall?", he answered : "There was a discussion amongst some members and some of us felt that this was in such a filthy language and scurrilous language that no body should go down to that level for the purpose of propaganda ... and we felt that at Jeast members of Parliament would decide issues like the Presidential election on better considerations. Therefore, we ignored the pamphlet." He said that he belonged to the Congress Party headed by Shri J agjivan Ram. In cross-examination he said : "There was discussion about this amongst some m·embers of Parliament who had received it by post" and that he did not H see the pamphlet in anybody's hand. Shri R. K. Sinha, M.P., R.W. 8, in his examination-in-chief said that he did not see anyone distributing the pamphlet in the 5-L308Sup.C.I.f71
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] 2 S.C.R.
C~ntra~ Hall, but there was some discussion about the pamphlet wtth fnends about this. He, however, did not join the discusr;on but only overheard. He characterised the suggestion that he was "one of the persons responsible for the publication and distributi~n of the pamphlet as 'wrong,' 'blasphemous', 'total lie'. He said that he never read the pamphlet but he knew about it because in the Central Hall friends had told him that this was a highly vulgar and spurious pamphlet. He further said that one or t~o _journalists an~ pro~ably Shri Balraj Madhok were discussmg .It and brought It to hts notice. He further added that "may be Justice Mulla was there" He also said that to his knowledge the pamphlet reached members of Parliament by post.
. These witnesses support t.he case of the petitioners at least to thts extent that there was discussion about the pamphlet in the
C
Central HalL Ih this connection the respondent's learned counsel relied on the statements of Shri Mohanlaf Sukhadia, Chief Minister Rajasthan, R.W. 42, and Shri V. P. Naik, Chief Minister Mah... ashtra, R.W. 43. The former deposed that he came to Delhi on the 12th 0 or 13th August and many Congress M.P.s came to see him but nobedy mentioned these pamphlets. Even Shri Nijalingappa, Shri Morarji Desai or Shri Chavan did not speak about them to him. Further, although he had telephonic talk with Shri Nijalingappa. so far as he could remember there was no talk about the pamphlet. He further deposed that when he came to Delhi on 24th August E be heard no complaint from any of the leaders or otherwise about the· pamphlet. Neither was there any talk in the meeting of the Working C~mmittee on August 25. We may mention that various witnesses support his version regarding the meeting of August 25. He further said that nobody in J aipur mentioned to him about the pamphlets and he did not see them there. Shri V. P. Naik said F that he came to Delhi often during the election period in August and no one spoke to him about these pamphlets. Neither was anything said to him during the course of telephonic conversation. which he had with members of Parliament, and Shri Nijalingappa. He further said that he was in Delhi abou, the 20th August, met the Prime Minister, the Home Minister and Shri Nijalingappa. but none of them made any complaint about these pamphlets. It is difficult to appreciate how the evidence of the two Chief Ministers helps us on the question of distribution of the pamphlet. Since the Prime Minster and so may members of Parliament have admitted receipt of the pamphlet by post, at the most the only inference that can be drawn is that the Prime Miniser and other members of Parliament who met the two Chief Ministers di<i not tltink it advisable or important to talk about it to the two Chief
s. :K. SINGH v. SHill V. V, GIRl (Sikri, ].)
A NWsters. We can, therefore, hardly draw the inference that no discussion of the pamphlet took place.
Viewing the evidence as a whole we are of the opinion that the pamphlet was ·distributed by post and in the Central Hall of Parliam~nt by some members of Parliament and there was wide. discussion about it in the Central Hall. As we have mentioned earlier, the evidence of the witnesses of the petitioners that there was distribution in the Central Hall is corrot;x>rated by contemporaneous documents.
On the question as to who were the persons who were distributing the pamphlet in the Central Hall it is not, in our opinion, necessary for us to arrive at a finding from a ~ass of evidence C which is both conflicting and partisan. The distribution of the pamphlet in the Ce.Iitral Hall was relied on by th~ petitioners for the purpose of bringing home to the respondent knowledge a~ut the pamphlet and its publication and his connection with it. The petitioners, however, have failed in their object, for, there ia no evidence whatsoever to show that the respondent had any conD nection with the pamphlet or with its distribution. Nor is there any evidence to show that anyone connected with the distribution either through the post or in the ce·ntral Hall had any contact with the respondent, or that he· distributed it with his knowledge or connivance. The question of identity of those who distributed it in the Central Hall, therefore, has in these circumstances beE come unnecessary and even futile. What is also equally important is that there is no provision in the Act for giving notice to and hearing persons alleged to be the distributors. A finding that a particular member or members of Parliament committed the offence of publication, an act punishable under the Penal Code, would thus amount to a finding arrived at without giving such F person or persons an opportunity of being heard. It was urged on behalf of the petitioners that the respondent, Shri V. V. Giri, had connived at the distribution of the pamphlet. Before we examine the evidence .relied on on behalf of the peti:tioners to prove connivance, it is necessary to give a few particulars about the house where Shri V. V. Giri had his office and G where Smt. Tarkeshwari Sinha, P.W. 34, and others are said to have gone to see him. There is a small lawn in front of the house and the size of the lawn is approximately 7ft. x 18 ft. when a visitor comes to the house he goes inside through the verandah, which is approximately 4 ft. x 10 ft. This verandah is open and adjoins the office room and the drawing room. Shri Giri used to sit in the drawing room which was air-conditioned. Shri N. P. C. Naidu, M.P., said that Shri Yunus Saleem gavPH him the pamphlet in the Central Hall on the 11th or 12th of August, and he also received the pr.mphlet by post. After reading
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971 J2 S.C.R.
the pamphlet he felt disturbed and he wanted to meet Shri V. V. Giri and tell him to contradict the pamphlet because Shri V. V. Giri's supporters were distributing the pamphlet. He said : "So I went to his house to meet him in Defence Colony. There wer~ the supporters of Mr. V. · V. Giri and they asked me if I was also his supporter when I told that I had only gone to see ·him. 1 could not see hiri1 and on the same day I wrot~ a letter to him requesting him to please contradict this otherwise it will not be a fair election." He stated that he sent the letter by ordinary post and though he thought that he had a copy of it he did not pro~ duce it. In cross-examination he admitted that he had not told the petitioners that he went to Shri V. V. Giri and brought the pam· phlet to his notice and asked him to dissociate himself from it. But .in the particulars supplied by Shri Sri Rama Reddy it is stated that persons nL~med below went to the residence of Shri V. V. Giri.at C-243, Defence Colony, New Delhi, on the dates noted against each and they brought this pamphlet to the notice of Shri V. V. Ghi: J. Shri Ram Krishan Gupta, M.P.-13~8-69 2. Smt. Tarkeshwari Sinha, M.P.-l 4:-8-69 3. Shri N. P. C. Naidu, M.P.-13-8-69
4. Shri Hari Krishna, M.P.-14-8-69
(We may mention that Shri Hari Krishna was not examined). It will be noticed that in his evidence Shri N. P. C. Naidu does not say that he saw Shri V. V. Giri; there is also no proof that he ever wrote a letter. Shri V. V. Giri denied in the witness box having received any letter from Shri Naidu. Shri V. V.Giri depos· ed that he did not know Shri Naidu and he did not think that he had ever seen him. Shri Giri further stated that he never received any letter from Shri Naidu requesting him to contradict the con· tents of the pamphlet. Smt. Tarkeshwari Sinha, M.P., P.W. 43, deposed that the mem" bers of Parliament seemed to be affected by the pamphlet and that the atmosphere was bad as the character of Shri Sanjiva Reddy was being discussed. She said : "I went to Mr. Giri's .house on 14th of August in Defence Colony. Somebody came out. I asked him that I would like to see Mr. Giri. He went inside and I was in verandah and Mr. Giri came and I showed this pamphlet to him and I said to him that the election that is· going on is for the highest office in the country and I think that you should repudiate this pamphlet, because this pamphlet is not only· untrue, but is mean. He
S. K. SINGH v. SHRI V. V.· GIRl (Sikri, J.)
. said : "What can I do about it?" I said to him that as a contestant for the highest office in the country it is your obligation to maintain the standard of the election campaign. He again repeated: "What can I do in the matter?" and suddenly became very cold and became ·quite and when I found that there was no response, I wished him and came back." She, however, admitted in cross-examination that she had not referred to this pamphlet in any of her articles but explained .that those articles were part of the .political commentary and there was no mention of the character of the candidates or their qualifications and disqualifications. She admitted that she belonged to the group of which Shri Nijalingappa is the President. She denied th~ suggestion that the entire alleged interview between her and Shn Giri was a fiction. She further said that she went alone and no one else was present when she had this conversation with · Shri Giri. She could not remember the exact time but is was sometime in the morning. Her statement which we have quoted above was put to Shri Giri and he characterised it as absolutely incorrect and said that she never came. He added: "I can only say with respect that it must be a figment of her imagination." He further said that he was always on good terms with her and had no enmity with anyone, especially not with her. He further stated that there was no reason why he should not have met her in the drawing r~om and he would certainly have invited her into the drawing room and heard her with respect "'hatever she wanted to say, but she never ·came at all. Before we evaluate this evidence we will have to refer to the evidence of some other persons. The next witness who was relied on in this respect is Shri Ram Krishan Gupta, M.P., P.W. 43. SD.ri Ram Krishan Gupta,' when asked whether he did anything in connection with the pamphlet, replied; "After two or three days (of the receipt of the pamphlet) my daughter told me that she had received a telephone from Shri V. V. Giri. She noted his address and telephone number also." He went to see Shri Giri in Defence Colony about two or three days before the election. He further ·said that he met Shri Giri and the following conversation took ,Place : "Q. What was the talk between you two ?
