SRI. Basanagouda Ramanagouda Patil Yatnal v. SRI. Shivananda S Patil
- Court
- High Court of Karnataka
- Date of judgment
- 12 November 2026
- Judge
- Justice Anant Ramanath Hegde
- Case number
- CRL.P No. 12881 of 2026
- Result
- DISMISSED
- Acts & sections
- Section 356 BNS, Section 499 IPC, Section 225 BNSS, Section 356 BNSS, Section 500 IPC, Section 202 CrPC
- Subject
- Criminal
Full judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 12TH DAY OF NOVEMBER , 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANANT RAMANATH HEGDE CRIMINAL PETITION NO. 12881 OF 2026 BETWEEN: SRI. BASANAGOUDA RAMANAGOUDA PATIL YATNAL, S/O RAMANAGOUDA PATIL YATNAL, AGED ABOUT 61 YEARS, MEMBER OF KARNATAKA LEGISLATIVE ASSEMBLY, VIJAYAPURA CITY, OCC AGRICULTURE, R/AT FARM HOUSE, SINDAGI ROAD, AINAPURA TALUKU, VIJAYAPURA 586104. ...PETITIONER (BY SRI DALWAI VENKATESH,ADVOCATE) AND: SRI. SHIVANANDA S PATIL, S/O. SIDRAMAPPA PATIL, AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS, PRESENTLY R/AT NEAR JAMKHANDI CROSS, OPPOSITE TO PETROL PUMP, JAMKHANDI ROAD, VIJAYAPURA-586101 ...RESPONDENT
Digitally signed by PRAMILA G V (BY SRI RAVI B NAIK, SENIOR COUNSEL) Location: THIS CRL.P IS FILED U/S.482(FILED U/S.528 BNSS) HIGH COURT CR.P.C BY THE ADVOCATE FOR THE PETITIONER PRAYING OF KARNATAKA THAT THIS HONOURABLE COURT MAY BE PLEASED TO A. ALLOW THE PRESENT CRIMINAL PETITION BY EXERCISING THE INHERENT POWERS OF THIS HONBLE COURT U/S 528 OF BNS 2023.B. SET ASIDE THE ORDER DATED 24.01.2026 PASSED BY THE LEARNED XLII ADDL CJM BENGALURU IN PCR NO.11492/2025 PRODUCED HEREIN AS ANNEXURE D WHEREBY THE LEARNED MAGISTRATE PROCEEDED AGAINST THE PETITIONER FOR THE ALLEGED OFFENCE P/US/ 356(2) OF BNS 2023 AND ETC.
R
THIS PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR ORDERS ON 06TH NOVEMBER, 2026 AND COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY, THE COURT PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING: CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANANT RAMANATH HEGDE CAV ORDER
The question that arises in this petition is, At the stage of taking cognizance and issuing process for offences under Section 356 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, whether Explanation-4 to Section 356(1) requires the complainant to examine a witness who would state that, in that person's own estimation, the complainant's reputation has been lowered; or would it suffice if the statement of a witness other than the complainant, or any other material indicates that the imputation has lowered the complainant's reputation in the estimation of others? 1.
The petitioner/accused is assailing the order dated
24.01.2026 taking cognizance of an offence under Section 356(2) of Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (for short 'BNS') in PCR No.11492/2025 by XLII Additional Chief Judicial Magistrate, Bengaluru. 2.
The petitioner has also assailed the order dated
18.08.2026 passed by the LXXXI Additional Sessions Judge,
Bengaluru, in Criminal Revision Petition No.65/2025, whereby the order dated 24.01.2026 passed in PCR No.11492/2025 is affirmed. 3.
The third prayer is to quash the entire proceedings
in PCR No.11492/2025. 4.
The respondent is the complainant.
5.
Heard the learned counsel for the petitioner and the
learned Senior Counsel for the respondent/complainant. 6.
The complaint is filed on 18.07.2025 for an offence
under Section 356 of the BNS in respect of defamatory statement allegedly made by the accused on 30.04.2025 on a channel named ‘Gadinada Kranti’ and broadcast on YouTube channel. 7.
Thus,
it
is
evident
that
the
alleged
offence
committed is under the Indian Penal Code, 1860 and the complaint is lodged under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 (for short 'BNSS'). 8.
The learned counsel for the petitioner would submit
that the Trial Court could not have taken cognizance based on the statement of the complainant and the two witnesses as the
requirements of Explanation-4 of Section 499 of IPC or Section 356 of BNS are not met. 9.
