Susheela Devi Vicharapu v. Union of India
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 28 October 2026
- Bench
- Justice P.sam Koshy, Justice Suddala Chalapathi Rao
- Case number
- WP No. 34360 of 2026
- Result
- ALLOWED NO COSTS
Full judgment
[ 3s23 ] IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
(Special Original Jurisdiction) WEDNESDAY, THE TWENTY EIGHTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENry SIX PRESENT THE HONOURABLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUST]CE P.SAM KOSHY AND THE HONOURABLE SRIJUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO WRIT P ETITIO N NO: 343 60 0F 2026
Between: Susheela Devi Vicharapu, W/o. Jana padma Seshu Kumar, aged about years, occ. Retired chief Ggnerar Manager (Finance), power Grii coipootion of India Limited, Rl/o. H.No.8-3-1 91t104(20-B), vengar Rao r.r"gar, n;"eip"i, Hyderabad - 500 038, Telahgana. ...PETITIONER
AND
1. Union of lndia, represented bylts Secretary, Ministry of Finance, Department of Revenue, North Block, New Delhi - 1 1O Ob1 .
2. central Board of Direct Taxes, represented by its chairman, North Block, New Delhi - 1 10 001 .
3, The Principal Commissioner of Income Tax, Hyderabad_4, Room No. 211, 2nd Floor, A-Block, lncome Tax Towers, A.C. Guardi, tvtasab TanX, Hyderabad - 500 004.
4. The Deputy Commissioner of lncome Tax, Circle_13(1), Hyderabad, lncome Tax Towers, A.C. Guards, Masab Tank, Hyderabad _ SOO 004.
...RESPONDENTS
Petition
under Articre 226 of the constitution of rndia praying that in the -oe circumstances stated in the affidavit fired therewith, the High cdr,t';;y prlaseo to issue a writ, order or Direction, more particurarry one in the nature of a'writ of
the order aated zo.ot.z626 bearins DiN- ;rJ Y"l93Tf..!99larino No.lrBA/coM/Fr17t2026-27t1091.638004(1)
'ii;;",
passea oy ft," l;'"n"-.pt"l"it Section 119(2)(b) of the rncome-tax Act, rbor reltctiig the petitioner,s fo-r condonation of deray in firing a revised retum "ppli"riin or in.or" for the Assessment year 2023-24 as iilegar, arbitrary,-being non-speaking anJ in vioratio" oiprinJpi"r-or naturar justice, contrary to section 119(2xb) oi th" rn"or"-tax nci, rs6i-Lno
i"i",
n
violative of Articles 14 and 265 of the Constitution of lndia, and consequently set aside the same and direct the 3rd Respondent to condone the delay and permit the Petitioner to file a revised return of income for the Assessment Year 2023-24 claiming exemption under Section 1 0(10AAXii) of the lncome-tax Act, 1961 in terms of Notification No ;a112023 daled 24.05.2023. Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI T. PRADYOTH Counsel forthe Respondent No.1: SRl. N BHUJANGA RAO DEPUW SOLICITOR GENERAL OF INDIA Counsel for the Respondent Nos.2 to 4: SRI K. SUDHAKAR REDDY, SC FOR INCOME TAX DEPARTMENT The Court made the following: ORDER
lrf IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD HON'BLE THE ACT'ING CHIEF IUST'ICE I'.SAM KOSHY AND HON'BLE SRI IUSTICE SUDDALA CHALAPATHI RAO WRIT PETITION NO.34360 OF 2026 (cNR NO.F{BHC01 0708r62026)
DA l'E: 28.10.2026 Between: Susheela Devi Vicharapu
Petitioner anrl L nion of [nt]ia, rep.by its Sccrctal.\,, \,linistry ()f I irranc,.,. I )(,1-,( .t n lr.n t i',1 Iit,r errut:, New Dclhi anrl threc othcrs.
