Vaibhav Raju Hunde v. The State of Maharashtra and Others
- Court
- Bombay High Court
- Date of judgment
- 4 November 2026
- Case number
- WP No. 631 of 2026
- Result
- DISPOSED OFF
- Acts & sections
- Section 35 BNSS, Section 119 BNS, Section 126 BNS
- Subject
- Criminal
Full judgment
2026:BHC-AUG:54491-DB
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD CRIMINAL WRIT PETITION NO. 631 OF 2026 Vaibhav S/o. Raju Hunde, Age : 22 Years, Occ. : Unemployed, R/o. Near Datta Mandir, Hudco,P Nanded, Tq. & Dist. Nanded.
..PETITIONER
~VERSUS~ 1.
The State of Maharashtra, Section Officer (Special), Home Department, Government of Maharashtra, Mantralaya, Mumbai-32.
2.
The District Magistrate & Collector, Dist. Nanded.
3.
The Superintendent of Police, Dist. Nanded.
4.
The Sub-Divisional Police Officer, Sub-Division Itwara, Dist. Nanded.
5.
The Police Inspector, Nanded Rural Police Station, Dist. Nanded.
...RESPONDENTS
__________________________________________________________ •
Adv. Yogesh G. Birajdar for the Petitioner • Mr. S. J. Salgare, A.P.P. for Respondent Nos. 1 to 5 __________________________________________________________ CORAM
: SANDIPKUMAR C. MORE & VAISHALI PATIL-JADHAV, JJ.
RESERVED ON
: OCTOBER 19, 2026
PRONOUNCED ON : NOVEMBER 04, 2026
Page|1 of 13
J U D G M E N T : [PER VAISHALI PATIL-JADHAV, J.]
.
Rule. Rule made returnable forthwith. Heard
finally at the admission stage with the consent of learned advocates for the parties. 2.
By this petition, the petitioner challenges the
detention order dated 31.12.2025 bearing No. 2025/RB1/Desk-2/T-4/MPDA/CR-85, passed by Respondent No. 2District Magistrate, Nanded, in exercise of the powers under Section 3(1) of the Maharashtra Prevention of Dangerous Activities
of
Dangerous
Persons,
Persons
Slumlords,
Engaged
Video in
Bootleggers, Pirates,
Drug-offenders,
Sand
Black-Marketing
of
Smugglers, Essential
Commodities, Illegal Gambling, Illegal Lottery and Human Trafficker Act, 1981 (hereinafter referred to as “MPDA”), and the confirmation order dated 27.02.2026 bearing No. MPDA-0126/CR-06/Spl-3B, passed by Respondent No. 1State Government, in exercise of the powers under Section 12(1) of the MPDA. By the impugned detention order, the petitioner is directed to be detained for a period of 12 months on the ground that the petitioner is a “dangerous person” within the meaning of Section 2(b-1) of the MPDA.
Page|2 of 13
3.
The record reflects registration of seven (07)
criminal cases and three preventive actions taken against the petitioner. The reference chart showing the criminal record of the petitioner is reproduced hereunder : Sr. No.
Police Station
C.R. No.
Under Section
Nanded Rural
680/2022
395, 397, 427 IPC, 4/25, 4/27 19/11/2022 Arms Act
Nanded Rural
74/2023
394, 397 IPC
Nanded Rural
232/2024
4/25 Arms Act
Court Case No.
Present Status
23/11/2022 03/01/2023
S.C. No. 91/2024
Court Pending
14/02/2023 28/02/2023
S.C. No. 206/2023
Court Pending
25/03/2024 25/03/2024
R.C.C. No. 794/2024
Court Pending
19/08/2024 25/10/2024
On On Investigation Investigation
31/08/2024 23/10/2024
On On Investigation Investigation
Date of filing Arrest Date
09/02/2023 25/03/2024
Bail Date
Mudkhed
176/2024
109, 132, 3(5) BNS, 4/25 Arms Act, Criminal 18/08/2024 Law (Amendment) Act, 2013, Section 7
Nanded Rural
745/2024
311 BNS
Nanded Rural
119(1), 352, 19/10/2025 1005/2025 351(2), 351(3), 3(5) BNS
26/12/2025 30/12/2025
On On Investigation Investigation
Nanded Rural
126(2), 115(2), 351(2), 351(3), 21/11/2025 1108/2025 3(5) BNS, 4/25 Arms Act
26/12/2025 26/12/2025
On On Investigation Investigation
19/08/2024
Preventive Action : Sr. No.
Police Station
Chapter Case No.
Section
Date
Present Status
Nanded Rural
429/2024
107 Cr.P.C.
04/06/2024
Closed
Nanded Rural
02/2023
110 Cr.P.C.
05/01/2023
Closed
Nanded Rural
11/2024
MPDA 3(1)
20/12/2024
Closed
4.
