V. Chandrashekar v. V. Kamala

Court
High Court of Karnataka
Date of judgment
12 November 2026
Bench
Justice Anu Sivaraman, Justice K.s.bharath Kumar
Case number
WA No. 529 of 2023
Result
DISPOSED
Acts & sections
Article 226 Constitution
Subject
Civil

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA AT BENGALURU DATED THIS THE 12TH DAY OF NOVEMBER, 2026 PRESENT THE HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN AND THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K.S.BHARATH KUMAR WRIT APPEAL NO. 529 OF 2023 (LB-BMP) C/W WRIT APPEAL NO. 612 OF 2023 (LB-BMP) IN WA No. 529/2023 BETWEEN:

Digitally signed by PAVITHRA N Location: High Court of Karnataka

1.

V. CHANDRASHEKAR AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS S/O LATE M. VENKATARAMAIAH RESIDING AT NO.9/1A GROVER ROAD SARVAGNANAGAR COX TOWN BENGALURU-560 005

2.

V. VASUDEV SINCE DEAD BY LR'S

2(A) GEETHA AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS W/O LATE.V.VASUDEV 2(B) V.ZAINKAR AGED ABOUT 26 YEARS D/O LATE V. VASUDEV 2(C) V.VINAY AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS

S/O LATE V. VASUDEV ALL ARE RESIDING AT NO. 9/1 GROVER ROAD SARVAGNANAGAR COX TOWN BENGALURU-560 005 3.

V.VINAYAKUMAR AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS S/O. LATE M. VENKATARAMAIAH RESIDING AT NO.9 GROVER ROAD SARVAGNANAGAR COX TOWN BENGALURU-560 005

4.

SRI SATHYANARAYANA EDUCATIONAL TRUST (FORMERLY A SOCIETY REGISTERED UNDER THE KARNATAKA SOCIETIES REGISTRATION ACT, 1960 AND SUBSEQUENT THERETO CONVERTED IN TO A TRUST UNDER INDIAN TRUST ACT) HAVING ITS OFFICE AT NO.10/4 RAMAMURTHYNAGAR MAIN ROAD BANASWADI BENGALURU-560 033 REPRESENTED BY ITS FOUNDER SECRETARY MR.T. VENUGOPAL S/O LATE THIMMAIAH …APPELLANTS

(BY SRI. AJOY KUMAR PATIL, ADV. FOR SRI. GANESH BHAT Y. H., ADV.) AND: 1.

V. KAMALA AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS W/O LATE M. VENKATESH

2.

SHRI. M. VENKATESH AGED ABOUT 74 YEARS S/O LATE M. MUNISWAMAPPA BOTH ARE RESIDING AT NO.105 DAMODAR MUDALIAR STREET ULSOOR, BENGALURU-560 008

3.

BRUHATH BENGALURU MAHANAGAR PALIKE BENGALURU-560 001 BY ITS COMMISSIONER

4.

THE COMMISIONER BRUHATH BENGALURU MAHANAGAR PALKE N.R. SQUARE BENGALURU-560 001

5.

ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER BRUHATH BENGALURU MAHANAGAR PALKE MARUTHI SEVANAGARA SUB-DIVISION BENGALURU-560 033 …RESPONDENTS

(BY SRI. B.M.ARUN, ADV. FOR CAVEATOR/R1 & R2; SRI. B.S.SATHYANANDA, ADV. FOR R3-R5) THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF THE KARNATAKA HIGH COURT ACT, 1961 R/W ARTICLE 226 OF THE CONSTITUTION OF INDIA, PRAYING TO ALLOW THE ABOVE WRIT APPEAL BY SETTING ASIDE THE ORDER DATED 20.04.2023 IN WRIT PETITION No.14685/2014 (LB-BBMP) PASSED BY THE LEARNED SINGLE JUDGE AND CONSEQUENTLY DISMISS THE WRIT PETITION No.14685/2014 (LB-BBMP).

IN WA NO.612/2023 BETWEEN: 1.

BRUHATH BENGALURU MAHANAGARA PALIKE BENGALURU - 560001 BY ITS COMMISSIONER

2.

THE COMMISSIONER BRUHATH BENGALURU MAHANAGARA PALIKE N R SQUARE BENGALURU - 560001

3.

