Dr. Vimal Kumar Bhadani @ Dr. Bimal Bhadani v. State of Bihar and Anr

Court
Patna High Court
Date of judgment
27 October 2026
Judge
Justice Sandeep Kumar
Case number
CR. MISC. No. 46698 of 2018
Result
ALLOWED
Acts & sections
Section 304 IPC, Section 304A IPC
Advocates
Saket Tiwary, Bharat Bhushan, Jharkhandi Upadhyay
Subject
Criminal

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT PATNA CRIMINAL MISCELLANEOUS No.46698 of 2018 CNR No. BRHC010424782018 Arising Out of PS. Case No.-10 Year-2011 Thana- GAYA KOTWALI District- Gaya

1. 2.

====================================================== Dr. Vimal Kumar Bhadani @ Dr. Bimal Bhadani S/o Sri Uma Nath Bhadani, Resident of Village- Katari Hill Road, Near Creane School, Police StationCivil Lines, District- Gaya Bihar. ... ... Petitioner/s Versus State Of Bihar Sri Suresh Prasad Keshri, Son of Sri Om Prakash Keshri, Resident of Mahila College, Police Station- Kotwali, District- Gaya Bihar. ... ... Opposite Party/s ====================================================== Appearance : For the Petitioner/s : For the Opposite Party/s :

Mr. Saket Tiwary Mr. Sri Bharat Bhushan Mr. Jharkhandi Upadhyay

====================================================== CORAM: HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE SANDEEP KUMAR ORAL ORDER

27-10-2026

Heard the parties including the learned counsel for the opposite party no. 02. 2. This application has been filed for quashing the order dated 31.05.2018 passed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Gaya in Kotwali P.S. Case No. 10 of 2011. 3. The prosecution case, in brief, is that Kotwali P.S. Case No. 10 of 2011, dated 13.01.2011, was instituted on the basis of the fardbeyan of Sri Suresh Prasad Keshri, alleging medical negligence on the part of the petitioner. It is alleged that the informant admitted his child in the nursing home of the petitioner on 11.01.2011 for medical treatment and blood transfusion was scheduled for 12.01.2011. However, despite the several requests for medical attention, the petitioner allegedly avoided him and the child died. It is further alleged that neither

2/11

the petitioner nor the nursing home staff attended the child and the informant was denied the medical prescription when he requested it. The informant attributed the death of his child to the medical negligence of the petitioner and declined to have a post-mortem examination conducted. Upon completion of the investigation, the police submitted Final Form No. 144 of 2011, dated 30.06.2011, finding the case true under Section 304 of the Indian Penal Code pursuant to which cognizance was taken by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Gaya. 4. The learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the petitioner is innocent and has not committed any offence as alleged against him. He further submits that no prima facie case under Section 304 of IPC has been made out against the petitioner. The order of cognizance has been passed in a routine manner, even though, at the time of passing the order, no expert opinion regarding the cause of death was available on record. Therefore, the learned court below has failed to apply its mind before taking cognizance. 5. Learned counsel for the petitioner further submits that in the absence of an expert opinion and definitive evidence, no case under Section 304 IPC can be made out against him. The Hon'ble Apex Court has consistently held that allegations of

3/11

medical negligence can only be determined with the assistance of expert opinion, and in the present case, such expert opinion was not obtained before taking cognizance. 6. It is further submitted that the continuation of these proceedings on the basis of the cognizance order passed in the absence of expert opinion and without considering crucial evidence would constitute an abuse of the process of the court. The continuation of such proceedings will serve no useful purpose and will result in a miscarriage of justice. 7. In support of his submission, the learned counsel for the petitioner has relied upon a judgment of the Hon’ble Supreme Court passed in the case of Jacob Mathews vs. State of Punjab & Anr., reported in AIR 2005 SC 3180 and in the case of Martin F. D’Souza vs. Mohd. Ishfaq reported in AIR 2009 SC 2049. 8. Learned counsel for the State and learned counsel for the opposite party no. 02 have opposed the application of the petitioner. 9. I have heard and considered the submissions of the parties and have gone through the records of the case. 10. In the case of Jacob Mathews vs State of Punjab and Anr. (supra), the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held in

4/11

paragraph nos. 48 to 52 as follows:“48. Conclusions summed up we sum up our conclusions as under:(1) Negligence is the breach of a duty caused by omission

to

reasonable

do

something

which

man

guided

by

a

those

considerations which ordinarily regulate the conduct of human affairs would do, or doing something which a prudent and reasonable man would not do. The definition of negligence as given in Law of Torts, Ratanlal & Dhirajlal (edited by Justice G.P. Singh), referred

to

hereinabove,

holds

good.

