SRI. Darshan J C v. SR. Manjunatha Kariyappa

Court
High Court of Karnataka
Date of judgment
4 November 2026
Judge
Justice Shivashankar Amarannavar
Case number
MFA No. 4959 of 2025
Result
Partly Allowed
Acts & sections
Section 173 Motor Vehicles Act
Subject
Service, Motor accident

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

-1HC-KAR

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 4TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL No. 4959 OF 2025 (MV-I) BETWEEN: SRI. DARSHAN J C S/O J.B.CHANDRA KEERTHI AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS R/O.No.218, 5TH CROSS SARASWATHI NAGAR, VIJAYANAGAR, BENGALURU NORTH BENGALURU-560 040. …APPELLANT (BY SRI HARISH N.R, ADVOCATE) AND: 1.

SRI MANJUNATHA KARIYAPPA S/O KARIYAPPA HUCHAPPA AGE: MAJOR R/O.No.1267, 12TH C CROSS 9TH MAIN ROAD, MAHALAKSHMI LAYOUT BENGALURU - 560 086. (R.C.OWNER OF CAR BEARING REG.No.KA-50-M-8530)

2.

TATA AIG GENERAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED No.69, 3RD FLOOR, J.P, AND DEVI JAMBUKESHWARA ARCADE

-2HC-KAR

MILLERS ROAD, BENGALURU - 560 052. (POLICY No. 01600494400300 VALID FROM 17-07-2022 TO 16-07-2023) …RESPONDENTS (BY SRI B PRADEEP, ADVOCATE FOR R2 V/O DATED 04.08.2025, NOTICE TO R1 IS D/W) THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTION 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED:01.10.2024 PASSED IN MVC No.1406/2023 ON THE FILE OF THE VIII ADDITIONAL JUDGE, COURT OF SMALL CAUSES, ACJM, MACT, BENGALURU (SCCH-5) PARTLY ALLOWING THE CLAIM PETITION FOR COMPENSATION AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT OF COMPENSATION. THIS MFA HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR ORDERS ON 31.08.2026, THIS DAY, SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR J, DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING; CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR

CAV JUDGMENT This

appeal

is

filed

by

claimant

seeking

enhancement of compensation awarded in the Judgment and

Award

dated

01.10.2024

passed

in

MVC

No.1406/2023 by VIII Additional Judge, Court of Small Causes and MACT, Bengaluru (SCCH-5). 2.

The appellant/claimant made a claim petition

praying to award compensation for the injuries sustained

-3HC-KAR

by him in a road traffic accident occurred on 30.01.2023 contending that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent

driving

driver

car

bearing

registration No.KA-50-M-8530. 3.

The Tribunal recorded the evidence adduced by

the parties and upon appreciating the evidence on record, assessed

compensation

and

awarded

compensation under various heads as under: Sl. Particulars No. 1. Pain and sufferings 2. Conveyance, nourishment and attendant charges 3. Medical expenses 4. Loss of amenities in life 5. Loss of income during laid up period Total 4.

Amount Rs. Rs.

15,000/15,000/-

Rs. Rs. Rs.

24,000/15,000/1,525/-

Rs.

70,525/-

The Tribunal has also awarded interest at the

rate of 6% per annum from the date of petition till realization and directed respondent No.2/insurer to deposit the award amount with interest. The claimant seeking

-4HC-KAR

enhancement

compensation

awarded

by

Tribunal has filed the present appeal. 5.

Heard the learned counsel for appellant and

learned counsel for respondent No.2/insurer. 6.