ASSISTANT EXECUTIVE ENGINEER BRUHATH BENGALURU MAHANAGARA PALIKE MARUTHI SEVANAGARA SUB DIVISION BENGALURU - 560033 ...APPELLANTS (BY SRI. SATYANAND B S, ADV.) AND: 1.

V. KAMALA AGED ABOUT 65 YEARS W/O LATE M VENKATESH

2.

SHRI M VENKATESH AGED ABOUT 74 YEARS S/O LATE M MUNISWAMAPPA BOTH ARE RESIDING AT NO.105 DAMODAR MUDALIAR STREET ULSOOR, BENGALURU - 560008

3.

V CHANDRASHEKAR AGED ABOUT 64 YEARS S/O LATE M VENKATARAMAIAH

RESIDING AT NO 9/1A GROVER ROAD SARVAGNANAGAR COX TOWN BENGALURU - 560005 4.

V VASUDEV SINCE DEAD BY LRS

4(A) MRS GEETHA AGED ABOUT 49 YEARS W/O LATE V VASUDEV 4(B) V ZAINKAR AGED ABOUT 26 YEARS D/O LATE V VASUDEV 4(C) V VINAY AGED ABOUT 22 YEARS S/O LATE V VASUDEV ALL ARE RESIDING AT NO.9/1 GROVER ROAD SARVAGNANAGAR COX TOWN BENGALURU - 560005 7.

V VIJAYAKUMAR AGED ABOUT 57 YEARS S/O LATE M VENKATARAMAIAH RESIDING AT NO.9 GROVER ROAD SARVAGNANAGAR COX TOWN BENGALURU - 560005

8.

SRI SATYANARAYANA EDUCATIONAL TRUST (FORMERLY A SOCIETY REGISTERED UNDER THE KARNATAKA SOCIETIES REGISTRATION ACT, 1960

AND SUBSEQUENT THERETO CONVERTED IN TO A TRUST UNDER INDIAN TRUST ACT) HAVING ITS OFFICE AT NO.10/4 RAMAMURTHYNAGAR MAIN ROAD BANASWADI BENGALURU - 560003 REPRESENTED BY ITS FOUNDER SECRETARY MR T VENUGOPAL S/O LATE THIMMAIAH ...RESPONDENTS (BY SRI. ARUN B M., ADV. FOR R1 & R2; SRI. AJAY KUMAR PATIL & SRI. GANESH BHAT Y.H., ADV. FOR R3, R4(A-C), R5 & R6)

THIS WRIT APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 4 OF THE KARNATAKA HIGH COURT RULES, 1961, PRAYING TO ALLOW THIS WRIT APPEAL AND SET ASIDE THE IMPUGNED DIRECTIONS AGAINST THESE APPELLANTS AS PER PARA NOS.24.16 AND PORTION OF THE PARA NO.25.1.ii, (BBMP IS ALSO DIRECTED TO MAINTAIN THE SAID PASSAGE/STREET AND ENTER THE SAME IN ITS PROPERTY REGISTER) IN ORDERS DATED 20/04/2023, PASSED BY THE LEARNED SINGLE JUDGE IN WP NO.14685/2014 (LB-BBMP), AND CONSEQUENTLY, ALLOW THE WRIT PETITION NO.14685/2014 (LB-BBMP), TO THE EXTENT OF THE WRIT PETITION PRAYER i.e., IN SO FAR AS IMPLEMENTATION OF ANNEXURES-U AND V, DATED 13/10/2011 AND 18/11/2011, RESPECTIVELY. THESE WRIT APPEALS HAVING BEEN HEARD AND RESERVED FOR JUDGMENT ON 29.10.2026 AND COMING ON FOR PRONOUNCEMENT OF JUDGMENT THIS DAY, ANU SIVARAMAN J., PRONOUNCED THE FOLLOWING: CORAM:

HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN and HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE K.S.BHARATH KUMAR

CAV JUDGMENT (PER: HON'BLE MRS. JUSTICE ANU SIVARAMAN)

Writ Appeal No.529/2023 is preferred by respondents No.4 to 7 in the writ petition and Writ Appeal No.612/2023 is preferred by Bruhat Bengaluru Mahanagara Palike (‘BBMP’ for short)

and its officers challenging the order dated

20.04.2023 passed by the learned Single Judge in Writ Petition

No.14685/2014

(LB-BBMP),

whereby

the

writ

petition filed by respondents No.1 and 2 herein was allowed, directing the BBMP to implement the notice/order dated 13.10.2011 and 18.11.2011, remove the compound wall and gate constructed across the passage measuring 40 feet × 159 feet, keep the said passage free from encroachments, maintain the same and enter it in its property register.