Drawing the
Court’s attention to the sworn
statements of the complainant and his two witnesses, the learned counsel for the petitioner would submit that the complainant has stated that his reputation is lowered in the estimation of others because of the imputation. The two witnesses examined on his behalf have also stated that the complainant's reputation is lowered; however, at the same time the witnesses have also stated 10.
that the allegations are false.
The learned counsel for the petitioner would urge
that unless the person, other than the complainant, in whose estimation the complainant's reputation is lowered makes a statement to that effect before the Court, the requirement of Explanation-4 to Section 499 of IPC or Section 356(1) of the BNS is not fulfilled and cognizance for the said offence cannot be taken. 11.
Learned
Senior
Counsel
appearing
for
the
respondent would submit that the contents of the complaint disclose the statements made by the accused. The accused has not disputed the statement made. The statements made are
per se defamatory. The statements have been widely circulated on social media. 12.
In his sworn statement the complainant has stated
that because of the imputation made by the accused, the complainant’s reputation is lowered in the estimation of others. The complainant has cited 3 witnesses. At this stage, 2 witnesses have been examined. Those two witnesses have stated that the complainant’s reputation has gone down in the estimation of others because of the defamatory statements made by the accused. 13.
Learned Senior Counsel would urge that as the
statement is per se defamatory, at the stage of taking cognizance, the Magistrate need not insist on a statement of a third person to say that the complainant's reputation has been lowered in that person’s 14.
estimation.
The Court has considered the contentions raised
and perused the records. 15.
The impugned order taking cognizance for the
offence runs into 17 pages and operative portion of the order reads as under:-
“Acting
under
Section
of
the
BNSS
2023,
Cognizance of the offence punishable under Section 500 of Indian Penal Code, 1860 (356(2) of BNS 2023) is taken as against the accused. Office to Register this case in Register-III as C.C. and issue summons to the Accused returnable by: 12.12.2025."
16.
While passing the said order, the Court has referred
to the contents of the complaint and also taken note of enactment of Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 and Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 and the repeal of the Indian Penal Code and the Criminal Procedure Code. 17.
The Trial Court has referred to the transcript of the
pen drive and the video clippings and also referred to the statement of the 2 witnesses. 18.
The Trial Court has also referred to the judgment of
the Apex Court in Subramanian Swamy Vs Union Of India1, Balraj Khanna And Others Vs Moti Ram2 Chaman Lal Vs State Of Punjab3 Arjun Panditrao
Khotkar Vs Kailash
Kushnarao Gorntyal4, to take a view that prima facie case is
(2016) 7 SCC 221
(1971 (3) SCC 399),
(1970) 1 SCC 590
(2020) 7 SCC 1
made
out
to
take
a
cognizance
and
thereafter
taking
cognizance. 19.
Said order was called in question before the
Jurisdictional Sessions Court and the Sessions Court in terms of its impugned order dated 18.08.2026 has dismissed the petition. 20.
The Sessions Court has also taken note of the
provision of law, the judgments of the Apex Court referred to in the order passed by the Trial Court. 21.
The Sessions Court has also taken note of the
statements in the documents produced before the Court and has confirmed the order passed by the Trial Court. 22.
Learned Counsel for the petitioner laid much stress
on the expression in the estimation of others in Explanation-4 to Section 499 IPC or Section 356 (1) of BNS. Relevant portion of Section 356 of BNS reads as under:"356. Defamation: (i)
Whoever, by words either spoken or intended to
be read, or by signs or by visible representations, makes or publishes any imputation concerning any person intending to harm, or knowing or having reason to believe that such imputation will harm, the reputation of such person, is said,
except in the cases hereinafter excepted, to defame that person. Explanation 1 - It may amount to defamation to impute anything to a deceased person, if the imputation would harm the reputation of that person if living, and is intended to be hurtful to the feelings of his family or other near relatives. Explanation 2 - It may amount to defamation to make an imputation concerning a company or an association or collection of persons as such. Explanation 3 - An imputation in the form of an alternative or expressed ironically, may amount to defamation. Explanation 4 - No imputation is said to harm a person’s reputation, unless that imputation directly or indirectly, in the estimation of others, lowers the moral or intellectual character of that person, or lowers the character of that person in respect of his caste or of his calling, or lowers the credit of that person, or causes it to be believed that the body of that person is in a loathsome state, or in a state generally considered as disgraceful. Illustrations: (a) A says “Z is an honest man; he never stole B’s watch”, intending to cause it to be believed the Z did steal B’s watch. This is defamation, unless it falls within one of the exceptions. (b) A is asked who stole B’s watch. A points to Z, intending to cause it to be believed that Z stole B’s watch. This is defamation, unless it falls within one of the exceptions.
