Smit Yogeshbhai Patel v. State of Gujarat

Court
High Court of Gujarat
Date of judgment
26 October 2026
Bench
Justice Bhargav D. Karia, Justice Hemant M. Prachchhak
Case number
SCR.A No. 15387 of 2026
Result
35-ANY OTHER MODE @ ADM.STAGE

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

I NTHEHI GHCOURTOFGUJARATATAHMEDABAD SPECI ALCRI MI NALAPPLI CATI ON( HABEASCORPUS)NO.15387of ==========================================================

SMI TYOGESHBHAIPATEL Ver sus STATEOFGUJ ARAT&ORS. ==========================================================

Appear ance: ANKI TM MODI 7418)f ort heAppl cant s)No.1 MRKI SHANRCHAKWAWALA( 9846)f ort heAppl cant s)No.1 MSMONALIBHATT,APPf ort heRespondent s)No.1 ==========================================================

CORAM:HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE BHARGAV D. KARIA and HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE HEMANT M. PRACHCHHAK Dat e:26/ ORALORDER PER:HONOURABLEMR.JUSTI CEBHARGAVD.KARI A)

1.Hear dl ned advocat e Mr .Anki tModiwi hl ned advocat e Mr .Ki shan Chakwawal af or t he pe nedAddi onalPubl cPr osecut orMs.Monal or t he r espondent St e and l ned advocat e Mr Devansh Kakkad f or l ned advocat e Mr . Ani k Ti mbal af ororr pondentno. 8–Cor

2.I ssuenot ce r ur nabl ef hwi h.Lear ned Addi onal Publ cPr osecut orMs.Monal twai vesser vi ceof not ceon be hal foft her espondentSt eand l ned advocat eMr .Devansh Kakkadwai vesser vi ceofnot ce onbehal fofr pondentno. 8–Cor

3. Re spondent St e has pr oduced r espondent no.

cor pus bef e us.Pe - Smi tYogeshbhaiPat el espondentno. 7-RahulDangar ,mot heroft pusSat ben Dangar and si st er of Cor pusJayshr eeben Dangar who i s ser vi ng i n Bhuj“ A” Di vi si on pol ce st on ar e al so pr esent i n per son i he chamber Respondentno. 6 –Devayat bhaiDangar -f heroft pus i snotpr esent

4.Byt spe on underAr cl e226 oft heConst ut on ofI ndi a,t onerwhoi shusband ofr espondent no. 8-Bhumi kahasmadef owi ngpr ayer s: “ b.Toi ssueaWr tofHabeasCor pusorany her appr opr e wr ,or der ,or di ect on commandi ngRespondentNos.2,3,4,and5

o pr oduce t he cor pus, name y Smt Bhumi ka,bef et sHon' bl eCour tf om t egal confinement of Respondent Nos. 6 and7; c.Tor ecor dt hevol unt ar yand i ndependent st ementoft hecor pus,Smt .Bhumi ka,i na secur e and f ess envi onment ,and se her at l ber yf hwi ht o enabl e her t esi deandcohabi twi ht hePe onerasper herown i ndependentwi land choi ceandt di ect Respondent Nos.1 t o5t o pr ovi de mmedi e,adequat e,and r ound-t hecl ock pol ce pr ect on t o t he Pe ,t cor pus ( Smt . Bhumi ka) , and t hei rf ami y member s agai nstany t hr eat s,vi ence,or honour ed offenses f om Respondent Nos.6and7andt hei rassoci es; ”

5.Wehavede ber edwi ht hecor puswhoi swi eoft pe Smi tPat land i s aged about23 year s.We have al so i act ed wi h pe oner Smi t Pat espondent no . 7RahulDanger who i s br her of pus,si st erofCor pusJayshr eeben DangarandMs. Sat benDangarwhoi smot heroft

6.I ti sal eged i on t hatCor puswhoi swi eof pe onerwas i egal y de ai ned by r espondentnos. and7f herandbr heroft hecor pusr espect ve y

7.On de ber on wi ht pus,shehasst ed t hat shewoul dl ket ogowi hherhusbandSmi tPat

8.I nvi ew oft hewi ngnessoft pusBhumi kat ogo wi hherhusbandpe Smi tPat el ,i hei est ofj ust ce,t hef owi ngor deri spassed:

1) Cor pusi sper mi edt ogoal ongwi ht Smi tPat lt ohermat moni alhouse.

2) Wedi ectSol a Hi gh Cour tPol cest on t oescor pust ohermat moni alhome.

3) Wedi ectr espondentno. 4-t heSuper endentof Pol c( SP) ,Anand t o seet hatr espondentnos. 6 and 7 and mor e par cul ar y , wi e of r pondent no. 6 – Sat benDangarorheraccompl cedoesnotaffectsaf y and secur y oft he Cor pus and r espondentno. 4t ur her di ect r espondent no. 2- t he Pol ce I ns pect

KhambhatCi yPol cest ont opr ovi desecur yt pusagai nstt het hr eatexpr essed be eust eoft

9.Wedi s posedoft spe oni nabovet ms.

Copy of t s or der may be made avai abl et nedAPPMs.Monal

BHARGAVD.KARI A,J)

HEMANTM.PRACHCHHAK, J) RAGHUNATHRNAI R

Original copy of this order has been signed by the Hon'ble Judges. Digitally signed by: RAGHUNATH RAVINDRANATHAN NAIR(HC00196), PRINCIPAL PRIVATE SECRETARY, at High Court of Gujarat on 26/10/2026 14:35:36

Related judgments

More Gujarat High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.