The Ahmedabad St.xaviers College Society & Anr. ETC. v. State of Gujarat & Anr.
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Date of judgment
- 26 April 1974
- Judge
- Justice A.N. Ray
- Neutral citation
- 1974 INSC 104
- Reported in
- [1975] 1 S.C.R. 173
- Result
- Disposed off
- Acts & sections
- Article 30 Constitution, Article 29 Constitution, Article 13 Constitution, Article 32 Constitution
- Subject
- Service
Full judgment
.
THE AHMEDABAD ST.. XAVIERS COLLEGE. SOCIETY & . ANR. ETC.
r.
STATE OF GUJARAT & ANR. April 26, 1974 [A. N. RAY C.J., D. G. PALEKAR, P. JAGANMOHAN REDD<, H. R. KHANNA K. K. MATHEW, M. H. BEG, S. N. Dw!VEDI, Y. V. CiiANDRACHUD AND A. ALAGIR!SWAMI, JJ.] Constitution of India 1950 Arts. 29 and 3~Whether mutually exclusiviScope of ·Gujarat Univusity Act, 1949-ss. 5, 33A(I) (a), 33A(l)(b), s. 39, s. 40(1) and .(2), a. 41(1), s. 51A(I) and 52A-Conslitutiona/ity.
•
.
The first petitioner a religious denomination, run~ a college to provide hiaker education to Christian and other students. The petitioner's college was accorded af!iliation under •· 33 of tho Gujarat Univeraity Act, 1949 as amended in 1972. The Senate of the University passed a resolution that all instruction, .teaching and training in courses of studies in respect of which the University is .competent to hold examinations shall, within the University area, be conducted by the Unive~ity and shall be imparted by the teachers of tho University. Section S ot the Act provides that no educational institution situated within the University shall, save with the sanction of the State Government. be a5sociated in any way with or seek admission to anv privilege of anv other University established by law. Section 33A(l)(a) of the Act provides that every Colle.1" other than a Government Coliege or a College maintained by the Government, shall be under the management of a governing body which includes amon&" others. the Principal of: the College and a representative of the University nominated by the Vice-Chancellor. Section 33A(I) (b)(i) provides that in the care of recruitment of the Principa~, a selectiOn committee is required to b~ constituted consisting of. among others, a representative of the University nomi~ nated by the VicC-Chancellor and (ii) in the case of selection of a member of the teaching Btaff of the College a selection committee consisting of the Principal and a representative of the University nominated by the Vi·:e-Chancellor. Subsection (3) of the section "States that the provisions of sub-section (1) of s. 33A sha11 be deemed to be a condition of affiliation of every college referred' to in that sub-section. Section 39 provides that within the University area all Post.graduate instruction. teaching- and training shall be conducre·d by the ·University or by such affiliated College or institution and in such su~ct~ as may be prescribed by statutes. Section 40(1) enacts that the· 'Cou.rt of the University may determine that all instructions, teaching and training in courses of studies in respect of which the Unive.rsHy is competcn.~ to ho1d examinations shall he conducted bv the University and shall be imparted by the teachers of the University. Sub-section (2) of s. 40 states that the State Gover~rnent aball issue a notification declaring that the provisions of s. 41 shalf come into force on such date as may be stx"cified in the notification. Section 41(1) of the Act slates that all colleges within the Univeraity area which are a<lmitted to tho privilege of the University under s. 5(3) and all colleges within· the said area which may hereafter be affiliated to the University shall be cons· ti tu tent colleges of the University. Sub-section ( 4) states that the relations cf the constituent colleges and other institutions within the Universitv area sha1J be governed by statutes to be made in that behalf. · Section 51A(l)(b) enacts that no member of the teaching other academic and non-teaching stall of an aftlliated college, shall be dismissed or removed or re~u~ in. rank except after ~n enquiry _in . accordan~ with. the procedureprescnbed m cl. (a) and the penalty to be mft1cted on hlill is approved by the V1ce-Chaacellor or any other Officer of the University authorised by the Vice-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1975) J S.C.R.
C!limcelloz in,.this behlllf. Similarly cl. (b) of sub-section (2) requires that .such termmatJOn should be approv.:d by the Vice-Chancellor or any officer of the University authorised by the Vice·OJ&ncellor in this behalf. Section 52A(I) enacts that any dispute between the governing body and any member of the teaching and other staff ~halt on a ~quest of the governing body or of the n1ember .concerned be referr.ed to a- tribuna:l -of arbitration consisting of one member nominated by the governing body of the colle_ge, one n1en1ber nominated by the .member concerned and an umpire appointed by the Vice.-Chancellor .. _ Article 29 ( 1) of the Constitution states llhat any section of the citizeiis residing in the territory of India or any P<l;ft_ thereof having a distinct language .script or culture of its own shall have the right •to conserve the same. Article 30(1) enacts that a11 minorities whether based on religion or language; shall ·.have the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. Under clause (2) in granting c.id to educational iristitutions, the state is enjoined not to discriminate against any -.educational institution on the ground 1hat it· is under the management of a minority~ whether based on religion or language.
In a petition under atircle 32 the petitioner contended that as religious and :linguistic minorities they had a fundamental right to eStablish and adminiSter educational institutions of their choice as also the right to affiliation. The petitioners challenged the constitutional validity of the abovci sections. The respondent on the other hand contended that articles 29 and 30 are n1utua"lly exclusive, that there was no fundamental right to affiliation or recognition. that a minority educational institution seeking affiliation or recognition must conform to the conditions prescribed for recogni.. tion or affiliation, that unless a Jaw -0r regulation is whoHy destructive of the :right of minorities under Art. 30(1) the same would not be liable to be strucl<l .down and lastly that the court should not strike down the impugned provisions but should wait till statutes or ordinance are made in pursuance of those sections.
y \
"
1IEW: :lly Majority: (Ray C.J., Palekar, Khanna, Mathew, Beg and Chandrachud, JJ.) Articles 29· and 30 are not mutually exclusive. (Jaganmohan Reddy and .Alagiriswami, JJ, did not deal with this question.)
Dwivedi, J.: The content of right under Article 29(1) differs from content of, tlie right under Articla 30(1)
·ay full. Court :. Ther.e is no fundamental right to affiliation. But recognition or affiliation is nece"Ssary 'for a n1eaningful exercise of the right to establish and administer educational institutions. By majority·:. (Ray, C. J., Pa1ekar, Jaganmohan Reddy. Khanna, ·Mathew. Chandrachud and Alagiriswan1i JJ.) Section 35 A cannot apply to minority institutions. 'Beg. J; Section 33A would not impinge upon the right under '.Article 30(1). 'Dwivedi, J.: Section 33A(l)(a·) is violative of minority rights. · By mafority : (Ray· C.J., Palekar, Jaganmohan Reddy, Khanna, Mathew, Chandrachud and Alagiriswami .. JJ.) Se:tion 40 and 41 cannot have compulsory ·application to minority institution;;, Beg, J.: Sections 40 and 41 would be violativ·e. of the right under At1icle 3-0( 1) and, therefore, do not apply to- ·minority 'inStitlltiOns' u.-n:Iess they opt for affiliation.
Dwivedi, J. : No legitimate objection could be taken of Sections 40 and 41. (R~y C.J., ·pa]ekar, Jaganrnohan Reddy, Khanna, Mathew, Cbandrachud and Alagiriswami, JJ.) Section 51(A)(l) and (2) and Section :52A cannot have application to ~minority institutions.
·By majority:
-1le$ J.''did-ItOt cOnsid.Cr it re3nY n.ecessary on the vieW he was taking; to consider 1he ~alidity ·~f'.Sections 5!A(l) and (2) and Section ~~(A) of the "'ct but, :after- 1.as~u~ng It was necessary to do so, held these provis~ons to be vahd.
,
ST, XAVIERS COLLEGE V. OUJARXT
Dwivedi, J.: Sections 5!A and 52A are not violative of Article 30(1) of Jhe Constitution.
Ray C.l. and Palekar. l.
.,
,E
:F
It will be wrong to read Art. 30 (1) as restricting the right of minorities to establiSh and administer educational institutions of their choice only to .cases where such institutions are concerned with language, script ·or culture of the minorities. If the scope of art. 30( 1) is to establish and administer educational institutions to conserve looguage, script or culture of minorities, it will render Art. 30 redundant. If the rights under Arts. 29(1) and 30(1) are the same then the consequences will be that any section of citizens, not necessarily linguistic or religious minorities, will have the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. The scope of Art. 3O rests on linguistic or religious minorities and no other section of citizens of India has such a right. If the scope of Art. 30(1) is made an extension of the right under Art. 29(1) as the right to establish and adn1inister educational institutions for giving religious construction or for in1parting education in their religious teachings or tenets, the fundamentM right of minorities to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice will be taken away. [19!CG] T/le Kera/a Education Bill 1957 [1959] S.C.R. 995 and Rev. Father Proost v. State of Bihar [1969] 2 S.C.R. 73 referred to. (2) The consistent vie\\' of this Con.rt has been that there is no fundamental right of a minority institution to affiliation. The regulatory measures for affiliation are for unifrirmity, efficiency and excellence in educational courses and do not violate any fundamental right of the minority institutions under Art. 30. '[l93C; 194D] (3) The right conferred' on the religious and linguistic minorities to adminis-ter educational institutions of their choice is not an absolute right. This right is not free from regulation. Just as regulatory measures are necessary for maintaining the educational character and content of minority institutions, similarly regulatory measures are necessary for ensuring orderly, efficient and sound ad . . ministration. [ l 94G-H]
The Kera/a Education Bj/[ 1957 [1959] S.C.R. 995 referred to. (4) The provisions of s. 3JA(l)(a) cannot aipply to minority institutions. Provisions of thi$ section have the effect of displacing the management and en~ trusting it to a different agency. The right to administer is the right to conduct and manage the affairs of the institution. This right is exercised through a body of peNons in whom the founders of the institution have faith and confidence and who have full autonomy in that sphere. The right to administer is ·subject to permissible re&ulatory· measures. If the administration has to be improved it should be done through the agency or instrumentality of the existing management and not by displacing it. Restrictions on the right of administration imposed in the interest of the general public alone and not in the interests of and for the benefit of minority educational institutions concerned will affect the autonomy in administration. [198G; !98H-199A; 199D-E] (5) The provisions contained in s. 33A (1) (b) cannot apDlY to minority institutions. [199H] (6) Section 40 of the Act cannot have any compulsory application to minority institutions because it will take away their fundamental right to administer the educational institutions of their choice. As soon as the court, which is one of the authorities of the µniversity, determines that the teaching and training shall be conducted by the University, the provisions of s. 41 -0f the Act come into force. It fa true that no determination haSJ yet been made by the court of the University under s. 40; but the po\ver can be used in relation to minority institutions. Once that is done, the minority institutions will immediately become constituent colleges. The real implication of s. 40 of the Act is that teaching and training shall be conducted by the university. [197C-E; G] (7) Since sections 40 and 41 .hang together, s.41 of the Act cannot have any Section 41 of the Act is a comou1sory application to minoiity institutions. corollary to s. 40 oI the Act Since an affiliated ::college becomes a constituent
l'/6
SUPREME COURT REPoRTS
[1975) J S.C.R.
1.."Qllege within the meaning of s. 41 of- the Act, it becomes integrated to the university. A constituent college does not retain its former individual character any longer and its minority character is 105t. [198E] (8) Section 5IA of the Act cannot apply to minority institutions. The approval of the Vice Chancelior may be intended to be a check on the a-dministration. The provisions contained ins. 51A (b) cannot be said to be a permissive reg12Jatory measure inasmuch as it confers a.bitrary power on the ViceChancellor to take away the right of administration of the minority institutions. [200CJ (9) The provisions contained in s. 52A cannot apply to minority institutions. Reference to arbitration \Vill introduce an area of litigious controversy inside the educational institutions. The governing body has its domestic Jurisdiction which \Vill be displ<.tCed and a new jurisdiction will be created in the administration. [200D-EJ
i\
y·
'
Ir
Jaganmo!zan Reddv and Alas:iriswanii. JJ. (1) The right under Art. 30 cannot be exercised in vacuo. Nor would it be C right to refer to affiliation or recognition as privileges granted by the State. 1\1eaningful exercise of the right under art. 30(1) would and must necessarily involve recognition of the secular education i'mparted by the minority institutions; without which the right will be a mere husk. This Court has consi!:.>lently struck down ·all attempts to make affiliation or recognition on terms tantamount to surrender of its rights under art. 30( I) as abridging or taking away those rights. Ag·ain, as without affiliation there can be no meaningful exercise of the right under arr. 30(1) the affiliation to be given should be consistent with that right nor can it indirectly try to achieve what it cannot directly do. [21 lE-G] Re. The Kera/a Ed11catio11 Bli! 1957 [1959] S.C.R. 995. State of Kera/a \'. Very Rev. Mother Provincial etc. (1971] 1 S.C.R. 734 aind D.A.V. College etc. v. The State vf Punjab & Ors. [1971] Supp. S.C.R. 688 followed. (2). 1'he only purpose. that the fundan1ental right under Art. 30 ( 1) would sefve would be that minorities might establish their institutions, lay down their own syllabi, provide instructions in the subjects of their choice, conduct exa1ninations and award degrees or diplomas. Such institutions have the right to seek recognition to their degrees and diplomas and ask for aid where ·aid is give1,1 to other educational institutions giving a like education on the basis of the .excellence achieved by them. The State is bound to give recognition to their qualifications and to the institution~ and they cannot be dis:riminated except on the grou.nd of want of excellence in their educational standards so far as recognition of degrees or. educational qualifications is con:erned and \Vant of efficient management so far as aid is concerned. [212E-F] Khanna, /. (I) Clause (I) of Art. 29 and clause (I) of art. 30 deal with distinct matters. It is not permissible to circumscribe or restrict the right conferred by cl. (1) of art. 30 by reading in it any limitation imported from cl. (1) of art 29. Article 29 ( l) confers ai right on any section of citizen'i havini distinct language, script or culture of its own to conserve the san1e. For invoking this clause it is no_t necesesary that the section of citizens should constitute a minority. As against that, the right conferred by art. 30(1) is only upon minorities which are based either on religion or language. Clause (1) of art. 30 contains the words "of 'their choice". These words which qualify "educational institutions" show the vast discretion and option which the minorities have in selecting the type of institutions which they WMlt to establish. In case an educational institution is cstab1ishCd _by a minority to conserve its distinct language, script or culture, the right to establish and administer such institution would fall both under art. 29( 1) as well as under art. 30(1). The right to establish and administer such an institution is guaranteed by art. 30( 1) and the fact that such an institution does not conserve the distinct language, script or culture of a minority \VOtlld not take it out of the ambit of art. 30(1). [238D-H] }l · (2) ·The object of artides 25 to 30 was to preserve the rights of reliiious and linguistic minorities, to place them on_ a secure pedestal and withdraw .them from the vicissitudes of political controversy. _These provisions enshrined a befitting
. _,,,.,,,.J,..,
T"
t
'
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE V. GUJARAT
I
•
•
j
~dge to the minorities in the Constitution of the country whose greatest son ha.d laid down his life for the protection of the minorities .. As long as the Constittjtion stands as it is today, no tampering with those rights can be countenanced. Any attempt to do so would be not only an act of breach of faith, it would be constitutionally impermissible and liable to be struck down by the courts. Although the words secular state are not expressly mentioned in the Constitution, there can be no doubt that our Constitution-makers wanted establishment of such a state. The provisions of the Constitution were designed accordingly. There is no mysticism in the secular character of the state. Secularism is neither antiGod. nor pro-G.od, it treats alike the devout, the agnostic and the atheist. It eliminates God from the matters of the state and ·ensures that no one shall be discriminated against on the ground of religion, [224A-C] The idea of giving some special rights to the minorities is not to have a kind of a privileged or pampered section of the population but to give to the minorities a sense of security and a: feeling of confidence. The great leaders of India since tin1e immemorial had preached the doctrine of tolerance and catholi;ity of outlook. Those noble ideas were. enshrined in the Constitu.tion. S~cial rights for minorities were designed not to create inequality. Their real effect was to bring about equality by ensuring the preservation of the minority institution and by guaranteeing to the minorities autonomy in the matter of the a<lministration of those institutions. The differential treatment for the minorities by giving them special rights is intended to bring about an equilibrium, so that the ideal of equality may not be reduced to a mere abstract idea but should become a living reality and result in true, genuine equality, an equality not merely in theory but also in fact. The majority in a system of adult franchise hardly needs any protection. It can look after itself and protect its interests. Any measure wanted by the majority can without much difficulty be brought on the statute book because the majority can get that done by giving such a mandate to the elected representatives. It is only the minorities who need protection, and Article 30, besides some other articles, is intended to afford and guarantee that protection. [224F-H] (3) It is permissible for the State to prescribe reasonable regulations and make it a condition precedent to the according of recognition or affiliation to a minority institution. It is not, however, permissible to prescribe conditions for recognition or affiliation which have the effect of in1pairing the right or the minority to establish and administer their educational institutions. Affiliation and recognition are not mentioned in Art. 30(1). The position all the same remains that refusal to rccognise or affiliate minority institutions unless the minorities surrender the right to administer those institutions would have the effect of rendering the right guaran~ teed by Art. 30 ( 1) to be wholly illusory and indeed a teasing illusion. An educational institution can hardly serve any purpose or put to any practical utility unless it is affiliated to a University or is otherwise recognised Jike other educational institutions. The right conferred by art. 30 is a real and meaningful right. Article 30(1) was intended to have a- real significance and it is not permissib~e to construe it in such a manner as would rob it of that significance. [240A-C] Re. The Kera/a Education Bill 1957, [1959] S.C.R. 995 referred to. ( 4) The argument that unless law is wholly destructive of the right of minorities under art.30(1) it would not be liable to be struck down is untenable and runs counter to the plain language of art.13. The law which interferes with the n1iniorities' choice of a governing body or management council would be violative of tho right guaranteed by art. 30(1). [241B-C]
Re. Kera/a Education Bill, 1957, [1959] S.C.R. 995, Sidhajbhai Sarabhai v. State n/ Bombay [1963] 3 S.C.R. 837; Rt. Rev Bishop S. K. Patro & Ors. v. Stale of Bihar and Ors. [1970) 1 S.C.R. 172; State of Kera/av. Very Rev. Mother Provincial (1971) 1 S.C.R. 734; D.A.V. College v. State of Punjab [1971] Supp. S.C.R. 688 followed.
(5) Section 33A which provides for a new governing body for the management of the colleg~ and also for selection committees a-s well as the constitution thereof should be quashed so far as the minority educational institutions are concerned lrecause of the contravention of Art. 30(1). [242A-B] (6) The law which interferes with a minority's choice of qualified teachers or its disciplinary control over teachers and other members of the staff of the institution is void as being violative of art. 30(1). [242G] 13-L 131Sup Cl/75
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 1 S.C.R.
Rev. Sid/iajbhai Sabhai & Ors. v. State "! B"mbay & A11r.. [1963) 3 SCR 837; Rev. Father W. Proo.it & Ors. v. The Stata of Bihar & Ors. [1969] 2 SCR 73 and Rt. Rev. Bishop S. K. Patro & Ors. v. State of Bihar & Ors. [1970) 1 SCR 172. . (7) It is permissible for the State and its educational authorities to prescribe .qualifications of teachers, but once teachers possessing the requisite qualificatiom arc selected by the minorities for their educational institutions, the State would. have no right to veto the selection of those teachers. The selection and appoint· ment of teachers for an educational institution is one of the essential ingredients I of the right to manage an educational institution and the minorities can plainly be not denied such right of selection and appointments without infringing art. 30(1). (242G-H] (8) Although disciplinary control over the teachers of a minority educational institution would be with the governing council, regulations can be made for en· suring proper conditions of service of the teachers and for securing a fair pro· cedure in the matter of disciplinary action against the teachers. Such provisions which are calculated to safeguard the interest of teachers would result in i;ecurity of tenure and thus inevitably attract competent persons for the posts of teachers. Regulations made for this purpose should be considered to be in the interest of minority educational institutions and as su:::h they would not violate art. 30( 1). [243E-F] (9) Clause (a) of sub-sections (I) and (2) of s. 51A of tho Act which make provision for giving a reasonable opportunity of showing cause against the penalty to be proposed on a member of the staff of an educational institution is valid. f243GJ (10) Clause (b) of each of the sub-sections of s. 51A should be held to be violative of art. 30 ( l) so far as minority educational institutions are concerned. f244C] Clause (b) of those sub.section which giv'!s a poWer to the Vice·Chancellor and officer of the University autliorised by him to veto the action of the manag· ing body of an educational institution in awarding punishment to a member of tho staff interferes with the d!sciplinary control of the managing body over its teachers. The power conferred by this clause is a blanket pcwer. No guidelines are laid down for the exercise of that power and it is not provided that the ap· J>roval is to be withheld only in case of dismissal, removal, reduction in rank or termination of service is mala fide or by way of victimisation or other similar cause. Conferment of such blanket pC>wer on the Vice-Chancellor or other officer authorised by him for vetoing the disciplinary action of the managing body of an educational institution makes a serious inroad on the right of the managing body to &dminister an educational institution. [244A-B] (II) Section 52A should be held to be violative of art. 30(1) so far as minority educational institutions are concerned. Section 52A is \Videly worded and as it stands it would cover within its ambit every dispute connected with the conditions of service of a member of the staff of an educational institution how· ever trivial or insignificant it n1ay be. 'The effect of this section would be that the R\anaai,ng committee of an educational institution would be embroiled by its cm· ployees in a series of arbitration proceedings. Provisions of thii section would act M a spoke in the wheel of effective administration of an educational insti. tution. What is obj'ectionable in the section is the giving of the power to the ViceChancellor to nominate the umpire. This would cause an inroad in th~ right of the governing body to administer the institution. [244E-F] (12) The concept,of constituent colleges which is visu.alised in ss. 40 and 41 of the Act contemplates that the imparting of teaching at the undergraduate level in the prescribed course of ~tudies shall be only by the teachers of the university. The minority Cplleges as such would not be entitled to impart education in course of study through their own teachers. [2460) (13) Sections 40 and 41 are void in respect of minority educational institution. [245EJ A provision which makes it imperative that teaching in undergraduate courses can be conducted onlv bv the University and can be imoarted onlv by the teachers of the University pta,inly violates rights of minorities to establish and adtni· nister their educational institbtions. Such a provision must consequently he held
•
...
•
,
•
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE V. GUJARAT
qua minority institutions to result in contravention of art. 30( 1). Once s. 46 is • held to be unconstitutional so far as minorities are concerned. the same vice would 8fflict s. 41 because s. 41 can operate on1y if s. 40 survives the attack and ts held lo be not violative of art. 30(1). [245C-£.]
(14) Abridgment of the right of the minorities to establish and.administer
•
educational institutions of their choice is writ large on the face of the impugned
provisions. The fact that no statutes or ordinances have been framed in pursuiµce of the impugned provisions would be hardly of much significance in determining the constitutional validity of the impugned provisions. It would not be a correct approach to wait till statutes arc framed violating the right under art. 30(1 ). [247El Trustees of Ronzan Catholic Separate Schools for Ottawa v. Ouawa Corporation and Ors. [1917] A.C. 76 referred to.
Mathew and Chandrachud. JJ.
( 1) A n1ere look at art. 29( 1) and 30( I) would be sufficient to show that art. 29(1) cannot limit the width of art. 30(1). The right guaranteed to a religious or linguistic minority under art. 30 ( 1) is the right to establish any educational institution of its choice. Whereas art. 29(1) confers the right not only upon a minority as understood in its technical sense but also upon a section of the citizens resident in the territory of India, which may not be a minority in its technical sense, the beneficiary of the right under art. 30 is a minority, either religious or linguistic. Secondly, whereas art. 29 does not deal with education as such, art 30 deals only with the establishment and administration of educational institutions. It might be that in a given case the two might overlap. When a linguistic minority establishes an educational institution to conserve its language, the linguistic minority can invoke the protection of both the articles. When art. 30(1) says that a linguistic minority can establish and administer educational institutions of irs choice, it means that it can establish and administer anv educational institution. If a linguistic minority can establish only an educational institution to conserve its language then the expression "of their :hoice" in art. 30( 1) is pr~tically robb~d
of it meaning.
[251C-E; 250F; 251A-B]
In re: The Kera/a Education Bill, 1957 [1959] S.C.R. 995. 1053; Rev. Fatlte' W. Proost and others v. State of Bihar and Ors. [1969] 2 s.C.R. 73; Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai and Others v. State 1Jf Bo1nbay [19631 3 S.C.R. 837; Rt. Rev. Bishop S. K. Patro and Others v. State of Bihar and Others f1970] 1 S.C.R, 172 and D.A.V. College etc. v. State of Punjab & Ors. [1971] Supp. S.C.R. 683 referred
to.
