Sri Urdhab Dutta and 13 Ors v. Sri Sankar Ranjan Paul and 12 Ors

Court
Gauhati High Court
Date of judgment
5 November 2026
Judge
Justice Mridul Kumar Kalita
Case number
I.A.(Civil) No. 3850 of 2023
Result
Disposed Of
Acts & sections
Section 5 Limitation Act

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

Page No.# 1/11 GAHC010236492023 undefined

THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) Case No. : I.A.(Civil)/3850/2023 SRI URDHAB DUTTA AND 13 ORS S/O LT. GAURANGA DUTTA, R/O CHAPARMUKH TOWN, MOUZA CHAHARI, P.S. RAHA, DIST. NAGAON (ASSAM), PIN 782001 2: JADAV DUTTA S/O LT. GAURANGA DUTTA DIST. NAGAON (ASSAM) 3: MADHAB DUTTA S/O LT. GAURANGA DUTTA DIST. NAGAON (ASSAM) 4.1: SHIPRA BANIK W/O LT. SANKAR BANIK S/O LT. SANKAR BANIK P.O. CHAPARMUKH DIST. NAGAON (ASSAM) 4.2: GAUTAM BANIK S/O LT. SANKAR BANIK P.O. CHAPARMUKH DIST. NAGAON (ASSAM)

Page No.# 2/11 4.3: SANJAY BANIK S/O LT. SANKAR BANIK P.O. CHAPARMUKH DIST. NAGAON (ASSAM) 4.5: SMTI. GEETA BANIK (PAUL) W/O SRI SIBU PAUL R/O SANKARDEV COLONY W/O NO. 5 P.O. MARIANI DIST. JURHAT (ASSAM) D/O LT. SANKAR BANIK 4.6: SMTI REETA BANIK (SINHA) W/O SRI RAJASH SINHA R/O HAIBORGAON NEAR HANUMAN MANDIR P.O. HAIBORGAON ASSAM D/O LT. SANKAR BANIK 5.1: SMTI DIPALI DUTTA W/O LT. BIJOY DUTTA MOUZA CHAHARI ASSAM. 5.2: SRI GOPAL DUTTA S/O LT. BIJOY DUTTA MOUZA CHAHARI ASSAM PIN 782001. 5.3: SMTI PAYAL MAZUMDAR D/O LT. BIJOY DUTTA W/O KISHO MAZUMDER R/O JAGIROAD KANABARI PIN 782410.

Page No.# 3/11 5.4: SMTI KOYAL ROY D/O LT. BIJOY DUTTA W/O SADHAN ROY R/O CHAPARMUKH MARWARIPATTI PIN 782410 VERSUS SRI SANKAR RANJAN PAUL AND 12 ORS S/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL, R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN, MOUZA CHAHARI, P.S. RAHA, DIST. NAGAON, PIN 782001 2:KASHI PAUL S/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN 3:GOPAL PAUL S/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN 4.1:ON THE DEATH OF NARAYAN PAUL HIS LEGAL HEIRS SUJATA RANI PAUL W/O LT. NARAYAN PAUL R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN 4.2:PRIYANKA PAUL @ PUJA D/O LT. NARAYAN PAUL R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN 5:GOBIND PAUL

Page No.# 4/11 S/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN 6:LAKHAN PAUL S/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN 7:KRISHNA PAUL S/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN 8:SHYAMAL PAUL S/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN 9:SMTI ANJU SUTRADHAR (PAUL) @ SHUKLA W/O LT. GAUTAM PAUL DAUGHTER IN LAW OF LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL 10:SMTI ARUNABALAL PAUL W/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL 11:SMTI PARUBALA PAUL

Page No.# 5/11 D/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL PIN 78200 Advocate for the Petitioner

: MS B DEVI,

Advocate for the Respondent : MR. R K JAIN,

Linked Case : RSA/309/2018 SRI URDHAB DUTTA AND 9 ORS S/O LT. GAURANGA DUTTA DIST. NAGAON (ASSAM) 2: JADAV DUTTA S/O LT. GAURANGA DUTTA DIST. NAGAON (ASSAM) 3: MADHAB DUTTA S/O LT. GAURANGA DUTTA DIST. NAGAON (ASSAM) 4.1: SHIPRA BANIK W/O LT. SANKAR BANIK S/O LT. SANKAR BANIK P.O. CHAPARMUKH DIST. NAGAON (ASSAM)

