Tombi Bibi v. Md. Amuba Represented by His Lrs

Court
High Court of Manipur
Date of judgment
28 October 2026
Case number
CRP(C.R.P. Art.227) No. 47 of 2026
Result
Dismissed
Acts & sections
Article 227 Constitution
Subject
Civil

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

Item Nos. 3 & 4 2026:MNHC:246

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MANIPUR AT IMPHAL CRP(CRP.Art.227) No. 47 of 2026

Mrs. Tombi Bibi, aged about 60 years, w/o late Md. Yusuf Khan/Ali of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur. … Petitioner -VersusMd. Amuba, s/o late Md. Babu @ Bapu Hazi of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur since deceased and represented by his legal Heirs (LRs) named below: a) Mrs. Humei, aged about 69 years, w/o late Md. Amuba of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur, being expired and represented by her L.Rs. i. Md. Sahidur, aged about 48 years s/o late Humei of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur at present Bishnupur Ward No. 2, Bishnupur District, Manipur. ii. Md. Apikpi, aged about 45 years, s/o late Humei of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur. iii. Md. Indraman, aged about 42 years, s/o late Humei of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur at present Lilong Ushoipokpi, P.S Lilong, Thoubal District, Manipur. iv. Md. Abothem, aged about 40 years, s/o late Humei of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur at present Sora P.S. Khongjom, Thoubal - District Manipur. v. Md. Sadam, aged about 34 years, s/o late Humei of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong Manipur, at present Lilong Ushoipokpi, P.S. Lilong, Thoubal District, Manipur. b) Mrs. Mani, aged about 67 years, w/o late Md. Amuba of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur. c) Mrs. Sanahanbi, aged about 65 years, w/o late Md. Amuba of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur. … Respondent/s

With MC(CRP(CRP.Art.227)) No. 84 of 2026 Mrs. Tombi Bibi, aged about 60 years, w/o late Md. Yusuf Khan/Ali of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur. … Applicant/Petitioner -VersusMd. Amuba, s/o late Md. Babu @ Bapu Hazi of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur since deceased and represented by his legal Heirs (LRs) named below: a) Mrs. Humei, aged about 69 years, w/o late Md. Amuba of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur, being expired and represented by her L.Rs. i. Md. Sahidur, aged about 48 years s/o late Humei of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur at present Bishnupur Ward No. 2, Bishnupur District, Manipur. ii. Md. Apikpi, aged about 45 years, s/o late Humei of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur. iii. Md. Indraman, aged about 42 years, s/o late Humei of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur at present Lilong Ushoipokpi, P.S Lilong, Thoubal District, Manipur. iv. Md. Abothem, aged about 40 years, s/o late Humei of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur at present Sora P.S. Khongjom, Thoubal - District Manipur. v. Md. Sadam, aged about 34 years, s/o late Humei of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong Manipur, at present Lilong Ushoipokpi, P.S. Lilong, Thoubal District, Manipur. b) Mrs. Mani, aged about 67 years, w/o late Md. Amuba of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur. c) Mrs. Sanahanbi, aged about 65 years, w/o late Md. Amuba of Lilong Tairen Makhong, Thoubal District, P.O. & P.S. Lilong, Manipur. … Respondent/s

BEFORE HON’BLE THE CHIEF JUSTICE MR. M. SUNDAR For revision petitioner

Mr. Lourembam Nongthang Ngamba along with Mr. A. Phulchand Sharma, Advocates.

Date of Judgment & Order

29.10.2026

JUDGMENT AND ORDER (ORAL) [1]

The following abbreviations/short forms have been used in this

order (for the sake of brevity, convenience and clarity): Sl. No.

Abbreviation/Short Form/other short references

Full Form/Expansion

1.

CRP

Civil Revision Petition

MC

Miscellaneous Case

3.

CPC

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908)

4.

said Trial Court

Court of Civil Judge(Junior Division) cum Judicial Magistrate First Class, Thoubal

5.

impugned order

Order dated 06.07.2026 in Judl. Misc. Case No. 375 of 2025 in Judl. Misc. Case No. 288 of 2025 (Ref: O.S. No. 4 of 2017)

[2]

Captioned CRP has been presented in this Court on 31.08.2026 (filed

after removal of objections on 21.09.2026) invoking Article 227 of the Constitution, assailing the impugned order. [3]

In and vide impugned order, an application being Judl. Misc. Case

No. 375 of 2025 in Judl. Misc. Case No. 288 of 2025 (Ref: O.S. No. 4 of 2017)

taken out by lone plaintiff in the main suit with a prayer to file replication, has been rejected. [4]

Captioned matter is in the Admission Board and it is listed under the

cause-list caption ‘ADJOURNED ADMISSION’. [5]

Mr. Lourembam Nongthang Ngamba, learned counsel on record for

revision petitioner/MC applicant along with Mr. A. Phulchand Sharma, co-counsel is before this Court. [6]