Respont-lents
OI(DER: (per I lort,btL, Sr t us tirc SuddtLo I
Oltrr I rrltitI I r
I{eard N,lr. 'l'.Prari_\roth, le,arnecl
Mr. K.Sudhakar Redi'ly, Iearned lrrcome Tax Department
2.
t Rrro)
\.orutsel for tltc petitioner
and
Senior Standing Counsel
Ior
appearing for respondent
The present Writ petition
has been filed secking
foliowing relicf: "... to issuc a LVrit,
Ot.rlcr.
in trrc naturc or.a
writ .rLrr
datecr 30 0z 20ro F
/
17 / 2026-2i,/
r
uncler Seciion 119(2)(b),r,
to grant the
Dirtrtion' m.ro particul.r.iy.rrc
0,.,,.,,.r"'uX,
1()9163800{(
N os.2 to 3.
"':1.,;:".]"il.ffi
j).Ji
bv lhtr 'l'i t'cspondcnt
:utt"t' ,,') re Income I.ax Act,
I961, r.ejecting
-
the p,)tilioner's application for condonation o[ rlelar.in Iilir-rg a revisecl re[ur]r of incorno ior Lhc r\sscssrnont Year 2()23-2-1,
as illeqal, arbitlan, being non-speakir-rg ancl rr-r ','iolation oI principk,s of natural Justice, contrarv to Scctiorl 119(2)(b) of the Inccrnc Tar Act,1 961, and violative oi Artic]es 1:l and 265
of tht: (hnstitution of India, and consequentlv to set asicle thc sar rr arrri rlircct lhe 3''r responrlcul to cortrlolc tho r'k'lar
and pet mlt the petitioner to file a reviseLl rcturn of inconLc tax lor t 1e saicl assessment vear 2023-21clair-l-ring r'xcmption in under S('c11on 10(10AA)(ii) of the lncome Iar Ait' 196t ancl Nlrtification No 13/2023 clated 2-1'05 2023
terms ol pass
3.
petitioner was an
are that' The trrie.' facts of the case
cadre' of Pourer emploYee, in the Executive
India, being
arld retired Enrplovee No 60030116'
superannuation
Upon
Grid Corporation of
attaining on 31 03'2023' upon
the age of 60 years'
petitioner became such rctir'ement' the
terminal benef
Income reflected in the petitioner'q
for the Assessnr:trt
\ear 2023-24 A part
including enc'rshnlent
N'lav,
l-
of the leave salar.u'
pav leave) aggregating half and leave earned
Rs.22,54,0701-' 'rs
Rs.1.5,1.6,191
entitled to various
equivaiellt it;' inclucling' the cash
(encashment of
fLom setvrce ou
to
Tax Return
of the saitl retiral ducs'
Pav Leave of 300 davs of Flalf
amounting to
through his rvas regulate d and Paid
31 05 2022 2022 r i'l' lcttel clatecl
issuecl
salarY from
bv tl.re Genclal
),
,
Manager
of the employer (Finance)'
stated that the
employer
deducted at source
from 01 04 2 027 ZOZ3-24, or
'I'ax
a certificate Corporation issuecl
(Parts A in Form No 16
to 37 05'2027
29'05'2OZZ and
rlot grant anY
petitiouer' Thereafter'
and B) for the Period
the in the said certificate'
(10AA) of the Income
source of Rs'16,37 '750
and uPto Rs.3;00,000/-
f - for the said financial
ileducted tax at
year' It is stated that'
which the terminal benefits as on the date, on encashment
of leave
saiary ailowing
as taxabie the entire amount
the leave encashment
along with leave
the exemption amount paid to the petitioner'
was Rs'3'00'000/-' rcspect oI leave encashment year 2002, Ccntrar Government in the
limit in
as fixed by the
which remained unchanged
for over tlvo decacles and uide Notificatiolr 21.05.2023 (S.O- 2276(E)), tl.rc Central
Year
emPloYer did
1n respect (for short' 'Act' 1961)
encashment, treated
of tax
Assessment relevant to the
Section 10 exemPtion un der
Act, 1961',
it is
No 31/2023' dated
Government enhanced the
exemption limit to I1s.25,00,000/- under section
10(10AA) (ii) of
theAct,lg6landstatedthatthesaiclnoti{icationshallbedeemed to have come into force with effect from 01 04 2023
4.
