Asrabai Tukaram Karhale (died) Thr Lrs Ambadas and Ors v. The Special Land Acquisition Officer Jaikwadi Project Aurangabad and Anr
- Court
- Bombay High Court
- Date of judgment
- 31 October 2026
- Case number
- FA No. 1740 of 2023
- Result
- PARTLY ALLOWED AND PARTLY DISMISSED
- Subject
- Civil, Property & land
Full judgment
2026:BHC-AUG:54130
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD 951 FIRST APPEAL NO. 164 OF 2023 Sunita Ramkisan Karhale VERSUS The Special Land Acquisition Officer Jaikwadi Project Aurangabad And Anr ... Mr. A. M. Hajare, Advocate for Appellant Mr. S. N. Kendre, Mr. S. P. Sonpawale, Mr. Mr. K. B. Jadhavar, Mr. R. K. Ingole, Mr. A. V. Lavte and Mr. B. V. Virdhe, AGPs for respective Respondent-State in respective Appeals. Mr. S. C. Arora, Advocate for Respondent no.2 in respective Appeals AND 952 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1598 OF 2023 Gopinath Tukaram Karhale VERSUS The Special Land Acquisition Officer Jaikwadi Project Aurangabad And Anr AND 953 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1652 OF 2023 Bhavlal Kondaji (died) Thr Lrs Uttam And Ors VERSUS The Special Land Acquisition Officer Jaikwadi Project Aurangabad And Anr AND 954 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1654 OF 2023 Kailas Gopinath VERSUS The Special Land Acquisition Officer Jaikwadi Project Aurangabad And Anr AND 955 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1740 OF 2023 Asrabai Tukaram Karhale (died) Thr Lrs Ambadas And Ors VERSUS The Special Land Acquisition Officer Jaikwadi Project Aurangabad And Anr
AND 956 FIRST APPEAL NO. 1799 OF 2023 Shamrao Govardhan VERSUS The Special Land Acquisition Officer Jaikwadi Project Aurangabad And Anr AND 957 FIRST APPEAL NO. 2578 OF 2023 Vilas Dada VERSUS The Special Land Acquisition Officer Jaikwadi Project Aurangabad And Anr ….. CORAM : AJIT B. KADETHANKAR, J. DATED : 31ST OCTOBER, 2026 P.C. :.
These appeals could be conveniently disposed of at
admission stage considering the submissions advanced by both the learned Advocates for the respective parties. The appeals arise out of the following Judgments and Awards: Sr. F.A. No. No.
L.A.R. No.
Date of Judgment
Court
1564 of 2010 28.06.2011 Civil Judge Senior Division Vaijapur.
1598 of 2023
1560 of 2010 22.01.2013 Civil Judge Senior Division, Vaijapur.
1652 of 2023
1433 of 2010 03.10.2011 Civil Judge Senior Division, Vaijapur
1654 of 2023
1322 of 2010 16.06.2011 Civil Judge Senior Division, Vaijapur
1740 of 2023
1379 of 2010 24.08.2011 Civil Judge Senior Division, Vaijapur
1799 of 2023
1425 of 2010 18.04.2011 Civil Judge Senior Division, Vaijapur
2578 of 2023
1419 of 2010 17.06.2011 Civil Judge Senior Division, Vaijapur
2.
For the purpose of construction of Sillegaon Minor
Irrigation Tank at village Manjarpur, Deoli, Siregaon, Taluka Gangapur, District Aurangabad, the appellants’ lands were acquired by the Acquiring Body. The details of the land acquisition are as follows: First Appeal No.164 of 2023 Section 4 notification: Possession date: Award date: Area of land: S.L.A.O. awarded: Reference Court:
16.11.1995; 16.11.1995; 12.08.1999; 1 H 1 R, Gut No.85, Deoli Rs.410 to 490 per R; Rs.1,500/- per are.
First Appeal No.1598 of 2023 Section 4 notification: 16.11.1995; Possession date: 16.11.1995; Award date: 12.08.1999; Area of land: 0 H 4 R, Gut No.127, Siregaon S.L.A.O. awarded: Rs.410 to 490 per R; Reference Court: Rs.1,500/- per are. First Appeal No.1652 of 2023 Section 4 notification: Possession date: Award date: Area of land: S.L.A.O. awarded: Reference Court:
16.11.1995; 16.11.1995; 12.08.1999; 2 H 99 R, Gut No.138, Siregaon Rs.410 to 490 per R; Rs.1,500/- per are.
