Smt. P. Shivaleela v. C. Narayana Reddy
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 30 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice K.lakshman
- Case number
- CC No. 2900 of 2025
- Result
- ALLOWED NO COSTS
Full judgment
[ 3304 ] IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD FRIDAY, THE THIRTIETH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENW SIX
PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE K.LAKSHMAN CONTEMPT GASE NO: 2900 OF 2025
Contempt Case under Sections 10 to 12 of Contempt of Courts Act 1971 to punish the respondent herein for intentionally, deliberately and brazenly defying and
willfully disobeying the orders passed by this Court on dt. 05-08-2025 in W.P.No. 22093 of 2025.
Between:
1. Smt. P. Shivaleela, Wo. Sri P. Venkateshwarlu, aged about 36 years, Occ. Home Maker - Agriculture R/o H.No.16-2-7541N38, A.P.A.U. Colony, Besides Revenue Board Colony, Land Mark. Sri Venkateshwara Commerce Degree College, Malakpet, Hyderabad. 2. Sri P. Venkateshwarlu, S/o. Late Sri P. Jangaiah, a ed about 50 years, 38, A,P.A.U. Colony, Occ. Government Servant ' Fl/o H.No Sri Venkateshwara hd Mark. Besides Revenue Board Colony, Commerce Degree College, Malakpet, H yderabad ...PETITIONERS
AND C. Narayana Reddy, S/o. Not Known to the Petitioner, Age. lvlajor, Occ. District Collector, RR District, Kongara Kalan Village, lbrahimpatnam, Kongara Kalan, RR Dist., Telangana 501 510. (Cause Title is amended as per the Court Order dtd.23.O1 .2026 in lA 112O26 in
cc 2s0012025). ... RESPONDENT
Counsel for the Petitioners : Sri Vijay B Paropkari Counsel for the Respondent : GP for Revenue The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT: IIYDERABAI) HON'BLE SRI JUSTTCE K. LAKSHMAN CONTEMPT CAS EN o.2900 OB 2025 CNR No. IJ1B'ilC010624912025
Pronounced on: 30-10-2026 Uploaded on : 30-10-2026
Reserved onz 16.10,2026 Between
.. Petitioners
Mrs. P. Shivaleela & another Vs.
Mr. C. Narayana ReddY, I.A.S., District Collector, Rangareddy District
.. Respondent
This Court delivered the following
ORDER:
Heard Mr. Vr.lay B. Paropkari, learned counsel for the petitioners and learned Govemment Pleader for Revenue appearing
for the respondent.
2. This Contempt Case is filed alleging willfrrl and deliberate violation of the order passed by this Court in W'P' No'22093 of 2025, dated 05.08.2025.
3. The petitioners herein had filed the aforesaid writ petition seeking the following relief:
"lt is, therefore, prayed that this Hon'ble Court may be pleased to issue a writ, order or direction, more
C C No.2900 o12025
particularly one in the natur: of Writ of Mandamus or any
other appropriate Writ d eclaring the action of the respondcnts in not considenng the applications dated 14.03.2024 submitted by the petitioners to respondent No.3
for issuance of NOC as illegrl, arbitrary, unjust and against
the principles of natural justice and consequently direct respondont rl-o.3 to issue NCC in respect of Plot No.59 and
Plot No.62 (Eastem Part) in Survey Nos.536, 53j, 657 and,
658 situated at Manne Mutt yalamma Kunta, Turkayamjal Municip rlity. Ranga Redd y District, in terms of the decision of respondent No.3 vide Lr.B/E41434512021 dared 27.08.2022 and the consequent Memo No.1573BlG1lZ022 dated 02 09.2022 issued by rr:spondent No.2 by deleting the
same from the Prohibitory Properties Register and pass such othr:r order or orders as this Hon'ble Court may deem
fit and proper in the interest r,fjustice."
4. Vide ord,er dated 05.0i;.2025, this Court disposed of the aforesaid writ p,ltition with the following direction to respondent No.3
therein i.e., the respondent herein:
"ln the light of the a:oresaid discussion, this writ petition is disposed of dirt:cting the 3'd respondent to consider the representation drted 14.03.2024 submitted by the petiti,rners herein for del:tion of the subject plots i.e.,
Plot No.(r2 (Eastern Part) and Plot No.59 in Survey Nos. 536, 537 657 and 658, sinrated at Manne Muthyalamma
Kunta, Turkayamjal Village and Municipality, Abdullapr.rrmet Mandal, Ranga Reddy Disrrict, from List of
J
KI,J C.C. No.2900 of2025
Prohibitory Properties in terms of th ED roceedinss issued
bv the 3'd re snondent vide Lr.BtE4l43451202l dated and the consequential Memo 27.08.2022 No.15738/G1/2022
dated 02.09.2022 of the 6th
resDondent. If the 3'd respondent is not inclined to accept the request made by the petitioners herein, he shall pass a reasoned order and communicate a copy of the said order to
the petitioners herein. He shall complete the aforesaid entire exercise within a period of sixty days (60) days from the date ofreceipt ofa copy of this order."
