SMT. Arogyamma v. Sri Francies
- Court
- High Court of Karnataka
- Date of judgment
- 6 November 2026
- Judge
- Justice Rajesh Rai K
- Case number
- RFA No. 1666 of 2020
- Result
- DISMISSED
- Acts & sections
- Section 96 CPC
- Subject
- Civil
Full judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 6TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH RAI K REGULAR FIRST APPEAL NO. 1666 OF 2020 (INJ) BETWEEN: 1.
SMT. AROGYAMMA W/O LATE Y JOSEPH AGED ABOUT 81 YEARS,
2.
MR LAWRENCE S/O LATE Y JOSEPH AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS,
3.
MR ANTHONY SWAMY @ KANNIGA S/O LATE Y JOSEPH AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
4.
MR DANIAL S/O LATE Y JOSEPH AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS,
Digitally signed 5. by PANKAJA S Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
MR JAMES S/O LATE Y JOSEPH AGED ABOUT 45 YEARS, ALL ARE RESIDING AT MARIYANNA PALYA ARABIC COLLEGE POST K.R PURAM, HOBLI BENGALURU-560 045 NOW RESIDING AT HA FARM POST, MARIYANNA PALYA K.R. PURAM, HOBLI BENGALURU-560 024
…APPELLANTS (BY SRI. K.S CHANDRAHASA, ADVOCATE FOR A1, A3 & A5, SRI. SANATH KUMAR SHETTY, ADVOCATE FOR A2)
AND: 1.
SRI FRANCIES S/O LATE DODDA ANTHONY B AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS,
2.
SRI BORTHALAM S/O LATE DODDA ANTHONY B AGED ABOUT 55 YEARS,
3.
SRI A ARALAPPA S/O LATE CHIKKA ANTHONY B AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS,
4.
SRI A FRANCIS S/O LATE CHIKKA ANTHONY B AGED ABOUT 62 YEARS,
5.
SRI A CHOURI RAJ SINCE DECEASED REP BY LR'S
A.
MRS. SAGAYA MARY W/O LATE A CHOURI RAJ AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS
B.
ANTHONY ASHA C D/O LATE A CHOURI RAJ AGED ABOUT 30 YEARS,
C.
PRABHU SAGAR C S/O LATE A CHOURI RAJ AGED ABOUT 35 YEARS,
D.
ROOPA KALA C D/O LATE A CHOURI RAJ AGED ABOUT 25 YEARS,
6.
SRI ANTHONY RAJ S/O LATE AMRUTHRAJ AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS, ALL ARE RESIDING AT NO.27 MARIYANA PALYA,
ARABIC COLLEGE POST K.R PURAM HOBLI BENGALURU-560 045 …RESPONDENTS (BY SRI. VIJAYA KUMAR K, ADVOCATE FOR R1, R2, R3 & R4, R5(A-D) & R6) THIS RFA IS FILED UNDER ORDER XLI RULE 1 READ WITH SECTION 96 OF CPC AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND DECREE DATED 06.07.2020 PASSED IN OS.No.1345/2002 ON THE FILE OF THE XXXIX ADDITIONAL CITY CIVIL AND SESSIONS JUDGE, BANGALORE CITY, DECREEING THE SUIT FOR PERMANENT INJUNCTION. THIS APPEAL HAVING BEEN RESERVED FOR JUDGMENT ON 15.10.2026 COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY, THE COURT DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAJESH RAI K CAV JUDGMENT
This Regular First Appeal is filed by the appellantsdefendants
challenging
the
judgment
and
decree
dated
06.07.2020 passed by the XXXIX Addl City Civil and Sessions Judge, CCH-40, Bengaluru (for short, "the Trial Court"), whereby the Trial Court decreed the suit of plaintiffs for permanent injunction against the defendants. 2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are
referred to as per their ranking before the trial Court. The
appellants
are
the
defendants
and
respondents
are
the
plaintiffs. 3.
The abridged facts of the case as borne out of
pleadings are that plaintiffs are the co-owners in possession and enjoyment of the property bearing Sy. No. 23, situated at Dasarahalli Village, Mariyana Palya, K.R. Puram, Bengaluru South Taluk, Bengaluru, measuring 18 guntas. According to the plaintiffs, their ancestors, late Dodda Anthonappa and late Chikka Anthonappa, acquired the said property from one Anthonamma under a registered sale deed dated 08.12.1951. Subsequent to the purchase, their ancestors applied for khatha and bifurcation of the property. Upon such bifurcation, the property was assigned a new survey number, namely, Sy. No. 23/8. However, only 15 guntas of land came to be entered in the revenue records. The plaintiffs contend that their ancestors were
duly
recorded
and
recognised
as
khathedars
and
occupants of the property bearing Sy. No. 23/8, measuring 15 guntas, situated at Dasarahalli Village, K.R. Puram Hobli, Bengaluru South Taluk, Bengaluru, which is hereinafter referred to as “the suit schedule property”.
4.
It is the further case of the plaintiffs that plaintiffs
Nos. 1 and 2 are the sons of late Dodda Anthonappa, while plaintiffs Nos. 3 to 5 are the sons of late Chikka Anthonappa. Plaintiff No. 6 is the son of Amrutharju, who is stated to be one of the sons of late Dodda Anthonappa. Apart from the plaintiffs, late Dodda Anthonappa had two other sons, namely, Amruth Raju and Bastin. The plaintiffs further contend that Amruth Raju died leaving behind his wife and children. According to the plaintiffs, they have succeeded to the estate of late Dodda Anthonappa and late Chikka Anthonappa as their surviving successors and legal heirs, including in respect of the suit schedule property. 5.
The plaintiffs contend that they have constructed
five houses on the suit schedule property and have been residing therein for several decades. After the demise of late Dodda Anthonappa and late Chikka Anthonappa, the khatha of the suit schedule property was transferred to the names of the plaintiffs and one Rosemary. The plaintiffs state that they have constructed the aforesaid houses and are residing in the respective houses constructed by them.
6.
It is further contended that one Y. Joseph, the
father of the defendants and the owner of an adjacent property, with an intention to cause damage and encroach upon the suit schedule property, began interfering with the plaintiffs' peaceful possession and attempted to construct a compound wall by encroaching upon the suit schedule property. Aggrieved by the alleged interference, the plaintiffs instituted a suit in O.S. No. 2456/1993 before the Additional City Civil and Sessions Judge, Bengaluru City, seeking the relief of permanent injunction against the said Joseph. During the pendency of the said suit, Joseph died, whereupon the suit was dismissed as abated. 7.
The plaintiffs further contend that late Joseph, the
father of the defendants, had earlier filed proceedings in LRF No. 4960/1975–76 before the Land Reforms Tribunal, claiming rights over the suit schedule property, and that the said claim was rejected. According to the plaintiffs, the rejection of the said claim supports their contention that neither the defendants nor their father had any right or lawful possession over the suit schedule property.
