Rojer Mathew v. South Indian Bank LTD. & Ors.
- Court
- Supreme Court of India
- Date of judgment
- 13 November 2019
- Judge
- Justice Ranjan Gogoi
- Neutral citation
- 2019 INSC 1236
- Reported in
- [2019] 16 S.C.R. 1
- Result
- Disposed off
- Acts & sections
- Article 110 Constitution, Article 226 Constitution, Section 55 Consumer Protection Act, Article 227 Constitution, Article 14 Constitution, Article 323B Constitution, Article 323A Constitution
- Subject
- Service, Consumer
Full judgment
[2019] 16 S.C.R. 1
ROJER MATHEW
v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. & ORS. (Civil Appeal No. 8588 of 2019) NOVEMBER 13, 2019
[RANJAN GOGOI, CJI, N. V. RAMANA, DR D. Y. CHANDRACHUD, DEEPAK GUPTA AND SANJIV KHANNA, JJ.] Tribunals – Finance Act, 2017 – Finance Act, 2017, a ‘money bill’ or not u/Art.110 – Validity of the Act, 2017 – Held: The majority in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5) pronounced the nature of the impugned enactment without first delineating the scope of Art.110(1) and principles for interpretation or the repercussions of such process – The majority dictum in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5) did not substantially discuss the effect of the word ‘only’ in Art.110(1) and offers little guidance on the repercussions of a finding when some of the provisions of an enactment passed as a ‘Money Bill’ do not conform to Art. 110 (1) (a) (b) – Without expressing a firm and final opinion, the analysis in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5) made its application difficult to the present case and raises a potential conflict between the judgments of Coordinate Benches – Being a Bench of equal strength as that in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5), the batch of matters directed to be referred to the Larger Bench. Tribunals – Finance Act, 2017 – S. 184 – Constitutionality of s. 184 on account of excessive delegations – Held s.184 does not suffer from excessive delegations of legislative functions as there are adequate principles to guide framing of delegated legislation, which would include the binding dictums of the Supreme Court – The objects of the parent enactments as well as the law laid down by the Supreme Court in R.K. Jain, L. Chandra Kumar, R. Gandhi, Madras Bar Association and Gujarat Urja Vikas undoubtedly bind the delegate and mandatorily requires the delegate u/s. 184 to act strictly in conformity with these decisions and the objects of delegated legislation stipulated in the statutes.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
Tribunals – The Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal and other Authorities (Qualifications, Experience and other Conditions of Service of Members) Rules, 2017 – Conformity of the Rules with the judicial principles inherent in the Constitutional scheme as established by the Supreme Court – Held: The composition of the search-cum-Selection Committees under the Rules amounts to excessive interference of the Executive in appointment of members and presiding offices of statutory Tribunals and it is detrimental to the independence of Judiciary – In addition to this, there has been a blatant dilution of judicial character in appointments whereby candidates without any judicial experience are prescribed to be eligible for adjudicatory posts such as that of the presiding Officer – Therefore, the Rules have an effect of dilution of the judicial character in adjudicatory positions – Further, earlier removal of members or presiding officer was done after an enquiry by the Supreme Court Judges and with necessary consultation with the Chief Justice of India, under the present Rules it is permissible for the Central Government to appoint an enquiry Committee for removal of any presiding officer or member on its own – The Members and Presiding Officers of Tribunals cannot be removed without either the concurrence of the Judiciary or in the manner specified in the Constitution for Constitutional Court Judges – Also, there must be uniform age of superannuation for all members in all the Tribunals, the Rules demonstrate disparity in age of superannuation of Members and Chairpersons/Presiding Officers of different Tribunals – Furthermore, there is inconsistency within the Rules with regard to the tenure prescribed for the Members of Tribunals insofar as a fixed tenure of three years for both direct appointments from the Bar and appointment of retired judicial officers or judges of High Court or Supreme Court – It is also discriminatory to the extent that it attempts to create equality between unequal classes – Therefore, the Rules suffer from various infirmities and are contrary to the Parent enactment and the principles envisaged in the Constitution, resultantly, directed to be struck down in entirety. Tribunals – Finance Act, 2017 – Whether there should be a single Nodal Agency for administration of all Tribunals – Held: It may not be very crucial as to which Ministry or Department performs the duties of Nodal Agency for a Tribunal, but what is
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
of utmost importance is that the Tribunal should not be expected to look towards such Nodal Agency for its day to day requirements – There must be a direction to allocate adequate and sufficient funds for each Tribunal to make it self-sufficient and selfsustainable authority for all intents and purposes.
Tribunals – A Judicial Impact Assessment of all tribunals in India – Need for – Held: It was directed in Salem Advocate Bar Association (II) v. Union of India for a Committee to be constituted to assess the need for Judicial Impact Assessment – Pursuant thereto, Jagannadha Rao Committee Report was submitted, it suggested that legislature must analyse the budgetary requirement of the staff, additional expenditure arising out of the new cases consequent to the enactment, the number of Civil and Criminal Cases expected to arise from the new enactment, the requirement of Judges etc. – The legislature has not conformed to the opinion of the Supreme Court with respect to ‘Judicial Impact Assessment’ and thus, has not made any attempt to assess the ramifications of the Finance Act, 2017 – Therefore, the Union of India directed to carry out Financial Impact Assessment in respect of all the Tribunals referable to ss. 158 to 182 of the Finance Act, 2017 and undertake an exercise to assess the need based requirements and make available sufficient resources for each Tribunal established by the Parliament.
Tribunals – Judges of Tribunals set up by Acts of Parliament under Arts. 323-A and 323-B of the Constitution equated in ‘Rank’ and ‘Status’ with constitutional functionaries – Held: There can be no doubt that executive action cannot confer status equivalent to that either Supreme Court or High Court Judges on any member or head of any Tribunal or other judicial fora – Tribunals are not substitutes of Superior Courts and are only supplemental to them – Hence, the status of members of such Tribunals cannot be equated with that of the sitting Judges of Constitutional Courts. Tribunals – Direct Statutory appeals from Tribunals to the Supreme Court – Consideration of – Held: Such statutory appeals take away the inherent ability of the Supreme Court, as envisaged in the Constitution, to regulate cases before it by confining its consideration to cases involving the most egregious of wrongs and/ or having the greatest impact on public interest – It is evident that Supreme Court has lost its original character owing to the routine
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
hearing of appeals through invocation of the discretionary jurisdiction u/Art. 136 – For the discharge of constitutional functions of deliberating on substantial questions of law, answering constitutional questions and resolving other issues of great Public importance, it is essential that Supreme Court has adequate time to apply its mind and consider matters in depth the practice of bringing every second case before the Supreme Court u/Art. 136 must be deprecated – Therefore, the Union of India in consultation with either the Law Commission or any other expert body revisit such provisions under various enactments providing for direct appeals to the Supreme Court against orders of Tribunals, and instead provide appeals to Division Benches of the High Courts, if at all necessary. Tribunals – Amalgamation of Existing Tribunals and setting up of Benches – Need for – Held: The ‘importance’ in distribution of case-load and inconsistencies in nature, location and functioning of Tribunals require urgent attention – It is essential that after conducting a Judicial Impact Assessment, Tribunals be amalgamed with others dealing with similar areas of law, to ensure effective utilisation of resources and to facilitate access to justice – Therefore, the Union Government directed to carry out an appropriate exercise for amalgamation of existing Tribunals adopting the test of homogeneity of the subject matters to be dealt with and thereafter constitute adequate number of Benches Commensurate with the existing and anticipated volume of work. Tribunals – Tribunalisation – A global trend – Discussed. Disposing of the Petition, the Court HELD : PER RANJAN GOGOI, CJI (FOR HIMSELF AND N.V. RAMANA, DR. D.Y. CHANDRACHUD, DEEPAK GUPTA AND SANJIV KHANNA, JJ.) 1. ISSUE I : WHETHER THE ‘FINANCE ACT, 2017’ INSOFAR AS IT AMENDS CERTAIN OTHER ENACTMENTS AND ALTERS CONDITIONS OF SERVICE OF PERSONS MANNING DIFFERENT TRIBUNALS CAN BE TERMED AS A ‘MONEY BILL’ UNDER ARTICLE 110 AND CONSEQUENTLY IS VALIDLY ENACTED? 1.1 Provisions of Part XIV can be broken down into three broad categories. First, abolition and merger of existing
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
Tribunals; second, uniformizing and delegating to the Central Government through the Rules the power to lay down qualifications; method of appointment and removal, and terms and conditions of service of Presiding Officers and members; and third, termination of services and payment of compensation to presiding officers and members of certain tribunals that have now become de-funct. [Para 112] [85-A-B]
1.2 Upon an extensive examination of the matter, this Court notices that the majority in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5) pronounced the nature of the impugned enactment without first delineating the scope of Article 110(1) and principles for interpretation or the repercussions of such process. It is clear to this Court that the majority dictum in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5) did not substantially discuss the effect of the word ‘only’ in Article 110(1) and offers little guidance on the repercussions of a finding when some of the provisions of an enactment passed as a “Money Bill” do not conform to Article 110(1)(a) to (g). Its interpretation of the provisions of the Aadhaar Act was arguably liberal and the Court’s satisfaction of the said provisions being incidental to Article 110(1)(a) to (f), it has been argued is not convincingly reasoned, as might not be in accord with the bicameral Parliamentary system envisaged under our constitutional scheme. Without expressing a firm and final opinion, it has to be observed that the analysis in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5) makes its application difficult to the present case and raises a potential conflict between the judgements of coordinate Benches. [Para 122] [90-A-D] 1.3 Given the various challenges made to the scope of judicial review and interpretative principles (or lack thereof) as adumbrated by the majority in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5) and the substantial precedential impact of its analysis of the Aadhaar Act, 2016, it becomes essential to determine its correctness. Being a Bench of equal strength as that in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5), this Court accordingly direct that this batch of matters be placed before Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India, on the administrative side, for consideration by a larger Bench. [Para 123] [90-E]
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
1.4 There is yet another reason why this Court feel the matter should be referred to a Constitution Bench of seven judges. L. Chandra Kumar, which was decided by a Bench of seven Judges, had also interpreted on the ambit of supervision by the High Courts under Article 227(1) of the Constitution to observe that the Constitutional scheme does not require all adjudicatory bodies which fall within the territorial jurisdiction of the High Courts should be subject to their supervisory jurisdiction, as the idea is to divest the High Courts of their onerous burden. Consequently, adding to their supervisory functions vide Article 227(1) cannot be of assistance in any manner. Thereafter, it was observed that different tribunals constituted under different enactments are administered by the Central and the State Governments, yet there was no uniformity in administration. This Court was of the view that until a wholly independent agency for such tribunals can be set up, it is desirable that all such tribunals should be, as far as possible, under a single nodal Ministry which will be in a position to oversee the working of these tribunals. For a number of reasons, the Court observed that the Ministry of Law would be the appropriate ministry. The Ministry of Law in turn was required to appoint an independent supervisory body to oversee the working of the Tribunals. As noticed above, this has not happened. In these circumstances, it would be appropriate if these aspects and questions are looked into by a Bench of seven Judges. [Para 124] [90-F-H; 91-A-B] 2. ISSUE II: WHETHER SECTION 184 OF THE FINANCE ACT, 2017 IS UNCONSTITUTIONAL ON ACCOUNT OF EXCESSIVE DELEGATION? 2.1. It will be difficult to hold that Part XIV of the Finance Act suffers from the vice of unguided delegation as it fails to clearly specify the eligibility qualifications for the Members, Chairpersons, Chairman etc. of different Tribunals as such requirements, though important, are not per se functionally undelegatable. [Para 142] [103-F-H] 2.2 The objects of the parent enactments as well as the law laid down by this Court in R.K. Jain, L Chandra Kumar, R. Gandhi, Madras Bar Association and Gujarat Urja Vikas
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
undoubtedly bind the delegate and mandatorily requires the delegate under Section 184 to act strictly in conformity with these decisions and the objects of delegated legislation stipulated in the statutes. It must also be emphasised that the Finance Act, 2017 nowhere indicates that the legislature had intended to differ from, let alone make amendments, to remove the edifice and foundation of such decisions by enacting the Finance Act. Indeed, the Attorney General was clear in suggesting that Part XIV was inserted with a view to incorporate the changes recommended by this Court in earlier decisions. [Para 143] [104A-C]
2.3. On examining the Constitutional scheme, the statutes which had created tribunals and the precedents of this Court laying down attributes of independence of tribunals in different facets, this Court does not think that the power to prescribe qualifications, selection procedure and service conditions of members and other office holders of the tribunals is intended to vest solely with the Legislature for all times and purposes. Policy and guidelines exist. Subject to aforesaid, the submission of Attorney General that Section 184 was inserted to bring uniformity and with a view to harmonise the diverse and wideranging qualifications and methods of appointment across different tribunals carries weight and, needs to be accepted. [Para 148] [107-C-D] 2.4 Cautioning against the potential misuse of Section 184 by the executive, it was vehemently argued by the petitioner(s) that any desecration by the Executive of such powers threatens and poses a risk to the independence of the tribunals. A mere possibility or eventuality of abuse of delegated powers in the absence of any evidence supporting such claim, cannot be a ground for striking down the provisions of the Finance Act, 2017. It is always open to a Constitutional court on challenge made to the delegated legislation framed by the Executive to examine whether it conforms to the parent legislation and other laws, and apply the “policy and guideline” test and if found contrary, can be struck down without affecting the constitutionality of the rule making power conferred under Section 186 of the Finance Act, 2017. [Para 149] [107-E-G]
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
3. ISSUE III: IF SECTION 184 IS VALID, WHETHER TRIBUNAL, APPELLATE TRIBUNAL AND OTHER AUTHORITIES (QUALIFICATIONS, EXPERIENCE AND OTHER CONDITIONS OF SERVICE OF MEMBERS) RULES, 2017 ARE IN CONSONANCE WITH THE PRINCIPAL ACT AND VARIOUS DECISIONS OF THIS COURT ON FUNCTIONING OF TRIBUNALS? 3.1 (A) Composition of Search-cum-Selection Committees
3.1 (1) The composition of the Search-cum-Selection Committees under the Rules amounts to excessive interference of the Executive in appointment of members and presiding officers of statutory Tribunals and would undoubtedly be detrimental to the independence of judiciary besides being an affront to the doctrine of separation of powers. [Para 154] [118C] 3.1 (2) This Court is in complete agreement with the analogy elucidated by the Constitution Bench in the Fourth Judges Case for compulsory need for exclusion of control of the Executive over quasi-judicial bodies of Tribunals discharging responsibilities akin to Courts. The Search-cum-Selection Committees as envisaged in the Rules are against the constitutional scheme inasmuch as they dilute the involvement of judiciary in the process of appointment of members of tribunals which is in effect an encroachment by the executive on the judiciary. [Para 158] [121-D-F] 3.2 (B) Qualifications of members and presiding officers
3.2 (1) There has been a blatant dilution of judicial character in appointments whereby candidates without any judicial experience are prescribed to be eligible for adjudicatory posts such as that of the Presiding Officer. [Para 160] [122-E]
3.2 (2) The contentions of the petitioner(s) are, therefore, duly accepted by this Court insofar as it is contended that the Rules have an effect of dilution of the judicial character in adjudicatory positions. It has been repeatedly ruled by this Court in a catena of decisions that judicial functions cannot be
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
performed by technical members devoid of any adjudicatory experience. [Para 161] [121-B]
3.2 (3) This Court concurs with the consistent view taken by this Court in a number of cases. It is also a well-established principle followed throughout in various other jurisdictions as well, that wherever Parliament decides to divest the traditional Courts of their jurisdiction and transfer the lis to some other analogous Court/Tribunal, the qualification and acumen of the members in such Tribunal must be commensurate with that of the Court from which the adjudicatory function is transferred. Adjudication of disputes which was originally vested in Judges of Courts, if done by technical or non-judicial member, is clearly a dilution and encroachment on judicial domain. With great respect, Parliament cannot divest judicial functions upon technical members, devoid of the either adjudicatory experience or legal knowledge. [Para 163] [127-D-F] 3.2 (4) It is necessary to notice few other changes brought about by the new Rules. Firstly, most Tribunals were earlier headed by judicial members. With the exception of some Tribunals like the Debt Recovery Tribunal, presiding officers were retired judges either of the Supreme Court or of High Courts. Under the present formulation of Rules, the Central Government has widened eligibility by making persons who otherwise have no judicial or legal experience but if they are otherwise of “ability, integrity and standing, and having special knowledge of, and professional experience of” certain specialised subjects “which in the opinion of the Central Government is useful” eligible for being appointed as presiding officers. Further, others who are “qualified to be” Supreme Court and High Court judges can also head Tribunals. A perusal of Articles 124(3) and 217(2) of the Constitution shows that it specifies only the very minimum prerequisites for appointment as a judge of the Constitutional Courts. Instead, a predominant portion of the consideration for appointment to this Court or to the High Courts is uncodified and is based on a holistic consideration of the practice, legal acumen, expertise and character of Advocates. The effect of the new criteria would be to make every second advocate eligible, in effect, vastly diluting the qualifications for
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
appointment. The characteristics necessary of such people are also vague which resultantly increases executive discretion. It thus affects both judicial independence as well as capability and competency of these Tribunals. The power/discretion vested to specify qualifications and decide who should man the Tribunals has to be exercised keeping in view the larger public interest and the same must be just, fair and reasonable and not vague or imprecise. [Para 164] [127-F-H; 128-A-C] 3.2 (5) At this juncture it must also be reiterated that equality can only be amongst equals, and that it would be impermissible to treat unequals equally on the basis of undefined contours of ‘Uniformity’. A Tribunal to have the character of a quasi-judicial body and a legitimate replacement of Courts, must essentially possess a dominant judicial character through their members/presiding officers. It was observed in Madras Bar Association (2010) that it is a fundamental prerequisite for transferring adjudicatory functions from Courts to Tribunals that the latter must possess the same capacity and independence as the former, and that members as well as the presiding officers of Tribunals must have significant judicial training and legal experience. Further, knowledge, training and experience of members/presiding officers of a Tribunal must mirror, as far as possible, that of the Court which it seeks to substitute. [Para 165] [128-D-G] (C) Constitutionality of procedure of removal
3.3 (1) It is clear from the Scheme contemplated under the Rules that the government has significantly diluted the role of the Judiciary in appointment of judicial members. Further, in many Tribunals like the NGT, the role of the Judiciary in appointment of non-judicial members has entirely been taken away. Such a practice violates the Constitutional scheme and the dicta of this Court in various earlier decisions already referred to. It is also important to note that in many Tribunals like the National Green Tribunal where earlier removal of members or presiding officer could only be after an enquiry by Supreme Court Judges and with necessary consultation with the Chief Justice of India, under the present Rules it is permissible for the Central Government to appoint an enquiry committee for removal of any
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
presiding officer or member on its own. The Rules are not explicit on who would be part of such a Committee and what would be the role of the Judiciary in the process. In doing so, it significantly weakens the independence of the Tribunal members. It is well understood across the world and also under our Constitutional framework that allowing judges to be removed by the Executive is palpably unconstitutional and would make them amenable to the whims of the Executive, hampering discharge of judicial functions. [Para 169] [129-F-H; 130-A-B]
3.3 (2) It is essential that the same be observed in letter and spirit and this Court therefore reiterate that Members and Presiding Officers of Tribunals cannot be removed without either the concurrence of the Judiciary or in the manner specified in the Constitution for Constitutional Court judges. [Para 171] [130G-H] 3.4 (D) Term of Office and Maximum Age 3.4 (1) Various enactments providing for appointment and other incidentals of members have been brought to our notice to demonstrate an apparent disparity in age of superannuation of Members and Chairpersons/Presiding Officers of different Tribunals. Illustratively, Section 14D of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India Act, 1997 provides a Member of Telecom Disputes Settlement and Appellate Tribunal shall not hold office after attaining the age of sixty-five years, whereas, Section 55(1) of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019 provides that a Member of the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission shall not hold office after attaining the age of sixty-seven years. This difference in superannuation age may lead to an undesirable situation wherein a member of a Tribunal with low retirement age can be reappointed in another Tribunal with a higher retirement age. [Para 172] [131-A-C] 3.4 (2) The Constitution of India doesn’t differentiate between High Courts in terms of conditions of service of judges and prescribes a uniform age of superannuation for judges of all High Courts. Conforming to the principle, as held in earlier judgements of this Court, the Tribunals should have similar standards of appointment and service as that of the Court it is
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
substituting. There must, therefore, be a uniform age of superannuation for all members in all the Tribunals. [Para 173] [131-D-E] 3.5 (E) Contradictions in the Rules
The Bench has observed following contradictions in the Rules:
(a) There is an inconsistency within the Rules with regard to the tenure prescribed for the Members of Tribunals insofar as a fixed tenure of three years for both direct appointments from the Bar and appointment of retired judicial officers or judges of High Court or Supreme Court. It is also discriminatory to the extent that it attempts to create equality between unequal classes. The tenure of Members, Vice-Chairman, Chairman, etc. must be increased with due consideration to the prior decisions of the Court.
(b) The difference in the age of superannuation of the Members, Vice-Chairmen and Chairmen, as formulated in the Rules is contrary to the objectives of the Finance Act, 2017 viz., to attain uniformity in the composition of the Tribunal framework. There should be a uniform age of superannuation for Members, Vice-Chairmen, Chairmen, etc. in all Tribunals. (c) Rule 4(2) of the Rules providing that the Secretary to the Government of India in the Ministry or Department under which the Tribunal is constituted shall be the convener of the Search-cum-Selection Committee, is in direct violation of the doctrine of Separation of Powers and thus contravenes the basic structure of the Constitution. Corollary to the dictum of this Court in the Fourth Judges Case, judicial dominance in appointment of members of judiciary cannot be diluted by the Executive. (d) Rule 7 accords unwarranted discretion to the Central Government insofar as it merely directs and not mandates the Central Government to consider the recommendation of Committee for removal of a Member of a Tribunal. The Central Government shall mandatorily consider the recommendation of the Committee before removal of any Member of Tribunal. Furthermore, the proviso to Rule 7 creates an unjust
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
classification between National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) and other fora inasmuch as the removal of Chairperson or member of NCLAT alone is to be in consultation with the Chief Justice of India.