5. In view of the above order, which is under contempt, the respondent was required to consider the application of the petitioners
within sixty (60) days from the date ofreceipt ofthe copy ofthe said
order. According to the petitioners, they have submitted copy of the aforesaid order to the respondent herein along with covering letter
dated 07.09.2025 under the acknowledgment dated 1l-08.2025' Therefore, the respondent has to consider the request of the petitioners
by 10.10.2025. Despite repeated requests made by the petitioners, the respondent neither considered the representation of the petitioners, nor
complied with the order under contempt. Thus, there is willful and deliberate violation of the order under contempt. Therefore, the petitioners have filed the present contempt case on 15-10.2025'
KI,J C.C. No.2900 oi2025
i) It is contended by the leamed counsel for the petitioners that the respondent has deliberately ard willfully violated the order under contempt by not passing any order within the stipulated period of sixty
(60) days as c,irected by this Ccurt. Only after filing the present contempt case and receipt of notice by the respondent in the said contempt case yide proceedings No. E41271612026, dated 26.02.2026, the respondent has passed the ord,:r rejecting the request made by the
petitioners. Rr:ferring to the sairl proceedings, the leamed counsel
would contenrl that there is no reference with regard to Lr.B/E41434512021, dated,27.08.2t)22 of the respondent herein and the
consequential Memo No.l5738lGl12022, dated 02.09.2022 of respondent No.6 in the writ petitirn, and thereby the respondent has
violated the ord,:r under contempt
ii) Accor:ding to the leameC counsel, the petitioners sought to delete the subject plots located in Survey Nos.536, 537 , 657 and 658
of Turkayamjal Revenue Village, ,rtbdullapurmet Mandal, Rangareddy
District. Out of the said Survey numbers, Survey No.537 has been already deleted from the prohibitoty properties list under Section 22A
(1) (d) of the Rt:gistration Act, l9()8 (for short 'Act, 1908'), however, the remaining survey numbers i.e. Survey Nos.536, 657 and 658 are
C.C. No.2900 of2025
not deleted, and there is no explanation from the respondent as to why and how Survey No.537 was deleted but Survey Nos.536,657 and 658
were not deleted from the prohibited list under Section - 22A of the Registration Act, 1908.
iii) Leamed counsel would submit that one of the subject plots i.e., PIot No.62 consists of 1067 square yards and the said plot was divided into two plots i.e., Plot No.62 (Eastem Part) and Plot No'62 (Western Part), admeasuring 533.5 square yards each. Plot No 62 (Western Part), admeasuring 533.5 square yards was already deleted
from the prohibitory list by the then District Collectot, vide Lr.BlE4l4345l202l, dated 27.08.2022 and the consequential Memo No.15738/G1/2022, dated 02.09.2022 of the District Registrar, Rangareddy District. In fact, the said proceedings were issued in pursuance of the orders passed by this Court in W.P. No.13624 of
2O2l ard the consequential initiation of contempt proceedings in C'C' No.t586 of 2021. Therefore, to maintain parity, the petitioners herein are also entitled to the said relief.
iv) The leamed counsel would also contend that as per the letter No.CCll8}lllBll975, dated 26.02.2010 issued by the Special
C.C No.2900 of2025
Grade Deputy Collector & Revenue Divisional Officer, Rangareddy
East Division to the Sub-Regisr rar, Vanasthalipuram, Rangareddy
District, various survey numbers including subject sun ey numbers were deleted from the ceiling pun iew. Pursuant to the said letter, the Sub-Registrar, Vanasthalipuram, has been accepting the documents
for registration Based on the strid letter, the petitioners have also purchased the subject plots
v) The l,:amed counsel world further contend that pursuant to the application rnade by the Layout Association and the writ petitioner
in W.P. No. I 36.24 of 2021, a detailed report was submitted by the then
Tahsildar, Abdullapurmet Mandal to the RDO, Ibrahimpatnam Division, vlde Lr.No.C/92012017, dated 03.06.2017, recommending the Authority tc, delere Plot Nos.1 to 2'17, which includes the subject
plots. In fact, in the said report, there is no reference with regard to the alleged takir.rg over possessior of the subject survey numbers by the RDO and on the other hand, i is mentioned that the members of
the Layout Ass,tciation are in ph.isical possession of the respective
plots. If really the RDO had taken possession of the land in Survey Nos.536, 537, C5'7 and 658, as mentioned in paragraph No.5 of the counter affidavir, a reference could have been made therein for the
C C. No.2900 of2025
relevant years in the 'possessor' column either as 'Ceiling Surplus' or
'Govemment Land'. There is no such reference either in the report or the counter affidavit. Therefore, the contention of the respondent that unless and until the RDO and the Tahsildar follows the procedure laid
down under A.P. Land Reforms (Ceiling on Agricultural Holdings) Rules, 1974 (for short 'Rules, 1974), the respondent cannot consider the request of the petitioners is false. Further, the said plea cannot be
considered in the contempt proceedings as the scope of contempt is very limited.