(c) A draws a picture of Z running away with B’s watch, intending it to be believed that Z stole B’s watch. This is defamation, unless it falls within one of the exceptions. Exception 1.xxxx"
(Emphasis supplied) 23.
Perusal of Explanation-4 reveals that the imputation
does not harm the reputation of a person if the imputation does not lower the reputation of the person in the estimation of others. 24.
The petitioner’s contention is the expression “in the
estimation of others” would warrant the complainant to examine the person in whose estimation the complainant’s reputation is lowered. However, a plain reading of the said Explanation does not necessarily mean that the expression “in the estimation of others” would only mean in the estimation of the “witnesses examined before the Court”. 25.
The expression “in the estimation of others” though
refers to
the persons in whose estimation the complainant's
reputation must be lowered, does not, by itself, warrant that the particular person whose estimation is alleged to have been affected must invariably be examined as a witness at the stage
of taking cognizance. The existence of the possible damage to the reputation, depending on the nature of the imputation and the material available, may be prima facie inferred from the circumstances surrounding the publication and the contents of the imputation itself. 26.
However, in a given case to prove the contention
that the complainant’s reputation is lowered in the estimation of others, the complainant may be required to examine the person in whose estimation the complainant’s reputation is lowered even at the stage of recording sworn statement. 27.
If the witness who is examined before the Court, at
the stage of sworn statement, states that he has good opinion of
the
complainant
despite
imputation,
however, in
the
estimation of others, the complainant’s reputation is lowered, then it may suggest two possibilities. Such is the evidence in this case. (a) The witness might have seen and heard “another person”
making a statement that because of the
imputation against the complainant, “another person” does not hold the complainant in as high esteem as he did before the imputation.
(b) The witness might have heard about the opinion of “another person”, on the complainant’s reputation being lowered because of the imputation, through some other person. 28. In scenario (a), the witness who personally heard another
person
express
an
adverse
opinion
about
the
complainant is competent to testify to the fact that such a statement was made. The witness is a direct witness to the making of that statement. However, the mere fact that another person
expressed
establish
that
the
such
an
opinion
imputation
does
lowered
not
the
necessarily
complainant's
reputation. If the making or significance of that statement is disputed, further evidence may be necessary to establish the alleged reputational harm. In scenario (b) referred to above, the statement
would be
hearsay. 29.
The
above
view
can
be
explained
with
two
illustrations. (i)
A tells B, that he heard C telling that D’s reputation is lowered in C’s estimation, because of E’s imputation on D.
(ii)
A tells B, that he heard C telling about D’s reputation is lowered, in F’s estimation, because of E’s imputation on D.
30.
In illustration (i), A has personally heard the
statement made by C that in C’s estimation D’s reputation is lowered. Thus, A is a witness to C’s statement. The fact that C made that statement about D’s reputation is admissible evidence. 31.
In illustration (ii) A has not personally heard F. A
has heard about the statement allegedly made by F, from C. Thus the evidence of A about the alleged statement of F on D’s reputation is hearsay. 32.
In the present case the witnesses examined on
behalf of the complainant have stated that they have good opinion about the complainant and the imputations are false, however, because of the imputation, the reputation of the complainant is lowered in the estimation of others. 33.
It is true that the witnesses have not given specific
details of the other/s in whose estimation the complainant’s reputation is lowered. Nevertheless if the witness has heard somebody
making
a
statement
about
another
person’s
reputation being lowered, the fact that the person heard the statement would be admissible but may not be conclusive proof of the fact stated. 34.
In such situation, if the imputations are per se
defamatory and lower the moral or intellectual character of that person, or lowers the character of that person in respect of his caste or of his calling, or lowers the credit of that person, or causes it to be believed that the body of that person is in a loathsome
state,
or
in
a
state
generally
considered
as
disgraceful, the Court can tentatively form an opinion that the person’s reputation might have been lowered in the estimation of others, for the purpose of taking cognizance or issuing the process. 35.
If the allegations or imputations are prima facie not
defamatory then the Court at the time of taking cognizance may take a view that the materials are not sufficient to proceed further and may insist on better materials or evidence. 36.
