Smt Seetha v. The Mangement of Karnataka Power Transmission
- Court
- High Court of Karnataka
- Date of judgment
- 28 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice H.T. Narendra Prasad
- Case number
- WP No. 17067 of 2018
- Result
- ALLOWED AND REMANDED
- Subject
- Labour
Full judgment
-1HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 28TH DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.T. NARENDRA PRASAD WRIT PETITION NO. 17067 OF 2018 (L-TER) BETWEEN: SMT SEETHA W/O. SRI H. MURALIDHAR AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS R/AT NO.132, TELECOM LAYOUT NEAR GANESH TEMPLE SUNKADAKATTE, BENGALURU - 560091. …PETITIONER (BY SRI. L MURALIDHAR PESHWA., ADVOCATE) AND: 1.
THE MANAGEMENT OF KARNATAKA POWER TRANSMISSION CORPORATION LIMITED REP. BY ITS MANAGING DIRECTOR HEAD OFFICE: CAUVERY BHAVAN K.G. ROAD, BENGALURU - 560009.
2.
THE GENERAL MANAGER KARNATAKA POWER TRANSMISSION CORPORATION LIMITED HEAD OFFICE: CAUVERY BHAVAN K.G. ROAD, BENGALURU - 560009.
…RESPONDENTS (BY SRI.H V DEVARAJU, ADVOCATE FOR R1 & R2) THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLES 226 AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO CALL FOR THE RECORDS PERTAINING TO THE AWARD DATED: 15.5.2017 MADE IN REFERENCE NO.32/2009 ON THE FILE OF
-2HC-KAR
THE PRESIDING OFFICER, PRINCIPAL BENGALURU VIDE ANNEXURE-L AND ETC.
LABOUR
COURT,
THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING IN ‘B’ GROUP, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER: CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE H.T. NARENDRA PRASAD ORAL ORDER
1.
This writ petition is filed under Articles 226 and 227
of the Constitution of India, challenging the award dated 15.05.2017 passed by the Labour Court, Bengaluru, in Reference No.32/2009, whereby the reference has been dismissed.
2.
For the sake of convenience, the parties are referred
to by their respective rankings before the Labour Court. The petitioner herein is referred to as the First Party, and the respondents are referred to as the Second Party.
3.
The brief facts of the case are that the First Party
was appointed as a Junior Assistant on compassionate grounds in the Karnataka Power Transmission Corporation Limited (for short, ‘KPTCL’) w.e.f. 26.09.1980. While she
-3HC-KAR
was working as an Assistant in the 6th Sub-Division at Sunkadakatte, Bengaluru, certain charges were levelled against her in 2005, alleging that she had remitted an amount lesser than the amount collected, tampered with entries
in
temporary permanent
counterfoils
of
challans,
misappropriation
of
Rs.1,23,20,665/-
misappropriation
of
committed and
Rs.35,55,805/-.
Accordingly, a charge memo dated 03.12.2005 was issued to her. Being dissatisfied with her reply to the charge memo, the disciplinary authority initiated a departmental enquiry. The Enquiry Officer submitted a report based on the Special Audit Report, holding that the charges levelled against her were proved. On the basis of the said report, the disciplinary authority dismissed the First Party from service by order dated 01.09.2007. Aggrieved by the order of dismissal, the First Party raised an industrial dispute, which was referred by the State Government to the Labour Court, Bengaluru, in Reference No.32/2009. The Labour Court,
by
impugned
award
dated
15.05.2017,
-4HC-KAR
dismissed the reference. Being aggrieved by the said award, the First Party has approached this Court.
4.
