State of Karnataka v. State of Andhra Pradesh and Ors

Court
Supreme Court of India
Date of judgment
25 April 2000
Judge
Justice S.B. Majmudar
Neutral citation
2000 INSC 239
Reported in
[2000] 3 S.C.R. 301
Result
Disposed off
Acts & sections
Article 262 Constitution, Article 131 Constitution, Article 142 Constitution
Subject
Civil

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

...

ORIGINAL SUIT NO. l OF 1997 STATE OF KARNATAKA v. STATE OF ANDHRA PRADESH AND ORS.

AND

•

-!

ORIGINAL SUIT NO. 2 OF 1997 STATE OF ANDHRAPRADESH v. STATE OF KARNATAKAAND ORS. APRIL 25, 2000

[S.B. MAJMUDAR, G.B. PATTANAIK, V.N. KHARE, RP. SETHI AND UMESH C. BANERJEE, JJ.]

Constitution of India, Articles 131, 262 r/w Inter-State Water Disputes Act 1956, Ss. 4, 5(2) and (3), 6, 6-A-lnter-State water dispute-Krishna River Basin-Sharing of Water.r between riparian States of Kamataka, Andhra Pradesh and Maharashtra-Disputes refen-ed to Tribunal-Tribunal giving report in December, 1973 incorporating Final Order-Upon references made by the States under S. 5(3) Tribunal giving further report in May, 1976 containing modified Final Order-In both reports two schemes evolvedScheme A making mass allocation infavour of three states of dependable flow at 75% which was 2060 TMC-Scheme 'B' evolved for giving effect to allocation on percentage basis. in surplus and deficit years of jbw-Andhra Pradesh not agreeing to constitution of Krishna Valley Authority ( KVA) for implementation of Scheme 'B'-Tribunal therefore not making Scheme 'B' part of Final Order-Kamatakafiling suit against riparian states and Union of India for a decree that sU1plus water in excess of 2060 TMC be shared in accordance with Scheme 'B'; a mandat01y injunction to Union of India to notify Scheme 'B' and establish the 'KVA' and an injunction restraining Andhra Pradesh from continuing to execute projects till Scheme 'B' was effectively implemented-Held, Scheme 'B' was not a decision ofthe 'Tribunal and was not capable of being implemented by a mandatory injunction from the Supreme Court. Andhra Pradesh filing suit claiming that project-wise allocation had to be read into the mass allocation of dependable flow made by Tn'hunal and for a declaration that Kamataka's construction of the Almatti Dam to a height of

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

524.256 meters constituted an infraction of Tribunal's decision-Andhra Pradesh, inter alia, praying for injunction restraining Kamataka from coriStructing Almatti Dam up to a height of 524.256 meters-Held, the Tribu:nal's decision only made mass allocation and not pmject-wise allocatiOn; further held, as long as total user of water by Kamataka did not exceed mass allocation, Tribunal's decision was not violated and no mandatory injunction could be granted; there was no bar to raising of the height of Almatti Dam up to 519.6 meters subject to clearances by appmpriat~ authority of Central Government. Constitution ofIndia, A1ticles 131, 262(2) r/w Inter-State Water Disputes Act 1956, Ss. 2(c) and 11-Maintainability of Suit-Kamatakafiling suit for decree that Scheme 'B' which did not form part of Final Order of the Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal should be notified and given effect to-Defendants Andhra Pradesh and Union of India contending that this was a fresh water dispute within the meaning of S. 2(c) of the Act attracting the bar under Article 262-Held, the asse1tions in the plaint and the relief sought for did not constitute a dispute under s. 2( c) of the Act and the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court under A1ticle 131 was not ousted. Constitution ofIndia, Articles 131, 142 and 262(2) 1iw Inter-State Water Disputes Act 1956, ss. 2(c), 3(A) and II-Relief of injunction against plaintiff sought by defendant-Maintainability of-Maharashtra in additional written statement expressing apprehension of submergence of land in Maharashtra on account of raising of height of Almatti Dam by Karnataka up to 524.256 and praying for injunction against it-Held, the dispute raised would be a complaint within the meaning ofs. 3(A) and a water dispute under s. 2(c) of the Act; Supreme Court could not entertain it under either Article 131 or 142. Inter-State Water Disputes Act 1956, s. 6-Tribunal giving report and decision in 1973 and further report and decision in 1976-Andhra Pradesh filing suit with prayer for declaration that both reports and decisions in their entirety were binding on the three riparian states~tates agreeing to partial dec1T!e in terms ofsaidprayer-Kamataka contending that Scheme 'B' fanning part of report, its suit seeking enforcement of Scheme 'B' could not be resisted by Andhra Pradesh in view of pa1tial decree-Andhra Pradesh contending that Tribunal's report was like a judgment and its decision a decree in a suit which had to be read consistent with the report-Held, Tribunal's decision was not a decree and its report not a judgment in a civil suit; further held, prayer

y

-

t

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P.

~

in Andhra Pradesh's plaint had to be understood in the light of its assertion regarding raising of height ofAlmatti Dam; partial decree could not make the entire report and further report binding on the panies-Law of Pleadings.

Original Suit 1/97

'

....,,

.-'

~

-'¥

·Y

The dispute between the three riparian States of Maharashtra, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh with respect to use, distribution and control of the water of inter-State river Krishna stood resolved by the decisions of the Krishna Water Dispute Tribunal ('Tribunal'), constituted under s. 4 of the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956 ('Act'). The Tribunal's first report submitted on December 24, 1973 as well the further report dated May 27, 1976 evolved two Schemes. Scheme "A" made the mass allocation in favour of three riparian States of the dependable flow at 75% which had been arrived at 2060 T.M.C., indicating that in any water year Maharashtra shall not use more than 560 T.M.C., Karnataka not more than 700 T.M.C. and Andhra Pradesh not more than 800 T.M.C. It has also indicated that Andhra Pradesh which was the last riparian owner, would be at liberty to use the remaining water that may be flowing in the river Krishna but by such user the State shall not acquire any right whatsoever in respect of the excess quantity, which it would use beyond the allotted quantity of 800 T.M.C.

For giving effect to the allocation on percentage basis in surplus as · well as deficit years of flow the Tribunal evolved Scheme ''B" and indicated the same in its original report as well as in its further report. For proper implementation of Scheme ''B", the constitution of the Krishna Valley Authority (KVA) was absolutely necessary, Andhra Pradesh not having agreed for the constitution of the KVA, the Tribunal did not make Scheme ''B" as part of its Final Order and thought it fit to leave the matter either ·to the good sense of the rival States or for the Parliament to make a legislation to that effect under Entry 56 List I of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution.

According to Karnataka Scheme ''B" being a part of the decision of the Tribunal was also required to be notified by the Central Government under s. 6 of the Act, making it binding on the parties. Andhra Pradesh did not agree. Karnataka then filed this suit in this Court under Article 131 against Andhra Pradesh, Maharashtra and the Union of India

r-

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000) 3 S.C.R.

I

seeking a decree that the surplus water in river Krishna i.e. in excess of 2060 TMC at 75% dependability be shared in accordance with the determinations and directions of the Tribunal; a declaration that Andhra Pradesh was not entitled to insist on its right to use the surplus water i.e. in excess of 2060 TMC at 75% dependability, so long as Scheme ''B" framed by the Tribunal was n_ot fully implemented and a mandatory injunction to Union of India to notify Scheme ''B" framed by the Tribunal and make provisions for establishment of a KVA for implementation of the Tribunal's directions. Karnataka also prayed for an order of injunction, restraining Andhra Pradesh from continuing to execute several projects until Scheme ''B" framed by the Tribunal was effectively implemented. Andhra Pradesh in its written st~tement took a preliminary objection that the adjudication sought for by Karnataka was itself a water dispute and, therefore, the suit under Article 131 was barred in view of the mandate under Article 262 of the Constitution read with s. 11 of the Act. Further it was contended that only Scheme "A" could be held to be the decision of the Tribunal. Whatever the Tribunal had observed in relation to framing of Scheme ''B" was obiter and not a part of its decision as such was un-enforceable. It was further asserted that Scheme "A" having been acted upon by the parties for over two decades and under the said Scheme review having been provided for after May 31, 2000, the question of implementation of Scheme ''B" at this length of time was not only inequitable but uncalled for. Maharashtra also took the stand that the suit was not maintainable inasmuch as the implementation of Scheme ''B" depended upon the consent of the States and the Court could not force the States to give consent nor direct the Parliament to enact a legislation for the same. Union of India in its written statement took the stand that the suit as framed was not maintainable by virtue of s. 11 of the Act read with Article 262 of the Constitution. So far as the user of water by the State of Andbra Pradesh ! was concerned, it contended that the award having set out in gross the quantity of water which could be used in a given water year by Maharashtra, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh with the liberty to Andhra Pradesh to use the surplus water, the said lib~rty did not confer or create any right in Andhra Pradesh and such user would be subject to right of upper riparian States of Maharashtra and Karnataka. It further asserted that the award

~

.....

'v .--.. '.

• r ~

* 'y-

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P.

~

did not give a project-wise allocation but docs the gross allocation and each of the States was bound to give effect to the award given by the Tribunal.

On "the basis of the pleadings this court framed 13 issue including the following: (a) Whether the suit was barred by Article 262(2) of the Constitution read with s. 11 of the Act? '

...,,

(b) Whether Scheme "B" was part of the "decision" of the Tribunal under s. 6 of the Act and whether it was capable of or just and equitable to implement Scheme ''B" at this stage?

Original Suit 2/97 /

4'

-"'j-

......

~

Andhra Pradesh filed this suit in this Court under Article 131 against Karnataka, Maharashtra and the Union of India on the basis that though in the Final Order of the Tribunal, there was a mass allocation of water in favour of the three riparian States out of the 2060 TMC of water under 75 % of dependability, a closer scrutiny of the report in its entirety revealed that the allocation in respect of different sub-basins had been made on the basis of projects undertaken in those sub-basins and consequently, no State would be entitled to use the entire quantity of water allocated in their favour in any particular sub-basin. In the circumstances the post award constructions undertaken by Karnataka, including its intention to raise the height to Almatti Dam to 524.256 meters, were a gross violation of the decision of the Tribunal. Accordingly, Andhra Pradesh inter alia sought a declaration that the Trihunal's report and decision dated December 24, 1973 and further report and decision dated May 27, 1976 in their entirety were binding on the three riparian states; a permanent injunction against Karnataka restraining it from undertaking or continuing with any further constitution with its projects, including Almatti Dam, in the post award phase. Karnataka in its written statement took the stand that the Tribunal had not made any project-wise allocation and on the other hand, the allocation was enbloc. As such the question of interpreting the decision of the Tribunal to the effect that there was restriction in the user of water in any particular basin was not correct. Karnataka had contemplated the

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

height of the Dam at Almatti as 524.256 meters in the Project Report of 1970 itself. That Report had been filed before the Tribunal and had been marked as document MYPK-3. Neither Andhra Pradesh nor any other State had raised any obje<;tion to the said project Report and there was no issue before the Tribunal on that score. In fact the height of Almatti Dam was not a matter of adjudication before the Tribunal. Therefore there was no question of any violation of the decision of the Tribunal. Further the project at Almatti had been undertaken at huge cost exceeding Rs. 6000 crores and it was not in national interest to stop the project at this advance stage. It was reiterated that the utilisation of water would be entirely within the allocated quantity made by the Tribunal. The stand of the Union of India was that Karnataka was entitled to utilise the gross amount of water for any such projects and so long as it was within 173 MC in the Upper Krishna Project, there was no violation of the Tribunal's decision.

~

Y· ~

~

~

In its first written statement Maharashtra supported Karnataka and contended that the relief sought for by Andhra Pradesh in the plaint would tantamount to a complete re-writing of the decision of the Tribunal which would be outside the scope of a suit under Article 131 of the Constitution.

However in an additional written statement filed subsequently Maharashtra took a new stand in relation to the alleged construction of Almatti Dam with FRL 524.56 m. by Karnataka. It was now averred that by raising the dam height at Almatti, there was likelihood of enormous damage to private and public properties. Apprehending submergence of lands \\ithin its territory, Maharashtra now supported Andhra Pradesh in praying for an injunction against Karnataka from raising the height of the dam.

+-

This Court framed 3~issues which included the following :

(a) Had Karnataka violated the Tribunal's decision by executing the projects in the post-award phase?

(b) Did Andhra Pradesh prove that allocation of waters by the Tribunal were. specific for projects and not en bloc?

-~

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P.

(c) Was Andhra Pradesh entitled to a declaration that all construetions by Karnataka not in conformity with the Tribunal's decision were illegal? (d) Would the construction by Karnataka of the Almatti Dam up to 524.256 m enable it to use more water than its allocated share and should it be permitted to proceed witb ·the construction without the consent of other riparian states or the approval of the Union of India? (e) Whether Karnataka could be permitted to raise the storage level at Almatti Dam above RL 5090.16 m in view of the likely submergence of territories in Maharashtra? On September 30, 1997, the Supreme Court recorded the statement of the three riparian states that they had no objection to prayer (a) in Andhra Pradesh's suit that the Tribunal's two reports and decisions in their entirety be declared to be binding on them. Accordingly, the Supreme Court directed. that a partial decree could be passed to that extent. At the final hearing Karnataka contended that since Scheme 'B' was a part of the report, its suit seeking enforcement of Scheme 'B' could not be resisted by Andhra Pradesh in view of partial decree. Andhra Pradesh contended that the Tribunal's report was like a judgment in a civil suit and its decision like a decree which had to be read consistent with the report.

C

Dismissing Original Suit No. 1/97 and disposing of Original Suit No. 2191, this Court Held : Per Pattanaik, J. (For himself and other Judges in the Bench, with separate concurring/supplementing judgments by Majmudar, Sethi and Umesh C. Banerjee, JJ.):

1.1. Scheme ''B" framed by the Tribunal was not the decision of the

Tribunal and as such, was not required to be notified under s. 6 of the Act and consequently could not be enforced at the behest of Karnataka. [332-D-E]

1.2. The Tribunal never considered Scheme ''B" to form a part of its decision for being implemented even though there could not be any doubt about the efficacy of the Scheme in question. A water dispute having arisen between the three riparian States in relation to sharing of water of river

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

Krishna and the said dispute having been referred to the Tribunal for its adjudication and the Tribunal having investigated the matters referred to it had having submitted its report containing the facts found as well as its decision, it was that decision which conclusively decided the disputes referred and was capable of being implemented which could be said to be the deeision of the Tribunal under s. 5(2). (331-F-HJ

•

Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal (1993) Supp 1 SCC 96, followed.

1.3. Scheme ''B" provided for a fuller and better utilization of the water resources in river Krishna and in future if the question of allocation of river Krishna was gone into by any authority then the said authority would certainly look to Scheme ''B" which had been evolved on the date available then and acceptability of the same would be duly considered. [333-B-C] 2.1. The assertions made in the plaint and the relief sought for showed it to he a claim on the basis of an adjudicated dispute, the enforcement whereof was sought for by filing a suit under Article 131 of the Constitution. It was not a dispute within the meaning of s. 2(c) of the Act. Such a suit was therefore not barred under Article 262 of the Constitution read withs. 11 of the Act. (339-F-G] State of Rajasthan v. Union of India, (1978] 1 SCR 1 and State of Karnataka v. Union of India, [1978] 2 SCR 1, referred to. Constitutional Law of India by H.M. Seervai, referred to.

2.2 Such a suit was also not premature on the ground that a review had been provided for after May 31, 2000. The review indicated in the Tribunal's order was in relation to the allocation made under Scheme 'A' and had nothing to do with Scheme 'B' which was sought to be implemented through the suit. [348-A-B] 3. It was for the Central Government to exercise the discretion while granting any scheme or project of the lowest riparian state so that the latter was not allowed to proceed with large-scale water projects for · utilisation of the surplus water in excess of the allocated quantity over which it had no right. The discretion had to be so exercised to allay any apprehension in the minds of the upper States that for all times to come, their right of sharing the surplus water would in any manner be

:~

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P.

endangered. (345-A-C]

" ;)

4.1. The relief of permanent mandatory injunction so far as construction of the dam at Almatti was concerned as well as the reliefs sought for in paragraph (b) to (k) of Andhra Pradesh's plaint could not be granted. (403-D]

. I

~

y

.

-

-· -~

4.2. Under the decision of the Tribunal there was mass allocation and not project-wise excepting those specific projects mentioned in clauses IX and X of the decision. The plaintiff Andhra Pradesh had utterly failed to establish that there was any specific allocation by the Tribunal in respect of Upper Krishna Project or the Almatti Reservoir. (381-D; 396-G-H] 4.3. There was no restriction for quantity of user of water in Upper Krishna Project by Karnataka and so long as the total user did not exceed mass allocation, it could not be said that the decision of the Tribunal was being violated infringing the rights of Andhra Pradesh which could be prohibited by issuing any mandatory injunction. The very fact that restrictions had been put by the Tribunal in several sub-basins and no restriction had been put so far as sub-basin K-2 wherein Upper Krishna Project of Karnataka was being carried on clinched the point. [380-D-EJ 4.4. There was nothing to show that Karnataka had carried out any project in contravention of the provisions of any particular law made by Parliament or in contravention of any direction issued by the Government of India. (399-BJ 4.5. There existed no materials on the basis of which it was possible for the Court to come to a conclusion that on account of the construction of Almatti Dam within Karnataka the plaintiff had been adversely affected or was likely to be adversely affected. (399-F-G] 5.1. There was no bar for raising the height of the Dam at Almatti up to 519.6 meters subject to getting clearance from the Appropriate Authority of the Central Government and any other Statutory Authority, required under law. (403-E] 5.2. Though Karnataka could have the dam at Almatti, but the height of the said dam could not be more than 519.6 m, particularly when Karnataka had not been able to indicate as to what the necessity of having a height of Dam at 542.256 meters when Scheme'P.' was not going to be

(

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

\

(2000] 3 S.C.R.

operated upon immediately. The question of further raising its height to 524.256 meters should be gone into by the Tribunal. [385-F; 386-H]

"'

k

5.3. The Central Government was not duty bound to take the consent of other States while sanctioning any project of any of the riparian States. The project of each State had to be approved by the Central Government as well as by other statutory authorities and the Planning Commission, but for which a State could not proceed with the construetion of such project. [382-B-C; 387-C] ~-

5.4. The question of getting concurrence of other riparian States raised by Andhra Pradesh was wholly misconceived. Neither there existed by law which compelled any State to get the concurrence of other riparian States whenever it used water in respect of inter-State river nor did the decision of the Tribunal impose any condition in this regard. [397-E]

......_

~

6.1. The question of submergence of land pursuant to the user of water in respect of an Inter-State river allocated in favour of a particular State was inextricably connected with the allocation of water itself and the present grievance of Maharashtra would be a complaint on account of an executive action of the State of Kamataka within the meaning of S~ction 3(A) and also would be a water dispute within the ambit of s. 2(c) and, therefore, it would not be appropriate for this Court to entertain and examine and answer the same in a suit filed under Article 131 as a part of implementation of an adjudication of a tribunal. [393-A-B; G] 6.2. However wide the power of the Court under Article 142 of the Constitution might be, it would not be proper to entertain the question of submergence, raised by Maharashtra in its additional written statement and decide the question of injunction, in relation to the height of Almatti Dam on that basis. [394-A-B]

Delhi Judicial Services Assn. v. State of Gujarat, [1991] 4SCC 406 and State of Rajasthan v. Union of India, [1978] 1 SCR 1, referred to.

7.1. The decision of the Tribunal was not a decree which has to be understood in the light of the judgment in the suit. The Tribunal's report was also not a judgment and was not required to be notified so as to make it binding on the parties. It was only the decision of the Tribunal which was required to be published in the Official Gazette and on such publication

'f .--

r"'-

}--

y

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P.

that decision became final and was binding on the parties. [370-E-G]

Kalikrishna Tagore v. The Secretary of State, LR 15 Indian Appeals 186; Law Repo11 25 Indian Appeals at 107-08 and 1913 Vol. 25 Mad. LI 24, referred to.

, -(

7.2. The order of this Court dated September 30, 1997 did not mean that a decree had to be passed making the entire report as well as the further report of the Tribunal binding on the parties. When a prayer was made in a plaint, the said prayer has to be understood in the light of the assertion. [371-B; 370-G] Per S.B. Majmudar, J. (Supplementing) :

1. No project-wise allocation of available water was decided upon by the Tribunal while framing Scheme "A" so far as the Upper Krishna Project (UKP) was concerned. [410-H] 2. What height the Almatti dam should be constructed was not on the anvil of scrutiny of the Tribunal nor was any decision rendered by the Tribunal in that connection which could be made subject matter of the challenge in the present suit of Andhra Pradesh on the ground that any such express direction of the Tribunal in this connection was violated by Karnataka. [410-H; 411-A-B] 3. If the height of Almatti Dam was fixed at FRL 519.6 m it would meet the requirements not only of Andhra Pradesh but also would not fall foul of the opinion of the Expert Committee as well as the clearance given by the Central Water Commission to Stage II of the UKP. Any increase of the height beyond FRL 519 m. depended upon further allotment of water to Karnataka by any subsequent decision of the Tribunal, as and when constituted, as that would depend upon the implementation of the proposed Scheme "B" which had not yet been elevated to the status of a binding decision of any Water Disputes Tribunal. [419-E; 420-CJ 4. Constitution of Almatti Dam with an FRL 524.256 together with all other projects executed and in progress and contemplated by Karnataka could not be granted nor could Karnataka be permitted to construct up to that height without the consent of all other riparian States as well as without the approval of the Central Government. However, this would be subject to the rider that there could not be any objection to permitting

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000) 3 S.C.R.

Karnataka to construct Almatti Dam up to a height of 519 m. This was further subject to clearance by all other competent authorities functioning under different statutes. Requisite clearance would be required by Karnataka for raising the height of the dam even up to 519 m. [427-D-E] 5. On a conjoint reading of s. 2(c)(i) and 3(a) of the Act, the grievance voiced by Maharashtra against Karnataka would fall within the forecomers of the Act enacted by the Legislature under Article 262 and cannot be adjudicated upon by the Supreme Court under Article 131. [425-D-E] Per Banerjee, J. (concurring)

C

1. Scheme B was not a decision of the Tribunal requiring publication or notification by the Central Government in terms of the provisions of the Act. The Krishna Valley Authority being the 'heart of the Scheme' not yet having been created by Central Government, the question of implementation of Scheme B, as a decision of the Tribunal did not and could not arise. [451-E; 453-B]

"1 •

State of Wisconsin v. State of Illinois, 74 L. ed. 799, referred to.

.G

2. The observations of the Tribunal on the issue of Scheme B were wholly without jurisdiction. A Tribunal could not exhypothesia pronounce a decision which required for its implementation, a law to be enacted by Parliament or by consent of the' parties. The Union Government would not have any obligation to agree to carry out any such directive. [452-B-C; G] 3. The suit by Karnataka was maintainable. It pertained to implementation, but did not require any further adjudication of water dispute between States within the meaning of s. 2(c) of the Act. [445-H; 446-D] In Re Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal AIR (1992) SC 522; N.P. Ponnuswami v. Returning Officer, Namakkal Constitutency, [1952] SCR 218 and Mohinder Singh Gill v. The Chief Election Commissioner; New Delh4 [1978] 2 SCR 272, referred to • 4. The situation was not conducive for the grant of injunction as prayed for by Andhra Pradesh neither was such injunction warranted at this juncture. [465-B]

Colgate Palmolive (India) Ltd. v.HindustanLever Ltd., [1999] 7SCC1

1'"-

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P.

and State of Kamataka v. Union of India, [1978) 2 SCR 1, referred to.

By reason of the report to the experts, the Almatti Dam and its upper limit could be placed at FRL 519 subject however, to clearance from appropriate authority or authorities as required under the l~w. Question of raising the ultimate height at Almatti Dam could be gone' into by the B Tribunal upon assessment of the situation as placed by the riparian States and upon assessment of the apprehension of submergence and the appre< __ hension of loss of Kharif crop as well. [468-B-C] · ' .........

5. The Tribunal is directed to look into the matter if and when occasion arose as regards the allocation of water in River Krishna Basin, totally uninfluenced by the observations made by the earlier Tribunal's view by reason of long lapse of time and the availability of modern technology. [468-D]

r

Per Sethi, J. (concurring)

C

Right to water is a fundamental right. The disputes relating to water management are to be considered not from rigid technical or legal angle but from humanitarian point of view. [470-E-G] CIVIL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION : Original Suit No. 1.

Under Article 131 of the Constitution of India.

