The Branch Manager v. SMT. Manthamma
- Court
- High Court of Karnataka
- Date of judgment
- 5 November 2026
- Judge
- Justice Ravi V Hosmani
- Case number
- MFA No. 6943 of 2017
- Result
- Partly Allowed
- Acts & sections
- Section 166 Motor Vehicles Act
- Subject
- Motor accident
Full judgment
-1HC-KAR
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 5TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026 BEFORE THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.9642 OF 2017(MV-I) C/W MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO.6943 OF 2017(MV-I) IN MFA No. 9642/2017: BETWEEN: MANTHAMMA @ MAHANTHAMMA W/O LAKSHMANAM, AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS, R/O CHIPPINAKERE VILLAGE, CHITRDURGA TALUK - 577 501. …APPELLANT [BY SRI N.R. RANGEGOWDA, ADVOCATE (PH)] AND: 1.
Digitally signed by ANUSHA V Location: High 2. Court of Karnataka
G B RAJANNA S/O G.B.BASAVARAJAPPA, AGED ABOUT 50 YEARS, R/O MALENAHALLY VILALGE, KUDLIGI TALUK - 583 135. THE BRANCH MANAGER NATIONAL INSURANCE CO.LTD., BRANCH OFFICE, JAGALURU MAHALINGAPPA COMPLEX, B.D.ROAD, CHITRADURGA - 577 501. …RESPONDENTS
[BY SRI P. NATARAJU, ADVOCATE FOR R1 (PH); SRI SRINIVASA K.N., ADVOCATE FOR R2 (PH)] THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 25.04.2017 PASSED IN MVC
-2HC-KAR
NO.377/2016 ON THE FILE OF THE 2ND ADDITIONAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE & ADDITIONAL MACT-5, CHITRADURGA, PARTLY ALLOWING THE CLAIM PETITION FOR COMPENSATION AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT OF COMPENSATION. IN MFA NO. 6943/2017: BETWEEN: THE BRANCH MANAGER NATIONAL INSURANCE CO LTD JAGALURU MAHALINGAPPA COMPLEX B D ROAD, CHITRADURGA NOW REPTD BY REGIONAL MANAGER NATIONAL INSURANCE CO LTD NO.144, SUBHARAM COMPLEX M G ROAD, BENGALURU 560001. ...APPELLANT [BY SRI A.N. KRISHNA SWAMY, ADVOCATE (PH)] AND: 1.
SMT.MANTHAMMA @ MAHANTHAMMA, W/O LAKSHMANAM AGED ABOUT 41 YEARS, AGRICULTURIST, R/AT CHIPPINAKERE VILLAGE CHITRADURGA TQ - 577 542.
2.
SRI G B RAJANNA S/O G B BASAVARAJAPPA AGED ABOUT 51 YEARS, R/AT MALENAHALLI VILLAGE KUDLIGI TQ - 583 101. ...RESPONDENTS
[BY SRI N.R. RANGEGOWDA, ADVOCATE FOR R1; SRI P. NATARAJU, ADVOCATE FOR R2 (PH)]
-3HC-KAR
THIS MFA IS FILED U/S 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 25.04.2017 PASSED IN
MVC
NO.377/2016
ON
THE
FILE
OF
THE
2ND
ADDITIONAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE & ADDITIONAL MACT-5, CHITRADURGA,
AWARDING
COMPENSATION
OF
RS.9,16,100/- WITH INTEREST AT 7.5% P.A. FROM THE DATE OF PETITION TILL THE DATE OF DEPOSIT. THESE APPEALS, COMING ON FOR ADMISSION, THIS DAY, JUDGMENT WAS DELIVERED THEREIN AS UNDER: CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVI V HOSMANI ORAL JUDGMENT
Challenging
judgment
and
award
dated
25.04.2017
passed by II Addl. Senior Civil Judge and Addl. MACT, Chitradurga, in MVC no.377/2016, these appeals are filed.
2.
MFA
no.9642/2017
is
filed
by
claimant
for
enhancement of compensation, while MFA no.6943/2017 is filed by insurer challenging finding of Tribunal on liability and on quantum.
3.