vi) The leamed counsel also would contend that the initial contention of the learned Govemment Pleader for Revenue that the subject land is the subject matter of LRA No'8 of 2022 is not helpful
for the reason that the said LRA No.8 of 2022 was already rejected by
the learned II Additional District Judge, Rangareddy District at L'B' Nagar vide order dated 25.04.2026 on the ground that it is barred by
limitation. It is flfttrer brought to the notice of this court that while pending LRA No.8 of 2022 itself, some of the plots including neighbouring plot were deleted from prohibitory list' The core
contention of learned Government Pleader to the effect that subsequent to the order dated 05.01.2004 passed by the Land Reforms
C.C. No 2900 of2025
Tribunal (LRT) under Section - 9 of the A.P. Land Reforms (Ceiling on Agricultural Holdings) Act, 19'73 (for short 'Act, 1973'), no orders
were passed by the Revenue Divir;ional Officer (RDO), to deliver the possession of th e land, which were deleted from the declarant holding,
and in pursuance ofthe orders ofthe LRT, dated 05.01.2004, no lands were reverted to the declarant undr:r the cover of panchanama in Form
- XI-A, and unless the procedure r:ontemplated under Rule - 10A (6), 10A (7) and 10A (8) of the Rules 1974 is followed by the RDO and
the Tahsildar, the respondent canrlot invoke to de-notify the subject lands under Se,;tion 22-A of the Act, 1908 is false and cannot be considered in this contempt procr:eding. The scope of contempt is
very limited and the respondent cannot agitate the aforesaid contention in cc,ntempt case and il'at all he is aggrieved by the order
under contempt, he has to challenge the same. Without challenging the order under contempt, the respondent cannot take the said plea in
the contempt proceedings. In support of the same, leamed counsel placed reliance on the decisions -endered by the Hon'ble Supreme
C.C No.2900 of2025
Court in Jalim Singh v. Nand Kishorer and Union of India v. Subedar Devasy PV2.
vii) With the aforesaid submissions, leamed counsel for the petitioner sought to punish the respondent for contempt in accordance
with law.
6. Whereas, the respondent opposed the contempt by filing counter affrdavit and two additional counter affidavits.
7. Admitting the ownership and possession of the petitioners in respect of the subject plots, the respondent contended that even though
LRA No.8 of 2022 was dismissed by learned II Additional District Judge, Rangareddy District at L.B. Nagar, still there is a procedure to be followed by the RDO and the Tahsildar as per the Rules, 1974,, for
reverting the land to the declarant.
i) Subsequent to the order dated 05.01.2004 passed by the LRT under Section - 9 of the Act, 1973 in CCll80l/Ell975,no lands were reverted to the declarant under the cover of panchanama in Form-XI-
A and unless the procedure contemplated under Rule - 10A (6), 10A (7) and l0A (8) of the Rules 1974,was followed by the RDO and the r. 2026 Livelaw (SC) 364 '. 1zoor1 r scc ot:
t0 C C. No.2900 of2025
Tahsildar, the respondent cannot de-notiff the subject lands under Section 22-Ao1:the Act,, 1908.
iD As thr as deletion of neighbouring plot i.e., Plot No.62 (Western Part) is concemed, it is contended that the then District Collector without following the albresaid procedure deleted the same,
which is illegal . Therefore, thert: is no violation, much less willful and deliberate 'violation of the orler under contempt. Therefore, he sought to dismiss the contempt case filed by the petitioners.
8. This Court heard leanred counsel for the petitioner and leamed Govenrment Pleader for Revenue extensively and gave thoughtful consideration of the sanle.
9. In Jalim Singhr reliec upon by leamed counsel for the petitioners, the Apex Court categorically held that while exercisinq contempt iurisdiction. the Court must conline its inquirv to the
compliance of the operative directions contained in the original
order. The i urisdiction is limited to examinins compliance and does not extend to the re-adiudication of issues that have already
attained finali8 between the parties.
C C. No.2900 of2025
10. In Subedarr Devassy PV2 relied upon by leamed counsel for the petitioners, the Apex Court held as under:
"5.|n Mohd. Iqbal Khanday v. Abdul Majid Rather l(1994) 4 SCC 341 it was held that if a party is aggrieved by the order, he should take prompt steps to invoke appellate proceedings and cannot ignore the order and plead about
the difficulties of implementation at the time contempt proceedings are initiated. 6. If any party concerned is aggrieved by the order which in
its opinion is wrong or against the rules or its implementation is neither pr acticable nor feasible, it should always either approach the court that passed the
order or invoke jurisdiction of the appellate court. Riehtness or wron eness of the o rder can not be ursed in
contempt p roceedinss. Rieht or wrong. the order has to be obeved. Floutin an orde r of the court would render the
a
liable for contem t . While dealing with an
application for contempt, the court cannot traverse beyond
the order, non-compliance with which is alleged' In other words, it cannot say what should not have been done or what should have been done. It cannot traverse beyond the order. It cannot test the correctness or otherwise of the order or give additional direction or delete any direction. That would be exercising review jurisdiction while dealing
with an application for initiation of contempt proceedings. The same would be impermissible and indefensible."
t2 C.C. No 2900 of2025
11. It is apt to note that tho scope of contempt is very limited and the Court cannot travel beyon<l its jurisdiction in such proceedings
as held by the Apex Court. At the same time, the Apex Court in a catena ofjudgrrrents time and again categorically held that to punish a
contemnor undr:r Sections - 10 to i2 of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971, there should be deliberate and willful violation of the order and mere allegation ofviolation of the order is not sufficient.
12. In J.S. Parihar v. Garrpat Duggar3 and Snehasis Giri v. Subhasis Mitraa, the Apex Court held that Court, in lawful exercise
of contempt juri sdiction cannot ex amine the merits of a decision
13. In Supreme Court Bar Association v. Union of Indias, the Constitution Bench of the Apex Court held that contempt of court
lsas ecial urisdiction to be ex,:rcised sparinslv and with caution whenever an act adversely affec:s the adminislration of iustice or which tends to impede its course r)r tends to shake public conhdence
in the iudicial institutions. This urisdiction mav also be ex ercised when the act com lained of adverselv affects the ma iesty of law or dignity of the courts. It is exerciserl in a summary manner rn aid of the
'. lteeo,1 o scc zsr '. lzoz:y ta scc szl '. 1teltl + scc +oo
l3 C C. No.2900 of2025
administration of justice, the majesty of law and the dignity of the courts. No such act can be permitted which may have the tendency to
shake the public confidence in the fairness and impartiality of the administration ofjustice.