8. The plaintiffs further contend that, on 23.02.2002, the defendants, claiming to be the children of late Joseph, began assembling materials with the intention of constructing a wall by encroaching upon the suit schedule property. Upon noticing the same, the plaintiffs immediately obstructed the alleged illegal
activities
of
the
defendants
and
questioned
their
authority to undertake such construction. The defendants allegedly asserted that, as the earlier suit had dismissed, they were entitled to construct the wall at the disputed place. Having no other alternative, the plaintiffs approached the jurisdictional Police, namely, the K.G. Halli Police Station, and lodged a complaint. According to the plaintiffs, although the police assured them of protection, they advised the plaintiffs to approach the competent Civil Court for appropriate relief, as the dispute was civil in nature. Hence, the plaintiffs have instituted the present suit in O.S. No. 1345/2002, seeking appropriate reliefs against the defendants. 9.
Upon service of summons, the defendants appeared
before the Court, and defendant No. 2 filed his written statement contesting the suit. The defendants have contended that the suit is barred by the principle of res judicata and that the cause of action alleged by the plaintiffs has nothing to do
with the defendants. It is their further contention that the suit, being one for the relief of bare injunction, is not maintainable. The defendants have specifically denied the right, title, interest and possession claimed by the plaintiffs over the suit schedule property. They have further contended that the property allegedly purchased by the plaintiffs under the registered sale deed dated 08.12.1951, bearing Sy. No. 23 and measuring 18 guntas, situated at Dasarahalli Village, has no connection whatsoever with the property claimed by the defendants, bearing Sy. No. 23/8 and measuring 15 guntas. 10.
The defendants have further contended that the
land bearing Sy. No. 23/8, measuring 1 acre 9 guntas, originally belonged to one Mariyappa, son of Chowrappa. According to the defendants, the said Mariyappa sold an extent of 34 guntas out of the total extent of 1 acre 9 guntas in favour of his sister, Smt. Susamma, under a sale deed dated 06.10.1931, marked as Ex. D-2, while retaining the remaining extent of 15 guntas in Sy. No. 23/8. It is their further case that, upon the demise of Mariyappa, the aforesaid remaining extent of 15 guntas also devolved upon Smt. Susamma. The defendants
have
stated
that,
pursuant
to
the
phodi
proceedings, the extent of 34 guntas conveyed in favour of
Smt. Susamma was assigned a separate survey number, namely, Sy. No. 23/8A. 11.
The defendants have further contended that the
remaining extent of 15 guntas in Sy. No. 23/8, which had been retained by Mariyappa, is situated on the northern side of the extent of 34 guntas conveyed in favour of Smt. Susamma. They have categorically denied the claim of the plaintiffs that they have any right or are in possession of the property described in the plaint schedule. The defendants have also challenged the entries made in the revenue records in favour of the plaintiffs, contending that such entries are illegal and have no legal sanctity. 12.
It is the specific defense of the defendants that, if
the plaintiffs have any property in the vicinity, the same is situated on the northern side of the land bearing Sy. No. 23/8, measuring 15 guntas, and that the plaintiffs, taking advantage of the existing circumstances, are attempting to encroach upon the property belonging to the defendants. The defendants have asserted that they are in actual possession and enjoyment of the land bearing Sy. No. 23/8, measuring 15 guntas, situated
at Dasarahalli Village. On these grounds, the defendants have sought for dismissal of the suit. 13.
The Trial Court on the basis of pleadings have
framed the following issues: i.
Whether, the Plaintiffs prove that they are in lawful possession and enjoyment of the plaint schedule property as on the date of suit?
ii. Whether, the Plaintiffs prove that the Defendants
are
interfering
with
the
peaceful possession and enjoyment of the Plaintiffs over the plaint schedule property as alleged? iii. Whether, the Plaintiffs are entitled for the relief of permanent injunction as sought? iv. What order or decree? 14.
Upon conclusion of the trial, the Trial Court, by its
Judgment dated 20.03.2010, dismissed the suit. Aggrieved by the said Judgment and Decree of dismissal, the plaintiffs preferred an appeal before this Court in R.F.A. No. 573/2010. This Court, by its Judgment and Decree, allowed the appeal and remanded the matter to the Trial Court for fresh consideration,
with a direction to afford an opportunity to both parties to adduce evidence. 15.
Pursuant to the order of remand, the Trial Court
recorded fresh evidence of the parties. Plaintiff No. 2 was examined as P.W.1 on behalf of the plaintiffs, and through his testimony, the plaintiffs got marked 89 documents as Exs. P-1 to P-89. On behalf of the defendants, defendant No. 2 was examined as D.W.1, and another witness was examined as D.W.2. The defendants also got marked 28 documents as Exs. D-1 to D-28. Upon completion of the recording of evidence, the Trial Court heard the arguments advanced by both parties and, by the Judgment and Decree impugned in the present appeal, decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiffs. 16.
The
Defendants
on
being
aggrieved
by
the
Judgment and Decree of the Trial Court have preferred this Appeal. 17.
Heard the learned counsel Sri. K.S. Chandrahas for
appellant Nos.1, 3 and 5, learned counsel Sri. Sanath Kumar Shetty for appellant No.2 and learned counsel Sri. Vijaykumar K. for the respondents.
18.
The learned counsel for the appellants/defendants
contended that the suit, being one for bare injunction, could not be decreed without establishing the identity of the suit schedule property and the plaintiffs’ lawful possession thereof. It was submitted that the plaintiffs trace their title to the registered sale deed dated 08.12.1951, marked as Ex. P-14, under which their predecessors-in-interest, Dodda Anthony and Chikka Anthony, allegedly acquired 18 guntas in Sy. No. 23 of Dasarahalli Village. Though the plaintiffs contend that the property was subsequently bifurcated and assigned Sy. No. 23/8, measuring 15 guntas, the defendants have specifically disputed the said claim and asserted that the property covered under Ex. P-14 is distinct from the suit schedule property. 19.
The
learned
counsel
further
submitted
that
Mariyappa, son of Chowrappa, acquired 26 guntas under the registered partition deed dated 14.08.1910, marked as Ex. P66, and subsequently purchased an additional extent of 23 guntas under Ex. D-25. Together with the other extent attributed to him, he held 1 acre 9 guntas in Sy. No. 23, which was assigned Sy. No. 23/8 upon phodi proceedings in 1930, as evidenced by Exs. D-27 and D-28. Mariyappa thereafter conveyed 34 guntas in favour of his sister, Smt. Susamma,
under the sale deed dated 06.10.1931, marked as Ex. D-2. The conveyed portion was subsequently assigned Sy. No. 23/8A, while the remaining extent of 15 guntas continued to bear Sy. No. 23/8. According to the defendants, upon the demise of Mariyappa, the remaining extent devolved upon Susamma, and the defendants, being her grandchildren, succeeded to the said property. 20.
