Sri M R Shivakumar v. Sri Renuka Prasad
- Court
- High Court of Karnataka
- Date of judgment
- 3 November 2026
- Judge
- Justice K. V. Aravind
- Case number
- WP No. 24066 of 2026
- Result
- ALLOWED
- Acts & sections
- Section 151 CPC, Article 226 Constitution
- Subject
- Civil
Full judgment
Reserved on: 21.09.2026 Pronounced on: 03.11.2026 IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 3RD DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K. V. ARAVIND WRIT PETITION NO. 24066 OF 2026 (GM-CPC)
BETWEEN: 1.
SRI M R SHIVAKUMAR, S/O LATE RAJASHEKARAPPA, AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
2.
SRI. M.R. JAGADISH, S/O LATE RAJASHEKARAPPA, AGED ABOUT 58 YEARS,
3.
SRI. M.R. GOWRISHANKAR, S/O LATE RAJASHEKARAPPA, AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS,
Digitally signed by VINUTHA B S Location: High Court of Karnataka
PETITIONER No.1 TO 3 ARE R/AT 2ND CROSS, R.R. ROAD, DOOMLIGHT, MAGADI TOWN, RAMANAGARA DISTRICT-562120. …PETITIONERS (BY SMT. S. SUSHEELA, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR SRI RAMESHA T. R., ADVOCATE) AND: 1.
SRI RENUKA PRASAD, S/O KARIBASAPPA, AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
2.
SRI. RUDRESH, S/O SIDDAGANGAPPA, AGED ABOUT 52 YEARS, R/AT NO. 19, 5TH CROSS, PIPELINE ROAD, VIJAYANAGARA, BANGALORE -560 023.
3.
SMT. NAGAMMA. D/O LATE SOMASHEKARAPPA, AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS, R/AT KANNALLI VILLAGE, YESHWANTHAPURA HOBLI, BENGALURU NORTH TALUK, BENGALURU-560 091.
4.
SMT. PARVATHAMMA, D/O LATE SOMASHEKARAPPA AGED ABOUT 63 YEARS, R/AT NO. 178, 1ST BLOCK, 19TH MAIN, RAJAJINAGAR, BENGALURU -560 010. SINCE DEAD BY LRS SMT.NIRMALA B.B, W/O UDAYA KUMAR B.S, AGED ABOUT 53 YEARS, R/AT NO.15, NEAR GOVT. HOSPITAL, BETTAHALSUR, BENGALURU NORTH, BENGALURU-562157.
5.
SMT. LATHA VINAYAK KULLAHALLI, W/O VINAYAK KULLAHALLI, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS, R/AT ANUGRAHA NILAYA, NEAR BGS WORLD SCHOOL, NELAMANGALA, BENGALURU NORTH, BENGALURU-562123.
6.
SMT. JYOTHI B. B., W/O RAJESH B.G, AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS, R/AT NO.466, BETTAHALSUR, NEAR SAI VIDYA MANDIR SCHOOL, BENGALURU-562157.
7.
SMT. KUSUMA, D/O PARVATHAMMA, AGED ABOUT 31 YEARS, RESIDING AT NO. K-178, 1ST BLOCK, 19TH MAIN, RAJAJINAGAR, BANGALORE-560 010.
8.
SRI. CHANDRASHEKARAIAH, MAJOR IN AGE, S/O. LATE RAJASHEKARAPPA, RESIDING AT KANNALLI VILLAGE, KODAGEHALLI PANCHAYATH, YESHWANTHAPUR HOBLI, VISHWANEEDAM POST, BANGALORE-560 091.
9.
SMT. UMADEVI, W/O. LATE GURUMALLAPPA, MAJOR IN AGE, RESIDING AT KANNALLI VILLAGE, KODAGEHALLI PANCHAYATH, YESHWANTHAPUR HOBLI, VISHWANEEDAM POST BANGALORE-560 091.