For the aforementioned reasons the expression “in
the estimation of others” in Explanation-4 to Section 499 of IPC or 356(1) of BNS cannot be construed as having mandated, that in every case at the stage of taking cognizance and issuing
the process, that a witness other than the complainant must be examined and said witness must state that in his own estimation the complainant’s reputation is lowered. 37.
If the complaint and the independent witness
examined state that the complainant’s reputation is lowered in the estimation of others because of the imputation, and if the imputation is of such a nature that the Court prima facie finds that it is inherently capable of lowering the moral or intellectual character of the complainant, or projects him as a person of bad character or as having engaged in conduct generally considered disgraceful, then the Court may without insisting on the statement of the witness, that in his own estimation, the complainant’s reputation is lowered, can take cognizance and issue the process. 38.
On the other hand, where the imputation is not
prima facie capable of lowering the complainant's reputation within the meaning of Explanation-4 of Section 499 of IPC or 356(1) of BNS,
mere assertion that the reputation of the
complainant has been lowered in the estimation of others may not be sufficient. In such circumstances, to satisfy himself that the essential ingredient of defamation is prima facie made out, the Magistrate may require further material or the statement of
an independent witness who would say that in his own estimation the complainant’s reputation is lowered. 39.
At this juncture, it is necessary to refer to the
judgment of the Apex Court in John Thomas vs Dr. K. Jagadeesan5.
Apex Court in the said case has held that in
case the statement is per se defamatory, it would relieve the burden on the complainant that publication has lowered the complainant’s reputation in the estimation of the right-thinking public. The Apex Court also held that the accused cannot seek discharge if the publication is not per se defamatory as the complainant can lead evidence at the trial. 40.
The Court has noticed from the said judgment that
it is not clear whether the witnesses are examined before the Court (at the time of recording sworn statement) to say that the
complainant’s
reputation
has
been
lowered
in
the
estimation of the person who is examined as a witness. 41.
The learned counsel for the petitioner relied on the
judgment of the Apex Court in Jaideep Bose vs Bid and Hammer Auctioneers Private Limited6.
(2001) 6 SCC 30
2025 SCC OnLine 348
In the said case,
the Apex Court set aside the order taking cognizance on the ground that the procedure contemplated under Section 202 of the Code is not followed as the accused were residing outside the jurisdiction of the Court taking cognizance and against some of the accused the order taking cognizance is set aside as there were no materials to take a view that some of the accused authored the publication. The Apex Court has also held that the complainant has failed to produce any evidence to show that the reputation is lowered in the estimation of others. 42.
In the instant case the contention relating to
Section 225 of BNSS is not raised as the Court which passed the order is a Special Designated Court. Moreover accused being the member of the legislative assembly cannot take a plea that he resides
outside the territorial jurisdiction of the
Court in Bengaluru which issued the process. In addition the Trial
Court
has
issued
pre
cognizance
notice
to
the
accused/petitioner and the petitioner/accused is heard. 43.
That apart, the complainant has also examined
witnesses who have said that the complainant’s reputation is lowered in the estimation of the public.
44.
The learned counsel for the petitioner heavily relied
on the judgment of the Calcutta High Court in Aveek Sarkar and Another vs The State of West Bengal & Others.7 45.
In the said case, it appears that the FIR was
registered pursuant to a publication and there is a contention that no private complaint is filed and the FIR was registered based on complaint by an Association represented by the Secretary. The Court held that such a complaint is not tenable for the offences under Section 356 of BNS and the Court also took a view that the publication was not defamatory in the said case. 46.
Though the Court has held that there has to be an
evidence of an independent witness to the effect that in the estimation of such independent witness the complainant’s reputation is lowered, this Court is not persuaded to follow the said view for the reasons already recorded supra. 47.
The Madras High Court in S. Ranganathan vs
Radhakrishnan8 has held that before taking cognizance for an offence under Section 356 of BNS there has to be an inquiry
(2014) 4 SCC 257
2023 SCC OnLine Mad 2732
under Section 202 of Cr.P.C. The Court is of the view that in the case on hand apart from examination of the complainant, two
witnesses
have
been
examined.
Thus,
there
is
no
procedural violation and the judgment in S. Ranganathan supra does not come to the aid of the petitioner. 48.
