Randheer Dinkarrao Deshmukh and Others v. The State of Maharashtra and Others

Court
Bombay High Court
Date of judgment
23 October 2026
Case number
WP No. 14850 of 2017
Result
DISPOSED OFF
Subject
Service

Download the official PDF

Full judgment

(1)

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD WRIT PETITION NO. 14850 OF 2017 01]

Randheer S/o. Dinkarrao Deshmukh

02]

Shivaji S/o. Shankarrao Pawar

03]

Ramdas S/o. Tukaram Bhise

04]

Manik S/o. Khanderao Khochare

05]

Mahadeo S/o. Keshavrao Ekhande

06]

Gundu s/o. Narsing Gajakhos

07]

Bhivaji s/o. Shekoba Janrao

08]

Mohd. Abdul Kadir s/o. Mohd. Abdul Nabi

09]

Sudhakar s/o. Baburao Rajmane

10]

Smt. Ratnamala Bharath Kokate

11]

Subhash s/o. Sanganappa Jidge

12]

Smt. Kusumbai Vyanketrao Sonkhede

13]

Smt. Radhika Ramesh Sangamkar

VERSUS 01]

The State of Maharashtra Through its Principal Secretary Rural Development and Water Conservation Department, Mantralaya Mumbai-32.

02]

The Principal Secretary, Irrigation and Water Resources Department, Mantralaya Mumbai-32.

03]

The Principal Secretary Public Works Department, Mantralaya, Mumbai-32.

...PETITIONERS

(2)

04]

The Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, Osmanabad. Tq. & Dist. Osmanabad.

05]

The Chief Executive Engineer, Minor Irrigation Division, Osmanabad, Tal. & Dist. Osmanabad.

...RESPONDENTS

Mr. V. G. Salgare, Advocate for Petitioners. Mr. K. N. Lokhande, AGP for Respondent Nos. 1 to 3-State. Mr. B. B. Bhise, Advocate for Respondent Nos. 4 and 5. CORAM

: KISHORE C. SANT & JITENDRA JAIN, JJ.

RESERVED ON

: 07th OCTOBER 2026.

PRONOUNCED ON

: 23rd OCTOBER 2026.

ORDER :- [PER: KISHORE C. SANT, J.] 1]

Heard Mr. Salgare, learned Advocate for the Petitioners, Mr.

Lokhande, learned AGP for Respondent Nos. 1 to 3/State and Mr. Bhise, learned Advocate for Respondent Nos. 4 and 5/Zilla Parishad. By consent of the parties, petition is taken up for final disposal at the stage of admission. 2]

The petitioners are the retired employees of Respondent No.4/Zilla

Parishad, Osmanabad. They were working in Technical Services (ClassIII) (Engineering) and District Services (Class-III) (Sub-ordinate

(3)

Engineering). Their grievance is only about non-granting the benefits of Assured Career Progression Scheme (ACPS) on completion of 12 years of service. 3]

The brief facts giving rise to the present petition are as follows:

.

The petitioners, on their respective dates of appointments, came to

be appointed in the Cadre of Maharashtra Zilla Parishads District Technical Services (Class-III) (Engineering) and District Services (ClassIII) (Sub-ordinate Engineering). They were appointed much prior to 1995. In the year 1995, Government took a policy decision dated 08/06/1995 to give time bound promotion. It was specifically decided to grant benefits to the persons who could not get regular promotions for want of actual promotional posts; however, they are eligible to be appointed to such promotional posts. It was thus decided that a person who is eligible for a promotional post shall be notionally given the benefits of the promotional post and to grant all other benefits except actual posting. The only condition is that the person should be otherwise fit and eligible to be appointed on the promotional post. 4]

The Government again took a decision on 20/07/2001 and instead

of giving time-bound promotion and introduced a policy of ACPS. This

(4)

scheme is made applicable to the employees whose salary is in pay scale is Rs.8,000-13,500 or less. The said benefit was to be given after completion of 12 years of service. The said benefit would not be applicable if the person had received such benefits twice in his service tenure. The said benefit would be given where no actual post is available. It is again reiterated that to receive the benefit, a person needs to

be

eligible

to

corrections/modifications,

get

actual

promotion.

the

Government

again

With

some

issued

another

decision on 01/04/2010. The said decision was taken considering the recommendations

made

by

Sukathankar

Committee

which

was

appointed for revised ACPS scheme that was made applicable from 01/01/2006.

