The Manager v. Smt Shobha @ Shobha Karigowder

Court
High Court of Karnataka
Date of judgment
1 October 2026
Bench
Justice Anu Sivaraman, Justice T.p.vivekananda
Case number
MFA No. 8164 of 2017
Result
DISMISSED
Acts & sections
Section 173 Motor Vehicles Act
Subject
Motor accident

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 1ST DAY OF OCTOBER, 2026 PRESENT THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN AND THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.P.VIVEKANANDA MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 1612 OF 2018 (MV-D) C/W MISCELLANEOUS FIRST APPEAL NO. 8164 OF 2017 (MV-D)

IN MFA No. 1612/2018 BETWEEN:

Digitally signed by PAVITHRA B Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA

1.

SMT. SHOBHA @ SHOBHA KARIGOWDER W/O LATE M.C. MANJUNATHA AGED ABOUT 34 YEARS HOUSEWIFE

2.

KU. SHARVANI D/O LATE M.C. MANJUNATH AGED ABOUT 7 YEARS STUDENT REPRESENTED BY APPELLANT NO.1 AS NEXT FRIENT

3.

CHANNABASAMMA W/O CHANDRAPPA AGED ABOUT 67 YEARS HOUSEWIFE

SRI. CHANDRAPPA S/O MADIHALLI SANGAPPA AGED ABOUT 74 YEARS AGRICULTURIST ALL ARE PERMANENTLY R/O BALAMURI VILLAGE HONNALI TALUK

NOW RESIDING AT C/O M. SANGAMESHA NAGARAJAPPA BUDIHAL'S BUILDING NEAR ANJANEYA TEMPLE SHAMANUR VILLAGE DAVANAGERE TALUK AND DISTRICT …APPELLANTS (BY SRI: SHANTHARAJA K G, ADVOCATE V/O/DTD 04.06.2025, APPELLANT NO.4 IS SURVIVED BY APPELLANT NO.3) AND: 1.

SRI. K. PUGAZHANTHI KUPPAN GOWNDER MAJOR R/O PINNADURAI VILLAGE POST: ODUGATHUR VIA VELLORE TAMILNADU (DRIVER OF LORRY BEARING REG NO.KA-01/AA 9279)

2.

SRI. R. SARAVANAN #5/62, GANDHI STREET ODUGATHUR VELLOR DISTRICT TAMILNADU STATE (OWNER OF THE LORRY BEARING REG NO.KA-01/AA 9279)

3.

THE MANAGER ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD., OLD NO.29/B, NEW NO.238 ARCOT ROAD, JAMBUBALA COMPLEX 1ST FLOOR, VELLORE TAMILNADU-632 004 (POLICY NO.413500/31/2016/146 POLICY PERIOD 09.04.2015 TO 08.04.2016) …RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI: K. SURESH, ADVOCATE FOR R3 - [VC]; R1 IS SERVED AND UNREPRESENTED; VIDE ORDER DATED 04.06.2025, NOTICE TO R2 IS HELD SUFFICIENT)

THIS MFA IS FILED UNDER SECTIONN 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 03.03.2017 PASSED IN MVC NO.236/2016 ON THE FILE OF THE I ADDITIONAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE & V ADDITIONAL MACT, DAVANGERE, PARTLY ALLOWING THE CLAIM PETITION FOR COMPENSATION AND SEEKING ENHANCEMENT OF COMPENSATION.

IN MFA NO. 8164/2017 BETWEEN: THE MANAGER THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE CO. LTD., OLD NO.29/B, NEW NO.238 ARCOT ROAD, JAMBUBALA COMPLEX 1ST FLOOR, VELLORE TAMILNADU-632 004 NOW REPRESENTED BY M/S THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LIMITED REGIONAL OFFICE 'SUMANGALA COMPLEX' OPPOSITE TO HDMC, LAMINGTON ROAD HUBLI-580 020 REPRESENTED BY ITS REGIONAL MANAGER ...APPELLANT (BY SRI: K SURESH, ADVOCATE - [VC]) AND: 1.

SMT SHOBHA @ SHOBHA KARIGOWDER W/O LATE M.C. MANJUNATHA AGED ABOUT 33 YEARS OCC: HOUSEWIFE

2.

KU. SHARVANI D/O LATE M.C. MANJUNATH AGED ABOUT 06 YEARS

REPRESENTED BY RESPONDENT NO.1 AS NEXT FRIEND 3.

SMT. CHANNABASAMMA W/O SRI. CHANDRAPPA AGED ABOUT 66 YEARS HOUSEWIFE

4.