Dipendra Nath v. State of Bihar A.I.R. 1962 Patna, 101 approved.
(2) (a) Over the years this Court has held that without recognition or affiliation there can be no real meaningful exercise of the right to estarblish and administer educational institutions under art. 30( 1). [256H]
Ill": The Kera/a Education Bill !957, [1959] S.C.R. 995. 1053; Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai and others v. State of Bombay [1963] 3 S.C.R. 837. 856 a:nd D.A.V. College, etc. v. State of Punjab and Ors. [1971] Supp. S.C.R. 688, 709 referred to.
(b) Jn The Kerala Education' Bill this Court pointed out that "no educational institution can in actual practi;;e be carried on without <i<id from the 'tat·"" and if they will not get it unless they surrender their right~. thl!y will, bv comnulsion of financial necessities. be compelled to give up their rights und"'~ art. 30( 1) ." The condition which involves surrender is M effective a det~rrr•nt to the exercise of the right under art. 30( 1) as a direct prohibition would h~ :-tius considered it is apparent that the religious minorily does not voluntarily w~ve its right-it has been coerced because of the basic importance of the privilege
involved, l)amely. allilialion.
[261H; 262A-B]
(e) It is doubtful whether the fundamental right u.nder art. 30(1) can be ba:tered away or surrendered by any voluntary _act or that it can be \Vaived.
• 18 0
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] l S.G.R.
The reason is that the fundamental right is vested in a plurality of persons .as a unit, that is, in a comn1unity of persons necessarily fluctuating. Oin the pre· sent .members of a minority community barter away or surrender the right under the article so as to bind its future members as a unit ? The fundamental right is 'for the living generation. By a voluntary· act of affiliation of an educational institution established and administered by a religious minority the pMt members of the co1nmunity cannot surrender the right of the future members of that
•
commu'nity. The future men1bers of the community do not derive the right under art. 30(1) by su;::cession· or inheritance. '[262C-D]
(d) In fact every one is not being offered the sa·me pa-;kage since the condi· tion serves as a significant restriction on the activities only of those who have the fundamental right of the nature guaranteed by art. 30(1), namely, the religious and linguistic minorities \Vho desire to exercise the right required to be waived as a condition to the receipt of the privilege. It is contradictory to speak of a constitutional right and yet to discriminate against a person who exercises that right. [264B-C] (e) The power to withhold recognition or affiliation altoge:her does not carry with it unlimited power to impose conditions \Vhich have the effect of restraining the exerciSe of fundamental rights. The normal desire to enjoy pri· vi1eges like affiliation or recognition without which the educational institutions established by the minority for imparting secular education will not effectively serve the purpose for which they were established cannot be made an in:stru· ment of st!.ppression of the right guaranteed. Infringement of ai fundamental right is nonetheless infringement because accomplished through the conditioning of a privilege. If ai legislature attaches to a public benefit or privilege an addendum, which in no rational wary advances the purposes of the scheme of benefits but does restrain the exercise of a fundamental right rthe restraint can draw no constitutional strength whatsaiver from its being attached to benefit or privilege but mcst be mea·sured as though it were a wholly separate enactment. [264F-G·J (f) But it cannot be said that by the general laws 'Such as the law of taxa .. tiou, Jaw relating to sanitation etc., the State in any way takes away or abridges the right guaranteed under art. 30 ( 1). Because art. 30( l) is couched in absolute terms, it does not foilow that the right guaranteed is not subject to regulatory laws \Vhich would not an1ount to its abridgment. [265B-CJ
Iludson Country Water Co. v. McCarter, 209 U.S. 349, 355, 357 and Co1n111011. ·wealth of Australia v. Bank of f'lew South Wales. [1950] A.C. 235, 310 referred to (g) Measures which are directed at other forms of activities but which have the secondary or indirect or incidental effect upon tbe right do not generally abridge the right unless content of the right is regulated. [2650) (h) It sounds p~radoxical that a right which the constitution makers wanted to be absolute can be subjected .to· regulations which need only sati"Sfy the nebulous and elastic test of State necessity. The very purpose of incorporating this right in ~art IIf of the Constitution in absolute term<; in marke.d contrast with tbe other fundamental rights wa•J to \Vithdraw it from the reach 0f the majority. To subject t11e right today to regulations dictated by the Protean concept of State necessity as conceived by the majority would be <to suhve1t the very pur. pose for which the right was given. [266E~FJ (i) Recognition or affiliation is a facility which the University grants to an educational institution for the purpose of enabling the students to isit for an exan1ination to be conducted by the University in the prescribed subjects and to obtain the degree conferred by the University and, therefore, it stands to rea.wn to hold that no regulation which is unrelated. to the purpose C<l!Il be imposed. If, h~side recognition Or affiliation an educational institution conducted hy a religious minority is granted aid. further regulations for ensuring that the a·id is utilised for tho~ purpose for which it is granled will be permiss.~lc. The heart of the matter is thait no educational institution established by a religious or linguistic minority can claim total immunity fiom regulations by the legislature or the University if it wants affiliation or recognition; but the character of the permissib~e regulations must depend u.pon their purpose. [267B-D]
.
ii
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE V. GUJARAT
(3) In every case when the reasonableness of a regulation comes up for consideration before the Court, the question to be asked and answered is whether the regulation is calculated to subserve or will in effect subserve the ,purpose of recognition or affiliation namely the exce-llen::e of the institution as a vehicle for general seculaor education of the minority commu.nity and to other persons who resort to it. The question whether a regulation is in general interest of the public h3!s no relevance, if it does not advance the excellence of the institution as a vehi-::le •for general secular education as ex-hypothesi the only pe'fmissible regulations are those whi::h secure the effectiveness of the purpose of the facility namely the excellence of the educational institutions in respect of their educational standards. [267E-F] Sidhajbhai v. State of Bombay, [!963] 3 S.C.R. 837, 856-857; /11 re: The Kera/a Education Bill 1957 [\959] S.C.R. 995, 1953 and Stare of Kera/a v. Mother Provincial [19711 1 S.C.R. 734 referred to.
•
(4) The provisions of sub-section 1 (a) and i(b) of s. 33A abridge the right of the religious minority to administer educational institutions· and therefore their choice. The requirement that the College should have a governing body including persons other than those who constitute the governing body of the sodely of Jesus ha'> the effect of divestihJ that body of its exclu'live right to manage the educational institution. Under the guise of preventing rnaladmihistration, the right of the governing body of the College constituted by the religious minority to administer the institution cannot be taken away. The effect of the provision is that the religious minority virtually loses its right to administer the in;>titution it has founded. [2690-H; 270B] Kerala v. Mother Provincial [1971] 1 S.C.R. 734 at 740, fV. Proost v. Biliar' [1969] 2 S.C.R. 73 •t 77-78 and Rev. Bisho,p S. K. Patro v. Bihm· [1970] 1 S.C.R 172.
JI
(5) It is u.pon the principal and teachers of a ccl1ege that the tone and temper of an educational institution depend. On them would depend its reputation, the maintenance of dis•::ipline and its efficiency in teaching. The right to ~hoose a principal and to have the teaching conducted by teachers appointed by the management after an overall assessrnent of their outlook and philosophy is perhaps the most important fact of the right to administer an educational institution. There is no reason why a representative of the University nominated by the Vice Chancellor should be on the 5election Committee far recruiting the principal or for the insistence of the head of the department besides the representative of the University being on the Selection Committee for recruiting the men1bers of the teaching staff. So long as the persons chosen have the qualifications prescribed by the University, the choice must be left to the management. [270G-HJ
.<?) On. the .Pl.ai~ wording <?f s. · 40 it is clear that the governing body of th~ religious minonty will be depnved of the most vital function which a::ipertains t? its ~ight to administer t~ co.llege, namely, the teaching, tr3.illing and instruct1oni; 1n the ~ou.r:se of studies 1n respect o_f which the University is competent to _hold e~a~1na.t1ons. ~e fun?amental i:ight of a minority to administer edU· cattonal inst1t?t1ons of t~s. cho1~e ~ompnses with it the elementary right to ~on~uc~ teaching, t~e tra1n1ng and instruction in courses of studies in the 1?Stltutions so established by teachers apJXJinted by the minority. If this essential. compon~_nt of th~ rig~t of administration is taken away from the minority a-nd veste~ 1n t~e ~1nryers1ty there can be no doubt thait its right to administer the educational 1nst1tution guaranteed under art. 30(1) is taken away. [271G·H] ._(7)_ If~· 40 is ultra vires art. 30(1) s. 41 which, in the present scheme of leg1slat1on is dependent upon s. 40 cannot survive. f272D] (8) The provisions contained in sub-clause (l)(b) and (Z)(b) of s. 51A are v1olat1ve of the r~ght under art. 30. The relationship between the management and. a teacher ts that of an employer and employee, and it pooses one's understanding that the ma~a,gement cannot terminate the services of a teadler
1 S2
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1975) ] S.C.R.
on the basis of the contract of employment. To require that for terminating the sen·ices of a teacher after an enquiry has been conducted the management should have the approval of an outside agency like the Vice-Ch3incellor or of his nominee ~·ould be an abridgement of its right to administer the educational institution. There. is no obligaition under sub-sections l(b) and Z(b) that the Vi~-Chancellor or his non1inee should give any reasons for disapproval. A blanket power wjthou.t any guidelines to disapprove the action of the management would certainly encroach upon the right of the management to dismiss or terminate the services of a teacher after an enquiry. [273F; 273C-E] (9) Section 52A is bad in its application to minorities. The provision cont•ined in this section subscrves no propose and there is no doubt that it will needlessly interfere with the day to day mamagement of the institution. Every petty dispute raised by a member of the teaching or non-teaching staff will be referred to arbitration if it seems to touch the service conditions. Arbitrations, not imparting cduc<ttion. will become the business of the educational institutions. [274-B] BEG, J. (1) Although articles,29 and 30 may supplement each other so far as certain rights of minorities are concerned yet, article 29 of the Constitution does not, in any way, impose .ai limit on the kind or character of education which a minority may chose to impart throu.gh its institution to the ::hildren of its own members or to others who may choose to send their children to its schools. [274E-F] (2) Even if article 30(1) of the Constitution is held to confer absolute and unfettered rights of management upon minority institutions, subject only to absolutely minimal and negative control~ in the interests of he~th and law and order, it could not be meant t9 exclude a greater degree of. regullltion aind control when a minority institution enrets the wider sphere of general secular and non-denominational education, largely employs teachers who are not members of the particular minority concerned and when it derives large parts of its income from fees paid by those who are not menlbers of the particular minority in question. Such greater degree of control could be justified by the need to secure the interest of those who are affected by the management of the minority institution .and the education it imparts but who are not members of the minority in management. , Where a minority institution has, of its own free will, opted for a.ffiliation under the tenns of a statute. it must be deemed to have chosen to give up, ru; a price for the benefits resulting from affiliaition, the exercise of certain rights which may, in another context, appear to be unwar.. ranted impairments of its fundamental rights. If the obje;:t of an enactment is to compel a minority institution, even indirectly, to give up :the exercise of its fundamental rights the provisions which have this effect will be void or inoper'ktive against a minority institi.!ltion. The price of affiliation cannot be a total abandonment of the right to establish and administer a minority institution conferred by article 30(1) of the Constitution. [29IH; 275D-E] (3) Affiliation being only a statutory and not a fundamental right of the minority under article 30(1) of the Constitution the right under this artio1e cannot be said to be violated unless and until it is shown •that application of the College for a-utonomy has been or is bound to b~ rejected. Compelling the co1lege to become a constituent part of the University amounts to taking away of .}ts separa:te, identity by the force of law. But if the College bas really attained such standards of organisation and excelleµce as it claims to have done, it can have :ln autonomous status under s. 38B of the A·(.".t with all its advantages and freedoms practi~ally for the asking. [277H] (4) In as mu.ch as s. 5 of the Act has a compelling effe;:t by denying to the petitioning college the option to keep out of the statute altogether, the section would be inoperative against it. Section 5 ( 1) has the effect of compelling a college to abandon its fundamental rights guaranteed by article 30( 1) of the iConstitution as a price for affiliation by the Gujarat University because it is not permitted to affiliate with any other University without the sanction of the Government. [277A; 276G] (5) The only provisions which could have a compulsive effect against the petitioning college cou'ld be s. 5 and then sections 40 and 41 which would aotontatically convert affiliated colleges into constituent colleges of the University,
,
.
,
ST. XAYIERS COLLl!GI! v. GUJARAT
•
'
'vithout the interposition of an option, and, therefore, could be said to deprive the petitioning co1Iege of the opportunity to become an autonomous :::o lege. Provisions of s. 40 and the remaining provisions of sec. 41 of the Act are all parts of the same compulsive scheme or mechanism which is struck by article 30(1). Section 41 (I) operates even more directly upon the petitioning college. which !rad been "admitted to the privileges of the University" under s.5 ( 3) by affiliation. This provision would have the compelling effect of maling it auto~ matically a constituent unit of the University, and n1ust, therefore, be held to be inoperative again~t the petitioning college as it cannot affect the fundamental rights guaranteed by article 30(1) of the Constitution. [27BD-B; 277B] (6) Section 41 of the Act, as it stands, could have' the effect of negativating the right conferred by s.38B of the Act by transforming, mechanically and by operation of the statute affiliated colleges into constituent colleges so that no question of autonomy could practi<ally arise after that. [278B]
(7) On the claims put forward by the petitioning colleg~ it appears very likely that the college will get the benefit of s.38B of the Act and therefore 'Will escape from the consequences of affiliation found in the impugned sectiorui. Jt is true that section 38B of the Act imposes certain conditions which, the college will have no difficulty in satisfying. In any case until its application for autonomous status is rejected, it could not reasonably complain that the other provisions of the Act. apart from section 5, 40 and 41, will be u.sed against it. [288D-E]
(8) The essence of the right guaranteed by article 30(1) of the Con•titution free exer:::ise of their choice by minority institutions of the part.tern of education as well as of the administration of their educational institutions. Both these taken together, determine the kind or character of an educational institution which a minority has the right to choose. Where these patterns are accepted voluntarrily by a minority institution itself, the requirement to observe these patterns would not be a real violation of rights protected by article 30(1). In a case in which the pattern is accepted voluntarily by a minority institution with a view to taking advantage of the benefits conferred by a statute. it cannot insist upon an absolutely free exercise of the right of administration. No doubt, the rights protected by a•rticle 30(1) are laid down in "absolute" terms without the kind of express restrictions found in articles 19, 25 and 26 of the Constiiution. But, if a minority institution has the option open to it of a\·oiding the statutory restrictions altogether, if it abandons with it. benefits of a statutory right, there is no reason why the absoluteness of the right under article 30(1) of the Coootitution is taken away or abridged. [280B-F] ~ a
-
(9) It is only when the terms of the statute ne.:essarily compel a minority i&titution to abandon the t:ore of its right'S under article 30 ( 1) that it could amount to taking away or abridgement of a fundamental right within the meaning of article 13(2) of the Constitution. [280-H] (10) The mere presence of the representatives of the Vicc-Chance11or tho teachers, members of the non-tea<:hing staff and the students of the CoJlege required by !. 33A, would not impinge upon the right to administer. Such a 0 '!1prinkIing'' is more likely to help to make that administration more effective and aruptable to everyone affected by· it. A minority institution can still have its majority on the governing body, [281D-E] ( 11) The provision! of s. 3 IA do net ccnstitu.te an unreasonable encroac}l.. ment on the essence of rights ot a minority insiitution protected by art 30( 1) of the Constitution which consists of freedom of .choice. Section 52A d~ not constitute an infringement of .the special minority rights under article 30( t) of tbe Constitution. [281-H] ·
'
Rt. Kuala Education Bill, 1957, [1959] S.C.R. 995; Rev. Sidhra;bhai Sabh•i le Or1. v. Staie of Bombay & Anr., [1963] 3 $.C.R. 837: Rev, Fathtr W. Proost ~ OTJ. v. The State of Biluir & 079. [1969] 2 S.C.R. 73; Rt. Rev. Bishop S. X. Patro & 079. v. Statt of Bihar & Ors_ [1970] I S.C.R. 172 and State 6f
18 4
to
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 1 S.C.R.
Kera/a etc. v. Very Rev. Mother Provincial etc., [1971] f S.C.R. 734 referred
IlwivEDI J. (!) The content of the right under art. 29(1) differs from the content of the right under Art. 30(1). Article 29(1) secures the right of a section o_f citizens having distinct script, language, or culture to conserve the same. Article 30( 1) on the other hand guarantees the right of a religious or linguistic minority to establish and administer educational institutions. Article 29(1) gives security to an interest : article 3()(1) gives security to an activity. [293 ])-El
(2) Article 30( 1) does not, in express or implied terms, limit the right of the minorities to establish an educational institution of a particular type. The right to establish an educaitional institution impliedly grants two kinds of choices. The minorities have a right to establish or not to establish any particular type of educational institution. This is the negative choice. The minorities, may establish any type of educational institution. This is the positive choice. Choice is inherent in every freedom. Freedom without choice is no freedom. So the words "of their choice'' mefely make patent what is latent in art. 30(1). Th6se words are not intended to enlarge the area of choice already implied in the right conferred by art. 30(1). [293 H, 294 A-BJ
•
C
or
- (3) Right affiliation: There is not express grant of the right of affiliation in art. 30 !). It is also not necessarily implied in art. 30(1). If the constitution framers intended to elevate the right of affiliation to the=status of a fundamental right they could have easily expressed their intention in c,ear words in irt. 30. As our State is secular in character, affiliation of an institution imparting religious instruction or teaching only theology of a particular religious minority may not comport \l(ith the secular character of the State. As art. 30( 1) does not grant right of affiliation 10 such an institution it cannot confer that right on an institution imparting secular general education. The content of the right under art. 30 (I) must be the same for both kinds of insti. tutions. [294 E-H]
In re. The Kera/a Education Bill [1959] S.C.R. 995 at pp. 1076-1077. · (4) Affiliatinf! University: Since art. 30(1) does not grant the right of
affiliation the State fa not under an obligation to have an affiliating university. It is ope~ to a State to establish only a teaching university. [296A] (5) A glance at the context and s:heme of Part Ill of the constitution would show th3't the constitution makers did not intend to confer absolute ri~ on a religious or linguistic minority to establish and administer educational institutions. It is true that art 30( 1) is expressed in spacious and unqualified language. And so is art. 14. However, this Court has read the limitation tb classificatoin in the general and unrestricted language of art. 14. The "liberty recognised in the Fir§t Amendment to the U.S.A. Constitution and the freedom of trade, commerce and intercourse expressed in s. 92 of the Australian Constitution, both of which are expressed in-absolute terms, are held to be subject to regu'ation. These ins~ances should be sufficient to explode the argument of absolute or near-absolute right to establish and adininister an educational insti. tution by a religious or linguistic minority from the absolute words of art. 30(1). Absolute words do not confer absolute rights, for the generality of the words may have been cut down by the context and the s:heme of the statute or the constitution as the case may be. [298 E; 2960; 298C] State of West Bengal v. Anwar Ali Sarkar [1952] S.C.R. 284 at P. 295, Charanft Lal v. Union of India [1950] S.C.R. 869 at p. 890, Ka/Jri Raning Rawat v. State of Saurashtra [1952] s:C.R 435 at p. 442, Cantwell v. Connie.. lieut (310) U.S. 296 at pp. 303-304, 95 Law Edn. 1137 at p. 1160. W.S.A. Waynes: Legfa:lative_ Executive and Judicial Powers in Austra 1ia. 2nd Edn: p. 339 and Commonwealth of Australia and others v. Bank of /\,rew South Walts and others [1950] Appeal i;ases 235. (6) Articles 29(2), 15(4) and 28(3) place certain express limitations on the right in art. 30(1). There are also certain implied limitation-; on this right. The right should be read subject to those implied limitations. [299C]
..
,, II
y
18 5
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE V. GUJARAT
(7) Part III of the Constitution confers certain rights on individuals, on £fOUps and on certain minority groups.
Those rights constitute a single, indivisib e balancing System of liberty in our Constitution. The system implies orde:- and harmony rumong the various rights constituting our liberty according
to the necessities of each case..
•
Obviously, the ri2h·s could never have been
intended by the constitution makers to be in collision with one another. According'y, the right in art. 30(1) cannot be so exercised as to violate a citizen's legal or constitutional rights. It is impossible for the liberty of ai civilised community to _have absolute rights. Some regulation of rights is necessary for Clue enjoyment by every member of the society of his O\Vn rights. [2990; 300 B; DE] (8) Extent of regulatory power: The extent of regulatory power of the State wou d vary according to various types of educational institutions established by religious and linguistic minorities. It may vai:y from class to dass a;; well as within a class. No minority educational institution can be singled out for treatment different from one meted out to the majotity edu::ntional institution. A regulation meeting out such a discriminatory treatment will be obnoxious to art. 30(1). [301 H; 302 DJ (9) The test of a valid regulation is its necessity. Any regulaition which does not go beyond what is nece5'5ary for protecting the interests of the society (which includes the minorities a11 so) or the rights of the individual member:; of the society should be constitutionally valid It cannot be said ~hat such a regulation takes away or abridges the rights conferred by art. 30(1). [302 E·F] •
(10) No hard and fast rule .can be prescribed for determining what is neoesThe question should be examined in the light of the impugned provision~ and the facts and circumstances of each case. Whttt is required is that the impugned Jay,· should seek to establish a reasonable balance between the right regulated and the social interest or the individual right protected. The court should balance in the scale the value of the right regulated and the value of the social interC":?t or the individual right protected. While balan:ing these competing interests. the Court should give due weight to the legislative judg· m~nt. Like the Court, the Legislature ha:s also taken the oath to uphold the Constitution. It is as much the protector of the liberty and welfare of the people as the Court. It is more informed than the Court about the pressing necessities of the Government and the needs pf the community. [302 G-H]
s~ry.
State of West Bengal v. Anwar Ali Sarkar [1952) S.C.R. 284 at p, 303 per
Das J
( 11) It is difficult to accept the argument that a regulation, in order to be always be shown to be ca.lculated to improve th., ex:cellen...~ of the minority educational institutions.. Th~ State prescri.bes the curriculum and syllabu~ as much from the point of view of excellence of instruction a,:; from the point of view of having a uniform standard of instruction. [303 B-CJ (12) Nor should the regulatory power be hamstrung by such concepts as "real and effective exercise of the right", should not be touched by the regulation or that regul~tion should not "directly and immediately'' impinge on the right conferred by art. 30(1). What is. a real and effective exercise of the right will depend on how far the impugned regulatiOJ?- is necessa-ry in. the co.n1ext of time place and circum!'itances for safeguarding any compe•1ng social interest or ;ny competing constitutional or legal right of an individu::i.1. [303, G-IIJ I~ constitu~iona\ must
•
Rev. Suthalbhai Sabhai and others v. State of Boml>ay [1963] 3 S.C.R. 817 at v. 850 referred to.
(13) The right under art. 30(1) forms part of a complex and interdependent group of diverse social interests. There cannot be a perpetually. fixed adjustment pf -the right and those social interests. Th.ey would need adjustment and readjustment from time to time and in varyifl:2 circumstances. [305 HJ
Section 33A (I) (a) is obnoxious to art. 30(1).
(307 El
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
{1975] l s.c.a.
(14) Since the right of affiliation is not a fundamental right g'1aranteed by art. 30( 1) there is no difficulty in the University t~king over the teaching in under-graduate cl~ses. No -iegitimate objection can be taken to sub-s.(1) ·of 9. 41. The mere circumstance that an affiliated college is made a constituent college of the university would not nece,ssarily offend art. 30( 1). The definition of the expression 'constituent college' by itself is innocuous. The concept of a constituent colJege is fluid. It ls the d~gre,e of external control ovir the administration of ~ minority college and DQt i!s statutory name that is relevant for tbe purposes of art. 30( I). [308 A-Cf
t.
y
(15) Sub-section (3) of s. 41 cannot also be objected to. It permits an affiliated college which does not want to be a constitueI,It college to get affiliated
to another university with the permission of the State and the Guja'fat University. [308 El (16) Even assuming for the sake of argument that .clauses (ii) to (vi) <1f sub-s. 4 of s-. 41 are violative of art. 30(1) the petitioners stand to j!;ain nothing thereby for no legitimate objection can be advanced against the first part of sub-section (4). Unless statutes are actually made the constitutional attack is premature. [309 A]
( 17) No legitimate objection can be taken to the first part of 5ub-scctions (I) and (2) of s. SIA. As the power of approval is confined to cbeckin~ the abn.se of the right to fire emp~oyees, it does not offend art. 30(1). The power of approval by the Vice-Chancellor is necessary in the interest of the security of service of the teaching and nop_-teaching staff. Security of service is ne~s-ary to promote efficiency and honest discharge of duty. It is calculated 1o improve the institution in the long run. Section 51A provides a cheaper and expeditious remedy to the staff for the redress of their grievances. [310 F] (18) It is difficult to discover any legitimate objection to s. 52A on the ba~s of art. 30( 1). This provision is intended to check the abuse of power of administration by the managing body and to provide a cheap and expeditious remedy to the small pursed teaching and non~teaching staff. l t is necessary in the interest of security of service. [311 CJ
C
•
Arguments for the petitioners : (I) The law declared by the Supreme Court has been the law of the Ia.nd since India becaJ!le a Republic. Minorities and educational institur:ons heve adapted themselves on the basis of the law so declared. The variom High Courts in India have also laid down the law on the same basis. The question of minority rights is a very- sensitive and delicate one and there are no compelling or coercive considerations which would justify this Court in over-ruling its previous decisions and reducing the content of the right given to the minorities.