5]

The above-referred Government decisions are applicable to all

employees under the State Government. So far as cadre of the petitioners is concerned, the Chief Executive Officer, Zilla Parishad, issued a letter dated 23/12/2008 in respect of some of the employees, including the present petitioners, who had completed 45 years of age and were therefore exempted from passing the qualifying test to become eligible to the post of Civil Engineering Assistant. In other words, they

(5)

were exempted from appearing for the qualifying test to become eligible to get promotion. The petitioners, therefore, became eligible for the promotional post of Civil Engineering Assistant. The Chief Executive Officer on 24/12/2008 again passed an order holding the petitioners eligible to get the pay scale of Junior Assistant Engineer on completion of 12 years in service. However, it was directed that though the pay scale is to be applied, the petitioners would not be entitled to get the arrears of

difference

in

salary.

The

petitioners,

thereafter,

preferred

representations to the authorities for getting actual benefits.

6]

The reliance is also placed on Government decision dated

20/05/1999, wherein the decision was taken to create only one cadre as a Civil Engineering Assistant by merging Mistri Grade-I, Mistri Grade-II, Road Clerk, Muster Clerk, Timekeeper, Draftsman, etc. and placing all of them as Civil Engineering Assistants. There is no dispute about the said proposition. The Additional Secretary, State of Maharashtra on 22/06/2007 passed an order making a pay scale of Civil Engineering Assistant applicable to Mistri Grade-I and Mistri Grade-II, Road Clerk, Muster Clerk, Timekeeper, Draftsman, etc. However, the same were not considered. The petitioners, therefore, approached this Court by filing

(6)

Writ Petition No.215/2017. 7]

This Court vide order dated 11/01/2017 disposed off the petition

by directing the respondents to decide the representations expeditiously within four weeks. Some of the petitioners again approached this Court by filing Writ Petition No.2962/2017 praying for deciding the representations which were made just prior to filing of the Writ Petition. This Court disposed of that petition by directing the respondents to decide their representations as well. 8]

Petitioner No.1 namely, Randheer Dinkarrao Deshmukh again

made a representation on 27/01/2017 requesting the Chief Executive Officer to grant actual benefits of difference of salary. It is stated in the representation that though notionally pay scale of the promotional post was made applicable, no actual monetary benefits were extended. It is in that view, now the petitioners have approached this Court.

9]

Respondent No.4 and 5 have filed a reply to the petition. It is

accepted that the petitioners were notionally given pay scale of the promotional post and their salary was fixed on that basis. It is also admitted that, however, the arrears were not paid. The defence which is

(7)

now taken is that since actual promotional posts were not available, the petitioners were not given the salary of promotional post on completion of 12 years of service. It is specifically accepted that the pay scale of Rs.5500-9000

was

granted

by

order

dated

24/12/2008

w.e.f.

01/01/1996. It is further admitted that the same was given only for the purpose of retirement benefits, and the employees would not be entitled to get any actual payment and allowance (Bhatta). It is further stated that since the petitioners have not worked on promotional posts, they would not be entitled to get actual salary. A reliance is also on the Government Resolution dated 28/07/2014. It is further stated in the reply that the employees would not be entitled to the benefits of first time-bound pay scale. The chart giving specific details of petitioners is as follows: Sr. No.

Name of petitioners

Designation

Randheer Deshmukh

Shivaji Shankarrao Pawar

Ramdas Tukaram Bhise

Mistry Grade-II

22/02/1971

Manik Khanderao Khochare

Mistry Grade-II

18/02/1971

Mahadeo Keshavrao Ekhande Mistry Grade-III 17/02/1971

Dinkarrao Mistry Grade-II

Date of appointment 03/1/1972 03/01/1972

(8)

