Smt. A. Kamala Devi v. The State of Telangana
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 5 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Pulla Karthik
- Case number
- WP No. 9445 of 2022
- Result
- ALLOWED NO COSTS
- Acts & sections
- Section 151 CPC, Article 226 Constitution
- Subject
- Service
Full judgment
+1
[ 321e I HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction) FRIDAY, THE THIRD DAY OF IMAY TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FOUR PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE T.MADHAVI DEVI WRIT PETITION NO: 9445 OF 2022
Between: Smt. A. Kamala Devi, W/o. Late A.V. Ranga Rao, Aged. 75 years, C/o. [Vl. Jagannath Rao, Plot No.l-15-41, FIat No. G4, Pradeeptha Residency, Venkatraopet Street No. 1 , Venkatapuram,,,rAlwal, Secunderabad, Medchel Dist. 500015
...PETITIONER AND
1. The State of Telangana, Represented by its Principal Secretary, Higher Education Department, Telangana Secretariat, Hyderabad.
2. The Commissioner, Department of Technital Education, Hyderabad. ...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 of the Constitution rof lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue a Writ, Order or Direction more particularly one in the nature of
Writ of [t/andamus declaring the actions of the Respondents No.2 in not considering the representations dt. 1 9/06/2O17 and dt.2510712017 of the petitioner
seeking the retirement benefits i.e-, P.F., Gratuity, pension benefits of her deceased husband as arbitrary, illegal, unjust and in violation of Article 21 of fundamental rights as guaranteed under the Constitution and consequently direct
the Respondents No.2 to consider the repiesentations dt.'19/0612017 and dt.25lo7l2O17 and pass on the retirement benefits i.e., PF., Gratuity, Pension benefits to the peiitioner.
(l
lA NO: 1 OF 2022
Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumr;tances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to
direct the Respondent No.2 to consider the detailed representation of the petitioner, dt.19lo6l2017 and 25107 t2017 for the pensionary benr:fits any other benefits that the petitioner is entitled to, pending disposal of the t/vrit petitioh in the interest of Justice. Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI C.VIKRAM CHANDRA Counsel forthe Respondents: GP FOR SERVICES The Court made the following: ORDER I
i:i
iJ'
THE HONOURABLE SMT JUSTICE T.MADHAVI DEVI WRIT PETITIO N No.9445 of 2022 ORDER:
This Writ Petition is filed by the petitioner seeking a
writ or direction more particularly one in the nature of Writ of Maldamus declaring the action of respondent No.2 in not considering the representations dated 19.06.2017 and, 25.07.2017 of the petitioner seeking retirement benefits
i.e., P.F., gratuity, pensionary benefits of her deceased husband as illegal, arbitrary and in violation of Article 21
of the fundamental rights as qfraranteed under the Constitution of India and consequently to direct respondent No.2 to pass orders on the reptesentation of the
petitioner seeking retirement benef,rts i.e., p.F., gratuit5r, pensionar5z benefits to the petitioner and to pass such
other order or orders.
2.
Brief facts leading to the hling of the present writ
petition are that the petitioner's husband Late A.V.Ranga Rao joined- as a Lower Division Clerk in the office of
Director of Technical Education on 31.O7.1965 and was
!
,e TMD.J ur.P.No.9445 of 2022
I
promoted as a Upper Division Clerk on 16.01.1972. While
the petitioner's husband was working as such, he was placed under suspension in the year 1978 on the allegation
of theft of typewritten memorandum of marks book on the
night of 04.12.1977 and fraudulent use of the sanre. He
was sanctioned subsistence allowance upto 1978. Thereafter, the petitioner's husbald was dismissed from service by respondent No.2 uide dismissal order dated 12.O7 .2018 w.r.e.f. 30.09.
1991. However, there was
mention of the retirement benefits or any other ber:Lefits in
the dismissal order. The date of pirth of the petitioner's
husbald is 18.O7.1943 and the date of superannuation would be 31.07.2001. It is further stated that no orders,
permitting him to retire from the government service on
attaining the age of superannuation, are found 1.o have been issued in the matter. Therefore, the petitioner seeks
pension to her husband, who was under suspension since
t6.ol .r978.
