State of Orissa and ANR. v. Damodar Nayak and ANR.
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Date of judgment
- 31 March 1997
- Bench
- Justice K. Ramaswamy, Justice D.P. Wadhwa
- Neutral citation
- 1997 INSC 337
- Reported in
- [1997] 3 S.C.R. 456
- Result
- Leave Granted & Allowed
- Advocates
- P.N. Misra, However, T.N.A
Full judgment
A
STATE OF ORISSA AND ANR,
v. OAMODAR. NA YAK AND ANR. MARCH 31, 1997'
B
(K. RAMASWAMY AND D.P. WADHWA, JJ.]
Se,:..,ice Law-Grant-in-aid Scheml~Entiilen;e,;t to salary 'under tiie
Scl1em~espq11de11t appoi11ted as. Lecture~uestion 'whether he wds entitled to receive lf'ant-i11-aid for payment of salary from ilie date of his acquir-
e i1ig qualification 01' froli1 the date of i11itial 'ajJpointmeiit-Held admittedly,
since the first respo11de11t 011 the date of his appointnlei;t w~s not pm:sessing the reqitisite qualification and acquired the sa1i1e only 011 March :21; l989, he will be eligible to the be1tefit of the grant-in~aid ~.e.f April 1, 1989 ai1d'oi1. ·. ·, ' wardS.
D
1997.
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No. 2666 of . . .· ' .
From the Judgment and Order dated 23.4.96 of the Orissa High Court in O.J.C. No. 3548 of 1996.
E
P.N. Misra for the Appellants. The following Order of the Court was delivered :
F
The report of the Registry indicates that the service is complete. However, the respondents are not appearing either in person or through counsel. Leave granted.
G
H
The question limited to the notice is : whether the respondent would be entitled to payment of salary under the Grant-in-Aid Scheme from the date of initial appointment till he improved his qualification or from the date of his acquiring the qualification? The admitted position is that respondent No. 1 came to be appointed as a lecturer in 1976. The Government issued clarification on January 5, 1987 that unqualified lectures having minimum second class, i.e., 48% or above and below 54% of marks in P.G. examination and appointed on or after 1.8.1977 in recognised non-Govern456
I
STATE v. DAMODAR NAYAK I
ment Colleges would be eligible to receive· grant-in-aid. The Resolution A dated September 13, 1983 issued by the Government prescribes the qualification for recruitment of .L'ecturers of affiliated Colleges which indicates that "candidate not holding an M. Phil degree should possess a high second Class Master's degree, i.e., 54% marks and a second class Honours/Pass in the B.A./B. ,Cpm./B:S~. examinafion.", Respondent No. 1 B secured 53.9% marks, ~hich is almost equivaleiit of 54% niarks, on March 21, 1989. Therefore, the. question arises : whether the second respoµdent is entitled tO receive grant~in-aid for payirient of salary to the first respondent from the date of his acquiririg qualification or from the date of initial appointment? Admittedly, sl~ce the first respondent on the date of his appointment was not possessing the requisite qualification anci acquired c. the\ame only oh March 21, 1989 he will be eligible to th~ benefit of the. grant-in-aid w'.e.f. Apr1il, 1989 dnd onwards. . ·. . . . . . . .
The appeal is accordingly allowed and the order of the High Court passed· on April 23, 1996 in OJC No. 3548/96, to that extent stands modified. No costs. · · · T.N.A.
Appeal . . aJ.lowed. ., -
i'
i
'
,,
..
.
••
i
...
O·