Talasani Sravan Reddy v. Union of India
- Court
- High Court for State of Telangana
- Date of judgment
- 26 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice N.v.shravan Kumar
- Case number
- WP No. 11752 of 2023
- Result
- DISMISSED
- Acts & sections
- Section 151 CPC, Article 226 Constitution
- Subject
- Property & land
Full judgment
[ 32s51 IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA
AT HYDERABAD (Special Original Jurisdiction) MONDAY, THE TWENTY SIXTH DAY OF OCTOBER TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY SIX PRESENT THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE N.V.SHRAVAN KUMAR WRIT PETITION NO: 11752 OE 2023
Between: Tatasani Sravan Reddy, S/o. Talasani Sekhara Reddy, aged about 35 Years, Rl/o. Kalvakurthy Village and Mandal, Nagar Kurnool District. ...PETITIONER AND '1
, Union of lndia, Ministry of Roads, rep. by its Regional Officer, Transport and
Highways, Regional Office, R & B Building complex, Erra Manzil, Hyderabad. 2. The Engineer-in-Chief (Roads & Buildings), National Highways, CRF Building' Hyderabad. 3. The National Highway Authority of lndia, rep. by its Chairperson, Sector- 10, Dwaraka, New Delhi 4. The Revenue Divisional Officer-Competent Authority, Kalvakukrthy Division, Nagarkurnool District. ...RESPONDENTS
Petition under Article 226 ol the Constitution of lndia praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed therewith, the High Court may be pleased to issue a Writ of Mandamus or any other appropriate writ declaring that the action of
the 4th respondent contained in file No. E126812O22 (Endorsement) dated Nil1Ot2O22 in not deciding the objections of the petitioner daled 17.10.2022 and only
redirecting to the petitioner to other officers for the information, particularly in not deciding the objections that the Kalvakurthy byepass road as per the final DPR Map commences from channel 7614o0 and not cH 76/'100 and hence acquisition of the land of the petitioner admeasuring one acre in sy-No.509 of Kotra village, Mandal, is
totally unnecessary and unwanted and hence the final notification issued under
section 3D of tho Act by including the land of the petitioner in Sy.No.509 of Kotrasivar village 1or the purpose of laying of Kalvakurthy byepass road on NH No.
167K is arbitrary illegal, and unjustified and set aside the final notification issued under section 3D of the act to the extent it includes the land of the petitioner in Sy.No.509 of Kotre Village, Veldanda lv'landal, Nagarkurhnool district is arbitrary and illegal and consequently direct the Respondents to delete the acquisition of the land
of the petitioner in Sy.No. 509, Kotrasivar Village, Veldanda Mandal, Nagarkurnool District for the purf,ose of Kalvakurthy byepass road formation on NH No.167K and
direct the respond,:nts not to interfere with the possession and enjoyment of the
Petitioner and his family members over the land admeasuring one acre in Sy.No.509, Kotrasivar Village, Veldanda Mandal, Nagar kurnool District.
l.A. NO: 1OF 2023 Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in suprort of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to direct the respondents not to ttilise/consume the land of the petitioner i.e. 25 guntas from out
of one acre in SY.l,,lo. 509 of Kotrasivar Village, Veldanda Mandal, Nagarkurnool district for the purt,ose of the Kalvakurthy byepass road on NH-167K, pending disposal of the Writ l)etition.
l.A. NO: 'l OF 2026 Petition under rlection 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to recall/set
asidetheorderdatect 09.04.2026madeinl.A.No.1 ol 2024inW.P.No.11752oI 2023 and give a fresh heirring on the vacate petition filed by the respondents or in the alternative adjudicatrr the main writ petition itself on the grounds raised in the writ petition.
l.A. NO: 2OF 2026 Petition under Section 151 cPc praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High court may be pleased to direct the
respondents not to ircquire/consume the land of the petitioner admeasuring 25
guntas our of Ac.'l -00 in Sy.No.509 of Kotrasivar Village, Veldanda Mandal, Nagarkurnool District, pending disposal of the writ petition.
l.A. NO: 2OF 2024 Between: The Engineer-in-Chief (Roads & Buildings), National Highways, CRF Building, Hyderabad. ...PETITIONER AND
1. Talasani Sravan Reddy, S/o. Talasani Sekhara Reddy, aged about 35 Years, FUo. Kalvakurthy Village and Mandal, Nagar Kurnool District.
2. Union of lndia, Ministry of Roads, rep. by its Regional Officer, Transport and Highways, Regional Office, R & B Building complex, Erra Manzil, Hyderabad. 3. The National Highway Authority of lndia, rep. by its Chairperson, Sector- 10, Dwaraka, New Delhi 4. The Revenue Divisional Officer-Competent Authority, Kalvakukrthy Division, Nagarkurnool District. ..RESPONDENTS Petition under Section 151 CPC praying that in the circumstances stated in the affidavit filed in support of the petition, the High Court may be pleased to vacate the
interim orders passed in W.P.No.11752 of 2023, (NBA) dt: 26.04.2023, pending disposal of the writ petition.