Learned
counsel
appearing
for
First
Party
contended that the Labour Court had rightly held that the departmental enquiry conducted by the Second Party was not fair and proper, thereby placing the burden on the management to prove the charges levelled against the First Party. However, while adjudicating the dispute on merits, the Labour Court relied solely on the alleged admission made by the First Party in the apology letter dated 22.06.2005, marked as Ex.M-40, and proceeded to hold that the charges against her stood proved. The First Party had categorically deposed that her signature on Ex.M-40 had been obtained forcibly and that she had admitted to a shortage of only Rs.1,21,878/- upon being persuaded by the officials. Except for Ex.M-40, the Second Party had neither produced any other relevant records nor
-5HC-KAR
adduced
sufficient
evidence
to
establish
alleged
misappropriation. 4.1. Learned counsel further contended that the Labour Court had recorded a finding of misappropriation to the tune of more than Rs.35,00,000/- based on the Special Audit Report. Despite a specific direction issued by
Labour
Court
to
produce
relevant
records
pertaining to the charges levelled against the First Party, the Second Party failed to produce the same. In the absence of such records, the Labour Court was not justified in concluding that the charges against the First Party had been proved. 4.2. Learned counsel further submitted that the evidence adduced on behalf of the Second Party disclosed that the First Party was not solely responsible for the remittance of cash and that two other employees were also facing similar allegations. Nevertheless, the Labour Court erroneously held the First Party alone responsible for the alleged misappropriation. The specific case of the First
-6HC-KAR
Party was that she had remitted the cash collected at the counter
and
was
unaware
of
any
misappropriation,
particularly when the keys to the cash box were also accessible to the other officials. It was contended that the Labour Court had failed to consider these material aspects. 4.3. Lastly, learned counsel submitted that a criminal case in C.C.No.36085/2010 had been registered against the First Party and two other officials on the basis of the same allegations. The witnesses examined in the criminal case
were
also
witnesses
in
departmental
proceedings. Subsequently, the First Party and the other officials were acquitted by order dated 03.09.2024. At the time of passing the impugned award, the criminal case was still pending. On these grounds, learned counsel sought to set aside the impugned award and allow the writ petition.
5.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the Second
Party submitted that the First Party had herself admitted
-7HC-KAR
in writing, through Ex.M-40, that there was a shortage of Rs.1,21,878/-. It was contended that, in view of the said admission regarding the shortage, no further documents were necessary to establish her misconduct. Learned counsel further submitted that the Special Audit Report clearly
established
misappropriation
of
more
than
Rs.35,00,000/- by the First Party and that the examination of
Deputy
Collector
of
Accounts
had
further
substantiated the allegations. It was also contended that the First Party had been acquitted in the criminal case on the benefit of doubt and that such acquittal could not, by itself,
invalidate
departmental
proceedings.
Accordingly, learned counsel sought dismissal of the writ petition.
6.
Heard the learned counsel for the parties and
perused the writ papers.
7.
It is not in dispute that, while the First Party was
working as an Assistant in the 6th Sub-Division at
-8HC-KAR
Sunkadakatte,
Bengaluru,
a
charge
memo
dated
03.12.2005 was issued to her and two other officials, namely,
Sri.M.Devaraj,
Accounts
Officer,
and
Sri.Puttaswamy, Assistant Accounts Officer, in connection with the alleged misappropriation of funds. The articles of charge levelled against the First Party and the other two officials, as contained in the charge memo, read as follows: ARTICLES OF CHARGES 1. You, Smt.Seetha have been working as Assistant (now under suspension) in N-6 Sub-Division, BESCOM, Bangalore from 14.01.2003 to 22.06.2005. Though you were expected to carry out the duties of the General Cashier of the Sub-Division as stipulated in Para 42.01, 42.06, 43.08 (f to i), 44.04, 45.01, 46.03, 50.02, 50.04 to 50.08 of KEB Accounts Manual Volume I and Sl.No.4 under Activity 6: Cash section work of KPTCL Working Instructions Manual Sub Division, You have failed to do so. You have committed the acts of i) Remitting lesser amount than the actual amount collected and to be remitted into the Bank and tampering the entries made in the counter foil of the challan ii) Making fictitious entries in the cash book and denomination registers.