14. In Niaz Mohammad v. State of Haryana6, the Apex Court that civil contempt under Section 2(b) of the Contempt of Courts Act, 1971 requires willful and intentional disobedience of a court order.
Mere non-compliance is insufhcient to warrant punishment. The Court must consider the facts and circumstances of the case, including whether compelling circumstances made compliance impossible' The alleged disobedience must be established beyond reasonable doubt.
15. While reviewing the nahrre of contempt proceedings, it is important to examine the acts of the alleged conternnor- The Court has
clarified that while the beneficiary of a Court order is entitled to its enforcement, the evaluation of whether a contemnor should be punished for non-compliance involves a comprehensive consideration
of all relevant facts and circumstances. The Contempt of Courts Act specifies that civil contempt involves willful disobedience of Court order. Consequently, before a contemnor can be penalized, the Court u. (1994) 6 scc 332
t4 KI,J C.C. No 2900 of2025
must come to zL conclusion that there has been disobedience but also that such disobr:dience was deliberate and intentional. Furthermore, if
the Court, upon examining the r;ircumstances of a particular case, concludes that disobedience occrrred due to extenuating factors, it retains the diso'etion to refrain f16r6 punishing the alleged contemnor despite acknowledging the anomaly, if any.
16. It is well settled that, itr contempt proceedings, the alleged contemnor cannot re-agitate issues which stand concluded in the
original proceedings. The jurisdiction of the Court is confined to examining compliance with its trinding directions and determining whether there has been willful disobedience thereof. The contempt
jurisdiction cannot be convertr:d into an appellate
or revlew
jurisdiction ove.r the originai judgnrent
17. Conring to the case on hand, there is no doubt that the petitioners are the absolute ownerr, and possessors of the subject plots i.e., Plot No.62 (Eastern Side) and Plot No.59, admeasuring 533.5 and 1067 square yards respectively, in Survey Nos.536, 537,65'7 and 658,
situated at Mame Muthyalamnra Kunta, Turkayamj al Revenue Village, Abdullrrpurmet Mandal, I'.angareddy District, and admittedly
KI,J C.C. No.2900 of2025
they are in possession of the same, on the strength of the registered sale deeds bearing document Nos.9167 of 2016 and 10442 of 2023, dated I 6.02.20 I 6 and 17 .08.202 3, respectively.
18. The only contention raised by the by the learned Government Pleader for Revenue appearing for the respondent in the counter, additional counters, and during the course of hearing is that
pursuant to the order dated 05.01.2004 passed by the LRT in CC/18OllEll975, the subject lands including the lands covered by the subj ect survey numbers were not reverted back to the declarant under
cover of panchanama in Form-XI-A, for which procedure was contemplated under Rule - 10A (6), 10A (7) and 10A (8) ofthe Rules,
1974. Since such procedure is not followed by the RDO and the Tahsildar, the respondent cannot consider the request of the
petitioners. Whereas, it is contended by leamed counsel for the petitioners that the adjacent plot and two other plots were already deleted from prohibitory properties list and, therefore, parity has to be
maintained in respect of the subject plots as well. Further, the scope
of contempt is very limited, and the aforesaid contention of the respondent cannot be considered in contempt proceedings. If the respondent is aggrieved by the order under contempt and not in a
l6 C.C. No.2900 of2025
position to conrply, he should have challenged the same. Even the order under contempt was passed by this Court considering the order dated 21.06.20121 passed in W.P. No. 13624 of 2021 in respect of the
adjacent plot and other plots. The order dated 21.06.2021 in W.P. No.13624 of 2(121 in respect of the adjacent plot had attained finality
and the adjace,nt plot and other plots were already deleted from prohibitory properties list. Therr:fore, without challenging both the orders, the respondent cannot e.gitate the same in the contempt proceedings.
19. On consideration of the submissions advanced, it is evident that the respondent had knowledge with regard to the order under contempt. However, only after the contempt case was filed, the respondent hacl issued notices to the petitioners and passed the
rejection order dated 26.02.202'i. After passing the order, the respondent filed counter on 13.03 2026 contending that the RDO and
the Tahsildar did not take any steps for reverting the possession to the declarant pursu,mt to the order dated 05.01.2004 passed by the LRT.
Even in the said counter, the respondent has taken the ground of pendency of LI{A No.8 of 2022. T\e petitioners filed an elaborate
reply affidavit dated 16.04.20116 to the counter refuting the
t7 C.C. No 2900 of2025
contentions of the respondent. on a perusal of the reply affidavit and
the subsequent dismissal of the said LRA No.8 of 2022, this Court once again directed the respondent to reconsider the request of the
petitioners. Pursuant thereto, again the respondent issued notice to the petitioners and passed order dated 08.07.2026 rejecting the request of
the petitioners. Though there is reference with regard to the Lr.BlB4l4345l202l, dated 27.08.2022 and the consequential Memo No.15738/G1/2022, dated 02.09.2022 in the second rejection order,
the explanation given by the respondent therein is against the order under contempt. Thereafter, the respondent filed additional counter along with the copies of order in LRA No.S of 2022 and the rejection order dated 08.07.2026.
