Tapasi Let v. State of West Bengal and ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
- Date of judgment
- 7 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Partha Sarathi Sen
- Case number
- WPA No. 28737 of 2026
- Result
- DISPOSED
Full judgment
07.10.2026 Sl. No. 06 (DL) Ct.No.19 (Susanta) (Bench I.D. 266052)
WPA 28737 of 2026 Tapasi Let Vs. The State of West Bengal & Ors. Mr. Biswaroop Bhattacharya, (V.C) Mr. Anindya Bose, Mr. Golam Mohiuddin, Ms. Raina Das, Mr. Md. Kaif Hossain, … for the Petitioner. Mr. Samrat Mukherji, Ld. AGP, Mr. Akash Adak, … for the State. Ms. Kardina Roy, … for the respondent nos. 29-31. Mr. Imtiaz Kabir, Mr. Mahendra Nath Sarkar, … for the respondent nos. 7-28. 1. Affidavit of service as filed today on behalf of the writ petitioner is taken on record. 2. The parties are represented by their respective learned advocates. 3. Learned advocate for the respondent State
has
also filed documents regarding communication of the last order dated 06.10.2026 to the concerned BDO. 4. The subject matter of the instant writ petition is the no-confidence motion notice, bearing no date, a copy of which has been annexed at page number 30 of the instant writ petition, as issued by the private respondents. 5. Mr. Bhattacharya, learned advocate appearing on behalf of the writ petitioner, submits before this Court
that on perusal of the impugned notice, it would reveal
that
said
notice
contains
stigmatic
allegations against the writ petitioner, which is not permissible in the eye of law. To substantiate his contention, Mr. Bhattacharya places his reliance upon a judgment passed by a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Razia Sultana vs. State of West Bengal & Ors., reported in AIR 2023 Cal 189. 6. It is submitted that in paragraph 17 of the judgment of Razia Sultana (supra), the Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court expressly held that in the event a notice for removal of a Pradhan contains stigma, such notice should not be acted upon. 7. Drawing attention to page nos.
27 to 29 of the
instant writ petition, being a copy of the order dated 10.09.2026 as passed by a Coordinate Bench of this Court in WPA 24420 of 2026 (Tapasi Let Vs. The State of West Bengal & Ors.), it is argued by Mr. Bhattacharya that the said Co-ordinate Bench in the case of Tapasi Let (supra) quashed the notice of motion containing stigma against the writ petitioner (the petitioner herein). 8. It is thus, submitted that in view of such settled proposition of law, the impugned notice may be quashed and appropriate relief/reliefs
may be
granted to the writ petitioner in terms of the prayers of the writ petitioner.
9. Learned advocate appearing on behalf of the private respondents submits before this Court that while allowing the instant writ petition, liberty may be given to the private respondents to issue notice of no confidence against the writ petitioner immediately after the disposal of the instant writ petition. 10.
Learned advocate appearing on behalf of respondent
State
leaves
matter
for
consideration of the Court. 11.
On careful perusal of the entire materials
as placed before this Court and after hearing the learned advocates for the contending parties, it appears to this Court that the notice impugned contains stigma against the writ petitioner and thus, the same cannot be allowed to stand in view of the proposition of law as decided in the case of Razia Sultana (supra) by the Hon'ble Division Bench of this Court, wherein the following has been held: 17. It is well established now that if a notice for removal of Pradhan or Upa-Pradhan addressed by the requisite number of members of a Panchayat to the prescribed authority contains stigma, such notice should not be acted upon. There is sound logic behind this. As argued by learned Advocate
for
respondent/writ
petitioner, the scheme of Section 12 of
1973
Act
does
not
contemplate
granting an opportunity of hearing to the
concerned office bearer who is sought to be removed. Hence, if a removal notice contains allegations against such office bearer,
he/she
does
not
get
an
opportunity to refute such allegations whether at a hearing or by way of a reply or written representation. The allegations may
be
of
various
types,
some
very
serious and derogatory and some not so bad. However, any allegation, in whatever words and however articulately framed, whether of financial dishonesty or of recalcitrance, which tends to tarnish the image
of
concerned
would
in
our
opinion,
office-bearer, amount
to
a
stigma. If in a removal notice statements are
included
which
would
give
impression to the members of the society that
concerned
office-bearer
is
completely unfit for and unworthy of the concerned post, the same shall amount to a stigma which is very likely to have an adverse impact on the future political carrier
of
that
person,
without
that
person getting an opportunity to deal with and disprove such allegations. This would
clearly
be
violation
of
principles of natural justice contrary to the rule of law.”
12.
In view of such settled proposition of law,
this Court thus finds sufficient merit in the instant writ petition. Accordingly, the instant writ petition is allowed. Consequently, the impugned undated notice of motion, a copy of which has been annexed at page number 30 of the instant writ petition, is hereby quashed. 13.
Consequently, the notice dated 29.09.2026,
as issued by the BDO, Nalhati-1, Development Block, District Birbhum, being the respondent no. 4, is also quashed. 14.
Before parting with, this Court grants
liberty to the private respondents to serve a notice of no-confidence motion against the writ petitioner on the self-same cause of action and/or on subsequent cause of action and/or if occasion so arises. 15.
With the aforementioned observation, the
writ petition is disposed of.
(Partha Sarathi Sen, J.)