A. He asked me to support him and I refuslo..d that I am committed to Sanjiva Reddy. I am a congress man and congress had put up Sanjiva Reddy. Therefore, I must support ·him. Moreover, a party or candidate which issues such posters does not deserve any help.
SUP.R.EME COU.R.T :UPOllTS
[1971] 2 S.C.R.
Q. What was his reply ?
A. He said nothing; only this much that'what can I do. Q. Did you ask him about this pamphlet? A. Yes, about this pamphlet that such posters should not be issued and should be contradicted by his party. His reply was : what can I do ?"
In -;ross-examination he stated that he did not tell Shri Abdul Ghani Dar or Shri Sri Rama Reddy the exact date he went to Shri Giri's house but only told them that it was two or three days before the election. He said that there was no guard posted at Shri Giri's house because Shri Giri was interested in the election and further that two or three persons were sitting when he had this conversation with Shri Giri but he did not know them. It was difficult for him to give any idea or description of those persons. He further said that he went in the evening and he went from the front side and he could not give any further description of ·the house, whether the entrance of the house was in the front side, or whether it is only a ground floor house or whether there is any upper floor on it because he went there casually. He .explained that by evening he meant 7 or 8. It was put to him that his entire story of g0ing to Shri Giri's house was false, and he said ; ·'It is absolutely correct. If you examine my telephone directory, his number is still written there by my daughter." The learned counsel for the respondent read the evidence, which we have extracted above, to Shri V. V. Giri and aslred the question : "Is any part of this statement correct ?" Shri Giri replied : "He never met me." We may reproduce the rest of the examination : "0. Did you telephone? A. I never telephoned to him. I think to his daughter also I never spoke on telephone. Q. Did you meet any visitors in the verandah'! · A. I never met anybody ·in the verandah; it was hot and sultry outside at that time and I received every one in the drawing room." Shri Harbans Lal Sehgal, Deputy Suprintendent ·of Police, R.W. 7, was one of the Security Officers assi.gned to guard Shri V. V. Giri. He had been with him since Shri V. V. Giri was Vice-President of India in 1967. He said that another Security Officer, Shri R. N. Mullick, was also assigned the same duty. Between themselves they took shifts at No. C-243, Defence Colony. Shifts were normally between 8 a.m. to 2 p.m., 2 p.m. to 8 p.m., and the first man would come from 9 p.m. till morning~ According to him there was ~o time when a Security Officer was
;
\
•'
I
'\
S. K. SINGH v. SHlU V. V, GIRl (Sikri, 1.)
not present. Shri Giri did not sleep at No. C-243 Defence Co!0ny but at C-496, where the Security Officer used to stay. He stated that he was on duty on August 14, 1969, and he remembered this because he returned from tour with Shri V. V. Giri on August 13, 1969, in the afternoon, then his co\lnter-part Shri Mullick took over the night duty and he came on duty in the morning of the B 14th. Re said that he took over duty at 8 in the morning. He further said that a gunman was always on duty and the gunnian used to stand near the gate. He described the procedure when anyone came to see Shri Giri thus : "He shall meet us--one of the Security Officers who was present there-and we informed either Mr. Krishna Rao or the son of the President, whosoever was preC sent and if they allowed him, we took hjm to the President in the drawing room where the President was sitting.'' He said that the drawing room door-a closable door-<>pened on the verandah from which they took the visitors. The further procedure was that after he had shown the visitor the door was closed as the room was air-conditioned. He further deposed that he knew Smt. Tarkeshwari Sinha by sight, that Smt. Tarkeshwari Sinha never D came during his duty hours and further that the President never met anybody in the verandah. When asked: "How do you know Shrimati Tarkeshwari Sinha ?", he replied : "I am in the Security Branch of the Police for 12 years and I know she i'l " prominent member of the Parliament and then she W\lS a Deputy Minist~r in the Ministry of Finance as I know some other members of ParliaE ment and Ministers which I saw during the official duties and came in contact otherwise.' He asserted that to his knowled2.e no one who came to see Shri Giri was ever refused entry. H~ ~aid that he did not know Shri Ram Krishan Gupta, M.P., neither ,lid he know Shri N.P.C. Naidu. In cross-:~xamination he said th~tt he did not keep a visitors book nor a vigilance book but he used to F make a report of his duties to the Superintendent of Police. He never gave the names of those persons who came and visited Shri Giri to the Superintendent of Police. He was unable to giv.-:: the names of the persons who visited Shri Giri on 28th July or 14th August. He explained : "I do nt remember as to who came and on what particular date but I can give you the names whom I saw coming and meeting the President." He said that he read the G evidence of Shri Krishna Rao in the press.
We may mention that the evidence of most of the witnesses used to be reported extensively in the press.
The witness denied that his relations with the family members of Shri V. V. Giri were informal and added : "we never cultivate relations with the family members of the VIP." It was suggested that it would be too hot for him to sit in the verandah or in the lawn but he replied that it all depended in one's training
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] 2 s.c.R.
&nd nature of duties. In cross-examination he said that he did -not know of any case where Shri Krishna Rao or Shri Giri's son refused to allow any visitors to see Shri Giri.
It is not necessary to give further details of the cro~s-examina tion but we are of the view that his evidence was not shaken by the. various~ questions put to him. There is no reason why we should not place reliance on the evidence of this officer. The evidence
of Shri Mullick, Deputy Superintendent of.
~olke, R.W. 45, is similar. He said that he kept a register of his
attendance duty and used to submit reports. These were in small bound plain paper register and they used to ·be shown to the S.P. Security, Shri .Marwaha. · He said that the book was misplaced c when he shifted in .the month of December to the President's estate. He added that this book was kept for his own r0nvenience; at the time of T.A. bill it was used; otherwise it was 1 no use. It was. not an official ·record 1 He t!len described the places he went with Shri Giri outside Delhi. He described the visits. He was asked how many persons came to see Shri Giri from the 21st of July .D to 29th of July, and he replied that he wo~ld not be able to tell that exactly, 'but he added : "Roughly about forty people during this period." He further said that during his duty hours between 6 and 7 sometimes 4 to 5 people came every day from August 13 to August 16. He said that among those who visited were Shri Krishna Menon, Shri Bhupesh Gupta, Shri Amar Singh Sehgal E and Smt. · Aruna Asaf Ali, and the persons who visited from 21st to 29th July included Shri Jagat Narain. Shri Yashpal, Shri N. C. Chatterjee and a few M.Ps. He said that he could not recollect any more. He asserted that Smt. Tarkeshwari Sinha never came during his duty hours. The learned l;Ounsel has not been able to give any convincing reason why we should disbelieve this officer. Shri P. Krishna Rao, R.W. 1, is the son-in-law of Shri V. V. Giri. C-243. Defence Colony, was his house, and he said that . Shri V. V. Giri conducted his campaign single-handed from this house, although members of his family assisted him. He said that Shri Girl went on tour on the 29th July and completed it on the 13th of August, 1969, but in between he came for a few hours on the lOth and ·again for a few hours on the 12th. He gave the same version about the duties of the Security Officers, and the procedure foltowed in the bouse for receiving visitors. He said that Smt. Tarkeshwari Sinha never came to see Shri Giri from the 20th July to the 16th August, and she did not come on the 14th Ammst in the morning. ·He further said that Shri Giri never intervi~wed anybody in the verandah as it was open to the
S. K. SINGH l'. t:l-lRI V. V, GIRl (Sikri, J.)
26 3
public gaze and wh!!re the Security Officer and probably the driver or some other clerk would be siting or standing. He further stated that· after Shri Giri returned from his tour on the 13th he was contitmously with him and he was in attendance on him on the 13th, 14th and 15th; only on the 16th he left in the morning and went to the Parliament House to watch the voting. He further deposed that he knew Shri N. P. C. Naidu and had met him at several places but was not on visiting terms with him.. He said . that he met him ( Shri Naidu) off and on when he went to see members of Parliament from Andhra, and that he first saw. hirn three or four years back at Madras at the house of late Shti V. Rama Krishnan. He denied that Smt. Tarkeshwari Sinha visited sometime in the morning of the 14th, or Shri N.P.C. Naidu came to see Shri Giri at C-243 ·and could not see Shri Giri. He added that ·it was impossible; Shri Naidu would not have been turned away; he never came. · Shri Jai Murti Prasad, P.W. 41, who wasone of the gunmen attached to Shri V. V. Giri said that there were three men on duty and they did duty in shifts. He said that he was on duty on the 14th from 2 a.m. to 9 a.m. and after 9 a.m. constable Rain Batta came. He said that he knew Smt. Tarkeshwari Sinha. She did not come to meet Shri Gid while he was on duty. . Constable Ram Batta, R.W. 59, stated that he was on duty on the 14th August from 9 a.m .. to 6 p.m. He corroborated Jai Murti Prasad that he took over duty at 9 a.m. on August 14. On this evidence we cannot accept the case of the petitioners that the pamphlet was brought to the notice of Shri V. V. Giri by Shri R. K. Gupta or Smt. Tarlceshwari Sinha or Shri N. P. C. Naidu.