20. Perusal of rejection orders dated 26'02'2026 atfi' 08.07.2026, rejecting the request of the petitioners wouid disclose that
though there is mention with regard to the instructions in the DLSC
meeting held on 24.02.2026 and the letter No'B/295012024, dated 26.02.2026 of the Tahsildar, Abdullapurmet Mandal, the respondent
did not file those documents along with the counter and additional counter for the reasons best known to him.
l8 C.C. No 2900 of2025
21. While so, it was brorLght to rhe notice of this Court by leamed counsel for the petitioners that only one of the subject survey
numbers (Suney No.537) was deleted from the prohibitory list
maintained under Section 22-A of the Acr, 1908 by retaining remaining survey numbers, for vrhich, leamed Govemment pleader
admits that it had occurred mi stakenly. This Court directed the respondent to file additional counter to that effect. Accordingly, the respondent filetl the additional colmter on 19.10.2026. Perusal of the
said additional counter affidavit would disclose that there is no whisper with rt:gard to the deletitln of Survey No.537 from Section
22-A of the Act, 1908 and keeping remaining Survey Nos.536, 657 and 658. It apprears that the addit.onal counter affidavits filed by the respondent are nothing but reiteration of the counter affidavit of the respondent..
22. The sum and substance of the counter and additional counters filed by the respondent il, that originally LRT passed orders
on 13.10.1977 under Section - 9 ol'the Act, 1973 determining that the declarant held land to an extent of8.9898 SH in excess ofthe ceiiing area. Pursuant to the said orders, LRT passed orders under Section -
10 (1) of the Act, 1974, requestirg the Tahsildar, to take necessary
C C. No.2900 of2025
action for taking possession of the lands as per the provisions of the
Act. Thereafter, the RDO has passed order vide No.E/1801/75, dated 08.09.1985, to take possession of the land in excess which is surrendered or deemed to have been surrendered under Section -
ll of
the Act, 1974. Even pursuant to the order dated 05.01.2004 of the LRT, no orders were passed by the RDO, to re-deliver the possession
of the land, which were deleted from the declarant holding under the cover of panchanama in Form-XI-A, and unless the procedure contemplated under Rule - l0A (6), 10A (7) and 10A (8) ofthe Rules, 1974 is followed by the RDO and the Tahsitdar, the respondent cannot
de-notify the subject plots/lands under Section 22'A ofthe Act, 1908.
But the respondent did not file any document to show that the RDO has passed order dated 08.09.1985 to take possession ofthe land in
various survey numbers including the subject survey mrmbers. However, all these pleas/contentions cannot be considered in this contempt case.
23. Perusal of the reply affidavit filed by the petitioners would reveal that pursuant to the order dated 15.02.2001 in C.R.P. No.1577
of 1997 and batch, this Court set aside the order dated 10.10.1996 and remanded L.RA. No.S of 1996 and batch to the Chairman, Land
z0 C.C. No.2900 of2025
Reforms Appr:llate Tribunal-cum-II Additional District Judge, Rangareddy Djstrict at L.B. Na1;ar, for fresh disposal of the said
LRAs, in accordance with law. Pursuant to the said remand, the LRAT a110wed L.R.A. Nos. 1 0f 19 96 to 8 0f 1996, 1 3 0f 1 996 to 20 0f I 996 and 37 of 1996 vide judgment dated 03 .04.2001 and accordingly
remanded the rrratter to LRA for deletion of respective extents in
various survey numbers includinll the subject survey numbers from 'ceiling purvievr'. Pursuant to the r;aid judgment dated 03.04.2001, the
LRT passed or,ler dated 05.01.2004 in C.C. No.E/I801/75, deleting various extents from ceiling purview including the subject survey numbers. As pr:r the said order, the declarant holds land of 1.6717 SH in excess of the ceiling on the notilied dated i.e., 01.01.1975.
24. As a.gainst the said ordt:r dated 05.01.2004, the Authorized Officer and Special Tahsildar (Larrd Reforms), Ranga Reddy District, lrled an application before the LRT vide letter No.AO/LRnl1-8}ll75 dated,29.04.20Cr4 seeking review of the order dated 05.01.2004, and
the same was rlismissed by the tRT vide order dated 26.05.2008. Aggrieved by thLe said order dated 26.05.2008, the Authorized Officer had preferred an appeal before tht, LRAT vide L.R.A. No.S of 2012,
which was disnrissed on 23.11.2Q15. Thus, the order of LRT dated
2l Kl-,J C C. No.2900 of2025
05.01.2004 had attained finality. In the interregnum, vide Lr.No.CCll8011E119'15, dared 26.02.2010, the Special Grade Deputy
Collector & Revenue Divisional Officer, Rangareddy East Division addressed a letter to the Sub-Registrar, Vanasthalipuram, Rangareddy
District, to accept documents for registration in respect of various
suwey numbers mentioned therein including the subject survey numbers. Pursuant to the said letter, the Sub-Registrar has been accepting the documents for registration.