10. SMT. HEMAVATHI, D/O. LATE GURUMALLAPPA, MAJOR IN AGE, RESIDING AT KANNALLI VILLAGE, KODAGEHALLI PANCHAYATH, YESHWANTHAPUR HOBLI, VISHWANEEDAM POST, BANGALORE-560 091. 11. SRI. SIDDALINGASWAMY, S/O. LATE GURUMALLAPPA, MAJOR IN AGE, RESIDING AT KANNALLI VILLAGE, KODAGEHALLI PANCHAYATH, YESHWANTHAPUR HOBLI, VISHWANEEDAM POST, BANGALORE-560 091
12. SMT.MAMATHA, D/O. LATE GURUMALLAPPA, MAJOR IN AGE, RESIDING AT KANNALLI VILLAGE, KODAGEHALLI PANCHAYATH, YESHWANTHAPUR HOBLI, VISHWANEEDAM POST, BANGALORE-560 091. 13. SRI. GURUSHANTHAPPA, S/O. LATE GURUMALLAPPA, MAJOR IN AGE, RESIDING AT KANNALLI VILLAGE, KODAGEHALLI PANCHAYATH, YESHWANTHAPUR HOBLI, VISHWANEEDAM POST, BANGALORE-560 091 14. SMT. SHARADAMMA, W/O. LATE RAJASHEKARAPPA, MAJOR IN AGE, RESIDING AT 2 CROSS, R.R. ROAD, NEAR DOME LIGHT, MAGADI, BANGALORE RURAL-562 120 15. SMT. VIMALAMBIKE, D/O. LATE RAJASHEKARAPPA, MAJOR IN AGE RESIDING AT 2ND CROSS, R.R.ROAD, NEAR DOME LIGHT, MAGADI BANGALORE RURAL-562 120 16. SMT. HEMAVATHI, D/O. LATE RAJASHEKARAPPA, MAJOR IN AGE, RESIDING AT 2ND CROSS, R.R.ROAD, NEAR DONME LIGHT, MAGADI BANGALORE RURAL-562 120 17. SRI. M.R.SHIVAKUMAR @ PRAKASH, S/O. LATE RAJASHEKARAPPA, MAJOR IN AGE, R/AT 2ND CROSS, R.R.ROAD, NEAR DOME LIGHT, MAGADI BANGALORE RURAL-562 120
18. SMT.INDRANI, D/O. LATE RAJASHEKARAPPA, MAJOR IN AGE, RESIDING AT 2ND CROSS, R.R.ROAD, NEAR DOME LIGHT, MAGADI, BANGALORE RURAL-562 120 19. SRI JAGADISH, S/O. LATE RAJASHEKARAPPA, MAJOR IN AGE, RESIDING AT 2ND CROSS, R.R. ROAD, NEAR DOME LIGHT, MAGADI, BANGALORE RURAL-562 120 20. SRI. SHANKAR, S/O. LATE RAJASHEKARAPPA, MAJOR IN AGE, RESIDING AT 2ND CROSS, R.R. ROAD, NEAR DOME LIGHT, MAGADI BANGALORE RURAL-562 120 21. SMT.JAGADAMBIKE, D/O. LATE SIDDAGANGAPPA, MAJOR IN AGE, RESIDING AT 6445, BEHIND MUNICIPAL QUARTERS, SUASHNAGAR, NELAMANGALA, BANGALORE-562 123 22. SMT.SHIVARATHNA, D/O. LATE SIDDALINGAPPA, MAJOR IN AGE, RESIDING AT OPP NO. 733, NETHAJINAGAR, BANGALORE-560 057 23. SMT.HEMALATHA, D/O. SRI. KARIBASAPPA, MAJOR IN AGE, C/O. REVANASIDDAPPA, NETHAJINAGAR, BANGALORE-560 079
24. SMT.VASANTHA, D/O. SRI. KARIBASAPPA, MAJOR IN AGE, C/O. SIDDARAMANNA, (RETIRED TAHSILDAR) ASHOK NAGAR, 9TH MAIN, 2ND CROSS, TUMKUR-572 102 25. SMT. HEMALATHA, W/O. KUMARASWAMY, (LATE), MAJOR IN AGE, RESIDING AT NARASANDRA VILLAGE, NARASANDRA POST, SOLUR SUB-POST, BANGALORE-562 127 26. MISS.RUPA, D/O. LATE KUMARASWAMY, MINOR-5 YEARS, REPRESENTED BY HER MOTHER, SMT. HEMALATHA AS NATURAL GUARDIAN, RESIDING AT NARASANDRA VILLAGE, NARASANDRA POST, SOLUR SUB-POST, BANGALORE-562 127 27. THE COMMISSIONER, BANGALORE DEVELOPMENT AUTHORITY, T. CHOWDAIAH, ROAD, KUMARA PARK WEST, BANGALORE-560 020 28. SRI. SRINIVASA MURTHY, S/O. LATE THIRUMALAGIRI GOWDA, AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS, RESIDING AT KODABORANAHALLI, HULIYUR DURGA HOBLI, KUNIGAL TALUK, TUMAKUR DISTRICT. 29. SRI.KUMARASWAMY, S/O. BORAIAH,
AGED ABOUT 38 YEARS, RESIDING AT NO. 274, 1ST N CROSS, 1STBLOCK, 2ND STAGE, NAGARABHAVI, BANGALORE-560 072 30. SMT.SUJATHA SHIVARAJU, W/O. SRI. SHIVARAJU, AGED ABOUT 43 YEARS, R/AT NO. 298, 8TH CROSS, 6TH BLOCK, II STAGE, NAGARABHAVI, BANGALORE-560 072 …RESPONDENTS (BY SRI K.N. PHANINDRA, SENIOR COUNSEL FOR SMT. P.C. VINITHA, ADVOCATE R1; SRI ANANTHA J., ADVOCATE FOR R2 AND R3; SRI K.V. NARASIMHAN, ADVOCATE FOR R22)