2. counsel

We have heard Shri. Ajoy Kumar Patil, learned appearing

for

the

appellants

in

Writ

Appeal

No.529/2023 and for respondents No.3 to 6 in Writ Appeal No.612/2023; Shri. B.M. Arun, learned counsel appearing for respondents No.1 and 2 in both the appeals and Shri. B.S Sathyananda, learned counsel appearing for respondents

No.3 to 5 in Writ Appeal No.529/2023 and for the appellants in Writ Appeal No.612/2023.

3.

The property bearing Corporation No.10, situated

at Ramamurthy Nagar Main Road, Banaswadi, Bengaluru, measuring about 49,613 sq.ft. originally belonged to one Shri. M. Venkataramaiah. During his lifetime, he executed two registered Gift Deeds and a Will dated 22.04.2004, whereby different portions of the property were gifted to his daughters and bequeathed to his sons. Under the registered Gift Deed dated 22.04.2004, a portion of the property was gifted to his daughter, Smt. V. Kamala, respondent No.1 herein, while the remaining portions were bequeathed in favour of his sons, namely Shri. V. Chandrashekar, Shri. V. Vasudev and Shri. V. Vijayakumar, who are appellants No.1 to 3 in Writ Appeal No.529/2023. A passage measuring 40 feet × 159 feet, leading to Ramamurthy Nagar Main Road, was shown in the documents relating to the respective properties.

4.

Pursuant to the aforesaid transactions, BBMP by

Special Notice dated 04.01.2006, effected separate khatas in

respect of the respective portions: No.10, 10/3 and 10/4 for the sons and No.10/1 and 10/2 for the daughters. The passage measuring 40 feet × 159 feet was not included in any of these numbers. Building plans were sanctioned by BBMP, including the plan dated 30.06.2009 for a school and hostel building on No.10/4. Appellants No.1 to 3 leased their properties to appellant No.4, an educational institution, which runs New Baldwin Residential School. Respondent No.1 gifted a 50% undivided share in her property to her husband - respondent No.2, on 18.04.2009. Thereafter, BBMP assigned No.10/5 to the rear portion and sanctioned a plan for it on 23.11.2010 on the basis of access through the passage. In January 2011, appellant No.4 enclosed the passage with a compound wall and gate for the safety of the students and hostel inmates.

5.

On 21.02.2011, respondents No.1 and 2

lodged a complaint before the Commissioner, BBMP alleging encroachment upon a public road by construction of the compound wall and gate. Pursuant thereto, BBMP issued a notice dated 03.03.2011 calling upon the appellants No.1 to

3 to submit their explanation. By reply dated 08.03.2011, they contended that the passage was a private passage forming part of the property of their father, Shri. M. Venkataramaiah, and was intended for ingress and egress to their respective properties. Thereafter, BBMP issued an endorsement dated 20.05.2011 stating that the 40 feet road, which respondent No.1 described as a passage to her property, was the subject matter of a joint family dispute which BBMP had no jurisdiction to adjudicate, and advising the parties, to approach the competent Civil Court to decide which of the property owners alone could use the said road.

6.

Subsequently,

BBMP

issued

a

notice

dated

13.10.2011 concerning the construction of the compound wall and gate across the disputed passage, stating that the Legal Advisor had instructed that action be taken and calling upon appellants No.1 to 3 to immediately remove the iron gate and compound wall built across the 40 feet road relating to property No.10/1, 10/3, 10/4, 10/5 and 10, and to explain why cement concrete had been laid on the said road

without

the

prior

approval

of

BBMP.