The learned counsel argued that the plaintiffs’ own
documents do not establish title to the suit schedule property. Under Ex. P-66, Andralappa was allotted 23 guntas in Sy. No. 23. The plaintiffs’ evidence indicates that an extent of 11½ guntas was subsequently conveyed under Exs. P-67 to P-69. However, the plaintiffs have failed to explain how their predecessors-in-interest
acquired
the
remaining
extent
necessary to support their claim over 18 guntas. Though the plaintiffs rely upon the proceedings in O.S. No.596/1942 and O.S. No.390/1950-51, they have not produced sufficient material to establish the precise extent and identity of the property in respect of which rights were acquired in those proceedings. Further, Ex. P-14 refers to a two-thirds share in 18 guntas, which does not, by itself, establish title to the entire extent claimed.
21.
It was further contended that Exs. D-27 and D-28
establish that Sy. No.23/8 had been assigned to Mariyappa’s land in 1930, much before the execution of Ex. P-14. Therefore, the plaintiffs’ assertion that the property purchased under Ex. P-14 was subsequently re-designated as Sy. No.23/8 is inconsistent with the documentary evidence. It was also pointed out that the boundaries recited in Ex. P-66 do not correspond with those mentioned in the plaint schedule. The learned counsel also relied upon the Gazette Notification marked as Ex. P-65, relating to the acquisition of 34 guntas belonging to Susamma under Sy. Nos. 23/8 and 23/8A, contending that the notification supports the defendants’ case regarding the identity and location of the property. It was submitted that the plaintiffs have failed to establish their title, the identity of the suit schedule property, and their lawful possession thereof as on the date of the suit. Referring to the observations made by this Court while remanding the matter, the learned counsel argued that, in the absence of cogent evidence establishing the identity and possession of the property, the plaintiffs were not entitled to a decree of permanent injunction and that the impugned Judgment and Decree of the Trial Court were liable to be set aside.
22.
He further contended that if the defendant raises a
substantial dispute regarding title, the plaintiff ought to have sought declaration by amending the plaint or institute a comprehensive suit for declaration and injunction. He disputed the plaintiffs’ contention that paragraph No. 7 of the written statement contains an admission of their ownership over Sy. No. 23/8, arguing that the defendants have consistently denied their title. It was further contended that an admission must be clear and unambiguous to be binding and that the presumption arising from revenue entries is rebuttable and cannot, by itself, establish title to the property. With these submissions, he prays to allow the appeal by setting aside the impugned judgment and decree. 23.
To buttress his argument, he relied on the following
judgments: 1. Ambika Prasad Thakur and Otehrs vs Ram Ekbal Rai and Others reported in AIR 1966 SC 605 2. M/s. Sodhi Transport Co. and another vs State of U.P and another reported in AIR 1986 SC 1099
3. Anathula Sudhakar Reddy vs P. Buchi Reddy and Others reported in (2008) 4 SCC 594 24.
Per
contra,
the
learned
counsel
for
the
plaintiffs/respondents, supporting the impugned Judgment and Decree, contended that the Trial Court has rightly decreed the suit upon proper appreciation of the evidence on record. He submitted that, under the partition deed dated 14.08.1910, marked as Ex. P-66, an extent of 23 guntas in Sy. No. 23 was allotted to Andralappa, who subsequently conveyed 11½ guntas to Urabagilu Chowrappa under Ex. P-67. Thereafter, Urabagilu Chowrappa’s sons conveyed the said extent to Joojappa under Ex. P-68, who, in turn, sold it to Dodda Anthony and Chikka Anthony under the registered sale deed dated 26.05.1950, marked as Ex.P-69. 25.
The
learned
counsel
further
submitted
that
Anthoniyamma instituted O.S. No. 390/1950-51 against Dodda Anthony, Chikka Anthony and others, which culminated in a compromise dated 08.12.1951, marked as Ex. P-73. Pursuant thereto, she conveyed her alleged 2/3 share in 18 guntas of Sy. No. 23 to Dodda Anthony and Chikka Anthony under the
registered sale deed dated 08.12.1951, marked as Ex. P-14. The plaintiffs claim through the said predecessors-in-interest and contend that they have continued in possession of the suit schedule property. 26.
To establish possession, the plaintiffs relied upon
the RTC extracts (Exs. P-1 to P-8), tax-paid receipts (Exs. P-9 to P-12, P-37 to P-39 and P-79), identity documents (Exs. P-13 and P-15 to P-26), house-related documents (Exs. P-40 to P46) and electricity bills (Exs. P-47 to P-63). The learned counsel submitted that these documents establish that the plaintiffs and their family members have constructed houses and have been residing on the suit schedule property for several decades. 27.
The learned counsel further relied upon the orders
marked as Exs.P-83 and P-84, whereby the appeal preferred by the defendants before the Assistant Commissioner and the subsequent revision petition before the Deputy Commissioner challenging the relevant revenue entries were dismissed. He contended that these orders, together with the revenue records, support the plaintiffs’ claim of possession. He also submitted that the defendants had acknowledged in paragraph
No. 7 of their written statement that the plaintiffs’ property lies to the north of Sy. No. 23/8. 28.
Regarding the identity of the property, the learned
counsel relied upon the joint survey records marked as Exs. P30 to P-32, particularly the sketch and mahazar at Ex. P-31, which bears the signature of D.W.2. He contended that the survey records establishes the identification and boundaries of the property in the plaintiffs’ possession. He further relied upon the compromise decree in O.S. No. 390/1950-51, marked as Ex.P-74, to contend that the boundary descriptions establish that the plaintiffs’ property lies to the north of the property claimed by the defendants. 29.
The learned counsel also relied upon the Land
Tribunal’s order dated 16.10.1981 in LRF No. 4960/1975-76, marked as Ex. P-80, rejecting the occupancy rights application filed by the defendants’ father, and the subsequent appellate proceedings. He contended that the plaintiffs had established their lawful possession and that the defendants had failed to demonstrate any enforceable right warranting interference with such possession. Placing reliance upon Rame Gowda (Dead) by LRs. v. M. Varadappa Naidu and Others, reported in
(2004) 1 SCC 769, he submitted that settled possession is entitled to protection against unlawful interference and that a suit for permanent injunction was maintainable. Accordingly, he sought dismissal of the appeal and confirmation of the impugned Judgment and Decree. 30. Learned counsel further relied on the following judgments: 1. Prataprai N. Kothari vs John Braganza reported in 1999 (4) SCC 403 2. Puran Singh and Others vs State of Punjab reported in (1975) 4 SCC 518 3.
