Ahmed Shah Khan Durrani @ A.S. Mubarak v. State of Maharashtra
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Date of judgment
- 21 March 2013
- Judge
- Justice P. Sathasivam
- Neutral citation
- 2013 INSC 178
- Reported in
- [2013] 16 S.C.R. 1
- Result
- Disposed off
- Acts & sections
- Section 212 IPC, Section 313 CrPC
- Subject
- Criminal
Full judgment
[2013] 16 S.C.R .. 1
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK
V.
STATE OF MAHARASHTRA (Criminal Appeal. No. 1438 of 2007) MARCH 21, 2013
[P. SATHASIVAM AND DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, JJ.] Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 - s.5 - Bombay serial blasts of 1993 - Possession of weapon - A-20 charged for keeping one AK-56 rifle and two magazines - Conviction of A-20 - Justification - Held: Justified - Sufficient material to show that recovery had been made at the behest of A-20 from the factory owned by a partnership to which he was the partner - In such a factsituation, he' ought to have explained the reason/source of his knowledge of such contraband articles being kept in his factory . - As he had not mentioned that he had seen someone . keeping the articles there, or somebody had told him about that, or he had seen the things lying there, the only reasonable inference drawn is that he himself had kept the same at that place - Being a partner of the firm if he was having the knowledge that some contraband were lying in his premises, he ought to have informed the police if he had no guilty mind -Explanation that at the time of recovery he did not have the key, not enough to tilt the balance in his favour - As A-20 made a statement leading to the discovery of AK-56 assault rifle and two magazines having kept in his workshop and the same had been found concealed on the loft, he cannot escape from the liability of possessing and concealing of the same, thus liable to be punished u/s.5 TADA.
C
-
Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 - ss. 3 and 5 -Bombay serial blasts of 1993 - Participation in landing and transportation of smuggled arn:is, ammunition and explosives ~-conviction of A-31 - Justification - Held:
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
A Justified - Evidence on record made it clear that A-31 had
C
participated in landing operation of contraband goods at Shekhadi as he was one of the persons who accompanied Tiger Memon (AA) and others and he had also been to Wangni Tower alongwith other associates and contraband material were loaded in tempo - The tempo was taken by him alongwith absconding accused to Mumbra as instructed by Tiger Memon (AA) - This version duly supported/corroborated by A-128 and by the evidence of PW-2 - Arms Act, 1959. Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 - ss.3(3) and 6 -Bombay serial blasts of 1993 - Facilitation of commission of terrorist activities - Smuggling and landing of arms, ammunition, hand grenades and explosives Conviction of A-30 - Challenged - Held: A-30 was aware that the smuggled goods were arms and ammunition, and even after acquiring such knowledge, he had continued the landing of said smuggled goods - He was thus liable for commission of offences uls.3(3) and 6 TADA - Evidence on record made it crystal clear that A-30 was not only a close associate of Tiger Memon (AA) and acting as a landing agent, but a man of confidence who could negotiate with the police and customs officials to fix the amount of bribe for facilitating the smuggling and transportation of the smuggled contraband - A-30 had been fully aware of the nature of contraband, and inspite of coming to know that the contraband contained arms, ammunition and explosives, he continued to help the smugglers - Further, A-30 had close association with A-82, officer of the customs department, who had been helping the smugglers by taking a bribe through A-30 - Therefore, A-30 also convicted for conspiracy - Penal Code, 1860 - s. 1208 - Arms Act, 1959.
Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 - ss. 3 and 6 - Bombay serial blasts of 1993 - Participation in landing and transportation of contraband smuggled into the H country by Tiger Memon (AA) - Abetting and participating in
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
terrorist activities - Conviction of A-46 - Challenged - Held: A Confession of A-46 revealed that he was in employment of the Memon family - It could not be accepted that A-46 was not aware of illegal business of Tiger Memon (AA) or about the nature of the contrabands smuggled into India - Presence of A-46 at the place where the goods were exchanged, at B Wangni Tower and concealed into cavities of vehicles for transportation to Bombay, shows that he was a very close confidant of Tiger Memon (AA) - A-46 handed over a motor vehicle containing arms and ammunitions at residence of A68 - Confessions of co-accused clearly established the c involvement of A-46 along with A-10 for taking co-accused persons, who were sent for training to Pakistan via Dubai, though he may not be aware of the purpose for which the coaccused were sent to Dubai - Conviction of A-46 confirmed. Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 D - ss.3(3) and 6 - Bombay serial blasts of 1993 - Landing and transportation of arms and ammunition for committing terrorist activities - Possession/storage of arms, ammunition and explosives - Conviction of A-73 ulss. 3(3) and 6 Justification - Held: Justified - A-73's involvement and E participation in the landing operations of the contraband substances was clearly established - His own confessional statement revealed that he, being fully aware of the contents of the contraband, shifted the same from the truck to other vehicles and that inspite of the fact that he knew that the F contraband contained arms, ammunition and ROX, he continued to be associated with the other co-accused Therefore, he aided and abetted terrorist activities - However, the said acts were committed by him in the early phases of the conspiracy, even prior to Tiger Memon (AA) deciding the G target of the Blast; and after this particular incident A-73 had not been involved in any landing job -Therefore, A-73 cannot be held guilty for the larger conspiracy. Tefforist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
- s. 3(3) - Bombay serial blasts of 1993 - Landing & transportation of smuggled arms, ammunition and explosives - Conviction of A-62 - Held: A-62, watchman of government premises i.e. Wangni Tower, had allowed the same to be used for the purpose of facilitating the smuggling and landing of B arms, ammunition, handgrenades and explosives as organized by Tiger Memon (AA) and his associates - The evidence further establishes his involvement in concealing 59 bags of ROX explosives in a field existing in his name Thus, he was rightly convicted uls.3(3) TADA and s.202 /PC C - Being a government servant, he intentionally omitted giving information to the authorities about the offences committed in his presence, which he was legally bound to do - Penal Code, 1860 - s. 202. Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 D - s.3 - Bombay serial blasts of 1993 - Larger conspiracy Involvement in landings and transportation of smuggled arms, ammunition and explosives - Whether A-42 could be held guilty for the offence of larger conspiracy - Held: Having regard to the fact that A-14 had chosen A-42 for the purpose E of keeping two revolvers with him and the fact that A-42 had readily kept the same, reveals that he was a man in which the prime accused had confidence with respect to the conspiracy - A-42 was involved in landing operations, however, since he had committed the relevant acts much prior to the date of the F bomb blasts and had not participated in any meetings, nor was he connected with the same in any manner, and the fact that the acts were committed by him at a time when even the targets of the Bomb blasts had not been fixed, he could not be held guilty for the offence of larger conspiracy.
Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 - s.3 - Bombay serial blasts of 1993 - Larger conspiracy Acquittal of A-79 by Special Judge - Justification - Held: The Special Judge was not justified in acquitting A-79 from the charge of larger conspiracy merely on the ground that he did
\ AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @AS. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA
not know about the places ~here the bombs had to be thrown and he was not th~ resident of Bombay and did not participate in the conspiratorial meetings - Finding of fact recorded by the Special Judge also contradictory as the court held that he participated in the arrri_s' training at Sandheri, however, he also observed that the evidence does not disclose that any of those accused had been trained in handling of handgrenades There being sufficient material on record that A-79 participated in the training of handling the handgrenades, there was no occasion for the Special Judge to take such a view - Arms Act, 1959.
c
Appeal - Appeal against acquittal - Scope for interference - Held: The appellate court should not ordinarily set aside a judgment of acquittal in a case where two views are possible, though the view of the appellate court may be the more probable one - The appellate court should bear in D mind the presumption of innocence orthe accused and further that the trial court's acquittal bolsters the presumption of his innocence - Interference in a routine manner where the other view is possible should be avoided, unless there are good reasons for interference. Evidence - Recovery evidence - Appreciation - Held: Signature of the accused is not required on the seizure memo - Plea that evidence of recovery cannot be relied upon for the reason that the same did not bear the signature of accused, not acceptable. Mrinal Das & Ors. v. State of Tripura (2011) 9 SCC 479: 2011 (14 ) SCR 411; State of Rajasthan v. Darshan Singh @ Darshan Lal AIR 2012 SC 1973: 2012 (6) SCR 18; State of W.B. v. Kai/ash Chandra Pandey (2004) 12 SCC 29: 2004 (5) Suppl. SCR 437; State of Rajasthan v. Teja Ram & Ors. (1-999} S SCC, 507: 1999 (2) SCR 29 482 and Prasad Ramakant Khade v. State of Maharashtra (1999) 8 SCC 493 - relied on.
C
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
Case Law Reference: 2012 (6) SCR 18
relied on
Para 320
2011 (14) SCR 411
relied on
Para 388
2004 (5) Suppl. SCR 437 relied on
Para 481
1999 (2) SCR 29
relied on
Para 482
(1999) 8 sec 493
relied on
Para 483
CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION: Criminal Appeal No. 1438 of 2007
From the Judgment and Order dated 30.05.2007 of the Presiding Officer of the Designated Court, u~der TADA (P) Act, 1987 for Bombay Blast Cases, Greater Bombay in D Bombay Blast Case No.1 of 1993
WITH
Crl.A. Nos. 912/2007, 1030/2012, 1311/2007, 417/2011, 1610/2011, 398/2011, 1420/2007, 1031/2012, 675-681/2008. 600/2011, 406/2011, 408/2011, 1034/2012, 416/2011, 512/ 2008, 401/2011, 595/2011, 171/2008, 172/2008, 403/2011. 1630/2007, 1029/2012, 207/2008, 415/2011, 2173/2010, 1632/2007, 271/2008, 598/2011, 1439/2007, 1035/2012, 203/ 2008, 396/2011, 414/2011, 1423/2007 and 1032/2012 Rajesh Pd. Singh, Mushtaq Ahmad, Arvind Kumar Sharma, K.N. Rai. Ms. Farhana Shah, Dr. Sushi! Balwada, Dr. Kailash Chand, Sanjay Jain, P. Parmeswaran, Vishwa Pal Singh, B. Krishna Prasad, Ms. Anjali Jha, Advs., for the Appearing Parties. The Judgment of the Court was delivered by
DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J. Criminal Appeal No. 1438 2007. 1. This appeal has been preferred against the impugned H judgment and order dated 30.5.2007, passed by Special Judge
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
of the Designated Court under the Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, 1987 (hereinafter referred to as the 'TADA') for the Bombay Blast, Greater Bombay, in the Bombay Blast Case No. 1/1993, convicting the appellant under Section 5 TADA, and awarding the punishment of 5 years RI, alongwith a fine of Rs.25,000/-, and in default of payment of fine, to further undergo RI for 6 months.
2. Facts and circumstances giving rise to this appeal are that:
A. As the facts of this case and all legal issues involved
C
herein have been elaborately dealt with in the connected appeal i.e. Criminal Appeal No. 1728 of 2007 [Yakub Abdul Razak it may be pertinent Memon v. State of Maharashtra thr. to mention only the relevant facts and charges against the appellant (A-20).
can,
B. Bombay Blast took place on 12.3.1993 in which 257 pers~ns lost their lives and 713 were injured. In addition thereto there had been loss of property worth several crores. The Bombay police investigated the matter at initial stage but subsequently it was entrusted to the Central Bureau of Investigation (hereinafter referred to as 'CBI') and on conclusion of the investigation, a chargesheet was filed against a large number of accused persons. Out of the accused persons against whom chargesheet was filed, 40 accused could not be put to trial as they have been absconding. Thus, the Designated Court under TADA framed charges against 138 accused persons. During the trial, 11 accused died and 2 accused turned hostile. Further the Designated Court discharged 2 accused during trial and the remaining persons including appellant (A-20) stood conyicted.
C. The appellant had been Charged for general conspiracy which is framed against all the accused persons for the offences punishable under Section 3(3) TADA and Section 120-B of Indian Penal Code, 1860 (hereinafter referred to as 'IPC') read
' - \I
•
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
with Sections 3(2)(i)(ii), 3(3), (4), 5 and 6 TADA and read with Sections 302, 307,326,324.427,435.436, 201and212 IPC and offences under Sections 3 and 7 read with Sections 25 (I-A), (1-B)(a) of the Arms Act, 1959 (hereinafter referred to as the 'Arms Act'), Sections 9-8(1)(a)(b)(c) of the Explosives Act, ·1884. Sections 3, 4(a)(b), 5 and 6 of the Explosive Substances Act, 1908 and Section 4 of the Prevention of Damage to Public Property Act, 1984.
D. In addition to the general charge of conspiracy, he had also been charged under Section 3(3) TADA, under Section 5 C TADA for keeping one AK-56 rifle plus two empty magazines and committed an offence in respect of the same under Section 6 TADA, and under Section 3(4) TADA read with Section 212 IPC, for harbouring criminals.
3. After conclusion of the trial, the appellant (A-20) had been convicted under Section 5 TADA, and awarded the sentence as mentioned hereinabove. Hence, this appeal.
4. Shri Sunil Kumar, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant (A-20), has submitted that conviction of the appellant (A-20) under Section 5 TADA, was not warranted in view of the fact that the recovery had not been proved in accordance with law. The disclosure statement alleged to have F been made under the provision of Section 27 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872 (hereinafter called 'Evidence Act') has not been strictly followed. The said alleged disclosure statement did not bear the signature of the appellant (A-20). There were two panch witnesses, only one has been examined. The panch G witness examined in the case had been a stock witness in the police as he had appeared as a panch witness in other cases. He was the resident of an area in close vicinity of the office of the Crime Branch of the police department. The watchman of the Ghanshyam building from which the recovery had been H made, has not been examined. None of the neighbours of that
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @A:S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. S.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
6. We have considered the rival submissions made by learned counsel for the parties and perused the recerd.
'f'
7. Evidence against the appellant <A-20): (a)
Confessional statement of the appell,ant (A-20)
(b)
Confessional statement of Muradilbrahim,Kh~n{A• 130)
(c)
Deposition of Mohame·d Ayub Mohamed Umar (PW-72)
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
(d)
Deposition of Sahadev (PW-181)
(e)
Deposition of Nagesh Shivdas Lohar (PW-356)
(f)
Deposition of Shivaji Shankar Sawant (PW-524)
(g)
Recovery of AK-56 rifle and two magazines
Confessional statement of the appellant (A-20): 8. The confessional statement made by the appellant has not been relied upon by learned Special Judge. Therefore, we C are not making any reference to it and it has to be ignored. More so, we do not find any force in the submission made by Shri Sunil Kumar that there had been two FIR's in respect of the same incident as a large number of remand applications had been filed and it is evident from the application that at initial D stage it was shown as L.A.C. 23/93, but a correction had been made though without initials by the person who made the correction, but in his subsequent application it had been shown as L.A.C. 22/93. More so, the FIR number connecting this case is the same. Only one FIR had been exhibited in the court as E Exhibit 1284-A dated 18.4.1993 and it contains case no. L.A.C. 23/93. Therefore, we do not think that the submission requires further consideration. )
Confessional statement of Murad Ibrahim Khan (A-130):
9. He had disclosed that he was fully acquainted with Yakub Veda and the appellant (A-20). Thus, he was having acquaintance with hardened criminals.
Deposition of Mohamed Ayub Mohamed Umar CPW-72)
Ji
1O. He is a pan ch witness and a hawker, selling fruits on the footpath near Crawford Market. He deposed that on 17.4.1993 at about 12.45 hours, he was called to the police station by a Hawaldar and there Constable, Shivaji Sawant, P.1. asked him whether he would like to act as a panch witness in
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J;}
a case related to the Bombay Blast. He consented for the same and one more panch witness was also present in the said room. In his presence, accused (A-20) disclosed his name as Salim Khan and he said in Hindi that he was in possession of one AK-56 rifle and two magazines in his workshop the recovery of which he would get effected. The witness further corroborated the entire version of the recovery The witness further deposed thaflhe police party alongwith the accused (A-20) and the panch witnesses proceeded in the police vehicle and towards the place disclosed by the appellant (A-20) and entered the building pointed out by the appellant (A20). The said workshop had a loft and one staircase. One police officer went on the loft. Thereafter, all other persons followed him. On the directions of the appellant, cartons, scrap material and gunny bag were found. The said gunny bag was turned out for emptying the same. One AK-56 rifle and two magazines were taken out of the said gunny bag. The AK-56 rifle and magazines were SE;!parately wrapped in brown paper and three packets were prepared and sealed separately. The packets were signed by him, co-panchas and St:lri Sawant.
C
In cross-examination, the witness (PW.72) said that label put up on the recovered goods had his slgnature and the goods had been seized. He further denied the suggestion __ made by the. defence that he was the regular panch witness for the police:How_ever, he had admitted that occasionally, he had worked as such and he had been a panch witness in other cases.
Deposition of Shivaji Shankar Sawant, P.I. (PW-524)
11. He deposed that on 17.4.1993, he was interrogating the appellant (A-20) who was arrested in C.R. No. 71/93 alongwith some other police officials. During the said interrogation, the appellant (A-20) consented to make the voluntary statement and in the presence of the panch witnesses
G-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2013] 16 S.C.R.
and other police officials, the appellant (A-20) made a disclosure statement in Hindi. He recorded the same in the panchanama. The panchnama was read over to the appellant (A-20) and the panch witnesses. It was signed by the panch witnesses and countersigned by him (A-20). He disclosed that B the appellant (A-20) had consented to show the place and take out AK-56 rifle and two empty magazines kept by the appellant (A-20). He further deposed that panchnama of the recovery from the workshop of the appellant (A-20) was correct. The same C bears his signature and the signatures of panch witnesses and it was ii;ompleted on 18.4.1993. He was a Police Inspector and working as a Dy. S.P. for Protection of Civil Rights, Unit Bombay. He clarified the D correction regarding L.A.C.Nos. 22/93 and 23/93 and explained that there was a correction on the L.A.C. numbers. However. he had admitted that he had made that correction while registering the said case though it did not bear his initials and he was not in a position to give any reason for not putting E his initials and correction was necessary as there had been some typographical error. He further stated that he arrested the accused formally in L.A.C. No. 23/93 at 1.25 a.m. on 18.4.1993.
In paras 65 and 66, he deposed that he did not register any L.A.C. No. 22/93 and also did not know the name of officer who had registered L.A.C. 22/93. Deposition of Sahadev CPW-181 ):
12. He deposed that on 14.5.1993, he received requisition from Worli Police station for recording the confessional statement of the appellant A-20 and he had proved the said confessional statement. Deposition of Nagesh Shivdas Lohar CPW-356)
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @AS. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
13. He has deposed that on 17.4.1993, he alongwith Shivaji Sawant and one Head Constable interrogating the appellant (A-20) in case No.C.R. 71/93. He corroborated that Shri Sawant had asked the appellant (A-20) whether he wanted to make the voluntary statement. Thereafter, appellant made the statement in Hindi. He recorded the statement of the appellant in Hindi in the panchnama which was ma~ked as Exh. 378 and is the same panchanama recorded by him about the statement of appellant (A-20) between 1.7th and 18th April, 1993. 14. The recovery of the AK-56 rifle and two magazines had been made on 17th/18th April, 1993 and in respect of the same panchanama Exh. 383 makes it clear that Farid Alam Rais Alam Qureshi and Mohamad Ayub Mohamad Umar had been the panch witnesses and in their presence the appellant (A-20) voluntarily made a disclosure statement that the AK-56 rifle was kept in his workshop. This panchnama was concluded at 23.10 hours on 17.4.1993. The panchnama has been signed by both the witnesses as well as by the Inspector of Police, Shri S.S. Sawant. However, it does not bear the signature of the · appellant (A-20). It further shows that in continuation of the same, the search was conducted and it reveals that after making the disclosure statement, the police had taken the accused alongwith the panch witnesses to a closed workshop named as 'Bon~ Parte' industry belonging to him. The said workshop was having its shutter down and locked and in absence of the key the police forced open the lock and opened the same. The panchas alorigwith _the accused (A-20) and the police party entered theworkshop and found that there was no electricity however, they found that the loft measured approximately 16' x 40'. had a loft with a staircase. The appellant (A-20) .led all of them to the loft by staircase. On reaching there the appellant (A-20) took out a box and scrap was removed. One AK-56 rifle and empty magazines were found wrapped in gunny sack. The police examined the said material and prepared the recovery memo. The recovery memo contained one AK-56 assault rifle of folding type butt, in rusted
C
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
A condition but had been greased and two magazines of AK-56 assault rifle with no identification marks and numbers and it was in rusted condition and greased. 15. The Designated Court after appreciating the evidence 8 on record came to the conclusion as under:
c
•D
"A-20 having not explained the reason of his knowledge of such a contraband articles being kept in a said factory of which he was partner the same will lead only to the inference of himself having kept the same. The same is obvious as A-20 could have knowledge about the same in three contingencies i.e. a) he had kept the contrabands himself b) having seen somebody keeping the same there c) somebody had told him that the 'same being kept at the said place or having seen himself of such articles being kept at that place. In view of failure of A-20 to give any explanation regarding his knowledge being due to the reasons as stated in the aforesaid cl.auses b) and c) the same will lead to the conclusion as stated aforesaid. With regard to matter stated in clause c) aforesaid it can be additionally added that since the accused was also partner of the said shop· allowing the remaining of such articles at the said place would also attract the liability for the same .... ] The same is the case regarding the submission advanced on the basis of A-20 at the time of reco'very not having the key of the relevant gala. In light of the aforesaid discussion it is difficult to accept the submission canvassed that the evidence only establish the knowledge of A-20 of the contraband material lying at the said place and the same does not amount to himself being in conscious possession of the same. Needless to add that the inferences flowing from the statement made by A-20 consciously are not of a nature of denoting himself not being in conscious
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. S.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
possession of contraband articles within the notified area .... " 16. We have appreciated the evidence on record and the case depends upon the veracity of evidence regarding recovery. There is sufficient material to show that the recovery had been made at the behest of the appellant (A-20) from the factory owned by a partnership to which he was the partner alongwith one Surjit Singh. In such a fact-situation, he ought to have explained the reason/source of his knowledge of such contraband articles being kept in his factory. 17. In the instant case, as he has not mentioned that he had seen someone.keeping the articles there, or somepody had told him about that, or he had seen the things lying there, the only reasonable inference is drawn that he hi,mself had kept the same at that place. Being a partner of the firm if he wa~ having the knowledge that some contraband were lying in his premises, he ought to have informed the police if he had no guilty mind. 18. So far as the explanation that at the time of recovery he did not have the key, would not be enough to tilt the balance in his favour. The fact that he did not have the key becomes totally redundant, as no conclusion can be drawn that the appellant (A-20) was not in possession of the said premises, and in such a fact-situation, it cannot be held that the appellant (A-20) was not in conscious possession of the contraband material.
C
19. We do not find any force in the submissions made by G Shri Sunil Kumar, learned senior counsel appearing for the · appellant (A-20), that the panch witness was the resfclent of Sitaram building, which was opposite to the office of the Commissioner of Police, or in a very close proximity of the . . same, and was working on the footpath nearby the said building,
J;
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
and he had acted earlier as a panch witness in test identification parade.
20. The police when searching for a panch witness, need not go to far off place of the police station as the panchnama is required to be recorded in a close proximity of time, when the accused apprehending his disclosure statement. Therefore, on such material suspicion about the credential of the police or panch witnesses cannot be doubted, unless there is some material to prove the contrary. Had it been picked up from a far off place, criticism could have been otherwise as to why the C panch witness could not be called from neighbourhood. 21. The panch witness Mohamed Ayub Mohamed Umar (PW-72) could not be held to be a tutored witness or acting at the behest ~f the prosecution only on the ground that he had D also been the witness in another case. It does not give a reason to draw inference that he was a stock panch witness unless it is shown that he had acted in such capacity in a very large number of cases.
22. More so, it cannot be held that. Mohamed Ayub Mohamed Umar (PW-72) was not an independent witness, or acting under the pressure of the police as he was carrying the. business illegally without any license. More so,_ the appeUant-(A20) had made the disclosure statement in his pr~sence, he could explain the same. Therefore, it could not be held that he F was deposing falsely. 23. We do not see any reason as to why his evidence should not be relied upon. Minor omissions/contradictions regarding labeling and sealing are not really the contradictions G which go to the root of the matter. Non-examination of the watchman of Ghanshyam Industrial Estate, or omission of factor regarding electricity being not mentioned in the panchnama, or . non-collection of broken lock, are the .omissions of trivial nature, and do not warrant any undue importance for doubting the H evidence of recovery.
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. S.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
24. Law does not require the witness to corroborate the evidence of an independent witness. Thus, the evidence of Mohamed Ayub Mohamed Umar (PW-72) duly corroborated by the contemporaneous panchnama is trustworthy.
25. As the appellant (A-20) made a statement leading to B the discovery of AK-56 assault rifle and two· magazines having kept in his workshop and the same had been found concealed on the loft, he cannot escape from the liability of possessing and concealing of the same, thus liable to be punished under· Section 5 TADA. We see no reason to interfere with the C conclusion drawn by the learned Designated Court. The appeal is accordingly dismissed. CRIMINAL APPEAL N0.912 OF 2007 Aziz Ahmed Md. Ahmed Shaikh ... Appellant
Versus State of Maharashtra
... Respondent
26. This appeal has been preferred against the judgments and orders dated 11.10.2006 and 31.5.2007, passed by Special Judge of the Designated Court under the TADA for Bombay Blast, Greater Bombay, in the Bombay Blast Case No. 1/93, by which the appellant had been found guilty under Section 5 TADA and on that count, he was sentenced to suffer RI for 5 years, and ordered to pay a fine of Rs.25,000/-, and in default of payment of fine, to suffer further RI for 6 months. He (A-21) was further convicted under Sections 3 and 7 read with Section 25(1-A)(1-B)(a) of the Arms Act, but no separate sentence was awarded for the same.
27. Facts and circumstances giving rise to this appeal are that: A. In addition to the first charge of general conspiracy, he was charged for attending conspiratorial meetings at Dubai
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
A where criminal conspiracy was discussed for distributing arms and ammunition to co-conspirators and for providing funds to them. Thus, he (A-21 )·was charged under Sections 3(3) and (4) TADA. Further, he (A-21) was charged with unauthorisedly being in possession of one U.S. Carbine Q.300 with three B magazines and 28 cartridges in the notified area under TADA, between January 1993 and 5th April, 1993, and thus, charged under Sections 5 and 6 TADA, and further under the provisions of Sections 3 and 7 read with Sections 25(-A), 25(1-B)(a) of the Arms Act.
c
B, After the trial, the appellant (A-21) stood acquitted of all the charges except charges under Section 5 TADA and under the Arms Act. Hence, this appeal.
