Smti Imlimenla and 97 Ors v. State of Nagaland and 6 Ors
- Court
- Gauhati High Court
- Date of judgment
- 1 November 2026
- Judge
- Justice Robin Phukan
- Case number
- WP(C) No. 241 of 2025
- Result
- Dismissed
- Acts & sections
- Article 226 Constitution
- Subject
- Service
Full judgment
Page No.# 1/106 GAHC020008312025
2026:GAU-NL:601
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) KOHIMA BENCH Case No. : WP(C)/241/2025 SMTI IMLIMENLA AND 97 ORS ADDRESS- PWD (R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI, MOKOKCHUNG, NAGALAND, MB - 9612569846. 2: SMTI MANGYANGINLA AGE-53 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 3: SMTI ASANGLA AGE-29 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 4: SMTI IMNASANGLA AGE-29 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 5: SHRI MEYISOSANG AGE-39 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG
Page No.# 2/106
6: SHRI IMLISUNGIT AGE-39 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 7: SMTI WATIENLA AGE-44 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--7005650434. 8: SMTI TEMSUYANGLA AGE-44 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 9: SHRI RAMPRAPU SEN AGE-42 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 10: SHRI SATEMTOZUNG AGE-42 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 11: SHRI KAVRAT SEN BENGALI AGE-42 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 12: SHRI AOMEREN PONGER AGE-42 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI
Page No.# 3/106 MOKOKCHUNG 13: SHRI SIMON AGE-32 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--9378131397. 14: SMTI IMTIRENLA AGE-32 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 15: SHRI KAMAL AGE-29 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--600944967. 16: SHRI ALEMLEPDEN AGE-29 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 17: SHRI RAMAN AGE-40 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--7005741681 18: SMTI ARENJUNGLA AGE-40 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG
Page No.# 4/106 19: SHRI GOBEN AGE-40 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 20: SHRI TSUKNUNGTOSHI AGE-40 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 21: SHRI TALI AGE-45 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--8414978390 22: SHRI PURLEPZUK AGE-45 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 23: SHRI TAKUM AGE-48 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--9383086195 24: SHRI TATONGLIBA AGE-48 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 25: SHRI TINU AGE-25 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI
Page No.# 5/106 MOKOKCHUNG MB--6009785117. 26: SHRI SOWALEMBA AGE-25 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 27: SHRI KIKAMEREN AGE-55 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--9862369356. 28: SHRI SAMANUKSHI AGE-55 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. 29: SHRI BENDANGMEREN AGE-49 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. MB--9612531009. 30: SHRI TIAYANGER AIER AGE-49 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. 31: SHRI TEMSUWATI AGE-53 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. MB--9089244368.
Page No.# 6/106
32: SHRI KIKALEMBA JAMIR AGE-53 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. 33: SHRI SASHIMONGBA AGE-49 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. MB--8413939953. 34: SHRI IMTILUIN AGE-49 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. 35: SHRI PREMNATH AGE-51 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. MB--9862652478. 36: SHRI IMSUWAR AGE-51 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. 37: SHRI TONGZUK AGE-50 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. MB--962705883. 38: SHRI NOKCHATEMJEN AGE-50
Page No.# 7/106 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. 39: SHRI MERENJUNGBA AGE-58 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. MB--9612506575. 40: SHRI MEYIPOKYIM AGE-58 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. 41: SHRI PANGJUNG AGE-52 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. MB--7085898700. 42: SMTI IMTITULA AGE-52 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. 43: SHRI ASANGBA AGE-51 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. MB--7628844993. 44: SHRI ALEMYANGER AGE-51 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG
Page No.# 8/106 NAGALAND. 45: SHRI AKOKBA AGE-46 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. MB--8974390642. 46: SHRI MATSUNGTEMJEN AGE-46 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 47: SHRI LANU AO AGE-34 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--7005151911. 48: SHRI TIASOBA AGE-34 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 49: SHRI TINGPO KONYAK AGE-46 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--8798340374. 50: SHRI SUTSUNGTOSHI AGE-46 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 51: SHRI LIMATOSHI
Page No.# 9/106 AGE-33 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--8787637173. 52: SHRI SHILUWATI AGE-33 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 53: SHRI WATI AGE-50 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 54: SMTI SENDENYALA AGE-50 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 55: SHRI RENDI AGE-39 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--8415945101. 56: SHRI MOAAKUM AGE-39 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 57: SHRI YASHI AGE-37 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG
Page No.# 10/106 MB--9612943658. 58: SHRI ARENSHILU AGE-37 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 59: SHRI TALI AGE-51 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--936621068. 60: SHRI ALIMEREN AGE-51 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 61: SHRI RENDINUKBA AGE-55 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--6009116715. 62: SMTI IMLIMONGLA AGE-55 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 63: SHRI CHUNGTINUNGBA AGE-52 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--8974098886.