(2) Jn the objectives resolutions passed unanimously by the c_onstituent assembly it was declared that adequate. s~eguards sho!J~d be proVIded f~r minorities in the Constitution. The mu~onty c?mmun1h~s gave up theu demand for political rights and we~e satisfied ~1tp. the nght. to p~ofe.ss .and practice their religion and to establish and adm1mster educationa_l insi;itutions of their choice. Articles 26, 29 and 30 were, therefo_re, embodied in _the Con!titution for guaranteeing these rights to. minorities. (Re. Kerala E1_u_:ati°1d Bill 1959 SCR 995). The histori:aI genes1~ and .constitutional bacA&'otlll RHMt at all times be remembered in construing article 30.
(3) Articles 29 and 30 of the Constitution co~er se~~rate and distinct rights viz. ( 1) the right of any section ~f the resident citizens ~o co115Cr:u itt! own language, script or culture [artic.le 290)1 (2), .the nght ~ religious and linguistic minorities to ~tabhsh and ~dm1n1ster ~ucat!4 imtiutions of their choice [Article 30(1)]; (3) the nght of an •. ucauona t·mtitutiofl not to be discriminated against in the !D.atter of ;Sta~ !lld <?D rityt)>o a-round that it is under the management of a reh11ous or Itngu.lSticadm~~..: [Article 30(2)]; llDd (4) the right of the citizen not to be denied =-"''
t
~ ..
• •
18 7
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE V. GUJARAT
• ll
•
•
into any State-maintained or state-aided. -educational institution on tho ground of religion, caste, race or language [Article 29(2)].
Article 30( l) cannot be whittled down by reading it along with article 29(1). The differences between article 30(1) and 29(1) are unn1tstakable : while article 29 confers the fundamental right to .. any section of the citizens" which would include the majority section. Article 30(1) confers the right only on minorities, While article 29( 1) is concerned with. ·'.language, script or culture", article 30( 1) deals with divisions of t?e nation based on ''religion or language"; while articl~ 29fl) is concerned With.· the right to consefve language, script or culture article 30(1) deals with the right to establish and administer ''edu;;ational institutions" of the minorities' own choice The word "administer'' is a word of very wide import. The other key ~vords are ''of their choice''. The minorities' ri&ht to admi~ter must necessarily include (i) the right to choose its man.ag~ng or governmg body; (ii) the right not to be compelled to refuse. admission ~ studen.ts; (iii) the right to choose its teachers; and (4) the nght to use its properties :ind assets for the benefit of its own institution. Although the minority institutions can claim the protection under Article 30· the_re are certain activities which cannot possibly be considered educational as for example a school of pick-pockets or where subversive or criminal activities are taught. Such institutions cannot invoke the protection of 1'i.rticle 30 because they are not imparting education at all. Though the freedom under Article 30 is unqualified in terms, it is not free from regulations. There can be no absolutes in a community governed by law. Accordingly an educational institution must comply with the laws like municipal taVi>-s regarding construction and maintenance. of buildings. labour laws, tax laws and so on. Under article 30 the permissible regulatory measures are those which do not restrict the right of administration to facilitate it and ensure better and more effective exercise of the right for the benefit of the institution and tbrough the instrumentality of the management of the ~~uca tional institutions, but without displacing the management. If ~e adnunts~a tion has to be improved it must be through the agency or instrumentality of the existing: management and not by displacing it. Restrictions on the right of administration imposed in the interest of the general public alone and not in the interest of and for the benefit of minority educational institutions are permissible. There is a fundamental distinction between restriction on the right of administration and a regulation prescribing the manner of administration. The right of a~ministratiol!- n;eai;is the right to effectively manage and' cpnduct the affa1rs of the institutions. It postulates autonomy in administration. T?e rig!J.t of. ad.mi~istration means the right to conduct and m ina,i;e the affatrs of the institution _through a Committee or body of persons in ~horn the manage~ent have fa~th. and confidence and who have full autonomy in tha! sphere sub1ect ~o permissible regulatory measures, the right to impart e~ucation . through on~ s own teachers having regard to their compatability \V1t? the _1de~ls . and aims, aspirations and traditions of the institution Educational institutions do not want a teacher who though brilliant ·but is cantanker~us or quarrelsome or who is antipathetic to the creed and beliefs aod . -practices of the religious minority. The right includes the ri&ht to aWn~t st~dents of the~r choice subject to reac;onable regulations about academic qualificaho!li. The nght to ~elec~ and appoint one's own teachers ;.::.d. nriali· pa.1, the nght to enforce dIScipltne by exercising , control and supervision Oller the ~eachers. Any act or measure which prevents the effective and rtal exercise ?f .a. fundamen1!11. right amounts to violation of that riaht. There.fore to ms1st upon affiliation on terms and conditions which rcatrict the nght of administration is violative of Article 30( 1).
~4) The wording of articl"6 29(1) and 30(1) does not support the contention that the latter article will apply only to educatiollll! l!lltitutlon• established by a minority community for the sole purpose of conserving ii$
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 1 S.C.R.
distinct language or script or culture. The words used in article 29(1) are :'any section of the c!tizens having a distinct language, .script or culture of tts ·own". Tbe words used in article 30( 1) are "minorities, whether based '°n religio_n or language.'' There is no reference to religion in articles 29(1); ~n article 30 ( 1) the reference is only to religion <ind language and there is no reference to culture. So far as the Christians in India are concerned they do not claim to have a culture of their own. Their culture is the culture of India. But they are a minority based on religion to whom .article 30(1) will apply. To insist that the minorities should surrender their fundamental right as a condition for getting recognition or aid from the State is to make the right unreal and illusory. To give recognition and aid to institutions of the majority community and to refuse them to those of the minorities on the ground that they refuse to surrender their fundamental right under the Constitution is in e.ffect discrimination within the meaning of a.rticle 30(2). Under the Constitution only the minorities have been given the fundamental right to establish and adininister educational institu,tion of their choice. The majority community has not got the right. It is the creation of power that is subject to objection and not its exercise. Reasonable manner of administration of statutes is irrelevant in considering -" its constitutionality. The. effect. of sections 41 a!1d 42 of the Amendment Act is that teaching and tra1ru~g 10 the colleg~s wdl be conducted by the University and private -colleges will become constituent colleges of the University which means that the minority colleges will Jose their minority character completely. The relations of the constituent colleges \vill be governed by the statutes made 'by the University. The right to administer means the right to effectively mafl:age and conduct the affairs_ of the institution. It postulates autonomy in ,administration. Sections 51 and 52 of the Amending Act have the effect of destroying · the educational agencies' disciplinary control over the teaching and nonteaching staff Of the college. No punishment can be inflicted by_ the management on a member of the staff unless it gets approval of the ViccChancellor or an officer authorised by him. A provision for compulsory arOitration of disputes will make it difficult for the management to have .effective disciplinary control over the staff. [D.A. V. College v. State of Punjab A.l.R. 1971 S.C. 737.J There could be no objection to make the rights of members of the staff justiciable but it will be an infringement of the right -0f administration if an outside body is made the fin1l a·Jthor"ty for determining all questions relating to disciplinary conyol over the members of the staff.
•
Arguments for the respondents:
Article 30( I) is to be interpreted not in isolation but in the context of ihe Constitution, particularly its id~al of a secular State and its object to preserve and strengthen the integrity and unity of the country. Freedom, which may be expressed in absolute terms in the Constitution, is not inconsistent with regulatory measures in an orderly society in the interest of the society, In the matter of any educational institution s·eeking affiliation to a University. regulatory measures in the interest of the general secular cduca,tion must necessarily relate to the management as a. ~hole of such edu~ational institution that is, the character and compos1hon of the governing body, the quality' of the tea.::hing staff. the security of it·s renure and dis~ipline in the educational institution. The regulatory measures must necessarily be uniformly applicable to al~ _educational. instit~tiOJ.lS ?nd cannot .be dis.cri,1;11-in~tory. "The right to administer educational institutions of their choice . tn article 30(1) which includes the right to imp:u:t gene~al secular.. education must therefore be limited by regulatory measures. Article 30( I) cannot ~ invoked where "the eduCation imparted is ~ecula! and of ~ .general or special .character. This article does not con~er ~ny nght o_r. pnyllege_ g_reater ti?-~ ,0 r superior to that enjoyed by any hngu1shc or rehg1ous maJOnty. Article
__ •._
~·
•
ST. XAYIERS COLLEGE V. GUJAMT
r,
30( 1) must be read along with other cognate prov1s10n$ viz., articles 30(2), 15, 26 and. 29 and particularly article 30(2) and 25(2)(a). There is no fundamental right of minority institutions to insist an affiliation by a University. A minority institution is _bound by the general law relating t• affiliation as any other minority or maiority institution based on language or religion. The provisions of sections 33A, 40, 41, 51A and 52A as also the impugned ordinances are not destructive of any fundamental right of the petitioners. They are only regulatory in nat_ure and im~ose only such restrictions as are indicated above. They are vahd and effective. No fundamental _right is absolute and claims based on ariy one right may be subject to qualifications in accordance with the claims based on other rights.
.
18 9
[)
.
Due regafd should be had to the Directive principles contained in articles 41, 45, 46 and 38 for securing which education is an essential 1and poweriul instrument. The right to administer a minority educational institution was not conceived to be unfettered and absolute. Administration can be carried on in accordance with the general law of the land. The object of administration of a minority educational institution is two fold.:., (1) the conservation of culture including religion, language and script (ii) to ensure that their children receive' general education also so that they could go into the world \veil and sufficiently equipped with the qualifications necessary for a l,<;eful carrer in 1if·.:! (Re Keral& Education Bill 1957). Therefore, a law which would impede the achievement of any of these twin objects of the minority would be invalid as violative of article 30( 1). Subject to these qualification the administration can be carried on in accordance with the law. The provisions of .the Gujarat Act were intended to improve the general education as also to guarantee security of tenure to the teachers . Security of the servjce is not merely intended to protect the teachers against exploitation but is intended to ensure academic freedom, l\iianagement-t~acher relations have to be understood in proper canvass than -mere en1ployere.tnployee relationship.
Writ Petition No. 232 and 233 of 1973. (Petitions Under Article 32 of the Constitution of India.) N. A. Palkhiwala, I. M. Nanavati, Sudhir Nanavati, A. Natrai, 'l. B. Dadachanji, P. C. Bhartari, 0. C. Mathur and Ravinder Narain for the Petitioners. F. S. Nariman, Add!. Sol. General of India, R H. Dhebar and S. P. Nayar for Respondent No. 1. ORIGINAL JURISDICTION:
S. T. Desai, S. N. Shelat and S. R. Agarwal for respondent No. 2. N. A. Palkhiwala, !. B. Dadachanji, A.G. Menesses, P. C. Bhartari, S. Swarup, 0. C. Mathur and Ravbzder Narain for Intervener Nos. 1, 9, and 10.
..
So!i J. Sorabjee, J. B. Dadachanji, P. C. Bhartari, S. Swaruo, o.
C. Mathur and Ravinder Narain for Intervener Nos. 2, 6, 7-8. · I. M. Nanavati, !. B. Dadachanji, 0. C. Mathur and Narain and P. C. Bhartari for Intervener Nos. 3 and 5.
Ravinder
Frank Anthony, !. B. Dadachanji, P. C. Bhartari, S. Swarup, O. C. Mathur and Ravinder Narain for Intervener No. 4.
Nirei1 De, Attorney General for India, S. P. Nayar for Intervener No. 11 (In WP No. 232/73). Dr. V. A. Seiyad Mohammed and K. M. K. Nair for No. 12 (In WP 232/73).
Intervener
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 1 S.C.R.
0. N. Tikku, Advocate General for the State of J & K and Vineet Kumar for Intervener No. 13. M. C. Setalvad, K. C. Agarwal, A. T. M. Sampath, M. M. L. .Srivastava, E. C. Agarwala for Intervener No. 14. Hardev Singh and R. S. Sodhi for Intervener No. 15. Joseph Vithayathil and E. C. Agarwala for Intervener No. 16. Naunit Lal and Miss Lalita Kohli for Intervener No. 17 (In WP. 232/73) and Intervener No. ·5 (In WP. 233/73). E. C. Agarwala and Danial A. Latifi fqr Intervener No. 18, 20, .to 43 and 50-52. Mrs. Scheherazade Alam, M. Qamaruddin and E. C. Agarwala for .Intervener No. 19. Haroo Bhai and J. Ramamurthi for Intervener No. 44. M. K. Ramamurthi, Haroo Bhai and J. Ramamurthi for Intervener No. 45. B. P. Maheshwari, C. L. Joseph and Suresh Sethi for Intervener No. 46. D. Gobardhan for Intervener No. 47. F. S. Nariman Addi. Sol. Gen. of India (for Intervener No. 48) .and M. N. Shroff for Intervener Nos. 48-49 (In WP. No. 233 of 1973). V. M. Tarkunde, Joseph Vithayathil, K. C. Agarwala, A.T.M. Sampath, P. C. Chandi, M. M. L. Srivastava and E. C. Agarwa/a for .the Intervener No. 53 (In WP. 233/73). The following Judgments were delivered by R:AY, C.J. The question for consideration is wheth~r the minorities tiased on religion or l'anguage have the right to establish and administer .educational institutions for imparting general secular education within the meaning of Article 30 of the Constitution. The minority institutions which are in truth and reality educational institutions where education in its various aspects is imparted claim protection of Article 3 0. This raises the question at the threshold whether Articles 30( 1) .and 29 (1) of the Constitution are mutually exclusive. Articles 29 and 30 of the Constitution are grouped under the heading "Cultural and educational rights". Article 29(1) deals with right of any section of the citizens residing in India to preserve their language, script or culture. Article 30(1) provides th"t all religious and linguistic- minorities have the ~ight to. establish and a~n_iinist_er ~duca tional institutions of their chmce. Article 29(2) proh1b1ts d1scnmmation in matters of admission into educational institutions of the types mentioned therein on grounds only of religion, race, c~ste, lang~rng~ ~r any of them. Article 30(2) p:eve.nts.Stat_es from.mak~ng any dmcnm1nation against any educat10nal ms!Itut10n m grantmg md on the grou11d that it is managed by a religious or linguistic minority.
. y '
C
•
•
,,
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Ray, C.J.)
Articles 29 and 30 confer four distinct rights. First is the right of any section of the resident citizens to conserve its own language, script or culture as mentioned in Article 29(1). Second is the right of all religious and linguistic minorities to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice as mentioned in Article 30( 1). Third is the right of an educational institution not to be discriminated against in the matter of State aid on the ground that it is under the managem>nt of a religious or linguistic minority as mentioned in Article 30(2). Fourth is the right of the citizen not to be denied admission into any State maintained or State aided educational institution on the ground of religion, caste, race or language, as mentioned in Article 29(2).
"'' •· .B
•
It will be wrong to react Article 30( 1) as restricting the right of minorities to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice only to cases where such institutions are concerned with language, script or culture of the minorities. The reasons are these. First, Article 29 confers the fundamental right on any section of the citizens which will include the majority section whereas Article 30(1) confers the right on all minorities. Second, Article 29 (1) is concerned with language, script or culture, whereas Article 30(1) deals with minorities of the nation based on religion or language. Third, Article 29( 1) is concerned with the right to conserve language, script or culture, whereas Article 30( 1) deals with the right to establish and administer educational institutions of the minorities of their choice. Fourth, the conservation of language, script or culture under Article 29 ( 1) may be by means wholly unconnected with educational institutions and similarly establishment and administration of educational institutions by a minority under Article 30(1) may be unconnected with any motive to conserve language, script or culture. A minority may administer an institution for religious education which is wholly unconnected with any question of conserving a language, script or culture.
If the scope of Article 30( 1) is to establish and administer educational institutions to conserve language, script or culture of minorities, it will render Article 30 redundant. If rights under Articles 29 ( 1 ) and 30( 1) are the same then the consequence will be that any section of citizens not necessarily linguistic or religious minorities will have the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. The scope of Article 30 rests on linguistic or religious minorities and no other section of citizens of India has such a right.
..
The right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice has been conferred on religious and linguistic minorities so that the majority who can always have their rights by having prop;:r fegislation do not pass a legislation prohibiting minorities to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. If the scope of Article 30(1) is made an extension of the right und·cr Article 29(1) as the right to establish and administer educational institutions for giving religious instruction or for imparting education in their religious teachings or tenets the fundamental right of minorities to establish and administer educational institution of their choice will be taken away.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] l S.C.R.
. Ev~ry section of t~~ pnbJ.ic, the majority as well as minority has A r!ghts ~n respect of rehg10n as contemplated in Articles 25 and 26 and rights m respect of language, script, culture as contemplated iu Article :?.9. The whole object of conferring the right on minorities under Article 3~ is :o ensure that. ther~ will be equality between the majority and the mmonty. If the mtnonties do not have such special protection they will be denied equality. In Re. The Kera/a Education Bill 1957 [1959] ·S.C.R. 995 this B C-:iurt said that Article 30( 1) covers institutions imparting general seen· !ar education. The object of Article 30 is to enable children of mino· rities to go out in the world fully equipped. All p~rsons whether in the majority or in the minority have the right under Article 25 freely to profess, practise and propagate religion. Any section of citizens which includes the majority ~s well as the minority shall have under Article c 29 the right to conserve their distinct language, script or culture. That is why the minorities are given a specific right in respect of educational institutions under Article 30. Article 30(1) gives the right to linguis· tic minorities as well where no question of religion aris-es. It is, therefore, not at all possible to exclude secular education from Article 30. Since the Kerala Education Bill case (supra) in 1959 this Court has consistently held that g~neral secular educmion is covered by Article 30. D This Court in Rev. Father Proost v. State of Bihar [1969] 2 S.C.R. 73 considered the question whether the protection guaranteed under Article 30( 1) is a corollary to the right guaranteed under Article 29(1). A contention was advanced that protection to minorities in Article 29-(,1) wa~ only a right to conserve a distinct language, script or culture of its own, and, therefore, the educational institutions which E imparted general education did not qualify for protection of Article 30. This Court said that the width of Article 30 could not be cut down by introducing aiJy consideration on which Article 29 ( 1) is based. Article 29 (1) is a general protection given to sections of citizens to conserve their language, script or culture. Article 30 is a special right to minorities to establish educational institutions of their choice. This Court said that. the two Articles create two separate rights though it is possible F that the rightSi might meet in a §iven case. The real reason embodied in Article 30 (1) of the Constitution is the conscience of the nation that the minorities, religious as well as linguistic, are not prohibited from establishing and administering educational institutions of their choice for the purpose of giving their children the best general education to make them complete men and women of the country. The minorities are given this protection under G Article 30 in order to preserve and strengthen the integrity and unity of the country. The sphere of general secular education is intend·w to develop the commonness of boys and girls. of our country. ~his is in the true spirit of liberty, equality and fratermty through the medmm of educJation. If religious or linguistic minori~es are not ~ven 1'ro~ec· . tion under Article 30 to establish and administer educational mstltu· H tions of their choice, they will feel isolated and. separate. General secular education will open doors of perception and act as the natural light of mind for our countrymen to live in the whole.
·~ y
I
•
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Ray, CJ) .
The second question which arises for consideration is whether re!F gious and linguistic minorities who have the right to establish· and' administer educationar Institutions of their choice, have a fundamental right to affiliation. It is contended on behalf of thqietitioners that the right to establish educational institutions of their chmce wiirbe without any meaning if affiliation is denied., The respondents pose the question whether 'educational institutions established and administered by minorities for imparting genera1'1secular education have a fundamental right to be affiliated to a. statutory University on terms of management · different from those appliC:1ble to oth·er affiliated colleges, · ...
The consistent view of this Court has been that there is no funda~ mental right of a minority institution to affiliation .. An explanation has been put upon that statement of law. It is that affiliation must be a real and meaningful exercise for minori~y institutions in the matter · c of imparting general secular education. Any law which provides for affiliation on terms .which will involve abridgement of the. right of linguistic and religious, minorities to administer and establish educational . institutions of their choice will offend ArticJ.e 30(1 ). The educational ·.institutions set up by minorities will be robbed of their utility if boys and girls cannot be trained in such institutions for University degrees. D Minorities will virtually lose their right to equip their childr·en for ordinary careers. if affiliation be on terms which .would make them surrender and lose their. rights to establish and administer educational institutions of their choic" under Article 30. The primary purpose of affiliation is that the students reading in the minority institutions will have qualifications in the shape of degrees necessary for a useful career in life. The establishment of a minority institution· is not only ineffecE tive but also unreal unless such institution is affiliated tb-a University· for the purpose of conferment of degrees on students. Affiliation to a University really consists of twff parts. · One part rdates to syllabi, curricula, courses of instruction, the qualifications of teachers, library, laboratories, conditions regarding health and hygiene. of students. This part relates to establishment of educational institu-tions. The second part consists of terms and conditions regarding· F management of institutions. It relates to administration of educational , instituHons. ==- -
With regard to a'ffiliation a minority institution must · follow the statutory' measures regulating educational standards and efficiency, the prescribed courses of study, courses of instruction.and the principles regarding the qualification of t·"achers, · education_al qualifications for entry of students into educational institutions etcetera.
Wb•n a minority institution applies to a University to be affiliatecf, it expresses its choice to participate in the syst·!m 'of general education and courses of instruction prescribed by that University; Affili~tion is regulating courses of instruction in. institutions for f1e purpose of coordinating and harmo,ising the standards· of education.· With regard Ii . to affiliation to a University, the minority· and non-minority institutions must agree in the. pattern and standards of edµcation. Regulatory measures of affiliation enable the minority institutions to share the same 14-13!Su;>Cl/7S
.
19 4
(J 975) l S.C.R.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
courses of instruction and the same degrees institutions.
with
the
non-minority
This Court in State of Kera/av. Very Rev. Mother Provincial, etc. [1971] 1 S.C.R. 73.4 explained the necessity and importance of regulatory measures of system and standard of education in the interest of the country and the people. When a minority institution applies for affiliation, it agrees to follow the uniform courses of study. Affiliation is regulating the education:,il character and content of the minority institutions. These regulations are not only reasonable in the interest of general secular education but also conduce to the improvement in the stature and strength of th·~ minority institutions. All institutions of general secular education whether established by the minorities or the non-minorities must impart to the students education not only for their intellectual attainment but also for pursuit of careers. Affiliation of minority institutions is intended to ensure the growth and excellence of their children and other students in the academic field. Affiliation mainly pertains to the acad·~mic and educational character of the institution. Therefore, measures which will regulate the courses of study, the qualifications and appointment of teachers, the conditions of employment of teaclms, the health and hygiene of students, facilities for libraries and laboratories are all comprised in matters germane to affil'iation of minority institutions. These regulatory measures for aftiliation are for uniformity, efficiency and exce1lence in educational courses and do not violate any fundamental right of the minority institutions under Article 30. The entire controversy centres round the extent of the right of the religious and linguistic minorities to administer their educational institutions. The right to administer is said to consist of four principal matters. First is the right to choose its managing or governing body. It is said that th·o founders of the minority institution have faith and confidence in their own committee or body consisting of persons selected by them. Second is the right to choose its teachers. It is said that minority institutions want teachers to have compatibility with the ideals, aims and aspirations of the institution. Third is the right not to be compelled to refuse admission to students. In other words, the minority institutions want to have the right to admit students of their choice subject to reasonable regulations about academic qualifications. Fourth is the right to use its properties and assets for the benefit of its own institution. The right conferred on the religious and linguistic minorities to administer educational institutions of their choice is not in an absoluk right. This right is not free from regulation. Just as regulatory measures are necessary for maintaining the educational character and content of minority institutions similarly regulatory measures are necessary for ensuring orderly, efficient and sound administratio~. Das, C.J. in the Kerala Educarion Bill case (supra) summed up 111 one sentence the trne meaning of the right to administer by saying that the right to administer is not the right to mal-administer.