Counsel for the Petitioner: SRI VEDULA VENKATA RAMANA, Sr. COUNSEL' REP. SRI D.B.CHAITANYA Counsel forthe Respondent No.1: SRI N.BHUJANGA RAO, DEPUW SOLICITOR GENERIAL OF INDIA Counsel for the Respondent No.2 & 3: SRI P.HARINATH GUPTA Counsel for the Respondent No.4: AGP FOR REVENUE The Court made the following: ORDER
IN THE HIGH COURT FOR THE STATE OF TELANGANA AT HYDERABAD
THE HONOURABLE SRI WSTICE N.V.SHRAVAN KUMAR WRIT PETITION No.11752 of 2023 CNR.No.HBHCO 102 1 5722o23 DATE OF ORDERz 26.LO.2O26 Reserved oln: 29.04.2026
Pronounced on : 26,10,2026 Uploaded on 30]-, li ')-oLb
Between:
Talasani Srari'an Reddy, S/o. Talasani Sekhara Reddy
...Petitioner AND
Union of Indirr, Ministry of Roads, Rep. by its Rr:gional Officer, Transport anrl Highways, Regional Office,
R&BBuildingComplex,
Erra Manzil, Ilyderabad & 3 others ...Respondents ORDER: This writ p:tition is filed questioning the endorsement issued by
respondent No..l- in Fiie No.El268l2022 (Endorsement), dated Nll/1O12022 in not deciding the objections of the petitioner dated 17 .IO.2022
and redirecting the petitioner to other ofhcers for
information, rega:ding the Kalvakurthy byepass road, as per the hnal DPR map comm,:ncing from CH 761400 and not CH T61100 and accordingly the a:quisition of the land of the petitioner admeasuring
JVySK, J W.P.No I1752 of2O23
Ac.1-0O guntas in Survey No.509 of Kotrasivar Village, Veldanda
Mandal, Nagarkurnool District is totally unnecessary and unwarranted. A consequential prayer is sought to declare the notification issued under Section 3D of the Act by including the petitioner's land in Survey No.509 of Kotrasivar Village for the purpose
of laying of Kaivakurthy byepass road on NH No. 167K as arbitrary and illegal.
2.
Heard Mr. Vedula Venkataramana, learned Senior Counsel
appearing on behalf of Mr. D.B.Chaitanya, learned counsel for the
petitioner, Mr. P.Harinath Gupta, learned counsel appearing for respondent Nos.2 and 3 and learned Government Pleader for Revenue
appearing for respondent No.4 and perused the material made available on the record.
3.
Facts giving rise to the fi1ing of this writ petition in brief as
stated are that the petitioner's name was recorded as owner and pattadar along with his family members on a converted agricultural
land admeasuring Ac.1-00 guntas in Survey No.5O9 of Kotrasivar Village, Veldanda Mandal, Nagarkurnool District (hereinafter referred
as "subject land").
The petitioner's father had earlier hled
W.P.No.27864 of 2022 before this Court questioning the action of respondents therein in attempting to consume the subject land of the
petitioner and his family members situated in Sy.No.SO9/ EE-E-/2 of Kotrasivar, Veldanda Mandal, Nagarkurnool District. This Court by
JWSr, J W.P No I 1752 of 2023
an order dalec 14.07 .2022 disposed of the writ petition directing respondent Nos 1 and 2 therein not to dispossess the petitioner in any
manner from the subject land. However, liberty was granted to respondent Nos I and 2 to take steps for acquisition of the land of the petitioner strictly in accordance with law.
.
The pe riti rner submits that Section 3A(2) of the Act requires
issuance of the .rotif-rcation for acquisition for public purpose required
for operation ol National Highways or part thereof in the Ofhcial Gazette and tha- every notification sha11 give a brief description of the
land sought fcrr ircquisition and Section 3C of the Act requires hearing of objections by the competent Authority (Revenue Divisional Officer) i.e. respondent Irlo.4 herein.
5.
The respondent No.4 has issued notice dated 07 .1O.2022
referring to Gazette Notification issued under Section 3(A), dated lO.O7 .2022 and informed
the petitioner about the hearing of
objections on 17 .)-O.2022. The petitioner attended the hearing on the
said date ancl submitted his objections to respondent No.4. It is further submitte([ that, as per Section 3C(3) of the Act, the respondent No.4 is obligatec to pass orders on the petitioner's objections and communicate the same to lhe petitioner.
6.
It is the car;e of the petitioner that the respondent No.4 instead
of deciding the petitioner's objections, had issued the impugned endorsement in File No.E/26812022, dated Nil/ tOl2022 and though
irvsl(, J w.P No.I 1752 ot 2023
referring to the petitioner's objections, had not decided any of the objections and when the petitioner was awaiting for a speaking order,
the respondent No.4 had issued notification under Section 3D of the Act, published in Namasthe Telangana News Paper on 13.04.2023. It
is further submitted that the Kalvakurthy byepass, as per the final map starts from CH 76 / 4OO, however as per the plan commences from CH 76llOO and if the byepass road starts from CH 76/4OO, the petitioner's land will not be affected at all. The petitioner requested respondent No.4 to furnish the reievant plans, as to how the byepass
is being commenced from CH 76i lOO, when the hnal rnap discloses
that it starts from CH 761 4OO and in the said circumstances the petitioner's land is unnecessary for Kalvakurthy byepass on NH No. 167K, as it commences from CH 76/4OO. It is further submitted that
the respondent No.4 has not adjudicated the petitioner's objections and the frnal notifrcation was issued under Section 3D of the Act, in which the petitioner's land in Survey No.5O9 was included.
7.
