Narendra Somnath Dhake (gpa) and Ors v. The State of Maharashtra Thr District Collector, Jalgaon and Ors
- Court
- Bombay High Court
- Date of judgment
- 31 October 2026
- Case number
- FA No. 2319 of 2021
- Result
- PARTLY ALLOWED AND PARTLY DISMISSED
- Subject
- Civil, Property & land
Full judgment
2026:BHC-AUG:54099
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD FIRST APPEAL NO. 2318 OF 2021 Rajesh Muralidhar Patil VERSUS The State Of Maharashtra Thr District Collector, Jalgaon And Ors ... Mr. J. V. Patil, Advocate for Appellant in respective FAs Mr. K. B. Jadhavar, AGP for Respondent-State in respective FAs Mr. S. B. Kadu, Advocate for Respondent no.3 in respective FAs AND FIRST APPEAL NO. 2332 OF 2021 Suhas Tukaram Kolhe Thr Gpa And Ors VERSUS The State Of Maharashtra Thr District Collector, Jalgaon And Ors AND FIRST APPEAL NO. 2335 OF 2021 Narayan Ramdas Narkhede (died) Thr Lrs Sanjay VERSUS The State Of Maharashtra Thr Collector, Jalgaon And Ors AND FIRST APPEAL NO. 2321 OF 2021 Sunita Shivdas Sonawane And Anr VERSUS The State Of Maharashtra Thr District Collector, Jalgaon And Ors AND FIRST APPEAL NO. 2323 OF 2021 Rajani Chandrakant Rade VERSUS The State Of Maharashtra Thr District Collector, Jalgaon And Ors
AND FIRST APPEAL NO. 2331 OF 2021 Ramkrushna Dongar Zope (died) Thr Lrs Suman And Ors VERSUS The State Of Maharashtra Thr District Collector, Jalgaon And Ors AND FIRST APPEAL NO. 2333 OF 2021 Vasudev Kalu Sutar Thr Gpa And Anr VERSUS The State Of Maharashtra Thr Collector, Jalgaon And Ors AND FIRST APPEAL NO. 2336 OF 2021 Digamber Galu Khadase (gpa) And Anr VERSUS The State Of Maharashtra Thr District Collector, Jalgaon And Ors AND FIRST APPEAL NO. 2334 OF 2021 Pandurang Waman Rade VERSUS The State Of Maharashtra Thr District Collector, Jalgaon And Ors AND FIRST APPEAL NO. 2319 OF 2021 Narendra Somnath Dhake (gpa) And Ors VERSUS The State Of Maharashtra Thr District Collector, Jalgaon And Ors AND FIRST APPEAL NO. 2320 OF 2021 Dashrath Mahipat Koli (died) Thr Lrs Kamalabai And Ors VERSUS The State Of Maharashtra Thr District Collector, Jalgaon And Ors …..
CORAM : AJIT B. KADETHANKAR, J. DATED : 31ST OCTOBER, 2026 P.C. :.
At the outset, both the learned advocates for the
respective parties make a joint request to dispose of the first appeals by remitting them back to the reference court in the light of an order dated 09.09.2026 passed by this court in First Appeal No.2326 of 2021 with connected appeals. It is submitted that the subject matter land in the cited appeals and in the present Appeals are acquired for the same project i.e. for the construction of Wagur Project Bhadali Distributory no.3950. 2.
The details of the First Appeals are as follows:
Sr. No.
First Appeal No.
2318 of 2021 275 of 2014 08.01.2021
Jt. Civil Judge Senior Division, Jalgaon
2332 of 2021
1081 of 2012
08.01.2021
Jt. Civil Judge Senior Division, Jalgaon
2323 of 2021
1080 of 2012
08.01.2021
Jt. Civil Judge Senior Division, Jalgaon
2334 of 2021
1075 of 2012
08.01.2021
Jt. Civil Judge Senior Division, Jalgaon
2335 of 2021
1082 of 2012
08.01.2021
Jt. Civil Judge Senior Division, Jalgaon
2336 of 2021
1077 of 2012
08.01.2021
Jt. Civil Judge Senior Division, Jalgaon
L.A.R. No.
Judgment date
Court
Sr. No.
First Appeal No.
L.A.R. No.
Judgment date
Court
2320 of 2021 483 of 2013 08.01.2021
Jt. Civil Judge Senior Division, Jalgaon
2333 of 2021
1083 of 2012
08.01.2021
Jt. Civil Judge Senior Division, Jalgaon
2321 of 2021
1078 of 2012
08.01.2021
Jt. Civil Judge Senior Division, Jalgaon
2331 of 2021
1074 of 2012
08.01.2021
Jt. Civil Judge Senior Division, Jalgaon
2319 of 2021 277 of 2014 08.01.2021
Jt. Civil Judge Senior Division, Jalgaon
3.
Having heard learned Advocates for both sides, I find
that in fact the claimants have produced sale instances before the reference court for consideration. Except one sale deed dated 06.11.2009 all three instances were at least five years old prior to the issuance of notification under Section 4 of the Act. Even the sale deed dated 06.11.2009 is also prior to the issuance of notification under Section 4 of the Act. 4.
It needs to be appreciated that the land acquisition for
the distributary of Waghur Dam Project affected the lands at village Nashirabad, Bhadali and Bholane. It is a fair statement of learned advocate for the appellants that the sale instances relied on by the appellants are from Nashirabad village and yet could be read in evidence for the purpose of accessing correct valuation in the present claims. It is submitted that in
view of these facts, the Appeals be remitted back to the reference court with suitable directions. 5.
I find that the request is a moderate one and in fact
deserves to be accepted in the fitness of the circumstances as narrated above. 6.
It is not disputed by Mr. J. V. Patil, learned advocate for
Acquiring Body that the distributary of Waghur Dam Project comprised land acquisition for three villages i.e. Nashirabad, Bhadali and Bholane. In view of this I deem it appropriate to dispose of the appeals by remitting the parties back to the Reference Court to decide the claims afresh on the point of appropriate valuation of the subject matter properties. Hence, the following order:ORDER a.
The First Appeals are partly allowed.
b.
The matters are remitted back to the
concerned Reference Court for adjudication of the claims afresh as directed herein. The Reference Court shall consider the sale deeds produced and relied on by the claimants which are referred at paragraph 16 of the common judgment.
b.
The Reference Court shall also take into
consideration that the sale instances although do not belong to the village Bhadali, yet they are from village Nashirabad which is adjacent to Bhadali village and where also land acquisition is conducted for the distributary of Waghur Dam Project. c.
The Acquiring Body is at liberty to cross-
examine the claimants, if so advised. d.
After
assessing
the
evidence
and
considering the same for fixation of adequate compensation the Reference Court shall conclude the proceedings. e.
The parties shall appear before reference
court on 19.11.2026 with a copy of this order. f.
Record and Proceedings, if called, be sent
back. g.
The Reference Court is
requested to
conclude the proceedings within a period of six months
from
receipt
of
the
Record
and
Proceedings. h.
Pending Civil Applications if any, stand
disposed of.
( AJIT B. KADETHANKAR, J. ) Rushikesh/2026