Sri Krishnappa v. Narayanaswamy

Court
High Court of Karnataka
Date of judgment
1 October 2026
Judge
Justice Sachin Shankar Magadum
Case number
WP No. 36528 of 2019
Result
ALLOWED
Subject
Civil

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

-1HC-KAR

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 1ST DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM WRIT PETITION NO.36528 OF 2019 (GM-CPC) BETWEEN: 1.

SRI. KRISHNAPPA S/O LATE DODDAPILLAPPA AGED 88 YEARS R/A NUGITHAHALLI VILLAGE NANDI HOBLI CHICKBALLAPURA TALUK CHICKBALLAPURA DISTRICT-562101 REPRESENTED BY HIS GPA HOLDER SRI. RAVI KUMAR S/O SRI NARAYANASWAMY AGED 30 YEARS R/A NUGITHAHALLI VILLAGE AJWARA POST, NANDI HOBLI CHIKKABALLAPURA TALUK AND DISTRICT-562101. …PETITIONER

(BY SRI. K.N. NITHISH, ADV., FOR SRI. K.V. NARASIMHAN, ADV.,) AND: NARAYANASWAMY SINCE DEAD BY HIS LRS. 1.

SRI. KRISHNAPPA S/O LATE NARAYANASWAMY

-2HC-KAR

AGED 42 YEARS. 2.

SRI. GANAPATHI S/O LATE NARAYANASWAMY AGED 40 YEARS.

3.

SRI. ANJINAPPA S/O LATE NARAYANASWAMY AGED 38 YEARS. R1 TO R3 ARE R/O NUGATHIHALLI VILLAGE NANDI HOBLI, CHICKBALLAPURA TALUK AND CHICKBALLAPURA DISTRICT-562101.

4.

SMT. MUNIRATHNAMMA D/O LATE NARAYANASWAMY W/O RAMANNA MAJOR R/AT. S. DEVAGANAHALLI VILLAGE SADALI HOBLI, SIDLGHATTA TALUK CHIKKABALLAPURA DISTRICT-562105.

5.

SRI. RAMACHANDRAPPA S/O DODDANARAYANAPPA AGED 60 YEARS.

6.

SRI. PUTTAPPA S/O VENKATAPPA AGED 45 YEARS.

7.

SRI. MUNIRAJU S/O VENKATAPPA AGED 42 YEARS.

8.

SRI. MUNIKRISHNAPPA S/O VENKATAPPA AGED 40 YEARS.

-3HC-KAR

9.

SRI. GOPALAKRISHNA S/O VENKATAPPA AGED 38 YEARS.

10.

SMT. SHANTHAMMA W/O LATE SUBRAMANI S/O LATE PUTTAPPA AGED 39 YEARS.

11.

S. GOWTHAM S/O LATE SUBRAMANI AGED 19 YEARS.

12.

SRI. MUNIYAPPA SINCE DEAD BY LR’S.

(a)

SMT. MUNIVENKATAMMA W/O LATE MUNIYAPPA AGED ABOUT 70 YEARS.

(b)

SMT. GANGAMANIYAMMA W/O LATE MUNIYAPPA AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS.

(c)

SMT. MANJULA D/O LATE MUNIYAPPA W/O MANJUNATH AGED ABOUT 46 YEARS.

(d)

SMT. GEETHA D/O LATE MUNIYAPPA W/O VIJAY KUMAR AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS. ALL ARE R/AT. NEEGUTHAHALLI VILLAGE NANDI HOBLI, CHIKKABALLAPURA TALUK & DISTRICT 562101.

13.

SRI. NARAYANASWAMY SINCE DEAD BY LR’S.

-4HC-KAR

13(a) RAJAMMA @ NARASAMMA W/O LATE NARAYANASWAMY AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS R/AT. KANDHAVARABAGILU C.C. CIRCLE, CHICKKABALLAPURA TALUK CHICKKABALLAPURA DIST – 562101. 13(b) GAYATRI D/O LATE NARAYANASWAMY W/O MURULI (L.I.C. AGENT) AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS R/AT. KANDHAVARABAGILU C.C. CIRCLE, CHIKKABALLAPURA TALUK CHIKKABALLAPURA DISTRICT-562101. 14.