28. Shri Mushtaq Ahmad, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has submitted that the appellant had wrongly been involved in the offence and convicted, though there is no sufficient evidence on record, to involve the appellant in the E crime. The evidence particularly the confessional statement of the appellant and the depositions of other witnesses particularly, Bhaskar Babu Rao Jadhav (PW-57), Dayandeo Sonaji Geete (PW-320), Vijay Meru (PW-561 ), and Shivajirao Kondiram Babar (PW-683) etc. are not worth reliance. The confessional F statement of the appellant cannot be rel)ed upon, as it was not made voluntarily and truthfully. The appeal deserves to be allowed. 29. Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the State has submitted that the appellant was a close G associate of Tiger Memon (AA). He was fully involved in the entire episode including the conspiracy. He has wrongly been acquitted for the said charge. Thus, no interference is called for. The appeal is liable to be dismissed.
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
30. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
31. Evidence against the appellant CA-21): (a)
Confessional statement of the appellant (A-21)
(b)
Deposition of Bhaskar Babu Rao Jadhav (PW-57)
(c)
Deposition of Dayandeo Sonaji Geete (PW-320)
(d)
Deposition of Vijay Meru (PW-561)
(e)
Deposition of Shivajirao Kondiram Babar (PW-683)
c
Confessional Statement of appellant CA-21 ): 32. His (A-21) confessional statement had been recorded, however, the same had been discarded by the Designated Court, thus it cannot be considered. The evidence against the appellant (A-21) remains the recovery of the aforesaid arms and ammunition. In fact, an FIR had been registered on 5.4.1993 at 6.10 p.m. that the appellant (A-21) was found hi possession of a Carbine of 30 Caliber of U.S. make, three magazines and 28 cartridges without holding a fire arms license. It was further revealed that on. that day, the police got information that the appellant (A-21) who was a resident of Pydhonie, Mumbai was scheduled to come near a mosque opposite Pydhonie Police Station to acquire arms and ammunition of foreign make. On that information the trap was arranged near the Pydhonie Police Station. At about 1.30 p.m. the trap party received the pre-decided signal, on which the appellant (A-21) was searched, however he was not carrying any arms and ammunition with him. He was brought to the DCB, CID office and during interrogation he expressed his willingness to make a voluntary statement. Therefore, two panchas were called from the nearby area and in their presence, the appellant (A-21) disclosed that he had acquired two Carbines of foreign make and some arms and ammunition from one Mujahidan and
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
A one of the said Carbine had been concealed at Naryalwadi, Mazgaon. The appellant (A-21) led the police party and Panchas to Naryalwadi Muslim Cemetery (Kabaristan), Mazgaon and from the said graveyard he took out one gunny bag duly tied with a rope. It had been concealed in thickly grown B trees and shrubs. On being examined, one single barrel Carbine, 28 cartridges and 3 magazines were found. Panchnamas have made for his disclosure statement as well as for recovery of the said articles. C Deposition of Bhaskar Babu Rao Jadhav (PW-57):
33. He is a panch witness. He supported the case of the prosecution and proved the disclosure statement of the appellant (A-21) as well as the recovery made at his behest. D He gave a full description of how the appellant (A-21) made the disclosure statement and how the recoveries were made. It corroborates the version given in the FIR. However, in his cross-examination, he (PW-57) stated that he (PW-57) had prepared the notes for deposing in the court. He had giv~n full E details of the incident of 5.4.1993. In cross-examination he had admitted that he had also acted as a panch witness in 3 more cases. Deposition of Dayandeo Sonaji Geete (PW-320):
34. His deposition revealed that he had accompanied the appellant (A-21) at the time of recovery alongwith others. He admitted in his cross-examination that he himself had not made any entry in the Station Diary regarding the information received by Senior P.I. Shri Kumbhar about the appellant (A-21 ). He has G further deposed that he could not remember the manner in which the panch witness arrived in the office. The said panch was brought by the police havaldar. The appellant (A-21) had been detained in the office of DCB, CID under suspicion due to the receipt of information that he was to be at Pydhonie for H acquiring arms. He also deposed that the office of the Bombay
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
Municipal Corporation was inside the Naryalwadi Kabristan from where the recovery had been made at the instance of the appellant (A-21 ). He further proved the recovery and denied the suggestions that the appellant (A-21) did not make any disclosure statement nor any recovery had been made at his behest. He has also identified appellant (A-21) in the court. 35. The deposition of Dayandeo Sonaji Geete (PW-320) has been fully corroborated by another police official Vijay Meru (PW-561) in all respects. However, he has admitted that he had not made any entry in the Station Diary regarding the information received by Senior P.I. Shri Kumbhar, nor he was aware how the panch witness arrived and who was the police havaldar who brought the panch witnesses. However, he (PW-561) deposed that he had detained the appellant (A-21) on information that he was to be at Pydhonie for acquiring arms. Appellant (A-21) came there at about 1.30 p.m. and on getting the signal, the police party pounced upon him and apprehended him. Appellant (A-21) was searched but he was not carrying any weapon, however, one Ceiko watch, his driving licence, labour card bearing his photograph of Arab Emirates and some Dirharns and a silver ring were found with him. The inventory ·of the said articles was prepared and they were seized. The currency in Dirhams was of the value of Rs. 13 to 14 thousand Indian rupees. He was interrogated by A.C.P. Shri Babar (PW683) and Senior P.I. Shri Kumbhar. It was during his interrogation that appellant (A-21) expressed his desire to make the voluntary statement regarding fire arms. Thus, two panches were called. The suspect was introduced to the panches. The memorandum panchnama was prepared in respect of his disclosure statement. It was signed by panch witnesses and, thus, he supported the recovery of the articles as narrated by the other witnesses. He had proved the complaint as well as the proforma FIR on the basis of the said complaint. PW.561 registered the said offence as LAC No. 18 of 1993 against the appellant (A-21) for the offences punishable under Sections 3 and 7 read with Section 25 of the Arms Act. Though he was
C
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2013] 16 S.C.R.
competent to answer as to whether the panch witnesses had been stock witnesses or whether there was any discrepancy in drawing the memorandum panchnama but defence did not ask any question during his cross-examination. He (PW-561) identified the appellant (A-21) on 24.4.1998 in the court and B he has denied the suggestion made by the defence that the appellant (A-21) had not made any disclosure statement, nor the recovery of arms had been made on his disclosure statement.
c
Deposition of Shivajirao Kondiram Babar, ACP (PW-683):
36. In his deposition, he revealed that he had received the information about appellant (A-21) that he would get the weapons near a mosque opposite police station Pydhonie. He had received the information from a secret source on telephone, D he recorded the same and passed on the same to the senior officers. He deposed that on 5.4.1993 while he was in his office at Crawford Market, he had received the information from his source on telephone to the effect that appellant (A-21) involved in Bombay blast case was in possession of fire arms and would E be available at Pydhonie. Immediately thereafter, he formed a team of police officers and staff and went to the Pydhonie and arrested the appellant (A-21), brought him to the office of DCB, CID at Crawford Market and he (A-21) was interrogated. This witness further supported the prosecution case that he made F a desire to make confession voluntarily etc. etc. 37. The recovered material was sent for FSL, and the report Ext. 1940-A was received. According to which US Carbine gun and 28 cartridges sent for FSL were examined. The carbine gun was found in working condition, and it was G capable of chambering and firing the cartridges recovered in that offence. So, the report was positive. 38. The appellant (A-21) made a complaint before the Designated Court, and the court directed his med.ical
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
examination. He was examined and again sent on policl'! remand.
39. After appreciating the entire evidence, the learned Designated Court came to the conclusion as under:
"Since criminal conspiracies are hatched in secrecy and it is extremely difficult to collect the direct evidence about the same the established principles of law indicate that the standard of a proof requiring such type of cases is loosened, unnecessary hard standards regarding the identity of a particular person can't be expected.. ... Thus, considering in proper perspective all the said evidence, no other conclusion will emerge of A-21 having committed all the offences for which he is charged with on the account of commission of overt acts, but the same will lead any prudent man to the legitimate conclusion of A-21 having committed the aforesaid acts for the purposes of furthering the object of conspiracy." 40. In view of above, the Designated Court found him guilty and imposed the punishment as referred to hereinabove. We find no reason to interfere with the directions of the Designated Court. The appeal is accordingly dismissed.
C
i
E!
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1030 OF 2012 State of Maharashtra Through CBI
... Appellant
Versus Ahmad Shah Khan @ Salim Durani & Anr
. . . Respondents
41. This appeal has been preferred against the judgments and orders dated 11.10.2006 and 31.5.2007, passed by the Special Judge of Designated Court under the TADA, in the Bombay Blast C~se No.1 of 1993, by which the respondents
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2013] 16 S.C.R.
(A-20 and A-21) had been convicted under Section 3(3) TADA, and acquitted of the main charge of conspiracy. 42. Facts and circumstances giving rise to this appeal are · that:
A. In addition to the main charge of general conspiracy,
the respondents were additionally charged under Section 3(3) TADA for facilitating the commission of terrorist activities etc., as they had agreed to send persons for receiving training in arms, ammunition and explosives and making arrangements C by harbouring and concealing their conspirators/terrorists for consideration of money from Tiger Memon (AA). They had further been charged with receiving and keeping in possession of one AK-56 rifle and two empty magazines with intel')tion to use and commit terrorist acts. Further, under Section 5 TADA, D for possessing the said AK-56 rifle; under Section 6 of TADA, in respect of the same AK-56 rifle; and lastly, for harbouring and concealing co-accused Javed Chikna, Yakoob Yeda and others terrorists/co-conspirators at Tonk, Rajasthan after the Bombay blast on 12th March, 1993.
B. Both the respondents (A-20 and A-21) had been found guilty for the offence punishable under Section 5 TADA, and awarded the punishment of five years, and ordered to pay ~ fine of Rs.25,000/- and, in default of payment of fine, to suffer F further R.I. for six months. But acquitted for the charge of conspiracy. Hence, this appeal. 43. Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing G for the appellant, has submitted that in spite of the ample evidence against the said respondents (A-20 and A-21) in view of their involvement in conspiracy, the court below committed the grave error in discarding the same. The evidence requires total re-appreciation and the confessional statements of the H respondents (A-20 and A-21) and other co-accused have to be
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
taken into consideration. Therefore, the appeal deserves to be allowed. 44. On the other hand, Shri M11c;htaq Ahmad, learned counsel appearing for the respondents (A-20 and A-21), has submitted that their confessional statements have rightly been discarded as the same had been recorded in utter disregard to the statutory provisions. The appeal lacks meritand is liable to be dismissed. 45. We have considered rival submissions made by the counsel for the parties and perused the records. 46. The confessional statements of Ahmad Shah Khan @ ~alim Durani (A-20), Shaikh Aziz Ahmed (A 721), Moiddin l}bdul Kadar Cheruvattam (A-48) and Ismail Abbas Patel (A80) had been relied upon by the prosecution. The same stood discarded completely by the learned Special Judge 'on the ground that all the confessional statements had been recorded by the Police officer in utter disregard to the mandatory provisions of Section 15 TADA and Rule 15 of TADA Rules, 1987. The police officer failed to inform the said accused persons while recording their respective statements that they were not bound to make confessional statement and further failed to warn that, in case, they made statements, the same would be used as evidence against them. More so, the required certificate was not attached to the said statements.
C
o
47. This Court has laid down parameters for interference against the order of acquittal time and again. The appellate court should not ordinarily set aside a judgment of acquittal in a case where two views are possible, though the view of the appellate court may be the more probable one. While dealing G with a judgment of acquittal, the appellate court has to consider · the entire evidence on record, so as to arrive at a finding as to whether the views of the trial court were perverse or otherwise unsustainable. The appellate court is entitled to consider whether in arriving at a finding of fact, the trial court had failed H
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
to take into consideration admissible evidence and/or had taken into consideration the evidence brought on record contrary to law. Similarly, wrong placing of burden of proof may also be a subject-matter of scrutiny by the appellate court. In exceptional cases where there are compelling circumstances, and the judgment under appeal is found to be perverse, the appellate court can interfere with the order of acquittal. The appellate court should bear in mind the presumption of innocence of the accused and further that the trial court's acquittal bolsters the presumption of his innocence. Interference in a routine manner where the other view is possible should be avoided, unless there are good reasons for interference. The findings of fact recorded by a court can be held to be perverse if the findings have been arrived at by ignoring or excluding relevant material or by taking into consideration irrelevant/ inadmissible material. The finding may also be. said to be perverse if it is "against the weight of evidence", or if the finding so outrageously defies logic as to suffer from the vice of irr atonality. 48. In view of the fact that no legal evidence which could be relied upon by the prosecution is available on record, we do not find any fault with the impugned judgment and order. The appeal lacks merit and is liable to be dismissed. More so, the respondents (A-20 and A-21) have filed appeals, as referred to hereinabove, and they have served 4 years of sentence and deposited the fine. The appeal stands dismissed. CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1311 OF 2007
Yusuf Khan @ Kayum Kasam Khan .. Appellant Versus State of Maharashtra (through CBI, STF) ... Respondent
AND
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.)
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 417 OF 2011 State of Maharashtra
... Appellant
Versus Yousaf Khan Kasam
. . . Respondent
Criminal Appeal No. 1311 of 2007 49. This appeal has been preferred against the judgments and orders dated 11.10.2006 and 31.5.2007, passed by the learned Special Judge of the Designated Court under the C TADA, in the Bombay Blast Case No.1 /93. The appellant (A31) was charged with general charge of conspiracy, and in addition thereto, he was further charged for participating in landing and transportation of the arms, ammunition and explosives smuggled into India by the conspirators and co- D accused at Shekhadi and further for transporting the RDX explosives in his motor tempo No. MCU 4409, which was part of-the said consignment and unloaded the same in the godown of co-accused Liyakat Ali Habib Khan (A-85) at MIDC, Thane. The appellant (A-31) was convicted under Section 3(3) TADA, E and sentenced for 5 years rigorous imprisonment, alongwith a fine of Rs. 25,000/-, and in default of payment of fine, to suffer further RI for 6 months. Hence, this appeal. 50. Ms. Farhana Shah, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant, has submitted that the appellant (A-31) has been wrongly convicted for the offences under TADA and the Arms Act. The confessional statements of the co-accused could not be relied upon for the reason as it has been obtained by coercion and it could not be held to be useful and truthful and, therefore, no worth reliance. The panch witnesses could not be relied upon as they were not the natural witnesses i.e. resident of the said area. Thus, appeal deserves to be allowed.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
51. Per contra, Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the State, has opposed.the appeal contending that the stand fully established by the evidence on record, particularly, because of the confessional statements of appellant (A-31), A-64, A-128 and further stand corroborated by the evidence of PW-2, PW-62 and PW-604. Thus, no interference is called for. 52 . We have considered the rival submissions made by learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
C
53. Evidence against the appellant (A-31) :
(a)
Confessional statement of Nasir Abdul Kader Kewal (A-64)
(b)
Confessional statement of Shahnawaz Khan (A128)
(c)
Deposition of Usman Jan Khan (PW-2)
(d)
Deposition of Padmakar Krishna Bhonsle (PW-62)
(e)
Deposition of AJit Surve (PW-604)
Confessional statement of Nasir Abdul Kader Kewal CA-
64):
54. In his confessional statement, he (A-64) has revealed that he had been associated in smuggling activities and had been participating in landing and transportation alongwith coaccused. He had earlier worked in Saudi Arabia and after coming back settled in Bombay. His father-in-law Gulam Dastgir used to run the business of Matka at Sandra and thus, he (A-64) also joined the said business. Subsequently, he came in association of the smugglers and started helping them in landing and transportation. He participated in landing and transportation from Shekhadi on 7.2.1993 and said that the associates of Tiger Memon (AA) were present including
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
appellant (A-31). At the instance of Tiger Memon, the bags of A arms ?and explosives brought from the trawler were loaded in a tempo driven by appellant (A-31). Confessional statement of Shahnawaz Khan CA-128): 55. Confessional statement of Shahnawaz Khan (A-128) 8 revealed that he participated in landing on 7.2.1993. He (A-128) alongwith co-accused brought the smuggled goods at Seashore and they found that two tempos were already parked there. One tempo was being driven by appellant (A-31). The smuggled goods were being loaded in both the tempos. Tiger C Memon (AA), Javed Chikna (AA) and Yeda Yakoob (AA) opened the sacks. The accused (A-128) saw that it contained rifles, hand-grenades and bags containing black coloured powder in it. Bullets were also there. Subsequently, those tempos were unloaded at a building with a tower. The goods D were reloaded in the cavity of Commander jeeps. The said . vehicles (Jeeps) left for Bombay. One tempo though empty followed the jeep. 56. Usman Jan Khan (PW-2) identified the appellant (A31) in.the court. Usman Jan Khan (PW-2) deposed that appellant (A-31) participated in transportation of smuggled articles. He deposed that on the relevant date they came. out of the hotel I after having the meal and noticed that Javed Chikna (AA) and Yeda Yakoob (AA), were standing near the white coloured tempo which was being driven by appellant (A-31). Tiger Memon(AA) told Usman Jan Khan (PW-2) to take a seat in the said tempo with the appellant (A-31 ). He (PW-2) sat in the tempo and they followed Tiger Memon (AA) and reached Shekhadi Coast at 9 p.m. The $muggled goods had already arrived at the Coast. The same' were wrapped in gunny bags. On the instruction of Tiger Memon (AA), the goods were loaded in the two tempos, one of them was being driven by appellant (A-31). The goods were brought by the said tempo to Wangni Tower and were unloaded there. It was at Wangni Tower that the goods were opened and the witness could see AK-56 rifles,
C
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
its rounds, handgrenades, pistols, magazines and ROX. They were reloaded in the cavity of the jeeps parked there. 57. Padmakar Krishna Bhonsle (PW-62) is the panch witness of the recovery of the vehicle and identified the vehicle recovered by Police Inspector, Anil Prabhakar Mahabole (PW506). It was recovered at the disclosure statement of the appellant (A-31). 58. Ajit Shivram Surve (PW-604), the Police Officer attached with DCB, CID who had been sent to get the samples prepared on 30.11.1993 by P.I. Shri Pharande, and.he corroborated the incident of collection of samples as described by Asit Binod Ghorai (PW-602). He also named 3 persons who collected the samples as Kulkarni, Malve and Surve. He (PW604) further deposed that he prepared the panchnama which was duly signed by the panch witnesses. 59. One application under Section .457 of Code of Criminal Procedure,. 1973 was filed by the appellant (A·31) before the Designated Court for release of the tempo and the same was allowed. However, the court passed the order that the vehicle should be thoroughly examined by experts as to whether it contained any traces of the ROX. It was in view ?thereof, 3 experts took samples on 30.11.1993 and the report dated 12.1.1994 detected traces of ROX. This was corroborated by panch witness, Asit Binod Ghorai (PW-602). 60. After conclusion of the trial, the learned Special Judge came to the conclusion that considering the confessions of the co-accused, Nasir (A-64) and Shahnawaz (A-128), as well as the statement made by Usman (PW-2) there can be no conclusion other than the fact that the appellant (A-31) was involved in the Shekhadi landing and the transportation operation. 61. After going through the evidence on record i.e. the
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. S.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
confession of the co-accused (A-64 and A-128) as well as the deposition of the various prosecution witnesses, we find no merit in this appeal. Therefore, it is accordingly, dismissed.
Criminal Appeal No. 417 of 2011 62. This appeal has been preferred against the judgment B and order dated 2.8.2007 passed by Special Judge of the Designated Court under the TADA for Bombay Blast Case No.1 of 1993. The charge against the respondent (A-31) had been· framed mainly for conspiracy. He was further charged with abetting and knowingly facilitating the commission of terrorist C activities during the period of December, 1992 to April, 1993 by involving himself in landing and transportation of arms, ammunition and explosives smuggled into India by his coconspirators and the role played by the respondent (A-31) had been, transporting the said explosives landed at Shekhadi by D his motor tempo No. MCU 4409 from Alibagh to Thane, which was unloaded in the godown of co-accused Liyakat Khan at MIDC. 63. After the trial, the said respondent (A-31) had been convide.P for the main charge under Section 3(3) TADA for transportation of the said explosives and awarded punishment of five years with a fine of Rs.25,000/- but has been acquitted of the charge of conspiracy. Hence, this appeal.
64. Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant has submitted that in addition to the general charge of conspiracy, the respondent (A-31) had been charged for assisting Tiger Memon (AA) and his associates in smuggling G of arms, ammunition, handgrenades and explosives and its landing and transportation from Shekhadi on 7.2.1993. The respondent was present at the instance of Tiger Memon and had transported the said contraband in his vehicle. Therefore, as the resporident had been aware of the nature of the H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
contraband, he cannot escape the liability of charge of conspiracy. Thus, the appeal deserves to be allowed. 65. Mr. Mushtaq Ahmad, learned counsel appearing for the respondent (A-31) has submitted that he is merely a transporter and not an associate of Tiger Memon, so he could not be involved in the charge of conspiracy. Thus, the appeal is liable to be 'dismissed.
66. We have considered the rival submissions made by the learned counsel for the parties and perused the evidence C on record. 67. The learned Special Judge dealt with the issue and came to the conclusion that 'in spite of the fact that the respondent (A-31) transported the contraband in his tempo and D took the same to a far distance but there was nothing on record to show that he had knowl~dge of the kinds of goods transported in his tempo. 68. The parameters laid down by this court in entertaining E the appeal against the order of acquittal have to be applied. 69. From the evidence on recor9, it becomes clear that Yusuf Khan Kasam (A-31) had participated in landing operation of contraband goods at Shekhadi as he was one of the persons who accompanied Tiger Memon and others and he had also F bE~en to Wangni Tower alongwith other associates and contraband material were loaded in tempo. The tempo was taken by him alongwith absconding accused to Mumbra as instructed by Tiger Memon (AA). This version is duly supported/ corroborated by Shah Nawaz Khan (A-128) (Ex. 1569-A) and G by the evidence of Usman (PW-2). However, there is nothing on record to show that he was aware as of what kinds of contraband were being transported in his tempo. 70. We are of the considered opinion that no further interference is required and appeal lacks merit and is, H accordingly, dismissed.
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1610 OF 2011
Uttam Shantaram Potdar ... Appellant Versus State of Maharashtra
. . . Respondent
AND CRIMINAL APPEAL N0.398 OF 2011 State of Maharashtra
... Appellant
c
Versus Uttam Shanta ram Potdar ... Respondent 71. Criminal Appeal No.1610 of 2011 has been preferred against the judgment and order dated 23.5.2007 passed by Special Judge of the Designated Court under the TADA, for Bombay Blast, Greater Bombay, in the Bombay Blast Case No. 1/1993, by which the appellant has been convicted under Sections 3(3) and 6 TADA.
72. Criminal Appeal No.398 of 2011 has been filed by the State against the order dated 2.8.2007 by which A-30 stood acquitted of the first charge of larger conspiracy. 73. Fact and circumstances giving rise to these appeals are that: A. In addition to the main charge of conspiracy, the appellant (A-30) was charged for overt acts by abetting and knowingly and intentionally facilitating the smuggling the landing of arms, ammunition, hand grenades and explosives in India at Dighi, Mhasla, District Raigad on 9.1.1993. This was done by providing his truck No. MH-06-5533 and mobilizing men, material and resources in connivance with the customs officers and police officials by bribing them and facilitating the safe
f7..
C
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
movements of arms, ammunition and explosives by piloting the motor truck, thus the offences punishable under Section 3(3) TADA and under Section 6 TADA have been committed. B. Further, the provisions of the Arms Act, the Arms Rules, the Explosive Act, 1884, Explosive Substance Act, 1908 and the Explosive Rules, have also been contravened, by facilitating the smuggling, landing and transportation of arms etc. C. After the conclusion of the trial, appellant (A-30) was acquitted of the umbrella charge of conspiracy including of the charge under Section 1208 IPC etc. However, he was convicted for charges under Sections 3(3) and 6 TADA. He has been awarded a sentence tO undergo R.I. for 10 years alongwith a fine of Rs.50,000/- and in default of payment of fine, to further suffer RI for one year under Section 3(3), and to undergo 14 years R.I. alongwith a fine of rupees one lakh and in default of payment of fine, to further suffer RI for three years under Section 6. TADA. 74. It is pertinent to mention that the appellant (A-30) has already served 14 years imprisonment, and has also deposited the fine. However, the appeal has been preferred by him only to get an acquittal, so as to remove the stigma attached to being convicted for offences as mentioned hereinabove. The State has also filed appeal against his acquittal of the first charge of conspiracy. 75. Shri C.U. Singh, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has submitted that the appellant has wrongly been enroped in the crime. The evidence on record falls short to prove the charges against him. The confessional statements are not admissible as had not been recorded in accordance with law. Thus, the appeal deserves to be allowed, and the stigma of the appellant is to be removed. 76. Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the State has opposed the appeal contending that the
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
appellant was a close associate of Tiger Memon (AA) and his associates. He was involved not only in landing and transportation, but in the larger conspiracy. Thus, the State has filed appeal against the order of his acquittal on the charge of conspiracy. Therefore, the appeal filed by the appellant is liable to be dismissed, and appeal filed by the State deserves to be allowed.
77. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. 78. Evidence against the Appellant (A-30):
c
(a) Confessional statement Of appellant (A-30) (b)
Confessional statement of Janardhan Pandurang Gambas (A-81)
(c)
Confessional statement of Jaywant Keshav Gurav (A-82)
(d)
Confessional statement of Mohd. Sultan Sayyed (A90)
(e)
Confessional statement of S.S. Talwadekar (A-113)
(f)
Confessional statement of Mohd. Kasam Lajpuria @Mechanic Chacha (A-136)
(g)
Confessional statement of Jamir Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-133)
(h)
Confessional statement of Salim Kutta (A-134)
(i)
Confessional statement of Faki Ali Faki Ahmed (A74)
0)
Deposition of Dilip Pansare (PW-97)
(k)
Deposition of Vyankatesh Hirba (PW-588)
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (I)
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
Deposition of Dinesh Nakti (PW-95)
Confessional statement of appellant CA-30): 79. The evidence against the appellant (A-30) is his own confession made on 12th/15th of July, 1993. He has stated B throughout that he was a landing agent and involved in smuggling. However, he had no knowledge that arms were being smuggled and he participated in the same, taking it to be smuggling of silver only. The confessional statements of coacc;used do not speak of the knowledge of the appellant (AC 30) regarding the smuggling of arms and they too, have only deposed about smuggling of silver. In view of the discussion in Criminal Appeal no.1728 of 2007, the date of the recording of the confession has no 0 bearing so long as the accused are being tried for the same crime in the same trial. After the amendment, confessional statement of co-accused Jamir Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-133), Salim Kutta (A-134) and Mechanic Chacha (A-136) trad bE;!en recorded. Jamir Kadri (A-133) stated in his confession on the E basis of hearsay that his brother Shabbir had told him that arms would be smuggled into the city, and that the same was also within the knowledge of the appellant (A-30). His confessional statement was recorded by A.K. Chandgude, Deputy S.P (PW-670) wherein the appellant (AF 30) has stated that he was well acquainted with other smugglers like Mohd. Dossa (AA) and Mechanic Chacha (A136), and he had been acting as a landing agent in smuggling activities for these smugglers, for a long time. He (A-30) had also participated alongwith the other co-accused like Salim G Kutta (A-134) and Mechanic Chacha (A-136) in the smuggling of contraband and in providing landing and transportation facilities on 3.12.1992. On 4.12.1992, he was contacted by Assistant Collector H (Customs) R.K. Singh (A-102) through a Customs Sepoy. On
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @AS. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J]
reaching there at 8.00 pm, R .K. Singh, Assistant Collector, A Custom (A-102) called him in the cabin and asked about the landing that had been made on the previous day upon replying he was told to wait with Custom Inspector Gurav (A-82). He (A30) went to Mohd. Dossa on 5.12.1992 and explained to him , and to Mechanic Chacha (A-136), the entire incident. Mechanic B Chacha (A-136) gave him (A-30), some money to be paid to the Mhasla Custom Staff, the Shrivardhan Custom Staff, the Murud Custom Staff and also to R.K. Singh (A-102). On the same day he (A-30) handed over the money to some of them. Subsequently, it was revealed that the rates that were to C be paid to the police officers as well as the customs officers per landing were fixed, and were also revised from time to time, and the appellant (A-30) had been very much involved in making the payment. Therefore, it is clear that he (A-30) enjoyed a higher status in the hierarchy of the gang of smugglers, and that he had been assigned an important role of negotiating with customs officers and police officers, to remove any hindrance in the said smuggling. It is also clear that payments were made through E him {A-30). The appellant (A-30) confessed, that on 9.1.1993 he, alongwith co-accused Salim Kutta (A-134) and Mechanic Chacha (A-136) had participated in the landing of smuggled F goods a·nd when they were coming to Dighi Jetty, on the way he had also met Gurav (A-82), who was driving his jeep. Thereafter, their vehicles were intercepted by Patil (A-116) an Inspector, near Gondghar Phata. In order to negotiate a safe passage for the smuggled goods, Mechanic Chacha (A-136) offered him a sum of Rs.10 lakhs, and when they were asked G about the contents of the wooden boxes, Mechanic Chacha (A136) stated that the same contained watches. On the said day, they had no cash and, therefore, Mechanic Chacha (A-136) took out five silver bricks from the first truck and gave them to
C
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
Shri Patil, SI of Shrivardhan. The appellant (A-30) drove Gurav's jeep (A-82) and came to Kanghar. There they shifted 170 bricks in the cavities of two trucks from Bombay. After loading the smuggled goods in the truck, the appellant went to Shabbir's residence alongwith Salim Kutta (A-134), Feroz and the driver. They removed 80 bricks from the cavity of the first truck from Bombay, and placed them in this truck. The appellant (A-30) left a message at the residence of Patil (A-116), stating that he would come with money on the night of the 10th of the month. Thus, he (A-30) subsequently met the said S.I. and it was decided that he would pay a sum of Rs.5 lakhs to the Havaldars and Rs.2 lakhs to the SI separately, and the said amount was paid by the appellant (A-30). Further, in his confessional statement he has revealed that the truck bearing No. MH-06-5533 which was used on 9.1.1993 did not belong to him. One Dilip Hegiste was the registered owner of the said vehicle. Thus, it is clear that in his confessional statement, the appellant (A-30) does not say anything to the effect that he had no knowledge with respect to the smuggled arms.
Confessional statement of Janardhan Pandurang Gambas CA-81 ):
80. In his confessional statement he has revealed the presence of the appellant (A-30) and also has deposed about his (A-30) participation in the landing and transportation of the smuggled goods. However, the goods were silver and gold, and it was the appellant (A-30) who had taken the said witness for the landing. He has stated that in addition to the silver and gold and rods kept in the gunny bags, there were 30 black military coloured boxes which were unloaded from the trawler and Mechanic Chacha (A-136) cautioned the labourer to handle the same with care, as the goods were made of glass.
Confessional statement of Jaywant Keshav Gurav (A-82):
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
81. He was working in the Customs Department at Mahad, A and it was his job to prevent illegal smuggling along the sea coast and to nab the smugglers by gathering secret information against them, and further, to register cases against the smugglers. He (A-82) has stated that he had been helping smugglers by taking bribes and facilitating their landing and B also the transportation of the smuggled goods. He had a settlement with Rahim Laundriwala that he would be paid Rs.1,60,000/- for silver landing and that the witness would be informed of such landings in advance. The appellant (A-30) had· met him in June 1992 and told the witness that he was a landing agent working at Dighi Jetty and that he had informed him (A82) that there would be landing at Dighi Jetty of silver, by Mohd. Dossa. The smuggled goods would come from Dubai and he (A-82) would be paid Rs.65,000/- for the said landing and appellant (A-30) had paid him this money after passing the said smuggled goods. This witness has corroborated the confessional statement of the appellant (A-30).
c
In respect of the incident dated 3.12.1992, i.e. his meeting with R.K. Singh, Assistant Collector, Customs (A-102) where he had bargained for a higher amount, as R.K. Singh (A-102) had told him (A-82) that he must go to the appellant (A-30) and bring back a sum of Rs.2.5 lakhs. After discussing the same with the appellant, he (A-82) went to Bombay and here he was paid Rs.2.5 lakhs which was to be paid to R.K. Singh (A-102) and Rs.1.5 lakhs was to be paid to the Superintendent. He collected this money and paid the same to the said officers. In respect of the incident dated 9.1.1993 the witness revealed that he had been informed by R.K. Singh (A-102) that on the said day, Mohd. Dossa would smuggle the goods and that the landing would take place at Dighi Jetty and that he (A82) must assist him. On that day, the appellant met this witness and informed him regarding the landing that would take place at the night at Dighi Jetty and has thus corroborated the confessional statement of the appellant (A-30)to the extent that
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
they had in fact met in the said manner and that it was the appellant (A-30) who had negotiated with Patil (A-116). It has further been revealed that the appellant (A-30) had driven the car of A-82.
Confessional Statement of Mohd. Sultan Sayyed (A-90):
82. He is S.P. Raigad. In his confessional statement he has corroborated the version of events provided by the appellant, regarding the association of the smugglers with R.K. Singh, Assistant Collector (A-102) and making regular payments of illegal gratification. He has also stated that it was the appellant (A-30) who had been negotiating with the customs and police officers to revise the rates per landing. He (A-90) had accepted a bribe from the appellant (A-30) of Rs.1 lakh out of the total amount of Rs.3.5 lakhs that was paid by the D appellant to R.K. Singh (A-102).
.c
Confessional Statement of SS Talwadekar (A-113): 83. He has also corroborated ·the confessional statement of the appellant regarding silver at Shekhadi sea-coast, in E collusion with the customs and police officers incfuding J.K. Gurav (A-82). He has revealed that he had been facilitating the smugglers in their landings and transportation, and he has also accepted that he had received Rs.1.6 lakhs as was decided earlier for the first landing, for the second and also third landing. F He has also admitted to accepting the said amount. So far as the incident dated 9.1.1993 is concerned, he has named the appellant (A-30) who met him (A-113) and paid him a sum of Rs.40,000/- out of the settled amount of Rs.1.25 lakhs.
G Confessional Statement of Mohd. Kasam Lajpuria @ Mechanic Chacha (A-136): 84. His statement corroborates the statement of Salim Kutta (A-134) to the extent that Uttam Potdar (A-30) was the landing H agent, and that the accused had (A-136) met Uttam Potdar (A-
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
30) at Mhasla. He (A-136) further corroborated the version of events which included the interception of contraband by the Shrivardhan police; the negotiation of the bribe by Uttam Potdar (A-30); and further the giving of fivP silver bricks to the police as security.
Confessional Statement of Jamir Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-
133): 85. He has stated that he is the elder brother of Shabbir. He knew the appellant (A-30) who was at that time, working for Mohd. Dossa. During a marriage in his family on 10.1.1993 when a large number of his relatives were visiting, Salim Kutta (A-134) and his friends Feroz and his brother Shabbir had come to his house on a Yamaha Motor Cycle alongwith the appellant (A-30). The appellant (A-30) left after having a discussion with his brother, Shabbir. Shabbir told him (A-133) that silver and weapons would arrive at Dighi Jetty on that day, and this landing was to be supervised by the appellant (A-30). After some time, Shabbir and the other co-accused Salim (A134), Feroz and the appellant (A-30) started talking about the unloading of the goods to be brought, and after discussing the same for a while, the appellant (A-30) went out to make arrangements for the un.loading of the concerned goods. It was on that day that he learnt that the goods were being sent by Mohd. Dossa. ·On 9.1.1993 at 7.00 p.m. Shabbir, Salim (A-134) and Feroz left for Dighi Jetty to unload the smuggled goods. He (A133) stayed at home. They returned at 5 a.m. with three wooden boxes, which were kept by them in the hall of the house, and he then slept there. From their conversation, the witness learnt that there were 300 ingots of silver in total, each of them weighing 30 Kgs. and 19 ingots which could not be loaded in the truck, and the same were then hidden in the open land of one Subedar who was at the said time, living in Nairobi.
C
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2013] 16 S.C.R.
On 10.1.1993, the appellant (A-30) came to his house during the night and spoke to Salim (A-134) and Shabbir and went away. From their discussion he (A-133) understood that silver and weapons had been smuggled at Dighi Jetty on the previous night. He (A-133), alongwith others. brought 19 silver ingots and 15/20 green coloured bags containing tin boxes in a bullock cart, and kept them in their house and then fell asleep. After about two days, Afzal Gadbad, who works in the office of Mohd. Dossa in Bombay, came there and took away the said silver ingots in a jeep. However, the tin boxes remained there. After about a month, upon being asked by Shabbir, the said tin boxes and bags were taken to the first floor of the house of Ali Mian Faki, which was in close proximity to their house. Janardhan Pandurang Gambas (A-81) who is a resident of that area, and a fisherman who had participated in the smuggling with Shabbir, the appellant (A-30) and Abdulla Surati told the witness that the smuggled goods also contained weapons alongwith silver ingots
Confessional Statement of SaHm Kutta (A-134):
86. He has corroborated the confessional statement of the appellant (A-30). However, he (A-134) did not say anything to show that the appellant (A-30) had knowledge regarding the contents of the boxes, particularly as regards the weapons. He stated that the appellant (A-30) was present during the landing at Dighi Jetty and had made arrangements for labour and a boat. After the loading of the landed goods on vehicles, the appellant (A-30) had also participated in negotiations with the police upon being interception by them.
Confessional Statement of Faki Ali Faki Ahmed (A-74): 87. He (A-74) corroborated the fact that the appellant (AH
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
30) was a landing agent and a resident of Mhasla, and that the appellant (A-30) was well acquainted with Shabbir and Jamir (A-133) who were involved in smuggling activities.
88. Deposition of Dilip Panseire (PW.97) - In his deposition, he reveals that he was a childhood friend of the B appellant (A-30) and had been working in a government department. However, he had driven the truck containing smuggled goods. He has also deposed that upon interception by Inspector Patil (A-116), a discussion ensued for half an hour, amongst the appellant (A-30), Gurav (A-82), Shabbir Kadri and C Inspector Patil (A-116). He identified the truck, though the owner and the driver of the truck were neither made accused, nor witnesses in this case. 89. Deposition of Vyankatesh Hirba (PW.588)- He was the officer who had effected the seizure of the Tempo bearing number MH-06-5533 on 12.4.93. The appellant (A-30) in his confession has stated that the said tempo was used to transport contraband items which were landed at Dighi Jetty. 90. Deposition of Dinesh Nakti (PW.95) speaks of silver ingots and wooden boxes. He 'identified the appellant in court 91. A conjoint reading of the confessional statement and deposition of witnesses reveal that appellant (A-30) had been an associate of Mohd. Dossa (AA) and was aware of the fact that Mohd. Dossa (AA) was involved in criminal activities. A30 was also associate of co-accused Mechanic Chacha, Shabbir, Salim, Feroz and Jamir Sayyed Kadri. A-30 has been working as a landing agent for Mohd. Dossa and others by arranging boats and coolies. A-30 was called to Mhasla on 4.12.1992 wherein he disclosed about the previous day landing to R.K. Singh (A-102), Custom Officer. Subsequent to the said meeting, A-30 received Rs.6.25 lacs from A-136 and paid Rs.1 lac to Mhasla Custom staff, Rs.1.5 lacs to Shrivardhan Custom staff, Rs.1.25 lac to R.K. Singh, Custom Officer. A-30 made arrangements for boats and coolies for another landing
E.
s
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
scheduled for 9.2.1993 and went to Dighi Jetty on his motorcycle on 9.2.1993. He met Custom Inspector Gurav (A82) and started driving jeep of Gurav. When the trucks carrying contraband smuggled goods were intercepted by police team headed by PSI V.K. Patil, A-30 told Mr. Patil that the money for earlier landing had been paid to Mali Havaldar who was also member of that police team. It was in his presence that Mechanic Chacha (A-136) offered Rs.10 lacs to PSI Patil and as they did not have money, they gave him 5 silver bricks as a security. A-30 alo~gwith others shifted 170 bricks in the cavity of two trucks of Bombay and 80 silver bricks were transferred from.one truck to another at the residence of Shabbir (AA). He also went to the residence of Shabbir. A-30 left the message at Shrivardhan Police Station that he would come with money on the night of 10.2.1993. In his presence Rs.2 lacs were paid to Patil, PSI at Shrivardhan Naka and Rs.5 lacs were paid to Havaldars. A-30 received Rs.3 lacs from Feroz on the same night to hand it over to Custom Officer of .Alibagh and he handed it over to R.K. Singh and Sayyed. 92. After appreciating the evidence on record, the learned Designated Court reached the following conclusions: " ........ However considering further events which had occurred at Ghonghar Patta i.e. interception of goods by police, allowing the same to be further proceeded after negotiations with smugglers, presence of A-30 who was one of the main person, or effecting landing, his role in the said episode, it is difficult to perceive that at the said juncture A-30 would not have gathered the knowledge of contraband material. Needless to add that in cases of conspiracy it is difficult to except to have direct evidence and the inference about certain aspects is required to be drawn from established facts & circumstances. Thus having regard to all the aforesaid facets it i~ difficult to accept that at least at the said place A-30 would not have gathered the nature of contraband goods also sent
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. S.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
along with smugglers. It is true that the said further acts committed by A-30 being in the nature of continuing job for which he had agreed i.e. effecting the silver landing the same may not make him liable for being party to the conspiracy to commit the terrorist act or the larger conspiracy for which the charge at head 1st ly is framed. Such a conclusion is obvious as hardly there exists any other material denoting that alter completion of job of landing & transportation, A-30 having committed any act furthering object of ally conspiracy. However, still now the further act being committed by A-30 being with an expressed knowledge that the contraband material was containing arms & ammunitions he will be squarely liable for commission of offence u/s 3 (3) of TADA. Similarly the quantity of the said arms & ammunition and the further acts actually committed by A-30 would also make him liable for commission of offence u/s.6 TADA .
c
... ... ... Thus considering the said aspect it will be · extremely difficult to accept that policemen would not have been aware about the nature of said goods in trucks which were in the said trucks i.e. silver and arms & ammunitions E as established by evidence. Such an inference is inevitable as such evidence pertaining to landing clearly . denotes of the material being of two different categories i.e. boxes and bachkies i.e. bundles. Having regard to the same it is difficult to perceive that during inspection of F trucks at least parcels from each category would not have been inspected by policemen . . . . . . . .Having regard to aforesaid even assuming that police party had permitted the said trucks to proceed away without inspection then also they cannot escape the liability arising out of said illegal omission committed by .them. In view of the same the knowledge of the nature. of contraband goods will he required to be presumed for them.
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
Now considering the liability of A-136 as revealed from the earlier discussion but without once again repeating the dilation made earlier it can be said that the same having revealed that A-136 had become aware about the nature of goods after he was told regarding the same and the direction of accused Mustafa Dossa by A-134. As dilated earlier, it is clear that though A-136 had continued with the said operation i.e. the operation of smuggling for which he had agreed earlier and in the process having committed the offence u/s.3 (3) of TADA still he cannot be said to be guilty for the offence of conspiracy to which A-134 was said to be party. Needless to add that considering the acts committed by A-136, his liability remained confined to having committed the offence u/s.3(3) and Sec. 6 of TADA.
The case of A-30 also appears to be similar to that of A136 i.e. himself being not aware since the beginning of the goods to be smuggled being arms & ammunitions and having acquired the knowledge about same during the midst of operation but in spite of the said knowledge having continued the said operation giving rise to the liability for commission of offence u/s. 3(3) & Sec. 6 of TADA. At the cost of repetition it will be required to be added that A136 and A-30 having committed the relevant acts in the month of Jan., 1993 on the dates on which even Tiger Memon had not disclosed his intent regarding the places at which the explosions were to be committed in Bombay and ?themselves having not committed any act other than completing the smuggling operation for which they had agreed they cannot he held guilty for any offence of conspiracy though would he liable for commission of offences as stated aforesaid."
93. The confession of A-134 does not show that the appellant (A-30) was aware of the contents of the contraband goods were arms and ammunition, either prior to the landing or thereafter. However, considering the event of interception of
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S, CHAUHAN, J.]
the said goods by the police and the presence and involvement A of the appellant (A-30) in negotiations with the police for clearing the said smuggled goods, it is difficult to believe, that at the said time, the appellant (A-30) did not have knowledge regarding the contraband material. The confession of A-133 however reveals that he (A-133) had overheard the appellant (A-30) discussing the contents of the contraband after the itenis had landed.
In case of conspiracy, it is difficult to find direct evidence and thus, inference is required to be drawn from established C facts and circumstances. Hence, it is difficult to accept, that in the said circumstances the appellant (A-30) was unaware of the nature of the smuggled goods. The acts that were further committed 0 by fhe appellant (A-30), were in the nature of continuing his job in effecting the landing of silver, and the same may not make him liable as a party to the conspiracy to commit terrorist acts. However, certain other acts that were committed by him (A-30), with the express knowledge that the contraband material did E . in fact contai1n arms and ammunition, would make him liable for commission of offence under Section 3(3) TADA. Furthermore, the quantity of arms and ammunition, and the further acts committed by the appellant would also make him liable for commission of offence under Section 6 TADA.
94. The examination of the appellant (A-30) under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. reveals that he had assisted in the landing of goods at Dighi Jetty on 9.1.1993, and that he had taken the stand of being involved in the landings of silver even prior to the said event, and that he did not know the nature of the goods G that were landed in the said landing. The evidence of PWs 95 and 97 corroborates the fact that landing had occurred at the said time and place. Their evidence reveals that the goodswere packed in boxes, or in green coloured cloth bag that had been tied at the mouth, and that thus, they were not aware of the H
C
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
contents. They had acted at the behest of the appellant (A-30) for which they had received payment. 95. The appellant (A-30) was aware that the smuggled goods were arms and ammunition, and even after acquiring such knowledge, he had continued the landing of the said smuggled goods. This makes him liable for commission of offences under Section 3(3) and 6 TADA 96. His (A-30) role is akin to that of Mechanic Chacha (A136). Thus, we do not find any force in the appeal and it is accordingly dismissed. 97. The parameters laid down by this court in entertaining the appeal against the order of acquittal have to be applied.
98. The evidence on record made it crystal clear that A30 was not only a close associate of Tiger Memon (AA) and acting 9s a landing agent, but a man of confidence who could negotiate with the police and customs officials to fix the amount of bribe for facilitating the smuggling and transportation of the smuggled contraband. He was a person who had negotiated with the police at Gondghar Phata. He had been fully aware of the nature of contraband, and in spite of coming to know that the contraband contained arms, ammunition and explosives, he continued to help the smugglers. It is also evident that he had close association with Jaywant Keshav Gurav (A-82), officer of the customs department, who had been helping the smugglers by taking a bribe through A-30. Therefore, in view of the above, we do not concur with the findings of fact recorded by the learned Designated Court that A-30 could not be convicted for conspiracy. 99. In the facts and circumstances, the appeal filed by the appellant (A-30) is dismissed, and appeal filed by the State through CBI is allowed. Appellant (A-30) is convicted for the offence under Charge I, and awarded the life imprisonment. The Designated Court is directed to take him into custody and send
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
him to Jail to serve out the remaining sentence, if any.
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1420 OF 2007 Mohd. Rafiq @ Rafiq Madi Musa Biyariwala
... Appellant
Versus State of Maharashtra
. . . Respondent AND
c
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1031 OF 2012 The State of Maharashtra thr. CBI ... Appellant '.;'
Versus
• · Mohd. Rafiq @ Rafiq Madi Musa Biy.ariwala .... Respondent
.Criminal Appeal No. 1420 of 2007 100. This appeal has been preferred against the judgment and order dated 31.5.2007, passed by Special Judge of the Designated Court under the TADA for Bombay Blast, Greater Bombay, by which the appellant (A-46) has been convicted under Section 3(3) TADA. However, Criminal Appeal No.1031 of 2012 has been filed by the State against the said judgment as A-46 stood acquitted of the charge of larger conspiracy. 101. Facts and circumstances giving rise to this appeal are that:
A. In addition to the main charge of conspiracy, the appellant (A-46) was charged for participation in landing and transportation of arms, ammunition, hand grenades and explosives like ROX to be used in Bombay blast on 12.3.1993.
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
B. He was further charged for abetting and participating in terrorist activities as the appellant participated in the month of February 1993 alongwith co-conspirators in the landing of arms, ammunition and explosives at Shekhadi. Further he (A46) alongwith co-accused Asgar Mukadam drove other coaccused to Sahar Airport who had gone for training to Pakistan. Further he delivered motor vehicle having arms, ammunition and explosives at the residence of Amjad Aziz Meharbux and thereby committed a separate offence punishable under Section 3(3) TADA. C. The appellant was further charged under Section 6 TADA for possessing and transporting arms, ammunition and explosives like hand grenades and detonators from Shekhadi to Bombay in an unauthorized manner. 102. The appellant (A-46) has been convicted under Section 3(3) TADA, and given a sentence of R.I. 5 years and a fine of Rs.25,000/-and in default of payment of fine, to suffer further imprisonment of six months; under Section 6 TADA, a sentence of R.I. 7 years and a fine of Rs.50.,000/- and in default of payment of fine, to further suffer one year RI. Both the sentences were directed to run concurrently. Hence, this appeal.
103. Shri Mushtaq Ahmad, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant, has submitted that the appellant (A-46) has wrongly been enroped in the crime, he was no where involved. The confessional statements of the appellant as well as the co-accused could not be relied upon·as it has been obtained by coercion and it could not be held to be useful and truthful. More so, the learned Designated Court failed to appreciate the evidence in correct perspective. Therefore, appeal deserves to be allowed. 104. Per contra, Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing on behalf of the State, opposed the appeal
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
contending that the appellant had been deeply involved, not only in the landing and transportation of the smuggled goods, but being a very close associate of Tiger Memon(AA), was involved in the conspiracy also for which he has wrongly been acquitted. The evidence on record fully established his involvement in the crime. Thus, appeal lacks merit and is liable to be dismissed.
We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
c
105. Evidence against the appellant {A-46): (a)
Confessional statement of Rafiq Madi(A-46)
(b)
Confession of Asgar Yusuf Mukadam @ Munna (A-
10)
(c)
Confession of Abdul Gani Ismail Turk (A-11)
(d)
Confession of Parvez Nazir Ahmed Shaikh (A-12)
(e)
Confession of Dawood Taklya Mohammed Phanse (A-14)
(f)
Confession of Dadabhai (A-17)
(g)
Confession of Shahnawaz Abdul Kadar (A-29)
(h)
Confession of Nasir Abdul Kader Kewal @ Nasir Dakhla (A-64)
(i)
Confession of Altaf Ali Mustaq Ali Sayed (A-67) Confession of Gu lam Hafiz Shaikh @ Baba (A-73)
(k)
Confession of Mubina Bhiwandiwala (A-96)
(I)
Confession of Parvez Mohmed Parvez Zulfikar Qureshi@ Parvez Kelewala (A-100)
@
Baya
Moosa
SUPREME COURT REPORTS (m)
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
Deposition of Usman (PW-2)
Confessional statement of Rafiq Madi(A-46) : 106. In his confessional statement. appellant (A-46) has deposed that he used to work as driver for Tiger Memon's B family and sometimes, when he was unemployed, used to sell clothes or cassettes on footpath. He worked as driver of Mushtaq Abdul Razak Memon@ Ibrahim@ Tiger for about 1012 months. Tiger Memon (AA) had been involved in Hawala business and smuggling of gold and silver from Dubai. The C appellant (A-46) used to participate in landing and transportation of the smuggled goods and was being paid Rs. 2500/- as salary.per month and Rs.3000 to 4000 per landing in addition to salary. Tiger's office stood closed due to riots in Bombay in December 1992 and January 1993, thus, the D appellant lost his work like a large number of other youths. One day when he went to the house of Tiger for collection of his salary for December, 1992 he (A-46) was directed to go out for Tiger's work. Appellant (A-46) was not willing to go for the work as he was not feeling well, however being poor he went E because of offer of money. Appellant (A-46) went in a jeep alongwith Tiger, Yakub Yeda, Javed Chikna, Usman and his associates for landing of smuggled goods. Dawood Taklya (A14) was present there alongwith his associates. They waited the whole night but the smuggled goods did not come. They F camei back and stayed in a Hotel and in the evening they went to the landing point but the articles did not arrive that night also. They came to Alibaug and stayed in a hotel for 2-3 days. On 3.2.1993 night, the appellant alongwith others proceeded from Alibaug and reached the place of landing. Tiger and Yakub G were also there.