(e) Moral turpitude is a term well defined by this Court in numerous decisions. Rule 7(b) cannot be allowed to survive as it allows the Executive to interpret the meaning of ‘moral turpitude’, which is an encroachment on the judicial domain. (f) The power of relaxation of rules with respect to any class of persons shall be vested with the Search-cum-Selection Committee and not with the Central Government as provided under Rule 20. As ruled by this Court earlier in Madras Bar Association (2014), the Central Government cannot be allowed to have administrative control over the Judiciary without subverting the doctrine of separation of powers. [Para 179] [133A-H; 134-A-D] 4. ISSUE IV: WHETHER THERE SHOULD BE A SINGLE NODAL AGENCY FOR ADMINISTRATION OF ALL TRIBUNALS? 4.1 This Court in L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India, envisaged the administration of the entire Tribunal Framework in the country to be monitored by a single nodal agency/ministry. It was observed not to be advisable to allow supervision of a Tribunal by a department/ministry which is a party before it. This Court recommended constitution of an independent agency by the concerned Ministry, to oversee the working of Tribunals. The independent agency when constituted, may also prescribe a uniform code for appointment, qualification, condition of service, manner of allocation of fund, etc. of the Tribunals. This will, the Court suggested, minimise the influence of the parent ministry of the Tribunal, in addition to ensuring uniformity in the entire Tribunal framework. [Para 181] [134-G-H; 135-A-B] 4.2 What appears to be of paramount importance is that every Tribunal must enjoy adequate financial independence for the purpose of its day to day functioning including the expenditure to be incurred on (a) recruitment of staff; (b) creation of infrastructure; (c) modernisation of infrastructure; (d) computerisation; (e) perquisites and other facilities admissible
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
to the Presiding Authority or the Members of such Tribunal. It may not be very crucial as to which Ministry or Department performs the duties of Nodal Agency for a Tribunal, but what is of utmost importance is that the Tribunal should not be expected to look towards such Nodal Agency for its day to day requirements. There must be a direction to allocate adequate and sufficient funds for each Tribunal to make it self-sufficient and self-sustainable authority for all intents and purposes. The expenditure to be incurred on the functioning of each Tribunal has to be necessarily a charge on the Consolidated Fund of India. Therefore, hitherto, the Ministry of Finance shall, in consultation with the Nodal Ministry/Department, shall earmark separate and dedicated funds for the Tribunals. It will not only ensure that the Tribunals are not under the financial control of the Department, who is a litigant before them, but it may also enhance the public faith and trust in the mechanism of Tribunals. [Para 184] [136-E-H; 137-A] 5. ISSUE V: WHETHER THERE IS A NEED FOR CONDUCTING A JUDICIAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT OF ALL TRIBUNALS IN INDIA? 5.1 The American principle of ‘Judicial Impact Assessment’ was first borrowed by this Court in its dictum in Salem Advocate Bar Assn. (II) v. Union of India, whereby it was observed that it is imperative for the Legislature to perform a Judicial Impact Assessment of the enactment passed to assess its ramifications on the judiciary. This Court had directed for a committee to be constituted to assess the need for Judicial Impact Assessment in the Indian context. Pursuant thereto the Jagannadha Rao Committee Report was submitted. The Report suggested that by way of Judicial Impact Assessment, the legislature must analyse the budgetary requirement of the staff that would require to be created by the statute and additional expenditure arising out of the new cases consequent to the enactment. Further, the financial memorandum, as prepared by the legislature, must specifically include the number of civil and criminal cases expected to arise from the new enactment, requirement of more judges and staff for adjudication of these cases and the necessary infrastructure. [Para 187] [137-E-H; 138-A]
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
5.2 (1) In the present case, this Court is of the view that the legislature has not conformed to the opinion of this Court with respect to ‘Judicial Impact Assessment’ and thus, has not made any attempt to assess the ramifications of the Finance Act, 2017. It can be legitimately expected that the multifarious amendments in relation to merger and reorganisation of Tribunals may result in massive increase in litigation which, in absence of adequate infrastructure, or budgetary grants, will overburden the Judiciary. [Para 188] [138-E-F]
5.2 (2) In the fitness of things, this Court deems it appropriate to direct the Union of India to carry out financial impact assessment in respect of all the Tribunals referable to Sections 158 to 182 of the Finance Act, 2017 and undertake an exercise to assess the need based requirements and make available sufficient resources for each Tribunal established by the Parliament. [Para 189] [138-G] 6. ISSUE VI: WHETHER JUDGES OF TRIBUNALS SET UP BY ACTS OF PARLIAMENT UNDER ARTICLES 323-A AND 323-B OF THE CONSTITUTION CAN BE EQUATED IN ‘RANK’ AND ‘STATUS’ WITH CONSTITUTIONAL FUNCTIONARIES? 6.1 (1) In light of the unequivocal assertions of a coordinate bench of this Court, there can be no doubt that executive action cannot confer status equivalent to that of either Supreme Court or High Court judges on any member or head of any Tribunal or other judicial fora. [Para 193] [141-B] 6.1 (2) Furthermore, that even though manned by retired judges of High Courts and the Supreme Court, such Tribunals established under Article 323-A and 323-B of the Constitution cannot seek equivalence with High Courts or the Supreme Court. Once a judge of a High Court or Supreme Court has retired and he/she no longer enjoys the Constitutional status, the statutory position occupied by him/her cannot be equated with the previous position as a High Court or a Supreme Court judge. The rank, dignity and position of Constitutional judges is hence sui generis and arise not merely by their position in the Warrant of Precedence or the salary and perquisites they draw,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
but as a result of the Constitutional trust accorded in them. Indiscriminate accordance of status of such Constitutional judges on Tribunal members and presiding officers will do violence to the very Constitutional Scheme. [Para 194] [141-C-D] 7. ISSUE VII: WHETHER DIRECT STATUTORY APPEALS FROM TRIBUNALS TO THE SUPREME COURT OUGHT TO BE DETOURED? 7.1 Such statutory appeals take away the inherent ability of the Supreme Court, as envisaged in the Constitution, to regulate cases before it by confining its consideration to cases involving the most egregious of wrongs and/or having the greatest impact on public interest. [Para 205] [146-E] 7.2 Further, in providing for appeals directly from Tribunals, the jurisdiction of High Courts is in effect curtailed to a great extent. Not only does this hamper access to justice, but it also takes away the much needed exposure for High Court judges, earnestly needed in a vibrant and ever-evolving judiciary. Since majority of the judges of the Supreme Court are elevated from the High Courts, their lack of exposure to these specialised areas of law hinders their efficacy in adjudicating the direct statutory appeals from specialised Tribunals. [Para 206] [146-F-G] 7.3 Providing statutory appeals directly to the Supreme Court dents this to no end. With increasing tribunalisation, statutory appeal provisions are ostensibly being included without undertaking any ‘Judicial Impact Assessment’. As of last count there are several hundreds of cases which have been decided by the NCLAT and many other thousands by other tribunals pending in this Court. [Para 214] [149-G] 7.4. In light of this, provisions for statutory appeals directly and liberally to the Supreme Court raises the inevitability of bogging the Court down and inhibiting its Constitutional objective. Further, providing statutory appeals to this Court against orders of Tribunals also undermines the essence of tribunalisation. It is hardly rational to state on one hand that an alternate to the ordinary method of justice dispensation needs to be provided owing to the complicated procedures and owing
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
to the lack of specialisation of District and High Courts, and in the same breadth also provide statutory appeals to the final Court in that very original system. [Para 216] [150-C-D]
7.5 If High Courts are ill placed to hear routine matters then it hardly seems justifiable that this Court would be any better placed to resolve disputes in appellate jurisdiction. Finality as a principle must be encouraged and providing statutory appeals to the Supreme Court only undermines the same. Instead, no discernible harm would arise if decisions of Tribunals or High Courts attain finality, without reaching this Court. [Para 217] [150-E]
8. ISSUE VIII: WHETHER THERE IS A NEED FOR AMALGAMATION OF EXISTING TRIBUNALS AND SETTING UP OF BENCHES 8.1 The ‘imbalance’ in distribution of case-load and inconsistencies in nature, location and functioning of Tribunals require urgent attention. It is essential that after conducting a Judicial Impact Assessment as directed earlier, such ‘niche’ Tribunals be amalgamated with others dealing with similar areas of law, to ensure effective utilisation of resources and to facilitate access to justice. [Para 226] [155-F]
CONCLUSION 9. In light of the discussions and analysis, it is held that: (i) The issue and question of Money Bill, as defined under Article 110(1) of the Constitution, and certification accorded by the Speaker of the Lok Sabha in respect of Part-XIV of the Finance Act, 2017 is referred to a larger Bench. (ii) Section 184 of the Finance Act, 2017 does not suffer from excessive delegation of legislative functions as there are adequate principles to guide framing of delegated legislation, which would include the binding dictums of this Court. (iii) The Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal and other Authorities (Qualifications, Experience and other Conditions of Service of Members) Rules, 2017 suffer from various infirmities as observed earlier. These Rules formulated by the Central
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
Government under Section 184 of the Finance Act, 2017 being contrary to the parent enactment and the principles envisaged in the Constitution as interpreted by this Court, are hereby struck down in entirety. (iv) The Central Government is accordingly directed to reformulate the Rules strictly in conformity and in accordance with the principles delineated by this Court in R.K. Jain, L. Chandra Kumar, Madras Bar Association and Gujarat Urja Vikas Ltd. conjointly read with the observations made in the earlier part of this decision. (v) The new set of Rules to be formulated by the Central Government shall ensure non-discriminatory and uniform conditions of service, including assured tenure, keeping in mind the fact that the Chairperson and Members appointed after retirement and those who are appointed from the Bar or from other specialised professions/services, constitute two separate and distinct homogeneous classes. (vi) It would be open to the Central Government to provide in the new set of Rules that the Presiding Officers or Members of the Statutory Tribunals shall not hold ‘rank’ and ‘status’ equivalent to that of the Judges of the Supreme Court or High Courts, as the case may be, only on the basis of drawing equal salary or other perquisites. (vii) There is a need-based requirement to conduct ‘Judicial Impact Assessment’ of all the Tribunals referable to the Finance Act, 2017 so as to analyse the ramifications of the changes in the framework of Tribunals as provided under the Finance Act, 2017. Thus, we find it appropriate to issue a writ of mandamus to the Ministry of Law and Justice to carry out such ‘Judicial Impact Assessment’ and submit the result of the findings before the competent legislative authority. (viii) The Central Government in consultation with the Law Commission of India or any other expert body shall re-visit the provisions of the statutes referable to the Finance Act, 2017 or other Acts as listed in para 174 of this order and place appropriate proposals before the Parliament for consideration of the need to remove direct appeals to the Supreme Court from
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
orders of Tribunals. A decision in this regard by the Union of India shall be taken within six months.
(ix) The Union Government shall carry out an appropriate exercise for amalgamation of existing Tribunals adopting the test of homogeneity of the subject matters to be dealt with and thereafter constitute adequate number of Benches commensurate with the existing and anticipated volume of work. [Para 228] [156-A-H; 157-A-F]
PER DR. D. Y. CHANDRACHUD, J. Passage as a Money Bill 10. The basic postulate of our Constitution is that every authority is subservient to constitutional supremacy. No authority can assume to itself the ultimate power to decide the limits of its own constitutional mandate. Judicial review is intended to ensure that every constitutional authority keeps within the bounds of its constitutional functions and authority. In holding a constitutional institution within its bounds, judicial review does not trench upon the doctrine of separation of powers. The adjudicatory power vests in the Supreme Court as a constitutional court. In adjudicating on whether there has been a violation of a constitutional mandate in passing a Bill as a Money Bill, judicial review does not traverse beyond the limit set by the separation of powers. On the contrary, the independence of judicial tribunals has been consistently recognised by this Court as an inviolable feature of the basic structure of the Constitution. Determination of the norms of eligibility, the process of selection, conditions of service, and those regulating the impartiality with which the members of the tribunals discharge their functions and their effectiveness as adjudicatory bodies is dependent on their isolation from the executive. By leaving the rule making power to the uncharted wisdom of the executive, there has been a self-effacement by Parliament. The conferment of the power to frame rules on the executive has a direct impact on the independence of the tribunals. Allowing the executive a controlling authority over diverse facets of the tribunals would be destructive of judicial independence which constitutes a basic feature of the Constitution. [Para 88] [217-B-F]
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
Violation of directions issued by this Court 11.1 It is evident that the Search-cum-Selection Committee is constituted entirely from personnel within or nominated by the Central Government. Barring the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal, the Search-cum-Selection Committee for all other seventeen tribunals specified in the Schedule is constituted either entirely from personnel within or nominated by the Central Government or comprises a majority of personnel from the Central Government. The Search-cum-Selection Committee of the National Company Law Appellate Tribunal consists of an equal number of members from the judiciary as well as from the Central Government with no casting vote to the Chief Justice of India or their nominee. [Para 90] [218-CE] 11.2 The procedure for selection is fundamentally destructive of judicial independence. The Union Government has vital status in the disputes before many tribunals. Even otherwise, conferring upon the government such a dominating and overwhelming voice in making appointments is a negation of judicial independence. [Para 90] [219-E] 11.3 The constitution of the Search-cum-Selection committees as stipulated in the Schedule to the 2017 Rules cannot pass constitutional muster under a system governed by the rule of law that accords primacy to the independence of the judiciary. Independence of the judiciary requires that judicial functioning be free from interference by the other two organs of the state. The Central Government is the largest litigant before the tribunals constituted under various statutes. The independent functioning of the tribunals stands compromised where the executive has the controlling authority in the selection of members to the tribunals. The executive is often a litigant before and has an interest in the disputes which are adjudicated by the tribunals. The constitution of the Search-cum-Selection committees stipulated in the 2017 Rules violates the principle of judicial independence and the directions issued by this Court in R Gandhi and Madras Bar Association. [Para 93] [221-E-G] 11.4 This Court finds that though the decision in R Gandhi was delivered in 2010 and in Madras Bar Association in 2014,
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
the same anomalies have persisted. An attempt has been made to dilute judicial independence by a creeping assertion of executive power. This is unconstitutional. [Para 98] [224-G-H]
Severability 12. In the present case, Part XIV of the Finance Act 2017 is severable. Parliament would, in any event, have enacted the valid parts of the Finance Act 2017 if it had known that Part XIV is invalid. The valid and invalid parts are not so inextricably linked that the invalidity of Part XIV should result in the invalidity of the rest. Nor is Part XIV a part of a composite scheme linked to the other parts of the Finance Act 2017. Even after the excision of Part XIV the remaining part of the Finance Act would still survive on its own. Hence, Part XIV of the Finance Act 2017 can be excised from the Act. [Para 101] [227H; 228-A-B] 12.2 Finally, a fervent plea was made by the Attorney General to the effect that even though some provisions contained in the Rules framed on 1 June 2017 may run contrary to the principles enunciated by this Court in R Gandhi and Madras Bar Association, the Central Government would be willing to proceed on the basis of the interim orders which were passed by this Court during the pendency of the proceedings with certain modifications. This Court unable to accept the submission. Part XIV of the Finance Act 2017 could not have been enacted in the form of a Money Bill. The rules framed by the Central Government are unconstitutional on the ground that they violate the principles of judicial independence set out in judgments of this Court. [Para 102] [228-C-D]
Conclusion 13. Part XIV of the Finance Act 2017 could not have been enacted in the form of a Money Bill. The rules which have been framed pursuant of the rule making power under Section 184 are held to be unconstitutional. However, since during the pendency of these proceedings, certain steps were taken in pursuance of the interim orders and appointments have been made, it is directed that those appointments shall not be affected by the declaration of unconstitutionality. The terms and
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
conditions governing the personnel so appointed shall however abide by the parent enactments. Upon the declaration of unconstitutionality, the conditions specified in all corresponding aspects in the parent enactments shall continue to operate. [Para 103] [228-E-F]
14. This Court has repeatedly emphasised the need for setting up an independent statutory body to oversee the working of tribunals. Despite the directions issued by this Court in Chandra Kumar nearly two decades ago, no action has been taken by the legislature to put in place an umbrella organisation which would be tasked with addressing the drawbacks of the system to which this Court has adverted above. The lack of a single authority to ensure competence and uniform service conditions has led to a fragmented tribunal system that defeats the purpose for which the system was constituted. Moreover, the co-ordinating authority for all tribunals must be the Department of Justice. Vesting that function in individual ministries has led to haphazard evolution of the tribunal structure, besides posing serious dangers to the independence of tribunals. [Para 104] [228-G-H; 229-A-B]
15. It is imperative that an overarching statutory organisation be constituted through legislative intervention to oversee the working of tribunals. This Court recommends the constitution of an independent statutory body called the “National Tribunals Commission” to oversee the selection process of members, criteria for appointment, salaries and allowances, introduction of common eligibility criteria, for removal of Chairpersons and Members as also for meeting the requirement of infrastructural and financial resources. The legislation should aim at prescribing uniform service conditions for members. The Commission should comprise the following members: (i) Three serving judges of the Supreme Court of India nominated by the Chief Justice of India; (ii) Two serving Chief Justices or judges of the High Court nominated by the Chief Justice of India;
(iii) Two members to be nominated by the Central Government from amongst officers holding at least
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
the rank to a Secretary to the Union Government: one of them shall be the Secretary to the Department of Justice who will be the ex-officio convener; and (iv) Two independent expert members to be nominated by the Union government in consultation with the Chief Justice of India. [Para 105] [229-B-F] The senior-most among the Judges nominated by the Chief Justice of India shall be designated as the Chairperson of the NTC. [Para 106] [229-F-G] 16. While the setting up of the NTC is within the competence of the legislature, it must be ensured that the guidelines that have been laid down by this Court to ensure the independence and efficient functioning of the tribunal system in India are observed. The independence of judicial tribunals is an inviolable feature of the basic structure of the Constitution. The procedure of selection, appointment, removal of members and prescription of the service conditions of tribunal members determine the independence of the tribunals. As this Court has held, in preserving the independence of the tribunals as a facet of judicial independence, the adjudicatory body must be robust: subservient to none and accountable to the need to render justice in the context of specialized adjudication. This is reflected in the need for vigilance in guarding the independence of courts and tribunals. [Para 107] [229-G-H; 230-A-B] 17. Competence, professionalism and specialisation are indispensable facets of a robust tribunal system designed to deliver specialised justice. The Commission must be vested with the power to oversee the administration of all tribunals established under the enactments of Parliament to ensure the adequate manning of the tribunals with the infrastructure and staff required to meet the exigencies of the system. The Union government should also consider formulating a law to ensure the constitution of an All India Tribunal Service governing the recruitment and conditions of service of the non-adjudicatory personnel for tribunals. At present, the administrative staff of the tribunals is by and large brought on deputation. The tribunals
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
are woefully short of an adequate complement of trained administrative personnel. Hence, there is an urgent need to set up an All India Tribunal Service in the interests of the effective functioning of the tribunal system. [Para 108] [230-C-E] PER DEEPAK GUPTA, J.
Issue No. 1 18. There is total agreement with the Chief Justice in as much as he has held that the decision of the Hon’ble Speaker of the House of People under Article 110 (3) of the Constitution is not beyond judicial review. There is also an agreement with his views that keeping in view of the high office of the Speaker, the scope of judicial review in such matters is extremely restricted. If two views are possible then there can be no manner of doubt that the view of the Speaker must prevail. Keeping in view the lack of clarity as to what constitutes a Money Bill, it is agreed with the Hon’ble Chief Justice that the issue as to whether Part XIV of the Finance Act, 2017, is a Money Bill or not may be referred to a larger bench. [Para 18] [236-E-F] Issue no. 2
19. As far as Issue No.2 is concerned, there is disagreement with the conclusion of Chief Justice. There can be no doubt that Parliament is not expected to deal with all matters and it can delegate certain “non-essential” matters to the executive. Every condition need not be laid down by the Legislature. [Para 19] [236-G] 20. I am in respectful disagreement with the Chief Justice that the objects of the parent enactments and the law laid down by this Court in R. K. Jain v. Union of India, L. Chandra Kumar, Union of India v.Madras Bar Association, Madras Bar Association v. Union of India, Madras Bar Association v. Union of India, Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Ltd. v. Essar Power Ltd. in essence should be read as the guidelines. One would expect the Union Government to abide by the directions of this Court. However, this expectation has been belied by this very enactment which violates every principle of law laid down by this Court and, as held in the judgments of both my brothers, the Rules framed by
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
the delegatee are violative of the law laid down by this Court. In this background, it is apparent that both the delegator and the delegatee felt that they were not bound by these judgments. This is also apparent from the fact that the Rules framed by the delegatee have not been brought in consonance with the law by the delegator. [Para 30] [240-F-G; 241-A-B]
Issue nos. 4,5,7 and 8 21. There are various reasons why there should be one nodal agency. Tribunals are facing many problems like lack of manpower, very few benches, vacancies lying unfilled for long period, financial dependence on the department which may be litigating before the tribunal etc. These are ills which can be avoided if Tribunals fall under one umbrella organisation. One umbrella organisation will be better equipped to understand the problems faced by all the Tribunals. This could lead to standardization of Tribunals and a uniform approach to the needs of each tribunal. A large number of tribunals, especially those cast with the duty of discharging adjudicatory functions have been constituted with a view to replace the courts and in many cases the jurisdiction earlier exercised by the High Courts has been vested in such tribunals. It is, therefore, imperative that these tribunals must be manned by persons of impeccable integrity, high intellect and having vast experience in the field in which they will exercise jurisdiction. These tribunals also must have functional autonomy. This cannot be achieved unless there is a nodal body which shall look after the administrative needs of the tribunals. For more than 2 decades the Government has not thought it fit to comply with the 7-Judge Bench judgment of this Court in L. Chandra Kumar. These matters cannot be permitted to linger on indefinitely. Therefore, a direction must be given to the Government to set up a single nodal agency within a period of 6 months from today till which time the present system may continue. Merely giving financial autonomy to the tribunals will not do away with the need of having one common umbrella organisation to supervise all the tribunals. [Para 36] [242-D-H; 243-A] 22. Even without carrying out any judicial impact assessment it is clear, as held in Madras Bar Association, 2010
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
that tribunals in India have unfortunately not achieved full independence. When tribunals are established, they depend upon the sponsoring department for funds, infrastructure and even space for functioning. Administrative members of the tribunal are, more often than not, drawn from this department. This, in my opinion, strikes at the very root of judicial independence because the biggest litigant or stakeholder itself becomes part and parcel of the adjudicating body which is supposed to be free, independent and fearless. [Para 37] [243-B-C] 23. (1) The need for carrying out judicial impact assessment of all the tribunals in India cannot be over emphasised. Experience has shown that the tribunals are not fully independent and more often than not, the number of vacancies in the tribunals are so high as to make the tribunals dysfunctional if not non-functional. The promised benches remain a mirage in the air and the litigants from remote areas of the country have to come to the State capitals or the National Capital for redressal of their grievances. [Para 38] [243-B] 23. (2) The committee which carries out the judicial impact assessment of the functioning of the tribunals has to deal with a whole lot of issues. It is neither feasible nor proper to lay down all the issues in this judgment but some are highlighted. Another important issue which must be dealt with is whether the tribunals have really helped in early disposal of the cases. The time spent for disposal may vary from case to case but this Court is mainly dealing with the cases which end in the High Courts or at the Supreme Court. This must be done not only on an all India basis but also on State to State basis. There are many smaller States in the country where the Civil Courts and the High Courts are not overburdened with work. In these States, the cases are decided much faster than in many other larger States. Normally, it is these smaller States which do not get permanent benches, sometimes not even Circuit Benches. It is a paradox that the States which are judicially well administered and where disposal is quick, do not get the permanent benches and the litigants suffer whereas States which are very slow in disposing of the cases get more benches. Even when Circuit Benches come to these States there is a huge time gap between two sittings. The whole purpose of providing cheaper and faster justice gets lost
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
because the Circuit Benches come rarely and many times the constitution of the Circuit Benches changes on every visit resulting in matters being reheard every time. [Para 43] [245E-H; 246-A-B]
24. Having tribunals without benches in at least the capitals of States and Union Territories amounts to denial of justice to citizens of those States and Union Territories. It also makes the justice delivery system very metropolis centric. This has many adverse effects. The bench and the bar in smaller district towns and capitals of smaller States which were handling these matters in a competent manner are deprived of handling these types of cases. This also makes access to justice expensive for the litigants. It also leads to a situation where the bench and the bar in these areas would not have any experience of handling matters relating to jurisdictions transferred to tribunals which they used to handle earlier. Therefore, the local bench and bar will never develop and the entire bulk of work will be captured by those practicing in Delhi or in those State capitals where benches of the tribunals are set up. Instead of taking justice to the common man, he is forced to spend more money, spend more time and travel long distances in his quest for justice, which is his fundamental right. [Para 44] [246-B-D] 25. The litigants cannot wait for judicial impact assessment and action by the Government which may or may not take place. Experience has shown that the judgments right from L. Chandra Kumar to Madras Bar Association, 2010 have not been complied with by the Union in letter and spirit. Citizens of this country cannot be denied justice which is the first promise made in the Preamble. Therefore, whichever State/Union Territory the bench of a particular tribunal is not established or functioning, the litigants of that State will have a right to invoke the extraordinary writ jurisdiction of the jurisdictional High Court under Article 226 of the Constitution for redressal of their grievances. They cannot be expected to go to far off distant places and spend huge amounts of money, much beyond their means to ventilate their grievances. The alternative remedy of approaching a tribunal is an illusory remedy and not an efficacious alternative remedy. The self-imposed bar or restraint of an alternative efficacious remedy would not apply. Such litigants are entitled to file petitions under
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
Article 226 of the Constitution of India before the jurisdictional High Court. In L. Chandra Kumar it was clearly held that the right of judicial review is a part of the basic structure of the Constitution and this right must be interpreted in a manner that it is truly available to the litigants and should not be an illusory right. [Para 45] [246-E-H; 247-A-B] 26. One more aspect which needs to be looked into is the need to have a two-tier tribunal system like in the United Kingdom- a lower tribunal and an appellate tribunal. If there are two-tier tribunals then there would be adjudication at the appellate level by an appellate tribunal. Having one appellate forum within the hierarchy of tribunals would probably lessen the burden on the High Courts and the Supreme Court. [Para 46] [247-B] 27. Recruitment to the lower tribunal should be done on the basis of an objective criteria like the written test conducted for the post of District Judges. The persons selected to the lower tribunals can be made eligible for promotion to the appellate tribunals. In fact, there can be common service to man more than one or more tribunals. [Para 47] [247-C-F] 28. If there are tribunal services and there is provision for appeal within the hierarchy of the tribunals and the High Courts exercise their writ jurisdiction or if in some matters appeals are provided to the High Courts in the first instance, many of the ills which plague the system may be overcome. If the aforesaid system is followed then the question of appointing retired Judges or bureaucrats will not arise. The amicus curiae in his note has raised an issue that tribunals should not become a haven for retired persons. In my view, there should normally be no post retiral sinecures. Though the ideal situation would be to have no appointments from retired judges or bureaucrats, this may not be possible in the near future because there are no tribunal services and most of the posts at this stage may have to be filled from amongst retired persons. At the same time, an effort has to be made to ensure that in the foreseeable future the number of retired persons being reappointed is brought down and more persons from within the tribunal services are appointed up to the highest level in the tribunal. [Para 48] [247-G-H; 248-A-B]
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
29. There may be some posts which require retired judges to be appointed such as Lokpal, Lokayukta, Chairpersons of the Human Rights Commission, Chairman of the Law Commission of India, etc. But this should not become a matter of routine especially when the appointments are being made by the executive. If the administration makes appointments and judges, serving or newly retired judges, are under consideration for such posts then the independence of the judiciary is likely to be compromised. The public of this country still reposes great faith in the judiciary. That faith will be eroded in case it is felt that the appointments are made for extraneous reasons. Most judges live up to the expectations of the high standards of integrity and propriety expected from them but one cannot shut our eyes to the harsh reality that there are a few black sheep. One cannot expect justice from those who, on the verge of retirement, throng the corridors of power looking for post retiral sinecures. Therefore, the majority of members of the selecting body must comprise of the Chief Justice of India and/or his/her nominees and the views of the Chief Justice and/or his/her nominees must be given precedence over the views of other members. [Para 49] [248-C-F]
30. It is agreed with the Chief Justice that an attempt should be made to do away with filing of first appeal as a matter of right to the Supreme Court. At present, at least 2 dozen statues provide for appeals directly to the Supreme Court. The Supreme Court becomes a Court of first appeal which is highly avoidable. If the law laid down in L. Chandra Kumar is followed, the High Courts should have the jurisdiction to entertain writ petitions against the orders of the tribunals. This will reduce the burden on the Supreme Court. Even more importantly, the High Courts, when they entertain these matters, will deal with them within the limited scope of writ jurisdiction. If the jurisdiction of the High Courts is bypassed by providing for appeals directly to the Supreme Court, soon a stage will come when we will have no High Court Judges who would have heard matters in various jurisdictions. It would be virtually impossible for them to handle such matters in the Supreme Court where the tenure of a Judge is on an average only about 4 years. [Para 51] [249-B-D]
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
31. The next issue is who should carry out the judicial impact assessment. The Judicial Impact Assessment Committee should comprise of two retired judges of the Supreme Court, the senior being the Chairperson of the Committee, and one retired Chief Justice of a High Court all three to be nominated by the Chief Justice of India. Out of the three at least two should have been the Chairperson or members of tribunals. Two members of the Executive, not below the rank of Secretary, to the Government of India, one from the Ministry of Law and Justice and one from some other branch can also be members but these members should be appointed in consultation with the Chief Justice of India. [Para 53] [249-E-G] 32. The last issue is whether there should be a Commission or a body to oversee the appointment of members of various tribunals. In my view it is necessary to have such a Commission which is itself an independent body manned by honest and competent persons. This body is required to select those persons who man the specialised tribunals in terms of the law laid down in various judgments of this Court. There is need to have persons who not only have grassroot experience but a judicious mix of judicial members and those with grassroot experience. There is need to have persons who have an independent outlook, integrity, character, good reputation and people who are totally free from the influence or pressure from the Government. It is only then that the people will have faith in the adjudicating mechanism of the tribunals. [Para 54] [249G-H; 250-A-B] PER RANJAN GOGOI, CJI (FOR HIMSELF AND N.V. RAMANA, DR. D.Y. CHANDRACHUD, DEEPAK GUPTA AND SANJIV KHANNA, JJ.): Union of India v. R. Gandhi, President, Madras Bar Association (2010) 11 SCC 1 : [2010] 6 SCR 857 ; L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India (1997) 3 SCC 261 : [1997] 2 SCR 1186 ; R.K. Jain v. Union of India (1993) 4 SCC 119 : [1993] 3 SCR 802 ; Madras Bar Association v. Union of India (2014) (2014) 10 SCC 1 : [2014] 10 SCR ; Gujarat Urja Vikas Ltd. v. Essar Power Ltd. (2016) 9 SCC 103 : [2016] 5 SCR 10 ; Salem Advocate Bar Assn. (II) v. Union of India
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
(2005) 6 SCC 344 : [2005] 1 Suppl. SCR 929 ; Raja Ram Pal v. Lok Sabha (2007) 3 SCC 184 : [2007] 1 SCR 317 ; Gwalior Rayon Silk Mfg. (Wvg.) Co. v. Asstt. Commissioner of Sales (1974) 4 SCC 98 : [1974] 2 SCR 879 ; T.N. Seshan v. Union of India (1995) 4 SCC 611 : [1995] 2 Suppl. SCR 106 ; Union of India v. Major General Shrikant Sharma (2015) 6 SCC 773 : [2015] 4 SCR 676 – relied on.