SRI. CHANDRAPPA S/O SRI. MADIHALLI SANGAPPA AGED ABOUT 73 YEARS OCC:AGRICULTURIST ALL ARE PERMANENTLY R/O BALAMURI VILLAGE HONNALI TALUK-577 002 NOW RESIDING AT C/O M. SANGAMESHA NAGARAJAPPA BUDIHAL'S BUILDING NEAR ANJANEYA TEMPLE SHAMANUR VILLAGE DAVANAGERE TALUK AND DISTRICT-577 002

5.

SRI. K. PUGAZHANTHI KUPPAN GOWNDER MAJOR R/O PINNADURAI VILLAGE POST: ODUGATHUR-632 004 VIA VELLORE, TAMILNADU

6.

SRI. R. SARAVANAN #5/62, GANDHI STREET ODUGATHUR-632 004 VELLOR DISTRICT TAMILNADU STATE ...RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI: SHANTHARAJA K G, ADVOCATE FOR R1, R3 & R4; R2 MINOR REP. BY R1; R5 IS SERVED AND UNREPRESENTED; VIDE ORDER DATED 04.06.2025, NOTICE TO R6 IS HELD SUFFICIENT)

THIS MFA IS FILED UNDEER SECTION 173(1) OF MV ACT AGAINST THE JUDGMENT AND AWARD DATED 03.03.2017 PASSED IN MVC NO.236/2016 ON THE FILE OF THE I ADDITIONAL SENIOR CIVIL JUDGE AND V ADDITIONAL MACT AT DAVANGERE, AWARDING COMPENSATION OF RS.11,95,000/- WITH INTEREST AT THE RATE OF 8% P.A. FROM THE DATE OF CLAIM PETITION TILL ITS REALIZATION. THESE MFAs, HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR JUDGMENT ON 18.09.2026 AND COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENT THIS DAY, T.P.VIVEKANANDA J., PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING:

CORAM:

HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN and HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.P.VIVEKANANDA CAV JUDGMENT

(PER: HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE T.P.VIVEKANANDA) MFA No.1612 of 2018 is filed by the claimants challenging the judgment and award dated 03.03.2017 in MVC No.236 of 2016 passed by the I Additional Senior Civil Judge and V Additional MACT at Davanagere, seeking enhancement of compensation.

2.

MFA 8164 of 2017 is filed by the appellant - insurer

challenging the judgment and award dated 03.03.2017 in MVC No.236 of 2016 passed by the I Additional Senior Civil Judge and V Additional MACT at Davanagere, on the ground that the

deceased

has

contributed

to

the

accident

occurred

on

11.05.2015; the compensation awarded under the head loss of dependency and other grounds are on the higher side.

3.

Brief facts of the case as narrated by the Tribunal

are as follows: The husband of claimant No.1, father of claimant No.2 and son of claimant Nos.3 and 4 viz., M C Manjunath, was seriously injured in the accident that occurred on 11.05.2015, while driving his motor cycle from K B cross towards Tumakuru and succumbed at the spot.

4.

The appellants in MFA No.1612 of 2018 being the

legal representatives of the deceased had approached the Claims Tribunal seeking compensation for the death of M C Manjunath.

The claim petition was opposed by respondent

No.3 - insurer.

Respondent Nos.1 and 2 have not filed any

objections.

5.

In the objection filed by respondent No.3 - insurer,

it was contended that the accident was occurred on account of the negligence of the deceased; the petition is bad for nonjoinder of necessary parties, since the owner and insurer of motor cycle, which was involved in the accident was not

arrayed as parties to the petition; the lorry bearing No.KA-01AA-9279 was not involved in the accident and the said vehicle has been implicated in order to get the compensation; the employment and the income asserted by the claimants were denied.

6.

On behalf of the claimants, claimant No.1 - wife of

the deceased was examined.

She has deposed that her

husband was working at VINUMAC Industries and was getting the salary of Rs.40,000/- per month; the accident was occurred only due to rash and negligent driving of the driver of the lorry; the criminal case has been registered against respondent No.1/driver of the lorry; she has lost her husband at the young age; she has to take care of her daughter as well as her inlaws, therefore, sought for allowing of the claim petition.

In

support of the claim, the documents at Exs.P1 to P11 were marked.

Exs.P1 to P6 are the police records; Ex.P7 is the

death certificate and Exs.P8 to P11 are the pay slips, which were marked subject to objection.

7.

Though PW1 was cross examined at length, nothing

important adverse to the claim made in the claim petition was elicited, except the suggestion regarding ownership of the

motor cycle, obtaining of BPL card, and the income being less than Rs.25,000/-, which is the precondition for obtaining the BPL card.

8.