3.
It is also submitted that the suspension of the
petitioner's husband was reviewed from time to tirrre and
TIV4J W.P.No.9445 oJ 2022
was extended and in the meantime, a criminal case was
also booked against the petitioner,s husband and the Criminal Court convicted the accused for the alleged offences uirle order dated 30.09. 1991.
lt is further
submitted that though the respondents have initiated disciplinary proceedings against the petitioner,s husband and issued a charge memo, they tailed to take any further
action against him.
petitioner,s iusbana expired on
19.O2.2O73 and subsequently, the petitioner herein being
the wife of late A.V.Ranga Rao, filed a representation before
Lok Ada_lat, Legal Services Aufority on 22.11.2OI3 requesting for sanction of pensionary benehts from the Department of Technical Education for the total service
rendered by the petitioner,s husband including the suspension period. ThereaJter, the respondents passed the
dismissal order dated l2.OZ.2}lg dismissing the petitioner's husband from service w.r.e.f.3O.09.1991. Therefore, the present writ petition has been f,rled seeking a
direction to the respondents to consider her representations ald grant the retirement benefits to
TMD,J W.P.No-9445 oJ 2022
petitioner's husband including family pen sion to the petitioner on account of service rendered by her husband'
4.
The respondents have filed a counter eLffidavit
admitting that ti1l 2O 18, the disciplinary proceedings
initiated against the petitioner's husband \ rere not concluded. It is stated in the counter affidavit that since the Criminal Court convicted the petitioner's husband for the atleged offences, there was no option but to dismiss the
petitioner's husband from service and accordingll', order
dated 12.O7.2}la has been issued dismissirrg the petitioner's husband from serviJe w.r.e.f. the 'late of conviction i.e., 30.09. 199 1.
5.
Having regard to the rival contention and the material
available on record, this Court finds that admittedly the petitioner's husband has been placed under susper: sion on
the allegation of theft of typewritten memoran,fum of marks and misuse of the same and has also been convicted
for the said offence by the criminal coutt uide ordr:r dated 30.09.1991 and therefore, the respondents passed the
gigpissal order dated 12.07 .2078 w.r.e.f. 30.09. 1991.
r_' .rtfrg 'T'//
I
l')
TUID,J W.P.No.9.l45 oJ 2022
Learned counsel for the petitioner has placed relialce upon several judgments to the effect that after the death of the
employee, the disciplinar5r proceedings would be abated
and therefore, the order of dismissal could not have been passed subsequent to death of the petitioner,s husband in (
(
the year 2013. The respondents have also not denied the
fact that the disciplinaqr proceedings. were not concluded
during the lifetime of the employee. However,. the petitioner is not challenging the said dismissal ordi:r dated
l2.O7.2OlB, but she is only seeking pension and other retirement benefits by duly takinq into consideration the
length of service rendered by her husbald including the suspension period. This Court finds that even if the date of
dismissal would be taken as 30.09. 1991, the petitioner,s
husband would have put in nearly 26 years of service. However, in view of the order of dismissal, the employee
would entail forfeiture of his past service and therefore would not be entitled to any benefits including pension and pensionar5r benefits, gratuity and also for encashment of
leave.
.-
f t t I
TMD,J w.P.No.!r445 oJ 2022
6.
This Writ Petition is dismissed. There shal.. be no
order as to costs.
7.
Miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in ttLis Writ
Petition, shall stand closed SD/- C.PRAVEEN KUMAR ASSTSTANT RFGljirf,AR //TRUE COPY//
\
To, { . One CC to SRI C.VIKRAIVI CHANDRA, Advocate [OPUC]
seclor)6rrrcen
'1
2. fwo CCs to GP FOR SERVICES, High Court for the State cf Telangana at Hyderabad [OUT]
3. Two CD Copies
g
i
tt 4,
HIGH COURT
DATED: 0310512024
( +
-) ,.)
ORDER I
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION,
b (9
.^\e
(
err
*ft,
I
(qYq
f sTetr
r .rlll 2[l2l
n u I
t OE
WP.No.9445 of 2022
WITHOUT COSTS
R rt1
-k s rr,.\. r e, ff r0,