Vijay Karan Pandey v. State of Uttar Pradesh and 4 Others
- Court
- Allahabad High Court
- Date of judgment
- 28 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Krishna Swaroop Dhar Dwivedi Senior Registrar (j)(conf.)
- Case number
- CRLP No. 16207 of 2026
- Acts & sections
- Section 145 CrPC, Section 146 CrPC, Article 226 Constitution
- Subject
- Criminal
Full judgment
HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD CRIMINAL MISC. WRIT PETITION No. - 16207 of 2026 Vijay Karan Pandey .....Petitioner(s) Versus State Of Uttar Pradesh And 4 Others .....Respondent(s) Counsel for Petitioner(s) Counsel for Respondent(s)
: :
Birendra Singh, Ratan Singh, Swati Singh Chetan Prakash, G.A.
Court No. - 78 HON'BLE SANDEEP JAIN, J. The instant petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India has been filed for the following reliefs:"Issue an order or directing setting aside the ex parte order dated 11.06.2026 passed by the respondent No. 2 the Executive
Magistrate/Deputy
Commissioner
Police
(City), Commissionerate, Prayagraj, in proceedings under Sections 145 and 146 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, whereby the respondent No. 3 has been directed to enforce the order dated 05.06.2017. Issue an appropriate order or direction commanding the respondent
authorities
residential
house
House
bearing
forthwith No.
de-seal
1646/928,
Mohalla
Dariyabad, Police Station Atarsuiya, District Prayagraj,
restore
peaceful
possession
thereof
petitioner. Issue any suitable order or direction as this Hon'ble Court
may
deem
fit
proper
under
facts
circumstances of thé case existing the present case." On 10.07.2026, the following order was passed:"The
instant
writ
petition
has
been
filed
following reliefs:"Issue an order or directing setting aside the ex parte order dated 11.06.2026 passed by the respondent No. 2 the Executive
Magistrate/Deputy
Commissioner
Police
(City), Commissionerate, Prayagraj, in proceedings under
Sections 145 and 146 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, whereby the respondent No. 3 has been directed to enforce the order dated 05.06.2017. Issue an appropriate order or direction commanding the respondent
authorities
residential
house
House
bearing
forthwith No.
de-seal
1646/928,
Mohalla
Dariyabad, Police Station Atarsuiya, District Prayagraj,
restore
peaceful
possession
thereof
petitioner. Issue any suitable order or direction as this Hon'ble Court
may
deem
fit
proper
under
facts
circumstances of thé case existing the present case." Learned
counsel
respondent
agreement
nos.4
petitioner's
sell
had
dated
father,
petitioner executed
12.02.1987
namely,
submitted
Ram
a
that
registered
favour
Asrey
Pandey
@
Bacha
Pandey, in respect of the disputed house. Since the sale deed was not executed despite the said agreement, the petitioner's
father
instituted
Original
Suit
No.67
2006 (Ram Asrey Pandey Vs. Mangal Das & others) before the Court of Civil Judge (Senior Division), Prayagraj, seeking specific performance of the registered agreement to sell. He further submitted that the private respondents entered appearance in the aforesaid suit and filed their written statement sell.
disputing
They
also
execution
preferred
a
agreement
counter-claim
praying
cancellation of the registered agreement to sell on the allegation seeking
that
it
recovery
forged
possession
fabricated,
besides
over
disputed
property. The said civil suit, along with the counterclaim, is still pending adjudication. It was further submitted that despite the pendency of the aforesaid civil proceedings involving identical questions relating
title
respondents,
after
application
an
possession,
inordinate
year
2017
delay, pursuant
private moved
an
which
proceedings under Section 145 Cr.P.C. were initiated in respect
same
property.