H.
The evidence of .Slui V. V. Giri is corroborated by the Security Officers. Besides, we find it difficult to believe that Smt. Tarkeshwari Sinha would have been treated. in such a crude and inhospitable manner. There is evidence that visitors were always off~ red coffee but no coffee was offered· to Smt. Tarkeshwari Sinha by Shri V. V. Giri. The story told by Shri Ram Krishan Gupta does not appeal to us. Why should Shri Giri telephone . Shri Gupta? No previous acquaintance between him and Shri Giri has been established. If it was Shri Giri's election technique we would have expected evidence to be produced that he telephoned a number of electors from Delhi. The·.learned counsel for the petitioners said that the witness was an i~portant person and Shri Giri might have been told at Chandigarh that he should contact the witness. But we cannot rely on conjectures. In order to prove connivance on the part of Shri Giri, the learned counsel also relied on a copy of a letter which Shri Abdul
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971]2 S.C.R.
Ghani Dar is supposed to have sent to the respondent. · Shri Dar deposed that he wrote a letter to Shri Giri and he produced a copy of it in Court--Ext. P·67. Shri Dar did not address the letter himself but he told his Personal Assistant to put the address of Shri Giri on it and the letter was posted by his P .A. , His P .A. , has not been produced. Shri Dar further said that he enclosed one printed pamphlet in Englisl:. with the letter. A copy of this- ·B was said to have been forwarded to the Prim.e Minster of India, .New Delhi,. and Prof. Humayun Kabir, who is now dead. There is no proof of this. Shri Giri was shown ~e copy of Ext. P-67 and he said that this letter was never received by him. In cross-examination it was suggested that the letter formed part of the .correspondence which was destroye4 when Shri V. y, Giri shifted C to Rashtrapati Bhavan. We are of the view ·that it bas not been proved that the letter was sent by Shri Abdul .Ghani Dar .. The learned counsel then relied on circumstantial evidence ~o prove that Shri V. V. ·Giri knew of the distributitm of the pamphlet · and connived at it. The learned "Counsel urged that according to Shri V. V. Giri he conducted the election campaign single· D banded arid left the entire work of apprQaching M.P .s to the supporters, and in his evidence also tried to show that be was not associated with the supporters at all. He urged that a necessary inference which flows from these facts is that the electors who actually supported Shri Giri must have been in constant touck with him. He said that this is the only logical conclusion. We E are unable to accede to this contention. Before Shri '-'. V. Giri left for his tour the Congress Party was . against his candidature. By the. time Shri Giri came back to Delhi on the 13th August; much had _already been said and done, and the pamphlet had been ·printed and distributed. There is no evidence that he was con· tacted by any of these alleged supp<;Jrters while he was on tour. The persoJ;lS belonging to the Congress party, now headed by Shri F Jagjivan Ram, were themselves vitally interested in the election of Shri V. V. Giri· as it ·had become a burning issue between the two ··Congress parties. On this evidence we cannot draw any inference that the supporters must have contacted Shri Girl. The learned counsel then said that some ·newspapers had carried news about the pamphlet, but there is no evidence that any G newspaper printed the whole pamphlet. The pamphlet was referred to in the Hindustan Times, Evening News, dated August 14, 1969, which summarised the letter written by Shri Kanwar Lal Gupta to the Election Commission as follows : · . "A Sangh MP Mr: K~:Piwar Lal Gupta, today addressH ed a Jetter to the Election Commission protesting against the alleg~d corrup~ practices by the Prime Minister, Mrs. Indtra Gandhi, and her Cabinet colleagues in the
I
~ \
) !-
''
.i
S. K. SINGH V. SHRI V. V. GIRl (Sikri, J.)
Presidential poll. He has charged them with pressurising M.Ps. in favour of Mr. Giri. He has also objected to a pamphlet circulated among the M.Ps. in which certain attacks have been made on Mr. Reddy."
'f'his news item could escape anybody and, therefore, there is no reason to disbelieve Shri Giri that he did not come across this news item. We must, therefore,. hold that it has .not been proved that there was any connivance on the part of Shri Giri to the printing, publishing or distribution of the pamphlet.
We have ·already said, and we may repeat, that there is no evidence whatsoever that there was any intimate connection bet· ween Shri V. V. Giri and the alleged distributors. What they were doing in this connection they were doing on their own and Shri Giri cannot be held responsible for their deeds unless, of course, it is established that the result of the election had been materially affected by the distribution of the pamphlet. This question we shall now consider.
It is weU-settled that the burden of proving that the result of the election has been materially affected is on the petitioners. (see Vashist Narain Sharma v. Dev Chandra(l); Mahadeo v. Babu Udai Pratap Singh(2); Paokai Haokip v. Rishang( 8 ); and
G. K. Samal v. R. N. Rao(4.). The learned cou'nsel, relying on Surendra Nath Khosla v. Dalip .Singh( 11 ), urged that this Court should draw a presumption, as was done in the case of a rejection of a nomination pap.er, that the result of the election has been materially affected, from the nature of thr~ pamphlet -and - the manner of its distribution. He further stressed the fact that the petitioners were not in a position to compel witnesses to disclose their change of view and say for whom they voted.
A similar argument was advanced before this Court in Samant N. Balakrishna v. George Fernandez( 8 ). But the learned
Chief Justice rejected it thus :
"In our opinion the matter cannot be considered on possibility. Vashist Narain's( 1 ) case insists on proof. If the margin of votes were srrtall something might be made of the points mentioned by Mr. Jethamalani. But the margin is large and the number of votes earned 0) [1955] I S.C.R. 509. (2) AJ.R 1966 S. C. 824.
(3) Civil 'Appeal No. 683 of 1968 decided on August 12, 1968. (4) Civil Appeal No. 1540 of 1969 decided on January 20, 1970. (S) [1957] S.C.R. 179. (6) A.I.R. 1969 S.C. 1201, 1225.
.. :&66
SUP.llBMB. CO~T. UPOllTS
[ 1971]2 'S.C.ll.
·8y the l'CQWning candidates also sufficiently huge. 1'bete il DO reason. therefore,· for a reasonable judicial gueas. The law requires ·proof. . HQ'W far that proof should go or what it should contain is not provided .by the legislature. In Vashis(s case and in lnayatulltlh v. Diwanclum,d Mahajan (1) the. provision was · ~ to prescribe an -impossible burden. The· law has however remained as before. W~ are bound by the ruling Qf this Court and must say that the burden has not been successfully discharged. We cannot overlook the rulings. of this Court and follow the English rulings cited to us/'
The learn~ counsel invited us to overrule th\s decision. It is too late in the day to do this. . This view was t~ken very eady by various Election Tribunals. It was observed in Rai JJahadur
Surendra Narain Sinha v. Babu Amul;yadhone Roy( 1 ) :
"In the direct form in which provision is made for this matter in paragraph 7 ( 1) (c) of the Order. there · is no scope for -interference on the ground that in the opinion of the Commissioners the· result of the election might have been affected by the irregularity. This view ·has been taken in respect of a similar provision to that laid down in paragraph 7 ( 1) (c) in three cases reported in Hammond's Election Cases ( 1936 edition), namely, in Bulandshahr District (East) 1921 (rage· 219), Lahore City (M) 1921 (page 469), and Patna West (N.M.R.) 1927 page 535). Then the. Commissioner goes on to say that "it may be that in · some circumstances the provision in this rule may operate harshly, where a tribun<ll may feel that the result of an election may well have been affected by a serious irregularity, but it may be impossible for the petitioner to establish this positively; but we have to interpret and follow the rule as it stands. 1' Parliament, knowing of the ·views held by various Commissioners and Judges·, have failed to intervene, and it is not for us to legislate. Let us then see if the petitioners have been able to affirmatively prove that the result of the eLection was materiaJly affected by the distribution of the pamphlet. They sought to prove this by showing what the impact of the pamphlet on various electors and their reaction was. The reactions, as is to be expected, {I) 15 E.L.R. 219. {2) Doaba's Indian Election Cases (1935·1950) Vol II; p. 368-378.
