Bhagyashree Chagan Kale and Ors v. The Divisisional Controller Msrtc
- Court
- Bombay High Court
- Date of judgment
- 6 October 2026
- Case number
- IA No. 1568 of 2026
- Result
- Allowed
Full judgment
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIRCUIT BENCH AT KOLHAPUR CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION 59 INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1568 OF 2026 IN FIRST APPEAL (ST) NO. 2225 OF 2026 Bhagyashree Chagan Kale And Ors Versus The Divisional Controller MSRTC
...Applicants ...Respondent
60 INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1569 OF 2026 IN FIRST APPEAL (ST) NO. 2229 OF 2026 Janabai Devnarayan Kashid And Ors Versus The Divisional Controller MSRTC And Ors.
...Applicants ...Respondents
61 INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1570 OF 2026 IN FIRST APPEAL (ST) NO. 2235 OF 2026 Rajshree Sambhaji Mahingade And Ors Versus The Divisional Controller MSRTC And Anr.
...Applicants ...Respondents
62 INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 1573 OF 2026 IN FIRST APPEAL (ST) NO. 2232 OF 2026 Arun Manikrao Mohare And Ors Versus The Divisional Controller MSRTC And Ors.
...Applicants ...Respondents
….. Adv. R. S. Alange, Advocate for Claimants/Applicants. Adv. Ketan Patil a/w Adv. Pinky Bhansali, Advocate for Respondent MSRTC. …..
CORAM : SHAILESH P. BRAHME, J. DATE
: 06th OCTOBER, 2026.
P.C. : Heard. 2.
These applications are decided by common order.
3.
The Corporation has preferred four (4) appeals challenging
distinct Judgments and Awards passed by the Tribunal. Following is the break - up of the claims at a glance : Interim Application No. IA/1568/2026 IA/1569/2026 IA/1570/2026
IA/1573/2026
4.
Name of the M.A.C.P. No. Awarded Amount Deposited Amount Deceased (Proceeding No.) Chagan Limbaji Rs.37,24,000/-@ Rs.51,36,018/Kale 7% p.a. Devnarayan Rs.71,10,436/-@ Rs.98,15,386/Mahadev Kashid 7% p.a. Sambhaji Rs.81,83,560/-@ Rs.1,12,98,926/Janardhan 7% p.a. Mahingade Rakesh Arun Rs.38,51,440/-@ Rs.53,12,114/Mohare 7% p.a.
The applicants are the defendants upon the deceased who were
employees of Panchayat Samiti and who were traveling in a Jeep which was collided with vehicle of the respondent – Corporation. 5.
It is contended that they have not been disbursed anything after
the awards. For the reasons stated in the application, they are claiming the amount. It is further contended that considering the expenses and needs of the family, amounts be disbursed. 6.
Per contra, the learned counsel appearing for the respondent –
Corporation would vehemently oppose the applications. It is submitted that the driver of the Jeep was responsible and he was overspeeding. It is a case of contributory negligence and exorbitant compensation is awarded in each case. It is further submitted that the applicants are unable to produce on record the relevant material and the claim is unfounded. The appeals have been preferred against unreasonable and arbitrary quantum. 7.
The deaths occurred in the accident are undisputed. The bread
earners of the family have lost their lives in the accident. The applicants have not been paid any amount. It would be wholly pedantic to keep the applicants waiting till final disposal of the appeals. The appeals are not likely to be decided finally within short time. 8.
Considering the defense raised by the respondent and the
findings recorded by the Tribunal, I am not inclined to disburse the entire deposited amount in each matter. But the ends of the justice would be met in permitting the applicants to receive 50% of the amount with accrued interest. The contentious issues involved in the matter can be dealt with at the time of final disposal of the appeals. Hence, I pass the following order : ::ORDER:: A.
The applications are partly allowed.
B.
The applicants in all the applications shall be disbursed 50% of
the amount with accrued interest on furnishing an undertaking to the satisfaction of the Presiding Officer of the Tribunal. C.
The balance amount shall be invested in nationalized Bank.
[ SHAILESH P. BRAHME, J.]