THIS WRIT PETITION IS FILED UNDER ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA PRAYING TO QUASHING THE ORDER
DATED
01.06.2026
PASSED
IN
OS.NO.786/2007,
PASSED BY HON'BLE VII ADDITIONAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND JMFC, BENGALURU RURAL AT BENGALURU AS PER ANNEXURE-A, ON I.A.NO. 28 AND 29, BY ALLOWING THE IAS WHICH IS PRODUCED AT ANNEXURE B AND B1. THIS PETITION HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR ORDERS, COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT THIS DAY, THE COURT PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING: CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K. V. ARAVIND
C.A.V. ORDER This writ petition is filed impugning the order dated 01.06.2026 in O.S. No.786/2007 passed on an application filed under Order VI Rule 17 read with Section 151 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (for short, ‘CPC’). The petitioners are defendant
Nos.13,
and
before
the
Trial
Court.
Respondent No.1-plaintiff instituted O.S. No.786/2007 seeking partition and separate possession in respect of the suit schedule properties. The plaintiff filed I.A. Nos.28 and 29 under Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC, seeking amendment of the pleadings and the prayer. The Trial Court, having considered that
the
proposed
amendment
was
necessary
for
the
comprehensive and complete adjudication of the dispute between the parties, allowed the applications.
2. submits
Learned that
the
counsel suit
was
appearing originally
for
the
instituted
petitioners as
O.S.
No.15001/2004 for partition and separate possession, which was subsequently renumbered as O.S. No.786/2007. It is submitted that, after the examination-in-chief of PW.1 was recorded on 28.11.2018, an application under Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC came to be filed, which was allowed and the
amendment was permitted. Thereafter, the plaintiff adduced additional evidence and marked additional documents. It is submitted that, subsequently, the present applications in I.A. Nos.28 and 29 seeking amendment were filed. The Trial Court, however, erroneously entertained the said applications.
3.
Learned
counsel
submits
that
the
proposed
amendment seeks to challenge the registered Will dated 13.05.1985 and the partition deed dated 20.07.2003. Learned counsel submits that the execution of the registered Will dated 13.05.1985 has been admitted in the plaint and that pleadings have also been made insofar as the partition deed dated 20.07.2003 is concerned. It is submitted that the prayers sought to be introduced by way of amendment are intended to delay the proceedings and dilute the admission made in the plaint. It is further submitted that the reliefs sought by way of amendment are also hit by limitation.
3.1
Learned
counsel
submits
that,
despite
the
registered Will dated 13.05.1985 and the partition deed dated 20.07.2003 being within the knowledge of the plaintiff, the applications have been filed after a lapse of 18 years, with a fraudulent intention to deprive the parties of their rights in the
joint family suit schedule properties.