Page No.# 11/106 64: SHRI WATITOSHI AGE-52 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 65: SHRI SARI AGE-49 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--7005725677. 66: SMTI NUNGSHIMENLA AGE-49 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 67: SHRI CHITTEN AGE-60 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--986251910. 68: SHRI CHONGPONGCHIDEN AGE-60 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 69: SHRI SIMON AGE-56 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--6009857329. 70: SHRI SAJUNG AGE-56
Page No.# 12/106 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 71: SHRI LIMABA AGE-56 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--8974271352 72: SHRI TEMJENMAR AGE-56 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 73: SHRI TOSHI AGE-46 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--7005598230 74: SHRI MARTUBA AGE-46 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 75: SHRI LIMA AGE-55 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--8974271352. 76: SHRI ALEMLILA AGE-55 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG
Page No.# 13/106
77: SHRI CHUBA AGE-36 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--8119927882. 78: SHRI SHIKASHE L AGE-36 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 79: SHRI KORALEMBA AGE-44 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--9862081240. 80: SHRI LEKOKIMLA AGE-44 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 81: SHRI RUBEN AGE-51 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--8732094349. 82: SHRI LEKOKLEMBA AGE-51 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 83: SHRI LANUSANGBA AO AGE-38
Page No.# 14/106 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--7630003825. 84: SHRI TONGPANGMEREN AGE-38 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 85: SMTI ALIKALA AGE-53 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--6009975137. 86: SMTI YASHIZUNGLA AGE-53 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 87: SHRI SUNGJEM AGE-55 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB--9862081240. 88: SHRI SUNGJEMONGBA @SUNGJEM AGE-55 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 89: SHRI SUTSUNG AGE-63 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG
Page No.# 15/106 90: SHRI SUTSUNGKABA AGE-63 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 91: SHRI M. SUNEP AGE-39 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 92: SHRI T. MERENKABA AGE-39 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 93: SHRI MARTOSHI AGE-52 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB-7005010229 94: SHRI LEPZUNGCHIBA AGE-52 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 95: SMTI ALILA AGE-51 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB-8413887061. 96: SMTI IMNASANGLA AGE-51
Page No.# 16/106 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG 97: SMTI MEYICHILA AGE-38 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG MB-7627946721. 98: SMTI ALEMCHUBA AGE-38 ADDRESS- PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROAD DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG VERSUS STATE OF NAGALAND AND 6 ORS THROUGH THE CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF NAGALAND, KOHIMA. PINCODE-797001. 2:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF NAGALAND DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL AND ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS DEPARTMENT. 3:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF NAGALAND WORKS AND HOUSING DEPARTMENT KOHIMA. PINCODE 797001. 4:THE FINANCE COMMISSIONER KOHIMA.PINCODE-797001. 5:THE ENGINEER-IN-CHIEF NPWD KOHIMA. PINCODE 797001. 6:THE CHIEF ENGINEER
Page No.# 17/106 PWD(R AND B) KOHIMA.PINCODE 797001. 7:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD(R AND B) FEEDER ROADS DIVISION TULI MOKOKCHUNG NAGALAND. PINCODE-79861 Advocate for the Petitioner CHANG
: SUPONGWATI WALLING, R ATSULA KIPS,T SEKMOU
Advocate for the Respondent : GOVT ADV NL,
Linked Case : WP(C)/240/2025 SHRI MERAIKAM@MARAIKAMBOU AND 448 2: SMTI KILAMCILE AGE-41 YEARS 3: SMTYI DZUVISANUO AGE- 41 YEARS 4: SHRI SAMKUBE AGE- 60 YEARS
Page No.# 18/106 5: SHRI AZIUBE AGE- 29 YEARS 6: SHRI ILAMCUBE AGE- 55 YEARS 7: SHRI IGANGHEING AGE- 55 YEARS 8: SHRI DAJANBO AGE- 55 YEARS 9: SHRI NAMJIUWI AGE- 55 YEARS 10: SHRI IRANGTOLE AGE- 39 YEARS NAGALAND. 11: SHRI IPEURAILA AGE- 39 YEARS
Page No.# 19/106 12: SHRI MEZAIBO AGE- 42 YEARS 13: SHRI SENTINARO OZUKUM AGE- 42 YEARS 14: SMTI.THANGKAMLAK AGE- 45 YEARS 15: SHRI PARANGLUNGBO AGE- 45 YEARS 16: SHRI KAULON AGE- 60 YEARS 17: SHRI SANGPOLONG AGE- 28 YEARS 18: SMTI ARAI AGE- 40 YEARS
Page No.# 20/106 19: SMTI ATSOLE WETSAH AGE- 40 YEARS 20: SMTI DISONG AGE- 52 YEARS 21: SMTI HERAKU AGE- 52 YEARS 22: SHRI WINITALAK AGE- 53 YEARS 23: SHRI DILYN NEWMAI AGE- 53 YEARS 24: SMTI LUNGHITALAK AGE- 34 YEARS 25: SHRI MOSE NEWMEI
Page No.# 21/106 AGE- 34 YEARS 26: SHRI AVIKA AGE- 37 YEARS 27: SHRI KHETOKA SHOHE AGE- 37 YEARS 28: SHRI YEHEKU AGE- 31 YEARS 29: SMTI KAHULI AGE- 31 YEARS 30: SHRI YEKHETO AGE- 53 YEARS 31: SMTI KHEBOLI SHOHE AGE- 53 YEARS
Page No.# 22/106 32: SMTI SAMPUNGLE AGE- 54 YEARS 33: SMTI KIPUILE NRING AGE- 54 YEARS 34: SHRI WANGBUI AGE- 31 YEARS 35: SMTI DEISUALE NRIAME AGE- 31 YEARS 36: SHRI SANENTIBA AGE- 36 YEARS 37: SHRI ALENG KHAYI AGE- 36 YEARS 38: SHRI BABALRAI AGE- 60 YEARS
Page No.# 23/106
39: SHRI KENGDINLUNG AGE- 28 YEARS 40: SHRI WIDI ZELIANG AGE- 49 YEARS 41: SMTI AMEN AGE- 49 YEARS 42: SHRI AWANGBOU AGE- 34 YEARS 43: SHRI ANATO ACHUMI AGE- 34 YEARS 44: SHRI HAUYI AGE- 36 YEARS 45: SHRI LEVILIU AGE- 36 YEARS
Page No.# 24/106 46: SHRI AWOTO AGE- 53 YEARS 47: SMTI ISIZEULE AGE- 53 YEARS 48: SHRI MALATI AGE- 60 YEARS 49: SHRI KAISIBUILE AGE- 26 YEARS 50: SHRI DAYA AGE- 58 YEARS 51: SHRI DEVO VESE AGE- 58 YEARS 52: SHRI NINGDAI AGE- 36 YEARS
Page No.# 25/106 53: SHRI MANTALE AGE- 36 YEARS 54: SHRI RAJ BAHADUR AGE- 36 YEARS 55: SHRI PADAM BAHADUR AGE- 36 YEARS 56: SHRI HAUKUTHONG AGE- 60 YEARS 57: SHRI MATHIUNING AGE- 25 YEARS 58: SHRI HAILIPOU AGE- 36 YEARS 59: SHRI BURNICE CHISHI AGE- 36 YEARS
Page No.# 26/106 60: SHRI ANGAMPOU AGE- 59 YEARS 61: SHRI JOSEPH AGE- 59 YEARS 62: SHRI THOMAS AGE- 49 YEARS 63: SHRI AMOS AGE- 49 YEARS 64: SHRI ISIANGBE AGE- 39 YEARS 65: SHRI PAURAMTEING AGE- 39 YEARS 66: SHRI NAMKAI AGE- 33 YEARS