In the backdrop of above discussion, the Court has
to consider the statements made by the accused. The relevant portion of the statements are as under:….ಅ
ೆಂಡ
ೊ ೆಯ ೇ ೆಂದು ಧಮ&
ಆಗುತ ೆ
ಕೃ ಾದ
ಭಯಂಕರ
ೋದವ ಅಂತವರು ಎ
ೆಲಸಗಳ* ಆಗುವ+,ಲ. ಅ
ೊರತು 0ಂದೂ ಧಮ&ದ
ದುಡು,
ಇರು"ಾ#ೋ ಅ
ಇ-ಾಂ
ೆಳವ./ೆ ಆಗು"ೆ
ೆಳವ./ೆ ಆಗುವ+,ಲ. ಅವ1/ೆ
ಅವರಪ31/ೆ ಹು56ದ7 ಅಂದ#ೆ 8 ಾನಂದ ಅಚ ಾ ಇ;ಾ<ೆ ಅವನ ಅಡ ೆಸರು =ಾ5ೕ> ಅಲ. ಇದನ? @ಾಧAಮದವರು ೇB ಅಚ ಾ ಅದು. 1ೕವ+ 1ಮD ಅ=ಾ3 1ೕವ+ ಕೂE 1ಮD ಅಡ ೆಸರು ZÉÃAeï @ಾE ೊಂ ೊರು Fಾಕಂ;ೆ #ಾಜHೕಯ ಸಲು ಾI, =ಾ5ೕ> ಅಂದ#ೆ
ಏ<ೋ
/ೌರವ
ಬರುತ;ೆ
ಅಂತ
ಅಂದೂಂ ಾ<ೆ.
ಅಚ ಾಕಂಪ1 ಮತು ಅOೊಬP ಹುನಗುಂದದವ ಅವನಲ, ಅವನು CªÀgÀ¥Àà¤UÉ ಹು56;ಾ7<ೆ ಅಂದ#ೆ ಒಂದು
ಾರಗRೆS ಳ/ೆ ಇಬPರು
TUಾನಸVೆಯ #ಾW<ಾX ಕೂಡ . Y3ೕಕ DUÀ°.
ಕ ೆZಂದ CAVÃPÀÈvÀ
<ಾ ಎರಡು ಕ ೆ 1ಲ ೆ[ ತFಾ\,7ೕ1, 1ಮD ಅಪ31/ೆ ಹು56ದ#ೆ ಮುಂ,ನ ಶುಕ^ ಾರದ ಒಳ/ಾI 1ೕವ+ ಇಬPರು
ೋI Y3ೕಕ
ೊಟು6 #ಾWೕ<ಾX ೊಟು6 ಎರಡು -ಾ`ನಗಳನು? "ೆರವ+ @ಾE\. ದa ಇದ7#ೆ 1ೕವ+ ಪbಾಂತರ ಬ\ೕ <ಾನು ಬರು"ೇ<ೆ. 1ಮDನು?
ಅOೇ ಮಣು ೊಟು6 ಬರುdೕ1. =ಾH-ಾನ ೆ[ ೋI ಮಣು ೊಟು6 అ ಇರುವಂತಹ ಬdೕ&1 1ೕ ೆOಾ =ಾH-ಾe ಏfೆಂg 1<ೆ? ನನ? Tರುದh ಏನು
ೋ#ಾಟ @ಾಡುdೕ\. ಒಬP<ೇ C°è EgÀĪÀAvÀºÀ
"ಾZಗಂಡಸೂRೆ ಮಗ Vಾರi @ಾ"ಾH fೈ ಅಂದ. =ಾH-ಾe ಮು;ಾ& ಾk ಅಂದ ಅOೆಲ ಕೂಡುವ+ದು ಎOಾ ಕೂಡುವ+ದು ಹOಾ> ೋ , ಹ#ಾa ೋ . ಅ ಾ ಇಂEೕ lಾಸಕ 4-5 ನೂರು
ೆಂmೕ ತಂ;ಾನ -ಾಬರನ?
nfಾಪ+ರ ೆ, ಇವ#ೆಲ\ಗೂ ಮುಂ,ನ ಚು<ಾವoೆಯ
ಸ\FಾI
ಬು,7 ಕಲು¹Ûë <ೋ ಾZ\, <ಾವ+ 0ಂದುಗಳ ಒಂದು ಒಟನು? <ೆ<ೆ? ಏನು -ೆ6ೕp XೕOೆ ಕೂ"ಾರಲ ಅವ\/ೆ nಳOಾರದಂ/ೆ 0ಂದೂಗಳ* <ಾವ+ ತFಾ#ಾI,7ೕT. 1ೕವ+ -ಾಬರನ?