First Appeal No.1654 of 2023 Section 4 notification: Possession date: Award date: Area of land: S.L.A.O. awarded: Reference Court:
16.11.1995; 16.11.1995; 12.08.1999; 0 H 40 R, Gut No.85, Deoli Rs.410 to 490 per R; Rs.1,500/- per are.
First Appeal No.1740 of 2023 Section 4 notification: Possession date: Award date: Area of land: S.L.A.O. awarded: Reference Court:
16.11.1995; 16.11.1995; 12.08.1999; 0 H 20 R, Gut No.117, Siregaon Rs.410 to 490 per R; Rs.1,500/- per are.
First Appeal No.1799 of 2023 Section 4 notification: Possession date: Award date: Area of land: S.L.A.O. awarded: Reference Court:
16.11.1995; 16.11.1995; 12.08.1999; 0 H 15 R, Gut No.86, Siregaon Rs.410 to 490 per R; Rs.1,500/- per are.
First Appeal No.2578 of 2023 Section 4 notification: Possession date: Award date: Area of land: S.L.A.O. awarded: Reference Court:
16.11.1995; 16.11.1995; 12.08.1999; 02 H 23 R, Gut No.85, Deoli Rs.410 to 490 per R; Rs.1,500/- per are.
3.
Thus, being dissatisfied with the inadequacy of the
award compensation, the claimants are before this court. This court appointed Mr. S. C. Arora, learned senior panel Advocate of the Acquiring Body to appear for the Acquiring Body. This was for the reason that despite having been served, the responsible Officers of the Acquiring Body had not Engaged any Advocate to look after the matters. 4.
When the matters are taken up for consideration,
Mr.
A.
M.
Hazari,
learned
Advocate
for
the
appellants/claimants produced before this Court a copy of judgment and order dated 27.07.2026 passed by this Court in group of First Appeals led by First Appeal No. 959 of 2017. He would submit that the cited appeal arises out of the same land acquisition proceeding, which is the subject matter in present appeals. He would submit that after considering the arguments of all the parties and the matter placed before it, this Court fixed the rate of compensation at the rate of Rs.3,500 per are (applicable for irrigated land). He would submit that these appeals are covered by the cited order and hence those be partly allowed in the same terms. 5.
After going through the text of the cited order and also
verifying the facts with the record, Mr. S. C. Arora, learned
Advocate fairly agrees that the land acquisition proceeding in the cited appeal is the same one which is subject matter of the present First Appeals. 6.
In view of this, I find that First Appeal No. 1799 of 2023
deserves to be dismissed for the reasons recorded above as also for the reasons rendered by this Court in the cited judgment and order delivered in First Appeal No.959 of 2017. The remaining First Appeals deserve to be partly allowed in following terms. Hence following order: ORDER a.
First Appeal No.1799 of 2023 stands
dismissed. b.
First appeals Nos.164 of 2023, 1598 of
2023, 1652 of 2023, 1654 of 2023, 1740 of 2023 and 2578 of 2023 stand partly allowed. c.
The appellants/claimants in allowed First
Appeals are held entitled for compensation at the rate of Rs.3,500/- per R, applicable for irrigated land. To that extent, the judgment and award be modified. d.
The Acquiring Body shall deposit the
compensation amount in this Court within a period of six months from today.
e.
While depositing the award amount, the
interest part shall be governed by the full bench judgment of this Court in the case of State of
Maharashtra Vs. Kailash Shiva Rangari, 2016(3) Mh.L.J. 457. f.
Deficit Court fees if any, be deposited by
the appellants in this Court before withdrawal of the amount. g.
If the amount is deposited by the Acquiring
Body, the appellants would be entitled to withdraw the same without making any separate application, however subject to payment of court fees. h.
First appeal stands disposed of.
i.
Suffice to note, the appellants shall not be
entitled for any statutory benefit and interest for the period of delay, if any. j.
Pending Civil Application if any, stands
disposed of.
( AJIT B. KADETHANKAR, J. ) Rushikesh/2026