Vithal Babarao Patil Died Through Lrs Gopal and ORS. v. The Special Land Acquisition Officer and Additional Collector Osmanabad.
- Court
- Bombay High Court
- Date of judgment
- 31 October 2026
- Case number
- CA No. 13000 of 2026
- Result
- Admitted/Allowed/Granted/Rule Absolute
- Subject
- Property & land
Full judgment
2026:BHC-AUG:54122
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY BENCH AT AURANGABAD CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 12999 OF 2026 IN X-OBJST/36013/2026 Vithal Babarao Patil Died Through Lrs Gopal And Ors. VERSUS The Special Land Acquisition Officer And Additional Collector Osmanabad. ... Mr. N. S. Birajdar, Advocate for Applicants Mr. B. V. Virdhe, AGP for Respondent-State Mr. S. N. Patil, Advocate for cross objectioners/claimants AND FIRST APPEAL NO. 2980 OF 2018 The State Of Maharashtra VERSUS Vitthal Babarao Patil AND FIRST APPEAL NO. 2982 OF 2018 The State Of Maharashtra VERSUS Shahaji Vithal Chavan WITH X-OBJECTION NO. 350 OF 2026 IN FA/2982/2018 Shahaji Vithal Chavan. VERSUS The Special Land Acquisition Officer And Additional Collector (earthquake), Osmanabad. WITH CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 13000 OF 2026 IN X-OBJST/36013/2026 AND
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2981 OF 2018 The State Of Maharashtra VERSUS Suresh Sopan Chavan WITH X-OBJECTION NO. 571 OF 2026 IN FA/2981/2018 Suresh Sopan Chavan. VERSUS The Special Land Acquisition Officer And Additional Collector (earthquake), Osmanabad. ….. CORAM : AJIT B. KADETHANKAR, J. DATED : 31ST OCTOBER, 2026 P.C. :CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 12999 OF 2026 .
Leave to correct the prayer clause by filling up blank
places of the days of delay. amendment be carried out forthwith. 2.
Present application is filed seeking condonation of delay
caused in filing Cross Objection. Feeling aggrieved by the judgment and award dated 16.08.2013 passed by Civil Judge Senior Division, Omerga in Land Acquisition Reference No.22 of 2005, (old L.A.R. No.319 of 1996), the Acquiring Body has filed First Appeal in this Court for enhancement. The Cross Objection is filed by the claimants. There is delay of 86 days caused in filing the Cross Objection.
3.
The reasons explaining delay are descriptively stated in
paragraph nos.2 to 4. For the reasons stated in the application and to protect the right of the claimants to seek enhancement as a statutory right, I deem it appropriate to allow the application. Hence following order: ORDER a.
Civil application stands allowed.
b.
Delay of 86 days caused in filing the Cross
Objection is hereby condoned. c.
Cross Objection be registered
CROSS OBJECTION ST. NO.36013 OF 2026 .
Issue notice to the respondents. Learned AGP waives
service of notice for respondent-State
CIVIL APPLICATION NO. 13000 OF 2026 .
This Civil Application is filed for directions to the
appellant to amend the title clause of the First Appeal and applications therein. It is submitted that during pendency of the First Appeal, applicant/claimant Vithal Patil is died and the present applicants are his legal representatives.
2.
For the reasons recorded in the application, same stands
allowed. Delay if any, stands condoned. Abatement if any, stands quashed and set aside. Amendment be carried out within a period of two weeks from today. Civil application stands disposed of.
FIRST APPEAL NO. 2981 OF 2018 WITH X-OBJECTION NO. 571 OF 2026 AND FIRST APPEAL NO. 2982 OF 2018 WITH X-OBJECTION NO. 350 OF 2026 .
The subject matter lands in the First Appeals and the
Cross
Objections
were
acquired
for
the
purpose
of
rehabilitation of the earthquake affected people, village Toramba, Taluka Lohara, District Osmanabad. The First Appeals arise out of a common judgment and award passed by learned Joint Civil Judge Senior Division, Osmanabad on 16.08.2013. The Acquiring Body has challenged the quantum of compensation granted by the Reference Court, while the claimants have sought enhancement by filing the Cross Objections.
2.