-

~-

Ashok H. Desai, Soli J. Sorabjee, Attonemey Generals, Harish N. Salve, Solicitor Generals, M.S. Usgaonkar, R.N. Trivedi, K.N. Rawal, Additional Solicitor General, F.S. Nariman, S.S. Javali, A.K. Ganguli, K. Parasaran, T.R. Andhyarujina, M.S. Nargolkar, G. Raghurarn, N.N. Goswami, A.N. Jayararn, (N.V. Rarnana), Addi. Advocate General for State of A.P., (A.N. Jayararn) Advocate General for State of Karnataka, S.P. Singh, Subhash Sharma, Mohan ")'- Katarki, Ms. Poonarn Kumar, Sanjay R. Hegde, G. Umapathi, G. Prabhakar, Subrat Birla, D.M. Nargolkar, S. Wasim, A. Quadri, S.K. Dwivedi, A.K. Sharma, B. Krishna Prasad, Ms. Sushrna Suri, K.K. Tyagi, Ms. Shalini Bhalla, Vmeet Kumar, K.R. Nagaraja, C. V. Sobba Rao, Shambhu Pd. Singh, S. Vijayashankar, A. Ram Narayan, Rajeev Shanna, (Nikhil Nayyar) for the State of A.P., Dhruv Mehta, R.N. Ve1ma, Dr. S.C. Jain and Parag Tripathi for the appearing parties.

'.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000) 3 S.C.R.

The Judgments of the Court were delivered by ii<

PATTANAIK, J. River Krishna originates in the State of Maharashtra and flows down through the State of Kamataka and State of Andhra Pradesh and meets the Bay of Bengal in Andhra Pradesh. It has got several tributaries and in the pre-independence era, there was not much dispute between the then · States for sharing water of any inter-State river. Even then, when large-scale projects were taken up in one State, the other riparian States were apprehensive of getting their share of water from the river and it is in this context, for sharing the water of Tungabhadra, another river in Krishna Basin, there was an agreement in 1944, settling the dispute concerning the share of the water of the said river Tungabhadra. After the Constitution of India came into force, the Krishna basin fell within the territories of the States of Bombay, Mysore, Hyderabad and Madras. The States went on planning for erection of big projects for proper utilization of the waters of Krishna basin and in July, 1951, a memorandum of agreement had been drawn up for apportionment of the D available supply of Krishna river system among the four riparian States namely, States of Bombay, Hyderabad, Madras and Mysore. It appears that the said memorandum of agreement had been drawn up to ·remain valid for a period of 25 years and even at that point of time, the State of Mysore refused to ratify the agreement. After implementation of the recommendations of the States Reorganisation Act, in the year 1956, the Krishna basin came to be E controlled by the States of Bombay, Mysore and Andhra Pradesh, which became the riparian States. Each of these States became active for exercising their right share over the water of Krishna valley and the Central Water and Power Commission had drawn up a scheme for re-allocation of the Krishna water. That however was not acceptable to the States and no agreement F between the States could be reached. Whenever any of the riparian State would come up with major projects, the other States would object to the same. By undertaking the construction of large projects py different States, pressure became more on the available supplies and disputes between the riparian States became more and more bitter. Several objections were raised in relation to Nagarjunasagar and Srisailam projects in Andhra Pradesh as well as Koyna G project in Maharashtra. The Central Government, in 1963 had taken a decision to clear up the pending new projects on the basis that the withdrawal of water by the States of Maharashtra, Mysore and Andhra Pradesh should not exceed 400, 600 and 800 T.M.C. respectively. This decision of the Central Government was not acceptable to the State of Maharashtra and in June, 1963, the H Maharashtra Government had requested the Govt. of India for making a·

'¥ ..

i1·

..,.__ ~

~-

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.

reference of the disputes to a Tribunal. Between the period of 1963 to 1969, the Central Government tried their best to resolve the disputes between the riparian States by negotiations and holding several inter-State Conferences. But it received more number of applications for reference of the dispute in the years 1968 and 1969. Then again, on account of re-organisation of the States and re-distribution of the Tungabhadra Valley itself between the States of Mysore and Andhra Pradesh, disputes also arose concerning the validity of the earlier Tungabhadra agreement and the control and distribution of Tungabhadra water. The State of Kamataka is the successor State of State of Mysore. Finally on lQth of April, 1969, Government of India constituted the Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal and called upon the Tribunal for adjudication of the water disputes regarding the inter-State river Krishna and the river valley thereof. The Tribunal was constituted under Section 4 of the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act'), which Act has been enacted by the Parliament in exercise of powers conferred under Article 262 of the Constitution of India. The said Tribunal on consideration of the materials placed before it, investigated into the matters referred to it and forwarded a repo1t to the Central Government, setting out the facts found by it and giving its decisions of the matters referred to it, on 24th of December, 1973, under Section 5(2) of the Act. On receipt of the said report and the decision, the Government of India as well as the three riparian States namely States of Maharashtra, Kamataka and Andhra Pradesh made references to the tribunal for further consideration under Section 5(3) of the Act and the tribunal on consideration of those references submitted its further report giving such explanations or guidance, as the tribunal deemed fit on the matters referred to it under Section 5(3) on 27th of May, 1976. It may be stated that the 01iginal report dated 24m of December, 1973 contained the Final Order of the tribunal and the further report dated 27th of May, 1976 also contained the modified Final Order, which modification was necessary because of explanations given to references made by different States under Section 5(3) of the Act. The Central Government construed the aforesaid Final Order to be the decision of the tribunal and accordingly, published the same in the Extraordinary Gazette dated 31 81 of May, 1976 and on such publication, the said Final Order has statutorily become final and binding on the parties to the dispute. In the Repo1t of the tribunal as well as in the further Report, submitted by the tribunal, two Schemes have been evolved - Scheme "A" and Schem~ "B". On the basis of agreement between all the States, the availability of water in Krishna basin was found out at 2060 T.M.C. on 75% dependability. The

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

tribunal under Scheme "A" made the mass allocation in favour of three riparian States of the dependable flow at 75% which had been an"ived at 2060 T.M.C., indicating that the State of Maharashtra shall not use in any water year more than 560 T.M.C., the State of Kamataka shall not use in any water year more than 700 T.M.C. and the State of Andhra Pradesh shall not use more than 800 T.M.C in any water year. It had also indicated that the State of Andhra Pradesh which is the last riparian owner, will be at liberty to use the remaining water that may be flowing in the river Krishna but by such user the State shall not acquire any tight whatsoever in respect of the excess quantity, which it uses beyond the allotted quantity of 800 T.M.C. It is to be stated that in course of the proceedings before the tribunal, several schemes had been submitted by the States for the examination of the tribunal and the tribunal considered all such schemes and had finally evolved the Scheme "A". On 4th of May, 1973, all the three States subrni tted their views under the signature of their respective counsel on the method of allocation to be adopted by the tribunal which was marked before the tribunal as Exhibit MRK- 340 and under that document the parties had called upon the tribunal not only to have mass allocation of utilisable dependable flow at 75% but also for allocation on percentage basis in surplus as well as deficit years of flow and restrictions with regard to the use and the nature of such restrictions was to be decided by the tribunal. It also called upon the tribunal to have a joint control body to monitor the said allocation on percentage basis in surplus as well as deficit years of flow. For giving effect to the allocation on percentage basis in surplus as well as deficit years of flow, the tt"ibunal evolved the Scheme "B" and indicated the same in its original report as well as in its fmther report. But for proper implementation. of Scheme "B", the constitution of the Krishna Valley Authot"ity was absolutely necessary and the State of Andhra Pradesh not having agreed for constitution of the controlling authority, the tribunal did not make Scheme "B" as part of its Final Order though the said Scheme "B" was a part of its original report as well as the further report and thought it fit to leave the matter either to the good sense of the rival States or for the Parliament to make a legislation to that effect under Entry 56 of List I of the Seventh Schedule to the Constitution. The State of Karnataka however being of the opinion that Scheme "B" having formed a part of the decision of the tribunal was also required to be notified by the Central Government under Section 6 of the Act, making it binding on the parties, and the same not having been done, filed the present suit on 1" of March, 1997, impleading the State of Andhra Pradesh, the State of Maharashtra and the Union of India as patty defendants, invoking the jurisdiction of this Court under Article 131 of the Constitution, seeking

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

relief for a decree that the surplus water in river Krishna i.e., in excess of 2060 TMC at 75% dependability be shared in accordance with the determinations and directions of the tribunal, contained in its report and further report and ; a declaration that defendant No. 1 State of Alldhra Pradesh is not entitled to insist on its right to use the surplus water i.e., in excess of 2060 TMC at 75% dependability, so long as Scheme "B" framed by the tribunal is not fully implemented and a mandatory injunction to the defendant No. 3 Union of India to notify Scheme "B" framed by the tribunal and make provisions for establishment of a Krishna Valley Authority for implemen~tion of the directions of the tribunal in its Report and Further Report. The State of Kamataka has also prayed for an order of injunction, restraining defendant No. 1 from continuing to execute several other projects like Telgu Ganga, Srisailam Right Bank Canal, Srisailam Left Bank Canal, Bheema Lift hrigation and Pulichintala Projects, until Scheme "B" framed by the tribunal is effectively implemented. The cause of action indicated in the plaint is the refusal of defendant Nos. 1 and 2 to consent to the sharing of smplus waters in excess of 2060 TMC and for implementation of Scheme "B". According to the assertions made in the plaint, the dispute centres round the interpretation 'scope and extent of the decision of the tribunal, and particularly Clause V (c) thereof' as well as the refusal of the first defendant for implementation of Scheme "B" drawn up by the tribunal and the further claim of the State of Andhra Pradesh to use the surplus water in excess of 2060 T.M.C. by constrncting large-scale permanent projects. The plaintiff, State of Kamataka in its plaint, broadly refened to the adjudicatio.a made by the tribunal, indicating therein that the tribunal considered the question of allocation of 2060 T.M.C., which in tum was determined on the basis of 75% dependable flow of river Krishna up to Vijaywada and allocated to the three States of Maharashtra, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh for their beneficial use to the extent provided in Clause V i.e. not more than 560 T.M.C., 700 T.M.C and 800 T.M.C. respectively. It was also averred in the plaint that the tribunal was of the opinion that for fuller utilisation of water of river Krishna, provisions would be made both for surplus and deficit years and accordingly, evolved Scheme "B" but since constitution of the Krishna Valley Authority was the back-bone of the aforesaid Scheme "B" and the State of Andhra Pradesh did not agree for the setting up of the said Krishna Valley Authority, the tribunal left the question of enforcement of such scheme to the good sense of the parties or the wisdom of Parliament. The State of Kamatak.a has also averred that clarificatory applications were filed before the tribunal under

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

Section 5(3) of the Act in respect of Scheme "B" and the tribunal did entertain the same and did answer the clarifications sought for by giving explanations and/or modifications to the original scheme and, therefore, the tribunal itself , accepted the position that Scheme "B" contained in the original repo1t is also a decision of the tribunal which could be clarified or explained on an application being filed under Section 5(3) of the Act. The plaint then, narrates as to how in the further report dated 27th of May, 1976, the tribunal investigated into and determined the shares of respective States in the surplus flows in excess of 2060 T.M.C. and how ultimately a comprehensive Scheme "B" was drawn up for fuller and better utilisation of all the waters in every water year and yet the same could not be given effect to as the tribunal thought it improper to constitute an authority in the absence of agreement between all the riparian States. It is in this context the tribunal had observed that it is unwise and impracticable to impose an administrative autho1ity by a judicial decree without the unanimous consent and approval of the parties. According to the plaintiff, since Scheme "B" provided for a fuller and better utilisation of the water of river Krishna, which the tribunal has itself evolved after deeply pondering over the matter, the same must be held to be a decision of the tribunal, required to be published by the Union Government under Section 6 of the Act and since the parties had not agreed for constitution of an authority when the uibunal gave its further report, it could not be made a part of the Final Order. But according to the plaintiff, Section 6(A) having been inserted into the Act, enabling the Central Government to frame Scheme or Schemes to give effect to the decision of the tribunal including establishment of an authority, there exists no legal impediment for enforcing the said Scheme "B" and appropriate directions could be given by the Court to the Central Government for constituting the authority and give full effect to the Scheme "B". The plaintiff also averred in the plaint how from time to time the State of Karnataka had been requesting the State of Andhra Pradesh as well as the Union Government for implementation of Scheme "B" and how the said State of Andhra Pradesh, defendant No. 1 has refused to agree for implementation of Scheme "B". The defendant No. l, State of Andhra Pradesh in the written statement filed, took the preliminary objection that the adjudication sought for by the plaintiff is itself a water dispute and, therefore, the suit under Article 131 is barred in view of the mandate under Article 262 of the Constitution read with Section 11 of the Inter-State Water Disputes Act. The further stand taken by defendant No. 1 is that it is only the Scheme "A" which can be held to be the

)If

..,,.

-4°

'r'- t

._

~

·.,__

le

•

_., .·

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

decision of the tribunal which comes into operation on the date of publication A of the same under Section 6 of the Act and whatever the tribunal has observed in relation to framing of Scheme "B", the same is merely tentative and obiter observation and cannot be held to be a part of the decision of the tribunal and as such is un-enforceable. It has also been averred that the tribunal itself having indicated that the Scheme "B" could be implemented either by agreement of the parties or by legislation by the Parliament and the parties having not agreed to, the Comt would not be competent to direct the Parliament to have a legislation and, therefore, the relief sought for cannot be granted in the suit. It has been further averred that in view of Clause V(c) of the Final Order, which has been notified in the official Gazette, the State of Andhra Pradesh is entitled to use any water, which may be flowing in the river Krishna, so that the same would not be wasted by entering tl1e sea and, therefore, the prayer for injuncting the State of Andhra Pradesh in going ahead with several projects is not entertainable. The defendant No. 1 further asserts that Scheme "A" having been acted upon by tl1e parties for over two decades and under the said Scheme review having been provided for after 31" of May, 2000, the question of implementation of Scheme "B" at this length of time is not only inequitable but also wholly uncalled for. While refuting the assertion made in different paragraphs of the plaint, it has been reiterated tl1at Scheme "B" never formed part of tl1e decision and as such question of its implementation does not arise and further Section 6(A) of tl1e Act not being there on the statute book on the date the rep01t of the tribunal was published, the same is not relevant in the context. According to Defendant No. 1, the plaintiff has attempted to raise an imaginary dispute in an attempt to invoke the jurisdiction of this Hon'ble Court so that tl1e attention of all concerned is diverted from the illegal projects continued to be executed by it contrary to the decision of the tribunal and the suit lacks bona fides. It has also been averred that the soF called Scheme "B" was merely a tentative one and witl1out its back-bone namely tl1e constitution of tl1e Monitoring Authority called Krishna Valley Authority, it cannot be held to be a Final decision of the tribunal having any binding effects. So far as different pn:~jects undertaken by the State of Andhra Pradesh, it has been averred that under the tripartite agreement even before the Final decision of the tribunal, the plaintiff voluntarily agreed for supply of 15 G TMC of drinking water to Madras, which is the Telgu Ganga Project and, therefore, the plaintiffs objection on tl1is score is baseless and frivolous. In respect of otl1er projects objected to by the plaintiff, it has been averred that the tribunal itself has granted tl1e liberty to the State of Andhra Pradesh to utilise the excess "t3-ter flowing in river Krishna and, therefore, there has been . H

-,~

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2000] 3 S.C.R

no infraction of the said liberty granted by the tribunal. It has also been further averred that the tribunal in its further report having adopted Scheme "A" as its Final decision, it is only that Scheme which is binding on the parties and whatever has been stated as Scheme "B" is not the decision of the tribunal. The State of Maharashtra, Defendant No. 2 also had taken the stand that the suit for directing implementation of Scheme "B" is not maintainable inasmuch as the implementation of the same depends upon the consent of the States and the Court cannot force the States for giving its consent nor can the Court direct the Parliament to have a legislation for the same. The defendant No. 2 however agreed with the State of Kamataka~so far as the allegation of appropriation of the remaining water of the river Krishna in a permanent way by constmcting projects like Telgu Ganga, Srisailam RBC, Srisailam LBC, Bhima Lift and Pulichintala by the State of Andhra Pradesh, Defendant No. 1. The positive stand of the State of Maharashtra is that until and unless a chain of ca1ry over reservoirs in entire Krislma basin are erected, the question of implementation of Scheme "B" would not arise and since the said carry over reservoir have not been constructed as yet, the prayer for implementation of Scheme "B" is premature. The said defendant also averred that the relief sought for is essentially a review of the Final Order and there were no circumstances justifying the prayer for implementation of Scheme "B", particularly, when a review is provided after 31" of May, 2000, which is quite near. The State of Maharashtra defendant No. 2 reiterates the stand of the Andhra Pradesh, defendant No. 1 to the effect tliat it is the tiibunal's decision in te1m of Scheme "A", which is final and binding order on all States and not the framing of Scheme "B" contained in the report of tl1e said ti·ibunal. Union of India, defendant No.3, in its written statement took the stand that the suit as framed is not maintainable by virtue of Section 11 of the Act read with Article 262 of t11e Constit:Ution. So far as the user of water by the State of Andhra Pradesh is concerned, the Union Government contends tllat the award having set out in gross the quantity of water which could be used in a given water year by Maharashti·a and Kamataka and Andhra Pradesh wit11 the liberty to Andhra Pradesh to use the surplus water, tlle said liberty does not confer or create any tight in the State of Andhra Pradesh and such user would be subject to right of upper riparian States namely Maharashtra and Kamataka. The Union Govenunent furtller asserts t11at tlle award does not give a project-wise allocation but does tlle gross allocation and each of tlle State is bound to give effect to t11e award given by the tribunal. On t11e averments

•

~

\

i .,

t'!'

'

,._

Y·

_, ,

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.J

of the other paragraph of the plamt, the Union Government has indicated that the same are all matter of record and do not require any further elucidation.

On the pleadings of the parties the following issues have been framed: "I. Whether the suit is ball'ed by Article 262(2) of the Constitution read with Section 11 of the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956? (A.P.)

2. Whether the suit is liable to be dismissed as not disclosing cause of Action? (A.P.)

....

,. t

3. Whether the suit is liable to be dismissed as seeking relief which are contrary to the Report and Decision of the KWDT? (A.P.)

4. What is the "decision" of the KWDT binding on the parties under Section 6 of the Act in relation to:(a)

Scheme 'B'

(b)

Use of surplus water as contemplated in Clause (V)(c) read with Clause XIV(A) of the Award.

5. Whether reference to Scheme 'B' in the l" and the furtherreport of the KWDT, disclose a complete scheme, and whether such scheme is capable of implementation at this stage, in view of circumstances refened to in para I I of the preliminary objections and par.a I of the parawise reply in the written Statement of Andhra Pradesh? (A.P.)

6. Is it just, fair and equitable to implement Scheme 'B' at this stage? (MAH).

7. Whether in view of the fact that Scheme 'B' does not form part of the "Final Order" of KWDT in the original report under Section 5(2) and the Further Report under Section 5(3) of the Act, the suit seeking the implementation of Scheme 'B' is maintainable? (A.P.) 8. Whether insertion of Sec.6A in 1980 in the ISWD Act, 1956, ipso facto entitles Kamataka to seek implementation of Scheme 'B' as refell'ed.to in the reports of the Tribunal by framing a scheme? (KAR - as modified by A.P.)

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

9. Whether the right of And.bra Pradesh to utilise surplus waters in terms of the liberty granted by the decisions of the Tribunal, is reviewable in the present proceedings? (A.P.) 10. Whether the liberty to use surplus water under the decision of the KWDT precludes utilisation of surplus water by A.P., by means of projects of permanent nature? (KAR as modified by A.P.) 11. Whether the decision of the KWDT entitles the State of Andhra Pradesh to execute the following projects :- (KAR - as modified by A.P.)

(a)

Telugu Ganga Project

(b) Srisailam Right Bank Canal (c)

Srisailam Left Bank Canal

(d) Bhima Lift Irrigation (e)

Pulichintala Diversion

12. Is not the suit of the Plaintiff unnecessary and premature as there can be review of the orders of the Tribunal after A.D. 2000? (MAH)

13. To what reliefs, if any, the Plaintiff is entitled to? (A.P.)"

ISSUES 4, 5 AND 7.

L

These three issues are taken up together as they are inter-linked and in fact the fate of the suit largely depends upon the answer to the aforesaid issues. Mr. Nariman, the learned senior counsel, appearing for the plaintiff- State of Kamataka contends that in the context of the water dispute which had been refeITed to by the Central Government to the tribunal under Section 4 of the Act and the said. tribunal having investigated the matters refeITed to it and framed two schemes for distribution of water in river Krishna amongst the three riparian States, giving immediate effect to Scheme "A" and postponing the date of giving effect to, in respect of Scheme "B" as there was no agreement between the riparian States for the constitution of the Monitoring Authority, the said Scheme-"B" cannot, but be held to be the decision of the tribunal and as such was required to be notified by the Union Government under Section 6 of the Act, making the same binding on all the three States.

....

i ..

-

-

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

According to Mr.· Nariman, th~ Act conceives of a report to be given by the tribunal setting out the facts as found by it and giving its decision on the matters referred to it and evolving Scheme "B" being an adjudication of the respective share of States in the waters of river Krishna, both in relation to the surplus water year and the deficit water year, the said adjudication must be held to be the decision of the tribunal and the Final Order containing Scheme "A" alone cannot be held to be the decision of the tribunal. The Central Government, therefore failed to perform its mandatory duties under Section 6 in publishing only the Final Order which is merely a mass allocation in favour of three states at 75% dependability and not the adjudication of the entire dispute which had been referred to the tribunal. Mr. Nariman further contended that the tribunal in its report dated 24.12.73 having reached the conclusion - "After deeply pondering over the matter we have come to the conclusion that it would be better if we devise two schemes for the division of the waters of the river Krishna between the States of Maharashtra, Mysore and Andhra Pradesh. These schemes will be called Scheme "A" and "B". Scheme "A" will come in operation on the date of the publication of the decision of this Tribunal in the Official Gazette under Section 6 of the InterState Water Disputes Act. Scheme "B" may be brought into operation in case the States of Maharashtra, Mysore and Andhra Pradesh constitute an interState administrative authority which may be called the Krishna Valley Authority by agreement between them or in case such an authority is constituted by legislation made by Parliament." It is difficult to conceive that Scheme "B" was not the decision of the tribunal. In fact the tribunal itself came to the conclusion that Scheme "B" is more comprehensive and provides for more equitable mode of utilisation of the waters of river Krishna and yet refrained from making it a part of the Final Order because a Monitoring Authority could not be constituted due to lack of agreement between the riparian States nor was it wise and practical to impose a Monitoring Authority without the consent of the parties and in this view of the matter Scheme "B" must be held to be a decision of the tribunal adjudicating the shares of each of the States in the water of river Krishna, making the apportionment, both in relation to SUI}Jlus as well as the deficit. Mr. Nariman, the learned senior counsel, also urged that the three States Maharashtra, the then Mysore (presently Kamataka) and Andhra Pradesh having themselves consented to, and having prayed for the method of allocation to be adopted by the tribunal to t11e effect : (i) mass allocation of utilisable dependable flow at 75%, (ii) allocation on percentage basis of water in surplus as well as deficit years of flow, (iii) restrictions with regard to use and the nature of restrictions to be decided by t11e tribunal and

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

(iv) constitution of a Joint Control Body to give effect to the decision of the tribunal, and Scheme "A" being an adjudication of item (i) above and Scheme "B" being adjudication of items (ii), (iii) and (iv) above, it is unthinkable that the Scheme "B" is not the decision of the tribunal. Mr. Nariman also contended that under Section 5(3) of the Act after considering the decision of the tribunal if Central Government or any State Government is of the opinion that any explanation or further consideration is needed,.then a further reference could be made and such a reference/clarification, having been made by the State of Kamataka in relation to Scheme "B" and the tribunal itself having entertained and answered the same, it is no longer open to hold that Scheme "B" is not a decision of the tribunal. It is in this connection, Mr. Nariman also contended that though the State of Maharashtra and State of Kamataka, also were heard by the tribunal on the further clarifications sought for by . the State of Kamataka, at no point of time they had taken the stand that Scheme "B" is not a decision and as such a clarification under Section 5(3) in respect of the same was not entertainable. In this view of the matter, there is no other option than to hold that Scheme "B" is also the decision of the tribunal, providing for a better and fuller equitable distribution of the water in river Krishna and the issue in question must be answered in favour of the State of Kamataka. Mr. Nariman also urged that the Constitution Bench of this Court in Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal, [1993] Supp 1 SCC 96, has held that even the interim order passed by the tribunal must be deemed to be a report and a decision within the meaning of Section 5(2) of the Act and in this view of the matter the final aqjudication evolving Scheme "B" must be held to be a decision of the tribunal and as such is required to be published by the Central Government under Section 6 of the Act.