A

further

communication dated 18.11.2011 was issued by the BBMP recording that appellants No.1 to 3 had not complied with the notice, and seeking police protection from the BMTF so that BBMP could remove the compound wall, security building and iron gate. In the meanwhile, the educational Institution instituted a Civil Suit as O.S.No.7544/2011 before the City Civil Court, Bengaluru, against the BBMP seeking permanent injunction against interference with its possession and enjoyment of the property. The said suit came to be decreed by judgment dated 29.11.2012, permanently

restraining

BBMP

and

its

officials

from

interfering with the plaintiff’s peaceful possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule properties. Thereafter, respondents

No.1

and

instituted

Writ

Petition

No.14685/2014 seeking a direction to BBMP to implement the

notice

and

communication

dated

13.10.2011

and

18.11.2011 and remove the compound wall and gate.

7.

The writ petition was initially dismissed by

order dated 08.11.2017, relegating the parties to the remedy before the competent Civil Court. The said order

was subsequently recalled by order dated 23.02.2021 in Review Petition No.155/2019 and the writ petition was restored for consideration. During the pendency of the writ petition, BBMP conducted a spot inspection on 30.09.2021, and the spot mahazar recorded that no BBMP road was found on the property, that no road ID was found on verification of the road history website and that the property was found to be private property. BBMP placed on record the spot mahazar, road identification map and photographs. BBMP also filed an affidavit dated 14.01.2022, asserting that the disputed passage had not been relinquished in favour of BBMP and did not vest in it, and produced the building plan sanctioned on 30.06.2009 for the school and hostel building.

8.

Subsequently, an affidavit dated 21.04.2022 was filed

on behalf of BBMP in April 2022 expressing willingness to implement the earlier notice and communication within three weeks,

pursuant

to

which

directions

were

issued

for

compliance by order dated 21.04.2022. The said directions were challenged in Writ Appeal No.407/2022 and, by order dated 25.08.2022, the Division Bench interfered with the

direction and directed the writ petition be considered afresh on merits, after hearing all the parties, while retaining the affidavit on record.

9.

The learned Single Judge, upon consideration of

the pleadings and material on record, noticed that BBMP had taken inconsistent stands regarding the nature of the disputed passage. Though BBMP had initially issued notices for removal of the alleged encroachment, it subsequently contended that the passage was private property which had not been relinquished in its favour. The learned Single Judge further notice that BBMP, while effecting khata bifurcation, assigning separate municipal

numbers and

sanctioning

building plans in favour of the respective parties, had recognised the existence of the passage measuring 40 feet × 159 feet as a means of access to their properties and that betterment charges had been paid only on 43,253.75 sq.ft. out of the total extent of 49,613 sq.ft. leaving out the passage measuring about 6,360 sq.ft. The stand of the BBMP that the passage had not been handed over to it under a Relinquishment Deed was a dishonest stand.

10.

Referring to Section 17 of the Karnataka Town

and Country Planning Act, 1961 and Section 505 of the Karnataka Municipal Corporations Act, 1976, the learned Single Judge held that, though no permission for subdivision had been obtained from the Planning Authority, BBMP had nevertheless

effected

khata

bifurcation

and

sanctioned

building plans by recognising the passage. It was held that the actions undertaken by BBMP in the year 2006 need not be disturbed at that stage, but were required to be construed harmoniously with the statutory provisions. The learned Single Judge further held that BBMP could not disclaim its responsibility to maintain the passage merely because no registered Relinquishment Deed had been executed in its favour. It was also observed that the passage did not form part of the properties bearing separate municipal numbers and that neither the writ petitioners nor the contesting respondents could claim any independent right, title or interest over the same so as to enclose it by constructing a compound wall and gate. Since the passage had not been specifically gifted or bequeathed to any

particular person, the children of Shri. M. Venkataramaiah were held to have equal rights therein. It was further held that the contesting respondents could not have leased the passage to the educational institution.

11.