Learned

counsel

for

appellant

would

contend that the Tribunal has not awarded loss of future income due to disability, even though the disability sustained by the claimant is 13% to the whole body. He placed reliance on the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in

case

RELIANCE

GENERAL

INSURANCE

COMPANY LIMITED vs. PRIYANKA DAS AND OTHERS, reported in AIR 2026 SC 4382 and the decision of coordinate Bench of this Court in the case of DR. YASHWANTH DONGRE vs. SALMAN RASHEED AND OTHERS, reported in ILR 2015 KAR 167 would contend that even though the claimant getting the same income after the accident, he has to be awarded loss of future income due to disability. He further contended that the

-5HC-KAR

Tribunal

has

not

awarded

medical

expenses

Rs.1,43,234/- only on the ground that the said expenses are reimbursed by a medical claim policy of his company. He submits that the said medical reimbursement got from a medical claim policy shall not be deducted and on that point, he placed reliance on the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of NEW INDIA ASSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED vs. DOLLY SATISH GANDHI & ANR. reported in 2026 INSC 498.

He also placed

reliance on the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of RAJ KUMAR vs. AJAY KUMAR AND ANOTHER, reported in AIR ONLINE 2010 SC 144 on the point of grant of compensation for loss of future earning due to disability. He further submits that the compensation awarded under other heads i.e., pain and sufferings, loss of amenities and loss of income during laid up period are on lower side. He submits that the Doctor has stated that the claimant has to undergo operation for removal of implant and therefore the claimant is to be awarded future

-6HC-KAR

medical expenses. With these, he prayed to allow the appeal. 7.

Learned counsel for respondent No.2/insurer

would contend that the compensation awarded by the Tribunal on all heads is just and proper and there are no grounds for enhancement. He further contends that the claimant was working in a company, continued in service, getting the same income as he was getting prior to the accident and therefore

Tribunal has rightly not

awarded loss of future income due to disability even though there is a disability to the whole body at 13%. With this, he prayed for dismissal of the appeal. 8.

Having heard the learned counsel for appellant

and learned counsel for respondent No.2/insurer, the Court has perused the Judgment and Award. 9.

The accident occurred on 30.01.2023 and as on

the date of accident the claimant was aged thirty two (32) years. The multiplier applicable to the said age is ‘16’.

-7HC-KAR

10.

The claimant has sustained open fracture both

bone left forearm middle third with multiple abrasion as per Ex.P8 - Wound Certificate and Ex.P14 - Discharge Summary. Considering the said injuries sustained by the claimant, the compensation awarded by the Tribunal towards pain and sufferings in the sum of Rs.15,000/- is enhanced to Rs.75,000/- and loss of amenities awarded in a sum of Rs.15,000/- is enhanced to Rs.60,000/-. 11.

The claimant has been admitted in hospital for

three (03) days and incurred huge medical expenses and considering the same, the Tribunal has rightly awarded attendant, conveyance charges, food, nourishment etc. in a sum of Rs.15,000/-. 12.

The claimant has stated that he was getting

salary of Rs.30,000/- per month. Considering the said aspect and the injuries sustained by the claimant, he has to take rest atleast for one (01) month and therefore entitled to loss of income during laid up period in a sum of

-8HC-KAR

Rs.30,000/-

as

against

Rs.1,525/-

awarded

by

Tribunal. 13.

The Tribunal has disallowed medical expenses

of Rs.1,43,234/- and has only awarded Rs.24,000/- on the ground that the said amount of Rs.1,43,234/- has been reimbursed by the company under medical policy (Health Insurance). The Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of DOLLY supra, has Held that if the claimant

SATISH GANDHI

has got reimbursement of medical expenses under any health insurance policy, the same shall not be disallowed on that ground and the claimant is entitled to award of the said

medical expenses got reimbursed

insurance

policy.

Therefore

claimant

under health apart from

Rs.24,000/- awarded by the Tribunal towards medical expenses is also entitled to a sum of Rs.1,43,234/- which he

got reimbursed

from his company

under health

insurance policy. Therefore the claimant is entitled to total medical expenses of Rs.1,67,234/- as against Rs.24,000/awarded by the Tribunal.

-9HC-KAR

14.

P.W.2 and P.W.3 - Doctors have stated that the

claimant has to undergo operation for removal of implant and estimated the cost of the same at Rs.60,000/-. Considering the fact that the claimant has to undergo medical operation for removal of implant, he is entitled to a sum of Rs.30,000/- towards future medical expenses. The claimant is not entitled to interest on future medical expenses awarded in a sum of Rs.30,000/-. 15. Whether the claimant is entitled to loss of future income due to disability as he continued in the service even after the accident and getting the same income as he was

getting

prior

to

accident. In

case

PRIYANKA DAS supra, the Hon'ble Apex Court has considered the award of compensation under loss of future income due to disability as the claimant has sustained disability at 100% and has observed that the present case shall not be treated as a precedent. In the said case, the Hon'ble Apex Court has observed as under:

- 10 HC-KAR

“36. The calculation of functional disability depends on assessing the victim’s earning capacity in the open, competitive market, rather than on retention in a specific, highly accommodated role. Evidence before the High Court, specifically the Career Growth

Letter

dated

06.02.2018

from

her

employer, confirmed that the Claimant lost out on her

normal

career

growth

and

promotional

progression, including advancement to the positions of General Manager, Director, or Vice President, as a result of the accident. The record further indicates that she is able to perform her current duties only through specially created software, flexible working hours, and extreme accommodations provided by her employer as an act of corporate compassion.

37. Based on the official Medical Board Report issued by Vardhman Mahavir Medical College & Safdarjung Hospital, which evaluated the Claimant and certified a 100% PPI of the whole body due to post-traumatic head injury with cortical blindness, pelvic fracture, and a permanent colostomy, the compensation

calculation

shifts

from

High

Court’s 80% assessment to a 100% functional disability

because

independently

secure,

Claimant’s

capacity

sustain,

or

to

advance

- 11 HC-KAR

employment in the open labour market has been entirely extinguished.

38. The Court is exercising its discretion in the peculiar facts and circumstances of this case to arrive at just and fair compensation payable to the Claimant. The Claimant is a well-educated lady with a reasonable income. In the circumstances of the present case, which shall not be treated as a precedent, a reasonable sum for the loss of marriage

prospects,

i.e.,

Rs.

20,00,000/-,

decision

cannot

is

considered.”

Therefore,

said

be

made

applicable as it cannot be followed as a precedent. 16.

In the case of DR. YASHWANTH DONGRE

supra, coordinate Bench of this Court has observed as under: “15. In this case, the claimant has got disability to the extent of 46%. The doctor has not spoken about the disability with regard to the whole body. The claimant has permanent

disability

and

thus

has

- 12 HC-KAR

permanent

diminution

his

earning

capacity, but he has been continued in the same employment without deduction of salary,

claimant

is

entitled

for

compensation for his handicap in the labour market. In many cases of comparatively not serious injuries, though there is some permanent disability, the disability has no immediate adverse effect on his salary. He may be getting the pre-accident salary. However, such a man is at a disadvantage when compared with his co-workers in the labour market. It may so happen that he continues to work with difficulty and gets the same salary but if there is reduction in

workforce

by

employers,

this

worker with disability is likely to be sent off first. 16. It may happen in some cases, though the claimant is in a position to work physically after the accident as before, the after effects of the accident may make it more difficult for him to find work or to retain his work. There would be some degree

physical

handicap.

In

these

- 13 HC-KAR

cases, the Court may have to add a suitable sum by way of damages having regard to this aspect. In the instant case, the claimant has got permanent disability to the extent of 46%. The income of the claimant is Rs.30,303/- per month. ⅓rd of 46% will be the disability to the whole body. Accordingly, the disability of the claimant to the whole body is 15%. The age of the claimant is 45 years and suitable multiplier that has to be adopted in this case

is

14.

proportionate

to

The

loss

income

disability of

15%

would be Rs. 4546/-. So due to the reduced capacity of work, the claimant has lost income of Rs.7,63,728/-(Rs. 4546/- × 12 = Rs.54552/- × 14 = Rs.7,63,728/-). Since

claimant

is

continuing

in

his

employment, he may not be entitled for compensation under the head of reduced eligibility

employment.

However,

applying the principle mentioned herein above, a suitable sum has to be awarded by way of damages having regard to his disability. 10% of reduced earning capacity

- 14 HC-KAR

can be awarded as suitable sum in respect of reduced eligibility of employment or handicap in the employment market i.e., Rs.77,000/.” 17.

In the case on hand, the claimant as per

evidence of the Doctors has sustained disability at 39% to the arm and 13% to the whole body. The claimant even after the accident and injuries, continued to work with his earlier company i.e., Swasti Health Care Company and getting same income of Rs.30,000/- per month. The claimant has a permanent disability and thus has a permanent diminution of his earning capacity, but he has been continued in the same employment without a deduction

salary,

claimant

is

entitled

for

compensation for his handicap in the labour market. In many cases of comparatively not serious injuries, though there is some permanent disability, the disability has no immediate adverse effect on his salary. He may be getting the pre-accident salary. However such a man is at a disadvantage when compared with his co-workers in the

- 15 HC-KAR

labour market. It may so happen that he continues to work with difficulty and gets the same salary, but if there is a reduction in the workforce by the employers, this worker with disability is likely to be sent off first. Even though the claimant is in a position to work physically after the accident as before, the after effects of the accident may make it more difficult for him to find work or to retain his work. There would be some degree of a physical handicap. In these cases, the Court may have to add a suitable sum by way of damages having regard to this aspect. In the instant case, the claimant has got a permanent disability at the extent of 13%. The income of the claimant is Rs.30,000/- per month. Accordingly the disability of the claimant to the whole body taken at 13% since he is having disability to the arm at 39%. The age of the claimant is thirty two (32) years and suitable multiplier that has to be adopted is ‘16’. The loss of income proportionate to the disability of 13% would be as under: Rs.30,000/- X 12 X 16 X 13% = Rs.7,48,800/-.

- 16 HC-KAR

18.

Since

claimant

is

continuing

in

his

employment, he may not be entitled for compensation under the head of reduced eligibility of employment, however applying the principle mentioned in the decision

coordinate

Bench

in

case

DR. YASHWANTH DONGRE supra, a suitable sum has to be awarded by way of damages having regard to his disability. 10% of reduced earning capacity can be awarded as a suitable sum in respect of reduced eligibility of employment or handicap in the employment market i.e., Rs.74,880/-. 19.

Considering all the above aspects, the claimant

is entitled to total compensation under various heads as under: Sl. Particulars No. 1. Pain and sufferings 2. Loss of amenities 3. Loss of income during laid up period 4. Attendant and conveyance charges etc.

Amount Rs. Rs. Rs.

75,000/60,000/30,000/-

Rs.

15,000/-

- 17 HC-KAR

5. 6. 7.

Medical expenses Future medical expenses Reduced eligibility of employment or handicap in the employment market Total

20.

Rs. Rs. Rs.

1,67,234/30,000/74,880/-

Rs.

4,52,114/-

The claimant is entitled to total compensation of

Rs.4,52,114/- as against Rs.70,525/- awarded by the Tribunal with interest. 21.

Consequently, the claimant is entitled to enhanced

compensation of Rs.3,81,589/- with interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of petition till realization. 22.

Respondent No.2/insurer is liable to pay the said

enhanced compensation with interest. 23.

The claimant is not entitled to interest on future

medical expenses of Rs.30,000/- awarded by this Court. 24.

In view of the above, the following:

ORDER i)

Miscellaneous First Appeal is allowed-in-part.

- 18 HC-KAR

ii)

The appellant/claimant is entitled to enhanced compensation of Rs.3,81,589/- with interest at the rate of 6% per annum from the date of petition till realisation.

iii)

Respondent

No.2/insurer

shall

deposit

enhanced compensation amount with interest before the Tribunal within a period of six weeks from this day. iv)

The claimant is not entitled to interest on future

medical

expenses

Rs.30,000/-

awarded by this Court. v)

Out

enhanced

compensation,

claimant is entitled to release of 50% and remaining 50% shall be kept in Fixed Deposit in his name in Karnataka Bank, City Civil Court Branch, Bengaluru for a period of three (03) years.

(SHIVASHANKAR AMARANNAVAR) JUDGE KLV List No.: 2 Sl No.: 2 Ct.sm

Related judgments

More Karnataka High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.