The main grievance of the petitioner is that when the byepass
road starts from CH 761400, there is no necessity to acquire the petitioner's 1and. In the absence of consideration of ttre objections submitted by the petitioner in a true perspective, the final declaration
issued under Section 3D of the Act is illegal. Questioning the endorsement issued by respondent No.4, dated Nil/ 10/2O22 in File
No.El268l2022, the present writ petition is filed.
NVSI(, J W.P No I 1752 of 2023
8.
This Court by an interim order dated 26.04.2023, by observing
that the impugned endorsement is berelt of reasons and not answered the otrjectior-rs r rised by the petitioner, granted interim direction, as prayed for. Sulrsequently, this Court by an order dated' 09.04.2026
has vacated th<: interim order dated 26.04.2023. Thereafter, the petitioner carri.ecl the matter in W.A.No.474 of 2026. A Division Bench
of this Court by an order dated 24.04.2026 has disposed of the writ appeal granting an opportunity to the appellant to file an application seeking modrfication or recall of the interim order and further directed to maintain stotl.s quo tlll 29.O4.2026. Thereafter, on the directions of
the Division Ben:h of this Court, the petitioner hled an application in I.A.No.1 of 2026 to recall / set aside the order dated 09.04.2026 made
in I.A.No.1 of 20'.1,4 in W.P.No.1 1752 of 2023 and give a fresh hearing on the vacate petition or adjudicate the main writ petition itself on the
grounds raisetl in the writ petition. In view of the same, the present u,rit petition has reen taken up for hnal hearing.
9.
The respondent No.4 hled counter and would submit that
Government of lndia has sanctioned the subject road work uide Gazette S.O. r+02:2 (E), dated 6fr November, and as per the alignment
the newly proposed NH No. 167K of Kalvakurthy-Karivena road connecting village of Kotra, Kalvakurthy, Kurmidda, Tharnikal,
Suddakal, Merlipur,
Tadoor,
Desi tky al,
Peddamudunur,
PeddakothapalJy, Kalwakol, Waridyal, Chotabela, Nagarkurnool,
Kollapur, Rampr, r in the State of Telangana and Mandugula
,wsx, J
W.P.No.1l752 of2023
Sivapuram Karivena for public use and terminates at its junction with NH-40 near Nandyal and the Detailed Project Report (for short "DpR") was approved and communicated for "widening to two lane with paved
shoulders from KM 0/000 to KM 79/3OO of Kalwakurthy - Kollapur Section of NH No. l67K in the State of Telangana under Annual Plan
2O2l-22 on EPC mode for an amount of Rs.886.69 Crores for a length
of
79.30
Kms
as
per
proceedings bearing
Lr.No.RW/HYD/NH167K/Kalwakurthy/l/401214012022, dated 31.03.2022. The scope of the work is to widen the road to two lane
with paved shoulders including Vehicle Under Pass (VUP) along with side drains, foot paths, central median and central lighting within R &
B Right of Way of 100' (i.e. 50' on both sides) from Kalwakurthy to Kollapur on NH No. l67K and out of 79.300 Kms in length, the land acquisition is required in the length of 26.467 kms to an extent of
146.87 Ha beyond the ROW of National Highway for curve improvements, realignment, bye-passes and to11 p1aza. Thereafter, the
Executive Engineer, National Highway Authority, Kalwakurthy uide
letter No.EE (R&B/NH/KKTY (NH-167K\ 3A12O22, dated 29.O3.2O23 has sent requisition proposal for acquisition of the subject land. The Government of India has published Gazette Notihcation under Section 3(A) of the Act, dated 10.03.2022 aulhorizrng the Revenue Divisional
Officer, Kalwakurthy Division - respondent No.4 as the Competent
Authority for Land Acquisition (CALA) in the stretch from Km.0+0 to Kn.2O+45O of Kalwakurthy -Kollapur Section of NH No.167K.
rwsx, J
w P.No.I1752 o12023
Accordingly, a preliminary notihcation was issued under Section 3(A)
of Act uide Gaz( tle of India, dated 01.09.2022 for the acquisition of land for an exte nt of 47 .9627 Hectors. The subject 3(A) notification was published in Namaste Telangana and Hindu local newspapers both on 21 .O9.2(t22. It is further submitted that in the proposed 3(A)
Notification, there are about 615 Iand losers, out of which, the petitioner alone has filed the objection petition on 23.09.2022. The CALA I Revenur: Divisional Officer, Kalvakurthy (respondent No.4)
issued notice to the petitioner for personal hearing on 77 .1O.2O22. The respondent l.lo.4 clarified the objections raised by the petitioner.
Further, the petrtioner raised some more objections on 17.1O.2O22 after 2l days of stipulated time. Thereafter, the CALA - respondent
No.4 has clarif-re,1 the objections and the same was communicated uide letter endorr;ement on 21.70.2022 and alternative service was done on 05.12.2)22. It is further submitted that 3A notification contains only detzLils of survey number, extenl and type of land and as per approved 3(D) Gazette Notification of India, dated 09.03.2023, the
petitioner's land t: an extent of 2529.2 square meters was published as non-agriculturrrl [and. It is further submitted that the information
regarding alignmt:nt / survey of the Kalvakurthy byepass of NH No. 167K was furnished through RTI reply
to the petitioner uide
Lr.No.DEE/NHlKliY lRTll2l /2022, dated 12.08.2O22 and that the hnalization of illigrrment will be done based on technical feasibility. It is further submitted that bye pass road starts diverting gradually from
ivysr, J W.P.No.l1752 of 2023
CH 761100 and completely diverts from existing road (Hyderabad to
Srisailam) of NH No.765 at CH 761400 and the same was
communicated through RTI reply to
the petitioner uide
Lr.No.DEE/NHlKKYlRTll21 12022, dated t2.O8.2022. It is further
submitted that the respondent No.4 has communicated the endorsement uide Ftle No. 81268/2022, dated 2t.tO.2O22 and. uide File No. 8126812022, dated 05.12.2O22 and in the endorsement dated
05.12.2022, it was informed that DPR consultancy has furnished three options of alignments, however, the Ministry of Road Transport
and Highways, Government of India approved 3'd alignment option.