•
n
•
ST. XAVJERS COLLEGE V. GUJARAT'(Ray, C.J.)
•
.,.
.
On behalf of the petitioners, it is said that the right to administer means autonomy in administration. Emphasis is pl'aced on the minority's claim to mould the institution as it thinks fit. It is said that the regulatory measures should not restrict the right of administration but facilitate the same through the instrumentality of the manag~ment of the minority institution. It is ,said that the management of the minority institution should not be displaced because that will amount to violation of the right to administer. The Kuala Education Bill case (supra) upheld certain regulatory provisions as to administration of minority institution not to infringe the right to adlrninister. The manager of an aided school was to be appointed subject to the approval'. of such officer as the Government might authorise. The Government prescribed the qualifications for appointment as teachers. The Public Service Commission selected candidates for appointment as teachers. The conditions of service were to be the same as in Government schools. No teacher was to be dismissed, removed or reduced in rank or suspended without the previous sanction of the officer authorised by the Govermnent in this behalf. The Kera/a Education Bill case (supra) did not uphold the validity of clauses 14 and 15 in the Kerala Education Bill, 1957. These clauses authorised the Government to take over ally aided school under certain circumstances. This Court found that those clauses amounted to. expropriation of the schools. The schools were recognised on condition that they submitted to those clauses. Such submission amounted to surrender of the right under Article 30 . This Court in Rev. Father W. Proost case (supra) held that section 48-A of the Bihar University Act which came into force from 1 March, 1962 completely took away the autonomy of the governing body of St. Xavier's College established by the Jesuits of Ranchi. Section 48-A of the said Act provided inter alia that appointments. dismissals, removals, termination of service by the governing body of the College were to be made on the recommendation of the University Service Commission and subject to the approval of the University. There were other provisions in that section, viz., that the Commission would recommend to the governing body names of persons in order of preference and in no case could the governing body appoint a person who was not recommended by the University Service Commission.
Jn Rt. Rev. Bishop S. K. Patro v. State of Bihar [1970] 1 S.C.R. 172, the State of Bihar requested the Church Missionary Society School, Bhagalpur to constitute a managing co~mittee of the school in accordance with an order of the State. This Court held that the Stat·~ authorities could not require the school to constitute a managing committee in accordance with their order. Jn D. A. V. College v. State.of Punjab [1971] Suppl. S.C.R. 688, clause1 17 of the impugned statute in that case which provided that the staff initially appointed shall be approved by the Vic·~·Chancellor and subsequent changes would be report~d to the University for the ViceChancellor's approval was found to mterfere with the nght of management.
19 6
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] I S.C.R.
This Court in State of Kera/a v. Very Rev. Mother Provincial case (supra) f~und sections 48 and 49 of the Kerala University Act of. 1969 to be mfract10n of Article 30. Those sections were found by this Court to have the effect of displacing the administration of the college and giving it to a distinct corporate body which was in no way answerable to the institution. The minority community was found to lose the right to administer the institution it founded. The governing body contemrilated m th?~e sections was to administer the coll<oges in accordance with the prov1S1ons of the Act, statutes, ordinances, regulal!ons, by·o-laws and orders made thereunder. The powers and functions ·of the governing body, the removal of the members and the procedure to be followed by it were all to be prescribed by the sfatutes. These provisions amounted to vesting the management and administration of the institution in the hands of bodies with mandates from the Uniwrsity. These rulings of this Court indicate how and when there is taking away or abridgement of the right of administration of minority institutions in regard to choice of the governin!J body, appointm(:nt of teac!hers and in the right to administer. The decision of this Court in Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai v. State of Bombay [1963] 3 S.C.R. 837 illustrates as to how the right of the minority institution is violated by the State order requiring the minority institution to reserve under orders of Government 80 per cent of ·the seats on threat of withholding grant in aid for non-compliance with the order. This Court in Kerala Education Bill case (supra) said that the State cannot do indirectly what it cannot do directly. Withholding aid on terms which demand the surrender of the right of the minority to administer the institution is an infringement of the right under Article 30. Educational institutions are tempks of learning. The virtues of human intelligence are mastered and harmonised by education. Where there is CQ!!!lllete harmony between the teacher an.ct J)t_.ll_!llUght, where the teacher imparts and the student receives, where there is complete dedication of the teacher and the taught in learning, where there is discipline between the teacher and the taught, where both are worshippers of barning, no discord or challenge will arise. An educational institution runs smoothly when the teacher and the taught are engaged in the common ideal of pursuit of knowledge. It is, therefore, manifest that the appointment of t-::achers is an important part in educational institutions. The qualifications and the character of the teachers are really important. The minority institutions have the right to administer institutions. This right implies the obligation and duty of the minority institutions to render the very best to the students. In the right of administration, checks and balances in the shape of regulatory measures are required to ensure the appointment of good teachers and their conditions of S·ervice. The right to administer is to be tempered with regulatory measures to facilitate smooth admi1_1istr.ation. 'D!e b~st administration will reveal no trace or colour of mmonty. A mmonty ·institution shonld shine in exemplary eclectism in the administration of the institution. The best compliment that can be paid to a minority institution is that it does not rest on or proclaim its minority character.
,
•
..
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE v: GUJARAT (Ray, C.J.)
19 7
Regulations which will serve the interest of the students, regul~ti~ns which will serve the ·interests of the teachers are of paramount importance in good administration. Regulations in the interest of efficiency of teachers, discipline and fairness in administration are necessary for pre$erving harmony among affiliated institutions. Education should be a great cohesive force in developing integrity· of the nation... Education develops the ethos of the nation. Regulations· are, therefore, necessary to see that there are no divisive or disintegrating forces in administration. · ·
Three sets of regulations are impeached as violative of. Article J~. ·The first set consists of section 40 and 41 of the Gujarat University Act, 1949 as amended, referred to, as the Act. The ·second set consists of 33A(l)(a). The third set consists of. sections 51A and section ' . - . 52A. , Section 40 of the Act enacts that· teaching and traii;iing shail be conducted by the university and shall be imparted by teechers of the university. Teachers of the university may be appointed or recognised by the university for imparting.instructions on its behalf/ As soon as the Court which is one of the authorities of the univers ty determines that the teaching.and training shalfbe conducted.by the university the provisions of section 41 of the Act come into .fotce. . . Section 41 of the Act consists .of four subCsections. The first sub· section states that all colleges· within the university area which are admitted to the privileges of the university under sub-section ( 3) of sectiori 5 of the Act· and all colleges which may heieafter be affiliated to the university shall· be constituent colleges of the university. It is E · true that no determination has yet been. made by the court of the university under section 40 of the Act bur the power exists; The power may be used in relation to minority institution, Once that is done the minority institutions will immediately become constituent colleges, The real implication of section 40 of the Act is that teaching and training , ... shall be conducted by the university. .The word "conduct" clearly· · · indicates that the university is a teaching university. Under section 40 of the Act the university takes oveneaching of under-graduate classes. Section 41 of the Act is a corollary to section 40 of the Act Sec- · tion 41 of the Act does not stand independent of section 40 of the Act. · Once an. affiliated. college becomes a constituent college within the meaning of section 41 ef !he Act pursuant to a declaration under section 40 of the Act it becom~ integrated to the university. A constituent college does not retain its former individual character any longer. The minoi;ity character of the college is lost: Minorify instifotions become part and parcel of thei university. The result· is that section 40 of the Act carinot have any compulsory application to minority instifutions because it will take away· their fundamental right to administer the educational institutions of their choice. · · Section 41 ·or" the Act contains four sub-sections.· The first subH section broadly states that all colleges within the University area shall '·be the constituent colfeges of the university. The second sub,$<!Ction states that all institutions within the university. area· shall be the constituent institutions of the· university. The third sub-section states that
.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] l s.c.R.
no educational institution situat.o within the university area shall, save with the consent of the university, and the sanction of the State Governn1ent be associated in any Way with or seek admission to any privil~ge of any other university established by law. The fourth sub-section states that the relations of the constituent colleges and constituent, recognised or approved institutions within tho university area shall be governed by the statutes to be made in that behalf and such statutes shall ·provide in particular for the exercise by the university of the po\\'ers enumerated therein in respect of constituent degree colleges and constituent recognised institutions. Section 41 ( 4) Oii) of the Act confers power o.n the ·university. to approve the appointment of the teachers made by colleges. Section 41 (4) (iii)' of the Act requires colleges to contribute teachers for teach· jng on behalf of the university. . Section 41(4)(iv) of t~i; ;!\ct cm!fcrs power on.the universtiy to co-ordmate and "'!fula~e t?e fa~1httes provided and expenditure incurred. by colleg~s and mst1tut10n.s m regard to . libraries laboratories and other eqmpmcms for teachmg and research. Section '41(.<4)(v)· confers power on the university to require colleges ar.d institutions when necessary to confine the enrolment of s~ude~ts in certain subjects.· Section 41(4)(vi)'~on!er~ power on the umvers1ty to levy contributions from colleges and mslttutmns and to make grants to them. · In view of our conclusion that sections 40 and 41 of the Act hang together and that section 40 of the Act cannot have any compuls0ry application to minority institutions, it follows that section 41 of the Act cannot equally have any compulsory application to minority institutions. It is not necessary to express any opinion on the provisions contained in section 41 of the Act. as to whether. such·provisions can be applied to minority institutions affiliated to a university irrespective of the conversion of affiliated colleges into constituent colleges. The provisions corttained in section 33A(l )(a) of the Act state that every ~ol!·~ge shall be m.1der the management of a governing body which shall. mclude amongst its members, a representative of the university nommated, by the Vice-Chancellor and representatives of teachers nonteaching staff and.students ofthe college .. These provisions are' challenged on the ground that this amounts to invasion of the fundamental right of administration. ·1t is said,Jhat the governing body of the college is a part of its administration and therefore that administration should n·ot ·be touched. The .right )O adininister is the right to conduct and manage the affairs of the institution: · This right is exercised through a body of persons in whom the founders pf the institiltion have· faith and confidence and w.lla!Jave full autonomy in that sphere'. The right to administer is sub~ llJ permissible regulatory measures •. Permissible regulatory measures are those which do not restrict the right of administration but facilitate it· and ensure better and more effective exercise . of the. right for the D!'tl<fit of the institution and through the instruriientarrty of the management of the educational institutions and withO'.it displacing the management. If the administration has to be improved 'it shOllld be· done. through the agency or instrumentality of the existing management and not by. displacing it. Restrictions on the right of
R
ST, XAV!ERS COLLEGE V. GUJARAT (Ray, C.J.)
19 9
administration imposed in the interest of the general public alone and not in th·c interests of and for the benefit of minority educational institutions concerned will affect the autonomy in ad.ministration.
•
•
Autonomy in administration means right to administer effectively and to manage and conduct the affairs of the institutions. The distinction is between a restriction on the right of administration and a regulation prescribing the manner of administration. The right of administration is day to day administration. The choice in the personnel of management is a part of the administration. The university will always have a right to see that there is no mal·administration. If there is mal-administration, the university will take steps to cure the same .. There may be control and check on administration in order to find out whether the minority institutions are engaged in activities which are not conducive to the interest of the minority or to th·~ requirements of the teachers and the students. In State of Kerd'a v. Very Rev. Mother Provincial etc. (supra) this Court said that if the administration goes to a body in the sdection of whom the founders have no say, the admin:strntion would be displaced. This Court also said that situations might be conceived when they might have a preponderating voice. That would also affect the autonomy in administration. The provisions contained in section 3 3 A ( l) (a) of the Act hav.o the effect of displacing the management and entrusting it to a different agency. The autonomy in administration is Jost. New elements in the shape of representatives of different type are brought in. The calm waters of an institution will not only be disturbed but also mixed. These provisions in section 33A(l)(a) cannot therefore apply to minority institutions. Tho provisions contained in section 33A(l )(b) of the Act were not chall'enged by the petitioners. Th·o interveners challenged those provisions. The settled practice of this Court is that an intervener is not to raise contentions which are not urged by the petitioners. In view of the fact that notices were given to minority institutions to appear and those institutions appeared and made their submissions a special consideration arises here for expressing the views on section 33A( I) (b) of the Act. The provisions contained in section 33A(l) (b) of the Act are that for the recruitment of the Principal and the members of the teaching staff of a college there is a sef.oction committee of the college which shall consist, in the case of the recruitment of a Principal, of a representative of the university nominated by the Vice-Chancellor and, in the case of recruitment of a member of the teaching staff of the college, of a reprcsentativ·~ of the university nominated by the Vice-Chancellor and the Head of the Department if any for subjects taught by such persons. The contention of the interv·eners with regard to these provisions is that there is no indication and guidance in the Act as to what types of persons could be nominated as the representativ·~. It was suggested that such matters should not be left to unlimited power as to choice. The provisions contained in section 33A (I) (b) cannot therefore apply to minority institutions. The third set of provisions impeached by the petitioners consists of sections SIA and S2A. Section SIA states that no memb~r of the teaching. 0th.er academic and non-teaching staff of an affiliated college
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 1 S.C.R.
shall ~e dismissed or removed or reduced in rank except after an inquiry m which he has been informed of the charges and given a reasonable opportunity of being heard and until (a) he has been given a reasonable opp?rti;nity of m~king representation on any such penalty proposed to be mihcted on him; and (b) the penalty to be inflicted on him is appro~ed by the Vice-Chancellbr or any other officer of the university authonsed by the Vice-Chancellor in this behalf. Objection is taken by the petitioners to the approval of penalty by the Vice-Chancellor or any other officer of the university authorised by him. First, it is said that a blanket power is given to the Vice-Chancellor without any guidance. Second, it is said that the words "any other officer of the university authorised by him" also confer power on the Vice-Chancellor to authorise any one and no guidelines are to be found there. In short. unlimited and undefined power is conferred on the Vice-Chancellor. The approval by the Vice-Chancellor may be intended to be a check on the administration. The provision ·contained in section 5 IA, clause (b) of the Act cannot be said to be a permissive regulatory measure inasmuch as it confer., arbitrary power on the Vice-Chancellor to take away the rlght of administration of the minority institutions. Section 51 A of the Act cannot, therefore, apply to minority institutions_ The provisions contained in section 52A of the Act contemplate reference of any dispute between the governing body and any member of the teaching, other academic and non-t-eaching staff of an affiliated college which is connected with the conditions of service of such mem-
..
ber to a Tribunal of Arbitration consisting of one member nominated
by the governing body of th·e college, one member nominated by the member concerned and an Umpire appointed by the Vice-Chancellor. These references to arbitration will introduce an area of litigious coPtrov·~rsy inside the educational institution. The atmosphere of the institution will be vitiated by such proceedings. The governing body has its own disciplinary authority. The governing body has its domestic jurisdiction. This jurisdiction will be displaced. A new jurisdiction will be created in administration. The provisions contained in section 52A of the Act cannot, therefore, apply to minority institutions.
For these reasons the provisions contained in sections 40, 41, 33A(l)(a), 33A{l)(b), 51A and 52A cannot be applied to minority institutions. These provisions violate the fundamental rights of the minori!y institutions. JThe ultimate goal of a minority institution too imparting general This Court has consistently held that it is not only permissible but also desirable to regulate everything in educational and academic matters for achieving excellence and uniformity in standards of education. s·~cular education is advancement of learning.
In the field of administration it is not reasonable to claim that minority institutions wiil have complete autonomy. Checks on the administration may be necessary in order to ensure that the administration is efficient and sound and will serve the academic needs of the institution. The right of a minority to administer its educational institution involves, as part of it, a correlative duty of good administrat1on.
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE V. GUJARAT (Ray, CJ.)
The teachers and the taught form a world of. their own where, everybody is a votary of learning. They should not be made to know any distinction. Their harmony rests on dedicated and disciplined . pursuit of learning. The areas of adininistration of minorities should bo adjusted to concentrate on making learning most excellent. That is possible only when all institutions follow the motto that the institutions are places for worship of learning by the students and tb teachers
together irrespeCtive of any denomination and distinction.
.
·
JAGANMOHAN REDDY, J. This larger Bench has been constituted to consider the scope of the fundamental rights under Art. 30(1), the interrelationship of those righ.ts with the rights und'ir Art. 29( 1), the scope of the regulatory powers of the State vis-a-vis thq rights under Art,.30(1), and in the light of the view taken on the several · aspects aforesaid to consider the validity of certain' impugned provision~ of the amended · Gujarat University Act, 1949-;-hereinafter referred to as 'the Act'. The. contentions raised before us on the scope and ambit of Arts. 29(1) and 30(1) are not. new but have been earlier urged before and·deeided by this Court. The attempt on behalf of the State of Gujarat has been to once again raise the same crucial issues wfiich go to the root of the rights conferred on the minorities to· establish educational institutions of their choi<e and whether the State could treat the majority and m!nority educational institutions equally, an issue upon which this Court has pron, ounccd in no uncertain terms on earlier occasions.
·
We agree with the judgment of Hon'ble the Chief Justice just pronounced and with his conclusions that ss. 40, 41, 33A (1) (a), 33A (I') (b), 5.l A and .52A of the Act violate the fundamental rights of minorities and cannot, therefore, apply to the institutions established and administered by them. We would not ordinarily have found · it necessary· to ·write a separate opinion when the same thing has to be said as has been. said so tersely by him, but in trying"to re-state what has already been said, the impression is sometimes created that something new is being stated or some departure from the principles already adumbrated is. being made .. In order to avoid giving scope to any such contention being raised, we. would merely refer to some earlier provisions already held to F violate.the fundamental rights of minorities guaranteed under Art. 30(1) which are analogous to the impugned provisions which, in the view this Court has already taken, can be held ·to be violative in their application to the minority educational institutions. The reason for this separate opinion, however, is not so much to point out the invalidity of the impugned provisions which Hon'ble the Chief Justice has held to be in·- applicable to the minority institutions but to examine the. question as G to what extent the right conferred by· Art: 30( 1) would include .within it the right of the minorities to claim affiliation for or recognition to educational institutions established by them. The right of a linguistic or religious mfoority ·to administer educational institutions of their choice, though couched in absolute terms has been held by this Court to be subject to 'regulatory measures which the . State might impose for furthering the excellence of the standards of eduH cation. The scope and ambit of the rights under Arts. 29(1) and30(1) were first considered and analysed by thisCourt while giving its advice on the PresidentiaJ. Reference un.der Art. 143 of the Constitution in Re. (I) 11959] SCR 995.
(2) [t944] F.C.R. 317.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1975] l S.C.R.
The Kera/a Education Bill, 1957('). The report which was made to the President in that Reference, it is true, is not binding on this Court in any subsequent matter wherein a concrete case the infringement of the rights under any analogous provision may be called in question, though it is entitled to great weight. Under Art. 143 this Court expresses its opinion if it so chooses and in some cases it might even decline to express its opinion, vide In Re. Levy of Estate Duty(") cited with approv~ by Das,, C.J. in In re. The Kera/a Education Bill, 1957. In some cases the opinion may be based on certain stated contingencies or on some assumed or hypothetical situations whereas in a concrete case coming before tbis Court by way of an appeal under Art. 133, or by special leave under Art. 136 or by a petition under Art. 32, the law declared by it by virtue of Art. 143 is binding on all courts within the territority of India. Nonetheless the exposition of the various facets of the rights under Art. 29(1) and Art. 30(1) by Das, C.J., speaking for the majority, with the utmost clarity, great perspicuity and wisdom has been the text from which this Court has drawn its sustenance in its subsequent decisions. To the extent that this Court has applied these principles to concrete cases there can be no question of there being any conflict with what has been observed by Das, C.J. The decisions rendered on analogous provisions as those that are under challenge in this case would prima facie govern these case•, unless this larger Bench chooses to differ from them.
t
In respect of certain provisions of the Kerala Education Bill, namely, clauses 9, 11(2) and 12(4), Das, C.J. sta'.c:!;
"These are, no doubt, serious inroads on the right of administration and appear perilously near violating that right. But considering that those provisions are applicable to all educational institutions and that the impugned parts of els. 9, 11 and 12 are designed to give protection and security to the illpaid teachers who are engaged in rendering service to the nation and protect the backward classes, we are prepared, "" at present advised, to treat these clauses 9, 11(2) and 12(4) as permissible regulations which the State may impose on the minorities as a condition for granting aid to their educational institutions.'' It was also observed therein that els. 7, 10, 11(1), 12(1), (2), (3) and (5) may easily be regarded as reasonable regulations or conditions for the grant of aid. But some of the provisions analogous to els. 11, l 2 (1), (2), (3) and (5) have been held invalid by this Court when they were challenged as offending fundamental rights of minority institutions. In the State of Kerala v.Very Rev. Mother Provincial(') sub-ss. (I) (2) and (9) of section 53 of the Kerala University Act, 1969, were held to be invalid. These provisions are similar in terms and effect as cl. 11 of the Kerala Education Bill, 1957. Similarly, sub-sections (2) and (4) of s. 56 of the Kerala University Act being similar in terms and effect to sub-clauses (!), (2) and (3) of clause 12 of the Kerala Education Bill, 1957, which were held to be reasonable and sub-clause (4) of (1)
[1971] I S.C.R. 734.
(2) [1971] Supp. S.C.R. 688.
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE V. GUJARAT
•
(Ray, C.J.)
that clause which was considered Ii> .be perilously near to violating the fundamental rights in that case, were held to be invalid as they fall with sections 48 and 49 of the Kerala Education Act. A similar provision in the Statutes of the Gnru Nanak University Act, namely, Statute 17 making a provision similar to sub els. ( l), (2) and (3) of clause 12 of the Kerala Education Bill was held invalid in D. A. V. College etc. v. State of Punjab & Ors(2). Sub-sections (4) and (6) of s. 63 of the Kerala University Act, 1969, which provide for similar contingencies as those provided in s. 52A of the impugned provisions of the Act dealing with the disputes between the governing body and any member of the teaching staff or other academic and non-teaching staff of minority institutions was held to be invalid in Mother Provincial case. The provisions of the impugned sections 33A(l) and (b) and 51A of the Act are similar in nature to the provisions of ss. 53, 56 48 and 49 of the Kerala University Act. Statute 2(1) (a) of the Guru Nanak University Act also corresponds to ss. 48' and 49 of the Kerala · University Act and is similar in nature to s. 33A of the Act. These have been held to be invalid in their application to minority educational institutions in the D. A. V. College case. Needless to say, in so far as these decisions lay down a principle slightly different from or even contrary to the opinion on the Kerala Education Bill, they are the law laid down by this Court.
The impugned provisions, namely, ss. 40, 41, 33A(l) (a), 33A(l) (b), SIA and 52A have already been given in the judgment of Hon'ble the Chief Justice. These may be compared with the provisions of the E . Kerala Education Bill, the Kerala University Act and the Statutes of the Guru Nanak University Act, which have been juxtaposed for an easy appreciation of the nature of the provisions which have been held void by the cases referred to above :
•
--------011r11 ~'i,;k-ufii;eiSiiY ·s1aiUiei----··---Kerala · Universily Act Kera/a Education Bill •· .cl.· 11-Appoint:"lent of teachers in Gov.. Section· 53ernment .and aided. schQOl~ Appointment of teachers in private· col· (I) T.be Public Service Commission legesfhall. as empowered' by this Act. select (I) Posts of principal of private colleges candidates for. appointmCnt as teachers in $h<ill be selection · po~ts. Government and aided · schools. Before O!JqOd oq1 ., ..... tp•• JO ACl\I 1s1 ( 041 (2) Appointment to thC post of princi· ~rvice Commi'>sion shal' se:lect candidates pal in a private college shall be made with du€= regar. .t to the· probable number by the i:overning body or managing conn· of vacancies of teachers that may arise in cil. as the case may be. from · among the course of tho year. The candidates teachers of the college or of au· the shall. be selected for each district separate ... colleges. as the case may be or if there ly and the list of candidates so selec_ted is no suitable· person in such college or shall be publishe<l in the Gazette. Teachers colleges, from other persons. of aided schools shall be appointed by (9> Any teacher. aggrieved bY ·an the ,.manager only from the candidates so selected for the district in which the appointment under · 'sub-section-f7') may . school is located provided that manager within sixty days "from the date of tµe uppointment, appeal to. the Syndicate, and may, for sufficient reason. \.'ith the per... mission of the Public Service Commission; the decision of the Syndicate thereon shall · appoint teachers selected for any . other be fim:il, district, Appointment of te.nchers in Gov.. ernment schools shall also be made from tl)e list of candiJatcs so published. Stati1tl! 17-The staff initially · appointe<l D (2) In- selecting canJidates under . sub· S. 56~Conditions. or scrvicl! of teachers shall bl! approv~d by the Vice·Chancellor. of p;:ivate collegessection (I), the Public Service Commissi::>n All subsequent changes shall be· reported shall have regard to the provisions made ( I) Thi: conditions of service of. teachers to the University for Vice-Chancellor's by the Government under cl. ( 4) of Art. 16 of private colleg~s. including conditions approval. In the case of training instituof the .Constitution.' · . relating to pay. pension, provident fund. tions the teachers. pupil ratio shall not gr::1tuity. it:11a1runce ;ind ng:e of retirement he less th~1n t : 12. Non-Government Cl. 12-Conditions of service of nidcd sln1ll·· be:_.s'i..1ch <l'i 1nay be prescribed by Colh.·g~·s sh;1IL con1plY with the require· School teachers : n1ents lait.1 down· in the Ordinance govern. the iStatutes. ing service and conduct of teachers in E ( 1) The. -conditions· of service' · relating (2) No teacher of private college shall non-Government Colleges as may be to pensions, provident fund, insurance and be. dismissed1 removed, or reduced in framed by the University, ~.-
..,
c::"'
"'
"''"
::::
"' "
~
....