Appellant (A-46) after taking the smuggled goods, which was in boxes came to the Tower in the jeep at 11.30 p.m. On being asked, Shafi told that the boxes contained electronic goods. On 4.2.1993 appellant (A-46) went to the house of Dadabhai (A-17) where Shafi asked the appellant (A-46) to
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
load the articles from the tower. Appellant (A-46) alongwith Dadabhai (A-17) and Shafi reached the tower with a truck and Maruti van and loaded the truck with 59 gunny bags and covered the same with empty gunny bags. Shafi left from there taking the truck. The appellant (A-46) and Dadabhai (A-17) went to the house of Dadabhai (A-17) and slept after having the dinner. On 5.2.1993 the appellant (A-46) went to Mahad and then to Nagothane in Maruti van. The vehicle being driven by . Shafi was left at Nagothane. Appellant (A-46), Shafi and Dadabai (A-17) left for Alibaug to bring Mohd. Hussain. From there Shafi left by jeep instructing the appellant (A-46) to reach at Sandra Talab with Maruti Van near in the evening. There the appellant (A-46) would exchange the van with a jeep given by Riaz. On &.2: 1993 the appellant (A-46) met Anwar at 11 O'Clock in the morning near his house. They went to bungalow of Meharbux (Discharged Accused) at Mahim in that vehicle. The appellant (A-46) was asked to remove the jeep and park it at the house of Meharbux.
c
Confession of Asgar Yusuf Mukadam @ Munna (A-10) 107 ..Asgar Yusuf Mukadam @ Munna (A-10) in his confessional statement has inyolved appellant (A-46) to the effect that he had been working for Tiger Memon (AA) and he dropped the co-accused (A-10) to Sahar Airport from where A-10 alongwith others went to Dubai.
Confession of· Abdul Gani Ismail Turk (A-11)
108. Abdul Gani Ismail Turk (A-11) has disclosed in his confessional statement that appellant (A-46) participated in the landing at Mhasala made by Tiger Memon (AA).
Confession of Parvez Nazir Ahmed Shaikh (A-12) 109. Parvez Nazir Ahmed Shaikh (A-12) stated in his confessional statement that appellant (A-46) was present at Al Husseini Building and money had been paid to (A-46) in his presence.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
Confession of Dawood Taklya Mohammed Phanse (A-14) 110. Dawood Taklya Mohammed Phanse (A-14) disclosed that appellant (A-46) told him that his ticket had been booked and he had to leave for Dubai on the same day.
B Confession of Dadabhi (A-17) 111. Dadabhai (A-17) disclosed that he alongwith appellant (A-46) and Shafi facilitated and participated in transfer of smuggled goods from Wangni Tower to Bombay.
c Confession of Shahnawaz Abdul Kadar (A-29) 112. Shahnawaz Abdul Kadar Qureshi (A-29) disclosed that appellant (A-46) was among the persons who participated in several landings. Appellant (A-46) had come to his residence D and told him that his tickets were ready. He (A-46) was present . at the airport and a sum of Rs. 50,000/- was paid to him for distribution among other co-accused. Confession of Nasir Abdul Kader Kewal @ Nasir Dakhla E {A-64)
I
113. Nasir Abdul Kader Kewal @ Nasir Dakhla (A-64) has disclosed that in January, 1993 he had seen appellant tA46) waiting for co-accused and appellant (A-46) was always seen with Tiger Memon (AA) and used to communicate Tiger's F messages. A-46 was also present at the Al-Husseini Building in the intervening night between 11th/12th March, 1993 when the ROX was filled up in the vehicles. 114. Bashir Ahmed Usman Gani Khairulla (Bashir G Electrical) (A-13), Altaf Ali Mustaq Ali Sayed (A-67), Gulam Hafiz Shaikh @ Baba (A-73), Gui Mohammed @ Gullu Noor Mohmed Shaikh (A-77), Mubina@ Baya Moosa Bhiwandiwala (A-96) and Parvez Mohmed Parvez Zulfikar Qureshi @ Parvez Kelewala (A-100) have also named the appellant A-46 giving H details of his involvement in landings etc.
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @A.S. MUBARAK v. . STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
Deposition of Usman Jan Khan (PW-2)
115. Usman Jan Khan (PW-2) has identified the appellant (A-46) in court and also disclosed that he was active participant in landing and transportation. 116. The Designated Court after appreciating the entire B evidence on record came to the conclusion that the appellant (A-46) actively participated in the Shekhadi landing and transportation operation of cor:itraband goods i.e. AK-56 rifles, ammunition, RDX etc. smuggled into the country by Tiger Memon (AA). Confession of the appellant (A-46) revealed that C he was in employment of the Memon family, ho.wever he had been to Shekhadi landing.· it could not be accepted that the appellant (A-46) was nor aware of illegal business of Tiger Memon (AA) or about the nature of the contrabands smuggled into India. The presence of the appellant (A-46) at the place D where the goods were exchanged, at Wangni Tower and concealed into cavities of vehicles for transportation to Bombay; shows that he was a person of very close confident of Tiger Memon (AA). The appellant (A-46) handed over a motor vehicle containing a_rms and.ammunitions at resid"ence of Amjaz Abdul E Aziz Meherbux (A-68). Confessions of co-accused clearly established the involvement of the appellant (A-46) along with Asgar (A-10) for taking co-accused persons, who were sent for training to Pakistan via Dubai, though he may not be aware of the purpose for which the co-accused were sent to Dubai. In view of ~he above well reasoned judgment, we do not find any evidence on record to warrant interference in the conclusion drawn by the Designated Court. The appeal lacks meri.t and is accordingly dismissed.
Criminal Appeal No. 1031 of 2012 117. This appeal has been filed by the State against the acquittal of the respondent of the charge of larger conspiracy.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
118. On the first charge, the learned Designated Court considered the entire evidence as referred to hereinabove and came to the conclusion: "However hardly there being cementing material for
c
establishing nexus of A-46 with conspiracy for which he is charged with and material having remained confined of himself having committed of aforesaid offences, it will be difficult to hold him liable for conspiracy for which he is charged with. The same is • obvious as hardly there is any material indicating A-46 having committed any other acts because of which he is said to have further object of conspiracy for which he is charged with."
119. The parameters laid down by this court in entertaining D the appeal against the order of acquittal have to be applied. 120. In view of the above, the appeal is liabte to be dismissed.
CRIMINAL APPEAL NOS. 675-681 OF 2008 Suleman Mohamed Kasam Ghavte & Ors .... Appellants Versus State of Maharashtra thr. STF, CBI Bombay. Respondent
121. These appeals have been preferred against the judgments and orders dated 11th, 12th 16th, 17th October, 2006, 23rd /24th May, 2007 and 1st June, 2007 passed by the Special Judge of the Designated Court under the TADA in the G Bombay Blast Case No. 1 of 1993, by which the appellants have been convicted. In view of the fact that each appellant being assigned different acts, has been charged differently and has been awarded a different sentence, it is desirable to deal with the case of each appellant separately to certain extent.
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @AS. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. S.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
I. Suleman Mohammed Kasam Ghavte (A-18): 122. The appellant(A-18) has been convicted on two counts under Section 3(3) of TADA, and has been awarded 7 years rigorous imprisonment alongwith a fine of Rs. 25,000/- and in default of payment of fine, to suffer further RI for 6 months on each count.
123. In addition to the first charge of conspiracy, he has been charged for the following offences: (i)
(ii)
(iii)
That he has participated alongwith the other conspirators in the landing and transportation of arms, ammunition and explosives at Shekhadi, and has smuggled goods into the country to be used for the commission of terrorist acts.
c
That, he alongwith co-accused Abdul Rehman Shaikh (A-28) and others transported RDX explosives in Motor Tempo No. MMP-4799 from Shekhadi to Panvel, and the same contained· goods that were smuggled into the country by Tiger Memon (AA) and his associates for the purpose of E committing terrorist activities .. That he participated in weapons' training at Sandheri/Borghat. Thus, he has been charged under Section 3(3) TADA and has been convicted and sentenced as mentioned hereinbefore.
124. Ms. Farhana Shah, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has submitted that the appellant was unaware of the fact that the items being landed were those other than silver, and that he realized this fact only later. Furthermore, his confession had not been made voluntarily, but under threat and coercion. Thus, the appeal deserves to be allowed.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
125. On the contrary, Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the State has submitted that the appellant has been named by several witnesses of the Shekhadi landing. Moreover, the said vehicle had been seized and the FSL report was also positive as regards the presence of ROX. Therefore, the appeal deserves to be dismissed. 126. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
c
127. Evidence against the aQQellant {A-18): (a)
Confessional statement of Suleman Mohd. Kasam Ghavte (A-18)
(b)
Confessional statement of Abdul Gani lsmial Turk (A-11)
(c)
Confessional statement of Rusi Framroze Mulla (A125)
(d)
Confessional Statement of Parvez Nazir Ahmed Shaikh (A-12)
(e)
Confessional statement of Sayyed Abdul Rehman Shaikh (A-28)
(f)
Confessional statement of Liyakat Ali Habib Khan (A-85)
(g)
Confessional statement of Abdul Gafoor Parkar (A17)
(h)
Deposition of Babydas Vasu (PW-290)
(i)
Deposition of Pradeep S. Dalvi (PW-293)
Q)
Deposition of Abdulmunaf A. Mahimi (PW-294)
(k)
Deposition of Asit Ghorai (PW-602)
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.] (I)
Deposition of Ajit Surve (PW-604)
(m)
Deposition of Moreshwar Thakur (PW-469)
128. Confessional Statement of Suleman Mohd.
Kasam Ghavte( A-18): In his confessional statement recorded on 18.4.1993 and 20.4.1993, the appellant has disclosed that he had been working as a driver. He has stated that he knew of a person named Anwar, who had lived in close proximity to his house right from his childhood. A relative of the appellq~t (A-18) had asked him whether he would travel to Ajmer Sharif along with Anwar in a Maruti Car. He had thus gone to Ajmer driving the said vehicle with Anwar, who had been working with Tiger Memon (AA) and was also being paid by him. A tempo bearing No. MMP-4799, belonging to a decorator was given to the appellant (A-18) on 5.2.1993. The said vehicle had been driven by him to take Sayyed Abdul Rehman Shaikh (A-28) and Abdul Gani (A-11) to Mhasla. Dawood Taklya (A-14) and Dadabhai (A-17) were already present at Mhasla. Fifty-sixty packets were loaded into the said vehicle. The said packets were dug out from the land. When the appellant (A-18) touched these packets, he realised that they did not contain silver smuggled from abroad. After collecting the aforementioned goods, he left for Bombay alongwith co-accused (A-55). When they reached Panvel, he realized that Tiger Memon (AA) had also come there in a Maruti car, and as per his instructions, they had then driven to the house of Dawood Taklya (A-14) in Mhasla in order to leave the tempo there. After some time, the appellant (A-18) had returned to Bombay, alongwith Gani (A-11) and others. After 2-3 days on 9.2.1993, he had gone to Mahad driving the said vehicle and had reached there at noon. He had seen a Maruti car and two jeeps parked there, and also saw Tiger Memon (AA), Yakub Haji, Anwar, Javed Chikna, Gani, Shafi and 5-6 other boys. Shafi asked the appellant (A-18) to stop the tempo at a petrol pump situated between Goregaon and Madgaon. At about 6 o' clock in the evening, two boys had
c
s
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013) 16 S.C.R.
come there in a tempo, and had asked the appellant (A-18) to take the said tempo to the Mhasla tower. The appellant (A-18) had then taken the vehicle to Mhasla tower and had reached there at about 9.30 pm. The accused Anwar, Tiger Memon (AA), Shafi, Gani, Dawood Taklya (A-14), Dadabhai (A-17), Javed Chikna and a few other persons had also come there at about 3.00 A.M. Upon the instructions of Tiger Memon (AA), the appellant (A-18) had then taken the vehicle to Chilpara Kalyar. where he f-iad arrived reached at noon. The appellant (A-18) was then asked to leave the jeep at the house of Anwar. He reached the house of Anwar at about 4 00 P.M., left the vehicle there and was paid a sum of Rs.5000/- for the two trips that had been made by the appellant (A-18). From the conversation of Anwar, Tiger Memon and his partner, the appellant (A-18) had understood that the goods which were in the said vehicle were not silver, but something else. After he learnt that the aforementioned accused had been smuggling something other than silver and gold, the appellant (A-18) had stopped working for Anwar. 129. Confessional Statement of Abdul Gani Ismail Jurk (A-11 ): Abdul Gani Ismail Turk (A-11 ), in his confessional statement has stated that the appellant (A-18) had been participating in smuggling activities with his consent, and that he had known what was being smuggled. On 7th /8th February, 1993, he (A-11) had gone to the house of Tiger Memon at the Al-Husseini building in Mahim. Tiger Memon had then taken him to the house of Anwar (AA), where they had met two other persons and he had learnt that the said people were Sayyed Abdul Rehman Shaikh (A-28) and the appellant (A-18), and that the two had a tempo with them. Tiger Memon had given him one lakh rupees and had asked him to go with the appellant (A-18) and to pay the said amount to Dawood Taklya (A-14) and to return with a chemical i.e. "black soap". The said "black soap" was the same chemical that had been brought to the
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
tower on the night of 3rd February, 1993. He (A-11) alongwith A the appellant (A-18) and Sayyed Abdul Rehman Shaikh (A-28) had left Mahim at midnight, and had reached the tower the next day at about 11 A.M. An amount of rupees one lakh that had been given by Tiger Memon (AA), was handed over to Dawood Taklya (A-14). The appellant (A-18) along with Abdul Gani lsmial B Turk (A-11 ), and Sayyed Abdul Rehman Shaikh (A-28) had then loaded about 59 bags of the said chemical into the tempo that evening, and had thereafter, left for Bombay. They reached the Welcome Hotel at Panvel at about 11-12 o' Clock at night. They ha~ met Tiger Memon (AA) there and he (A-11) and the c appellant (A-18) were directed to instruct Dawood Taklya (A14) to keep some persons ready for work. They had conveyed the said message to Dawood Taklya (A-14). Dawood Taklya (A-14) had sent his son Sarfaraz (A-55) alongwith the appellant (A-18), Abdul Gani Ismail Turk (A-11) and Sayyed Abdul D Rehman Shaikh (A-28) to Bombay. 130. Confessional Statement of Rusi Framroze Mulla {A-125): He has corroborated the prosecution's version of events regarding the transportation of smuggled goods from Shekhadi to Panvel. Thus, in their confessional statements the aforesaid accused persons have revealed that the appellant (A-18) had fully participated in the landing and transportation of smuggled goods, which includedweapons and not just silver and gold.
131. Confessional Statement of Parvez Nazir Ahmed Shaikh CA-12): He (A-12) in his confessional statement has revealed that he had been working with Tiger Memon (AA) in the execution of hawala transactions and that he had been paying money to persons as was directed by Tiger Memon (AA) from time to time. After the Bombay riots he could not att~nd the office of H
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
Tiger Memon (AA) as the same had been closed. During this period he (A-12), has stated that he, alongwith Ajgar were staying in Shaffi's house and that he would call the house of Tiger Memon's at the Al Husseini building intermittently, but upon his doing so, he was always told that there was no work. B Upon the instruction of Tiger Memon (AA) in January, 1993 he had gone to Mhasla and had met Dawood Taklya (A-14) and had also participated in the landing. The smuggled goods were brought from the jetty to the Wangni tower. The men employed by Javed and Yakub who had come from Bombay had then c opened the boxes which contained bullets, revolvers, pistols etc. All the contraband were shifted into false cavities in the jeeps and tempos that had been organized, and which thereafter, departed for Bombay. One such jeep had been entrusted to him (A-12). He along with Nasir had been told by D Tiger Memon (AA) to wait at Khandala, and one contact number had been given to them. At Khandala, they had gone to Hotel New Taj. A-12 had then tried to contact Tiger Memon (AA) C?Ver the telephone, using the said c~ntact number at Hotel Big Splash, Alibagh. However, he was only able to speak to Mohd. Hussain who had advised A-12 to wait there, and l)ad stated E that A-18 would come there in the morning. Consequently, the appellant (A-18) had come there with lmtiyaz in the afternoon. With them, A-12 had gone to Bombay, and had been dropped off at Sandra Talab and the appellant (A-18) and lmtiyaz had also left from there. 132. Confessional Statement of Sayyed Abdul Rehman Shaikh (A-28): His confessional statement reveals that on 5th February, 1993 at about midnight, when he (A-28) was returning from G shooting, the appellant (A-18) had met him on the road itself and had told him (A-28) that Tiger Memon (AA) was calling for him. Tiger Memon (AA) was standing nearby, and hence he met Tiger Memon who had told him to go to Mahim. Yeda Yakub
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @AS. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
had also been standing there alongwith Tiger Memon. Thus, he has corroborated the statement of Abdul Gani Ismail Turk (A11 ). 133. Confessional Statement of Liyakat Ali Habib Khan (A-85): His confessional statement reveals that in the second week of February 1993, his uncle Yakub Khan had asked his father to allow him to keep a few bags, for the period of a few months in their godown at Thane and thus, he had been allowed to do so. After a while, his uncle Yakub Khan, Tiger Memon (AA) and Nisar had come to his house in a jeep and had taken him along with them. After opening the godown of the factory, two tempos had been taken inside, and it was then that the goods were unloaded. There were 80 packets in gunny bags, and each bag weighed about 30 to 35 Kgs. Tiger Memon had given Liyakat Ali Habib Khan (A-85) a sµm of Rs.600/- out of which he had given Rs.200/- to Nisar and thereafter, Liyakat Ali Habib Khan (A-85), Nisar and the appellant (A-18) had gone to the said factory and had then left for Bombay. On the way, the appellant (A-18) had told him that the goods that had kept in their factory were actually explosives. 134. Sharif Abdul Gafoor Parkar@ Dadabhai (A-17), in his confessional statement has disclosed that the appellant (A-18) had in fact been present when 59 packets had been brought into Bombay.
C
135. Deposition of Babydas Vasu CPW-290): He had been working in a hotel in lndraprastha at Nage Thana, District Raigad. He has deposed that the appellant (A- G 18) alongwith others, had come there and had stayed in the said hotel for some time. There are entries to this effect in the hand writing of the appellant (A-18). Room No. 106 had been booked for them in the said hotel. He has produced the register
'
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
to prove the same, but the said entries are of the year 1992, and not of 1993. 136. Deposition of Pradeep S. Dalvi (PW-293):
He has deposed that he was the registered owner of the B • vehicle Matador Tempo bearing registration No. MMP-4799 which had been sold to a decorator in 1988. The said tempo, bearing this registration number had been .used for the smuggling of various types of contraband, including weapons, from Shekhadi to Panvel by the appellant (A-18).
c
137. Deposition of Abdulmunaf A. Mahimi (PW-294):
He has deposed that he was the brother of.Abdul Samad who had been carrying on the business of electrical and mandap decoration, and that the said vehicle had been O purchased by his brother Abdul Samad (not examined) between 5.2.1993 and 9.2.1993. The tempo was not found in the campus. The said vehicle had been seized on 30.11.1993, but no samples etc. were taken from the vehicle to determine whether it contained ROX explosives etc. or riot.
138. Deposition of Asit Ghorai (PW-602):
He has deposed as a panch witness and has stated that 13 samples were in fact taken after the seizure of the vehicle on 30.11.1993. The samples were then sent for chemical analysis. 139. Deposition of Ajit Surve (PW-604):
He has proved the seizure of the vehicle and the sending of the ROX samples for chemical analysis and also the receipt of the report stating that ROX had been found therein. 140. Deposition of Moreshwar Thakur (PW-469):
He has deposed that the Test Identification Parade had been held in accordance with law, and has further stated that
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
;. some witnesses had identified the appellant (A-18), as the person who was had been involved in the landing at Shekhadi. 141. After due consideration of the entire evidence on record, the Designated Court came to the conclusion that as the appellant (A-18) was involved in the Shekhadi landings operation, he has committed the offence under section 3(3) TADA. The evidence has also established his involvement in commission of the offence of conspiracy with the object of committing terrorist acts, as the appellant (A-18) had been made aware of the nature of the smuggled goods and had still transported the same. The said act amounts to furthering the object of conspiracy to commit terrorist acts. However it has been held that the appellant (A-18) himself has not committed any act and that he himself has not participated in any conspiratorial meetings, to denote that he was actually a party to the conspiracy to commit serial bomb Blast or a party to the larger conspiracy i.e. the first charge. 142. So far as the appellant (A-18) is concern~d. undoubtedly, there is sufficient evidence to show that he was involved in the transportation of contraband. From the facts and circumstances of the case, and after taking into consideration the evidence on record, it cannot be inferred that despite being a close associate of Tiger Memon (AA), he remained unaware of the nature Qf the contraband. Furthermore, when a person has been transporting goods for a long period of time it is difficult to believe that he would transport the said goods, without ascertaining the exact nature of goods being loaded into his vehicle, particularly, in view of the fact that the vehicle is likely to be checked at several places by the police, as well as by custom officials. Thus, we do not see any cogent reason to hold .that the appellant (A-18) is not guilty of the charges for which he has been punished by the Designated Court.
C
II. Sayyed Abdul Rehman Shaikh CA-28)
143. The appellant (A-28) has been convicted on two
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2013] 16 S.C.R.
counts under Section 3(3) TADA for the offence of conspiracy, and has been awarded 7 years rigorous imprisonment alongwith a fine of Rs. 25,000/-, and in default of payment of fine, to suffer further RI for 6 months on each count. 144. In addition to the first charge of conspiracy, he had been charged under Section 3(3) TADA for the following offences:
(i) That he participated alongwith the other co-accused in the landing and transportation of arms, ammunition and C explosives at Shekhadi, and transported the same from Shekhadi, Mhasla to Shilphata, Bombay in a Motor Tempo, bearing Registration No. MCY-2279. Further, he (A-28) has also transported ROX explosives from Mhasla to the godown of co-accused Noor Mohmed Haji Mohmed Khan and Mohmed D Jindran Mumtaz Jindran in Motor Tempo No. MMP-4799, while accompanied by Shakil Shahbuddin Shaikh (A-59). He (A-28) has been convicted and sentenced as mentioned hereinabove. 145. Ms. Farhana Shah, learned counsel for the appellant E has submitted that the appellant (A-28) did not own the van in which the goods were transported. Moreover, he has served 3 years out of the total sentence awarded to him, and is now 60 years old. Therefore, leniency should be shown to him. Thus, the appeal deserves to be allowed.
146. Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the State has submitted that he was involved in the transportation of arms and ammunition within the territory of India, and owing to the serious nature of the offence committed by him, there should be no leniency. Thus, the appeal deserves G to be dismissed. 147. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. 148. Evidence against the appellant (A-28):
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
(a)
Confessional statement of the appellant (A-28)
(b)
Confessional statement of Abdul Gani Ismail Turk (Ac11)
(c)
Confessional statement of Dawood Taklya Mohammed Phanse (A-14)
(d)
Confessional statement of Sharif Parkar @Dadabhai (A-17)
(e)
Confessional statement ~f Suleman Mohammed Kasam .Ghavate (A-18)
(f)
Confessional statement of Shakil Shahbuddin Shaikh (A-59)
(g)
Confessional statement of Shahnawaz Khan (A128)
(h)
Deposition of Vijay Govind More (PW.137)
(i)
Deposition of Uttam K. Kale (PW.190)
0)
Deposition of Dileep M. Katarmal (PW.284)
C
o
149. Confessional statement of Sayyed Abdul
Rehman Shaikh CA-28): His statement was recorded by Sanjay Pandey (PW.492), DCP on 23.4.1993 and 26.4.1993. In his' confessional statement, he has disclosed that he was a driver by profession and that he had a driving licence. He had known Tiger Memon (AA) for the last 6-7 months and also Anwar, Gani (A-11), Rafique Madi and Haji Yakub. Hazi Yakub was a friend of Anwar's. He had gone to Ajmer alongwith the other co-accused Suleman and Anwar in April 1992, for smuggling activities. After 2-3 months of his visit to Ajmer, upon the instructions of Anwar, the appellant (A-28) had reached Sandra station with one change of clothes. Shafi and Suleman had come there in
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
a Maruti car, in which he (A-28) had also driven alongwith them, till Linking Road. From there, the appellant (A-28) alongwith the others had gone to an open theatre by way of taking a jeep. Tiger Memon (AA) had arrived there alongwith lmtiyaz and Anwar in a blue coloured Maruti car. Anwar had instructed the B appellant (A-28) to follow the car of Tiger Memon (AA), and they had gone to Panvel and had reached the Welcome Hotel. Anwar had gone with Tiger Memon (AA). lmtiyaz and the appellant (A28) were directed to reach the tower alongwith the other coaccused. They had gone to Goregaon, Raigad and had slept there at night. At about 3.30 in the morning, Tiger Memon (AA) had come with a truck carrying lmtiyaz, Anwar, Dadabha1 (A17), Dawoodbhai (A-14) and about 20-25 labourers. The appellant (A-28) had woken up and realized that there were also two more jeeps and one truck. Silver bricks were removed from D the truck that had been brought by Tiger Memon and the same were loaded into all the vehicles standing at the tower. The appellant (A-28) alongwith Rafique Madi, had taken 18 silver bricks and had thereafter, proceeded towards Hyderabad. In Kolhapur, they had handed over the goods to Pradeep Chandra Jain and had thereafter, returned to Bombay with an empty E vehicle.
c
After this, on 5.2.1993 at about 12.30 A.M., when he was returning from shooting (as he has claimed that he worked in movies, particularly in stunts), he had been called by Tiger F Memon (AA), and had been asked to go to Mhasla. Yeda Yakub who was also there, had given him the keys to a Matador tempo, which belonged to Abdul Samad, a decorator in Mahim. He had gone to Mhasla alongwith Suleman (A-18) and Gani (A-11) and there he had met Dawood Bhai who had taken them G near the tower, and had told them that the goods had been kept in a pit, and that it would take some time to remove them. Dawood (A-14) had then asked him, alongwith the others to return at around 7-7.30 a.m. with a vehicle. From there he had gone to the house of a lady (school teacher) in Mhasla Village, H and had eaten and also rested there. In the evening, they had
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @AS. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. S.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
gone to the tower. It was a moon-lit night, and at the said time Dawood (A-14) and Dadabhai (A-17), alongwith their 10-15 servants had come there and had proceeded to load the goods, i.e. 55-60 sacks into the vehicle that had been brought by him. Some empty sacks were also put in after folding the same over the goods. They had then gone to the Welcome Hotel at Panvel. Tiger Memon had also come there. Tiger Memon had sent Gani (A-11) and Suleman (A-18) to the Persian Darbar Hotel. Then Tiger Memon had gone inside the Welcome Hotel with the appellant (A-28), they had met one fair and tall person who had brown eyes. The appellant (A-28) had been introduced to him by Tiger Memon (AA), and was also directed to work in accordance with his instructions. On being asked, the appellant (A-28) had disclosed that he (A-28) had also seen the Delhi Darbar Hotel in Dahisar Check Naka. Then, the fair tall man had told the appellant (A-28) to park the said vehicle in front of the hotel, on the other side of the road and had told him that one Shakeel (A-59) would meet him there, who would then unload the vehicle. As per the instructions of Shakeel, the appellant (A-28) had proceeded to park the vehicle. A Nepali had then come there, and some persons had unloaded the goods from the vehicle and had then brought the said vehicle back to the Delhi Darbar Hotel, after which, the appellant (A28) had left for Virar in the said vehicle. Subsequently on 8.2.1993, at about 6-6.30 in the evening, Anwar had met the appellant (A-28) at Sandra Talab naka and had asked him to go to Mhasla again. The appellant (A-28) had gone there alongwith Yakub. Tiger Memon (AA) had.also arrived there after about one hour alongwith a jeep. He had given the jeep to Suleman (A-18) and thereafter, told him to leave. The appellant (A-28) upon the instructions of Tiger Memon (AA), had returned alongwith the vehicle and had handed over the said vehicle to Gani (A-11) and returned to Sandra Talab. Anwar had then paid Rs.5,000/- to the appellant (A-28) in the evening, in lieu of the aforementioned job. The appellant (A-28) had thus been working continuously for Tiger Memon. However, he had ·.:,\·,\.