Jaswant Sugar Mills Ltd., Meerut v. Lakshmichand AIR 1963 SC 677 : [1963] Suppl. SCR 242 ; Associated Cement Co. Ltd. v. PN Sharma AIR 1965 SC 1595 : [1965] SCR 366 ; M.C. Mehta v. Union of India (1986) 2 SCC 176 : [1986] 1 SCR 312 ; Union of India v. R. Gandhi, President, Madras Bar Association (2010) 11 SCC 1 : [2010] 6 SCR 857 ; Madras Bar Association v. Union of India (2015) 8 SCC 583 : [2015] 6 SCR 638 ; Rajiv Garg v. Union of India (WP No. 120 of 2017) on 08th February, 2013 ; MSM Sharma v. Dr. Shree Krishna Sinha (2007) 3 SCC 184 : [2007] 1 SCR 317 ; Union of India v. Jyoti Prakash Mitter (1971) 1 SCC 396 : [1971] 3 SCR 483 ; R (Jackson) v. Attorney General [2005] UKHL 56 ; Mohd. Saeed Siddiqui v. State of Uttar Pradesh (2014) 11 SCC 415; Yogendra Kumar Jaiswal v. State of Bihar (2016) 3 SCC 183 : [2015] 14 SCR 1037 ; Justice Puttaswamy (Retd.) and Anr. v. Union of India (2019) 1 SCC 1 ; Hari Ram v. Babu Gopal Prasad (1991) Supp. 2 SCC 608 ; M/s Saru Smelting (P) Ltd. v. Commissioner of Sales Tax, Lucknow (1993) Supp. 3 SCC 97 : [1993] 3 SCR 719 ; Kihoto Hollohan v. Zachillhu and Others (1992) Supp. 2 SCC 651 : [1992] 1 SCR 686 ; In re: The Delhi Laws Act, 1951 AIR [1951] SCR 747 ; B. Shama Rao v. Union Territory of Pondicherry, (2015) 4 SCC [2015] 2 SCR 51 ; Ramesh Birch v. Union of India 1990 AIR 560 : [1989] 2 SCR 629 ; Devi Das Gopal Krishnan & Ors v. State of Punjab & Or AIR 1967 SC 1895 : [1967] SCR 557 ; Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Birla Cotton, Spinning and Weaving Mills, Delhi and Another AIR 1968 SC
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
1232 : [1968] SCR 251 ; M.K. Papiah & Sons v. Excise Commissioner (1975) 1 SCC 492 : [1975] 3 SCR 607 ; Avinder Singh v. State of Punjab (1979) 1 SCC 137 : [1979] 1 SCR 845 ; Registrar of Coop. Societies v. K. Kunjabmu (1980) 1 SCC 340 : [1980] 2 SCR 260 ; Keshavlal Khemchand and Son Private Limited & Others v. Union of India (2015) 4 SCC 770 : [2015] 2 SCR 51 ; Supreme Court AdvocatesOn-Record Association and Another v. Union of India (2016) 5 SCC 1 : [2015] 13 SCR 1 ; Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala (1973) 4 SCC 225 : [1973] Suppl. SCR 1 ; Union of India v. Madras Bar Association (2010) 11 SCC 1 : [2010] 6 SCR 857 ; Madras Bar Association v. Union of India & Anr. (2014) 10 SCC 1 : [2014] 10 SCR 1 ; Bihar Legal Support Authority v. Chief Justice of India (1986) 4 SCC 767 : [1987] 1 SCR 295 ; Mafatlal Industries Ltd. v. Union of India (1997) 5 SCC 536 : [1996] 10 Suppl. SCR 585 ; Sangram Singh v. Election Tribunal [1955] 2 SCR 1 – referred to. Marbury v. Madison 5 U.S. (1 Cranch) 137 (1803) – referred to. Case Law Reference
[2010] 6 SCR 857
relied on
Para 4
[1997] 2 SCR 1186
relied on
Para 5
[1963] Suppl. SCR 242
referred to
Para 13
[1965] SCR 366
referred to
Para 13
[1986] 1 SCR 312
referred to
Para 40
[1993] 3 SCR 802
relied on
Para 44
[2010] 6 SCR 857
referred to
Para 47
[2014] 10 SCR 1
relied on
Para 50
[2015] 6 SCR 638
referred to
Para 53
[2016] 5 SCR 101
relied on
Para 54
[2007] 1 SCR 317
relied on
Para 101
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
[2007] 1 SCR 317
referred to
Para 102
[1971] 3 SCR 483
referred to
Para 102
(2014) 11 SCC 415
referred to
Para 106
[2015] 14 SCR 1037
referred to
Para 107
(2019) 1 SCC 1
referred to
Para 108
(1991) Supp. 2 SCC 608
referred to
Para 114
[1993] 3 SCR 719
referred to
Para 114
[1992] 1 SCR 686
referred to
Para 115
[1951] SCR 747
referred to
Para 131
[2015] 2 SCR 51
referred to
Para 131
[1989] 2 SCR 629
referred to
Para 134
[1967] SCR 557
referred to
Para 134
[1968] SCR 251
referred to
Para 136
[1975] 3 SCR 607
referred to
Para 137
[1979] 1 SCR 845
referred to
Para 138
[1980] 2 SCR 260
referred to
Para 139
[2015] 2 SCR 51
referred to
Para 140
[1974] 2 SCR 879
relied on
Para 141
[2015] 13 SCR 1
referred to
Para 144
[1973] Suppl. SCR 1
referred to
Para 153
[2010] 6 SCR 857
referred to
Para 155
[2014] 10 SCR 1
referred to
Para 155
[2005] 1 Suppl. SCR 929
relied on
Para 187
[1995] 2 Suppl. SCR 106
relied on
Para 192
[1987] 1 SCR 295
referred to
Para 210
[2015] 4 SCR 676
relied on
Para 218
[1996] 10 Suppl. SCR 585
referred to
Para 221
[1955] 2 SCR 1
referred to
Para 222
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
PER DR. D.Y. CHANDRACHUD, J.: Kihoto Hollohan v. Zachillhu and Others (1992) Supp. 2 SCC 651 : [1992] 1 SCR 686; N P Ponnuswami v. Returning Office, Namakkal Constituency, Namakkal, Salem, Dist. [1952] SCR 218 ; Union of India v. Tulsiram Patel (1985) 3 SCC 398 : [1985] 2 Suppl. SCR 131 ; Babulal Parate v State of Bombay [1960] 1 SCR 605 ; Special Reference No. 1 of 1964 Powers, Privileges and Immunities of State Legislatures, In re (Special Reference No. 1 of 1964), AIR 1965 SC 745 : [1965] SCR 413 ; Ramdas Athawale v Union of India (2010) 4 SCC 1 : [2010] 3 SCR 1059 ; Raja Ram Pal v Hon’ble Speaker, Lok Sabha (2007) 3 SCC 184 : [2007] 1 SCR 317 ; L. Chandrakumar v. Union of India (1997) 3 SCC 261 : [1997] 2 SCR 1186 ; Union of India v. R. Gandhi, President, Madras Bar Association (2010) 11 SCC 1 : [2010] 6 SCR 857 ; Madras Bar Association v. Union of India (2014) 10 SCC 1 : [2014] 10 SCR 1 ; State of Bombay v. United Motors (India) Ltd. [1953] SCR 1069 ; – relied on. S P Sampath Kumar v Union of India (1987) 1 SCC 124 : [1987] 1 SCR 435 ; Madras Bar Association v. Union of India (2015) (2015) 8 SCC 583 : [2015] 6 SCR 638 ; Union of India v. Jyoti Prakash Mitter (1971) 1 SCC 396 : [1971] 3 SCR 483 ; Mangalore Ganesh Beedi Works v State of Mysore AIR 1963 SC 589 : [1963] Suppl. SCR 275 ; Mohd. Saeed Siddiqui v State of Uttar Pradesh (2014) 11 SCC 415 ; Yogendra Kumar Jaiswal v State of Bihar (2016) 3 SCC 183 : [2015] 14 SCR 1037 ; Pandit MSM Sharma v Dr Shree Krisha Sinha AIR 1960 SC 1186 ; Justice Puttaswamy (Retd.) and Anr. v. Union of India (2019) 1 SCC 1 ; Kuldip Nayar v Union of India (2006) 7 SCC 1 : [2006] 5 Suppl. SCR 1 ; State of West Bengal v. Anwar Ali Sarkar [1952] SCR 284 ; R.K. Garg v. Union of India (1981) 4 SCC 675 : [1982] 1 SCR 947 ; Subramanian Swamy v. Director, Central Bureau of Investigation (2014) 8 SCC 682 : [2014] 6 SCR
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
873 ; Bhim Singh v. Union of India (2010) 5 SCC 538 : [2010] 6 SCR 218 ; R.M.D. Chamarbaugwalla v. Union of India [1957] SCR 930 ; State of Bombay v. F N Balsara [1951] SCR 682 – referred to.
The Treatise on The Law, Privileges, Proceedings and Usage of Parliament C. Knight & Company, 1844 HM Seervai, Constitutional Law of India, Universal Law Co Pvt Ltd, Vol I, (1991), at pp.299-300 – referred to.
Case Law Reference [1987] 1 SCR 435
referred to
Para 11
[1997] 2 SCR 1186
relied on
Para 12
[2010] 6 SCR 857
relied on
Para 14
[2014] 10 SCR 1
referred to
Para 16
[2015] 6 SCR 638
referred to
Para 19
[1952] SCR 218
relied on
Para 34
[1971] 3 SCR 483
referred to
Para 35
[1985] 2 Suppl. SCR 131
relied on
Para 36
[1992] 1 SCR 686
relied on
Para 36
[1960] 1 SCR 605
relied on
Para 38
[1965] SCR 413
relied on
Para 39
[2010] 3 SCR 1059
relied on
Para 39
[2007] 1 SCR 317
relied on
Para 39
[1963] Suppl. SCR 275
referred to
Para 41
(2014) 11 SCC 415
referred to
Para 41
[2015] 14 SCR 1037
referred to
Para 41
AIR 1960 SC 1186
referred to
Para 46
(2019) 1 SCC 1
referred to
Para 47
[2006] 5 Suppl. SCR 1
referred to
Para 47
[1952] SCR 284
referred to
Para 74
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
[1982] 1 SCR 947
referred to
Para 74
[2014] 6 SCR 873
referred to
Para 74
[2010] 6 SCR 218
referred to
Para 74
[1957] SCR 930
referred to
Para 99
[1951] SCR 682
referred to
Para 99
[1953] SCR 1069
relied on
Para 100
PER DEEPAK GUPTA, J.:
L. Chandrakumar v. Union of India (1997) 3 SCC 261 : [1997] 2 SCR 1186 ; Gwalior Rayon Mills v. Assistant Commissioner, Sales Tax AIR 1974 SC 1660 : [1974] 2 SCR 879 ; Ramesh Birch v. Union of India 1989 Supp (1) SCC 430 : [1989] 2 SCR 629 relied on. Union of India v. Madras Bar Association, (2010) 11 SCC 1 : [2010] 6 SCR 857 ; Madras Bar Association v. Union of India (2015) 8 SCC 583 : [2015] 6 SCR 638 ; Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Ltd. v. Essar Power Ltd. (2016) 9 SCC 103 : [2016] 5 SCR 101 ; Minerva Mills Ltd. v. Union of India, (1980) 2 SCC 591 ; Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala, (1973) 4 SCC 225 : [1973] Suppl. SCR 1 ; Re Article 143, Constitution of India and Delhi Laws Act (1912) etc. AIR (38) 1951 SC 332 : [1951] SCR 747 ; Harishankar Bagla v. M.P. State AIR 1954 SC 465 : [1955] SCR 313 ; Madras Bar Association v. Union of India (2014) 10 SCC 1 : [2014] 10 SCR 1 ; Anita Kushwaha v. Pushap Sudan, (2016) 8 SCC 509 : [2016] 9 SCR 560 – referred to. Case Law Reference
[1997] 2 SCR 1186
relied on
Para 6
(1980) 2 SCC 591
referred to
Para 10
[1973] Suppl. SCR 1
referred to
Para 10
[2010] 6 SCR 857
referred to
Para 15
[1951] SCR 747
referred to
Para 21
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD.
[1974] 2 SCR 879
relied on
Para 22
[1955] SCR 313
referred to
Para 23
[1989] 2 SCR 629
relied on
Para 24
[2014] 10 SCR 1
referred to
Para 30
[2015] 6 SCR 638
referred to
Para 30
[2016] 5 SCR 101
referred to
Para 30
[2016] 9 SCR 560
referred to
Para 39
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION : Civil Appeal No. 8588 of 2019.
From the Judgment and Order dated 20.01.2017 of the High Court of Kerala at Ernakulam in W.A. No. 2349/2016 in W.P.(C) No. 26290/2014. With
W. P. (C) No. 267/2012, 279/2017, 558/2017, 561/2017, 625/2017, 640/2017, 1016/2017, 788/2017, 925/2017, 1098/2017, 1129/2017, 33/ 2018, 205/2018, 467/2018, T. C. (C) No. 49/2018, 51/2018 and T. P. (C) No. 2199/2018. K.K. Venugopal, A.G., Tushar Mehta, S.G. A.N.S. Nadkarni, A.S.G., Ms. Madhavi Diwan, A.S.G., Arvind P. Datar, Sr. Advocate (A.C.), Mohan Parasaran, Ms. Priya Hingorani, Ms. Aishwarya Bhati, Ms. Prem Lata Bansal, Sidharth Luthra, Ashok Kumar Panda, Ms. V. Mohana, R. Balasubramanian, Sr. Advs., Rahul Unnikrishnan, N. Sai Vinod, T.V.S. Raghavendra Sreyas, Ms. Mayuri Raghuvanshi, V. Ranghuvanshi, Mr. Renjith B. Marar, Ms. Lakshmi N. Kaimal, Anil Sharma, Krishnadas V., Ms. Ruchira Goel, Muhammad Ali Khan, Abhishek Jebraj, Omar Hoda, Namrah Nasir, Sparsh Prasad, Ms. Aditi Pani, Nikhil Swami, A.K. Behera, V.K. Verma, Tarun Verma, Gp. Capt. K.S. Bhati, Ms. Vaidruti Mishra, Ms. Tanuja Patra, Rupesh Kumar, Ms. H. Mota, Pravesh Bahuguna, Anand Varma, Dhairya Madan, Shwetank Singh, Sanjay Sharma, K. Krishna Kumar, Sudipto Sircar, A. Subba Rao, Annam D. N. Rao, Annam Venkatesh, Rahul Mishra, Mrs. Maneesha Dhir, Alok Dhir, Karan Batura, Ashu Kansal, Ms. Anushree Prashit Kapadia, Ms. Diksha Rai, Varun K. Chopra, Tejaswi Kumar Pradhan, Satyabrata Panda, Manoranjan Paikaray,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
Aniruddha Purushotham, D.K. Gandhi, Sanjay Sharma, Jagjit Singh Chhabra, Rajiv Shukla, Ms. Shivani Kapoor, Prakash Ranjan Nayak, Gorang Goyal, V.P. Gupta, Jagdish Kumar Chawla, Anuj Bansal, A. Kumar, Nikhil Nayyar, Ms. Shraddha Deshmukh, Ms. Rukhmani Bobde, Saurabh Mishra, Ankur Talwar, Ms. Ankita Sharma, Ms. Nikita Kapoor, Zoheb Hossain, Rajat Nair, Chinmayee Chandran, Mohd. Shahan Ulla, Vivek Gurnani, Piyush Goyal, Arvind K. Sharma, G.S. Makker, Mukesh Kumar Maroria, P. I. Jose, Ms. P.S. Chandralekha, Mrs. Anil Katiyar, Ashok Mathur, Sonal Jain, E.C. Agrawal, Parthiv K. Goswami, Ms. Diksha Rai, Ms. Palak Mahajan, Ishan Bisht, M/s Saharya & Co., Ajay Bansal, Gaurav Yadav and Ms. Veena Bansal, Advs. for the appearing parties. The Judgments of the Court were delivered by RANJAN GOGOI, CJI 1. Leave granted.
BRIEF BACKGROUND: 2. In the present batch of cases, the constitutionality of Part XIV of the Finance Act, 2017 and of the rules framed in consonance has been assailed. While it would be repetitious to reproduce the pleadings of each case separately, a brief reference is being made, illustratively, to the prayers made in three matters to aid the formulation of core issues arising for adjudication. 3. The Madras Bar Association has preferred Writ Petition (Civil) No. 267 of 2012 seeking the following reliefs:
“i. A writ of mandamus, directing the Union of India, to implement the directions of this Hon’ble Court in Union of India v. R. Gandhi [(2010) 11 SCC 1, para 96 at pg. 310] and L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India [(1997) 3 SCC 261], paras 120 and 121 at page 65 to 67], where Ministry of Law and Justice, Govt. Of India was ordered to take over the administration of all tribunals created by Parliament and streamline the functioning of the same. ii. A writ of mandamus directing the Ministry of Law & Justice to promptly carry out a ‘Judicial Impact
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI] Assessment’ on all tribunals created by Parliament and submit a report on the same to this Hon’ble Court.” 4. This Writ Petition was originally heard by a three-judge Bench on 18th February, 2015 wherein it was observed that the case presented substantial questions of Constitutional interpretation, necessitating hearing by a Constitution Bench. The orders passed from time to time reveal that, on 18th January, 2016, this Court perused the contents of the Tribunals, Appellate Tribunals and other Authorities (Conditions of Service) Bill, 2014 and felt that “it would be more appropriate if observations made in Union of India vs. R. Gandhi, President, Madras Bar Association 1 (in paragraphs 64-70) are also considered by the Government.” 5. The matter was listed again on 27th March, 2019 and this Court took cognizance of non-implementation of the directions issued vide para 96 of L. Chandra Kumar vs. Union of India2, which reads as follows: “96. We are of the opinion that, until a wholly independent agency for the administration of all such Tribunals can be set up, it is desirable that all such tribunals should be, as far as possible, under a single nodal ministry which will be in a position to oversee the working of these tribunals. For a number of reasons that Ministry should appropriately be the Ministry of Law. It would be open for the Ministry, in its turn, to appoint an independent supervisory body to oversee the working of the Tribunals.”
6. Thereafter on the same day, this Court opined as follows: “Tentatively, we are of the view that the said directions ought to have been implemented by the Government of India long back. In the course of hearing today, learned Attorney General for India relying on an affidavit filed on behalf of the Union of India in the year 2013, had pointed out certain difficulties including the need for an amendment of the Government of India (Allocation of Business) Rules, 1961. Learned Attorney General has also pointed out that the Ministry of Law and Justice is overburdened and may not be able to act and function as the nodal agency, which the Court had in mind while issuing directions way back
(2010) 11 SCC 1. (1997) 3 SCC 261.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
in the year 1997 in L. Chandra Kumar (supra). There cannot by any manner of doubt that to ensure the efficient functioning and to streamline the working of Tribunals, they should be brought under one agency, as already felt and observed by this Court in L. Chandra Kumar (supra). The Court would like to have benefit of the view of the Government of India as on today by means of an affidavit of the competent authority to be filed within two weeks from today. The second prayer made in the writ petition has also been considered by us and in this regard we have taken note of compilation placed before the Court by the learned Attorney General, which would go to show the present vacancy position in different Tribunals, which is one of the issues that we would attempt to resolve. From the compilation of the learned Attorney General, it appears that the Central Administrative Tribunal, the Intellectual Property Appellate Board, the Armed Forces Tribunal, the National Green Tribunal and the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal would require immediate attention. While every endeavour would be made by the nominee of the Chief Justice who heads the Selection Committee before whom the issue of recommendations may have been pending to expedite the same, such of the recommendations which have already been made by the Search-cum-Selection Committee as is in the case of National Company Law Tribunal and National Law Appellate Tribunal, should be immediately implemented by making appointments within the aforesaid period of two weeks and the result thereof be placed before the Court vide affidavit of the competent authority, as ordered to be filed by the present order. Once the aforesaid information is made available, appropriate orders will be passed by this Court, which may, inter alia, include remitting the matter to smaller Bench for monitoring on a continuous basis, so as to ensure due and proper functioning of the Tribunals. Matter be listed before this Bench after two weeks.” 7. During the pendency of the aforementioned writ petition, the present lead matter bearing SLP(C) No. 15804/2017 was filed by Rojer Mathew, assailing the final judgment and order of the High Court of Kerala. The petitioner had originally approached the High Court
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
challenging the constitutional validity of Section 13 (5-A) of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Securities Interest (SARFAESI) Act, 2002 which permits secured creditors to participate in auction of immoveable property if it remained unsold for want of reserve bid in an earlier auction. Rojer Mathew claimed that the aforementioned provision violated his rights under Article 300A and Article 14 of the Constitution, besides being in contravention of the Code of Civil Procedure which prohibits mortgagees from participating in auction of immovable property without prior Court permission.