At this juncture learned Advocates for both the sides
cites an order dated 22.10.2026 passed by this Court in the group of First Appeals led by First Appeal No.2976 of 2018. It is candidly submitted that after hearing both the parties, this Court by reasoned order partly allowed the First Appeals to the extent of interest and holding the claimants entitled for compensation at Rs.22/- per sq.ft. Suffice to note the claimants also rely on an order dated 29.06.2026 passed by this court in Cross Objection No.4047 of 2011. The judgment and order dated 21.04.2026 passed by this Court in First Appeal No.2100 of 2020 is the base for the cited orders. It is submitted that the First Appeals and the Cross Objections be disposed of on the same line of the cited order dated 22.10.2026 (supra). 3.
Undisputed fact of the cases is that the lands in the
Land Acquisition Reference Applications decided by the Reference Court were acquired by the Acquiring Body for the purpose of rehabilitation of earthquake affected people village Toramba. After compliance of the procedure in the Land Acquisition Act, Special Land Acquisition Officer offered compensation and published the award. Special Land
Acquisition Officer offered compensation @ Rs.19,000/- per hectare. 4.
The claimants sought compensation under Section 18 of
the Land Acquisition Act before the Reference Court with a request to consider the non agricultural potentiality of the lands. After assessing the evidence on record and rendering findings in favour of the claimants, the Reference Court partly allowed
the
references
and
granted
compensation
@
Rs.11,000/- per R to each of the claimant. Suffice to note, the evidence in all the matters was common. 5.
While allowing the Land Acquisition References in cited
appeals partly, the Reference Court relied upon its earlier judgment and award in the case of Dhanraj Babarao Patil Vs.
The State of Maharashtra (L.A.R. No.496 of 2004, decided on 07.03.2013). Needless to mention, in Dhanraj Case (supra), the Reference Court granted compensation @ Rs.11,000/- per R. Subsequently, the claimant i.e. Dhanraj Patil filed an appeal in this Court wherein this Court by relying on various judgments and particularly in the light of the judgment and order dated 21.04.2026 passed in First Appeal No.2100 of
2020 held the claimant (Dhanraj) entitled to compensation @ Rs.22/- per Sq. ft. 6.
The claimants in other Land Acquisition References
similarly
situated
like
present
cross objectioners
filed
corresponding Cross Objections. This Court in Cross Objection No.4047 of 2011 vide order dated 29.06.2026 observing the rate granted by this Court in the case of Dhanraj, partly allowed the Cross Objection, dismissed the First Appeal filed by the Acquiring Body and held the claimant entitled for compensation @ Rs.22/- per sq.ft. Placing reliance on these orders, Mr. Patil, learned Advocate for the cross objectioners submits that the First Appeals filed by the Acquiring Body be dismissed and the Cross Objections be partly allowed in terms of the referred orders. 7.
Mr. B. V. Virdhe, learned AGP after going through the
order cited by Mr. Patil fairly agrees that the First Appeals and the Cross Objections are squarely covered by the orders passed by this Court. 8.
With the able assistance of the learned Advocates for
both the sides, I have gone through the text of the judgments and awards passed by the Reference Court in the present cases
as also in the case of Dhanraj. I have also gone through the orders passed by this Court in the cited matters. Undoubtedly the
lands
were
acquired
for
the
same
project
i.e.
Rehabilitation of Earthquake Affected Persons. Section 4 notification in both the matters is also one and the same. There is no reason for me to disagree with the view taken by this Court in the cited orders. In view of this, I find that the proceedings could be disposed. Hence, I pass following order: ORDER a.
First Appeals are partly allowed to the
extent of interest. b.
Cross Objections are partly allowed.
c.
Cross
objectioners/claimants
are
held
entitled for compensation @ Rs.22/- per sq.ft. d.
The interest part shall be governed by the
full bench judgment of this Court in the case of
State of Maharashtra Vs. Kailash Shiva Rangari, 2016(3) Mh.L.J. 457. The awards be modified. e.
The Acquiring Body/respondent in the
Cross Objections shall deposit the compensation in this Court within a period of six months from today together with accrued interest.
f.
After such deposit, the claimants/cross
obectioners shall be at liberty to withdraw the same with accrued interest. g.
While disbursing the amount, the Registry
shall ensure compliance to the law laid down in
Kailash Shiva Rangari (supra) case. h.
Any security, if offered by the claimants in
First Appeals while withdrawing any amount stands discharged. i.
Civil Application if any, stands disposed of.
( AJIT B. KADETHANKAR, J. ) Rushikesh/2026