Mr. Parasaran, the learned senior counsel, appearing for Defendant No. 1, State of Andhra Pradesh on the other hand contends that the plaintiff in his plaint also has not averred that Scheme "B" is a decision of the tribunal. According to the learned counsel the plaint read as a whole indicates that the plaintiff wanted enforcement of both Scheme "A" and Scheme "B" and thus the relief sought for is amalgam of both these Schemes favourable to the plaintiff- State and not necessaiily the implementation of Scheme "B" and this has purposely been done as the plaintiff was well aware of the fact that the said Scheme "B" does not form a part of the decision. In this connection, the learned counsel relied upon the assertions made in paragraph 2(b) of the plaint, which really deals with Scheme "A" and not Scheme "B". He also relied upon the assertions made in paragraph 6(1) wherein the plaintiff itself has averred

·)"

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

_.,,

-A\

that the tribunal made Scheme "A" as part of its final decision and left the Scheme "B" to the good sense of the parties or to the wisdom of Parliament. Mr. Parasaran also with reference to assertion made in paragraph 21 of the plaint contends that according to the plaintiff the tribunal merely expressed hope for getting the consent of all the States for adoption of Scheme "B" and, therefore, it was not a decision of the tribunal. Mr. Parasaran also strongly relied upon the assertions made in paragraph 23 to the effect "as submitted earlier, the Tribunal, while adjudicating the claims, has declared the rights of basin states in the surplus waters under Scheme "B" although such scheme was not made pmt of the decision" and contends that the aforesaid admission on the part of the plaintiff clinches the matter and Scheme "B" cannot be held to be a decision of the tribunal. In fact Mr. Parasaran submitted that in view of the aforesaid averment in the plaint and in view of the provision contained in Order 12 Rule 6, the suit should be dismissed straight-away. Mr. Parasaran also urged that the plaint itself is merely for sharing excess water as indicated in Scheme "B" having derived the benefits of the mass allocation under Scheme "A" and is thus not a suit for implementation of Scheme "B" as contended by Mr. Nariman, the learned counsel appearing for the plaintiffState. According to Mr. Parasaran, constitution of a Monitoring Authority like Krishna Valley Authority being the back-bone of Scheme "B" and the tribunal having failed to get the consent of parties to constitute such authority and there being no law by the Parliament under Entty 56 of List I of the Seventh Schedule, at the most it can be said that the tribunal had conceived of a more equitable scheme like Scheme "B" and had given its blue print, but the same cannot partake the character of a decision of the tt·ibunal under Section 5(2) of the Act, so as to make it binding on all parties concerned. According to the learned counsel Mr. Parasaran, it is that adjudication or order made by the tribunal which can be implemented independently of any agreement or law made by Parliament, as in this case the Final Order, containing Scheme "A" which can be held to be the decision of the tt·ibunal and not any observation or order made in the report in course of the proceedings. Mr. Parasaran urged that the tribunal in its Furtl1er Report Exhibit PK2 having categorically stated "we do not think it proper that Scheme "B" should be implemented by our order". It is futile to contend that the said Scheme "B" is the decision of the tribunal. Mr. Parasaran further contended that in the report itself, tl1e tribunal having considered the two schemes- Scheme "A" and Scheme "B" and under Scheme "B", the moment the scheme is given effect to, the Scheme "A" ceases to be operative and effective and the tribunal having ultimately opted to make Scheme "A" as Final Order, which could be implemented, it is not possible

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

to contend that Scheme "B" evolved by the tribunal is also a decision of the tribunal.

Mr. Andhyarujina, the learned senior counsel, appearing for the State of Maharashtra, Defendant No. 2 supported the stand of the State of Andhra Pradesh and contended that Scheme "B" cannot be held to be a decision of the tribunal. According to the learned counsel, what can be held to be a decision of the tribunal is what the tribunal himself considered to have binding effect and in this view of the matter, the tribunal having itself said that it is Scheme "A" which formed the part of the Final Order and which can be implemented, immediately on being notified, it is abundantly clear that the tribunal did not think Scheme "B" to be its 'decision' though in course of proceedings, it might have discussed about the feasibility of such a scheme and its efficacy. Mr. Andhyarujina, the learned senior counsel, ultimately urged that it is only t11e Final Order of tl1e tribunal, containing Scheme "A", which can be held to be the decision of the tribunal. Mr. Salve, the learned Solicitor General, appearing for the Union Government, reiterated the stand taken by the two other defendant States and submitted that the tribunal itself has never thought Scheme "B" to be its decision and the expression "decision" has to be interpreted with reference to .the water dispute defined in Section 2(c), the complaints and reference made under Section 3 and the adjudication provided for in Section 5. A combined reading of the aforesaid provisions of the Act, according to Mr. Salve, indicates that it is that adjudication of the uibunal which is capable of being implemented on its own, which can be held to be the decision of the tribunal, binding on the parties and not observations made or consideration of several proposed schemes by the uibunal itself, in course of the proceedings. According to Mr. Salve, the tribunal was qui5e conscious of the fact that it is not possible to implement Scheme "B" unless and until a Monitoring Authority could be provided for the same and such authority could be provided for either by the consent of the patties or by legislation made by the Parliament and since both were lacking, tl1e tribunal advisedly, did not make it a part of the Final Order to be its decision and in this view of the matter, Scheme "B" evolved by the tribunal cannot be held to be a decision. Before examining t11e rival stand of the parties on this contentious issues in the light of the pleadings as well as the documents refen-ed to, it may be necessary to indicate t11e scheme of the Act. The Inter-State Water Disputes

l

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

Act, 1956, refened to as 'the Act' has been enacted by the Parliament in the seventh year of the republic as the law providing for adjudication of any dispute or complaint with respect to the use, distribution or control of the water in any inter-State river, as envisaged under Article 262(1) of the Constitution. Section 2(c) defines water dispute and Section 3 of the Act provides under what conditions, a State can make a complaint and request to the Central Government for refening a dispute to a tribunal for adjudication. Section 4 provides for constitution of the tribunal by the Central Government and Section 5 provides for adjudication of the dispute by the tribunal. Section 5(2) empowers the tribunal to investigate the matters referred to it and then forward to the Central Government, a report, setting out the facts as fow1d by it and giving its decision of the matters refened to it. Thus the report required to be given by the tribunal after investigation under Section 5(2) of the Act must contain the facts as found by it as well as the decision of the matters referred to the tribunal. A distinction, therefore, has been drawn by the legislature on the two expressions used in Section 5(2) of the Act, namely 'facts as found' and 'decision of the matters refened to'. The cmcial question which has to be answered in the aforesaid three issues, which have been taken together is whether Scheme "B" considered and evolved by the tribunal would come within the expression 'facts as found' or the 'decision of tribunal on the matter refened to'. It is in this context, what was the 'matter refened to the tribunal' assumes great significance. The Govenunent of India in its letter dated lO'b of April, 1969 made a reference to the tribunal for adjudication of the water dispute regarding the inter-State river Krishna and the river valley thereof emerging from the letters of the Mysore Government dated the 29 1b January, 1962 and the 8'b July, 1968, the letters of the Maharashtra Government dated the 11th June, 1963 and the 26th August, 1968 and the letters of the Andhra Pradesh Government dated the 21'1 April, 1968 and the 21" January, 1969. TI1e tribunal in Chapter II of its report, swnmarised the complaints of each of the Governments and formulated the point of dispute for adjudication to the effect "that the parties want an equitable apportionment of the Krishna waters for their beneficial uses, so that they may know the limits within which each can operate and may plan their water resources development accordingly" arid it further stated as to how and on what basis the equitable apportionment should be made. On the basis of the rival stand of the parties, the tribunal framed issues and sub-issues on 14th of April, 1971 and for the present discussion, we are concerned with issue No. II, as Issue No. 1 relates to the question whether there was any concluded agreement regarding allocation of the waters of river Krishna and whether such agreement was enforceable and was still subsisting

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

and operative upon the States concerned. Issue No. II framed by the tribunal is to the effect that what directions if any, should be given for the equitable apportionment of the beneficial use of the waters of Krishna river and the river valley. Under the said issue, there are as many a~ eight sub-issues and subissue 8 was to the effect "what machinery if any, should be set up to make available and regulate the allocation of water, if any, to the states concerned or otherwise to implement the decision of the tribunal". This Issue No. II has been discussed in Chapter IX of the Report dated 24111 of December, 1973, which has been marked as Exhibit PKl and one of the sub-issue namely, on what basis should the available water be dete1mined?, the tribunal considered at length the several data and finally an agreement between the parties was arrived at that 75% dependable yield of the river Krishna upto Vijaywada is 2060 TMC, which has been indicated in Chapter IX itself. The tribunal then proceeds with embarking upon the difficult and delicate task of division of waters of river Krishna and what directions ultimately could be given for equitable apportionment of the beneficial use of the waters of Krishna river and the river valley. In Chapter XIV of the report dated 24'h of December, 1973, Exh.PKl, the tribunal ultimately summarised as to how each State claimed equitable share in the dependable flow and also in the water in excess over the dependable flow. It also considered the evidence of expert witnesses, adduced by the parties, indicating the advantage that will accrue by carry over storage, made in the Krishna basin. The tribunal also thought over the matter as to whether the scheme for division of water should endure forever or there should be a room for review and ultimately was of the opinion that a review and modification of the allocation may become necessary to keep pace with the changing conditions. It also provided for a review of the order of the tribunal at any time after 31'' of May, 2000. After making such general observations, it proceeded to consider the scheme of division of water and it did notice the agreed views of all the three states, submitted on 4'h of May, 1973, indicating that there should be a mass allocation of utilisable dependable flow at 75% and there should be allocation on percentage basis of water in surplus ·as well as deficit years with certain restrictions with regard to the use to be decided by the tribunal and, there should be a joint control Body to give effect to the decision of the tribunal. The tribunal indicated the merits and demerits of the schemes given by each of the states consisted of two pa1ts and part II related to the constitution and powers of the Monitoring Authority, called the Krishna Valley Authority and though initially, the counsel for the parties had agreed upon the constitution of Krishna Valley Authority, but after the matter was heard again, the State of Andhra Pradesh categorically

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STAfE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.)

-l

indicated that no consent can be given to set up Krishna Valley Authority. After noting the rival contentions of the parties on the question of constituting an authority and the best tradition as to how the Federal Structure functions and how the states are bound to obey the law made by the Parliament, it also came to the finding that the matter of setting up of an authority becomes the back-bone of the decision and an integral part of it and unless that can be given effect to, it will be of no use to have a decision as envisaged under Scheme "B" for equitable allocation of water amongst the three riparian states. TI1e tribunal in no uncertain terms, came to the conclusion that it will not be proper to set up any authority without the consent of the parties, and, therefore, the so-called document Exh.MRK-340 provided no assistance notwithstanding the fact that it was agreed to by the counsel of all the three states on 41h of May, 1973. Having failed in its attempt to reach a decision, containing the principle of allocation, envisaged under the agreed document Exh. MRK 340, the tribunal thought it appropriate to evolve the two schemes called Scheme "A" and Scheme "B'' and at Page 166 of Exh. PKl, the tribunal itself made it crystal clear that Scheme "A" will come in operation on the date of publication of the decision of the tribunal in the Official Gazette under Section 6 of the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956, and Scheme "B" may be brought into operation in case the States themselves constitute an Inter-State Administrative Authority, which may be called the Krishna Valley Authority by agreement between them or in case, such an authority is constituted by legislation made by Parliament. The aforesaid conclusion of the tribunal, unequivocally indicates that it is Scheme "A" alone which has been made the decision of the tribunal and the tribunal nomenclatured the same to be the Final Order, which order in its tum has been notified in the Official Gazette by the Central Government under Section 6 of the Act. At Page 182 of the Report Exh. PKl, the tribunal itself has given a complete picture to facilitate further discussion by setting out different clauses of the Final Order which according to the tribunal embodies all the provisions on the subject of app01tionment of the water of river Krishna between the states of Maharashtra, Mysore and Andhra Pradesh and then it is stated "these provisions of the Final Order cover all matters mentioned in Issue No. II and its sub-issues and issue no. II, is, therefore, decided as provided in these clauses of the Final Order." After deciding issue no. II, as aforesaid, and thereafter deciding issue IV(B) in the next paragraph, the tribunal then proceeds to examine the efficacy of Scheme "B". It is no doubt true that Scheme "B" is more beneficial and provides for more beneficial and fuller utilisation of waters of river Krishna but the tribunal itself has not considered the same to be a part of its decision, which could be

p

\

i>

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2000) 3 S.C.R.

implemented by a notification wider Section 6 of the Act. It may be noticed at this stage that in Cauvery Water Dispute Case (1993 (Suppl.) 1 SCC 96) while considering the question as to what formed the decision of the Tribunal under Section 5(2) of the Act this Court examined the interim order which had been passed by the Tribunal and came to the conclusion that if the order is not meant to be merely declaratory in nature but is meant to be implemented and given effect to by the parties, then it would constitute a decision within a meaning of Section 5(2) and is required to be published by the Central government under Section 6 of the Act. Applying the aforesaid ratio to the case in hand and in view of the unequivocal statement made by the Tribwial while deciding Issue No.II to the effect that Issue No. II and its sub-issues are decided as per the clauses of the final order which contains Scheme 'A', it is difficult to sustain the argument of Mr. Nariman, appearing for the plaintiffState that Scheme 'B' also is a decision of the Tribwial. As has been indicated earlier that in course of the proceedings before the Tribunal all the party States, no doubt, have consented to the points of dispute to be resolved by the Tribunal as per Exhibit MRK 340. But the Tribunal itself records the finding that on account of non-agreement between the parties it has not been possible to reach a decision on the principle of allocation agreed to under MRK 340 and, therefore, the Tribunal thought it fit to evolve Scheme 'A' which could be implemented on its own, the same being notified under Section 6 of the Act. In terms of the judgment of this Court in Cauvery Water Disputes case, Scheme 'B' had not been meant to be implemented and given effect to by the parties to the dispute and as such cannot be a decision of the Tribwial under Section 5(2) of the Act. It can be held to be 'facts found' in the report submitted. The Tribunal in considering different proposals submitted by the States came to hold "unless a joint control body or inter State authority was established, it would be difficult to divide the waters of river Krishna between the parties in every water year on the lines suggested by the parties." (at page 161 Ex.PK-1). The Tribunal also recorded a finding:

"It is not possible for us to take the view that we can infer the consent of the parties from Ex.MRK-340 filed on 4tb May, 1973." In its further Report after answering the references made to it under Section 5(3) of the Act, in Exhibit PK-2 the Tribunal negatived the contentions :-· of the State of Karnataka that allocation of water under Scheme "A" is not the

..

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.)

•

Scheme for the division of water in accordance with the provisions of the Act. In said PK-2 at page 24 the Tribunal did observe: "The apportionment of water of the inter-State river Krishna must be adapted to the peculiar characteristics of the river system. We may also point out that until 1971-72 less than 1000 T.M. C. was utilised in the entire Krishna basin, and until the entire dependable supply of 2060 TMC is fully utilised, the complaint regarding the apportionment of the remaining water is unrealistic." In answering Clarification No.III filed by the State of Kamataka, requiring the Tribunal to give direction for implementation of Scheme "B" the Tribunal, no doubt, drew up a complete Scheme "B' and came to the conclusion that Scheme "B' provides for a fuller and better utilisation of the Waters of river K.tishna, but hasten to add "We cannot make Scheme "B" part of our final order as requested by the learned counsel for the Government of India because the final order should contain only such provisions as may be implemented independently of any agreement or law made by Parliament." (see Ex.PK 2 at page 26)

In its furtl1er report Ex .. PK-2 after considering the question of abolition of Tungbhadra Board the Tribunal held :

"In these circumstances we do not think it proper that Scheme 'B' should be implemented by our order." The aforesaid findings of the Tribunal both in the Original report as well as the further report unequivocally indicate that the Tribunal never considered Scheme 'B' to form a part of its decision for being implemented even though there cannot be any doubt about the efficacy of the Scheme in question. A water dispute having arisen between the three riparian States in relation to sharing of water of river Krishna and the said dispute having been referred to the Tribunal for its adjudication and the Tribunal having investigated the matters referred to it and having submitted its report containing the facts found as well as its decision, it is that decision which conclusively decides the dispute referred and is capable of being implemented on its own can be said to be the decision of the Tribunal under Section 5(2). In the case in hand the Tribunal itself being of the opinion that it is unable to implement Scheme 'B' by its own order and having apportioned the water of river Krishna as per

,.

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

'<..

(2000] 3 S.C.R.

Scheme 'A', the said Scheme 'B' cannot be held to be a decision of the Tribunal. It is also true, as contended by Mr. Nariman that the Tribunal did entertain clarification sought for by the State of Kamataka under Section 5(3) of the Act to some of the clauses in Scheme 'B' and a party is entitled to invoke the jurisdiction of the Tribunal under Section 5(3) only in respect of a decision but that by itself, in our opinion, will not clothe Scheme 'B' with the character of a decision of the Tribunal. Mr. Nariman may be right in his submission that there has been an adjudication by tlie Tribunal in evolving Scheme 'B' indicating the manner in which tlie water of said river Krishna could be shai·ed by three States in surplus and deficit water year, but every adjudication made by the Tribunal cannot be held to be a decision within the meaning of Section 5(2) unless such adjudication is capable of being implemented on its own and applying the aforesaid test Scheme 'B' not being capable of being implemented on its own so long as the back bone of tlie Scheme, namely, the constitution of Monitoring Authority is not agreed to, the said Scheme cannot be held to be a decision within the meaning of Section 5(2) of the Act. In the aforesaid premises, we answer aforesaid three issues by holding that the Scheme 'B' framed by the Tribunal is not the decision of the Tribunal and as such, was not required to be notified under Section 6 and, consequently cannot be enforced at the behest of the plaintiff. The issues are accordingly answered against the plaintiff. Though we have come to the aforesaid conclusion yet we think it approp1iate to notice that the disputes for sharing waters of an inter-State river are not easy to be solved. A Tribunal presided over by a judge of tl1is Court took several years in formulating its conclusion. For arriving at its conclusion the Tribunal has attempted several negotiations between the rival States and also has taken into account the experts' evidence adduced by the parties. In evolving the two Schemes - Scheme 'A' and Scheme 'B' it has also taken into account several schemes produced by each of tlie State. The Tribunal also thought while evolving Scheme 'B' that though it cannot be implemented as it was unable to constitute the Monitoring Authority on account of lack of consent between the parties yet it placed on record the said Scheme 'B' which according to the Tribunal is a better one for fuller utilisation of water resources of Krishna basin amongst the three States. While placing Scheme 'B' in its Rep011 the idea was that the labour of the Tribunal in evolving the Scheme would not be totally lost and that is why it hoped that the parties may agree

1' -

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

for constituting an authority or if they fail to agree the Parliament also could make a law but unfortunately, neither of the two contingencies has happened. Though Scheme 'B' has been held by us not to be a decision of the Tribunal and as such, is not capable of being implemented by a mandatory injunction from this Court yet we have least hesitation to agree with the findings of the Tribunal itself that said Scheme 'B' provides for a fuller and better utilization of the water resources in river Krishna and in future if the question of allocation of river Krishna is gone into by any auth01ity then the said authority will certainly look to the Scheme 'B' which had been evolved on the data available then and acceptability of the same will be duly considered.

t

We may, however, hasten to add that it will be for the appropriate authority to be entrusted with the task of resolving the long simmering water dispute in Krishna basin between the three riparian States to come to its own decision on the basis of the data placed before it by the contesting States. Scheme-B formulated by the earlier Tribunal can only serve as a useful blueprint to this authority, though it may not strictly be binding on it. Our aforesaid observations on Scheme-B be understood in that light. Needless to mention that in course of proceedings before the Tribunal not only the three iiparian States had requested the Tribunal by submitting a document Ex. MRK - 340 on 4'h May, 1973, indicating the principles of allocation signed by three counsel appearing for the three States which, however, was not agreed to later on, but also the learned counsel appearing for the Union of India had submitted before the Tribunal when the Tribunal was considering the clarificatory applications filed by different States on 81h May, 1975, to the effect :-

"The Government of India have examined both Schemes 'B' and 'A'. They feel that Scheme 'B' is better and easier to implement than Scheme 'A'. If Scheme 'B' comes as part of the final order of this Hon'ble Tribunal, the Government of India will take necessary steps for putting it into operation. Scheme 'B' may be put as part of the final order in the manner as the Hon'ble Tribunal feels fit. We would like to have a complete scheme formulated by this Hon'ble Tribunal." This really indicates how the Union Govenment was anxious to have an order of the Tribunal to make Scheme 'B ', a part of its decision though ultimately for the reasons already indicated the Tribunal did not accede to the same.

· A

C

p

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2000) 3 S.C.R.

Issue No. 1. The next imp01tant issue is Issue No. l which raises the question as to the maintainability of the suit in view of the bar provided under Article 262 (2) of the Constitution read with Section 11 of Inter-State Water Disputes Act. Learned Solicitor General Mr. Salve, appearing for the Union of India in fact piloted this issue which was, of course, supported by Mr. Parasaran appearing for the State of Andhra Pradesh. According to Mr. Salve the relief sought for by the plaintiff-State is itself a water dispute under the Act, and therefore, the suit is not maintainable in view of Section 11 of the Act. Referring to different avennents made in the plaint learned Solicitor General contends that under the plaint the plaintiff really ask for implementation of the allocation already made under Scheme 'A' in respect of 2060 TMC at 75% dependability and the sharing of surplus as evolved under Scheme 'B' and as such the prayer tantamounts to have a new Scheme altogether not evolved by the Tribunal itself and, consequently, a fresh water dispute and therefore, such a dispute cannot be ente1tained by this Court under Aiticle 131 of tl~e Constitution, the same being barred under Section 11 of the Act. Learned Solicitor General elaborated his argument with reference to the constitutional scheme and even went to the extent of contending that in a given case even the prayer for implementation of an Award of the Tribunal may become a water dispute under Section 2(c) of the Act and the moment it becomes a water dispute this Court will have no jurisdiction to entertain a suit under Article 131 of the Constitution. Learned Solicitor General also refen-ed to issues 4 and 5 formulated in this proceeding and contended that the very issues indicate a water dispute has arisen and consequently suit will not lie. According to Mr. Salve, even in a suit for implementation of the decision of a tribunal, if issues arise, which would be a water dispute under Section 2(c)(i) of the Act or fall under Section 3(b) or 3(c) of the Act, then the jurisdiction of the Court under Article 131 must be held to be barred and in the case in hand, in fact, the relief sought for by the plaintiff-State tantamounts to a fresh water dispute. Learned Solicitor General contends that the language of Section 2(c) read with Section 3 is wide enough to enable any riparian State to raise a dispute in relation to the use, control or distribution of the waters of an Inter-State river and the machinery for resolution of such a dispute is referable to Article 262 of the Constitution, which provision manifests an intent to insulate the Courts from disputes which may assume political overtones and applying the test to the case in hand, the conclusion is irresistible that this Court will not be entitled to entertain a suit under Article 131 of the Constitution.

)..