The petitioner
Year 2023-24 in
filecl her income
I.orm ITII_2 on
tax retu rn for
the Assessment
22.06.2023, r"',ithir.r the
due
daie nder Sq.tior.r 139(1) of the AcL tg67 t,irtc acknowledgrnr:r.rt prescribed
u
No.278246070220623,
Rs.3,00,000/- towarcJs
leave encashment
of the saicl Nlotification Rs.3,00,000/_
v,.as
notification b,:ing
claiming exemption Subsequentl-v,
No.31/2023, the
beneficial
entitlement to benefit 37.05.2023 and in view
claims
petitioner retired on
of the restriction imposed
upto Rs.3,00 ,00A / -, the petitioner
b y the employer
claims entitlement to rhe
arso extended to the Non-Governme.t
Emplovees
5. It is further statecj that, by the time the petitioner became aware of the appli,-abiliti.of the said notification ar-rd
exemption lirnit, the prescribed time for filirrg
the enhancecl
a revised return of
income uncler Stction 139(5) of the Act, 7L)61 {or the Assessment , Year 20i23-24. has e'xpired. Therefore, petitioner was constrained to
move an apPlicirtioll datcd 13.07.2026 before ihe 3'd respondent
lebl' sec\'rrrP' ' ' '' ul ^( 5ccticin llq(2[h) o[ tht''\cl"
under the Pr()Y1>1r')lr
of
and the said
rn nature, the petitioner
there under. The
enhanced berrelit as it is
by vrrtue
exemption limit
enhanceci to Rs.25,00,000/ _,
of
)-
deiay and permission of condonation Assessment
income for the
petitioner that
end of
respondent issued
of
is also the case It 2073-74 \ear
of the
the period made well within
of five
application was
years from the
return to file a revised
3'd 2023-24' The \car the Assessment
impugnecl
order clatetl 3007'2076'
rejecting the
petitioner's aPPiication'
6.
It is contended bv
the 3'd respondent superannuated
for the the learned counsel
of the petitioner rejected the case
from the respondent-Corporation
received termirral yeat 2027-23 and had encashment
petitioner that as he was
in the financial
dues including leave
No31/2023 by holcling that the Notification
is
to persons who retired applicable prospectively only
on or after
upon the iudgment O.l.O4.2[23and by placing reiiance
of the High
Court for the Staic of Kerala in
WP(C) No 3145 oI 2022 and
connected cases, the Jrcl lsspq^6tnt
reiected the request of the
petitioner for condonation of delay in filing
the revised income tax
rcturn.
Aggrieved by the same, the present writ petition
assailing the imPugned orcler'
is filed
8.
Learned counsel
power unclel Section competent atrtrroritv
for the petitioner would
119(2)(b) of the
genuine hardshlp and
Act, 7961, isconferred
for the avoidance of
the enquiry c.ntemprated
debatabre question o[ Iar,r.'.
on the
gc,ui,e hardship ancl
there under is whether
whether the craim is primu
does not cor.r l.emplate a
contend that the
the case is one of fnciegenuine, a,ci
final adjudicatior_r on the
merits o[ a
]t is further contended that
Nodfication
No.31l2023 15 ,1 berreficial notification and
suppression oI anr,, material fact,
as there was no
as on the date of issuance of
Form-16, the p':titioner has submittecr
the same. The notificatior-r
No.31/2023, errhancir.rp,, tl.re exemption limir
to i<s.25,00,000/_,
applies to the ernplovees who retired even prior to
01.04.2023, and
that the saicl rrotificati.n is appriecl to manv of the similarly situated person-c across the countrv, along with the various Income
Tax Appellate I ribunal Benches held that the Notification No.31/2023 beinp; beneficial irr rlature to all those who retired
prior to 01.04.20.23,.'fhe learned counsel thus prays to condone the the impugnecl orcler aside settin'1 bV delav responclerrt
to
acr'ept t-he revised
bv directing the 3'd
return of inconre'
,
a
9.