25. While so, it appears that the association of the subject survey numbers layout as well as the adjacent plot owner of the petitioners made representations separately to the District Collector, Rangareddy District, with a request to delete the plots from Section
22-A of the Act, 1908. Pursuant to the said representations, the then Tahsildar, Abdullapurmet Mandal, submitted rePort to the District
Collector through RDO, Ibrahimpatnam Rangareddy Division vlde Lr.No.C/99992012017, dated 03.06.2017 to the RDO, recommending
for grant of NOC for Plot Nos.1 to 277 as the layout consists of total 277 plots. Despite submitting the report, the District Collector did not
take any steps on the representation of adjacent land owner, he approached this Court by filing a writ petition vide W .P. No. 13624 of
KI,J C.C. No 2900 o12025
2021. Vide order dated 21.06.2021, this Court considering all the aforesaid aspects, directed the District Collector to consider the representation of the adjacent plot owner. The District Collector rejected the request of the adjacer t plot owner. As the said order was
not in compliance with the order lated21.06.202i in W.P. No.13624
of 2021, the adjacent plot owner filed contempt case vide C.C.No. 1586 of 2021. During p:ndency of the said contempt case,
the respondent got filed appeal vtde LRA No.8 of 2022 challenging the order dated 05.01.2004 of the LRT after lapse of about eighteen
(18) years. Hr)wev€r, subject to the result of the said LRA No.8 of 2022, the then District Collector issued proceedings deleting adjacent
Plot No.62 (Pt, 64 (P) and 74 (P) from the list of prohibitory properties unde: Section - 22-A ol the Act, 1908. Pursuant to the said
proceedings, vide order dated 05.19.2022, this Court closed the said
C.C. No.1586 of 2021. RelyinE, upon the said proceedings, the petitioners herern filed the writ per.ition and this Court also passed the order to maintain parity. During pendency of the present contempt, it is also brought 1.o the notice of thir; Court that LRA No.8 of 2022 was rejected on the ground that it is birrred by limitation vide order dated,
25.04.2026. Thrrs, the order dated 05.01.2004 had attained hnalifi.
KI,J C.C. No.2900 of2025
26. Thus, as per the said order dated 05.01.2004 of the LRT, the lands in several survey numbers including the land in Survey No.537 were deleted. Having deleted the same, the respondent's contention that the subject plots cannot be deleted on the ground that pursuant to the order of the LRT dated 05.01.2004, no lands were reverted to the declarant under the cover of panchanama in Form-XI-
A, and unless the procedure contemplated under Rule - 10A (6), l0A (7) and 10A (8) of the Rules, 19'74, is followed by the RDO and the Tahsildar, the respondent cannot de-notify the subject lands under Section 22-A of the Act, 1908, which is self-contradictory and cannot be gone into in the contempt proceedings.
27. lt is contended by the respondent in paragraph No.5 of the counter that the RDO, Hyderabad East Division has passed otder vide
No.E/I801i75, dated 08.09.1985, to take possession of the land to an extent of Acs.528.85 cents in various survey numbers including the
subject survey numbers, which are surrendered or deemed to have
been surrendered under Section ll
of the Act, 1973,, but the
respondent did not file any documentary evidence to the said effect'
On the other hand, it is disputed by learned counsel for the petitioners
by referring to the report submitted by the Tahsildar, Abdullapurmet
C C No.2900 of2025
Mandal, Rangareddy District vide Lr.No.Cl920l20l7, dated 03.06.2011 to lhe RDO, Ibrahimpatnam Division. On one hand, the entries made in the said report d: not disclose the possession of the subject survey numbers taken or er by the Govemment; and on the
other hand, right from 1954-55 onwards till 2002-03, the subject survey numbers are being shown as 'Patta'. In fact, the said report
was submitted by the Tahsildar recommending to grant NOC for entire plot Nos.l to 277 in Sun'ey Nos.536, 537,657 and 658 of
Turkayamjal \'illage pursuant tc the application submitted by the President of the said Colony as well as the writ petitioner in W.P.
No.13624 of 2021 . Pursuant to the letter No.CC/1801,811975, dated 26.02.2010 issued by the Special ,3rade Deputy Collector & Revenue
Divisional Officer, Rangareddy Irast Division to the Sub-Registrar, Vanasthalipurarn, Rangareddy District, the registering authorities had been accepting the documents fo: registration, including that of the petitioners here.n. However, subsequently, the respond ent vide Lr. No. E11403412024 Cated, 27.10.2025, put the subject survey numbers
except Survey No. 537 and othi.r survey numbers covered by the aforesaid letter dated 26.02.2010 rmder the prohibitory properties list under Section 22A of the Act, 1908. There is no explanation to that
K-L,J
C.C. No 2900 0f2025
effect. However, all the aforesaid contentions cannot be considered in the present proceedings as it is beyond the scope of contempt.
28. It is apt to note that in paragraph No.6 of the counter affidavit filed by the respondent vide USR No.33014 of 2026, dated' 13.03.2026, it is specihcally mentioned as under
".....As such the Land Reforms Tribunal has once again considered the matter and passed orders Uis 9 of the Act in
C.C No Ell80l/75 Dt.05-01-2004 by deleting certain lands
includin s the subiect lands from the holdin g of the declarant. . ..."