Insofar

as

the

civil

suit

instituted

by

the

educational institution was concerned, the learned Single Judge noticed that the suit had been filed after issuance of the notice by BBMP and that BBMP, despite entering appearance,

had

failed

to

effectively

contest

the

proceedings. It was observed that the suit proceeded on an incorrect description of the properties as a composite unit, notwithstanding

the

existence

of

separate

municipal

numbers and the absence of amalgamation of khatas. The learned Single Judge held that the Civil Court ought to have examined the maintainability of the suit and that the decree of permanent injunction would not prevent BBMP from taking action in accordance with law. The learned Single Judge also expressed concern over the conduct of BBMP officials in defending the civil proceedings and directed the Chief Commissioner to initiate an enquiry, besides issuing

directions for effective monitoring of litigation involving BBMP

and

conducting

a

survey

of

roads

within

its

jurisdiction. Accordingly, the learned Single Judge allowed the writ petition and directed BBMP to implement the notice/order dated 13.10.2011 and 18.11.2011, remove the compound wall and gate constructed across the disputed passage measuring 40 feet × 159 feet, keep the passage free from encroachments, maintain the same and enter it in its property register.

12.

The learned counsel appearing for the appellants

in Writ Appeal No.529/2023 contends that the learned Single Judge erred in adjudicating disputed questions of title and ownership

in

proceedings

under

Article

of

the

Constitution of India. It is submitted that the passage measuring 40 feet × 159 feet forms part of the larger private

property

originally

belonging

to

Shri.

M.

Venkataramaiah and was provided exclusively for ingress and egress to the properties bequeathed to his sons. The passage had neither been relinquished in favour of BBMP nor acquired by it in accordance with law and, therefore, could

not be treated as a public street. It is further contended that respondents No.1 and 2 have independent access to their property and no right, title or easementary right over the disputed passage. The original owner had merely gifted and bequeathed portions of his property to his children and had not formed any layout requiring approval under Section 17 of the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act. Mere khata bifurcation, sanction of building plans or collection of property taxes would not result in vesting of the passage in BBMP.

13.

It is further contended that the findings of the

learned Single Judge are mutually inconsistent, inasmuch as,

having

observed

that

the

children

of

Shri.

M.

Venkataramaiah have equal rights over the passage, the learned Single Judge proceeded to direct BBMP to maintain the same as a public street. It is submitted that such disputed questions could not have been determined without recording evidence before the competent Civil Court. The compound wall and gate were constructed for the safety and security of the students and hostel inmates, the passage

was never intended for public use. It is also contended that the notice dated 13.10.2011 was merely a show-cause notice and the communication dated 18.11.2011 was an internal communication, neither of which constituted a final statutory order. It is contended that the learned Single Judge failed to consider the spot mahazar, inspection reports and affidavits of BBMP indicating that the passage had not vested in the Corporation.

14.

It

institution

is

had

also

submitted

instituted

a

that

the

educational

suit

for

permanent

civil

injunction, which was decreed on 29.11.2012 and the judgment and decree had attained finality. The learned Single Judge could not have virtually nullified the decree or questioned

the

maintainability

of

the

suit

in

writ

proceedings. It is therefore contended that the directions issued for removal of the compound wall and gate and for treating

the

unsustainable.

passage

as

a

public

street

are

legally

15.

The learned counsel appearing for the appellants

in Writ Appeal No.529/2023 has placed reliance on the following decisions:• Commissioner of Sales Tax and Others v. M/s. Subhash and Company reported in (2003) 3 SCC 454; • Kalabharati

Advertising

v.

Hemant

Vimalnath Narichania and Others reported in (2010) 9 SCC 437; • Mohd.

Abdul

Quayyum

v.

State

of

Karnataka and Others reported in 2013 SCC OnLine Kar 10363; • Ramamurthy

N.

v.

Bruhat

Bangalore

Mahanagara Palike and Others passed in W.P.No.22305/2016 decided on 24.03.2023; • Sri Vinod Damji Patel v. The Hoskote Yojana

Pradhikara

passed

in

W.P.No.15103/2022 decided on 17.04.2023; • Tukaram

Kana

Maharashtra

Joshi

and

Industrial

Others

v.

Development

Corporation and Others reported in (2013) 1 SCC 353, and • Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Limited v.

Darius

Shapur

Chenai

and

Others

reported in (2005) 7 SCC 627 : AIR 2005 SC 3520.

16.