ೆನ? ಹdರಲ -ಾಬ
ೆe ಹd <ೆ<ೆ? ಅವರು ಾqXೕ> @ಾEದರು -ಾಬು^ . 1ೕವ+ ಬರ ಲ ಅಂದ#ೆ ಮುಂ,ನ -ಾ\ 1ಮDನ <ೋಡdೕ ೆ ಅಂತ <ಾRೆ ನಮD 0ಂದು ಸ<ಾತನ ಧಮ&ದ ಒಬP<ೆ ಒಬP ವAH ಈ WOೆಯ ಏ<ಾದರು ಆದ#ೆ <ಾವ+ ೊಡುವಂತ ಕ#ೆ/ೆ 1ೕವ+ ಬರ ಲ ಅಂದ#ೆ 1ೕವ+ <ೇರ ಾI -ಾಬ\/ೆ ಹು56,7ೕ\ ಅಂತ <ಾವ+ dಳ* ೊBT. 1sDಬP\/ೆ ದa "ಾಕi, 1ಮDಪ31/ೆ ಹು56ದ#ೆ ಒಂದು ಾರ;ಾಗ #ಾW<ಾX ೊE. ಈ ಯ"ಾ?t ಪbೇತರ ಾI 1ಂತು ಭಗ ಾಜಂ ಾ ತ/ೊಂಡು ಾ\YnEೕ1. ಸgï =ಾH-ಾನ ಮತು ಇಂEFಾ ಯುದh ………………….. =ಾH-ಾನ ಮತು ಇಂEFಾ ಪರ ಾI @ಾತುಗಳ* ೇB ಬರು"ಾ ಇªÉ. Fಾರು ¥ÁH-ಾನ ಪರ ಾI @ಾ"ಾ ಾರ ಅವರು ;ೇಶ;ೊ^ೕ0ಗಳ* ಇವತು <ೋE =ಾH-ಾನ ಎಲ\ಗೂ vೂೕಷoೆ ೊ ೆ^ -ಾವ&ಜ1ಕ#ೆ ಚ¦è-ೇ ೆ @ಾ ಾಕ"ಾ#ೆ. ಇನು? ಮುಂ;ೆ =ಾH-ಾನ ಪರ ಾI @ಾ"ೋ ೋದು ನಮD ;ೇಶದ ಬ/ೆx, ಅಪ@ಾನ @ಾಡುವಂ"ೆ ಎOಾದರು ನ ೆದ#ೆ <ಾ ಇEೕ ಕ<ಾ&ಟಕ #ಾಜAದ ನಮD ಎOಾ ಯುವಕ\/ೆ ಕ#ೆ ೊEೕ1, 1ೕವ+
ಚ¦è-ೇ ೆ @ಾE ಅದು ಏನು ಾನೂನು
ೋ#ಾಟ ಅದ ಅದನು?
<ಾನು £ÉÆÃqÉÆÌÃwÛä. ಇನ? <ಾವ+ ನಮD ;ೇಶದ ಇದು ನ ೆಯ;ೆ ಅದು =ಾH-ಾನ ಯುದh =ಾ^ರಂಭ ಆದ#ೆ ಇ ರುವಂತ ಅ#ಾy[ೕ =ಾ5ೕ>,
ಾಷzನಂತ ಯಶವಂತ#ಾಯ/ೌಡರು "ಾZಗಂಡರು
ಇ;ಾರಲ ಇವರು ಎOೆ 'ಇ"ಾ&ರ.
ಅಂತ 8 ಾನಂದ
ಇ"ಾ&ರ ಇಂತಹ ಅ#ಾa ೋ
ಇ ೆ6ೕ
ಇವ#ೆಲರ ಅಪ31ಗು56ದ#ೆ ಚು<ಾವoೆಯ
ನನ/ೆ
{ಾOೆಂp ೇB;ಾ7ರಲ <ಾ|ೕe ಅ¥ïà ಅಂತನ ೊ56ದ7ರಲವರು ಈ #ಾWೕ<ಾX ೊಡ ೇಕಲ ಆ 8 ಾನಂk =ಾ5ೕ> nೕfಾಪ+ರ ೆ[, ಬdೕ&T ಎದ ಾ[. ಇವ1ಗಂತು
ಾಂ/ೆ^ೕ}/ೆ ಮುYಂ/ೆ 5 ೇg
ೊ ಾರ.