Balkrishna
Dattatraya
Galande
vs
Balakrishna
Rambharose Gupta and another reported in (2020) 19 SCC 119 4. M/s Eureka Builders vs Gulabchand and others reported in (2018) 8 SCC 67 5. Prem Singh and others vs Birbal and Others reported in (2006) 5 SCC 353 31.
Having heard the learned counsel for the parties,
the points arising for our consideration is: "i. Whether the defendants proved that there is some apparent defect in the title of the plaintiffs in respect of the suit schedule
property, as such bare injunction suit is not maintainable? ii. Whether the plaintiffs prove that they are in lawful possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule property and the defendants are interfering with their lawful possession? iii. Whether the impugned judgment and decree suffers from any perversity or illegality, which call for interference?” 32.
In order to answer the point No.1 it is relevant to
trace the title of the plaintiffs in respect of the suit schedule property as claimed by them as under:
Sl. No
Document / Exhibit
Person / Party
Nature of Transaction / Event
Extent
14.08.1910
Mariyappa S/o. Chowrappa, Andralappa @ Aralappa and Appanna
Partition of ancestral properties under Panchayath Parikath. In Sy. No. 23, 23 Guntas fell to the share of Mariyappa and 23 Guntas fell to the share of Andralappa @ Aralappa.
Guntas each
Ex.P66
05.05.1915
Andralappa @ Aralappa → Uragabalu Chowrappa S/o. Joneshappa
11½ Guntas
Ex.P67
After 05.05.1915
Uragabalu Chowrappa
11½ Guntas
—
Date
Registered Sale Deed in respect of portion of land falling to the share of Andralappa @ Aralappa.
Purchaser remained in possession and enjoyment of 11½ Guntas.
Prior to 23.03.1948
Uragabalu Chowrappa → Thomasappa & Jonesappa
Uragabalu Chowrappa died leaving behind his sons Thomasappa and Jonesappa as successors. Sale of the entire extent purchased by their father.
11½ Guntas
—
11½ Guntas
Ex.P68 – Sale Deed, Doc. No. 4714/4748
11½ Guntas
Ex.P69
23.03.1948
Thomasappa & Jonesappa → Jojappa S/o. Chowrappa
26.05.1950
Jojappa → Chikkaanthony & Doddaanthony
08.12.1951
Pursuant to compromise Smt. in O.S. No. 390/50-51, Anthoniyamma Anthoniyamma agreed to → Chikkaanthony sell her 2/3rd share out & Doddaanthony of 18 Guntas.
2/3rd share in Guntas
Ex.P73 – Compromi se
08.12.1951 / registered 10.12.1951
Smt. Sale Deed executed Anthoniyamma pursuant to the → Chikkaanthony compromise. & Doddaanthony
2/3rd share in Guntas
Ex.P14, Doc. No. 5667/5152
After 1951
Chikkaanthony & Doddaanthony
Possession of the property; subsequently, after their demise, possession continued with their successors.
Suit schedule property
Ex.P40– P46 and other document s
Plaintiffs / their predecessors
Plaintiffs claim continuous possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule property through their predecessors, including the property on which their houses are situated.
Suit schedule property
Ex.P1– P13, P15– P26, P37– P46, P79
Present
Sale of the 11½ Guntas.
33.
The above transactions and the documents marked
before the Trial Court are not seriously disputed by the defendants. However, the primary contention of the defendants is that the parent document of the plaintiffs is the partition deed of the year 1910 (Ex.P66), under which the plaintiffs’ predecessor in interest, Andralappa, acquired only 23 guntas of land in Sy.No.23. Out of the said extent, he sold only 11 and 1/2 guntas to the predecessors in interest of the plaintiffs; as such, it is not known how the plaintiffs acquired the remaining extent of 7 and 1/2 guntas in Sy.No.23. On careful perusal of Ex.P27, the depicts that Sy.No.23 measured 4 acres 18 guntas and was phoded in the year 1930, and that the land belonging to Mariyappa measuring 1 acre 9 guntas was reassigned as Sy.No.23/8. After the sale of 34 guntas in Sy.No.23/8 in the year 1931, further phoding was effected, and the land sold to Susamma measuring 34 guntas upon phoding the land was reassigned as Sy.No.23/8A, while the remaining continued to bear the designation Sy.No.23/8. As such, the defendants' contention that the land purchased by their predecessors in interest as per Ex.P14 in 1951 was reassigned as Sy.No.23/8 upon phoding cannot be sustained in light of documents Ex.P27 and Ex.P28 of the years 1930 and 1931.
34.
Additionally
the
document
produced
by
the
defendants at Ex.D2, i.e., the sale deed dated 06.10.1931 executed by Mariyappa in favor of his sister Susamma, depicts 34 guntas in Sy.No.23. In the said sale deed, there is no recital or reference regarding the source of title to Mariyappa. When Mariyappa had rights to an extent of only 23 guntas in Sy.No.23 as per the Ex.P66 partition deed, the question of Mariyappa executing a sale deed in respect of 34 guntas in favor of Susamma does not arise. Furthermore, regarding Ex.D3 (the Record of Rights), it is clear from its contents that the entries were made at the instance of DW.1, and it is further mentioned
that
the
issuing
authority
is
not
responsible
regarding the names entered in the Record of Rights and other revenue documents. 35.
Ex.D4 and Ex.D10 are the RTC extracts in respect
of Sy.No.23/8A measuring an extent of 34 guntas, whereas Ex.D5, Ex.D8, and Ex.D9 are the RTCs for the years 1974– 1979, 1977–1980, and 1979–1984 in respect of Sy.No.23/8A measuring an extent of 15 guntas. These exhibits pertain to two
different
portions
of
land
in
Sy.No.23/8A,
but
the
defendants have failed to explain how the extent of land differs across the RTCs. Likewise, Ex.D12 and Ex.D13 are the RTC
extracts in respect of survey number 23/8A to an extent of 34 guntas, but the letter '8A' was handwritten in Kannada. Ex.D14 is the RTC in respect of Sy.No.23/8B measuring 34 guntas for the years 1976–1979, Ex.D16 is the RTC for the years 1977– 1980 in respect of Sy.No.23/8B measuring 34 guntas, and Ex.D15 is the RTC in respect of Sy.No.23/8A for the years 1976–1979 to an extent of 15 guntas. As can be seen from the above-said RTCs, it is clear that the claim made by the defendants shifts: at one breath, their claim is in respect of Sy.No.23/8A, and in another breath, it is over Sy.No.23/8B. However, the measurements do not tally with each other, and the defendants have failed to explain the same. 36.