-9HC-KAR
iii) Using bogus pass sheets to support the entries made in respect of remittance. iv) Temporary misappropriation of Rs.1,23,20,665/and permanent misappropriation of Rs.35,55,805/-. v) Not pasting the Counter foil of challans, after remittance in the remittance book. vi) Not tallying the figures of closing balance of cash in the cash Register and in the denomination register. vii) Not signing cash book 08.03.2005 and 10.03.2005.
on
15.11.2003,
viii) Not signing in the denomination register on 22 days. The exact dates, reference, quantum of amount in respect of all the acts referred to item (i) to (viii) have been furnished in the Special Audit Report enclosed to this notice. Your above said acts which are grave in nature are misconduct as per Regulation 3(1) (i), (ii) and (iii) and item no.(i), (vii), (xviii) of Annexure-B read with Regulation 33 of KEB Employees' Service (Conduct) Regulation 1988.
II. You, Sri.N.Devaraj, Accounts Officer, were working as Assistant Accounts Officer (Cash Officer) in N-6 Sub-Division, BESCOM, Bangalore from 01.11.2002 to 07.07.2004. As a cash Officer, you were responsible for carrying out the duties as stipulated in para 50.09 to 51.03 of KEB Accounts Manual volume 1 and Sl.No.4&5 of Activity 6: Cash section work of KPTCL Working Instructions Manual
- 10 HC-KAR
Sub- Division. But you have failed to observe the following acts of Smt.Seetha, General Cashier. i) Remitting lesser amount than the actual amount collected and to be remitted into the bank and tampering the entries made in the counter foil of the challan. ii) Making fictitious entries of remitance in the cash book and denomination registers. iii) Using bogus pass sheets to support the entries made in respect of remittance. iv) Temporary misappropriation misappropriation of cash.
and
permanent
v) Not pasting the Counter foil of challans, after remittance in the remittance book. vi) Not tallying the figures of closing balance of cash in the cash Register and in the denomination register. vii) Not signing cash book on 15.11.2003. viii) Not signing in the denomination register on 15 days. The exact dates, reference, quantum of amount in respect of all the acts referred to item (i) to (viii) have been furnished in the Special Audit Report enclosed to this notice. Your above said failure amounts to misconduct as per Regulation 3(ii) and (iii), 2 and item (viii) of Annexure-B read with Regulation 33 of KEB Employees' Service (Conduct) Regulations 1988.
- 11 HC-KAR
III. You, Sri. Puttaswamaiah, Senior Assistant have been working as Cash Officer in N-6 Sub-Division, BESCOM, Bangalore from 08.07.2004 to 22.06.05. As a cash Officer, you were responsible for carrying out the duties as stipulated in para 50.09 to 51.03 of KEB Accounts Manual volume 1 and Sl.No.4&5 of Activity 6: Cash section work of KPTCL Working Instructions Manual Sub Division. But you have failed to observe the following acts of Smt.Seetha, General Cashier, N6 Sub Division, BESCOM, Bangalore. i) Remitting lesser amount than the actual amount collected and to be remitted into the bank and tampering the entries made in the counter foil of the challan. ii) Making fictitious entries of remittance in the cash book and denomination registers. iii) Using bogus pass sheets to support the entries made in respect of remittance. iv) Temporary misappropriation misappropriation of cash.
and
permanent
v) Not pasting the Counter foil of challans, after remittance in the remittance book. vi) Not tallying the figures of closing balance of cash in the cash Register and in the denomination register. vii) Not signing in the denomination register on 8 days. viii) Not signing cash book on 08.03.2005 and 10.03.2005. The exact dates, reference, quantum of amount in respect of all the acts referred to item (i) to (viii)
- 12 HC-KAR
have been furnished in the Special Audit Report enclosed to this notice. Your above said failure amounts to misconduct as per Regulation 3(ii) and (iii), 2 and item (viii) of Annexure-B read with Regulation 33 of KEB Employees' Service (Conduct) Regulations 1988.
8.
Being dissatisfied with the reply submitted by the
First Party to the charge memo, the Second Party initiated a departmental enquiry. The Enquiry Officer, relying on the Special Audit Report, held the charges levelled against the First Party to be proved. Based on the enquiry report, the disciplinary authority, by order dated 01.09.2007, dismissed the First Party from service. Insofar as the other two officials, namely, Sri M. Devaraj and Sri Puttaswamy, are concerned, minor penalties were imposed. Aggrieved by the order of dismissal, the First Party raised an industrial dispute, which was referred by the State Government to the Labour Court, Bengaluru, in Reference No.32/2009. The reference made reads as under:
- 13 HC-KAR
1.