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

~-

Mr. Parasaran appearing for the State of Andhra Pradesh supported the argument advanced by Mr. Saive, the learned Solicitor General and contended, that the suit being one not merely for implementation of Scheme 'B', as contended by the plaintiff, but an amalgam of both the Schemes, sharing of 2060 TMC under Scheme 'A' and sharing of surplus above 2060 TMC as per Scheme 'B' it is obviously an innovation which the Tribunal has itself not thought of and more appropriately a fresh water dispute within the meaning of Section 2(c) of the Act and consequently a suit under Article 131 would not lie. Mr. Nariman appearing for the plaintiff-State on the other hand contended, that a suit filed under Article 131 is not exactly a suit filed in ordinaiy Civil Court. The pleadings of the parties cannot be construed in a pedantic maimer and reading the plaint as a whole the conclusion is iiTesistible that the plaintiff has made out a case to the effect that Scheme 'B' evolved by the Tribunal is also the decision of the Tribunal, though it could not be implemented in the absence of Constitution of Monitoring Authority and taking into account the time and energy spent by the Tribunal in evolving such a beneficial Scheme for better and fuller utilisation of the water resources of River Krislma, this Court should issue appropriate direction for implementation of the said Scheme 'B'. According to the learned counsel the dispute relating to sharing of water of River Krislma having been adjudicated by the Tribwial and two Schemes having been evolved for that purpose and the relief being for implementation of Scheme 'B', it is essentially a suit for implementation of.an adjudicated dispute and no longer forms a dispute under Section 2(c) of the Act, as contended by the learned Solicitor General. In this view of the matter the bar under Section 11 of the Act cannot be attracted. Before examining the rival stand of the parties it may be stated at the outset that the question of maintainability has to be decided upon the averments made by the plaintiffs and the relief sought for and taking the totality of the same and not by spinning up one paragraph of the, plaint and then deciding the matter. In interpreting the scope of Article 131 of the Constitution, in the case of State of Rajasthan v. Union of India, [1978] 1 SCR 1 Chandrachud, J., as he then was, held that the requirement is that the dispute must involve a question, whether of law or fact, on which the existence or extent of a legal right depends. It is this qualification which affords the true guide for determining whether a particular dispute is comprehended within Article 131. The purpose of Article 131 is to afford a fornm for the resolution of disputes which depend for their decision on the existence or extent of a legal right. In the very same decision Bhagwati, J., as he then was, analysing the provisions of Article 131 of the Constitution came to hold that there are two limitations in regard to the

C

p

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2000] 3 S.C.R.

nature of the suit whether can be ente1tained by the Supreme Court under the Article. One is in regard to parties and the other is in regard to the subject matter. In the present case, so far as parties are concerned, it is covered by clauses (a) and (c), inasmuch as the grievances of the plaintiff is that an adjudicated decision of the Tribunal in evolving Scheme 'B' was not notified by the Government of India under Section 6 of the Act and, as such, a dispute between the plaintiff and the defendant no. 3 - the Union of India and further it is a dispute between the State of Kamataka and the State of Andhra Pradesh under Clause (c) of Article 131 as the said State of Andhra Pradesh did not agree to the constitution of a Monitoring Authority for implementation of an adjudicated decision of the Tribunal by evolving Scheme 'B'. In the very same decision Bhagwati, J., also further indicated that the Supreme Comt would have the power to give whatever reliefs are necessary for enforcement of legal right claimed in the suit if such legal right is established. In State of Karnataka v. Union of India & Am:, [1978] 2 SCR 1 this Court again considered the scope of Article 131 of the Constitution. Chandhrachud, J., as he then was, held thus : "The jurisdiction confeITed on the Supreme Court by Aritcle 131 of the Constitution should not be tested on the anvil of banal rules which are applied under the Code of Civil Procedure for dete1mining whether a suit is maintainable. Article 131 undoubtedly confers 'original •jurisdiction' on the Supreme CourtJ and the commonest form of a legal proceeding which is tried by a court in the exercise of its original jurisdiction is a suit. But a constitutional provision, which confers exclusive jurisdiction on this Comt to entertain disputes of a certain nature in the exercise of its original jurisdiction, cannot be equated with a provision confeITing a right on a civil cowt to entertain a common suit so as to apply to an original proceeding under Article 131 the canons of a suit which is ordinarily triable under section 15 of the Code of Civil Procedme by a court of the lowest grade competent to try it. Advisedly, the Constitution does not describe the proceeding which may be brought under Article 131 as a 'suit' and significantly, aiticle 131 uses words and phrases not commonly employed for detennining the jurisdiction of a court of first instance to ente1tain and try a suit. It does not speak of a 'cause of action', an expression of known and definite legal impo1t in the world of witness actions. Instead, it employs the word 'dispute', which is no part of the elliptical jargon of law. But above all, Article 131 which

~ .....

'"""

..!

\

~

' .·

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

__ , -11

;

in a manner of speaking is a self-contained code on matters falling within its purview, provides expressly for the condition su~ject to which an action can lie under it. That condition is expressed by the clause: "if and in so far as the dispute involves any question (whether of law or fact) on which the existence or extent of a legal right depends". By the very terms of the article, therefore, the sole condition which is required to be satisfied for invoking the original jurisdiction of this Court is that the dispute between the parties ret(m-ed to in clauses (a) to (c) must involve a question on which the existence or extent o~- a legal right depends. The quintessence of Article 131 is that there has to be a dispute between the pmties regarding a question on which the existence or extent of a legal right depends. A challenge by the State Government to the authority of the Central Government to appoint a Commission of Inquiry clearly involves a question on which the existence or extent of the legal right of the Central Government to appoint the Commission of Inquiry depends and that is enough to sustain the proceeding brought by the State under Article 131 of the Constitution. Far from its being a case of the "omission of the obvious". Justifying the reading of words into Article 131 which are not there, I consider that the Constitution has purposefully cohferred on this Court a jurisdiction which is untrammelled by considerations which fetter the jurisdiction of a court of first instance, which entertains and tries suits of a civil nature. The very nature of the disputes arising under Alticle 131 is different, both in form and substance, from the nature of claims which require adjudication in ordinary suits." The learned judge had also further observed : "A proceeding under Alticle 131 stands in sharp contrast with an ordinary civil suit. The competition in such a proceeding is between two or more govenunents - either the one or the other possesses the constitution power to act."

C

Bhagwati, J. agreeing with Chandrachud, J. had a:so observed thus : "The only requirement necessary for attracting the applicability of Article 131 is that the dispute must be one involving any question "on which the existence or extent of a legal right" depends, irrespective

SUPREME COURT REPORT'S

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

whether the legal right is claimed by one party or the other and it is not necessary that some legal right of the plaintiff should be infringed before a suit can .be brought under that article."

~·

Kailasam, J. and Beg, J. agreed with the conclusions airived at by Chandrachud, J. and Bhagwati, J.

The eminent Jurist Shri H.M. Seervai, in his book on "Constitutional Law of India" , dealing with the scope of Alticle 131 of the Constitution states : "when a Court is given exclusive jurisdiction in respect of a dispute between patties, it is reasonable to hold that the Court has power to resolve the whole dispute, including the enforcement of its decrees or orders, especially when provision has been made for such enforcement. The words 'if and in so far as the dispute involves any question (whether of law or fact) on which the existence of a legal right depends' are meant to emphasize the fact that the dispute must be one relating to leg<ll rights, and not a dispuk on the political plane not based on a legal right".

.~

t-

'

.....__

~

Alticle 131 of the Constitution subject to the other provisions of the Constitution confers Original Jurisdiction on the Supreme Court over a dispute between the Central Government and one or more States or between two or more States subject to the condition that dispute involves any question whether of law or fact on which the existence or extent of a legal right depends. Article 262(1) of the Constitution authorises the Parliament to make law for adjudication of any dispute or complaint with respect to the use, distribution or control of the waters of, or iu, any inter-State river or river valley. Sub-Alticle 2 of Article 262 also authorises the Parliament to provide by law excluding the jurisdiction of the Supreme Comt or any other Court in respect of a dispute or complaint as is referred to in Clause (1). Thus Article 131 being subject to the other provisions of the Constitution including Article 262, if Parliament has made any law for adjudication of any water dispute or a dispute relating to distribution or control of water in any inter-State river or river valley, then such a dispute cannot be raised before the Supreme Comt under Alticle 131, even if the dispute be one between the Centre or the State or between the two States. In exercise of Constitutional power under Article 262(1), the Parliament, in fact has enacted the law called the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956 and Sec~ion 11 of the said Act provides that neither the Supreme Court nor any other Court shall have jurisdiction in respect of any water dispute which could be refeITed to a tribunal under the Act. This being the position, what is necessary to be found out is whether the assertions made in the plaint

-I

"....

(.

+

~ !}'-

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAlK, J.]

...

..

-

-+

filed by the State of Kamataka and the relief sought for, by any stretch of imagination can be held to be a water dispute, which could be refeffed to the tribunal, so as to oust the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court under Article 131. On examining the ave1ments made in the plaint and the relief sought for, by the plaintiff-State, we are of the considered opinion that what really the State of Kamataka wants is a direction from the Supreme Court to the Union Government to notify the Scheme "B" evolved by the tribunal and for a direction to the Union Government to constitute an authority under Section 6A of the Act, which was inserted into the Act by amendment, though the said provision was not there on the date, the tribunal submitted its report and the decision. The plaintiff asserts in the plaint, that the dispute between all the three riparian States in relation to sharing of the water of iiver Krishna was finally adjudicated upon by the tribunal by evolving the two schemes and under Scheme "A", mass allocation in favour of three States being made in respect of the availability of water in the river basin at 75% dependability, under Scheme "B" allocation has been made both in respect of surplus as well as water in the deficit water year and according to the plaintitl~ the entire water dispute which had been referred to the t:J.ibunal c;m be said to have been resolved only when Scheme "B" comes into operation, The said Scheme "B" not having been treated as the decision of the tribunal by the Union Government, and therefore, not being notified under Section 6 of the Act, the tights of the State of Kamataka flowing from implement;ation of said Scheme "B" is being infringed and the State is not in a position to have its future plan for utilisation of any surplus water in the river basin, and therefore, the approp1iate authorities should be mandatorily called upon for notifying the said scheme and for constitution of the Monitoring Authority. This being the nature of the assertions made in the plaint and the relief sought for, it is difficult for us to hold that it constitutes a dispute within the meaning of Section 2(c) of the Act, and therefore, the jurisdiction of this Court gets baiTed under Article 262 read with Section 11 of the Act. In fact, the assertions made in the plaint and the relief sought for cai1 be held to be a claim on the basis of an adjudicate~ dispute, the enforcement whereof is sought for by filing a suit under Article 131 of the Constitution. Such a suit cannot be held to be barred under Atticle 262 of the Constitution read with Section 11 of the Act. It is true, we have held while deciding issues 4, 5 and 7 that Scheme " B" evolved by the tribunal is not the decision of the tribunal under Section 5(2) of the Act but such conclusion of ours, would not necessarily lead to the conclusion that the suit itself gets baffed under Section 11 of the Act, as contended by the learned Solicitor General. The question whether the jurisdic-

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2000) 3 S.C.R.

tion of this Court gets barred in view of Section 11 of the Act has to be answered by examining the assertions in the plaint and the relief sought for and by doing so, we are not in a position to hold that the assertions in the plaint together with the relief sought for, constitu~e a dispute under Section 2(c) of the Act, thereby ousting the jurisdiction of this Court under Section 11. We, therefore, hold this issue of maintainability in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants.

ISSUE NO. 6

C

The aforesaid issue has been struck on the assertions made in the written statement of the State of Maharashtra. It has been averred in the written statement of the State of Maharashtra that Scheme "A" having been implemented from the date of its notification in the Official Gazette under Section 6 and being in operation for 21 years and parties having worked out their equities on the basis of said scheme on the mass allocation of water in river Krishna, the question of implementing Scheme "B" at this stage does not arise even assuming that Scheme "B" is held to be a decision of the tribunal. According to the State of Maharashtra to make Scheme "B" effective, it is necessary that all the States should have their reservoirs in the basin at the places to be indicated by the so-called Monitoring Authority, supposed to have control under the very scheme. The same not having been possible, any direction after a lapse of 21 years to implement Scheme "B" would be grossly prejudicial to the State of Maharashtra. The further stand taken in the written statement is that Scheme "A" itself having been implemented all the years and having provided for a review after 31" of May, 2000, which is fast approaching and the State .:>f Kamataka also at one point of time having taken the stand that the Scheme "B" should not be implemented, it would not be appropriate for this Court to issue any direction for implementation of the said Scheme "B". In course of arguments, Mr. Andhyarujina, the learned senior counsel, appearing for the State of Mahar·ashtra, emphasised the fact that even as late as 30th of August, 1993, the Secretary to the Government, Irrigation Department, Kamataka, had intimated to the Secretary to the Government, Ministry of Water Resources, Government of India as per Exh. PK-94 that the Karnataka Government is of the firm opinion that establishment of Krishna Valley Authority is not called for, since even without reference to Scheme "B", the surplus water can be shared by the parties by mutual agreement. This indicates the stand of the Kamataka Government with regard to the implementation of the so-called Scheme "B" evolved by the tribunal.

--

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

Mr. Nariman, appearing for the plaintiff on the other hand contended that the State of Kamataka has all along been keen in requesting for implementation of Scheme "B ", though in that letter PK 94, referred to by Mr. Andhyarujina, it has been merely stated that at that point of time it may not be necessary to have the Krishna Valley Authority. According to Mr. Nariman, rights in relation to sharing of water of river Krishna having been crystalised by formulation of both the schemes, that right cannot be negatived merely because it has not been operated for this length of time. Having considered several correspondence between the parties, we find that though initially the State of Kamataka had requested the Union Govemment for implementation of Scheme "B'', thinking the same to be the decision of the tribunal and even though at one point of time the Union itself through its counsel Mr. Seyid Muhammad, had requested the tribunal itself to make Scheme "B" operative but later on each of the states began their water management projects on the basis of the mass allocation made under Scheme "A". Mr. Nariman is right in his submission that the states had no other altemative inasmuch as it was only Scheme "A" which was notified and was made binding between the parties but the fact remains that having planned their respective projects on the basis of mass allocation made by the tribunal, the State of Kamataka did tbink in the year 1993 in response to the letter from the Union Government for constitution of the Krishna Valley Authority that the State does not think it proper to have the Authority at that point of time. Thus all the three states have made their respective planning for utilisation of the allocated water in their respective share by the tribunal under Scheme "A" which as until today continues to be effective but for the apprehension and dispute between the State of Andhra Pradesh and Kamataka, when Kamataka started construction of dam at Almatti and Andhra Pradesh went on with large projects like Telugu Ganga, Nagarjunasagar and others. In the matter of sharing of waters of interState river when the tribunal constituted under the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, evolved a scheme of mass allocation as under Scheme "A" and that scheme has remained operative for all these years and could be reviewed at any time after 31 '1 of May, 2000 even as per the decision of the tribunal itself, the contention of the State of Maharashtra that direction to implement scheme "B" at this length of time should not be given effect to is of considerable substance. In a dispute of the present nature when the Court is in cession of the matter before issuing any direction, the Court is not examining merely the rights of the parties, if any, flowing from any earlier order of tribunal but also the question of the equitability and the question of the efficaciousness of any such direction. It is in this context, the submission of Mr. Parasaran, the

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

learned senior counsel, appearing for the State of Andhra Pradesh to the effect that a tested scheme like Scheme "A" which has remained operative for all these years should not be given a go-bye, abruptly by directly implementation of Scheme "B", particularly, when it is an admitted fact that not only the backbone of said Scheme "B", the Krishna Valley Authority, has not been constituted but alsci the States themselves have not been able to build-up their reservoirs for storage of surplus water, which is also a part of Scheme "B" itself. We, however need not further delve into this matte~ in view of our conclusion earlier that Scheme "B" is not a decision of the tribunal and as such the Court will not be justified in issuing .any direction in implementation of the said scheme. This issue is answered accordingly.

ISSUE NOS. JO AND 11.

These two issues are inter-linked and, therefore are taken up together for consideration. The plaintiffs stand in this respect is that while making mass allocation in favour of tlrree States in respect of 2060 TMC of Krishna river, which was found at 75% of dependability and while allocating specified quantity of water in a water year in respect of the three states, the tribunal has also observed that Andhra Pradesh will be at liberty to use in any water year, the remaining water that may be flowing in river Krishna but such liberty will not confer any right whatsoever nor can the State claim any right in respect of any water in excess of the quantity specified namely 800 TMC. The relevant Clause of the Final Order as notified in the Gazette by the Government of India is extracted hereto: "(C) The State of Andhra Pradesh will be at liberty to use in any

water year the remaining water that may be flowing in the river Krishna but thereby it shall not acquire any right whatsoever to use in any water year nor be deemed to have been allocated in any water year, water of the river Krishna in excess of the quantity specified hereunder:as from the water year commencing on the 1st June next after the date of the publica~on of the decision of the Tribunal in the Official Gazette up to the water year 1982-83. 800 T.M.C. (i)

(ii) as from the water year 1983-84 up to the water year 1989-90. 800 T.M.C. plus

k

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

a quantity of water equivalent to 10 per cent of the excess of the· average of the annual utilisations for irrigation in the Krishna river basin during the water years 1990-91, 1991-92 and 1992-93 from its own projects using 3 T.M.C. or more annually over the utilisations for such irrigation in the water year 1968-69 from such projects.

-

(iii) as from the water year 990-91 up to the water year 1997-98 800 T.M.C. plus a quantity of water equivalent to 10 per cent of the excess of the average of the annual utilisations for irrigation in the Krishna river basin during the water years 1982-83, 1983-84 and 1984-85 from its own projects using 3 TMC or more annually over the utilisations for such irrigation in the water 1968-69 from such projects.

C

(iv) as from the water year 1998-99 onwards 800 T.M.C. plus

.,._

a quantity of water equivalent to 10 per cent of the excess of the average of the annual utilisations for irrigation in the Krishna river basin during the water years 1990-91, 1991-92 and 1992-93 from i•; own projects using 3 T.M.C. or more annually over the utilisation for such irrigation in the water year 1968-69 from such projects." But notwithstanding the aforesaid observations made by the tribunal, the State of Andhra Pradesh is going ahead with large-scale water projects for utilisation of all the surplus water, flowing in river basin to pre-empt the upper riparian States like Maharashtra and Kamataka from claiming their share in surplus water in excess of 2060 T.M.C., allocated under Scheme "A". The State of Maharashtra as well as the Union Government also support the aforesaid stand of the State of Kamatak:a but the State of Andhra Pradesh on the other hand takes the stand that Andhra Pradesh being the lowest riparian State in the river basin and the tribunal having granted the liberty to use the remaining water which may be flowing in river Krishna, there should not be any fetter in exercise of that libe1ty by the State and the apprehension of the State of Kamataka as well as the State of Maharashtra is unfounded. In the context of the rival stand of the parties, the question that arises for consideration is whether the liberty granted by the tribunal in favour of the lowest riparian State, namely the State of Andhra Pradesh to use the excess water is unfettered and the State can use the same in any manner it likes, or there

\

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

should be some restrictions in such use. At the outset, it may be noticed that in the very clause, while giving liberty to State of Andhra Pradesh to use the remaining water, the tribunal itself has hastened to hold - "but thereby it shall not acquire any right whatsoever to use in any water year nor be deemed to have been allocated in any water year, water of the river Krishna in excess of the quantity specified." The aforesaid direction of the tribunal itself curtails the so-called liberty granted to the State of Andhra Pradesh but since the tribunal was givip.g a mass allocation in respect of the three States and unless such liberty is granted in favour of the lowest riparian State, the water would have otherwise entered into the Bay of Bengal and, therefore, it was thought fit that the lowest riparian State could utilise the same, but can never claim a right by using the excess water. In the context of the expenses involved for such major projects and the national loss, which the country cannot afford to sustain in a Federal Structure like our country, it is the duty of the Central Government to bear this in mind. while sanctioning any such major project of the lowest riparian State like Andhra Pradesh. A bare reading of the report of the tribunal and its decision in the form of a Final Order, which has been notified by the Central Government, unequivocally indicates that the so-called liberty granted to the lowest riparian state does not confer any right beyond the allocable share, in other words, what the lowest riparian state bas been granted under the decision of the tribunal is a liberty to utilise the surplu~­ water flowing without creating any right in favour of the State concerned. Such a liberty, therefore would mean that so long as the mass allocation ;,, in force, the lowest riparian State can certainly utilise any excess water, flowing in the river basin, before it merges into the sea but such user should not be, by way of permanent construction of large-scale projects and water reservoirs, particularly, when the so-called mass allocation under Scheme "A" itself is liable to be reviewed after 31" of May, 2000, which is fast approaching. The contention of Mr. Parasaran, appearing for the State of Andhra Pradesh, in this regard to the effect that there is no fetter on the manner of user of the surplus water, the liberty having been given, cannot be accepted in such broad basis though it cannot be denied that so long as Scheme "A" is under operation and so long as the two upper riparian States get their share of allocation of water, the lowest riparian State of Andhra Pradesh can use the excess water flowing down in the river basin. It is true that while granting such liberty, the tribunal bas not indicated as to the manner of its user but the same must be read into the moment the other part of the Order is read namely such user will neither confer a right nor can be deemed to have been allocated in favour of the said lowest riparian State. This being the nature of direction of the tribunal, it is

.l

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTA..'fAIK, J.]

appropriate for the Central Government to exercise the discretion while granting any scheme or project of the lowest riparian state and bearing in mind, what is really meant by the liberty granted, so that the lowest riparian state should not be allowed to proceed ahead with large-scale water projects for utilisation of the surplus water in excess of the allocated quantity over which, the State has no right. It is the Central Government which has to exercise this discretion while clearing projects of the lowest riparian State and it should be so exercised that there should not be any apprehension in the minds of the upper States that for all times to come, their right of sharing the surplus water would in any manner be endangered. These two issues are answered accordingly.

ISSUE NO. 9

In view of what has been stated by us while answering Issues 10 and 11, this issue, no longer survives for any further consideration and this jssue is accordingly answered against the defendant State of Andhra Pradesh.

ISSUE NO. 2 This issue has to be answered on the basis of the assertions made in tlie plaint as well as the cause of action for filing of the suit. As has been stated earlier, the State of Karnataka being of the opinion that Scheme "B" evolved by the tribunal is also a decision of the tribunal, which unfortunately could not be given effect to, on account of lack of consent of all the States for constituting a Monitoring Authority and having failed in its attempt to get the said scheme implemented by getting a Monitoring Authority constituted, the said state filed the present suit. It is the refusal of the State of Andhra Pradesh to agree to the constitution of an authority, thereby making the scheme unimplementable, which gave the cause of action to file the present suit on the basis of which the suit has been filed and taking into account the fact that the State of Andhra Pradesh has never agreed to the constitution of the Krishna Valley Authority, which was thought to be the back-bone of Scheme "B", it cannot be said that the plaintiff-State has no cause of action for filing the suit. This issue is answered in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants.

p

ISSUE NO. 3 The aforesaid issue really does not arise for any further elucidation and discussion inasmuch as it has been held by us that Scheme "B" is not the decision of the tribunal, though the same is mentioned in the report. The relief

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2000] 3 S.C.R.

sought for, therefore, in the plaint cannot be held to be contrary to the report as the report submitted by the tribunal did contain both the schemes- Scheme "A" and Scheme "B" but it is certainly contrary to the decision of the tribunal inasmuch as tribunal itself resolved the dispute referred to it by formulating Scheme "A" for distribution of the water on mass allocation basis and which according to the tribunal itself is contained in the Final Order of the tribunal. This issue is answered accordingly.

ISSUE NO. 8

The aforesaid issue arises in view of Prayer (c) of the plaint, whereunder, the plaintiff has prayed that Defendant No. 3 be directed by mandatory order to notify Scheme "B" and make provisions for establishment of Krishna Valley Authority, as contemplated under Section 6(A) of L'ie Inter-State Water Disputes Act. It is the contention of the plaintiff that constitution of the Monitoring Authority under Scheme "B" being the back-bone of the scheme and Section 6(A) having been brought on the Statute book by amendment, such authority could be constituted by the Central Government in exercise of powers under Section 6(A) and, therefore, though on the date, the further report of the tribunal was submitted, it would not have been possible for tl1e Union Government to constitute tl1e Monitoring Authority but now after insertion of Section 6(A) of the Act, there is no impediment for exercise oi that power and, therefore, this Comt should issue appropriate directions in that regard. According to Mr. Nariman, the very object of insertion of Section 6(A) of the Act, being the implementation of the decision of the tribunal under the Act, which decision may involve of setting up of a machinery for the purpose, as is indicated in the Statement of Objects and Reasons and in the case in hand, setting up of such authority, not having been agreed to by the parties, nor the Parliament having come forward with any legislation under Entry 56 of List I of the Seventh Schedule and at the same time the said Scheme "B" having been evolved for better and fuller utilisation of the water of river Krishna by all the riparian States, this Court should issue necessary mandatory orders, calling upon the Union Government to constitute the authority. According to Mr. Nariman, the learned senior counsel for the State of Karnataka, Section 6(A) confers power upon the Central Government and correspondingly, casts a duty on the said Government and if the Statute confers a power coupled with duty, the Court can always compel the authority concerned to perform the said duty, if the same is not performed at all. Mr. Nariman contends that though the tribunal devoted a good deal of its time in evolving Scheme "B" for better

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

'..

,~,....

Al

lilt ?""

)"

_........