Whereas, Ex.D17 and Ex.P36 (one and the same)
i.e. IHC NO.1/1990-91, standing in the name of the plaintiffs and the said documents are much earlier to filing of the suit and the same prove that the plaintiffs are in possession of the suit schedule property as on the date of filing of the suit. The Ex.D18 and D19 are the tax paid receipts in respect of Sy.No.23/8 & 23/8A, but the defendants have failed to say as to how they are related to Sy.No.23/8. The Ex.D25 is the sale deed dated 20.03.1929 in respect of Sy. No.23, measuring to an extent of 23 guntas, the said land was purchased by one
Mariyappa son of Sowrappa from Yagappa. There is no recitals with regard to origin of title in the sale deed in Ex.D25. The defendants have not produced any document to show that how Mariyappa got 1 acre 9 guntas of land in Sy.No.23, even as per Ex.D2 and Ex.D25 the total extent of land is 1 acre 17 guntas (34 guntas and 23 guntas). In the absence of non production of documents in respect of alleged 1 acre 9 guntas of land in Sy.No.23 an adverse inference can be drawn in respect of Ex.D2. The Ex.D26 is the official memorandum issued from the Office
of
the
Deputy
Commissioner,
Bengaluru,
dated
30.01.2015 and the said document cannot be taken into consideration since Ex.D26 is subsequent to filing of the suit in respect of the alleged 34 guntas of land. 37.
Apart from the documents discussed supra on
careful scrutiny of the evidence of PW.1 and DW.1, the claim of the plaintiffs in respect of their clear title substantiates with the following suggestions to PW.1 by the defendants and admission of DW.1 in his cross examination. The relevant extracts of the suggestion are as below: “ ಅಸಲು
ಾ ಾ ನಂ.390/1950
ನಂ.23ರ ೇತ 18 ಗುಂ ೆ ಜ
ೕ ನ
2/3
ೆದರ
ಅಂ ೋಣಮ ಸ ೆ
ಾಗವನು! "ೇ#ದ$ರು ಎಂದು
ಸೂ&ಸುವ'ದು ಸ(ಯಲ, 18 ಗುಂ ೆ ಜ
*-71 ರ +ೆಡೂ-. ನ
ಸ ೆ ನಂ.23ರ ೇತ
ೕನು ಎಂದು ನಮೂ/ಸ0ಾ1 ೆ ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ಜ.
*-14 ಕ ಯಪತ ದ 4ೆಡೂ-.ನ ಯೂ ಸಹ 2/3 64ೆ7 ಎಂದು ನಮೂ/ಸ0ಾ1 ೆ ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ಜ. ಖ(ೕ/ ಪತ ಗಳನ:ಯ
ಮತು= &ಕ> ಅಂ ೋ<ರವರು ಅಂ ೋಣಮ
ೊಡ; ಅಂ ೋ<
ರವ(?ೆ ಬಂದಂತಹ 2/3
6AೆBಯನು! Cಾತ ಖ(ೕ/DರುEಾ=Fೆ ಎಂದು ಸೂ&ಸುವ'ದು ಸ(ಯಲ, *-73ರ
ನಮೂ/ಸ0ಾದಂತಹ
ಅಂ ೋಣಮ ರವ(?ೆ 7 (ಂದ 8 ಗುಂ ೆ ಜ
FಾG
ಪತ ದನ:ಯ
ೕನು ಬಂ/ತು= ಎನು!ವ'ದು
*-9 (ಂದ 12 ಮತು= 79 ಕಂ ಾಯ ತುಂHದ ರIೕ/ಗಳJ ಮತು= (ಂದ
*-63 Kದು-L H. ಮತು= ರIೕ/ಗಳJ,
Mೕ ೋಗಳ
ಜ.
*-47
*-40 (ಂದ 45
ಕಂಡು ಬರುವ ಮ ೆಗ#?ೆ ಸಂಬಂNDದವ'ಗಳJ ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ಜ. Further on perusal of the cross examination of DW.1, he has categorically admitted as under:
“ಮ(ಯಪ7ನ 4ಾಳ-ದ
ಮ(ಯಣO ಎಂಬ ವ-P=?ೆ ಮೂರು ಜನ
ಗಂಡು ಮಕ>ಳJ ಇದ$ರು ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ಜ, ಸದ(ಯವರು ಗಳನು
ಅಂದರ ಅರಳಪ7, ಅಪ7ಣO, Rೌರಪ7 ಎನು!ವ'ದು Rೌರಪ7
1910 ರ
ಮರಣ
ಜ. ಸದ(
Tೊಂ/ದರು ಮತು=
ಅವ(?ೆ
ಮ(ಯಪ7 ಎಂದು ಒಬV ಮಗ ದ$ನು ಎನು!ವ'ದು ಅಂದರಅರಳಪ7
ಅಪ7ಣO
ಮತು=
/:14.8.1910 ರಂದು
ಮ(ಯಪ7
*-6 ರಂEೆ
Aೇ("ೊಂಡು
ೊಂ ಾWತ 4ಾಲು
K ಾಗಪತ ವನು! CಾX"ೊಂXದ$ರು ಎನು!ವ'ದು ಾ/ಯರು
ಜ. ಸದ(
ಜ.
ೊಡ;ಅಂEೋ ಯಮ &ಕ>ಅಂEೋ
ಮತು=
ಾರಸು ಾರರು ಮತು=
ಾ/ಯರನು! Tೊರತು ಪYೆD ZೇFೆ
[ಾರು
ಇರುವ'/ಲ,
ಾರಸು ಾರರು
ಾ ಾಸ:\=ನ
ಸ ೆ
ನಂಬ] ಮತು= ಅದರ Kವರ^ೆಯ ಕು(ತು ನನ?ೆ Cಾ6\ ಇರುವ'/ಲ.
ಾದಪತ ದ
_ೆಡೂ-.ನ
ನಮೂ/ಸ0ಾದ
&ಕು>ಬಂ/ ಬ?ೆ` ನನ?ೆ Cಾ6\ ಇರುತ= ೆ. ಾದಪತ ದ _ೆಡೂ-. ನ
ನಮೂ/ಸ0ಾದ ಪaವ ಪIbಮ ಮತು= ಉತ=ರದ ಚಕು>ಬಂ/
ಸ([ಾ1 ಇರುತ= ೆ ಅದFೆ ದeಣ"ೆ> ಸೂಸಮ ಮತು= ಮ(ಯಪ7 ರವರ ಸ:ತು= ಇರುತ= ೆ.
ಾ ಾಸ:\=ನ ದeಣ"ೆ> ಇರುವಂತಹ
ಸ:ತ=ನು!
