Sri P.jaya Prakash v. The State of Telangana,
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 3 November 2026
- Judge
- Justice G.M. Mohiuddin
- Case number
- WP No. 13116 of 2023
- Result
- DISMISSED
- Acts & sections
- Section 151 CPC
- Subject
- Property & land
Full judgment
[ 32961 HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD (SPecial Original Jurisdiction) WEDNESDAY, THE THIRTEENTH DAY OF NOVEMBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FOUR PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTIGE C.V. BHASKAR
REDDY
WRIT PETIT ION NO:13 116 0 F 2023 Between:
years' Occupation Private *,"*n r.rJ-.s"-s0d';";;5; ts;oi- rempte, v6dcnat, Medchal-Malkajgiri
Sri P.Java Prakash, S/o. Late P.Anjaiah, Aged about 40
E[,[r;",fr,i
District 501401. .....PETITIONER AND
1. The State of Telangana, Rep' by its Principal Secretary Revenue
Department'
Secretariat, HYderabad 5OO O22'
2. The District Collector, Medchal-Malkajgiri District 501 301 ' 3.TheRevenueDivisionalofficer'KeesaraDivision,Medchal.MalkajgiriDistrict 501 301
4.TheTahsildar,MedchalMandal,Medchal-MalkajgiriDistrict50,l401. .....RESPONDENTS
Petition Under Article 226 ol lhe Constitution of
lndia praying that in the
Circumstancesstatedintheaffidavitfiledtherewith,theHighCourtmaybe
partlcularly one in the nature pleased to issues a writ or order or a direction more 2023 issued by the 2nd of Writ of Mandamus declaring the order dated ' 26'04 to an extent of Ac'5'00 Respondent refusing to De-Notify the Land in Sy'No'503 District from gts situated at Pudur Village, Medchal Mandal' Medchal-Malkaigiri
theProhibitedListU/s22-AandnotissuingN.o.C.onthepretextthattheoriginal refusing to receive the Sale assignment file is not available in their office and before the 4th Deed dated. Og.O1 .2023 presented manually for Registration of the Tahsildar as highly illegal' arbitrary' capricious' violative RespondenU
Fundamental rights and consequently direct the Respondents to De-notify the land from the Prohibited list U/s. 22A and to issue N.O.C. |.A.NO:1 OF 2023
Petition Under Section 15'1 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the 4th Respondent to receive the sale deed Dt. 09.01 .2023 and register the same and release the document in favour of the petitioner. |.A.NO:2 OF 2023
Petition Under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in
the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the Respondents not to make any allotments in the remaining portion of Ac
5.19 gts of land in sy No 503 of Pudur village Medchal Mandal, MedchatMalkajgiri District Counsel for the Petitioner : SRI K.S.SUNEEL Counsel for the Respondents : AGP FOR REVENUE The Court made the following ORDER
-
(
HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE C.V.BHASKAR REDDY WRI T PETITION No.13116 of2023 ORDER:
This Writ Petition, under Ar[icle 226 of the Constitution of India, is filed seeking the following relief: '.-..to issue a Writ of Mandamus declartng the order dated: 26.04.2023 issued bg the 2'd Respondent refusng to De-Nottfg the Land in Sy.No.503 to an ertent of Ac.5.O0 gls situated at F\tdur Village, Medchal Mandal, Medchat-Malkajgtrt Distict from tlle Prohibited Ltst U/s.22-A and not issuing N.O.C. on th.e pretext tllo,t the oiginal assignment file is not auailoble tn their ofJice and refusing to receiue the Sate Deed dated: 09.01.2023 presented. manuallg for Registration belore the 4th Respondent/ Tahsitdar as highlg itlegat, arbttrary, capictous, viotative of the Fundamentot ights and consequentlg direct the Respondents to DenotiJg the land Jrorn the Prohibited list U/ s 22A and lo issue N.o.C.-.."