"'"''0"
"'"' ....
-
~
"_,' "' "''
-
~
"i"
age of retirement applicable to teachers rank by the Governing body or managing of Government schools shall apply to council without the previous sanction of teachers of aided schoolsthe Vice.Chancellor ·or placed under sus. i . pension by the Govcrnini:t · Body · or (il who are · Jpointed under ·sec 11 Managing Council for a continuous period· .. after the commenCement of this sec"tion; exceeding fifteen days without such pre.. ·and · vious sanction. (ii) who. have been appointed be[Ore. the (4) A teacher against whom disciplinary cai.lfllencement of this section, . but who action is taken shall have · a right of JlM>'o ·expressed in writing their willingness · appeal to the Syndicate, and the Syndicate to tie governed by such conditions, within shall have power to order ·reinstatement of qe year from ·sucn commencement; · · the teacher in case of wrongful removal or dismissal and to_ order such other (3) The Goveu\ment shall extend to the remedial measures as it deems fit. and the teachers of. aided schools who have· O:en governing body or managing, council, as appointed before the commencem:nt of the case may be, shall .comply with the this section and who have not expressed · order. their willingness under clause (ii) of ·sub.. section (2) within the time speci_fied : there(or the conditions of service relating to pension, provident fund, insurance and age of retirement. applicable to teachers pf Government schools with such modifi.. cations as the Government may deem fit, (4) No teacher of an aided school shall be . dismissed· removed, reduced in rank or suspended- by the manager without the previous sanction of the officer authorised by the Government in this behalf•. (S) Subject to the provisions of sub• sections (1), (2), (3) and (4), the condi. tions of service · of teachers of aided schools shall be such s.s mav . be prescribed,
"' :-'
"<:>
;;;
"'"' g
I"' I"'
"'
Cl
c :"""
Cl
c::
;
...:;:;
'"'
~ §
~
i'l 'It ~
:-.
~
"' ""
I
I
-----Section 48-Governing body for
( 1)
-----·----
private college not under corporate rn:i.nagement(I) The educational agency of a priVate college, other than a private college under a corporate management, shall constitute in accordance with the provisions , of the statutes a governing body consisting: of foliowinc members, namely : (a) the princip<1l of the private college;
(b) the manager of the private-. college;
(2)
------ -----------------···--· Statute 2(l)(a) A College applying for admission to lhe privileges of the University shall send a letter of application to the Registrar nnd shall satisfy the Senate : (a) That the College shall have a regulul'ly constituted ·governing body consisting of not mor_f? than 20 ·persons approved by the Senate and including. among others, '.? representatives of the University and the Principal of the college ex-officio.
. ·-·----------·-----"·-
( 3)
(d) a person nominated by the Govern· ment; (e~
a person clcclcd in accordance with ~uch procedure 01s may be prescribed by the · Statutes fron1 among themselves by the permanent teachers of the private college; and (f) not more than six .persons non1inat .. cd _by the educational agency. · ·(2) The governing body shall be a body corpor:1te havin.(? perpetual succe.co.c;ion :ind a con11no11 seal.
(3 The riunager or the private college shall b~ the Chairman of the Governing body, ( 4) 1\ 1nc1nbcr of the _governing body sh•1ll holJ office fQr n period of four yea'rs from the date. of its constitution.
"'
(c) a person. nominated by the Univer·
sity in accordance with the provisions in that behalf contained in the statutes.
,.,
o
"'c: Provi<led that the said condition shall not apply in the case 'of College main· fained. by Go"lr:ernment which shall however have an advisory Committee consisting: of among others the principal of the College (E.x-ollicio) and two rcprc~enta· lives of the University.
"'"'
"' ;: "'
"c: ..,"'
"'0"'"' .... "'
"'
-"'
~
..... V>
-
~
?'
r
!"
(!i) Tl shall be the Juty of· the govcrn-
in1: body 10 administer the private college
in accordrince with the provisions of ·this Act and the Statutes, Ordinances, Regulations, Rules, Byc-lriws. rind orders made thereunder. ( 6) The powers and fllnctions of the ~overning body, the removal of members thereof ;.ind the procedure to be followed by it, including the· delegation of its powers. sh:.lll be prescribed by the Statute~. (7) Notwithst:::inding anythin2 contained in sub-section (6), decisions of the governing body shall be taken at meetings on the basis of simple majority of the members .present ·and voting. 1.1',
"' ,. < ,,;:;;
:-' ><
"'n
........
'" Cl
"':"
Cl
Scc~ion 49Managing Council for private Colleges under corporate management(a) one principo1l by rotation in such ntanncr as may be prescribed by the Statutes: (b) !he m:1n:.1£Cr of the private college:
·cc) a person nominated by·the Univer-
8,.
,,,. ....
....
~
~;::
::;
~
"' ;::
sity in accordance with ·the provisions in that behalf contained in the Statutes; Cd} a person nominated by the Governn1ent; f c) twu persons elected in accordance with such procedure as may be prescribed
·by the Statutes from among themselves by the permanent teachers 'lf all the private colleges: nnd
::<l
"ft
:.< .... .:....
I
I
..."'
( I)
( 2) ( f) riot more than fifteen persons no mi.. nated by the educational agency.
(2) The nianaging council shall be a. body corporate having perpetual succession and a comn;ion seal.
-
(3)
-A
"'
"'
(3) The manager of the private colleges shall be the chairman of the managing
council.
·
-
( 4) A member of the nianaging council shall hold office for a period of four years from tho date of the constitution,
•
(5) It shall be the. duty of the mapaging council to administer all the private colleges under the .Corporate management in accordance With the .provisions of· this Act and the Statutes, Ordinances, Regn-: lations, Dye-laws and Ord~rs made thereunder.
n "' c: ~
(4) Tf the goVerning -body or managing col.lncll, as 'the case may - be, disapproves
~
( 6) ·The powers and -functions of the managing council, the removal of members thereof and the. procedure to be followed by it, including the delegation of its powers. shall be prescribed by . the Stah1..: tes. . (7) Notwithstanding anything coniained in sub-section (6). decisions of.' the managing council shaU be taken at meetings on the basis of simple majority of the members present and voting, · Section 63-PowCr to regulate the management of private colleges-
..."'"' n"' ..,fa ~
"'0"' .., ~
. "'
-
~
...... '"'
"" /'::::
~
, !" n
;., •
i-:::
( 2)
( 1)' -------~
"'c '&
any decision tak""en by the University In connebtion with the management of theo · private college the matters shall be referred by the governina: body or managing coun.. cil, as· the case may be, to the Govern ..
( 3)
"':-i ~
ment, within one month of the date - of receipt of the report under sub.section (3) who shall thereupon pass such ·order thereon as they think fit and communieate lhe same to the governing body· or m::inagin& council and also to the Univer· sity.
.."'
<
r;; n
-~
.....0 ~
- (6) The manager appointed under sub·
"'" :"'
section ( 1) of section ~O shall be bound
·.
to give eflect to the decisions of tht University and. if at any time, it appear,) to the Univenity that the manager ·is not carrying out its decisions, it may,· for reasons to be rei;ordcd in writing and after giving the manager an opportunity of being heard, by order remove him from office and appoint another ; person to b~ the manager after consultin$ · thQ edµcaiional
>
~
-i
~
i
BJCDC)',
:i
,_
~
"):!
.
~
:.< :--....; E· I
I
.
...
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 1 s.c.R.
In spite of the consistent and categorical decisions which have held
invalid certain provisions of the University Acts of some of the States as interfering with the fundamental rights of management of minority insituations inherent in the right to establish educational institutions of their choice under Art. 30( I), the State of Gujarat has incorporated similar analogous provisions to those that have been declared invalid by this Court. No doubt education is a State subject, but in the exercise of that right any transgression of the fundamental right guaranteed to the minorities will have its impact beyond the borders of that State and the minorities in the rest of the country will feel apprehensive of their rights being invaded in a similar manner by other States. A kind of instability in the body politic will be created by action of a State which will be construed as a deliberate attempt to transgress the rights of the minorities where similar earlier attempts were successfully challenged and the offending provisions held invalid. The Central Government to which notice was given probably realising the sensitive nature of the issue did not put forward any contentions contrary to those that have already been considered and decided by this Court, though we had the advantage of the personal views of the Attorney-General on some of the aspects of those rights. Equality of treatment of minority and majority or equality before law precludes discriruination. According to Advisory opinion of the Permanent Court of International Justice on Minority Schools in Albania (6 April 1935), Publications of the Court, series A/B No. 64, p. 19 : "whereas equality in fact may involve the necessity of differential treatment in order to attain a result which establishes an equilibrium between different situ.ations.
•
f11
............ It is easy to imagine cases in which equality of treatment of the majority and of the minority whose situation and requirements are different, would result in inequality ........ The equality between members of the majority and of the minority must be effective, genuine equality ...... "
We are of opinion that this view is a sound one and the contentions advanced on behalf of some of the respondents in support of the validity of the impugned provisions cannot be accepted. In so far as the right of affiliation or recognition is concerned, no doubt, the observations of Das, C.J., in Re. The Kerala Education Bill case('") seem to negative any such right under Art. 30 (I). He said at p. 1067: "There is, no doubt, no such thing as fundamental right to recognition by the State but to deny recognition to the educational institutions except upon terms tantamountto the surrender of their constitutional right of administration of the educational institutions of their choice is in truth and in effect to deprive them of their rights under Art. 30(1)." These observations appear to us to be somewhat at variance with certain other observations. But if these observations are carefully scruti(1)
[I959J s.c.R. 995.
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE
v. GUJARAT (Jaganmohan Reddy, J.) 2l L
nised, they can be reconciled and .harmonised. Das, C.J., had observed earlier at pp. 1066~1067 that:
"The minorities, quite understandably, regard it as essential that the education ot their children should be in accordance with the teachings of their religion and they hold, quite honestly, that such an education cannot be obtained in ordinary schools designed for all the members of the public but can only be secured in schools conducted under the influence and guidance of people well versed in the tenets of their religion and in the traditions of their culture .......... They also desire that scholars of their educational institutions should go out in the world well and sufficiently equipped with the qualifications necessary for a useful career in life. But according to the Edu-. cation Code now in operation to which it is permissible to refer for ascertaining the effect of the impugned provisions on existing state of affairs the schol"ars of unrecognised schooIS are not permitted to avail themselves of the opportunities for higher education in the University and arc not eligible for entering the public services. Without recognition, therefore, the educational institutions established or .to be established by the minority communities cannot fulfil the real objects of their choice and the rights under Art. 30 (!) cannot be effectively exercised. The right to establish educational institutions of their choice must, therefore, mean the right to establish real institutions which will effectively-serve the needs of their community and the scholars who resort to their educational institu-. tions."
·
The right under Art. 30 cannot be exercised in vacuo. Nor would it be right to refer to affiliation or recognition as privileges granted by the State. In a democratic system of Government with emphasis on education and enlightenment of its citizens, there must be elements which give protection to them. The meaningful exercise of the right under Art. 30 (I ) would and must nccesssarily involve recognition of the secular education imparted by the minority institutions without which the right will be a mere. husk. This Court -has so far consistently struck down all attempts to make· affiliation or recognition on terms taritamount. to · surrender· of its rights under Art. 30(1) as abridging or taking· away those -rights. _ Again as without affiliation there can be· no meaniiigful exercise of the right under Art. 30(1), the affiliation to be given should be consistent with that right, 'nor can it indirectly try· to achieve what it cannot directly do. See Kera/a Education Bill Case(p Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai & others v .. Stale of Bombay and Another(') and D.A.V. College Case(') at p. 709. If the right of recognition is not a fundamental right, the logical result of this postulate would be !bat the State need not recognise except on general terms open to all institutions.. Bnt if the recognition by a State is limited in so far as minority institutiotis are concerned, in that under (I) 11959] S.C.R. 9~5, at.P-1059, 1060, 1067 & 1068. (2) 11963) 3 S.C.R. 837 at 856.
(3) (1971] Supp. S.C.R. 688 at 709.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 1 S.C.R.
the guise of exercising this power, the State cannot prescribe conditions which will make an inroad and take away the right guaranteed under Art. 30(1), then there is no meaning in saying that the right to recognise vis-a~vis minority institutions is not a fundamental right. This is one conclusion that can possibly be derived from the above observations of Das, C.J. The second conclusion which is possible is that these observations will have to be confined to the provisions of law regarding the validity of which the opinion of the Court was sought. In that case, the Bill had provided for giving recognition to schools for preparing students for the examinations conducted by the Board, and in so providing it had imposed conditions which the Court construed as tantamount to the minority institutions being required to surrender or denying them the right under Art. 30 ( 1). The Court was not concerned with a law which did not deal with the question of affiliation or recognition at all or where the teaching was confined only to State managed and maintained schools. The observations of Das, CJ. cannot therefore, strictly speaking, apply to this fact situation. When it is so read, they cannot be held to have laid down that the State must provide for giving recognition at least to the minority institutions or accord recognition subject lo such conditions as would in truth and in effect not amount to an infringement of their right under Art. 30 ( 1). In other words, where the law does not provide for giving recognition or affiliation to any educational institution irrespective of whether it is a majority or a minority institution, can the minority institution claim recognition on the ground that without recognition or affiliation the educational institution established by them cannot fulfil the real objects of their choice and the minorities cannot effectively exercise their rights under Art. 30 ( 1) ? If the logi('al answer flowing from the observations is that it cannot, then the· question would arise as to what is the purpose which clause (I) of Art. 30 serves ? The only purpose that the fundamental right under Art. 30' (I) would serve would in that case be that minorities may establish their institutions, lay down their own syllabi, provide instructions in the· subjects of their choice, conduct examinations and award degrees or diplomas. Such institutions have the right to seek recognition to their degrees and diplomas and ask for aid where aid is given to other educa-· tional institutions giving a like education on the basis of the excellence achieved by them. The State is bound to give recognition to their qualifications and to the institutions and they cannot be discriminated except on the ground of want of excellence in their educational standardY.: so far as recognition of degrees or educational qualifications is concerned and want of efficient management so far as aid is concerned. In the D. A. V. College case(') the compulsory affiliation of minority educational institutions to the University which had prescribed a medium of instructions other than the language of the minority a via media was suggested, having regard to the formation of the linguistic States throughout India, that no compulsory affiliation can be insisted upon which offends the right guaranteed under Arts. 29 ( !) and 30 (1) . If, as was held, compulsory affiliation is bad, it will leave them free to get affiliated to a University in that linguistic State which provides facility for the language and script of the minorities. This pre-supposes that (1) [1971] Supp. S. C. R. 688 at 709.
•• B.
E.
HI
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE v; GUJARAT (Khanna, J.)
there is a right to get recognition or affiliation where it is possible in India for minority institutions to preserve their language, script and culture. We may in this connection refer to a unanimous resolution of Parliament dated September 19, 1956, on the safeguards proposed for the linguistic minorities, Vide Part IV of the States Reorganisation Report, recommending that the concerned States should provide necessary facilities to safeguard minority rights by amending their University Statutes. The fifth paragraph of the memorandum as approved by Parliament states : "5. Affiliation of schools and colleges itsing niinority la;zguages.-Connected with the proposals contained in the preceding paragraphs is the question of the affiliation of educational institutions located in the new or reorganised States to appropriate Universities or Boards of Education. It is of course desirable that every effort should be tnade to evolve arrangements whereby educational institutions like schools and colleges can be affiliated, in respect of courses of study in the mother-tongue, to Universities and other authorities which are situated in the same State. However, it may not always be possible to make such arrangements; and having regard to the number of institutions of this kind, it may sometimes be convenient, both from the point of view of the Universities or the educational authorities concerned, and from the point of view of the institutions themselves, that they should be permitted to seek affiliation to appropriate bodies located outside the State. This may be regarded in fact as a necessary corollary to the provisions contained in Article 30 of the Constitution, which gives to the minorities the right to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice."
But what would happen if the educational institutions of a minority find it inconvenient or impossible to secure such a recognition or affiliation even outside the State in which they are established ? In such circumstances, education including University education being a State subject and the legislative power of the State also being subject to Art. 29 ( 1) and Art. 30(1), minorities able to establish an educational institution can insist on recognition, where affiliation is not provided for by the University Acts to the educational qualifications awarded by them, whether degrees, diploma or other certificates, which conform to the educational standards prescribed by the State for the recognition of such degrees, diplomas and other certificates. KHANNA, J. What is the scope and ambit of the rights of minorities, whether based on religion or language, to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice under clause (1) of article 30 of the Constitution is the question which arises for consideration in this writ petition filed by the Ahmedab~d St. Xavier's College Society and another under article 3 2 of the Constitution. The respondents impleaded, in the petition are the State of Gujarat and the Gujarat University. The first petitioner (hereinafter referred to as the petitioner) is a Society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860 (Act
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1975] 1 S.C.R.
21 of 1860) and a Trust under the Bombay Public Trusts Act, 1950 (Act 29 of 1950). The petitioner is running St. Xavier's College of Arts and Commerce in Ahmedabad. The said college was established in June 1955 by a religious denomination known as the Society of Jesus, a religious order of Catholic priests and bro:hers. The petitioner society was formed with the object of taking over the above mentioned college.
.K
"
The petitioner society and the St. Xavier's College seek to provide higher education to Christian students. Children, however, of all classes and creeds provided they attain the qualifying academic standards are admitted to the St. Xavier's College. Before the bifurcation of the erstwhile State of Bombay into State of Maharashtra and State of Gujarat, the. Bombay State legislature passed the Gujarat University Act, 1949 (hereinafter referred to as the principal Act). The obiect of the Act was to establish and incorporate a teaching and llffiliated university. St. Xavier's College was accorded affiliation under section 33 of the principal Act on or about June 1955. Section 2 of the principal Act contained definitions. We may set out the relevant definitions : "(1) 'Affiliated College' under section 5 or 33.
means a college
affiliated
(2) 'College' means a degree college or an intennediate college. (2A) 'Constituent College' means a University college or affiliated college made constituent under section 41. ( 3) 'Degree College' means an affiliated college which is authorised to submit its students to •an examination qualifying for any degree of the University. (8) 'Recognized Institution' means an institution for research or specialized studies other than an affiliated college and recognized as such by the University.
(12) 'Teachers' means professors, readers, lecturers and such other persons imparting instruction in the University, an •affiliated college or a recognized institution as may be declared to be teachers by the Statutes. ( 13) Teachers of the University' means teacher appointed or recognized by the University for imparting instruction on its behalf. (15A) 'University College' means a college wvich the University may establish or maintain under this Act or a college transferred to the University •and maintained by it. (16) 'University Department' means any college, postgraduate or research institution or department maintained by the University."
•
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE V, GUJARAT (Khanna, J.)
•
•
•
Section 39 of the Principal Act provided that within the University area, all post-graduate instruction, teaching and trainini; shall be conducted by the University or by such affiliated colleges or institutions and in such subjects as may be prescribed by the Statutes. According to section 40 of the Act, within a period of three years trom the date on which section 3 (which dealt with the incorporation of the University) comes into force, the Senate sttall determine that n all instructions teaching and training beyond the stage of Intermediate Examinations shall, within the area of the City of Ahmedabad and such other contiguous area as the Sen-ate may determine, be conducted by the University and shall be imparted by the teachers of the University. The Senate shall then communicate its decision to the State Government which Government may, after making such mqmry as it thinks fit, by notification in the Official Gazette decl-are c that the provisions of section 41 would come into force on such date as may be specified in the notification. Section 40 was amended by Bombay Act 30 of 1954, as a result of which the words "three ~years" were substituted by the words "seven years". The effect of that amendment was that the Senate could take its decision under section 40 of the Act within seven years from the date on which section 3 came into force. Section 41 of the principal Act dealt with constituent colleges and institutions. The provisions of this section would be dealt with at length hereafter. Suffice it to say at present that sub-section (2) of that section provided that all institutions within the Ahmedabad area would be constituent institutions of the University. No educational institution situate within the Ahmedabad area, it was specified, would save with the consent of the Univorsity and the sanction of the State Government, be assoE ciated in any way with, or seek admission to any privileges of, any other University established by law. Sub-section (4) of section 41 dealt with the relations of the constituent colleges and the constituent mstitutions within the Ahmedabad area and provided that the same would be governed by the Statutes to be made in this behalf. The matters in respect of which the Statutes were to make provisions in particular regarding the relations of the constituent colleges and F recognized institutions were also specified.
The Senate of Gujarat University did not take any decision mentioned in section 40 within the stipulated period of seven years. The s•aid period expired on November 22, 1957. The colleges affiliated to the Gujarat University accordingly continued to be affiliated colleges alter that date. On September 28, I 971 the Senate passed a resolution that all instructions, teaching and training beyond the stage of mtermediate ex•amination in the city of Ahmedabad be conducted by the University ai:d imparted b~ the teachers of th~ University._1:he Registrar of the Umvers1ty was directed to commur,u~ate the dec1s1on of the Senate to the State Government. The pettt10ners and some others then filed petitions under article 226 of the Constitution in the Gujarat High Court on the ground that the powers of the Senate and the State Government under section 40 of the principal Act bid got exhausted on November 22, 1957 when the period of seven years from the commencement of the principal Act had expired. In the
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
_[1975] ] S.C.R.
alternative, it was stated by the petitioners that the provisions of sections 40 and 41 were violative of articles 14, 19, 26, 29 and 30 of the Constitution. In view of the pendency of these petitions, the State Government did not act upon the inpugned resolution passed by the Senate on September 28, 197 l.
..
' I(
The Gujarat University (Amendment) Act, 1972 (Act No. 6 of B 1Y"/3) (hereinafter referred to as the amending Act) was thereafter pa>Sed by the Gujarat legislature. The amending Act came into force on March 12, 1973. It substituted the word "Court" for the word "Senate" and the words "Executive Council" for the word "Syndicate". The Gujarat University Act as amended by the amend-' ing Act may for the sake of convenience be described as the amended Act. Sect10ns 33A, 39, 40, 41, 51A and 52A of the amended Act c read as >omder : "33A. ( 1) Every college (other than a Government college or a college maintained by the Government) affiliated before the commencement of the Gujamt University (Amendment) Act,_ 1972 (hereinafter in this section referred to as 'such commencement')(a) shall be under the management of a governing body which shall include amongst its members the Principal of the college, a representative of the University nominated by the Vice-Chancellor, and three representatives of the te-achers of the college and at least one representative each of the Members of the non-teaching staff, and the students of the college, to be elected respectively from amongst such teachers, members of the non-teaching staff and students; and ( b) that for recruitment of the Principal and members of the teaching staff of a college there is a selection committee of the college which shall include-
(2) Every college referred to in sub-section (1) sh•all,-(a) within a period of six months after such commencement, constitute or reconstitute its governing body in conformity with sub-section (1), and ( b) as and when occasion first arises after such commencement, for recruitment of the Principal and teachers of
,,. I
(I) in the case of recruitment of the Principal, •a representative of the University nominated by the ViceChancellor, and (2) in the case of recruitment of a member of lhe teaching staff of the college, a representative of the University nominated by the Vice-Chancellor and the Head of the Department, if any, concerned with the subject to be taught by such member.