ಸೂಸಮ
ಮ(ಯಪ7 ಂದ
ಖ(ೕ/Dದು$
ಸೂಸಮ
ಮರಣ Tೊಂ/ದ ನಂತರ ಸದ( ಸ:ತು= ನನ! ತಂ ೆ[ಾದ fೋAೆg ರವ(?ೆ ಬಂ/ರುತ= ೆ. 2002 ರ
ಈ ಪ ಕರಣ
ಾಖ ಸುವ "ಾಲ"ೆ> ಸೂಸಮ ಬದುPರ ಲ ನನ! ತಂ ೆ[ಾದ ಬದುPದ$ರು ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ಜ. ಮರಣದ ನಂತರ
ಾ ಾಸ:\=ನ
ದeಣ"ೆ> ಇರುವ ಸ:ತು= fೋAೆg ರವ(?ೆ ಬಂ/ದ$(ಂದ ಸದ( ಸ:ತು= fೋAೆg ರವರ ಸ:ತು= ಎಂದ ಕFೆಯು\=ದರ $ ು ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ಜ.
ಾದಪತ ದ _ೆಡೂ-.ನ ದeಣ"ೆ> fೋAೆg ರವರ ಸ:ತು=
ಎಂದು
ನಮೂ/ಸ0ಾ1ದು$
ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ಸದ(
fೋAೆg
ನನ!
ತಂ ೆ
ಜ.
ಾ ಾಸ:ತ=ನು! ೋಡುEಾ=
ಾನು
ಬಂ/ರುEೆ=ೕ ೆ.
ಸುCಾರು
ಾ ಾಸ:ತು=
ಮೂಲತಃ
ನಂ.23 ರ ಒಂದು ಾಗ ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ವಷ ಗ#ಂದ ಸ ೆ
ಜ, ಸದ( ಸ ೆ ನಂ.23
kೕX[ಾದ ನಂತರ 23/8 ಎಂದು ಆ1ರುತ= ೆ ಎನು!ವ'ದು ಸ ೆ
ನಂ.23 ರ ಒಟುn KD=ೕಣ
ನಂ.23 ೇದು$
4 ಎಕFೆ. ಸದ( ಸ ೆ
kೕX[ಾ1ರುತ= ೆ.
1930ರ
ಜ.
*-87
/:27.1.1930ರ
kೕX[ಾದ Kಷಯ"ೆ> ಸಂಬಂNDದ
ಾಖ0ೆ ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ಜ. ಸ ೆ
ನಂ.23 ರ
ಒಟುn 8
ಾಗಗoಾ1ರುತ= ೆ. ಸದ( ಅಂದರಅರಳಪ7 ?ೆ ಅಂEೋನಮ
ಎಂಬ ಮಗಳJ
ಇದ$ಳJ ಎಂದು ಸೂ&ಸುವ'ದು ಸ(ಯಲ, ಸದ( ಅಂದರಅರಳಪ7 4ಾಲು ಜ
K ಾಗದನ:ಯ ತನ?ೆ ಸ ೆ
ೕ ನ
11 ವFೆ ಗುಂಟ ಜ
ನಂ.23 ರ
ಬಂದಂತಹ
ೕನನು! 05.05.1915 ರಂದು
*-67ರಂEೆ fೋ ೊಸಪ7ನ ಮಗ Rೌರಪ7 ರವ(?ೆ CಾFಾಟ CಾXದ$ರು ಎನು!ವ'ದು ಸ:\=?ೆ
ಸಂಬಂNDದಂEೆ
ಜ.
*-67ರ
ಚಕು>ಬಂ/
ನಮೂ/ಸ0ಾದ ಇರುತ= ೆ
ಎಂದು
ಸೂ&ಸುವ'ದು ಸ(ಯಲ,
*-67 ರಂEೆ ಖ(ೕ/Dದ ಸ:ತ=ನು!
fೋ ೊಸಪ7ನ ಮತು= ತಮಸಪ7 ರವರು /: 23.3.1948 ರಂದು ಜೂಜಪ7 ರವ(?ೆ
*-68 ರಂEೆ CಾFಾಟ CಾXದ
Kಷಯ ನನ?ೆ ?ೊ\=ಲ,
*-68 ರಂEೆ ಖ(ೕ/Dದ ಸ:ತ=ನು!
ಜೂಜಪ7 /: 26.5.1950 ರಂದು &ಕ>ಅಂEೋ ೊಡ;ಅಂEೋ
ಮತು=
ರವ(?ೆ
*-69 ರಂEೆ CಾFಾಟ CಾXದ
Kಷಯ ನನ?ೆ ?ೊ\=ಲ.
*-65 (ಂದ 87 ರ ವFೆ1ನ
ಾಖ0ೆಗಳನು! ವPೕಲರ
ಾನು
ೋXರುವ'/ಲ ಮತು= ಅವ'ಗಳ ಬ?ೆ`
ಮೂqಾತರ
&ಕ>ಅಂEೋ
ಮತು=
ಸಹ
\#ದು"ೊಂXರುವ'/ಲ.
ೊಡ;ಅಂEೋ
ಖ(ೕ/Dದ$ರು ಮತು= ಸದ( ಸ:\=ನ ಮತು= qಾ
ಸದ(
*-69 ರಂEೆ ಸ:ತ=ನು! ಮಂಗಳrರು Tೆಂ&ನ ಮ ೆ
fಾಗ ಇತು= ಎಂದು ಸೂ&ಸುವ'ದು ಸ(ಯಲ,
*-
69 ಖ(ೕ/ಪತ "ೆ> fೋAೆg, ಅಂEೋನಪ7 ಮತು= [ಾಗಪ7 ರವರುಗಳJ Aಾe ಾರFಾ1 ಸ6 CಾXರುEಾ=Fೆ ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ಜ.
ಾ/ಯರ ತಂ ೆ Tೆಸ(?ೆ ಅದಂತಹ ಮ ೇಷನನು! ಪ I!D ಾನು
sೕಲ ನK
ಉಪK ಾ?ಾN"ಾ(ಗಳ ಎನು!ವ'ದು ೕನು
ನಂ.207-2008-09
ೇದ$ನು!
"ಾಯ ಲಯದ
ಾಖ D ೆ$ೕನು
ಜ. ಸದ( sೕಲ ನKಯ
*ー83 ಅ ೇಶ
ಾಖ Dದಂತಹ sೕಲ ನKಯನು! \ರಸ>(ಸ0ಾ1 ೆ
ಎಂಬ ಪ _ೆ!?ೆ Aಾeಯು
ಾನು sೕಲ ನKಯನು! ಸ D ೆ$ೕನು
ಅದFೆ ಅ ೇಶದ TೊರXDದ Kಷಯ ನನ?ೆ ?ೊ\=ಲ.