2.
lt is the case of the petitioner that his father, who was an Ex-
Serviceman, was assigned land admeasuring Ac.5.0O gts in Survey
No.503 situated at Pudur Viilage, Medchal Mandal, Ranga Reddy
District, under Ex-Servicemen quota, vide Patta Certificate No.B/5963/ 1998 dated 28.06. 1998. It is further case of the
petitioner that his father died on 26.02.2004, leaving behind himself, his mother and two others as legal heirs and a Legal Heir Certificate No.RK/566/2004 dated 25.O3.2OO4 was also issued. It is
further case of the petitioner that his mother also died on 08.05.202 I and thereafter, when he along with other legal heirs
submitted application for mutation of the subject property in their
Iffi
favour, it u,as found that the subject land in Sy.No.5O3 was rccorded as Government- land in lhe Dharani porttrl and listed in
the Prohibiti.r List under Sectio n 22-A of the Rcgistration Act, 1908. It is also case of the petitioner that on lJ6.04.2022, he submitted a representation to the respondent No.2 seeking to remove thc subject land in Sy.No.5O3 from the I,rohibition List, wherein thc respondent No.2 called for report from the respondent
No.4 through the respondent No.3 and uide endorsement dated 26.O4.2023
rejected his request citing non-availability of the
original assignment fi1e and that assignment dctails are not implemented in revenue records Hence the writ petil ion
3.
The respondent No.4 has filed counter affidavit, inter alia
stating that in pursuance of the application datcd 06.04.2022 submitted by the petitioner, the respondent No.2 has addressed a
letter vide No.tr2l7B3 12022 daLed 05.O7.2022 instructing the respondent Nos.3 and 4 to enquire into the mattcr and submit proposals for taking further action with regard to issuance of No objection certificate. It is further stated by the responclent No.4 that as per the instructions of the respondent No.2, on verification of the
Revenue Records, it was found that as per pahanr for the year
1959-60, thc land admeasuring Ac.T-39 gts in Sy.No.5O3, situated
at Pudoor Village, Medchal Mandal, was classificd as ,,Gairan
T,.::4Y
Sarkari," indicating that it belongs to the Government'
Despite bcst
not be
efforts, the original hle bearing No'B/5963/ 1998 could including traced. However, on verification of the revenue records' Section' the Pahanies and Faisal Patties available in the records name of late Sri Penjenrla Anjaiah, who is alleged assignee, was never brought on record at any
to be the
point in time' and no
Pattadar Pass Book was issued in his favor' It is
further stated that of the petitioner
there are no traces of cultivation done by the father
or his family members in respect of the subject
land lt is further
stated that from the year 1959-60 to till date' the revenue
records
consistently shows that the total extent of land admeasuring
Ac'7-
39 gts in Sy.No.5O3 of Pudoor village is recorded as Government Iand and out of the said extent, an area of Ac.3-36
gts was already
allotted to various Government Departments for public use'
It is
further stated by the respondent No'4 that a factual report
was
prepared and submitted vide Letter No'B 1652 12022 dated 25.11.2022 to the respondent No'3, who in turn submitted
a report
vide Lr.No.Cl l140612022 dated 07'O2'2023 to the resPondent No.2. Based on the said report, the respondent No'2 issued Endorsement No.E2 1783 12022 dated 26'04'2023, informing the petitioner that request for issuance of a No Objection Certihcate in respect of the Government land in Sy'No'503 situated at Pudoor village of Medchal Mandal cannot be considered'
--
''-
4.
Heard the submissions of learned counsel firr the respective
parties and perr-rsed the record.
5.
The learned counsel for the petitioner submitted that absence
of original hle cannot negate the legal rights of the petitioner under the Patta Certificate issued to his father. Further, the assigned land
becomes the absolute property of the assignce after 10 years. Therefore, the impugned rejection order dated 26.04.2023 passed
by tlre respondent No.2 is illegal, arbitrary and violative of principles of natural justice and ultimately prayed ro allow the writ
petition by setting aside the impugned order dated 26-04-2023 and issue a direction to the respondents to rectily the revenue records and grant succession rights in favor of the Iegal heirs.
6.
On the other hand, the learned Assistant Govc,rnment pleader
for Revenue appearing for the respondents vehemcntly contended
that father of the petitioncr is not an Ex-servir:emen and no assignment u,as made in respect of subject land. It is submitted
that the total land admeasurir-rg Ac.7 -39 gts in Sy.No.SO3 of pudoor village is recorded as Government land and out of the said extent, an area of Ac.3-36 gts was already allotted to various Government Departments for public use and the petitioner merell, basing on the alleged patl,a certificate and without any substantial evidence, is trying to grab the valuable Government land. It is further submitted
I
{
that the petitioner has no locus standi and the present writ petltron frled by him is not maintainable and ultimately prayed to dismiss the same.