During
said
proceedings, the learned Additional City Magistrate-III, Prayagraj, by order dated 05.06.2017, directed attachment of the disputed property under Section 146(1) Cr.P.C. Aggrieved
by
Criminal
Revision
Bacha
Pandey
said
Vs.
order,
No.290
2017
State
U.P.
petitioner
preferred
(Ram
Pandey
&
Asrey
others),
which
@
decided by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, Court No.9, Prayagraj, on 17.05.2019. Learned counsel submits that
although
reasoning,
revisional
categorically
court,
recorded
its
findings
detailed
warranting
interference with the order dated 05.06.2017 and remand the matter to the Magistrate for fresh consideration, the operative portion of the judgment, apparently due to an inadvertent
error,
records
that
criminal
revision
stood dismissed. According to him, the reasoning and the operative portion of the revisional judgment are mutually irreconcilable. He further submitted that after the matter was remitted, the concerned Magistrate/Deputy Commissioner, Prayagraj, instead
accordance
independently with
law,
reconsidering
merely
implemented
matter
earlier
attachment order dated 05.06.2017 and, by the impugned order dated 11.06.2026, once again directed attachment of
disputed
property
without
recording
any
fresh
satisfaction or assigning independent reasons. Per contra, learned A.G.A. submitted that a plain reading of the revisional judgment dated 17.05.2019 unmistakably demonstrates that the learned Revisional Court intended
allow
revision
petition.
The
entire
reasoning
recorded in the judgment culminates in setting aside the order dated 05.06.2017 and remanding the matter for fresh adjudication. However, owing to an apparent inadvertent mistake, the operative portion mentions that the revision stands dismissed. He submitted that where there exists an irreconcilable conflict between the reasoning contained in the body of the judgment and the operative portion thereof, such an inconsistency is liable to be treated as a manifest error. Learned A.G.A. further submitted that, in any event, once a comprehensive civil suit relating to
same
property
already
pending,
initiation
proceedings under Section 145 Cr.P.C. in the year 2017 was itself legally questionable. I
have
learned
considered counsel
rival
submissions
parties
have
advanced
by
perused
material brought on record. From the record, it is evident that respondent nos.4 and
executed
12.02.1987
a
registered favour
agreement
sell
petitioner's
dated
father,
Ram
Asrey Pandey @ Bacha Pandey. Upon failure of the vendors to execute the sale deed, Original Suit No.67 of 2006 was instituted
seeking
specific
performance
said
agreement. The private respondents contested the suit by filing a written statement coupled with a counter-claim alleging
that
fraudulent
agreement
seeking
its
sell
cancellation
forged as
well
as
recovery of possession over the disputed property. A perusal of the written statement filed by the private respondents
reveals
that
they
themselves
have
acknowledged that the petitioner is in possession of the disputed
property
pursuant
agreement
sell,
though they dispute the validity of the said document. Thus, the questions relating to possession and title are already sub judice before the competent Civil Court. It further transpires that notwithstanding the pendency
Section
aforesaid
civil
Cr.P.C.
proceedings,
were
initiated
proceedings
year
under 2017,
culminating in an attachment order dated 05.06.2017 under Section 146(1) Cr.P.C. The petitioner challenged the said order by filing Criminal Revision No.290 of 2017. A
careful
reading
revisional
judgment
dated
17.05.2019 prima facie indicates that while the learned Revisional
Court
has
assigned
warranting
interference
with
remand
matter
elaborate
reasons
attachment
order
Magistrate
fresh
adjudication, the operative portion unexpectedly records dismissal of the revision. The reasoning contained in the judgment
inconsistent
its
operative
incapable
portion
are
harmonious
manifestly
construction.
Prima facie, therefore, it appears that the revisional
court
intended
allow
revision
remand
matter, but due to an inadvertent error the operative portion came to be drafted otherwise. Had the revision actually been allowed, the attachment order dated 05.06.2017 would have stood set aside and the Magistrate would have been under a legal obligation to independently reconsider the controversy after recording fresh
satisfaction
accordance
with
law.