8. During the course of arguments, it was brought to the notice of this Court that appointments to the Debt Recovery Tribunals was not in consonance with the Constitutional spirit of judicial independence. Accordingly, though Rojer Mathew was given an opportunity to approach the High Court for reconsideration of his plea on 16 th May, 2018, nevertheless this Court kept his petition pending to allow consideration of broader issues concerning restructuring of Tribunals. Assistance of Shri Arvind P. Datar, Sr. Advocate as Amicus Curiae was also requested by this Court. 9. The third matter to be taken note of is Writ Petition (Civil) No. 279/2017 where the petitioner, Kudrat Sandhu, has filed a Public Interest Litigation challenging the vires of Part XIV of the Finance Act, 2017 by which the provisions of twenty-five different enactments were amended to effect sweeping changes to the requisite qualifications, method of appointment, terms of office, salaries and allowances, and various other terms and conditions of service of the members and presiding officers of different statutory Tribunals. The impugned provisions of the Finance Act, 2017 have been referred to in extenso at appropriate parts of this order.
GENESIS OF TRIBUNALISATION: 10. Delay and backlogs in the administration of justice is of paramount concern for any country governed by the rule of law. In our present judicial setup, disputes often take many decades to attain finality, travelling across a series of lower courts to the High Court and ending with an inevitable approach to the Supreme Court. 11. Such crawling pace of the justice delivery system only aggravates the misery of affected parties. Although with nebulous
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
origins, the adage “justice delayed, is justice denied” is apt in this context. Courts in this country, probably in a quest to ensure complete justice for everyone, overlook the importance of expediency and finality. This situation has only worsened over the years, as evidenced through piling pendency across all Courts. It would however be wrong to place the blame of such delay squarely on the judiciary, for an empirical examination of pendency clearly demonstrates that the ratio of judges against the country’s population is one of the lowest in the world and the manpower (support staff) and infrastructure provided is dismal. 12. In addition to the delay in administration of justice, another important facet requiring attention is the rise of specialization and increase of complex regulatory and commercial aspects, which require esoteric appraisal and adjudication. The existing lower courts in the country are not well equipped to deal with such complex new issues which see constant evolution as compared to the stable nature of existing civil, criminal and the tax jurisprudence. 13. Evidently, there is a desperate need to overcome these hurdles of delay in administration of justice. Creation of tribunals has evolved as one solution in the ever-constant strive to increase access to justice. A ‘Tribunal’ can be understood as a body tasked with discharging quasi-judicial functions with the primary objective of providing a special forum for specific type of disputes and for faster and more efficacious adjudication of issues. In Jaswant Sugar Mills Ltd., Meerut vs. Lakshmichand3, a test was laid down whereunder it is to be examined whether the authority has the trappings of a Court, facets of which include the authority to make determinations, evidentiary and procedural powers and ability to impose sanctions. However, per a five-judge bench in Associated Cement Co. Ltd. v. PN Sharma4, Tribunals were vested with a primarily judicial character for it was observed that: “9. ….. Special matters and questions are entrusted to them for their decision and in that sense, they share with the courts one common characteristic; both the courts and the tribunals are “constituted by the State and are invested with judicial as distinguished from purely administrative or executive functions”, (vide Durga Shankar Mehta v. Thakur Raghuraj Singh [(1955)
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
AIR 1963 SC 677. AIR 1965 SC 1595.
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
1 SCR 267 at p. 272] ). They are both adjudicating bodies and they deal with and finally determine disputes between parties which are entrusted to their jurisdiction. The procedure followed by the courts is regularly prescribed and in discharging their functions and exercising their powers, the courts have to conform to that procedure. The procedure which the tribunals have to follow may not always be so strictly prescribed, but the approach adopted by both the courts and the tribunals is substantially the same, and there is no essential difference between the functions that they discharge. As in the case of courts, so in the case of tribunals, it is the State’s inherent judicial power which has been transferred and by virtue of the said power, it is the State’s inherent judicial function which they discharge. Judicial functions and judicial powers are one of the essential attributes of a sovereign State, and on considerations of policy, the State transfers its judicial functions and powers mainly to the courts established by the Constitution; but that does not affect the competence of the State, by appropriate measures, to transfer a part of its judicial powers and functions to tribunals by entrusting to them the task of adjudicating upon special matters and disputes between parties. It is really not possible or even expedient to attempt to describe exhaustively the features which are common to the tribunals and the courts, and features which are distinct and separate. The basic and the fundamental feature which is common to both the courts and the tribunals is that they discharge judicial functions and exercise judicial powers which inherently vest in a sovereign State.”
14. Further, this Court has in various judgments explicitly held that tribunals are mutually exclusive from administrative or legislative bodies, and although not strictly Courts, they nevertheless perform judicial functions. With the inclusion of technical members along with judicial members in composition of Tribunals, it is ensured that the adjudicatory authority is equipped with the technical knowledge required to comprehend and decide issues involving specialised subjects.
15. Such issues are not unique to our country. Globally, the issues such as need for specialization or pendency have resulted in a unanimous consensus for tribunalisation. A perusal of the prevailing legal regime governing tribunals and their interface with the government,
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
provides a useful benchmark in examining methods to retain their character. AN INTERNATIONAL PERSPECTIVE
16. The global approach to the institution of specialized Tribunals is a largely consistent one. A cursory examination brings to fore a universal inherent need to disperse disputes across different adjudicatory bodies to reduce the burden on Constitutional Courts and ensure faster resolution of specific disputes. Almost all countries in the world have incorporated laws pertaining to the working of Tribunals within their Constitutional framework in some form or the other. In light of our common law traditions and colonial history, it would be imperative to examine the position of law across the world: I. United Kingdom
17. Tribunals are one of the most important institutions in the dispensation of justice in the British Judicial system. Numerous Tribunals have been established to deal with issues involving property rights, employment, immigration, mental health, etc. Their functions are similar to the mainstream judicial bodies and are concerned with disputes between individuals and the State. However, there is a stark distinction between Tribunals and Ordinary Courts in England; for unlike ordinary Courts, the Tribunals comprise of members with special expertise and experience with many of them being appointed from amongst advocates or from persons with technical exposure. 18. Such tribunalisation traces its origins to the early twentieth century. The efficacy of a specialised, quasi-judicial body for adjudication of specific disputes was realised over a period of time as the newly evolved system of Tribunals gradually gained appreciation and recognition in the legal fraternity. During the development of the railways in the early 19th century, the judges found themselves ill-equipped to deal with technically specialised trade disputes arising from monopolistic railway companies. Such inexpert adjudication also resulted in dissatisfaction of the litigants. Consequently, a specialized tribunal of Commissioners was appointed in 1873 and later converted to the Railways and Canals Commission. Later in the nineteenth century, the British Government set up tribunals for pension and unemployment benefit to enhance accessibility to the poor and less-educated, including, special tribunals set up to adjudicate disablement pensions for
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
servicemen wounded in World War I. In the twentieth century, post the Leggatt review, many dozens of tribunals for subjects as diverse as tax, mental health, social security, employment and asylum were set up, with thousands of adjudicating members.
19. As Tribunals started marking their individual identity and resolving conflicts brought before them, there was an emergent need to amend the framework of these alternate fora in tune with societal changes. The Donoughmore Committee, in 1932, critiqued the delegation of judicial functions to quasi-judicial body and recommended that the judicial powers should vest solely with the Ordinary Courts of law. It was further recommended that establishment of Tribunals should only be in special cases where Ordinary Courts lacks expertise. Applicability of principles of natural justice must also be extended to such Tribunals. Courts should be adequately empowered to ensure that the Tribunals function within their restricted domain. 20. The need for supervisory jurisdiction over Tribunals was again discussed in 1957 when the Frank’s Committee made its recommendations which were implemented by the Tribunal and Inquiries Act, 1958. The Frank’s Committee Report presented a glowing critique in favour of tribunalisation, contending that it was cheaper, faster, better and more accessible. This finding has been echoed by various international commissions which have noted the beneficial impacts of tribunalisation viz., cost effectiveness, accessibility, reduction in pendency, specialized expertise, etc. “Tribunals are not ordinary courts, but neither are they appendages of Government Departments. Much of the official evidence … appeared to reflect the view that tribunals should properly be regarded as part of the machinery of administration, for which the Government must retain a close and continuing responsibility. Thus, for example, tribunals in the social services field would be regarded as adjuncts to the administration of the services themselves. We do not accept this view. We consider that tribunals should properly be regarded as machinery provided by Parliament for adjudication rather than as part of the machinery of administration. The essential point is that in all these cases Parliament has deliberately provided for a decision outside and independent of the Department concerned, either at first instance … or on appeal from a decision of a Minister or of an
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
official in a special statutory position… Although the relevant statutes do not in all cases expressly enact that tribunals are to consist entirely of persons outside the Government service, the use of the term ‘tribunal’ in legislation undoubtedly bears this connotation, and the intention of Parliament to provide for the independence of tribunals is clear and unmistakable.”5
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
21. Pursuant to this, the Council on Tribunals was established with the purpose of overseeing composition and working of various Tribunals. Further, the Sir Andrew Leggatt Committee (2001) scrutinised the existing state of Tribunals wherein the inherent deficiencies of a nonuniform Tribunal system were highlighted. The report of the Committee, titled ‘Tribunals for User— One System, One Service’ suggested a new structurally reformed system of Tribunals with a more uniform administration and procedure. It was also suggested that a single Appellate Division should be the only route of appeal against the orders of the Tribunals. In 2007, the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act was enacted which formulated a new system of two Tribunals -the Firsttier Tribunal and the Upper Tribunal - with unified route for appeal. 6 22. In the year 2006 the United Kingdom created a Tribunal Service, which was later merged with the Courts Service in 2010, resulting in the creation of a single cohesive judicial structure and service for the country. II. Canada
23. The Tribunal system in Canada, although of recent origin, is well established having a distinct identity of its own. Similar to the system in England, in Canada too, the Tribunal system has successfully become one of the foundations of the judicial system.7 Federal or provincial legislations are enacted to constitute and empower specialised Tribunals for specific subject matters such as human rights, insurance claims, etc.8
Drewry, Gavin, “The Judicialisation of Administrative Tribunals in the U.K: From Hewart to Leggatt” 28 TRAS 51 (2009) Excerpts from the ‘Explanatory Notes to the Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act, 2007’ prepared by the Ministry of Justice, British Parliament. Malik, Lokendra; Lata, Kusum; Kaur, Avneet, Constitutional Government in India (Satyam Law International, New Delhi, 2016) at p. 191. Administrative Tribunals in Canada, available at: http:// www.thecanadianencyclopedia.ca/en/article/administrative-tribunals/ (last visited on 10.09.2019).
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
The work of the Tribunals are regulated by legislation and Members are usually appointed for their expertise in the subject.
24. Many of the Tribunals are empowered by their enabling legislation or general legislations to have powers similar to Civil Courts. However, Tribunals in Canada are less formal than Courts and are outside the general Court system; their decisions are subject to Judicial Review to ensure adherence to law. In a striking resemblance to our judicial system, the Canadian Constitution also provides inherent power of judicial review of decisions of Tribunals to superior Courts, where either no provision of appeal is provided or is specifically barred by a statute. Appeals from orders of Tribunals in Canada are heard by Federal Court of Canada, the immediate forum below the Supreme Court of Canada.
III. Australia 25. The Australian system of Tribunals is an amalgamation of the system prevalent in England and Canada. Tribunals in Australia were established primarily to reduce the burden on Civil Courts and provide an effective, yet cheap means of justice for the public. There prevails a variety of Tribunals to review different types of Government decisions including social security, taxation, etc. The Tribunals serve a multifarious purpose, deciding issues between individuals and individuals & State. For instance, in several Australian States, the Tribunals work as Small Claims Courts. The Court of Appeals is a facet of the Supreme Court, enjoying appellate powers over all the other Courts and Tribunals in the country. IV. United States of America 26. The doctrine of separation of powers is adhered to in a much stringent manner in comparison to other common law countries. There is no delegation of judicial powers and no judicial power is vested in administrative bodies which are not Courts. The inception of judicial control over administrative action was with the enactment of Administrative Procedure Act, 1946. However, the Act merely made the decisions of Tribunals appealable on question of interpretation of law. Nevertheless, the Supreme Court of the United States had taken a more liberal view of the same leaving scope, though extremely limited, for judicial review.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
V. France 27. Being a Civil Law system, France has a dual legal system comprising of— Private Law (droit privé) and Administrative Law (droit administratif). 9 It has a special Tribunal viz. Tribunal des Conflicts for performing both judicial and administrative functions.10 The decisions of Tribunal des Conflicts are not entirely within the purview of judicial review. Judicial Review is expressly ousted from some of the administrative actions. Further, to adjudicate disputes between individual and officials of State, the Counseil d’Etat was formed. 28. With change in time, the Tribunal system of France also evolved. A new Three-Tier Tribunal system was established. The first tier being Tribunal administratif — Administrative Court or the Original Court having a wide jurisdiction covering all subject matters; the second tier is Cour administrative d’appel — Administrative Court of Appeal, formed to decide appeals from the Original Court and; the third tier is Conseil d’Etat — Court of Last Resort, which was formed to finally decide appeals from the Original Court or Court of Appeal. However, unlike in common law countries, the Appellate Courts in France lack power of judicial review on the ground of authority being ultra vires. VI. South Africa 29. South Africa having similar colonial origins as India, inherited a similar legal system as India. Having multiple functions and discharging a range of judicial, quasi-judicial as well as administrative powers, every tribunal is a unique creation of its parent statute. Akin to many critiques in India, such tribunals are often criticized for their lack of uniformity, incoherence and haphazardness. DOMESTIC PERCEPTION:
30. It is interesting to note that establishment of Tribunals in India relate back to as early as the year 1941 when the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) was established to expedite tax disputes. To structuralise the establishment of Tribunals, vide the 42nd Constitutional Amendment, Article 323A and 323B were introduced, delineating powers as well as
George A. Bermann; Etienne Picard, Introduction to French Law (Kluwer Law International, Netherlands, 2008) at p. 58. Bartlett, C. A. Hereshoff, “The French Judicial System” 33 CLT 952 (1913).
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
the composition and formation of Tribunals. Numerous Tribunals thereafter have been established, with the source of power to legislate for establishing such tribunals being referable to Article 323A or Article 323B of the Constitution. The three-tier tribunal system in India finds its resemblance to the system as prevalent in France. The forums of first instance have Original Jurisdiction with High Court as the Appellate Court and the Supreme Court being the final adjudicatory body. Furthermore, it is not out of context to point out the similarity of the Constitution of India with the Canadian Constitution, insofar as it also provides inherent power of judicial review to Constitutional Courts over all subordinate Courts.
31. Hence, the need for establishment of newer and more specialised adjudicatory bodies is not newfound but has evolved through developments spread over an era.
I. Administrative Reforms Commission - 1966 32. The Administrative Reforms Commission was set up to explore the arenas for establishing Administrative Tribunals for different subject matters. It recommended establishment of Civil Services Tribunals as adjudicatory entities for disciplinary punishments awarded to civil servants. II. Wanchoo Committee - 1970 33. The Wanchoo Committee recommended reforms to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal to effectuate replacement of Civil Courts for expeditious redressal of tax disputes. It also recommended formation of a Direct Taxes Settlement Tribunal to ensure speedy remedies and decisions of disputes.
III. High Court’s Arrears Committee Report - 1972 34. A committee headed by Justice JC Shah highlighted an urgent need for individual-specialised Tribunals for exclusively dealing with service matters and to unburden High Courts by restricting the barrage of writ petitions being filed by government employees.
IV. Swaran Singh Committee - 1976 35.The Swaran Singh Committee took a radical view by advocating amendments to the Constitution for regulation of Tribunals and to curtail the writ jurisdiction of High Court and the Supreme Court.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
This report attracted a lot of critique from the legal fraternity and was later rejected in Sakinala Hari Nath vs. State Of Andhra Pradesh11. V. Raghavan Committee - 2002
36. In accordance with contemporaneous evolutions in the commercial sphere, the Raghavan Committee was set up to suggest methods to regulate anti-competitive practices. This Committee recommended establishment of the Competition Commission of India (CCI), which was envisioned to maintain adequate competition in the market and protect consumer welfare. Further, the Competition Act, 2002 was later enacted which provided certain powers of Civil Courts to the CCI for effective enquiry and adjudication. 37. Tribunals can thus be viewed as alternate avenues to facilitate swift dispensation of justice through less-formal procedures of adjudication. An examination of existing Tribunals in India and across foreign jurisdictions, shows that they are best suited to deal with complex subject-matters requiring technical expertise such as service law, tax law, company law or environment law, etc. LEGISLATIVE DEVELOPMENT OF TRIBUNALISATION :
38. In India, the Constitution (42nd Amendment) Act, 1976 paved way for tribunalisation of the justice dispensation system by introduction of Articles 323A and 323B in the Constitution. These provisions are to the following effect: “PART XIV-A: TRIBUNALS
323-A. Administrative tribunals.—(1) Parliament may, by law, provide for the adjudication or trial by administrative tribunals of disputes and complaints with respect to recruitment and conditions of service of persons appointed to public services and posts in connection with the affairs of the Union or of any State or of any local or other authority within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India or of any corporation owned or controlled by the Government.
1993 (3) ALT 471; See also: L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India 1997 (2) SCR 1186
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
(2) A law made under clause (1) may—
(a) provide for the establishment of an administrative tribunal for the Union and a separate administrative tribunal for each State or for two or more States; (b) specify the jurisdiction, powers (including the power to punish for contempt) and authority which may be exercised by each of the said tribunals;
(c) provide for the procedure (including provisions as to limitation and rules of evidence) to be followed by the said tribunals; (d) exclude the jurisdiction of all courts, except the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court under Article 136, with respect to the disputes or complaints referred to in clause (1); (e) provide for the transfer to each such administrative tribunal of any cases pending before any court or other authority immediately before the establishment of such tribunal as would have been within the jurisdiction of such tribunal if the causes of action on which such suits or proceedings are based had arisen after such establishment;
(f) repeal or amend any order made by the President under clause (3) of Article 371-D; (g) contain such supplemental, incidental and consequential provisions (including provisions as to fees) as Parliament may deem necessary for the effective functioning of, and for the speedy disposal of cases by, and the enforcement of the orders of, such tribunals.
(3) The provisions of this article shall have effect notwithstanding anything in any other provision of this Constitution or in any other law for the time being in force.
323-B. Tribunals for other matters.—(1) The appropriate Legislature may, by law, provide for the adjudication or trial by tribunals of any disputes, complaints, or offences with respect to all or any of the matters specified in clause (2) with respect to which such Legislature has power to make laws.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
(2) The matters referred to in clause (1) are the following, namely:— (a) levy, assessment, collection and enforcement of any tax;
(b) foreign exchange, import and export across customs frontiers; (c) industrial and labour disputes;
(d) land reforms by way of acquisition by the State of any estate as defined in Article 31-A or of any rights therein or the extinguishment or modification of any such rights or by way of ceiling on agricultural land or in any other way; (e) ceiling on urban property;
(f) elections to either House of Parliament or the House or either House of the Legislature of a State, but excluding the matters referred to in Article 329 and Article 329-A; (g) production, procurement, supply and distribution of foodstuffs (including edible oilseeds and oils) and such other goods as the President may, by public notification, declare to be essential goods for the purpose of this article and control of prices of such goods; (h) rent, its regulation and control and tenancy issues including the right, title and interest of landlords and tenants;
(i) offences against laws with respect to any of the matters specified in sub-clauses (a) to (h) and fees in respect of any of those matters; (j) any matter incidental to any of the matters specified in sub-clauses (a) to (i). (3) A law made under clause (1) may— (a) provide for the establishment of a hierarchy of tribunals;
(b) specify the jurisdiction, powers (including the power to punish for contempt) and authority which may be exercised by each of the said tribunals;
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI] (c) provide for the procedure (including provisions as to limitation and rules of evidence) to be followed by the said tribunals; (d) exclude the jurisdiction of all courts except the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court under Article 136 with respect to all or any of the matters falling within the jurisdiction of the said tribunals; (e) provide for the transfer to each such tribunal of any cases pending before any court or any other authority immediately before the establishment of such tribunal as would have been within the jurisdiction of such tribunal if the causes of action on which such suits or proceedings are based had arisen after such establishment; (f) contain such supplemental, incidental and consequential provisions (including provisions as to fees) as the appropriate Legislature may deem necessary for the effective functioning of, and for the speedy disposal of cases by, and the enforcement of the orders of, such tribunals.
(4) The provisions of this article shall have effect notwithstanding anything in any other provision of this Constitution or in any other law for the time being in force. Explanation.—In this article, “appropriate Legislature”, in relation to any matter, means Parliament or, as the case may be, a State Legislature competent to make laws with respect to such matter in accordance with the provisions of Part XI.” 39. Drawing its competence from Article 323A of the Constitution, the Parliament enacted the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985. The primary objective was to provide a forum alternative to the High Courts for routine service appeals, which otherwise was overburdening the working of the Constitutional Courts. It recognised that the higher Courts were envisaged to primarily deal with important Constitutional issues and substantial question of law of general public importance.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
40. Furthermore, guidelines were issued by this Court in numerous decisions to highlight a paucity of technical expertise in certain subjectmatters and thus the imminent need for an expedited disposal of such cases through Tribunals. It was indicated in M.C. Mehta v. Union of India12, that a dedicated Tribunal with both judicial and technical experts is necessary to hear environmental disputes. 41. Consequently, the National Environment Tribunal Act, 1995 and National Environment Appellate Authority Act, 1997 were enacted. However, these were soon found to be incapable of providing expeditious resolution of disputes which necessitated reforms as suggested by the Law Commission of India. This led to the establishment of the National Green Tribunal (NGT) in 2010 as a special fast-track Court only to deal with issues related to the environment. 42. Similarly, Article 323B empowers the appropriate Legislature to enact legislation to provide for adjudication or trial by Tribunals of any disputes, complaints or offences with respect to the matters specified in Clause (2) of the said Article. The matters specified in Article 323B(2) exhaustively deal with a variety of matters which can be brought within the purview of tribunalisation by both the Parliament and State Legislatures. JUDICIAL DEVELOPMENT OF TRIBUNALISATION : 43. This Court has observed through numerous decisions that the term ‘Tribunal’ refers to a quasi-judicial authority. A test to determine whether a particular body was merely an administrative organ of the Executive or a Tribunal was evolved by this Court in Jaswant Sugar Mills Ltd., Meerut vs. Lakshmichand 13. It was to be examined whether the body is vested with powers of a Civil Court or not, and it was held that any adjudicatory body vested with powers of taking evidence, summoning of witnesses, etc. must be categorised as a Tribunal. 44. In R.K. Jain vs. Union of India14 a three-judge Bench of this Court emphasised the need for a safe and sound justice delivery system adept at satisfying the confidence of litigants. It was further noted that since members of Tribunals discharge quasi-judicial functions,
1986 (2) SCC 176 AIR 1963 SC 677. (1993) 4 SCC 119.
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
it is imperative that they possess requisite legal expertise, some judicial experience and an iota of legal training. Moreover, since Tribunals are constituted as substitutes to Courts, their efficacy in upholding the faith of litigants cannot be compromised. It was however observed that true delivery of justice by Tribunals was still a far-fetched idea since the mechanism for judicial review and remedy of appeal to the Supreme Court was costly and discouraging. People from remote areas often found their right to appeal being handicapped by geographical and financial constraints. Hence, it was suggested by this Court that newer fora be dispersed across the country and that members from the Bar also be included in the composition of such Tribunals. An urgent need to reform the working of tribunals and regular monitoring of their functioning was also stressed upon.
45. Subsequently, in L. Chandra Kumar v. Union of India15, a Constitution Bench of seven judges of this Court examined reports of expert committees and commissions analysing the problem of arrears. The Malimath Committee Report (1989-1990) was also referred to, wherein it was found that many Tribunals failed the test of public confidence due to purported lack of competence, objectivity and judicial approach. This Court thus called for drastic measures to elevate the standards of Tribunals in the country. 46. It was also reiterated that the exclusion of judicial review by High Courts was impermissible and providing direct statutory appeals to the Supreme Court impeded the common litigant from exercising his right to appeal because the appellate forum, being situated in Delhi, was inaccessible to many. While criticising the short terms of members and the lack of judicial experience of non-judicial members, this Court observed a need for establishment of an oversight mechanism to review the competence of all persons manning Tribunals. Thus, it was suggested that all Tribunals be brought under a ‘Single Nodal Ministry’, most appropriately the Ministry of Law & Justice, for overseeing of working of Tribunals. Liberty was however, granted to the Ministry to appoint an independent supervisory body to delegate the aforesaid functions. Further, the court noted that the procedure of selection of members of Tribunals, allocation of funds and all other intricacies would have to be culled out by such an umbrella organisation.