Page No.# 27/106 67: SHRI NAMHINGTING AGE- 33 YEARS 68: SHRI HEZUILO AGE- 49 YEARS 69: SHRI ZUHEI AGE- 49 YEARS 70: SHRI RAMBAHADUR AGE- 60 YEARS 71: SHRI RAMPAUYING AGE- 27 YEARS 72: SHRI NAMAI AGE- 50 YEARS 73: SHRI KHANYALO KATH
Page No.# 28/106 AGE- 50 YEARS 74: SHRI HAIKING AGE- 37 YEARS 75: SHRI HANCHULO KATH AGE- 37 YEARS 76: SHRI IZKANG AGE- 63 YEARS 77: SHRI KIEGUM AGE- 63 YEARS 78: SHRI BUDUBAHADUR AGE- 59 YEARS 79: SHRI RUOKO AGE- 59 YEARS
Page No.# 29/106 80: SHRI TAMANG AGE- 30 YEARS 81: SHRI SUIZWAYING AGE- 30 YEARS 82: SHRI YANGER AGE- 49 YEARS 83: SHRI IBADING AGE- 49 YEARS 84: SHRI AMAMAI AGE- 46 YEARS 85: SHRI PEILEU AGE- 46 YEARS 86: SHRI SUMSAI AGE- 39 YEARS
Page No.# 30/106
87: SMTI KISUILUNGLE AGE- 39 YEARS 88: SHRI T R ALUM AGE- 34 YEARS 89: SHRI POUKHULUNG AGE- 34 YEARS 90: SHRI TEKA BAHADUR AGE- 31 YEARS 91: SHRI RONGSENNUKSHI AGE- 31 YEARS 92: SHRI BHAGABAN OZUKUM AGE- 41 YEARS 93: SHRI BENDANGJUNGSHI OZUKUM AGE- 41 YEARS
Page No.# 31/106 94: SHRI ACHUNG AGE- 59 YEARS 95: SHRI HAINSUNG AGE- 59 YEARS 96: SHRI SEREH AGE- 30 YEARS 97: SHRI DISAPPE CHAMLAK AGE- 30 YEARS 98: SHRI MANGAL AGE- 41 YEARS 99: SEHKHOLAL KHONGSAI AGE- 41 YEARS 100: SHRI WIPI AGE- 42 YEARS
Page No.# 32/106 101: SHRI PUIKAILIU AGE- 42 YEARS 102: SHRI AGONG AGE- 42 YEARS 103: SHRI KUZIBE AGE- 42 YEARS 104: SHRI INDU@IMDULUNGBE AGE- 50 YEARS 105: SHRI ITUKANG AGE- 32 YEARS 106: SHRI KEDIGUMHEING AGE- 32 YEARS 107: SHRI MIHIA AGE- 30 YEARS
Page No.# 33/106 108: SHRI LAMKHOMANG SITLHOU AGE- 30 YEARS 109: SHRI ILIABE AGE- 35 YEARS 110: SHRI ABAM NRIAME AGE- 35 YEARS 111: SHRI PAUSAP AGE- 54 YEARS 112: SHRI ILUBILE KAURING AGE- 54 YEARS 113: SHRI DINGAU AGE- 60 YEARS 114: SHRI DILEUCU AGE- 35 YEARS
Page No.# 34/106 115: SHRI KENINGBE AGE- 35 YEARS 116: SHRI ILEUCU AGE- 38 YEARS 117: SHRI DEIWANGBE AGE- 38 YEARS 118: SHRI HEIBANG AGE- 38 YEARS 119: KEBAYING AGE- 38 YEARS 120: SHRI ITEICANGBE AGE- 32 YEARS 121: SHRI IDALUNG
Page No.# 35/106 AGE- 38 YEARS 122: SHRI NAMRO AGE- 38 YEARS 123: SHRI NDILANG AGE- 50 YEARS 124: SHRI DEKHAIBE AGE- 50 YEARS 125: SHRI DEDINLANG AGE- 45 YEARS 126: SHRI AKANG AGE- 45 YEARS 127: SHRI DEDRUNG AGE- 47 YEARS
Page No.# 36/106 128: SHRI ILUNGNIM AGE- 47 YEARS 129: SHRI AROKBE AGE- 50 YEARS 130: SHRI KEYINGAULUNG AGE- 50 YEARS 131: SHRI HEITO AGE- 45 YEARS 132: SHRI HEILAMDING AGE- 45 YEARS 133: SHRI ITEIHANG AGE- 41 YEARS 134: SHRI NEIKAM AGE- 41 YEARS
Page No.# 37/106
135: SHRI ADAM@ADAU ZELIANG AGE- 41 YEARS 136: SHRI KENLUMBO AGE- 32 YEARS 137: SHRI ZERANGLE AGE- 32 YEARS 138: SHRI RANGRANG AGE- 57 YEARS 139: SHRI IRANGSWANG AGE- 57 YEARS 140: SHRI NAMKENGAU@ NAMKWETNGAU AGE- 48 YEARS 141: SHRI SUIDI@ SUIYIDI AGE- 60 YEARS
Page No.# 38/106 142: SHRI RAJU AGE- 60 YEARS 143: SHRI HAOSAT AGE- 25 YEARS 144: SHRI RELUICHULE AGE- 64 YEARS 145: SMTI PAIKULE AGE- 64 YEARS 146: SHRI HANGCHEO AGE- 45 YEARS 147: SHRI KEKIECTLUNGBE AGE- 45 YEARS 148: SHRI ITINGONG AGE- 60 YEARS
Page No.# 39/106 149: SHRI LUNGSIULUNG AGE- 53 YEARS 150: SHRI TAKHAMBO KAURINTA AGE- 53 YEARS 151: SHRI AHOTIUNG AGE- 54 YEARS 152: SHRI PAHUTLUNGBO AGE- 54 YEARS 153: SHRI ATOKA AGE- 65 YEARS 154: SHRI OTOVA KAPPO AGE- 65 YEARS 155: SHRI AHEZHE AGE- 44 YEARS
Page No.# 40/106 156: SHRI A NIUTO AGE- 44 YEARS 157: SHRI NIHEZE AGE- 56 YEARS 158: SHRI KHUVUTO AGE- 56 YEARS 159: SHRI NISHETO AGE- 58 YEARS 160: SHRI PHUTOI SWU AGE- 58 YEARS 161: SHRI PERA AGE- 60 YEARS 162: SHRI KICHU AGE- 30 YEARS
Page No.# 41/106 163: SHRI HANGCIAM AGE- 60 YEARS 164: SHRI HIAGANG AGE- 40 YEARS 165: SMTI RELUILUNGLE AGE- 40 YEARS 166: SHRI SAMZAI AGE- 34 YEARS 167: SHRI IKUGWANGBE HEGEU AGE- 34 YEARS 168: SHRI KIELIA AGE- 35 YEARS 169: SHRI IKIELIALE
Page No.# 42/106 AGE- 35 YEARS 170: SHRI PAUBAM AGE- 35 YEARS 171: SMTI RAMDEILE AGE- 35 YEARS 172: SHRI SUBA AGE- 41 YEARS 173: SHRI MIREUSING NSA AGE- 41 YEARS 174: SHRI RANGTEI AGE- 53 YEARS 175: SHRI LUNGRANGTEI AGE- 53 YEARS
Page No.# 43/106 176: SHRI SUBHAS AGE- 60 YEARS 177: SHRI PAUZIERANG AGE- 28 YEARS 178: SHRI AZUIDI AGE- 34 YEARS 179: SHRI KENZEUDING NSA AGE- 34 YEARS 180: SHRI PANDABULE AGE- 45 YEARS 181: SHRI SAMZAILE MBUNGTSA AGE- 45 YEARS 182: SHRI DIPU AGE- 45 YEARS
Page No.# 44/106
183: SHRI PAURAMHUNG AGE- 45 YEARS 184: SHRI GAUDA AGE- 38 YEARS 185: SHRI IKWALUBE AGE- 38 YEARS 186: SHRI ABALE AGE- 60 YEARS 187: SHRI KELEZAILE AGE- 30 YEARS 188: SHRI BIR BAHADUR AGE- 53 YEARS 189: SMTI ILAMGUILE AGE- 53 YEARS
Page No.# 45/106 190: SHRI HECHIRANG AGE- 43 YEARS 191: SHRI MAHEIGUM NDANG AGE- 43 YEARS 192: SHRI BAITI AGE- 54 YEARS 193: SHRI ARANGBE AGE- 54 YEARS 194: SHRI PUIDI ZELIANG AGE- 38 YEARS 195: SHRI RANGKOLUNG AGE- 38 YEARS 196: SHRI RANGRANG AGE- 45 YEARS
Page No.# 46/106 197: SHRI KIULANGBO AGE- 45 YEARS 198: SHRI HOLITO AGE- 45 YEARS 199: SHRI REHUNGLUNGBE AGE- 45 YEARS 200: SHRI RAMLIT AGE- 35 YEARS 201: SMTI ARANGNA AGE- 35 YEARS 202: SHRI RAMBAHADUR AGE- 35 YEARS 203: SHRI HIAZULUNG AGE- 35 YEARS
Page No.# 47/106 204: SHRI KANGBUIBO AGE- 36 YEARS 205: SHRI KERANGLEUYIBE AGE- 36 YEARS 206: SHRI NAMSODI AGE- 58 YEARS 207: SHRI NAMSWADI AGE- 58 YEARS 208: SHRI TSIDWA AGE- 60 YEARS 209: SHRI IDATUI AGE- 39 YEARS 210: SHRI LALBANU AGE- 54 YEARS
Page No.# 48/106 211: SHRI KEHUNGRANGLE HENGAME AGE- 54 YEARS 212: SHRI ADOLE AGE- 60 YEARS 213: SHRI RAMA NAIK AGE- 31 YEARS 214: SHRI PEURANG AGE- 60 YEARS 215: SHRI IPEURANG RAMLYA AGE- 32 YEARS 216: SHRI SHARMA AGE- 57 YEARS 217: SHRI IRIEGONG
Page No.# 49/106 AGE- 37 YEARS 218: SHRI ANATHDU AGE- 59 YEARS 219: SHRI HAISUIYIBE AGE- 42 YEARS 220: SHRI NIPU AGE- 60 YEARS 221: SHRI KEDIPEU AGE- 38 YEARS 222: SHRI LUNGNA AGE- 52 YEARS 223: SMTI RELUICUILE AGE- 42 YEARS
Page No.# 50/106 224: SMTI AVINO AGE- 51 YEARS 225: SMTI AKWALIE AGE- 43 YEARS 226: SHRI ALOIBE AGE- 58 YEARS 227: SHRI KEYISOHEI AGE- 42 YEARS 228: SHRI SABAU AGE- 50 YEARS 229: SMTI INDULE AGE- 43 YEARS 230: SHRI RAMU AGE- 59 YEARS
Page No.# 51/106
231: SHRI TIAKBA AGE- 32 YEARS 232: SHRI IKIELU AGE- 57 YEARS 233: SHRI HANGLEIKAM AGE- 31 YEARS 234: SHRI ANIELE AGE- 62 YEARS 235: SMTI INGAURAILE AGE- 39 YEARS 236: SHRI SAMRANG AGE- 60 YEARS 237: SHRI SAMRANGBE AGE- 37 YEARS