Learned advocate for the petitioner submits that
there is an inordinate and unexplained delay of more than two months in passing the impugned order of detention. He
Page|3 of 13
submitted that though the proposal for detention was initiated on 28.10.2025, and forwarded to the detaining authority on 05.11.2025, the order of detention was passed only on 31.12.2025. Such long and unexplained delay, after the alleged prejudicial activities and after recording of the in-camera statements has resulted in snapping of the live link. He further submitted that the petitioner was arrested on 26.12.2025 and he was granted bail on 30.12.2025. Before the bail order could reach the prison authorities and formalities could be completed for releasing the petitioner, the detaining authority passed the detention order on 31.12.2025, when the petitioner was already granted bail in C.R. No.1005/2025. This shows that the detention of the petitioner was predetermined by the detaining authority, without there being any substantive satisfaction. Learned advocate lastly submitted that the detention order is liable to be quashed and set aside and prayed for the release of the petitioner. 5.
Per contra, learned APP while supporting the
impugned order submitted that the petitioner has an ascending trend of serious criminal offences under the IPC, BNS, and Arms Act, creating an atmosphere of fear in the
Page|4 of 13
jurisdiction of Nanded Rural Police Station. It is submitted that the detaining authority was fully aware of the bail position, as reflected in the grounds of detention, and that bail is no bar to preventive detention. It is also submitted that all mandatory provisions and statutory timelines were strictly complied with, including the timely approval by the State Government and obtaining the opinion of the Advisory Board; thus, the impugned order of detention is justified and the live-link is not snapped. Learned APP lastly submitted that the detaining authority has passed the detention order after applying its mind to the entire record and recording the requisite subjective satisfaction, and prayed for dismissal of the petition. 6.
Heard learned Advocate Mr. Yogesh G. Birajdar
for the petitioner and learned APP Mr. S.J. Salgare for the respondents. With the assistance of the learned advocates, we
have
perused
the
petition,
the
affidavit-in-reply,
citations and the record. 7.
The detaining authority, while passing the
impugned detention order, has mainly relied upon two offences, i.e., C.R. No.1005/2025 registered on 19.10.2025
Page|5 of 13
under Sections 119(1), 352, 351(2), 351(3), 3(5) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, and C.R. No. 1108/2025 registered on 21.11.2025 under Sections 126(2), 115(2), 351(2), 351(3), 3(5) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 and Section 4/25 of the Arms Act, 1959, both registered with Nanded Rural Police Station, Nanded, along with two in-camera statements of confidential witnesses "A" and "B", to declare the petitioner a “Dangerous Person”. 8.
The record shows the following chronology: the
crimes considered while passing the detention order were registered on 19.10.2025 and 21.11.2025. The confidential statements of witnesses ‘A’ and ‘B’ were recorded on 27.10.2025. After completion of the confidential inquiry, the proposal was initiated on 28.10.2025 by the Police Inspector, Police Station, Nanded Rural. The P.I. forwarded the proposal to the Sub-Divisional Police Officer, Itwara, Nanded, who verified the statements of the witnesses on 28.10.2025. The Sub-Divisional Police Officer forwarded the proposal to the Superintendent of Police, Nanded, who forwarded the same to the District Magistrate, Nanded, i.e. the detaining authority, on 05.11.2025. Thereafter, the
Page|6 of 13
detention order came to be passed by the detaining authority only on 31.12.2025. 9.
The last crime which was considered by the
Sponsoring Authority while forwarding the proposal to the detaining authority was registered on 19.10.2025; and the proposal reached the detaining authority on 05.11.2025. The second crime i.e. C.R. No.1108/2025 registered on 21.11.2025 was considered by the detaining authority though the same was not there in the proposal forwarded by the Sponsoring Authority. As the detention proposal had reached the detaining authority on 05.11.2025, still the detention order is passed on 31.12.2025 i.e. after a delay of almost two months. There is an absence of any live link between the material considered by the detaining authority as being prejudicial to the maintenance of public order and the
subjective
satisfaction
reached
by
the
detaining
authority that the activities of the petitioner were indeed prejudicial to the maintenance of public order. Moreover, the said delay is unexplained. 10.
If the affidavit-in-reply of the detaining authority
is perused, there is no explanation as to the delay in passing the detention order. In paragraph no.10 of the
Page|7 of 13
affidavit, it is stated that, "Deponent further submits that there is no delay in passing the order and no delay in submitting the report to the State Government. All the mandatory provisions have been completed in time as stipulated period mentioned in the said Act. Therefore, the deponent submits that the detention order passed by the respondent No.2 is as per law." There is no sentence in the affidavit explaining the reasons for the delay caused in passing the detention order from the date of last crime, which is considered for passing the detention order or from the date of receiving the proposal by the detaining authority. 11.
