Shri Keweputso Kapfo and 106 Ors v. DR. J. Alam, Ias and 11 Ors

Court
Gauhati High Court
Date of judgment
14 October 2026
Judge
Justice Mr Nchumbemo Mozhui
Case number
I.A.(Civil) No. 274 of 2026
Result
Disposed Of

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

Page No.# 1/20 GAHC020008692026

THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) KOHIMA BENCH Case No. : I.A.(Civil)/274/2026 SHRI KEWEPUTSO KAPFO AND 106 ORS KHALASI (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER, PWD (R AND B), PFUTSERO DIVISION, NAGALAND

VERSUS DR. J. ALAM, IAS AND 11 ORS CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF NAGALAND, NAGALAND KOHIMA

Advocate for the Petitioner

: SUPONGWATI WALLING,

Advocate for the Respondent : ,

Linked Case : COP(C)/2/2025 SHRI KEWEPUTSO KAPFO AND 106 ORS KHALASI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD ( R AND B) WOKHA DIVISION WOKHA

Page No.# 2/20 NAGALAND 2: SHRI. NAHNGNAM KONYAK KHALASI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD - R AND B MON DIVISION MON - NAGALAND 3: SMTI. THUNGSALI KHALASI WORK-CHARGED PWD - R AND B BAGHTY DIVISION WOKHA - NAGALAND 4: SMTI. LIYINGBENI KHALASI WORK-CHARGED PWD - R AND B BAGHTY DIVISION WOKHA - NAGALAND 5: SMTI. IMTIRENLA PHOM TYPIST WORK-CHARGED PWD H TUENSANG - NAGALAND 6: SHRI. LAXMI JUGALI WORK-CHARGED PWD H CENTRAL DIVISION KOHIMA - NAGALAND 7: SHRI. JABESWAR KHELIKE SWEEPER (WORK-CHARGED) PWD (H) CENTRAL DIVISION KOHIMA - NAGALAND 8: SHRI. MAIKHAL EKHA SWEEPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE

Page No.# 3/20 PWD (H) CENTRAL DIVISION KOHIMA - NAGALAND 9: SHRI. M. CHAGO KONYAK S.A WORK-CHARGED PWD (H) DIVISION-I KOHIMA MON SUB-DIVISION 10: SHRI. K. HOKHETO SEMA KHALASI WORK-CHARGED PWD H DIMAPUR NAGALAND 11: SHRI. CHUBANUNGSANG H/MAN (WORK-CHARGED) PWD (H) DIMAPUR NAGALAND 12: SMTI. K MANNGOI PHOM JUGALI WORK-CHARGED NPWD - R AND B TUENSANG NAGALAND 13: SHRI. THANGPONG KHIAM JUGALI WORK-CHARGED NPWD - R AND B TUENSANG NAGALAND 14: SHRI. VANPHYO S.A WORK-CHARGED NPWD - R AND B NAGALAND KOHIMA 15: SMTI. RONGSENKUMLA JAMIR HELPER WORK-CHARGED NPWD - R AND B NAGALAND KOHIMA

Page No.# 4/20

16: SMTI. NZANO LOTHA TYPIST WORK-CHARGED NPWD - (R AND B) NAGALAND KOHIMA 17: SHRI. ZHEKEQHE M/HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE PWD - (R AND B) ZUNHEBOTO NAGALAND 18: SHRI. YEZUKHU SEMA KHALASI WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B ZUNHEBOTO NAGALAND 19: SHRI. PUCHOLE SWEEPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B SOUTH DIVISION NAGALAND KOHIMA 20: SHRI. VIHOTO SEMA CHOWKIDAR WORK-CHARGED PWD - R AND B ATOIZU DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO NAGALAND 21: SHRI. AJEN HASNU JUGALI WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B DIMAPUR - NAGALAND 22: SHRI. LUTOZU SEMA C/HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 23: SHRI. VIHOSHE C/HELPER WORK CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER

Page No.# 5/20 PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 24: SHRI. AKATO CHOWKIDAR WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO NAGALAND 25: SHRI. GHUJUHE CHOWKIDAR WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 26: SHRI. ALLU HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 27: SHRI. ALAPU M/HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 28: SHRI. IHANIZU M/HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 29: SHRI. KAMTO M/HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 30: SHRI. KAMU M/HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND

Page No.# 6/20

31: SHRI. TUSHOLI PEON WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 32: SHRI. YEXULI M/HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 33: SHRI. KEALI PEON WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 34: SHRI. VIHELI SWEEPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 35: SHRI. KIYELHO SUMI P/HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 36: SHRI. KIVITO M/HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 37: SHRI. KIYEKHU CHISHOLI M/HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 38: SHRI. KIKHEHO C/HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND

Page No.# 7/20

39: SHRI. LUZHE CHOWKIDAR WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 40: SHRI. KHULUPU HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 41: SHRI. CHIHATO M/HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 42: SHRI. KHULU P/HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 43: SHRI. AKHALU P/HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 44: SHRI. NIHOZHE M/HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 45: SHRI. NITOVI P/HELPER WORK-CHARGED PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 46: SHRI. HEMILI SWEEPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B

Page No.# 8/20 PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 47: SHRI. LOVITO HELPER WORK-CHARGED OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 48: SHRI. TULAPU HELPER WORK-CHARGED PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 49: SHRI. VIHOTO PAINTER/HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE PWD - R AND B PUGHOBOTO DIVISION ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 50: SHRI. B. METJEI PHOM KHALASI (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD(R AND B) LONGLENG - NAGALAND 51: SHRI. LEISUNG PHOM KHALASI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD (R AND B) LONGLENG - NAGALAND 52: SHRI. LAMTAN PHOM S.A (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD (R AND B) LONGLENG - NAGALAND 53: SHRI. NEHETO SEMA KHALASI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(R AND B) LONGLENG - NAGALAND 54: SMTI. I. YASHITULA JUGALI (WORK-CHARGED)

Page No.# 9/20 PWD(R AND B) F.R. TULI DIVISION MOKOCHUNG - NAGALAND 55: SHRI. L. HOPONG KHIAMUNGAN S.A (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(R AND B) NOKLAK - NAGALAND 56: SMTI. SAZONU KIKHI M/HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE PWD(R AND B) DIVISION-II NAGALAND KOHIMA 57: SMTI. C.SANO JUGALI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(R AND B) PHEK - NAGALAND 58: SHRI. KEKHROWLO-U JUGALI (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD(R AND B) PHEK- NAGALAND 59: SHRI. KEDUWEPRE KHUPFU S.A (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(R AND B) PFUTSERO - NAGALAND 60: SHRI. ASATONG JUGALI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(R AND B) TSEMINYU - NAGALAND 61: SHRI. W. JOHN LOTHA S.A (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD(R AND B) BAGHTY DIVISION WOKHA - NAGALAND 62: SHRI. RENTHUNGO LOTHA

Page No.# 10/20 S..A (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(R AND B) BAGHTY DIVISION WOKHA - NAGALAND 63: SHRI. THSAMUKHIBA SANGTAM MASON/HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(R AND B) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 64: SHRI. HONTUN KONYAK S.A (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(R AND B) MON - NAGALAND 65: SHRI. ABO KONYAK S.A (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD(R AND B) MON - NAGALAND 66: SHRI. HONGLEM KONYAK PAINTER (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) DIVISION-I KOHIMA - NAGALAND 67: SHRI. KICHIMONG CARPENTER HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD(H) DIVISION-I KOHIMA - NAGALAND 68: SHRI. LHIWEZO FITTER /HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE PWD(H) DIVISION-I KOHIMA - NAGALAND 69: SHRI. MEYA AO S.A (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H)