(1997) 3 SCC 261.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
47. In Union of India vs. R. Gandhi, President, Madras Bar Association16, a Constitution Bench of five judges of this Court reviewed the Constitutional validity of Parts I-B and I-C of The Companies Act, 1956 inserted by the Companies (2nd Amendment) Act, 2002. 48. The bench observed that if Tribunals are established in substitution of Courts, they must also possess independence, security and capacity. Additionally, with transfer of jurisdiction from a traditional Court to a Tribunal, it would be imperative to include members of the judiciary as presiding officers/members of the Tribunal. Technical members could only be in addition to judicial members and that also only when specialised knowledge or know-how is required. Any inclusion of technical members in the absence of any discernible requirement of specialisation would amount to dilution and encroachment upon the independence of the judiciary. 49. This Court also observed that higher administrative experience does not necessarily result in better adjudication and that there had been a gradual encroachment on the independence of the judiciary through inclusion of more administrative/technical members in the Tribunals. It held that such practice needed to be checked and accordingly made requisite corrections to Parts I-B and I-C of The Companies Act, 1956 (as amended in 2002) as elucidated in para 120 of the judgement, which is reproduced below: “120. We may tabulate the corrections required to set right the defects in Parts I-B and I-C of the Act: (i) Only Judges and advocates can be considered for appointment as judicial members of the Tribunal. Only High Court Judges, or Judges who have served in the rank of a District Judge for at least five years or a person who has practised as a lawyer for ten years can be considered for appointment as a judicial member. Persons who have held a Group A or equivalent post under the Central or State Government with experience in the Indian Company Law Service (Legal Branch) and the Indian Legal Service (Grade I) cannot be considered for appointment as judicial members as provided in subsections (2)(c) and (d) of Section 10-FD. The expertise
(2010) 11 SCC 1
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI] in Company Law Service or the Indian Legal Service will at best enable them to be considered for appointment as technical members. (ii) As NCLT takes over the functions of the High Court, the members should as nearly as possible have the same position and status as High Court Judges. This can be achieved, not by giving the salary and perks of a High Court Judge to the members, but by ensuring that persons who are as nearly equal in rank, experience or competence to High Court Judges are appointed as members. Therefore, only officers who are holding the ranks of Secretaries or Additional Secretaries alone can be considered for appointment as technical members of the National Company Law Tribunal. Clauses (c) and (d) of sub-section (2) and clauses (a) and (b) of subsection (3) of Section 10-FD which provide for persons with 15 years experience in Group A post or persons holding the post of Joint Secretary or equivalent post in the Central or the State Government, being qualified for appointment as Members of Tribunal, are invalid (iii) A “technical member” presupposes an experience in the field to which the Tribunal relates. A member of the Indian Company Law Service who has worked with Accounts Branch or officers in other departments who might have incidentally dealt with some aspect of company law cannot be considered as “experts” qualified to be appointed as technical members. Therefore clauses (a) and (b) of sub-section (3) are not valid. (iv) The first part of clause (f) of sub-section (3) providing that any person having special knowledge or professional experience of 20 years in science, technology, economics, banking, industry could be considered to be persons with expertise in company law, for being appointed as technical members in the Company Law Tribunal, is invalid. (v) Persons having ability, integrity, standing and special knowledge and professional experience of not less than
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
fifteen years in industrial finance, industrial management, industrial reconstruction, investment and accountancy, may however be considered as persons having expertise in rehabilitation/revival of companies and therefore, eligible for being considered for appointment as technical members. (vi) In regard to category of persons referred in clause (g) of sub-section (3) at least five years’ experience should be specified.
(vii) Only clauses (c), (d), (e), (g), (h), and the latter part of clause (f) in sub-section (3) of Section 10-FD and officers of civil services of the rank of the Secretary or Additional Secretary in the Indian Company Law Service and the Indian Legal Service can be considered for purposes of appointment as technical members of the Tribunal. (viii) Instead of a five-member Selection Committee with the Chief Justice of India (or his nominee) as Chairperson and two Secretaries from the Ministry of Finance and Company Affairs and the Secretary in the Ministry of Labour and the Secretary in the Ministry of Law and Justice as members mentioned in Section 10-FX, the Selection Committee should broadly be on the following lines: a. Chief Justice of India or his nominee—Chairperson (with a casting vote);
b. A Senior Judge of the Supreme Court or Chief Justice of High Court—Member; c. Secretary in the Ministry of Finance and Company Affairs—Member; and
d. Secretary in the Ministry of Law and Justice— Member. (ix) The term of office of three years shall be changed to a term of seven or five years subject to eligibility for appointment for one more term. This is because considerable time is required to achieve expertise in the
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
field concerned. A term of three years is very short and by the time the members achieve the required knowledge, expertise and efficiency, one term will be over. Further the said term of three years with the retirement age of 65 years is perceived as having been tailor-made for persons who have retired or shortly to retire and encourages these Tribunals to be treated as post-retirement havens. If these Tribunals are to function effectively and efficiently they should be able to attract younger members who will have a reasonable period of service.
(x) The second proviso to Section 10-FE enabling the President and members to retain lien with their parent cadre/ministry/department while holding office as President or Members will not be conducive for the independence of members. Any person appointed as member should be prepared to totally disassociate himself from the executive. The lien cannot therefore exceed a period of one year.
(xi) To maintain independence and security in service, subsection (3) of Section 10-FJ and Section 10-FV should provide that suspension of the President/Chairman or member of a Tribunal can be only with the concurrence of the Chief Justice of India.
(xii) The administrative support for all Tribunals should be from the Ministry of Law and Justice. Neither the Tribunals nor their members shall seek or be provided with facilities from the respective sponsoring or parent Ministries or Department concerned.
(xiii) Two-member Benches of the Tribunal should always have a judicial member. Whenever any larger or special Benches are constituted, the number of technical members shall not exceed the judicial members.”
50. Later, in Madras Bar Association vs. Union of India (2014)17, whilst striking down the newly-created National Tax Tribunal under the National Tax Tribunals Act, 2005, it was observed that
(2014) 10 SCC 1.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
procedure of appointment and conditions of service of members must be akin to judges of the Courts which were sought to be substituted by the Tribunal(s). 51. Only persons with professional legal qualifications coupled with substantial experience in law were held to be competent to handle complex legal issues. It was further held that a litigating party (Govt.) should never be a participant in the appointment process of members of the Tribunal. Similarly, a provision for reappointment or extension of tenure is ipso facto prejudicial to the independence of the members of Tribunal. A difference was also drawn between appointments to Tribunals which substituted Courts of first instance and to those which were not subordinate to High Courts. 52. It was further reiterated that establishment of a Tribunal with its seat at Delhi could cause hardship to litigants from other parts of the country, depriving them of convenient access to justice. Moreover, the Court held that in order to uphold their independence and fairness it would be inappropriate for the Central Government to have any administrative control over members of the Tribunal. 53. In Madras Bar Association vs. Union of India (2015) 18, vires of the Companies Act, 2013 which contemplated establishment of National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) and National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) were challenged. Interestingly, while examining Chapter XXVII of Companies Act, 2013 i.e. Sections 407 to 434, this Court held that although the establishment of NCLT and NCLAT was not unconstitutional but there was a need for curing defects in accordance with the dictum of R. Gandhi (supra). 54. Finally, in Gujarat Urja Vikas Ltd. vs. Essar Power Ltd.19, while examining the composition and working of Tribunals and statutory framework thereof, this Court reiterated its earlier decisions in L. Chandra Kumar (supra) and Madras Bar Association (2014) (supra), observing that remedy of appeal to this Court was in effect, being obliterated due to cost and inaccessibility. In addition to this, a flood of appeals from all the Tribunals directly to this Court hindered its efficiency in fulfilling its primary Constitutional role. Since appellate tribunals, manned by non-judicial members, were adjudging complex
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
(2015) 8 SCC 583. (2016) 9 SCC 103.
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
questions of law, the composition of Tribunals was put under review by this Court and a reference to the Law Commission of India was made in this regard. Pursuant to this, the Law Commission of India, in its 272 nd Report titled ‘Assessment of Statutory Frameworks of Tribunals in India’ gave a detailed analysis of statutory framework with respect to Tribunalisation in India.
THE FINANCE ACT, 2017: ITS LEGISLATIVE BACKGROUND 55. Primary challenge in the present batch of cases is to the Finance Act, 2017. Though this enactment was purportedly to give effect to “the finance proposals of the central government for the financial year 2017-18” but Part XIV thereof consists of comprehensive provisions meant to effect “Amendments to Central Acts to Provide for Merger of Tribunals and other Authorities and Conditions of Service of Chairpersons, Members, etc”. 56. A scrutiny of Part XIV of the Finance Act, 2017 discloses how by virtue of Sections 158 to 182, Parliament has amended twentyfive central enactments which form the foundation for multiple Tribunals. It has been submitted by the learned Attorney General, these amendments seek to rationalise the functioning of Tribunals, in conformity with the principles laid down by this Court in its prior decisions. 57. Sections 158 to 182 of Part-XIV are broadly in pari materia except that each Section deals with a separate Tribunal. In order to comprehend the manner in which Parliament has sought to achieve a uniform pattern of qualifications, appointment, term of office, salaries and allowances, resignation, removal and other terms and conditions of service of members and presiding officers of various Tribunals, it would be sufficient to illustratively reproduce Sections 158 and 173 of Part XIV of the Finance Act, 2017. Section 173 reads as follows: “I.—AMENDMENT TO THE CINEMATOGRAPH ACT, 1952
173. In the Cinematograph Act, 1952, after section 5D, the following section shall be inserted, namely:— “5E. Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, the qualifications, appointment, term of office, salaries and allowances, resignation, removal and the other terms and conditions of service
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
of the Chairman and other members of the Appellate Tribunal appointed after the commencement of Part XIV of Chapter VI of the Finance Act, 2017, shall be governed by the provisions of section 184 of that Act: Provided that the Chairman and member appointed before the commencement of Part XIV of Chapter VI of the Finance Act, 2017, shall continue to be governed by the provisions of this Act and the rules made thereunder as if the provisions of section 184 of the Finance Act, 2017 had not come into force.”. 58. In addition to this, some Sections in Part XIV also amalgamate existing Tribunals. Section 158 has been reproduced below as an example of such Sections which in addition to the elements of Section 173 also effect amalgamations: “158. Amendment of Act 14 of 1947.— In the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947,—
(a) in Section 7A, after sub-section (1), the following sub-section shall be inserted, namely:— “(1A) The Industrial Tribunal constituted by the Central Government under sub-section (1) shall also exercise, on and from the commencement of Part XIV of Chapter VI of the Finance Act, 2017, the jurisdiction, powers and authority conferred on the Tribunal referred to in Section 7D of the Employees’ Provident Funds and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 (19 of 1952).”; (b) after Section 7C, the following section shall be inserted, namely:— “7D. Qualifications, terms and conditions of service of Presiding Officer.— Notwithstanding anything contained in this Act, the qualifications, appointment, term of office, salaries and allowances, resignation and removal and other terms and conditions of service of the Presiding Officer of the Industrial Tribunal appointed by the Central Government under sub-section (1) of Section 7A, shall, after the commencement of Part XIV of Chapter VI of the Finance Act, 2017, be governed by the provisions of Section 184 of that Act:
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
Provided that the Presiding Officer appointed before the commencement of Part XIV of Chapter VI of the Finance Act, 2017, shall continue to be governed by the provisions of this Act, and the rules made thereunder as if the provisions of Section 184 of the Finance Act, 2017 had not come into force.”
59. There are two significant expressions worth noticing in these similarly worded Sections 158 to 182. First, every such Section opens up with a non-obstante clause and it provides that “notwithstanding anything contained in …… Act the qualifications, appointment, term of office, salaries and allowances, resignation, removal and the other terms and conditions of service of the Chairman and other members of the Appellate Tribunal appointed after the commencement of Part XIV of Chapter VI of the Finance Act, 2017, shall be governed by the provisions of section 184 of that Act”. Second, Section 184 of the Finance Act overrides all other provisions in both the Finance Act, 2017 as well as the other twenty-five enactments which stand amended.
60. To critical analyse the intention of the legislature in enacting Section 184, reference must be made to the immediately preceding Section 183 which is to be found in sub-part ‘S’ of the Act titled “Conditions of service of Chairpersons and members of Tribunals, Appellate Tribunals and other Authorities”. Since Sections 183 and 184 would need to be read conjointly, both are reproduced below:
“S.—CONDITIONS OF SERVICE OF CHAIRPERSON AND MEMBERS OF TRIBUNALS, APPELLATE TRIBUNALS AND OTHER AUTHORITIES 183. Application of Section 184.— Notwithstanding anything to the contrary contained in the provisions of the Acts specified in column (3) of the Eighth Schedule, on and from the appointed day, provisions of Section 184 shall apply to the Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson, Chairman, Vice-Chairman, President, VicePresident, Presiding Officer or Member of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, other Authorities as specified in column (2) of the said Schedule: Provided that the provisions of Section 184 shall not apply to the Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson, Chairman, Vice-Chairman, President, Vice-President, Presiding Officer or, as the case may
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
be, Member holding such office as such immediately before the appointed day. 184. Qualifications, appointment, term and conditions of service, salary and allowances, etc., of Chairperson, ViceChairperson and Members, etc., of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal and other Authorities.— (1) The Central Government may, by notification, make rules to provide for qualifications, appointment, term of office, salaries and allowances, resignation, removal and the other terms and conditions of service of the Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson, Chairman, Vice-Chairman, President, Vice-President, Presiding Officer or Member of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, other Authorities as specified in column (2) of the Eighth Schedule: Provided that the Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson, Chairman, ViceChairman, President, Vice-President, Presiding Officer or Member of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or other Authority shall hold office for such term as specified in the rules made by the Central Government but not exceeding five years from the date on which he enters upon his office and shall be eligible for reappointment: Provided further that no Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson, Chairman, Vice-Chairman, President, Vice-President, Presiding Officer or Member shall hold office as such after he has attained such age as specified in the rules made by the Central Government which shall not exceed,— (a) in the case of Chairperson, Chairman [President or the Presiding Officer of the Securities Appellate Tribunal], the age of seventy years; (b) in the case of Vice-Chairperson, Vice-Chairman, VicePresident, Presiding Officer [of the Industrial Tribunal constituted by the Central Government and the Debts Recovery Tribunal] or any other Member, the age of sixty-seven years: (2) Neither the salary and allowances nor the other terms and conditions of service of Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson, Chairman, Vice-Chairman, President, Vice-President, Presiding Officer or Member of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
case may be, other Authority may be varied to his disadvantage after his appointment.”
61. Further, the Central Government in purported exercise of its powers under the aforementioned provisions, has notified the ‘Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal and other Authorities (Qualifications, Experience and other Conditions of Service of Members) Rules, 2017’ [in short “the Rules”].
PETITIONERS’ CASE : 62. The pleadings and arguments in most of the individual cases are similar and overlapping. Hence, for the sake of brevity, it is not necessary to refer to the submissions of each of the counsel individually. Broadly, however, petitioners have questioned the validity of Part XIV read with the 8th and 9th Schedules of the Finance Act 2017, as being ex-facie unconstitutional, arbitrary, in colourable exercise of legislative power, and offensive to the basic structure of the Constitution. 63. The foremost contention on behalf of the petitioners is that Part-XIV could not and ought not to have been made part of the Finance Act, 2017 as the said part is not classifiable as a ‘money bill’. Emphasis was placed on the wordings of Article 110 which allows those bills which contain “only” provisions which fall within the metes and bounds of Clauses (a) to (g) thereof, to be treated as ‘money bill’. By virtue of inclusion of Part XIV, the entirety of the Finance Act, 2017 was contended to have lost its colour as a ‘money bill’ under Article 110 and hence its passage without the assent of the Rajya Sabha as required under Article 107 renders it ultra vires the legislative scheme contemplated in the Constitution. 64. Learned counsels vehemently placed reliance on the Constituent Assembly Debates to lend strength to the importance of the expression “only” under Article 110(1). They seek to make out a case that such phraseology was deliberately incorporated in the Constitution by making a conscious departure from Section 37 of the Government of India Act, 1935. Inclusion of Part XIV in the Finance Act, 2017 is shown as being an act of camouflage and a colourable exercise and petitioners assert that such indirect manner of bypassing of the Rajya Sabha is impermissible. A larger narrative was presented before this Court, that is, of the Central Government undermining the character and essence of a bicameral legislature as envisaged under
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
the Constitution; and interference of this Court was sought through examination of the substance of the legislation and not mere acceptance of the nomenclature accorded by the Lok Sabha Speaker under Article 110(3). 65. A nuanced argument was also furthered by petitioners’ counsels who highlighted that Tribunals are governed by Article 323-A and 323-B of the Constitution and laws enacted in this regard cannot be classified as money bills. Further, Parliament in making changes to Tribunals can trace its competence to Entry 11-A of List III of the Constitution which deals with administration of justice, and not financial matters. 66. Part XIV was also impugned for its effect of terminating the services of presiding officers and members of various now-defunct Tribunals, which was claimed as being a direct interference in the independence of the judiciary.
67. Section 184(1) of the Finance Act, 2017, in so far as it empowers the Central Government to make rules to provide for qualifications and procedure of appointment, conditions of service, terms and salaries was contended to suffer from the vice of excessive delegation. It was stated that the said provision takes away all judicial safeguards and makes the Tribunals amenable to the whims and fancies of the largest litigant, the State. This was contended as being against the grain of the Constitution, besides affecting administration of justice. In the alternative, counsels also contended that the present formulation of Rules under Section 184 was ultra vires the parent enactment and the binding dictum expressed by this Court in a catena of judgments. 68. Further, during the course of arguments, various other deficiencies and contradictions in the administration of Tribunals and certain anomalous situations like providing direct appeals to this Court were highlighted, which were contended as being against the spirit of the Constitution. Petitioners, in addition to challenging the vires of the Finance Act, 2017 also prayed for a mandamus directing the State to mandatorily conduct ‘Judicial Impact Assessment’ of legislations. UNION OF INDIA’S CASE :
69. Learned Attorney General, on the other hand, passionately drew attention to the existence of over 40 tribunals, statutory commissions, and authorities functioning under the Government of India,
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
each of which has been established under a different enactment and is governed by different set of rules. As a result, the conditions of service, modes of appointment, tenures etc. of members and presiding officers in different Tribunals were shown as vastly varying from one to another, giving rise to several anomalies and distortions. He put forth multiple examples; like how while members of some of the Commissions/ Tribunals enjoy the status of Supreme Court judges, others like the members of the Debt Recovery Tribunal have only been kept at par with District Court judges. Similarly, while a person once appointed to the ITAT can continue till the age of superannuation, tenures of persons appointed to the APTEL was merely three years. The Attorney General attributed such inconsistencies as drafting errors and further stressed the need to streamline and harmonise the applicable rules, which is what was attempted through the Finance Act, 2017.
70. He also highlighted the inherent contradiction in according status and rank equivalent to that of Constitutional Court judges to members and presiding officers of such Tribunals and regulatory bodies. It was argued that the two have different functions and roles in our Constitutional setup. While the Supreme Court had a strength of 31 judges (when the matter was argued), he pointed out, that there are more than 50 functionaries enjoying the conditions of service of a Supreme Court judge and more than 150 such functionaries who have been brought at par with High Court judges. After placing on record multiple problems arising in the administration of justice as a result of such practice, he advocated the need to keep ‘rank’ and ‘status’ separate from ‘salary’ and ‘allowances’. 71. Learned Attorney General further relied upon an order passed by this Court in Rajiv Garg vs. Union of India (WP No. 120 of 2017) on 08th February, 2013 directing that a decision be taken by the Central Government on uniformity of service conditions in various tribunals. Reliance was also placed on the 13th Report of the 2nd Administrative Reforms Commission submitted in April 2009 which recommended greater uniformity in service conditions in various tribunals. It was pointed out that, in fact, the Tribunals, Appellate Tribunals and other Authorities (Conditions of Service) Bill, 2014 was introduced in the Rajya Sabha on 14 th February, 2014 but somehow could not be passed. Introducing separate amendments for each of these Tribunals would have been unwieldy and impractical, besides resulting in several inconsistencies. Resultantly, he submits a holistic view was taken and
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
a single enactment was sought to be introduced in order to harmoniously bring uniformity. 72. On behalf of the Union, the petitioners’ contentions were elaborately refuted. It was submitted that it is a settled principle of Constitutional interpretation that terms of the Constitution, including Clauses (a) to (g) of Article 110(1), must be interpreted in their widest amplitude, with the result that when the principal enactment had the dominant character of a ‘money bill’, all matters incidental thereto and inserted therein would also draw the colour and characteristic of a ‘money bill’. 73. In the alternative, he took aid of Clause (3) of Article 110 to contend that the Speaker of the Lok Sabha was the final and only Constitutional authority to adjudge the nature of a bill sought to be introduced under Article 109. Such decision was both final and hence not subject to any judicial review by any Court; even otherwise such exercise of passing legislations and certifications by the Speaker were “proceedings in Parliament” and could hence “not be called in question” before this Court in view of Article 122(1). 74. Both sides have extensively relied upon case law and Constitutional history to substantiate their respective pleas. Relevant portions of the same are being referred to in the latter parts of this judgment whenever necessary. BRIEF REFERENCE TO INTERLOCUTORY ORDERS:
75. After considering the suggestions filed during the course of hearing in SLP(C) No. 15804/2017, this Court passed an interim order on 9 February 2018, suggesting: “1. Staying the composition of Search-cum-Selection Committee as prescribed in Column 4 of the Schedule to the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal and Other Authorities (Qualification, experience and other conditions of service of members) Rules, 2017 both in respect of Chairman/ Judicial Members and Administrative Members. A further direction to constitute an interim Search-cumSelection Committee during the pendency of this W.P. in respect of both Judicial/Administrative members as under :
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI] a. Chief Justice of India or his nominee - Chairman
b. Chairman of the Central Administrative Tribunal Member c. Two Secretaries nominated by the Government of India - Members
2. Appointment to the post of Chairman shall be made by nomination by the Chief Justice of India. 3. Stay the terms of office of 3 years as prescribed in Column 5 of the Schedule to the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal and other Authorities (Qualification, experience and other conditions of service of members) Rules, 2017. A further direction fixing the term of office of all selectees by the aforementioned interim Search-cumSelection Committee and consequent appointees as 5 years.
4. All appointments to be made in pursuance to the selection made by the interim Search-cum-Selection Committee shall be with conditions of service as applicable to the Judges of High Court. 5. A further direction to the effect that all the selections made by the aforementioned interim selection committee and the consequential appointment of all the selectees as Chairman/Judicial/Administrative members for a term of 5 years with conditions of service as applicable to Judges of High Court shall not be affected by the final outcome of the Writ Petition.”
76. The learned Attorney General agreed with all except the fourth and fifth suggestions reproduced above, and suggested certain modifications as follows: “4. All appointments to be made in pursuance to the selection made by the interim Search-cum-Selection Committee shall abide by the conditions of service as per the old Acts and the Rules. 5. A further direction to the effect that all the selections made by the aforementioned interim selection committee
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
and the consequential appointment of all the selectees as Chairman/Judicial/Administrative members shall be for a period as has been provided in the old Acts and the Rules.” 77. This Court agreed to the learned Attorney General’s suggestions and accordingly made the following operative directions: “In view of the aforesaid, we accept the suggestions and direct that the same shall be made applicable for selection of the Chairpersons and the Judicial/Administrative/ Technical/Expert Members for all tribunals.”
78. Since many of the Search-cum-Selection Committees had initiated selection processes and had completed a substantial portion of the exercise prior to the above order dated 9th February, 2018, this Court, on 12th February, 2018 passed the following order: “As some Committees had proceeded, the matter was listed for further hearing. We have heard learned counsel for the parties. Mr. Rohit Bhat, learned counsel assisting the learned Attorney General for the Union of India shall file the status of the selection process by the Committees, by 13.2.2018. Mr. Arvind Datar, Mr. C.A. Sundaram and Mr. Mohan Parasaran, learned senior counsel shall also file through their Advocates-onRecord a joint memorandum with regard to which tribunals are covered and not covered. The same shall be filed by 10.30 a.m. on 13.2.2018. Orders reserved.”
79. Further, vide order dated 20th March 2018, this Court clarified its previous order of 9th February 2018 and directed: “(iii) The tenure of the Chairperson and the Judicial/ Administrative/Expert/Technical Members of all the Tribunals shall be for a period of five years or the maximum age that was fixed/determined under the old Acts and Rules;” 80. The following directions were also issued on 16th July, 2018 with regard to the age of superannuation of Members of the ITAT:
“At this juncture, we may note that there is some confusion with regard to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) as regards
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
the age of superannuation. We make it clear that the person selected as Member of the ITAT will continue till the age of 62 years and the person holding the post of President, shall continue till the age of 65 years.”
