The Commissioner, Nashik Municipal Corporation, Nashik v. Laxman Hari Tambe and Ors
- Court
- Bombay High Court
- Date of judgment
- 13 October 2026
- Case number
- IA No. 18175 of 2023
- Result
- Disposed Off
Full judgment
Vivekanand
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
Digitally signed by VIVEKANAND VIVEKANAND RAJENDRA BONDE RAJENDRA BONDE Date: 2026.10.14 18:45:18 +0530
FIRST APPEAL (ST) NO. 20641 OF 2023 WITH INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 18156 OF 2023 WITH INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 18155 OF 2023 WITH INTERIM APPLICATION NO. 8072 OF 2026 The Commissioner, Nashik Municipal Corporation, Nashik V/s. Dnyaneshwar Popat Pawar And Ors.
… Appellant … Respondents
Ms. Chaitali Deshmukh a/w Mr. Vikas More, for the appellant/applicant. Mr. A. R. Patil, Additional G. P., for the Respondent/State & Applicant in IA(st)/29798/2026. Mr. Vivek Salunke, for the Respondent No. 1 & Applicant in IA/8072/2026 and IA/8074/2026. CORAM
: AMIT BORKAR, J.
DATED
: OCTOBER 13, 2026
P.C.: Interim Application Nos. 18155/2023, 18152/2023, 18158/2023, 18149/2023, 18151/2023, 18153/2023, 18167/2023, 18162/2023, 17698/2023, 18175/2023, 18146/2023, 18171/2023, 18174/2023, 18160/2023, 17632/2023, 18168/2023. 1.
For the reasons stated therein, the interim applications are
allowed in terms of prayer clause (b).
2.
The delay in filing first appeal is condoned.
First Appeal (St.) No. 20641/2023, 20645/2023, 20651/2023, 20660/2023,
20672/2023,
20683/2023,
20689/2023,
20693/2023,
20686/2023,
20637/2023,
20655/2023,
20665/2023,
20697/2023,
20702/2023,
20709/2023,
20715/2023. 3.
Admit.
4.
Appellant to file paper book in the lead matter before the
next date of hearing. 5.
List these appeals for “final hearing” on 8 December 2026 at
the Bottom of Board.
Interim Application Nos. 8072/2026, 8073/2026, 8077/2026, 8078/2026, 8061/2026, 8062/2026, 8074/2026, 8075/2026, 29790/2026, 29791/2026, 29798/2026, 29802/2026, 29810/2026, 29811/2026, 29816/2026, 6.
It is pointed out that the Reference Court has determined
the market value of the acquired land on the basis of the judgment delivered by it in a connected matter. It is submitted out that the rate awarded in the present matter is lower than the rate awarded in the Land Reference Award concerning similarly situated lands, after making deductions on account of certain adverse factors. The record, therefore, indicates that the acquiring body has not deposited the entire amount payable under the impugned award.
7.
The record indicates that, as on 13 June 2023, the total
amount
payable
in
all
these
appeals
was
approximately
Rs.19,80,84,655/-. Having regard to the passage of time, the total liability may, by now, exceed Rs.25 crores. Against this liability, the amount deposited is only about 12.5% of the total amount payable, which is substantially below 50%. 8.
In view of the aforesaid circumstances, the Applicants are
permitted to withdraw the amounts deposited with the Reference Court, along with accrued interest subject to their filing undertakings before this Court that, in the event the appeals are decided against them, they shall reimburse the Municipal Corporation the entire amount withdrawn by them, in accordance with the final order passed in the respective appeals. 9.
The applications seeking withdrawal of the deposited
amounts stand disposed of in the above terms. 10.
The Reference Court shall permit each claimant to withdraw
the
amount
deposited
in
the
respective
Land
Reference
proceedings, subject to compliance with the conditions stipulated above. 11.
It is clarified that, in the event the appeals are not heard and
decided within a reasonable period, it shall be open to the claimants to renew their request before this Court for permission to withdraw the entire amount deposited or such amount as may be found appropriate. (AMIT BORKAR, J.)