Negligence becomes actionable on account of injury resulting from the act or omission amounting to negligence attributable to the person sued. The essential components of negligence are three: 'duty', 'breach' and 'resulting damage'. (2) Negligence in the context of medical profession necessarily calls for a treatment with a difference. To infer rashness or negligence on the part of a professional, in particular considerations

a

doctor, apply.

A

additional case

of

occupational negligence is different from one of professional negligence. A simple lack of care, an error of judgment or an accident, is not proof of negligence on the part of a medical professional. So long as a doctor follows a practice acceptable to the medical profession of that day, he cannot be held liable for negligence merely because a better alternative course or method of

5/11

treatment was also available or simply because a more skilled doctor would not have chosen to follow or resort to that practice or procedure which the accused followed. When it comes to the failure of taking precautions what has to be seen is whether those precautions were taken which the ordinary experience of men has found to be sufficient; a failure to use special or extraordinary precautions which might have prevented the particular happening cannot be the standard for judging the alleged negligence. So also, the standard of care, while assessing the practice as adopted, is judged in the light of knowledge available at the time of the incident, and not at the date of trial. Similarly, when the charge of negligence arises out of failure to use some particular equipment, the charge would fail if

the

equipment

was

not

generally

available at that particular time (that is, the time of the incident) at which it is suggested it should have been used. (3) A professional may be held liable for negligence on one of the two findings: either he was not possessed of the requisite skill which he professed to have possessed, or, he did not exercise, with reasonable competence in the given case, the skill which he did possess. The standard to be applied for judging, whether the person charged has been negligent or not, would be that of an ordinary competent person exercising ordinary skill in that profession.

6/11

It is not possible for every professional to possess the highest level of expertise or skills in that branch which he practices. A highly

skilled

professional

may

be

possessed of better qualities, but that cannot be made the basis or the yardstick for judging the performance of the professional

proceeded

against

on

indictment of negligence. (4)

The

test

for

determining

medical

negligence as laid down in Bolam's case [1957] 1 W.L.R. 582, 586 holds good in its applicability in India. (5)

The

jurisprudential

concept

of

negligence differs in civil and criminal law. What may be negligence in civil law may not necessarily be negligence in criminal law. For negligence to amount to an offence, the element of mens rea must be shown to exist. For an act to amount to criminal

negligence,

the

degree

of

negligence should be much higher i.e. gross or of a very high degree. Negligence which is neither gross nor of a higher degree may provide a ground for action in civil law but cannot form the basis for prosecution. (6) The word 'gross' has not been used in Section 304A of IPC, yet it is settled that in

criminal

law

negligence

or

recklessness, to be so held, must be of such a high degree as to be 'gross'. The expression 'rash or negligent act' as occurring in Section 304A of the IPC has

7/11

to be read as qualified by the word 'grossly'. (7) To prosecute a medical professional for negligence under criminal law it must be shown that the accused did something or failed to do something which in the given facts and circumstances no medical professional in his ordinary senses and prudence would have done or failed to do. The hazard taken by the accused doctor should be of such a nature that the injury which resulted was most likely imminent. (8) Res ipsa loquitur is only a rule of evidence and operates in the domain of civil law specially in cases of torts and helps in determining the onus of proof in actions relating to negligence. It cannot be pressed in service for determining per se the liability for negligence

within

the

domain

of

criminal law. Res ipsa loquitur has, if at all, a limited application in trial on a charge of criminal negligence. 49. In view of the principles laid down hereinabove and the preceding discussion, we agree with the principles of law laid down in Dr. Suresh Gupta's case (2004) 6 SCC 422 and re-affirm the same. Ex abundanti cautela, we clarify that what we are affirming are the legal principles laid down and the law as stated in Dr. Suresh Gupta's case. We may not be understood as having expressed any opinion on the question whether on the facts of that case

8/11

the accused could or could not have been held guilty of criminal negligence as that question is not before us. We also approve of the passage from Errors, Medicine and the Law by Alan Merry and Alexander McCall Smith which has been cited with approval in Dr. Suresh Gupta's case (noted vide para 27 of the report). Guidelines re: prosecuting medical professionals 50. As we have noticed hereinabove that the cases of doctors (surgeons and physicians) being subjected to criminal prosecution are on an increase. Sometimes such prosecutions are filed by private complainants and sometimes by police on an FIR being

lodged

and

cognizance

taken.