As per approved alignment, the bye pass road starts diverting gradually from CH 76l1OO and completely diverts from existing road (Hyderabad to Srisailam) of NH No.765 at CH 7614OO. The same was
communicated to the petitioner through RTI reply duly enclosing the
approved alignment uide Lr.No.DEE/NH/KKY/RTI / 21 I 2022, dated 12.08.2022. In view of the same, the petitioner's request to start the bye pass from Km 76.400 of NH No.765 was disallowed. Further, the
Iinal declaration under Section 3D of the Act was published in Gazette of India, dated 09.03.2023, and published rn the Namaste Telangana and the Hindu under Section 3G of the Act, 1956 on 13.O4.2023. It is
further submitted that the petitioner was granted personal hearing on 17.10.2022 and on [he same day, the petitioner has raised some more
objections and the same were considered and orders were passed on 2O.1O.2O22 and 05.12.2022 elaborately dealing with all the objections
rvvsr(, J w.P.No.l1752 of 2023
raised by the pe titioner and when the said orders were sought to be served on the potitioner, the petitioner did not accept to receive said
orders. Horvever, the same were served by an alternative mode on 1.2.12.2022 after conducting panchanama.
10. A counter afhdavit has been filed by respondent No.2 reiterating the details of acquisition proceedings, as submitted by respondent
No.4. It is further submitted that for the aforementioned work, tenders were inv ted and work was entrusted to one M/s. RKIPL-KMV (JV) to complete the work with 24 months to widen the road Lo 214 -
lane with paved shoulders including construction of side drains, foot
paths, central rnedian and central lighting with improvement to geometrics at sorle locations for curve improvements.
1. In addition to the submissions made by respondent No.4, the
respondent No.2 further submitted that in terms of Section 3D (2) of the Act, 1956 thet once the publication of the declaration under Sub-
Section (1) is issued, the land shall vest absolutely in the Central Government free lrom all encumbrances and as per Section 3D (4) of
the Act, 1956 a rleclaratron made by the Central Government under Sub-Section (11 slrall not be called in question in any Court or by any
authority.
1,2. It is further submitted that, out of 6 5 land losers being affected
in the said land a:quisition, the petitioner alone has raised objections and approached t.tis Court only with an intention to stall the process
xvsr, J
w_P.No 11752 0f 2023
of further land acquisition / construction works. It is further submitted that as the lands in Survey No.509/EE-E/2 fa1ls under Kalvakurthy bye pass location of the highway, almost 95yo of the land acquisition is completed under Kalvakurthy revenue division and due
to unavaiiability of the land for a length of 2OO meters, the construction work of the Highway is getting delayed and it has become
a crucial issue, as the bye pass work is in brisk progress, even after 95% completion of Kalvakurthy bye pass road work and though huge
amounts have been spent, the aforesaid road is not coming in to usage of public at large due to unavailability of the 200 meters length
and there is no connectivity for the Kalvakurthy bye pass and the construction work on the Highways is getting delayed and eventually pray to dismiss the petition. SUBMISSIONS:
13. Learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner draws attention of this Court to the impugned endorsement bearing File No.El268l2O22, dated N11.1O.2O22, wherein the objections of the petitioner are recorded. The same are extracted for reference: "1) As per Final DPR Map the By-Pass Road stdrt from
NH 175.00 KM 76.400 Mts but os per 3(A) Notification
the land acquisition uill start from KM 76.100 due to uhich the land in Sg.No.509 ruill come for acquisition and requested to start BA-Pass from NH 765 KM 76.400 as shown in the DPR Map.
rvsr(, J
W P No 11752 of2023
2) Tze fnat altgnment of DPR NH 765 u.lith copies of suntzAs conducted earlier in thts regard was not prou ded earlier euen afi.er seueral request hence re-qu,,,sted for supplg of DPR NH 765.
3) A:; per 3(A) Notificatton in Sg.No.509 of Kotra Shiuar
tlte land to be acquired t as shown in tuice, but t hich area correct wos not mention in the notification. 4) Tt,e land in Sy.No.SO9 of the petitioner as per record
s a r ommercial tand uhere as in 3(A) notifi.cation it was ment.on as agncuLture lands. Hence, requested lor its cofte )tion.5) Pr tuide Bg-Pass starting from KM 76.4OO qnd its
relat€d surueg copies and Maps along uith reasons for starting BA-Pass from KM 76.400."