Page No.# 52/106 238: SHRI GIMHEI AGE- 50 YEARS 239: SHRI KEYIREULUNG NDANG AGE- 39 YEARS 240: SMTI REENA AGE- 40 YEARS 241: SHRI PAUSUINGAU AGE- 32 YEARS 242: SHRI TRINATH AGE- 60 YEARS 243: SHRI NGIMHEILE AGE- 32 YEARS 244: SHRI MAHESH AGE- 60 YEARS
Page No.# 53/106 245: SHRI TABI ZELUI AGE- 46 YEARS 246: SHRI RAI BAHADUR AGE- 60 YEARS 247: SHRI RAMKU AGE- 59 YEARS 248: SHRI GWAKEY AGE- 60 YEARS 249: SHRI LAMYINA AGE- 35 YEARS 250: SHRI SUBHASH AGE- 59 YEARS 251: SHRI HEIGUILE AGE- 43 YEARS
Page No.# 54/106 252: SHRI GAUDHA AGE- 60 YEARS 253: SMTI KETAMLE AGE- 52 YEARS 254: SHRI CHUNCHUN AGE- 54 YEARS 255: SHRI NGAULUNA AGE- 45 YEARS 256: SHRI GOVINATH AGE- 60 YEARS 257: SMTI ADALE AGE- 52 YEARS 258: SHRI PAUHEIRANG AGE- 59 YEARS
Page No.# 55/106 259: SHRI HELUIPEU AGE- 50 YEARS 260: SHRI APWA AGE- 58 YEARS 261: SHRI KETEIBWALE AGE- 42 YEARS 262: SHRI ASAP@ANIN AGE- 50 YEARS 263: SHRI HAISODIBE AGE- 60 YEARS 264: SHRI NAMZEIRANG NDANG AGE- 38 YEARS 265: SHRI PAULAM
Page No.# 56/106 AGE- 35 YEARS 266: SHRI KANGZANGBE AGE- 32 YEARS 267: KEKUROIDING TERIENG AGE- 45 YEARS 268: SHRI BANGA AGE- 52 YEARS 269: SMTI ARINGLE AGE- 47 YEARS 270: SHRI IZIEDING AGE- 60 YEARS 271: SHRI GASILAKPE AGE- 40 YEARS
Page No.# 57/106 272: SHRI PAUZIE AGE- 53 YEARS 273: SMTI KEIZEULE AGE- 40 YEARS 274: SHRI NAMDAU@IDIRAIBE AGE- 51 YEARS 275: SHRI HEGONRAING AGE- 52 YEARS 276: SHRI PAUSUILE AGE- 42 YEARS 277: SHRI RATNA AGE- 52 YEARS 278: SHRI RACILUNGBE AGE- 40 YEARS
Page No.# 58/106
279: SHRI DABEPUL AGE- 52 YEARS 280: SHRI ISAPLOILIE AGE- 47 YEARS 281: SHRI IDETPETPE AGE- 56 YEARS 282: SMTI RANILIE AGE- 39 YEARS 283: SHRI NGAUBANG AGE- 55 YEARS 284: SHRI AGWELIE AGE- 38 YEARS 285: SHRI KEPELUNG AGE- 59 YEARS
Page No.# 59/106 286: SHRI KOLUNGBE AGE- 44 YEARS 287: SHRI. KENGIR PAULUNG AGE- 50 YEARS 288: SHRI HANGSIBE AGE- 50 YEARS 289: SHRI HOIRANGBE AGE- 51 YEARS 290: SHRI ISAPLUNGBE AGE- 51 YEARS 291: SHRI LUIKOBE AGE- 53 YEARS 292: SHRI KOGOIBE AGE- 49 YEARS
Page No.# 60/106 293: SHRI LEULAK AGE- 45 YEARS 294: SHRI LUNGKIAO AGE- 38 YEARS 295: SHRI HEINGAUNEULE AGE- 56 YEARS 296: SHRI NAMYISING AGE- 43 YEARS 297: SHRI HIAREUHEING AGE- 50 YEARS 298: SHRI ILAMHUBE AGE- 42 YEARS 299: SHRI INDUBUI AGE- 52 YEARS
Page No.# 61/106 300: SHRI NAMPUNGRING AGE- 32 YEARS 301: SHRI NAMPUNGRING AGE- 32 YEARS 302: SHRI SEILAI AGE- 47 YEARS 303: SHRI NSAMLU NEWME AGE- 32 YEARS 304: SHRI LAISET AGE- 59 YEARS 305: SMTI SISILE AGE- 32 YEARS 306: SHRI HUKIEBE AGE- 47 YEARS
Page No.# 62/106 307: SMTI APOMLE AGE- 35 YEARS 308: SHRI IDABUI AGE- 55 YEARS 309: SHRI MENGAILAK AGE- 33 YEARS 310: SMTI HEURANG AGE- 48 YEARS 311: SHRI HAILUNGRING CERAI AGE- 29 YEARS 312: SMTI HEIBEU AGE- 48 YEARS 313: SHRI IGUMHEILE
Page No.# 63/106 AGE- 38 YEARS 314: SHRI MERUT AGE- 54 YEARS 315: SHRI KEYIKANGLUNGBE CERAI AGE- 32 YEARS 316: SHRI ADING AGE- 59 YEARS 317: SHRI KIYIRANGBEU AGE- 54 YEARS 318: SHRI RAMDAGONG AGE- 48 YEARS 319: SHRI IZIE AGE- 40 YEARS
Page No.# 64/106 320: SHRI AVINO AGE- 56 YEARS 321: SHRI NAMDUN AGE- 55 YEARS 322: SHRI DAS AGE- 57 YEARS 323: SHRI KAIRITAN AGE- 48 YEARS 324: SHRI MUGHAPE AGE- 53 YEARS 325: SHRI LIALAK AGE- 50 YEARS 326: SHRI KELUNGTA AGE- 50 YEARS
Page No.# 65/106
327: SHRI MAISUANGDIN AGE- 25 YEARS 328: SHRI ILEU AGE- 60 YEARS 329: SMTI WILUNGSI AGE- 26 YEARS 330: SHRI KIKANG AGE- 46 YEARS 331: SHRI PUMAIZENG AGE- 33 YEARS 332: SHRI NAMKIE AGE- 47 YEARS 333: SHRI KIKOLUNG AGE- 37 YEARS
Page No.# 66/106 334: SHRI HOZIEZIN AGE- 45 YEARS 335: SHRI MIHIARANG AGE- 32 YEARS 336: SHRI HEIDO AGE- 50 YEARS 337: SHRI POKLEULUNG AGE- 48 YEARS 338: SHRI DINGAU AGE- 58 YEARS 339: SHRI ISALUNG AGE- 53 YEARS 340: SHRI RANSAM AGE- 44 YEARS
Page No.# 67/106 341: SHRI NDETHING AGE- 34 YEARS 342: SHRI ZUIGONG AGE- 60 YEARS 343: SHRI HEIKIA AGE- 59 YEARS 344: SHRI GOHIANG AGE- 50 YEARS 345: SHRI HEUSUANEING AGE- 34 YEARS 346: SHRI HAICHI AGE- 40 YEARS 347: SHRI KEYITARANG PUTLANG AGE- 32 YEARS
Page No.# 68/106 348: SHRI MAIDIN AGE- 60 YEARS 349: HUKENG NGUNG AGE- 60 YEARS 350: SHRI DIL BAHADUR AGE- 59 YEARS 351: SHRI LUNGKIU AGE- 47 YEARS 352: SHRI RAM KRISHNA AGE- 55 YEARS 353: SHRI KILENGLUNG AGE- 32 YEARS 354: SHRI MARACHAN AGE- 45 YEARS
Page No.# 69/106 355: SHRI ALAM LOTHA AGE- 38 YEARS 356: SHRI JOBIN AGE- 47 YEARS 357: SMTI WITHINSULE DOMTA AGE- 38 YEARS 358: SHRI VOTSO AGE- 57 YEARS 359: SHRI MAIRISIBO RENGMUNTA AGE- 57 YEARS 360: SHRI TINLUNG AGE- 46 YEARS 361: SHRI KEWIMENAI
Page No.# 70/106 AGE- 29 YEARS 362: SHRI HEIKUTUI AGE- 50 YEARS 363: SHRI NAMKWETEI AGE- 32 YEARS 364: SHRI IZIETEILU AGE- 48 YEARS 365: SHRI KIRAPA AGE- 33 YEARS 366: SHRI NAMDI AGE- 62 YEARS 367: SHRI IRAINEU AGE- 62 YEARS
Page No.# 71/106 368: SHRI KILUNGDI AGE- 50 YEARS 369: SHRI IREUGA AGE- 38 YEARS 370: SHRI BIN BAHADUR AGE- 58 YEARS 371: SHRI M JONNY SINGH AGE- 28 YEARS 372: SHRI PEREM AGE- 44 YEARS 373: SHRI CHAHUTHINBO AGE- 37 YEARS 374: SHRI SUDERSAN AGE- 50 YEARS
Page No.# 72/106
375: SHRI DITSOLO WETSAH AGE- 29 YEARS 376: SHRI BISWAS AGE- 55 YEARS 377: SMTI LUNGBUILIU DIALIAM AGE- 50 YEARS 378: SHRI GUMHEI AGE- 47 YEARS 379: SHRI WISISIAK AGE- 39 YEARS 380: SHRI DILIP AGE- 55 YEARS 381: SHRI N AZANBO AGE- 35 YEARS
Page No.# 73/106 382: SHRI DITIANG AGE- 52 YEARS 383: SHRI MEZITHUI AGE- 46 YEARS 384: SHRI JIBON AGE- 58 YEARS 385: SHRI AWANG AGE- 42 YEARS 386: SHRI NITON AGE-45 YEARS 387: SHRI OBED AGE- 33 YEARS 388: SHRI TENBO AGE- 55 YEARS
Page No.# 74/106 389: SHRI KHANMASALAK AGE- 48 YEARS 390: SHRI GANESH AGE- 60 YEARS 391: SHRI KIZAIBO AGE- 41 YEARS 392: SHRI LUNBO AGE- 52 YEARS 393: SHRI MESENWANG AGE- 27 YEARS 394: SHRI HINGTEU AGE- 63 YEARS 395: SHRI TAKNGEULE AGE- 63 YEARS
Page No.# 75/106 396: SHRI AGWANG AGE- 62 YEARS 397: SHRI T. YANPOTHUNG LOTHA AGE- 62 YEARS 398: SHRI NAMBEU AGE- 58 YEARS 399: SHRI SUIRANG AGE- 53 YEARS 400: SHRI IBUING AGE- 55 YEARS 401: SHRI HUNEI AGE- 45 YEARS 402: SHRI KHAMGE AGE- 64 YEARS
Page No.# 76/106 403: SHRI HAITUABUING AGE- 64 YEARS 404: SHRI TINGBAM AGE- 57 YEARS 405: SHRI ALAMBE AGE- 36 YEARS 406: SHRI AYEI AGE- 60 YEARS 407: SHRI NDALAK AGE- 53 YEARS 408: SHRI TEBAM AGE- 52 YEARS 409: SHRI PAUNEI
Page No.# 77/106 AGE- 44 YEARS 410: SHRI V. NGOUSI AGE- 45 YEARS 411: SHRI WIMESANNE NRAK AGE- 29 YEARS 412: SHRI DIRANG AGE- 55 YEARS 413: SHRI CHAMCHANGPUNE AGE- 42 YEARS 414: SHRI RACHI AGE- 51 YEARS 415: SHRI CHEMAICHA AGE- 33 YEARS