SRI. GOVINDAPPA S/O DODDAPILLAPPA AGED 53 YEARS. ALL ARE R/O NUGITHAHALLI VILLAGE NANDI HOBLI, CHICKBALLAPURA TALUK AND CHICKBALLAPURA DISTRICT-562101.

15.

SRI. RAMAIAH SINCE DEAD BY LR.

15(a) LAKSHMIDEVAMMA W/O LATE RAMAIAH AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS R/O NUGITHAHALLI VILLAGE NANDI HOBLI, AJJAVARA POST CHICKBALLAPURA TALUK AND CHICKBALLAPURA DISTRICT-562101. 15(b) MUDDUKRISHNA S/O LATE RAMAIAH AGED ABOUT 31 YEARS

-5HC-KAR

R/O NUGITHAHALLI VILLAGE NANDI HOBLI, AJJAVARA POST CHICKBALLAPURA TALUK AND CHICKBALLAPURA DISTRICT-562101. 15(c) PRAMILA D/O LATE RAMAIAH W/O BASAVARAJ AGED ABOUT 39 YEARS R/O GUNDLAHALLI VILLAGE JARABANDAHALLI POST MANCHENAHALLI HOBLI GAURIBIDANUR TALUK CHICKBALLAPURA DISTRICT-562101 15(d) SHAIYLA D/O LATE RAMAIAH W/O GOPAL AGED ABOUT 37 YEARS R/AT. KAMMADAKA VILLAGE SOMENAHALLI POST SOMENAHALLI HOBLI GUDIBANDA TALUK CHICKKABALLAPURA DIST-560082. 15(e) SHILPA D/O LATE RAMAIAH W/O GOPAL AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS R/AT. POLARPALLI VILLAGE MANDIKAL HOBLI PERESANDRA POST CHICKKABALLAPURA TALUK CHICKKABALLAPURA DIST – 562104. …RESPONDENTS (BY SRI. MUNIRAJA M, ADV., FOR R1-R4, R8-R12 & R15 R5, R6, R7, R14 ARE SERVED AND UNREPRESENTED V/O/DTD:03.01.2020 SERVICE OF NOTICE TO R13 IS H/S P’SD R12(a) – SD & V/O/DTD:11.07.2025 NOTICE PROPOSED R12(b) IS H/S

TO

-6HC-KAR

R12(b), PROPOSED R13(b), PROPOSED R15(c) ARE SD V/O/D 23.01.2026 PRO’SD R12(c) MANJULA – SD PRO’SD 12(d) GEETHA – SD V/O/DTD: 01.07.2026 SERVICE OF NOTICE IN R/O R15(a), R15(b), R15(d), R15(e) IS H/S R15(a) - R15(b) – R15(d), R15(e) – V/O/DTD:12.08.2026 NOTICE TO R13(a) IS H/S)

THIS W.P. IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226 AND 227 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO SET ASIDE THE ORDER DTD 14.08.2019 PASSED BY THE LEARNED 1ST ADDITIONAL CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC AT CHICKBALLAPUR IN O.S.NO.172/2012 VIDE ANNX-E & ETC. THIS PETITION, COMING ON FOR PRELIMINARY HEARING IN ‘B’ GROUP, THIS DAY, ORDER WAS MADE THEREIN AS UNDER: CORAM: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM ORAL ORDER

The captioned petition is filed by the plaintiff calling in question the order passed by the learned Trial Judge declining to permit amendment of the plaint at the stage when the matter had been set down for arguments.

-7HC-KAR

2.