The

investigating officer and the private complainant cannot always be supposed to have knowledge of medical science so as to determine whether the act of the accused medical professional amounts to rash or negligent act within the domain of criminal law under Section 304-A of IPC. The criminal process once initiated subjects the medical professional

to

serious

embarrassment

and

sometimes harassment. He has to seek bail to escape arrest, which may or may not be granted to him. At the end he may be exonerated by acquittal or discharge but the loss which he has suffered in his reputation cannot be compensated by any standards. 51. We may not be understood as holding that doctors can never be prosecuted for an offence of which rashness or negligence is an essential ingredient. All that we are doing is to emphasize the need for care and caution in the interest of society; for, the service which the medical

9/11

profession renders to human beings is probably the noblest of all, and hence there is a need for protecting doctors from frivolous or unjust prosecutions.

Many

a

complainant

prefers

recourse to criminal process as a tool for pressurizing

the

medical

professional

for

extracting uncalled for or unjust compensation. Such malicious proceedings have to be guarded against. 52. Statutory Rules or Executive Instructions incorporating certain guidelines need to be framed and issued by the Government of India and/or the State Governments in consultation with the Medical Council of India. So long as it is not done, we propose to lay down certain guidelines for the future which should govern the prosecution of doctors for offences of which criminal rashness or criminal negligence is an ingredient. A private complaint may not be entertained

unless

the

complainant

has

produced prima facie evidence before the Court in the form of a credible opinion given by another competent doctor to support the charge of rashness or negligence on the part of the accused doctor. The investigating officer should, before proceeding against the doctor accused of rash or negligent act or omission, obtain an independent and competent medical opinion preferably from a doctor in government service qualified in that branch of medical practice who can normally be expected to give an impartial and unbiased opinion applying Bolam's test to the facts collected in the investigation. A doctor accused of rashness or negligence, may not be

10/11

arrested in a routine manner (simply because a charge has been levelled against him). Unless his arrest is necessary for furthering the investigation or for collecting evidence or unless the investigation officer feels satisfied that the doctor proceeded against would not make himself available to face the prosecution unless arrested, the arrest may be withheld.”

11. Further, in the case of Martin F. D’Souza vs. Mohd. Ishfaq (supra) the Hon’ble Supreme Court has held in paragraph no.17 with regard to obtaining expert’s opinion before lodging the F.I.R. against a doctor, which is as under:“117. We, therefore, direct that whenever a complaint is received against a doctor or hospital by the Consumer Fora (whether District, State or National) or by the Criminal Court then before issuing notice to the doctor or hospital against whom the complaint was made the Consumer Forum or Criminal Court should first refer the matter to a competent

doctor

or

committee

of

doctors, specialized in the field relating to which the medical negligence is attributed, and only after that doctor or committee reports that there is a prima facie case of medical negligence should notice be then issued to the concerned doctor/hospital. This is necessary to avoid harassment to doctors who may not be ultimately found to be negligent.

11/11

We further warn the police officials not to arrest or harass doctors unless the facts clearly come within the parameters laid down in Jacob Mathew's case (supra), otherwise the policemen will themselves have to face legal action.”

12. In light of the judgments referred to above and the fact that no expert opinion has been obtained in the present case to establish prima facie medical negligence, the order taking cognizance under Section 304 of IPC appears to have been passed without application of mind and without considering the essential evidence required to establish negligence. 13. In view of the facts of the case, submissions of the parties and the law laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the afore-quoted judgments, the present application stands allowed. 14. Accordingly,

the order dated 31.05.2018

passed by the learned Chief Judicial Magistrate, Gaya in Kotwali P.S. Case No. 10 of 2011 is hereby quashed.

(Sandeep Kumar, J) Vikas/U

Related judgments

More Patna High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.