•
ST. XAVJERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Khanna, J.)
the college, constitute or reconstitute its selection committee so as to be in conformity with sub-section (I). (3) The provisions of sub-section ( 1) shall be deemed to be a condition of affiliation of every college referred to m sub-section (I). ·
39. Within the University area, all post·graduatc instruct10n, teaching and training shall be conducted by the University or by such affiliated colleges or institutions and in such subjects as may be prescribed by the Statutes. 40. ( 1) The Court may determine that all instructions, teaching and training in courses of studies in respect of which the University is competent to hold examiimtions skll within the University area be coducted by the. University and shall be imparted by the teachers of the University and the Court shall communicate its decision to the Srnte Government. (2) On receipt of the communication under sub-section ( l), the State Government may, after making such inquiry as it thinks fit, by notification in the Offic1al Gazette declare that the provisions of section 41 shall come into force on such date as may be specified in the notification. 41. (1) All colleges within the University area which are admitted to the privileges of the University under subsection ( 3) of section 5 and all colleges within the said area which may hereafter be affiliated to the University shall be constituent colleges of the University. (2) All institutions within the University area recognized under sections 35 and 63 or approved under section 35A shall be the constituent institutions of the University.
(3) No educational institution situate within the University area shall, save with the consent of the University and the sanction of the State Government, be a'sociate<1 in •any way with, or seek admission to any privileges of, any other University established by law. ( 4) The relations of the constituent colleges and constituent, recognizeci or approved institutions within the University .area shall be governed by the Statutes lo be made ;n that behalf, and such Statutes shall provide in particular for the exercise by .the University of the following powers in respect of the constituent degree colleges and constitue"t recognized institutions(i) to lay down minimum educational qualifications for the dtt!erent classes of teachers and tutorial staff employed by such colleges and institutions and the conditions of their service;
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 1 S.C.R.
(ii) to approve the appointments of the teachers made by such colleges and institutions;
•
(iii) to require each such college and institution to contribute a prescribed quota of recognized teachers in any subject for teaching on behalf of the University;
(iv) to co-ordinate and regulate the facilities provided and expenditure incurred by such colleges and institutions in regard to libraries, laboratories and other equipments for teaching and research; ( v) ·to require such colleges and institutions, when necessary, to confine the enrolment of students to certain snbjects; (vi) to levy contributions fiom such institutions and mal::e grants to them; and
colleges
and
(vii) to require satisfactory arrangements for tutorial and simil•ar other worl:: in such colleges and institutions and to inspect such arrangements from time to time; Provided that a constituent degree college or a constituent recognized institution shall supplement such teaching by tutorial or other instruction teaching or
tra1nii.ig
in
I)
a
manner to be prescribed by the Regulation to be made by the Academic Council.
'
(5) Subject to the provisions of the Statutes the Board ot University Teaching •and Research shall organize and co-ordinate the instruction, teaching and training within the University area. SIA(!) No member of the teaching, other academic and non-teaching staff of an affiliated college and recognized or approved institution shall be dismissed or removed or reduced in rank except •after an inquiry in which he has been informed of the charges against him and given a reasonable opportunity of being heard in respect of those charges and until( a) he has been given a reasonable opportunity of making representation on any such per:alty proposed to be inflicted on him, and (b) the penalty to be inflicted on him is approved by the Vice-Chancellor or any other officer of the University authorised by the Vice-Chancellor in this behalf.
(2) No termination of service of such member not amounting to his dismissal or removal falling under subsection (I) shall be valid unless( a) he has beer, given a reasonable opportunity of showing cause against the proposed termination, and
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Khanna, !.)
21 !>
( b) such termination is approved by the Vice-Chancellor or any officer of the University authorised by the ViceChancellor in this behalf : Provided that nothing in this sub-section shall apply to any person who is appointed for •a temporary period only.
•'
•
52A. (I) Any dispute between the governing body and any member of the teaching, other academic and nonteaching staff of an affiliated college or recogn:z"d or approved institution which is connected with the conditions of service of such member, shall; on a request of the governing body, or of the member concerned be referred to a Tribunal of Arbitration consisting of one nominated by the governing body of the college or, as the case may be, member of the recognized or approved institution, one member nominated by the member concerned and an Umpire appointed by the Viee-Chaneel!or. (2) The provisions of section 52 shall, thereupon mutatis mutandis apply to such request and ti:e decision . that may be given by such Tribunal." A meeting of the. University Senate was convened for March 27,. 28 and 29, 1973 wherein resolutions were proposed to be moved as items Nos. 144 and 145 of the agenda that all instructions, leaching and training in courses of studies in respect of which the University was competent to hold examinations be conducted by the University ana be imi:-urted by the teachers of the University. 'Ihe petitioners thereupc1a filed the present petition under article 32 of the Constitution. According to the petitioners, the St. Xavier's College Ahmedabad is an educational institution established by a minority and the provisions of sections 40 and 41 of the amended Act are violative of the fundamental rights c[ the petitioners guaranteed under articles 14, 19, 26, 29, 30 and 31 of the Constitution. The petitioners have a]SC} questioned the competence of the Gujarat legislature to pass the amending Act. The three main reliefs sought by the petitionersc are : "(!) That sections 40 and 41 of the Gujarat UniYersity Act, 1949 (Bombay Act No. L of 1949) as amended by the Gujarat University (Amendment) Act, 1972 (Gujarat Act No. 6 of 1973)' are ultra vires the legislative powers of the State Legislature and/or are violative of articles 14. 19 (I )(a). (f) and (g), 26, 29, 30 and 31 of the Constitution of India;
(2) That sections SIA and 52A as inserted in the Gujarat University Act, 1949 (Bombay Act No. L of 1949) as amended by the Gujarat University (Amendment) Act, 1972 (Gujarat Act No. 6 of 1973) are ultra vires article 14, 19 (l)(a)(f) and (g), 26, 2\1 and 30 of the Constitution of India, and Ordinances 120D, 120E, 120F and !20G of the
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1975] l S.C.R.
Ordinances framed by the Gujarat University under the Gujarat University Act, 1?49 and saved by sub'sectiou (4) of sectiqJ 55 of the Gujarat University (Amendment) Act, 1972 are ultra vires articles 14, 19(1) (f) and (g), 26, 29 and 30 of the Constitution of India; (3) That section 33A inserted in the Gujarat udvcrsity Act 1949 (Bombay Act No. L of 1949) as amended by the Gujarat University (Amendment) Act, 1972 (GujJrat Act No. 6 of 1973) read with section 20 (Clause XXXIX) a> Jnserted in the Gujarat University Act, 1949 by the Gujarat University Amendment Act, 1972 are ultra vires article' I 4. 19(1) (f) and (g), 26, 29 and 30 of the Constitution of India.'' Prayer was also made by the petitioners fc~ restraining the University from considering or passing the resolutions at items Nos. 144 and 145 of the agenda in the meeting proposed to be held on March 2 7, 2 8 and 29, 1973. When the petition came up for preliminary hearing on March 27, 1973 this Cciurt made an order that the University might pass the resolutions in question on March 27, 28 and 29, 1973 but should not implement the same. The following resolution was passed by the Senate in the meeting held on March 27 and 28, 1973 . "It is hereby resolved that af! instructions, teaching and training in courses of studies in respect of which the Umversity is competent to hold examinations shall within the University area be conducted by the University and shall be imparted by the teachers of the University."
ll
In view of the stay order of this Court, the above resolution has not been implemented. The petition has been resisted by the two respondents, and the affidavits of the Under Secretary to the Government of Gujarat and the Registrar of the University have been filed in opposition to the petition. When the petition came up for hearing on November 12, 1973, the Court referred the petition to a larger Bench. It was dtrected that notice of the matter be issued to the Advocates Gcne:·al of the States, Attorney General of India as well as the Union of India. Public notice was also issued to the minority institutions to enter appeaiance, if so advised. The All India University Teachers Ass.ociation was also granted permission for being heard in the matter. Lengthy arguments have thereafter been addressed ocfc~e U5 on behalf of the petitioners, the respondents as well as others who have been allowed to intervene. The arguments have, however, been confined to the question as to whether the impugned provision> viofate article 30 of the Cc1nstituiton. No arguments were heard on the point as to whether the impugned provisions are liable to be struck down on other grounds.
•
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Khanna./.)
•
We may now refer to some of the relevant provisions of the Constitution to which reference has been made. According to clause (I) of article 25, subject to public order, morality and health and to the other provisions of Part III, all persons are equally entitled to freedom o! conscience and the right freely to profess, practise and propa~ate religion. Article 26 gives a right, subject tel public order, moral!Jy and health, to every religious denomination or any section thereof (a) to establish and maintain institutions for religious and cha1itable purposes; (b) to manage its own affairs in matters of religic,n; (c) to own and acquire movable and immovable property; and (d) to admini~ter such property in accordance with law. Articles 28, 29 and 30 contain provisions for educational institutions and read as uuder : "28. (I) No religious instruction shall be providei in any educational institution wholly maintained out of State funds. (2) Nothing in clause (!) shall apply to an educational institution which is administered by the State but has. been established under any endowment or trust which requires that religious instruction shall be imparted in such institut10n.
\
~
(3) No person attending any educatic!l1al institution re· cognized by the State or receiving aid out of State funds shall be required to take part in any religious in>truction that may be imparted in such institution or to attend any religious worship that may be conducted in such institution Cir in any premises attached thereto unless such person or. if such person is a minor, his guardian has given
his consent
thereto. 29. (I) Any section of the citizens residing in the territory of India or any part therecjf having a distinct language, script or culture of its own shall have the right to conserve the same.
(2) No citizen shall be denied admission into any educational institution maintained by the State or receiving aid out of State funds en grounds only of religion, race, caste, lar.guage or any of them. 30. (I) All minorities. whether based on religion or language, shall have the right to establish and admini3tcr educafonal institutions of their choice. (2) The State shall not, in granting aid tc educational institutions, discriminate against any educaticl!'al institut;on on the ground that it is under the management of a minority, whether based on religion or language."
Article 28 forbids. snbject to the exception c·ontained in clcusc (2), the imparting of religious instructions in any educational institutic111 wholly maintained out of State funds. The article also contarns provision against compulsion for persons attending an educational insti-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 1 s.c.R.
tuticlll, recognized by the State or receiving aid out of State funds, to take part in any religious instruction that may be imparted in rnch institution or to attend any religious worship that may be c~nducted in such institution or in any premises attached thereto. Although the marginal note of article 29 mentions protection of minority rights, the rights actually conferred by that article are not restricted merely to the minorities. According to clause (1) of that article, any section of the citizens residing in the territory of India qr any part thereof having a distinct language, script or culture of its own shall have the right to conserve the same. In order to invoke the benefit of this clause, all that is essential is that a section of the citizens residing in the territory c~ India or any part thereof shculd have a distinct language, script or culture of its own. Once that is provided those citizens sha!J have the right to conserve their language, script or ·culture irrespective of the fact whether they are members of the majority. community or minority community. Clause (2) of a•ticlc 29 forbids the denial of admission to citizens into any educational institution maintained by the State or receiving aid out of State funds on grounds only of religion, race, caste, language or an)· of them. Clause (1) of article 30 gives right to all minorities, whether based -on religion or language, tel establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. Analysing that clause it would follow that the right which has been oonferrcd by the clause is on two types of minorities. Those minorities may be based either on religicni or on language. The right conferred upon the said minorities is to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. The word .. establish" indicates the right to bring into existence, wbile tJ:Le r.igh( io administer .an institution means the right to effectively manage and ·conduct the affairs of the institution. Admimstration conllQtes management of the affairs of the institution. Th.e. ma11a&eme11_t must be free of control so that the fctunders or their nominees can mould the "institution as they think fit and in accordance with their ideas of bow the interest of the community in general and the imtltution in particular will be best served. The words "of their choice" qualify the educational institutions and show that tlie educl!l!onal institutions established and administered by the minorities need not be of some particular class; the minorities have the right and freedom to establish and administer such educational institutions as they choose. Clause { 2) of article 30 prevents the State from making discrimination in the matter of grant of aid t.o any educational instiution on the ,uound that the institution is under the management of a minority whether 'based on religion or language. Before we deal with the contentions advanced 1Jefore us and the scope and ambit o! article 30 o1' the Constitution, it may be pertinent to refer to the historical background. India is the second most populous country of the world. The people inhabiting this vast land profess different religions and speak different languai;,es. Despite the ·diversity of religion and language, there runs through the fabric of the nation the golden thread of a basic innate unity. It is a mosaic of ·different religions languages and cultures. Each of them has made a
• X
C
.. ( ,
II
ST. XAVJERS COLLEGE v, GUJARAT (Khanna, J.)
mark on the lndian polity and India today represents a· synthesis· of them all. The closing years of the British rule wero ma,ked by com-
munal riots and dissensions. There was also a feeling of distrust hn.d
the demand was made by a secticlll of the Muslims for a separate homeland. This ultimately resulted in the partition of the country. Those who led the fight for independence in India always :aid great stress on communal amity and accord. They wanted the establishment of a secular State wherein people belonging to the different religions should all have a feeling of equality and non-discriminatirn. Demand had also been made before the partition by sections of peoplo belonging to the minorities for reservation of seats and separa•e ekctorates. . In order to bring abc;ut integration and fusion of the difiercnt s~ctions of the population, the framers of the Constituti·on did away with separate electorates and introduced the system of joint electorat<s. so that every candidate in an election should have to look for support of all sections of the citizens. Special safeguards were guaranteed for the minorities and they were made a part of the fundamental rights with a view to instil a sense of confidence and security in the minorities. Those provisions ·were a kind of a Charter of rights for rhc n1innriti~s so that none might have the feeling that any section of the population ccmisted of first-class citizens and the others of secund-ctass citizens. The result was that minorities gave up their claims for rc>ervation of seats. ·Sardar Patel, who was the Chairman of the Advisory Coinmittee dealing with the question of minorities, said in the course of his speech delivered on February 27. 1947 : "This Committee forms one ct the most vital palls of the Constituent Assembly and one of the mo.st difficu!t tasks that has to be done by us is the work of this committee. Often you must have heard in various debates in British Parliament that have been held on this question recently and before when it has been claimed on behalf of the British Government that they have a special 'responsibiirty-a special obligation-for protection of the interests of the mh:orities. They claim to have more special interest than 11·e hove. It is for us to prove that it is a bogus claim. a false 1=laim. and that nci'Jody can be more interested than us in Indra in the protection of our mi"noritics. Our-- missjon is to satisfy every interest and safeguard the interests of all the minorities to their satisfaction." (The Framing of India's Constitution B. Shiva Rao Select Dc1:uments. Vol. H p. 66). Jt is in the context of that background that we should view the provisions of the Constitution contained in articles 25 to 3il. The object of articles 25 to 30 was to preserve the rights of rdigicus and linguis· tic minorities. to place them on a secure pedestal ai.d withdraw them from the vicissitudes of political controversy. These provisions enshrined; a befitting pledge to_ the minorities in the Coustiluticn of the country whose greatest son had laid down his life for the_ protection.of the minorities. As long as the Constitution stands as it is today, no tampering with those rights can be countenanced. Any attempt to do so would be not only an act of breach of faith, it would be constitu-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1975} 1 S.C.R.
tionally impermissible and liable to be struck dowu by the co;rts. Although the words secular state are not expressly mentioned in the Constitution, there can be no doubt that our Constitution-makers wanted establishment of such a state. The provision; ol the Constitution were designed accordingly. There is no mysticism in the secular character of the state. Secularism is neither anti ·God, nor pro·God; it treats alike the devout, the agnostic and the atheist. It eliminates God frcm the matters of the state and ensures that no one shall be discriminated against on the ground of religion. The Constitution at the same time expressly guarantees freedom of conscience and the right freely to profess, practise and propagate religion. The Constitution-makers were consciq:is of the deep attachment the vast masses of our country had towards religion, the sway it had on their minds and the significant mle it played in their lives. To a:Jay all apprehensions of interferenc;; by the legislature and the executive in matters of reli· gion, the rights mentioned in articles 25 to 30 wrc made a part of the fundamental rights and religious freedom contained in those articles was guaranteed by the Constitution. As in the case of religion so in the case of language, the importance of the matter and the sensitivity of the people on this issue was taken note of by the Constitution-makers. Language has a close relationship with culture. According to the Royal Commission on Bilingu-alism and Biculturalism ( 1965), the vitality of the language is an essential condition for the preservation of a culture and an attempt tel provide for cultural equality is primarily an attempt to m~k~ provisions for linguistic equality (quoted on page 590 of Cana:lian Constitutional Law in a Modern Perspective by J. Noel Lycp: and Ronald G. Atkey). The idea of giving some special rights to the minorities is not to have a kind of a privi'eged or pampered section of the poou!alion but to give to the minorities a sense ct security and a feeling of confidence. The great leaders of India since time immemorial had preached the doctrine of tolerance and catholicity of outlook. Those noble ideas were enshrined in the Constitution. Special rights fctr minorities were designed not to create inequality. Their real effect was to bring about equality by ensuring the preservation of the minority institutions and by guaranteeing to the minorities autonomy in the matter of the admi· nistration of thci>o imtitutions. The differential treatment for the minorities by giving them speciai rights is intended to brinq about an equilibrium, so that the ideal of equality may not be reduced to a mere abstract idea but should become a living reality and result in true, genuine equality, an equality not merely in theory but also in 'act. The majority in a system of adult franchise hardly needs any protection. It can look after itself and protect its interests. Any measure .vanted by the majority can witho.ut much difficulty be brought on the statute book because the majority can get that done by giving such a mandate to the elected representatives. It is onlv the minorilles who need protection, and article 30, besides some other articles. is intended to afford and guarantee that protection. It may be appos·te in this comext to
C
• (
•
.
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Khanna,/.)
J>
•
•
.2.25
refer to the observations made by Latham C.J. in Adelaide Co. of !elwmh's Witnesses Inc .. v. The Commonweallf1( 1 ) while dealing, \··:it'.t sectioil I16 of the Commonwealth of Australia (Constitution) Act which provides inter alia that the Commonwealth shall not· make any law for prohibiting the free exercise of any relig on. Said the learned Chief Justice : " .... it should not be forgotten that such a provision as section 116, is not required for the protection of the religion of a majority. The religion of the majority of the people can loJ'.( after itself. Section 116 is required to protect the religion (or absence of religion) of minorities, and, in particular, of unpopular minorities." It would in the above context be also pertinent to refer tq the observations of the majority of the Permanent Court of International Justice in a matter relating to the minority schools in Albania. On October 2, 1921 Albania, subsequent to her admission into the League of Nations, signed a Declaration relatin15 to the position of minorities in Albania. The first paragraph of Article 4 of. that Declaration ran as follows : "All Albanian nationals shall be equaloefore 'the law, and shal' enjoy the same civil and political rights without distinction as to race, language or religion". Article 5 of the Declaration was in the following words :
"Albanian nationals who b~long \0. racial, religious or linguistic minorities will en.i'1Y the same treatment and security in law and in fact as other Albanian nationals. In particular they shall have an equal right to maintain, manage and control at their own expense or to establish in the future, charitable, religious and social institutions,, schools and other educational. establishments, with the right to use their own Janvuge and to exercise their religion freely therein":. In .. 1933 the Albanian National Assembly modified Articles 206 rina 207 of the Albanian Constitution which permitted the- setting up of private schools. Henceforth those articles provided a~ !allows ; -"The .illStrµ<:c lion and education of Albanian subjects are reserved to the State and will b given in State schools. Primary education is compuE'ary for all Albanian nationals and will be given free of charge. Private schools of all categories at present in operation will be closed." Follow.ing upon the ab.ave change in the articles of .thG Constitu · tion, a number of petitions were presented to the Council of the League stating that the new provisions of the Constitution were contrary to the Declaration. In January 1935 the Council of.the League adopted a Rcwlution requesting the Permanent C<Jurr of International Justice to give an ·Opinion on the question "whether, regard being had to the above·mentioned Declaration of October 2, 1921, as a whole, the Alba~ian Government is justified in its plea that, as the abolition of private schools in Albania constitutes a general measure applicable to the majority as well as to-the minority, it-is in conformity with the letter and the spirit of the stipulation". It was held by S' votes to 3 that the plea of the Albanian Government that, as the abolition of private schools in Albania constitutes a general measure applicable to the (1) [19431 67 Com. L. R. 116. 16-L 131 Sup. Cl./7} .
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 1 S.C.R.
majority as well as to the minority, it is in conformity with the letter and spirit of the stipulations laid down in Article 5, first paragraph, of the Declaration of October 2, 1921, is not well founded. In the above conte~ the Court observed :
"1. The Object of Minorities Treaties.-'The idea underlying the treaties for the protection of minorities is to se~"Ure for certain elements incorporated in a State, the population of which differs from them in race, language or religion, the possibility of living peaceably alongside that population and co-operating amicably with it, while at the same time preserving the characteristics which distinguish them from the majority, and satisfying the ensuring special needs.
• '1
In order to attain that object, two things were regarded as particularly necessary, and have formed the subject of provisions in these treaties. The first is to ensure that nationals belonging to racial, religious or linguistic minorities shall be placed in every respect on a footing of perfect equality with the other nationals of the State. The second is to ensure for the minority eleme]lts suitable means for the preservation oi their racial peculiarities, their traditions and their national characteristics.
These two requirements are indeed. closely interlocked, for there would be no true equality between a majority and a minority if the latter were deprived of its own institutions and were consequently compelled to renounce that which constitutes the very essence of its being a minority."
It was further observed : "There must be equality in fact as well as ostensible legal equality in the sense of the absence of discrimination in the words of the law. Equality in law precludes discrimination of any kind; whereas equality in fact may involve the necessity of different treatment in order to attain a result which estabIishes an equilibrium between different situations.
T
It is easy to imagine cases in which equality of treatment of the majority and of the minority, whose situation and requirements. are different, would result in inequality in fact; treatment of thi& description wc111Id run counter to the first sentence of puragraph I of Article 5. The equality between members of the majority and of the minority must be au effective, genuine equality; that is the meaJting of this pro· vision." ..
The Court referred to Article 5 of the Declaration and observed : "This sentence of the paragraph being linked to the first by the words 'in particular', it is natural to conclude that it
•
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Khanna,!.)
•
'
•
.envisages a particularly important illustration of the application of the principle of identical treatment in law and in fact that is stipulated in the first sentence o~ the paragraph. For the institutions mentioned in the second sentence are indispensable to enable the minority to enjoy the same treatment as the majority, not only in law but also in fact. The abolition of these institutions, which alone can satisfy the special requirements of the mirn>rity groups, and their replacement by government instituticlns, would destroy this .equality of treatment, for its effect would be to deprive the minority of the institutions appropriate to its needs, whereas .the majority would continue to have them . supplied in the institutkms created hy the State." It would be appropriate tq refer at this stage to the cases wherein this Court has dealt with the impact of article 30 on the educational institutions established by the minorities. The first case ('1 ) was a reference made by the President under article 143 ( 1J .Jf the Constitution for obaining the opinion of this Court upon certain questions relating to the constitutional validity of the provisions of !he Kerala Education Bill which had been passed by the Kera!a Legbiativc Assembly and had been reserved by the Governor for the consideration of the President. Four questions were referred to the Court, out of which we are at present concerned with question No. 2 which was as under :
"Do sub-clause (5) of clause 3, sub-clau1e (3) of clause 8 and clauses 9 to 13 of Kerala Educatictll Bill, or any provision thereof, offend clause ( 1) of article 30 of the Constitution in any particulars or to any extent ?" Clause 3 ( 5) of the Bill made the reoognition of new schools sub· ject to other provisions of the Bill and the rules framed by the Government under clause 36. Clause 15 authorised the Government to acquire any category of schools. Clause 8 ( 3) made it obligatory on all aided schools to band over the fees to the Government. Clauses 9 to 13 made provisions for the regulation and management of schools, payment of salary to the teachers and the terms and conditirn1s of their appointment. The Bench which heard the reference consisted of 7 judges. Six members of the Bench speaking through Das CJ answered question No. 2 in the following words :
"Question No. 2 : (i) Yes, so far as Anglo-Indian educational institutions entitled to grant under Art. 337 are concerned. (ii) As regards other minorities not entitled to grant as of right under any express provision of the Constitution, but are in receipt of aid or desire such aid and also as regards Anglo-Indian educational institutions in so far as they are receiving aid in excess of what are due to them under Art. 337, clauses 8(3), and 9 to 13 do not offend Art. 30 ( 1) but clause 3 ( 5 j in so far as it makes such educational . (I) (1959] S. C.R. 995.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1975] 1 S.C.R.
institutions subject to clauses 14 and 15 do offend Art. 30 (1). (iii) Clause 7 (except sub-els. (1) and (3) which applies only to aided schools), cl. 10 in so far as they apply to recognized schools to be established after the said .Bill comes into force do not offend Art. 30(1) but cl. 3(5) in so far as it makes the new schools established after the commencement of the Bill subject to cl. 20 does offend Art. 30(1)."