In support of the
submissions, learned counsel places reliance on the judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Basavaraj v. Indira and Others1.
4.
Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the
respondents
submits
that,
when
the
applications
for
amendment were filed, the trial in the suit had not commenced and the matter was at the stage of examination of PW.1. It is submitted that any amendment which is relevant for the adjudication of the dispute between the parties is required to be construed liberally, so as to avoid multiplicity of proceedings and facilitate comprehensive and complete adjudication of the dispute. In that view of the matter, learned senior counsel places reliance on the judgments of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in Ragu Thilak D. John v. S. Rayappan and Others2; Pankaja and Another v. Yellappa (Dead) by LRs. and Others3; and Life Insurance Corporation of India v. Sanjeev Builders Private Limited and Another4.
(2024) 3 SCC 705 (2001) 2 SCC 472 (2004) 6 SCC 415 (2022) 16 SCC 1
5.
Considered the submissions made by learned senior
counsel appearing for both the parties and perused the writ papers and the impugned order.
6.
It is evident from the record that the suit in
question was instituted on 01.01.2004 and was numbered as O.S. No.15001/2004. Thereafter, the said suit came to be transferred and renumbered as O.S. No.786/2007. The parties filed their respective written statements, pursuant to which issues were framed on 02.01.2016. Additional issues were framed on 23.08.2016. The examination-in-chief of the plaintiff as PW.1 was recorded only on 28.11.2018. An application seeking amendment of the pleadings was thereafter allowed on 31.07.2024.
The
present
applications
seek
a
second
amendment to the pleadings.
7.
The affidavit accompanying the applications seeks
to explain that the amendment was necessitated on account of subsequent information which, according to the plaintiff, was not within his knowledge despite exercising due diligence. The alleged subsequent information relates to Palupatti
dated
02.05.1948.
On
the
basis
the of
Panchayat the
said
information, amendment is sought to incorporate a prayer to
declare the registered partition deed dated 20.07.2003 as null and void. A further prayer is sought to be incorporated to declare, on the same basis, the Will dated 13.05.1985 as a created document.
8.
Learned counsel appearing for the respondents
invited the attention of this Court to the unamended plaint in O.S. No.786/2007. In paragraph 14 of the unamended plaint, reference is made to the admission regarding the registered Will dated 13.05.1985. Further, in paragraph 19 of the unamended plaint, reference is made to the registered partition deed dated 30.07.2003. I.A. No.29 relates to compensation in respect of the land acquired by the BDA in Survey No.104, measuring 2 acres 33 guntas, in respect of which a right to share in the compensation is claimed.
9.
In both the applications, amendment is sought after
commencement of the trial. When the earlier application for amendment was filed, the suit was at the stage of recording the evidence of the plaintiff, and the said application came to be allowed. The suit has remained at the same stage even after seven years. Therefore, the proviso to Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC is attracted in the present case. In that view of the matter,
whether
the
applications
for
amendment
satisfy
the
requirements of the proviso to Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC is a necessary issue that requires consideration by this Court.
10.
Learned counsel appearing for the petitioners has
relied upon the three judgments referred to supra, wherein it has been held that an amendment to the pleadings is required to be considered liberally at any stage, if such amendment has a bearing on the issues to be adjudicated in the suit. However, certain exceptions have been carved out. One such exception is that an amendment, if permitted, should not have the effect of withdrawing any admission made by the party seeking the amendment. It is further held that even where the amendment raises an issue of limitation, the same can be permitted, subject to the issue of limitation being decided by directing the Trial Court to frame an appropriate issue.
11.
The interpretation of the proviso to Order VI Rule
17 of the CPC was not the subject matter for consideration in the aforesaid judgments. Whereas, in the judgment relied upon by the petitioners in the case of Basavaraj (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court examined the effect of the proviso to Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC when an amendment is sought. In
the present case, the requirements of the proviso have to be satisfied before the amendment can be permitted.
12.
