Hanmant Babarao Banbare and Anr v. The State of Maharashtra and Ors
- Court
- Bombay High Court
- Date of judgment
- 3 November 2026
- Case number
- FA No. 1574 of 2020
- Result
- PARTLY ALLOWED AND PARTLY DISMISSED
- Subject
- Civil, Property & land
Full judgment
2026:BHC-AUG:54683
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD 941 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1560 OF 2022 SADASHIV RAJARAM BANBARE VERSUS THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS AND 952 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1451 OF 2020 SANDEEP BALAJI AATNURE AND ANR VERSUS THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS AND 953 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1574 OF 2020 HANMANT BABARAO BANBARE AND ANR VERSUS THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA AND ORS ... Mrs. Laxmi Thakur h/f. Mr. L. C. Patil, Advocate for Appellants Mr. K. B. Jadhav, Mr. B. V. Virdhe and Mr. S. N. Kendre, AGPs for Respondent-State respectively Mr. S. P. Sonpawale, Advocate for Respondent/Acquiring Body … CORAM : AJIT B. KADETHANKAR, J. DATED : 03.11.2026 P.C. :.
Considering the short controversy involved in the
matters and in the light of the view expressed by this Court in earlier First Appeal No.3591 of 2023 vide judgment and order dated 22.01.2026, the appeals could conveniently be disposed
of at the admission stage. 2.
The subject matter house properties were acquired by
the acquiring body for the purpose of the Lendi Project. The details are as follows: FA No. Judgment date
LAR No.
Gut No. and Area
Notificatio Award u/s. LAO n u/s 4 granted
Reference Court granted
1560/2022 283/12 Old House 03.05.2007 27.08.2010 3,14,244/- 1,25,698/No.111 08.04.2019 New House No.346 Total area 63.75 sq.mtr. 1451/2020 448/12 Old House No.47 26.06.2019 New (Chalta) House No.307 Area 168.75 sq.mtr and Old House No.340 New (Chalta) House No.245 Area 53.00 sq.mtr
03.05.2007 27.08.2010 4,34,441/- 6,96,868/2,62,427/-
1574/2020 240/12 Old House 03.05.2007 27.08.2010 2,19,103/- 87,641/No.93 27.06.2019 New (Chalta) House No.327 Tota Area 94.00 sq.mtr.
3.
So far as the compensation granted towards the lands is
concerned, the same is not in dispute. The claims of the claimants towards their house properties are as follows: FA No.
Compensation claimed towards house property
1560 of 2022
Rs.10,06,867/-
1451 of 2020
Rs.21,65,180/-
1574 of 2020
Rs.5,75,104/-
4.
Learned Advocate for the appellants submits that in
First Appeal No.1560 of 2022, the valuation report prepared by the private valuer was at Exhibit 25. In First Appeal No.1451 of 2020, the report was at Exhibit 26 whereas in First Appeal No.1574 of 2020, the valuation report was also at Exhibit 25. It is further contended by the appellants that the claimants examined the respective private valuers and proved the valuation reports. It is further contended that no contrary evidence was adduced by the acquiring body to enable the Reference Court to take any other view or to discard the evidence tendered by the claimants on the point of valuation of the house properties. Thus, she submits that the appellants are entitled to compensation towards their house properties as per the valuation reports which remained uncontroverted during the trial. The reasons assigned by the Reference Court for discarding the said valuation reports are not at all justifiable. Thus, it is prayed that the appeals be allowed. 5.
While advancing these arguments, learned Advocate for
the appellants seeks to place on record a copy of the order dated 22.01.2026 passed by this Court in First Appeal No.3591 of 2023 arising out of the same land acquisition
project. She submits that in the said matter, though the valuation report of the private valuer was discarded by the Reference Court, this Court accepted the said valuation report and granted compensation to the concerned appellants towards their residential properties. Clause No.5 of the said order reads thus :
“5. Appellant has adduced evidence of private valuer and his report is proved and marked as Exhibit 25. The valuation is shown to be of Rs.3,25,761/-. There is no contra evidence adduced by the respondent - acquiring body. This Court has been taking consistent view in accepting the report of the private valuer for enhancing the compensation. A useful reliance can be had to following judgment/order of this Court : 1. Kashinath s/o Nagnath vs. The State of Maharashtra and Ors. in First Appeal No.2460 of 2021 with connected matters dated 13.07.2022 2. Ramesh Govindrao Patil vs. The State of Maharashtra and Ors. in First Appeal No.1814 of 2023 dated 18.12.2025.” The copy of the cited order is taken on record and marked as Annexure “X” for identification. 7.
Learned Advocate for the acquiring body would fairly
submit that the said order was passed after hearing the acquiring body.
8.
With the able assistance of both the learned Advocates
for the respective parties, I have gone through the text of the cited order. With due respect, I find no reason to disagree with the view taken by this Court in the cited case. In the present matters also, the evidence tendered by the appellants was that of private valuers. The valuation reports were accepted and duly proved by examining the concerned valuers. No contrary evidence was adduced by the other side. In view of this, I am of the considered view that the appeals deserve to be partly allowed thereby granting the appellants compensation towards their acquired house properties. 9.
Hence, I pass the following order: ORDER I.
First Appeals are partly allowed.
II.
In First Appeal No.1560 of 2022, the
appellant is held entitled to compensation towards the house property at Rs.10,06,867/- as per the valuation report at Exhibit 25. III.
In First Appeal No.1451 of 2020, the
appellants are held entitled to compensation towards the house property at Rs.21,65,180/- as per the valuation report at Exhibit 26. IV.
In First Appeal No.1574 of 2020, the
appellants are held entitled to compensation
towards the house property at Rs.5,75,104/- as per the valuation report at Exhibit 25. V.
The appellants shall not be entitled to
interest and statutory benefits for the delayed period, if any. VI.
The
acquiring
body/respondent
shall
deposit the compensation amount in this Court within a period of six months. VII.
The interest part shall be governed by the
law laid down by the Full Bench judgment in the case of State of Maharashtra v. Kailash Shiva
Rangari, reported in 2016 (4) ALL MR 513. VIII. Save
and
except
above,
impugned
Judgment and Award passed by Reference Court shall stand unaltered. IX.
The appellants shall pay the deficit court
fees, if any. X.
Award be modified accordingly.
XI.
Record and proceedings be sent back to
the Reference Court. XII.
Civil Applications, if any, stand disposed
of.
PRW
( AJIT B. KADETHANKAR, J. )