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
been unaware of the contents or nature of the goods. It was only after the Bombay Blast had taken place on 12.3.1993, and when Tiger Memon's name had appeared in the newspapers, that the appellant (A-28) had realised that he had committed a mistake by participating in the said landing and transportation, B as he thought that perhaps, instead of silver and gold, it had actually been weapons that were smuggled in by him. He was arrested during the shooting of a movie, in which he was working.
C
150. Confessional Statement of Abdul Gani Ismail Turk (A-11 ):
His confessional statement has revealed that the appellant (A-28) had been at the residence of Tiger Memon (AA) at the Al-Husseini building. When he had gone there on 4.2.1993, D after about 4-5 days, he had met Suleman Kasam Ghavate (A-. 18) and Sayyed Abdul Rehman (A-28). They also had a tempo with them. Tiger had given Gani (A-11) a sum of Rs.1 lakh and had asked him to go alongwith the appellant (A-28) and Suleman Mohammed Kasam Ghavte (A-18), to pay the said E amount to Dawood Taklya (A-14), and while returning, to bring back with them, the black soap. It was the same black soap which had been brought to the tower on the night of 3.2.1993. The tempo was thus loaded by the appellant (A-28), alongwith Suleman Mohammed Kasam Ghavte (A-18) and several F others. The same finally contained 59 boxes of chemical, and was brought to Bombay, after which he had met Tiger Memon. 151. Confessional Statement of Dawood Taklya Mohammed Phanse (A-14): In his confession, he has revealed that after collecting the smuggled goods, he alongwith others, including the appellant (A-28) had reached the tower. Tiger Memon (AA) had instructed all the persons to remain outside, except his own men. Tiger Memon (AA) had even asked the watchman (A-62) to leave. H Tiger Memon (AA) had further instructed them to remove all the
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
empty boxes and jute cloth from there, and to burn the same. At the time when they had gone inside, they had seen that the men of Tiger were opening boxes, and that they were placing rifles, pistols, bullets, hand grenades, bundles of wire with white pencils on top of them, and black soap like material on the side. Tiger Memon (AA) was seen sitting on the side and after counting, he would make notes in his diary. Baba, Driver (A73) and the appellant (A-28), were among the men of Tiger Memon who were opening the cavities of the jeeps and tempos parked there. At this time, Tiger Memon (AA) took out a pencil like thing made of white steel like material, and showed the same to him (A-14) and to Dadabhai (A-17). He had told them that each object was worth Rs.25,000/- and that the same could even be used to explode the Oberoi Hotel. 152. Confessional Statement of Sharif Parkar @ Dadabhai (A-17):
c
His confessional statement has disclosed that on 7.2.1993 Gani (A-11) had come with a tempo. He had been accompanied by Miya@ Suleman Ghavte (A-18) and Sayyed Abdul Rehman Shaikh (A-28). At this time, Gani (A-11) had brought Rs.1 lakh with him and had given the same to Dawood Taklya (A-14 ). The smuggled goods were loaded into the tempo, which then left for Bombay.
153. Confessional statement of Suleman Mohammed Kasam Ghavate (A-18):
This accused (A-18) in his confessional statement disclosed that he reached Mhasla on 6.2.1993 alongwith appellant (A-28) and A-11, A-14 and A-17 were already present there. They put 59-63 packets containing powder in a vehicle. While they were coming back they met Tiger Memonn (AA) in Panvel. On 8th February, 1993, A-18 drove a white tempo as directed by Anwar and got off at Panvel. After some time, another yellow tempo, driven by appellant (A-28) arrived there in which A-16 sat and drove upto Mahad. They reached in front
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
A of Besawa Hotel in Mahad where another tempo, driven by appellant A-28 appeared and then they went to Mhasla where goods were divided in both the tempos. On their way to Panvel, he saw Tiger Memon (AA) in a car and he asked A-18 to take the tempo to Chilparakalyan. When they reached 8 Chilparakalyan, they met Tiger Memon (AA). Tiger Memon drove the tempo himself and came back with an empty tempo •in half an hour. 154. Shakil Shahbuddin Shaikh (A-59) and Shahnawaz Khan S/o Faiz Mohmed Khan (A-128) in their C confessional statements have supported the case of the prosecution, as they have stated that the appellant (A-28) had participated in the !anding and transportation. 155. Deposition of Uttam K. Kale (PW.190) - He deposed that he has recorded the confession ofappellant (A28). On 1.6.1993, .appellant (A-28) expressed his willingness to make a voluntary confession because of repentance and denied being induced or coerced. He was givEln 48 hours to re-think and he recorded his statement on 4.6.1993 as he was E busy on 3.6.1993. The said witness identified the confessional statement of A-28 in court.
o
156. Deposition of Vijay Govind More (PW.137) - He deposed that he was working as labourer at Wangni Tower. He wrongly identified the appellant (A-28) as Anwar and in his F statement did not name appellant (A-28) but corroborated in general particulars in respect of transportation of goods smuggled at Shekhadi. He also stated that goods were unloaded at Wangni Tower and shifted in another vehicle and at that time Tiger Memon (AA) and Dawood Taklya (A-14) G among others were present. 157. Dileep M. Katarmal (PW.284) in his statement has deposed that A-17 has purchased a few dozens gunny bags from his shop on 10.2.1993, though he did not name the H appellant (A-28) specifically but he corroborated in general
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
particulars the confession of appellant (A-28) wherein he stated that he alongwith Najeeb had purchased 1500 sacks from the said shop.
158. Considering the material contained in the confession of the appellant (A-28), and in those of the aforesaid co- B accused, it Was held that the same leads to the inescapable conclusion that the appellant (A-28) had intact been involved . in the Shekhadi landing operation, and had thus committed the offence under section 3(3) TADA. The evidence also establishes his involvement in the commission of the offence of cons~iracy to commit terrorist acts since the appellant (A- . C 28) was certainly aware of the nature of the contraband material, and had still transported the same, the said act amounts to furthering the object of the conspiracy to commit terrorist acts. However, it was held that the appellant (A-28) had not committed any acts and had not participated in any D conspiratorial meetings, to denote that he had been a party to the conspiracy to c~mmit the serial bomb Blast or the larger conspiracy i.e. the first charge. 159. So far as the appellan~ (A-28) is concerned, his confessional statement which standS' corroborated by the confessional statements of the other co-accused, particularly, Abdul Gani Ismail Turk (A-11), Dawood@ Dawood Taklya (A14), lmtiyaz Yunusmiya Ghavte (A-15), Sharif Abdul Gafoor Parkar @ Dadabhai (A-17) and Shahnawaz Khan (A-128) reveals his involvement in the Shekhadi landing and further establishes that he had been fully aware of the· nature of contents of the contraband and had still transported the same. Such an act tantamounts to furthering the object of the conspiracy to commit terrorist acts. Taking into consideration his close association with Tiger Memon (AA) and his associates, with respect to their smuggling activities, it is difficult to believe that he was unaware of the nature of the contents. Thus, we are of the view that he has rightly been convicted under Section 3(3) TADA by the Designated Court.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
Ill. Sajjad Alam @Igbal Abdul Hakim Nazir (A-61) :
160. The appellant (A-61) has been convicted under Section 3(3) TADA on two counts, and has been awarded 7 years rigorous imprisonment alongwith a fine of Rs. 50,000/-, B and in default of payment of fine, to suffer suitable RI. 161. The appellant (A-61) has been charged for criminal conspiracy, and in addition thereto, has also been charged under Section 3(3) for his participation in the landing at Shekhadi on 3rd and 7th February, 1993 and in the C transportation of arms, ammuni~ion, hand grenades and explosives like ROX which were to be used in the Bombay Blast on 12.3.1993, and further, for using his auto rickshaw bearing registration No.MH-06-2243 to bring the aforementioned smuggled items to Bombay. He has been acquitted of the first D charge of conspiracy, however, he has been convicted of the second charge under Section 3(3), and has been sentenced as referred to hereinabove. 162. Ms. Farhana Shah, learned counsel for the appellant E has submitted that his confession had not been made voluntarily, and that the same had been retracted on 3.12.93 and therefore, must not be taKen into consideration. Hence, the appeal deserves to be allowed.
163. Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel for the respondent, has submitted that even if the confessional statement of the appellant (A-61) was retracted. the same has been corroborated by the confessional statements of the other co-accused, as well as by the depositions of various witnesses. Therefore, this appeal deserves to be dismissed. 164. We have considered the rival submissions made by learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. 165. Evidence against the appellant CA-61 ):
(a)
Confessional stc.tement of the appellant (A-61)
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, .J.]
(b)
Confessional statement of Dawood Taklya (A-14)
(c)
· Confessional statement of Khalil Ahmed Sayed Ali Nasir (A-42)
(d)
Confessional statement of lmtiyaz Yunusmiya Ghavte (A-15)
(e)
Confessional statement of Muzammil Umar Kadri • (A-25)
(f)
Confessional statement of Tulsiram Dhondu Surve (A-62)
(g)
Deposition of Vijay Govind More (PW-137)
(g) - Depositions of Chandrakant Afaraz (PW-111 ), Vyankatesh Hirba (PW-588) and Shridhar Gawade (PW-151).
c
166. Confessional Statement of Sajjad Alam @ Igbal Abdul Hakim Nazir CA-61 ): His own confession has been recorded by Shri K.L. Bishnoi, DCP (PW.193), wherein he has revealed that he had taken certain persons in his auto rickshaw bearing No. MH-062243, to the place of the landing. He had seen that certain materials had been removed in gunny bags from a jeep i.e. 16 rifles and 32 cassettes and that the same were taken into a room where the appellant (A.61) was not allowed to enter. He had been paid Rs.4,000/- for participating in two landings. He has further revealed that on 9.2.1993 Dawood Taklya (A-14) had met him at the Mhasla S.T. Stop and had asked him to come to Mehandari. He (A-61) had taken him to Mehandari where they met Khalil Nazir and Muzammil (A-25). Here, Dawood had told Muzammil to hand over to him 3 rifles and 6 cassettes. Muzammil had then handed over the said weapons in gunny bag~. The appellant (A-61), Khalil and
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
Dawood Taklya (A-14) had gone alongwith the said arms, to Lonery Phata. After sometime Tiger Memon (AA) had arrived there in his blue Maruti car and thereafter, the said goods were shifted to his car.
167. Confessional Statement of Dawood Taklya (A14):
He has disclosed that on the date of the landing, Tiger Memon (AA) had sent him to the place of landing alongwith some persons who had also been given guns by Tiger Memon C {AA). Such armed persons were spread over all sides. After sometime the said goods had arrived in a trawler. Persons who had been called from the village then began to unload these goods and bringing them to shore. Khalil and Iqbal (A-61) had also come there with trucks. The entire cargo was loaded into D two trucks and thereafter, they all come to T.V. Tower, where the said goods were unloaded. Some time after this, Tiger had instructed them to remove all the empty boxes and jute bags from there and to burn the same When they had gone inside, they had seen the men of Tiger opening boxes which contained E rifles, pistols, bullets, hand grenades, black soap and bundles of wires with wrnte pencils on top. 168. Confessional Statement of Khalil Ahmed Sayed Ali Nasir tA-42): His statement has disclosed that the aforementioned goods were smuggled. He had gone to the house of Dawood Taklya (A-14) in the afternoon at about 4 p.m. to inform him that the landing of the said goods would take place that night, and that appellant (A-61) should thus be sent to Dawood Taklya at G 7 p.m. by Rickshaw. On the said day he had sent appellant (A61) from Mehandari to Mhasla in his Rickshaw.
169. Confessional Statement of lmtiyaz Yunusmiya Ghavte (A-15):
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STJl:TE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.)
He has deposed about the landing at Shekhadi in early February. He had gone to Tiger's residence at the Al-Husseini Building, and it was there that he had learnt of the said landing. Shaffi and Rafiq were also present there at such time. From there, they had gone to Shekhadi for the landing alongwith a large number of persons, and after the landing, the goods were brought to the Wangni Tower. The appellant (A-61) had been present at the Tower with his Rickshaw. 170. Confessional Statement of Muzammil Umar Kadri (A-25):
c
His.confessional statement has disclosed that on 3.2.1993, in the evening at about 7.30 p.m. he had been told by Khalil from Mehandari, that he should stay alongwith Suleman (A-18), at a particular house. When he had gone there, he had found Sajjad Alam (A-61) Rickshawala there. The appellant (A-61) D had come there after having dropped Dawood Taklya (A-14) and Khalil to Shekhadi. He has further furnished otner details regarding the landing on 7.2.1993. He has said that at 11.30 p.m., Dawood (A-14) had come in the rickshaw of the appellant (A-61), and had collected 3 rifles and 6 cassettes which had E been kept with him in January, 1993. The remaining 13 rifles and 26 cassettes were recovered by the police from his house later on.
.
171. Confessional statement of Tulsi Ram Dhondu Surve (A-62):
He is· a government employee and working at Wangni tower. He has identified A-61 and named him as a participant in smuggling, landing and transporation. 172. Deposition of Vijay Govind More (PW-137): He has deposed that he was a labourer working at the Tower, and has identified the appellant (A-61) in court as the person who had come to the Tower quite often. He has also
C
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
named him as .a participant in smuggling, landing and transportation. 173. Chandrakant Afaraz (PW-111 ), Vyankatesh Hirba (PW-588), PSI of the Mhasla Police Station and Shridhar Gawade (PW-151) have proved the Seizure Memo of the autorickshaw and the related panchnama. 174. After due consideration of the entire evidence on record, the Designated Court came to the conclusion that the appellant (A-61) being involved in the Shekhadi landing operation, has committed the offence under section 3(3) TADA. The appellant (A-61) was a close associate of Dawood Taklya (A-14) and had participated and/or assisted Dawood Taklya (A14) in effecting the said landing. The appellant (A-61) had also taken Dawood Taklya (A-14) and his other associates to the Shekhadi coast, at odd hours ·of the night for the purpose of the landing operation. Even prior to the ~aid landing, the appellant'(A-61) had been involved in the concealment of rifles and magazines at residence of Muzammil Umar Kadri (A-25), and thereafter on 9.2.1993, had transported rifles and magazines from the house of Muzammil Umar Kadri (A-25) and had handed over the same to Tiger Memon (AA) at Lonery Phata. The appellant (A-61) had also received an amount of Rs. 4000/- for the work done by him in the landing operation. 175. The evidence on record clearly establishes the above and thus, the fact that he was one of the main persons who was responsible for effecting the said landing. Hence, he has rightly been convicted by the learned Special Judge under Section 3(3) TADA, and no interference is required in the said order. IV. Tulsi Ram Dhondu Surve (A-62) : 176. He was a watchman at the Wangni Tower which was permitted to be used by the appellant (A-62), for the reloading of weapons and explosives from one vehicle to another. The appellant (A-62) has been charged for criminal conspiracy, and
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
in addition thereto, for his participation in the landing and transportation of arms, ammunition, hand grenades and explosives like ROX to be used in the Bombay blast on 12.3.1993.
He has been further charged with abetting and facilitating B acts that were preparatory to the main terrorist acts, in January to February 1993 at Shekhadi and places close by, as well as at Wangni Tower, District Raigad. The main terrorist acts were executed in Bombay on 12.3.1993 in the form of multiple bomb Blast. This was done by the appellant (A-62), permitting C Dawood@ Dawood Taklya (A-14), Tiger Memon (AA) and his associates to use the said premises for the. purpose of facilitating the smuggling and landing of arms, ammunition, handgrenades and explosives like ROX; which were smuggled into the country by Tiger Memon and his associates on 3rd and 7th February, 1993. The tower was used for re-loading and 0 transportation of the contraband into Bombay and other places. He has further been charged with permitting Dawood Taklya (A-14), Tiger Memon (AA) and his associates to conceal 59 bags of ROX explosives in his agricultural field which were removed subsequently by the terrorists. He has further been charged, being a government servant, of having failed to furnish information in relation to th~ smuggled weapons, which he was legally bound to do and can therefore, be said to have committed the offence punishable under Section 202 IPC.
177. The appellant (A-62) has been acquitted of the first charge. However, he has been given the sentence of 9 years alongwith a fine of Rs.50,000/- and in default of payment of fine, G he has been ordered to suffer further RI for one year under Section .3(3) TADA, and of 6 months alongwith a fine of Rs.5,000/- under Section 202 IPC. 178. Ms. Farhana Shah, learned counsel for the appellant
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
has submitted that the appellant (A-62) was a watchman at the Wangni tower and that he had no knowledge of the contents of the contraband goods. Moreover, he has served over 6 years of the sentence awarded to him. He should at most therefore, be tried under Section 202 IPC. Hence, the appeal deserves to be allowed. 179. Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the State has submitted that he was aware of the contents of the smuggled goods as the same had been unloaded in front of him. Therefore, the appeal deserves to be dismissed. 180. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. 181. Evidence against the appellant (A-62):
(a)
Confessional statement of the appellant (A-62)
(b}
Confession of Dawood Taklya (A-14)
(c)
Confession of Sharif Abdul Gafoor Parkar (A-17)
(d}
Confession of Munna @ Mohammed Ali Khan (A24)
(e)
Confession of Rashid Umar Alware (A-27)
(f)
Confession of Khalil Ahmed Sayed Ali Nasir (A-42)
(g}
Confessional statement of Sajjad Alam (A-61)
(h)
Deposition of Harish Chandra Surve (PW.108)
(i)
Deposition of Vijay Govind More (PW.137)
0)
Deposition of Ravindra Sarant (PW.145)
(k)
Deposition of Vyankatesh Hirba (PW.588)
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN. J.]
182. Confessional Statement of Tulsi Ram Dhondu Surve (A-62)
In his confession, Tulsiram Dhondu Surve (A-62) has disclosed that he had been working as a watchman at the Tower alongwith other employees, namely, Harish Chandra . "B Surve (PW-108) and Vijay Govind More (PW-137). He has disclosed that one and a half years prior to the recording of his statement. one Sharif Adhikari of Mhasla had brought Dawood Phanse (A-14) to him, who had asked the said appellant (A62) to help them in the smuggling of silver and other goods, by C allowing them to keep the same in the Tower for some time, in return for some consideration, and that he had agreed to the same. At night, 9-10 persons had come alongwith Tiger Memon (AA), and one truck and a jeep. They had loaded the goods into a tempo from the truck. At the said time, Tiger Memon (AA) and his associates had been armed with guns and pistols, and D after completing the loading they had all left the Tower. The appellant (A-62) had been paid Rs.1000/- for each occasion, which he had shared with other persons. He also received 10 acres of land in his name, which was a benami property, as the same belonged to Dawood (A-14). He has further disclosed E that he had also been paid a sum of Rs.2000/- and for two or more trips, a sum of Rs.6000/- which he had distributed among others. 183. Confessional Statement of Sajjad Alam CA-61) : In his confession, he has corroborated the evidence available as regards the meeting with Tulsiram Dhondu Surve (A-62). Though Dawood Taklya (A-14) did not name him, he has corroborated the evidence of the other co-accused by stating that A-62 had been helping them at the Tower for loading and unloading etc. Khalil Ahmed (A-42) has stated that when the smuggled goods were being reloaded, the same consisted of 59 gunny bags containing a· cement like black soap, 91 boxes and 7 long canvas bags. Vijay Govind More (PW-137) has deposed that the landing had taken place in
C
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2013) 16 S.C.R.
February 1993, and that the goods had then been brought to the Tower and that from there, the same were shifted into the jeep. He has identified the appellant (A-62) in court. Ravindra Sawant (PW-145) was the panch witness for the recovery of goods at the Tower, and has also identified A-62 in court. 184. Deposition of Vijay Govind More (PW.137) He deposed that at the relevant time he was working as labourer at Wangni Micro Wave Tower since 1986 to 1993. In October 1992 he was on duty at Wangni Tower alongwith Harishchandra Surve. On that day appellant (A-62) was also on duty at the Tower and the appellant (A-62) told them that one party shall come at the Tower on the said day in the night. Appellant (A-62) after his duty left Wangni Tower for his residence and returned at about 7.30 to 8.30 p.m. At about 9.30 p.m three persons came by a Maruti car at Wangni Tower. Out of them, Sarfaraj Phanse called for appellant (A-62) and asked him to arrange for tea. Appellant and the witness prepared tea. Subsequently, Tiger Memon, Dawood Phanse, Sharif Adhikari, Abdul Gharatkar, Dadamiya Parkar also came there. At about 11 p.m., a truck came at Wangni Tower. Following the same, one tempo and two jeeps also arrived. The goods which had been brought in the said truck were loaded into jeeps and tempo and then all the vehicles left the Tower. Again in February 1993 when the witness was on duty, the appellant (A-62) told him that goods of Dawood Phanse had to arrive. After the duty hours, appellant (A-62) went to his house and again returned to the tower in the evening. At about 8.30 p.m., three persons came by a car. One of them was Iqbal whom the witness had seen at Wangni Tower in earlier trip alongwith others. After about 11 p.m., one truck, two jeeps and a tempo arrived at Wangni Tower. Dawood Phanse, Sharif Adhikari, Abdul Gharatkar, Dadamiya Parkar also came. Just thereafter, Dawood Phanse and his companions arrived in a jeep. This witness identified the appellant (A-62) and other accused, namely, accused nos.14, 17, 28, 42, 60, 61 and 73.
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
185. After due consideration of the entire evidence on record, the Designated Court came to the conclusion that as the appellant (A-62), was involved in the Shekhadi landing operati~n. he has committed the offence under section 3(3) TADA. The appellant (A-62) being a watchman of the Wangni Tower i.e. government premises, had allowed the same to be used for purpose of facilitating the smuggling and landing of arms, ammunition, .hand grenades and explosives that was organized by Tiger Memon (AA) and his associates. The appellant (A-62) had also permitted the co-accused to conceal 59 bags of ROX explosives in his field. Hence he was held guilty for the offence punishable under Section 3(3) TADA.
/
c
186. So far as appellant (A-62) is concerned, the evidence on record, particularly the confessional statement of the appellant (A!62), which has been duly supported by the other material on record, clearly reveals that being a watchman of D government premises i.e. Wangni Tower he had allowed the same to be used for the purpose of facilitating the smuggling and landing of arms, ammunition, handgrenades and e)tplosives as organized by Tiger Memon (AA) and his associates. The evidence further establishes his involvement E in concealing 59 bags of RDX explosives in a field existing in his name. Thus, he has rightly been convicted by the learned Special Judge under Section 3(3) TADA and Sect)on 202 IPC. Being a government servant, he has intentionally omitted giving information to the authorities about the offences committed in F his presence, which he was legally bound to do. Thus, no interference is required in his order of punishment. V. Gulam ·Hafiz Shaikh @ Baba CA-73):
187. The appellant (A-73) has been charged for the offence of criminal conspiracy and in addition thereto, for his participation in the landing at Shekhadi and the transportation of arms, ammunition, hand grenades and explosives like RDX t0<be used in the Bombay Blast on 12.3.1993, under Section
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
3(3) TADA and has further been charged under Section 6 TADA for the possession/storage of arms, ammunition and explosives in his garage, in contravention of the provisions of the Arms Act and the Rules thereunder, by transporting such unauthorized arms, ammunitions and explosives from Shekadi B to Bombay. He has been found guilty of the charge under Section 3(3) TADA and has been awarded the sentence of 8 years alongwith a fine of Rs.10,000/-, and in default of payment of fine, further RI for two months. He has further been found guilty under C Section 3(3) TADA for facilitating the landing and transportation of the aforementioned contraband, and has been awarded RI for 6 years alongwith a fine of Rs.5,000/- and in default of payment of fine, RI for one month. He has also been found guilty under Section 6 of TADA for possession and storage of the D said weapons in his garage and for this he has been given a sentence of RI for 8 years, alongwith a fine of Rs.10,000/- and in default, further RI for two months. All the sentences have been directed to run concurrently.
188. Ms. Farhana Shah, learned counsel for the appellant has submitted that there are contradictions in the statements of the co-accused, and that therefore, they should not be relied upon. Moreover, the confessional statements of the co-accused were taken at odd hours, and there is no other corroborative F evidence available against him. Therefore, the appeal deserves to be allowed. 189. Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel for the respondent has submitted that the appellant (A-73) was aware of the nature of the goods that he had kept in the false cavities G of the vehicles. Moreover, his confession has been corroborated by various co-accused. Therefore, the appeal deserves to be dismissed. 190. We have heard learned counsel for the parties and H perused the record.