Page No.# 11/20 DIVISION-I KOHIMA - NAGALAND 70: SHRI. ZAKHURE SWEEPER (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) DIVISION-I KOHIMA - NAGALAND 71: SHRI. CHUTSUTHO KAJIRE KHALASI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) DIVISION-I KOHIMA - NAGALAND 72: SHRI. A. NAGATO SEMA JUGALI (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD(H) YOUTH RESOURCE NAGALAND KOHIMA 73: SHRI. HETO ZHIMO KHALASI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) DIMAPUR DIVISION 74: SMTI. ARENLA SANGTAM KHALASI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) DIMAPUR - NAGALAND 75: SHRI. YANCHANG CHANG MALI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 76: SHRI. MEZUNG MALI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND

Page No.# 12/20 77: SHRI. K. AKHAM YIMCHUNGER MASON/HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 78: SMTI. V. TOKALI KHALASI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 79: SHRI. Y. LATO YIMCHUNGER S.A (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 80: SHRI. CHUMOSE SANGTAM MASON /HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 81: SHRI. T. BUMEING KHIAM PAINTER/HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 82: SHRI. Y. SHOMONG TIKIR PAINTER/HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 83: SHRI. KANGKHAO KHIAM FITTER /HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 84: SHRI. BESU CHANG MASON (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 85: SHRI. T. CHANG CARPENTER (WORK-CHARGED)

Page No.# 13/20 PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 86: SHRI. THSAPISE SANGTAM TRACER (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 87: SHRI. NGUPNYEI PHOM JUGALI (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 88: SHRI. THSALONGSE SANGTAM FITTER /HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 89: SMTI. NEOJILA YIMCHUNGER SWEEPER (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 90: SMTI. YOUNGPHULA SWEEPER (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 91: SHRI. Y. LATO YIMCHUNGER S.A (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 92: SHRI. KANGKHAO KHIAM FITTER/HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 93: SHRI. ASOKIUNG CHOWKIDAR (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE

Page No.# 14/20 PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 94: SHRI. PUKHATO SEMA JUGALI (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD(H) NCCD KOHIMA DIVISION KOHIMA - NAGALAND 95: SMTI. NOSWU KHALASI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) CENTRAL DIVISION KOHIMA - NAGALAND 96: SHRI. ALTAF HUSSAIN ELECTRICIAN/HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD(H) CENTRAL DIVISION KOHIMA NAGALAND 97: SHRI. CH. PUNI JUGALI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) CENTRAL DIVISION KOHIMA - NAGALAND 98: SHRI. VIMEDOLE ZUTSO JUGALI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) CENTRAL DIVISION KOHIMA - NAGALAND 99: SHRI. DUKHIRAM SHAHAY SCAVANGER (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE PWD(H) CENTRAL DIVISION KOHIMA - NAGALAND 100: SHRI. RAVI KUMAR CARPENTER HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER

Page No.# 15/20 PWD(H) CENTRAL DIVISION KOHIMA - NAGALAND 101: SHRI. DZUVICHU PAINTER HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) OFFICE OF THE EXECUTIVE PWD(H) CENTRAL DIVISION KOHIMA - NAGALAND 102: SHRI. UTTAM CHETRI KHALASI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) CENTRAL DIVISION KOHIMA - NAGALAND 103: SMTI. BITOLI MASON (WORK-CHARGED) PWD ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 104: SMTI. Y. KIUKHANGLA PLUMBER (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 105: SHRI. KISHEHO SEMA PAINTER (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) ZUNHEBOTO - NAGALAND 106: SHRI. THEVEKIU YIM JUGALI (WORK-CHARGED) PWD(H) TUENSANG - NAGALAND 107: SHRI. K. THSALISE SANGTAM MASON HELPER (WORK-CHARGED) PWD TUENSANG - NAGALAND

Page No.# 16/20 VERSUS DR. J. ALAM IAS AND 11 ORS CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF NAGALAND NAGALAND KOHIMA 2:SHRI R. RAMAKRISHNAN IAS COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF NAGALAND P AND AR DEPARTMENT NAGALAND KOHIMA 3:SHRI KESONYU YHOME IAS COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF NAGALAND WORKS AND HOUSING DEPARTMENT NAGALAND KOHIMA. 4:ER. P.I. IMNA AO ENGINEER-IN-CHIEF NPWD NAGALAND KOHIMA 5:ER. KEVIDE NAKHRO CHIEF ENGINEER PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT (R AND B) NAGALAND KOHIMA. 6:ER. I. TIAMEREN CHIEF ENGINEER PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT(H) NAGALAND KOHIMA. 7:ER. PUKRONEIZO KERA