On behalf of the respondents, no evidence was led

in. However, Ex.R1 which is the copy of Insurance policy was marked by consent. We have noticed the order sheet of the Tribunal

dated 28.01.2017, wherein, it is

recorded that

respondent No.3 did not propose to lead any evidence.

9.

Based on the pleadings and the evidence led in by

the claimants, the Tribunal has proceeded to consider the matter and awarded compensation of Rs.11,95,000/- under various heads. The details of which is as follows: Sl. No.

Particulars of Heads

Loss of love and affection in 2,25,000/respect of petitioner Nos.2 to 4 Loss of consortium 1,00,000/-

Los of estate

Transportation of dead body 50,000/and funeral expenses Total 11,95,000/-

Loss of dependency

Amount granted (Rs.) 8,10,000/-

10,000/-

10.

We have heard learned counsel for the parties and

perused the appeal papers, so also, the Trial Court records.

11.

We propose to first consider the appeal of the

insurer, which is filed on the ground of contributory negligence by

the

deceased

and

also

challenging

the

quantum

of

compensation.

12. that

We have noticed from the records of the Tribunal

except

taking

a

contention

regarding

contributory

negligence in the statement of objections filed to the petition, no independent evidence was led in by the insurer to prove the said contention. A feeble attempt was made to suggest to PW1 in the course of cross examination that the accident was occurred due to the fault of husband of PW1, which suggestion has been denied by the witness.

Except the same, neither

there is any further cross examination nor any independent evidence led in by the insurer. As observed above, no evidence was led in on behalf of the insurer, however, the policy of insurance was marked by consent as Ex.R1.

13.

At the time of hearing, learned counsel for the

insurer invited our attention to Ex.P3 the spot mahazar, more particularly, paragraph 9 of the said document and contended

that the accident was occurred at the middle of the road. Therefore, an inference can be drawn that the deceased was riding his two wheeler at the middle of the road and contributed for the accident occurred.

14.

We are afraid the reading of entire paragraph 9 of

the spot mahazar, at any stretch of imagination does not suggest that the two wheeler was at the midst of the road and the deceased has contributed to the accident occurred. None of the signatories to the spot mahazar were the eye witnesses and none of them have been examined on behalf of the insurer. It is also necessary to notice that, if at all any person who has witnessed to the accident other than the deceased is only respondent No.1 the driver of lorry i.e., the offending vehicle. It is not known as to why the insurer has not made any attempt to examine the driver of the lorry.

15. that

We have also noticed from the Trial Court records

after investigation, the police have filed chargesheet

against the driver of lorry. Therefore, we have no hesitation to hold that the contention regarding contributory negligence on the part of deceased is not proved and accordingly, the contention urged on behalf of the insurer in this appeal are

considered only for rejection.

Accordingly, the appeal of the

insurer does not merit consideration and liable to be rejected.

16.

Since

the claimants are also in appeal being not

satisfied with the compensation awarded by the Tribunal and we are considering the said appeal separately, the contentions of the insurer as regards awarding of excess compensation need not be considered independently.

17.

It is the contention of the appellants - claimants in

MFA No.1612 of 2018 that, the deceased was an employee of VINUMAC

Industries

and

was

getting

monthly

salary

of

Rs.40,000/-. In support of the said contention, the claimants have produced the salary slip at Exs.P8 to P11. However, the Tribunal has not considered the said documents on the ground that the said salary slips are unsigned and not authenticated by the competent authority. It is the contention of the appellants that the salary slip at Exs.P8 to P11 are computer generated and it did not require signature.

It is his further submission

that in a case of motor accident claims, strict proof of evidence is not required since it is a summary proceedings, therefore, the claimants cannot be expected to examine the employer to prove the employment and payment of salary.

18.

Learned counsel further pleaded that after the

death of her husband, appellant No.1 who is an uneducated and

homemaker

was

unable

to

procure

the

necessary

documents relating to employment of her husband, so also, salary particulars.

On these submissions, learned counsel

prays that the compensation awarded under the head loss of dependency requires re-assessment.

19.

On the contrary, learned counsel for the insurer has

contended that Exs.P8 objection.

to

P11

were

marked subject to

Therefore, it was incumbent for the claimants to

prove the authenticity and genuineness of the said documents, without which, the said documents are inadmissible so as to consider it for the purpose of determination of compensation. Learned counsel for the insurer contended with vehemence that the Tribunal has grossly erred in awarding compensation under the head love and affection in respect of claimant Nos.2 to 4 in a sum of Rs.2,25,000/-, loss of consortium of Rs.1,00,000/- for claimant No.1 and Rs.50,000/- towards transportation of dead body and funeral expenses, which are in higher side and contrary to

judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court in

National Insurance Co. Ltd., Vs Pranay Sethi1,

Magma

General Insurance Co. Ltd., Vs Nanu Ram2 and United India Insurance Co. Ltd., Vs Satinder Kaur3 and prayed for reduction of the compensation under the aforesaid heads. Thus, learned counsel for the insurer contends that the compensation awarded by the Tribunal is more than sufficient and does not require any re-assessment or enhancement.