Page No.# 6/11 4.2: GAUTAM BANIK S/O LT. SANKAR BANIK P.O. CHAPARMUKH DIST. NAGAON (ASSAM) 4.3: SANJAY BANIK S/O LT. SANKAR BANIK P.O. CHAPARMUKH DIST. NAGAON (ASSAM) 4.4: BAPPI BANIK S/O LT. SANKAR BANIK P.O. CHAPARMUKH DIST. NAGAON (ASSAM) 4.5: SMTI. GEETA BANIK (PAUL) W/O SRI SIBU PAUL R/O SANKARDEV COLONY W/O NO. 5 P.O. MARIANI DIST. JURHAT (ASSAM) D/O LT. SANKAR BANIK 4.6: SMTI REETA BANIK (SINHA) W/O SRI RAJASH SINHA R/O HAIBORGAON NEAR HANUMAN MANDIR P.O. HAIBORGAON ASSAM D/O LT. SANKAR BANIK 5: ON THE DEATH OF BIJOY DUTTA HIS LEGAL HEIRS NAMELY5.1: SMTI DIPALI DUTTA W/O LT. BIJOY DUTTA MOUZA CHAHARI

Page No.# 7/11 ASSAM. 5.2: SRI GOPAL DUTTA S/O LT. BIJOY DUTTA MOUZA CHAHARI ASSAM PIN 782001. 5.3: SMTI PAYAL MAZUMDAR D/O LT. BIJOY DUTTA W/O KISHO MAZUMDER R/O JAGIROAD KANABARI PIN 782410. 5.4: SMTI KOYAL ROY D/O LT. BIJOY DUTTA W/O SADHAN ROY R/O CHAPARMUKH MARWARIPATTI PIN 782410. VERSUS SRI SANKAR RANJAN PAUL AND 10 ORS S/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN 2:KASHI PAUL S/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN 3:GOPAL PAUL S/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN

Page No.# 8/11 4:NARAYAN PAUL S/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN 5:GOBIND PAUL S/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN 6:LAKHAN PAUL S/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN 7:KRISHNA PAUL S/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN 8:SHYAMAL PAUL S/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL R/O PHAPARMUKH TOWN 9:SMTI ANJU SUTRADHAR (PAUL) @ SHUKLA W/O LT. GAUTAM PAUL DAUGHTER IN LAW OF LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL

Page No.# 9/11 10:SMTI ARUNABALAL PAUL W/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL 11:SMTI PARUBALA PAUL D/O LT. CHITTYA RANJAN PAUL -----------Advocate for : MR. G C PHUKAN Advocate for : MR. R K JAIN (R1-R3 R5-R9 R11) appearing for SRI SANKAR RANJAN PAUL AND 10 ORS

BEFORE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE MRIDUL KUMAR KALITA ORDER

06.11.2026 1.

Heard Ms. B. Devi, the learned counsel for the applicant. Also heard Mr. R. K. Jain, the learned counsel for the opposite parties.

2.

This application under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 has been filed by the applicant for condoning the delay of 2018 days in filing application for setting aside the abatement of the connected appeal, i.e., RSA No. 309/2018 on failure to substitute the legal heirs of respondent No. 4, who had reportedly died on 18.12.2017.

3.

The learned counsel for the applicant has submitted that the engaged counsel for the appellant came to know about the death of

Page No.# 10/11

respondent No. 4 for the first time on 03.06.2019, when the said fact was informed by the engaged counsel of the respondent before the Court. 4.

She further submits that it was the advocate's clerk of the appellant's counsel, who was directed to take steps for filing Interlocutory Applications for substitution of legal heirs of deceased respondent No. 10 in RSA No. 309/2018 as well as RSA No. 306/2018, which are appeals analogous to each other.

5.

However, due to inadvertent mistake, though the advocate's clerk filed the Interlocutory Applications in RSA No. 306/2018, he did not file any application for setting aside abatement and for substitution of legal heirs of respondent No. 4 in connection with RSA No. 309/2018.

6.

The learned counsel for the applicant further submits that it is only on 30.08.2023, when the counsel for the appellant made an inquiry in this regard, she came to know that the Interlocutory Applications were not filed by the advocate's clerk, namely, Shri Hitesh Barman.

7.

She submits that there was no mala fide on the part of the applicants, as apparently the mistake was committed by the advocate's clerk, and in this process, a delay of 2018 days in filing the connected applications occurred.

8.

She, therefore, submits that as the reasons for delay in filing the application for setting aside abatement and substitution petition were beyond the control of the applicants, the same may be regarded as sufficient cause, which prevented the applicants from preferring the connected applications within the prescribed period of limitation.

Page No.# 11/11

9.

On the other hand, Mr. R. K. Jain, the learned counsel for the opposite parties, has opposed and submitted that an inordinate delay of 2018 days has not been sufficiently explained by the applicant. As such, he prays for dismissing the instant Interlocutory Application.

10.

I have considered the submissions made by learned counsel for both sides and have gone through the materials available on record.

11.

On perusal of the grounds stated in paragraph Nos. 3, 6, 7, and 8 of the instant Interlocutory Application, this Court is of the considered opinion that the same may be regarded as sufficient cause within the meaning of Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963, which prevented the applicants from preferring the connected applications within the prescribed period of limitation.

12.

As such, the delay in preferring the application for setting aside abatement and in filing application for substituting the legal heirs of deceased respondent No. 4 is hereby condoned, and this Interlocutory Application is disposed of.

JUDGE

Comparing Assistant

Related judgments

More Gauhati High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.