Sushma Kumari v. Lalita Devi and Another

Court
High Court of Himachal Pradesh
Date of judgment
2 November 2026
Judge
Justice Virender Singh
Case number
CMPMO No. 549 of 2026
Result
Dismissed
Acts & sections
Article 227 Constitution
Advocates
Dr.Rajesh, Kumar, Parmar
Subject
Civil

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH AT SHIMLA CMPMO No. 549 of 2026 Decided on: 2.11.2026 Sushma Kumari … Petitioner Lalita Devi & anr.

Versus

…Respondents _____________________________ ______________ Coram Hon’ble Mr. Justice Virender Singh, Judge Whether approved for reporting?

___________________________________________________ For the Petitioner:

Dr.Rajesh Advocate.

Kumar

Parmar,

For the Respondents : Mr. Ashok Thakur, Advocate. Virender Singh, Judge (oral) Petitioner has filed the present petition, under Article 227 of the Constitution of India, against the order dated 30.06.2026, passed by the court of learned District Judge, Kangra at Dharamshala, District Kangra, HP (hereinafter referred to as, ‘the First Appellate Court’),

in

Civil

Miscellaneous

Appeal

No.

16-K/XIV/2025, titled as, ‘Sushma Kumari versus Lalita Devi and another’.

2.

By way of order dated 30.06.2026, the appeal

preferred by the petitioner, against the order dated 6.11.2025, passed by the Court of learned Civil Judge, Court No. 2 Kangra, District Kangra, HP (hereinafter referred to as ‘the trial Court’), in CMA No. 1079/2022 filed in Civil Suit CIS No. 229/2022, titled as ‘Sushma Kumari versus Lalita Devi & anr.’, has been challenged. 3.

Vide order dated 6.11.2025, by virtue of which,

the learned Trial Court has dismissed the application, under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 of the CPC, preferred by the present petitioner. 4.

Parties to the present lis, are hereinafter referred

to, in the same manner, in which, they were referred to by the learned Trial Court. 5.

Brief facts, leading to filing of the present

petition, as borne out from the documents, annexed with the petition, may be summed up, as under: Plaintiff Sushma Kumari has filed a suit for permanent

prohibitory

injunction,

restraining

defendants from cutting, felling, removing the trees, raising construction of residential house, boundary

wall/retaining wall and digging the foundation

of

residential house, interfering in the privacy of the plaintiff, changing the nature of the land, bearing Khata No. 401, Khatauni No. 495, Khasra Nos. 242 and 272, kita 2 area measuring 00-24-35 hectares, situated at R/o Mohal Haler Khurd, Patwar Circle Jogipur, Tehsil and District, Kangra, H.P. (hereinafter referred to as ‘the suit land’), which is

recorded in the ownership of the

plaintiff, other co-sharers and defendants. 5.1

In

alternative,

decree

of

mandatory

injunction has been sought, directing the defendants to demolish and restore the suit land, to its original position. 5.2

The suit has been filed on the ground that the

suit land is owned and possessed by the plaintiff and other co-sharers, as per the revenue record; suit land is joint between the parties,

and the same has not yet

been partitioned, by metes and bound. 5.3

According to the plaintiff,

the defendants are

threatening to forcibly lay the foundation stone of the residential house in the suit land.

6.

On the basis of the above facts, the following

relief has been sought: “It is therefore prayed that, decree for permanent prohibitory injunction restraining to the defendants from cutting felling, removing the trees, raising construction of residential house and digging the foundation of residential house Wall interference in the privacy of plaintiff, changing the nature in any manner over the suit land bearing khata No 401 Khatauni 495 Khasra Nos 242 and 272 kita 2 area measuring 00-24-35 Hects, Jamabandi for the year 2019-202 situated at R/O Mohal Haler Khurd, Patwar Circle Jogipur, Tehsil, Distt Kangra H.P is recorded in the ownership of the plaintiff, othersCo shares and defendants and other alternative suit for the mandatory

injunction

directing

defendants

to

demolish or restore the suit land in the original position in case defendant succeed to raise construction over the suit land during the pendency of the suit.”

7.

Along with the suit, an application, under Order

39 Rules 1 and 2 CPC, has been filed, with the prayer to issue

ad

interim

injunction,

restraining

defendants from raising construction of residential house, boundary/retaining wall, as well as, interference, in the privacy of the plaintiff/applicant and changing the nature of the suit land.

8.

The said application has been contested on the

ground that the applicant has not approached the Court with clean hands. 9.

The suit, as well as, application has been

contested, by denying the allegations, which have been leveled, against the defendants, in the suit. 10.

The learned trial Court, after hearing the learned

counsel, for the parties, has dismissed the application, under Order 39 Rules 1 and 2 of the CPC, vide order dated 6.11.2025. 11.

The said order has unsuccessfully been assailed

by the plaintiff, by filing the appeal, before the learned First Appellate Court. 12.

Now, the plaintiff is before this Court, by way of

present petition. 13.

Heard.

14.

The plaintiff is before this Court, under Article

227 of the Constitution of India, where scope of interference by this Court is very limited. 15.

Hon'ble Supreme Court in "K. Valarmathi & Ors.

