Pousali Ghosh v. State of West Bengal and ORS.
- Court
- Calcutta High Court
- Date of judgment
- 7 October 2026
- Judge
- Justice Amrita Sinha
- Case number
- WPA No. 1284 of 2026
- Result
- DISPOSED
- Subject
- Service, Property & land
Full judgment
S/L 1
07.10.2026 Court No.24
SD
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA CONSTITUTIONAL WRIT JURISDICTION
WPA 1284 of 2026 Pousali Ghosh Vs. The State of West Bengal & Ors. Mr. Arun Kumar Mohanty Mrs. Kaberi Sengupta Mohanty Mr. R.R. Mohanty Ms. Pusprita Chowdhury Ms. P. Bala Ms. Tithi Guchhait Ms. Susmita Saha Dutta, Ld. AGP Ms. Tapasi Palit Sinha Mr. Suman Chattopadhyay Mr. Niladri Saha
1.
… for the Petitioner.
… for the State.
Affidavit of service filed in Court today be kept
with the records. 2.
The mother of the petitioner was a pensioner.
She received her PPO on December 18, 2013 and she expired on June 5, 2023. For the entire period that the mother of the petitioner received her pension, no issue with regard to her entitlement to receive the amount was ever raised by the authority. 3.
The petitioner being the unmarried daughter of
the pensioner applied for obtaining family pension in August 2023.
The pension was sanctioned in her
favour and PPO issued on June 24, 2025, however, with a rider that the payment will be made as per the corrigendum order dated June 24, 2025. 4.
The aforesaid corrigendum dated June 24, 2025
was made in the Memo issued for commutation of
pension in favour of the petitioner’s mother on February 18, 2015. 5.
According to the authority, the mother of the
petitioner was paid excess amount for which the petitioner would be entitled to receive reduced amount
of
family
pension
for
purpose
of
adjustment of the excess payment received by her mother. 6.
Learned advocate for the petitioner submits that
as the pensioner, who was allegedly paid any amount over and above her entitlement has already expired, the excess amount ought not to be recovered from the family pension payable to the petitioner. 7.
The petitioner, being the unmarried daughter of
the deceased teacher, would be legally entitled to receive family pension as per her entitlement in law and the same ought to be disbursed in her favour at the proper rate without making any adjustment. 8.
In support of the submission that the alleged
overdrawal amount would not be recoverable, learned advocate for the petitioner relies on the judgment delivered by the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the matter of State of Punjab & Ors. vs. Rafiq Masih (White Washer) reported in (2015) 4 SCC 334 wherein the Court laid down instances where recovery would be impermissible.
9.
Prayer has been to direct the authority to
disburse pension to the petitioner as per her own entitlement. 10. Learned
advocate
representing
State
respondents submits that as an error has been detected in the amount that was paid to the pensioner, accordingly, the same may be permitted to be recovered by the authority from the family pension receivable by the petitioner. 11. It has also been submitted that the petitioner would be entitled to receive family pension only after making necessary deduction. 12. Upon hearing the submission made on behalf of both the parties and on perusal of the materials on record, it appears that the authority took more than a decade to identify and detect the error of making excess amount to the retired teacher. By the time the error has been detected, the retired teacher had expired.
Incidentally the retired teacher left behind
an unmarried daughter who applied for grant of family pension in her favour. 13. At the time of processing the family pension file of the petitioner, the authority apparently detected the mistake. The authority presently intends to rectify the mistake by making necessary deduction from the family
pension
petitioner.
that
will
be
receivable
by
According to the authority the excess
payment made to her mother can be adjusted from
the family pension amount that will be receivable by the petitioner. 14. Such stand of the respondents cannot be accepted at all.
There is no proof or evidence on
record that the excess amount was received by the retired teacher due to any fault or misrepresentation on her part. After the teacher retired, the authority calculated her terminal dues and paid the same to her.
She accepted and enjoyed the money till her
death. Now, the authority ought not to contend that as excess money was paid to her mother, the same will be recovered from the family pension of the petitioner. The recovery is sought to be made by making
a
corrigendum
in
June,
2025
of
commutation of pension order dated 18th February, 2015. 15. Had the deceased teacher not left behind an heir eligible to receive family pension, in this case an unmarried daughter, then the alleged error would not have been detected at all. 16. Rafiq Masih (supra) bars recovery from retired employees. In corollary thereof it can be clearly said that
recovery
from
deceased
employees
would
certainly not be permissible. 17. The excess amount, if any, cannot be recovered and/or adjusted from the family pension amount receivable by the petitioner. The petitioner ought to
receive the actual amount of family pension that she is entitled to in law without any deduction. 18. The Treasury Officer, Barasat-II is directed to release the actual family pension amount receivable by the petitioner forthwith without any further delay w.e.f. the date of her entitlement, i.e., June 6, 2023. 19. As the petitioner would be receiving the family pension at a delayed point of time, the arrear dues shall be paid to her with simple interest at the rate of 5% per annum to be calculated on and from the due date till the actual date of payment. 20. It will be open for the competent authority of the respondents
to
initiate
appropriate
proceeding
against any officer for whose mistake excess amount was paid in to the mother of the petitioner. 21. The writ petition stands disposed of. 22. Parties to act on the basis of the server copy of this order duly downloaded from the official website of this Court. 23. Certified server copy of this order, if applied for, be supplied to the parties upon compliance of all requisite formalities. (Amrita Sinha, J.)