[e arned l]enior Counsel would further submit
that the
petitioner has attended the meeting on 77.10.2022 and submitted another petition ,rn the following points: "ct. 'I'trc land tn Surueg No.509 of the petitioner is a commzrcial land though tahg thts land wcts conuenient
for fonnatton of Bg-pass road and to provide copies of su.vey conducled to thts elJect. b. The Land in Survey No.509 as per locql market ualue
is mo,e than 5 Crores and requested Jor providing copies of all surueV conducted for formation of Bg-pass roqd. c. As Fer NH 765 finat map, the road from CH 76/ a1O of
Ralwakurthg BA-pass road uill stort but qs per nottfic(Ltion the acquisition of land for formation of Bgpass <tad is starled from CH 76 / 10O. Hence, requested for its clarification for change of area.
d. The land of tLLe petitioner in SurueA No.5O9 is quite adjace'Lt to Hgderabad to Srisailam HighuaA and its
flysr, J W.P.No. r 1752 of2023
ualue of land is uery high. Hence, requested for changtng notifcation qs commerciql area.
e. To prouide mptes of marking for formation of Bg-pass road at KaluqkurthA."
Learned Senior Counsel refers to remarks by the Revenue Divisional Officer wherein the petitioner was informed with certain remarks on the objections. The same are extracted for reference: "1) As per requisition and alignment receiued from E-E (R&B)/ NH/ Kaluakurthg vide reference 2"d cited, the 3(A) Notification was issued and. the same wos approued vide reference Sth cited. 2) The copies of final alignment in the SurueA and other record
mag be obtained from the concemed authoities. 3) As per 3(A) Notification ttle qrea of Sy.No.509 utas sLaun
0.9712 Hectors and 0.8093 Hectors as Agicltlture and Non-
Agiculture land respectiuely.
a) The 3(A) Notifi.cation was issued onlg shouing uith its details of Surueg Number, Drtent and tgpe of land proposed for acquisition as per record, 5) The Reuenue Dtuisional Officer, Kalu)akurthA utas appointed
as CALA for acquisition of land due to fonnation oI NH 167K and as per aLignment receiued from reEtisition authoritA 1.e., Exealtiue Engineer (R&B) qnd Nationql Highutag KaluakltrthA
the 3(A) Notification uas issued LLence the required records if anA mag be obtained from the concerned Authoities. a) The Reuenue Duisional Officer, Kalutakurthg uta.s appointed
as CALA uide reference 1s cited, for acquisition of roa.d coming
under By-Pass Road 167 K and 3(A) Notification zr.ras isszed
as per alignment receiued from requisition authoitg i.e., Exeantiue Engtneer (R&B) and National HighuaA.
rwsr(, J
W P \o.I 1752 of 2023
b) As pe - alignment receiued from requisition quthoritA the 3(A)
Notificat on uas issued. The required alignment Record magbe obtaineo from the concerned. c) As pet ahgnment receiued from requisition authoritA the 3(A)
Notificahon uas issued. Tle required Record mag be obtained
from the concented.
d) The 3(A) Notification ruas issued u-thile shouing details oJ Sy.,Vos cnd its total ertents coming under acqtisition and its onlg wa: nohrt.ed q.s per act. e) As per alrynment receiued from requisition authoitg the 3(A)
Nott"ficc,ti)n was issued. The required alignment infotmation maA be abtained from the concerned."
14. Learned S,:nior Counsel further draws attention to objection No.(c) stating tha: as per NH 765 final map, the road will start from CH
76l4OO of Ka1val.:urthy By-pass road, but as per the Land Acquisition
notification, the acquisition of land for formation of by-pass road starts from CH 76llOO and would submit that the respondent No.4 has to give clarifrcation for the change of area. However, the same was not considered b1'respondent No.4 in his remarks on the objections made
by the petitioner and by strictly applying NH No.765 linal map, the petitioner's lands are not required.
15. Learned Se -rior Counsel for the petitioner refers to the various provisions of the \ct and would submit that the respondents had not followed the provisions of Sections 3(A), 3(C) & 3(D) of the NH Act,
1956 and that the respondent authorities had not decided the objections of the letitioner and thereby violated the provisions of the
Act, 1956.
xvsl(, J
W.P.No.t1752 of 2023
16. Learned Government Pleader for Land Acquisition appearing for respondent No.4 draws attention to the endorsement dated 05.12.2022, wherein the respondent No.4 by giving para wise remarks
to the objections made by the petitioner, denied the objections. The entire endorsement dated 05.12.2022 is extracted for reference: GOVERNMENT OF TELANGANA REVENUE DEPARTMENT
File No. E/26812O22
Date: OS-72-2O22
ENDORSEMENT Sub: Land Acquisition - NH-167K-Veldana Mandal - Kotra Village UP-gradation to 2/4 lane with paved shoulders conhguration of newly declared NH167K starting from NH167-K near Kalwakurthy to Nandyal Endorsement objections denied - Reg.
Rel
1) CALA Appointment : 3(a) cazette Notification 1091(E) No. 1056, dated 1O.03.2022.
2) EE (R&B)/ NH/KKry(NH- 167K)3(Al12022, dared 29.O3.2O22 3) The Gazette Publication of 3(A) Notihcation No. 4111(E)
so.No.3936(E), dated o 1.o9.2022
4) Objection petition received from Sri T.Sravan Reddy, R/o
Kalwakurthy, dated 23.09.2022
5) RDO, Kalwakurthy Oflice, Notice in Frle No.E/268/2022,
dated
07.10.2022. 6) A/o. Sri T. Sravan Reddy, R/o. Kalwakurthy, dated
lZ.|O.2O2Z
7) RDO, Kalwakurthy Endorsement :- File No.E/26812022, dt.