The petitioner-plaintiff initially instituted the

suit seeking a declaration that he is entitled to 1/4th share in the suit schedule properties. When the matter was set down for arguments, the petitioner filed an application under Order VI Rule 17 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short, ‘the CPC’), seeking leave to incorporate a prayer for partition as an alternative/consequential relief. The said application came to be rejected by the learned Trial Judge principally on the ground that the proposed amendment would alter the nature and character of the suit. The learned Trial Judge also declined the amendment on the ground of delay, observing that the application had been filed after lapse of several years.

3. and

Learned counsel appearing for the petitioner learned

counsel

appearing

for

the

respondents/defendants have been heard. This Court has also considered the judgment relied upon by learned

-8HC-KAR

counsel

for

the

respondents

in

M.

Revanna

vs.

Anjanamma1.

4.

The genealogy/family tree placed before this

Court by learned counsel for the petitioner discloses that one Doddapillappa had two wives, namely, Puttamma and Kondamma. The petitioner-plaintiff represents the branch of

the

first

wife,

respondents/defendants

Puttamma, represent

the

whereas

the

branch

the

of

second wife, Kondamma.

5.

The pleadings further disclose that the parties

do not dispute that there was a partition in the year 1955, during the lifetime of Doddapillappa, in respect of the ancestral properties. The case of the petitioner, however, is that the suit land was an Inam land and that Doddapillappa along with his three sons had sought regrant of the said land under the provisions of the Inam Abolition Act. The Deputy Commissioner, pursuant to the

AIR 2019 SC 940

-9HC-KAR

said

proceedings,

granted

the

land

in

favour

of

Doddapillappa and his three sons.

6.

The

petitioner,

while

acknowledging

the

partition of the ancestral properties effected in the year 1955, has instituted the present suit claiming a declaration that he is entitled to 1/4th share in the suit land. The defence of the respondents, on the other hand, is that there had been a partition and severance even in respect of the suit land and, therefore, the petitioner is not entitled to claim any share therein.

7.

On a careful examination of the pleadings in the

plaint and the proposed amendment, this Court is of the considered view that the learned Trial Judge has adopted an unduly technical approach in rejecting the application merely on the ground that the amendment was sought after a lapse of seven years and that the same would alter the nature and character of the suit.

- 10 HC-KAR

8.

The proposed amendment has to be examined

in the context of the substantive relief already sought in the plaint. The petitioner has, from the inception, asserted that he is entitled to 1/4th share in the suit land. The amendment does not introduce an altogether new or inconsistent case; rather, it seeks to incorporate the consequential

relief

of

partition

flowing

from

the

declaration already claimed.

9.

Significantly, when a specific query was put to

learned counsel appearing for the respondents regarding the nature of the suit land, he fairly conceded that the suit land was admittedly Inam land and that the same had been re-granted in favour of Doddapillappa and his three sons.

10.

In view of the aforesaid admission, learned

counsel for the petitioner submits that the entitlement of the three sons to the respective shares in the re-granted Inam land is not in dispute. According to the petitioner, his

- 11 HC-KAR

claim is confined to 1/4th share in the 1/4th share held by his father, Doddapillappa. It is further submitted that the pleadings already contain the necessary foundational facts and that the petitioner has led both oral and documentary evidence

on

the

relevant

aspects.

Learned

counsel,

therefore, fairly undertakes that the petitioner shall not seek

permission

to

adduce

any

further

evidence

consequent upon the proposed amendment, particularly since the matter has already reached the stage of arguments.

11.

In

the

backdrop

of

these

undisputed

and

admitted facts, this Court is of the view that the learned Trial Judge has failed to examine the substance of the proposed amendment in the context of the relief already sought in the plaint.

12.

The real controversy between the branches

represented by the petitioner and the respondents is with regard

to

the

1/4th

share

which

was

granted

to

- 12 HC-KAR

Doddapillappa in the re-granted Inam land. While the petitioner claims a share therein by succession, the defence of the respondents is that even the said 1/4th share had been partitioned and there had been severance of the joint status.

13.