Instead,
relying upon the apparent inconsistency in the revisional judgment,
Magistrate
has
merely
reiterated
earlier attachment order and, by the impugned order dated 11.06.2026, directed attachment of the disputed property, which
thereafter
executed
by
concerned
police
authorities on 21.06.2026. At this stage, it is also evident that the petitioner has not challenged the revisional judgment dated 17.05.2019, which
appears
be
genesis
present
controversy. Unless the apparent contradiction contained in the revisional judgment is appropriately addressed, the legality of the consequential proceedings cannot be effectively examined by this Court. Accordingly,
learned
counsel
petitioner
is
permitted to amend the writ petition during the course of
day
by
suitably
incorporating
a
challenge
revisional judgment dated 17.05.2019 passed in Criminal Revision
No.290
2017
by
making
appropriate
consequential prayers. Issue notice to respondent nos.4 and 5. Steps shall be taken by both modes within three days. List this matter as a fresh case on 20.07.2026." Learned counsel for respondent Nos. 4 and 5 has filed a counter affidavit, and learned counsel for the petitioner has filed a supplementary affidavit. Both the affidavits are taken on record. Learned counsel for respondent Nos. 4 and 5 admits that there is an error in the judgment dated 17.05.2019 passed by the revisional court in Criminal Revision No. 290 of 2017, Ram Asrey Pandey @ Bacha Pandey v. State of U.P. and Others, by the Additional Sessions Judge, Court No. 9, Allahabad. The body of the judgment
contains reasoning indicating that the revision ought to have been allowed, however, in the operative portion, it has erroneously been mentioned that the revision stands dismissed. Learned counsel admits that, had the revision been allowed, the impugned order dated 05.06.2017 passed by the concerned Magistrate would have been set aside, and the Magistrate would have been under an obligation to decide the controversy afresh after hearing the parties. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that, owing to the erroneous order passed in Criminal Revision No. 290 of 2017, the impugned order dated 05.06.2017 passed by the City Magistrate has remained in force and in furtherance of the said order, respondent No. 2 directed its execution by order dated 11.06.2026, which has been challenged by the petitioner by filing Criminal Revision No. 244 of 2026, Vijay Karan Pandey v. State of U.P. and Others. Learned counsel for the private respondents submits that the private respondents are entitled to a one-third share in the disputed property, whereas the petitioner is claiming the entire property, which is erroneous. However, learned counsel admits that there is no legal document to establish that the disputed property has been duly partitioned and that a one-third share therein has been allotted to the private respondents. It is admitted by learned counsel for both parties that Original Suit No. 67 of 2006, Ram Asrey Pandey vs. Mangal Das and Others, concerning the disputed property, is pending before the Civil Judge (Senior Division), Prayagraj, wherein specific performance of a registered agreement to sell has been sought. The execution of the said agreement has been disputed by the defendants on the ground that it is a forged and fabricated document. It is further apparent that, in the aforesaid original suit, the private respondents, who are defendants therein, have entered appearance and filed their written statement, wherein they have admitted that the plaintiffs are in actual possession of the disputed property. The validity of the aforesaid registered agreement to sell is yet to be adjudicated by the competent civil court. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, it is crystal clear that the revisional court intended to allow Criminal Revision No. 290 of 2017 but, owing to an inadvertent error, dismissed the revision by order dated 17.05.2019, thereby causing grave prejudice to the petitioner. In view of the above, the order dated 17.05.2019 passed by the revisional court in Criminal Revision No. 290 of 2017 is hereby quashed, and consequently, the said criminal revision stands allowed.
The effect of allowing the aforesaid criminal revision is that the impugned order dated 05.06.2017 passed by the concerned Magistrate in the proceedings under Section 145 Cr.P.C., whereby the disputed property was attached and the order dated 11.06.2026 whereby its execution was directed stands set aside. Consequently, the matter is remanded to the concerned Magistrate for fresh consideration and decision on merits, in accordance with law, after affording an opportunity of hearing to both parties. It is made clear that the concerned Magistrate shall not be influenced by any observation or finding recorded in this order and shall be at liberty to decide the matter independently on its merits, in accordance with law. With the aforesaid observations and directions, the instant petition stands allowed. October 29, 2026 Himanshu (Sandeep Jain,J.)
Digitally signed by :HIMANSHU YADAV High Court of Judicature at Allahabad