2t.10.2022
8) RO MoRTH Hyd Lr.No.RW/HYD/NH 16 7K / Katwakwt]ny /777,
Dt.21.O1.2022 Alignment Approval Communicated
9) EE LT.NO.EE/NH/KKY/ NH 167 lKlky - Kollapur/ Endorsement Reply, Dt; 02-12-2022
With reference to the subject and reference gth cited, the Executive Engineer, NH Division, Kalwakurthy has furnished para wise replies as follows:
NYSK, J W.P.No. 117s2 ot 2023
Sl.No
Ob ection As per Fioal DPR Map the By-Pass
Road start from NH 175.00 KM
Re
lt is clarified that the bypass road
starts diverting gradually from CH 76/ 100 and completely diverts Notificaticn the land acquisition will from existing road (Hyderabad start frorr KM 76.100 due to rvhich Srisailam) of NH 765 ar CH 76 / 4OO the land n Sv.No.509 will come for and same is communicated clearly acquisitio.r and requested to start through RTI reply to the petitioner By-Pass fi om NH 765 KM 76,400 as dated 12|t August 2022 uide
76.400 \4ts but as per 3(A)
shown in he DPR Map.
Lr. No. DEE/ NH / KKY IRIT 12112022,
Dl. l2/O812O22 (RTI reply given to T.Sravan Reddy). ln view of the above objectioner's request to start
the Bypass from Km. 76.400 of NH 765 is not technical feasible. The final alignment of DPR NH 765 NH 765 road pertaining to National with copies of surveys conducted Highway Authority of India. The earlier irL this regard was not final approved alignment of DPR providr-'d earlier even after several NH 167K copies of Survey and request h:nce requested for supply other record furnished of DPR NI 765.
As per available revenue record of Kolra Shivar the land to be nature oI land in Suwey No.509 is acquired ,,ras shown in twice, but two types. Hence in 3(A) which arerr correct was not mention Notification, the area of Survey No.509 was shown as 0.9712 in the nol ification. Hectors and 0.8093 Hectors as agriculture and non agriculture
As per 3(A) Notification in Sy.No.509
land respectively. Hence, both are correct and no changes
The lancl in Sy.No.5O9 of the petitioner as per record rs a commerciel land where as in 3(A) notificatiorr it was mention as
The 3(A) Notihcation was issued only details of Survey number,
agricultur( lands. Hence, requested for its corr:ction.
under non-agriculture category and the same may be reflected in 3(D) Gazette Notification. DPR consultancy has furnished three options of alignments.
Provide B1-Pass starting from KM 76.400 anr its related survey copies and N{aps along with reasons for starting Bv Pass from KM 76.400.
extent and type of land. However,
objectioner's land totally comes
However, Ministry of Road Transport and Highways,
Government of lndia approved 3.d alignment option. As per approved alignment, the bypass road starts
diverting gradually from CH 761 1O0 ar,d completely diverts
from existing road (Hyderabad Srisailam) of NH 765 at CH 761400 and same is communicated clearly through RTI reply to the petitioner
vide Lr.No. DEE/ NH / KKY/ Rtr /21 I 2022, DL12/Oal2O22 (RT reply given to T.Sravan Redd
XYSK, J
W.P.No.l 1752 of 2023
On receipt of objection petition a notice has been issued to the petitioner uide reference 5th cited, for personal appearance fixing a date on 77.10.2022 for personal hearing. Accordingly, Sri T.Sravan Reddy, R/o. Kalwakurthy was attended arld submitted another petiLion on tl1e same day for the following points. I am herewith furnishing the para wise replies as
follows: Sl.No
ob ection The land in Survey No.509 of the petitioner is a commercial land
R As per approved alignment, around
road and to provide copies of survey conducted to this effect.
done based on Technical feasibility and financial feasibility irrespective of surv no Here with furnishing the approved alignment of Kalwakurthy Bypass. Rate of individual survey number is not a criteria for hnalization of alignment.
84 survey numbers are affected. In
though why this land was that Sy.No.509 is one. Generally convenient for formation of By-pass flnalization of alignment will be
The land in Survey No.509 as per local market value is more than 5 Crores and requested for providing copies of all survey conducted for formation of By-pass road. As per NH 765 hnal map, the road from CH 761400 of Kalwakurthy By-pass road will start but as per notification the acquisition of land for formation of By-pass road is started from CH 76 I 100. Hence clearly requested for clarifrcation.
It is clarified that the bypass road starts diverting gradually from CH 76l1OO and completely diverts from existing road (HyderabadSrisailam) of NH 765 ar CH 761 4OO communicated through RTI reply to the petitioner
and same is
dated 12ft August, 2022 uide Lr. No. DEE/ NH/ KKY /RTr 121 /2022,
The land of the petitioner in Survey No.509 is quite adjacent to Hyderabad to Srisailam Highway and its value of land is very high. Hence, requested for notiflcation as commercial Iand.
dated 12 /08 /2022 (RTI Reply given to T.Sravan Reddy). In view of the above, objectioner's request to start the Bypass from Km 76.400 of NH 765 is not technically feasible. As per available record, nature of land in Survey No.509 is two types. Hence, in 3(A) notification, the area of Sy.No.5O9 was shown as O.9712 Hectors and 0.8093 Hectors as agriculture and non-agriculture
land respectively. The 3(A)
Notihcation was issued with only details of Survey Number, extent
and type of land.
