Tanay Sarkar and Ors v. State of West Bengal and ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
- Date of judgment
- 5 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Bivas Pattanayak
- Case number
- WPA No. 13209 of 2026
- Result
- DISPOSED
- Subject
- Service
Full judgment
05.10.2026 Sl. No.2047 Ct.-14 ss IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION APPELLATE SIDE
W.P.A. 13209 of 2026 Tanay Sarkar & ors. -VsState of West Bengal & Ors. Mr. Sudipta Dasgupta Mr. Ritwik Basu …. For the petitioners. Mr. Ranjan Kumar Sinha Mr. Shaunak Ghosh … for the State .
1.
Since the petitioners have separate, distinct and independent cause of action, the writ petition is taken up for consideration of prayer of petitioner no.1 only. So far as the other petitioners (petitioner no.2-36) are concerned, it is left open to them to file separate writ petition praying for notional benefit on their selfsame independent cause of action.
2.
By the present writ petition the petitioner no.1 seeks direction upon the respondent authorities to grant notional benefits of service in favour of the petitioner no.1 such as fixation of pay with all increment, seniority etc. and effect such notional fixation of pay on all consequential service benefits with effect from the date of provisional approval of panel i.e. 17th June, 2015.
3.
The petitioner no.1 contends that pursuant to an advertisement dated 23rd April, 2010 of
District
Primary
Council,
North
Parganas (in short ‘DPSC’) for recruitment of primary teachers, the petitioner no.1 submitted application in order to participate in the said recruitment petitioner
process.
Subsequent
appeared
in
thereto,
written
examination conducted by the concerned DPSC. However,
since
certain
irregularities
were
detected in the examination procedure, the written examination was cancelled vide Order No.255-SSE/12/ES/P10M-141/2010 (Pt) dated 21st June, 2012 of Principal Secretary to the Government of West Bengal, School Education Department
and
direction
was
issued
for
conducting the examination de novo. As per the said notification, de novo examination was conducted. The petitioner no.1 appeared in the de novo written examination and on being successful was called for interview. Though the panel was provisionally approved on 17th June, 2015, however, the DPSC failed to publish the panel
and
consequently
issue
letters
to
candidates
successful
appointment
a
misconceived plea of judicial restraint despite there being no subsisting order of stay. Several candidates being aggrieved by such action of the DPSC approached this Hon’ble Court by filing writ petitions and ultimately those writ petitions were considered including the writ petition filed
by the present petitioner being WPA 15128 of 2017 and the Coordinate Bench on 8th January, 2021 directed DPSC, North 24 Parganas and DPSC, Malda to publish panels as provisionally approved vide Memo dated 11th June, 2015/17th June, 2015 in their respective websites within a period
two
weeks
from
date
communication of the order. Pursuant to such order, the panel of successful candidates were finally published on 10th February, 2021 and appointment was given to the petitioner no.1 in the month of September, 2021. Owing to such illegal
and
arbitrary
action
authorities, the appointment of the petitioner no.1 was given belatedly. Such inordinate delay in giving appointment is solely attributable to the respondents. The petitioner no.1 for such reason has lost considerable period of service. Hence this writ petition seeking for notional benefit from the date of provisional approval of the panel i.e. 17th June, 2015. 4.
Mr.
Sudipta
Dasgupta,
learned
advocate
appearing for the petitioner no.1 submits that the petitioner no.1 on being successful in the recruitment process of 2009 was provisionally empanelled for appointment on 17th June, 2015. Upon direction issued in Nihar Biswas & Ors. versus State of West Bengal & Others (In Re: WPA 15128 of 2017) the panel was published on
10th February, 2021. Ultimately appointment letter was issued on 21st September, 2021 and petitioner no.1 joined on 30th September, 2021. In Uttam Samadder -versus- The State of West Bengal & ors. (In re: WPA 4043 of 2026), the petitioner therein has been granted notional benefit from provisional empanelment. Being similarly circumstanced, the petitioner no.1 seeks similar benefit. 5.
Though District Primary School Council, North 24-Parganas
was
represented
last
occasion i.e. 24th September, 2026, however, today none appears for the Council. 6.
Learned Advocates for the State concedes to the fact
that
circumstanced
petitioner as
petitioner
is
similarly in
Uttam
Samadder (supra). 7.
In Uttam Samadder (supra) upon hearing the learned Advocates for the respective parties, this Court was of the opinion that the petitioner therein was entitled to notional benefit on and from June, 2015 on the ground that delay in appointment was solely attributable to the
authorities.
Undeniably,
petitioner no.1 is similarly circumstanced as of the petitioner in WPA 4043 of 2026. 8.
In
above
conspectus,
concerned
respondents authorities are directed as follows:
(i)
To fix the pay of the petitioner no.1 granting notional benefits from June, 2015.
(ii)
On upward fixation of pay of the petitioner
by
granting
notional
benefits,
payment shall be made from the date of appointment of the petitioner no.1. If any increment has been given to the teacher who joined at a prior date till September, 2021, the same shall be made available to the petitioner no.1 prospectively from the date of his joining. The salary slip and the pay scale of the petitioner no.1 shall be revised accordingly. (iii) It is clarified that the petitioner no.1 will not be entitled to monetary benefits from June, 2015. (iv) The petitioner no.1 shall also be entitled to the notional increments and the length of his service shall be calculated from June, 2015. (v)
Arrears, if any, from September, 2021 till date shall be paid to the petitioner no.1.
9.
Respondent
no.3,
Commissioner
Education is directed to pass formal order on completion of aforesaid exercise within a period of six weeks from the date of communication of this order.
10.
Learned advocate for the petitioner no.1 is directed
to
communicate no.3,
this
order
Commissioner
to
Education, Government of West Bengal and Council,
no.4,
North
District
Primary
24-Parganas,
for
necessary
compliance. 11.
With the above direction, the writ petition being WPA 13209 of 2026 stands disposed of.
12.
Since no affidavits have been called for, the allegation made in the writ petition is deemed to be not admitted.
13.
Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
14.
All
connected
applications,
if
any,
stand
disposed of. 15.
There shall be no order as to costs.
16.
All concerned parties shall act in terms of the copy of the order duly downloaded from the official website of this Court.
17.
Urgent Photostat certified copy of the order, if applied
for,
be
given
to
parties
compliance of all necessary legal formalities.
(Bivas Pattanayak, J.)