The Hon’ble Supreme Court, in Basavaraj (supra),
has held that, though amendments to pleadings are ordinarily allowed to avoid multiplicity of litigation, the Court is required to consider whether the application for amendment is bona fide or mala fide and whether the amendment would cause such prejudice to the opposite party, which cannot be adequately compensated in terms of money. Another consideration is whether the amendment would fundamentally alter the nature and character of the suit or whether a fresh suit on the amended claim would be barred on the date of filing of the application. It is further held that any right accrued to the opposite party cannot be taken away on account of delay in filing the application. It has also been held that what cannot be done directly cannot be permitted to be done indirectly.
13.
The suit is one for partition. If the facts of the
present case are tested in the light of the aforesaid principles laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court, and the amendment sought were to include additional items of properties in the suit schedule,
the
same
would
necessarily
require
liberal
consideration in order to avoid multiplicity of proceedings and facilitate comprehensive adjudication of the dispute. However, the amendment sought in the present case travels in a different direction.
14.
Insofar as the registered Will dated 13.05.1985 and
the disputed partition deed dated 30.07.2003 are concerned, reference thereto can be found in the pre-amended plaint itself. On a plain reading of the plaint, no dispute was raised with regard to the registered Will or the partition deed. However, under the guise of amendment, the plaintiff now seeks to challenge the same by seeking a declaration that the partition deed dated 20.07.2003 is not binding on the plaintiff and also seeks alteration of the share claimed in the suit schedule properties.
15.
Though it is stated that the amendment was
necessitated on account of fresh facts coming to light pursuant to the Panchayat Palupatti dated 02.05.1948, no substantive or consequential relief is sought on the basis of the said Panchayat Palupatti dated 02.05.1948.
16.
Insofar as the claim for compensation made in I.A.
No.29 is concerned, the same relates to Survey No.104. It is
clearly stated that the acquisition of the said land was within the knowledge of the plaintiff as on the date of institution of the suit.
17.
From the above, it is clear from the pleadings of the
plaintiff itself that all the three issues relating to the registered Will dated 13.05.1985, the partition deed dated 20.07.2003, and the compensation payable by the BDA in respect of the acquisition of land in Survey No.104 were well within the knowledge of the plaintiff. In view of the proviso to Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC, an amendment can be permitted only if the party
seeking
the
amendment
establishes
that,
despite
exercising due diligence, such pleading could not have been made at the time of filing the plaint.
18.
As
held
by
the
Hon’ble
Supreme
Court
in
Basavaraj (supra), the burden is on the party seeking amendment to establish that, despite exercising due diligence, the amendment could not have been sought earlier. In the present case, facts which were within the knowledge of the plaintiff in the year 2004, when the suit was instituted, are sought to be introduced by way of amendment after a lapse of 18 years.
19.
The successive amendments sought by the plaintiff,
coupled with the fact that a suit instituted in the year 2004 is still at the stage of recording the plaintiff’s evidence, indicate the manner in which the proceedings have progressed. The intention behind seeking the present amendment cannot be said to be bona fide; rather, the circumstances indicate that the amendment is sought with a mala fide intention to delay the proceedings, thereby affecting the rights of the parties in respect of their shares in the joint family properties.
20.
Further, the amendment permitted by the Trial
Court has the effect of seeking to resile from the admissions made with regard to the registered Will dated 13.05.1985 and the partition deed dated 20.07.2003. The Trial Court, without examining whether the requirements of the proviso to Order VI Rule 17 of the CPC were satisfied, mechanically permitted the amendment. In that view of the matter, the order passed by the Trial Court cannot be sustained.
21.
Accordingly, the following:
ORDER (i)
Writ petition is allowed.
(ii)
The order dated 01.06.2026 on I.A. Nos.28 and 29 on the applications filed under Order VI Rule 17 of CPC is set aside.
(iii)
I.A. Nos.28 and 29 filed under Order VI Rule 17 of CPC stands rejected.
(iv)
Considering that the suit of 2004 is pending for more than 22 years at the stage of plaintiff's evidence, which do not provide any justifiable reasons for such inordinate delay, this Court finds it appropriate to direct the trial Court for expeditious disposal of the suit, which shall be within one year from the next date of hearing.
Sd/(K. V. ARAVIND) JUDGE
VBS