-lf

and fuller utilisation of the water of river Krishna amongst the three riparian States, but could not make it a part of the Final Order as one of the States did not give consent to the tribunal for constituting the Monitoring Authority, which in fact is said to be the back-bone of the scheme. But to obviate such difficulties when the Parliament itself has come forward, engrafting Section 6(A) on the Statute Book, which confers ample powers on the Central Government to form the authority for implementation of the decision of the tribunal, the Court, if it comes to the conclusion that Scheme "B" is the decision and should be implemented, can issue appropriate directions to the Central Government for constituting the Monitoring Authority. According to ·Mr. Nariman, Section 6(A)(l) is purely an executive function and does not contain an iota of flavour of subordinate legislation and, therefore, there should be no difficulty for the Court in issuing mandatory injunction. Mr. Parasaran, appearing for the State of Andhra Pradesh, on the other hand contended that the power under Section 6(A) is not executive, but legislative in nature and, therefore, Cowt would not be justified in issuing a mandamus or mandatory injunction for performance of a legislative function in the same way as the Court cannot call upon the legislature to frame a law. Mr. Parasaran also further argued that sub-section (7) of Section 6(A) contemplates that the scheme framed under Section 6(A) has to be laid before each House of · Parliament and it is only after the Parliament ratifies the scheme, will have effect and in the event, the Parliament does not agree for the framing of the Scheme, the same shall not have any effect. This being the position, the Court will not pass a decree which ultimately is capable of being nullified by the Parliament Mr. Parasaran further argues that Section 6(A) having come into existence in 1980, long after the decision of the tribw1al, even if it is held that Scheme "B" is a decision of the tribunal and the performance of duty by the Central Goveminent under Section 6(A) is executive in nature, yet the power cannot be exercised vis-a-vis the decision of the tribunal except those subject matter which would fall within the power related to Entry 56 of List I. According to the learned counsel, the Central Govemment can establish an authority only if Parliament makes law under Entry 56 of List I and also makes a further declaration as required. Mr. Andhyarujina, the learned senior counsel for the State of Maharashtra, also supported the contention of Mr. Parasaran and submitted that the power under Section 6(A) is essentially a delegated legislative power and, therefore, no court would be justified in issuing mandamus for exercise of such power. This issue really does not require to be answered since question of direction to constitute an authority like Krishna Valley Authority would crop up, only if it is held that Scheme "B" evolved

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

by the tribunal is the decision of the tribunal and for its implementation an Authority is required to be constituted. We have already held that Scheme "B" cannot be held to be the decision of the tribunal, while deciding issue Nos. 4, 5 and 7 and in that view of the matter, we are not inclined to examine the contentious issues as to whether the exercise of power by the Central Government under Section 6(A) is an executive one, as contended by Mr. Narirnan or is legislative in nature, as contended by Mr. Parasaran. We, therefore, leave this issue open, not deciding the same.

ISSUE NO. 12

C

p

This issue has been framed at the instance of the State of Maharashtra, in view of the stand taken by the said State that a review having been provided for, in 2000 A.D., the suit filed by the plaintiff is pre-mature. While providing mass allocation in favour of three riparian States on the basis of 2060 T.M.C. bf water at 75% dependable flow, the tribunal itself has observed in its Original Report, which has been marked as Exhibit PKl that the Order of the tribunal could be reviewed at any time after 31 '1 of May, 2000 and this period is considered reasonable in view of the fact that during the intervening period there will be increasing demands for water for irrigation and other purposes in the Krishna basin which may have to be examined in the light of the fresh data that may be available and further in view of the stupendous advance in the technology in the matter of conservation of water and its uses and also for other reasons. But the aforesaid review which has been indicated in the Order of the tribunal is in relation to the allocation made under Scheme "A" and has nothing to do with Scheme "B". Since plaintiff-State has filed the suit on the assumption that Scheme "B" is the decision of the tribunal and should be implemented by a mandatory order of the Court, such a suit cannot be held to be pre-mat:ure on the ground that a review has been provided for after 2000A.D. This issue is, therefore, answered in favour of the plaintiff and against the defendants.

ISSUE NO. 13 In the context of the prayer made in the plaint as well as the basis of the said prayer and in view of our findings on Issues 3, 4 arid 7, question of granting relief sought for by the plaintiff State does not arise. But at the same· time this being a suit under Article 131 of the Constitution, and in view of the nature of disputes raised by the parties and in view of our discussion in the

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

judgment relating to Scheme 'B' evolved by the Tribunal, we think it appropriate to observe that in the event any of the riparian State approaches the Central Government, the Central Government would do well in constituting a Tribunal which Tribunal can go into the entire gamut of disputes and in the said proceedings the parties can certainly place the datas and materials on the basis of which Bacchawat Tribunal had evolved the two Schemes for efficacious allocation of water in river Krishna. It will also be open for the parties to place fresh datas on the basis of improved method of gauging even for finding out the availability of water in Krishna basin. In fact the learned Solicitor General, fairly stated that in the event any of the riparian States approaches the Central Government, it would not hesitate to discharge its statutory obligation for constitution of a Tribunal and that is the only solution at this juncture.

The suit is accordingly dismissed with these observations. There would, however, be no order as to costs.

PATTANAIK, J. The State of Andhra Pradesh has filed the suit under

,· '

y·

Article 131 of the Constitution of India, impleading the State of Karnataka, Union of India and State of Maharashtra as party defendants, seeking relief of ·declaration and mandatory injunction on the allegation that the State of Karnataka, in particular has made gross violations of the decision of Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal and such violations have adversely affected the residents of the State of Andhra Pradesh. The relief sought for in the suit are as under: "(a) declare that the report /decision dated 24.12.1973 and the further report/decision dated 27 .5.1976 of the Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal (KWDD in their entirety are binding upon the three riparian States of Maharashtra, Kamataka and Andlu·a Pradesh and also the Union of India; (b) declare that the riparian States are duty bound to fully disclose to each other and also to the Union of India all particulars of all projects undertaken or proposed after December, 1973 and May, 1976 and to direct the defendants to ensure that execution thereof are in confonnity with and do not conflict with or violate the decisions of the KWDT and they do not adversely affect the rights of the other riparian States; (c) declare that the party States are entitled to utilise not more than the quantity of water which is allocated or permitted by the decisiop.s of the KWDT for the

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2000] 3 S.C.R.

respective projects of the respective party States before the Tribunal; and that any variation in either storage or utilisation of the waters by each such state in respect of each of such projects could only be with the prior consent or concurrence of the other riparian States; (d) declare that all the projects executed and/or which are in the process of execution by the State of Kamataka which are not in conformity with and conflict with or violate the decisions of the KWDT, as illegal and unauthorised. (e) declare that approvals I sanctions I clearances I in-principle clearances granted by the Union of India on or after KWDT decisions on 24.12.1973 and on 27.5.1976 in respect of schemes I projects I undertaken by the Government of Karnataka are invalid and direct the Union Government to review I reconsider all such schemes I projects proposed I undertaken by Karnataka, afresh, after obtaining the views thereon of the other riparian States; (f) declare that the State of Kamataka and Maharashtra shall not be entitled to claim any rights preferential or otherwise in respect of ~torage, control and use of waters of the inter- State river Krishna in respect of the schemes /projects not authorised by the decision of the KWDT; (g) declare that the Uniop. Government is duty bound to consult all the riparian States of Maharashtra, Kamataka and Andhra Pradesh before according any approvals I sanctions I clearances I inprinciple clearances to any schemes I projects proposed I unde1taken by any of t11e riparian States on the inter-State river Krishna and direct the Union Government to act in terms of the said declaration; (h) grant a mandatory injunction directing the State of Kamataka to undo al! its illegal, unauthorised actions regarding projects/ schemes and in pa1ticular the following projects executed by it contrary to the decisions of KWDT so as to bring them in conformity with the said decisions:

Almatti Dam under UKP Construction of Canals/Lifts Schemes on Almatti Reservoir. Upper Krishna Projects in K-2 Sub-basin.

Hippargi Weir/Irrigation Schemes.

'•

't

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.)

Construction of lndi and Rampur lift schemes on Narayanpur reservoir and the canals. (i) grant a permanent injunction restraining the State of Kamataka from unde1taking, continuing or proceeding with any further construction in respect of the following proj~cts: Almatti Dam under UKP Constmction of Canals/Lifts Schemes on Almatti Reservoir

Upper Krishna Projects in K-2 Sub-basin. Hippargi Weir/Irrigation Schemes. Construction of lndi and Rampur lift Schemes on Narayanpur reservoir and the canals.

G) appoint a team of experts for making a comprehensive technoeconomic evaluation and environmental impact analysis in respect of the following projects and, pending orders of this Hon'ble Court on the report of the team of experts, grant an order of injunction restraining the Defendant No. 1 - State of Karnataka from proceeding with any further construction in any of the following projects/ schemes: Almatti Dam under UKP Construction of Canals/ Lifts Schemes on Almatti Reservoir. Upper Krishna Projects in K-2 Sub-basin.

Hippargi Weir/Irrigation Scheme. Construction of lndi and Rampur lift schemes on Narayanpur Reservoir and the canals. (k) to issue a permanent injunction restraining the Defendant No. 1 State of Kamataka from growing or allowing to grow sugarcane or raising other wet crops in the command areas falling under the projects/schemes within the Upper Krishna Project; (I) pass a decree in terms of prayers (a) to (k); and (m) award costs of the present proceeding in favour of the Plaintiff;

(n) pass such further decree or decrees or other orders as this Hon'ble Court may deem fit in the facts and circumstances of the case." Though there are as many as 14 reliefs sought for as stated above, but

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000) 3 S.C.R.

essentially the reliefs relate to the construction of Almatti Dam under Upper Krishna Project by the State of Karnataka to a height of 524.256 M. Though the averments of facts in the plaint have been made in 71 paragraphs, shorn of minute details, the same may be stated as under:

...,.. :

"

\

That the dispute between the three riparian States namely Maharashtra, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh with respect to use, distribution and control of the water of inter-State river Krishna stood resolved by the decisions of the tribunal, constituted under Section 4 of the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956 (hereinafter referred to as 'the Act') by the decision rendered in 1973 and the Further decision rendered in 1976. The said decision having been notified by the Central. Government under Section 6, became binding on all parties. ·All the parties-States being constituents of the Federation of Republic of India, the plaintiff expected that each State, while undertaking their projects for utilisation of the quantity of water allocated in their favour by the tribunal would consult with the other concerned States and would so use, which will not be against the decision of the tribunal in any manner. But the State of Karnataka has not been acting in accordance with the letter and spirit of the d,ecision of the tribunal and on the other hand has violated the expressed terms and conditions of the tribunal, which compelled the State of Andhra Pradesh to invoke the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court under Article 131 of the Constitution. After indicating the topography of the river as well as the three riparian States and the disputes which arose between the States that lead the Central Government to constitute the Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal, the plaintiff has stated that the tribunal framed seven main issues and under issue No. II with its eight sub-issues, decided the question of equitable apportionment of the beneficial use of the waters of the river Krishna and the river Valley by evolving Scheme "A" and making the same as its Final Order or decision, which became binding on all the parties, after the same was notified by the Union Goveinment under Section 6 of the Act. It is not necessary for us to reiterate all the facts leading to the raising of disputes and constitution of the tribunal, which we have already narrated in judgment in O.S.l of 1997, filed by the State of Karnataka. The plaintiff then has averred as to how on the basis of agreement between the parties, the 75% dependable flow at Vijayawada was found to be 2060 TMC and while considering the case of each State for allocation of their respective share of water in respect of the aforesaid 75% of dependable flow, several projects in the river basin, already undertaken by the States as well as the quantity of water required for the projects were considered by the tribunal on the basis of which the ultimate figure of

.Aii..

~

-(

___.__ - .

~

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

·~

.........

allocation were arrived at. According to the plaint, the tribunal, while restraining the States of Maharashtra and Mysore from using more water than allocated in their favour, granted liberty to the plaintiff-State of Andbra Pradesh to use the remaining water with the rider that the State of Andbra Pradesh will not acquire any right to the user of such water except to the extent allocated to it. The plaintiff also averred that while making allocation to the three States, no express provisions were made for sharing of any deficiency and further the tribunal took note of the fact that out of 100 years, deficiency may occur in 25 years. It was also averred that to relieve the State of Andbra Pradesh from the aforesaid difficulty, the tribunal permitted the State of Andbra Pradesh to store water in the Nagai:junasagar Dam and in Srisailam Dam and held that for such storage, there would not be any deduction from its share out of the dependable flow on the ground that if the water is not allowed to be stored by the plaintiff-State, then it would flow down and get submerged in the sea. According to the plaint, the tribunal did consider the different project reports which had been produced before it, in relation to the Upper Krishna Project and allowing the protected utilisation of 103 TMC, it came to the conclusion that the demand of State of Kamataka to the extent of 52 TMC to be utilised by Narayanpur Right Bank Canal is worth consideration. After enumerating the different clauses of the Final Order of the tribunal in its original report of 1973, the plaintiff has averred that though the tribunal has made allocation enbloc in a negative form namely that the State cannot utilise more than the allocable quantity of water in its share in any water year but the said enbloc allocation has to be read in the light of the relevant stand of the parties before the tribunal, the facts and figures produced before the tribunal and the ultimate basis on which the conclusion was arrived at. According to the plaintiff, by taking recourse to the aforesaid method, it would be crystal clear that party- States were restrained from utilising in different sub-basins of river Krishna within their respective territory, beyond what was considered as the protective use and the additional quantity allocated to their share. It has been averred in the plaint that' so far as Upper Krishna Project is concerned within the State of Kamataka, the tribunal has allocated only 160 TMC of water for being used and the construction of Almatti Dam to the height of 524 Meters, as indicated by the State of Kamataka, would, therefore, on the face of it, is in violation of the decision of the tribunal. After referring to the different applications for clarifications sought for by different States under Section 5(3) of the Act and the answer of the tribunal on the same, the plaintiff has also avened as to how the tribunal dealt with the contentions raised by the State of Maharashtra before it, in relation to the allocation of 52

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R

TMC of water from Narayanpur Right Bank Canal. According to the plaintiff, though, no doubt in the Final .Order of the tribunal, there has been a mass allocation of water in favour of the three riparian States out of the 2060 TMC of water under 75% of dependability at Vijayawada, which figure was arrived at by consent of the parties, but a closer scrutiny of the report in its entirety being examined, it would be apparent that the allocation in respect of different sub-basins had been made on the basis of projects undertaken in those subbasins and consequently, no State would be entitled to use the entire quantity of water allocated in their favour in any particular sub-basin. The plaintiff, then has averred that the post award developments undertaken by the State of Karnataka, intending to raise the height of Almatti Dam to 524 Meters is nothing but a gross violation of the decision of the tribunal and, therefore, this Court should injunct the State of Karnataka in going ahead with the Almatti Dam upto the height of 524 Meters, as indicated in its project. The plaintiff then referred to several correspondence made between the State of Karnataka and State of Andhra Pradesh inter se, as well as correspondence between these States and Union Government and Central Water Commission. It has also been averred that allowing the State of Kamataka to construct the dam at Almatti up to a height of 524 Metres would be grossly detrimental to the lower riparian state of Andhra Pradesh inasmuch as for three months in a year from July to September, the State of Andhra Pradesh may go dry and the entire crop in the State would get damaged for paucity of water. The plaintiff also has averred in several paragraphs of the plaint, as to how the plaintiff-State has been demanding from the State of Karnataka to have suitable information in relation to the construction of the dam at Almatti and how the plaintiff-State has been prevented from being favoured with any such information. In paragraph 34 of the plaint, the plaintiff refers to the letter addressed to the Chief Minister of Andhra Pradesh by the then Union Minister for Water Resources, proposing to convene a meeting of Chief Ministers of the Krishna Basin States for discussing Upper Krishna Project Stage-II and along with the said letter, the observation of Central Water Commission, indicating how the project at Almatti creates a physical capability of water utilisation in excess of 173 TMC, which would be possible in view of the proposed top of the radial gate at FRL 521 meters against the required level of 518.7 meters for utilisation of 173 TMC of water. In the subsequent paragraph of the plaint, it has also been indicated as to how the State of Andhra Pradesh has been objecting to the proposals of the State of Karnataka to have the height of Almatti dam at 524 meters under the guise of flood protection measure and then how the plaintiff State requested the Prime Minister of India to intervene in the matter to avoid

_,.._ .

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

violation of the award of the Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal. In paragraph A 39 of the plaint, it has been averred that the Union Government as well as the Central Water Commission which are responsible for clearance of inter-State Projects, bent upon clearing the Almatti Project up to a dam height of 524 meters without even consulting the State of Andhra Pradesh, though, according to the plaintiff in a Federal Structure of the Government, each constituent State would be entitled to know the progress of any project in relation to interState river, since it may have several adverse effects on the other States. The plaintiff also averred that at the behest of the State of Andhra Pradesh, the United Front Government, which was at the Centre, constituted a Committee of four Chief Ministers to examine the issues relating io the construction of Almatti Dam, which committee in tum, decided to constitute an Expert Committee with a representative of the Central Water Commission and Planning Commission, who, however, did not ultimately participate in the proceedings. The said Expert Committee has found that the proposal of the Upper Krishna Project with FRL of 524.256 meters for Almatti Dam is under consideration and has not been approved by the Government of India, though D many canals have been designed and constructed for larger capacity meant for future uses and it is not necessary to build a bigger storage of 227 TMC at Almatti dam with top of shutter at 524.256 meters. The said Committee had also observed that the FRL on the top of the shutter be fixed for the present at 519 .6 meters and the gates be manufactured and erected accordingly and this will be adequate to take care of the annual requirements of 173 TMC presently envisaged under the Upper Krishna Project. The said Committee, therefore, suggested the restriction of the height of the dam at 519.6 meters. The plaintiff however does not accept of the entitlement of the first defendant to use 173 TMC under UKP and the height of the dam at 519.6 meters. From paragraph 52 onwards, the plaintiff then has made averments indicating the negotiations and further developments in the matter and then states tl1at the Ministry of Power, Government of India having indicated that 'in principle' clearance of construction of Upper Krishna Hydro- electric power project at Almatti, contemplating the height of the dam at 524.256 meters was contrary to the award of the tribunal, and therefore, the plaintiff-State lodged its objections by letter dated 18th of October, 1996, to which the reply came that G 'in principle' clearance is not a techno- economic clearance and it is purely an administrative action to facilitate developmental activities. The plaintiff, · thereafter by its letter dated 18th of December, 1996, requested the Secr~tary, Ministry of Water Resources, Govt. of India to ensure forthwith the publication in the Gazette of India the decision of the Krishna Water Disputes H

-~

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

Tribunal i.e. the report dated 24.12.1973 and the further report dated 27.5.1976 in its entirety. But since it became apparent that the Defendant No. 1 State of Karnataka was not at all inclined to resolve the problem by any amicable discussion nor did it desire any effort for mediation being undertaken by anyone whatsoever,the plaintiff had no other alternative but to approach this Court under Article 131 of the Constitution for declarations and injunctions against the Defendants for protection of the rights of the plaintiff State as well as the rights of its inhabitants flowing from the decision of the Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal. From paragraph 65 onwards, the plaintiff has narrated several facts constituting violations of the decision of the tribunal by the State of Kamataka and from paragraph 69 onwards, the plaintiff has indicated the role played by the Central Government in the matter of allowing the State of Karnataka to raise the height of the dam, which would ultimately lead to violation of the terms and conditions as well as the restrictions in the award of the tribunal and which wouW infringe the rights of the State of Andhra Pradesh and its inhabitants. The cause of action for filing the suit has been indicated in paragraph 73 of the plaint, namely indulgence of the State of Karnataka in going ahead with the Upper Krishna Project Stage I and II with the construction of the Almatti Dam which is in violation of the decision of the tribunal in letter and spirit. Defendant No. 1- State of Kamataka in its written statement, took the stand that the tribunal had not made any project-wise allocation and on the other hand, the allocation is enbloc and as such the question of interpreting the decision of the tribunal to the effect that there is restriction in the user of water in any particular Basin is not correct. It has been further averred that the State of Kamataka had contemplated the height of the Dam at Almatti as 524.256 m in the Project Report of 1970 itself and that Report had been filed before the tribunal and had been marked as document MYPK-3. Neither the State of Andhra Pradesh nor any other State had raised any objection to the said Project Report and there was no issue before the tribunal on that score and in fact the height of the Almatti Dam was not a matter of adjudication before the tribunal. In this view of the matter, the plaintiff-State is not entitled to raise that issue on the purported allegation that it amounts to violation of the decision of the tribunal. It is also contented that an identical issue having been raised by an individual by filing a writ petition in the Andhra Pradesh and after dismissal of the same, the matter having been brought to this Court and the order of the Andhra Pradesh High Court has been affim;ied, the same I question cannot be re.:agitated by filing a suit by the State under Article 131

-..,.... -

~

.---<

~

~-

)'-

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

of the Constitution of India. In respect of the decision of the Committee, which stated about the FRL 519 .6 m, it has been averred in the written statement that the said Committee considered the height at 519.6 meters to be sufficient, taking into account the storage capacity of the dam which will take care of the annual requirement of 173 TMC in a water year but it did not take into account the further water that may be needed for generation of power and the project at Almatti with the height of the dam beyond 519.6 meters and up to 524.256 meters being only for power generation and the water thus used for power generation being non-consumptive, there is no question of violation of any direction of Jie tribunal when the .:itate of Karnataka has decided to have the height of the dam at Almatti at 524.256 meters. It has been specifically averred in the written statement that the decision of the tribunal which has been Gazetted under Section 6 of the Act has not imposed any restriction on any State for construction of any Project and on the other hand Clause XV expressly mentioned that : "Nothing in the order of the tribunal shall impair the right or power or authority of any State to regulate within its boundaries the use of water, or to enjoy the benefit of water within that State in a manner not inconsistent with the order of this tribunal" and in view of such specific provision, it is futile for the State of Andhra Pradesh to contend that the height of the dam at Almatti should not be raised to 524.256 meters. The defendant has further averred that the Project at Almatti has been undertaken at huge cost exceeding Rs.6000 crores and it is not in national interest to stop the project at this advance stage and the suit has been filed with the design to cause delay in the completion of the projects undertaken by the State of Kamataka. It has been reiterated that the utilisation of water would be entirely within the allocated quantity made by the tribunal. According to Defendant No. 1, the plaintiff has not made out any case of breach of its legal rights and, therefore the suit under Article 131 of the Constitution is not maintainable. The defendant also narrated the background under which the Central Government set up the tribunal for adjudication of the disputes between the riparian States and how ultimately the tribunal gave its report, stating therein the facts found as well as the decision thereon. The defendant State has also stated in the written statement that the Almatti Dam has been designed for utilisation of 173 TMC for Upper Krishna Project in two stages and the State had indicated that height, right from the inception before the tribunal itself, though neither any party raised any objection nor any issue was struck, nor any decision thereon has been given by the tribunal itself and in this view of the matter any grievance with regard to the height of the dam at Almatti would be a fresh water dispute and would not come withi'l the adjudicated dispute and decision

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

thereon by the tribunal itself and, therefore, the suit filed under Article 131 is not maintainable. It has been specifically averred that the storage level at Almatti Dam from 519.6 meters to 524.256 meters is not at all an increase, particularly, when the tribunal itself expressly noted the contemplated completion of the Almatti Dam to the full height that is the height in Exhibit MYPK3. The defendant also referred to the report of the Central Water Commission dated January 30, 1994, whereunder it has been indicated that since the power generation is contemplated under the project at Almatti by way of utilising the extra storage of water between 519.60 meters and 521 meters, the prqject may be treated as a multi-purpose project (the level required to utilise 173 TMC of water for inigation is 519. 60 meters). The Defendant-State of Kamataka has specifically averred that even though the dam height is raised to this final level of 524.256 meters, the quantity of water that could be utilised for irrigation is only 173 TMC as per allocation made in the Award and any additional quantity over and above 173 TMC will be let out into the river after generating power. It has also been contended that the dispute raised being a water dispute in respect of an inter-State river, the same is governed by Article 262 of the Constitution read with Section 11 of the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, and therefore, suit under Article 131 is not maintainable. All allegations made by the plaintiff about the misuse of position have been denied. It has also been denied that neither there is any requirement of the decision of the tribunal nor any liability which compels any State to consult another State in the matter of planning of the projects for utilisation of its water resources and the contention raised by the State of Andhra Pradesh in this regard is wholly misconceived. The defendant further contends that the State of Andhra Pradesh not having utilised the opportunity to seek clarification under Section 5(3) of the Act with regard to the height of or any other specification of the Almatti Dam is not entitled to raise this dispute in this Court by filing a suit under Article 131 of the Constitution. The defendant-State of Kamataka reiterated that the utilisation of water under the U.K.P. first at Almatti and later at Narayanpur downstream, is entirely within the scope of 173 TMC and in any event within the aggregate share of 734 TMC allocated to the defendant Kamataka and the construction of the Upper Krishna Project at Almatti and at Narayanpur is all consistent with the work specifications prescribed by the Expert technical bodies in all respect including the provision for river sluices. In respect of Clause XV of the Final Order of the tribunal, the defendant averred that the quantity of 155 TMC considered in respect of Upper Krishna Project does not restrict the defendant Kamataka from planning increased utilisations by taking into account quantities of 34 TMC regeneration, 23 TMC

