Vijendra Singh v. Superintendent Range IV Bally II Division Howrah Commissionerate and Anr
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
- Date of judgment
- 1 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Smita Das De
- Case number
- WPA No. 22119 of 2026
- Result
- DISPOSED
- Subject
- Civil
Full judgment
07.10.2026 Item No.1 Ct. No. 10 BR
WPA 22119 of 2026 Vijendra Singh -vsSuperintendent Range IV Bally II Division Howrah Commissioner and another Mr. Vinay Kumar Shraff, Mr. Dev Kumar Agarwal … for the petitioner Mr.Uday Shankar Bhattacharyya, Ms. Sretapa Sinha … for the respondent 1. The
petitioner
challenged
the
dated
17.08.2026 whereby the GST registration of the petitioner has been cancelled with retrospective effect
from
16.07.2026
the
dated
17.08.2026, is not sustainable in the eye of law. 2. Main grievances of the petitioner are as follows:i)
The registration of the petitioner has been
cancelled
only
on
the
ground
lack
ownership of the property of the petitioner which is wholly without jurisdiction. ii)
Neither Section 29(2) of the Central Goods
and Services Tax Act, 2017 nor Rule 21 of the CGST Rules, 2017 mandates cancellation of registration for want of exclusive ownership. The petitioner has produced tenancy agreement from one of the co-owners and continued to carry on bonafide
manufacturing
premises in question.
activities
from
the
iii) The impugned order suffers from illegality and irregularity and has been passed in excess of jurisdiction, arbitrarily and is liable to be set aside. 3. It is further contended that despite filing a detailed reply dated 23.07.2026 to the Show Cause Notice, which is annexed as Annexure ‘P21’ at page 106 of the Writ Petition and duly acknowledged by the GST Authorities, the respondent No. 1 has erroneously recorded in the impugned order that no reply has been filed. 4. The
Learned
Counsel
appearing
for
the
GST
Authorities vehemently opposes the submissions made by the petitioner and submits that at thetime of personal hearing the petitioner failed to produce relevant documents pertaining to the property in question. 5. A Civil Suit has been filed by the petitioner against the co-owners of the property in question. 6. Heard the Learned Advocates for the respective parties and upon perusing the materials available on record, this Court has taken the judicial notice of the reply dated 23rd July 2026 being Annexure ‘P21’ at page 106 of the Writ Petition. This Court finds that the petitioner has been able to make out a prima facie case warranting interference at this stage. This Court is of the considered view that the Show
Cause
Notice
also
the
Cancellation of registration have been passed in a very
mechanical
manner
without
proper
application of mind and without considering the reply filed by the petitioner and thus warrants to be set aside on this score alone. 7. However,
this
Court
is
also
conscious
that
cancellation of GST registration results in severe civil consequences. It completely disables a dealer from carrying on business. It is a well proposition that object of GST Law is compliance and not punishment. When assessee expresses bona fide willingness to file return and pay outstanding dues, a liberal and pragmatic approach is warranted as held in
Kanaklal Sutradhar –vs- State of West
Bengal , reported in (2024) 165 Taxmann. com 468 (Calcutta)
and in Basudev Karmakar –vs- the
Superintendent of CGST and CX, Range VIII, B.B.D. Bag II Division, Kolkata North Commissionerate and Ors. in WPA 13801 of 2026 8. In view of the above in the interest of justice this Court deems fit appropriate to pass following directions. i.
The petitioner shall file a comprehensive and detailed representation before respondent No. 1 within a period
of 7 days from date,
explaining is bonafide to refute allegations mentioned in Show Cause Notice.
ii.
The respondent No. 1 shall consider dispose of
the same in light of ratio in
Kanaklal Sutradhar (supra) and Basudeb Karmakar (supra) by passing a reasoned and speaking order within three weeks from the date of receipt of the representation
after
affording an opportunity of personal hearing to the petitioner and the decision shall be accordingly
communicated
within
a
week
thereafter. iii.
The respondent no. 1 shall arrive at a logical and conclusive finding regarding
restoration
of registration for running business in a seamless manner. iv.
The respondent No. 1 shall take independent decision
without
being
influenced
by
observations made hereinabove. v.
The petitioner
shall not seek for further
adjournment and shall provide in advance serving
his Email ID
with the respondent no. 1 for
notice of hearing . Accordingly the
respondent no. 1 shall fix date and time and serve the notice through such email. vi.
If satisfied with credentials , respondent No. 1 shall activate
petitioner’s portal and log in
credentials within
a week from date of final
decision to enable filing of return and making
payment of requisite amount in accordance with law. vii.
Consequently
registration dated quashed
cancellation
17.08.2026 is hereby set
aside
subject
to
compliances as above. viii.
It is made clear
if the petitioner fails to
comply with the above direction , benefit of this order shall not enure to the petitioner.
9. With the above observations and directions, the Writ Petition stands disposed of without going into the merits of the case.
(Smita Das De, J.)