81. Corollary to the order dated 16th July 2018, six officers who had been selected as Member (Judicial) in CESTAT, also demanded the age of superannuation as noted in the case of Members of ITAT, to be applicable to them. Following the same dictum, vide order dated 21st August 2018, clarification regarding the age of superannuation for Members of CESTAT, Armed Forces Tribunal and Central Administrative Tribunal was made. The relevant portion of that order reads as follows:
“CESTAT: 2. In IA 113281 of 2018, the applicant is an Additional District and Sessions Judge in the State of West Bengal, who has been selected as Member (Judicial) in the CESTAT. The notification of appointment of six officers who have been selected as Member (Judicial), including the applicant, stipulates that they shall hold office for a period of five years or till attaining the age of 62 years, whichever is earlier “in terms of the Hon’ble Supreme Court’s order dated 20 March 2018". A member of the judicial service would have ordinarily continued until the date of superannuation in the state judicial service, subject to the service rules. It would be manifestly inappropriate to adopt an interpretation as a result of which, upon assuming office as Member (Judicial) in CESTAT the officer will have a tenure which will expire after five years, if it falls prior to attaining the age of 62 years. We, accordingly, are of the view that the clarification issued for the ITAT in the order dated 20 March 2018 needs to be reiterated in the case of the members of the CESTAT, which we do. We clarify that a person selected as Member of the CESTAT will continue until the age of 62 years while a person holding the post of President shall continue until the age of 65 years.
AFT: 3. Members of the Armed Forces Tribunal shall hold office until the attainment of the age of 65 years. Chairpersons who have
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
been former Judges of the Supreme Court shall hold office until the attainment of the age of 70 years. CAT: 4. In the case of the Central Administrative Tribunal, we clarify that the old rules/provisions shall continue to apply.”
CONCEPT NOTE OF LEARNED AMICUS CURIAE : 82. On the request of this Court, learned Senior Advocate Arvind Datar has provided invaluable assistance as the Amicus Curiae. In his detailed Concept Note, he has stressed the need for setting up an independent oversight body in light of the observations in L. Chandra Kumar (supra), and as reiterated in Madras Bar Association v. Union of India (2015) (supra) to the effect that Tribunals or their members should not be required to seek facilities from the sponsoring or parent ministries or concerned departments. 83. The Concept Note also emphasised the need to implement the ‘74th Report of the Parliamentary Standing Committee’ which recommended the creation of a `National Tribunal Commission’ (NTC) to oversee all the Tribunals in the country. Mr. Datar further suggests that such National Tribunal Commission may consist of the following: Two retired Supreme Court Judges (with the senior-most amongst them to be Chairman). Two retired High Court Judges (Members). Three members representing the Executive.
84. It is further suggested in the concept note that such members be appointed by the following Selection Committee : Chief Justice of India (as Chairperson of the Committee who exercises a casting vote); Two senior-most judges of the Supreme Court after the Chief Justice of India;
Current Law Minister; and Leader of the opposition. 85. The Concept Note also contains the following suggestions:
The NTC should oversee functioning of central Tribunals and similar body may be constituted for State Tribunals.
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI] The NTC should deal with appointment and removal of members of the Tribunals by constituting sub-committees. The member of the Tribunals should be recruited by national competition. Once recruited they should continue till the age of 62/65 years subject to their efficiency and satisfactory working.
The Tribunals should not be haven for retired persons and appointment process should not result in decisions being influenced if the Government itself is a litigant and the appointing authority at the same time. There should be restriction on acceptance of any employment after retirement. Bypassing of High Court jurisdiction under Article 226/ 227 need to be remedied by statutory amendment excluding direct appeals to this Court. There should be proper mechanism for removal of members. 86. The aforementioned Concept Note of Learned Amicus Curiae was considered by this Court on 07.05.2018, resulting in the following observations:“We broadly approve the concept of having an effective and autonomous oversight body for all the Tribunals with such exceptions as may be inevitable. Such body should be responsible for recruitments and oversight of functioning of members of the Tribunals. Regular cadre for Tribunals may be necessary. Learned amicus suggests setting up of all India Tribunal service on the pattern of U.K. The members can be drawn either from the serving officers in Higher Judicial Service or directly recruited with appropriate qualifications by national competition. Their performance and functioning must be reviewed by an independent body in the same was as superintendence by the High Court under Article 235 of the Constitution. Direct appeals must be checked. Members of the Tribunals should not only be eligible for appointment to the High Courts but a mechanism should be considered whereby due consideration is given to them on the same pattern on which it is given to the members of Higher
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
Judicial Service. This may help the High Courts to have requisite talent to deal with issues which arise from decisions of Tribunals. A regular cadre for the Tribunals can be on the pattern of cadres for the judiciary. The objective of setting up of Tribunals to have speedy and inexpensive justice will not in any manner be hampered in doing so. Wherever there is only one seat of the Tribunal, its Benches should be available either in all states or at least in all regions wherever there is litigation instead of only one place.” 87. On 07.05.2018 itself, the following additional issues were also suggested for consideration: “(i) Creation of a regular cadres laying down eligibility for recruitment for Tribunals;
(ii) Setting up of an autonomous oversight body for recruitment and overseeing the performance and discipline of the members so recruited and other issues relating thereto; (iii) Amending the scheme of direct appeals to this Court so that the orders of Tribunals are subject to jurisdiction of the High Courts;
(iv) Making Benches of Tribunals accessible to common man at convenient locations instead of having only one location at Delhi or elsewhere. In the alternative, conferring jurisdiction on existing courts as special Courts or Tribunals.” 88. Thereafter, this Court opined the following recourse :“20. The above issues may require urgent setting up of a committee, preferably of three members, one of whom must be retired judge of this Court who may be served in a Tribunal. Such Committee can have inter action with all stakeholders and suggest a mechanism consistent with the constitutional scheme as interpreted by this Court in several decisions referred to above and also in the light of recommendations of expert bodies. This exercise must be undertaken in a time bound manner.” 89. This was followed by yet another order of 16th May, 2018 recommending constitution of a Committee within two months and
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
expecting the Committee to give its report within three months thereafter.
FORMULATION OF ISSUES: 90. The core issues canvassed at the Bar concern the constitutionality of the Finance Act, 2017, particularly whether it satisfies the test of a ‘money bill’ under Article 110 of the Constitution? Further, in the eventuality that it is held that the impugned legislation has been validly enacted, then does it through Section 184 excessively delegate legislative power to the Executive? Finally, whether the Rules thus framed as delegated legislation are ultra vires their parent enactments and are liable to be struck down? 91. In addition, learned Counsel for the parties have drawn attention to the need to rationalise the administration of Tribunals, especially the conditions of service, mode of appointment, security of tenure and requisite qualifications of members and presiding officers of various Tribunals. They have also highlighted the growing menace of pendency before this Court arising from direct statutory appeals from orders of such Tribunals. 92. In light of these arguments put forth by learned Counsels and the suggestions of by the Amicus Curiae, the following issues arise for our consideration: I. Whether the ‘Finance Act, 2017’ insofar as it amends certain other enactments and alters conditions of service of persons manning different Tribunals can be termed as a ‘money bill’ under Article 110 and consequently is validly enacted?
II. If the answer to the above is in the affirmative then Whether Section 184 of the Finance Act, 2017 is unconstitutional on account of Excessive Delegation? III. If Section 184 is valid, Whether Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal and other Authorities (Qualifications, Experience and other Conditions of Service of Members) Rules, 2017 are in consonance with the Principal Act and various decisions of this Court on functioning of Tribunals?
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
IV. Whether there should be a Single Nodal Agency for administration of all Tribunals?
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
V. Whether there is a need for conducting a Judicial Impact Assessment of all Tribunals in India?
VI. Whether judges of Tribunals set up by Acts of Parliament under Articles 323-A and 323-B of the Constitution can be equated in ‘rank’ and ‘status’ with Constitutional functionaries? VII. Whether direct statutory appeals from Tribunals to the Supreme Court ought to be detoured?
VIII. Whether there is a need for amalgamation of existing Tribunals and setting up of benches. ISSUE I: WHETHER THE ‘FINANCE ACT, 2017’ INSOFAR AS IT AMENDS CERTAIN OTHER ENACTMENTS AND ALTERS CONDITIONS OF SERVICE OF PERSONS MANNING DIFFERENT TRIBUNALS CAN BE TERMED AS A ‘MONEY BILL’ UNDER ARTICLE 110 AND CONSEQUENTLY IS VALIDLY ENACTED? 93. The Indian Parliament is a bicameral legislature. In order to become law, as per the general legislative scheme as provided under Article 107, an ordinary bill must be passed by a simple majority of both the Rajya Sabha and the Lok Sabha and must then receive Presidential ratification. Ordinary bills can be introduced either by the government or by any private member in either house of Parliament. After securing requisite majority in the House it is introduced in, ordinary bills are then sent to the other House for its assent. The Constitution, however, makes two exemptions to this general legislative procedure for formulation of laws. 94. Article 368 provides for the Constituent power of the Parliament to amend the Constitution itself and concomitantly requires a higher threshold of majority in both houses of Parliament, and in certain cases also require the assent of a simple majority of the State legislatures. Article 110, in stark contrast, reverses the threshold and significantly reduces the role of the Rajya Sabha for ‘money bills’. Articles 109 and 110 provide that: “109. (1) A Money Bill shall not be introduced in the Council of States.
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI] (2) After a Money Bill has been passed by the House of the People it shall be transmitted to the Council of States for its recommendations and the Council of States shall within a period of fourteen days from the date of its receipt of the Bill return the Bill to the House of the People with its recommendations and the House of the People may thereupon either accept or reject all or any of the recommendations of the Council of States.
(3) If the House of the People accepts any of the recommendations of the Council of States, the Money Bill shall be deemed to have been passed by both Houses with the amendments recommended by the Council of States and accepted by the House of the People.
(4) If the House of the People does not accept any of the recommendations of the Council of States, the Money Bill shall be deemed to have been passed by both Houses in the form in which it was passed by the House of the People without any of the amendments recommended by the Council of States.
(5) If a Money Bill passed by the House of the People and transmitted to the Council of States for its recommendations is not returned to the House of the People within the said period of fourteen days, it shall be deemed to have been passed by both Houses at the expiration of the said period in the form in which it was passed by the House of the People.
110. (1) For the purposes of this Chapter, a Bill shall be deemed to be a Money Bill if it contains only provisions dealing with all or any of the following matters, namely:— (a) the imposition, abolition, remission, alteration or regulation of any tax;
(b) the regulation of the borrowing of money or the giving of any guarantee by the Government of India, or the amendment of the law with respect to any financial obligations undertaken or to be undertaken by the Government of India;
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
(c) the custody of the Consolidated Fund or the Contingency Fund of India, the payment of moneys into or the withdrawal of moneys from any such Fund; (d) the appropriation of moneys out of the Consolidated Fund of India;
(e) the declaring of any expenditure to be expenditure charged on the Consolidated Fund of India or the increasing of the amount of any such expenditure; (f) the receipt of money on account of the Consolidated Fund of India or the public account of India or the custody or issue of such money or the audit of the accounts of the Union or of a State; or (g) any matter incidental to any of the matters specified in sub-clauses (a) to (f).
(2) A Bill shall not be deemed to be a Money Bill by reason only that it provides for the imposition of fines or other pecuniary penalties, or for the demand or payment of fees for licences or fees for services rendered, or by reason that it provides for the imposition, abolition, remission, alteration or regulation of any tax by any local authority or body for local purposes. (3) If any question arises whether a Bill is a Money Bill or not, the decision of the Speaker of the House of the People thereon shall be final. (4) There shall be endorsed on every Money Bill when it is transmitted to the Council of States under article 109, and when it is presented to the President for assent under article 111, the certificate of the Speaker of the House of the People signed by him that it is a Money Bill.” 95. ‘Money bills’ as defined under Article 110(1) thus include bills which contain “only” provisions covered by sub-clauses (a) to (g). These money bills can be introduced only in the Lok Sabha and the role of the Rajya Sabha is merely consultative. Unlike in the case of ordinary bills where the Upper House can block the proposed legislation and act as a check on the power of the directly elected Lower House, in case of money bills, the Rajya Sabha merely has the ability to recommend amendments, that too only within fourteen days. In case
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
the Lok Sabha refuses to accept those recommendations or in case no recommendations are made by the Rajya Sabha within the period of fourteen days, the money bill can be directly sent for Presidential ratification and thereafter it becomes valid law.
96. Such an exceptional provision has its roots in British tradition and is an inheritance of the Westminster form of government. The Parliament Act of 1911 was formulated by the United Kingdom Parliament in response to the Constitutional crisis of 1909 whereby the unelected Upper House (House of Lords) had stalled important budgetary bills passed by the elected Lower House (House of Commons), causing a governmental crisis and forcing the elected government to resign and seek re-election. Through Section 3, the said enactment required the Speaker of the House of Commons to certify that the bill was a ‘money bill’ and post such certification, the Upper House would forfeit its ability to amend or veto the bill. Further, it also allowed ‘public bills’ to become law irrespective of refusal by the House of Lords, in case the House of Commons had passed the same draft thrice in a minimum span of two years. It must be noted that the Indian adaptation under Article 109 and 110 do not have exceptions for ‘public bills’ nor do they explicitly provide that such certification shall not be amenable to judicial review unlike in the Parliament Act of 1911.
97. The Constitution of India by Article 110(4), requires that every ‘money bill’ be certified to be so by the Speaker before it is transmitted to the Rajya Sabha for their non-binding consideration. The Speaker of the Lok Sabha hence is the only appropriate authority to decide the nature of a bill under Article 110(3).
98. In the present dispute, the Union has relied upon the finality accorded to such certification by the terminology of Article 110(3) which provides that in case of any dispute as to the nature of a bill, “the decision of the Speaker of the House of the People thereon shall be final.” The Lok Sabha Speaker, in fact, on a dispute having so arisen has adjudicated the then Finance Bill, 2017 to be a ‘money bill’. Further, the Union also places emphasis on Article 122(1) of the Constitution which provides that:
“122. (1) The validity of any proceedings in Parliament all not be called in question on the ground of any alleged irregularity of procedure.”
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
99. The Union thus, alternatively, contends that the challenge before this Court to the certification of the Speaker of the Finance Bill, 2017 as a ‘money bill’ and its consequent passage without the assent of the Rajya Sabha would at best amount to an ‘irregularity of procedure’ of ‘proceedings in Parliament’ and hence cannot be inquired into by this Court. 100. It must be noted once again, that like Articles 109 and 110, Article 122 of our Constitution too can be traced to the Constitutional history and developments in the United Kingdom. Certain Members of Parliament were tried and imprisoned for their remarks in Parliament during the seventeenth century resulting in the enactment of Article 9 of the Bill of Rights, 1688 which specifies that “…. proceedings in Parliament ought not to be impeached or questioned in any Court….” Article 212(1) of the Constitution of India provides a direct corollary of Article 122(1) with respect to State legislatures. 101. This provision was initially interpreted in MSM Sharma vs. Dr. Shree Krishna Sinha20 to mean that legislative business cannot be invalidated even if it is not strictly in compliance with law for such issues were within the “special jurisdiction” of the legislature to regulate its own business. 102. The Union’s contention that Article 122 would exempt from judicial scrutiny passage of bills is a far-fetched contention. If such a blanket exemption were to be granted, then it would open the floodgates to deviation from any Constitutional provision governing the functioning of Parliament and its legislative procedure. Since the Constitution explicitly provides a self-contained detailed procedure for enactment of legislation, and does not suggest that mere assent of the President to a law, by whatsoever method adopted, would become a valid law, it is necessary that this Court being the highest Constitutional forum for judicial review is provided with enough space for enforcement and protection of the Constitutional scheme. A perusal of the expressions used in Article 122 and a comparison with its British roots make it clear that the “proceedings” referred to include the power of the Parliament to frame its own rules, set out procedures for debate and discussion and powers to enforce disciple. Section 3 of the Parliament Act, 1911 in the United Kingdom makes the decision of the Speaker of the House of Commons ‘conclusive for all purposes’ and ‘shall not be questioned
AIR 1959 SC 395.
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
in any court of law’. The Constitution of India however, under Article 110(3), states that ‘if any question arises whether a Bill is a Money Bill or not, the decision of the Speaker of the House of the People thereon shall be final’. A different syntax seems to indicate that our Constitution makes the decision of the Speaker as to the nature of Bill final qua members of both the Houses of Parliament, though it is not conclusive and unchallengeable before the Courts. The scope of judicial review of decisions that enjoy the status of finality under the Constitution has been examined by this Court on several occasions. We would like to refer to a few precedents in this regard. In Raja Ram Pal v. Lok Sabha21, this Court had examined the ambit and scope of judicial review in matters of Parliamentary privileges and powers under Article 105 of the Constitution. The Court had held that under Article 122(1) and 212(1), immunity that has been granted is limited to ‘irregularity of procedure’ and does not extend to substantive illegality or unconstitutionality by observing:
“Any attempt to read a limitation into Article 122 so as to restrict the court’s jurisdiction to examination of the Parliament’s procedure in case of unconstitutionality, as opposed to illegality would amount to doing violence to the constitutional text. Applying the principle of “expressio unius est exclusio alterius” (whatever has not been included has by implication been excluded), it is plain and clear that prohibition against examination on the touchstone of “irregularity of procedure” does not make taboo judicial review on findings of illegality or unconstitutionality.”
In Union of India v. Jyoti Prakash Mitter22, this Court had examined clause (3) to Article 217 which makes the decision of the President after consultation with the Chief Justice of India ‘final’, if the question arises as to the age of a Judge of a High Court. It was observed that notwithstanding the declared finality of the order of the President, the Court can, in appropriate cases when the order has been passed on collateral considerations or the rules of natural justice are not observed or when the judgment of the President is coloured by the advice or representation made by the Executive or is made with no evidence, set aside the order of the President made under Article 217(3).
(2007) 3 SCC 184 (1971) 1 SCC 396
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
The Courts, however, do not sit in appeal over the judgment of the President or decide the weight to be attached to the evidence which is entirely within the domain of the President. Reading of the above decisions exposit that ‘finality’ of decisions under the Constitution has been subject to judicial review by the Courts. However, the jurisdiction exercisable by the Courts in such matters is rather limited and is subject to the satisfaction of specific conditions as discussed. We find no good ground and reason to take a different view with respect to the power of judicial review against certification of a bill as a Money Bill by the Speaker under Article 110(4). Article 110(3) which makes this decision final qua both the Houses of Parliament and Article 122(1) which prohibits review by the courts in matters of ‘irregularity of procedure’ cannot operate as a bar when a challenge is made on the ground of illegality or unconstitutionality under the Constitutional scheme.
103. Determining whether an impugned action or breach is an exempted irregularity or a justiciable illegality is a matter of judicial interpretation and would undoubtedly fall within the ambit of Courts and cannot be left to the sole authority of the Parliament to decide. Such a position has also been taken in the United Kingdom by the House of Lords in R (Jackson) vs. Attorney General23 where notwithstanding the explicit bar to judicial consideration of all Parliamentary proceedings (and not just procedural irregularities as under the Constitution of India), the Court assumed jurisdiction whilst noting that interpretation of statutes dealing with legislative processes would fall within the domain of the Courts; statutory interpretation being a judicial exercise, regardless of the immunities granted to parliamentary proceedings under the Bill of Rights.
104. It would hence be gainsaid that gross violations of the Constitutional scheme would not be mere procedural irregularities and hence would be outside the limited ambit of immunity from judicial scrutiny under Article 122(1). In the case at hand, jurisdiction of this Court is, hence, not barred.
105. On the substantive question of whether the Finance Act, 2017 was a ‘money bill’ under Article 110(3) it must be noted that until the turn of the twenty-first century, this Court took a consistent position
[2005] UKHL 56.
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
that Article 110(3) of the Constitution would act as an express bar against judicial inquiry into the correctness of the certificate of ‘money bill’ given by the Speaker of the Lok Sabha.
106. In Mohd. Saeed Siddiqui vs. State of Uttar Pradesh24, a three-judge bench refused to judicially review the speaker’s certification of the Uttar Pradesh Lokayukta and Up-Lokayuktas (Amendment) Bill as a Money bill. The phrase “proceedings of the Legislature” under Article 212(1) was interpreted to include “everything said or done in either house”. This Court thus held: “43. As discussed above, the decision of the Speaker of the Legislative Assembly that the Bill in question was a Money Bill is final and the said decision cannot be disputed nor can the procedure of the State Legislature be questioned by virtue of Article 212. Further, as noted earlier, Article 255 also shows that under the Constitution the matters of procedure do not render invalid an Act to which assent has been given to by the President or the Governor, as the case may be. Inasmuch as the Bill in question was a Money Bill, the contrary contention by the Petitioner against the passing of the said Bill by the Legislative Assembly alone is unacceptable.” 107. This was relied upon in Yogendra Kumar Jaiswal vs. State of Bihar25, wherein a division bench of this Court refused to judicially review the certification of ‘money bill’ accorded by the Speaker to the Orissa Special Courts Bill noting that it was settled post Mohd. Siddiqui (supra) that any such certification would be an “irregularity” and not a “substantiality”. 108. A co-ordinate bench of this Court in Justice Puttaswamy (Retd.) and Anr. v. Union of India 26, was tasked with a similar question of the certification of ‘money bill’ accorded to the Aadhaar (Targeted Delivery of Financial and Other Subsidies, Benefits and Services) Act, 2016 by the Speaker of the Lok Sabha. The majority opinion after noting the important role of the Rajya Sabha in a bicameral legislative setup, observed that Article 110 being an exceptional provision, must be interpreted narrowly. Although the majority opinion did not
(2014) 11 SCC 415. (2016) 3 SCC 183 (2019) 1 SCC 1.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
examine the correctness of the decisions in Md. Siddiqui (supra) and Yogendra Kumar Jaiswal (supra) or conclusively pronounce on the scope of jurisdiction or power of this Court to judicially review certification by the Speaker under Article 110(3), yet, it independently reached a conclusion that the impugned enactment fell within the fourcorners of Articles 110(1) and hence was a ‘money bill’. The minority view rendered, however, explicitly overruled both Md. Siddiqui (supra) and Yogendra Kumar Jaiswal (supra). 109. The majority opinion in Puttaswamy (supra) by examining whether or not the impugned enactment was in fact a ‘money bill’ under Article 110 without explicitly dealing with whether or not certification of the speaker is subject to judicial review, has kept intact the power of judicial review under Article 110(3). It was further held therein that the expression ‘money bill’ cannot be construed in a restrictive sense and that the wisdom of the Speaker of the Lok Sabha in this regard must be valued, save where it is blatantly violative of the scheme of the Constitution. We respectfully endorse the view in Puttaswamy (supra) and are in no doubt that Md. Siddiqui and Yogendra Kumar Jaiswal in so far as they put decisions of the Speaker under Article 110(3) beyond judicial review, cannot be relied upon. 110. It must be emphasized that the scope of judicial review in matters under Article 110(3) is extremely restricted, with there being a need to maintain judicial deference to the Lok Sabha Speaker’s certification. There would be a presumption of legality in favour of the Speaker’s decision and onus would undoubtedly be on the person challenging its validity to show that such certification was grossly unconstitutional or tainted with blatant substantial illegality. Courts ought not to replace the Speaker’s assessment or take a second plausible interpretation. Instead, judicial review must be restricted to only the very extreme instance where there is a complete disregard to the Constitutional scheme itself. It is not the function of Constitutional Courts to act as appellate forums, especially on the opinion of the Speaker, for doing so would invite the risk of paralyzing the functioning of the Parliament. 111. In light of the aforementioned narrow scope of inquiry and the high burden to be discharged by the petitioner(s) against the Speaker’s certification, we may now examine the challenge laid to the Finance Act, 2017.
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
112. Provisions of Part XIV can be broken down into three broad categories. First, abolition and merger of existing Tribunals; second, uniformizing and delegating to the Central Government through the Rules the power to lay down qualifications; method of appointment and removal, and terms and conditions of service of Presiding Officers and members; and third, termination of services and payment of compensation to presiding officers and members of certain tribunals that have now become de-funct.
