Srinivas Tirumala v. Union of India
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 28 October 2026
- Bench
- Justice P.sam Koshy, Justice Suddala Chalapathi Rao
- Case number
- WP No. 34359 of 2026
- Result
- ALLOWED NO COSTS
Full judgment
[ 3523 ] IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction) WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY EIGHTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT THE HONOURABLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE P,SAM KOSHY AND THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO WRlT PETITION NO: 34359 OF 2026
Between:
Srinivas Tirumala, S/o. Venkata Ramanuja Chari Tirumala, aged about 63 years, Occ. Retired Officer, SBl, R/o. H.No. '11-13-706, Green Hills, Road No.4, Saroornagar, Hyderabad -500 035. ...PETITIONER AND
1. Union of lndia, represented by its Secretary, Ministry of Ftnance, Department
of Revenue, North Block, New Delhi - '1 '10 001 2. Central Board of Direct Taxes, represented by its Chairman' North Block, New Delhi - 1 '10 001 . 3. The Principal Commissioner of lncome Tax, Hyderabad-4' Room No. 21 1' 2nd Floor, A-Block, lncome Tax Towers, A.C. Guards, Masab Tank, Hyderabad - 500 004. 4. The lncome Tax Officer, Ward-13(3) lncome Tax Towers, A.C. Guards, Masab Tank, Hyderabad - 500 004
...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Arlicle 226 of the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High court may be pleased
to issue a Writ, Order or Direction, more particularly one in the nature of a Writ of [\,4andamus, declaring the Order dated 20.01.2026 bearing DIN and Order No.ITBA/COM/F11712025-2611084967065(1 ) passed by the 3rd Respondent under
Section 1 19(2Xb) of the lncome-tax Act, 'l 961 rejecting the Petitioner's application
for condonation of delay in filing a revised return of income for the Assessment Year
2023-24 as illegal, arbitrary, contrary to Section 119(2)(b) of the lncome-tax Act,
1961 and violative ol Articles 14 and 265 of the Constitution of lndia, and consequently set aslde the same and direct the 3rd Respondent to condone the delay and permit the Petitioner to file a revised return of income for the Assessment Year 2023-24 claiming exemptron under Section 10(1 0AA) (ii) of the lncome{ax Act, 1961 in terms of Notification No. 31/2023 daled 24.05.2023.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRl. M NAGA DEEPAK Counsel for the Respondent No.1: SRI N. BHUJANGA RAO, DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERAL OF INDIA Counsel for the Respondents No.2 To 4: SRI K. SUDHAKAR REDDY, SC FO-R INCOME TAX DEPARTMENT The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOII THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERAI]AD HON'BLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE I'.SAM KOSHY AND HON'BLE SRI JUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAI'ATHI RAO WRIT PETITION NO.34359 OT 2026 (CNR No I lRl lcol07{,81 52016 }
DATE:28.10.2026
Iletween: Srinivas 'firumala Petitioncr and
Union of lndia, rep.bf its Secretar\', Ministry ol Ilinarrce, I)cpat Lrttortt ()i Rcvenu(', N.'rr' Delhi and three othcrs. Respondents
OITDER: (per Hon'ble Sri Jtrslice Suddnln ClLtlnprttltr Rtttl I leard NIr. lvl.lrlaga Deepak, learned counsel
for the
pctitioner and Nih. K.Suclhakar Rcclcly, learr.rtld Senior Standing Counsel for Income 'I'ax Dcpartment appcaring for respondent Nos.2 to 3.
1'he prcscnt writ petition has bct:rt liletl sceking to grant the
followir-rg reliel
"... lo issue a Writ, Orclcr or [)irection, more particularlv one
in thc nature trf a !Vlit tri \'lanclarnu>, tlcr:larrn1l the orcler clateel 20.01.2026 bearinli I)lN & Older No.ll'llA/COM/ F/17 /2025-26/lt)8l9o7Uo5(l) passcri bv thr: 3,.r rcsponclcnt
unL{er Scctiolr 119(2)(1.r) oI th(. I]lconrc
-l
ar Act, l96.l , r.cjoctrrlg
the petitlo:rcr's application for conclonation of rlelav irr filing a revisecl return of incor-rre for the Assessment Ycitr 2023-21,
as illcgal, albitrarv, contrarv to Section i19(2)(b) of thc Income Iax r\ct,.] 961, ancl violatir,e of Articles 14 ancl 265 of the Crtttstiiutiou rri Ittrli;r, attrl conscrlut rrl]1, Lcl sct .rsicle the same ancl Jirect the 3,.irespondent to conclone the clelar.and
permit the pctitioncr to file a revisecl return of irrcorne [ax for the saitJ a:is('ssn'lor1t r ear 2023-2-1 claimir-rg excrnptron urrcier Sectiorr L0(10Ar\)tii) oi the Incomc I ax Act, 196-l irr tcrms of Notif ica Lior L No. 1.l/ 2023 ciatec{ 2.1.05.2023 arrcl pas5 . .. "
3. The briel facts of the casc are that, pctitioner was an emplovee of St,rte Ilank ol lndia (SBI) and retired from service or.r superannrration on 31 .03.2023 upolt attailliilg tllc agc o[ 60 years