However,
objectioner's land total comes
To provide copies of marking for formation of By-pass road at Kalwakurthy."
under non-agriculture category and same may be reflected in 3(D) Gazette Notification. Here with furnishing the approved alignment of Kalwakurthy Bypass.
JVySI(, J W.P.No.1 1752 of 2023
The petitior er's objections and the replies submitted by Executive Engineer (R
& B), National H ghway Division, Kalwakurthy, have been examined and your request for change of alignment from 76/ 100 to 76140O is disallowed in toto.'
17. Learned (iovernment Pleader for Land Acquisition submits that the information submitted by the petitioner were completely provided
and all the objrctions raised by the petitioner was repled. Learned Government Pleader for Land Acquisition in support of his submissions relied upon the judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in its
judgment dated 25.03.2015 in Civil Appeal Nos.3177-3178 of 2015 in the matter of Mohan Singh Gtll and others a. Sta,te of PunJab and Others, whereir the Hon'ble Apex Court held that it is not for the Courts to decide as what should be the extent of land that needs to be
acquired and it is for the Government to look into these aspects.
karned Govern ment Pleader for Land Acquisition would further submit that the ljtate is empowered to acquire the private property for public purpose a;rd eventually prays to dismiss the writ petition.
18. lrarned c()unsel appearing for respondent No.2 has made similar submissic ns. ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSION:
19. The petitioner in the present writ petition has challenged the endorsement issrred by respondent No.4 in File No. E 12681 2022 (Endorsement) , drrted Ntl / 10 I 2022. In the counter affidavit fi1ed by
the respondent Nt.4, it is noted that subsequent to the endorsement
dated Nil/ 1,O 12022, the respondenr No.4 has issued another
tvvsK, J
W.P.No I I752 of 2023
endorsement dated O5.12.2022 referring to the objections received from the petitioner on 23.09.2022 and the earlier endorsement issued
by respondent No.4 pertaining to File No. 8126812022, dated 2t.10.2022.
20. This Court in the order dated 26.04.2023 considered the impugned endorsement issued by respondent No.4 and granted interim direction. The petitioner has not challenged the endorsement dated 05.12.2022 and no reply has been filed to that effect. It is
further stated in the endorsement that when the respondent authorities tried to serve the endorsement dated O5. 12.2022 to the petitioner, the petitioner was not in his residence on two instances.
Thereafter, on 12.72.2022, when the petitioner was not in his residence, they tried to hand over the same to his family members.
But the family members had not received the said endorsement. As such, the same was affrxed I posted on the wall of the petitioner's house in the presence of two witnesses. During the course of arguments, no submissions were made on the endorsement dated 05.12.2022 and the said endorsement was not disputed. This Court observes that since the endorsement dated Nil/1012022 is the subject
matter of the writ petition, this Court by an order dated 26.04.2023 considering the impugned endorsement, has granted interim direction, as prayed for and on a perusal of the endorsement dated 05.12.2022,
the objections of the petitioner were clarihed. Further, the petitioner has not challenged the subsequent endorsement dated 05.12.2022,
nrvsr(, J W P No.1 I752 of 2023
which $'as hled as a material paper in I.A.No.1 of 2024, and no reply has been fi1ed in that regard.
21. A Division Bench of this Court in National Highways Authority of India v. G.Narsing Rao & othersl on the aspect of which lands to be acquired lbr laying national highways, held as follows:
"24. vVe are ofraid tue can examine or adludicate on such gneuance raised bg the writ petitioners. The NtLtio,ral llighuaVs Act, 1956 lays dotun the procedure Jbr a< quisrtion of land for laying of national hightaags incluc'tng award of compensatton. Wit petitioners haue their remedg there under.. In the Jacts and circunlst%nces of the case, u)e are of the uieu thqt there u.)as t .o occaston Jor any consensus amongst the parties
to the LUit petttion. Since acquisttion of lond is for the purpose of four laning of national highwag, u-thich is of
pubtic tnterest, interference bg the High Court under ArTicle 226 of the Constitution of India would not be justified.
25 TL ctt apctrt, there are hardlg ang materiats placed on recoro bg the Lunt petitioners to proue that executton of the fou laning of N.H.161 project ts actuqted bg mala
fdes to oust the uit petittoners from their Land. On pleade,d facts and the mateidls on record this Court
canno come to ang such sweeping conclusion. 26 It i; for the technical experts to detennine alignment
of a 'oad. Courts are not equipped to instruct the outhotities how to go about laging of roads or nationq.l
highu"rgs; or uthtch lands should be acquired and which shoutd not be acquired for such purpose. In case oJ rratttnaL htghwags, a statutory frameutork is in place
with rnbutlt remedial prouisions for those affected bg land a':qutsition for consttuction of such road. ' 2022 (3) ALT 7oz (D 3)
JVySX, J
W P No.l 1752 of 2023
27.
Sounding a note of ca tion, Supreme Court in Union of Indta ys. I(ushata SheftU [e011) 12 SCC 691 has mentioned tltot Nationaj Highu.tags AuthoitA of India (NHAI) is a professionally managed statutory bodA
hauing expertise in the field of d.euelopment and maintenance of national highutags. The projects inuoluing construction of neut highwags and. u;id.ening
and deuelopment of ttle existing highwags, u.thich are uitat for tLLe deuelopment of infrastn_rcture in the country,
are entrusted to experts in the field of hightuags. It compises of persons hautng uast knouledge and. expertise in the fietd of highutag deuelopment and_ maintenance. NI{AI prepares and tmplements projects
relating to deuelopment and maintenance of national highwaAs afi.er thorough studA bg expetTs in different
fields. Detaited project reports are prepared keeping in uieu the relatiue factors incLuding intensttA of heaug uehicular trafrt.c and larger public interest. Courts are
not qt all eEtipped to dectde upon the uiabititA and feasibilitA of a particular project and utheth,er a particular alignment uould sub-serue the larger pubtic interest. In such malTers, scope of ludicial revtew is uery limited."