Page No.# 78/106 416: SHRI AKUANGBO AGE- 54 YEARS 417: SMTI RASUILULE AGE- 46 YEARS 418: SHRI METHUICHANIUNG AGE- 46 YEARS 419: SHRI MELUMBUI AGE- 33 YEARS 420: SHRI LUNGKIUBO AGE- 59 YEARS 421: SHRI THUNLAK AGE- 50 YEARS 422: SHRI CHANGTAI AGE- 60 YEARS
Page No.# 79/106
423: SHRI NRILUNG AGE- 27 YEARS 424: SHRI TUTUANG AGE- 55 YEARS 425: SHRI KUGGUMLU AGE- 43 YEARS 426: SHRI KICHUN AGE- 42 YEARS 427: SHRI NINGKAMLAKLE AGE- 32 YEARS 428: SHRI SAMDI AGE- 45 YEARS 429: SHRI REMINGLULE AGE- 38 YEARS
Page No.# 80/106 430: SHRI ZINTA AGE- 42 YEARS 431: SHRI KHUIZENGLU AGE- 38 YEARS 432: SHRI MICHEAL AGE- 57 YEARS 433: SHRI MERILAGE AGE- 56 YEARS 434: SHRI KENSUNG AGE- 45 YEARS 435: SHRI KUNGMAI AGE- 40 YEARS 436: SHRI NAIWANG AGE- 48 YEARS
Page No.# 81/106 437: SHRI RANGHUNG AGE- 38 YEARS 438: SHRI ZINGHA AGE- 64 YEARS 439: SHRI PELENGWINI AGE- 62 YEARS 440: SHRI WIRAIBO AGE- 55 YEARS 441: SHRI KHANGRAINGBO AGE- 48 YEARS 442: SHRI IGALUNGBO AGE- 60 YEARS 443: SHRI SHANTIBO AGE- 55 YEARS
Page No.# 82/106 444: SHRI KEDILUNGWANG AGE- 35 YEARS 445: SHRI KEDILUNGGONG AGE- 35 YEARS 446: SHRI MENCHOBE AGE- 59 YEARS 447: SHRI NAMCHOBE AGE- 59 YEARS 448: SHRI GWANEU AGE- 43 YEARS 449: SHRI GWAMNO AGE- 43 YEARS VERSUS STATE OF NAGALAND AND 6 ORS
Page No.# 83/106 REPRESENTED THE CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF NAGALAND KOHIMA. PIN-797001. 2:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF NAGALAND DEPARTMENT OF PERSONNEL AND ADMINISTRATIVE REFORMS DEPARTMENT. KOHIMA. PIN-797001 3:THE COMMISSIONER AND SECRETARY TO THE GOVERNMENT OF NAGALAND WORKS AND HOUSING DEPARTMENT KOHIMA.PIN-797001. 4:THE FINANCE COMMISSIONER KOHIMA. PIN-797001. 5:THE ENGINEER-IN-CHIEF NPWD KOHIMA. PIN-797001. 6:THE CHIEF ENGINEER PWD(R AND B) KOHIMA. PIN-797001. 7:THE EXECUTIVE ENGINEER PWD(R AND B) PEREN DIVISION.PIN-797101.
-----------Advocate for : SUPONGWATI WALLING Advocate for : GOVT ADV NL appearing for STATE OF NAGALAND AND 6 ORS
Page No.# 84/106 BEFORE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ROBIN PHUKAN
Date on which judgment is reserved
:-
01/09/26
Date of pronouncement of judgment
:-
02/11/26
Whether the pronouncement is of the operative part of the judgment?
:-
N/A
Whether the full judgment has been pronounced?
:-
Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV)
Heard Mr. Supongwati Walling, learned counsel for the petitioners. Also heard Mr. N. Angami, learned Sr. Government Advocate for the State respondents. 2.
Since a common question of law is involved in these two Writ
petitions, being WP(C) No. 240/2025 and WP(C) No. 241/2025, and since the relief(s) claimed in both the petitions are same, and as agreed upon by both the parties, it is proposed to dispose of both these petitions, by this common judgment and order. 3.
It is to be noted here that in WP(C) No. 240/2025, under Article 226
of the Constitution of India, 450 petitioners of Peren District, and in WP(C) No. 240/2025, under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, 98 petitioners of Mukokchung District, have prayed for the following relief(s):(i)
to direct the respondents authorities to release the back-log
Page No.# 85/106
salaries of the petitioners within a specific time period. (ii) to pass appropriate directions to the respondents authority for payment of the petitioners backlog salaries in line with the directions laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court and/or pass similar Order passed by this Court in WP(C) No. 162(K)/2015, vide Judgment & Order (Oral) dated 06-09-2019. The Background Facts:3.
The background facts’ leading to filing of the present petition is
briefly stated as under:“The petitioners were all appointed as work-charged
fixed Labourers, under the establishment of the Executive Engineer, PWD (R&B), Peren Division, Peren, and the Executive Engineer (PWD) (R&B), Tuli Division, Nagaland. They served the department continuously without any break for a considerable period. They had attended their duties, like any regular employees, till issuance of a common show cause Notice, dated 05-10-2024. In the said Notice, it was stated that after verification they were found to be irregular employees. Accordingly, the petitioner(s) had filed their reply to the show cause Notices, dated 29-10-2024, & 30-102024, to the Engineer-In-Chief, NPWD, Nagaland, Kohima clarifying that due verification was taken by the appropriate authority before their appointment. However, their reply was rejected by the authorities. Then, vide Notification, dated 06-11-2024, the Engineer-In-
Page No.# 86/106
Chief, NPWD, Nagaland, Kohima had terminated them from services with immediate effect. The petitioners then filed one representation, dated 11.08.2025, to the Engineer-In-Chief, NPWD, and the Chief Engineer, PWD (R&B), Nagaland, Kohima for payment of their backlog salaries, which was held up by the department w.e.f. March 2020, prior to termination from service. But, the same failed to evoke any response. Being aggrieved the petitioners approached this Court by filing the this petition seeking the relief(s) as aforesaid. Stand of the respondents:4.
The Engineer-in-Chief of NPWD, has filed affidavit-in-opposition in
both the writ petitions, denying the statement and averment made by the petitioners. It is stated that upon verifications of the appointment orders of the petitioners, by the respondent department, it was found that many of the petitioners’ appointment orders were not available in the Department. The petitioners, also in their writ petitions, besides making an averment, have not annexed their appointment orders. And therefore, in the absence of any documents showing that they were appointed in the establishment of Executive Engineer (R&B), Peren Division, Peren, and the Executive Engineer (R&B), Tuli Division, Mukakchung, Nagaland, as Fixed paid Labour by the respondent authorities, the same are denied. It is also stated that upon verification of the documents of the petitioners’, many anomalies were detected, including their appointment orders, for which the petitioner were place in the Category ‘N’ for further verifications.