7.
The case of the petitioner is that his request to de-notify the
subject land from the Prohibition List under Section 22-A of Ll:,e Registration Act, 1908 and to issue a No Objection Certificate (NOC)
for registration, was erroneously rejected by the respondent No'2 uide impugned order dated 26.04.2023.In contrast, it is the case of
the respondents that the original assignment file is missing and there is no proof that the subject land was assigned to the father of
the petitioner under Ex-Servicemen Quota, and that the petitioner had not applied for rectification of the revenue records for over [wo decades. It is also case of the respondents that out of the total land
admeasuring Ac.7 -39 gts in Sy.No 503 of Pudoor village, an extent
of Ac.3-36 gts was already been allotted to various Government departments for public purposes and they are in possession and i I
enjoyment of the same.
8.
A careful examination of the impugned order dated
26.04.2023 passed by the respondent No.2 reveals that the request I
of the petitioner was rejected due to non-availability of the original assignment file, classification of the land as Government property in
revenue records, and lack of evidence supporting the petilioner's
- ttf +i
{, -.--; .
claim that his father was granted
patta under the Ex_servicemen
Quota. As per the provisions of the Telangana Pattadar pass Books Act, 7971,
pattadars (including those
pattas for. Ex_Servicemen, freedom are entitled to have their names
entries made in the Revenue Telangana Land Revenue Act,
mutated in the revenue records
Records under the provisions
which are in existence since long
the present writ petition in the
correction of revenue entries
time. No reasons are forthcoming
from the petitioner as to why implementation of the patta said
steps were not taken for
to have issued in the name of
his
earliest point of time. Further,
as
of the total land admeasuring
39 gts in Sy.No.S03 of pudoor village, already allotted to various Government
r
entries in the year 2022 and,
thc respondent No.2 vide impugned
year 2023. The petitioner sought
I
in
the petitioner that he made an
order, dated 26.04.2023, he filed
and they are in possession and
of the
Act, 2O2O and the Rules made
application for correction of revenue
stated by the respondents, out
the
1317 Fasli and lelangana Rights
thereunder. It is the case of
father in the year 199g, at the
The entries in the Dharani
that are carried forward from
Land and pattadar pass Books
when the same was rejected by
issued
fighters, and political sufferers)
and to receive pattadar passbooks. Portal are consequential entries
Rights in Land and
Ac.7_
an extent of Ac.3_36 gts was Departments for public use
enjoyment of the same. Therefore,
if
iadr8
;w ,_: .€
the case of the petitioner has to be accepted, the exact extent of the
Iand claimed by him under the alleged patla must bc available' In the absence of same, the contention of the petitioner that his father
was assigned land under Ex-servicemen quota cannot be countenanced.
In view of the above, this Court is of the opinion that the
9.
present writ petition is not maintainable, as the petitioner has sought correction of entries in the revenue records after a lapse of nearly two decades. Furthermore, substantial extent of the land was already allotted to various public organizations' At this juncture, any order directing the correction of revenue records would disturb
the settled position. Therefore, for the foregoing reasons, this writ petition is devoid o[ merits and is liable to be dismissed'
10. Accordingly, this Writ Petition is dismissed. As a sequel, the miscellaneous petitions pending, if any, shall
stand closed. No order as to costs
sD/-P /TTRUE COPY//
DDY RAR 33BTAN+REt'F
\i\
SECTION OFFICER
to
,. ,rro ccs to Gp FoR REVENUE, High Hvderabad. [OUTI
court for the State of relangana
dir r''s'suseel' Advocate [oPUc] ,. iji:"bCi;CoPies 3. Two CD
SA BS
\
at
,-
HIGH COURT DATED:1311112024
. I db. s l'4 -)
o
02 r:; ztflt
t)
ORDER
WP.No.13116 of 2023
DISMISSING THE W.P WITHOUT COSTS.
Y
*
.D5
'SPal cH EO
*
6(