Upon such retircmcn t, the peti tioner becante entitlec-l to varlous terminal trencfits ir-rclucling the cash ecluivalent of the leave salarv
in respect of the Earnecl l,eave stanclirlg Lo his creclit. ,\ccordinglr,, the SBI credited the said benefits along with I-cave Encashment
amounl to zr l.une of Rs.10,69,889.12 Ps. to the account of thc petitiorler on 01.04.2023. 'Ihereafter, it is statec.l that the SBI issuec]
a certificate ol' tax deducted at source in Forn-r No.16 for the -F-inancial
Year 2022-23. rclevant b thc Asscssmellt year 2023_24,
on 16.05.2023 antl ir.r the saicl certificate, the emplover restricted thc
exemption under Section 10 (10AA) of the lncome 'Iax Act, 1961 (for short, ' Act,.1961') respcct oI leavt: encashment to Rs.3,00,000/-
bt,ing the exemption limit then applir:able io Non-Government employees, and treatecl the balance amount as taxable salary and consequently deducted tax at source of Rs.9,73,679/- for the said
financial year. I'he leave encashment benefit which was Rs.3,00,000/- as on tht: clate was enhanccd oide Notification
No.37/2023, dated 24.05.2023 (S.O. 2276(E)) of the Central Government to Rs.25,00,000/- under Section 10(10AA) (ii) of the
Act, 1961. It is stated that the tax deducted at source by the ernployer of the petitioner is reflected in the petitioner's Annual 'l'ax Statement in lrorm No.26AS for thc' Assessment Year 2023-24,
and the petitioner filed l-ris income tax return for the Assessment
\ear 2023-24 in F'orm ltR-l on 12.07.2023, within the due date plescribed under Section 139(1) of thc Act, 7961 r,ide acknowledgment No.435337790720723, claiming exemption of Rs.3,00,000/- towards lt:avt: t'ncashment, by' virtue of the said
notification No.37/2023, the exemption limit of Rs.3,00,000,/- was errhanced to Rs.25,00,000/- and it bcing beneficial in nature and
applicable to employces retiring before or aftcr 0'l .04.2023
-
4. It is urther stated that, bv the time the petitioner beca*e f
au'are of the applicabirit' of the said notification
and the enhanccci
exemption lirnit, the prescribed time for filing, a revisecl
rcturn of
income untler sc'cti.n 139(5) of the Act, 196r, for tr're Assessme.t
Year 2023-24, has a lrcac.ly erpired. Therefore, petitioner r,r,.as constrainecl t. move an applicatio. dated 2g.11.202s bcfore
the 3,.r
respondcnt rr nder lhe provision o[ Section I I 9(2)(b) of the Act, 1961, seeki.g c..dorratior-r of deray a.cl permissio. to fire
a revis.d
return of incttme for the Assessmcnt y ear ZO23-24, claiming the enhanced cxernl'r1iep [or,r,ards lea'c crrc.ashmctrrt in terms .f
Notificatio, N,.31/2023 a^d the petitio^er macll, the application well within the period of five vears prescribecl in respect of the Assessmcnt \ear 2023-24, a,ci that the 3,..r resp.nclent issucd a noticer datt:d 2.2.122025, ancl thereafter, the 3,r rcspondent b'
impugnecl Order, dated 20.01 .2026 rejected rhc application of the
petitioner stating that appropriate recorcls were callecl from the Jurisdictiona L\ssessing Officcr a.d the ]oint (,ommissioner of
Income fax, Rangr:-13, Il.,.derabacl, I;urthcr, as thc Joint commiss j o..r i, f,rnrccl tha t Notifica tio. No.3 I 2023 is applicable /prospectivc'lY .nlv to persolls u,ho retired on or
aftcr 07.04.2023
--
and by placing reliauce upon the juclgmcnt of the Fligh Court for the, State of Kerala in l{P(C) No.3l45 of 2022 anrl connected cases,
the 3.r respondent rejected the request of the petitioner for condonation of delay in filing the revised income tax return Aggrieved thereby, Lhe present writ petition is filed assailing the impugned order
5.
Learnod counscl for tht-. petitioner would contend that the
power under Section 119(2)(b) of thc Act, 1967 is con{erred on the cLrmpetent authority for the avoidance of genuine hardship and
the enquiry contemplated thcre under is whether the case is one
oi genuine harclship ancl whether the claim is primn fncie genuine, and does not contemplate a final adjudication on the merits of a clebatable question of law. It is further contended that Notification
No.37/2023 is a benelicial notification, and as there is no suppression or material concealment on the part of the petitioner,
the subsequent circular issuccl by the competent authority uide
Notification No.31/2023, enhancing the exemption limit to Rs.25,00,000/-, even applies to the emplovees, who retired even
prior to 01.04.2023, and that several similarly situated persons, who retired from the sen ices of the SBI alorrg with the petitioner
at various plac.-s across the counkl,, have also been extended ihe benefit undcr saicl \otification No.3 I/2023, along rvith va nous Income Tar ,\ppellatc Iribu,al Be.chcs l.relcl that thc Notificaiio,
No.31/2023 being be,eficial in nature extended the benefit to the emplovees. n ho rctired prior to 07.0,1.2023
6.