*-83
ರಂEೆ TೊರXಸ0ಾದ ಅ ೇಶವನು! ಪ I!D G0ಾN"ಾ(ಗಳ ಮುಂ ೆ (Kಜu *vಷu ನಂ. 193/2013-14 ಾಖ DರುEೆ=ೕ ೆ ಎನು!ವ'ದು 2. 193/2013-14 ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ನಮೂ/DದಂEೆ
TೊರXಸ0ಾದಂತಹ
జ
ೇದ$ನು!
*vಷu ನಂ. ಅ ೇಶ ಾ1ರುತ= ೆ
ಅ ೇಶವನು!
ಪ I!D
sೕಲ ನKಯನು! ಾಖ Dರುವ'/ಲ.” 38.
On perusal of the above documents and evidence of
P.W-1 and D.W-1, it is unequivocally established that the plaintiffs are in possession of the suit schedule property. Further Ex.P80 and P81 are undisputed documents in which the father of the defendants had categorically admitted the ownership of the ancestors of the plaintiffs over the suit schedule property. Further, the plaintiffs in order to establish their title and lawful possession have produced the title deeds stated supra and the RTC extracts standing in their names. As such, they have independently proved their possession and flow of title. The DW.1 has admitted that, Mariyappa has acquired the property through partition deed – Ex.P66, admittedly in the partition deed ‘C’ schedule property was allotted to the share of said Mariyappa to the extent of 23 guntas, as such, the
question of Mariyappa executing sale deed in respect of 34 guntas to Soosamma does not arise as discussed supra. 39.
The
Hon’ble
Apex
Court
in
the
judgment
of
ANANTHULA SUDHAKAR VS B. BUCHI REDDY reported in 2008 (4) SCC 594, held that, a cloud is said to raise over a person’s title when some apparent defect in his title to a property, or when some prima facie right of a third party over it, is made out or shown. An action for declaration is the remedy to remove the cloud on the title to the property. On the other hand, where the plaintiff have clear title supported by documents, if a trespass without any claim to title or an interloper without any apparent title, merely denies the plaintiff title it does not amounts to raising a cloud over the title of the plaintiff and it will not be necessary for the plaintiff to sue for declaration and a suit for injunction may be sufficient. 40.
Collocating the above findings to the instant case,
the flow of title of the plaintiffs in respect of the suit schedule property described in the chart supra and the discussion unequivocally establishes that, the plaintiffs have acquired the title
originally
under
Ex.P66
dated
14.08.1910
and
subsequently Ex.P67 to P69 and Ex.P73 and Ex.P14. Further,
on perusal of the testimony of PW.1, the suggestion of the defendants reveals that pursuant to the compromise in O.S No.390/1950-51 Anthoniyamma agreed to sell her 2/3rd share out of 18 guntas of land as per Ex.P73. Thus, on careful examination of the documents and evidence discussed supra in my considered view, the defendants failed to prove any apparent defect in the title of the plaintiffs in respect of the suit schedule property. Accordingly, I answer the point No.1 in favour of the plaintiffs. 41.
As far as the point No.2 is concerned, apart from
the admission in the oral evidence of DW.1, as per Ex.P30 to P32, a joint survey was conducted in respect of Sy.No.23/8 on 31.10.2007 and at the time of joint survey DW.2 was also present and he has signed the mahazar – Ex.P31 prepared by Taluk Surveyor. As could be seen from Ex.P30 and P31, the property is in possession of the plaintiffs and has been demarcated
and
identified
by
the
competent
revenue
authorities and fixed the boundaries and prepared a sketch and mahazar. Admittedly the said documents are not challenged by the defendants. Additionally the plaintiffs produced Ex.P47 to P63, the electricity bills issued by the BESCOM and the said bills pertaining to the house of plaintiffs built over the suit
schedule property. A contention was raised by the learned counsel for the defendant that, there is no mentioning of the house in the suit schedule property, however, on perusal of the plaint it is categorically stated that, there exists a house in the suit schedule property. Further, the suggestion to PW.1 in the cross examination by the defendants reads that: ನಮ ಜ
ೕ ನ ಪaವ "ೆ>
"ೆ>ೕಲಪ7ನ ಮಗ [ಾಗಪ7 ರವ(?ೆ
Aೇ(ದ ಸ:ತು= ಇ ೆ ಎನು!ವ'ದು [ಾಗಪ7ನ ಜ
ಜ.
"ೆ>ೕಲಪ7ನ ಮಗ
ೕ ನ ದeಣ"ೆ> ಮ(ಯಪ7ರವರ ಜ ೕನು ಇ ೆ
ಎಂದು ಸೂ&ಸುವ'ದು ಸ(ಯಲ. Aಾe ಮುಂದುವFೆದು ತಮ ಜ
ೕನು
ಇರುವ' ಾ1
[ಾಗಪ7ನ ಜ
ನುX/ರುEಾ=Fೆ.
"ೆ>ೕಲಪ7ನ
ೕ ನ ದeಣ"ೆ> ಸಮ ಾ1 ನಮ
ಜ
ಮಗ ೕ ನ
ದeಣದ ಾಗ ಇರುತ= ೆ ಎಂದು ಸೂ&ಸುವ'ದು ಸ(ಯಲ, *-2 (ಂದ 8 ಆ] v D ಗಳ
ೊಡ; ಅಂ ೋ< ಮತು=
&ಕ> ಅಂ ೋ< ರವರ Tೆಸರುಗಳನು! ಸ ೆ ಸಂಬಂNDದಂEೆ
ಅಕ ಮ ಾ1
ಸೂ&ಸುವ'ದು ಸ(ಯಲ,
Aೇ(DರುEೆ=ೕ ೆ
ೆದ"ೆ> ಎಂದು
*-40 (ಂದ 45 Mೕ ೋಗಳ
ಕಂಡು ಬರುವ ಮ ೆಗಳJ ಮತು= ಮ ೆಗಳJ ಅಂದFೆ
ನಂ. 23
X-23 ರ
ಕಂಡು ಬರುವ
X 23(ಎ) ಮತು= (H) ಯನು! Tೊರತು
ಪXD ಒಂ ೇ ಆ1ರುತ= ೆ ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ಜ.
*-40 (ಂದ 45
Mೕ ೋಗಳ ಪತ ದ
ಕಂಡು ಬರುವ ಮ ೆಗಳನು!
ನಮೂ/ಸ0ಾದ ಸ:\=ನ
ಎನು!ವ'ದು
*-14 ಖ(ೕ/
Cಾ ಣ Cಾಡ0ಾ1 ೆ
ಜ.
*-73ರ
FಾG
ಪತ ದನ:ಯ
ಅಂ ೋಣಮ ರವ(?ೆ 7 (ಂದ 8 ಗುಂ ೆ ಜ
ೕನು ಬಂ/ತು=
ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ನಮೂ/ಸ0ಾದಂತಹ
ಜ.