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
191. Evidence against the appellant (A-73): (a)
Confessional Statement of Gulam Hafiz Shaikh @ Baba (A-73)
(b)
Confessional statement of Dawood Taklya (A-14)
(c)
Confessional statement of lmtiyaz Yunusmiya Ghavte (A-15)
(d)
Confessional Statement of Sharif Abdul Gafoor Parkar @ Dadabha1 (A-17)
(e)
Confessional statement of Mohammed Rafiq (A46)
(f)
Deposition of Vijay Govind More (PW .137)
(g)
Deposition of Vinod Lokhande (PW.183)
~
192. Confessional Statement of Gulam Hafiz Shaikh @ Baba CA-73) The confession of the appellant (A-73) was recorded by Shri Vinod Balwant Lokhande, D.C., Airport Zone, Bombay on 15.5.1993 and 17.5.1993. In his confessional statement, the appellant (A-73) has disclosed that he has been working in the garage of his maternal uncle since his childhood. His uncle had handed over the garage to him 27 years ago. He had been running the said garage for repairing vehicles. He knew Tiger Memon (AA) and his associates Sunil, Shaffi, lmtiyaz, Anwar, Rafique Madi, Raju Marwari, Riyaz, Majeed etc. They would do the work of smuggling silver. The same was unloaded at the sea-shore near the village Mhasla. The goods were to be brought by trucks to the Tower, and the contraband were then to be unloaded and concealed in the cavities of tempos and jeeps there. The work of the appellant (A-73) was to take the tempo or the jeep full of smuggled silver to its destination, and after this, he was paid a sum of Rs.2,000 to 3,000 for each
C
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
transµortation/landing. In the last week of January, 1993 he had reached the Welcome Hotel, Panvel alongwith the jeep at 8.30 p.m. upon receiving instructions to this effect. Four jeeps and a Maruti car were already parked there. Tiger and Sunil were also sitting in the jeep. The goods were smuggled in the next day with the help of a large number of persons including Tiger, Shaffi, Anwar, lmtiyaz, Gani and Rafique etc. The truck was then unloaded, and all goods were kept in the tempos and jeeps. There were several green coloured boxes containing black soap, and cartridges. The appellant (A-73) had parked the tempo full of smuggled goods outside his garage in lslampura. The appellant (A-73) had then gone to Persian Darbar Hotel upon being called by Tiger Memon. The .appellant (A-73) was asked by Tiger Memon to take the tempo outside his garage to Sankhvi street, opposite Bata Company, near Lokhandi gate near the place where Chiliyaki Hotel was situated. He was informed that there would be a boy at the gate who would give him a signal with a white handkerchief upon seeing the said tempo. The appellant (A-73) was told to take the vehicle as per his direction, and unload the goods there. The next day, the appellant (A-73) had taken the tempo to Sankhvi Street to the aforesaid address, and as per the direction, the goods were unloaded there. He had been paid Rs.1000 for this work. The appellant (A-73) has confessed that he had participated in landings of silver, and that it was only on one occasion that weapons had been smuggled.
193. Abdul Gani Ismail Turk (A-11), Dawood@ Dawood Taklya (A-14), lmtiyaz Yunusmiya Ghavte (A-15), and Mohd. Rafiq (A-46) have supported the case of the prosecution by stating that the appellant (A-73) participated in G the landing and transportation of the smuggled goods including arms, ammunition etc. 194. Confessional Statement of Sharif Abdul Gafoor Parkar
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.] @ Dadabhai (A-17)
·
In his confessional statement, he has disclosed details of the incident dated 28th /29th February, 1993: He has stated that at 1.30 - 2.00 a.m., the smuggled goods had been were brought in a lorry to the tower, and that Tiger Memon (AA), · Yakub {AA), Javed (AA), Dawood Taklya (A-14) and their men and others had also come there. Shafi, Anwar and driver Baba (appellant A~73) had opened the boxes and the same contained hand bombs, wires, rifles, pistols and bullets. The appellant (A-73) and others had put all the weapons and explosives into the cavities of jeeps and tempos. The goods C had also contained a chemical, black soap. 195. Deposition of Vijay Govind More (PW.137) He. was labourer ,at Wangni Tower and he had clearly deposed that appellan~ (A-73) was involved in the loading and unloading of smuggled goods at Wangni Tower. He identified the appellant (A-73) in court. 196. Deposition of Vinod Lokhande CPW.183) He has recorded the confessional statement of the appellant and he deposed that it was voluntary and had been made strictly in accordance with law and the confessional statement was forwarded to the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Alibagh. .
197. In view of the above, we have to consider whether in light of the evidence on record, the conviction of the appellants can be sustained. 198. All the material on evidence was collected and after appraisal, the Special Judge came to the conclusion that A73 had in fact been involved in the landing operations of the contraband substances. The evidence against appellant (A73) includes his own confession wherein he has confessed
C
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
(2013] 16 S.C.R.
to being fully aware of the fact that the contraband were shifted from trucks to other vehicles, which contained arms, ammunition and RDX. The Designated Court came to the conclusion that his act of driving the vehicle containing such material could not be for any purpose other than to aid and abet terrorist activities. However, the Designated Court has stated that the said acts had been committed by him in the early phases of the conspiracy, even prior to Tiger Memon (AA) deciding the target of the Blast. The court also went on to say that after this particular incident A-73 had not been involved io any landing job. Therefore, he (A-73) cannot be held guilty for the larger conspiracy, for which the charge firstly, was framed against him. 199. So far as appellant (A-73) is concerned, like other appellants, his involvement 'and participation in the landing operations of the contraband substances has been clearly established. His own confessional statement has revealed that he, being fully aware of the contents of the contraband, shifted the same from the truck to other vehicles and that in spite of the fact that he knew that the contraband contained arms, ammunition and RDX, he continued to be associated with the other co-accused. Therefore, he has aided and abetted terrorist activities, and we do not see any cogent reason to interfere with his order of conviction as recorded by the Designated Court.
200. In view of the above, we do not find any substance in these appeals and the same stand dismissed. 201. In case, if the appellants are on bail, their bail bonds are cancelled and they must surrender within four weeks from today, failing which the Learned Designated Court under TADA shall take them into custody, and send them to jail to serve out the remaining part of their sentences, as have been awarded by the learned Designated Court under TADA.
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
CRIMINAL APPEAL N0.600 OF 2011 State of Maharashtra
... Appellant
Versus Sayed Abdul Rehman Shaikh ... Respondent 202. This appeal has been preferred against the judgment and order dated 2.8.2007 passed by Special Judge of the the Designated Court under the TADA for Bombay Blast Case No.1 of 1993, by which the respondent has been convicted under Section 3(3) TADA, and awarded rigorous imprisonment for 7 years alongwith a fine of Rs.25,000/-, and in default of payment of fine, to suffer further RI for six months, and secondly RI for 7 years under Section 3(3) TADA, but had been acquitted of the charge of larger conspiracy.
C
Hence, this appeal. 203. Heard rival submissions by counsel for both parties and per.used the evidence on record. 204. The evidence against the said respondent includes his own confession wherein he had disclosed that he was a driver and was acquainted with Tiger Memon (AA}, Mohd. Rafiq (A-46), Anwar (AA), Abdul Gani Ismail Turk (A-11 }, Suleman Mohd. Kasam Ghavate (A-18) and Uttam Potdar (A-30). In April 1992, the accused (A-28) had gone along with Suleman Mohd. Kasam Ghavate (A-18) and Uttam Potdar (A-30) to Ajmer for taking silver. On 5.2.1993 Suleman Mohd. Kasain Ghavate (A18) took the accused (A-28) to Tiger Memon (AA) who asked him to go to Mhasla. Yeda Yakub gave the accused (A-28) the keys of a tempo in which the accused (A-28) alongwith Suleman Mohd. Kasam Ghavate (A-18) and Abdul Gani Ismail Turk (A11) went to Mhasla. On the next day, at Mhasla the accused (A-28) met Dawood Taklya (A-14) who took him alongwith other co-accused to Wangni Tower and told them that the goods are to be dug out from a pit. After the goods were taken out, they
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
were placed in the vehicle in the presence of Dawood Taklya (A-14). Then, they came to Nagothane (near Pen) and stayed in a hotel. The accused (A-28) alongwith Tiger Memon (AA) went inside Welcome Hotel wherein they met a man who told the accused (A-28) to park the vehicle in front of Hotel Delhi Darbar at Dahisar Check naka. The accused (A-28) parked the vehicle as directed and the goods were unloaded there with the help of some persons. The accused (A-28) again met Tiger Memon (AA) on 8.2.1993 and went to Mhasla alongwith Anwar and Tiger Memon and brought 1500 sacks from one Gujarati in Pen. On 11.2.1993 Tiger Memon met them at Goa Road and asked Suleman Mohd. Kasam Ghavate (A-18) and the accused (A-28) to accompany him till Kalyan, wherein they handed over the vehicle to Tiger's man, namely, Usman Gani Choudhary. The accused (A-28) was paid Rs.5,000/- for the said job.
205. The said confessional statement was duly supported and corroborated by the confessional statements of Abdul Gani Ismail Turk (A-11), Dawood Taklya (A-14), Suleman Mohd. Kasam Ghavate (A-18) and Uttam Potdar (A-30), Sharif Abdul Gafoor Pa.rkar (A-17) and Shakil Shabbuddin Shaikh (A-59).
C
206. Uttam M. Kale (PW.190) also supported the prosecutions case to the extent that the confessional statement was given by the accused (A-28) voluntarily and it had been recorded strictly in accordance with law. The deposition of Sanjay Pandey (PW.492) and Vijay Govind More (PW.137) also supported the case of the prosecution. 207. After appreciating the evidence on record the learned Designated Court recorded the conclusion as under :-
?"574) Thus in light of the reasoning given aforesaid, it will be difficult to accept submission of Ld. Chief P.P. to give maximum punishment to A-18 & 28 for the reasons canvassed by him and dealt earlier and so also for any other reason, which is also precisely absent. At the cost
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
of repetition, it will be necessary to say that even it is accepted that smuggling of arms, ammunition and explosives substance, even accepted to be very heinous merely on said count awarding i 11C1ximum punishment to each of the accused involved in such landings de hors considering the extent of act committed by him and thereby assessing the element of criminality exist in him would amount allowing oneself to be swayed by feeling and would amount ·of having acted without any logical reasoning behind it. Having regard to the same while awarding punishment to A-18 & 28 it will be necessary to take into account the gravity of the act committed by both of them and so also the other circumstances relevant to same as urged on their behalf or even otherwise." 208. The parameters laid down by this court in entertaining the appeal against the order of acquittal have to be applied. 209. The instant case is similar as that of Suleman Mohd. Kasam Ghavate (A-18) and therefore, we are not in a position to take a view different to the view taken in that case.
C
The appeal lacks merit and is accordingly dismissed. CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 406 OF 2011 State of Maharashtra
... Appellant
Versus Gu lam Hafiz @ Baba
... Respondent
210. This appeal has been preferred against the judgment and order dated 2.8.2007 passed by Special Judge of the Designated Court under the TADA for Bombay Blast Case No.1 of 1993, by which the. respondent has been convicted under Section 3(3) TADA and awarded rigorous imprisonment for 8 years with a fine of Rs. 10,000/- and in
C
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
default of payment of fine, to suffer further RI for 2 months on the first count and on second count he has been awarded under Section 3(3) TADA, a rigorous imprisonment for 6 years with a fine of Rs.5,000/- and in default of payment of fine, to suffer furtfier RI for one month. 211. In addition to the general charge of conspiracy the Respondent (A-73) was charged for participating alongwith his co-conspirators in the smuggling and landing of arms and ammunition at Shekhadi and participating in transportation of the same from Shekhadi to Bombay for committing terrorist activities. He was further charged under the provisions of Arms Act for possessing/storing the weapons at his garage and unauthorisedly transporting smuggled weapons from Shekhadi to Bombay. 212. After conclusion of the trial, the respondent had been convicted under Section 3(3) TADA, but had been acquitted of the first charge of conspiracy. Hence, this appeal.
213. Heard rival submissions made by counsel for both parties and perused the evidence on record. 214. The learned Special Judge after considering the evidence on record against the respondent recorded the following findings:"61-C) Thus considering material in the confession of A73 and aforesaid co-accused the same leads to the conclusion of A-73 also being involved in Shekadi landing operations denoted by said material and as such having committed offence under Section 3(3) of TADA for which he is charged at head 2ndly. Similarly, considering said evidence in proper perspective and same and particularly own confession of A-73 squarely denoting that he was fully aware that contraband goods which were shifted from
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. S.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
trucks lo other vehicles where arms, ammunition, handgrenades and ROX etc. and still himself having transported the same to Bombay by driving vehicle and even in Bombay having committed further acts regarding contraband goods the same clearly indicates that his act were directed to further object of conspiracy to commit terrorist act. No doubt that he has received amount of Rs.1 thousand for work effected by him. However the same will never change character of act committed by him. Similarly the acts committed by him were obviously for purposes of aiding and abetting terrorist accused who were to use the same for commission of terrorist act. A- 73 having committed said act by contravening provision of Arms and Explosive Act he was also required to be held liable for offence under Section 6 of TADA for which he charged at head 3rdly. However unlike other accused involved in transportation alike A-73, A-73 after Shekhadi landing operation had not participated in commission of any act furthering object of any conspiracy. The acts were committed by him during early phase i.e. much prior to even Tiger Memon fixing target for commission of serial blast. A-73 had never been party to any conspiratorial meeting after effecting said landing job nor was involved in any of operation thereafter effected in pursuance of conspiracy to commit serial blast. In view of same though A-73 is found to be guilty for offence of conspiracy the same would be conspiracy to commit terrorist act punishable under Section 3(3) of TADA or in other words he cannot be held liable for larger conspiracy for which charge at head 1stly is framed against him." 215. In view of the fact that there is no evidence to show that the respondent (A-73) ever participated in any of the conspiratorial meetings after the said landing, or was involved in any of the operation thereafter in pursuance of the conspiracy to commit the serial Blast, he could be punished only for smaller conspiracy under Section 3(3) TADA and not for the larger
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
conspiracy for which the charge no.1 had been framed. In the facts and circumstances of the case, the respondent (A-73) had been convicted and awarded sufficient punishment.
216. The parameters laid down by this court in entertaining B the appeal against the order of acquittal have to be applied.
c
217. In view of the above, we do not find any cogent reason to hold that findings recorded by the learned Designated Court are perverse, warranting any interference by this Court. The appeal lacks merit and is accordingly dismissed.
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 408 OF 2011 State of Maharashtra
... Appellant
Versus
Suleman Kasam Ghavate ... Respondent
218. This appeal has been preferred agl:iinst the judgment and order dated 2.8.2007 passed by the Special Judge of the Designated Court under the TADA for Bombay Blast Case No.1 of 1993 by which the respondent has been convicted under Section 3(3) TADA on two counts and awarded rigorous imprisonment for 7 years with a fine of Rs. 25,000/- and in default of payment of fine, to Suffer further RI for a period of six months on one count and 7 years rigorous imprisonment under Section 3(3) TADA on the second count. However, he had been acquitted of the first charge of conspiracy.
219. The appeal has basically been filed only for enhancement of punishment, or for conviction of the respondent G for main charge of conspiracy. In addition to the first charge, the general charge of conspiracy had been framed for participating in the landing and transportation of contraband at Shekhadi for commission of terrorist activities; for transporting the smuggled contraband, including weapons' through his H tempo bearing no.MMP-4799 from Shekhadi to Panvel for
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v, STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
committing terrorist acts; and further for participating in weapons training at Shekhadi. Out of the said charges, the charge of participation in weapons' training at Shekhadi was not proved. Hence, this appeal.
220. Heard rival submissions made by the counsel for both parties and perused the evidence on record .. 221. The evidence against the said respondent has been his own confession which had been retracted and it had been corroborated by the confessional statements of Abdul Gani Ismail Turk (A-11), Parvez Nazir Ahmed Shaikh (A-12), Sayyed Abdul Rehman Shaikh (A-28), Liyakat Ali Habib Khan and Sharif AbduLGafoor Parkar (A-17). His.involvement in the crime has also been corroborated by the deposition of Uttam M. Kale (PW.190) in whose presence the confessional statement of coaccused had been recorded. Deposition of Vijay Govind More (PW.137), a labourer at Wangni Tower and Sanjay Pandey (PW.492) have also supported the case of the prosecution. The Designated Court appreciated the evidence and held as under:"Thus, considering material in the confession of A-18 and aforesaid co-accused the same leads to the conclusion of A-18 also being involved in Shekhadi landing operation as denoted by said material and as such having committed offence under Section 3(3) of TADA for which he is charged at head 2ndly clauses 'a' and 'b' to the extent of transportation of contraband material of the said landing effected by him. Similarly, considering the manner in which he had acted in the said episode for furthering the object of conspiracy to commit terrorist act as denoted by said material the same also establishes his involvement in commission of offence of conspiracy to commit terrorist act punishable u/s. 3(3) of TADA. Now taking up work of determining sentence for A-18 &
c
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
28 in light of submission canvassed at Bar, reasoning given during earlier part of judgment and particularly declaration made in consequent to same on 11th of October, 2006 regarding A-18 and 17th Oct., 2006 regarding A-28 reveals that though both of them were charged for commission of offence of conspiracy and for commission of offence under Section 3(3) of TADA i.e. A18 on 3 sub-counts & A-28 on 2 sub-counts each of them was found guilty for commission of offence only on two subcounts to the extent as found during the assessment of evidence for commission of offences punishable under Section 3(3) of TADA. Without unnecessarily reiterating every aspect connected with decision arrived accordingly, in short it can be said that both of them are found guilty accordingly mainly due to acts committed by each of them in connection with Shekhadi Landings and/or transportation of contraband goods smuggled by effecting the said landings. The said landing was effected by Tiger Memon on two occasions in month of February, 1993 in which Tiger Memon and his associates at the behest of absconding accused Dawood Ibrahim has smuggled arms, ammunition and explosives and transported same from Shekhadi Coast via Wangni Tower to Bombay. The evidence surfaced and/or reasoning given thereon earlier also reveal that both A-18 & 28 since earlier had close association with Tiger Memon and were carrying out the work of Drivers for transportation of smuggled goods and in the questioned landing they had transported the contraband goods in a manner as discussed in the earlier part of the judgment. The reasons given earlier in terms reveal the evidence having established that both of them were men of confidence of Tiger Memon. The same also reveals that they were aware and/or had become aware about the nature of the goods which they were transporting and/or had transported. Having regard to the same and having regard to the fact that both of them, even after
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. S.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
acquiring the knowledge had not taken any steps revealing that they were against transportation of such a contraband goods, which was arms and ammunition and RDX material and since the act committed by them being in the nature of furthering the object of conspiracy to commit terrorists act, they were held guilty for the offence of a conspiracy to the said extent. Since, evidence has not revealed that both these accused had committed any further acts after the said transportation and/or thereafter A-18 having stopped the work for Anwar at the behest of whom he was involved in the said work and so also both of them being not connected with any of the operation effected for achieving the object of entire conspiracy i.e. both of them being not involved in acquiring the training, attending conspiratorial meetings, in which the targets were selected etc. they could not be held guilty for commission of offence of conspiracy to commit the serial bomb blast etc."
c
222. The parameters laid down by this court in entertaining the appeal against the order of acquittal have to be applied. 223. We do not see any cogent reason to interfere with the impugned judgment. The appeal lacks merit and is accordingly dismissed.
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1034 OF 2012 State of Maharashtra
.. Appellant
Versus Tulsi Ram Dondu Surve
... Respondent
224. This appeal has been preferred against the judgment and order dated 2.8.2007 passed by Special Judge of the Designated Court under the TADA for Bombay Blast case, Greater Bombay in B.B.C. No.1 of 1993. The respondent Tulsi Ram Dondu Surve (A-62), has been found guilty for offences
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013) 16 S.C.R.
punishable under Section 3(3) TADA. and on the said count, has been convicted and sentenced to suffer RI for 9 years and a fine of Rs.50,000/- and in default, to suffer further RI for one year. He has also been found guilty under Section 202 IPC, and sentenced to suffer RI for 6 months and ordered to pay a fine B of Rs.5,000/-, and in default of payment of fine, he was ordered to suffer further RI for one month. Both the sentences were directed to run concurrently. However, he has been acquitted for charge of conspiracy.
c
Hence, this appeal.
225. Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant would submit that the respondent (A-62) was a Watchman - a government servant, at Wangni Tower. He had not only facilitated the unloading of goods smuggled in India, D rather served the smugglers by taking money as a consideration for this work. He was fully aware of the contraband material but he did not inform the police authorities about the same. Therefore, he ought to have been held guilty of the charge of conspiracy also.
226. On the contrary, Ms. Farhana Shah, learned counsel appearing for the respondent has opposed the appeal contending that he has already served 5 years of sentence. He did not participate in hatching the conspiracy by attending any conspiratorial meetings. Therefore, this Court should not grant F any indulgence, taking into consideration the parameters laid down by this Court for hearing the appeal against order of acquittal. The appeal is liable to be dismissed. 227. We have considered the rival submissions made by G learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. 228. Evidence against respondent:
(a)
Confessional statement of respondent (A-62)
(b)
Confessional statement of Dawood Phanse (A-14)
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.)
(c)
Confessional statement of Sharif Abdul Gafoor Parkar (A-17)
(d)
Deposition of Usman (PW.2)
229. Confessional statement of respondent Tulsi Ram Dondu Surve (A-62) : In his confessional statement, the respondent revealed that he was working as a Watchman in Wangni Tower. Dawood Phanse (A-14) had become acquainted with him and Tiger Memon (AA) who had been using Wangni Tower for loading, unloading and shifting the contraband from one vehicle to another. Tiger Memon (AA) used to keep the smuggled goods and silver in Wangni Tower. As Harish Chandra Surve (PW.108) and Vijay Govind More (PW.137) had also been working in the same tower as employees, the respondent had persuaded them for helping the smugglers. Payment was made to them from the money received by him for rendering such assistance. He also disclosed that Dawood Phanse (A-14) had purchased 10 acres of land in the name of the accusedrespondent (A-62). In respect of the incident of smuggling, he disclosed that one tempo, jeep and Maruti car arrived at the Wangni Tower. Tiger Memon (AA) and his associates Iqbal, Mobin, Anwar, Munna, Shafi were accompanying the vehicles. Silver bricks were shifted from the truck into the tempo. There were gunny bags and boxes covered with clothes also and about 50 bags out of the aforesaid goods remained unloaded. The said bags were taken by the truck of Alware in the field which was in his name and were concealed in the pits by putting soil on it. Dawood Phanse (A-14) had told him that the contraband was "Kala Sabun", and he was warned not to disclose the same to any one. Tiger Memon (AA) cut one bundle from the said bundles, and saw the same to ascertain whether the goods were proper or not. He threw the plastic at that place and packed the same in another bundle and took the same with him. Thereafter, on 7 .1.1993 again Dawood
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
Phanse had informed the respondent (A-62) that goods were about to arrive and this was being informed to Harish Chandra Surve (PW.108) and Vijay Govind More (PW.137). One truck, three jeeps, one rickshaw and two motor cycles came there alongwith the accused persons, namely, Dawood Phanse (AB 14), Dadamiya Parkar (A-17), Sharif Adhikari (A-60), Abdul Gharatkar (A-34) and Tiger Memon (AA). After 5-6 days Dawood Phanse (A-14) had paid him Rs.2,000/- for the assistance. Dawood Phanse (A-14) used to give an amount of Rs.1000/- for each of them i.e. accused, Harish Chandra C Surve (PW.108) ar.id Vijay Govind More (PW.137). 230. Confessional statement of Dawood Phanse (A-
W: The accused Dawood Phanse (A-14) did not name Tulsi D Ram Dondu Surve (A-62) but corroborated the incident of unloading and shifting of goods at Wangni Tower. 231. Same remained the position in respect of the confessional statement of Sharif Abdul Gafoor Parkar (A-17). E Even the Deposition of Usman (PW.2) corroborated the same. 232. After appreciating the entire evidence, the Designated Court came to the conclusion as under:
"59-A - The aforesaid material contained in the confession of A-62 not only reveals his involvement in Shekadi landing & transportation but also reveals involvement of A-14, 17, 27, 34, 42, 55, 60, PW 108, PW 137 and Tiger Memon.
59-B - The corroborative material to matters contained in confession of A-62 i.e. his involvement in Shekadi landing & transportation operation for which he is charged with is also found in the confession of co-accused no.17.
59-C - Thus considering material in the confession of A62 and aforesaid co-accused the same leads to the conclusion of A-62 also being involved in Shekadi landing
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
operation as denoted by said material and as such having A committed offence u/s.3(3) of TADA for which he is charged at head 2ndly clause 'a' and 'b'. Similarly the same evidence also establishes his involvement in commission of offences for which charge was framed at head 3rdly i.e. offence u/s.202 of IPC on count of himself B in spite of being watchman and Government servant has still knowingly and intentionally omitted to give information about offences committed in his presence being in possession of contraband material unauthorisedly." 233. The parameters laid down by this court in entertaining C the appeal against the order of acquittal have to be applied. 234. We have given our conscious thought to the facts but are not convinced that the respondent can be held guilty for the charge of larger conspiracy also. We concur with the learned D Special Judge so far as the respondent is concerned. The appeal lacks merit and is dismissed accordingly. CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 416 OF 2011 State of Maharashtra Through CBI ... Appellant
Versus Sujjad Alam
. . . Respondent
235. This appeal has been preferred against the judgment F and order dated 2.8.2007 passed by Special Judge of the Designated Court under the TADA for Bombay Blast Case No.1 of 1993 by which the Respondent (A-61) had been convicted under Section 3(3) TADA and awarded rigorous imprisonment for 7 years with a fine of Rs. 50,000/- However, G Respondent (A-61) has been acquitted of the general charge of conspiracy. Hence, this appeal.
s
C
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013) 16 S.C.R.
236. Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the appellant, has submitted that the respondent had very close association with terrorists and had been a kingpin in all the terrorist activities and most of the accused in their confessional statements had revealed his involvement. Therefore, he ought to have been convicted for the charge of general conspiracy and, thus, the appeal deserves to be allowed. 237. On the contrary, Ms. Farhana Shah, learned counsel appearing for the respondent, has submitted that the respondent (A-61) has already been convicted and punished appropriately. He has already served 3-1/2 years in prison and had paid fine, therefore, no further punishment is required and the appeal is liable to be dismissed. 238. The evidence against the respondent Sujjad Alam @ Iqbal Abdul Hakim Nazir (A-61) is his own confession. In his confessional statement, he had disclosed that his materna.I uncle Khalil Ali Nazir had been involv:ed in landing of silver for Tiger Memon (AA) at Shekhadi Beach. Accused (A-61) used to take Dawood Taklya (A-14) and Abdul Aziz Gharatkar to the place of landing in his auto rickshaw. Accused (A-61) participated in the landing and transportation of the contraband. Accused (A-61) was paid Rs. 2000/- per landing through Khalil. On 20th January, 1993, Accused (A-61) went to the residence of his maternal uncle and found Khalil, Muzammil, Shafi and other Khalil, resident of Shrivardhan present there. They were shifting some goods wrapped in gunny bags from the jeep to a room. At that time, son of Dawood Taklya Sarfaraz (A-55) was also there. Shafi, driver of Tiger Memon(AA), asked accused (A-61) to leave the room. When they opened the gunny bags inside the room, accused (A-61) saw that the bags contained 16 rifles and 32 cassettes (magazines). After coming outside, A-61 saw that Khalil, resident of Shrivardhan, was closing secret cavities in the jeep. Shafi then took that jeep towards Mhasla. The accused (A-61), Khalil and Muzammil took the said arms,
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.)
ammunition in the auto rickshaw of Muzammil at the residence of Muzammil and dropped the same there. On 3rd ·February, 1993, his uncle Khalil asked him to help in the landing of contraband for Tiger Memon (AA) in the night. So A-61 went to the place of landing in his auto rickshaw alongwith Dawood Taklya (A-14) and Abdul Aziz. After reaching there, he found 2-3 jeeps carrying Tiger Memon (AA) and 20-25 of his associates. The accused (A-61) was then directed to reach Tower, upon which, he left to wake the people there. On reaching the place the accused (A-61) parked the vehicle on one side of the tower and slept on the back seat. After a long time, Muzammil came to the vehicle and woke him up. Rashid and Khalil also came there. By that time, all the vehicles from Shekhadi had arrived. The associates of Tiger Memon (AA) were unloading and shifting the articles inside the Tower. The accused (A-61) was forbidden to enter inside. After sometime, Dawood, Khalil, Abdul Aziz and accused (A-61) left the Tower ill the auto rickshaw. It was in the evening of 9th February, 1993, that the accused (A-61) took Dawood Taklya in his auto rikshaw to Mehandari. From there they took Khalil Nazir from his residence and reached Muzammil's residence. On being asked by Dawood Taklya, Muzammil handed over 3 rifles and 6 cassettes in a gunny bag. All the three accused then took the said weapons and ammunition and came to Lonery Phatta on the highway via Goregaon and handed over the same to Tiger Memon (AA), who had arrived there. After 4-5 days, Dawood Taklya sent Rs.4000/- for both the landings.
c
239. Confessional statement of Mohd. Phanse @ Dawood Taklya (A-14) - His statement corroborated the version.given by the accused (A-61) about the landing at Shekhadi and disclosed the role of accused (A-61) as a participant in the landing and his facilitation in the transportation. According to him, Tiger Memon (AA) was there with 20-25 persons. Out of them 8-10 persons were carrying pistols in their pockets. Immediately, after the arrival of trawler, accused (A-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
61) was sent alongwith his auto rickshaw to call Rashid from Borli with his truck so he left. The goods were unloaded and . put in the trucks. Immediately, another trawler arrived carrying the goods which were also unloaded. Tiger Memon (AA) made 2-3 boys carrying guns to sit over the goods which were loaded B in the truck. Then they had reached Wangni Tower, where the goods were unloaded. When they went inside the Tower. he saw the men of Tiger Memon (AA) opening those boxes and putting rifles, pistols, bullets, black wire, handgrenades and bundles of wire with white pencil on top and "black soap" like C material at the side. Tiger Memon (AA) was sitting at their side and counting and noting things in his diary. Once the landing and transportation was over, co-accused (A-14) came back to his village alongwith accused (A-61) in his auto rickshaw. 240. Confession of Khalil Ahmed Sayed Ali Nasir (AD 42) - So far as ac.cused (A-61) is concerned, A-42 in his confessional statement disclosed that on 3rd March, 1993 he and Dawood Taki ya (A-14) had reached M hasla in the autorickshaw of accused (A-61 ). Then· the acccused (A-61) was sent to village Borli with autorickshaw to bring the truck and E labourers. 241. Confession of Muzammil Umar Kadri (A-25) - On 3rd February, 1993, this accused (A-25) on being· called reached in front of Bashir's house in Borli. Accused (A-61) auto F rickshawala also came there sometime later after dropping Dawood Taklya (A-14) and Khalil at Shekhadi. Sometime later, Khalil had come alongwith another Khalil of Shrivardhan on his scooter. Khalil sent accused (A-61) to the tower just before the jeep came and accused (A-25) also went to the tower alongwith G Khalil by following the truck. On 7th February, 1993, Dawood Taklya (A-14) had taken him in the auto rickshaw of accused (A-61 ), to Shekhadi. In the morning of 7th February, 1993 Dawood Taklya (A-14) had come in the rickshaw of accused (A-61) and took 3 rifles and 6 cassettes which had been kept in his house earlier. The remaining 13 rifles and 26 cassettes
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
had been recovered later on by the police from his house. 242. Deposition of Vijay Govind More (PW.137) - This witness deposed about the incident of February, 1993 stating that Tiger Memon (AA) and his companions came in jeeps and motorcycles and an auto rickshaw at Wangni Tower. Accused (A-61) was also with them. He also identified the accused (A61) in court. 243. The Designated Court after appreciating the entire evidence reached the conclusion as under:
c·
"The aforesaid material contained in the confession of A61 not only reveals his involvement in Shekadi landing and transportation but also reveals involvement of A-14, 15, 17, 25, 27, 34, 42, 55 & Tiger Memon." 244. In addition, the Designated Court also reached the conclusion that the accused (A-61) had no knowledge about the use to which weapons were to be put into. In awarding the punishment, the court took into consideration the role played by the respondent (A-61) and concluded that charge for larger conspiracy could not be made out. 245. It is evident that he was not allowed to enter into the Wangni tower and thus he had no knowledge that arms had been smuggled into India to be used in Bombay Blast, and further, the fact that the arms were kept in the house of Muzammil, and the arms and ammunition had been transported in the vehicle belonging to Muzammil and not in the vehicle of accused (A-61 ). There is nothing on record to show that accused (A-61) had participated in loading and unloading of the same. His rickshaw had been used for carrying the accused persons. The accused (A-61) had transported the arms, i.e. 3 rifles and 6 cassettes alongwith Dawood Taklya from the house of Muzammil which were subsequently taken from him by Tiger Memon (AA).
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
246. The scope and ambit of Section 3(3) TADA is very wide. Punishment for the off~nces under section 3(3) varies from 5 years to life imprisonment depending on the gravity of the overt act done by particular accused. Each of them cannot be held to be at par, as one of them may be instrumental in B arranging the landing, another maybe helping in organising and affecting transportation, some may be given supervisory work while other persons might have been engaged as labourers. Therefore, while determining the quantum of punishment the precise act committed by an individual accused is of prime consideration.
c
247. In the instant case, appellant (A-61) had been found guilty on the single count of participating in landing on two occasions and additionally of being involved in the concealment of arms and ammunition at the house of A-25 and further for D . the transportation of some arms from the house of A-25 to Lonery Phata and handing over the same to Tiger Memon (AA). Undoubtedly he had been working as an auto driver and was pard only for that.
248.The parameters laid down by this court in entertaining the appeal against the order .of acquittal have to be applied. 249. The judgment of th~ learned Special Judge does not require interference. The appeal lacks merit and is accordingly dismissed. CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 512 OF 2008 Abdulla Ibrahim Surti & Ors .... Appellants
Versus State of Maharashtra thr. CBl-STF, Bombay .. Respondent AND
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 401 OF 2011
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.] State of Maharashtra
.... Appellant
Versus Faki Ali Faki Ahmed & Ors ..... Respondents AND
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 595 OF 2011 The State of Maharashtra .... Appellant Versus Abdullah lbrahimSurti
.... Respondents
c
Criminal Appeal Nol. 512 of 2008
. 250. This appeal has been preferred against the judgments and orders dated 21.5.2007 and 25.5.2007, passed by the Special Judge of the Designated Court under the TADA in Bombay Blast Case No. 1/93, Greater Bombay, by which the appellants have been convicted under Sections 3(3) and 6 TADA. In view of the fact that each appellant being assigned different acts, has been charged differently and has been awarded a different sentence, it is desirable to deal with the case of each appellant separately'to certain extent.
I. Abdulla Ibrahim Surti CA-66): 251. Appellant (A-66) was charged for concealing 12 AK 56 rifles, 36 magazines and 19500 cartridges of AK 56 rifles which were kept in 3 bags in a cloth and 13 cloth bags were kept in the mango grove of Abdul Razak Subedar. These arms and ammunition had been smuggled into India to be used for terrorist activities and were recovered at his instance on 7.4.1993 from the said place. He was further charged for disposal of the said arms and
D-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
ammunition alongwith other co-accused dumping the same in Kandalgaon creek. And lastly for aiding and abetting the coaccused Shabir (AA) and Jamir (A-133) having possession and carrying fire arms and ammunition under Section 6 TADA.
Appellant (A-66) stood acquitted on the first charge of B conspiracy. However, he has been convicted under Sections 3 (3) TADA and awarded RI of five years and a fine of Rs.25,000/-, and in default of payment of fine, to suffer further RI of six months. Under Section 6, has been awarded RI of six years and a fine of Rs.25,000/- and a suitable R.I. for default C of payment of fine. Hence, this appeal. 252. Ms. Farhana Shah, learned counsel appearing for the D appellant (A-66) has stated that the appellant (A-66) had no knowledge that the items being transported were arms and ammunition. Moreover, he has not made any confession and the confessional statement of the co-accused cannot be relied upon to convict him. Further it was urged that he (A-66) has already served 3 years out of the sentence that has been E awarded to him. Thus, the appeal deserves to be allowed. 253. Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the State has submitted that confessional statement of Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) disclosed the involvement of F the appellant in disposal of 3 wooden boxes concealed in the cattleshed of Firoz Khan as the latter wanted to dispose of the hidden boxes of weapons and bags of bullets in the creek after the Bombay Blast on 12.3.1993. He explained how the said contraband material was taken in the boat and thrown in the G Kandalwada Creek with the help of some persons including Abdullah Ibrahim Surti (A-66). Therefore, the appeal deserves to be dismissed.
254. We have heard the rival submissions made by learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
255. Evidence against the appellant (A-66): (a)
Confessional statement of Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74)
(b)
Confessional statement of Janardhan Pandurang Gambas (A-81)
(c)
Confessional statement of Jamir Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-133)
(d)
Deposition of Shridhar Shantaram Borkar (PW-88)
(e)
Deposition of Dattaraybhiku Udarkar (PW-89)
(f)
Deposition of Anil Ramchandra Baswat (PW-90)
(g)
Deposition of Janu Hajari (PW-378)
(h)
Deposition of Vyankatesh Hirba Rane (PW-588)
c
256. Confessional statement of Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74): According to this accused, in the 2nd/3rd week of March, 1993, Shabir came to him and asked for help as Firoz Khan had come from Bombay where some communal disturbance had taken place and he had to hide certain boxes of weapons and bags of bullets in the creek. He wanted a boat to take those weapons to the creek. Thereafter, the Shabbir (AA), Jamir (A133) (dead), appellant (A-66) and Janardhan Pandurang Gambas (A-81) removed those three wooden boxes and six greenish coloured bags kept under the haystack in their cattle shed and kept them in the boat on the shore. Janya Sarsai was in the said boat. Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) showed them torch light while bags and boxes were being carried. Thereafter, Shabir came and told that the bundles of weapons and bags of bullets were to be hidden in the mango groves. At that time, appellant (A-66), Janardhan Pandurang Gambas (A-
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
A 81), and Jamir Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-133) (dead) were also present. 257. Confessional statement of Janardhan Pandurang Gambas (A-81 ):
He disclosed that he had a boat and helped smugglers in landing and transportation and, for that purpose, he had been . paid by Shabbir Rs.1000/- for each landing. He stated that on 2nd December, 1992, Uttam Potdar (A-30) came to him and conveyed the message of Shabbir to help him in landing of gold, C silver and, accordingly, they went to Dighi Jetty in the night. They found a large number of labourers alongwith Shabbir and Uttam Potdar (A-30) and Mechanic Chacha (A-136) and he participated in landing and transportation and he was paid a sum of Rs.5,000/-. On 9th January, 1993, he was again D contacted by Uttam Potdar (A-30) and he went for landing alongwith Firoz Khan, Mechanic Chacha (A-136) and Shabbir Kadri. After the landing Uttam Potdar (A-30). brought 30 bundles wrapped by gunny cloth around the box and 30 bags · of military black colour and, at that time, Mechanic Chacha (AE 136) said that the boxes contained glass wares so they had to be carried carefully. After the Bombay Blast, he (A-81) w~nt to Shabbir Kadri's house where he told him (A-81) that the goods which landed on that day were contained guns and ammunition and the same were to be hidden into a pit. They dug pits in the F mango grove of Shabbir, came back to his house again and wrapped 12 guns, 4 each from 3 boxes, into the gunny clothes and boxes, packing with thermacol and 26 boxes were hidden in the pit. He (A-81) was paid Rs.1,000/- for doing the said work. While hiding the rifles and ammunition, Faki Ali Chacha G (A-74), Abdullah Surti (A-66) and Shabbir's father Sayed Ismail (A-105) were also present. They opened 3 wooden boxes in the house of Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74). Shabbir told him that the same were magazines of guns. Thereafter, Shabbir (AA}, his brother Jamir (A-133), Abdullah Surti (A-66), Faki Ali H Faki Ahmed (A-74) and he (A-81) went to the boat which was
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
tied near the house of Shabbir, taking 3 boxes, and 6 bags, where Janu Vethkoli was also present who neatly arranged the 6 bags and 3 boxes in the boat. On being asked Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) informed him (A-81) that there were bullets in the bags. Subsequently, he was informed that the said goods have properly been kept in the creek water.
258. Confessional Statement of Jamir Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-133): He disclosed that in January 1993, he had participated in the landing alongwith Uttam Potdar (A-30) and, at that time, on 9th January, 1993, he was also informed by Shabbir that silver and weapons would arrive at Dighi Jetty on the same day. He further deposed that some of the smuggled goods were brought to the house of Shabbir and those wooden boxes and greenish coloured boxes wer~ kept in the house of his (A133) maternal grandmother for about one month as the house generally used to remain closed. Subsequently, Shabbir said that the boxes had to be shifted to the house of Ali Mian Faki (A-74) which was in close proximity. Janarda.n Pandurang (A81), Ali Mlan Faki (A-74), Abdulla Surti (A-66), Shabbir and he (A-133) picked up those boxes and bags and took to the house of Ali Mian Faki (A-74).
C
After 4-5 days of bomb Blast on 12.3.1993, Janardan Gambas (A-81) and Abdullah Surti (A-66) also arrived at his place. Shabbir told them that the wooden boxes and bags had F to be thrown in the water. As per the instruction, he brought the. boat near the village and Shabbir, Flroz, Abu Bakar, Janardhan Gambas (A-81), Ali Mian Faki (A-74), Abdullah Surti (A-66) and A-133 loaded three wooden boxes and few green colour bags in the boat from the house of Ali Mian Faki (A- . G 74). Shabbir had said that those boxes and bags have to be thrown in creek near Kandalwada. Next night Shabir took him (A-133) to the house of Ali Mian Faki (A-74). Janardan Gambas (A-81), Ali Mian Faki (A-74) and Abdullah (A-66),
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
participated in burying the arms bags and sacks in the mango grove of Subedar. 259. Deposition of Shridhar Shantaram Borkar (PW-
88.l.;.
He was the panch witness to the disclosure statement made by Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) on 7.4.1993, arid also the recovery of weapons from the mango grove. 260. o·eposition of Dattaraybhiku Udarkar (PW-89):
c
He was the panch witness to the statement made by Janu Vetkholi (PW-378) on 8.4.1993, and to the recovery of weapons from Kandalwada creek. He recognised the seizure panchnama Exh. 503 in court. 261. Deposition of Anil Ramchandra Baswat (PW-90): He deposed that he had arranged for a boat and took police party and Janu Vetkholi (PW-378) into Kandalgaon creek, wherefrom three wooden boxes and six military colour bags were found from whic~ weapons and ammunition were recovered. 262. Deposition of Janu Vetkholi (PW-378) :
His deposition revealed that he was earlier an accused but subsequently discharged. He did not name the appellant A-66, however, corroborated the confessional statement made by all others including Ali Mian Faki (A-74) and Janardan Pandurang Gambas (A-81). 263. Deposition of Vyankatesh Hirba Rane CPW-588): He had recorded the disclosure statement made by Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) in presence of the panch witnesses on 7.4.1993. In the said statement, he had disclosed the location where arms were hidden. Faki Ali Faki Ahmed
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @AS. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
Subedar (A-74) led the police party to mango grove from where the weapons were recovered. Vyankatesh Hirba Rane (PW588) recorded the FIR and arrested Janu Vetkholi (PW-378) on 8.4.1993. Janu Vekholi (PW-378) took the police party to the creek from where three wooden boxes and six military coloured boxes were recovered containing weapons.
264. The learned Designated Court after appreciating the evidence came to the conclusion that the involvement of the appellant (A-66) in commission of similar acts was established by the material contained in confession of the appellants (A74 and A-81) and Jamir Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-133) and he was held guilty for commission of offences under sections 3(3) and 6 TADA.
C
265. We find no reason to interfere with the judgment of the learned Special Judge. The appeal with respect to appellant (A-66) lacks merit and is accordingly dismissed.
II. Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar CA-74) : 266. Appellant (A-74) was further charged for concealing 12 AK 56 rifles, 36 magazines and 19500 cartridges of AK 56 rifles which were kept in 3 bags in a cloth and 13 cloth bags in the mango grove of Abdul Razak Subedar. These arms and ammunition had been smuggled into India to be used for terrorist activities and had been recovered at his instance on 7.4.1993 from the said place.
He was further charged with disposal of the said arms and ammunitiqn alongwith other co-accused dumping the same in Kandalgaon creek. He was lastly charged with aiding, abetting the co-accused Shabir and Jamir (absconding) having in possession and carrying fire arms and ammunition under Section 6 TADA. 267. He had been acquitted on the first charge of conspiracy. However, he had been convicted under Sections
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
3 (3) TADA and awarded RI of five years and a fine of Rs.25,000/-, in default of payment of fine, to suffer further RI of six months. Under Section 6, he had been awarded RI of six years and a fine of Rs.25,000/- and a suitable R.I. for default of payment of fine. 268. Ms. Farhana Shah, learned counsel appearing for the appellant (A-74) and Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the State have raised the same contentions which have been raised in respect of Abdulla Ibrahim Surti (A-66). 269. We have considered the rival submissions made by learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. 270. Evidence against the appellant (A-74):
(a)
Confessional statement of the appellant (A-74)
(b)
Confessional statement of Janardhan Pandurang Gambas (A-81)
(c)
Confessional statement of Jamir Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-133)
(d)
Deposition of Shridhar Shantaram Borkar (PW-88)
(e)
Deposition of Dattatray Udharkar (PW-89)
(f)
Deposition of Anil Baswat (PW-90)
(g)
Deposition of Janu Hajari (PW-378)
(i)
Deposition of Rajan Dhoble (PW-585)
Q)
Deposition of Pratap Dighavkar (PW-586)
271. Confessional Statement of Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74): He disclosed that he was a neighbour of Sayed Ismail
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
Kadri (A-105) and his sons Shabir (AA) and Jamir (A-133) indulged in smuggling activities and had connections with Uttam Potdar (A-30). After the bomb Blast on 12th March, 1993, Shabir came to his (A-74) house and asked him to help one Firoz Khan who had come from Bombay and Firoz Khan told him to hide the boxes of weapons and bags of bullets in the creek. Therefore, he wanted his help to take the things upto the boat. Shabir, his brother Jamir (A-133), Abdullah Surti (A66) and Janardhan Gambas (A-81) removed three wooden boxes and six greenish coloured bags kept under the haystack in their 'cattleshed and kept it in the boat at the shore. Janu Vetkholi (PW. 378) was present in the said boat. The appellant (A-74) showed them torch light while bags and boxes were being carried. They sailed the boat towards Kandalwada Creek. On the next day, Shabir came and said that bundles of weapons and bags of bullets which were in his possession, were to be hidden in the mango groves. So again in the night the appellant (A-74) along with other co-accused took the 13 greenish coloured bags of bullets of guns and 3 bundles having ·guns wrapped in the plastic paper from under the haystack and · they were buried in the pit dug in the mango grove of Abdul Razak Subedar who was staying in Nairobi at that time and the &ame was filled and covered by soil and hay. At that time also, the appellant (A-74) had shown the torch light. The appellant (A-74) was taken to the police station after making the inquiry about Shabir (AA) and Jamir (A-133) and the appellant (A-74) disclosed that 13 greenish bags of bullets of guns wrapped in the wax cloth had been buried in the mango grove of Abdul Razak Subedar. The said items were earlier recovered from there on the confessional statement of the appellant (A-74). He took out the hidden articles from the pit by removing the soil and hay and produced the same. The police seized the arms and ammunition. 272. Confessional Pandurang Gambas
statement
of
c
Janardhan
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
(A-81 ):
He has disclosed in his confessional statement that after the Blast, Jamir Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-133) came to Gambas's (A-81) house and alongwith Abdulla Ibrahim Surti (AB 66), Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74), Shabir and his father (A-105), they hid the weapons in mango grove that landed on 9.2.1993 at Dig hi. Thereafter, Gambas (A-81 ), Jamir Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-133), Abdulla Ibrahim Surti (A-66) and Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) took out three boxes and six packets from the house of A-74 and placed them in a boat with C the help of Janu Vetkholi (PW-378), who took the boat to Mahendali creek. Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) told Gambas (A-81) that the boxes qontained bullets and Shabir had informed Gambas (A-81) that the goods had been kept in creek water. ·
Thus, the confession of Gambas (A-81) corroborates the confession of Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) in material respects in so far as the hiding of weapons in mango grove is concerned and also about taking the weapons to a boat and E hiding them in creek water after the Blast. 273. Confessional statement of Jamir Savved Ismail Kadri (A-133): He had participated in the landing at Dighi and he knew F that weapons had been smuggled into India. Boxes containing weapons were kept at the house of Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) on instructions of Shabir (AA) by Jamir. Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-133), Abdulla Ibrahim Surti (A-66) and Janardhan Pandurang Gambas (A-81). Faki Ali Faki Ahmed G Subedar (A-74) alongwith others loaded three wooden boxes and few green bags in the boat of Janu Vetkholi (PW-378), which Shabir and Firoz threw in the Kandalwada creek. Next day, Shabir took Jamir Sayyed Ismail K~dri (A-133) to the house of Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74), where Abdulla H Ibrahim Surti (A-66) and Gambas (A-81) were already present.
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
They buried the bags containing weapons in the mango grove at a little distance from his house. Jamir Sawed Ismail Kadri (A-133) was present in the house of Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) when police raided his house searching for Shabir after the Blast. 274. Deposition of Shridhar Shanta Ram Borkar CPW-
88): He revealed that he was called at the police station by P:S.I. VH Rane (PW.588) through the Constable. When he reached there he found two more persons present in the room and P.S.I. VH Rane (PW.588) told him that one of them was Sonkar, resident of the village. He was told that the second person was arrested in connection with the Bombay Blast and for that purpose P.S.I. Rane wanted the witness to become a panch witness. The witness was examined in his presence. After preparing the panchnama (Ext. 448) he disclosed his name to be Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) and he got some recovery effected from Shabir Kadri's compound. Thus, the panchnama was drawn up about the said event (Ext. 449). Thereafter, the witness (PW.88), Co-panch, the said accused (A-74) and VH Rane (PW.588) went to the place at Agarwada as shown by the said accused. After entering the compound he (A-74) said that the weapons were concealed beneath the grass. The accused (A-74) thereafter removed the grass from the said place and a trench could be seen. The said trench contained three black coloured bundles. A-74 took out the said three bundles. The said trench was also contained 13 military coloured cloth bags. All the said 13 bags were taken out of the said trench. On opening the said trench four rifles and twelve magazines were found wrapped in a gunny bag. The said four rifles were having black colour barrel and wooden colour grip. The rifles were bearing some numbers but the same were illegible as it had been rubbed off. The first military coloured bag contained two rectangular tin boxes, one of the boxes was opened contained 750 cartridges. The second tin box was
C
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013) 16 S.C.R.
sealed and the same was not opened in his (PW-88) presence. The remaining _12 military coloured bags contained two rectangular tin boxes each like the boxes found in the first bag and on opening the tin boxes they were found containing 750 cartridges each. The panchnama of the said articles was drawn B by P.S.I. Rane (PW.588). One of the rifle out of 12 rifles and one of magazines and five cartridges was taken by the police by way of sample and the same were sealed. In his cross-examination he has admitted that he had C recorded the date 7.4.1993 in his small diary on which day he was made the panch witness. He further deposed that statement of Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) was recorded wherein he had disclosed that the arms and ammunition had been concealed by three persons. He has admitted in his cross-examination that he had signed a. large D number of slips/labels. All the labels signed by him were not pasted upon all the articles. He further deposed that he was not in a position to identify the boxes or say that the boxes shown to him in the court were E the same which had been recovered from the grove of Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74). He has also admitted that certain newspapers had been used for sealing the recovered articles which were of the date subsequent to the date of recovery i.e. 7.4.1993, for example. Bombay Sakal dated 9.4.1993 and F Krushival dated 13.4.1993. 275. Deposition of Dattatray Udharkar (PW-89): He revealed that he is a recovery witness on 8.4.1993. This witness has deposed that he was called at the police G station to act as a panch witness. The accused person arrested by the police was also at the police station. On being asked the accused person disclosed his name as Janu Vethkoli. He disclosed that certain weapons had been hidden in creeks. All the persons alongwith the police party and said accused and H swimmers went in a fishing boat around Kandalwada and they
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.)
waited till the low tide was complete. As the water recedes the A signs of the bags were seen in the water and the mud of the ' creek. The said bags were of military colour. Three wooden boxes were also seen at some distance away from the said bags. The said six bags and 3 wooden boxes were taken in the boat. The mouth of one of the bags was loose. The said B bag was opened. It contained two sealed tin boxes. One of the boxes was opened and found to contain cartridges. Each box contained 30 paper boxes with 25 cartridges each. The second box was not opened in his presence. The box contained 13 magazines. The panchnama of recovery was prepared. c However, when the boxes were opened in the court, newspaper in which boxes had been wrapped was of date subsequent to the date of recovery e.g. Nava Kaai dated 13.4.1993. He identified the green colour bag recovered from the creek.
276. De-position of Anil Baswat (PW-90): He revealed that he was a panch witness of recovery on 8.4.1993. He went to the creek alongwith Mhasla and Bombay police and one Janu Vethkoli (PW.378) was also in the boat. There they found three wooden boxes and 6 military cloth boxes at the shore of Kandalwada creek. They got down from the boat and brought the said articles and kept them in the boat. They returned to village Pabala by the same boat. In his cross-examination, he has admitted that one of the newspapers used for wrapping the articles was dated 13.4.1993 which is subsequent to the date of recovery.