Thus,

the

central

issue

which

requires

adjudication is whether there was a partition or severance in respect of the 1/4th share held by Doddapillappa and, consequently, whether the petitioner is entitled to claim a share therein. Both parties have already adduced evidence touching upon this controversy. Therefore, the proposed amendment

would facilitate adjudication of

the

real

controversy between the parties rather than introduce a new cause of action unconnected with the existing pleadings.

14. cannot

There is yet another significant aspect which be

lost

sight

of.

Even

assuming

that

the

amendment is declined, the petitioner would not be

- 13 HC-KAR

precluded

from

instituting

an

independent

suit

for

partition, subject of course to all questions of limitation and other defences available in law. Such a course would inevitably

result

in

multiplicity

of

proceedings,

notwithstanding the fact that the foundational dispute is already before the Trial Court and the parties have adduced evidence.

15.

The

Hon’ble

Supreme

Court

in

Sampath

Kumar v. Ayyakannu and Another AIR 2002 SC 3369 has

emphasized

that

amendments

the

real

determination

of

multiplicity

proceedings

of

which

controversy ought

facilitate

and

ordinarily

avoid to

be

permitted, particularly where the proposed amendment does not fundamentally alter the nature of the dispute between the parties.

16.

In the present case, the petitioner has not

sought to substitute the original cause of action with an entirely different cause of action. The claim that he is

- 14 HC-KAR

entitled to 1/4th share in the suit property is already embedded in the original plaint. The proposed prayer for partition is essentially consequential to, and in aid of, the declaration already sought.

17.

It is also relevant that the petitioner has

approached the Court asserting a specific share in the suit property. Merely because the suit was initially framed as one for declaration of entitlement to 1/4th share, the incorporation of a consequential prayer for partition cannot, in the facts of the present case, be regarded as altering the fundamental nature or character of the suit. The proposed amendment does not substantially displace the defence of the respondents. On the contrary, it enables the Trial Court to conclusively adjudicate the dispute regarding the alleged severance and entitlement of the petitioner to the share claimed.

18.

The fact that the application was filed at the

stage of arguments, by itself, cannot be determinative

- 15 HC-KAR

when the amendment is otherwise necessary for effective adjudication of the dispute. The delay can be adequately balanced by imposing appropriate conditions. In the present case, the petitioner has voluntarily undertaken not to lead any further evidence on the proposed amendment. The respondents can also be permitted to file a limited written statement confined to the amended pleadings.

19.

The judgment relied upon by learned counsel

for the respondents has no application to the facts of the present case. The present case is distinguishable on facts and, more importantly, the proposed amendment does not introduce a new and inconsistent cause of action so as to alter the basic structure of the suit.

20.

For the foregoing reasons, this Court is of the

considered view that the order impugned suffers from an erroneous and overly technical approach and cannot be sustained. The petitioner deserves to be permitted to amend the plaint, subject to appropriate safeguards.

- 16 HC-KAR

21.

Accordingly, this Court proceeds to pass the

following:

ORDER

(i) The writ petition is allowed. (ii) The order dated 14.08.2019 passed in O.S.No.172/2012 by the learned I Additional Civil

Judge

and

JMFC,

Chikkaballapur,

vide

Annexure-E, is hereby quashed and set aside. (iii) The petitioner-plaintiff is permitted to incorporate the proposed amendment to the plaint. It is made clear that the petitioner shall not be entitled to adduce any further oral or documentary

evidence

on

account

of

the

proposed amendment. (iv) The respondents/defendants shall be permitted to file a limited written statement, confined to the pleadings incorporated by way of amendment. (v)

Upon

completion

of

the

aforesaid

formalities, the learned Trial Court shall proceed

- 17 HC-KAR

with the matter and adjudicate the suit on its merits, in accordance with law, preferably within an outer limit of six months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order.

(SACHIN SHANKAR MAGADUM) JUDGE

CA List No.: 1 Sl No.: 8

Related judgments

More Karnataka High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.