Shivnath v. State of U.P. and 3 Others

Court
Allahabad High Court
Date of judgment
22 October 2026
Judge
Justice Chandra Kumar Rai
Case number
WRIC No. 41655 of 2026

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD WRIT - C No. - 41655 of 2026

Shivnath .....Petitioner(s) Versus

State Of U.P. And 3 Others .....Respondent(s) Counsel for Petitioner(s) Counsel for Respondent(s)

: Narendra Singh, Sandeep Kumar Chaturvedi : C.S.C., Sudhir Bharti, Ved Prakash Shukla

Court No. - 37

HON'BLE CHANDRA KUMAR RAI, J.

1. Heard learned counsel for the petitioner, Mr. Dinesh Kumar Tiwari, learned Standing Counsel for the State, Mr. Ved Prakash Shukla, learned counsel for the complainant and Mr. Sudhir Bharti, learned counsel for the Gaon Sabha. 2. Brief facts of the case are that the order for eviction and damages has been passed in the proceeding under Section 67 of U.P. Revenue Code, 2006 against the petitioner by Tahsildar vide order dated 15.12.2022. Against the order of Tahsildar dated 15.12.2022, appeal under Section 67 (5) of U.P. Revenue Code, 2006 filed on behalf of petitioner has been dismissed by Additional District Magistrate vide order dated 21.11.2024. Against the order dated 21.11.2024 recall application has been filed on behalf of petitioner which was allowed vide order dated 18.2.2026 and appeal was restored to its original number. Appellate Court/ Additional District Magistrate again heard the appeal and dismissed the same vide order dated 11.6.2026. Hence, this writ petition on behalf of petitioner for the following reliefs: "issue a writ, order or direction in the nature of certiorari quashing the impugned order dated 11-06-2026 passed by respondent no. 2 in Appeal no. RST/11/2023, bearing its Computerized Case no.D202305440000011 (Shivnath Vs. Gaon Sabha), under section 67(5) of U.P. Revenue Code-2006 and order dated 15-12-2022 passed by respondent no. 3 in Case no. 347/2022, bearing its Computerized Case no. T202205440500347 (Gaon Sabha Vs. Shivnath, under section 167 of U.P. Revenue

Code-2006 (which are annexure no. 10 and 5 respectively to the writ petition)."

3. Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the order for eviction and damages has been passed against the petitioner in illegal and arbitrary manner without considering the fact that revision filed on behalf of petitioner before the Consolidation Court is pending for consideration. He further submitted that in the similar circumstance, the appeal filed by other persons have been allowed and matter has been remitted back before Tahsildar vide appellate order dated 11.7.2025, as such, petitioner's case should also be examined afresh. He further submitted that reason assigned in the appellate order dated 11.7.2025 will be applicable in the petitioner's case also. He further submitted that there is no partition of plot no.1376, as such, the order for eviction and damages cannot be sustained in the eye of law. He further submitted that the impugned order should be set aside and proceeding against the petitioner should be dropped. 4. On the other hand, learned Standing Counsel for the State, learned counsel for the Gaon Sabha and learned counsel for the complainant submitted that no interference is required in this matter in view of the entry of the plot in question. They further submitted that no right will accrue in favour of petitioner in view of the entry of the plot in question. They further submitted that proper demarcation was made by the authorities and it has been found that the petitioner is in possession of plot no.1376, as such, no interference is required in this matter. They further submitted that mere filing of revision before the Consolidation Court will not stop the authority, under Section 67 of U.P. Revenue Code, 2006 to decide the matter on the basis of entry of the plot in question. He further submitted that the remand order passed in appeal at the instance of other parties will not entitle the petitioner that his claim should also be considered afresh rather he should establish his case before the Court. They further submitted that the writ petition filed by petitioner should be dismissed. 5. I have considered the argument advanced by learned counsel for the parties and perused the records. 6. There is no dispute about the fact that the order for eviction and

damages has been passed against the petitioner in the proceeding under Section 67 of U.P. Revenue Code, 2006 which has been maintained in appeal. 7. In order to appreciate the controversy involved in the matter, perusal of the remand order passed in Case No.12 of 2023, under Section 67 (5) of U.P. Revenue Code, 2006 will be relevant, which is as under:यालय : अपर

"

ला का , (

क)