It was held that : "Article 30(1) of the Constitution made no distinction between minority institutions existing from before the Con.stitution or established thereafter and protected both. It did not require that a minority institution should be confined to the members of the community to which it belonged and a minority institutions could not cease to be so by admitting a non-member to it. Nor did Art. 30(1) in. any way limit the subject to be taught in a minority institution, and its crucial words 'of their own choice', clearly indicated that the ambit of the rights i.t conferred was determinable by the nature of the institutions that the minority communities chose to establish and the three categories into which such institutions could thus be classified were (1) those that sought neither aid nor recognition from the State, (2) those that sought aid, and (3) those that sought recognition but not aid. The impugned Bill was .concerned only with institutions of the second and third categories."
•
It was further held : "The right of the minorities to administer their educationaf institutions under Art. 10(1). wa< nnt incM<i<tent with the right of the State to insist on proper safeguards against maladministration by imposing reasonable regulations as conditions precedent to the grant of aid. That did not. however, mean that State Legislature could, in the exercise of its powers of legislation under Arts. 245 and 246 of the Constitution, override the fundamental rights by employing indirect methods, for what it had no power to do directly, it could nC)t do indirectly." Dealing with the question of State recognition of the minocity institulions, 'the Court held : · "While it was undoubtedly true that there could be no fundamental right to State recognition, denial of recognition except . on such t·erms as virtually amounted to a surrender of the . right tp adqlinister .the institution, must, in substance ·and . ·effect infringe Art, 30(1) of the Constitution." Verikatarama Aiyar J. in his minority opinion held that 'a~ticl~ 390.l of the Constitution did not in terms confer a nght on the mmon\y mst1tutions to State• recognition, nor, properly construed,. could' it d{J so by
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Khanna,!.)
implication, for such an implication, if raised, would be contrary to the express provisions of articfe 45 of the Constitution. Article 30( 1) was primarily intended to protect such minority institutions as imparted purely religious education and to hold that the State was bound thereunder to recognize them would be tantamount not on~y to rendering article 45 wholly infructuous but also to nullifying the basic concept of the Constitution itself, namely, its secular character.
Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai & Ors. v. State of Bombay & Anr.('J was the next case in which this Court went into the question of the right of minoriti·es to establish and administer educational institutions. The petitioners in that case professed the Christian faith and belonged to the United Church of Northern India. They were members of a society which maintained educational institutions primarily for the benefit of the Christian Community. The society conducted forty-two primary schools and a Training College for teachers. The teachers trained in the college were absorb-ed in the primary schools conducted by the society and those not so absorbed were employed by other Christian Mission Schools conducted bv the United Church of Northern India. The cost of maintaining the iraining college and the primary schools was met out of donations received from the Irish Presbyterian Mission, fee from scholars and grant-in-aid from the State Government. On May 28, 1955, the Government of Bombay issued an order that from the academic year 1955-56, 80% of the seats in the training colleges for teachers in non-Government training colleges should be reserved for teachers nominated by the Government. The Principal of the Training College was thereafter asked by the Educational Inspector no to admit without specific permission of the Education Department private students in excess of 20% of the total strength in each class. It was also mentioned by the Educational Inspector that the refusal to admit Government nominated teachers was irregular and against Go"' ernment policy. Warning was administered to the petitioners that disregard of the Government orders would result in the stoppage of grant. The petitioners thereupon approached this Court under article 32 of the Constitution on the allegation that the directions issued to them were violative of article 30(1) and other provisions of the Constitution. It was held by a Bench of six judges speaking through Shah J. (as he then was) that the rules for recognition of private training institutions, in so for as they related to reservation of seats therein und·or orders of Government and directions given pursuant ther·:=to re,Q:arding reservation of 80% of the seats and the threat to withhold grant-in-aid and recognition of the college, infringed the fundamental freedom under article 30(1). Rev Father W. Proost & Ors. v. The Stale of Bihar & Ors.(') was the next cas·3 wherein this Court dealt with the protection afforded by article 30(1) to educational institutions established by the minorities. The case related to the St. Xavier's College Ranchi which had been establish·3d by the Jesuits of Ranchi and was affiliated to Patna University. The object of founding the College, inter alia, was to give Catholic (l) [1963] 3 S. C.R. 837.
(2) [1969] 2 S. C. R. 73.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1975) 1 S,C.R.
youth a full course of moral and liberal education, by imparting a thorough religious instruction and by maintaining a Catholic atmosphere in the Institution. However, the College was open to nonCatholics and all non-Catholic students received a course of moral science. The Bihar Legislature by an amending Act introduced section 48-A in the Bihar Universities Act with effect from March I, 1%2. The said section related to the establishment of a University Service Commission for affiliated colleges no\ belonging to the State Government. According to clause 6 of that section, subject to the approval of the University, appointments, dismissals, removals, termination of service or reduction in rank of teachers of an at!iliated college not belonging to the State Government shall be made by the governing body of the colle&e on the recommendation of the Commission. Clause 11 of that section inter alia provided that the Commission shall be consulted by the governing body of a college in all disciplinary matters affecting a teacher of the college and no memorials or petitions relating to such matters shall be disposed of nor shall any action be taken against, or any punishment imposed on, a teacher of the college otherwise than in conformity with the finding of the Commission. The petitioners approached this Court under article 32 of the Constitution and contended that the St. Xavier'~ College Ranchi was founded by Christian minority and they had a right to administer it. According to the petitioners, section 48-A deprived them of the right under article 30 inasmuch as its provisions required inter alia that appointments, dismissals, reduction in rank, etc., of the stafI must. be madei by the governing body on the recommendation of the University Service Commission for affiliated colleges; in no case could the governing body appoiI<t person not recommended by the Commission; the Commission had to be consulted in all disciplinary matters and any punishment imposed on a teacher could be only in accordance with the lindings of the Commission. Subsequent to the introduction of section 48-A, in view of differences arising between the University and the college, the University withdrew the affiliation of the college. While the petition was pending, section 48-B was inserted into the Bihar Universities Act whereby it was provided that the governing body of affiliated colleges established by a minority based on religion or language would bo entitled to make appointments, dismissals, termination of service or reduction in rank of teachers or take other disciplinary measures sub~ iect only to the approval of the Commission and the Syndicate of the Uni~ersity. While allowing the petition tiled by. the petitioners, it was held by a Constitution Bench of this Court speakmg through H1dayatullah C.J. that the protection claimed by the petitioners cl'early flowed from the words of article 30(1) of the Constitution. It was further held that the width of article 30(1) could not be cut down by introducing in_ it considerations on which article 29 ( 1) was based. Rt. Rev. Bishop S. K. Patro & Ors. v. State of Bihar & Ors.( 1) was th·e next case wherein this Court dealt with a claim based on article 30(1) of the Constitution. The case related to a schooffounded in 1954 at Bhagalpnr. The school was being managed by the National (I) [1970] I S.C,R. 172.
•
HI
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Khanna, J.)
•
•
2 31
Christian Council of India. Two persons were elected as the President and Secretari)' of the school and their election was approved by the President of the Board of Secondary Education. The order of the President of the Board of Secondary Education was set aside by the Secretary to the Government, Education Department by order dated May 22, 1967. On June 21, 1967 the Regional Deputy Director of Education, Bhagalpur addressed a letter to the Secretary, Church Missionary Society School, Bhagalpur inviting his attention to the order dated May 22, 1967 and requesting him to take steps to constitute a Managing Committee of the School in accordance with that order. A petition was then filed in the High Court of Patna by four petitioners for restraining the State of Bihar and its officers from interfering with the right of the petitioners to administer and manage the affairs of the school. The High Court dismissed the petition on the ground that the school was not an educational institution established by a minority. The aforesaid petitioners then came up in appeal to this Court. Petitions under article 32 of the Constitution were also filed by other petitioners in this Court. This Court held that the school in question was an educational institution established by a religious minority. On the above finding the Court speaking through Shah J. (as he then was) held that the order passed by the educational authorities requiring the Secretary of the School to take steps to constitute a Managing Committee in accordance with the order dated May 22, 1967 was invalid. Question of the protection of article 30 (1) next arose in the case of State of Kera/a, etc. v. Very Rev. Mother Provincial.(') This case related t.1 the Kerala University Act, 1969. The said Act was passed to reorganise the University of Kerala with a view to establish a teaching, residential and affiliating University for the southern districts of the State of Keral'a. Some of its provisions affected prjvate colleges, particularly those founded by minority communities in th0 State. The constitutional validity of those provisions was challenged by members of the' minority communities in writ petitions filed in the High Court. Sections 48 and 49 of the Act dealt with governing body for private colleges not under corporate manag,ment and with managing council for private colleges under corporate management. In either case the educational agency of a private college was required to set up a governing body for a private college or a managing council for private colleges under one corporate management. The sections provided for the composition of the two bodies so as to include Principals and Managers of the private colleges, nominees of the.University and Government, as well as elected representatives of te,achers. Subsection (2) provided that the new bodies would be bodies corporate having perpetual succession and a common seal. Sub-section {4) provided that the members would hold office for four years. Subsection ( 5) of each section cast a duty on the new governing body or the managing council to administer the private college or colleges in accordance with the provisions of the Act. Sub-section (6) oT each section laid down that the powers and functions of the new bodies, the removal of members thereof and the procedure to be followed by them, (1) [1·971] l. S.C.R. 734.
SUPREME COURT ·R.EPORTS
[1975] f S.C.R.
"'.o~ld be prescribed by statutes. The petitioners challenged the prov1s1ons of those two ~ect10ns as also sub-sections ( 1), (2), (j) and (~) of sect10n 53 which conferred on the Syndicate of the University (he power to veto the d~cisions of the governing council and a right of ~ppeal to any person aggrieved by their action. Likewise, the petltloners challenged section 56, which conferred ultimate powers on the University and the Syndicate in disciplinary matters in respect of teach· ers, section 5 8, which removed membership of the Legislative Assembly as a disqualification for teachers and section 63 ( 1), which provided that whenever Government was satisfied that a grave situation had arisen in the working of a private college, it could inter alia appoint the University to manage the affairs of such private college for a temporary period. The High Court on petitions filed by the petitioners declared some of the provisions of the Act to be invalid. On appeal this Court sp·,aking through Hidayatuliah CJ. held that the High Court was right in holding that sub-sections (2) and ( 4) of sections 48 and 49 were ultra vires article 30( 1). Sub-section ( 6) of each of those two sections was also held to be ultra vires, The High Court, it was further held, was also right in declaring that sub-sections (J), (2) am! (9) of section 53, sub-sections (2) and (4) of section 56, were ultra vires as they fell within sections 48 and 49; that section 58 (in so far as it removed disqualification which the founders might not like to agree to), and section 63 were ultra vires article 30(1) in resp~ct of the minority institutions.
The last two cases wherein this Court considered the impact of article 30 on minority institutions were D.A.V. College Bathinda, etc. v. State of Punjab & Ors.( 1 ) and D. A. V. College etc. v. State of Punjab & Ors. ( 2 ) Judgments in both these cases were pronounced on May 5, 1971. Jaganmohan Reddy J. spoke for the Court in these two cases. The petitioners in the case of D. A. V. College Bathinda were educational institutions founded by the D.A.V. College Trust and Society. It was an association of Arya S.amajis. The instltutions were before the reorganization of the State of Punjab affiliated to the Punjab University. The Punjabi University was constituted in 1961. After the. reorganization of Punjab, the Punjab Government under section 5 of the Act specified tbe areas in which the Punjabi University exercised its power and notified the date for the purpose of the section. The efl;ec_t of the notification was that the petitioners \vere deemed to be associated with and admitted to the privikges of the Punjabi Universiny and ceased to be associated in any way with the Punjab University. Thereafter by circular dated June 15, 1970 the University declared that Punjabi would be the sole medinm of instruction and examination for the pre-University even for science gronps, with effect from the academic year 1970-71. On October 7, 1970 a modification was made allowing English as an alternative medium of examination. It was, however, mentioned that qualifying in the elementary Punjabi papers would be obligatory for the students offering English medium. Petitions were thereafter filed in this Court under article 32 of the Constitution on the ground that the University had no power (1) [1971] S. C. R. 677.
(2) [l971] 1 S. C.R. 6S8.
B'
(
j
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Khanna,].)
··------
to ma'.,e, Punjabi as the sole medium of instruction. It was held by this Court :trnt th~ drcular of June 15, 1970 as amended by the circulars of July :, _'.J7Q ani;t Octorer 7, 1970· was invalid and ultra vlres the powers vested in the University. The Court further held that the· petitioners were institutions maintained by a religious minority and as such the directive for the exclusive use of the Punjabi langu"£!' in the Gurmukhi script as the medium for instruction and for examination in all colleges direetly infringed the petitioners' right to conserve their script and administer their institutions. The relaxation n;iade subsequently in the earlier directive of the University, it was observed, made little difference because the concession did not benefit students with Hindi as the medium and· Devnagri as the script. The right of- the minorities to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice, it was further held, included the right to have a choice of .the medium of instruction also. That would be the result of reading article 30(1) with article 29(1). No inconvenience or difficulties, administrative or financial, could justify the infringement of guaranteed rights.
The other case, D.A. V. College v. State of Punjab (supra) arose out of writ petitions filed by .the various colleges J!!il,Ilaged and administered b.)I Pie D.A.V. Colleg~ Trust and Managing Society. These colleges were before the Punjab Reorganization Act affiliated to the Punjab University. As a result of notification issued under section 5 of the Guru Nanak.University (Amritsar) Act (Act 21 of 1969) those colleges, which were in the specified areas ceased to be affiliated to the Punjab University and were to be associated and admitted to the privileges of the Guru Nanak University. By clause 2(1 )(a) of the statutes framed under the Act the coll-:ges were required fo have a regularly .constituted governing body consisting of not more thal.l 20 persons approved by' the Senate. It was also provided that the governihg body would include two representatives of the University and the Principal of the College. Under clause ( 1)(3) if these requirements were no.t complied with, the affiliation was liable to be withdrawn. Under clause 17 the staff initially appointed had to be approved by the· I' Vice-Chancellor and all subsequent changes were also to be reported to the University for Vice·Chancellor's approval. Clause 18. required non-Governm~nt colleges to comply with the requirements laid down in the ordinance governing service and conduct of teachers in nonGovernment colleges· as might be framed by the University. This · - Court held that Arya Samaj was a part of the Hindu ·religious minority in the State of Punjab and that Arya Samajis had a distinct script of their own, namely, Devnagri. Arya Samajis were held entitled to invoke the right guaranteed by article 29 (I) because they were a sec.lion of citizens having a distinct script; they were also- entitled · to invoke article 30(1) because they were a religious minority. Clauses · 2(1 )(a) and 17 of Chapter V of the statutes were struck down by ihe Court as offending article 30(1) because they interfered with the right of the religious minority to administer their educational institutions. H Oanse 18 was held notto suffer from the. same vice as clause 17.
•
I have giv~n above the gist of the different decisions of this Court dealing with articles 29 and 30. Having done that, we should now
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 1 S.C.R.
consider the principle which should be adopred in construing those articles.
-A
A liberal, generous and sympathetic approach is reflected in the Constitution in the matter of the preservation of the right of minoritie·s so far as their educational institutions are concerned. Although at· tempts have been made in the past to whittle down the rights of the minorities in this respect, the vigilant sections of the minorities have B resisted such attempts. Disputes have consequently arisen and come up ·before this Court for determining whether the impugned measures viofate the provisions of the Constitution embodied in articles 29 and 30. This Court has consistently upheld the rights of the minoriti.embodied in those articles and has ensured that the ambit and scope of the minority rights is not narrowed down. The broad approach has . been to see that nothing is done to impair the rights of the minorities c in the matter of their educational institutions and that the width and scope of the provisions of the Constitution dealing with those rights are not circumscribed. The principle which can be discerned in the various decisions of this Court is that the catholic approach which Jed to the drafting of the provisions relating to minority rights should !'.ot be set at naught by narrow judicial interpretation. The minorities are as much children of the soil as the majority and the approach has been I> to ensure that nothing should be done as might deprive the minorities of a sense of belonging, of a feeling of security, of a consciousness of equality and of the awareness that the conservation of their religion, culture, language and script as also the protection of their educational institutions is a fundamental right enshrined in the Constitution. The same generous, liberal and sympathetic approach should weigh with the courts in construing articles 29 and 30 as marked the delibera· tions of the Constitution-makers in drafting those articles and making them part of the fundamental rights. The safeguarding of the interest of the minorities amongst sections of population is as important as the protection of the interest amongst individuals of persons who are below the age of majority or are oth~rwise suffering from some kind of infir. niity. The Constitution and the laws made by civilized nations, there- F fore, generally contain provisions for the protection of those interests. It can, indeed, b~ said to be an index of the level of civilization and catholicity of a nation as to how far their minorities feel secure and are not subject to any discrimination or suppression. We may now deal with the scope and ambit of t~e right guara:itelJ!I
ht clause (1) of artid~ 30. The clause confers a right on all mmon· ties, whether they are based on religion or language; to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice. The right conferred by the clause ~s in absolut-~ terms a\ld is not subject to _res!fictions, as in the case of nghts conferred by article 19 of the Constitution. The right of the minorities to administer educational institutions does not. however, prevent the making of reasonable re~ations in res~ct of those institutions. The regulations have necessanly to be made Ill the interest of the institution as a minority educational institution. Th~y have to be so designed as to make it an effective vehicle for imparting education. The right to administer educational institutions can plainly
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Klza1111a, /.)
·-
not include .the right to malaeminister. Regulations can be made·· to preve~t the hous;na, of an educµtional institution in unhealthy sur-· roundrngs as also to prevent the setting up or continuation of an educa•· tional institution without qualified teachers. The State can prescribe regulations to ensure the excellence of the institution. . Prescription of standards for educational institutions does not militate against the right cf the minority to administer the institutions. Regulations made in the true interests of efficiency of instruction, discipline, health, sanitatfon, morality, public order and the like ·may undoubtedly 1>: imposed. Such regulations are not restrictions on the substance of tbe ·right which is guaranteed : they secure the proper functioning of 1he institution, in matters educational (,see observations of Shah J. in Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai, supra, p. 850). Further, as observed by Hidayatullah CJ. in the case of Very Rev. Mother Provi11Cial. (supra) the standards concern the body politic and are dictated by considerations of the advancement of the country and its pwple, Therefore, if·universities establish syllabi for. examinations they must be followed, subject however to special sub~ jects which the institutions may seek to teach, and to a certain extent the State may also regulate the conditions of employment of teachers and the health and hygiene of students. Such regulatiO!lS do not bear directly upon management as such although they may indirectly affect it. Yet the right of the State to regulate education, educational stand~ . ards and allied matters cannot be denied. The minority institutions cannot be allowed to fall below the standards of excellence cxp-~cted of educational institutions, or under the guise .of·exclusive right· of man·· agement, to decline to follow th·: general pat(err.. While the manage•·. ~ent must be left to them, they may be compelkd to keep in step with · others.
It is, in mty opinion, permissible to make regulations fer ensuring the regular payment of salaries before a particular date of the month. Regulations may well provide that the funds of the institution ·should be spent for the purpo•es of education or for the betterment of the bstitution and not. for extraneous purposes. Regulations may also F contain provisions to prevent the diversion of funds of institutions to the pockets of those incharge of management or their .embezzlement in any other manner. !;"revisions for audit of the accounts of the .. institution would be permissible regulation. Likewise, regulations may provide that ·no anti-national activity would be permitted in the educational il>Slitutions arul that those employed as members of the staff should not have been guilty of any activities against the national interG est. Minorities are as much part of the nation as the majority, and anything that impinges upcn national interest must necessarily in its ultimate operation affect the interes!S of all those who inhibit this vast Iarur krespective of the fact whether they belong to the majority O( minority. sections of the pepulation. It is, therefore, as much in the ·interest of minorities as that of the majority to ensure that the protec· · iion.. affordCd to minorit,y institutions is not used as a cloak for doing something .which is subversive. of national interests. Regulations to pre·· vent anti-national activities in educational institutions can, therefore,. be considered to be_reasonable.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] ! S.C.R.
A regulation which is designed to prevent maladministration of an . educational institution cannot be said to offend clause (I) of article 30. At the same tim~ it has to be ensured that under the power of making regulations nothing is done as would detract from the charac· ter of the in&titution as a minoritv educational institution or which would impinge upon the rights of the· minorities to establish and ~dminister educational institutions of their choice. The right conferred by arti:le 30(1) is intended to be real and effective and not a mere pious and .abstract sentiment; it is a promise of reality and not a teasing illusion. Such a right cannot be allowed to be whittled down by any measure .masquerading as a regulation. 'i\s observed by this Court in the use of Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai (supra), regulations which may lawfully be imposed either by legislative or executive action as a condition of ;receiving grant or of recognition must be directed to making the institution while retaining its character as minority institution effective as an educational institution. Such regulation must satisfy a dual testthe test of reasonableness, and the test that it is regulative of the eJu.cational character of the institution and is conducive to making the institution an effective vehicle of education for the minority community or other persons who resort to it. It has been said in the context of the American Constitution ~nd lhe Canadian Bill of Rights that the constitutional protection of religious freedom terminated disabilities, it did not create new privileges. It gave religious equality, not civil immunity. .Its essence is freedom from conformity to religious dogma, not freedom from conformity to law because of religious dogma (see dissenting opinion of Frankfurter J . .in West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnene• 1) .as well as the judgment of Ritchie J. speaking for the majority of Canadian Supreme Court in Robertson & Rosetanni v. Quern\') As a broad proposition not much exception can be taken to the above dictum and it may provide a workable yardstick in a large number of .cases. Difficulty, however, arises in cases which are in the twilight region. Provisions for prevention of disabilities do not, no doubt, create positive privileges, the two aspects are sometimes so intermixed ~hat the danger is that one may not while denying what appears to be a privilege· impinge upon a provision which is designed lo prevent a -disability and thus set at naught the guarantee of the Constitution. Apart from that whatever might be the position in USA and Canada, .so far as our Constitution is concerned it contains articles which are -designed not only to prevent disabilities of the minorities but "1>o create positive rights for them. Article 30( I) belongs to that ca:egory. If a request is made for the affiliation or recognition of an educa• tional institution. it is implicit in the request that the educational insti1ution would abide by the regulations which are made by the autho· rity granting affiliation or recognition. The said authority can always prescribe regulations and insist that they should be complied with ·before it would grant affiliation or recognition to an educational insti-· 1ution. To deny the power of making regulations to the authority (!) 319 u. s. 624
(2) 11963] S. C. R. 651; (1964) D. L. R. 2d 485.
' '( .
•
• (
•
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Khanna, J.)
concerned vnuld result in robbing the concept of affiliation or recognition until it cot.form' !o a certain standard. The fact that the· institution· .Is of the ~J:escribed standard irideed. inheres in the very concept of _affiliation or recognition. It is, therefore, permissible .for the authority concerned to prescribe regulations which must be CO!I'.-· . plied .with before an institutidn can seek and retain affiliation am.1 recognition. Question then arises whether there is any limitation on the prescription of regulations for minority educational institutions. So far as this aspect is concerned, the authority prescribing the regulations must. bear in mind that the Constitution has guaranteed a fundamontal right to the minorities for establishing and administering their educational institutions. Regulations made by the authority concerned should not impinge upon that right. Balance has, therefore, to be kept between the two objectives, that of ensuring the standard c cf excellence of the institution and that of preserving the right of the minorities to establish and administer their educational institutions. Regulations which embrace and reconcile the two objectives can be considered to be T.easonable.
It has not been disputed on behalf of the petitioners that if. the State or other statutory authorities make reasonable regulations for educational institutions, those regulations would not violate the right of a minority to administer educational institutions. We agree with the stand taken by the petitioners in this respect. 1t would be wrong to assume that an unrestricted right as in article 30 postulates absence of regulations. Regulations can be prescrib~d in spite of the unrestricted nature of the right. . The unrestricted. nature of the right connotes· freedom in the exercise of the right. Even the words '"freedom" and "free" have certain limitations. In James v. The Co111111011wea/1h(') the Privy Council dealt with the meaning of the words ... absolutely free" in section 92 of the Constitution of Australia. It was said: ·'Free" in itself is vague and indeterminate. It must . take its colour from the context. Compare for instance, its use in free speech, free love, free dinner and free trade. Free speech does not mean free speech; it means· speech hedged in by all the laws against defamation, blasphemy, sedition and so forth; it means freedom governed by Jaw, •... " The First Amendment of the American Constitution provides inter· alia that the Congress shall make no Jaw respecting establishment of religion or prohibiting the free exercise thereof. Dwline with that Amendment, the· US Supreme Court held in the case of Reynolds v. United StateJ(') that that Amendment did not deprive the Congress of the power to punish actions which were in violation of social duties or subversive of good order. The contention advanced on behalf of the appellant iii that case that polygamy was ·a part of his religious belief and the Act of the Congress prohibiting polygamy violated his free exercise of religion was repelled. In the tase of Cantwell.;; Connactic11t( 3 ) Roberts J. speakin~ for the US Supreme Court observed in respect of the First Amendment:
<n lt936J A.C. s18•.