A profitable reference can be made to the
judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Smt. Hemlata Kantilal Shah Vs. State of Maharashtra and another, reported in (1981) 4 SCC 647, wherein it is held that, "delay ipso facto in passing an order of detention after an incident is not fatal to the detention of a person, for in certain cases delay may be unavoidable and reasonable. What is required by law is that the delay must be satisfactorily explained by the Detaining Authority."
Page|8 of 13
12.
In the facts of the present case, there is no
explanation as to the delay caused from the date of initiation
of
detention
proceeding
by
recording
the
statements of confidential witnesses on 27.10.2025, the detaining authority receiving the proposal on 05.11.2025 and the passing of detention order on 31.12.2025. The detaining authority has failed to satisfactorily explain the delay in passing the detention order. Therefore, the judgment in the case of Hemlata Shah (supra) is squarely applicable to the facts and circumstances of the present case. 13.
Out of the two crimes considered for passing the
detention order, in C.R. No.1108/2025, the petitioner was only served with a notice under Section 35(3) of the BNSS, 2023 as the police authorities did not find it necessary to arrest
the
petitioner.
In
Crime
No.1005/2025,
the
petitioner was arrested on 26.12.2025 and was released on bail
on 30.12.2025. Before the bail order could reach the
prison authorities and they could complete the formalities for releasing him on bail, the detaining authority passed the detention order on 31.12.2025. It is merely mentioned in paragraph 10 of the detention order that the petitioner
Page|9 of 13
has been released on bail on 30.12.2025 and that he is on bail in other offences. However, there is no discussion in the
grounds
of
detention
as
to
the
sufficiency
or
insufficiency of the bail conditions. The detaining authority has thus mechanically applied its mind without examining the actual gravity and impact of the incidents or the efficacy of the bail conditions, which clearly demonstrates non-application of mind while arriving at the subjective satisfaction
or
rather
the
detaining
authority
was
predetermined to see that the petitioner does not come out of the jail. Hence, the detention order was passed only after passing bail order by the Competent Court. This clearly indicates that the detaining authority had already made up its mind to detain the petitioner and merely waited for bail orders of the Competent Court. Such course of action reflects complete non-application of mind. In view of this, the detention order cannot sustain. 14.
Before passing the order of detention, the
Detaining Authority must keep in mind that the recording of subjective satifaction by the Detaining Authority in an order of preventive detention is a sine qua non for passing a valid order of preventive detention. This Court is well aware
Page|10 of 13
of the position of law that, while deciding the validity of an order of preventive detention, this Court cannot decide whether there was adequacy of material before the Detaining Authority. This Court can only examine whether there was material before the Detaining Authority and whether the Detaining Authority has recorded subjective satisfaction that the grounds provided in the statute for passing an order of detention exist. The order of preventive detention is an order of a very drastic nature. The result of passing an order of preventive detention is to deprive the detenu of his liberty without trial. Therefore, an order of preventive detention cannot be passed in a casual manner. Passing of an order of preventive detention involves careful application of mind and recording of subjective satisfaction on the basis of the material on record that the grounds of detention provided by the statute exist. 15.
In our view, there has been an inordinate delay
from receiving the proposal by the detaining authority till the passing of the detention order. The explanation furnished in the affidavit-in-reply is not satisfactory and plausible. In fact, no explanation is given in the affidavit-inreply as to the delay of approximately 2 months caused in
Page|11 of 13
passing the detention order. The delay caused in passing the detention order has snapped the live link between the prejudicial activities of the petitioner and the rationale of clamping the detention order on the petitioner. From the detention order, it can also be gathered that the detaining authority had already made up its mind to detain the petitioner and merely waited for the bail orders of the Competent Court as the detention order is passed only after the bail orders were passed by the Competent Court. This shows that there was no actual subjective satisfaction on the part of the detaining authority. As such, it can be inferred that there was no ground as required for detention under Section 3(1) of the MPDA as to the subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority.
As a result, the
detention order has ceased to be preventive, as it should be in law, and has instead become punitive and must therefore be struck down. Accordingly, we pass the following order :ORDER (i)
The Writ Petition is allowed.
(ii)
The detention order dated 31.12.2025 bearing No.
2025/RB-1/Desk-2/T-4/MPDA/CR-85,
passed
by
Respondent No. 2- District Magistrate, Nanded and the
Page|12 of 13
confirmation order dated 27.02.2026 bearing No. MPDA0126/CR-06/Spl-3B, passed by Respondent No. 1- State Government, are hereby quashed and set aside. (iii)
The Petitioner- Vaibhav S/o Raju Hunde shall be
released forthwith, if not required in any other offence. (iv)
Rule is made absolute in the above terms.
[VAISHALI PATIL-JADHAV] JUDGE
[SANDIPKUMAR C. MORE] JUDGE
Page|13 of 13