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF AP. [PATTANAIK, J.]

of water by diversion of Godavari waters and of 50% of the surplus flows A becoming available after the adoption of Scheme "B" devised by the tribunal. It is contended that the tribunal having not provided for allocation or utilisation project-wise, so long as there has been no contravention of the mass allocation made, the plaintiff has no grievance and is not entitled to file the' . suit. It has been stated in the written statement that in the re- submitted modified proposal dated 21st of April, 1996 for Upper Krishna Project Stage II as multi-purpose project, incorporating compliance of the various comments of CWC and also then again proposing a FRL of 524.256 meters, clearly stating that even though the dam was to be raised to its final level of 524.256 m, the utilisation for irrigation would be only 173 TMC as per the readjustment of the project-wise allocations in the Master Plan within the scope of the Scheme "A" allocation of 729 TMC and as such, there has been no deviation, so far as the height of the dam at Almatti is concerned. With regard to the allegations made in the plaint, concerning development seeking a political solution to the dispute, the defendant-Kamataka denies all the averments made in that respect and asserts that execution of projects is within its entitlement and limits permitted by the decision of the tribunal. With regard to the initiative taken by the Prime Minister of India by holding a meeting on 10.8.1996, it has been stated that such initiative was frustrated by the uncompromising and unreasonable attitude of political leaders of Andhra Pradesh. So far as the Committee of four Chief Ministers are concerned, it has been averred that the Committee of Experts, constituted by the four Chief E Ministers even did not frame any terms of reference for consideration, though requested by the State of Kamataka and it conducted the proceedings in a summary mam1er. The Chief Minister of Karnataka in fact had apprised the Chief Minister of West Bengal about the same by letter dated 19.12.1996 and after receipt of the so-called report of the Expert Committee, the Chief F Minister of Karnataka had conveyed its reaction to the findings by his letter dated 25.2.1997 to which the Chief Minister of West Bengal had replied that the points are being examined and according to the State of Kamataka, the matter remained inconclusive and as such camiot have any binding effect. In the written statement, the defendant No. 1 also averred that the findings of the said Expe1t Committee are erroneous. With regard to the allegations in the G plaint that storage of huge quantity of water by construction of Almatti Dam would affect t11e interest of Andhra Pradesh and its inhabitants, the defendant Karnataka denies the same and also stated that the dam is intended to utilise about 173 TMC of water for irrigation and the remaining storage water will be used for non-consumptive purpose i.e., production of power and, therefore, H

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

the water will tlow down to Andhra Pradesh and the said State will not be affected in any manner. With respect to allegations in the plaint regarding incorporation of Chamundi Power Corporation Ltd., the State of Kamataka has averred that the State is pursuing the matter before the Central Electricity Authority in accordance with law and the question of getting the consent of the plaintiff does not arise. So far as the assertions made in the plaint about the cascading and far-reaching effect on the environment is concerned, the State of Kamataka denies the same. On the question of alleged submergence, it has been averred that the State of Kamataka would take all adequate steps to provide compensation in accordance with law and rehabilitate the displaced population, if any. The assertions that Almatti Dam would render the major projects in Andhra Pradesh redundant, has been denied. So far as the allegation regarding violation of environmental law is concerned, it has'been averred in the written statement that the applications for environmental clearance ~e under process by the Government of India and the State of Kamataka has not done anything without the appropriate clearance from the Appropriate Authorities. According to the defendant-State of Kamataka, the averments in the plaint are mis-leading and lacking of bona fides and all allegations and insinuations against the Chief Minister of Kamataka are denied. All other allegations of illegality being perpetuated by the State of Karnataka have been denied. So far as creation of Jal Nigam is concerned for effective execution of the Upper Krishna Project, the State of Kamataka contends that the said Nigam is wholly Government owned company and all its activities are controlled by the Department of Irrigation, Govt. of Kamataka and, therefore, the allegation of the plaintiff that the State is abdicating its responsibility for the execution of the project is incorrect and is denied. It has been categorically averred that the Kamataka State would be subjected to irreparable loss if the works at Almatti are stopped and the State of Andhra Pradesh wants to reap the benefit of the liberty to use the surplus water flowing in the river in view of the mass allocation made in favour of the three States. It has been specifically averred that the storage of additional water between the height of 519.6 to 524.256 meters will be used for power production only and not for irrigation till the augmentation of waters by Godavari diversion and surplus waters under Scheme "B" is made available. It has been specifically averred as to how the Government of Karnataka has sought for approval for taking up the cluster of hydel projects at Upper Krishna Project in phases and how the Central Electricity Authority has accorded "in-principle" clearance. At the cost of repetition, the State of Karnataka has averred that there has been no deviation of the decision of the tribunal and the Almatti Dam has been planned

~-

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

for utilisation of the allocated water by the tribunal in favour of the State of Kamataka. According to this defendant, the State of Andhra Pradesh being the last riparian State is receipient of abundant waters comprising the un-utilised share of upper riparian States in addition to its allocations made in its own favour and, therefore, no case has been made out establishing any injurious hardships so as to entitle the State to get a discretionary relief of injunction. The defendant also averred that the plaintiff has not placed an iota of evidence based on any acceptable material establishing the alleged loss of drinking water, food grains or unemployment and all such allegations are falacious. According to the State of Kamataka, all the revised schemes at all relevant times had been submitted before the Appropriate Authorities of the Central Government and projects are being taken up only after getting clearance from the competent authorities. It has been averred at the end that the basis of the suit being that the allocation made by the tribunal is project-wise and the said basis being in-correct, the plaintiff is not entitled to tl.te reliefs prayed for by filing the suit under Article 131 of the Constitution. Union of India - defendant no. 2 in its written statement raised the preliminary objection about the maintainability of the suit on the ground that the suit as framed is not maintainable in view of Article 262 of the Constitution of India read with Section 11 of Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956. Generally denying the allegations made in the plaint the Union of India took the positive stand that Kamataka multipurpose project Stage II which envisages generation of Hydropower is still under examination and the project report provides for Hydropower generation by storing water at the addition of storage space from 519.6 M to 524.256 Mand it has been indicated that after generating the Hydropower the tail race water after power generation will be let into the river Krishna and the utilisation of river Krishna water under UKP will be within 173 TMC. With regard to the plaint allegation that under the Award Tribunal has allocated water projectwise, the Union of India submitted that the allocation of water is gross allocation and not the project wise allocation. It has been further stated that the State is entitled to utilise the gross amount of water for any such projects and so long as utilisation by Kamataka is within 173TMC in upper Krishna project. there is no violation of Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal Award. It has also been indicated that Stage I of UKP has been approved and Stage II is under various examination and not yet been approved. So far as the plaint case that Central Government is required to consult other States while clearing projects of one State, it has been averred that there is no obligation on the Central Government to consult said party

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

State while clearing projects of other party State of Krishna basin when they are within the framework of KWDT Award. The financial assistance by Central Government is being given to the State in the shape of grants and loans. So far as Almatti project in particular is concerned the stand of the Union Government in its written statement is that UKP stage I has already been approved and it was approved by the Planning Commission on 22nd April, 1978 under which the construction of Almatti Dam to a partial height corresponding to FRL 512.2 m with solid spillway crest level at EL 500 m and with 12.2 m high gates. But in view of the technical difficulty of dismentaling and reerecting the radial gates of such height in Stage II, the Government of Kamataka desired to do construction of Almatti dam with full section as required for ultimate stage and solid crest upto 512 min UKP Stage I itself. The revised proposal of Government of Kamataka was examined by the Central Water Commission and considered by Technical Appraisal Committee in its 20th Meeting held on 12.5.1982. The TAC recommended that the clearance of the Government of India for raising Almatti Dam in full width upto EL 500 m may be accorded subject to the observation that revised estimate be submitted by the State Government. Subsequently, the State Government came up with modified proposals with Almatti spillway crest at EL 509 m and 15 .2 high radial gates with a view to reduce submergence under Stage I of the project. This revised stage I estimate got the approval of the Planning Commission on 24.4.1990. According to the written statement of the Central Government, Stage I of UKP was duly approved by the Central Water Commission as well as by the Planning Commission with certain modifications enabling the State Government to take upto Stage II at later stage. It has further been averred that the Karnataka Government has revised Upper · Krishna Project Stage II (1993) as UKP Stage II Multipurpose project (1996) and that project is under examination. The State of Andhra Pradesh has sent their comments to the said project and various appraising agencies are checking the design of gates from the structural aspect. But no final approval has been given. The allegation of State of Andhra Pradesh that Central Government adopted partisan attitude has been denied and on the other hand it has been stated that the State of Andhra Pradesh has not been able to prove that by constructing Alm'ltti Dam the State of Kamataka will be utilising more water than allocated by KWDT. It is in this context the Central Government has also averred that the State of Andhra Pradesh is constructing Telugu Ganga Project which is an unapproved Project. So far as the allegation in the plaint that State of Andhra Pradesh had not been consulted before the Department of Environment and Forestcfeared the Upper Krishna Project, it has been

.....,....

-'""(

-~

--.. .

--,,.. -

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATIANAIK, J.]

'

~

_,..

averred that there is no obligation on the part of Department of Environment and Forest, Government of India to obtain the views of State of And.bra Pradesh while clearing of the Upper Krishna Project of State of Karnataka. According to the Central Government the Award of the Tribunal is binding on the parties and the plaintiff has not been able to show any violation of the decision of the Tribunal. On behalf of Ministry of Power who is Defendant No. 2 (C) a separate written statement has been filed giving reply to the averments made in paragraphs 56 and 57 of the plaint and it has been indicated that the expression "In Principle" clearance given by the Central Electricity Authority to Upper Krishna Project at Almatti does not tantamount to sanction of the project by the competent authority. According to the said defendant while appraising various proposals for power project received from the States due care is taken by the Ministry of Power for proper evaluation.

)r

-...

-

.

The State of Maharashtra - Defendant No.3 filed a written statement fully supporting the stand taken by the State of Karnataka and it has been averred in the written statement that the complaint of State of A.P. proceeds on certain assumptions which are not correct. With regard to the main question, namely, whether there was enbloc allocation or project wise allocation the defendant State of Maharashtra categorically avers that the Tribunal equitably allocated the waters of the river Krishna by allocating the quantities enbloc or in mass quantities. Though it has discussed individual projects of each State only for the limited purpose of assessing the needs of each State in accordance with the principles of equitable distribution. It has further been stated in the said written statement that apart from the restrictions expressly stated in the final order of the Tribunal which has been notified by the Central Government no other restrictions have been imposed on the method of use by each State within the allocated share of the State concerned and Tribunal has not put any restriction on the storage by each State and according to Clause VII of the final order the storage of water by each State would not be considered as use of water by the State c.oncemed. In the very written statement several paragraphs of the Report of the Tribunal have been quoted to indicate that the ultimate allocation was enbloc and not projectwise and further there has been no restriction or restraint placed by the Tribunal with regard to storage, size and height of dams in the Krishna Basin. The State has also referred to the subsequent conduct, that after the submission of original report and the decision of the Tribunal the Sta~e of And.bra Pradesh infact filed

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

clarification note 9 and 10 on 7.5.1975 and 8.5.1975 raising objection to the storage but ultimately withdrew those notes and did not want any clarification on the subject of storage which fortifies stand of the State of Maharashtra that there is no restriction on any State in respect of storage of water within the Krishna Basin so long as it does not exceed the enbloc allocation given by the Tribunal. According to this defendant the relief sought for in the plaint would tantamount to a complete re-writing of the decision of the Tribunal which would be outside the scope of a suit under Article 131 of the Constitution. After refuting the stand taken by the State of Andhra Pradesh in the plaint in paragraph 16 of the written statement the State of Maharasptra submitted , "that the plaintiff does not deserve to be granted any of the prayers prayed for in this para and the Suit should be dismissed with costs". Having filed the aforesaid written statement on 7th July, 1997 fully supporting the stand taken by the State of Kamataka and seeking relief of the dismissal of the suit filed by the State of Andhra Pradesh an additional written statement was filed by the said State on 9th April, 1999 giving a clear go bye to the earlier written statement and taking a new stand in relation to the alleged construction of Almatti Dam with FRL RL 524.56 m. by the State of Kamataka. In this additional written statement it has been averred that by raising the dam height at Almatti, there is likelihood of eno1mous damage to private and public properties and works and structures including archeological structures and pilgrimage places in the State of Mal1arashtra. There would also be disruption of communications, enhanced distress and damages during floods each year due to sedimentation. It has been furtlier avened that the details of the magnitude, duration and extent of submergence were not clear to the State of Maharashtra as the said submergence has not been discussed by the Tribunal itself but on getting subsequent documents from the State of Karnataka and on ascertaining the effect of the proposed Almatti Dam at 524.256 m it appears that there would be large scale submergence of area in the State of Maharashtra and no State should be allowed to have its project which will have deleterious and adverse effect on the other State. It is in this connection in the additional written statement it has been further avened that the said State of Karnataka has not obtained the relevant clearance from different environment authorities and forest authorities and even the Central Water Commission has not given the clearance and, therefore, the State of Karnataka should be injuncted from raising the dam height from 519.00 m. to 524.256 m. until and unless the actual area likely to be submerged is made known after due survey. In the written statement the adverse effect of submergence have been indicated in different paragraphs and ultimately it has been prayed that the prayer h, i &

~

/

~·

--1

-~

~.

-

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

j sought for by the plaintiff so far as it relates to Almatti Dam under UKP should be allowed, namely, the State of Kamataka should be injuncted. Though the State of Maharashtra filed the aforesaid additional written statement taking the stand totally contrary to the stand taken earlier but no order had been passed on the same and it is only when the hearing of this suit began the Court passed an order that without prejudice to the contention of the State of Kamataka the said additional written statement be taken into consideration on the basis of which an additional issue is also required to be framed. On the pleadings of the parties, 22 issues were framed which are extracted hereinbelow:I. Whether the State of Karnataka has violated the binding decisions

dated 24.12.1973 and 27.05.1976 rendered by the KWDT by executing the projects mentioned in para 66, 68n & 69 of the Plaint? (A.P./ KAR)

2. Has this Hon'ble Court jurisdiction to entertain and try this suit?

(MAH.)

.,.

.

3. Does the Plaintiff prove that the allocation of Krishna Waters by the KWDT in its Final Order are specific for projects and not enbloc as contended by the Defendant? (MAH.)

4. Does the Plaintiff prove that the upper States are not entitled to construct pr~ject without reference to and consent of the other States? (MAH.)

5. Whether the Plaintiff is entitled to a declaration that all the projects executed and/or which are in t11e process of execution by the State of Karnataka, and not in conformity with or in conflict with the Decisions of the KWDT are illegal and unauthorised? (A.P.) 6. Is not the Union Government duty bound to consult all the riparian States before accor<ling any approval/sanction/clearance in principle clearances to any schemes, projects proposed/undertaken, by any of the riparian States on the Inter-State river Krishna? (A.P.) 7. Whether the sanctions and the approvals granted by the 2nd Defendant to the State of Kamataka for the projects referred to in

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2000] 3 S.C.R.

Issue I, without the prior concurrence of State of Andhra Pradesh are valid and binding upon the Plaintiff? (A.P.)

-r·

8. Whether sanctions and the approvals granted by the 2nd defendant are liable to be reviewed, reconsidered afresh, after obtaining the views thereon of the other riparian States? (A.P.).

9.

(a)

Whether the construction of the Alrnatti darn with a FRL • of 524.256 111 together with all other projects executed, in progress and contemplated by Karnataka would enable it to utilise more water than allocated by the Tribunal? (A.P.)

·'it-

(b)

Whether Karnataka could be pe1mitted to proceed with construction of such a dam without the consent of other riparian States, and without the approval of the Central Government? (A.P.)

10. Whether the Plaintiff proves that the reservoir and inigation canals as alleged in paragraph 68 of the Plaint are oversized. If so, are they contrary to the Decision of the Tribunal? (A.P.)

11. Whether the Plaintiff State of Andhra Pradesh proves specific allocation/utilisation for UKP and canals as alleged? (A.P.) 12.Whether State of Kamataka is entitled to provide for any irrigation under Alrnatti canals and ot11er new projects, when no allocation is made under the decisions of the KWDT? (AP.)

13. Whet11er t11e Defendant State of Kamataka is entitled unilaterally to reallocate/readjust the allocation/utilisation under the UKP or any other project? Is concunence of other riparian States necessary? (A.P.)

14. Whether the Union of India can permit and/or is justified in permitting the State of Kamataka to proceed with various projects which are in violation of the decisions rendered by KWDT? (A.P.) 15. Whether Upper Krishna Stage-II Multipurpose Project could be. executed without the environmental clearance under t11e Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 and t11e Notification issued by the Central .

.......

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

_,

Govenunent in 1994 in exercise of its power under the said Act and the Rules made thereunder which mandatorily requires various analysis including dam break analysis?(A.P.) 16. Whether the acts of the State of Kamataka adversely effect or would adversely effect th~. State of Andhra Pradesh, and if so, with what consequences? (KAR)

..,...

17. Whether Hippargi was always part of the UKP and on that basis the KWDT awarded 5 TMC utilisation thereunder? (AP.) 18. Whether the utilisation of water under Chikkapada Salagi, Heggur and 5 other barrages is not 33 TMC as assessed by the Plaintiff State? (AP.) 19.Whether the cumulative utilisations in the K2 sub-basin is 173 TMC as claimed by the State ofKamataka or428.75 TMC as assessed by the Plaintiff State? (A.P.)

"'f'

20.Whether the State of Kamataka has violated the KWDT award by proceeding with several new projects in the sub-basin such as K-6, K-8 and K- 9 in respect of which restrictions in quantum of utilisation have been imposed in the final decision of the Tribunal? (AP.)

21.Whether utilisation under Alrnatti would be of the order of 91 TMC as claime~ in para 66(iii) of the plaint? (AP.) 22.To what reliefs if any, the plaintiff is entitled to? (AP.)

The additional issue framed as 9(C), because of the additional w1itten statement filed on behalf of defendant no.3 is to the effect, "Whether Kamataka can be permitted to raise the storage level at Alrnatti dam, above RL 509.16 meters in view of the likely submergence of territories in Maharashtra."

Before we take up the different issues framed by the Court and answer the same in the light of the contentions raised as well as with reference to the documents filed in support of the same it would be appr~priate for us to notice the order of this Court dated 30th September, 1997 and its effect on the

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000) 3 S.CR

ultimate decision of the suit itself. On 30th of September, 1997, this Court passed the following Order:

"Sh. F.S. Nariman, learned Senior counsel for the State of Kamatakadefendant No. 1 and Sh. T.R. Andhyarjuna, learned Solicitor General appearing for the State of Maharashtra- defendant No. 3 referred to the prayer (a) (at page 72 of the Paper book) and submits that both these States namely, Kamataka and Maharashtra accept this claim of the plaint of the State of Andhra Pradesh and agree to the grant of relief in the suit in terms of prayer in clause (a) as under: "(a) declare that the report/decision dated 24.12.1973 and the further report/decision dated 27 .5 .197 6 of the Krishna Waters Dispute Tribunal (KWDT) in their entirety are binding upon the three riparian States of Maharashtra, Kamataka and Andhra Pradesh and also the Union of India.

-...(

In other words, there is no controversy in the Suit between the plaintiff and Defendarits 1 and 3 i.e. Andhra Pradesh, Kamataka and Mal1arashtra and that the report/decision dated 24.12.1973 and the further report/decision dated 27 .5 .1976 of the Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal (KWDT) in their entirety are binding upon the three riparian States of Maharashtra, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh. There is thus no controversy between the three riparian States to this extent. The learned Attorney General appearin& for the Union of India submits that he is unable to make any statement today in this behalf as he has to seek instructions in the matter. This statement made by the learned counsel for the three riparian States is placed on record to indicate that a partial decree to this extent on the basis of admission of the defendants (1 and 3, Kamataka and Maharashtra) can be passed and therefore, there is no need to frame :any issue to cover this aspect of the Suit." In course of hearing of the suit arguments had been advanced on behalf of the State of Kamataka by Mr. Nariman that the aforesaid partial decree in terms\ of prayer 'a' of OS No. 2 of 1997 unequivocally indicates that the entire report i.e. 24.12.1973 and the further report dated 27.5.1976 in entirety must be held to be binding upon.three riparian States, and that being the position, there is

,.a-

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

--'f

. no logic on the part of the State of Andhra Pradesh to resist the prayer of Plaintiff No. 1 in OS No. 1 of 1997 to make Scheme 'B' binding on parties which Scheme obviously form a part of the report and the further report. Mr. Ganguli, learned senior counsel appearing for the State of Andhra Pradesh.on the_ other hand contended, that a prayer made by the plaintiff has to be understood in the context of the averments made in the plaint itself and not bereft of the same. According to Mr. Ganguli prayer 'a' in the case in hand, if read in the light of the averments made in the plaint itself it would only mean that the plaintiff State having averred in the plaint that the Tribunal had made projectwise allocation which should be read into the fmal decision of the Tribunal which has been notified in the Official Gazette by the Government of India and, therefore, the State of Kamataka is not entitled to faise the height of the Dam at Almatti to 514.256 meters whereby it would be able to store more than 200 TMC of water with the utilisation capacity of about 400 TMC. It is in this context Mr. Ganguli placed before us paragraphs 3.1, 3.2 and 3.3 of the written statement to indicate to us as to how the said defendant w1derstood the prayer 'a' in the plaint. Mr. Ganguli ultimately urged that the final order of the Tribunal' can be equated with a decree in a civil suit and decree must be consistent with the judgment and, therefore, applying the said analogy the fmal order requires to be read in the light of the adjudication made by the Tribunal in tl1e final report. The learned counsel placed reliance on the following decisions in support of the aforesaid contentions:-

Kalikrishna Tagore v. The Secretary of State,

'

(i)

LR 15

Indian Appeals 186 at 192.3 (ii) Law Report 25_Indian Appeals at 107 -08

·-

(iii) 1913 Vol. 25 Madras Law Journal 24. At the outset we are unable to accept the contention of Mr. Ganguli that the decision of the Tribunal which is ultimately notified under Section 6 of the Act can be held to be a decree of a s~it and the report being the judgment and, therefore, the decided case laws on which reliance has been placed has no application at all. The inter-State Water Disputes Act having been framed by the Parliament under Article 262 of the Constitution is a complete Act by itself and the nature and character of a decision made thereunder has to be understood in the light of the provisions of tl1e very Act itself. A dispute or difference between two or more State Governments having arisen which is a water dispute under Section 2(C) of the Act and complaint to that effect being

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

made to the Union Government under Section 3 of the said Act the Central Government constitutes a Water Disputes Tribunal for the adjudication of the dispute in question, once it forms the opinion that the dispute cannot be settled by negotiations. The Tribunal thus constituted, is required to investigate the matters referred to it and then forward to the Central Government a report setting out the facts as found by him and giving its decision on it as provided under Sub-Section (2) of Section 5 of the Act. On consideration of such decision of the Tribunal if the Central Government or any State Government is of the opinion that the decision in question requires explanation or that guidance is needed upon any point not originally referred to the Tribunal then within three months from the date of the decision, reference can be made to the Tribunal'tor further consideration and the said Tribunal then forwards to the Central Government a further report giving such explanation or guidance as it deems fit. Thereby the original decision of the Tribunal is modified to the extent indicated in the further decision as provided under Section 5(3) of the Act. Under Section 6 of the Act the Central Government is duty bound to publish the decision of the Tribunal in the Official Gazette whereafter the said decision becomes final and binding on the parties to the dispute and has to be given effect to, by them. The language of the provisions of Section 6 is clear and unambiguous and unequivocally indicates that it is only the decision of the Tribunal which is required to be published in the Official Gazette and on such publication that decision becomes final and binding on the parties. It is not required that the report containing the arguments or basis for the ultimate decision is also required to be notified so as to make that binding on the parties. This being the position, it is difficult to appreciate the contention of Mr. Ganguli that the decision of the Tribunal as notified, is in fact a decree of a civil suit and that decree has to be understood in the light of the judgment of the suit. We accordingly are n9t persuaded to accept the submission of Mr. Ganguli on this point but, at the same time we cannot accept the argument of Mr. Narirnan that the order of this Court dated 30th September, 1997 passed in the suit in terms of prayer 'a' must be held to mean that a decree is to be drawn up in OS 2 of 1997 making the entire report and the further report binding on the parties. When a prayer is made in the plaint the said prayer has to be understood in the light of the assertion of facts on which the prayer has been made. The defendant State of Kamataka understood the prayer on that basis as would appear from the averments made in the written statement of defendant no. 1 in paragraphs 3.1, 3.2 and 3.3. The aforesaid prayer had been made for the relief that notwithstanding enbloc allocation made in the final order of the Tribunal which is the decision of the Tribunal but the very basis

~--

)l_

I

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.] , ;

-r

•

to arrive at that decision being the projectwise allocation contained in the report the said projectwise allocation must be read into the enbloc allocation and, therefore, there must be restriction on the part of the State of Karnataka not to use more water in Upper Krishna Project than the allocated quantity of 160 TMC. Thus read the order of this Court dated 30th September, 1997, cannot be construed to mean that a decree has to be passed making the entire report as well as the further report of the Tribunal binding on the parties. So far as the question whether allocation made enbloc or projectwise the same has been answered while discussing issue nos. 1, 3 and 5 and in this view of the matter the earlier order dated 30th September, 1997 is of no consequence in disposing of the suit in question.