Per contrat learned
the respondent
Nos.2 to 4,
competent authority the issue and
Senior
that vehementry contendecl
has i e',, 3'd respondent'
placing reliance Keraia
contention' It
is further
issued subsequent
said notification
upon the judgment
since the contended that'
to the
for
in fact' the
already considered
reiected (suPra) has rightll'
IligJr Court of
notif ication would
appearing Standing Counsel
of the Hon'ble the petitioner's
notification was
the retirement' petitioner's
and prospectivelv ective f ef be
to would not be applicable
said
theref ore' the
the present case'
10. OnaP erusaloftherecord'evidently'asonthedateofthe respondentfrom the services of the p etitioner's retirement
I'IR2 specifically reflected Corporation, Form No is only respect of leave encashment
the exemption in
Rs3'00'000/-' Subsequently'
clated by virtue of Notification No31/2023'
24'052023' the said
to Rs 25'00'000/exemption limit was enhanced of the notification was issued for the benefit a beneficial legislation. In the present
and said
employees' more so is
case' the petitioner has duly
clisclosed the terminal benefits received at the time of
retirement
ancl claimed exemption only to the extent of Rs 3,00,000f - as was
permissible at the relevant3oint of time. I'he petitioner has not
suppressed anv
-\ income that
benefits. Furlhermore,
Tribunal being simirar vic'it' zrnd similar.ry situ
several Benches
quasi_judicial extended the
a tec-i emproyees
other pubric s€'ctors discrimina tor\,,
was derivecj out
of Income Tax
Tribunals have benefit of the
Appeilate
already taken
saicr nofification
ancr
and deniar of the
same to the petitioner
suppression ot, rnaterial
there is no allegation
facts. Thus, the im
ancl liable to h e set
11. We respectfully clisagree
of Hon'bje High Court oI Kerala, benefits wourd rerate from the
Pugnecl orders are ltot
with the clecision reiied upon
the 3,d respondont in W.p.(C).No.3
bv
of 2022and batch on the file
ancl normally all the terminal
date oI joini.g tilr superannuation
shall be comput.d a,cl thus, the petitio,er
has made out a case for
warranting interlerencc with the impugnecl orders.
72. fherefore, in view of the above aforesaid facts anc.l circumstances, tlic impuguecl proceedings, clatecl 30.07.2026 are
hgfebV
delay in fiiing set asidtl, ancl thc
herebV
condonetl'
is
of
aside
the saicl application is
and the matter:remandecl
back to thc 3'\
a
to
of the respor.rde,t-Corporation
more particularly when
valid in the r:,vr, oI law,
oI the terminal
rcsPondent
with a direction
petitioner to
file the revised
respondent shall
N o'31 / the N otif ication
the 3'd
the benefit
2023 d'ated' 24'05'2023
Petition directions' the Writ
shall be no accorclingly' There
Miscellaneous
to the
appropriate orders
extending with law' by cluly
13. With the aforesaid allowed
such filing' returns and on
and pass consider the same
srictly in accord'ance av ailable under
to afforcl an opPortunity
stands
order as to costs'
this any, pencling in if Petittons'
shall stand tlosed
Writ Petition
iB!'!i;iYh"tl3"-'JJ //TRUE COPY/, SECTTON OFFIGER
To,
r LlintBi;liii'v' *u3'3li"lll3'3by'.**o ]'* 2. The Chairman, Central Bol'O
Department or Revenue'
^-. Block' New Delhi oio''""tTaxes' North
1' Room No lncome Tax' Hyderabad-4' of sioner '21 Commis 3. The Principal A'C Guards' Masab Tank' rr*Ho"m"" A-Block, Floor, 2nd Hyderabad - 500 004' lncome lncome Tax' Circle-'13(1)' Hyderabad' The Deputy Commissioner of i'nft' Hyderabad - 500 004' Tax Towers, n'C Cuaros' Ul"'n Advocate [OPUC] 5 . One CC to Sri T. Pradyoth' lndia [OPUC] Deputy Solicitor G-eneral of nao' ehujanga N. Sri to CC One 6. *"oi'' iot lncome Tax Department[oPUC] 7 . One CC to Sri K' Sudnaral 001.
io*"",
t"
TJ
W
Two CD CoPies
HIGH COURT
DATED: 2Bt1Ot2OZ6
ORDER
WP.No.34360 of 2026
( R
1HE S14 (.
f.
l
I ,J-)
t2 ilr,y ?a6
\i ,)
,'+
! 4,.._. . _. c, .
ALLOWING THE WRIT PETITION WITHOUT COSTS
rot{n0 \0
&.
*-