113. Interpretation of Article 110 was made by a coordinate Constitution Bench in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5) and is relied upon by both sides. 114. The majority judgment in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5) under the heading ‘Money Bill’, in paragraph 448 and then in paragraphs 452 to 461, had recorded the submissions made by the learned counsel, including the submission made on behalf of the petitioners relying upon the word ‘only’ appearing in Article 110 which defines a ‘Money Bill’. With regard to the interpretation to be given to the meaning of the word ‘only’, reliance was placed on Hari Ram v. Babu Gopal Prasad27 and M/s Saru Smelting (P) Ltd. v. Commissioner of Sales Tax, Lucknow28. The majority judgment had thereupon referred to the power of judicial review notwithstanding the use of the word ‘final’ with reference to the power of the Speaker under Article 110(3) of the Constitution, an aspect which we have already answered earlier, and examined Section 7 of the Aadhaar Act to observe “it is also accepted by the petitioners that Section 7 is the main provision of the Act”. Thereafter, reference was made to the other provisions of the Aadhaar Act to record the majority opinion that the bill in question was rightly introduced as a “Money Bill”. The majority judgment, therefore, did not elucidate and explain the scope and ambit of sub-clauses (a) to (f) to clause (1) of Article 110 of the Constitution, a legal position and facet which arises for consideration in the present case and assumes considerable importance. 115. Ashok Bhushan, J., in his concurring judgment, from paragraph 886 onwards, had examined the issue of “Money Bill” and its justiciability and as noticed above, overruled Mohd. Saeed Siddiqui
(1991) Supp. 2 SCC 608 (1993) Supp. 3 SCC 97
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
(supra) and Yogesh (supra) as not laying down the correct law by relying upon the decisions of this Court in Kihoto Hollohan v. Zachillhu and Others29 and Raja Ram Pal (supra). Referring to the definition of “Money Bill” and the meaning and purpose of the word ‘only’ used in Article 110(1) of the Constitution, Ashok Bhushan, J. had observed that legislative intent was that the main and substantive provision of an enactment should only be any or all of the sub-clauses from (a) to (f). In the event the main or substantive provisions of the Act are not covered by sub-clauses (a) to (f), the bill cannot be said to be a “Money Bill” {See paragraph 905}. It was further observed that the use of the word ‘only’ in Article 110(1) has its purpose, which is clear restriction for a bill to be certified as a “Money Bill” {See paragraph 906}. Referring to the Aadhaar Act, it was observed that it veers around the government’s constitutional obligation to provide for subsidies, benefits and services to individuals and other provisions are only incidental provisions to the main provision. Therefore, the Aadhaar Bill was rightly certified by the Speaker as a “Money Bill”. 116. Dr. D.Y. Chandrachud, J., in his minority opinion on the said question, referring to the word ‘only’ in Article 110(1) of the Constitution had observed that the pith and substance doctrine which is applicable to legislative entries would not apply when deciding the question whether or not a particular bill is a “Money Bill”. Referring to sub-clause (e) of Article 110(1), it was held that the Money Bill must deal with the declaration of any expenditure to be charged on the Consolidated Fund of India (or increasing the amount of expenditure) and, therefore, Section 7 of the Aadhaar Act did not have the effect of making the bill a Money Bill as it did not declare the expenditure incurred on services, benefits or subsidies to be a charge on the Consolidated Fund of India. Section 7 mandates Aadhaar for availing services, benefits or subsidies which were already charged to the Consolidated Fund of India. However, this view was not accepted by the majority judgment. 117. In the context of Article 110(1) of the Constitution, use of the word ‘only’ in relation to sub-clauses (a) to (f) pose an interesting, albeit a difficult question which was not examined and answered by the majority judgment in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5). While it may be easier to decipher a bill relating to imposition, abolition, remission, alteration or regulation of any tax, difficulties would arise in the
(1992) Supp. 2 SCC 651
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
interpretation of Article 110(1) specifically with reference to sub-clauses (b) to (f) in a bill relating to borrowing of money or giving of any guarantee by the Government of India, or an amendment of law concerning financial obligation. In the book, “Practices and Procedures of Parliament” by Kaul and Shakdher, it is opined that unless the word ‘only’ is interpreted in a right manner, Article 110(1) would be a nullity. A liberal and wide interpretation, on the other hand, possibly exposits an opposite consequence. Relevant portion of the opinion by Kaul and Shakdher reads:
“Speaker Mavalankar observed as follows: “Prima facie, it appears to me that the words of article 110 (imposition, abolition, remission, alteration, regulation of any tax) are sufficiently wide to make the Consolidated Bill a Money Bill. A question may arise as to what is the exact significance or scope of the word ‘only’ and whether and how far that word goes to modify or control the wide and general words ‘imposition, abolition, remission, etc.’. I think, prima facie, that the word ‘only’ is not restrictive of the scope of the general terms. If a Bill substantially deals with the imposition, abolition, etc., of a tax, then the mere fact of the inclusion in the Bill of other provisions which may be necessary for the administration of that tax or, I may say, necessary for the achievement of the objective of the particular Bill, cannot take away the Bill from the category of Money Bills. One has to look to the objective of the bill. Therefore, if the substantial provisions of the Bill aim at imposition, abolition, etc., of any tax then the other provisions would be incidental and their inclusion cannot be said to take it away from the category of a Money Bill. Unless one construes the word ‘only’ in this way it might lead to make article 110 a nullity. No tax can be imposed without making provisions for its assessment, collection, administration, reference to courts or tribunals, etc, one can visualise only one section in a Bill imposing the main tax and there may be fifty other sections which may deal with the scope, method, manner, etc., of that imposition. Further, we have also to consider the provisions of sub-clause (2) of article 110; and these provisions may be helpful to clarify the scope of the word ‘only’, not directly but indirectly.” 118. The majority judgment did not advert to the doctrine of pith and substance whereas judgment of Ashok Bhushan, J. had referred
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
to the dominant purpose. The test of dominant purpose possibly has its own limitation as many a legislation would have more than one dominant objective especially when this prescription is read with reference to sub-clauses (a) to (f) of Article 110(1) of the Constitution. Further, determination of what constitutes paramount and cardinal purpose of the legislation and the test applicable to determine this compunction and incertitude itself is not free from ambiguity. Difficulties would arise with reference to sub-clauses (b), (c), (d) and (e) of Article 110(1), when we apply the principles of dominant or the main purpose of an enactment test. Sub-clause (c) to Article 110(1) refers to payment of monies into or withdrawal of monies from the Consolidated Fund of India. Sub-clause (d) refers to appropriation of monies out of the Consolidated Fund of India. Sub-clause (e) refers to declaration of any expenditure charged on the Consolidated Fund of India or increasing of the amount of such expenditure. Sub-clause (f) relates to receipt of money on account of Consolidated Fund of India or Public Account of India or issue of such money or the audit of the accounts of the Union or of State. Even clause (b) in its amplitude includes an amendment of the law in respect of a financial obligation undertaken or to be undertaken by the Government of India. Once we hold that the decision of the Speaker under clause (3) of Article 110 of the Constitution though final, is subject to judicial scrutiny on the principle of constitutional illegality, the provisions of Article 110(1) have to be given an appropriate meaning and interpretation to avoid and prevent over-inclusiveness or under-inclusiveness. Any interpretation would have far reaching consequences. It is therefore, necessary that there should be absolute clarity with regard to the provisions and any ambiguity and debate should be ironed out and affirmatively decided. In case of doubt, certainly the opinion of the Speaker would be conclusive, but that would not be a consideration to avoid answering and deciding the scope and ambit of “Money Bill” under Article 110(1) of the Constitution. For example, taxation enactments like the Income Tax Act would qualify as Money Bill under sub-clause (a) to clause (1) of Article 110 and may include provisions relating to Appellate Tribunals which would possibly qualify as incidental provisions covered under sub-clause (g) to clause (1) of Article 110, even if we exclude application of sub-clause (d) to clause (1) of Article 110. The position it could be argued would be different with reference to provisions for constitution of a tribunal under the Administrative Tribunal Act or the National Green Tribunal
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
Act. The bill could however state that the expenditure would be charged on the Consolidated Fund of India.
119. Another aspect which would arise for consideration would be the legal consequences in case a Non-Money Bill certified by the Speaker as a Money Bill, when presented before the Rajya Sabha is specifically objected to on this count by some Members, but on being put to vote no recommendations are made in respect of “Non-Money” Bill related provisions. 120. The petitioners had argued on the strength of the concurring opinion by Ashok Bhushan, J. holding that in addition to at least one provision falling under Article 110(1) (a) to (f), each of the other remaining provisions must also be incidental to such core provision(s), and hence must satisfy the requirement of Article 110(g). Such an interpretation, it was contended, would make the insertion of the word ‘only’ under the prefatory part of Article 110(1) purposeful, which was said to have been glossed over by the Union. Further, it was contended that the manner in which the majority correlated Section 7 of the Aadhaar Act to Article 110(1)(e) was erroneous, for it only regulated procedure for withdrawal by imposing a requirement for authentication and did not declare any expenditure to be a charge on the Consolidated Fund of India. They had contended that the interpretation of the enactment by the majority judgement was constitutionally inexact and that a similar analysis ought not to be made in the present case. The petitioners, therefore, contend that every impugned provision be individually examined and brought either under Article 110(1)(a) to (f) or be incidental thereto, as permitted by Article 110(g). In case even a single provision did not satisfy either of the aforementioned two categories, then the entire Finance Act, 2017 would be an affront to the prefatory phraseology of Article 110(1) and must be declared as being unconstitutional. 121. However, the learned Attorney General has propounded that constitutionality of the Finance Act, 2017 would be safe if its dominant provisions, which form the core of the enactment, fall within the ambit of Article 110(1)(a) to (f). Other minor provisions, even if not strictly incidental, could take the dominant colour and could be passed along with it as a Money Bill. As per such interpretation, provisions ought not to be read in a piece-meal manner, and judicial review ought to be applied deferentially.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
122. Upon an extensive examination of the matter, we notice that the majority in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5) pronounced the nature of the impugned enactment without first delineating the scope of Article 110(1) and principles for interpretation or the repercussions of such process. It is clear to us that the majority dictum in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5) did not substantially discuss the effect of the word ‘only’ in Article 110(1) and offers little guidance on the repercussions of a finding when some of the provisions of an enactment passed as a “Money Bill” do not conform to Article 110(1)(a) to (g). Its interpretation of the provisions of the Aadhaar Act was arguably liberal and the Court’s satisfaction of the said provisions being incidental to Article 110(1)(a) to (f), it has been argued is not convincingly reasoned, as might not be in accord with the bicameral Parliamentary system envisaged under our constitutional scheme. Without expressing a firm and final opinion, it has to be observed that the analysis in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5) makes its application difficult to the present case and raises a potential conflict between the judgements of coordinate Benches. 123. Given the various challenges made to the scope of judicial review and interpretative principles (or lack thereof) as adumbrated by the majority in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5) and the substantial precedential impact of its analysis of the Aadhaar Act, 2016, it becomes essential to determine its correctness. Being a Bench of equal strength as that in K.S. Puttaswamy (Aadhaar-5), we accordingly direct that this batch of matters be placed before Hon’ble the Chief Justice of India, on the administrative side, for consideration by a larger Bench. 124. There is yet another reason why we feel the matter should be referred to a Constitution Bench of seven judges. L. Chandra Kumar (supra), which was decided by a Bench of seven Judges, had also interpreted on the ambit of supervision by the High Courts under Article 227(1) of the Constitution to observe that the Constitutional scheme does not require all adjudicatory bodies which fall within the territorial jurisdiction of the High Courts should be subject to their supervisory jurisdiction, as the idea is to divest the High Courts of their onerous burden. Consequently, adding to their supervisory functions vide Article 227(1) cannot be of assistance in any manner. Thereafter, it was observed that different tribunals constituted under different enactments are administered by the Central and the State Governments, yet there was no uniformity in administration. This Court was of the
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
view that until a wholly independent agency for such tribunals can be set up, it is desirable that all such tribunals should be, as far as possible, under a single nodal Ministry which will be in a position to oversee the working of these tribunals. For a number of reasons, the Court observed that the Ministry of Law would be the appropriate ministry. The Ministry of Law in turn was required to appoint an independent supervisory body to oversee the working of the Tribunals. As noticed above, this has not happened. In these circumstances, it would be appropriate if these aspects and questions are looked into by a Bench of seven Judges.
ISSUE II: WHETHER SECTION 184 OF THE FINANCE ACT, 2017 IS UNCONSTITUTIONAL ON ACCOUNT OF EXCESSIVE DELEGATION? 125. The second challenge against Part XIV of the Finance Act, 2017 is predicated on the assertion that this is a case of excessive delegation as it falters on the anvil of “essential legislative functions” and “policy and guidelines” tests. 126. The Eighth Schedule referred to in Section 183 contains a list of 19 tribunals with corresponding enactments under which they were constituted. Section 183 overrides the provisions of the enactments specified in column (3) of the Eighth Schedule and mandates that from the appointed date, the Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson, Chairman, Vice Chairman, President, Vice-President, Presiding Officer or Member of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, other Authorities as specified in column (2) of the Eighth Schedule shall be appointed in terms of provisions of Section 184 of the Finance Act. These provisions however, do not apply to those who have already been appointed to the said posts immediately before the appointed date, that is the date on which the Central Government may, by a notification in the Official Gazette, bring the said provisions into effect.
127. Section 184, to repeat, reads as under: “184. Qualifications, appointment, term and conditions of service, salary and allowances, etc., of Chairperson, ViceChairperson and Members, etc., of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal and other Authorities.—(1) The Central Government may, by notification, make rules to provide for qualifications, appointment, term of office, salaries and allowances, resignation, removal and the other terms and conditions of service of the
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson, Chairman, Vice-Chairman, President, Vice-President, Presiding Officer or Member of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, other Authorities as specified in column (2) of the Eighth Schedule: Provided that the Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson, Chairman, ViceChairman, President, Vice-President, Presiding Officer or Member of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or other Authority shall hold office for such term as specified in the rules made by the Central Government but not exceeding five years from the date on which he enters upon his office and shall be eligible for reappointment: Provided further that no Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson, Chairman, Vice-Chairman, President, Vice-President, Presiding Officer or Member shall hold office as such after he has attained such age as specified in the rules made by the Central Government which shall not exceed,— (a) in the case of Chairperson, Chairman or President, the age of seventy years; (b) in the case of Vice-Chairperson, Vice-Chairman, VicePresident, Presiding Officer or any other Member, the age of sixty-seven years: (2) Neither the salary and allowances nor the other terms and conditions of service of Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson, Chairman, Vice-Chairman, President, Vice-President, Presiding Officer or Member of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, other Authority may be varied to his disadvantage after his appointment.” Section 184 has conferred upon the Central Government power to make rules by way of notification to provide for (a) qualifications; (b) appointment; (c) term of office; (d) salaries and allowances; (e) resignation; and (f) removal and other terms and conditions of service of the Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson, Chairman, Vice-Chairman, President, Vice-President, Presiding Officer or Member of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, other Authorities as specified in column (2) of the Eighth Schedule. The first proviso states that the incumbent officers shall hold office for such terms as may be specified in the rules made by the Central Government but the term shall not
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
exceed five years from the date on which he assumes the office and shall be eligible for reappointment. The second proviso states that the persons so appointed shall hold office till they attain the age specified in the rules made by the Central Government which shall not exceed in the case of Chairperson, Chairman and the President, the age of 70 years and in the case of Vice-Chairperson, Vice-Chairman, VicePresident or any other Members, the age of 67 years. Sub-section 2 to Section 184 states that the salaries and allowances and other terms and conditions of service of the persons appointed may not be varied to their disadvantage after appointment.
128. Section 185 (1) of the Finance Act is also relevant and reads: “185. Transitional provisions.— (1) Any person appointed as the Chairperson or Chairman, President or Vice-Chairperson or Vice-Chairman, Vice-President or Presiding Officer or Member of the Tribunals, Appellate Tribunals, or as the case may be, other Authorities specified in column (2) of the Ninth Schedule and holding office as such immediately before the appointed day, shall on and from the appointed day, cease to hold such office and such Chairperson or Chairman, President, Vice-Chairperson or Vice-Chairman, Vice-President or Presiding officer or Member shall be entitled to claim compensation not exceeding three months’ pay and allowances for the premature termination of term of their office or of any contract of service.” The Chairperson or Chairman, President or Vice-Chairperson or Vice-Chairman, Vice-President or Presiding Officer or Member of the Tribunals/Appellate Tribunals specified in column (2) of the Ninth Schedule who hold office as per the above provisions before the appointed date shall cease to do so and will be entitled to compensation not exceeding three months’ pay and allowance for the premature termination of the office or the contract of office. However, we would clarify that presently we are not examining constitutional vires of subsection (1) to Section 185.
129. Section 186 of the Finance Act, 2017 reads as under: “186. General Power to make rules.— Without prejudice to any other power to make rules contained elsewhere in this Part, the Central Government may, by notification, make rules generally to carry out the provisions of this Part.”
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
The aforesaid provisions stipulate that without prejudice to any other power to make rules contained elsewhere in the Part XIV of the Finance Act, 2017, the Central Government may, by notification, makes rules generally to carry out the provisions of the said Part. 130. Reading of the said provisions indicates that except for providing the upper age limit and that the person appointed shall not have tenure exceeding five years from the date on which he enters office and shall be eligible for re-appointment, the Finance Act delegates the power to specify the qualifications, method of selection and appointment, terms of office, salaries and allowances, removal including resignation and all other terms and conditions of service to the Central Government which would act as a delegatee of the Parliament. The governing statutory provisions embodied in the existing parent legislation specified in the column (3) of the Schedule and the rules made thereunder are overwritten and authority and power is conferred on the Central Government to decide qualifications for appointment, process for selection, and terms and conditions of service including salaries allowance, resignation and removal through delegated or subordinate legislation. Before we look into the vires of this delegation, it behoves us to recount and reflect on the approach adopted by this Court in gauging the validity of delegated legislation. 131. This Court addressed this conundrum the first time in In re: The Delhi Laws Act,30 wherein a seven-Judge Bench delivered seven different judgements clearly evincing the divergence of opinion on the issue. Albeit, the majority view, as clarified and held by J. M. Shelat, J. speaking for the majority in B. Shama Rao v. Union Territory of Pondicherry,31 can be deduced as under: “In view of the intense divergence of opinion except for their conclusion partially to uphold the validity of the said laws it is difficult to deduce any general principle which on the principle of state decision can be taken as binding in for future cases. It is trite to say that a decision is binding not because of its conclusion but in regard to its ratio and the principle laid down therein. The utmost therefore that can be said of this decision is that the minimum on which there appears to be consensus was
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
1951 AIR 332 (2015) 4 SCC 770
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
(1) that legislatures in India both before and after the Constitution had plenary power within their respective fields; (2) that they were never the delegates of the British Parliament; (3) that they had power to delegate within certain limits not by reason of such a power being inherent in the legislative power but because such power is recognised even in the United States of America were separatist ideology prevails on the ground that it is necessary to effectively exercise the legislative power in a modem state with multifarious activities and complex problems facing legislatures and (4) that delegation of an essential, legislative function which amounts to abdication even partial is not permissible. All of them were agreed that it could be in respect of subsidiary and ancillary power.”
All the seven Judges were in unison that abdication or effacement by conferring the power of legislation to the subordinate authority even if partial is not permissible. The difference of opinion primarily arose from the meaning and scope of the abdication or effacement of the legislative power. On the said aspect, we would like to refer to the judgments of Fazl Ali, J, Mukherjea, J and Bose, J. Fazl Ali, J. had expressed the said principle as : “The true distinction ..... is this. The legislature cannot delegate the power to make a law; but it can make a law to delegate a power to determine some fact or state of things upon which the law makes, or intends to make, its own action depend. To deny this would be to stop the wheels of Government.
2. The true import of the rule against delegation is this: “This rule in a broad sense involves the principle underlying the maxim, delegatus non potest delegate, but it is apt to be misunderstood and has been misunderstood. In my judgment, all that it means is that the legislature cannot abdicate its legislative functions and it cannot efface itself and set up a parallel legislature to discharge the primary duty with which it has been entrusted. This rule has been recognised both in America and in England ...... xx
xx
xx
What constitutes abdication and what class of cases will be covered by that expression will always be a question of fact, and
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
it is by no means easy to lay down any comprehensive formula to define it, but it should be recognised that the rule against abdication does not prohibit the Legislature from employing any subordinate agency of its own choice for doing such subsidiary acts as may be necessary to make its legislation effective, useful and complete.” The learned Judge had further observed that an act is a law when it embodies policies, defines standards and directs the authority chosen to act within certain prescribed limits and not go beyond. The Act should be a complete expression of the will of the Legislature to act in a particular way and of its command on how it should be carried out. When the Legislature decides the circumstances as the best way to legislate on a subject, then, such legislation does not amount to abdication of powers because from the very nature to legislation it is manifest that when power is misused it can be withdrawn, altered and repealed. Most importantly, the delegate is to only adopt and extend the laws enacted by the Legislature. 132. Mukherjea, J. opined that the legislative functions concern with declaring the legislative policy and laying down the standards which is to be enacted into a rule of law, and what can be delegated as the task of subordinate legislation by its very nature is ancillary to the statute which delegates the power to make it. When the legislative policy is enunciated with sufficient clearness or the standards are laid down, the Courts cannot interfere with the discretion that the Legislature has exercised in determining the extent of necessary delegation. The delegatee cannot be allowed to check the policy declared by the legislators and cannot be given the power to repeal or abrogate any statute. 133. Bose, J. while observing that the main function of the legislature is to legislate and not leave it to others, nevertheless acknowledged that it is impossible to carry on government of a modern State with its infinite complexities and ramifications without a large devolution of power and delegation of authority. This is a practical necessity which has been acknowledged even by the American Courts. To decide otherwise would make it difficult for the government to function and work effectively.
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
134. A Division Bench of this Court in Ramesh Birch v. Union of India32 had examined the aforesaid seven opinions and culled out the ratio to observe that the lines of reasoning were different but nevertheless the judges had accepted the inevitable- that while Parliament has ample and extensive powers of legislation, these would include the power to entrust some of the functions and powers to another body or authority. At the same time, in Delhi Laws Act (supra) the judges had agreed that there should be limitations on such delegation. However, on the question as to what is this limitation, there was a lack of consensus. The two judges in Ramesh Birch (supra) relying on the ratio in Delhi Laws Act (supra), had observed:
“Some thought that there is no abdication or effacement unless it is total i.e. unless Parliament surrenders its powers in favour of a “parallel” legislature or loses control over the local authority to such an extent as to be unable to revoke the powers given to, or to exercise effective supervision over, the body entrusted therewith. But others were of opinion that such “abdication” or “effacement” could not even be partial and it would be bad if full powers to do everything that the legislature can do are conferred on a subordinate authority, although the legislature may retain the power to control the action of such authority by recalling such power or repealing the Acts passed by the subordinate authority. A different way in which the second of the above views has been enunciated—and it is this view which has dominated since—is by saying that the legislatures cannot wash their hands off their essential legislative function. Essential legislative function consists in laying down the legislative policy with sufficient clearness and in enunciating the standards which are to be enacted into a rule of law. This cannot be delegated. What can be delegated is only the task of subordinate legislation which is by its very nature ancillary to the statute which delegates the power to make it and which must be within the policy and framework of the guidance provided by the legislature.”
Thereupon the Division Bench had referred to the “policy and guideline” theory as a test to decide whether or not it is a case of excessive delegation which it was observed means reference and giving proper regard to the context of the Act and the object and purposes
1990 AIR 560
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
sought to be achieved which should be clear and it is not necessary that the legislation should “dot all the i’s and cross all the t’s of its policy”. It is sufficient if it gives the broadest indication of the general policy of the legislature. 135. We would now refer to an earlier decision of this Court in Devi Das Gopal Krishnan & Ors v. State of Punjab & Ors33 wherein K. Subba Rao, CJ. speaking for the Court had struck down Section 5 of the East Punjab General Sales Tax Act, 1948 which had empowered the State Government to fix rate of tax to such rate as it deemed fit, as bad and unconstitutional observing that the needs of the State and the purposes of the Act did not provide sufficient guidance for fixing the rates of tax. It was observed: “16. ...But in view of the multifarious activities of a welfare State, it cannot presumably work out all the details to suit the varying aspects of a complex situation. It must necessarily delegate the working out of details to the executive or any other agency. But there is a danger inherent in such a process of delegation. An overburdened legislature or one controlled by a powerful executive may unduly overstep the limits of delegation. It may not lay down any policy at all; it may declare its policy in vague and general terms; it may not set down any standard for the guidance of the executive; it may confer an arbitrary power on the executive to change or modify the policy laid down by it without reserving for itself any control over subordinate legislation. This self effacement of legislative power in favour of another agency either in whole or in part is beyond the permissible limits of delegation. It is for a Court to hold on a fair, generous and liberal construction of an impugned statute whether the legislature exceeded such limits. But the said liberal on construction should not be carried by the Courts to the extent of always trying to discover a dormant or latent legislative policy to sustain an arbitrary power conferred on executive authorities. It is the duty of the Court to strike down without any hesitation any arbitrary power conferred on the executive by the legislature.”