Page No.# 17/20 CHIEF ENGINEER PUBLIC WORKS DEPARTMENT(NH) NAGALAND KOHIMA 8:SHRI SENTIYANGER IAS CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF NAGALAND NAGALAND KOHIMA 9:SHRI MOHAMMED ALISHIHAB IAS COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVT. OF NAGALAND DEPTR. OF P AND AR NAGALAND KOHIMA 10:ER. SWARAI MERU CHIEF ENGINEER PWD (R AND B) NAGALAND KOHIMA 11:ER. HOZHEZO SHIKHU CHIEF ENGINEER PWD (H) NAGALAND KOHIMA 12:ER. M.Z. AKHO CHIEF ENGINEER PWD (NH) NAGALAND KOHIMA -----------Advocate for : SUPONGWATI WALLING Advocate for : appearing for DR. J. ALAM IAS AND 11 ORS

BEFORE HONBLE MR JUSTICE NCHUMBEMO MOZHUI

ORDER 15.10.2026

Ms. Vizoneinuo, learned counsel for the Applicants present.

Page No.# 18/20

2.

By filing the instant application, the Applicant has sought for

impleadment of the new incumbent, namely, (a) Er. Swarai Meru, Engineer-in-Chief, NPWD, Kohima, Nagaland, (b) Shri Abhijit Sinha, IAS, Commissioner and Secretary to the Government of Nagaland, Department of Personnel and Administrative Reforms, Kohima, Nagaland, (c) Er. H. Vihokhe Sema, Chief Engineer, Public Works Department (R&B), Kohima, Nagaland, (d) Er. M. Hotokhu Achumi, Chief Engineer, Public Works Department(H), Kohima, Nagaland, and (e) Er. Neilabeizo Angami, Chief Engineer, Public Works Department(NH), Kohima, Nagaland, as Respondent Nos. 13, 14, 15, 16 and 17 on the ground that the previous incumbents have retired, namely:(a) Er. P.I. Imna Ao (Respondent No. 4), Engineer-in-Chief, NPWD, Kohima, Nagaland, (b) Shri Mohammad Ali Shihab, IAS (Respondent No. 9), Commissioner and Secretary to the Government of Nagaland, Department of Personnel and Administrative Reforms,

Page No.# 19/20

Kohima, Nagaland, (c) Er. Swarai Meru (Respondent No. 10), Chief Engineer, Public Works Department (R&B), Kohima, Nagaland, (d) Er. Hozhezo Shikhu (Respondent No. 11), Chief Engineer, Public Works Department(H), Kohima, Nagaland, and (e) Er. M.Z. Akho (Respondent No. 12), Chief Engineer, Public Works Department(NH), Kohima, Nagaland. 3. In view of the retirement/transfer of the Respondent Nos. 4, 9, 10, 11 and 12 it has become necessary to implead the new incumbents, namely:(a) Er. Swarai Meru, Engineer-in-Chief, NPWD, Kohima, Nagaland, (b) Shri Abhijit Sinha, IAS, Commissioner and Secretary to the Government of Nagaland, Department of Personnel and Administrative Reforms, Kohima, Nagaland, (c) Er. H. Vihokhe Sema, Chief Engineer, Public Works Department (R&B), Kohima, Nagaland, (d) Er. M. Hotokhu Achumi, Chief Engineer, Public Works Department(H), Kohima, Nagaland, and

Page No.# 20/20

(e) Er. Neilabeizo Angami, Chief Engineer, Public Works Department(NH), Kohima, Nagaland. 4. The prayer is allowed. 5. The Applicants shall take appropriate steps for amendment of the Causetitle. 6. The I.A. stands disposed of.

JUDGE

Comparing Assistant

Related judgments

More Gauhati High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.