Factual matrix in a nutshell is that the CRP petitioner presented a

plaint dated 27.01.2017 in the said Trial Court with prayers inter alia for declaration of title qua suit land, cancellation of a Registered Sale-Deed, cancellation of Jamabandi patta and costs besides usual residuary prayer limb; that the defendants in the suit completed pleadings by filing written statement dated 05.08.2017; that pending suit, Judl. Misc. Case No. 38 of 2022 being an injunction application was taken out by the plaintiff with a prayer to restrain defendants from filling earth or trying to possess, occupy suit land; that this injunction application was dismissed on 15.06.2022; that

thereafter, the plaintiff took out another

application being Judl. Misc. Case No. 288 of 2025 (application dated 22.07.2025) with prayers inter alia to vacate the defendants from the suit land by demolishing the structures said to have been put up therein; that the defendants filed objections to this application; that pending this application, owing to the contents of the objections filed by the defendants in Judl. Misc. Case No. 288 of 2025, the plaintiff took out one more judicial miscellaneous case being Judl. Misc. Case No. 375 of 2025 with a prayer to file replication and this application is dated 03.10.2025; that this application, with a prayer to file replication, taken out by the

plaintiff was dismissed by the said Trial Court in and vide impugned order (impugned order dated 06.07.2026); that the CRP petitioner who is plaintiff before the said Trial Court, contending that she is aggrieved by the impugned order, has presented the captioned CRP along with captioned MC thereat in this Court on 31.08.2026 as alluded to supra and after removal of defects it has been filed on 21.09.2026. [7]

Before plunging into the matter, it is deemed appropriate to write

that a perusal of Judl. Misc. Case No. 375 of 2025 brings to light that it has been filed by resorting to Order VIII Rule 9 of CPC, however, in the impugned order, said Trial Court has referred to the same as an application under Order VII Rule 9. This is obviously a typographical error. Be that as it may, as regards the replication application, Mr. Lourembam Nongthang Ngamba, learned counsel on record for CRP/MC applicant notwithstanding myriad grounds in memorandum of CRP, adverted to the objections of defendants in Judl. Misc. Case No. 288 of 2025, more particularly, paragraph No. 2 thereat and submitted that the suit was originally filed and conducted by another counsel. Thereafter, learned counsel submitted that there are certain errors qua pleadings in the plaint and that has necessitated the filing of the replication application. [8]

A careful perusal of the impugned order brings to light that said Trial

Court has opined that contents of written objection in a Judl. Misc. Case with a prayer to vacate defendants from suit land by demolishing super structure cannot be the basis for filing a replication application, that too, when the suit is at a very advanced stage and when it is listed for final arguments.

[9]

This Court carefully considered the case file, impugned order and the

submissions of learned counsel for CRP petitioner/MC applicant. The burden of song of CRP petitioner/MC applicant is that some errors in pleadings (plaint) have been made by erstwhile counsel for plaintiff, the same have to be set right for effectively pursuing a Judl. Misc. Case No. 288 of 2025 filed with a prayer for vacating the defendants from suit land by demolishing super structures set to have been put up and therefore the replication application ought to have been allowed. [10]

This Court finds that the captioned CRP is bereft of merits and it

deserves to be dismissed. The reasons are as follows: i.

A replication application under Order VIII Rule 9 of CPC can be filed only with the leave of the Court post written statement. The written statement was filed on 05.08.2017 and in less than 1(one) year from now the written statement will be 1(one) decade old. Post written statement in 2017, injunction application was taken out in 2022, the same was dismissed on 15.06.2022 and thereafter, Judl. Misc. Case No. 288 of 2025 has been taken out. It is clearly too late in the day besides protraction and procrastination. In any event, a replication application under Order VIII Rule 9 cannot be filed for the purpose of buttressing an interlocutory application in a suit;

ii.

If pleadings have to be amended, the plaintiff has to resort to Order VI Rule 17 of CPC. In the light of the amended Order VI Rule 17 of CPC, amendments post completion of pleadings/commencement of trial is an exception. The plaintiff, without even attempting to resort to Order VI Rule 17, has filed a replication application that too, on

the ground that it is necessary for buttressing an interlocutory application. Therefore, this Court finds no error or infirmity in the impugned order of the said Trial Court; iii.

This Court finds from the e-Court website that the suit itself is at a very advanced stage and it is scheduled to be next listed on 25.11.2026 for final arguments. A scanned reproduction of the download from the e-Court website is as follows:

iv.

In less than 3(three) months from now, the plaint itself will be 1(one) decade old. As already alluded to supra, the suit is for declaration of title, cancellation of registered sale deed and allied reliefs;

v.

It is seen that the contents of the replication application are to the effect that the plaintiff wants to file replication in response to written objection of defendants in Judl. Misc. Case No. 288 of 2025. Therefore, this Court deems it appropriate to extract and reproduce the short application for replication being application dated

03.10.2025 and a scanned reproduction of the same (together with support affidavit) is as follows:

vi.

It is also seen from the proceedings of the Trial Court that it has recorded the submission that costs imposed in at least 3(three) earlier Judl. Misc. Cases had not been paid by the plaintiff till date;

vii.

It comes across as an attempt to delay and if possible derailing the suit.

[11]

As already alluded to supra, captioned CRP is bereft of merits and

the same deserves to be dismissed and adumbration of reasons i.e., dispositive reasoning has been set out supra. [12]

Ergo, the sequitur is, captioned CRP fails and the same is dismissed.

Consequently, captioned MC thereat also perishes with the main CRP and the same is also dismissed. This Court refrains itself from imposing costs.

CHIEF JUSTICE Indrajeet

P.S. I : Upload forthwith P.S. II : All concerned will stand bound by web copy uploaded in High Court website inter alia as the same is QR coded.

LAIRENMAY Digitally signed by LAIRENMAYUM UM INDRAJEET SINGH INDRAJEET Date: 2026.10.29 18:54:05 +05'30' SINGH

Related judgments

More Manipur High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.