20.

Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, on

perusal of the memorandum of appeal, impugned judgment and award, so also, records of the Trial Court, we are of the opinion that the compensation awarded for the death of husband of appellant No.1, father of appellant No.2 and son of appellant

No.3

re-assessment.

is

grossly

inadequate

and

requires

Accordingly, we propose to consider the

entitlement of the appellants/claimants as follows:

21.

On the date of death, deceased was 37 years.

Though the employment and salary of the deceased are not proved by examining the author of Exs.P8 to P11/the employer, however, it cannot be ignored that the deceased was doing some employment and was only earning member of the

(2017) 16 SCC 680 (2018) 18 SCC 130 (2021) 11 SC 780

appellants family.

Though this Court propose to consider the

notional income of the deceased in a sum of Rs.9,000/- per month, we find it appropriate to add future prospectus at 40% of the monthly income, because there is some element of possibility of the deceased having been employed on a fixed salary. We are not considering the exact salary as indicated in Exs.P8 to P11 since the claimants have failed to prove the said documents and also failed to produce the account pass book, details of the provident fund or the details of the professional tax paid, since in Exs.P8 to P11 we see a column regarding deductions. If only the claimants have produced any one of the aforesaid documents, we would have no hesitation to consider the monthly salary as shown in Exs.P8 to P11. circumstances,

the

loss

of

dependency

is

In the

assessed

at

Rs.17,01,000/- (9000 + 40% x 12 x 15 x 3/4th).

22.

In view of the judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme

Court in Pranay Sethi (supra), the appellants are not entitled for any separate compensation for love and affection, however, they are only entitled for loss of spousal consortium, parental consortium and filial consortium in a sum of Rs.1,20,000/(40000 x 3) for each of the appellants. The appellants are entitle for Rs.15,000/- towards loss of estate and funeral

expenses

Rs.15,000/-.

Accordingly,

the

re-assessed

compensation is as follows: Sl. No.

Particulars of heads

MACT Award Re-assessed (Rs.) compensation in MFA 1612/2018 (Rs.) Loss of dependency 8,10,000/17,01,000/Loss of love and 2,25,000/affection in respect of + 1,20,000/claimant Nos.2 to 4 1,00,000/and loss of consortium Loss of estate 10,000/15,000/Transportation of dead 50,000/15,000/body and funeral expenses Total 11,95,000/- 18,51,000/-

The

total

re-assessed

compensation,

to

which

the

appellants are entitled is Rs.18,51,000/-.

23.

We have noticed that during the pendancy of this

appeal, appellant No.4 i.e., father of the deceased died. Hence, this Court deems it appropriate to redo the apportionment of compensation in light of the death of appellant No.4 - father. 24.

We are of the considered opinion that in light of

changed circumstances, appellant No.1 should be made entitled for 40% of the total compensation and appellant No.2 shall be

entitled for 30% of the compensation and appellant No.3 is entitled for 30% of the compensation. 25.

In the result,

(i)

MFA 1612 of 2018 is allowed in part.

(ii)

MFA 8164 of 2017 is dismissed.

(iii)

The judgment and award dated 03.03.2017 in MVC No.236 of 2016 passed by the I Additional Senior Civil Judge and V Additional MACT at Davanagere, is modified entitling the appellants for re-assessed compensation of Rs.18,51,000/- as against the the compensation already granted by the Tribunal in a sum of Rs.11,95,000/-.

(iv)

The enhanced compensation shall carry interest at 8% per annum from the date of petition, till its realization.

(v)

In

view

of

compensation

the as

re-apportionment detailed

above,

of

the

necessary

adjustment of the compensation already released and the compensation to be released on account of enhancement in this appeal shall be made by the Tribunal while releasing the balance compensation. (vi)

The appellants are not entitled for the interest for the delayed period of 237 days.

(vii) The statutory deposit of Rs.25,000/- alongwith accrued interest be transmitted to the Tribunal for disbursement. Registry is directed to transmit the Trial Court records, forthwith, along with the copy of this judgment, for needful action.

Sd/(ANU SIVARAMAN) JUDGE

Sd/(T.P.VIVEKANANDA) JUDGE

BGN

Related judgments

More Karnataka High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.