ೊ ೋ,ಲ. ಇವ1/ೆ nfಾಪ+ರ ೆ[ ಬ#ೊ ,ಂಡು
ಎದು ಾ[ ಅಂದ#ೆ ಇ
ಏನು YಗವOಾ/ೈ"ೆ ಾ/ೆ ಾEFಾ/ೆ ಇ
nfಾಪ+ರದ
ಇ
0ಂದೂಗಳ* ಏನು ಓಟು
ಾ ೋ,ಲ 1ನ/ೆ
-ಾ§Ææ ಓಟು
ಾ ೋ,ಲ. ಇವತು <ಾನು 8 ಾನಂದ =ಾ5>
nfಾಪ+ರ ೆ[ 1ಂ"ೋಳ*•dೕ ೆ ಅಂತ dಳ* ೊB•\. 8 ಾನಂದ ಅಚ ಾದ -ಾ\ =ಾ5ೕ> ಅಂ;ೆ. 8 ಾನಂದ ಅಚ ಾದ <ಾನು nfಾಪ+ರ ೆ[ 1ಂತು ೊಂE ಅಂತ dಳ* ೊB•. 0ಂದೂಗಳ* ನನ/ೆ ಾಗ ೆ. ಮುಸOಾDನರು ಏನು @ಾ ಾ#ೆ UÉÆgÀÄvÉÛöÊvÁ. ಅವರ;ೇ ಒಂದು ಾಂE ೇg 1ಲ¸ÁÛರ. ಈ ಅಚ ಾ ೆ[ Fಾಕ ಾ ಾ\ ಅವ Fಾವ ಮಗ ಹುನಗುಂದವ ಬdೕ&1 ಅಂದ ಾ
ಾರಪ3 ಮಗ<ೇ
1ಮDಪ31/ೆ ಹು56ದ#ೆ ಾ, ಮ"ೊಬPರ ಅಪ3ನ? ೇBಯOಾ ಮಗ<ೇ 1ನ? @ಾ\ <ೋEದ#ೆ ಗುತು& ಆ ೈ"ೆ Fಾ\/ೆ ಹು56 ಅ<ೊ?ೕದು. 1ನ? ಬ\ೕ @ಾ\ <ೋE;ೆ ಗು"ಾ&ಕ"ೆ. ಪಂಚಮ -ಾ ಸ@ಾಜಕ. yೕಸ @ಾE, 1ೕ ಎOೆ #ೊ ಾ. ತ/ೊಂ, ೊ@ಾDZ ªÀÄ£Éð JµÀÄÖ
vÀUÉÆAqÀÄ
§A¢.
ೊ@ಾDZ
ªÀÄÄRåªÀÄAwæ
EzÁÝUÀ
=ಾದFಾ"ೆ^/ೆ ಎಷು6 #ೊPÀÌ. ತಂದು dಂ,ೕ 1ೕನು ಮ"ೊಬPರ ಸಂಘ ಸಂ-ೆ`ಗಳ ಬ/ೆx @ಾ"ೋ ೊ <ೈdಕ"ೆ 1ನ/ೆ ಇಲ 1ೕ•ಬP ಮ ಾ ಭ^ ಾ6 Oೋಪ
ಇ,ೕ. £À£Àß ಬ/ೆx ಇ<ೆ?ೕOೆ @ಾ"ಾE, ಅ;ೇ Vಾ ೆ,
ಏ ಾಂzÀæ nfಾಪ+ರ;ಾಗ ನಮD Vಾ ೆ ಬಹಳ ಸು‚ೕ\ಯ
ಐdೕ.
ಅವ MqÉÆzÉæ ನಮD ಉತರ ಕ<ಾ&ಟಕದ Vಾ ೇದ/ೆ 1ೕವ+ ಏe ಇವರಪ3ನಂ/ೆ ¨ÉÊಯ ೆ, ನನ? ಬB ಶಬ7 ೋಶ ಬಹಳ ಐ"ೆ ಇನ?Xೕ/ೆ ಇವ\ಬPರ ಮಕ[ಳ* ಏ<ಾದು^ 1ಂದುdೕ&1 ಅಂದ#ೆ 1ಮDಪ31/ೆ ಹು56ದ#ೆ 1ಂ,ೕ ಇನು? ಒಂದು
ಾರದ ನಂತರ <ಾನು EPÉèöÊgï
@ಾEೕ1 ಇವ\ಬPರು ಅಪ31/ೆ ಹು56ಲ, ಆZ"ಾ 1ೕ ಪಂ"ಾವ1/ೆ ಅವ\/ೆ ೇB#ೇನು 1ೕವ+ 8 ಾನಂk ಅಚಡk ಅಂತ 1ಮD sEFಾ;ಾ/ೆ,
ೇBೕ\
ೇಳ ೇ ಾಗುತ;ೆ, 1ೕವ+ ಬ\ೕ ಯ"ಾ?t
ಯಂ… ಮoಾ/ೆ ಇಡ ೇಕು ಾಯ&ಕ^ಮ @ಾಡ ೇE. ಯ"ಾ?t ಏನು @ಾ ೋದು ಆಗು,ಲ. <ಾಲು[ sEಯದವರು 0 ಾE, W/ಾxE ನe Tರುkಧ ಬ#ೆk ಯ"ಾ?t ಅUಾAಯ ಮುIk ಏe -ೆಂ ಾನು ಮುI,ಲ. ಇವರು ಎಲ ಅUಾAಯ ಮುI-ಾ ೆ <ಾನು nfಾಪ+ರ;ಾ/ೆ E¢Ýä.