Page No.# 87/106
4.1. It is further stated that in the Department, there are both Work Charged as well as Fixed paid employees, who were appointed without a sanction post and many of this categories of employees were also detected to be a bogus appointee, resulting in a huge financial distress to the State Government, and therefore, in order to identify and verify the details of the employees, the State Government has, by an Office Memorandum No. WH/R&B-20/2018/W/C/924, dated 21.08.2021, divided the work charged employees under the department into three categories, namely Category B, C and D, by the OM dated 21.08.2021, and a District Verification
Committee
was
also
constituted
with
the
Deputy
Commissioner of respective Districts as Chairman of the Committee and the Executive Engineer of respective Divisions, as Member Secretary and the Committee was entrusted to verify the authenticity of the employees. 4.2. The Committee undertook the verification drive of the concerned categories of employees mentioned in the OM dated 21.08.2021, and several anomalies were detected and therefore, in order to correct the anomalies, the concerned employees were further sub-divided into four categories i.e. Category A, R1, R2 and ‘N’. 4.3. Category ‘A’ are those concerned employees, who have no discrepancies in their service records. Category ‘R1’ are those concerned employees who have minor clerical error in their documents. Categories R2 are those concerned employees, who have several errors in their documents and Category ‘N’ are those employees, whose appointments itself are either doubtful or found to be bogus due to several errors, which does not tally with their service records. 4.4. The petitioners, in both the writ petitions, fall under the Category
Page No.# 88/106
‘N’. It is also stated that on completion of the verification, the Committee had submitted its report to the Government, which was subsequently place before the Cabinet and thereafter, the Cabinet, in its meeting held on 11.09.2024, approved the termination of services of 1309 (one thousand three hundred nine) number of Work-Charged employees, under the respondent Department. In the list of 1309 (one thousand three hundred nine) number of Work-Charged employees, whose services were approved to be terminated by the cabinet, the names of the petitioners in both the writ petitions were present in the list and therefore, by following the
due
process
of
law,
ENC/PIMS/WC.VER/CORR/2022/
the
Show
557/1038,
Cause
dated
Notice,
No.
05.10.2024,
with
direction to justify on or before 31.10.2024, as to why their services should not be terminated; were issued to the petitioners, and after serving them the show cause Notice, the services of the petitioners in both the writ
petitions
were
terminated,
vide
Notification
No.ENC/PIMS/WC.VER/CORR/2022/ 557/4115, dated 06.11.2024. It is also stated that in the Office Memorandum, dated 21.08.2021, it is clearly stated that till the verification process is over, the above categories of employees should be directed not to report for duty, and only to report, as and when the Verification Committee calls for the same. A Corrigendum, dated 25.08.2021, was thereafter issued with a modification made to Sl. No. 2 of the O.M. dated 21.08.2021, by stating that Sl. No. 2 should be read as till the verification process is over, and the ‘C’ and ‘D’ categories of employees should be directed not to report for duty, but only to report as and when the Verification Committee calls for the same, and not as issued. It is also stated that the petitioners’ falls within the category of
Page No.# 89/106
Work Charged employees mentioned at Sl.No.2 of the OM dated 21.08.2012, and the subsequent Corrigendum, dated 25.08.2021, and as such, the petitioners could not attend and discharge their duties, as they were stopped from reporting to their duties, and as such, the contention of the petitioners that after utilizing their services by the department and sending them without even paying their salaries is not acceptable in the eyes of law and the contention is out and out false, and misleading. 4.5. It is also stated that from their own admission of the petitioners of WP(C) No.240/2025, it is apparent that only two of the appointment orders could be traced, which goes to show that the authenticity of the statement made by the respondent authorities, in this affidavit with regards to bogus/doubtful appointment order of the petitioners which has resulted in their termination from service. It is also stated that on careful perusal of the two appointment orders, referred to by the petitioners, it is seen that it is just a replacement order, which is an internal arrangement made by the Division concerned and as such this internal arrangement does not give or creates any legitimate right, as stated by the petitioners and therefore, such averment made by the petitioners are denied by the respondent authorities. And that the petitioners have failed to make out a prima facie case. Therefore, both the writ petitions are liable to be dismissed. Submissions of learned counsel for the petitioners:5.
Mr. Supongwati Walling, learned counsel for the petitioners’, in both
the writ petitions, submits that the petitioners have not challenged their termination order. Their only prayer is to release their arrear salary, to which they are legally entitled to. Mr. Walling also submits that the State
Page No.# 90/106
respondents cannot avail the service of the petitioner without payment of their salary. And though for some days the petitioners could not attend and discharge their service, yet, it was not for their fault, but, due to the fault of the respondent authorities. It is the further submission of Mr. Walling that the right of the petitioners to salary is violated in both the cases. Therefore, Mr. Walling has contended to allow this petition. 5.1. Mr. Walling has referred following decisions in support of his submissions:(i)
Sudhendu Mohan Talukdar vs. State of Assam & Ors.reported in MANU/GH/0291/2006;
(ii)
Narendra Kumar Chandla vs. State of Haryana and Others, reported in (1994) 4 SCC 460;
(iii)
People’s Union For Democratic Rights and Others. vs. Union of India and Others, reported in (1982) 3 SCC 235;
(iv)
Shobha Ram Raturi vs. Haryana Vidyut Prasaran Nigam Limited and Others, reported in (2016) 16 SCC 663;
(v)
Asha vs. Pt. B.D. Sharma University of Health Science and Others, reported in (2012) 7 SCC 389;
(vi)
Dulu Deka vs. State of Assam and Others, reported in (2023) 9 SCC 749;
Submissions of learned counsel for the respondents:6.
Per contra, Mr. N. Angami, learned Sr. Government Advocate for the
State respondents, has vehemently opposed the petitions. He submits that the appointment of the petitioners, in both the writ petitions, are bogus
Page No.# 91/106
and to ascertain the same verification was conducted by the department and upon verifications of the appointment orders of the petitioners, it was found that many of the petitioners’ appointment orders were not available in the Department and the petitioners’ also, in the writ petitions, failed to annexed any appointment orders and in the absence of any documents showing that they were appointed in the establishment of Executive Engineer (R&B), Peren Division, Peren, Nagaland and also under the Executive Engineer, PWD (R&B) Tuli Division, as Fixed pay Labour, by the respondent authorities could not be established. 6.1. Mr. Angami also submits that upon verification of the documents of the petitioners’ of both the petitions, many anomalies were detected, including their appointment orders, for which the petitioners of both the petitions were place in the Category ‘N’, by theDistrict Verification Committee, which was constituted with the Deputy Commissioner of respective District as Chairman of the Committee and the Executive Engineer of respective Divisions as Member Secretary, vide Office Memorandum No. WH/R&B-20/2018/W/C/924, dated 21.08.2021. The committee has divided the work charged employees, under the Department, into three categories, namely, Category ‘B’, ‘C’ and ‘D’, by the OM dated 21.08.2021,and in order to correct the anomalies the concerned employees were further sub divided into four categories i.e. category ‘A’, ‘R1’, ‘R2’ and ‘N’. 6.2. Mr. Angami also submits that category ‘A’ are those concerned employees who have no discrepancies in their service records. Categories ‘R1’ are those concerned employees who have minor clerical error in their documents. Categories ‘R2’ are those concerned employees who have
Page No.# 92/106
several errors in their documents and Category ‘N’ are those employees whose appointment itself are either doubtful or found to be bogus, due to several errors, which does not tally with their service records. 6.3. Mr. Angami also submits that on completion of the verification, the Committee had submitted its report to the Government and the same was subsequently place before the Cabinet and the Cabinet, in its meeting held on dated 11.09.2024, approved the termination of services of 1309 WorkCharged employees, under the respondent Department and that the names of the petitioners were also present in the said list and therefore, by following the due process of law the service of the petitioners of both the
writ
petitions,
were
terminated
vide
Notification
No.ENC/PIMS/WC.VER/CORR/2022/557/4115, dated 06.11.2024. 6.4. It is the further submission of Mr. Angami that in the Office Memorandum dated 21.08.2021, it is clearly stated that till the verification process is over, the above categories of employees should be directed not to report for duty, but, only to report as and when the Verification Committee calls for the same. He also submits that the petitioners hadnot attended and discharged any duty for the said period. And as such they are not entitled to any back wages. Mr. Angami also submits that if the respondent authorities are directed to pay the arrear salary to the petitioners, then it would be inequitable to them, as it would become a burden upon the public exchequer. Therefore, Mr. Angami has contended to dismiss both the writ petitions. Issue before this Court:7.
In vise of the rival submissions of learned counsel for both the
parties, the issue, to be answered by this court is :-
Page No.# 93/106
(i) Whether the petitioners in both the writ petitions, are entitled to back wages from the date of the Office Memorandum dated 21.08.2021, by which they were asked not attend the office, till termination of their services vide Notification No.ENC/PIMS/WC.VER/CORR/2022/557/4115, dated 06.11.2024, with immediate effect? Discussion and analysis:8.
Having heard the submissions of the learned Advocates of both
sides, this Court has carefully gone through the petitions and the documents placed on record and also perused the Office Memorandum dated, dated 21.08.2021 and the terminated order, issued vide Notification No.ENC/PIMS/WC.VER/CORR/2022/557/4115 dated 06.11.2024. 9.
The basic facts in both cases are not in dispute. The petitioners in
both the writ petitions were working as fixed paid Labour in the establishment of Executive Engineer (R&B), Peren Division, Peren, Nagaland and in the establishment of Executive Engineer, PWD (R&B) Tuli Division. And upon verification of their documents, the Department has detected many anomalies, including their appointment orders. The District Verification
Committee,
which
was
constituted
with
the
Deputy
Commissioner of respective District as Chairman of the Committee and the Executive Engineer of respective Divisions as Member Secretary, videsOffice
Memorandum
No.