277. Deposition of .Janu Vethkoli (PW-378) : He revealed that he was earlier accused but subsequently discharged. He had been arrested in connection with Bombay blast and prior to the Bombay blast he had been called by Jamir Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-133) (dead) to bring his boat. Accordingly, he went to Agarwada with his (PW. 378) boat and Jamir Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-133) told him to wait there. He
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
reached there and after reaching the sea shore at Agarwada he found that Shabir was present. He was asked to anchor his boat and wait. Accordingly, he waited. Thereafter, Shabir told him that there is a foul smell of things in his house and hence the same is to be thrown away in the sea. Two persons who B were present alongwith Shabbir transported the things alongwith them. Shabir kept the same in the boat. The things had been wrapped in a gunny bag. Shabbir also boarded his boat and the boat was taken in the creek away from the shore. Upon reaching the creek, Shabir threw away the said articles wrapped in the gunny bag in the water. Thereafter, the witness took the boat to the shore of Agarwada. Shabir alighted from the boat and the witness returned to his village. Shabir did not give any money to PW . .378 though he promised to pay the same.
c
278. Deposition of Rajan Dhoble (PW-585):
In his deposition, he reveals that the recovery from the Kandalwada creek was effected and three wooden boxes were found and opened at the sea shore. The said bags contained E 18, 13 and 13 magazines of black colour. The said recovery had been made at the instance of Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74). In his cross-examination he (PW-585) admitted that one F of the newspapers in which the said articles had been wrapped was subsequent to the date of recovery as it was of 13.4.1993. He is the officer who had arrested Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74). 279. Deposition of Pratap Dighavkar (PW-586):
He revealed that while interrogating Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74), the said accused expressed his desire to make a voluntary confession. Thus, on the same day he wrote a letter to the S.P. Raigad requesting him to record his
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
confession and he was produced for recording the confession on 7.5.1993 and it was so recorded.
280. With regard to Faki Ali Fr',: Ahmed Subedar (A-74), the Designated court came to the conclusion that on the basis of disclosure statement made by the appellant (A-74), 12 AK- B 56 rifles and 36 magazines and cartridges were recovered from mango groves. The appellant (A-74) was having knowledge about the same due to being involved in shifting the said contraband from the house of Jamir Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A133) and Shabbir (AA) to said mango groves along with Jamir . C Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-133) and other co-accused. It was held that said acts and the further acts of the appellant (A-74) of giving assistance in dumping the cartridges of AK-56 rifles and magazines in Kandalwada creek, would make him guilty for commission of offences under sections 3(3) and 6 TADA
281. We find no evidence on record warranting the interference with the judgment of the learned Designated Court. The appeal with regard to appellant (A-74) lacks merit and is accordingly dismissed. Ill. Janardhan Pandurang Gambas (A-81): 282. Appellant (A-81) was further charged for participating and assisting the co-accused Mechanic Chacha (A-136), Shabir and Jamir Kadri (A-133), Feroz Khan and co-accused Uttam Potdar (A-30) in smuggling, landing and transportation of arms, ammunition and explosives smuggled in India on 9.1.1993. He was further charged with aiding and abetting, wanted accused Shabir and Jamir Kadri (A-133) and Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) in concealing 12 AK 56 rifles, 36 magazines and 19500 cartridges of AK 56 rifles in the mango grove of Abdul Razak Subedar, knowingly and intentionally that these arms and ammunition had been smuggled into the country for committing terrorist acts. Lastly he was charged with aiding and abetting co-accused Abdullah Ibrahim Surti (A-66), Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74), Sayed Ismail Sayed Ali Kadri
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
A (A-105) etc. in disposal of arms and ammunition by dumping the said consignment of arms and ammunition in Kandalgaon Creek which was recovered on 8.4.1993. 283. After conclusion of the trial, appellant (A-81) stood 8 convicted and sentenced to suffer RI for 6 years and a fine of Rs.50,000/-, and a suitable R.I. for default of payment of fine under Section 3(3) TADA and further sentenced to suffer RI for 3 years and a fine of Rs.25,000/- for conviction under Section 111 read with Section 135(b) of the Customs Act, 1962.
C
284. Ms. Farhana Shah, learned counsel appearing for the appellant (A-81) and Shri Mukul Gupta, learned sen_ior counsel appearing for the State have raised the same contentions which have been raised in respect of Abdulla Ibrahim Surti (A-66).
285. We have considered the rival submissions made by learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
286. Evidence against the appellant (A-81 ):
(a)
Confessional statement of the appellant (A-81)
(b)
Confessional statement of Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74)
(c)
Confessional statement of Jamir Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-133)
(d)
Confessional statement of Mechanic Chacha (A136)
(e)
Deposition of Tikaram Shrawan Bhal (PW-191)
287. Confessional Statement of Janardhan Pandurang Garn bas CA-81 ):
In his own confession he has admitted that he was a fisherman and used to help Shabir and Jamir Kadri (A-133) in , H smuggling. He participated in landing on 9.1.1993 at Dighi Jetty
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.)
1·23
wherein arms and ammunition had been smuggled into the country with Uttam Shantaram Potdar (A-30), Mechanic Chacha (A-136) etc. and facilitated their transportation. He further confessed that he rendered assistance in hiding the said weapons in the mango grove of Abdul Razak Subedar alongwith Abdullah Ibrahim Surti (A-66), Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74), Sayed Ismail Sayed Ali Kadri (A-105) etc. He further said that he helped Shabir, Abdullah Ibrahim Surti (A66), Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74). in taking the boxes from the house of Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) containing weapons and hiding them in mango grove. He has also admitted that he was told by Shabir (AA) that the boxes contained guns and further admitted that he had been informed by Faki .Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) that the boxes contained bullets. 288. Confessional Statement' of Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74): In his confession he has admitted that he had met the appellant (A-81) at the house of Shabir and took the smuggled goods from there with the help of appellant (A-81), duly assisted by Abdullah Ibrahim Surti (A-66) and Jamir Sayyed Ismail Kadri (A-133). 289. Confessional Statement of Jamir Savved Ismail Kadri (A-133):
c
He disclosed that in January 1993 he met Uttam Shantaram Potdar (A-30), Feroz Abdul Rashid Khan and Salim (A-134) and on 9.1.1993 Uttam Shantaram Potdar (A-30) came to his house on motorcycle and asked his help in landing work. So far as appellant (A-81) is concerned he disclosed that the wooden boxes and green coloured bags after being smuggled into this country were kept in the house of the maternal grandmother of Shabbir and were then shifted to the house of Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) with the help of appellant
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
(A-81), Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) and Abdulla Ibrahim Surti (A-66). He further deposed that it was with the help of Abdullah Ibrahim Surti (A-66) and the present appellant (A-81) that the goods were loaded in the boat which were to be dumped in the sea. It was duly supported by Janu Vethkoli (PW.378). He has also deposed that appellant (A-81) assisted in hiding weapons in the mango grove after taking away the same from the house of Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74). 290. Confessional Statement of Mechanic Chacha CA· 136):
He does not name the present appellant (A-81) directly but disclosed that it was on the instructions of co-accused that weapons were hidden by Shabir. There are further depositions of Janu Vethkoli (PW.378), T.S. Bhal (PW.191 ), Shridhar O Borkar (PW.88), Dattatray (PW.89), Anil Baswat (PW.90) and Ashok (PW.670) to support the allegations against the present appellant A-81. 291. Deposition of Tikaram Shrawan Bhal (PW-191):
He has recorded the confessional statement of Gambas (A-81) as well as the confession of Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74). He had deposed that he had recorded the same strictly in accordance with law, and it was a voluntary confessional statement and after recording the same he had given time to re-think as required in law, and after recording the confession, the same was forwarded to CJM, Alibagh on 21.5.1993.
292. The issue whether confessional statements made by G Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) and Janardhan Pandurang Gambas (A-81) were voluntary, had been considered by the Designated Court in its judgment and after considering all the objections it came to the conclusion that Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) and Janardhan Pandurang Gambas (A-81) had made confessional statement voluntarily as T.S. Bhal
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
(PW.191 ), S.P., Raigad has deposed that the appellant (A-81) was produced by Ashok Krishanji Chandgude (PW.670) before him on 20.5.1993 and after asking certain questions to him, T.S. Bhal (PW .191) was fully satisfied that appellant (A-81) wanted to make a voluntary confession. He was again asked to be produced on 21.5.1993 and on that day appellant (A-81) narrated the entire matter and his confession has been recorded verbatim. The Designated Court rejected the suggestion in his (A-81) Section 313 Cr.P.C. statement before the court that he had never been produced before T.S. Bhal (PW .191) on either of the two days as claimed by the prosecution and his thumb impression had been obtained on blank papers while he was in custody of Alibagh Police Station. The theory was rejected .. .
c
.
293. After appreciating the evidence on record the learned Designated Court came to the conclusion that the involvement of the appellant (A-81) in landing at Dighi Jetty is established, but there is hardly any evidence to reveal that the appellant (A81) had knowledge of contraband goods being arms and ammunitions, and thus the appellant (A-81) cannot be held lia.ble for offence under Section 3(3) TADA on said count i.e. first limb of second charge, but guilty for offence punishable under Section 111 read with Section 135(b) of Customs Act, 1962 for the same. However it was held that the appellant (A-81) after having ·acquired the knowledge about nature of said contraband being arms and ammunition and still having committed acts mentioned in second and third limbs of second charge i.e. concealment of weapons in mango groves and dumping of cartiridges and magazines in Khandalgaon creek, he would be guilty for commission of offence under Section 3(3) TADA for the said offences. 294. More so, the Designated Court has taken into consideration the other confessional statements of other accused to support the prosecution case. We are not inclined
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013) 16 S.C.R.
to interfere with the judgment of the Designated court. The appeal with reference to Gambas (A-81) lacks merit and is accordingly dismissed. IV. Sayed @ Muiiu Ismail Ibrahim Kadri CA-104):
295. Appellant (A-104) was further charged with aiding, abetting and knowingly and intentionally facilitating the commission of terrorist acts by transporting AK 56 rifles in his motor jeep No. MH-06-A-9175 from Mhasla to Bombay _and delivering it to co-accused. He was further charged for C possessing and concealing five plastic boxes containing initiating devices of hand grenades smuggled into India for committing terrorist acts, thus charged under Section 3(3) TADA. He was lastly charged with contravening the provisions of Arms Act and Rules and acquiring the possession of fire D arms and ammunition and five plastic boxes containing initiating devices of hand grenades, thus charged· under Section 6 TADA. 296. He was acquitted of first charge of criminal E conspiracy. However, he was convicted under Section 3(3) TADA and sentenced to suffer 5 years RI and a fine of Rs.10,000/- and a suitable R.I. fo r default of payment of fine.
297. Ms. Farhana Shah, learned counsel appearing for the appellant (A-104) has submitted that the appellant has not made any confession that can be used against him and placing a heavy reliance on the confessional statement of the coaccused is erroneous. Moreover, th.e appellant has already served 3 years of the sentence that was awarded to him. Thus, the appeal should be allowed.
298. Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the State has submitted that the recovery was made at the behest of the appellant and his knowledge of the place where the contraband material was kept implicates him in the present H case. Therefore, the appeal deserves to be dismissed.
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
299. We have considered the .rival submissions made by learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.
300. Evidence against the appellant (A-104): (a)
Deposition of Laxman Nakti (PW-91)
(b)
Deposition of Vasant Jadhav (PW-484)
(b)
Deposition of Dayanand Dhome (PW-573)
(c)
Qeposition of Pratap Dighavkar (PW-586)
c
301. Deposition of Laxman Nakti (PW-91 ): He proved t~e recovery of arms and ammunition on 17.4.1993 wherein he deposed that recovery was made at the behest of disclosure statement of appellant (A-104). He has further deposed that the police party whom the said witness accompanied y.ias led by appellant (A-104) to a lavatory in the courtyard of the house of Subedar. He removed the dry leaves on the ground at the said place and thereafter took out a plastic bag which was below the said dry !eaves. The mouth of the said bag-was closed by tying the same by mean!) of a string. It was a green colour plastic bag and the same was opened and five tin boxes of similar size were recovered. He has also proved the disclosure panchnama. 302. Deposition of Vasant Jadhav (PW-484): He revealed that he was incharge of bomb detection and disposal squad. On 18.4.1993, P.S.I. Gahrate from Mhasla Police Station came to his office with a letter sent by SubDivisional Officer, Raigad and a plastic box. He examined the material suspected to be explosives in the plastic box. He sent it for FSL and received the report. (Ext. 2650).
303. Deposition of Dayanand Dhome (PW-573): In his deposition, he revealed that he was instructed to
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
seize motor jeep bearing registration No. MH-06-A-1 in connection with C.R.No. 6/1993 and he was the person who arrested appellant (A-104) in the presence of two panchas and the panchnama was prepared (Ext. 1996). He has also deposed that on being interrogated, appellant (A-104) gave B information regarding explosives which were recovered in presence of the panch witnesses,. It was recover~d from the lavatory of the house of Subedar. It contained a military colour bag containing five plastic round shape boxes. The panchnama was prepared and it was proved before the court.
c
~04. Deposition of Pratap Dighavkar CPW-586):
He revealed that he instructed P.S.I. Gahrate to send the explosives seized on 17 .4.1993 for Bomb Disposal Unit, Santacruz. and he proved the letter by which the said explosives D were sent for disposal. (Ext. 2024). He (PW. 586) further deposed that the sample was taken out of the recovery and sent for FSL report. 305. The learned Designed Court after appreciating the E evidence concluded that the appellant .(A-104) having knowledge of said articles being kept at said place reveals his authorship of keeping them at said place. The same not being rebutted by the appellant (A-104) would lead to conclu!>ion of him being in possession of contraband material and liable for F commission of offence under section 3(3) TADA i.e. second limb of second charge. However, it was held that there being no sufficient evidence to establish offence under section 6 TADA, he cannot be held liable for the same. Similarly there being no evidence to G ~stablish that the appellant (A-104) transported AK-56 rifles in motor jeep from Mhasla to Bombay i.e. first limb of second charge, he cannot be held guilty for the same. 306. We find no cogent evidence on record requiring H interference with the judgment of the learned Designated Court.
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
The appeal with reference to the appellant (A-104) lacks merit and is accordingly dismissed.
V. Srikrishna Yeshwant Pashilkar (A-110): 307. Appellant (A-110) was further charged for allowing the accused persons to smuggle and transport arms and ammunition into India for the purpose of committing terrorist acts, by illegal omission to thoroughly check the motor lorries carrying arms, ammunition and other contraband though intercepted by them on the night of 9.1.1993 at Gondghar Phata. He was f~rther charged with failing to seize the aforesaid motor tr1,Jck and its contents in lieu of bribe of Rs.7 lakhs agreed by all of them on negotiation with the co-accused Uttam Potdar (A-30), Custom Inspector Gurav (A-82), thereby, facilitating the commission of terrorist activities on 12.3.1993. Thus, charged under Section 3(3) TADA. 308. He was awarded sentence of 6 years under Section 3(3) TADA and a fine of Rs.25,000/-, in default of payment of fine, to suffer further RI of 6 months. He has already served more than 3 years. 309. Ms. Farhana Shah, learned counsel appearing for the appellant has submitted that the appellant (A-110) has not made any confession and reliance on the confessional statement of the co-accused by the learned Designated Court was erroneous. Thus, the appeal deserves to be allowed. 310. Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the State has submitted that Uttam Shantaram Potdar (A30) established the presence of the appellant (A-110) during the incident of interception of trucks at Gondghar Phata therefore, the appellant was involved in allowing arms and ammunition to be transported into India. Thus, the appeal deserves to be dismissed.
c
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
311. We have considered the rival submissions made by learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. 312. Evidence against the appellant (A-110):
c
(a)
Confessional statement of Uttam Potdar (A-30)
(b)
Deposition of Dilip Pansare (PW-97)
(c)
Deposition of other witnesses
313. Confessional Statement of Uttam Potdar (A-30):
In his confessional statement, he stated that as the smuggling party did not have money to pay to the police when they were intercepted while smuggling the contraband, five D silver bricks from the first truck were given to the appellant (A110) who was specifically named by the co-accused (A-30). In the confessional statements of co-accused Dawood Taklya Mohammed Phanse (A-14), Jaywant Keshav Gurav (AE 82), Salim Kutta (A-134) and Mechanic Chacha (A-136) though did not name the appellant (A-110) specifically but they corroborated the version of the prosecution of interception by the police of Shrivardhan Police Station headed by Vijay Krishnaji Patil (A-116) and alongwith silver bricks, some F wooden boxes were al~o in the truck. 314. Deposition of Dilip Pansare CPW-97): In his deposition he revealed that he was working as a mechanic in the State Road Transport Corporation and was a G childhood friend of Uttam Potdar (A-30) who used to help him in transporting and smuggling the goods alongwith others. He had brought the truck for transporting the smuggled contraband on 9.1.1993 and when they were bringing the contraband in two H trucks one of them was being driven by him. They were
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
intercepted by the police of Shrivardhan Police Station at Gondghar Phata junction. He (PW 97) stopped the vehicle on getting the signals by the police. The appellant (A-110) got down from the jeep and he heard the appellant (A-110) shouting to take out the key of the said vehicle and bring the driver to him. He (A-110) came near the truck and took away the keys of the first truck. Othe( police men started shouting that there was silver in the truck. Mechanic Chacha (A-136), Shabir Kadri and Uttam Potdar (A-30) negotiated with the officer Vijay Krishnaji Patil (A-116) foi about half an hour. Gurav, the Customs Officer (A-82) also arrived and after negotiating for about half an hour, five silver bricks were taken from the truck in the police jeep by Hawaldar and the key of the truck was returned to the said witness (PW. 97).
315. Sujjat Peoplankar (PW-158), Bhaskar Boda (PW159), Gopichand Sathnag (PW-160), Tukaram Kalankar (PW161 ), Ganpat Giri (PW-162), Anant Lad (PW-166) and Dhiryasheel Koltharkar (PW-167) have deposed that the defence taken by Vijay Krishnaji Patil (A-116) and the appellant (A-110) that they had gone to a village for patrolling was false as none of them had reached that village on that day.
316. The learned Designated Court after appreciating the evidence came to the conclusion that landing of contraband material took place at Dighi Jetty on 9.1.1993 during night time and goods were transported from said Jetty in two trucks. The said contraband contained arms and ammunition, AK-56 rifles and bullets etc.The police party of Shrivardhan had intercepted the convoy carrying said contraband at Gondghar Phata. Furthermore it was held that confessions of co-accused and Dilip Bhiku Pansare (PW-97) reveal the identity and involvement of the appellant (A-110) in the landing episode. However, it was further held that the appellant (A-110) was
C
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
member of police party headed by his superior Vijay Krishnaji Patil (A-116) and though the appellant (A-110) could not be said to be responsible for taking decision of permitting further transportation of said goods, however taking into account the fact that he had not reported about Vijay Krishnaji Patil (A-116) B to higher officials, reveals that he had also connived with Vijay Krishnaji Patil (A-116) in performing said acts.
317. We find no evidence on record requiring interference with the judgment of the learned Designated Court. The appeal C with reference to appellant (A-110) lacks merit and is accordingly dismissed. 318. So far as the serious objection that when tbe contraband material, arms and ammunition recovered at the D disclosure statements of the appellants were opened in the court the material they were wrapped were subsequent to the date of recovery i.e. 8.4.1993. This has been explained fully in the court by Pratap Dighavkar (PW-586).
He deposed that as some of the samples had to be taken out of the recovered material and sent for FSL report, it was re-opened on 18.4.1993 and samples had been sent for FSL. Thus, the contraband materials recovered on the disclosure statement of these appellants were further wrapped in F newspapers. So, it was quite possible that newspapers upto 18.4.1993 could have been used. None of the appellants had put any further question on possibility of tampering of the evidence to the said witness (PW- 586), though he proved the letter with which the contraband materials were sent for FSL G and the FSL report itself, but none of the appellants put any question in his cross-examination on the possibility of tampering of the material etc. He was the only person who could have explained all the questions raised by the appellants before us.
More so, Ms. Farhana Shah, learned counsel for the
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. S.S. CHAUHAN, J)
appellants could not satisfy the court as under what circumstances none of the appellants could raise this issue before the learned Designated Court. In view of the above, the contention raised does not have any force. The appeal is dismissed accordingly.
Criminal Appeal Nos. 401 and 595 of 2011 319. These appeals have been preferred by the State against Abdullah Ibrahim Surti (A-66), Faki Ali Faki Ahmed Subedar (A-74) and Janardhan Pandurang Gambas (A-81), who· were acquitted of the charge of larger conspiracy. The evidence against all the three respondents had elaborately been dealt with in the connected appeal filed by them. The learned Designated Court has dealt with the issue after considering the entire evidence on record and appreciating the depositions as well as the confessional statements made by the parties. 320. We are fully aware of our limitation to interfere with an order against acquittal. In exceptional cases where there are compelling circumstances and the judgment under appeal is found to be perverse, the appellate court can interfere with the order of acquittal. The appellate court should bear in mind the presumption of innocence of the accused and further that the trial Court's acquittal bolsters the presumption of his innocence. Interference in a routine manner where the other view is possible should be avoided, unless there are good reasons for interference. (Vide: State of Rajasthan v. Darshan Singh @ Darshan Lal, AIR 2012 SC 1973).
C
321. In view of the above, we do not see any cogent reason to interfere with the order of the Designated Court so far as the acquittal of the respondents on a particular charge is concerned. The appeals lack merit and are liable to be· dismissed.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
Criminal Appeal No. 171 & 172 of 2008 322. These appeals have been preferred against the judgments and orders dated 26.9.2006 and 21.5.2007, passed by the Special Judge of the Designated Court under the TADA for the Bombay Blast, Greater Bombay, in the Bombay Blast Case No. 1/1993, by which the appellants have been convicted under Section 3(3) TADA.
They have been acquitted of the first charge of conspiracy, but have been convicted under Section 3(3) TADA and have C been sentenced to suffer RI of 6 years alongwith a fine of Rs.25,000/-, and in default of payment of fine, to suffer further RI for six months. They have already served a sentence of 4 years and 3 months.
323. Facts and circumstances giving rise to these appeals are that:
A. In addition to the first charge of conspiracy, the appellants have been charged for intentionally aiding and abetting terrorists, by allowing them to smuggle and transport E arms and ammunition into India for the purpose of committing terrorist acts, by their illegal omission to thoroughly check motor lorries carrying arms, ammunition and other contraband, though the same had been intercepted by their team on the night of 9.1.1993, at Gondghar Phata, and for their failure to seize the F aforesaid motor truck and its contents, in lieu of a bribe of Rs. 7 lakhs which had been agreed to and accepted by them, after negotiations with terrorists and their associates. Thus, they have been charged under Section 3(3) TADA.
B. After conclusion of the trial, the learned Designated Court held the appellants guilty and awarded punishment as referred to hereinabove. Hence, these appeals.
324. Shri P.K. Dey, learned counsel appearing for the
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @ A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
appellants, has submitted that sufficient evidence on record A does not exist -to convict the appellants. In their confessional . statements, Uttam Shantaram Potdar (A~30) and Jaywant Keshav Gurav (A-82), have not made any reference to the smuggling of arms and ammunition, intact, they have spoken of the smuggling of silver. Therefore, the question of framing B any charge against the present appellants under TADA, in view ·of such confessional statements could not arise. Moreover, the memorandum annexed to the confessional statement is a part and parcel of the confession, and the same has to be filled up simultaneously, and not subsequently.
c
So far as the confessional statement of Uttam Shantaram Potdar (A-30) is concerned, the said memorandum had been sent subsequently. Thus, the same was in violation of the statutory provisions of TADA and, the TADA Rules, particularly, as the same was not in compliance with the requirements of sections 15(3)(b) and 15(5) of the TADA Rules, The said confessional statement required a certificate under Rule 15(4), and such a certificate was not annexed by the officer recording the confessional statements of Uttam Shantaram Potdar (A-30), Jaywant Keshav Gurav (A-82) and Salim Kutta (A-134). The confessional statement of Salim Kutta (A-134) was recorded on 19.8.1995, and the same was sent to the CMM on 24.8.1995. Therefore, the same is not valid. It has also been contended that after the recording of the confession on 19.8.1995 at Ahmedabad, Salim Kutta (A-134) had been brought to Bombay by the CBI to the STF office, and that subsequently, he had been taken back to Ahmedabad on 24.8.1995 and that here, he was produced before the CMM Ahmedabad.
325. Shri Mukul Gupta, learned senior counsel appearing for the respondent, has submitted that these two appellants have failed to perform their duty. They had not checked the boxes, they had only counted the bricks in the trucks. The previous
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2013] 16 S.C.R.
A amount of bribe of Rs.25,000/- was enhanced to a sum of Rs.10 lakhs after a negotiation of about half an hour. Therefore, the matter is not one of mere negligence, but of intentional facilitation of the accused persons in the smuggling of arms and ammunition into the country.
326. We have considered the rival submissions made by learned counsel for the parties and perused the record. 327. Evidence against the appellants:
c
(a)
Confessional statement of Uttain Shantaram Potdar (A-30)
(b).
Confessional statements of Dawood Taklya (A-14) and Dadabhai (A-17)
(c)
Confessional statement of Jaywant Keshav Gurav (A-82)
(d)
Confessional statement of Salim Kutta (A-134)
(e)
Confessional statement of Mechanic Chacha (A136)
(n
Deposition of Dilip Bhiku Pansare (PW-97)
(g)
Deposition of Yeshwant Kadam (PW-109)
(h)
Deposition of Pramod Mudbhatkal (PW-681)
(i)
Deposition of other witnesses
328. Uttam Shantaram Potdar (A-30), Jaywant Keshav G Gurav (A-82), Salim Kutta (A-134) and Mechanic Chacha (A-136) in their confessional statements, while narrating the incident of the interception of trucks at Gondghar Phata, have stated the presence of 5-7 police officials in the party, headed by VK Patil (A-116), though they have not specifically named H the appellants. This police party further allowed the goods to
AHMED SHAH KHAN DURRANI @A.S. MUBARAK v. STATE OF MAHARASHTRA [DR. B.S. CHAUHAN, J.]
go past, without proper checking after negotiating a bribe to the tune of Rs.7 lakhs. As the smugglers did not have said amount of Rs.7 lakhs with them at the said time, they had given five silver bricks that had been sm• ·~died in the landing; to the police as security and subsequently, upon making them payment of the said amo"unt to the officials, the silver bricks had been returned to die smugglers.
Confessional statement of Uttam Potdar (A-30): 329. He has stated that on 9.1.1993, at night, after the smuggling of the goods, they had been intercepted by the Shrivardhan police near Gondghar Phata. Upon inquiry, Shri Patil (A-116), SI of the Shrivardhan Police Station, had asked Salim (A-134) why the money promised to them had not been paid, as regards the earlier landing. Uttam Potdar (A-30) had told him that he had given the said money to Ramesh Mali Hawaldar. SI Patil (A-116) had seemed very annoyed. Mechanic Chacha (A-136) had then offered a sum of Rs. 10 lakhs to Hawaldar Ramesh Dattatray Mali (A-101) and Hawaldar Ashok Narayan Muneshwar (A-70), who were counting the silver bricks that had been loaded into the truck. There were 175 bricks in one truck, and in the other, there were about 100 bricks and also some boxes. Upon being asked by the Hawaldar to reveal the contents of the boxes, Mechanic Chacha (A-136) had said that the boxes contained watches and