22. Earlier, the petitioner had challenged the endorsement dated NIL.IO.2022, wherein respondent No.4 had offered his remarks on the objections raised by the petitioner, directing the petitioner to obtain
the required information from the concerned authorities. Accordingly,
the petitioner was informed of the same by the said endorsement. Thereafter, by an endorsement dated 05.12.2022, the request of the petitioner for change of alignment from Km.76l1OO to Km.76/4O0 was considered by respondent No.4 and was disallowed in toto and the same was served on the petitioner. Though the petitioner was informed
rwsr(, J W P :,1o.11752 of 2023
of the rejection of his request through the said endorsement dated 05.12.2022, the petitioner filed the present writ petition on 24.O4.2023
without challenging lhe said endorsement. Thus, the objections raised
by the petitioner were subsequently considered and decided by the rejection endorsr:rnent dated 05.12.2022. As such the relief sought in
the present writ petition has already been rejected by the competent
authority b), wry of subsequent endorsement dated 05.12.2022 wherein the objections of the petitioner were clarihed. Further, respondent No.2 has hled a memo enclosing a copy of the award dated 20.O9.2023 issue d by the competent authority, respondent No.4, and a
copy of the Gazette notification dated 09.03.2023 issued by the Ministry of Roacl Transport and Highways. Wherein, it was recorded
that no objections rvere received under Section 3C of the National Highways Act, 1956, within a period of 2 i days from the publication of the notification u;rder Section 3A of the Act.
23. It is furtlrer noted that at the time of recording, the apportionment ir r the Kotra Village Apportionment, Kalwakurthy Division, in the award enquiry, the petitioner's name was recorded in respect of the lan,1 under acquisition to an extent of 0.70819 hectares
in Sy.No.509. In t-re enquiry it was further recorded that the petitioner
did not attend the award enquirv and, hence, the compensation payable in respect of the said land, as shown in the apportionment
statement under the agricu.ltural category, would be paid after deciding the righl ful owner, whenever the claimant approaches the
xysr, J
W-P-No-l1752 ol 2023
competent authority with documentary proof of ownership. Further,
the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, vide notihcation dated 09.O3.2O23, referring to the substance of the notification published in
"Namaste Telangana" (Telugu) and "The Hindu,, (English), both dated 21.O9.2022, under sub-section (3) of Section 3A of the Act, recorded
that t1le objections received were considered and disallowed by the competent authority. The t6entral Government,
in exercise of the
powers conferred under sub-section (1) of Section 3D of the Act, declared that the lands specihed in the Schedule sha1l be acquired for
the aforesaid purpose. In pursuance of sub-section (2) of Section 3D of
the Act, the Central Government further declared that, upon publication of the notification in the Official Gazette, the lands specified in the Schedule sha11 vest absolutely in the Central Government, free from all encumbrances. On perusal of the notification, the petitioner's land in Sy.No.509 is also recorded as patta
land, classified as dry (non-agricultural land), admeasuring 0.70819 hectares. The award dated 20.09.2023 and the 3D notification concludes the land acquisition proceedings. Since the land acquisition proceedings have been concluded, the petitioner may pursue his remedy in accordance with law. Therefore, the relief sought by the
petitioner cannot be granted and no writ of Mandamus can be issued to the respondents. In view of the above, the writ petition is devoid of merits, fails and is liable to be dismissed.
rwslq J w.P.No. I t7s2 o12023
24. According y, this Writ Petition is dismissed. There shall be no order as to co sts
As a sequel, miscellaneous applications, if any pending, shall stand closed. SD/- C.DEEPIKA ASSISTANT REGTSTRAR //TRUE COPY// SEC
@"
FFICER
One Fair Co cy to the Hon'ble SRI JUSTICE N.V.SHRAVAN KUMAR (For His LordshiPs Kind Perusal) To,
1. One CC to SIRI D.B.CHAITANYA, Advocate [OPUC] 2. One CC to Sltl P.HARINATH GUPTA, Advocate [OPUC] 3. 04 LR Copies 4. The Under S ?cretary, Union of lndia, Ministry of Law, Justice and Company Affairs, New l)elhi.
5. The Secretary, Telangana Advocates Association, Library, High Court Buildings, Hytlerabad.
6. One CC to siRl N.BHUJANGA RAO, DEPUTY SOLICITOR GENERIAL OF
lNDlA, High C;ourt for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad IOPUC] 7. Two CCs to ,3P FOR REVENUE, High Court for the State of Telangana at Hyderabad [C UT]
B. Two CD CoPi,:s BSR
CC TODAY HIGH COUFIT
DATED: 261'1012026
e lrnre 9
f
o o
DISMISSING THE WRIT PETITION, WITHOUT CC)STS
A
I
l. OES, ,A1
WP.No.1175',2 ot 2023
6"
ts :c
+.
ORDER
@
s2 N$'l