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
AIR 1967 SC 1895
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
136. A year later in Municipal Corporation of Delhi v. Birla Cotton, Spinning and Weaving Mills, Delhi and Another34 this Court, however, upheld Section 113(2) of the Delhi Municipal Act, 1957 which had empowered the corporation to levy certain optional taxes by observing that there were sufficient guidelines, safeguards and checks in the Act which prevented excessive delegation as the Act had provided maximum rate of tax. It was observed that the nature of body to which delegation is made is also a relevant factor to be taken into consideration in determining whether there is sufficient guidance in the matter of delegation and also when delegation is made to an elected body accountable to the people including those who paid taxes, as this acted as a sufficient check. It was observed:
“A review of these authorities therefore leads to the conclusion that so far as this Court is concerned the principle is well established that essential legislative function consists of the determination of the legislative policy and its formulation as a binding rule of conduct and cannot be delegated by the legislature. Nor is there any unlimited right of delegation inherent in the legislative power itself. This is not warranted by the provisions of the Constitution. The legislature must retain in its own hands the essential legislative functions and what can be delegated is the task of subordinate legislation necessary for implementing the purposes and objects of the Act. Where the legislative policy is enunciated with sufficient clearness or a standard is laid down, the courts should not interfere. What guidance should be given and to what extent and whether guidance has been given in a particular case at all depends on a consideration of the provisions of the particular Act with which the Court has to deal including its preamble. Further it appears to us that the nature of the body to which delegation is made is also a factor to be taken into consideration in determining whether there is sufficient guidance in the matter of delegation.” Thus, the guidelines in the form of providing maximum rates of tax up to which a local body may be given discretion to make its choice or provision for consultation with the people of the local area and then fixing the rates or subjecting the rate of tax so fixed by the local authority
AIR 1968 SC 1232
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
to the approval of the Government which acts as watch-dog were treated as satisfying the policy and guideline test. 137. This ratio was followed and expounded in M.K. Papiah & Sons v. Excise Commissioner35 in which this Court had examined what constitutes essential features that the legislature cannot delegate, to observe that this cannot be delineated in detail but nevertheless and certainly it does not include the change of policy. The legislator is the master of the policy and the delegate is not free to switch the policy for then it would be usurpation of legislative power itself. Therefore, when the question of the excessive delegation arises, investigation has to be made whether policy of the legislation has not been indicated sufficiently or whether change of policy has been left to the pleasure of the delegate. This aspect is of substantial importance and relevance in the present case. 138. In Avinder Singh v. State of Punjab36 this Court had highlighted that the founding document, that is, the Constitution had created three instrumentalities with certain basic powers and it is axiomatic that legislative powers are not abdicated for this would mean betrayal of the Constitution and is intolerable in law. Therefore, legislature cannot self-efface its personality and make over in terms the plenary and essential legislative functions. Nevertheless, the complexities of modern administration are bafflingly intricate and present themselves with urgencies and difficulties and the need for flexibility, which the direct legislation may not provide. Delegation of some part of the legislative powers therefore became inevitable and an administrative necessity. Thus, while essential legislative policy cannot be delegated, however inessentials can be delegated over to relevant agencies. 139. Similar opinion was expressed in Registrar of Coop. Societies v. K. Kunjabmu37, wherein it has been observed: “3. …They function best when they concern themselves with general principles, broad objectives and fundamental issues instead of technical and situational intricacies which are better left to better equipped full time expert executive bodies and
(1975) 1 SCC 492 (1979) 1 SCC 137 (1980) 1 SCC 340
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
specialist public servants. Parliament and the State Legislatures have neither the time nor the expertise to be involved in detail and circumstance. Nor can Parliament and the State Legislatures visualise and provide for new, strange, unforeseen and unpredictable situations arising from the complexity of modern life and the ingenuity of modern man. That is the raison d’etre for delegated legislation. That is what makes delegated legislation inevitable and indispensable. The Indian Parliament arid the State Legislatures are endowed with plenary power to legislate upon any of the subjects entrusted to them by the Constitution, subject to the limitations imposed by the Constitution itself. The power to legislate carries with it the power to delegate. But excessive delegation may amount to abdication. Delegation unlimited may invite despotism uninhibited. So, the theory has been evolved that the legislature cannot delegate its essential legislative function. Legislate it must by laying down policy and principle and delegate it may to fill in detail and carry out policy. The legislature may guide the delegate by speaking through the express provision empowering delegation or the other provisions of the statute, the preamble, the scheme or even the very subject matter of the statute. If guidance there is, wherever it may be found, the delegation is valid. A good deal of latitude has been held to be permissible in the case of taxing statutes and on the same principle a generous degree of latitude must be permissible in the case of welfare legislation, particularly those statutes which are designed to further the Directive Principles of State Policy.”
The above decision states that the policy and principles test can be applied through express provisions empowering delegation or any other provision of the statute including the preamble, the scheme or even the subject matter of the statute. 140. We will refer to a recent decision of this Court in Keshavlal Khemchand and Son Private Limited & Others v. Union of India38 wherein a Division Bench of this Court had observed that in spite of abundance of authority on the subject we are not blessed with certainty, and then observed that in Kunjabmu (supra) this Court had declined to consider whether M.K. Papiah & Sons (supra) had beaten the final retreat from the position enunciated in Delhi Laws Act (supra) and had
(2015) 4 SCC 770
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
proceeded to examine the theory of “policy and guidelines” referring to several judgments. The Division Bench then went on to observe that the earlier judgments had not been able to lay down the principle including as to what exactly constitutes “essential legislative function”, but the following inferences can be drawn:
“51.1 The proposition that essential legislative functions cannot be delegated does not appear to be such a clearly settled proposition and requires a further examination which exercise is not undertaken by the counsel appearing in the matter. We leave it open for debate in a more appropriate case on a future date. For the present, we confine to the examination of the question:
‘Whether defining every expression used in an enactment is an essential legislative function or not?’ 51.2 All the judgments examined above recognize that there is a need for some amount of delegated legislation in the modern world.
51.3 If the parent enactment enunciates the legislative policy with sufficient clarity, delegation of the power to make subordinate legislation to carry out the purpose of the parent enactment is permissible.
51.4 Whether the policy of the legislature is sufficiently clear to guide the delegate depends upon the scheme and the provisions of the parent Act.
51.5 The nature of the body to whom the power is delegated is also a relevant factor in determining “whether there is sufficient guidance in the matter of delegation.”
141. Appropriate in regard to ‘policy and guideline’ test would be reference to yet another earlier judgment of this Court in Gwalior Rayon Silk Mfg. (Wvg.) Co. v. Asstt. Commissioner of Sales 39 wherein while referring to the views of an eminent American jurist Willioughby, it was stated: “24. The matter has been dealt with on page 1637 of Vol. III in Willoughby on the Constitution of the United States, 2nd Edition, in the following words:
(1974) 4 SCC 98
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI] “The qualifications to the rule prohibiting the delegation of legislative power which have been earlier adverted to are those which provide that while the real law-making power may not be delegated, a discretionary authority may be granted to executive and administrative authorities: (1) to determine in specific cases when and how the powers legislatively conferred are to be exercised; and (2) to establish administrative rules and regulations, binding both upon their subordinates and upon the public, fixing in detail the manner in which the requirements of the statutes are to be met, and the rights therein created to be enjoyed.” 25. The matter has also been dealt with in Corpus Juris Secundum Vol. 73, page 324. It is stated there that the lawmaking power may not be granted to an administrative body to be exercised under the guise of administrative discretion. Accordingly, in delegating powers to an administrative body with respect to the administration of statutes, the Legislature must ordinarily prescribe a policy, standard, or rule for their guidance and must not vest them with an arbitrary and uncontrolled discretion with regard thereto, and a statute or ordinance which is deficient in this respect is invalid. In other words, in order to avoid the pure delegation of legislative power by the creation of an administrative agency, the Legislature must set limits on such agency’s power and enjoin on it a certain course of procedure and rules of decision in the performance of its function; and, if the legislature fails to prescribe with reasonable clarity the limits of power delegated to an administrative agency, or if those limits are too broad, its attempt to delegate is a nullity.” 142. It is in this context we have to examine whether the plea of excessive delegation would prevail and merits acceptance as Section 184 of the Finance Act does not prescribe the qualifications for appointment, and terms and conditions of service. It will be difficult to hold that Part XIV of the Finance Act suffers from the vice of unguided delegation as it fails to clearly specify the eligibility qualifications for the Members, Chairpersons, Chairman etc. of different Tribunals as such requirements, though important, are not per se functionally undelegatable.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
143. The objects of the parent enactments as well as the law laid down by this Court in R.K. Jain (supra), L Chandra Kumar (supra), R. Gandhi (supra), Madras Bar Association (supra) and Gujarat Urja Vikas (supra) undoubtedly bind the delegate and mandatorily requires the delegate under Section 184 to act strictly in conformity with these decisions and the objects of delegated legislation stipulated in the statutes. It must also be emphasised that the Finance Act, 2017 nowhere indicates that the legislature had intended to differ from, let alone make amendments, to remove the edifice and foundation of such decisions by enacting the Finance Act. Indeed, the learned Attorney General was clear in suggesting that Part XIV was inserted with a view to incorporate the changes recommended by this Court in earlier decisions. 144. Independence of a quasi-judicial authority like the tribunal highlighted in the above decisions would be, therefore, read as the policy and guideline applicable. Principle of independence of judiciary/tribunal has within its fold two broad concepts, as held in Supreme Court Advocates-On-Record Association and Another v. Union of India40 {See paragraph 714}, (i) independence of an individual judge, that is, decisional independence; and (ii) independence of the judiciary or the Tribunal as an institution or an organ of the State, that is, functional independence. Individual independence has various facets which include security of tenure, procedure for renewal, terms and conditions of service like salary, allowances, etc. which should be fair and just and which should be protected and not varied to his/her disadvantage after appointment. Independence of the institution refers to sufficient degree of separation from other branches of the government, especially when the branch is a litigant or one of the parties before the tribunal. Functional independence would include method of selection and qualifications prescribed, as independence begins with appointment of persons of calibre, ability and integrity. Protection from interference and independence from the executive pressure, fearlessness from other power centres – economic and political, and freedom from prejudices acquired and nurtured by the class to which the adjudicator belongs, are important attributes of institutional independence. 145. Further, cursory examination of the specified enactments mentioned in column (3) of the Eighth Schedule reveals that most
(2016) 5 SCC 1
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
enactments did not stipulate the manner of appointment, terms of office, salaries and allowances, resignation, removal, that is, the terms and conditions of service, which stipulations are delegated and they are not part of the principal enactment. For example, sub-section (1) of Section 252 of the Income Tax Act, 1961 states that the Central Government may constitute the Appellate Tribunal consisting of as many judicial and accountant members as it thinks fit to exercise the powers and discharge the functions prescribed by the Act. Sub-sections (3) and (4) state that the Central Government shall ordinarily appoint a judicial Member as the President and may appoint one or more members as Vice President or Senior Vice President. Sub-section (2) prescribes the eligibility requirements for being a judicial member and sub-section (2A) stipulates the eligibility requirements for being an administrative member. The Income Tax Act does not prescribe or stipulate manner or method for selection or terms and conditions of service. This is equally true for the Appellate Tribunal constituted under the Central Excise Act.
146. Wanchoo, CJ. in The Municipal Corporation of Delhi (supra) had observed:
“13. The question as to the limits of permissible delegation of legislative power by a legislature to a subordinate authority has come before this Court in a number of cases and the law as laid down by this Court is not in doubt now. Considering the complexity of modern life it is recognised on all hands that legislature cannot possibly have time to legislate in every minute detail. That is why it has been recognised that it is open to the legislature to delegate to subordinate authorities the power to make ancillary rules for the purpose of carrying out the intention of the legislature indicated in the law which gives power to frame such ancillary rules. The matter came before this Court for the first time In re The Delhi Laws Act, 1912 and it was held in that case that it could not be said that an unlimited right of delegation was inherent in the legislative power itself. This was not warranted by the provisions of the Constitution, which vested the power of legislation either in Parliament or State legislatures and the legitimacy of delegation depended upon its being used as an ancillary measure which the legislature considered to be necessary for the purpose of exercising its legislative powers effectively and completely. The legislature must retain in its own
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
hands the essential legislative function. Exactly what constituted “essential legislative function”, it was held further, was difficult to define in general terms, but this much was clear that the essential legislative function must at least consist of the determination of the legislative policy and its formulation as a binding rule of conduct. Thus where the law passed by the legislature declares the legislative policy and lays down the standard which is enacted into a rule of law, it can leave the task of subordinate legislation which by its very nature is ancillary to the statute to subordinate bodies i.e. the making of rules, regulations or bye-laws. The subordinate authority must do so within the frame-work of the law which makes the delegation, and such subordinate legislation has to be consistent with the law under which it is made and cannot go beyond the limits of the policy and standard laid down in the law. Provided the legislative policy is enunciated with sufficient clearness or a standard is laid down, the courts should not interfere with the discretion that undoubtedly rests with the legislature itself in determining the extent of delegation necessary in a particular case. xx
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
xx
xx
28. A review of these authorities therefore leads to the conclusion that so far as this Court is concerned the principle is well established that essential legislative function consists of the determination of the legislative policy and its formulation as a binding rule of conduct and cannot be delegated by the legislature. Nor is there any unlimited right of delegation inherent in the legislative power itself. This is not warranted by the provisions of the Constitution. The legislature must retain in its own hands the essential legislative functions and what can be delegated is the task of subordinate legislation necessary for implementing the purposes and objects of the Act. Where the legislative policy is enunciated with sufficient clearness or a standard is laid down, the courts should not interfere. What guidance should be given and to what extent and whether guidance has been given in a particular case at all depends on a consideration of the provisions of the particular Act with which the Court has to deal including its preamble. Further it appears to us that the nature of the body to which delegation is made is
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
also a factor to be taken into consideration in determining whether there is sufficient guidance in the matter of delegation.”
147. Referring to The Municipal Corporation of Delhi (supra), this Court in Keshav Lal, had observed: “45. ... The Court held that there was no impermissible delegation of legislative power. Hidayatullah, J. speaking for himself and for Ramaswami, J. agreed with the conclusion reached at by Wanchoo, C.J., though on slightly different reasons.” 148. On examining the Constitutional scheme, the statutes which had created tribunals and the precedents of this Court laying down attributes of independence of tribunals in different facets, we do not think that the power to prescribe qualifications, selection procedure and service conditions of members and other office holders of the tribunals is intended to vest solely with the Legislature for all times and purposes. Policy and guidelines exist. Subject to aforesaid, the submission of learned Attorney General that Section 184 was inserted to bring uniformity and with a view to harmonise the diverse and wide-ranging qualifications and methods of appointment across different tribunals carries weight and, in our view, needs to be accepted. 149. Cautioning against the potential misuse of Section 184 by the executive, it was vehemently argued by the learned counsel for the petitioner(s) that any desecration by the Executive of such powers threatens and poses a risk to the independence of the tribunals. A mere possibility or eventuality of abuse of delegated powers in the absence of any evidence supporting such claim, cannot be a ground for striking down the provisions of the Finance Act, 2017. It is always open to a Constitutional court on challenge made to the delegated legislation framed by the Executive to examine whether it conforms to the parent legislation and other laws, and apply the “policy and guideline” test and if found contrary, can be struck down without affecting the constitutionality of the rule making power conferred under Section 186 of the Finance Act, 2017. ISSUE III: IF SECTION 184 IS VALID, WHETHER TRIBUNAL, APPELLATE TRIBUNAL AND OTHER AUTHORITIES (QUALIFICATIONS, EXPERIENCE AND OTHER CONDITIONS OF SERVICE OF MEMBERS) RULES, 2017 ARE IN CONSONANCE
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
WITH THE PRINCIPAL ACT AND VARIOUS DECISIONS OF THIS COURT ON FUNCTIONING OF TRIBUNALS? 150. Given that the Central Government has formulated the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal and other Authorities (Qualifications, Experience and other Conditions of Service of Members) Rules, 2017, (hereinafter referred to as “the Rules”) under Section 184 of the Finance Act, 2017, it is necessary at this stage to examine whether the Rules conform to the judicial principles inherent in our Constitutional scheme as established by this Court in its earlier dicta. Some salient provisions of the Rules are extracted hereunder: “Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal and other Authorities (Qualifications, Experience and other Conditions of Service of Members) Rules, 2017 xxxxxx
3. Qualifications for appointment of Member.— The qualification for appointment of the Chairman, Chairperson, President, Vice-Chairman, Vice-Chairperson, Vice-President, Presiding Officer, Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Law Member, Revenue Member, Technical Member or Member of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, Authority shall be such as specified in column (3) of the Schedule annexed to these rules. 4. Method of recruitment.— (1) The Chairman, Chairperson, President, Vice-Chairman, Vice-Chairperson, Vice-President, Presiding Officer, Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Law Member, Revenue Member, Technical Member or Member of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, Authority shall be appointed by the Central Government on the recommendation of a Search-cum-Selection Committee specified in column (4) of the said Schedule in respect of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, Authority specified in column (2) of the said Schedule. (2) The Secretary to the Government of India in the Ministry or Department under which the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, Authority is constituted or established shall be the convener of the Search-cum-Selection Committee.
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
(3) The Search-cum-Selection Committee shall determine its procedure for making its recommendation.
(4) No appointment of Chairman, Chairperson, President, ViceChairman, Vice-Chairperson, Vice-President, Presiding Officer, Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Law Member, Revenue Member, Technical Member or Member of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or Authorities shall be invalid merely by reason of any vacancy or absence in the Search-cum-Selection Committee. (5) Nothing in this rule shall apply to the appointment of Chairman, Chairperson, President, Vice-Chairman, Vice-Chairperson, VicePresident, Presiding Officer, Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Law Member, Revenue Member, Technical Member or Member of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, Authority functioning as such immediately before the commencement of these rules.
xxxxxxx 6. Resignation by a Member.— A Member may, by writing under his hand addressed to the Central Government, resign his office at any time: Provided that the Member shall, unless he is permitted by the Central Government to relinquish office sooner, continue to hold office until the expiry of three months from the date of receipt of such notice or until a person duly appointed as a successor enters upon his office or until the expiry of his term of office, whichever is the earliest. 7. Removal of Member from office.— The Central Government may, on the recommendation of a Committee constituted by it in this behalf, remove from office any Member, who — (a) has been adjudged as an insolvent; or
(b) has been convicted of an offence which, in the opinion of the Central Government, involves moral turpitude; or (c) has become physically or mentally incapable of acting as such a Member; or
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
(d) has acquired such financial or other interest as is likely to affect prejudicially his functions as a Member; or (e) has so abused his position as to render his continuance in office prejudicial to the public interest:
Provided that where a Member is proposed to be removed on any ground specified in clauses (b) to (e), the Member shall be informed of the charges against him and given an opportunity of being heard in respect of those charges: Provided further that the Chairperson or member of the National Company Appellate Tribunal shall be removed from office in consultation with the Chief Justice of India. 8. Procedure for inquiry of misbehavior or incapacity of the Member.— (1) If a written complaint is received by the Central Government, alleging any definite charge of misbehavior or incapacity to perform the functions of the office in respect of a Chairman, Vice-Chairman, Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson, President, Vice-President, Presiding Officer, Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Law Member, Revenue Member, Technical Member or Member, the Ministry or Department of the Government of India under which the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, Authority is constituted or established, shall make a preliminary scrutiny of such complaint. (2) If on preliminary scrutiny, the Ministry or Department of the Government of India under which the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, Authority is constituted or established, is of the opinion that there are reasonable grounds for making an inquiry into the truth of any misbehavior or incapacity of a Chairman, Vice-Chairman, Chairperson, Vice-Chairperson, President, Vice-President, Presiding Officer, Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Law Member, Revenue Member, Technical Member or Member, it shall make a reference to the Committee constituted under rule 7 to conduct the inquiry. (3) The Committee shall complete the inquiry within such time or such further time as may be specified by the Central Government.
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
(4) After the conclusion of the inquiry, the Committee shall submit its report to the Central Government stating therein its findings and the reasons therefor on each of the charges separately with such observations on the whole case as it may think fit.
(5) The Committee shall not be bound by the procedure laid down by the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 (5 of 1908) but shall be guided by the principles of natural justice and shall have power to regulate its own procedure, including the fixing of date, place and time of its inquiry. 9. Term of office of Member.— Save as otherwise provided in these rules, the Chairman, Chairperson, President, ViceChairman, Vice-Chairperson, Vice President, Presiding Officer, Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Law Member, Revenue Member, Technical Member or, as the case may be, Member shall hold office for a term as specified in column (5) of the said Schedule and shall hold the office up to such age as specified in column (6) in the said Schedule from the date on which he enters upon his office and shall be eligible for reappointment.
10. Casual vacancy.— (1) In case of a casual vacancy in the office of,— (a) the Chairman, Chairperson, President, or Presiding Officer of the Security Appellate Tribunal, the Central Government shall have the power to appoint the senior most Vice-Chairperson or Vice-Chairman, Vice-President or in his absence, one of the Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Law Member, Revenue Member, Technical Member, or Member of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, Authority to officiate as Chairperson, Chairman, President or Presiding Officer. (b) the Chairperson of the Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal, the Central Government shall have power to appoint the Chairperson of another Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal to officiate as Chairperson and in case of a casual vacancy in the office of the Presiding Officer of the Debts Recovery Tribunal, the Chairperson of the Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal shall have power to appoint the Presiding Officer of another Debts Recovery Appellate Tribunal to officiate as Presiding Officer.
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
11. Salary and allowances.— (1) The Chairman, Chairperson or President of the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, Authority or the Presiding Officer of the Security Appellate Tribunal shall be paid a salary of Rs. 2,50,000 (fixed) and other allowances and benefits as are admissible to a Central Government officer holding posts carrying the same pay. (2) The Vice-Chairman, Vice-Chairperson, Vice-President, Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Law Member, Revenue Member, Technical Member or, as the case may be, Member shall be paid a salary of Rs. 2,25,000 and shall be entitled to draw allowances as are admissible to a Government of India Officer holding Group ‘A’ post carrying the same pay. (3) A Presiding Officer of the Debt Recovery Tribunal or a Presiding Officer of the Industrial Tribunal constituted by the Central Government shall be paid a salary of Rs. 1,44,2002,18,200 and shall be entitled to draw allowances as are admissible to a Government of India officer holding Group ‘A’ post carrying the same pay. (4) In case of a person appointed as the Chairman, Chairperson, President, Vice-Chairman, Vice-Chairperson, Vice President, Presiding Officer, Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Law Member, Revenue Member, Technical Member or Member, as the case may be, is in receipt of any pension, the pay of such person shall be reduced by the gross amount of pension drawn by him. 12. Pension, Gratuity and Provident Fund.— (1) In case of a serving Judge of the Supreme Court, a High Court or a serving Judicial Member of the Tribunal or a member of the Indian Legal Service or a member of an organised Service appointed to the post of the Chairperson, Chairman, President or Presiding Officer of the Security Appellate Tribunal, the service rendered in the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, Authority shall count for pension to be drawn in accordance with the rules of the service to which he belongs and he shall be governed by the provisions of the General Provident Fund (Central Services) Rules, 1960 and the Contribution Pension System.
ROJER MATHEW v. SOUTH INDIAN BANK LTD. [RANJAN GOGOI, CJI]
(2) In all other cases, the Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Law Member, Revenue Member, Technical Member or Member shall be governed by the provisions of the Contributory Provident Fund (India) Rules, 1962 and the Contribution Pension System.
(3) Additional pension and gratuity shall not be admissible for service rendered in the Tribunal, Appellate Tribunal or, as the case may be, Authority.
13. Leave.— (1) The Chairman, Chairperson, President, ViceChairman, Vice-Chairperson, Vice President, Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Law Member, Revenue Member, Technical Member, Presiding Officer or a Member shall be entitled to thirty days of earned Leave for every year of service. (2) Casual Leave not exceeding eight days may be granted to the Chairman, Chairperson, President, Vice-Chairman, ViceChairperson, Vice President, Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Law Member, Revenue Member or Technical Member, Presiding Officer or a Member in a calendar year. (3) The payment of leave salary during leave shall be governed by rule 40 of the Central Civil Services (Leave) Rules, 1972. (4) The Chairman, Chairperson, President, Vice-Chairman, ViceChairperson, Vice President, Presiding Officer, Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Law Member, Revenue Member, Technical Member or Member shall be entitled to encashment of leave in respect of the earned Leave standing to his credit, subject to the condition that maximum leave encashment, including the amount received at the time of retirement from previous service shall not in any case exceed the prescribed limit under the Central Civil Service (Leave) Rules, 1972.
14. Leave sanctioning authority.— (1) Leave sanctioning authority,— (a) for the Vice-Chairman, Vice-Chairperson, Vice-President, Presiding Officer of the Debts Recovery Tribunal and Industrial
SUPREME COURT REPORTS
[2019] 16 S.C.R.
Tribunal, Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Law Member, Revenue Member, Technical Member or Member shall be Chairman, Chairperson or as the case may be, President; and (b) for the Chairman, Chairperson, Presiding Officer of Security Appellate Tribunal or President, shall be the Central Government, who shall also be sanctioning authority for Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member or Member in case of absence of Chairman, Chairperson, Presiding Officer of Security Appellate Tribunal or President.
(2) The Central Government shall be the sanctioning authority for foreign travel to the Chairman, Chairperson, President, ViceChairman, Vice-Chairperson, Vice-President, Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Technical Member, Presiding Officer or a Member.
xxx
18. Other conditions of service.— (1) The terms and conditions of service of a Chairman, Chairperson, President, ViceChairman, Vice-Chairperson, Vice-President, Accountant Member, Administrative Member, Judicial Member, Expert Member, Technical Member, Presiding Officer or Member with respect to which no express provision has been made in these rules, shall be such as are admissible to a Group ‘A’ Officer of the Government of India of a