49.
On perusal of the statement, there is no difficulty in
taking a prima facie view that the statements cast serious aspersions on the complainant's integrity and character and are inherently
capable
of
lowering
the
reputation
of
the
complainant. Of course even if the allegations are true, whether the case falls under an exception can be considered by the Court.
On the basis of the said publication and the
statements of two witnesses, the Court has taken cognizance of the offence under Section 356 of BNS. Said impugned order cannot be said to be erroneous. Because at this stage the Court
need not consider whether the evidence is sufficient to convict the accused. 50.
Whether the public or any person believed the
imputation to be true or whether the complainant’s reputation was in fact lowered in the estimation of others, are the questions to be considered at the time of trial. 51.
At this juncture, the Court does not find any error in
the order passed by the Trial Court or the Revisional Court in taking a view that a case is made out to proceed further for the offence under Section 356 of BNS. 52.
Though the learned counsel for the petitioners
relied on the judgment of the Apex Court in Manoj Kumar Tiwari Vs Manish Sisodia & Ors.9, and the judgments of the co-ordinate
bench
Shamegowda10,
S
of
this
Court
in
P
Bobati
&
Ors.
Jayappa Vs
Vs
Mahadev
Virupaxappa Latti11 and Sri M Krishna Reddy Vs N R Ramesh12 to urge that the petition has to be allowed following the ratio laid down in the said cases, the Court is of the view
2002 Livelaw (SC) 853
1983 SCC On Line Kar.6
2004 SCC On Line Kar.511
Criminal Petition No.3549/2024
that in the aforementioned cases the accused were either acquitted or the complaint is quashed based on the nature of the imputations made against the complainant in those cases. The imputations in the present case against the complainant are way different from the cases referred to above.
It is not
necessary to refer to the imputations made in those cases. Hence, the said judgments have no application to the case on hand.
CONCLUSIONS.
(i)
At the time of taking cognizance for an offence and issuing process, in a case alleging defamation, Explanation-4 to Section 499
of IPC, or Section
356(1) of BNS, does not necessarily mandate the complainant to examine a witness other
than the
complainant
that
the
in
the
complainant’s
to
make
a
reputation
statement is
lowered
estimation of “said witness”. (ii)
Whether such statement of a witness other than the complainant at the time of taking cognizance is required
or
not,
is
dependent
on
nature
of
imputation
and
other
materials
and
attendant
circumstances. (iii)
If the imputation is of such a nature that the Court prima facie finds that it is inherently capable of lowering the moral or intellectual character of the complainant, or projects him as a person of bad character or as having engaged in conduct generally considered disgraceful, then the Court may without insisting on a statement from a witness that, in his own estimation, the complainant’s reputation is lowered, may take cognizance and issue the process based on the statements of the complainant and the witness who state that the complainant’s reputation is lowered in the estimation of others.
(iv)
Where the imputation is not prima facie capable of lowering the complainant's reputation within the meaning of Explanation-4 to Section 499 of IPC or Section 356(1) of BNS, a mere assertion by the complainant and his witness that the reputation of the complainant has been lowered in the estimation of
others
may
not
be
sufficient.
In
such
circumstances, the Magistrate to satisfy himself that
the essential ingredient of defamation is prima facie made out, may require further material or the statement of a witness other than the complainant who would say that in his own estimation the complainant’s reputation is lowered.
53.
Hence, the following:
ORDER (i)
The petition is dismissed.
(ii)
The Observations made in this order are not the opinion on the merits of the complaint and defence of the accused.
(iii)
All contentions on merits are kept open to be adjudicated by the Trial Court.
Sd/(ANANT RAMANATH HEGDE) JUDGE
CHS/BRN