Gundu Narsing Gajakhos

Mistry Grade-II

20/02/1971

Bhivaji Shekoba Janrao

Mistry Grade-II

17/09/1974

Mohd. Abdul Kadir Mohd. Mistry Grade-II Abdul Nabi

23/02/1973

Sudhakar Baburao Rajmane

Mistry Grade-II

01/09/1964

Smt. Ratnamala Kokate

Bharath Mistry Grade-II

17/02/1971

Subhash Sanganappa Jidge

Mistry Grade-II

27/06/1970

Smt. Kusumbai Vyanketrao Mistry Grade-II Sonkhede

23/02/1971

Smt. Radhika Sangamkar

Ramesh Mistry Grade-II

19/02/1971

10]

Mr. Salgare, learned Advocate for the petitioners, vehemently

argued that the petitioners were given first time-bound pay scale on completion of 12 years from 1996. The second promotional benefits also ought to have been given upon completion of 12 years after 1996. In the present case, though notional promotions were given, the pay scale was considered only for the purpose of giving retiral benefits while fixing pension. This is against the policy of the Government as is seen from the Government decisions dated 08/06/1995 and 24/12/2008. On the other hand, it is accepted that the petitioners were given the benefits of pay scale of promotional post on completion of 12 years and in some cases,

(9)

24 years of service, as the case may be. However, no monetary benefits are given. There is no reason assigned except that actual promotional posts were not available. He thus submits that the said reasoning needs to be held against the scheme and in unconstitutional by giving the benefits of actual monetary benefits.

11]

Mr. Bhise, learned Advocate for Respondent Nos. 4 and 5

vehemently opposes the petition. He submits that the petitioners have not worked on promotional posts. There is no question of giving them the benefits of salary or to pay the salary as per the pay scale applicable to the promotional post. The decision is rightly taken. The decision to consider the said pay scale for the purpose of pensionary benefits is in consonance with the policy. The petitioners have thus been benefited to the policy and no grievance can be raised by them.

12]

This Court has considered the facts of the case. It is clearly seen

that the petitioners were held eligible to be appointed to the promotional post. They could not be appointed only for the reason that no actual posts were available.

( 10 )

13]

This Court has considered the scheme of time bound promotion

and also of ACPS. The Government had taken a decision specifically keeping in view that though many of the employees are eligible to get the promotional posts, they are not deprived of the same for the reason that no promotional posts are available. For this reason, benefits are not given of the promotional post. The policy is framed particularly, for the reason that such person should not be deprived of promotion, it is thought that there is stagnation because of this. It is to remove such stagnation the said scheme is framed. 14]

In the present case, there is no denial of the fact that the

petitioners were held to be eligible to get the promotion. Though it is argued that some of the petitioners could not pass qualifying test; however, they were given exemption from passing qualifying test in view of the fact that they have completed age of 45 years. It is not the case that they are wrongly given exemption. Such argument also cannot be made for the reason that it is the Respondents only who granted such exemption. To the reply, the petitioners have filed rejoinder exhaustively. This Court however finds that when the position is clear on record, there is no need to call the details.

( 11 )

15]

This Court in Writ Petition No.10171 of 2015 had already held

petitioners therein entitled to the time-bound promotion on completion of 12 years of their service as Mistry Grade-II. If the 12 years period is completed prior to 1994, the benefits were to be given from 1994. 16]

This Court, therefore, is of the opinion that the same course should

be made applicable to the present petitioners. If they have completed a period of 12 years prior to 1996, in that case, they will be entitled to promotional post benefit, as it is also a case of the petitioners that they are given the benefits from 1996. 17]

It is seen in the petition that some of the petitioners opted to retire

voluntarily, in such cases, if they have not completed 12 years after 1996, then naturally they would not be entitled to get the second-time benefits. 18]

Considering all above, this Court finds that the petition deserves to

be allowed. The petition is allowed in terms of prayer clause (C). 19]

The said exercise be done within a period of four weeks from

today and arrears be paid to the petitioners to which they are entitled to within a period of six months from today.

( 12 )

20]

With these, Writ Petition stands disposed off.

21]

Civil applications, if any, also stand disposed off.

[JITENDRA JAIN, J.] D.A.ETHAPE

[KISHORE C. SANT, J.]

Related judgments

More Bombay High Court judgments

Search all Supreme Court and High Court judgments

Reproduced from the official court copy published on eCourts (Indian Court Judgments open dataset, CC-BY-4.0). Not legal advice.