WH/R&B-20/2018/W/C/924,
dated
21.08.2021,had divided the work charged employees, under the department into three categories, namely, Category ‘B’, ‘C’ and ‘D’, by the OM dated 21.08.2021,and in order to correct the anomalies the concerned employees were further sub divided into four categories, i.e. category ‘A’,
Page No.# 94/106
‘R1’, ‘R2’ and ‘N’. 9.1. It also appears that out of the said categories, the Committee has placed those employees in category‘A’, who have no discrepancies in their service records. Then in category‘R1’, those concerned employees who have minor clerical error in their documents. Then in categories ‘R2’, those concerned employees who have several errors in their documents and in Sub-category ‘N’, those employees, whose appointments itself are found to be either doubtful or bogus, due to several errors which does not tally with their service records. 9.2. Indisputably, the petitioners of both the writ petitions, were place in the Sub-category ‘N’, by the said Committee, whose appointments itself are either doubtful or found to be bogus, due to several errors which does not tally with their service records. 9.3. As pointed out by Mr. Angami, and that too rightly, the petitioners in WP(C) No. 240/2025, in paragraph No.10 of the petition, admitted that they have in their custody only two appointment letters, i.e. appointment letters of the petitioners No. 73 and 77. Rest of the appointment letters were not enclosed with the petition. And those two appointment letters are also found to be just replacement orders which is an internal arrangement of the Department which does not create any legal right. 9.4. It also appears that the report of the Committee was submitted to the Government and the same was subsequently place before the State Cabinet and the State Cabinet, in its meeting held on 11.09.2024, had approved the termination of services of 1309 Work-Charged employees, under the respondent Department. And it also appears that the names of
Page No.# 95/106
the petitioners of both the writ petitions also finds mention in the said list. 9.5. Further, it appears that before the termination order being passed, the respondent authorities had issued show cause Notice, to the petitioners and the all the petitioners of both the writ petitions, have filed their response. And only thereafter, the service of the petitioners were terminated vide Notification No.ENC/PIMS/WC.VER/CORR/2022/557/4115, dated 06.11.2024. Thus, due process of law appears to be followed by the respondent authorities before termination of services of the petitioners. 9.6. Moreover, it is not the pleaded case of the petitioners that due process of law was not by the respondent authorities while terminating their services. 9.7. It also appears from a perusal of the report of the committee, constituted vide Office Memorandum, No. WH/R&B-20/2018/W/C/924, dated 21.08.2021, that those petitioners, who were placed in ‘N’ Subcategory, have no PIMS and their ADHAR data are completely different. One example is also given in the report that if the name an employee in PIMS is KEVI, the name in ADHAR is- Bokato. 9.8. Further, it appears that even after submission of the report by the committee
constituted
vide
Office
Memorandum
No.
WH/R&B-
20/2018/W/C/924, dated 21.08.2021, cross-checking was done by the Department’s Officials and the employees placed under ‘N’ Sub- category have not been able to produce relevant documents to defend their case, despite providing them ample opportunities. 9.9. It is worth mentioning in this context that the petitioners in both the writ petitions have not filed any reply to the affidavit in opposition filed by
Page No.# 96/106
the respondent authorities. And as such the stand taken by the respondent
authorities
in
their
affidavit
in
opposition
remained
uncontroverted. 10.
Thus, from the pleadings of the parties as well as from the
submissions of their respective counsel following facts emerges:(i)
The petitioners, except petitioner Nos. 73 and 77, (Annexure 15 & 16) of WP(C) No. 240/2025, do not possess their appointment letters.
(ii)
Those two appointment letters (Annexure 15 and 16) are also found to be just replacement order, which is an internal arrangement of the Department and it does not create any legal right.
(iii)
The petitioners have failed to furnish their complete address, such as their fathers’ name and place of residence etc.in the writ petitions.
(iv)
What the petitioners have enclosed with the petitions is their identity card, which also failed to disclose their complete address.
(v)
They have not challenged the Office Memorandum No. WH/R&B-20/2018/W/C/924, dated 21.08.2021,by which a
committee
was
constituted
with
the
Deputy
Commissioner of respective District as Chairman of the Committee and the Executive Engineer of respective Divisions as Member Secretary, and the report filed by the said Committee.
Page No.# 97/106
(vi)
They have also not challenged their terminated order, issued vide Notification No.ENC/PIMS/WC.VER/CORR/ 2022/557/4115, dated 06.11.2024.
(vii)
It also appears that those petitioners, who were placed in ‘N’ Sub-category, have no PIMS and their ADHAR data are completely different.
(viii)
Prior to the matter of the petitioners being placed before the Cabinet, cross-checking was done by the Department’s Officials and the petitioners have not been able to produce relevant documents to defend their case, despite providing them ample opportunities.
11.
Thus, from the aforesaid facts, the appointment of the petitioners
seems to be illegal that from the very inception. As stated above and also indisputably, the petitioners had failed to annex any appointment orders, except however, petitioners’ No. 73 and 77, (Annexure 15 & 16) in WP(C) No.240/2025, which are also just replacement order and internal arrangement of the Department and create no legal right. And in the absence of any documents showing that they were appointed in the establishment of Executive Engineer (R&B), Peren Division, Peren, Nagaland and also by the Executive Engineer (R&B), Tuli Division, Mukokchung, Nagaland as Fixed pay Labour, by the respondent authorities could not be established. 11.1. Even, after placing the petitioners in the Category ‘N’, by the District Verification Committee and before the matter being placed before the Cabinet, the same was cross-checked by the Department’s Officials and
Page No.# 98/106
the petitioners were granted the opportunity to defend their case, but, they have not been able to produce relevant documents, despite ample opportunities being providing them. 11.2. In view of the aforesaid factual background, and in view of the stand taken by the respondent authorities, now another question, to be addressed by this Court is, whether the petitioners can be granted any equitable relief, as prayed for. 11.3. This aspect was considered by Hon’ble Supreme Court in State of Bihar & Ors. v. Devendra Sharma, reported in (2020) 15 SCC 466. In the said case Hon’ble Supreme Court has held as under:“The rights to salary, pension and other service
benefits are entirely statutory in nature in public service. Therefore, these rights, including the right to salary, spring from a valid and legal appointment to the post. Once it is found that the very appointment is illegal and is non-est in the eye of the law, no statutory entitlement for salary or consequential rights of pension and other monetary benefits can arise.” 11.4. When an appointment is found to be bogus, without documents, forged, fraudulent, or otherwise illegal and void ab initio, the same is not merely irregular, and as such no legal employer-employee relationship ever existed. And as such, there is no statutory or enforceable right to salary, arrears, or other service benefits for any period, including the inquiry period, when salary was stopped and the petitioners were kept away from duty. The right to salary is consequential upon a valid appointment to a post. If the root (appointment) is non-existent in law,
Page No.# 99/106
the claim to salary cannot survive. 11.5. In the instant case, the finding of the committee and subsequent approval of the Cabinet and termination of their services from the date of the order, and after the petitioners were stopped from attending office, and salary was not paid and the final finding that the appointments were found to be bogus and without documents, brings the case within the ratio laid down in the case of Devendra
Sharma
(supra). The
petitioners herein cannot claim the stopped salary as of right. 11.6. It is however a fact that ‘No Work, No Pay’, principle is not applicable herein this case, as the respondent authorities itself prevented petitioners from working during the enquiry period. But, it is equally important that said proposition would have been applicable to them had the petitioners been validly appointed and prevented from working in the case of suspension or termination, later set aside, as held by Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Srikantha S.M. v. Bharath Earth Movers Ltd., reported in (2005) 8 SCC 314. Once the appointments of the petitioners are found to be bogus and contrary to their service record and as such the same being void ab initio, there was never a valid right to be on duty or to receive salary. 11.7. The petitioners herein have failed to demonstrate that the finding of the committee itself is perverse, based on no evidence, or violated the principle of natural justice in a manner that vitiates the entire process. When the appointment is correctly found to be bogus, equitable relief for the stopped salary is not available. It is well settled that once the appointment is finally held to be bogus/void, this Court, under Article 226
Page No.# 100/106
of the Constitution of India has exercised limited equitable discretion, that does not ordinarily override this principle. 12.
It is also to be noted here that while dealing with the issue of
granting equitable relief in a proceeding under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, Hon’ble Supreme Court in the case of Ritesh Tewari v. State of U.P., reported in (2010) 10 SCC 677, held as under:“26.