S. K. SINGH v. SHRI V. V. GIRl (Sikri,/.)
varied greatly in its intensity. The witnesses describe it variously: "It was in bad taste, very derogatory; it was dirty, scandalous, extremely bad, pernicious, contemptible, character assassination, horrible, vulgar and scurrilous, false and malicious, foul and filthy, unpleasant and foul." Sht:i Madhu Limaye, M.P., though~ that it would affect the chances of his candidate, Shri Giri. Shn Kanwar Lal Gupta, M.P., was in doubt what to do and what not to do. Shri K. S. Chavda, M.P., said that he changed his mind. Shri N.P.C. Naidu, M.P., concluded that members would not vote for Shri Reddy. Shri Shiv Narain, M.P., frankly stated that though he thought that 'such a man should not be the President, yet Shri Rama Reddy convinced him that pamphlet was totally false and he abided by the c the decision . of the Congress Party Board. Smt. Jayabehn Shah, M.P., felt perplexed right upto the date she cast the vote but failed to positively assert that she voted for some other candidate because of the ~amphlet. Shri N. N. Patel, M.P.; said that he changed his attitude after reading the pamphlet and adhered to it till the last moment. Shri Mohan Lal Gautam, D M.P., does not disclose how he voted .. Neither does Shri S. Supakar, M.P., disclose how he. voted, although he felt very sad on reading the pamphlet. Shri C. D. Pande, M.P., said that although his faith in the uprightness of Shri Sanjiva Reddy was shaken, it did not affect his vote. Shri P. N. Deb, M.P., felt very much prejudiced against Shri Reddy but did not say tha.t he voted E against him because of this pamphlet. Shri Hukam Chand Kachwai, M.P., a member of the Jan Sangh, said that at that time he thought the allegations foul and they did influence his mind, but failed to say who he voted for. Shri Suraj Bhan, M.P., deposed that ·the pamphlet, so far as he was concerned, affected the directions which had been given by his leaders. Smt. Pushpabehn Mehta, M.P., does not say that the pamphlet affected her vote. Shri Morarji Desai, M.P .. described the impact on his mind thus :
"This would affect an average voter against Shri S. Reddy adversely, because the contents are so shocking ~nd in this country people believe many things without going into them, especially wrong things are believed more easily." Shri Shri Chand Goyal, M.P., admitted that "it is not I that exercised my franchise guided by it." The impact on Shri Ram Krishan Gupta was totally different than intended. He said that after reading the pamphlet "I became a stronger supporter of Shri Sanjiva Reddy because I thought such like postets are not good and should not be issued." Shri R. Muniswamiah, M.L.A.. sai<l that the contents prejudiced his mind, and he could not risk
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1971] 2 S.C.R.
not to believe them, but did not disclose how he voted. He, A however, admitted that he is a loyal Congressman and has adhered scrupulously to the directives of his party. Shri S. Nijalingappa said that the pamphlet "'"luld adversely affect Shri Reddy's chances of success. Shri J.~: S. _Gurupadaswamy, M.P., did not say that the pamphlet affected nim. although "the motivation was to defame the candidate Shri Sanjiva Reddy and jeopardise his chances of being elected as President." Shri D. S. Raju, M.P., said that he was shocked by the pamphlet but he had' always been a loyal Congressman and scrupulously abided by the direcr tives of the party. Shri Patil Putappa, M.P., felt whether he would be doing the right- thing by voting for Shri Sanjiva Reddy after reading the pamphlet but admitted that he had always been disciplined and loyal Congressman and loyal to the directives of c the party. Shri Sher Khan, M.P., did not believe in the truth of the allegations in the pamphlet as he had known ihri Sanjiva Reddy personally, but felt that tposo persons who did not know Shri Sanjiva Reddy _ might be affected by the pamphlet. Chaudhary A. Mohammad, M.P., said that the pamphlet difi affect his mind but h.e did not view his decision in that light, D being a loyal soldier of the Congress. Shri C. M. Kedaria deposed that after reading the pamphlet he could not risk voting for such a candidate for such a high post. Whether he actually voted for Shri Sanjiva Reddy or not is anybody's guess because neither side asked him that question. Shri N. Sri Rama Reddy, M.P., one of the petitioners, had known Shri Sanjiva ~y for -E the last 35 years, and was his counting agent. It is not suggested that his vote was affected by the pamphlet. Shri Abdul Ghani Dar, M.P., a petitioner, stated that after the pamphlet was read out to him he thought "that country was sinking and extreme danger has been posed to the democracy." It is, however, quite dear from his evidence that he did not believe that Shri Sanjiva Reddy was a debauch. We have not referred to the evidence of electors from U.P. who deposed to meeting Shri Dinesh Singh at Lucknow because, as will presently · appear, much reliance cannot be placed on what they .say.
It will be evident from the above analysis of the evidence that apart from two witnesses it is not certain whether the others were so affected by the pamphlet that they changed their mind. Then there are witnesses who say that there was no effect on their voting, either because they knew Shri Sanjiva Reddy or did not believe the allegations or that they were loyal and disciplined members of the Congress Party. Five witnesses were strongly prejudiced but they do not say that this prejudice finally affected their voting or not. Two remained sad or disgusted but failed
S. K. SINGH v. SHRI V. V. GIRl (Sikri, /.)
to disclose. whether it had any affect, on them. One thought that the party directive was affected. Apparently he was not periooally affected. One witness became :: rirm supporter of Shri Sanjiva Reddy because of the pamphlet. Some witnesses opined that others would get affected, which evidence cannot assist the petitioners in any manner.
On this -evidence it is difficult to hold that the petitioners have proved that the publication and distribution of the pamphlet materiallv affected the result of the election. It only leads to the c~mciusion that it probably did have some effect but the vast . majority of the electors were able to throw off the effect of the pamphlet and vote according to their own personal wish or according to ·the mandate of their party.
There is ·evidence that there was a great deal of talk about the pamphlet. There was time before voting for the electors to exchange views about the pamphlet and ascertain the truth. Shri Sanjiva Reddy had been the Speaker ·of the Lok Sabha and was a well-known and leading political personality
There were various other issues exercising · the minds of electors, particularly belonging to the Congress party. If in spite of all these factors some were unduly influenced in their thinking, it was for them to come and say so. There was no landslide against Shri Sanjiva Reddy. Two hundred and sixty eight members of Parliament gave him the ·first preference. Ninety two members of Parliament, who had given first prefrence ~o Shri C. D. Deshmukh, gave second preference to Shri Sanjiva Reddy. It is, however, true that if 26 more members of Parliament had voted for Shri Sanjiva Reddy, instead of Shri Giri, th.e former would have been elected. Therefore, on the evidence before us, it is impossible .to sustain the contention of the petitioners. In the result we hold that it was not been proved that the result of the election was materially affected by the publication and distribution of the pam. phlet.
The learned counsel for the petitioners urged another i>oint It was said that Shri Dinesh Singh, then Minjster for External Affairs, visied Lucknow somewhere round about the lOth of August and exe~cise<! undue_infiuenc~ on var~ous memb~r~ of U.P. Legislature. Shn Dinesh Smgh demed havmg ever VlSlted Lucknow round about that time. He said that \J,e did not go to Lucknow till after the polling date. A number of witnesses have been produced on behalf of the petitioners to establish the visit of Shri Dinesh Singh to .Lucknow.
in order to impeach the validity of the election.
:.!iu
SUPRE\lE COURT REPORTS
fl971] 2 S.C.~.
Shri 1,3ansi Dhar P;mdcy. M.L.A., U.P., ~.W. 18, deposed 1·e- A ~ardim/ Shri Giri\ vi-.it to Lucknow. He said that ·shri Dincsh Singh -came io Unar Pradesh for canvassing for Shri Giri, met hin) and -had a talk. He deposed : ··He held ::1. me~ting of the leaders in B Block. I was also there. He told i.1s that we should supp{)rt Mr. Giri... He added : ··He s<tiu we should support Mr.· Giri tll1d thus we ~IHHJid support Prime Minister's view; she beB Jonos'lto our St;ltc:·· Accordin~ to him Shri Dincsh Singh then t': .... said : -··tf we do not suppnrt _th.: can~litlature or Mr. Giri, we will not get Central p~1tronugc <ind we, would ·not get the support of the Prim~ Minister in, the generul eledions nnd we would not get the party ticket\ i1~ the elections." ·He d_cposed to the receipt of the pamphlet hy p(.1Sl. This examirl6tion took place before c us on the 25th F:!bru<u·y. 1970. and the learned counsel for the ~espondent at thut stage did not·put any question in cross-ex-amination tq suggest that as a matter of fact Shri Dinesh Singh never visited Lucknow. Jt appears'that the persons in charge of preparing Shri Giri's case had by then not co111e in contact with Shri Dinesh Singh and sould not ~scertain- whether he had as a matter of fact gone to L1.1cknow. ~
The next witness, Shri Ram Singh, M.L.A., U.P., P.W. 19, gave evidence ilf the same strain. lk said that four or five ~_ days after. Shri Giri~s visit Shri Dinesh Singh came to Lucknow·. He also stated that Shri Dinesh Singh said that "if you vote to Mr. Reddy, y<;>u will be in difficulty because Central support E will not be giv.en to you, the party candidature will not be given to you, partrohage of the Central leaders will not be given to you." This evidenc~ was also .given on ·the 25th February, and :no questi~n was :asked in cross-examination to suggest that Shri Dinesh Singh did not visit Lucknow during this period. Shri Jagdish Prasad, M.L.A., U.P., P.W., 20, .als6 gave evidence to the effect. Shri Basant Lall Sharma, M.L.A., P.W. 22, also s~d that Shri Dinesh Singh visited' eight or nine days before the polling date .
.Shr~ Rajez:dra P.rapat Singh, M.L.A., P.W. 21, deposed that
Shn Dmesh Smgh came .~o Lucknow .seven or eight 'days before
the polling and he .met hi,m and others in a block of the Councfllors' Residence. According to him Shri D:inesh Singh told him that "it is the desire of the Prime Minister that don't vote fo: the. o.ther candi~ate." The witness further deposed that Shri Dmesh Smgh told hun that he had come to know from Shri Giri that "I was not prepared to vote for Shri Girl." According to the witness by "th~ other candidate"-Shri Dinesh Singh meant Shri H ·Reddy, t_he Congress can~li~ate. Shri Dinesh Singh is further ulleged to have told the wxtness that the "Prime Minister is a
S. K. SINGH v. SHlll V. V. GIRl (Sikr~, 1.)
great leader of the party and her wishes altro fell within the diJcipline''. Shri Dinesh Singh .is further alleged to have poilltod to the witness that the witness came from Rai Bareli which was Prime Minister's constituency and great help was received from her in election. The witness understood this to mean that if he voted against the Prime Minister then the help available to him· from her would not be available. Sbri Ram Pyare Panika, M.L.A., P.W. 37., who was examin· ed on March 2, 1970, gave similar evidence as the earlier wit· nesses from Uttar Pradesh. He said that Shri Dinesh Singh visited Lucknow about 9 or 10 days before the polling but· he could not give the exact date. He said that Shri Dinesh spent two or three days in Lucknow but he could not say where he stayed. To the question : "How do you know that he was there for two or three days?", he replied : "Because he met me once and some friends of mine told me that he also met them two or three days after that." He wa~ a~kea : "Now look here I put it to you that Mr. Dinesh Singh never visited Lucknow between the lst' and the 16th August and that what you have said is untrileu. He an~ wered: "He visited Lucknow and he met me." Other questions were al~o asked. This is the first occasion that questions were asked with a view to establish that.Shri Dinesh did not visit Lucknow between the 1st and the 16th.. The next witness, Shri Abdul Salim Shah, M.L.A., P.W. 38, also deposed that Shri Dinesh Singh came about a week before the poJling day and he saw him (Shri Dinesh Singh) at Darulshafa where Shr~ Dinesh Singh addressed the people. He further told that Shri D~nesh Singh talked to him individually. In crossexamination he saitl that the did not· know where Shri Dinesh Singh was Jiving or where he stayed. He met him oJily ·flnce at Darulshafa about noon. He could not remember the names of persons who were present when Shri Dinesh Singh had conVer· sation with him but ultimately said : ''Dr. Sia Ram. Th. Mehram . Singh, Mumtaz Khan, Abid Ali, Jogeshwar Dayal and many others.'' To the question : ''I put it to you that between the first of August and the 16th of August Dinesh Singh never went to Lucknow and you could not have met him," he replied: ''No. · I met him and he came to Lucknow." The next witness on this point is Shri Mumtaz Mohd. Khan, M.L.A., U.P., P.W. 44, He also gave similar evidence and he _said that Shri Dinesh Singh came to Lucknow a.bout a. ~eek . before the Presidential election and met him. He descrilied the talk which he had with Shri Dinesh Singh. ln cross-examination he said that Shri Abdul Ghani Dar came to Lucknow after he had
6-L308Sul). CI 171
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] 2 S.C.R.
filed the petition and stayed in 24B Block in Darulshafa, very near 23 B Block in Darulshafa where the witnesses was staying. When pressed to remember the names of persons who were present when Shri Dinesh Singh addressed the meeting, he ventured the names of Shri Kamlapati Tripathi and Shri Jagdish Gandhi, and added that perhaps Shri Abdul Salim Shah was' also there. As we said before, Shri Dinesh Singh, R.W. ~. said that between the beginning of August or rather after his return from abroad on 18th July, and the 22nd of August, 1969, he . never went to Lucknow and he was in Delhi right upto the 2nd August. He said that his Secretary keeps th~ Jiary of his engagements and consults him before making any appointment unles~ he tells the .Secretary :thead that someone is going to see him. He said that whenever he goes out, whether on an official or a private tour, a tour programme is issued, and it is indicated in the tour programme whether the visit is official or private and it has the list of people to whom it is circulated. He further stated that. whenever he goes to Lucknow he stays with the Governor in the Raj Bhavan or in the State Guest House and he usually goes by train and sometimes by pl~tne. The diary kept by the Private Secretary was produced and .shown to the counsel for the petitioners, and the witness was -cross-examined in det:Iil about the diary and the way it is maintained. To the question : "I put it to you that you were in Lucknow on Sunday the lOth August", he an:;wered :" No. it would not be correct because I did not go out of Delhi." This date was apparently chosen by the learned counsel because in the diary the page of August 10, 1969, was blank. It was further suggested that the witness perhaps went by car towards the evening of 9th and reached Lucknow by the morning and then proceeded to Partapgarh for three ho).lrs and then back to Lucknow by 12 0' clock, and after spending six or seven hours in Lucknow he took the car and came to Delhi. To this suggestion he said that the distance between Delhi and Lucknow involved a very long journey. He added : "This is a hypothetical question in respect of time and I would have to be more sure about it." The witness further said that he though• that he attended a tea party at Mysore House given by the then c.. overnor of Mysore on August 10. We will presently show that uis version of his attending the party on August 10 is con oborated by other evidence. The respondent also produced a number of M.L.As. from U.P. to prove that Shri Dinesh Singh did not visit Lucknow between the 1st and the 16th. ·They are Shri Syed Ali Zaheer, · M.L.A., R.W. 9, Shri Genda Singh, M.L.A., R.W. 12, and Shri
S. K. SINGH v. SHRI V. V. GIRl (Sikri,/.)
. I
lf. N. Bahuguna, R.W. 28, who was the General Secret:u:y d the U.P. Congress Committee in 1969. Shri BahUQ"l! ~r\ :...iJ that Shri Dinesh did not visit Lucknow before the poH in August. He said that he knew it for certain that Shri Dinesh Singh did not visit Lucknow between the 1st and the 17th August because had he visited Lucknow he was sure to hear from Shri Dinesh Singh. · The witness added : "He is a kind friend who keeps me informed of his tour programme ev~o here. 1 always receive his tour programme and, therefore, if he had come to Lucknow I would have surely got his tour programme through dak or if it was a hurried programme a telephonic call that Mr. Dinesh Singh will be in town and in view of my plastered leg, if he were to come to Lucknow he would have certainly visited me as he did before." It was put to him : "If I say that Mr. Dinesh Singh did visit Lucknow between the 1st of August and the 14th of August, will it be correct?", he answered : "Totally jn~ correct'~
Shri Abid Ali, M.L.A., R.W. 33, deposed that he had not met Shri Dinesh Singh personally. He was asked : "Mr. Abdul Salim Shah has deposed before this Court as a witness and stated that Mr. Dinesh Singh came to Lucknow in August '69 and you were present alongwith him and others when Mr. Dinesh Singh and he had a conversation. Is it correct ?" He answered : "No it is quite wrong." He stuck to this position in cross-examination. Shri Rao Rafay Khan, M.L.A., R.W. 37, said in crossexamination that he could not say whether Shri Dinesh Singh went to Lucknow or not and he said that he had not yet met Shri Dinesh Singh. Further he did not hear of Shri Dinesh Singh go-· ing to Lucknow in the month of August. Shri Kamlapati Tripathi, R.W. 61, who was the President of the U.P. Congress Committee at the relevant time also stated that he was in Lucknow between the 1st of August and the 16th of August and that during this period, as far as he could recollect, Shri Dinesh Singh did not visit Lucknow. He further said:· "Usually when he comes to Lucknow, he gives me a ring that he js coming to Lucknow, and after reaching Lucknow he informs ~e of his arrival there." The evidence of Shri Mumtaz Mohd. Khan, R:"Y· 44, whom. he knew, regarding Shri Dinesh Singh's alleged VISit to Lucknow was put to him where he had said that Shri Kamlapati Tripathi was one of the persons present in the meeting; the witness replied : "No meeting was held. Neither I was present anywhere. This is a false statement.'' Shri I. K. Gujral, R.W. 40, attended Shri G. S. Pathak's party on Sunday the 1Oth August and produced a letter dated August 9, 1969, signed by Shri G. S. Pathak and addressed to Shri I. K. Gujral, inviting him to tea at Mysore Bhavan. Shri
,274
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] 2 S.C.R.
Gujaral said that Shri Dinesh Singh was present there alongwith some others, including Shri Om Mehta, Shri K. C. Pant, Dr. Ram Subhag Singh, Shri M. P. · Bhargava and a few others, and also Shri Kanwar Lal Gupta, M.P. Shri G. N. Mathur, R.W. 14, who has. br.en in the govern· · ment service for the last 30 years and was Private Secretary to .Shri Dinesh Singh said that he fixed up appointments and tour programmes and looked after coordination work in the Minister's office. He had been Private Secretary to Shri Dinesh Singh since 1962. He produced the diary of 1~69 and said that it had been kept by him and the name of the diary was "Rampart Index Diary by Thakar & Co." This particular diary was supplied by the Ministry of Commerce when he was there and when Shri Dinesh Singh was Minister of Commerce. ·He also produced the diaries of 1966, 1967 and 1968. It is not necessary to go into· his evidence in detail but it is quite clear from his evidence that he keeps the diaries in regular manner and it may be that sCime· time he may rub out or score out an engagement which has been cancelled, .otherwise most of the engagements are put in the diary. He then gave. the procedute for making a tour ,prog· ramme. He admitted that if some appointment is made by the Minister at his house and the Personal Assistant who attends the house does not inform him abOut it, it would not be found in the diary. He was asked: "If the Minister gees out on tour out of Delhi, is there any entry in your diary ?'' He replied : "Sometimes I do make, but I keep a tour register and it is used for tour . purposes." He was asked : "If he (the Minister) decides to go on tour, let us say, suddenly in the evening, will a tour prog~ ramme be issued?" He· replied : "If it is possible. We will contact the District Magistrate of the place he is visiting to in· form him that the Minister is arriving at that place, by telephone. · If the Minister is likely to stay there for a day, we issue a prog~ ramme, although it is afterwards." He was asked : "If he is coming back immediately, no programme will be issued?" He replied : "No. But it is my responsibility to inform the District Magistrate that he is coming." The witness produced a file containing the tour programmes between the 22nd of February, 1969, and the 22nd December, 1969. He said thafif the Minister changes his route while he is on the way, theti if he gets information he would issue a revised programme.· He pointed out that according to the schedule date of return the Minister was supposed to return on Saturday, the 19th July, but he returned in fact on the 18th July, a day earlier, and he issued a revised programme on the 17th of July. After looking up the tour programmes file he said thar Shri Dinesh Singh went to Lucknow only on the 22nd August and he then
A·
S. K, SINGH v. SHP.I V. V. GIRl (Sikri, /.)
27 S
went by plane and returned by plane and the tour programme was issued. In cross-examination the learned counsel for the petitione~ tried to show that the diary was not absolutely complete. In reply to the learned counsel the witness said : "So far as the prior engagements are concerned, if an· engagement hao; not been B fulfilled, either it would be rubbed off or scored out, but whatever engagements appear in the diary, tlley would indicate they have been fulfilled." He further admitted that he did not always score out the entry specially in the case of the national days of the Embassies, because he had to inform the Chief of Protocol that the Minister would not be able to attend the reception and c he has to explain the Minister's inability to attend to the Ambassador concerned. He added : "1)Ierefore, to remind myself, I do not cancel such type of entries from the diary." The witness further admitted that the tour programme consisted of loose sheets tagged 'together as these programmes were cyclostyled and they are not entered in any bound register, but he said that when D T.A. bill is prepared it would indicate the visits of the Minister. He denied that any second diary was maintained at the residence under the control of the Personal Assistant. He further said that even if the Minister wants to go and meet someone out of Delhi in his personal capacity,, as a matter of security if the security man is informed then he will accompany him and even if he goes to a picture the security man would sit outside the picture E house.
We are satisfied that nothing has been brought out in cross· examination which would dest'roy the evidence of the Private Secretary that most of tbe engagements of the Minister appear in the diary and whenever he goes out a tour programme is framed and issued. Shri Ram Nath Singh, constable, R.W. 36, who had been attached to Shri Dinesh Singh for security purposes as guard for the last four years was posted at Shri Dinesh Singh's residence. He said that there was no ·iimit to the time he served as a guard at a time but usually it was for six hours. He described the procedure by which the revolver. and the cartridges are transferred to the man who comes on duty. If the Minister goes out of Delhi for more than 24 hours the revolver and the cartridges are deposited in the security line. When the Minister is away the gunman still attend the house. He produced the Roznamcha which was maintained in the year 1969 and he said that he would make an 'entzy in the Roznamcha as to whether Shri Dinesh Singh was in Delhi or not. He showed the entries from the first of August to the 16th. He pointed out ¥arious entries. The first entry was dated 11th August. This entry would show that
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] 2 S.C.R.
the Minister spent the night of the lOth in·Delbi. Various sue~ entries were pointed out. He was asked to see if there was anything to show that the Minister was not in Delhi during this timet and he answered : "There is no entry showing that he was away from Delhi." The counsel brought out the entries on the 22nd of August to show that an entry was maae when Shri Dinesh Singh went to Lucknow. In the entry it is recorded inter alia that "at 7 a.m. the Minister is in the house". The entry at 3 0' clock · shows that "the Ministe,r started for Palam Airport; he would go by plane from there to Lucknow. Signed Ravi Bhan Singh." He stated that the gunman on duty went with the Minister upto Palam airport and stayed there till the plane took off and that was why he would know that he was going to Lucknow by plane. Nothing useful was ~rought out in cross-examination and we are satisfied tl;lat the Roznamcha was kept in the regular course of duty and the entries in it support Shri Dinesh Sin~h's version that he did not go to Lucknow on the lOth August, or . between the 1st August and the 16th August. If there had been any truth in the version given :by the petitioners it would not have been difficult for them to produce evidence either from the railway records or the records of the Indian Airlines to show that reservation was made on beha,lf of Shri Dinesh Singh and he travelled to Lucknow and back. Further in those days the local papers, if not the national papers, would at least have carried some news items about thr visit of Shri Dinesh Singh to Lucknow as it was a visit alleged to be for election purposes, and accord· ing to the petitioners he had met a number of persons openly. Further the evidence of the petitioners' witnesses does not fix the date of the visit. It was the blank page in the diary which led to the suggestions about that day in cross-examination.
·~r~;
We are satisfied from the evidence which we have extracted above that Shri Dinesh Singh did not visit Lucknow on the 1Oth of August or any other day thereabout and the case of the peti· tioners that Shri Dinesh Singh visited "Lucknow is not true. We have already mentioned that it was alleged in the petition that Shri V. V. Giri repeatedly stated at various places that "a man of character and integrity should have been selected" and he, in well-guarded language, was stating that Shri Reddy was not a man of character. Shri V. V. Giri denied these allegations and stated thaJ thro•Jghout his statements he ,adhered to the stand as a candidate for the office of the President. The petitioners pro~ duced 8 witnesses to substantiate this charge. It is common ground that Shri V. V. Giri visited Lucknow during his election · tour-:-Lp.cknow was his first halt-and addressed a meeting at
..
S, K. SINGH v. SHRI V. V. Gnu (Sikri, 1.)
Datulshafa. There is dispute as to ·what Shri Girl said at ·the meeting and as to whether he met M.L.As. individually· or in groups. The eight witneSses mentioned are : Sbri Bansidhar Pandey, P.W. 18, Shri Ram Singh, P.W. 19, Shri Jagdish Pershad, P.W. 20, Shri Rajendra Prasad, P.W. 21, Shri Basant Lal Sharma, P.W. 22, Shri Ram Pyare Panike, P.W. 37, and Shri AbdUl Salim Shah, P.W. 38. These witnes~ also deposed to Shri Dinesh Singh's visit to Lucknow and we have disbelieved their · version. In these circumstances we must view their evidence with extreme care and caution. It will be noticed that the witnesses have given different versions as to what Shri V. V. Giri said. Shri Bansidhar Pandey, P.W. 18, Shri Jagdish Pershad. P.W. 20, and Shri Basant Lal Sharma, P.W. 22, said that Shri Giri told them that they should vote for him in the Presidential election. P.W. 19, Shri Ram Singh's version was : "At that time he asked us that I am the' candidate of the Prime Minister and I must be voted for the Presidential· Election and she has supported him and therefore I must get the votes." Shri Ram Pyare Panike, P.W. 37, struck a different note. According to him Shri V. V. Girl said: ~'He told us that we should vote for him because he told us that he was also the Governor of other States and he was also Vice-President So he told us that a man lie him should be voted and we should vote in favour of Mr. Giri." He· further deposed that after the meeting he and three or four M.L.As. met Sh:ri Girl separately and he told them the same thing and in addition said : uu you want to progress India a man like me should be voted.'' · P.W. 38, Shri Abdul Salim Shah's version is that Shri V. v. Girl said that he had been the Vice President and also a Governor on behalf of the .Congress and ''I have spent the whole of · my life in the Congress in the companionship with Mahatama Gandhi. I deserve it more that I should be elected as the President of India.'' He added that at a personal meeting along with Shri Mumtaz Khan Shri Girl asked us whether we should vote for
him. The last witness on this point, Shri Mumtaz Khan, P.W. 44, gave the most detailed version. According to him Shri Giri "appealed to the members of the Assembly to vote for him. He said that he has -held very high offices. He was the Vice-President of India. H~ was also the Governor of U.P.; he has been doing social service all throughout his life and he was a very fit candidate for the Presidentship of India. Besides this, he said that the other candidates are not as good as he is. Besides, he also said this thing that the Congress had done a great blun-
S~PREME
der in nominating Mr.
COURT REPORTS
[197 1] 2 S.C.!<..
Sanjiva Reddy as its candidate.