म ल : गोरखपुर, जनपद: कुशीनगर, तहसील: ख वाद सं

: -12/2023 कं ट कृत वाद सं

:-D202305440000012

ओम काश बनाम गावसभा अंत त धारा:- 67(5), अ उपरो

के प

उभय प

के

प वली तथा उस संल गया।

वेचनोपरा

सम

नअ व सा

रा

त

त बहस भी दा ल

उ

त

का सं न न लेकर ह

यालय को आप क

रा उ

त

सं

1377क के बावत चकबंदी

यालय

आप

व सा

उ

एवं

त बहस

य त

यालय के सम अपीलक अवर

यालय

वेचना करके

1377क व 1377ख का भू वाद

र

अलग अलग

वेचना होने यो

ये

सा

, और ण

या

यालय के सम अपीलक

जो अवर

यालय

आप क

व

त बहस

के आप

गत आदेश पा त स त आदेश पा त

या गया है। जब

है

अवर

या जाना चा ये था। यह

भा त नही है। इसके अ

गत भूख

यालय के सम

अपीलक

रा

त

यालय

गत आदेश पा त

या

ना ही अवर

है। ऐसी

यालय

वत अवलोकन एवं प

रा आप क

चाराधीन है। इस कार अवर

तत

स त नही होने के कारण या जाना

अवर

व सा

सं

संल

नांक 15.12.2022 पा त होने के के पू अवर

लेखपाल के पो को आधार बनाकर

खनीय है

कार

भूख

नांक 15.12.2022 का

या गया है पर

भी उ

गया है जो

गत आदेश

या गया है, इसके अ

दा ल

के

व

गत आदेश

व सा

सं ता - 2006

गण के ता क बहस को सुना तथा प वली

त है

रा आप

यम : उ र देश राज

त अपील

रा प

बल होने के कारण अपील

आव क तीत होता है। आदेश

उपरो

वेचना के आधार पर अपीलक

नांक 15.12.2022 यालय

र

प वली इस

रा

त अपील

या जाता है। य कोई श के साथ

त

नांक 02.01.2023

कार करते ए अवर

यालय का आदेश

गन आदेश हो तो उसे समा

या जाता है। आदेश

के साथ अवर

या जाता है

को सुनवाई का अवसर दान करते ये गुण-दोष के आधार पर

यि

न्या

री

धि

जि

ड्डा री

प्यू

ख्या

में

र्ता

र्ता

कि

न्या क्ष त्ति खि

ण्ड स्तु कि

प्र

श्नं

क्त

प्र

द्वा रि

र्ता

रि

हि

कि

लि

में

क्ष

री

क्ष्यों

हि

स्त

में धि

न्या

र्व

न्या

र्ता

त्ति

त्ति

र्ता

कि

रि

कि

रि

ति क्ष श्न

प्र

द्वा

प्त

र्या

में

न्या

न्या

जि

म्म

श्न धिं स्तु

प्र

में

ति

बि

प्र

वि

वि

प्र

द्वा

क्ष

रि

वि

त्रा

स्व

प्र

त्त

नि धि

द्वा

वि

न्या

दि

क्षों

में

ति

प्र न्या

में

हु

स्वी

की

कि

र्देशों

नि

ल्लि

में

खि क्ष

रि

रें

प्त न्ति

र्ण म्म र्य

खि

क्षों

धि

कि स्थि दि

नि

कि धि

वि श्य

में

क्ष्य

प्रे

र्कि न्या

न्या

न्तु र्ट वि त्र

चि

की

रि क्ष्यों वि

वि

की

थ्यों

ग्य

स्त स्तु

प्र

स्थ

दि षि

कि त्रा

की

रि

क्ता

दि

श्न

प्र

क्त

रि

ति

दि

क्ष्यों

स्त

में

त्रा

की

ग्न

श्न

प्र

कि

दि

न्त

वि

वि खि

क्ष्य

त्ति

द्वा

कि

कि

खि

खि

स्तृ

वि

द्वा

लि

ज्ञा

ओं

न्दु

वि

खि

ल्लि

ल्का

ओं

न्दु

वि

खि

ल्लि

र्ता

त्ति

न्या

द्वा

ख्या

ण्ड

कि

ल्ले ख्या

न्या

खि

ल्लि

में

खि

क्ष्य

त्ति

लि

नि

धि

वि

म्म

श्य

में

हि

न्या

कि

स्वी

प्र द्वा

र्ता

क्त

वि

स्त

नि

दि

कि

प्रे

ति

प्र

र्दे

नि

की

त्रा

प्र

हु न्या

स्थि

न्या

में

क्त

र्ग

प्र

ख्या

ण्ड

न्या

24.07.2025 को उप

त हो। इस

यालय

य के अ

म पैरा

उ

स त आदेश पा त क । प

प वली वाद आव क का वाही दा ल दफतर हो।

त अवर

के आलोक

प

यालय

नांक

नॉक : ( म कुमार राय) अपर

ला का (

क) कुशीनगर।"

8. Perusal of the appellate order passed in Case No.12 of 2023 as quoted above demonstrates that the appeal filed by certain person in respect to the same plot in dispute has been allowed and matter has been remitted back before the Tahsildar to decide the proceeding afresh considering the pendency of the consolidation case in respect to the plot in question. 9. Considering the aforementioned facts and circumstances of the case, the instant matter also requires fresh consideration by Tahsildar along with the cases which have already been remanded back by the appellate Court vide order dated 11.7.2025. 10. Considering the entire facts and circumstances of the case, impugned order dated 11.6.2026 passed by respondent no.2 and order dated 15.12.2022 passed by respondent no.3 are liable to be set aside and the same are hereby set aside. 11. The writ petition stands allowed. The matter is remitted back before respondent no.3 to register the proceeding against the petitioner on its original number and decide the same afresh after affording proper opportunity of hearing to the parties along with other cases, which has been remanded back in appeal by appellate Court, expeditiously preferably within a period of three months from the date of production of certified copy of this order.

(Chandra Kumar Rai,J.)

October 23, 2026

यि

न्या

री

धि

जि

प्रे

दि

Rameez

Digitally signed by :RAMEEZ AHMED High Court of Judicature at Allahabad

Related judgments

More Allahabad High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.