The power under Article 226 of the Constitution is discretionary and supervisory in nature. It is not issued merely because it is lawful to do so. The extraordinary power in the writ jurisdiction does not exist to set right mere errors of law which do not occasion any substantial injustice. A writ can be issued only in case of a grave miscarriage of justice or where there has been a flagrant violation of law. The writ court has not only to protect a person from being subjected to a violation of law but also to advance justice and not to thwart it. The Constitution does not place any fetter on the power of the extraordinary jurisdiction but leaves it to the discretion of the court. However, being that the power is discretionary; the court has to balance competing interests, keeping in mind that the interests of justice and public interest coalesce generally. A court of equity, when exercising its equitable jurisdiction must act so as to prevent perpetration of a legal fraud and promote good faith and equity. An order in equity is one which is equitable to all the parties concerned. The petition can be
Page No.# 101/106
entertained only after being fully satisfied about the factual statements and not in a casual and cavalier manner. (Vide Champalal Binani vs. CIT [(1971) 3 SCC 20: AIR 1970 SC 645]; Chimajirao Kanhojirao Shirke v. Oriental Fire and General Insurance Co. Ltd. [(2000) 6 SCC 622: AIR 2000 SC 2532]; LIC v. Asha Goel [(2001) 2 SCC 160: AIR 2001 SC 549]; Haryana Financial Corpn. vs. Jagdamba Oil Mills [(2002) 3 SCC 496]; Chandra Singh v. State of Rajasthan [(2003) 6 SCC 545: 2003 SCC (L&S) 951] and Punjab Roadways vs. Punja Sahib Bus and Transport Co. [(2010) 5 SCC 235] ) 27. Where a party's claim is not founded on valid grounds, the party cannot claim equity. A party that claims equity must come before the court with clean hands as equities have to be properly worked out between parties to ensure that no one is allowed to have their pound of flesh vis-àvis the others unjustly. (Vide Sikkim Subba Associates vs. State of Sikkim [(2001) 5 SCC 629].) 28.In A.P. State Financial Corpn. vs. Gar ReRolling Mills [(1994) 2 SCC 647: AIR 1994 SC 2151] this Court observed: (SCC p. 662, para 18) “18. … Equity is always known to defend
the law from crafty evasions and subtleties invented to evade law.”
new
29. In M.P. Mittal vs. State of Haryana [(1984) 4 SCC 371: AIR 1984 SC 1888] this Court held: (SCC p. 374, para 5)
Page No.# 102/106 “5. … it is open to the High Court to
consider whether, in the exercise of its undoubted discretionary jurisdiction, it should decline relief to such petitioner if the grant of relief would defeat the interests of justice. The Court always has power to refuse relief where the petitioner seeks to invoke its writ jurisdiction in order to secure a dishonest advantage or perpetuate an unjust gain.” 30. This Court in State of Maharashtra vs. Prabhu [(1994) 2 SCC 481: 1994 SCC (L&S) 676: (1994) 27 ATC 116] considered the scope of equity jurisdiction of the High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution and pointed out as follows: (SCC p. 486, para 5). “5.
… It is the responsibility of the High Court as custodian of the Constitution to maintain the social balance by interfering where necessary for sake of justice and refusing to interfere where it is against the social interest and public good.” 31. The present appeal does not present any special feature warranting exercise of equitable discretionary jurisdiction in favour of the appellants. The equity jurisdiction is exercised to promote honesty and not to frustrate the legitimate rights of the other parties. 32. It is settled legal proposition that if an order is bad in its inception, it does not get sanctified at a later stage. A subsequent
Page No.# 103/106
action/development cannot validate an action which was not lawful at its inception, for the reason that the illegality strikes at the root of the order. It would be beyond the competence of any authority to validate such an order. It would be ironical to permit a person to rely upon a law, in violation of which he has obtained the benefits. (Vide Upen Chandra Gogoi v. State of Assam [(1998) 3 SCC 381: 1998 SCC (L&S) 872]; Satchidananda Misra v. State of Orissa [(2004) 8 SCC 599: 2004 SCC (L&S) 1181] and SBI v. Rakesh Kumar Tewari [(2006) 1 SCC 530: 2006 SCC (L&S) 143].) 33. In C. Albert Morris vs. K. Chandrasekaran [(2006) 1 SCC 228] this Court held that a right in law exists only and only when it has a lawful origin. 34. In Mangal Prasad Tamoli vs. Narvadeshwar Mishra [(2005) 3 SCC 422] this Court held that if an order at the initial stage is bad in law, then all further proceedings consequent thereto will be non-est and have to be necessarily set aside. 35. In the instant case, as we have observed that the alleged sale deed dated 20-4-1982 in favour of Mayur Sahkari Awas Samiti has been a void transaction, all subsequent transactions have merely to be ignored. 12.1. Same proposition is reiterated in the case of State of Orissa vs. Mamata Mohanty, reported in (2011) 3 SCC 436, as under:“37. It is a settled legal proposition that if an
order is bad in its inception, it does not get
Page No.# 104/106
sanctified at a later stage. A subsequent action/development cannot validate an action which was not lawful at its inception, for the reason that the illegality strikes at the root of the order. It would be beyond the competence of any authority to validate such an order. It would be ironic to permit a person to rely upon a law, in violation of which he has obtained the benefits. If an order at the initial stage is bad in law, then all further proceedings consequent thereto will be non-est and have to be necessarily set aside. A right in law exists only and only when it has a lawful origin.” 12.2. Application of the aforesaid proposition of law, to the given factual matrix, this Court afraid, the relief, as prayed for, by the petitioners herein, cannot be granted, since the illegality strikes at the root of the appointment of the petitioners, from the very inception. As held in the case of Mangal Prasad Tamoli(supra), C. Albert Morris(supra) and Mamata Mohanty(supra) right in law exists only when it has a lawful in origin. 12.3. As held in the case of Ritesh Tewari (supra), while exercising the power of the extraordinary jurisdiction; the court has to balance competing interests, keeping in mind that the interests of justice and public interest coalesce generally. An order in equity is one which is equitable to all the parties concerned. It is also well settled in the said case that where a party's claim is not founded on valid grounds, the party cannot claim equity. A party that claims equity must come before the court with clean hands as equities have to be properly worked out between the
Page No.# 105/106
parties to ensure that no one is allowed to have their pound of flesh vis-àvis the others, unjustly. 12.4. As discussed in the foregoing paragraphs, the petitioners herein had failed to annex any appointment orders, except however, petitioners’ No. 73 and 77, (Annexure 15 & 16), which are also just replacement orders which is an internal arrangement of the Department. They had also failed to produce any documents showing that they were appointed in the establishment of Executive Engineer (R&B), Peren Division, Peren, and Tuli Division, Mukokchung, Nagaland, as Fixed pay Labour, by the respondent authorities. 12.5. In that view of the matter the submission of Mr. Angami that the state exchequer cannot be burdened to pay arrear (backlog) salary to the petitioners, whose very appointment was illegal and bogus, is found to be justified and it has considerable force. The approach of the petitioners herein appears to be not clean and if the respondent authorities are directed to pay the arrear salary to the petitioners, then it would be inequitable to them, as it would not only becomes a burden upon the public exchequer, but also it would secure a dishonest advantage or perpetuate an unjust gain to the petitioners. 13.
This Court has carefully gone through the decisions, so referred by
Mr. Walling, learned counsel for the petitioner, and finds that there is no quarrel about the propositions laid down therein. But, the same proceeds on their own facts and are not applicable in all force to the given factual matrix on account of the discussion and finding recorded herein above. Further, the appointment of the petitioners were not irregular, but illegal.
Page No.# 106/106
Therefore, this Court afraid the decisions referred by Mr. Walling would not advance the case of the petitioners. 13.1. It is the responsibility of this Court to maintain the social balance by interfering where necessary for sake of justice, and refusing to interfere, where it is against the social interest and public good. The petitioners herein havefailed to present any special reasonto exercise the equitable discretionary jurisdiction in their favour, while it is well settled that the equity jurisdiction is exercised to promote honesty and not to frustrate the legitimate rights of the other parties. 14.
Under the given factual and legal matrix, the issue, so formulated
herein above, has to be answered in negative. And accordingly, the same stands answered. The petitioners in both the writ petitions, are not entitled to back wages from the date of the Office Memorandum, dated 21.08.2021, by which they were asked not to attend the office, till termination
of
their
services,
vide
Notification
No.ENC/PIMS/WC.VER/CORR/2022/557/4115, dated 06.11.2024. 15.
In the result, this Court finds these petitions devoid of merit and
accordingly, the same stand dismissed, leaving the parties to bear their own costs.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant