Sri Koduru Pitcheswara Rao v. The State of Telangana

Court
High Court for State of Telangana
Date of judgment
29 October 2026
Judge
Justice J Sreenivas Rao
Case number
CRLP No. 17909 of 2026
Result
DISPOSED OF NO COSTS
Acts & sections
Section 3 BNS, Section 52G BNSS, Section 204 CrPC, Section 190 CrPC
Subject
Criminal

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

[ 33031 IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD

THURSDAY, THE TWENTY NINTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J. SREENIVAS RAO CRIMINAL PETITION NO: 17909 OF 2026

Between:

Sri Koduru Pitcheswara Rao, S/o. Late Subba Rao, age 63 years, Occ. Business, Rl/o. Flat no.104,304 of Koduru Mansion, lndra Nagar, Gachibowli, Serilingampally Mandal, Rangareddy District, N/o. Vijayawada ... Petitioner/Defacto Complainant

AND

The State of Telangana, through PS Gachibowli, Hyderabad. Rep by its

Public Prosecutor. 2 Sri Pasam Amarnath Reddy, S/o. Pasam VijayShekar Reddy, Aged about 36 Years, Occ. Hotel Business, Fl/o.plot no.2l,opposite UCO Bank, Kishan Bhavan, Vinayak Nagar, lndra Nagar, Gachibowli, N/o. Vidavaluru village and Mandal, Nelloure district, Andhra Pradesh. 3 Dama Venkata Rao, S/o. Chinna Kondaiah, Aged about 40 years, Occ. Hostel owner Rl/o. Flat No. 20,21,24,25,Vinayak Nagar, lndra Nagar, Gachibowli N/o. Rajampally village, Darsi Mandal, Prakasham District, Andhra Pradesh. 4 Palakolanu Venkata Subbi Reddy, S/o. Jaya Rami Reddy, Aged about 55 years, Occ: Business, Ri/o. H.No.1414, Venkateswara Luxury Woman's pg

hostel, Siddicinagar, Madhapur, Serilingampally, Ranga Reddy N/o.

o

Thimmareddy Palli, Porumamilla Mandal, Kadapa District Andhra Pradesh. Vennum Surya Vardshan, S/o. Hari Prasad, Ag:. 40 years, Occ: Hostel Business Ri/c. Plot no. 1582, Siddiq Nagar, Gachibowli, Rangareddy N/o. H.No.2-73, Veerapur village, Birpur Mandal, Kama Reddy District. Kaku Madhusudhan, S/o. Venkata Krishnaiah, Age:30, Occ: Hostel Business,

FI/o. Laxmi Enclave, Vinayak Nagar, lndra Nagar, Gachibowli, N/o.

Vedavaluru Village and Mandal, Nellore District, Andhra Pradesh. 7 Nandyamma Raghavender, S/o. Lallapa, Age:20 years, Occ. Kitchen Work in Nextgen Womens Hostel F|/o. Vinayak Nagar, lndra Nagar, Gachibowli, N/o. Jingurthi village, Tandur Mandal, Vikarabad District. 8 Thanikonda Gopi Krishna, S/o. Rama Rao, Age.25 years, Occ: supervisor in Nextgen Evergreen Hostel, R/o. Next gen evergreen Hostel, Vinayak Nagar, lndra Nagar, Gachibowli N/o. Rajampally village, Darsi Mandal, Prakasham District, Andhra Pradesh ...Respondents/Accused no.2 to 8

-tc

Petition under section 52g of BNSS praying that in the circumstances stated in the Memorandum of Grounds of criminar b"titioi, the High corrt ,a/ o" pr"rr"J t" quash the cognizance orders in cc No.2616 of 2026 pLnding on the firl oi il.," lr Additional Junior civir Judge-cum-X Addr. Judiciar Magistrate-of rrrst-ctass Ranga Reddy district, at Kukatpaili in the interest

l.A. NO: 1 oF 2026

"i,r;tG.

Petition under section b2B of BNSS praying that in the circumstances stated in the Memorandum of Grounds of criminar petitioi, tre High corrt stay all further proceedings in cc No.2616 ot )oza pending m"v oe pr"u.Ji to on the fire oiln" rr Additional Junior civir Judqe-cum-X- Addr. Judiciar MagistratJof First ctass Ranga Reddy district at Kukatpaiiy pending oiip"-rf tf,""ni"i. ,,i interest of the justice. "i

Orrrf,";;ffi

il"

This

Petition coming on for hearing, upon perusing the Memorandum of ^ Grounds of Criminat petition and upon heaiin g the prasad

arguments of Mr. VSRIVIV Sanaka, Advocate for the petitioner and Mr. Jithender Rao Veeramalla, Additional Public Prosecutor on behalf of the Res pondent No.1 and None Appeared for the Respondents No.2 to 8

The Court made the following: ORDER

t IN THE HIGH COURT F'OR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HyDERABAD THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE J.SREENryAS

RAO

CRIMINAL PETI TION No .L7909 0 f 20.26 (cNR No.HBHCOlO742g62ci26l Between:

Date: 29.1O.20.26

Sri Koduru pitcheswara Rao Petitioner/ de /acfo complainant AND

The State of Telangana and seven others .Respondents

::ORDER:: This Criminal perition has been filed aggrieved by order passed by the learned II Additional Junior Additional Judicial Magistrate ol.First Class,

the docket

Civil Judge_cum-X

Ranga Reddy District at

Kukatpatly, (for short, ,the learr:red trial Court)

in taking cognizance

of the offence under Section 122(2) of the Bharatiya 2023 (for short, the BNS), against respondent

Nyaya Sanhita,

Nos.2 to g/accused

Nos. I to 7.

2.

Heard Mr VSRMV Prasad Sanaka, learned counsel for

petitioher, and Mr. Jithendcr Rao Veeramalla, )

Public Prosecutor appearing for respondent

3.

Notice in respect o[ resporrdent Nos.2

the ground that the petitioner is the

the

learned Additional

No. 1_State.

to g is dispensed with on

de facto complainant filed the

present crilnin.rl pctition, aggricved b-v the cognizance order

passed

by rhe learncd r rial Courl

4.

Learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that the learned

X Additional .Jr-rdicial Magistrate of First Class, tl R District at Kukatpally, (for short, 'the learned Magistrate'), without recording satisfactiotr atro rvithour assigning any reasr)ns' took cognizan"e against responclent Nos 2 to 8 artd not against the olfr:nce' and

summons ancl thc sanle is conlrarv to lau"

issued

'l'hc learned Maglslrate

ought to have t-aken cognizanc'': of thc offcnce ancl not against the responclent Nos.2 to 8, as heltl by the Honblc Supreme Court

in

SunilBharatiMittalv.CentralBureauoflnvestigationl,GHCL Employees Stock Option TruIit v' India Infoline Limited2' Chief

Enforcemnet Officer v. Vidcocon International Limited3 ancl Fakhruddin Ahmad v. State of Uttaranchal and anothera Unless

the <:ognizance order passed b1' the learned Magistrate is quashed and neccssary directions are :SSLled to takc cognizancc trfresh in terms of the principles laicl dou'n by the Flon'ble Supreme Court

in

the judgn'rents cited supra, the petitioncr $'ill be put to great ha rd sh

iP.

(2015) 4 SCC 609 (2013 ) 4 SCC 50s (2008) 2 SCC 192

(2008) 17 SCC 1s7

:

5.

Learned Additional Public Prosecutor fairly submits that the

learned trial Court ought to have taken cognizance of the offence and

not against the accused i.e-, respondenl Nos.2 to 8'

6.

Having considered the submissions made by the respective

parties and upon perusal of the material available on record, it reveals that based on the complaint lodged by the petitionet f de facto

complainanl, Crime No.1887 of 2025 was registered on 25'O8 2025 at

Gachibowli Police Station, Cybel abad Commissionerate, against respondent Nos.2 to 8/accused Nos. 1 to 7 for the offence under Section 109 read with Section 3(5) of the BNS' Subsequently, the section of law was altered from 109 re ad with Section 3(5) of the BNS

to 122(21of the BNS. The Investigerting Officer/ LW '26, after recording the statements of the witnesses/ LWs. 1 to 25 and conducting the investigation, filed the final report before the learned trial Court on 31.07.2026. A perusal of the certified copy of the final report, which

was enclosed along with this criminal petition, reveals that the learned Magistrate took cognizance of the offence under Section 12212J of the BNS against accused Nos

l to 7 and issued summons

even without mentioning the date when he took cognizance'

7.

lt is relevant to mention tl-rat in sunil Bharti Mittal (supra) the

I{on'ble Supreme Court held tha't application of judicial mind by the Magistrate and his satisfaction that the allegations, if proved, would

constitute an offence are essential prerequisitcs lor laking cognizance. 'I'he Magistrate rs required to examine the complaint or

police report and the material placed on record ro determine whether

a prima lacie case is made out against the accused. Cognizance is taken rvhen the Magistratrl, upon such consideration, decides to initiate proceedings by issuing process. At this stage, the Court is required to judiciously assess whether the material placed bcforc it discloses a prima facie case and not to cletermine the guilt of the accusc<1

8.

Ir-r Fakhruddin Ahmad (supra) the Hon'b1e Supreme Court held

that before a Magistrate can be said to have taken cognizance of an offence, he must take notice of rhe accusations and apply his judicial

mind to the allegations contained in the complaint, police report or informzLtion received from any other source, alor-rg with the material file d the reu'ith. It is only whcn thc Magistratc applies his mind.

satisfies himsclf that the allcg:rtions, il provcd. u'ould constitute an

offence, anC decides to initiate proceedings against the alleged offender, that cognizance can bc said to have been taken. Cognizance

is taken of the offence and not oi the offender.

9.

In M/s. GHCL Employees Stock Option Trust (supra) the

Hon'ble Supreme Court held that summoning an accused in a criminal casr.. is a scrious mattor and criminal la*,cannot be set into

motion as a matter of course. The Magistrate is required to apply

judicial mind to the facts of the case and the 1aw applicable thereto and record satisfaction regarding the existence of a prima facie case on the basis of specific allegations supported by satisfactory evidence

and other material on record. Mere general and vague allegations,

without specifying the individual role played by each accused, are insuffucient to initiate criminal proceedings, and issuance of summons without such judicial application of mind amounts to abuse of the process of law.

10. In Chief Enforcement Officer (supral th,c Honble Supreme Court held that taking cognizance of an offence and issuance of process against the accused are two distinct stages under the Code of

Criminal Procedure. Cognizance is taken when the Magistrate applies his judicial mind to the suspected commission of an offence with a vie\ / to proceeding under the rele;vant provisions of the Code, and it

does not require any formal action. Further, cognizance is taken of an

offence and not of an offender. The initiation of proceedings under

Chapter XIV and. commencement of proceedings under Chapter XVI

are different, and issuance of process under Section 204 Cr.P.C. is

consequential to taking cognizance under Section 190 Cr.P.C. Therefore, the mere fact that process is issued subsequently cannot be treated as the date on w,hich cognizance was taken.

1. The petitioner, being a de facto complainant, himself had

approachr:d this Court and filed the present criminal petition aggrieved by the cognizance order passed by the learned Magistrate.

The record further reveals that the matter before the learned trial Court is at the stage of summons and posted to 04.O3.2O27.

12. The specific case of the learned counsel for the petirioner is that basing upon the impugned cognizance order. if the learned trlal

Court proceeds further and even if the accused are ultimately convicted of the offence alleged against them after a full-fledged trial, the1, may, at a subsequent stage, question the validity and legality of

the impugned cognizance order and the same is contrarv to lhe principles laicl down by the Flon'ble Supreme Court supra. In such

an event. it would cause serious prejudice and hardship and the petitioner would be compelled to face further rounds of litigation. In order to avoid such an eventuality and to ensure that the proceedings

are conducted in accordance with law from the inception, the petitioner'/d.e facto complainant has approached this Court seeking to

set aside the impugned cognizance order and to direct the learned Magistral e to take cognizance afresh and proceed with the matter in

accordance with 1aw.

13. It is aLready stated suprc that the learned Magistrate took cognizance of the offence against the accused and the same is

contrary to the observations and directions of the Hon,ble Supreme Cou rt in the judgments referred to supra, the act of issuing process

for summoning an accused to face a criminal trial is a serious issue

and such orders directing the issuance of summons to a person to face criminal trial cannot bc passed on the basis of cryptic orders and

iL should be an order reflecting due application of mind by the Presiding Officer while taking cognizance and issuing summons.

14. For the foregoing reasons as well as the principles iaid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court as mentioned supra, tJne impugned cognizance order passed by the learned Magistrate is liable to be set aside and accordingly, set aside. The iearned Magistrate is directed to take cognizance afrcsh in accordance with law, keeping in view the

principles laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court as mentioned supra and proceed with the mattei' in accordance with law.

t5. At this juncture, it is necessary to observe that this Court has been consistently coming across several matters wherein the learned

Magistrates are taking cognizance of offences without recording the

pima facie satisfaction against the accused for the offences by using rubber slamps. In several such matters, cognizance is being taken

bv passing routine and mechanical orders, without indicating due application of mind to the ntaterial placed before the Court. Consequently, this Court has, on several occasions. set aside such

orders ar)d remitted the matters to the respective trial Courts with a

direction to :ake cognizance alresh in accordance with 1aw. Since Januarv 2025, tlnis Court has set aside more than 500 cognizance orders. In 1.hosc matters, the accused approachecl this Court b-v fihng criminal petiLions, questioning thc legality of the proceedings, inter

alict, on thr-' ground that the learncd Maglstrates had taken cognizance u,ithout following the procedure prescribed by lau,.

16. 11. is a matter of seriorrs concern that, despitc sevcral orders passed kry this Court pointing out such proccdural irregularities, the same lapses c:ontinue to recur. The learned Magistrates arc expected

to inde pendently examine the malerial placed belbre them and record

their prima /acie satisfaction with regard to the specific offences discloserl against the accused while taking cognizance. Ilot,evcr,

lailure to adherc to this r( quircn.r( nt is rcsulting in avoLclabie challenges br:fore this Cor-rrt. Whenever such cognizance orde rs are

set asicle ard the matters are remitted to the trial Courts, the proceed ings have to recommence from the threshold stage, including

the issuancc of fresh sumrnons to the accused. Consequentlv, considerable judicial time is consumed in correcting procedural errors \\'hich could have been avoided at the initral stage itself.

. S.rch repeate d proceduri_rl lapses not onl,l l-lurden this Court

with avoiclable litigation but also consumc thc valuablc trme and

resources of the subordinate judiciary, the prosecution, the State

machinery and the parties concerned. More importantly, they adversely affect the interests of both the accused and the victims, as

the proceedings are unnecessarily delayed and the parties are compelled to undergo repeated rounds of litigation and also they have

to incur expenditure. The time and resources spent in rectrfying such defects could otherwise be utilised for the effective and expeditious disposal of pending criminal cases.

18. It is also relevant to point out that, in one of the matters previously dealt with by this Court, the proceedings were remrtted to

the Iearned Magistrate on account of an order taking cognizance contrary to law. However, even in the subsequent round of litigation, this Court noticed that the learned Magistrate, without application of mind, once again took cognizance of the offences against the accused and issued summons. Further, the learned Magistrate, even at the stage of taking cognizance, came to the conclusion that accused have

committed the offence and liable for punishment, without duly adhering to the directions issued earlier. Such instances indicate

thal merely setting aside the cognizance orders and remitting the matters to Lhe trial Courts may not, by itself, achieve the desired result unless the judicial officers concerned are properly sensitised to the legal requirements governing the exercise of such jurisdiction.

i0

19. I{ence, this Court is of the consrdered view that the recurring nature of such procedural irrcgularities calls for corrective measures

at the institutional level. 'l'he judicial officcrs concerned must be adequately sensitised to the legal principles governing the taking of cognizance and the necessity of recording pima facie satisfaction

with ref'erencc to the specific offences alleged against the accused. Such procedural deficiencies can be effectively addressed at the initral

stage iiself through appropriat-e training and guidance, thereby avoiding Llnllecessary challerrges bcforc this Court.

20.

IrL the larger interests ofjustice and to prevenL the recurrence

of such procedural lapses, this Court considers it appropriate to issue

necessary directions to the ltegistrar (Judicial-l) to communicate a copy of this order to all the l)rl-rcipal Distrrct anC Sessions Judges,

who shall, in turn, communicate Lhe same to all the learned Magist.ratcs rl ithin their rcspr:r-'tivc.iurisdrctions.

27. ,{ copl of this order strzrll also be foru.arded to the If ire ctor ol the Telangana State Judicial Acaclemy, Secunderabad, with a direction to organize appropriate training programmes for concerned judicia.l oflicers, particularly on the lcgal rcquircments and principles governing the taking of cognizance and the necessity of recording indepen den1. prima focie satisfaction before proceeding further rn a

crim ina I casc.

-a--;

22. This Court hopes and trusts that, by imparting appropriate training and sensitization to the judicial ofhcers concerned, such avoidable procedural irregularities can be eliminated at the threshold

itself. The object of these directions is not merely to rectify the procedural defects arising in indivirlual cases but also to ensure that

such errors do not recur, thereby preventing unnecessary litigation, reducing the trurden on the IJigh Court, safeguardlng the interests of

the accused and victims, and ensuring the effective utilization of valuable judicial time and pubiic resources. Ultimately, strict adherence to the procedure prescribed by 1aw at the stage of taking

cognizance would substantially contribute to the efhcient and expeditious administration of criminal justice.

23. Accordingly, the criminal petition is disposed of Miscellaneous applications, pending if any, shall stand closed SD/- B. REKHA RANI ASSISTANT REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY//

t.

IL

sEcrtdiv OFFICER One Fair Copy to the HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE J. SREENIVAS RAO f (For His Lordship's kind Perusal)

To,

1. The ll Additional Junior Civil Judge-cum-X Additional Judicial Magistrate of First Class, Ranga Reddy District at Kukatpally.

2. fhe Station House Officer, Gachibowli Police Station, Cyberabad Commissionerate.

3. Two CC to Public Prosecutor, High Court for the State of Telangana, Hyderabad [OUT]

4. One CC to Mr. VSRMV Prasad Sanaka, Advocate [OPUC] 5. 4 LR Copies 6. The Under Secretary, Union of India Ministry of Law, Justice and Company Affairs, New Delhi

T The secretary' Teranoana Advocates Association

Library. High

court for the Bri;i.si. ,i ,rri""lroro ^ The Registrar [Judicilt_t] Hish 8. C;;; ;;,;;"" state of Teransana .. State of Teta,rgana. figr, cor.t

communicate the order to alr

to tnJprincipar Oi.tri.i,lno Sessions Judges. r, reransana st# Jffi ;i ;cademy, s".r.0""i. Lro ?, ff : 33 [#:.o'*'to

KAM/GNK

i

HIGH COURT

DATED: 2911012026

4.

(o

o

12 il0ll zflffi

LJ

ORDER

CRLP.No.17909 of 2026

DISPOSING OF THE CRIMINAL PETITION

$ s

\\

1 HE 5I4

J-

''\-\-..-::

i\;

v * ,-/

Related judgments

More Telangana High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.