Brief facts leading to these cases as per claimant
were that at 1:45 pm on 08.02.2015 when claimant was walking
by
side
of
road
near
Nayakanahatty
Math,
-4HC-KAR
Kalyanamantapa, driver of Tractor Trailer no. KA-35/TA-136970 drove it in rash and negligent manner and dashed against her. In accident, she sustained grievous injuries and despite treatment at SSIMS Hospital, Davanagere, she did not recover fully and there was amputation of her right leg below knee. Due to same, she sustained loss of earning capacity. Therefore, she filed claim petition in MVC no.377/2016 under Section 166 of Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 ('MV Act') owner and insurer of Tractor Trailer.
4.
On contest, wherein claim petition was opposed on
all grounds, Tribunal framed issues and recorded evidence.
5.
Claimant along with Dr.Ambrish deposed as PWs.1
and 2 and got marked Exs.P1 to P20. On other hand, two witnesses were examined by respondents as RWs.1 and 2 and got marked Exs.R1 to R4.
6.
On
consideration,
Tribunal
held
accident
had
occurred due to rash and negligent driving of Tractor Trailer by its driver causing permanent physical disability, loss of earning
-5HC-KAR
capacity and claimant was entitled for compensation from insurer. Dissatisfied with findings, these appeals are filed.
7.
Sri N.R. Rangegowda, learned counsel for appellant
- claimant submitted that as on date of accident, claimant was 40 years of age doing agriculture and earning Rs.2,00,000/per annum. However without justification, Tribunal assessed her monthly income at only Rs.6,000/-. Further, medical records as well as deposition of PW.2 would indicate that claimant had sustained amputation of right leg below knee assessed by PW.2 to have caused 70% disability. However, Tribunal assessed functional disability at only 60% which was on lower side.
8.
Relying on decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court in
case of S. Ettiappan v. D. Kumar and Anr., reported in 2025 SCC OnLine SC 3690, it was submitted that in case of amputation of leg functional disability at 100% was considered and sought for adoption of same.
9.
It was further submitted that Tribunal erred in not
adding future prospects to monthly income. Even compensation
-6HC-KAR
of only Rs.1,00,000/- towards pain and suffering; Rs.20,000/towards diet and
other
incidental
expenses; Rs.48,100/-
towards medical expenses; Rs.50,000/- towards loss amenities and for artificial limb and Rs.50,000/- towards future attendant charges were on lower side and sought enhancement.
10.
In MFA no.6943/2017, Sri A.N. Krishna Swamy,
learned counsel for appellant - insurer submitted that appeal was filed mainly challenging finding of Tribunal on liability. Alleging that merely on ground that driver held driving licence to drive Tractor only and would not justify fastening of liability on insurer as accident in question was caused by a Tractor attached with Trailer i.e. Tractor Trailer unit, which would be a goods vehicle. It was further submitted that age of claimant in prosecution records was 48 years. Therefore, Tribunal was not justified in assessing her age at 40 years and applying higher multiplier. It was further submitted that award of interest at 7.5% was also excessive and seeks reduction.
11.
In
reply,
learned
counsel
for
claimant
would
submits that there was no substance in insurer's appeal but fairly conceded for reduction of rate of interest to 6%.
-7HC-KAR
12.
Heard
learned
counsel,
perused
impugned
judgment, award and material on record.
13.
From above since both insurer as well as claimant
are in appeals, points that would arise for consideration are: 1. Whether Tribunal was justified in holding insurer liable to pay compensation? 2. Whether assessment of compensation by Tribunal calls for modification? Point no.1: 14.
To establish actionable negligence against insurer,
claimant relied on prosecution records, namely complaint, FIR, spot mahazar, wound certificate, motor vehicle inspector's report and charge sheet marked as Exs.P1 to P6. Respondents have led evidence and got marked driving licence extract as Ex.R1 and insurance policy as Ex.R2. While passing impugned award, Tribunal referred to same and observed that Ex.R1 would indicate that driver had driving licence to drive Tractor. Though accident had occurred while Tractor was attached with Trailer, as per prosecution records, claimant sustained injuries due to collision by Tractor engine and not with Trailer. Under
-8HC-KAR
above circumstances, challenge of liability on ground of driving licence would not be substantiated. That apart, Hon'ble Supreme Court in Nagashetty v. United India Insurance Company Limited and Ors., reported in (2001) 8 SCC 56, held merely on ground that a Trailer is attached to Tractor, when driver of Tractor holds driving license to drive Tractor, insurer cannot avoid liability. Same would also apply to instant case. Point no.1 is therefore answered in affirmative.