*-9 (ಂದ 12 ಮತು= 79 ಕಂ ಾಯ
ತುಂHದ ರIೕ/ಗಳJ ಮತು= H. ಮತು= ರIೕ/ಗಳJ,
*-47 (ಂದ
*-63 Kದು-L
*-40 (ಂದ 45 Mೕ ೋಗಳ
ಕಂಡು ಬರುವ ಮ ೆಗ#?ೆ ಸಂಬಂNDದವ'ಗಳJ ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ಜ.
Further, the admission of DW.1 in his cross examination in that regard that, “ಪ _ೆ!: ಾ/ಯರು ಾ ಾಸ:\=ನ ಉತ=ರಃ 11 ವFೆ ಗುಂ ೆ ಜ
ಮ ೆ ಕvnD"ೊಂXರುEಾ=Fೆ? ೕ ನ 2/3 6AೆBಯ
ಮ ೆ
ಕvnD"ೊಂXರುEಾ=Fೆ. ಾ/ಯರು 11 ವFೆ ಗುಂ ೆ ಜ
ೕ ನ 2/3 6AೆBಯ
ಮ ೆ ಕvnD"ೊಂXರುEಾ=Fೆ ಎನು!ವ ಕು(ತು ಸ ೆ
ಾಖ0ೆಯನು!
Tಾಜರು ಪYೆDರುವ'/ಲ,
ಾ/ಯರ Tಾಗೂ ನಮ ಒ*7?ೆಯ
sೕFೆ?ೆ 2007 ರ
ಾ ಾಸ:\=ನ ಸ ೆ
CಾXಸ0ಾ1ತು=
ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ಜ.
*-30 ಸದ( ಸ ೆ
Tಾಗೂ ನ ೆ ಎನು!ವ'ದು
CಾXದಂತಹ ವರ/
ಜ. ಸದ( ಸ ೆ
Tಾಜರು ಪYೆಸ0ಾದಂತಹ ಪಂಚ ಾs ಅದರ
ನನ! ಸ6 ಇರುತ= ೆ.
ಬಂದ ನಂತರ
*-31
ೋಡು\=ದು$
ಾ ಾಸ:ತು= HHಎಂ*
ಾ-*=?ೆ
ಾ/ಯರು HHಎಂ*?ೆ ಕಂ ಾಯ ತುಂಬುEಾ=
ಬಂ/ರುEಾ=Fೆ ಎನು!ವ'ದು ಗುಂ ೆ ಜ
ವರNwಂ/?ೆ
ಜ, Aಾe ಮುಂದುವFೆದು 11 ವFೆ
ೕ ನ 2/3 6AೆBಯ
ಮ ೆ ಕvnD"ೊಂXರುEಾ=Fೆ
ಮತು= ಅದ"ೆ> ಸಂಬಂNDದಂEೆ ಕಂ ಾಯ ತುಂHರುEಾ=Fೆ.
*-
79 ಸದ( ಕಂ ಾಯ ತುಂHದ ರIೕ/ಗಳJ ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ಜ.
*-40 (ಂದ 45 k ೋಗಳ
ಕಂಡುಬರುವ ಮ ೆಗಳ
ಾ/ಯರು ಾಸ ಾ1ರುEಾ=Fೆ ಎನು!ವ'ದು ಕvnD"ೊಂಡಂತಹ ಮ ೆಗ#?ೆ ಎಂದು
ಸೂ&ಸುವ'ದು
k ೋಗಳ
ಜ. ಈಗ ಾ/ಯರು
ೕರು ಮತು= ಚರಂX ವ-ವAೆx ಇ ೆ
ಸ(ಯಲ.
*-40
ಕಂಡುಬರುವ ಮ ೆಗ#?ೆ
(ಂದ
ಮ(ಯಪ7ನ4ಾಳ-
?ಾ ಮಪಂRಾW\ಯವರು
ೕ(ನ ಸಂಪಕ ವನು! "ಒದ1Dರುವ
Kಷಯ ನನ?ೆ ?ೊ\=ಲ.
ಾನು ಕoೆದ \ಂಗಳJ
ಹ\=ರ
*-40
Tೋ1 ೆ$ೕವ'.
ಕಂಡುಬರುವ ಮ ೆಗಳ ಹ\=ರ
(ಂದ
ಾ ಾಸ:\=ನ k ೋಗಳ
ಾನು Tೋ1ರುವ'/ಲ.
*-40
(ಂದ 45 k ೋಗಳ
ಕಂಡುಬರುವ ಮ ೆಗಳ KD=ೕಣ ನನ?ೆ
Tೇಳಲು ಅಗುವ'/ಲ.
*-40 (ಂದ 45 k ೋಗಳ
ಕಂಡುಬರುವ ಮ ೆಗ#?ೆ ZೆAಾ>ಂನವರು Kದು-L ಸಂಪಕ ವನು! ಒದ1DರುEಾ=Fೆ ಎನು!ವ'ದು
ಜ. ಸ ೆ
ಸಂಬಂNDದಂEೆ ಇವ\=ನ ವFೆಗೂ ಬರುತ= ೆ ಎನು!ವ'ದು 42.
ನಂ.23/8
ೇದ$"ೆ>
ಾ/ಯ Tೆಸ(?ೆ ಪಹ<
ಜ.”
Hence, by considering the evidence of both the
parties, it clearly goes to show that, the plaintiffs are in possession of the suit schedule property. The Hon’ble Apex Court in the case of Ananthula Sudhakar supra, held that, in suit for permanent injunction to restrain the defendant from interfering in the plaintiff's lawful possession, the plaintiff will have to establish, as on the date of the suit, he was in lawful possession of the suit property and the defendant tried to interfere or disturb such lawful possession. Where the property is a building or building with appurtenant land, there may not be much establishing possession. The plaintiff may prove physical or lawful possession either of himself or by him through his family members or agents or lessees/licence. The question of title is not an issue in such a suit though it may arise incidentally or collaterally. 43.
Further,
the
plaintiffs
have
also
proved
the
interference of the defendants to lawful possession of the
plaintiff over the suit schedule property, and since, the defendants have denied the possession of the plaintiffs over the suit schedule property and also made an attempt to interfere with their possession in the suit schedule property. 44.
For the foregoing discussion, I am of the view that,
the plaintiffs have established their possession and interference by the defendants. Accordingly, I answer the second question of law in favour of the plaintiffs. 45.
In view of my answers to point Nos.1 and 2 in
favour the plaintiffs, I am of view that there is no perversity or illegality in the impugned judgment and decree passed by the Trial Court. Hence the same needs no interefence by this Court. Being devoid of merits the appeal is dismissed.
SD/(RAJESH RAI K) JUDGE
PKS/V