M/S Krishna Highbase PVT LTD v. State of Hp and Others

Court
High Court of Himachal Pradesh
Date of judgment
1 October 2026
Judge
Justice Gurmeet Singh Sandhawalia
Case number
ARB.C No. 401 of 2025
Result
Disposed Off
Acts & sections
Section 11 Arbitration Act
Advocates
Suneet Goel, Vishwas Kaushal
Subject
Civil, Arbitration

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

2026:HHC:42788

IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH SHIMLA

Arb. Case No. 401 of 2025 Reserved on : 25.09.2026. Pronounced on: 01.10.2026 Uploaded on: 01.10.2026 ______________________________________________________ M/s Krishna Highbase Pvt. Ltd. …..Petitioner Versus State of Himachal Pradesh & others ..Respondents ______________________________________________________ Coram: The Hon’ble Mr. Justice G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice. Whether approved for reporting?

______________________________________________________ For the Petitioner: Mr. Suneet Goel, Senior Advocate with Mr. Vishwas Kaushal, Advocate. For the Respondents: Mr. Navlesh Verma, Additional Advocate General. G.S. Sandhawalia, Chief Justice The petitioner seeks the appointment of an Arbitrator under Section 11(6) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Act’).

The work in question was for the

construction of Keoldhar Seri Sainj Bagra Road Km. 0/0 to 19/0 (SH:-Passing Plac2026:HHC:42788 e, B/Wall, C.D. and V-Shape Drain etc. (portion Naglog

to Balidhar road Km. 11/0 to 19/0 for an amount of Rs.1,98,42,159/-

with

stipulated

time

for

its

completion as 18 months to be reckoned up till 9.11.2016. 2.

The formal letter of award was issued

26.10.2018 (Annexure P-2) and thereafter, formal Agreement No. 196 of 2018-2019 (Annexure P-3) was entered into between the parties, which contained Arbitration Clause 25 to settle disputes through arbitration. 3.

It is the pleaded case of the petitioner that

the project site was located in a snowbound area. Even though machinery was mobilized in March, 2019, but the work could not be completed on account of heavy snowfall in the winter of 2020, leaving the tarring work unexecuted. The work apparently remained incomplete, leading to the imposition of liquidated damages on 20.05.2021 (Annexure P-4), wherein the Executive Engineer, Karsog Division had noticed that the work had not been completed and tarring had not been carried

out,

despite

issuing

repeated

notices

dated

16.10.2020, 21.11.2020, 09.04.2021 and 23.04.2021. Resultantly, there was breach of the relevant clause of

contract

and

liquidated

damages

were

imposed @ 10% of the awarded amount, totaling Rs. 19,84,215/-, while directing the resumption of the work. 4.

The work was subsequently rescinded on

27.05.2021 (Annexure P-5) in terms of clause 3(ii)(iii) and 3(a) of the contract agreement and the security deposit in respect of the said work alongwith the earnest money in the shape of an FDR, was forfeited. 5.

Apparently, the petitioner took no action

on the same and only submitted a representation after 2½ years on 07.12.2023 (Annexure P-6) to waive off the penalty as levied upon it and also to release the security amount, while admitting that the tender had already been closed. 6.

On

24.05.2025

(Annexure

P-7),

Executive Engineer, Karsog Division wrote to the District Collector, Mandi regarding history of the

litigation that approximately 62.89% of the work, amounting to Rs.1,24,79,172/- had been completed and the penalty as such had been reduced to Rs.7,36,200/- vide letter dated 26.06.2021. Further, the security deposit of Rs.4,72,965/- had been forfeited vide various transfer entry orders, leaving an un-covered sum of Rs.7,36,200/- under Clause 29 of the Agreement and steps were being taken to blacklist

08.04.2025.

Contractor,

as

per

letter

dated

Resultantly, a total sum of Rs.

10,33,665/- was sought to be recovered, inclusive of the interest at the rate of 9%. 7. up

Apparently, thereafter, the petitioner woke and

sent

a

legal

notice

dated

05.09.2025

(Annexure P-9) seeking the appointment of an Arbitrator,

mentioning

aforesaid

facts

and

alleging that the security had been forfeited without affording an opportunity of being heard, challenging wrong

imposition

escalation etc.

of

penalty,

claiming

price

It was also mentioned that arrears

were being recovered through the Sub-Divisional

Magistrate, Karsog and reference was made to the notice issued in that regard. 8.

Learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner

submitted that a representation dated 07.12.2023 (Annexure P-6), had been filed and therefore, the present petition is within limitation from the said date. 9. has

The State, on the other hand, it its reply specifically

stated

there

exists

no

dispute

between the parties which can be referred to arbitration. The contract having been rescinded and terminated way back in May, 2021, the appointment of an Arbitrator could not be sought in the year 2025, after a lapse of about four years. Therefore, the petition deserves to be dismissed. 10.

In the replication, it has been pleaded that

the cause of action arose when the communication dated 24.05.2025, was sent to the District Collector, Mandi to recover the liquidated damages and thus, the period of limitation should be computed from the said date.

11.

This Court is not in agreement with the

arguments raised by the learned Senior Counsel for the petitioner. The representation dated 07.12.2023 (Annexure P-6) made by the petitioner was only to the extent of waiving off the penalty as levied upon it and releasing the security deposit.

No such claim

was made regarding the forfeiture of the security deposit, nor any prayer was made for referring the matter to arbitration.

The petitioner was satisfied

as such, did not complete the work and never sought to resolve the issue by referring the matter to the arbitration.

The starting point as such to count the

limitation would be from 27.05.2021 when the contract was rescinded. 12.

The issue is no longer res integra since

three Judge Bench of the Apex Court in Elfit Arabia and Another Vs. Concept Hotel Barons Limited and Others (2024) SCC OnLine SC 1739, has held that the Court must ‘cut the deadwood’ by refraining from appointing an arbitrator when claims are ex

facie time-barred and dead, or where no subsisting dispute exists. 13.

Reliance can also be placed upon the

judgments passed by the Apex Court in Bharat Sanchar Nigam Limited and Another Vs. M/s. Nortel Networks India Private Limited (2021) 5 SCC 798 and also in Civil Appeal No. 4320 of 2026, titled as State of West Bengal and Others Vs. M/s. B.B.M. Enterprises, dated 09.04.2026, wherein the order of the High Court which had restored a dead dispute after a period of twenty years, was set-aside. 14.

In Arbitration Petition (C) No. 13 of

2023, titled as M/s B and T AG Vs. Ministry of Defence, decided on 18.05.2023, a similar issue concerning the appointment of

Arbitrator arose

before the Apex Court. The encashment of the warranty bond had taken place on 16.02.2016 and thereafter, the parties apparently discussions.

The

petitioner

remained in requested

respondents to review the wrongful imposition of the

liquidated damages on 04.09.2019 and a notice of

arbitration

08.11.2021.

was

sent

by

petitioner

on

The said notice was held to have been

sent after a period of more than five years, far beyond

limitation

period

of

three

years.

Resultantly, it was held that the ‘Breaking Point’ should be treated as the date on which the cause of action arose for the purpose of limitation, which was the encashment of the bank guarantee. The entire history of the case has to be seen and party

has

settlement.

abandoned

efforts

at

whether a

arriving

at

a

The relevant paragraphs of the said

judgment read as under “62. At the cost of repetition, we state that when the bank guarantee came to be encashed in the year 2016 and the requisite amount stood transferred to the Government account that was the end of the matter. This "Breaking Point should be treated as the date at which the cause of action arose for the purpose of limitation. 63. Negotiations may continue even for a period of ten years or twenty years after the cause of action had arisen. Mere negotiations will not postpone the "cause of action" for the purpose of limitation. The Legislature has prescribed a limit of three years for the enforcement of a claim and this statutory time period cannot be defeated on the ground that the parties were negotiating.”

15.

Resultantly, it was held that the case was

hopelessly time-barred and the petition was found to have been filed after more than a period of five years. Even though, there was an arbitration clause, but the same could not be acted upon on account of inordinate delay.

In such circumstances, in the present

case, it is held that the contract with the Contractor was rescinded on 27.05.2021.

Merely because

amount was to be recovered on account of the land revenue and the Executive Engineer, Karsog Division wrote to the District Collector, Mandi on 24.05.2025 (Annexure P-7), the period of limitation would not be extended, as contended by the learned Counsel for the petitioner.

Thus, the legal notice issued

on

05.09.2025 invoking the arbitration clause, was far beyond the limitation period of three years, which had expired in May, 2024. 17.

Resultantly,

petition

being

time-

barred, no occasion is made out to refer the parties to

arbitration

and

it

is

accordingly

dismissed.

Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of.

(G.S. Sandhawalia) Chief Justice. October 01, 2026 (hemlata)

Related judgments

More Himachal Pradesh High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.