The learned counsel appearing for the appellants

in Writ Appeal No.612/2023 contends that the learned Single Judge exceeded the scope of the writ petition by directing BBMP to maintain the disputed passage as a public street and enter it in its property register, though the relief sought was

confined

to

implementation

of

the

notice

dated

13.10.2011 and the communication dated 18.11.2011 and removal of the compound wall and gate. It is submitted that no declaration regarding the nature or vesting of the passage in BBMP had been sought. Mere khata bifurcation, sanction of building plans or collection of property taxes would not convert a private passage into a public street, particularly when the passage had neither been acquired by nor relinquished in favour of BBMP.

17.

It is further contended that the learned Single

Judge erred in applying Section 17 of the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act and Section 505 of the Karnataka Municipal Corporations Act, as the original owner, Shri. M. Venkataramaiah, had merely gifted and bequeathed portions of his property to his children without forming any layout or

public road. The statutory provisions relating to formation of layouts

and

relinquishment

of

roads

were

therefore

inapplicable. It is also submitted that BBMP maintains a Road History Register under Section 293 of the Karnataka Municipal Corporations Act and that the general directions issued by the learned Single Judge for conducting a survey of roads throughout Bengaluru were neither sought by the writ petitioners nor warranted for adjudication of the dispute concerning the particular passage.

18.

It is also submitted that the affidavit filed on

behalf of BBMP in April 2022, expressing willingness to implement the earlier notice and communication, could not be treated as an admission that the disputed passage vested in BBMP or as conferring any statutory authority over the same. It is therefore contended that the directions requiring BBMP to maintain and register the passage as a public street, as also the wider directions concerning the survey of roads, are legally unsustainable and liable to be set aside.

19.

The learned counsel appearing for respondents

No.1 and 2 in both the appeals contends that the disputed

passage measuring 40 feet × 159 feet was specifically provided under the registered Will and Gift Deeds dated 22.04.2004 executed by Shri. M. Venkataramaiah and is reflected in the boundaries of the respective properties. It is submitted that the passage was intended to provide access to

the

properties

allotted

to

his

children,

including

respondent No.1 and that the appellants in Writ Appeal No.529/2023 cannot claim exclusive rights over the same. It is further submitted that BBMP, having recognised the passage while effecting khata bifurcation, assigning separate municipal numbers and sanctioning building plans, cannot subsequently contend that it is not a public street. It is also pointed out that, out of the total extent of 49,613 sq.ft., betterment charges were paid only in respect of 43,253.75 sq.ft., leaving out approximately 6,360 sq.ft. comprising the disputed passage, which, establishes that the passage vests in BBMP.

20.

It is further contended that, having regard to the

definitions of private and public streets under Sections 2(30) and 2(31) of the Karnataka Municipal Corporations Act, the

disputed passage, being accessible to the public, constitutes a public street. Reliance is placed on Sections 265, 280, 285, 287, 288, 288-A and 288-D of the Karnataka Municipal Corporations Act to contend that BBMP is empowered and obligated to prevent and remove unauthorised obstructions over streets and that the compound wall and gate could not have been constructed without obtaining the requisite statutory permission.

21.

We have considered the contentions advanced.

We notice that the writ petition itself was filed specifically alleging that the entire property belonged to Shri. M. Venkatramaiah and that the owner had bifurcated the property into 5 portions and had executed a Will and 2 Gift Deeds, dividing the property among his three sons and two daughters. It is contended that the passage road measuring 40 feet x 159 feet leading to Ramamurthy Nagar Main Road, which bifurcated the properties allotted in favour of the petitioner No.1 and respondents No.4 to 6, vested in respondent No.1's authority, under Section 265 of the Karnataka Municipal Corporations Act, 1976. It is on these

contentions directions

that to

the

the

writ

petition

respondent

was

No.3

to

filed,

seeking

remove

the

encroachment and dismantle the compound and gate legally installed in the 40 feet road.

22.

The learned Single Judge, after considering the

contentions, held that the order of injunction passed in the suit file by the Educational Institution as against the BBMP could not come in the way of this Court directing the BBMP to remove the compound wall and gate put upon its passage/street, which was deemed to have been vested with the BBMP on account of the respondents No.4 to 6 having obtained bifurcation of khata.

23.