Versus Kumaresan”, 2025 INSC 606" has elaborately

discussed the scope of interference under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. Relevant para 9 of the judgment, is reproduced, as under: "Essence

of

power

under

Article

being

supervisory, it cannot be invoked to usurp the original jurisdiction of the court which it seeks to supervise. Nor can it be invoked to supplant a statutory legal remedy under the Civil Procedure Code, 1908. For example, existence of appellate remedy under Section 96 of the Code operates as a near total bar to exercise of supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227."

16.

In a recent decision in "Nandi Infrastructure

Corridor Enterprises Ltd. & Anr. Versus B. Gurappa Naidu & Ors.”, 2026 INSC 434", the scope of interference has again been explained by the Hon'ble Supreme Court. Relevant paragraph 35 of the judgment, is reproduced, as under:"35. In short, the principles laid down in the above matters is as follows: a) The power of superintendence under Article 227 is not to be exercised unless there has been an (a) unwarranted assumption of jurisdiction, not vested in Court or tribunal, or (b) gross abuse of jurisdiction or (c) an unjustifiable refusal to exercise jurisdiction vested in Courts or tribunals. b) It is also well settled that the High Court while acting under this. Article cannot exercise its power

as an appellate court or substitute its own judgment in place of that of the subordinate court to correct an error, which is not apparent on the face of the record. c)

The

High

Court

exercising

supervisory

jurisdiction does not act as a court of first appeal to reappreciate, reweigh the evidence or facts upon which the determination under challenge is based. Supervisory jurisdiction is not to correct every error of fact or even a legal flaw when the final finding is justified or can be supported. The High Court is not to substitute its own decision on facts and conclusion, for that of the inferior court or tribunal."

17.

Moreover,

under

Article

of

Constitution of India, this Court cannot re-assess or review the material, which was taken into consideration, by the learned trial Court. While holding so, the view of this Court is being guided, by the decision of Hon’ble Supreme Court, in Vinay Raghunath Deshmukh versus

Natwarlal Shamji Gada and another, 2026 INSC 416 . Relevant paragraph-16 of the judgment is, reproduced, as under:“16. Yet another aspect that goes to the root of the matter is that the tenants challenged the order

passed

by

Appellate

Bench

permitting the amendment by filing a writ

petition under Article 227 of the Constitution of India. It is well settled that in exercise of such jurisdiction, it would not be open for the High Court to review or reassess the material that was taken into consideration by the Court while passing the impugned order. In this regard we may usefully refer to the decision in Raj Kumar Bhatia Vs. Subhash Chander Bhatia, wherein a three Judge Bench of this Court held as under: “11 ……The High Court has in the exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution entered upon the merits of the case which was sought to be set up by the appellant

in

amendment.

This

is

impermissible. Whether an amendment should be allowed is not dependent on whether the case which is proposed to be set up will eventually succeed at the trial. In enquiring into merits, the High Court transgressed the limitations on its jurisdiction under Article 227. In Sadhna Lodh v National Insurance Company4, this Court has held that the supervisory jurisdiction conferred on the High Court under Article 227 is confined only to see whether an inferior court or tribunal has proceeded

within

parameters

of

its

jurisdiction. In the exercise of its jurisdiction under Article 227, the High Court does not act as an appellate court or tribunal and it is not open to it to review or reassess the evidence upon which the inferior court or tribunal has passed an order. The Trial Court had in the

considered exercise of its jurisdiction allowed the amendment of the written statement under Order 6 Rule 17 of the CPC. There was no reason for the High Court to interfere under Article 227.” Thus, the discretion exercised by the Appellate Bench while allowing the amendment was not liable to be interfered with in exercise of the Article 227 of the Constitution of India, especially

when

there

was

no

error

of

jurisdiction nor a statutory bar for permitting the plaint to be amended based on subsequent events.” (Self emphasis supplied)

18.

Being

guided by the above decision, now this

Court

would

proceed

further

to

point

out

jurisdictional error, if any, committed by the learned trial Court. 19.

Admittedly, the parties to the lis are co-sharers

and without making any effort to get the suit land partitioned, no relief can be granted to the applicant. 20.

Moreover, the subject matter of the lis is abadi

deh and even in the spot map, no dimension of the suit land has been mentioned by the plaintiff. Meaning thereby, the plaintiff is not entitled for the final relief. As

such, the interim relief has rightly been declined to her by the learned trial Court. 21.

The suit of the plaintiff is totally silent about the

description of the land, which is in her possession. 22.

Even

in

pleadings,

nothing

has

been

mentioned about the portion, upon which, defendants are now trying to raise construction forcibly. 23.

In view of above, this Court is of the considered

opinion

that

learned

trial

Court

has

rightly

concluded that the plaintiff has no prima-facie case, in her favour. As such, the findings of the learned trial Court do not require any interference, by this Court. 24.

Consequently, the present petition is dismissed,

so also the pending application(s), if any. 25.

Any of the observations, made hereinabove, shall

not be taken as an expression of opinion, on the merits of the case, as these observations, are confined, only, to the disposal of the present application.

2.11.2026 Kalpana

(Virender Singh) Judge

Related judgments

More Himachal Pradesh High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.