29. In paragraph No.l3 of the said counter affidavit, the respondent also contended as under: ". ....consequent on receipt of orders from Hon'ble High
court in w.P No.22093 of 2025, Dt:05-08-2025 !!!q respondent wit h due respec t to the orders. have issued notices to the applicant and also called for the relevant
material from the Tahsild ar. AbdullaDurmet Mandal
and Revenue Divisional Officer
Ibrahim atnam
Division as instructed the reon in the orders The aforesaid statement is palpably false for the following reasons:
i)
As discussed above, on receipt of the order of this Court, the respondent did not pass any order within the stipulated period of
sixry (60) days. Along with the counter dated 13.03.2026, the
C.C. No.2900 of2025
respondent f,iled the copy of notice dated 17.12.2025 and also issued another notice datec 18.02.2026. Hearing was held on
21.02.2026. The column of signatures of RDO, Tahsildar and Authorized Officer, was k,:pt blank, however petitioner No.2 was present and, therefore, he signed in the relevant column.
If
the RDO, Tahsildar and Authorized Officer were present in the hearing conducted on 21 .0'.>-.2026, they should have signed in the appropriate column
ii)
Secondly, the copy of order was served upon the respondent on
11.08.20115. The period cf sixty (60) days had expired by 10.10.20:15. After waiting ior the completion of the sixry (60)
days period, the petition:rs filed the contempt case on 15.10.20r'.5. Therefore, the contention of the respondent that
after recr:ipt of orders from this Court, he has passed the rejection order is incorrect. Even the references mentioned in the order dated 26.02.2026 ere of October 2025, January 2026 and FebnLary 2026. Thus, il is evident that only after receipt of
notice in the contempt case. the respondent started the process
for considering the representation of the petitioners
KI,J C.C No.2900 of2025
30. It is also apt to note that, the very adjacent plot of the petitioners i.e., Plot No.62 (Western Part) was akeady deleted from the prohibitory list of properties under Section 22-Aof the Act, 1908
by the then District Collector, Rangareddy District, vide proceedings
Lr.BlE4l4345l202l dated 27.08.2022 and the consequent Memo No.15738/G1i2 022 dated 02.09.2022 issued by the District Registrar, Rangareddy District. Perusal of the record would also reveal that those proceedings were issued by the then District Collector pursuant to the
order dated 21.06.2021 passed by this Court in W'P' No'13624 of 2O2l andthe consequential contempt proceedings in C'C' No'1586 of
2021. ln fact, after compliance with the order dated 2l'06'2021 in W.P.No.13624 of 2021, the said C.C. No.1586 of 2021 was closed' The subject plots and the plot No.62 (Westem Part) are covered by the same layout. Leamed counsel for the petitioner filed a copy of the said Layout. Further, pursuant to the orders dated2l '06'2021 in W'P'
No.13624 of 2021, Plot Nos'62 (Western Part), PIot No'64 (Part) and
Plot No.74 (Part) of the very same layout were deleted' The respondent did not challenge the order dated 21.06'2021 passed by
this Court in W.P. No.13624 of 2021. Therefore, the said order attained finality. Relying on the said order dated 21.06'2021 and the
C C No.2900 ot2025
deletion proceedings, the petition:rs fi1ed the writ petition vide W.P. No.22093 of 2025. Considering .he said order dated 21.06.2021 and, the proceedings dated 27.08.2022 and 02.09.2022, this Court passed the order dated 05.08.2025 in W.t'. No.22093 of 2025, which is under
contempt. The relevant extract of the order under contempt is as under:
"4. Perusal of record woulcl reveal that vide order dated 21.06.2021 in W.P.No.13621 of 2021, this Court directed the 3'd respondent - District rlollector to consider the claim
of the petitioner therein to delete Plot No.62 (part), Plot No.64 (part) and Plot No.74 (Part) covered by the subject Layout consists of the afores aid Survey Numbers from the
List of Prohibitory Properties and dispose of the said request made by the petitiont:r therein. If he is not inclined
to accept the request made by the petitioner therein, he shall pass orders duly assigning reasons and communicate copy ofthe said order to the petitioner therein, he shall pass orders dtLly assigaing reasons and communicate copy of the said order to the petitioner (hr:rein. 5. I'ursuant to the said crder, dated 21.06.2021 in W.P.
No.13624 of 2021 and the consequential contempt proceedirrgs in C.C.No.1 58 6 of 2021, the 3'd respondent has taker. steps for deletion r,f the aforesaid plots from the
list of prohibitory properties vide proceedings Lr.BE4/,t345/2021, dated 2i.08.2022 subject to the result
of LRA l{o.8 of 2022. On rr:ceipt of the said proceedings
C.C. No.2900 of2025
d,ated 27.08.2022, respondent No2 issued a Memo No.G3/8684/2022, dated09.09.2022 to respondent No 6 to take further necessary action as per Act and Rules in vogue.
Pursuant to the said Memo, dated 02.09 -2022 of respondent No. 2, vide Memo No.15738/G112022, dated
02.09.2022, respondent No.6 deleted Plot Nos.62 (Part), 64 (Part) and 74 (Part) in Survey Nos.536, 537,657 and' 658, sinuated at Manne Muthyalamma Kunta, Turkayamjal
Village and now under Municipality, Abdullapurmet Mandal, Rangareddy District. Therefore, the petitioners herein are also standing on the very same footing. To maintain parity, they are also entitled for the same relief."
