The Oriental Insurance Company LTD v. Kalyani Das and 2 Ors
- Court
- Gauhati High Court
- Date of judgment
- 5 November 2026
- Judge
- Justice Arun Dev Choudhury
- Case number
- MACApp. No. 104 of 2015
- Result
- Disposed Of
- Acts & sections
- Section 304 IPC
- Advocates
- H Das
- Subject
- Criminal
Full judgment
Page No.# 1/7 GAHC010002902015
2026:GAU-AS:16324
THE GAUHATI HIGH COURT (HIGH COURT OF ASSAM, NAGALAND, MIZORAM AND ARUNACHAL PRADESH) Case No. : MACApp./976/2018 THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD (A CENTRAL GOVT. UNDERTAKING) HAVING ITS REGIONAL OFFICE AT GUWAHATI, G.S. ROAD, ULUBARI, GUWAHATI 781007 REPRESENTED BY THE REGIONAL MANAGER, GAUHATI REGIONAL OFFICE, ULUBARI, GUWAHATI 781005 VERSUS MOFIDA AHMED @ MINU AHMED and 2 ORS W/O LATE ZAHIDUL ISLAM, SANTINAGAR OF GOALPARA TOWN, WARD NO. 17, P.O. BALADMARI, P.S. and DIST. GOALPARA ASSAM 2:JADAV CH. ROY S/O LATE KANAI RAY VILL. CHAKAPARA P.S. and DIST. BONGAIGAON ASSAM 3:SAYED ALI S/O MAHAR ALI VILL. CHOTOPARA P.O. and P.S. JOGIGHOPA DIST. BONGAIGAON ASSAM Advocate for the Petitioner
: MS. R D MOZUMDAR, MRS. B BORAH
Linked Case : MACApp./104/2015 THE ORIENTAL INSURANCE COMPANY LTD A CENTRAL GOVT. UNDERTAKING HAVING ITS REGIONAL OFFICE AT GUWAHATI G.S. ROAD ULUBARI
Page No.# 2/7 GUWAHATI 781007 REPRESENTED BY THE REGIONAL MANAGER GAUHATI REGIONAL OFFICE ULUBARI GUWAHATI 781005 VERSUS KALYANI DAS and 2 ORS W/O LATE JYOTISH DAS BAPUJI NAGAR OF GOALPARA TOWN WARD NO. 17 P.O. BALADMARI P.S. and DIST. GOALPARA ASSAM 2:JADAV CH. ROY S/O LATE KANAI RAY VILL. CHAKAPARA P.S. and DIST. BONGAIGAON ASSAM DRIVER ------------
BEFORE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE ARUN DEV CHOUDHURY JUDGMENT
For the appellants
: Ms. R.D. Mozumdar, Adv
For the Respondents
: Mr. H Das, Adv
Date on which judgment was reserved
: 29.09.2026
Date of pronouncement of judgment
: 06.11.2026
Whether the pronouncement is of the operative part of the judgment?
: N.A
Whether the judgment has been pronounced?
: Yes
JUDGMENT & ORDER (CAV) 1.
These two appeals are taken up together, as
both challenge the common judgment and award dated
Page No.# 3/7
21.11.2014, passed in MAC Case No. 51/2011 and MAC Case No. 52/2011. Both the MAC cases are offshoots of a motor vehicular accident, wherein the husbands of both the claimants in the respective cases died. 2.
The appellant's principal challenge is to the
finding of negligence and liability. It is contended that the deceased themselves were negligent, that they violated traffic rules, that the accident occurred due to their own negligence, and, alternatively, that there was contributory negligence on the part of the deceased to the extent of 50 percent. The appellant has also questioned the quantum of compensation awarded by the learned trial court. 3.
The facts giving rise to the claim are not in
serious dispute. 4.
On 12.04.2010, at about 6 p.m., Jahedul Islam,
who was working as Forester-I in the Forest Department, and Jyotish Das, Forester-II, were on duty at Budhipara/Agiya Beat Office. At that time, they noticed the offending truck bearing registration number AS-25/6049 coming from Bolbola side, loaded with sand. 5.