He sai.d.
all t~eSG things." At a personal meeting with him and two or· thr~ friends, according to this witness, Shri Giri 14 appealed to uS"" ~hat you vo~e for me a~d,_besides this he said that Sanjiva Reddy
lS not a su1table candidate. There are so many spots on his· character_ and t~e <;ongr~ss High Command has done a great blunder m nommatmg h1m as its candidate. Besides this he said you see my services and all these things." '
It will be noticed that Shri Mumtaz Khan, P.W. 44, is the only witness who stated that reference was made to Shri Sunjiva Reo.Jy, and Shri Ram Singh, P.W. 19, is the only witness who men~ioned that a reference was made to the Prime Minister. Shri Daphatry, the learned counsel for the respondent, put ·,all .the above statements to Shri V. V. Giri. Shri Git:i categori~ cally denied meeting M.L.As. individually or in small groups. He said that aU his addresses were on the basis of the statement :that.he issued on July 13, 1969. He stated that at no stage he said that he was supported qy the Prime Minister either at Luck~ now or elsewhere. He fuJther deposed that he never referred . to . to the "other candidates" and whatever he stated was about his own qualifications. He denied having referred to Shri Sanjiva Redcly and also denied having ever said that Shri Sanjiva Ri!dQ.y was not a suitable candidate, and further, according to Shri Giri. it was absolutely Jalse that he said that "there are so many spots ()D his character and the Congress High Command has done a great blunder in nominating him as its candidate." He admitted that he said about himself, his qualifications, but there aho he was very guarded. On the respondent's side Shri Shivanand Nautiyal, M.L.A.• R.W. 26, supported Shri Giri's version of the meeting~ Shri Nautiyai aQ1nitted that he was an active supporter of Shri Giri. Ac~ordihg to him, Shri Giri said that he was an independent candidate and told everything about his work and not.hing more: in particular he did not, in the course of what he sa1d, refer to Shri Sanjiva Reddy, nor did Shri Giri say that he was Shrimnti Indira Gandhi's candidate. According to the witness, after the meeting Shri Giri left, accompanied by 17 or 18 people. and that no talk took place between them and Shri Giri. In crossexamination he stated that Shri Giri talked about his work and his visit to many countries and he explained everything but did not discuss political issues with them. Another witness, :Shri Ashraf Ali Khan, M.L.A., R.W. 27, gave an account ol Shri Giri's. talk to them. He said : "He talked about his candidature that he was seeking his election as .an independent candidate, because he considered that the post
\·•.
S. K, SINGH v. SHR.I V, V, GIRl (Sikri, ],)
of the President was of such a stature that a non-party man should seek election, and that he had always stood for the common man and worked for him throughout his labour move· ment, and he was seeking the vote of all persons who believed in the ideology of the common man." He further added that not a single word was said about Shri Sanjiva Reddy or that he was a candidate put up by Smt. Indra Gandhi. The witness admitted that he was elected on the Congress ticket; he only went to the meeting because it was held in the hostel compound. He said that other congressmen also atended the meeting because it was held in the hostel. The statement of Shri V. V. Giri, dated July 13, 1969, is ex· nibited as P. 66A. Our attention was invited by the learned counsel for the petitioners to the sentence in the statement : "I would only say that the candidate selected for the highest office should possess character, integrity, patriotism, experience, record of service and sacrifice. I feel in all modesty I could claim to have these attributes in some measure." We are unable to appreciate how this sentence makes it probable that Shri Girl would mention ·Shri Sanjiva Reddy and say something about his character at Lucknow. Another passage in the statement which was pointed out was : "The highest office of the land must be one that is above party politics. While the majority party has every right to choose its nominee, in a democracy care should be taken to see that the candidate so selected enjoys, as far as possible, the confidence of other groups also. I am deeply pained by the recent events that have tended to lower the dignity and moral authority of this august office." We are again unable to see how this makes it more probable that Shri Giri would attack the character of Shri Sanjiva Reddy at Lucknow. Further, on August 1, 1969, it was not definitely known whether Smt. Indira Gandhi would support the candidature of Shri ·Giri. There is no evidence of Shri Giri · having met the Prime Minister except on July 20, 1969. Shri Giri said that he had not spoken either to the Prime Minister or to any Minister before he announced his candidature. He further stated that he saw the: Prime Minister on July 20, 1969, when she came to see him at a ceremonial function when he was· leaving the Rashtra· pati Bhavan and she had come to say "good·bye" and he said "good-bye" to her. He categorically stated that they did not meet each other any time between the 20th July and the 16th August, 1969. We are of the view that Shri Giri's version is· preferable to the version given by the petitioners in so far as there is any con· flict, and therefore we hold that the allegations made in the p.eti· tion in this respect have not been substantiated.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] 2 S.C.R.
We may next deal with the allegations in paragraph 13(c)
(iii) of the petition to the effect that Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed
and Shri Yunus Saleem threatened Muslim voters that Shri Sanjiva Reddy was in fact a candidate of the Jan Sangh Party and that if he was elected the fate of the Muslim, community in India will be in danger and in constant threat of extinction. An instance was given of the conversation which took place betweenShri Yunus Saleem and Shri Abdul Ghani Dar, petitioner. The following particulars were supplied regarding the allegations in this sub-para : Date
Name of person threatened
Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed 11.!~.69 Sh. Abdul Ghani Dar, M.P. 11.8.69 Sh. Sher Khan, M.P. Chaudhary A. Mohammad 11.8.69 M.P. Shri Yunus Saleem 11.8.69 Sh. Abdul Ghani Dar, M.P. 11.8.69
Sh. Sher Khan M.P.
11.8.69
Chaudhary A. Mohammad M.P.
)
J
\
l
Place where threatened At his residence on telephone At his residence by telephone At his residence on telephone In the Central Hall of Parlia-ment
In the Central Hall of Parli· ment In the Central Hall of Parliament.
, \
I
The particulars stated above were stated to be true to information received by Shri Abdul Ghani Dar from Shri A. Mohammad, M.P., and Shri Sher Khan, M.P., and were believed to be true to his knowledge in so far as they related to himself. Shri Sher Khan, M.P., P.w.· 51, deposed that perhaps on the morning of August 11, 1969, Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed rang him up and told him on the telephone that all Muslirils together will vote for Shri Giri and that he should side with them. The witness replied that "I am a man of the Organisation and as an old Congressman I cannot move away from the official candidate and vote for another." Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed then told the witness : "He told me if I want to go along alone I could do so but they all together have unanimously decided to support Mr. Giri. You, may do whatever you like alone, but I may remind you of one thing that with the return of Mr. Sanjiva Reddy on election would be posing a danger for the Muslims and also for the Muslim Community, there is a compromise between him and the Jan Sangh. In future it is possible that he may obliterate the names of the Muslims."
I \
S. K.'SINGH v. SHRI V. V, GIRl (Sikri, J.)
The witness in reply said that he could not ag~ee. . The witness further stated that nothing more was said on the telephone and Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed said that they shall meet in the Central Hall. The witness further deposed that Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed met the witness at noon time -in the Central Hall on the same day, and is alleged to have said, inter alia, that "as the entire ruling party is supporting Mr. Giri1 you will not be put in future either on the Delegations, or on the Committees or in other Nominations." Then the witness deposed that Shri Yunus Saleem gave him a ring on the same day and repeated almost the same thing and further Shri Yunus Saleem met him in the Central Hall and said : "If I am differing from him, I might vote for Mr. Reddy. In that case that will not be good for me in future." In crossexamination he said that before he gave his evidence in Court he did not have any conversation with Shri Abdul Ghani Dar or anyone on his behalf about what the witness was going to depose to in this Court. He, however, said later that he had informed Shri Abdul Ghani Dar about the. conversation which the witness had with Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed on the telephone, and similarly he informed Shri Abdul Ghani Dar about the entire conversation which he had with Shri Yunus Saleem .. He denied the suggestion that Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed had no conversation with him in the Central Hall and he also denied the suggestion that Shri Yunus Saleem had no conversation with him on the telephone or in the Central Hall. He further said that he had told Shri Mishra, who is the leader of the Congress Party in the Rajya Sabha, about what Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed had told him. It will be notict!d that in the particulars Shri Sher Khan is not stated to have met Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed in the Cent· ral Hall and it is not stated that Shri Yunus Saleem had telephoned to him. Chaudhary A. Mohammad, M.P., P.W. 52, deposed that Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed telephoned him on the 10th or 11th of August and told him : "It has been decided to support Mr. Giri in the election and also that in this the Muslims stand to gain and if Mr. Sanjiva Reddy wins the interest of the· Muslim community will be in danger." The witness plainly told Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed that he was a soldier of the organisation and he could not go against the decision of the Congress. He then added that he was with Shri Sher Khan when Shri F akhruddin Ali Ahmed addressed Shri Sher Khan and was saying that "they had decided to vote for Mr.' Giri and therefore we should obey this final decision and also that this was in the interest of the Muslims." According to the witness Shri Fakhruddin
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1971] 2 s.c.R.
Ali Ahmed was threatening Shri Sher Khan by saying: "We distribute tickets and that he will not be given any ticket and that he was retiring." We may mention that Shri Sher Khan was due to retire from Rajya Sabha as Member on April 2, 1970.