Point no.2: 15.
Though claimant stated that she was 40 years old,
agriculturist earning Rs.2,00,000/- per annum, same was not substantiated with any material. In absence, Tribunal assessed her income notionally at Rs.6,000 per month. But notional income for year 2015 being Rs.9,000, Tribunal was not justified in considering it at Rs.6,000/-.
16.
Further, there is dispute about age of claimant. As
per claim petition and medical records, her age was 40 years. But prosecution records would note it as 48 years. Tribunal considered her age as 40 years. Though insurer is contending perversity of finding, there is no specific document about age of
-9HC-KAR
claimant. In absence, age could be determined by referring to material
on
record.
Though
there
is
conflict
between
prosecution records and medical records, age mentioned in medical records would fare better than prosecution records and Tribunal justified in considering same.
17.
Further, Hon'ble Supreme Court in Erudhaya Priya
v. State Express Transport Corporation Ltd., reported in 2020 SCC OnLine SC 601, has held that future prospects has to be added to monthly income even in personal injury claim. Since claimant is 40 years of age and self-employed, future prospects at 40% has to be added. Insofar as loss of earning capacity, there is no dispute about claimant having sustained amputation of right leg below knee. Ex.P10 - photographs would indicate that claimant was using artificial limb same would mitigate loss of earning to some certain extent. There is no material to establish that claimant was totally disabled from doing agriculture or any other alternate avocation to earn income as would supplement her regular income. Though Ex.P14 - disability certificate issued by PW.2 would assess physical
disability
at
70%,
Tribunal
assessed
functional
- 10 HC-KAR
disability at 60%. Assessment of functional disability or loss of earning capacity cannot be directly proportionate to physical disability. It would require moderation based on avocation and how disability sustained affects earning capacity. Under above circumstances, assessment of functional disability at 60% by Tribunal is held as justified. Consequently, compensation towards future loss of income would be (Rs.9,000/- + 40%) = Rs.12,600/- X 60% X 12 X 15 = Rs.13,60,800/-.
18.
Considering
fact
that
claimant
has
sustained
amputation of right leg below knee, award of Rs.1,00,000/towards pain and suffering would not be justified. Referring to decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar and Ors., reported in (2011) 1 SCC 343 it is found appropriate to enhance it to Rs.1,50,000/-. Considering inpatient treatment period of 40 days, award of Rs.20,000/towards diet and other incidental expenses would appear just and proper, no enhancement. There is complete reimbursement of amount for which medical bills were produced. Hence, compensation of Rs.48,100/- towards medical expenses is sustained. Tribunal has awarded Rs.50,000/- towards loss of
- 11 HC-KAR
amenities and artificial limb apart from an additional amount of Rs.50,000/- towards future attendant charges. There would be no basis for award of future attendant charges as this is not a case of total disablement. However, taking judicial notice of fact that artificial limb would require periodic maintenance and replacement and considering age of claimant at 40 years and requirement of replacement of artificial limb several times during her lifetime, it is found fit to modify award towards loss of amenities, artificial limb and future attendant charges to Rs.2,00,000/-. It is also seen that Tribunal has not awarded any compensation towards laid-up period. Taking 3 months as layoff, claimant would be entitled to Rs.27,000/- towards same.
Thus,
total
re-assessed
compensation
would
be
Rs.18,05,900/-. Therefore, point no.2 is answered partly in affirmative.
19.
Consequently, following: ORDER
(a) MFA
no.6943/2017
filed
by
insurer
is
allowed in part only insofar as interest, which is reduced from 7.5% to 6%.
- 12 HC-KAR
(b) MFA
no.9642/2017
filed
by
claimant
is
allowed in part, judgment and award dated 25.04.2017 passed by Tribunal, in MVC no.377/2016 is modified, enhancing total compensation to Rs.18,05,900/- as against Rs.9,16,100/- assessed by Tribunal. (c)
Same shall carry interest of 6% per annum from date of claim petition till its realization.
(d) Insurer is directed to deposit re-assessed compensation with interest before Tribunal within six weeks. (e) On
deposit,
compensation
25% is
ordered
of to
re-assessed released
in
favour of claimant, with liberty to claimant to seek release of remaining compensation by showing just cause.
Sd/(RAVI V HOSMANI) JUDGE
GRD List No.: 1 Sl No.: 10