The finding of the learned Single Judge is to the

effect that since the khata of the property had been bifurcated and since the passage was not included in any of the khata so bifurcated there is a deemed vesting of the road in favour of the BBMP. We are unable to accept the said contention.

Section

of

the

Karnataka

Corporations Act, 1976 reads as follows:-

Municipal

"265.

Vesting

of

public

streets

and

their

appurtenances in corporation.(1) All public streets in the corporation reserved under the control of the Government, with the pavements, stones and other materials thereof and all work materials, implements and other things provided for such streets, all sewers, drains, drainage works, tunnels and culverts whether made at the cost of the corporation fund or otherwise, in or alongside or under any street, whether public or private, and all works, materials, implements and other things appertaining thereto and all trees not being private property growing on public streets or by the side thereof, shall vest in the corporation. (2) The Government may, after consulting the corporation by notification withdraw any such street, sewer, drain, drainage work, tunnel, culvert or tree from the control of the corporation."

24.

The provisions of Section 17 of the Karnataka

Town and Country Planning Act also provides for sanction for subdivision of plot or layout of private street, though it is stated in the instant case that no particular permission under Section 17 of the KTCP Act had been taken by appellant No.1, there was a subdivision of plots and a mention of the road in the plan sanctioned obtained by the appellants. It is on these grounds that the learned Single

Judge has held that there is a deemed surrender and vesting of the road in question in the BBMP. 25.

The BBMP in its affidavit filed on 14.01.2022 had

specifically stated as follows:"I Submit that, to clear the ambiguity and to ascertain the actual facts, on 30.09.2021, I, along with the Assistant Engineer of Maruthi Sevanagar Sub-Division, BBMP visited the spot and conducted an inspection. In the said inspection, it was found that there is no encroachment on the public road. The alleged 40 feet road, which is in fact a passage, does not belong to the BBMP. Copy of the Sport Mahazar Report, Road ID Map and Photographs depicting the spot in question are produced herewith and marked as Document Nos.1, 2 & 3 respectively."

26.

Further, the Civil Court by judgment and decree

dated 29.11.2012 in O.S.No.7544/2011 filed by the School against the BBMP, held that in the absence of pleading and evidence on the part of the BBMP to prove the acts stated in the Notice dated 13.10.2011, it was not possible to believe that appellants No.1 to 3 had put up the compound wall and iron gates across the 40 feet road or had laid the concrete road illegally. It was held that appellant No.4 had proved its lawful possession of the suit schedule properties and the threat of interference, therefore, the Civil Court permanently

restrained the BBMP and its officials from interfering with appellant No.4's possession and enjoyment of the suit schedule

properties.

Even

from

the

pleadings

of

the

petitioners in the writ petition there is absolutely no whisper as to any relinquishment of the passage in question in favour of the BBMP so as to enable the BBMP to treat the property as a Public Road. The learned Single Judge has also noticed that there is no such relinquishment of the road in question.

27.

In the facts and circumstances of the instant

case, where, admittedly, no sanction under Section 17 of the Karnataka Town and Country Planning Act was ever sought for or obtained by the parties, the finding of the learned Single Judge that there was a deemed vesting in the BBMP of the road formed in a private property by agreement of the owners

of

the

plots,

cannot

be

accepted

under

any

circumstances.

28.

We notice that the learned Single Judge also has

not adverted to any vesting of the road in question in the BBMP by any specific order or act and has relied on a

deemed vesting on account of the fact that Khata in respect of the 5 separate plots had been subdivided and the road was not included in any of such plots.

29.

We are of the opinion that in view of the fact that

there is no specific vesting of the road which is admittedly formed within a private property in the BBMP, the finding of the learned Single Judge cannot be sustained.

30.

Appeal is accordingly disposed of with the

following observations:-

(i)

Findings of the learned Single Judge with regard to

vesting of the road in the BBMP shall stand

vacated.

(ii)

In case the parties have any disputes with regard to use of the road may agitate the same in appropriate proceedings before the competent Civil Court.

All

pending

Interlocutory

Applications

shall

disposed of.

Sd/(ANU SIVARAMAN) JUDGE

Sd/(K.S.BHARATH KUMAR) JUDGE PN/CP*

stand

Related judgments

More Karnataka High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.