Regarding Shri Yunus Saleem the witness deposed that he met Shti Yunus Saleem at a breakfast and talked about the B .election and Shri Yunus Salee~ said the same thing but he did .not ,talk to him on the telephone about the election. He further .stated that he had met Shri Yunus Saleem a number of times in the Rajya Sabha lobby· and in the Central Hall and they talked .about election and the reasons· that Shri Yunus Saleem gave for supporting the respondent were that "if Mr: Sanjiva Reddy is C -electe~ the .government will be upturned and that Mr. SanJlV& . Reddy w~s a very bad man. And there. were some pamphlets which he had distributed a copy of which was given to me also." He denied the suggestion that there was ilo talk between him and Shri Yunus Saleem of the nature deposed to by him. He admitted 1hat he belonged to the Congress party of which Shri Nijalingappa is the President.· In the particulars it is not stated that Chaudhary A. Mohammad ·overheard the conversation between Shri Sher Khan, M~P., and Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed. further, Shri Sher Khan does ilot say that Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed threatened and said "We distribute tickets and that he will ·not be given any ticket ~nd that he was also retiring."
·E
The- last witness on this point is Shri Abdul Ghani Dar, M.P. He deposed that Shri Fakhruddiit Ali Ahmed approached · him on the telephone on the 11th August in the evening and he t'old him .that "he was told by Mr. Yunus Saleem that in spite of baving been told by him (Shri Yunus Saleem) I had decided not . F to side with Mr. Giri and Shrimati Indira Gandhi." The witness further deposed that Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed said that "it meant that in spite of my being a Muslim.I was an enemy of the Muslims." He further said that. he told Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed that this was wrong. According to the witness, he addressed a letter !o Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed and also to all G the Muslim Members of Pariiamen( on this. The letter is Ext. P 68. He further deposed that Shri Yunus Saleem gave t!te pamphlets to him, took him aside and told him four things; the two relevant to this point being ( 1) that Shri Sanjiva Reddy was in collusion with the Jan Sangh, and (2) that if Sanjiva Reddy wins it will be a victory·for Jan S~ngh and the Muslims will stand H ~liminated. According to the witness he replied that "this is also ·wrong that by the return of Mr. Sanjiva Reddy there will be any . <langer for the Muslims."
s. K. SINGH v. SHRI V. \'. GIRl (Sikri, J.)
The letter, Ext. P-68, was alleged to have been written _by Shri Abdul Ghani Dar on August 13, 1969,, and the followt~g passage may be extracted : "Brothers it is said that Muslim League and Syed Baderuja are openly with communists. It is also said that Mr. F. A. Ahmed and Mr. Yunus Saleem are canvassing· with Muslim members to defy the mandate of fue congress president for congress Shri ·S. Sanjiva Reddy because Jan Sangh is on his side ...... Now· what right the communists or my brother Ahmed and Saleem have to canvass Muslims in the name of Islam and Muslims of India. It.is very sad that they are playing a very dangerously game." (emphasiz,...supplied.} This letter does not support Shri Abdul Ghani Dar that Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed and Shri Yunus Saleem canvassed with him because the sentence begins : "It is also said" In other words he seems to. have heard from some source that Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed and Shri· Yunus Saleem were canvassing the Muslim Members.. If his evidence is true we would have expected him to have stated in ths le.tter that Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed and Shri Yunus Saleem had approached him. Further what is attribu~ed to them is something milder though. objectionable.
We have already mentioned that it was brought out during the cross-examina,tion that. there was conflict Qetween the evidence that he had given regarding Shri Yunus· Saleem taking him aside and his statement in sub-para 13(b)(iv) of the petition in which it is stated : "As a single instance Shri Yunus Saleem approached Shri Abdul Ghani Dar, Member of the Parliament, F one of the petitioners herein and talked to him in· this behalf as stated .earlier. This was said in presence of a number of Members of Parliament." Shri Abdul Ghani Dar said: "I have even now hot denied that where I was taken no other Members were present." · This fnswer seemed to us surprising. Further it seems to us that Shri Abdul Ghani Dar had been G trying to collect and collate evidence right from the beg~g and his statement d~ not inspire confidence. He went to Lucknow arid his visit apparently resulted the story of the visit of Shri Dinesh Singh to Lucknow. The tape record of his conversation with Shri Jagat Narain, which took place after the election, also lends strong support to this view. It is true that Shri Jagat H · Narain tried to contact Shri Abdul Ghani Dar in order to dissuade him from filing the election petition. Shri Jagat Narain hid first spoken to Shri .Abdul Ghani Dar's wife and, according to $hri Abdul Ghani Dar, Shri Jagat Narain had created an imE
m
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
'
[1971] 2 S.C.R.
pression on his wife that there would be peril to Shri Abdul Ghani Dar in case he insisted on filing the petition. Shri Dar's wife did not give evidence. The tape record of the conversation between Shri Abdul Ghani Dar and Shri Jagat Narain clearly indicates that whereas Shri Jagat Narain was trying his best to make out that in his conversion with Shri Abdul Ghani's w1fe he had not held out any threat to the life of Shri Abdul Ghani Dar, the lattet was trying his best to get an admission to that effect from Shri Jagat Narain on to the tape, Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed denied that he telephoned Shri Sher Khan; M.P., as alleged by Shri Sher Khan in his evidence . .He further denied that he had any conversation with him in the Central Hall on the 11th of August, as alleged by him. He furthe~;' denied that he telephoned Chaudhary A. Mohammad regarding the election or any other matter. He maintained that he had no talk with him in his office or in the Central Hall of Parliament. He further said that he knew Chaudhary A. Mohammad but he did not visit him and they did not meet very often. He further characterised Shri Abdul Ghani Dar's evidence as absolutely incorrect that he approached him on the telephone. He added that he had never approached him regarding the election matters. He said that he did not receive any letter from Shri Abdul Ghani Dar. In cross-examination he stuck to the stateeJCamitiation-in-chie.f regarding Shri Sher ment he had given Khan, Chaudhary A. Mohammad and Shri Abdul Ghani Dar, and non-receipt of the letter, Ext. P 68. He denied that during the course of the ·presidential election any propaganda along the lines suggested by these three witnesses was carried on by him among the Muslim Members of Parliament.
in
. Here again there is direct confiict between the witnesses. We have already held that the particulars given by Shri Abdul Ghani Dar were given on pure guess work and the verification he appended to the particulars was not true. Even on this aspect of the case the evidence given in Court is different from what is stated in the particulars. The Learned counsel for the respondent read the statement of Shri Sher Khan to Shri Yunus Saleem and asked him whether the deposition of Shri Sher Khan was correct regarding the telephonic call or about the meeting. He replied : "No, it is not correct. I had a talk with him about the Presidential election but when he informed me that he is committed to Shri Nijaiingappa and that he was working for Shri S. Reddy, the question of any further talk did .not arise." The witness further stated that no communal issue was involved in the election and he did not approach Shri Sher Khan on communal considera-
~
I
S. K. SINGH v. SHR.l V. V. Gllll (Sikri, J.)
C
tions. The learned counsel then read out the statement of Chaudhary A. Mohammad to Shri Yunus Saleem and he replied : "I am sorry this is absolutely incorrect. It is correct that ~e came to me at breakfast more than once but no talk regarding Presidential election took place between him and me." He said that Chaudhary A. Mohammad was supponing the Congress Party of which Shri NijaJingappa is the President and he was working for Shri Sanjiva Reddy. Similarly the learned counsel read out the relevant eviden= of Shri Abdul Ghani Dar and to the question : "Is it correct?, Shri \'unus Saleem answered ·: "Except this that I had a talk with Mr. Abdul Ghani Dar about the Presidential election in the Central Hall every part of it is incorrect." Shri Yunus Saleem described the talk thus : "I wanted to know his views about the Presidential ·election because he claimed to be an independent member of the Parliament who did not belong to any political party. We discussed several points and he said that he had decided to support Mr. S. Reddy and he also mentioned that the late Prof. Humayun Kabir was also of the same view that Mr. S. Reddy should be supported. Therefore I said that he may consider that whether it would be advisable in the interest of democracy and socialism to support Mr. S. Reddy or Mr. Girl. He said that he would think over it and also discuss with Prof. Humayun Kabir. Except this no talk between myself and Mr. Abdul Ghani Dar took plaee about the Presidential election.''
'
In this connection reference may be made to the statement of some other Muslim Members of Parliament. Syed Ahmed Agha, M.P., R.W. 10, said that Shri Sher Khan was collecting signatures for Shri Sanjiva Reddy. He further stated that no meeting of the Muslim Members of Parliament was held at about that time in connection with the Presidential election. To the question : "Did any Minister of the Centnl Government contact him and told him what he should do about voting, otherwise tl;le Muslims would be wiped out?", he replied: "Certainly not." Sbri P. M. Syed, R.W. 13, said that he did not hear any cqmmunal cry raised by Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed in the context of the election nor was any communal cry raised by Shrl Yunus Saleem during those days.
It seems to us highly improbable that Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed and Shri Yunus Saleem would approach these three witnesses and canvass support for Shri Giri on the ground that the
SUPREME COURT B.EPOllTS
[19711 2 S.CJl.
fate of the Muslim community would be.in danger. . It "See.DlS to Mohammad was pte8¢t alongwith Shri Sher Khan in the Central Hall, Shri Fakhrudclin Ali Ahmed would not talk directly to bo~ of . them 9ccaaccording to them they both had already been contacted over .the telephone. If Shri Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed wanted to SUpPlement the talk he·already had on the telephone it would. have- been nat.1ral for him to have talked to both of them. Moreover, ,if it was true some mention of it would have been made in the parti· . culars. It seem's to us tha