(3).310 u. s. 296 (t940).
(2) 98 U.S. t4S 0878).
.238
SUP-RE!yfE COURT REPORTS
[1975] 1 S.C.R .
"Thus the Amendment embraces two concepts-freedom to beheve and freedom to act. The first is absolute but, in the nature of things, the second cannot be. Condu~t remains subject to regulation for the protection of society. The freedom to act must have appropriate definition to preserve the enforcement of that protection." Similar view was expressed by Latham CJ. in the case of Adelaide ,Company of Jehovah's Witnesses Inc. (supra) while dealing with ·Section 116 of the Australian Constitution when he said that "obli.Jlation to obey the laws which apply generally to the community is not regarded as inconsistent with freed'om "'. It would, therefore, follow that the unrestricted nature of a right does not prevent the making of regulations relating to the enforcement of the right. Question has been posed during the course of arguments whether .the educational institutions referred to in clause ( 1) of article 30 must only be those institutions which have been established with a view to conserve language, script or culture of a minority. To put it in other words, the question is whether clause ( 1) of article 30 is subject to the provisions of clause ( 1) of article 29. In this respect I am of the view that clause ( 1) of article 29 and clause (1) ·of article 30 deal with distinct matters, and it is not permissible to circumscribe or restrict the right conferred by clause ( 1) of article .30 by reading in it any limitation imported from clause (I) of article 29. Article 29 (I) confers a right on any section of citizens having a distinct language, script or culture of its own to conserve the same. It is not necessary, as mentioned earlier, for invoking this .clause that the section of citizens should constitute a minority. As .against that, the right conferred by article 30(1) is only upon minorities which are based either on religion or language. The right con'ferred by article 29 (1) is for the conservation cf bnguagc, script or culture, while that guaranteed by artide 30( 1) is for the establishment and administration of educational institutions of the choice of minorities. Had it been the intention of the Constitution-makers that 1he educational institutions which can be established and administered by minorities should be ouly those for conservation of their language, script or culture, they would not have failed to use words to that effect in article 30( 1). In the absence of those words, it is difficult to subscribe to the -view that' educational institutions mentioned in article 30(1) are only those which are intended to conserve language, script or culture of the minority. Clause (1) of article 30 also contains the words "of their choice". These words which qualify "educational institutions" show the vast discretion and option which the minorities have in selecting the type of institutions which they want to establish. In case an educational institution is established by a minority to conserve its di,<;tinct language, script or culture, the right -to establish and administer such institution would fall both under article 29 (1) as well as under article 30 ( 1). The minorities can, however, choose to establish an educational institution which is purely of a general secular character and is not dej;igned to conserve their distinct language, script or culture. The right to establish and administer ;such an institution is guaranteed by article 30(1) and the fact that
'y
.,
•
I
•
••
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Khanna, J.)
. I
...
'
•
such an institution does not conserve the distinct language, script or culture of a minority would not take it out of the ambit of article 30( I).
I am fortified in the above conclusion by the observations of Das CJ. in Re Kera/a Education Bill (supra) and Hidayatullah CJ. in the case of Rev. Father Proost (supra). Das CJ. observed: "The right conferred on such minorities is to establish educational institutions of their choice. It does not say that minorities based on religion should establish educa· tional institutions for teaching religion only, or that linguistic minorities should have the right to establish educational institutions for teaching their language only. What the article says and means is that the religious and the linguistic minorities should have the right to establish educational institutions of their choice. There is no limitation placed on the subjects to be taught in such educational institutions. As such minorities will ordinarily desire that their children should be brought up properly and efficiently and be eligible for higher university education and go out iii the world fully equipped with such intellectual attainments as wiil iD make them fit for entering the public services, educational institutions of their choice will necessarily include institutions imparting general secular education also." Hidayatullah CJ. expressed somewhat similar view in the following words : "In our opinion, the width of Art. 30 (1) cannot be cut down by introducing in it considerations on which Art. 29 (I) is based. The latter article is a general protection which is given to minorities to conserve their language, script or culture. The former is a special right to establish educational institutions of their choice. This choice is not limited to institutions seeking to conserve language, script or culture and the choice is not taken away if the r1inority community having established an educational institution of its choice also admits members of other communities. That is a circumstance irrelevant for the application of Art. 30(1) since no such limitation is expressed and none can be implied. The two articles create two separate rights, although it is possible that they may meet in a given case." It has been argued on behalf of the respond~nts that there is no fundamental right to affiliation or recognition and that a minority educational institution seeking affiliation or recognition must conform to the conditions which are prescribed for recognition or affiliation. So far as this aspect is concerned, I am of the view that it is permis· sible for the State to prescribe reasonable regulations like the one to which I have referred earlier and make it a condition precedent to the according of recognition or affiliation to a minority institntion. !H It is not, however, permissible to prescribe conditions for recognition or affiliation which have the effect of impairing the right of the minority to establish and administer their educational institutions. Affiliation
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1975] J S.C.R.
.and. :ecognition are, no doubt, not mentiont;d in article 30 (I), the pos1t10n all the same remains that refusal to recognize or affiliate minority institutions unless they (the miuorilies) surrender the right to administer those institutions would have the effect of rendering the right guaranteed by article 30(1) to be wholly illusory and indeeo " teasing illusion. It is, in our opinion, not permiss;ble to exact from the minorities in lieu of the recognition or affiliation of their institutions a price which would entail the abridgement or extinguishment of the right under article 30(1). An educational institution can hardly serve any purpose or be of any practical utility ur:less it is afliliated to a University or is otherwise recognized like other educational institutions. The right conferred by article 30 is a real and meaningful right. It is neither an abstract ri!!ht nor is it to be exercised in vacuum. Article 30(1) was intended to have a real significance and it is no' permissible to construe it in such a manner as would rob it of that signincance. It may be appropriate in this context to refer to the observations or Dus CJ .. n the case of Re Kera/a Education Bill (supn) on pages 1067·68 :
-
"Without recognition, therefore, the educational institu· lions established or to be established by the minority communities cannot fulfil the real objects of their choice and the rights under Art.30(1) cannot be effectively exercised. The right to establish educational institutions of their choice must, therefore, mean the right to establish real institutions which will effectively serve the needs of their community and the scholars who resort to their educational institutions. There i5, no doubt, no such thing as fundan12ntal right to r~cogni tion by the State but to deny recognition to the educational institutions except upon terms tantamoi;nt to the surrender of their constitutional right of administration of the educational institutions of their choice is in truth and in effect to deprive them of their rights under Art.30(1). We repeat that the legislative power is subject to the fundamental rights end the legislature cannot indirectly take away or abridge the fundamental rights which it could not do directly and yet that will be the result if the said Bill containing any offending clause becomes law."
Simil3r view was expressed in the. case of . Rev .. Sidhajbliai Sabhai (supra) wherein it was observed : . 'The Government also holds examinations for grantin; certificates to successful candidates as trained primary teachers, and scholars receiving training in recognized institutions alone are entitled to appear at the examination. Manifestly, in the absence ~r recognition bX. the '.Govern\!1.ent trai,n" ing in the College will have. httle pract1ca! ut1hty. Tn.c College is a non-profit making .institution 'and depends .i;ri-'. ' marily upon donations and Government grant for meetmg its expenses. Without such grant, it wquld be extremely· difficult if not impossible for ·the 'institution fo function." -
ST. XAV!ERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Khanna, /.)
What is said above with regard to aid or recognition applies equally to affiliation of a college to the University because but for such affiliation the student will not be able to obtain a University degree which is recognized as a passport to several professions and future employment in Public Service. Argument has been advanced on behalf of the respondents that unless a law or regulation is wholly destructive of the right of minorities under article 30(1), the same would not be liable to be struck down. This argument is untenable and runs counter to the plain language of article 13. According to that article, a law would be void even if it merely abridges a fundamental right guaranteed by Part III and does not wholly take away that right. The argument that a law or regulation could not be deemed to be unreasonable unless it was totally destructive of the right of the minority to administer educational institutions was expressly negatived by this Court in the case of Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai (supra). After referring to the case of Re. Kera/a Education Bill (supra) this Court observed in the case of Rev. Sidhajbhai Sabhai :
"The Court did not, however, lay down any test of reasonableness of the regulation. The Court did not decide that pub!'c or national interest was the sole measure or test' of reasonableness: it also did not decide that a regulation would be deemed unreasonable only if it was totally destructive of the right of the minority to administer educational institution. No general principle on which reasonableness or otherwise of a regulation may be tested was sought to be laid down by the Court. The Kerala Education Bill case, therefore, is not an authority for the proposition submitted by the Additional Solicitor General that all regulative measures which are not destructive or annihilative of the character of the institution established by the minority, provided the regulations are in the national interest or public interest, are valid."
It is, no doubt, true that on page 1065 of the case Re Kera/a Education Bill Das CJ. while dealing with clauses 14 and 15 of the
Bill observed that the provisions of those clauses might be totally destructive of the rights under article 30 (1). These observations were intended to describe the effect of those clauses. There is, however, nothing in those observations to indicate that this Court would have upheld those clauses if those clauses had abridged or partially destroyed the right under article 30 ( 1) and not totally destroyed that right. In the light of the above principles, it can be stated that a law which interferes with the minorities choice of a governing body or ll!anagement council would be violativ.e of the right gua;ameed ~y article 30(1). This view has been consistently taken by this Court m the cases of Rt. Rev. Bishop S. K. Patro, Mother Provincial and D.A.V. College affiliated to the Guru Nanak University (supra).
17-131SupCI/75
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[1975] 1 S.C.ll.
Section 33-A which provides for a new governing body for the management of the college and also for selection committees as well as the constitution thereof wouid consequently have to be quashed so far as the minority educational institutions are concerned because of the contravention of article 30 ( 1). The provisions of this section have been reproduced earlier and are similar to those of section 48 of the Kerala University Act, sub-section (2), (4), (5) and (6) of which were held by this Co_urt in the case of Mother Provincial (supraJ to be violative of article 30( I). In the case of Rt. Rev. Bishop S. K. Patro, this Court declared invalid the order passed by the education1l authorities requiring the Secretary of the Church Missionary Society Higher Secondary· School to take steps to constitute a managing committee in accordance with the order of the educational authorities. Section 33-A is also similar to statute 2(1) (a) which was framed under the Guru Nanak University (Amritsar) Act. Statute 2(1) (a) was as under : "2(1) (a) A College applying for admission to the privileges of the Universi~v shall send a letter of application to t)le Registrar and shall satisfy the Senate : (a) that the College shall have a regularly constituted governing body consisting of not more than 20 persons approved by the Senate and including, among others, 2 representatives of the University and the Principal of the College Ex-officio. Provided that the said condition shall not apply in the case of College maintained by Government which shall however have an advisory Committee consisting of among others the principal of the College (Ex-officio) and two representatives of the University." The above statute was struck down by this Court in the second D.A.V. College case. Another conclusion which follows from what bas been discussed above is that a law which interferes with a minority's choice of qualified teachers or its disciplinary control over teachers and other , members of the staff of the institution is void as being violative of article 30 (I). It is, of course, permissible for the State and its educational authorities to prescribe the qualifications of teachers, but once the teachers possessing the requisite qualifications are selected by the minorities for their educational institutions, the State would have no right to veto the selection of those teachers. The selection and appointment of teachers for an educational institution is one of the essential ingredients of the right to manage an educational insti'.Ution and the minorities can plainly be not denied such right of selection and appointment without infringing article 30( 1). In the case of Rev. Father W. Proost (supra), this Court while dealing with section 48-A of the Bibar Universities Act observed that the said provision
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Khanna, J.)
•
•
completely took away the autonomy of the governing body of the college and virtually vested the control of the college in the University Service Commission. The petitioners in that case were, therefore, held entitled to the protection of article 30(1) of the Constitution. The provisions of that section have been referred to earlier. According to the section, subject to the approval of University appointments, dismissals, removals, termination of service or reduction in rank of teachers of an affiliated college not belonging to the State Government would have to be made by the governing body of the college on the recommendation of the University Service Commission. The section further provided that the said Commission would be consulted by the gmerning body of a college in all disciplinary matters affecting t_eachers of the college and no action would be taken against or any punishment imposed upon a teacher of a college otherwise than in conformity with the findings of the Commission.
In the case of D.A.V. College which was ,affiliated to the Guru Nanak University, statute 17 framed under the Guru Nanak University (Amritsar) Act inter (f/ia provided that the Staff initially appointed shall be approved by the Vice-Chancellor and that all subsequent changes shall be reported to the University for Vice Chancellor's approval. This Court held that statute 17 interfered with the right of management of the petitioner colleges and, as such, offended article 30(1).
Although disciplinary control over the teachers of a minority educational institution would be with the governing council, regulations, in my opinion, can be made for ensuring proper conditions of service -of the teachers and for securing a fair procedure in the matter of disciplinary action against the teachers. Such provisions which are calculated to safeguard the interest of teachers would result in security of tenure and thus inevitably attract competent persons for the posts of teachers. Such a provision would also eliminate a potential cause of frustration amongst the teachers. Regulations made for this purpose should be considered to be in the interest of minority educational institutions and as such they would not violate article 30 (I).
' Clause (a) of sub-sections (1) and (2J of section SIA of the impugned Act which make .provision for giving a reasonable opportunity of showing cause against a penalty to he proposed on a member of the staff of an educational institution would consequently be held to be valid. Clause (b) of those sub-sections which gives a power to the Vice-Chancellor and officer of the University authorised by him to veto the action of the managing body of an educational institution in a11arding punishment to a member of the staff. in my opinion, interferes with the disciplinary control of the managing body over its
SUPRU,'.IE COURT REPORTS
(1975] l S.C.R.
teachers. It is significant that the power of approval conferred by clause (b) in each of the two sub-sections of section 51A on the ViceChancellor or other officer authorised by him is a blanket power. No guidelines are laid down f~r the exercise of that. power and it is. not provided that the approval 1s to be withheld only m case the dmmssal, removal , reduction in rank or termination of service is ma/a fide- or by way of vic_timisation or other similar cause. The conferment of such blanket power on the Vice-Chancellor or other officer authorised by him for vetoing the disciplinary action of the managing body of an educational institution makes a serious inroad on the right of the managing body· to administer an educational institution. Clause (b) of each of the two sub-sections of section 5 IA should, therefore, be held to be violative of article 30 (]) so far as minority educational· institutions are concerned. Section 52A of the Act relates to the reference of disputes between a governing body and any member of the teaching, other academic and non-teaching stall' of an affiliated college or recognized or approved institution connected with the conditions of service of such member to a Tribunal of Arbitration, consisting of one nominated by the governing body of the college or, as the case may be, of the recognised or approved institution, one member nominated by rhe member of the staff involved in the dispute and an Umpire appointed by the Vice-Chancellor. Section 52A is widely worded, and as it stands it would cover within its ambit every dispute connected with the conditions of service of a member of the staff of an educational institution, however trivial or insignificant it may be, which may arise between the governing body of a college and a member of the staff. The effect of this section would be that the managing committee of an educational institution would be embroiled by its employees in a series of arbitration proceedings. The provisions of section 52A would thus act as a spoke in the wheel of effective administration of an educational institution. It may also be stated that there is nothing objectionable to selecting the method of arbitration for settling major disputes connected with conditions of service of staff of educational institutions. It may indeed be a desideratum. What is objectionable, apart from what has been mentioned above, is the giving of the power to the Vice-Chancellor to nominate the Umpire. Normally in such disputes there would be hardly any agreement between the arbitrator nominated by the governing body of the institution and the one nominated by the concerned member of the staff. The result would be that the power would vest for all intents and purposes in the nominee of the Vice-Chancellor to decide all disputes between the governing body and the member of the staff connected with the latter's conditions of service. The governing body would thus be hardly in a position to take any effective disciplinary action against a member of the staff. This must cause an inroad in the right of the governing body to administer the institution. Section 52A should, therefore, be held to be violative of article 30(1) so far as minority educational institutions are concerned.
l
J
ST. XAVIERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Khanna, J.)
•
In view of what has been mentioned above, sections 40 and 41 of the Act would also have to be struck down so far as the minority colleges are concerned as being violative of article 30(1). The effect of sections 40 and 41 is that in case the University so determines and the State Government issues the necessary notification under subsection (2) of section 40, all instructions, teaching and training in under-graduate courses shall within the University area be conducted by the University and shall be imparted by the teachers of the University. The result would be that except in matters mentioned in the proviso to sub-section (4) of section 41 no instructions, teaching and training in undergraduate courses of study, which has hithertofore been conducted by the affiliated colleges, would be conducted by theso colleges, because the same would have to be conducted by the University and would have to be imparted by the teachers of the University. The affiliated colleges would also as a result of the above become constituent colleges. A provision which makes it imperative that teaching in under-graduate courses can be conducted only ):JY the University and can be imparted only by the teachers of the Umvers1ty plainly violates the rights of minorities to establish and administer their educational institutions. Such a provision must consequently be held qua minority institutions to result in contravention of article 30(1). I would, therefore, strike down section 40 so far as rrcinority educational institutions are concerned as being violative of Art.30( 1) Further, once section 40 is held to be unconstitutional so far as minority educational institutions are concerned, the same vice would afflict section 41 because section 41 can operate only if section 40 survives the attack and is held to be not violative of article 30(1). T would therefore, hold section 40 and 41 to be void in respect of minority educational institntions. It has been argued on behalf of the respondents that in the case of Re Kera/a Education Bill (supra) this Court upheld clauses 11 and 12. Clause 11 made it obligatory for all aided schools to select teachers from a panel of candidates selected for each district by the Public Service Commission. Clause 12 related to the conditions of service of aided teachers. According to sub-clause ( 4) of clause 12, no teacher of an aided school could be dismissed, removed or reduced in rank or suspended by the manager without the previous sanction of the authorized officer. Das CJ. observed that the above provisions were serious inroads on the right of administration and appeared perilously near violating that right. All the same, he observed that this Court "as at present advised" was prepared to treat those regulations as permissible regulations. I have already mentioned above that in subsequent cases this Court held similar provisions to be violative of article 30(1 l in the case of minority institutions. The opinion expressed by this Court in Re Kerala Education Bill (supra) was of an advisory character and though great weight should be attached to it because of its persuasive value, the said opinion cannot override the opinion subsequently ·expressed by this Court in contested cases. It is the law declared by this Court in the subsequent contested cases
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1975] 1 S,C.R.
which would have a binding effect. The words "as at present advised" as well as the preceding sentence indicate that the view expressed by this Court in Re Kera/a Education Bill in this respect was hesitant and tentative and not a final view in the matter. It has been pointed out that in Re Levy of Estate Duty(1) Spens CJ. referred to an observation made in the case of Attorney-General for Ontario v. AttorneyGeneral for Canada(') that the advisory opinion of the. Court would have no more effect than the opinion of the law officers. I need not dilate upon this aspect of the matter because I am of the opinion that the view expressed by this Court in subsequent cases referred to above by applying the general principles laid down in the Re Kerala Educa tion Bill is ·correct and calls for no interference. Reference has been made on behalf of the respondents to the recommendation of Dr. Radhakrishnan Commission made in 1948-41f wherein preference was shown for constituent colleges. So far as this aspect 1s concerned, I may observe that if any statutory provision is found to be violative of article 30(1) of the Constitution, the fact that it has been enacted in pursuance of the recommendation of an expert body would not prevent the Court from striking down that provision. It may also be mentioned that in the case of Mother Provincial (supra) reliance was placed upon the report of the Education . D Commission. This! Court in that context remarked that that fact as well as the fact that the provisions were salutary could not stand in the face of the constitutional guarantee. Reference to the said report was, therefore, considered to be not necessary. I may further mention that subsequent to the report of Dr. Radhakrishnan Commission, three other bodies submitted their reports. One of the reE ports was given by Kothari Committee in 1965. The other was the report of the Education Commission presided over by Dr. Kothari in 1966. The third was the report of Dongerkery Commission submitted in 1972. There was no reference to the conversion of affiliated colleges into constituent colleges in any of these three reports. No observation was also made in any of the reports that the provisions of article 30(1) and the construction placed upon that had in any way stood in the way of raising the standards of education or improving the excellence of educational institutions. It may also be mentioned that the concept of constituent colleges is not a rigid concept and can vary from university to university. The concept of constituent colleges which is visualized in the impugned provfaions of sections 40 and 41 of· the Act contemplates that the imparting of teaching at the under-graduate level in the prescribed course of studies shall be only by the teachers of the University. The minority colG leges as such would not be entitled to impart education in courses of study through their own teachers. Sections 40 and 41 would, therefore be as already mentioned violative of article 30(1). An a matter like this, one may perhaps. have also to ~ake into account the accepted norms for the impartmg of education. So tar as post-graduate teaching is concerned, .the general patte~n which prevails and has been accepted so far 1s that the education 1s imparted by the University. As against that, the mode for under(I) [1944] F. C. R. 317.
(2) [ 1912] A. C. 571.
'
ST. XAV!ERS COLLEGE v. GUJARAT (Khanna, J.)
'I".
• I j,.
F.
-
r
graduate teaching has been that it is imparted by the individual colleg es. A very large number of colleges, including minority colleges, have been established and are in existence for th·~ purpose ot imparting under-graduate education. The impugned provisions are calculated to do away with the .present system and in the process they impinge upon the rights of minorities under article 30(1). It would not be a correct approach to the problem to hold that because the imparting of post-gr~duate teaching by the Universities has been accepted without objection, the same rule should also hold good for the nndergraduate teaching and the same shonld not be impermissible. Such a process of extension, in my opinion, is not very helpful. If it is permissible for tb.e State to prevent the imparting of education by colleges at under-graduate level because such a course has been acceptcd at post-graduate level, there would be no reason why this principle be not extended further to the school education. The process of extension can thus totally annihilate the right guaranteed by article 30( 1). It has also been argued on behalf of the respondents that we should not strike down the impugned sections but should wait till statutes or ordinances are made in pursuance of those sections. In this respect I am of the view that since the impugned sections confer the power to frame statutes or regulations violative of the frmdamental right under article 30 (1), the very provisions of the Act conferring such power are void so far as minority institutions are concerned. The abridgement of the right of the minorities to establish and administer educational institutions of their choice is writ large on the face of the impugned provisions. The fact that no statutes or ordinances have been framed in pursuance of the impugned provisions would consequently be hardly of much significance in determining the constitutional validity of the impugned provisions. It would not, therefore, be a correct approach to wait till statutes are framed violating the right under article 30(1). No rules or statutes or ordillances framed und·er the provisions of the Act can take away the constitutional infirmity of those provisions. It is, as observed by the Judicial Committee in the case Trustees of the Roman Catholic Separate Schools for Ottawa v. Ottawa Corporation & Ors.,(1) the creation of the power and not its exercise that is subject to objection and the objection would not be removed even though the powers conferred were never exercised at all. SimiJar view was expressed in the case of Re Kera/a Education Bill (supra) wherein Das CJ. while dealing with clause 3 ( 5) read with clause 20 observed :
"It is true that cl. 36(2)(c) empowers the Government to make rules providing for the grant of recognition to pri· vate schools and we are asked to suspend our opinion until the said Bill comes into force and rules are actually made. But no rule to be framed under cl. 36(2)(c) can nullify the constitutional infirmity of cl. 3 ( 5) read with cl. 20 which is calculated to infringe the fundamental rights of (I) [1917] A. C. 76.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(1975) 1 S.C.R.
minority communities in respect of recognized schools to be established after the commencement o\ the said Bill." Reference has also been made on behalf of the respondents to the provision of Chapter VIA containing sections 38B to 38E which has been inserted by the amending Act. These provisions relate to autonomous colleges, autonomous institutions and autonomous University departments. According to section 38B, the University authorities may allow an affiliated college, a University college, a recognized institution or a University department to enjoy autonomy in the matter of admissions of students, prescribing the courses of studies, imparting instructions and training, holding of examinations and the-powers to make necessary rules for the purpose in case the University authorities are satisfied that the standard of education in such college, institution or department is so developed that it would be in the interest of education to allow the college, institution or department to enjoy autonomy. It is urged that the provision for the conversion of affiliated colleges into constituent colleges is part of a scheme which covers within its ambit autonomous colleges on the one end and constituent colleges on the other. This circumstance, in my opinion, is hardly of any significance. If the conversion of affiliated colleges of the