DqÀ½vÀªÀUÀðzÀªÀgÁzÀ
ªÉÄB
PÀ£ÁðlPÀ
¥ÀªÀgï
mÁæ£ïì«ÄµÀ£ï
PÁ¥ÉÆðgÉõÀ£ï °; PÁªÉÃj ¨sÀªÀ£À, ¨ÉAUÀ¼ÀÆgÀÄ EªÀgÀÄ ²æÃªÀÄw ¹ÃvÁ, ªÀAiÀĸÀÄì 50 ªÀµÀð, £ÀA.21, PÉ.J.©. PÁélæð¸ï, gÁeÁf£ÀUÀgÀ, 2£Éà ¨ÁèPï,
¨ÉAUÀ¼ÀÆgÀÄ
EªÀjUÉ
DzÉñÀ
¸ÀASÉå:
PÀ«¥À椤/©53/©2114536/2005-06 ¢£ÁAPÀ:01-09-2007 PÉ®¸À¢AzÀ ªÀeÁUÉÆ½¹gÀĪÀÅzÀÄ £ÁåAiÀĸÀªÀÄävÀªÉÃ?
9.
On the basis of the pleadings of the parties, the
Labour Court, has framed the following issues: 1. Whether II party management proves that D.E. held against the Ist party was fair, proper and under natural justice? 2. whether the Ist party proves that the punishment imposed by the management is harsh, arbitrary and disproportionate to the alleged misconduct?
Addl. Issue No.1 was treated as preliminary issue
10.
To prove the case, First Party has examined herself
as WW-1 and marked 17 documents. The Second Party has examined 4 witnesses as MW-1 to 4 and marked 49 documents. After hearing the parties, the Labour Court
- 14 HC-KAR
has answered the Reference No.1 in the affirmative, Additional/preliminary issue No.1 in the negative and Reference No.2 as per the final order.
Consequently,
dismissed the reference.
11.
Since there were allegations against the First Party of
tampering with ledger entries, she filed an application before the Labour Court seeking production of the ledger and other relevant documents. The Labour Court, by order dated 02.09.2015, directed the Second Party to produce the said documents. However, the documents were not produced. To
prove
charges,
Second Party
examined its witnesses. MW-1 has categorically stated that all three officials were responsible for handling the cash and that the keys to the cash box were accessible to all three officials. The Labour Court, however, solely on the basis of the admission allegedly made by the First Party in Ex.M-40 that she had not remitted Rs.1,21,878/to the cash chest, which was found to be short, concluded
- 15 HC-KAR
that she had misappropriated the amount. Further, relying on the Special Audit Report, the Labour Court concluded that
there
was
misappropriation
of
more
than
Rs.35,00,000/-. The Labour Court has not discussed the evidence of MW-1 to MW-4 in its award. It is also relevant to
note
that
order
of
acquittal
passed
in
C.C.No.36085/2010 was not available before the Labour Court, as the criminal case was pending at the time of passing the impugned award.
12.
In view of the above facts and circumstances of the
case, this Court is of the opinion that the matter requires to be remitted back to the Labour Court to reconsider the matter afresh in accordance with law.
13.
Accordingly, the following order: ORDER a)
The writ petition is allowed.
- 16 HC-KAR
b)
The impugned award dated 15.05.2017 passed by the Labour Court, Bengaluru, in Reference No.32/2009, is hereby set aside.
c)
The matter is remitted to the Labour Court, Bengaluru,
for
fresh
consideration
in
accordance with law. d)
The parties shall not be permitted to adduce any additional evidence, and the matter shall be decided on the basis of the evidence already available on record.
e)
The Labour Court shall reconsider the matter afresh,
taking
into
consideration
observations made hereinabove and the order of
acquittal
dated
03.09.2024
passed
in
C.C.No.36085/2010, and shall dispose of the reference within four months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
(H.T. NARENDRA PRASAD) JUDGE
DM LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 14