ISSUE Nos. I, 3 and 5:

_,.

•

Though, there are as many as 22 issues, which have been framed and necessarily to be answered in the suit, but in course of arguments advanced by Mr. Ganguli, the learned senior counsel, appearing for the State of Andhra Pradesh, the entire emphasis was on the height of Almatti Dam Stage-II at 524.256 meters, as proposed by the State of Karnataka and as it appears from various project reports. In view of the arguments advanced by the counsel for the parties, these three issues essentially form the bone of contention. It is necessary to be stated that too many issues have been framed by the three different States and Court has also permitted such issues to be struck and most of the issues over-lap one another and in fact have no bearing in relation to the prayer made by the plaintiff. But instead of re-framing the issues, arguments having been advanced by the counsel for the parties, we would deal with each of them, but with specific emphasis on the vital issues. So far as the thtee issues with which we are concerned at the moment, when read with the paragraphs of, the plaint, dealing with the same, it appears that the plaintiff Andhra Pradesh has made out a case in the plaint that under Scheme "A" which is the decision of the tribunal and which has been notified by the Central Government under Section 6 of the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, though there has been allocation of water enbloc but on going through the report itself and the very basis on which the mass allocation has been quantified, it would indicate. that project-wise allocation must be read into the so-called mass allocation. This being the position, in Upper Krishna Project, the tribunal having allocated only 160 TMC of water, construction of Almatti Dam to a height of 524.256 meters itself constitutes an infraction of the decision of the tribunal, and, therefore, the Court should injunct the State of Karnataka from

-H

'

(. i'( -~

'

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000) 3 S.C.R.

constructing a dam at Almatti up to the height of 524.256 meters. The stand of the State of Kamataka in the written statement filed as well as the. stand Of Union Govenunent and State of Maharashtra in its original written statement filed however is that, there. has been an enbloc allocation: by the tribunal and consequently, there has been no fetter on any State to utilise water up to a limited quantity in any of its project, except those mentioned in the order of· the tribunal itself and that being the position, the plaintiff would not be entitled to an order of injunction in relation to the construction of Almatti Dam to a height of 524.256 meters: Before we focus our attention to the evidence on record in answering these tlrree issues, in the light of arguments advanced by the c~urtsel for the pa~ties, it must be bOme in rni:nd that injunction being a discretionary remedy, a Court may not grant an order of injunction, even ifall. the tlrree necessary ingredients are established and tllose ingredients are prirna facie case of infraction of legal rights, such infraction causes irreparable loss and injury to the plaintiff and the injury is of such nature that it cannot be compensated by way of damages. In the case in hand, when the plaintlff lias prayed for an order of mandatory injunction to injunct the State of Kamataka from constructing the dam at Almatti to a height of 524.256 meters and makes out a case of infringement of legal rights of the State of Andhra Pradesh, tlowing from the decision of the Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal, which decision has become final and binding on being notified by the Union Government under Section 6, what is required to be established is that in fact in the said decision of the tribunal, there has been a project-wise allocation in respect of Upper Krishna Pr~ject and if this is established, tllen the further fact required to be established is whether by construction of Almatti Dam up to a height of 524.256 meters, there has been any infraction of the said decision of the tribunal which has caused irreparable injury and damage to the lower riparian State of Andhra Pradesh and the said damage cannot be compensated by way of damages. Since the plaintiff-State has to establish all the aforesaid requirements, so that an order of injunction, as prayed for, can be granted, let us examine the very first mgredient namely whether under the decision of the tribunal, there has at all been a project-wise allocation as contended by Mr. Ganguli, appearing for the State Of Ari.dhfa Pradesh or the allocation was enbloc, as contended by Mr. Nauman, appearing for the State of Kamataka and reiterated by Mr. Salve, the learned SoliCitor General and Mr. Andhyarujina, appearing for the State of Maharashtra. While d~ciding the Original.Suit No. 1 of 1997, filed by the State of K.amataka, negativing the contention of the said State to the effect that Scheme "B" evolved by the tribunal, whether forms

---..,.. '-

-

+

.,,,.

·~

..

.,....

~

,~)

-

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF AP. [PATTANAIK, J.]

-r

__..,.

-+

.... .;

;...

y

a decision of the tribunal or not, we have already recorded the finding that Scheme "B" cannot be held to be the.decision of the tribunal inasmuch as it is only that order of the tribunal which conclusively decides the dispute referred to, and is capable of being implemented on its own, can be held to be a decision of the tribunal under Section 5(2) of the Act. In fact the plaintiff in the present" suit also bases its case on the Scheme "A" and contends that there has been an illfraction of the said Scheme "A" by the defendant-State of Karnataka. If we examine the Final Order of the tribunal contained in Chapter XVI of the Original Report Exhibit PKl as well as the modified order after answering the application for clarifications made by different States, in the Further Report of December, 1976 in Chapter VII of Exh. PK2, which has been notified by the Central Government under Section 6 of the Act in. the Gazette oflndia dated 31st of May, 1976, it is crystal clear that the allocation made, has been enbloc and not project-wis~ and, therefore, there is no fetter on any of the Stat~s in utilising water in any project to a limited extent, excepting those contained in Clause (IX) of the decision. The allocation made to the three States of Maharashtra, Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh for their beneficial use has been provided in Clause (V) and subject to such conditions and restrictions as are mentioned in the subsequent clauses. Clause (V) of the decision which in fact makes the allocation, may be quoted herein below in extenso: "Clause V (A) The State of Maharashtra shall not use in any water year more than the quantity of water of the river Krishna specified hereunder:- (i) as from the water year commencing on the 1st June next after the date of the publication of the decision of the Tribunal in the Official Gazette upto the water year 1982-83 560 TMC.

(ii) as from the water year 1983-84 up to the water year 1989-90 560 TMC plus a quantity of water equivalent to 10 per cent of the .excess of the average of the annual utilisations for irrigation in the Krishna river basin during the water years 1975-76, 1976-77 and 1977-78 from its own projects using 3 TMC or more annually over the utilisations for such irrigation in the water year 1968-69 from such projects.

(iii) as from the water year 1990-91 up to the water year 1997-98 560 TMC plus

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

a quantity of water equivalent to 10 per cent of the excess of the average of the annual utilisations for irrigation in the Krishna river basin during the water years 1982-83, 1983-84 and 1984-85 from its own projects using 3 TMC or more annually over the utilisations for such irrigation in the water year 1968-69 from such projects. (iv) as from the water year 1998-99 onwards 560 TMC plus

+

a quantity of water equivalent to 10 per cent of the excess of the average of the annual utilisations for irrigation in the Kiishna river basin during the water years 1990-91, 1991-92 and 1992-93 froni its own projects using 3 TMC or more annually over the utilisations for such irrigation in the water year 1968-69 from such projects. (B) The State of Karanataka.sliall not use in any water year more than the quantity of water of the river Krishna specified hereunder:(i) as from the water year commencing on the 1st June next after the date of the publication of the decision of the Tribunal in the Official Gazette up to the water year 1982-83 700 TMC plus

lo--

~

""<If.

(ii) as from the water year 1983-84 up to the water year 1989-90 700 TMC plus a quanti" of water equivalent to 10 per cent of the excess of the average of the annual utilisations for irrigation in the Krishna iiver basin during the water years 1975-76, 1976-77 and 1977-78 from its own projects using 3 TMC or more annually over the utilisations for such irrigation in the water year 1968-69 from such projects.

~-

(iii) as from the water year 1990-91 up to the water year 1997-98 700 TMC plus a quantity of water equivalent to 10 per cent of the excess of the average of the annual utilisations for irrigation in the Krishna river basin during the water years 1982-83, 1983-84 and 1984-85 from its own projects using 3 TMC or more annually over the utilisations for such irrigation in the water year 1968-69 from such projects.

...

-

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATIANAIK, J.]

(iv)as from the water year 1998-99 onwards 700 TMC plus a quantity of water equivalent to 10 per cent of the excess of the average of the annual utilisations for irrigation in the Krishna river basin during the water years 1990-91, 1991-92 and 1992-93 from its own projects using 3 TMC or more annually over the utilisations for such irrigation in the water year 1968-69 from such projects. (C) The State of Andhra Pradesh will be at liberty to use in any water year the remaining water that may be flowing in the river Krishna but thereby it shall not acquire any right whatsoever to use in any water year nor be deemed to have been allocated in any water year water of the river Krishna in excess of the quantity specified hereunder:-

(i) as from the water year commencing on the 1st June next after the date of the publication of the decision of the Tribunal in the Official Gazette up to the water year 1982-83. 800 TMC

(ii) as from the water year 1983-84 up to the water year 1989-90. 800 TMC plus a quantity of water equivalent to 10 per cent of the excess of the average of the annual utilisations for irrigation in the Krishna river basin during the water years 1990-91, 1991-92 and 1992-93 from its own projects using 3 TMC or more annually over the utilisations for such irrigation in the water year 1968-69 from such projects. (iii) as from the water year 1990-91 up to the water year 1997-98 800 TMC plus a quantity of water equivalent to 10 per cent of the excess of the average of the annual utilisations for irrigation in the Krishna river basin during the water years 1982-83, 1983-84 and 1984-85 from its own projects using 3 TMC or more annually over the utilisations for such irrigation in the water year 1968-69 from such projects.

(iv) as from the water year 1998-99 onwards 800 TMC plus a quantity of water equivalent to 10 per cent of the excess of the average of the annual utilisations for irrigation in the Krishna river

\

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

basin during the water years 1990-91, 1991-92 and 1992-93 from its own projects using 3 TMC or more annually over the utilisations for such irrigation in the water year 1968-69 from such projects. (D) For the limited purpose of this Clause, it is declared that :-

(i) the utilisations for irrigation in the Krishna river basin in the water year 1968-69 from projects using 3 TMC or more annually were as follows:From projects of the State of Maharashtra

61.45 TMC

From projects of the State of Karnataka

176.05 TMC

From projects of the State of Andhra Pradesh

170.00 TMC

(ii) annual utilisations for irrigation in the Krishna river basin in each water year after this Order comes into operation from the project of any State using 3 TMC or more annually shall be computed on the basis of the records prepared and maintained by that State under Clause XIII. (iii) evaporation losses from reservoirs of projects using 3 TMC or more annually shall be excluded in computing the 10 per cent figure of the average annual utilisations mentioned in sub-Clauses A(ii), A(iii), A(iv), B(ii), B(iii), B(iv), C(ii), C(iii) and C(iv) of this clause."

The aforesaid Clause V, no doubt is in a negative form, prohibiting the State of Maharashtra and State of Kamataka from using in any water year more than the water that has been allotted in their favour respectively but by ··no stretch of imagination, any restriction can be said to have been put on: any of the States in the aforesaid Clause V, so long as they do not use more than the quantity allotted in their favour in any water year. In other words under. Clause V of the decision, the State of Maharashtra is entitled to use up to 560 TMC in any water year and the State of Karnataka similarly is entiµed to use . · up to 700 TMC in any water year. The language used by the triblDlal in formulating Clause V of the decision is clear and unambiguous and as such it is difficult for the Court to read into it any restrictions as submitted by the H learned senior counsel, appearing for the State of Andhra Pradesh. We may·

.a

·.,

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

mention at this stage, that the original report and the decision of 1973 was marked as Exhibit PK-1 in OS 1/97 and the further repot and the decision of 1976 was marked as Exhibit PK-2 in OS 1197, and those two documents having been referred to by the parties in course of arguments as PK- 1 and PK-2. We have also in judgment referred as PK-1 and PK-2 which were exhibited as such in OS 1/97.

-+

~-

Mr. Ganguli, the learned senior counsel however contended before us that before the tribunal, each of the three riparian States claimed water for their various projects, covering utilisation to the order of 4269.33 TMC, as is apparent from Exhibit PKI itself and then at a subsequent stage of the proceedings before the tribunal, all the party States agreed that 75% dependable flow up to Vijayawada in the river Krishna is 2060 TMC, which is, therefore much less than the total demand made by each of the States, amounting to 4269.33 TMC. The learned counsel further urged that all the three States entered into an agreement on 7 .5 .1971, indicating therein that 20 of the projects in Maharashtra, 13 projects in Kamataka and 17 projects in Andhra Pradesh should be protected and the parties also agreed to the specified quantity of utilisation of water in respect of each of the projects which could be treated as protected utilisation and total of such protected utilisation came to 751.20 TMC, as is apparent from the Original Report Exhibit PKI. It is the further contention that since in respect of one project in Maharashtra, five projects in Karnataka and five projects in Andhra Pradesh, the parties could not agree to the quantity of utilisation which should be protected and all tlie States invited the tribunal to decide the extent of utilisation to be protected in respect of those 11 projects and the tribunal adjudicated the additional utilisation to the extent of 714.91 TMC in respect of 9 out of the 11 projects and thus the total protected utilisation out of the dependable flow at 75% dependability worked out at 1693.36 TMC , which of course includes 227.25 TMC on minor irrigations. Having thus arrived at the figure of 1693.36 TMC for protected utilisation, the balance quantity out of the dependable flotv to the extent of 366.64 TMC was further distributed by the tribunal to the extent of 50.84 TMC to Andhra Pradesh for Srisailam reservoir and Jurala Project. Out of the remaining 315.80 TMC, taking into consideration all germane factors, the tribunal allocated 125.35 TMC to Maharashtra and 190.45 TMC to Kamataka. Mr. Ganguli contends that while making these allocations, so far as Upper Krishna Project in the State of Kamataka is concerned; the tribunal merely permitted utilisation of only 52 TMC in the Right Bank Canal of Narayanpur in addition to the protected

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

utilisation of 103 TMC already granted in respe~t of the Left Bank Canal under the Narayanpur Canal and, therefore, the total worked out at 155 TMC and there had been no allocation made by the tribunal so far as Almatti Dam is concerned. At a later stage when in its Further Report Exhibit PK2, the tribunal allocated additional 5 TMC for utilisation under Hippargi Project, the conclusion is irresistible that in Upper Krishna Projects in Hippargi, Almatti and Narayanpur, a total quantity of 160 TMC was allocated and this must be read into the Final Order in Clause (V), though not specifically mentioned therein. It is in this connection, Mr. Ganguli took us through the different pages of Exhibit PKI as well as the plaint and the written statement of the State of Karnataka. But as has been stated earlier, if the decision of the tribunal is C its Pinal Order, as notified by th_e Central Government in exercise of power under Section 6 of the Act, we really fail to understand, how the aforesaid limitations can be read into the said decision, particularly, when Clause (V) of the decision is clear and there is no ambiguity in the same. It is undoubtedly · trne that while conside1ing the question of extent of allocation of water in D favour of the three riparian States out of 2060 TMC of water at 75% dependability, the tribunal did take into account the different projects already undertaken by different States but consideration of those projects is only for the purpose of arnvmg at the quantity of water to be allocated and not for making any project-wise allocation, as contended by Mr. Ganguli. In Exhibit PKI itself, the tribunal records to the following E effect:

"Our examination of the project reports and other relevant documents has a very limited purpose and it is to determine what are the reasonable needs of the two States so that an equitable way may be found out for distributing the remaining water between the two States. It is of course, always to be borne in mind that the allocation of waters though based on consideration of certain projects being found to be worth consideration are not on that account to be restricted and confined to those projects alone. Indeed the States (and this applies to all the States) would be entitled to use the waters .for irrigation in such manner as they find proper subject always to the restrictions and conditions whi.::h are placed on them." This unequivocally indicates the purpose for which the projects of different States were being examined and it is explicitly made clear that the States should be entitled to use tl1e waters for irrigation in such manner as they

....

.\

"f'

.f

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF AP. [PATTANAIK, J.]

find proper, subject, always to the restrictions and conditions which are placed on them. Unless, therefore, any restriction or conditions in the decision of the tribunal can be found out for utilisation of a specific quantity of water out of the total allocated share in the Upper Krishna Project, there cannot be any fetter on the part of the State of Karnataka to make. such user. In the decision of the tribunal, there does not appear to be an iota of restrictions or conditions, which even can be inferred and, therefore, the submission of Mr. Ganguli, appearing for the State of Andhra Pradesh on this score cannot be accepted.

In the report of the Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal Exhibit PK-1 for the purpose of allocation of water in the Krishna Basin the Tribunal has examined each project of each of the .three States and then recorded its conclusion as to whether the project is worth consideration. The Tribunal expressed the meaning of the expression "worth consideration" by saying that the expression is used in the sense that it means the requirements of an area in the State concerned. It would be appropriate at this stage to quote the exact findings of the Tribunal in this regard:"In saying that the project is worth consideration we do not wish to be understood to say that the project, if feasible, should be adopted. Likewise when we say that the project is not worth consideration we do not say that no water should ever be allowed for it. If at some future date more water becomes available it is possible that more projects may come upto the worth consideration standard. In assessing whether the project is worth consideration or not we have taken into account the physical characteristics of the area like rainfall etc., the catchment area, the commanded area, the ayacut of the project, the fact whether the project is meant for irrigating the scarcity area or not and such other facts. In other words we determine on pragmatic considerations what needs of the States of Maharashtra and Mysore can be satisfied so that an equitable way may be found out for distributing the balance of the dependable flows between the two States. It should not be taken our observations relating to the projects which we have noted as worth consideration are to be accepted in any way as final and binding by the Planning Commission or any other authority." The aforesaid fmding fully negatives the contention of Mr. Ganguli, appearing for the State of AP., that the allocation was projectwise which can be read into

\

,. •I

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2000] 3 S.C.R.

the final order. Clause IX of the final order bas placed restriction on the use of water in the Krishna Basin by the three States. The reasons for putting such restrictions appears to be that on the main streani there has been only restriction on river Bhima whereas on the side streams there has been restriction in case of Tungbhadra and Vedavathi sub-basin. Even in case of sub-basin K-3 there has been restriction on the State of Maharashtra from using more than 7 TMC in any water year from Ghataprabha and the reason for such restriction is that the requirements of the State of Mysore for the projects in that sub-basin may suffer. Similarly restriction has been placed on the State of Andhra Pradesh not to use more than 6 TMC from the catchment of the river Koyna, the idea being that the waters of that river would reach the main streams of river Bhima. Even while placing such resuiction the Tribunal has placed the upper limit slightly above the total requirements of that State as assessed from the demands made whic;h had been either protected or which have held as worth consideration. The very fact that restrictions have been put by the Tribunal in several sub-basins and no restriction has been put so far as sub-basin K-2 wherein Upper Krishna Project of the State of Kamataka is being carried on clinches the point raised by the State of Andhra Pradesh and discussed in these three issues, namely, it is not possible to read any restriction for quantity of user of water in Upper Krishna Project by the State of Kamataka and so long as the total user does not exceed mass allocation, it cannot be said that the decision of the Tribunal is being violated infringing the rights of the State of Andhra Pradesh which can be prohibited by issuing any mandatory injunction. After receiving the copy of the repmt and t11e decision of the Tribunal under Exhibit PK-1 tl1e State of Andhra Pradesh filed application for clarification, being clarification No.4 under Section 5(3) of the Act, requesting reduction of 1.865 TMC from t11e Koyna Project of State of Maharashtra. Having filed such application on 5th March, 1976, the learned Advocate General of the State of Andhra Pradesh did not press the said clarification No.4 on the ground that the allocations are enbloc which is apparent from Exhibit PK-2 dealing with clarification no.4. Having made an unequivocal statement before the Tribunal itself that the allocations are enbloc we fail to understand how the State of Aildhra Pradesh has filed the suit making out a case that there has been any project-wise allocation by the Krishna Water Disputes Tribunal. The aforesaid statement of the learned Advocate General made before the Tribunal has not been explained either in the plaint filed by the State nor even in course of hearing of the suit, and in our view, the State of Andhra Pradesh also fully understood that the allocations made under Scheme 'A' was enbloc. lt further appears from Exhibit PK-2 that

..,,..._ '.~

t=

_,._.

....

.....

-,....

).

~

j

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

·-(

--.it

_..._

the State of Andhra Pradesh did file a clarification no. 5 under Section 5(3) of the Act praying that the maximwn quantity which could be utilised in K5 and K- 6 sub-basin of the State of Maharashtra and Karnataka should be specified and ultimately on 23rd August, 1974, the learned Advocate General for the said State did not press the clarification as it had no materials on record on which he could substantiate it. The very fact that State had not filed any clarification application so far as K-2 sub-basin is concerned, though it did file such application in respect of sub-basin K-5 and K-6 as well as in case of Quana Krishna Lift IJ.rigation Scheme w1equivocally indicates that the State had no grievance so far as the allocation enbloc made by the Tribunal and not ' consists of the Upper putting any restriction of the user in K-2 sub-basin which Krishna Project. This in our view, fully clinches the matter and the conclusion is irresistible that under the decision of the Tribunal there has been mass allocation and no project-wise allocation as contended by the State of Andhra Pradesh in the suit. ill the aforesaid premises, we answer the three issues against the plaintiff and in favour of the defendants and hold that under the decision of the Tribunal the allocation of water in river Krishna was enbloc and not project-wise excepting those specific projects mentioned in clauses IX and X of the decision.

ISSUE NO. 2

......

~

Though this issue has been raised at the behest of the State of Maliarashtra but in view of the stand taken by the said State in the additional written statement and the additional issues framed thereon, the learned counsel appearing for the State of Maliarashtra did not argue the question of jurisdiction, and on the other hand conte11ded, that the jurisdiction of this Court in a suit under Article 131 of the Constitution should not be restricted or narrowed down and on the other hand the Court should be capable of granting all necessary reliefs in adjudicating the dispute raised. That apart on the basis on which the plaintiff State filed the suit and the relief sought for it cannot be said that the suit is not maintainable. We, therefore, answer this issue in favour of the plaintiff.

ISSUE NOS. 4, 6, 7 and 8

These four issues are inter-linked and have been framed in view of the positive stand taken by the State of Andhra Pradesh that in case of an inter State river when any project of one State is considered by the Government of

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

India or any other appropriate authority the other State should also be made aware of and their consent should also be taken. Though this stand had been taken by the plaintiff-State of And.hra Pradesh but all the three defendants refuted the same. In course of hearing of the suit the learned counsel Mr. Ganguli has not placed before us any material or any law which compels the concerned authority to consult all the riparian States before sanctioning a project of one State. In the absence of any legal basis for such stand we are not able to agree with the stand taken by the State of Andhra Pradesh that the Central Government was duty bound to take the consent of other States while sanctioning any project of any of the riparian States. That apart, these issues I are academic in the context of the Upper Krishna Project of the State of Karnataka and,in particular, the construction of the Almatti Dam. Before the Tribunal the State of Karnataka had submitted the report of Upper Krishna Project of July 1970 which was exhibited before the Tribunal as MYPK-3 and the said document has been marked as Exhibit PAP-42 in the present suit. The salient features of the said project, so far as Almatti Dam height is concerned, was shown as FRL 524.256 m and top of the Dam at 528.786 m. The entire project itself being there before the Tribunal, though the Tribunal did not consider it necessary to discuss the project in particular in view of enbloc allocation made by it, the grievance of the State of Andhra Pradesh that the project was being SU1Teptitiously constructed is devoid of any substance. We, therefore, answer the aforesaid issues against the plaintiff.

~

. ~

•.:-

.,.__

~

--f-

ISSUE NO. 9 (a) (b)

This issue is an important issue in the present suit and the relief sought for essentially depends upon the findings arrived at on this issue. The entire issue has to be decided on the basis as to whether there exists any prohibition in the decision of the Tribunal from constructing Dam at Almatti upto 524.256 meter or from storing any particular quantity of water therein. And if the answer is in the negative then the prayer for injuncting the State of Karnataka to raise the Dam height upto 524.256 has to be r~jected. If the decision of the Tribunal is examined from the aforesaid stand point and in view of our conclusion that it is that final order which has been r.otified in the Official Gazette by the Central Government under Section 6 of the Act which is the decision of the Tribunal, we find nothing stated therein which even can be held to be a prohibition or restriction on the power of the State of Karnataka to have the height of Dam upto a particular height. In this view of the matter the plaintiff's prayer to injunct the State of Karnataka from constructing the Dam

l-

~-

)

.