Per con tr,t, learrrecl Scnior Stanciing Counsel appearing for
the respondenl Nos.2 to 4, r.ehementh. contenclccl that in fact, the
competent atrthoritv i.e., l"l responclent, has alreaclv cor-rsicler.cl
thc issr-re anci olacir-rg reliance upon thc iuclp,.rnetrt of thc I {o1,i.l--
High Co,rt .f Kerala (supra) has ri,o,lr tlr,, rejeclccl thc petitioner.s conte'r-rtion. ll is iurthcr conterrdec-l that sirrcc thc rrotification \^.as
issued su bscquerrt to thc petiiiorrcr's rctircment, the said notification w,ould be prospective that would not be applicable tcr thc presen t c,t sr:
7.
On a pcrusal of thc rccord, c.,,icletrtly, as on thc date of r-hc
pt'titioncr's rotircmcnt fron-r the sen'ic:es oi SBI, ];orm No.26.\S specificallv rcf lectecl the cxemptron i. rcspect of leave encashment
to onlv i{s.3.0i.),000/,, anrl br virtuc ol. \otification No.31/202.3, datecl 24.05 2021, thc saicl c'remptio, limit rvas c.ha,ced t.
Rs.25,00,000/- and was issued for the benefit of the employees and
it is a beneficial legislation. Further, the petitioner has duly clisclosed the terminal benefits receivt:c1 at the time of retirement
and claimecl exemption only to the extent of Rs.3,00,000/- as was permissible at the relevant point of timc, and admittedly, there was no suppression or concealment oI any material. l'he fact that several Benches of Income Tax Appellate lribunal being quasi-
judicial fribunal, have already taken a similar view and extended thr. benefit ol: the saici notification to similarly situated employees
of the very same Bank, is not disputed by the learned Senior Standing Counsel for the Department
8.
We most respectfullv disagree witlr the view taken in the
dccision relied upon by the 3..t respondent in W.P.(C).No.3145 of 2l)22 and batch, renderecl bv the Hig,h Court of Kerala, and all the
terminal benefits would relate to the clate of appointment of the en.rployees in service and when once a beneficial notification is issucd, it shoulcl normally bc extendcd to all thc similarly situated PCrSOns
9.
In that r.,iew oi thc mattcr, for tht-. reasons assailed in tire writ
pt'tition, the pctitioner has made valid reasons to condone the
clelav for filinq of thc rc'ised retu,r oI irrc.me before the competent authorrlr., ic., ?'.4 rcspondeut. Ihereforc, in'iew of the
above aforesaid facts and circumstances, the impugned proceedines datecl 20.01 .2026 are herebv sct aside arrcl the delav in
filing the saitl rpplication is herebv condonccl a'rcr the matter is remancled back. to thc 3rcl respondent to co^sider the case of the
petitioner ln rcspect of the revised return of income for the
relevant r\ssessmelrI Years, bv extending, the benefit of Notificatio. No.31/2023, dated 24.05.2023, and pass orders strictlv in accordancr: with lalv
10. l! ith thc aforesaid directions, the Writ petition stands allowed acr-ording,l_y. There shall be no order as to costs
NIiscr'1l.rr.reous petrtio.s, if any, pcncling,
i. this Writ petition
sha1l stand closeti
SD/.P.C.SULEKHA DEVI ASSISTANT REGISTRAR //TRUE COPY//
SECTION OFFICER To,
1. The Secretarv, Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, Union of India, North Block I\Jew Delhi - 1 10 001 2. The Chairmarr, Central Board of Direct Taxes, North Block, New Delhi - 1 10 001. The Princ pal Commissioner of lncome Tax, Hyderabad-4, Room No. 211. 2nd Floor A-BIock, lncome Tax Towers, A.C. Guards, lVasab Tank, Hyderabad - 500 004 3. The Principal Commissioner of lncome Tax, Hyderabad-4, Room No. 211. 2nd Floor, A-Block. Income Tax Towers, A.C. Guards, l\rlasab Tank, Hyderabad - 500 004.
-
-
The lncome Tax Officer, Ward-13(3) lncome Tax Towers, A.C. Guards, Masab Tank, Hyderabad - 500 004
o
One CC to SRl. M NAGA DEEPAK, Advocate [OPUC]
One CC to SRl. N BHUJANGA RAO, Deputy Soticitor Generat of tndia loPUCl One CC to SRI K. SUDHAKAR REDDY, SC FOR |NCO|VE TAX DEPARTMENT [OPUCI
DAN
Two CD Copies
o
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2811012026
e STATR
ORDER
WP.No.34359 of 2026
t)
12w 2{P6
.!,
t
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION WITHOUT COSTS
lD
t& I e_[ lal
at