31. The aforesaid order under contempt was passed by this Court only after hearing both sides. During the course of hearing in the said writ petition, the respondent did not take any plea which has been raised in the present contempt case. The respondent neither preferred any appeal against the order under contempt nor took any such plea in the writ petition. In the order under contempt, this Court
directed the respondent to complete the entire exercise within sixty
(60) days from the date of receipt of the copy of the order' Despite receipt of the said order, the respondent did not pass any order within
the stipulated time. There is no explanation, much less plausible explanation to that effect. Thus, the action of the respondent amounts
C C No.2900 of2025
to willful disobedience and violirtion of the order under contempt. Further, the respondent passed .he rejection order on 26.02.2026, which is only alter receipt of notice in the contempt case.
32. Pen-,rsal of the said order dated 26.02.2026 would disclose that there is nerther reference nc'r consideration with regard to the proceedings passed by the then District Collector deleting the adjacent
Plot No.62 (Pafi) from the prohibitory list of properties under Section
22-A of the Act, 1908. As stared above, even in the subsequent proceedings dtl/ted 08.07.2026 tassed by the respondent, it is mentioned that rtdjacent plot and o:her two plots were deleted from the
list of prohibited properties wittrout complying with the statutory procedure prescribed under the Rules, 1974. It is not fair on the part
of the responrlent to make su ch contentions in the contempt proceedings without challenging the order dated 21.06.2021 in W.p. No. 13624 of 2021 and the order dated 05.08.2025 in W.P. No.22093
of 2025, as rov.ng inquiry is impr:rmissible in contempt proceedings as held by the Apex Court in Jalim Singhl. The said contention of the
respondent is also against the prin;iple laid down by the Apex Court
in Subedar Devassy PV2, whel:in it was held that if any party concemed is aggrieved by the ordt:r which in its opinion is wrong or
3l
KI,J C.C No.2900 of2025
ag.ainst the rules or I ts tmplementation is nei ther
p racficable nor
feas[L!, it should always either approach the court that passed the order or invoke jwisdiction of the appellate court' Rightness or wronsness of the ord er cannot be ur sed in contempt Dro ceedinss.
Rieht or wrong. the or der has to be obeyed. Flouting an order of the court would rend er the partv liable for contempt.
33. There is also no explanation as to why the respondent deleted Survey No.537 out of the four subject survey numbers and several other survey numbers as per the order dated 05 '01 '2004 of the
LRT. On one hand, the respondent deletes Survey No'537 and several other survey numbers from the prohibitory list of properties under Section 22-A of the Act, 1908 without following the procedure
as contemplated under the Rules, 1914; whlle on the other hand, opposes the deletion of subject plots from Section 22-A of the Act, 1908 without any valid ground. However, the said contentions cannot
be considered in the present contempt proceedings'
34. ln the light of the aforesaid discussion, it is clear that the order under contempt passed by this court directing the respondent to consider the request made by the petitioners in terms of the decision of
C.C No.2900 of2025
the then District Collectr,r, Rangareddy District vide Lr.BlE4l4345l1\021 dated 27.08.2022 and the consequential Memo No. 1 5 73 8/G 1/2:-022 dated, 02.09.2)22 issued by the District Registrar,
Rangareddy District, is not conplied with. Pursuant to the said proceedings, adjacent plot and otrer two plots were deleted from the
prohibitory list of properties uncer Section 22-A of the Act, 1908. Therefore, instr:ad of implementing the order under contempt in such
manner, the rr:spondent had dis,tbeyed the same, despite granting
sufficient opportunity. Thus, thrr act of the respondent amounts to
willful and deliberate disobedienr;e and violation of the order under contempt. The explanation offererl by the respondent is unsatisfactory and the same cannot be accepted.
35. In the light of the afort:said discussion, this Court is of the considered vie w that the respo ndent has committed willful and deliberate viola:ion of the order dated 05.08.2025 passed by this Court
in W.P. No.22093 of 2025 and he is liable for punishment in terms of Section - 12 of the Contempt of Cc,urts Act, 1971.
36. The present Contempt Case is accordingly allowed. The respondent is sentenced to suffer simple imprisonment for a period of
six (06) monttrs and to pay a fine of Rs.2,000/- (Rupees Two
C.C. No.2900 of2025
Thousand Onty) within 04 (four) weeks from today' However' the sentencs of imprisonment is suspended for a period of four (04) weeks
from today. In the circumstances of the case, there shall be no order as to costs.
As a sequel thereto, miscellaneous petitions, if any, pending in the contempt case shall stand closed. Sd/. V. KAVITHA OEPUTY REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY// SECTION OFFICER
To
1. C. Narayana Reddy, S/o. Not Known to the Petitioner' Age Major' Occ' District bollector, RR District, Kongara Kalan Village' lbrahimpatnam'
Kongara Kalan, RR Dist., Telangana 501 510' 2. The Registrar (Judicial-1), High Court at Hyderabad' 3. The SeJtion Oificer, O.S. Section, High Court at Hyderabad' 4. The Section Officer, Accounts Section, High Court at Hyderabad' 5. One CC to Sri Vijay B Paropkari, Advocate (OPUC) 6. Two CCs to GP for Revenue, High Court at Hyderabad (OUT)
7. Two CD CoPies Mvj,&am
<"
HIGH COURT
DATED: 3011012026
/.
t
I
1 tt E SIA
)
(J
ORDER
CC.No. 2900 of 2025
ALLOWING THE GC
/V\
U 1.P ltG .l^ -t 1,,
z
0 6 l'lo\J 202fi
* D
-(\ f5-IATC t\
o .L *