Suspecting the vehicle was carrying forest
produce, they signaled the vehicle to stop. The driver did not stop the vehicle, and when both the deceased attempted to pursue and stop the truck, the truck knocked them down.
Page No.# 4/7
Both of them sustained injuries and died. 6.
An FIR was lodged by Dalim Das, Range Forest
Officer, Goalpara Range, which was registered as Goalpara PS case No.232/2010, under section 304/427 IPC, and upon investigation, a charge-sheet was submitted against the driver of the offending vehicle for rash and negligent driving, though subsequently, the driver was acquitted for want of evidence. 7.
Sayed Ali owned the offending vehicle, which
was insured with the Insurance Company under Policy No.322300/31/2010/4484, valid on the date of the accident. The deceased, Jeherul Islam, was stated to be aged about 47 years and was serving in the Forest Department.
The
claimants are the widow Mofida Ahmed @ Minu Ahmed, his son Md. Rohan Afridi, his daughter Rosleen Islam, and his mother Jahanara Begum. 8.
The other claimants are Kalyani Das, wife of the
deceased Jyotish Das, and the deceased's sons, Nilam Kr. Das and Bikram Das and mother Dhaneswari Das. The victim was serving in the Forest Department and his age was 55 years. 9.
The
Insurance
Company,
in
its
written
statement, denied liability and, inter alia, pleaded that the deceased violated traffic rules and that the accident occurred due to their own negligence. It was further pleaded that there was suppression of material facts and that, in any event, the
Page No.# 5/7
deceased had contributed to the accident. 10.
In
the
alternative,
the
appellant
pleaded
contributory negligence to the extent of 50%. These pleas were specifically taken as grounds to avoid or reduce the insurer's liability. However, the Insurance Company led no evidence. Therefore, the difficulty in accepting the aforesaid defense is that the allegations made in the written statements were not supported by any evidence. 11.
There is no evidence on record establishing that
the deceased had violated any particular traffic rule, that they had acted negligently in a manner which contributed to the occurrence, or that their negligence was either the sole cause or a contributing cause of the accident. The plea of 50% contributory negligence in particular remains a bare assertion in the written statement. 12.
It is true that the claimants were not eyewitnesses
to the actual impact. PW-2 Binoy Kr. Nath, who claimed to have witnessed the occurrence, had admitted in his crossexamination that he was at a distance when he saw the Forest Officer signaling the vehicle. The learned Tribunal therefore did not place implicit reliance upon his evidence. 13.
Though such evidence may not conclusively
establish the manner of impact, it also does not establish the
Page No.# 6/7
affirmative defense of contributory negligence pleaded by the Insurance Company. 14.
The
burden
to
establish
specific
plea
of
contributory negligence lies upon the party asserting it. A plea in the written statement is not evidence. In the present case, apart from making the allegation, the appellant has not brought on record any material from which it can be concluded that the deceased had acted negligently or that their conduct materially contributed to the accident. 15.
A reference to the police case, violation of traffic
rules, or the observation made in the criminal case against the driver, or his acquittal, cannot, without evidence proved before the Tribunal, be a sufficient ground to apportion liability or conclude that the deceased contributed to the accident. 16.
The materials on record, therefore, do not justify
interference with the finding of the learned Tribunal fastening liability upon the offending vehicle, consequently upon the appellant insurance Company. 17.
Accordingly, the challenge to the finding of
negligence and liability fails. The appeals are dismissed. 18.
The appellant Insurance Company shall deposit
the compensation,
after
adjusting the
amount already
deposited or paid pursuant to the impugned order, together with interest, before the learned Tribunal in terms of the
Page No.# 7/7
impugned judgment. 19.
The direction of the learned Tribunal regarding
disbursement and protection of compensation shall insofar remain
operative
subject
to,
however,
the
change
in
circumstance of attainment of majority by the minors in the meantime or death of any of the claimants. 20.
Registry to return the statutory deposit to the
appellants. The TCR be returned back forthwith.
JUDGE
Comparing Assistant