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF AP. [PATTANAIK, J.)

--

height at Almatti upto 524.256 meter cannot be granted. The issue has two sub-issues ; Sub-issue 'a' relates to the height of Almatti Dam ;and sub-issue 'b' being on the question whether State of Karnataka could be permitted· to proceed with the construction without the consent of the other riparian States and without the approval of the Central Government? At the outset it may be stated that though the State of Karnataka had produced its project report relating to the construction of the Almatti Dam as per Exhibit PAP-42 but neither the Tribunal had c~msidered the same nor any decision has been arrived at on the question of height of the said Dam. Even after the original report and the decision being made known under Section 5(2) of the Act as per Exhibit PK-1 the State of Andhra Pradesh also did not raise any dispute or clarificatory application objecting to the construction of the Almatti Dam or even to the height of such Dam under Section 5(3) of the Act. In the absence of a decision of the Tribunal on the question of construction of Dam at Almatti or its height and mass allocation made, being binding upon all parties after being notified under Section 6 of the Act, the grievance relating to the construction of Dam at Almatti or to its height would be a matter of water .dispute within the meaning of Section 2(C), in as much as it would be a matter concerning use of water of river Krishna and, therefore, cannot be a matter for adjudication in a suit under Article 131 of the Constitution of India. If the complaint of the State of Andhr~-Pradesh is that by constrnction of Almatti Dam which is an executive action of the State of Karnataka the State of Andhra Pradesh is likely to be prejudicially affected then also on such complaint being made to the Union Government under Section 3(a) the matter could be referred to a Tribunal for adjudication. But, we fail to understand how this Court could entertain the aforesaid lis and decide the same, particularly when the Tribunal has not focussed its attention on the same nor has made any adjudication in respect to the construction of Dam at Almatti or its height. Needless to mentien that otwithstanding the allocation of water in river Krishna beir.J.g made enbloc no State can construct any project for use of water within the State unless such project is approved by the Planning Commission, the Central Water Commission and all other Competent Authorities who might have different roles to play under different specific statutes. Under the federal structure, like ours, the Ce~tral Government possesses enormous power and authority and no State can on _its own carry on the affairs within its territory, particulary when such ~roJects may have adverse effect on other States, particularly in respect of an mter_ State river w~ere. each riparian State and its inhabitants through which the nver flows has its _nght. From the averments made in the plaint it is crystal clear that the State of Andhra Pradesh feels aggrieved by the proposal of the

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

State of Kamataka to have the Dam height at Almatti FRL 524.256 m. In the plaint itself in paragraph 51 the plaintiff has referred to the observation of the Committee to the effect: "For required utilisation of 173 TMC at UKP the height of the Dam at FRL 519.6 m would be adequate." The Committee referred to in the said paragraph is Expert Committee which the four Chief Ministers had appointed, which Committee had examined _the pros and cons of the Almatti Dam and the aforesaid views of the Expe1t Committee was approved by the four Chief Ministers who had been requested by the Prime Minister of India to intervene and find out the efficacy or otherwise of the stand of Karnataka to have Almatti Dam upto the height of FRL 524.256 m. The said Expert Committee had observed that the proposal of the State of Kamataka of having Upper Krishna Project with FRL 524.256 m in Stage II at Almatti has not been approved by the Government of India. And it has been fmther observed that it would be desirable to proceed with utmost caution in the larger interest of the Nation to wait and watch operation of various Krishna system upstream and down stream before embarking on creating larger storage at Almatti Darn than what is needed to suit the prevailing conditions. We are taking note of the observations made by the Expert Committee for the purpose that the plaintiff having failed to establish its case for getting an injuction, would it be appropriate for this Court to allow the State of Karna:taka to have the height of the Dam at Almatti at 524.256 m or it would be obviously in the larger interest of the country and all the States concerned to allow the Dam upto the height of 519.6 m and then leave it open to the States concerned to put forth their grievances before the Tribunal to be appointed by the Central Government for resolving the disputes relating to sharing of water in river Krishna. Reading the plaint as a whole it appears to us that the plaintiff State had not made any grievance for having a Dam at Almatti upto a height of FRL 519.6 m and on the other hand, the entire grievance centers round the proposal of the State of Kamataka to have the height at 524.256 m. The report of the Expert Committee referred to in the. plaint has been exhibited as Exhibit PAP-212 and even that report indicates that the com~1laint of Andhra Pradesh was that the height of Almatti Dam at FRL 524.256m which has not been approved as yet by the Government of India, would adversely affect the lower riparian State of Andhra Pradesh both in the matter of irrigation as well as generation of power. The said report further reveals that the State of Kamataka is desirous of having the Dam height

'

"

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.)

--·.....

>--

,,.

~

at FRL 524.256 m so that it can store its share of water available to it under Scheme 'B' when it con.ies. It is only on fructification of Scheme 'B' the need for a larger storage at Almatti would arise, and therefore, the State is planning ahead to have the height of the Dam at 524.256m. According to the report of the said Expert Committee even if the height is allowed not upto 524.256 m it can be allowed later only when the necessity arises and technically it is feasible. The report also records that for utilisation of 173 TMC at Almatti and Narainpur the height of the Dam required would be 519 m and not 524.256 m. Thus an expert body appointed by the four Chief Ministers of 4 different States who are not in any way connected with the inter-State river Krishna taking into account the present need envisaged by the State of Kamataka for utilisation of 173 TMC at Upper Krishna project and taking into account the report submitted by Indian Institute of Science at Bangalore did record a finding that the top of the shutters at Almatti should be fixed at 519.6 m which will provide a storage of about l 73TMC which along with storage of 37.8 TMC at Narainpur will be adequate to take care of annual requirement of 173 TMC envisaged under Upper Krishna Project. In view of our conclusion in O.S. 1of1997 holdin~ that Scheme 'B' is not a decision of the Tribunal, and as such, cannot be implemented by a mandatory order from this Court and the stand of the State of Kamataka before the so called Expert Committee being that they have designed the height of Almatti Dam at 524.256 m keeping in view that in the event Scheme 'B' fructifies the State will be able to get the smplus water and store it as a carry over reservoir, as observed by the Tribunal itself, notwithstanding the fact that the plaintiff has failed to establish a case on its own for getting the relief of injunction in relation to the construction of Almatti Dam by the State of Kamataka, it would be reasonable to hold that though the State can have the Dam at Almatti but the height of the said Dam should not be more than 519.6 m, particularly when the State of Kamataka has not been able to indicate as what is the necessity of having a height of Dam at 524.256 m when Scheme 'B' is not going to be operated upon immediately. The Upper Krishna Project Stage II, detailed project report of October 1993 which has been exhibited in the present case as PAP 45 also indicates that minimum FRL required to get 173 TMC utilisation is found to be 518.7 m. It is in that report it has been indicated that it is because of probable maximum flood of 31000 qmx., the water level is expected to go upto 521 m and, therefore, the proposal is to keep the height of the gate to 521 from the crest level with 2 rats. as the gate height. It may be stated at this stage that the height of the Almatti as approved by the Competent Authority is crest Jevel 509 meter and it is in this context to have the height at FRL 524.256 m the State of

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

Kamataka has proposed to have the gate height of 15 meters. But as has been indicated earlier, since the entire basis of the State of Kamataka to have the height of the Dam at 524.256 mis contingent upon implementation of Scheme 'B' of the Tribunal thereby entitling the State of Kamataka to get its share in excess water and continue the Almatti Dam as a carry over reservoir and since we have decided against the State of Kamataka in O.S. 1 of 1997 which the State had filed for implementation of Scheme 'B', there is absolutely no justification for the said State to have the Dam height at Almatti of 524.256 m. We hasten to add that at the same time there cannot be any injunction or . prohibition to the said State of Kamataka for having the Dam height at Almatti upto 519.6m which would be in the interest of all concerned.

----

f.'

~

Mr. Ganguli, the learned senior counsel, appearing for the State of

.

,

Andhra Pradesh submitted that the State of Kamataka in the Project Report filed before the Central Water Commission in respect of UKP Stage II, itself indicated that the minimum FRL required at Almatti Reservoir is 519.60 M as per Exhibit PAP 46. In the written statement also, the State of Kamataka also indicated that contemplated height of Dam at 524.256 meters is for additional storage, though for the purpose of generation of power which is non-consumptive use and at a height of 524.256 meters, it would utilise 302 TMC, which would be in excess of the enbloc allocation of 734 TMC. Mr. Ganguli also contended that the Upper Krishna Multipurpose Stage II Project Report of 1996 as per Exh. PAP 48, would indicate that the State has planned irrigation from the water at Almatti which the State would receive under Scheme "B" being implemented. This being the position, the very idea of having the dam height at Almatti at FRL 526.256, is even contrary to the mass allocation made in its favour under Scheme "A" and, therefore, the State should be injuncted. We are unable to appreciate this contention of the State of Andhra Pradesh inasmuch as on today the Central Government as well as the appropriate authority have not sanctioned the Upper Krishna Project StageII with the dam height at 524.256 meters. It would not be possible for this Court to pronounce that there will be a v~olation of the mass allocation if the State of Kamataka is allowed to have,,.the dam height at Almatti at 524.256 meters, though as stated earlier, according to the State of Kamataka itself for utilisation of 173 TMC, the required dam height is 519.6 meters. It is under these.circumstances, we are of the considered opinion that there should not be any bar against the State of Karnataka to construct the dam at Almatti upto the height of 519.6 meters and the question of further raising its height to 524.256 meters should be gone into by the tribunal, which learned Solicitor

..

~

....

~--

).

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

General agreed on behalf of Govt. of India to be constituted immediately after the delivery of judgment of these two suits, so as to mitigate the grievance of each of the riparian States on a complaint being made by any of the States .. So far as· sub-issue (b) is concerned, we really do not find any substance in the contention of Mr. Ganguli, the learned counsel appearing for the State of Andhra Pradesh. Though it may be fully desirable for all the States to know about the developments of the other States but neither the law on the subject require that a State even for utilisation of its own water resources would take the consent of other riparian States in case of an Inter-State river. So far as the second part of Issue 'b' is concerned, the answer is irresistible that the project of each State has to be approved by the Central Government as well as by other statutory authorities and the Planning Commission, but for which· a State should not proceed with the construction of such project. Issues"9(a) and (b) are answered accordingly.

ISSUE 9(C) Issue 9(C) had been framed while allowing the additional written statement of the State of Maharashtra, which relates to the question of _submergence. It is to be noted that in the original written statement filed by the State of Maharashtra, a positive stand had been taken that under the decision of the tribunal, there has been an enbloc allocation of water in favour of each of the three riparian states and as such there was no bar on the State of Karnataka to have a dam at Almatti up to any height and, therefore, it was prayed that the suit filed by the Andhra ·Pradesh should be rejected. In the additional written statement that was filed by the State of Maharashtra, it has however been averred that the eventual submergence of area within the State of Maharashtra had not been known earlier and, therefore, neither before the tribunal nor in the original written statement filed, any grievance had been niade with regard to the construction of dam at Almatti to a height of 524.256 meters, but since the joint study made by the officers of both the states have brought out that a large area within the State of Maharashtra would get submerged, if Karnataka is pe1mitted to have the dam height at Almatti up to 524.256 meters, the State of Maharashtra has brought these facts to the notice of this Court in the additional written statement and the additional issue has been framed. In the absence of any relief being sought for in the plaint by the plaintiff against the State of Maharashtra, whether the defendant State of Maharashtra can claim any relief against the co-defendant is itself a debatable issue. Mr. Andhyarujina, the learned senior counsel, appearing for the State

D.·

p ·

I

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2000) 3 S.C.R.

of Maharashtra , however contended that a suit filed in the Supreme Court under Article 131 of the Constitution is of a very peculiar nature and the normal principle of a suit filed in an ordinarY civil Court should not apply. According to Mr. Andhyarujina, if a dispute between the two states involving the existence or extent of a legal right of one State is being infringed by the action or in-action of another State, is brought before this Court invoking jurisdiction under Article 131 of the Constitution, this Coprt would be fully justified in entertaining and adjudicating the said dispute, no matter whether the dispute is raised as a plaintiff or a defendant in any proceeding before the Court. It is in this context the learned counsel referred to the observations of Bhagwati J and Chandrachud J, in the case of State of Ka~ataka v. Union of India, (1978] 2 SCR l; wherein Hon'ble Bhagwati J had indicated that the original jurisdiction of the Supreme Court under Article 131 on being invoked by means of filing a suit, the Comt should be careful not to be influenced by the considerations of 'cause of action' which are germane in suit and the scope and ambit of the said jurisdiction must be determined on the plain terms of the article without being inhibited by any a priori considerati~ns. The learned Judge in the same decision had also indicated that the very object of Article 131 seems to be that there should be a Forum, which could resolve such disputes between two States or the State and the Union and that forum should be the highest Comt in the land so that the final adjudication of disputes could be achieved speedily and expeditiously without either party having to embark on a long tortuous and time consuming journey through a hierarchy of Courts. Mr. Andhyaiujina also relied upon the observations of Bhagwati J in the aforesaid case to the effect: "What article 131 requires is that the dispute must be one which involves a question on which the existence or extent of legal right depends. The article does not say that the legal right must be of the plaintiff. It may be of the plaintiff or of the defendant. What is necessary is that the existence or extent of the legal right must be in issue in the dispute between the parties. We cannot construe A.J.ticle 131 as confined to cases where the dispute relates. to the existence or extent of the legal right of the plaintiff, for to do so, would be to read words in the article which are not there. It seems that because the mode of proceeding provided in Part III of the Supreme Court Rules for bringing a dispute before the Supreme Court under Article 131 is a suit, that we are unconsciously influenced to import the notion of 'cause of action', which is germane in a suit, in the interpretation

~.

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF AP. [PATTANAIK, J.]

of ArtiCie 131 and to read this article as limited only to cases where some legal right of the plaintiff is infringed and consequently, it has a 'cause of action' against the defendant. But it must be remembered that there is no reference to a suit or 'cause of action' in Article 131 and that article confers jurisdiction on the Supreme Court with reference to the character of the dispute which may be brought before it for adjudication. The requirement of 'cause of action', which is so necessary in a suit, cannot, therefore, be imported while construing the scope and ambit of Art. 131."

The learned counsel Mr. Andhyarujina, also relied upon the observations of Bhagwati J in the said decision to the following effect:-

"What has,. therefore, to be seen in order to determine the applicability of Art.131 is whether there is any relational legal matter involving a right, liberty, power 7r immunity qua the parties to the dispute. If there is, the suit would be maintainable, but not otherwise."

Reliance was also placed on the observations of Chandrachud J, in the self same case, which may be extracted herein under:"By the very terms of the article, therefore, the sole condition which is required to be satisfied for invoking the original jurisdiction of t11is Court is tllat the dispute between the parties referred to in clauses (a) to (c) must involve a question on which tl1e existence or extent of a legal right depends." Chandrachud J also had categorically stated:"I consider that the Constitution has purposefully conferred on this Couit, a jurisdiction which is untrammeled by considerations which fetter the jurisdiction of a Court of first instance, which entertains and tries suits of a civil nature. The very nature of the dispute arising under Alticle 131 is different, bot11 in form and · substance, from t11e nature of claims which require adjudication in ordinary suits."

Mr. Andhyarujina, also referred to the comments of Mr. Seervai in his book, wherein the autlior has said tliat it is reasonable to hold that the court

p

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2000] 3 S.C.R.

has power to resolve the whole dispute, unless its power is limited by express words or by necessary implications and the Supreme Court would have the . power to give whatever reliefs are necessary for enforcement of a legal right claimed in the suit, if such legal right is established. Mr. Andhyarujina also contended that once the grievance of the State of Maharashtra having brought forth before the Supreme Court in a pending proceeding under Article 131 of the Constitution, the jurisdiction having been invoked by the State of Andhra Pradesh, the Court has ample power under Article 142 of the _Constitution and for doing complete justice between .the parties, the Court would not be bound by the provisions of any procedure and can make a departure of the same. It is in this context, reliance· was placed on the observations made by the Supreme Cowt in the case of Delhi Judicial Services v. State of Gujarat, (1991] 4 SCC 406, whereunder this Court has observed as follows:"No enactment made by Central or State legislature can limit or restrict the power of this Court under Article 142 of the Constitution, though while exercising power under Article 142 of the Constitution, the Cowt must take into consideration the statutory provisions regulating the matter in dispute. What would be the need of "complete justice" in a cause or matter would depend upon the facts and circumstanc;es of each case illld while exercising that power the Court would take into consideration the express provisions of a substantive statute. Once this Court has taken seisin of a case, cause or matter, it has power to pass any order or issue direction as may be necessary to do complete justice in the matter."

Mr. Andhyarujina submitted that the likelihood of submergence within the State of Maharashtra on account of height of darn at Almatti being raised to 524.256 meters, was disclosed only during the pendency of the present suit and the State of Kamataka itself in its letter dated 10th of August, 1998 had communicated to the State of Maharashtra that the State need not approach the Court of law on this issue as the matter can be resolved amicably. According to the learned counsel, the State of Kamataka too agreed to carry out actual field surveys and calculations to determine the extent of submergence under the directions of Central Water Commission in its meeting dated 22.2.1999 and 'iliose studies are still under progress and further the Supreme Court itself had passed an order of status quo relating to the height of Almatti Dam by order dated 2.11.1998 and consequently, the State of Maharashtra never thought it fit to file an independent suit, inveking the jurisdiction of the Court under

...

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.]

Article 131. But the State of Kamataka having obtained the liberty from this Hon'ble Court to proceed further with the installation of the assembly of the gates by order dated 4.11.1998 and the said State of Kamataka refusing to give an undertaking to the State of Maharashtra not to raise the height of the Almatti Dam beyond the present level of 509 meters, the State of Maharashtra was compelled to put forth its grievance on the question of likely submergence of its territory and has prayed for the relief of injunction against the State of Kamataka for raising the dam height up to 524.256 meters. Mr. Andhyarujina also submitted that the exact extent of area to be submerged in the event the Almatti Dam is allowed to be constructed upto 524.256 meters, has not yet been ascertained and surveys are still on, but there cannot be any doubt that a large scale of the area within the State of Maharashtra wo1:J.ld get submerged. ! Mr. Nariman, the learned senior counsel, appearing for the State of Kamataka did not seriously dispute the right of a co-defendant like State of Maharashtra to put forth the grievances so as to get relief against another co-defendant, though he undoubtedly, submitted that in the event, the State of Maharashtra I was allowed to have the additional written statement and an adjudication of the additional issues framed, the State of Kamataka should have been given I an opportunity, putting forth its case. He however contended that the dispute relating to submergence of tenitory of Maharashtra on account of the height I of the dam at Almatti being raised to 524.256 meters, cannot,be a matter of adjudication in a suit under Article 131, since the State of Maharashtra had ! not raised the dispute before the tribunal itself, even though the Project Report submitted by the State of Kamataka before the tribunal indicated the height I of the dam at 524.256 meters. According to Mr. Nariman, such a dispute would be a fresh water dispute and would not be a part of adjudicated dispute and as such under Article 131 of the Constitution this dispute cannot be entertained and decided upon by this Court. Mr. Nariman also contended that I the materials on record do not establish or do not help the Court to come to . a positive finding that in the event, the Almatti Dam is raised to 524.256 I meters, a large extent of the State of Maharashtra would get submerged inasmuch as the submergence, if any and the flow back, if any, would be in I the river itself and not any territory beyond the river. Mr. Nariman further urged that the State of Maharashtra did anticipate submurgence of its te1ritory I as would appear from its stand before the tribunal which is apparent from paragraph 6.3.l(k) ofExh. MRK-1. It is true, according to the learned counsel I that the tribunal did not consider the said question but after the Original Repo1t I was submitted, Maharashtra could have filed an application under Section 5(3) of the Act, seeking clarifications on the question of submergence but, that was

C

i.

EI

p

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

(2000] 3 S.C.R.

not admittedly done, which would indicate that it had no grievance on the question of submergence. Having examined the rival contentions on this issue, v.re have no hesitation to hold that the issue must be answered against the State of Maharashtra. . It is no doubt true that the jurisdiction of the Court in a suit under Article 131 of the Constitution is quite wide, which is apparent from the language used in the said article and as has been interpreted by this Court in the two cases already referred to (see [1978] 2 SCR 1 and [1978] 1 SCR 64). It is also true that Article 142 confers wide powers on this Court to do complete justice between the parties and the Court can pass any order or issue any direction that may be necessary, but at the same time, within the meaning of Article 131, the dispute that has been raised in the present suit is between the .State of Andhra Pradesh and State of Karnataka and question, therefore, would be whether it involve any existence or extent of a legal right of such dispute. In answering such a dispute, it may be difficult to entertain a further dispute on the question of submergence as raised by the State of Mabarashtra. a codefendant. But in view of the stand taken by Mr. Nariman, without further delving into the matter and without expressing any final opinion, whether such a stand, as the one taken by Maharashtra is possible for being adjudicated upon, we would examine the merits of the said contention. .A bare perusal of the report of the tribunal setting out the facts as found by. it and giving its decision on the matters referred to it as per Exh.PKl as well as the Further Report of the said tribunal, giving explanation to the application for clarifications filed by the different States, as per Exh. PK2, we find that the question of submergence within the territory of the State of Maharashtra on account of Almatti Dam in the State of Karnataka has not at all been discussed nor any opinion has been expressed thereon. The tribunal having given its decision on the question of sharing of the water in river Krishna on enbloc allocation basis, if the user of such water in a particular way, becomes detrimental to another State, then such a grievance would be a fresh dispute within the meaning of Section 2(C) read with Section 3 of the Act and it cannot be held to be an adjudicated dispute of the tribunal. We have already indicated that it is only an adjudicated dispute between the States on which a decision has been given by a tribunal constituted under Section 4 of the Act by the Government of India, can be a subject matter of a suit under Article 131, if there is any breach in implementation of the said decision of the tribunal. But a dispute between the two states in relation to the said Inter- State river arising out of the user of the water by one State would be a fresh water dispute and as such would

STATE OF KARNATAKA AND ORS. v. STATE OF A.P. [PATTANAIK, J.)

be barred under Article 262 read with Section 11 of the Inter-State Water Disputes Act, 1956. The question of submergence of land pursuantto the user of water in respect of an Inter-State river allocated in favour of a particular State is inextricably connected with the allocation of water itself and the present grievance of the State of Maharashtra would be a complaint on account of an executive action of the State of Karnataka within the meaning of Section 3(A) and also would be a water dispute within the ambit of Section 2(C) and, therefore, it would not be appropriate for this Court to entertain and examine and answer the same. We do appreciate the concern of the State of Maharashtra, when it comes to its knowledge that there would be large-scale inundation and submergence of its territory if the height of Almatti Dam is allowed to be raised to 524.256 meters, as per the latest Project Report of the State of Karnataka, but such concern of the State of Maharashtra alone would not be sufficient for this Court to decide the matter and issue any order of injunction as prayed for in the additional written statement filed by the State of Maharashtra and on the other hand, it would be a matter for being agitated upon before a tribunal to be constituted by the Govt. of India in the event, a complaint is made to that effect by the State of Maharashtra. We also do not find sufficient materials in this proceeding before us to enable this Court to come to a positive conclusion as to what would be the effect on the question of submergence, if the height of the dam at Almatti is allowed to be constructed up to 524.256 meters inasmuch as, according to the State of Maharashtra, the joint surveys are still on. It is too well settled that no Court can issue an order of mandat01y injunction on mere apprehension without positive datas about the adverse effects being placed and without any definite conclusion on the question of irreparable injury and balance of convenience. TI1en again, while allowing a particular State to use the water of an inter- State river, if the manner of such user really submerges some land in some other State, then the question has to be gone into as to what would be the amount of compensation and how the question of rehabilitation of those persons within the submerged area can be dealt with which really is an aspect of the doctrine of equitable apportionment and all these can be gone into, if a complaint regarding the same is made and the Government of India appoints a tribunal for the said purpose. But these things cannot be gone into, in a suit filed under Article 131 as a part of implementation of an adjudicated dispute of a tribunal. It is also surprising to note that even though the Original Project Report of 1970 in relation to Almatti Dam had been produced before the tribunal, which was adjudicating the disputes raised by different States, yet the State of Maharashtra never thought of the question of submergence and never at-

,

C

SUPREME COURT REPORTS

[2000] 3 S.C.R.

tempted to get that question decided upon. In the aforesaid premises, howsoever wide the power of the Court under Article 142 of the Constitution may be, we do not think it proper to entertain the question of submergenc

Related judgments

More Supreme Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.